Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society

Page created by Tony Casey
 
CONTINUE READING
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
February 2017

   Who’s watching?
           Fact and fiction
           in streaming TV

                  Plus
Mark Thompson’s encounter with the President
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
CrewStart                       TM

Struggling with start paperwork?
Hiring artists and crew? CrewStart™ manages the
onboarding process for you, from the initial invitation,
to ensuring that paperwork is completed correctly,
signed and approved online. CrewStart™ is designed to
help your team automate the processing of contracts,
start forms, daily rate vouchers and timesheets.

CrewStart™ benefits:
   Reduce administration
   Sign contracts securely
   Submit start paperwork
   Calculate timesheets
   Approve documents
   Ensure accuracy
   Auditable reports

To find out how you can save time and go
paperless on your next production, visit
the Digital Production Office® website

www.digitalproductionoffice.com

Contact our team for more information:
T: +44 (0)1753 630300
E: info@sargent-disc.com

www.digitalproductionoffice.com          www.sargent-disc.com
  @DigiProdOffice                          @SargentDisc
  /digitalproductionoffice                 /SargentDisc
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
RTS NEWS                                                                                 Your guide
                                                                                         to upcoming
                                                                                         national and
                                                                                         regional events

                                                                          NORTH WEST                          SOUTHERN
National events                       Local events                        Wednesday 22 February               Wednesday 22 March
                                                                          Student media conference            Meet the professionals
RTS EARLY EVENING EVENT               BRISTOL                             Followed by the Student             An opportunity for students
Thursday 23 February                  Sunday 19 March                     Television Awards. The              from production-based courses
False news, unverified claims         RTS West of England                 conference is for media             across the South to meet
and alternative facts                 Awards 2017                         students across the North West.     informally a wide range of
What is the future for honest         Venue: Bristol Old Vic, King        Sessions include: How to get        media production professionals.
journalism in a post-truth world?     Street, Bristol BS1 4ED             into TV; Using digital media        2:00pm-5:30pm
Panellists include: Nick Robinson,    ■ Belinda Biggam                    in drama; Exploring virtual         Venue: Bournemouth University,
BBC journalist and Today pre-         ■ belindabiggam@hotmail.com         and augmented reality; and          Talbot Campus BH12 5BB
senter; Allegra Stratton, national                                        Newsgathering. To reserve your      ■ Gordon Cooper
editor, ITV News, ITN; Patrick        DEVON & CORNWALL                    place, email rachelpinkney@         ■ gordonjcooper@gmail.com
Walker, director of media part-       ■ Kingsley Marshall                 yahoo.co.uk. 1:30pm to 5:30pm
nerships, Facebook; and Rt Hon        ■	Kingsley.Marshall@falmouth.      Venue: Compass Room, The            THAMES VALLEY
John Whittingdale OBE MP, former         ac.uk                            Lowry, Salford Quays, Salford       Wednesday 15 February
Secretary of State for Culture,                                           M50 3AZ                             Advances in compression
Media and Sport. Chair: Stewart       EAST                                Student Television Awards           Speaker: Ian Trow, senior direc-
Purvis CBE. More speakers TBA.        ■ Nikki O’Donnell                   Presented by Roger                  tor, emerging technology and
6:30pm for a 7:00pm start.            ■ nikki.odonnell@bbc.co.uk          Johnson, with special guest         strategy at Harmonic. 6:30pm
Venue: The Hospital Club, 24 Endell                                       Jack P Shepherd. Book via           for 7:00pm
Street, London WC2H 9HQ               LONDON                              rachelpinkney@yahoo.co.uk.          Venue: Pincents Manor Hotel,
■ Book online at www.rts.org.uk       ■ Daniel Cherowbrier                6:30pm                              Calcot, Reading RG31 4UQ
                                      ■ daniel@cherowbrier.co.uk          Venue: Compass Room, The            ■ Penny Westlake
RTS AWARDS                                                                Lowry, Salford Quays, Salford       ■ info@rtstvc.org.uk
Wednesday 1 March                     MIDLANDS                            M50 3AZ
RTS Television Journalism             Thursday 23 March                   ■ Rachel Pinkney 07966 230639       WALES
Awards 2017                           Networking seminar                  ■ rachelpinkney@yahoo.co.uk         Thursday 16 February
Venue: London Hilton on Park          Find out what’s happening in                                            Clive Myrie, in conversation
Lane, London W1K 1BE                  your region from guest speakers,    NORTHERN IRELAND                    with Tim Hartley
■ Jamie O’Neill 020 7822 2821         and network with other              ■ John Mitchell                     Booking essential: email
■ jamie@rts.org.uk                    professionals. To book a place,     ■	mitch.mvbroadcast@btinter-       hywel@aim.uk.com or call
                                      email RTSMidlands@rts.org.uk.          net.com                          07980 007 841. 6:15pm (light
RTS EARLY EVENING EVENT               11:45am-2:30pm                                                          refreshments available) for
Tuesday 7 March                       Venue: University of Worcester,     REPUBLIC OF IRELAND                 7:00pm
John Petter, in conversation          Henwick Grove, Worcester WR2 6AJ    Wednesday 15 February               Venue: Television Studio, ATRiuM
John Petter, CEO of BT Consumer.      ■ Jayne Greene 07792 776585         Student Television Awards           Building, USW, 86-88 Adam
6:30pm for 6:45pm start               ■ jayne@ijmmedia.co.uk              8:00pm                              Street, Cardiff CF24 2FN
Venue: BT Tower, Maple Street,                                            Venue: RTÉ Television Centre,       ■ Hywel Wiliam 07980 007841
London W1T 4JZ                        NORTH EAST & THE BORDER             Studio 1, Stillorgan Road,          ■ hywel@aim.uk.com
■ Book online at www.rts.org.uk       Thursday 23 February                Montrose, Dublin 4
                                      Networking evenings                 ■	Charles Byrne (353) 87251 3092   YORKSHIRE
Tuesday 21 March                      The last Thursday of the month,     ■ byrnecd@iol.ie                    Friday 10 March
RTS Programme Awards 2017             for anyone working in TV, film,                                         Emmerdale: Anatomy of a hit
In partnership with Audio N
                          ­ etwork    computer games or digital           SCOTLAND                            Speakers TBA. Panellists
Venue: Grosvenor House Hotel,         ­production. 6:00pm onwards.        Wednesday 1 March                   will include producers,
Park Lane, London W1K 7TN              Venue: Tyneside Bar Café, Tyne-    AGM followed by                     directors, writers and actors.
■ Alice Turner 020 7822 2822           side Cinema, 10 Pilgrim St, New-   Student Television Awards           There will also be craft
■ ATurner@rts.org.uk                   castle upon Tyne NE1 6QG           AGM at 6:00pm, followed by the      workshops for students and
                                       ■ Jill Graham                      awards reception (light buffet)     young people interested
RTS CONFERENCE                         ■ jill.graham@blueyonder.co.uk     at 7:00pm                           in a career in television. To
13-15 September                                                           Venue: The Hub Glasgow, Pacific     register your interest, email
RTS Cambridge Convention                                                  Quay, Pacific Drive, Glasgow        rtsyorkshireevents@rts.org.uk
2017                                                                      G51 1EA                             Venue: Leeds College of Music,
Venue: West Road Concert Hall,                                            ■ James Wilson 07899 761167         3 Quarry Hill, Leeds LS2 7PD
Cambridge CB3 9DP and King’s                                              ■	james.wilson@cityofglasgow-      ■ Lisa Holdsworth 07790 145280
College, Cambridge CB2 1ST                                                   college.ac.uk                    ■	lisa@allonewordproductions.
■ Booking opens soon                                                                                             co.uk

4
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
TV diary
                                   Jess Fowle celebrates a historic week for
                                    True North, which seems to have grown
                                             too big for its pizzas

    A
                          n auspicious start      on the four-hour train ride to pitch       from tales of Bake Off’s drawn-out ges-
                          to the week. The        in London. There are times when I          tation. In the meantime, we’re deter-
                          news breaks that        board the East Coast main line from        mined to prove the concept works.
                          Sky has taken a         Happy Valley to Medialand slightly
                          majority stake in       resentfully.                               ■ Our development exec is teaching
                          True North. Our           But, today, I’m feeling philosophical.   herself piano and I am training for
                          baby, born 16 years     The post-Brexit world presents an          a particularly masochistic challenge
    ago, is all grown-up. What started with       enormous challenge to all of us media      called Up the Buttress (The Buttress
    three people, one desk and one com-           luvvies, and something tells me that       being a ridiculously vertiginous,
    puter regularly employs more than             those 200 miles that separate us from      slimy, cobbled local “snicket”, to be
    150 talented programme-makers                 the metropolis are going to give us a      conquered on a mountain bike).
    across bases in Leeds and Manchester          creative edge in years to come.               The only way I can train is to do it
    and has 11 series in production.                Rather than seeing the M62 as            secretly – at 6:00am – while no one is
      The deal with Sky has been a long          a long, thin car park, we’re now            watching. Today I manage 25 metres
    time in the making and it’s both excit-      ­reimagining it as a cultural fault line    before coming off. Tomorrow, I am
    ing and a relief to finally tell our team.    across modern Britain. And we’re           determined it will be 30.
    We’re all fiercely proud of our inde-         perched right on top of it.
    pendent Northern roots and massively                                                     ■ The week that started so well has
    invigorated by what the future holds.        ■ One of our shows, Building the            ended even better. True North is
                                                 Dream, is exactly half way through a        named as one of the best places to
    ■ I’m woken slightly befuddled after         five-year, 100-part order. We want to       work in TV. A near crisis is averted
    last night’s fizz. Our development           make sure that we’re not missing any        after Dominos says our celebratory
    WhatsApp group is going crazy. My            tricks. Thankfully, we have some ded-       order is too big to deliver.
    co-creative director, Andrew Sheldon,        icated viewers inside the company.            Our brilliant office manager heads
    is at Realscreen with executive pro-            Today, we’re running a programme         into town to pick up the pizzas and
    ducer Fiona O’Sullivan - creator of          review. It’s like a book group but          we finally celebrate with a Skype
    our toe-­curlingly honest relationship       without the wine. The brilliant series      hook-up between the teams in Leeds
    show, The Lie Detective. Three US net-       producer is remarkably resilient as         and Manchester.
    works are fighting over the format.          his colleagues analyse and question
       Andrew and I have been partners           every part of the format.                   ■ Various members of the True North
    in crime for 23 years and he had felt           We come away with lots of tweaks         cycling team nobble me – to ask if
    torn – having to be away from base           – all within budget – that will give        Sky will provide brand new Pinarellos
    for our Sky announcement. He                 the show even greater production            for our little team or if Chris Froome
    seems to have cheered up now.                values and creative edge.                   can be our coach. I say I will investi-
                                                                                             gate. Maybe some jerseys, perhaps?
    ■ Try to run off the hangover with a         ■ We’re developing a dramatic trans-
    headtorch-lit riverside run at home          formation show with a BBC commis-           Jess Fowle is creative director and
    in Hebden Bridge, before setting off         sioning editor and I’m taking heart         co-founder of True North.

Television www.rts.org.uk February 2017                                                                                                5
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
Streaming facts
            from fiction

    H
                    ave Netflix and Amazon                                                 surrounding both shows. In December,
                    Prime Video finally come           Audience research                   the Mail on Sunday reported that Clark-
                    of age as viewing                                                      son’s The Grand Tour was the most ille-
                    platforms in the UK,                                                   gally-downloaded TV show in history.
                    thanks to the uber-hyped        How big are the                        The source was a piracy data firm
                    The Crown and The Grand
    Tour? But how many people have
                                                 changes in UK viewing                     called Muso.
                                                                                              The story was picked up by the
    watched these, the first two big British     habits that Netflix and                   Guardian, Independent, Daily Telegraph,
    commissions by the streaming                                                           Fortune and other media.
    companies? And what impact are the
                                                 Amazon are fostering?                        But Variety checked the details with
    video-streaming companies having                 Torin Douglas                         Muso and squashed the claim. It said
    on our viewing habits more generally?                                                  The Grand Tour may have had piracy
      With their huge budgets and endless             investigates                         problems but it “was not even close to
    press and online coverage, there is a lot                                              being the most-pirated show over the
    riding on the return of Jeremy Clark-       change is far less dramatic than the       last three weeks” – let alone ever.
    son and co, and the drama series about      internet cheerleaders would have us        Similarly, when Netflix launched The
    the young Queen Elizabeth.                  believe.                                   Crown, the Times proclaimed: “Stream-
      Since neither company will share its        “We are experiencing profound            ing upstarts seize traditional televi-
    viewing figures or UK subscription          change, with new ways to watch, and        sion’s crown. Britain is turning into
    numbers, it i s not easy to gauge their     new global providers of content,” says     a digital couch-potato economy, with
    real impact, but we can try to sift the     Jonathan Thompson, Chief Executive         four in five of us subscribing to at least
    fact from the fiction.                      of Digital UK, which co-ordinates the      one streaming service.”
      If you believe the headlines, services    Freeview DTT platform. “But it is really      Thompson publicly challenged this
    such as Netflix are carrying all before     important that we separate rhetoric        claim at Digital UK’s stakeholder con-
    them. But, while everyone agrees that       from reality and not get carried away      ference: “The survey’s ‘four in five’
    viewing habits are changing – particu-      with a Silicon Valley view of the future   figure was for people subscribing to
    larly among the young – the stalwarts       of broadcast TV.”                          any type of service, not just streaming
    of terrestrial television insist that the     There has been a fog of hype             – gym membership, publications,

6
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
compared directly, because Amazon            1.8 episodes, considerably fewer than
                                                          and Netflix don’t publish figures or         the top US shows on Amazon.
                                                          submit themselves to Barb’s strict              GfK says that this could be because
                                                          rules, as broadcasters do – though           viewers were disappointed after the
                                                          Amazon has made an approach.                 first episode or they simply hadn’t
                                                             “We had an enquiry                                            caught up yet. Ama-
                                                          recently from a repre-                                           zon releases a new
                                                         sentative of Amazon
                                                         about measuring audi-
                                                                                      A MASSIVE                            Grand Tour show every
                                                                                                                           Friday (in contrast to
                                                         ences for The Grand Tour,    37% OF THE                           Netflix, which puts out
                                                         but it came to nothing,”
                                                         wrote Barb CEO Justin        UK’S AMAZON                          a whole series straight
                                                                                                                           away); there were
                                                         Sampson on its website.
                                                         “I’ll leave you to draw
                                                                                      PRIME USERS                          eight episodes in
                                                                                                                           November and
                                                         your own conclusions.”       WATCHED THE                          December.
                                                             Barb requires all
                                                         programmes to be
                                                                                      GRAND TOUR                             “The Grand Tour is
                                                                                                                           astonishing,” says Julia
                                                         measured on a similar                                             Lamaison, insight
                                                         basis so that figures can                                         director of GfK UK.
                                                         be shared and compared. But Amazon            “I’ve never seen a pattern like that for
                                                         won’t even tell its series producers          any other original programme launch.
                                                         how their shows are doing.                    It certainly attracted a massive number
                                                             Clarkson has confirmed that The           of Amazon users and it will be inter-
                                                         Grand Tour team has not been told –           esting to see whether the interest con-
                                                         and will not be told – how many               tinues through time.”
                                                         ­people have watched the programme.              But how many people have actually
                                                          Amazon has revealed only that the            watched the show? GfK keeps this sort
                                                          show was its biggest premiere ever,          of analysis for the broadcasters and
                                                          “with millions of members streaming          platforms that subscribe to its tracker,
                                                          the first episode in the US, UK, Ger-        but we can make some assumptions.
                                                          many, Austria and Japan over the first          The latest Barb Establishment survey
                                                          weekend”.                                    shows that 6.13 million UK households
                                                             Netflix’s recently published results      subscribed to Netflix in the third quar-
              Netflix newcomer A Series
                                               Netflix

                                                          for Q4 2016 reveal a record quarterly        ter of 2016, while Amazon Prime mem-
                  of Unfortunate Events
                                                          rise in subscriptions, up by 7 million       bership grew strongly to 2.55 million.
                                                          to almost 94 million worldwide. At the          The survey shows that 13.8 million
software, music and so on,” he said.                      same time, Netflix confirmed plans to        adults had access to Netflix and
“It was commissioned by a company                         spend $6bn on content in 2017. But it        5.4 million to Amazon. A third of adults
called Zuora, which runs a subscription                   remains as coy as Amazon about its           – 16.9 million – had at least one SVoD
management programme.”                                    viewing figures. Chief content officer       service, including Now TV.
   The headline on Zuora’s press                          Ted Sarandos told analysts simply that          Assuming, as GfK says, that The Crown
release was dramatic, echoing a theme                     The Crown was “very popular” in the          reached 9% of 13.8 million Netflix
repeatedly peddled by internet busi-                      UK, and also did well across the US,         adults, it would mean that 1.2 million
nesses: “Is broadcast dead? Half of                       Europe, and Asia.                            saw at least part of an episode. If The
Brits now rarely watch ‘normal TV’ due                       Fortunately, the UK’s wealth of           Grand Tour reached 37% of Amazon’s
to Netflix and Amazon Video, finds                        research expertise and viewing data          5.4 million adults, the audience would
consumer research.”                                       means we can get a clearer picture.          work out at 2 million – at least for part
   This assertion was contradicted by                        Figures released to Television by GfK     of the first episode.
the release itself. It stated that a quarter              UK from its SVoD Content Tracker (see           That is good for a show that is not on
of British consumers subscribed to                        charts) show that The Crown and The          “normal” TV – the best-watched epi-
video streaming services and almost                       Grand Tour went straight to the top          sode of Game of Thrones on Sky Atlantic
half of these subscribers said they                       spots on their platforms in the UK.          got an average audience of 2 million.
rarely watched “normal” TV.                                  Across November and December              But it’s not large in UK audience terms
   “That’s 12% of the UK adult popula-                    2016, 9% of Netflix users watched The        (the Bake Off final topped 15 million) and
tion,” the release declared. But 12% is                   Crown, putting it well ahead of proven       it’s a lot less than Clarkson and chums
not “half of Brits”. And, as rigorous                     US hits such as Breaking Bad, Narcos,        got on Top Gear.
researchers know, what people say in                      Orange Is the New Black and Gilmore Girls.      So, what impact is internet video
a survey can be very different to what                    On average, these viewers watched 3.9        having on our viewing habits generally?
they actually do.                                         of The Crown’s 10 episodes.                     UK subscriptions to Netflix and
   So how do The Crown and The Grand                         A massive 37% of the UK’s Amazon          Amazon Prime are undoubtedly grow-
Tour compare with the most popular                        Prime users watched The Grand Tour,          ing, boosted by The Crown and The Grand
series on “normal” TV, such as The Great                  four times the figure for the number-        Tour, but most viewers seem to use
British Bake Off, Strictly Come Dancing, and              two show, The Man in the High Castle.        them as additions to broadcast TV,
Planet Earth II? Their audiences can’t be                 But on average they only watched             not as replacements. �

Television www.rts.org.uk February 2017                                                                                                               7
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
� And change is happening faster
    Orange Is the                                                                        among the young. A much higher
    New Black
                                                                                         proportion of the 16-34 age group
                                                                                         have access to an SVoD service and
                                                                                         they are watching less live TV than
                                                                                         they did two years ago.
                                                                                            According to Barb, this group’s
                                                                                         average viewing fell to 1 hour 54 min-
                                                                                         utes a day in 2016, from 2 hours 4
                                                                                         minutes in 2015. Ofcom’s Digital Day
                                                                                         diary survey agrees, and records a
                                                                                         steeper fall over the past two years.
                                                                                            But the young have always watched
                                                                                         less TV than all adults and, among
                                                                                         viewers as a whole, the drop in view-
      Netflix                                                                            ing to “normal” TV is much lower.
                                                		Average                                Barb and Thinkbox say it is down by
      Top 10 Netflix programmes           Percentage Percentage streams/                 just three minutes a day, from 3 hours
      November/December 2016                of total   of total episodes                 26 minutes in 2015 to 3 hours 23 min-
                                             users    streams   per user                 utes last year. They insist that broad-
      The Crown                               9%               4%             3.9        cast TV remains easily the most
      Breaking Bad                            6%               4%             5.4        popular form of video.
      Narcos                                  6%               3%             5.1           “TV – live, playback or on-demand,
      Orange is the New Black                 5%               3%             4.4        across all screens – had a 76% share
      Gilmore Girls                           4%               2%             5.1        of total video viewing in 2015 in the
      Once Upon a Time                        4%               2%             4.5        UK,” declared a recent publication,
      Marvel’s Luke Cage                      4%               2%             4.7        “TV in the video world”, published by
      Stranger Things                         3%               2%             4.7        Thinkbox and the Marketing Society.
      Sons of Anarchy                         1%               2%            15.4        “SVoD viewing – Netflix, Amazon
      Star Trek: Deep Space Nine              1%               2%            10.8        Prime and other SVoD services –
                              Source: GfK Subscription Video on Demand Content Tracker   totalled 4%,” it said. The YouTube
                                                                                         figure was 4.4%.
                                                                                            Yet, many people in TV find it hard
    The Man in the                                                                       to accept this. Nigel Walley, Managing
    High Castle                                                                          Director of Decipher, the media strat-
                                                                                         egy consultancy, wrote recently:
                                                                                         “Speaking at a conference, I quoted
                                                                                         an Ofcom figure about the resilience
                                                                                         of linear broadcast viewing in UK TV.
                                                                                            “After my talk, I was accused of
                                                                                         lying about it by an audience mem-
                                                                                         ber. It was a strangely shocking
                                                                                         moment. They were convinced that
                                                                                         the truth they felt in their gut was
                                                                                         more true than an exhaustively
                                                                                         researched Ofcom number.”
                                                                                            The Chair of Thinkbox, Tess Alps,
      Amazon Prime                                                                       tirelessly challenges all misleading
                                                		Average                                claims about “the death of TV”. She
      Top 10 Amazon programmes            Percentage Percentage streams/                 says: “We’ve recently published a
      November/December 2016                of total   of total episodes                 study through Ipsos, called “TV nation/
                                             users    streams   per user                 ad nation”, which looks at marketers’
      The Grand Tour                         37%              13%             1.8        opinions of what consumers do. It’s
      The Man in the High Castle              9%               6%             3.6        pretty terrifying. If you ask marketers
      Lucifer                                 8%               5%             3.1        how much time they think the aver-
      The Walking Dead                        6%               5%             4.2        age person is watching YouTube, they
      Mr Robot                                5%               5%             4.3        say over an hour a day – the real
      Vikings                                 5%               4%             4.1        number is 16 minutes.”
      Black Sails                             2%               3%             9.3           It may be apocryphal, but an Amazon
      Arrow                                   2%               3%             9.2        executive was recently quoted as say-
      Outlander                               3%               3%             4.7        ing that no one in north London
      Prison Break                            2%               2%             6.3        watches broadcast TV any more.
                              Source: GfK Subscription Video on Demand Content Tracker   To which the response was “in your
                                                                                         dreams”.

8                                                                                               February 2017 www.rts.org.uk Television
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
Flying
     high
    under
     the
    radar
             The Billen profile

     Miranda Curtis, a key
    player in the expansion
     of cable TV and BA’s
      all-time top woman
       passenger, gives a

                                                                                                                                         Liberty Global
        rare interview to
          Andrew Billen

    W
                              hen you are       painfully young in Japanese business        bewildering summary of acquisitions
                              talking to a      years, rather than over the hill), to her   and renamings – been huge but was
                              woman as          benefit.                                    only really noticed by customers
                              successful          “A Japanese colleague,” she tells me      when it reacquired Virgin Media
                              as the former     over coffee in a London business            in 2013.
                              president of a    centre, “said to me one night after            Privacy is also part of Curtis’s style.
    key division of Liberty Global, a multi-­   we’d had quite a lot of sake, ‘Miranda-­    When she tells me that Vanity Fair has
    millionaire who has driven the expan-       san, you have to understand that, to        recently brought Malone back from
    sion of cable television and telephony      us, all western men look exactly the        its “hall of fame” into the main body
    across the world, and who is now            same, particularly Americans: square        of its annual power list because, at 75,
    firmly in the ranks of Britain’s great      jaw, blue eyes, same shirts. At least we    he is still such a “player”, I ask if she
    and good, it is hard to prosecute the       can remember which one you are.’”           is on any list.
    case that sexism has held her back.           Here, however, few people would              “No. Not the power list. Nor the gay
       Miranda Curtis, however, has no          recognise the neat, blonde, composed        power list.”
    compunction in saying she has               yet forthright woman, now a youthful           Would she want to be? “No. Not
    encountered it, not least in Japan,         61, who is talking to me. There are         interested.” She is not in Who’s Who,
    where she struck one of telephony’s         reasons for this. Liberty Global,           I notice. “Not in Who’s Who, not on
    deals of the century without – for fear     chaired by the low-key John Malone          Wikipedia, nothing. It suits me fine.”
    of frightening the locals – ever being      (go on, tell me you could pick him out         Why? Why doesn’t she want to
    named as chair of the company on            in a line-up                                shout about what she’s done, and as
    whose behalf she was negotiating.           of American tycoons), does not court        a gay woman? “I just fly under the
       Somehow, she turned the curse of         publicity.                                  radar. It’s the way I always was. It’s
    being, as she puts it, “female, foreign       Its role in British cable has – as        very effective. I get on with my life
    and fortysomething” (which is               Curtis will explain to me in a              and do interesting things and meet

Television www.rts.org.uk February 2017                                                                                                               9
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
The Curtis                             interest­ing people. I don’t feel the need
                                            for it.” �
                                                                                           struction. So what we’re doing now in
                                                                                           the UK is bringing Virgin Media back
     chronicles                             � This, it turns out, is only the second
                                            full-blown press interview she has
                                                                                           up to the standards of some of our
                                                                                           other networks in Europe.”
                                            ever given in Britain. But we should              But some Virgin employees feel that,
                                            not mistake reticence for bashfulness.         under its new owners, it has lost its old
                                            Curtis knows her worth. Early on, she          Bransonian spirit, I venture. “It’s got a
                                            tells me she is “the grandmother of the        Liberty spirit, instead,” she says firmly.
                                            British cable industry”, having written           She was raised in a home full of the
                                            some of the original cable franchise           spirit of inquiry. Her father was editor
                                            applications that created what is now          of the liberal-minded News Chronicle,
                                            Virgin Media. Of her work in Japan, she        her mother, a sub-editor on The Sunday
                                            calls it “the most successful investment       Graphic. Miranda was three when they
                                            Liberty Global has ever made”.                 split up, but she continued to see her
     Miranda Curtis, board member of            She joined the Malone empire in            father, who, by then, was working for
     Liberty Global, Marks & Spencer,       1992 and, although she left the staff          the Aga Khan and was pleased to
     RSC, Garsington Opera and the          six years ago, she remains on Liberty          introduce her to travel in both Europe
     Institute for Government               Global’s board. Malone has been loyal          and Africa.
                                            to her, and she is a loyalist back.               Her mother reinforced the interna-
     Born 26 November 1955; brought             I ask her about the recent acquisition     tionalism by sending her and twin
     up in London with two brothers         by the sister company, Liberty Media,          sister Julie (now a Russian literature
     and one twin sister                    of Formula One. She says that “John”           don at Oxford) to the Lycée Français
     Father Michael Curtis, editor of the   has always invested in content, as well        in London. The result was that, when
     News Chronicle and later executive     as distribution, and “it’s an increasingly     they had something to conceal from
     aide to the Aga Khan                   porous industry”.                              their mother, they’d say it in French.
     Mother Barbara Gough, sub-editor           He seems, I suggest, to be looking            After studying Spanish at Durham
                                            forward to President Trump loosening           University, Curtis took a graduate
     Single But previously in a civil       the rules for the US cable industry and,       traineeship at the BBC. In those days,
     partnership                            by doing so, opening the way for some          linguists tended to head there or the
     Lives Central London (where            big mergers.                                   Foreign Office.
     she cannot get Virgin cable) and           “I think one of John’s great strengths        She found a role subtitling and dub-
     Oxfordshire (ditto)                    is that he’s never got involved in poli-       bing foreign programmes, but it only
     Education Lycée Français, London;      tics, at all, directly,” she responds. “Is     lasted a year. Rather than accept a
     Durham University (read Spanish)       he, by nature, on the Republican liber-        secretarial job, she applied for a posi-
                                            tarian end of the spectrum? Abso-              tion in BBC Enterprises selling BBC
     1977 BBC graduate trainee              lutely. Is he an economic liberal?             programmes abroad.
     1978 Joins BBC Enterprises,            Absolutely.”                                      Aged 25, with no training, she found
     followed by a spell at Robert              And then there is Liberty Global’s         herself travelling to the US to imple-
     Maxwell-owned tech company             CEO, Mike Fries, quoted at Davos,              ment a new North American distribu-
     Pergamon Compact Solutions             ­worrying that Brexit may lead to less         tion contract and sell shows such as Life
     1988 Joins United Cable, which later    investment in the UK (although not            on Earth. She became commercial man-
     becomes TCI                             from Liberty).                                ager for the BBC Micro computer initia-
     1992 International development             Liberty Global, she points out, was a      tive and the BBC Domesday Project.
     director for Europe and Asia, TCI       major supporter of the Remain cam-               Deciding that she needed a business
     International                           paign, after “a very interesting debate       education, she enrolled at London
     1996 Executive vice-president, Lib-     around the board table, where many            Business School. To pay off the fees,
     erty Media International Holdings       individuals would probably instinc-           she joined Robert Maxwell’s CD-Rom
     2005 President, Liberty Global          tively have been Brexit supporters”.          publishing house and then United
     Japan Division                             So the company favours the “consist-       Cable, where her great adventure in
     2010 Completes sale of Liberty          ent European media and telecoms               cable began.
     Global’s Japanese assets                regulation policy” it helped shape. Its          Out in Denver, John Malone was as
     2010 Takes early retirement, joins      $4bn investment in British cable is safe:     interested as she was in a country
     Liberty Global board                                    “In the years that we         starting a cable industry from scratch,
     2011 Chair of Waterstones after its                         didn’t own the com-       and not just for TV but for telephony.
     sale to Alexander Mamut                                          pany, there was no   He was interested in Curtis, too, and
     2012 Joins board of Marks & Spencer                                 investment in     flew her over in May 1992 to appoint
                                                                              network      her as the first development director
     Watching Unforgotten on catch-up                                            con-      of what was then TCI International.
     Reading Barkskins by Annie Proulx                                                        “He said, ‘There is the planet. Go and
     (‘not yet convinced’)                                                                 tell me what we can do.’ And that was
     Expertise ‘Cultural management –                                                      my job description. We divided the
     which is unusual’                                                                     planet into three. I had Asia, Pacific
     Hobby Scuba diving                                                                    and Continental Europe. That was my
                                                                                           patch. And for the next 12 years – a

10
Who's watching? Fact and fiction in streaming TV - Plus - Royal Television Society
corporate history. Liberty got a pre-
                                                                                                            mium of 60% on the share price. With
                                                                                                            a few concurrent exits, Liberty was
                                                                                                            handed $14bn, on a total investment

                           ‘THERE IS THE                                                                    over the years of less than $1bn.
                                                                                                               Wasn’t the trouble with this that she
                          PLANET. GO AND                                                                    had negotiated herself, aged 54, out of

                           TELL ME WHAT                                                                     a job that paid her over £1m a year?
                                                                                                               “Well, I did, exactly. So, at that point,
                         WE CAN DO.’ AND                                                                    I thought, ‘Crikey’, but I also definitely
                                                                                                            needed to get off a plane. At that stage,
                           THAT WAS MY                                                                      I was in BA’s all-time top flyers. I’m

                         JOB DESCRIPTION                                                                    still BA all-time top female passenger.
                                                                                                            I’ve just had my 16th black card.”
                                                                                                               Had all that flying, all that work, con-
                                                                                                            tributed to the end of her civil partner-
                                                                                                            ship, I ask. “I think that’s a personal
                                                                                                            question I’m not prepared to discuss.
                                                                                                            I think the point is that, actually, I was
                                                                                                            spending at least two weeks of the
                                                                                                            month on a farm [her second home
                                                                                                            near Woodstock]. There was quite a lot
                                                                                                            of time where, actually, I could live a
                                                                                                            completely normal existence.”
                                                                                                               In Denver, Malone asked her to take
                                                                                                            early retirement – which she could
                                                                                                            afford to do having made her own
                                                                                                            money from the J:Com sale – but
                                                                                                            remain in the “family”, as a non-­
                                                                                                            executive board member.
                                                                                                               Now began a different sort of life; on
                                                                                                            the board of Marks & Spencer: chairing,
                                                                                                            until last July, Waterstones; director-
                                                                                                            ships at the RSC and Garsington Opera.
                                                                                                            She is also on the board of the Institute
                                                                                                            for Government, an influential think
                                                                                                            tank that examines the machinery of
                                                                                                            government (she was “stunned” to find
                                                                                                            that each department had a separate
                                                                                        123RF Photography

                                                                                                            way of measuring its performance).In
                                                                                                            addition, she chairs the African girls’
                                                                                                            education charity Camfed, which, she
                                                                                                            says, in five years has educated more
                                                                                                            than 2 million children.
                                                                                                               What I cannot tell, because I don’t
bit more than that ‑ I didn’t have an        To begin with, the male Japanese                               understand the business mind, is
employment contract, I didn’t have a      board she headed in all but title at the                          whether she would have been as bril-
job description, I never had an           cable business J:Com would go behind                              liant in any other business. She says
appraisal. I worked my way up the         her back to Malone to ask if she could                            she has always been interested in
ranks and I could bring back anything     really have meant what she said. Yes,                             communication technologies and
I wanted in distribution, content and     she did, he always told them.                                     communicating between different
technology, joint ventures, directions,      “In the later years, I simply became a                         cultures. There is a synergy there.
partnerships.”                            senior, genderless, hierarchical construct.                          I ask if Liberty’s old slogan, “Connect,
  She was flying from her base in         It was a very comfortable place to be.”                           discover, be free” – recently replaced by
Denver to Europe and Singapore. She          For a year, she nursed KDDI, the                               “Investing, innovating and empowering”
bought content, but wholesale through     second-largest wireless operator in                               – spoke to her, especially. “They are,”
companies such as Discovery, never        Japan, as a potential buyer for Global’s                          she says, “useful slogans around which
imposing her will on programmes.          37.8% stake in J:Com, unsure if it would                          to rally executive teams.”
  Between 1991 and 2002, Malone           finally bid. In December 2009, KDDI                                  Well, I say, in any case, congratula-
owned UK cable franchises and then        asked for a meeting with Mike Fries.                              tions. She never expected to go into
he moved out. There was a setback in      With unheard-of directness, they said                             business, and she made an absolute
Germany. So it was in Japan that glory    they wanted to buy.                                               fortune. “I hope,” she responds, “that
awaited her, once its government             On 24 January, the sale was announ­                            I’ve created an absolute fortune.”
relaxed ownership rules.                  ced, the fastest deal in Japanese                                    No doubt about that, either.

Television www.rts.org.uk February 2017                                                                                                                    11
Trust us,
                                        not them
     T
                     rolls, bots, Russian                                                   the technology companies had inter-
                     hackers, fake news,                 Television news                    posed themselves between media and
                     disinformation and lies                                                audience to cream off both revenue
                     – 2016 was the year that                                               and valuable user data.
                     news seemed to collapse      Objective facts are                          And there are editorial problems for
                     into Hunter S Thomp-
     son’s dystopian vision of television
                                                  scarcer than ever in                      news online. Social media rewards
                                                                                            speed and sensation over accuracy.
     as a “cruel and shallow money trench,         an era defined by                        While it is true that “if you’re first and
     a long plastic hallway where thieves                                                   wrong, you’re not first”, Macedonian
     and pimps run free and good men die           Trump and Brexit.                        teenagers making money from fake
     like dogs”.
        Which leaves those of us who still,
                                                  Richard Sambrook                          news don’t care.
                                                                                               BuzzFeed co-founder Jonah Peretti
     quaintly, believe in the civic value of    asks if UK broadcasters                     tells us that sharing is the key indicator
     good journalism in a quandary: where                                                   of user value for media on the internet.
     can we find the truth in a world of        can rise to the challenge                   He’s not a man to bet against. But,
     “alternative facts”?                                                                   although sharing may reveal what
        There’s good news and bad news.            There is a crisis in print journalism.   interests the public, it is no indicator
     The bad news has been much dis-            Newspaper advertising is still falling,     of what is in the public interest.
     cussed in the aftermath of Donald          newsrooms are being hollowed out,              Traditional media still carries an
     Trump’s election and the Brexit result.    and, in a race for impact, many news-       inherited sense of the civic importance
     Undoubtedly, the media has problems.       papers are becoming more partisan,          of news and information. A series of
     Faced with successful political cam-       fixing facts around political policy.       algorithmic misjudgements last year
     paigns based on lies, many have lam-          Social media – which many hoped          illustrated how tech companies are
     basted the news for false equivalence      would be a saviour with its open            struggling with that public expectation
     and balance.                               access, extensive reach, targeted           and responsibility.
        In a climate where politicians          advertising and user convenience               Social media held such promise for
     increasingly see media as either “with     – turns out to have problems, too.          democratic engagement and collabo-
     us or against us”, and where expertise        Over the past two years, news            ration, but too much of it has become
     is actively undermined, the space for      organisations piled into distributed        a noxious echo-chamber undermining
     neutral, open debate is shrinking.         content strategies only to discover that    the public interest by treating political

12
2016 SHOWED
      journalism as a commodity no differ-
      ent to the latest cat video.                  THAT, IN SPITE                                   In turn, news organisations should
                                                                                                  open up their own methods to rebuild
        It is not just the media that has prob-     OF ALL THAT                                   trust. Media, more than is generally
      lems: society remains deeply divided
      and rancorous in spite of repeated urg-       AUDIENCE                                      acknowledged, has to work to repair its
                                                                                                  relationship with much of the public.
      ings from all sides of every debate to        RESEARCH, NEWS                                Regional broadcasting’s proximity to
      “get over it”. This seems unlikely to heal
      in the short term. Polarised politics and     ORGANISATIONS                                 the audience ought to help - along
                                                                                                  with a greater dose of humility.
      “post-truth” campaigning have proved          DID NOT                                          Reuters has moved fast to introduce
      highly successful in the past year – so
      we should expect more, along with
                                                    UNDERSTAND                                    greater transparency into its news
                                                                                                  operations. Editor-in-chief Steve Adler
      more shouts of “fake news” directed at        THEIR PUBLIC                                  says that it is time to “double down”
      anything anyone disagrees with.
        If nothing else, 2016 showed that, in
                                                    IN KEY RESPECTS                               on being good, dispassionate journal-
                                                                                                  ists and “open the door” a little bit
      spite of all that audience research,                                                        more on how Reuters obtains and
      news organisations did not understand                                                       handles information.
      their public in key respects. Public            A glance across the Atlantic at what           Other organisations should follow its
      disenchantment with “elites” ran far          has happened to US broadcasting since         lead. In broadcasting, many people still
      deeper than they recognised.                  the end of the Fairness Doctrine in the       judge a devil’s advocate question to be
        In return, the public doesn’t under-        1980s, which required broadcasters to         tantamount to betraying the inter-
      stand the media. Levels of media liter-       provide balance, should be sufficient         viewer’s personal view. Or fail to see a
      acy remain low; and trust, even in            warning not to follow suit.                   distinction between a political editor’s
      broadcasters, continues to fall. The sins       Furthermore, at a time when audi-           professional judgement and their per-
      of toxic media have cross-contaminated        ences are questioning who they can            sonal opinion.
      even the best – much of the public            trust, regulation should be a differenti-        Journalists have developed a profes-
      lumps “the media” into one odorous            ating mark of quality from the press          sional shorthand in how they report
      bucket.                                       and online-only services – offering           – understood by those inside their
        So where, in all of this, is the good       clear, independent accountability.            bubble but, I suspect, not by many
      news? Well, there is a real opportunity         There are more signs for optimism           outside. On Google trends, two of the
      here – particularly for broadcasters.         in the early response of major news           most searched-for terms in the past
BBC

        As the new wave of populism seeks           organisations to the current moral            year were “austerity” and “populism”.
      to rearrange the political landscape and      panic over false news.                        Yet, day in, day out, report after report
      dismiss old assumptions, it provides            The BBC’s announcement of a per-            assumes these and other once-obscure
      plenty of meat for journalists to dig into.   manent “Reality Check” team to hunt           terms are widely understood.
      Weak political leadership and poor            down and flag fake news, as well as              Broadcasters could do more to sup-
      accountability should feed a renaissance      fact-check the politicians, is welcome.       port greater media literacy among the
      in investigative journalism. And broad-         Fact-checking is clearly going to           public by explaining the complex world
      casters still have the resources to do it.    become a more central part of the news        we are now in, as well as better
        Those of us who have been judging           offer – building on Channel 4’s success       explaining how they report it and
      this year’s RTS Television Journalism         with FactCheck, and sites such as Full        arrive at their own news judgements.
      Awards cannot fail to be impressed by         Fact. It is one clear way of increasing the      Greater transparency and accounta-
      the quality of Britain’s broadcast jour-      cost of political lying, which currently      bility are much needed in the current
      nalism. Fresh, original investigation on      appears to be too cheap.                      climate of misinformation, political lies
      topics outside the main agenda, such as                                                     and widespread distrust.
      Michael Crick’s pursuit of Tory election                                                       But, above all, the strength of broad-
      expenses for Channel 4 or the BBC’s
      long-term commitment to investigating         FAR FROM                                      casting’s case to “trust us, not them”
                                                                                                  will lie in sharp, confident, fair report-
      mental-health provision. We don’t             INHIBITING A                                  ing. That means journalism that is
      celebrate it enough.
        Perhaps unfashionably, I believe            BROAD RANGE                                   differentiated and breaks from the
                                                                                                  pack, that is clearly in touch with pub-
      that this strength is rooted in broadcast     OF VIEWS,                                     lic concerns and attitudes, and which
      regulation. We will shortly face, I am
      sure, another round of argument to            PROPERLY                                      is confident in holding the powerful to
                                                                                                  account and calling out lies or spin.
      loosen the impartiality rules that apply      APPLIED                                          These are the qualities that will keep
      to broadcasters – it would be a mistake
      to do so.
                                                    IMPARTIALITY                                  news out of Hunter S Thompson’s
                                                                                                  media sewer. They are the traditional
        From the BBC to ITV, Channel 4 to           REGULATION                                    strengths of British TV journalism –
      Sky, we keep each other honest and
      raise the bar. Far from inhibiting a
                                                    SHOULD                                        and are needed now more than ever.

      broad range of views, properly applied        ENCOURAGE                                     Richard Sambrook is professor of journal-
      impartiality regulation should encour-
      age such views.
                                                    SUCH VIEWS                                    ism, Cardiff University, and a former
                                                                                                  director of BBC News.

      Television www.rts.org.uk February 2017                                                                                                  13
The
     insider’s
     insider
                          D
                                           avid Clementi is the         for what is intended to be a full-time
       BBC governance                      first Chairman of a          job, might put off potential candidates
                                           single, unitary BBC          less financially fortunate than himself.
        Roger Bolton                       Board, his appointment
                                           confirmed by Parlia-
                                                                        Presumably, he will give up his current
                                                                        roles as chairman of both World First,
     profiles the BBC’s                    ment and the Sover-          a currency exchange firm, and King’s
                          eign. He is now Mr BBC and the                Cross Central, the company overseeing
       new Chairman,      Director-General works directly to him.       development of the land around the
      David Clementi,         From now on, there is no debate
                          about who runs the corporation, no
                                                                        London station.
                                                                          He is relatively old: he is 68 this
       who arrives at     discussion about whether the gover-           month. He is, therefore, unlikely to be
                          nors or the Trust are more powerful           looking for another job following this
     the corporation in   than the Executive. There is only one         one. This could make him more inde-
        testing times     Board and he runs it. Indeed, he
                          designed it. So he can hardly blame
                                                                        pendent (although a peerage would be
                                                                        a nice reward for being a successful
                          anyone else if it goes wrong. And, of         BBC chairman).
                          course, things often go wrong.                  Clementi certainly knows about
                              In many ways, Sir David is well           money. He has been, among other
                          ­qualified for the job of which he is the     things, Chairman of Virgin Money,
                           architect. He is rich and, according to a    Chairman of the Prudential, a Deputy
                           friend, “has never had to worry about        Governor of the Bank of England and
                           money”.                                      Vice-Chairman of Kleinwort Benson.
                              That will help, as his £100,000 salary,   He advised Margaret Thatcher on the

14
chaired by an ex-head of defence pro-        BBC can cut around 25% – according
                                                  curement and included a former private       to some estimates – off its spending
                                                  secretary to the Queen and a permanent       over the next few years. It seems cer-
                                                  secretary of the DCMS. One might be          tain that more services will have to go;
                                                  tempted to say that the Establishment        salami slicing will not be enough.
                                                  has got its man.                                Clementi arrives just as BBC Studios
                                                     Clearly, if you think the most impor-     prepares to begin operating as a com-
                                                  tant thing about the person running one      mercial division. In one of its final acts,
                                                  of the greatest broadcasting organisa-       the Trust recently gave the go-ahead to
                                                  tions in the world should not be tainted     the revamped BBC Studios, but the
                                                  by any experience of broadcasting,           trade unions are going to ballot their
                                                  David Clementi is the ideal choice.          members about strike action.
                                                     However the job of the BBC is not to         Some independent producers think
                                                  make a profit, but to produce brilliant      that the only way Studios can cut its
                                                  public service programmes. Its job is to     cost base is by making more staff
                                                  reflect the complex and varied cultures      redundant, changing employment
                                                  of the UK.                                   practices for the worse and issuing far
                                                     Its job, more necessary than ever in      more short-term contracts.
                                                  these divided times, is to speak truth          In other words, greater casualisation
                                                  to power. The BBC should, on occa-           and a widening of the gap between
                                                  sions, embarrass and anger govern-           pay levels at the BBC. This is unlikely
                                                  ments. Is Sir David up for that?             to enhance staff morale.
                                                     Does the new Chairman know how               If Studios is to make a profit, surely
                                                  to create the best conditions for crea-      it will have to concentrate on popular
                                                  tive talent? Will he encourage those         formats, returning series and shows
THE BBC                                           who have an appetite for making
                                                  trouble?
                                                                                               that have foreign sales potential. The
                                                                                               purely public service programmes that
SHOULD, ON                                           Is he ready for the full fury of the      only the BBC can provide will have to

OCCASIONS,                                        Brexit debate as we move towards
                                                  withdrawal, or the Trumpian blasts
                                                                                               be subsidised in some way.
                                                                                                  So much now depends on brilliant
EMBARRASS                                         that blowing across the Atlantic?
                                                     Who wants a well-run, efficient
                                                                                               commissioners with a passion for their
                                                                                               subject matter and the confidence to
AND ANGER                                         organisation that makes dull pro-            fight their corner. Does the new Board
GOVERNMENTS.                                      grammes and safe journalism? Perhaps
                                                  certain members of the Establishment
                                                                                               know what is needed to find, enthuse
                                                                                               and empower them?
IS SIR DAVID UP                                   do, but not the licence-fee payers who          Clementi, like most politicians in

FOR THAT?                                         are the BBC’s shareholders.
                                                     By the way, does the new Chairman
                                                                                               Westminster, knows about The Great
                                                                                               British Bake Off and the Today programme
                                                  have any ideas about how to make the         – but how much else? The lifestyles of
                                            BBC

                                                  corporation properly accountable to          such public figures leave them little
                                                  those who pay for it, as well as to those    time for watching or listening. But he
privatisation of another great British            who regulate it?                             appears to be an exception, having
organisation, BT.                                    Clementi’s in-tray is full to overflow-   recently told the Commons that he is
   He is, in other words, the epitome of          ing. He has to form an effective relation­   an avid TV watcher, and that his “spe-
the City grandee.                                 ship with the BBC’s new regulator,           cialist subject is BBC One and BBC
   Clementi knows about regulation as             Ofcom. He has to select the other new        Two between 8:00pm and 11:00pm”.
well, having undertaken a wide-ranging            members of the unitary Board.                   Clementi does have interests beyond
independent review of the regulation                 There are, at present, four seats set     his professional world. For example, he
of legal services in England and Wales            aside for members of the executive.          is a keen yachtsman and seems pas-
in 2003.                                          The DG, Tony Hall, and his deputy,           sionate about sport.
   City colleagues, such as Lord Myners,          Anne Bulford, get two of them. Pre-             The new Chairman will be on a
have called him “an inspired choice”              sumably, James Harding, director of          steep learning curve and will have to
and “very wise and sensible”, “a man              news, gets the third.                        take some crucial decisions very early
of high integrity”. He certainly feels at            That seems to leave a choice              in his tenure. We must all wish him
home in the establishment.                        between director of content Charlotte        luck and hope that he goes a little, but
   Clementi’s grandfather was Gover-              Moore and director of radio and edu-         not too, native.
nor of Hong Kong, and his father was              cation James Purnell for the fourth.            At the very least, he should be pre-
an air vice-marshal. He was educated                 And Clementi has to make this deci-       pared to lose some friends in the Gov-
at Winchester and Oxford and then                 sion with a view to developing poten-        ernment and the Establishment. He
qualified as a chartered accountant.              tial successors to Tony Hall as DG. In       ought to find that being Chairman of
   He has been Warden of Winchester               that case, Purnell’s political past as a     the BBC is a lonely job.
College and Master of the Mercers’                Labour culture secretary will, presum-
Company.                                          ably, count against him.                     Roger Bolton is a former BBC and ITV
   The panel that appointed him was                  Another pressing problem is how the       executive, and independent producer.

Television www.rts.org.uk February 2017                                                                                                      15
TV sport

                        Is TV’s coverage of female sport finally heading into the
                           mainstream? Ross Biddiscombe canvasses opinion

        Promotion year for
         women’s sports?
     I
               n a year when women’s sports      committed as ever to women’s sports.          being regarded as secondary to the
               events will be at the forefront   She argues that it is not necessary to        male equivalents.
               of many broadcasters’             operate any kind of quota system                 “We judge all sports the same,” he
               schedules, it’s a legitimate      because audiences are increasing.             says. “It’s about the potential audience,
               time to ask if these sports are     “We have provided live TV coverage          the brand that we have developed and
               poised for a breakthrough.        of women’s football since the mid-1990s       the commercial reality. We welcome
        More women are taking part in sport      and audience interest has grown con-          great women’s sport because what we
     than ever before and there are more         siderably,” says Slater. “More people         really want is the best sporting stories,
     hours of women’s sport on TV, includ-       watched the 2015 Women’s World Cup            wherever they come from.”
     ing significant numbers of live fixtures.   on BBC TV than our live coverage of              Both the UK’s pay-TV sports chan-
     But is the coverage better and is           the men’s Open golf championship.”            nels, Sky Sports and BT Sports, are big
     change happening fast enough?                 For new women’s football broad-             supporters of women’s cricket. Sky
        Some observers would argue that,         caster Channel 4 and Eurosport (the           Sports has been broadcasting the game
     judged by audiences, commercial             pan-European channel covering the             for two decades and is showing this
     return on investment and scheduling,        women’s Euros), the national game is          year’s women’s World Cup. BT Sport,
     women’s sports on TV still lag woefully     seen as one of the breakthrough sports        meanwhile, has just announced its
     behind men’s.                               for women. Strong performances by             coverage of the women’s Ashes series
        A level playing field for coverage       either England or Scotland in the tour-       and the Big Bash league from Australia.
     with men’s events is rare. The obvious      nament would develop that trend.                 In addition, Sky Sports News
     exceptions are grand slam tennis tour-        Although Channel 4 is very selective        launched the SportsWomen magazine
     naments, major track and field events       in broadcasting any sporting event            show in 2012. It was one of the many
     and both winter and summer Olympics.        – male or female – its commissioning          initiatives that grew out of the success
        Everywhere else, the inequality          editor for sport, Stephen Lyle, wants to      of the London Olympics.
     remains a sensitive topic for partici-      build on his channel’s reputation for            SportsWomen producer Anna Edwards
     pants, administrators, fans and view-       innovation: “Our remit is always to go        believes women’s sports need to have
     ers, as well as broadcasters.               for programming that has an underdog          their own identities. “We want to get to
        There, it seems, is no shortage of       quality, and this falls into that category.   a point where we don’t have the term
     goodwill for events such as the UEFA          “We’ll try and bring something new          ‘women’s sport’,” she insists. “We actu-
     women’s European football tourna-           to the coverage, but the women also           ally have debates about this and, just to
     ment, the women’s cricket World Cup         have to step up, entertain and show           make the point that it’s all just sport, we
     and Ashes series and golf’s Solheim         the audience what they can do.”               dropped the word ‘women’ from the
     Cup to succeed on screen, but question        Eurosport CEO Peter Hutton argues           caption when referring to Mark Samp-
     marks remain. This month, Sky               that producers and broadcasters must          son, the England women’s manager.
     announced that it would show live           not skimp on production quality, if              “Those are small points, but changes
     domestic cricket for the first time on      they are to stop women’s competitions         like that make a difference. If we sat
     UK television, this summer, with eight                                                    here in five years’ time and the situation
     matches from the Kia Super League.                                                        was the same, then I’d be concerned.”
        Inevitably, the BBC has the longest
     history of broadcasting women’s             WE WANT TO                                       When BT Sport launched in 2013, one
                                                                                               of its justifications for claiming to be a
     sports. These days, however, the rights     GET TO A POINT                                game changer in British TV sport was
     are spread around – Channel 4, for
     example, has outbid the Beeb for UK
                                                 WHERE WE DON’T                                the signing of high-profile presenter
                                                                                               Clare Balding.
     rights to the women’s Euros.                HAVE THE TERM                                    She was given her own chat show,
        BBC head of sport Barbara Slater
     says the corporation remains as
                                                 ‘WOMEN’S SPORT’                               with a brief to focus on women guests.
                                                                                               The channel has also heavily backed

16
live women’s sport: BT Sport has a           stadium means more exciting TV.” One      Football Union’s policy of staging Eng-
particularly high profile for tennis and     strategy that both the federations and    land women’s test matches ahead of
hockey.                                      the broadcasters want to avoid is         the men’s Six Nations games will ben-
   “There are nearly 1,000 hours of live     “ghettoisation” – in other words, gath-   efit from live Sky Sports
WTA tennis on our channel and, in            ering women’s sports in a separate        coverage this season.
terms of hours, that’s more than the         part of the schedule.                       “It is naive to
English Premier League or Champions             Every broadcaster thinks this is       think that only
League or MotoGP,” says Simon Green,         inappropriate, especially given the       women watch
head of BT Sport.                            efforts of female athletes to appeal      women’s
   He adds: “We’re doing much of it          to male viewers as well as female.                                          sports,”
with our own commentary teams and               Instead, many sports are moving                                        says Sky’s
our own personalities on screen. It’s        towards Olympic-style formats that                                     Edwards.
the same with the Women’s Super              allow men and women to perform at                                    “More aware-
League in this country. We treat those       the same time and location, as with a                              ness will breed
OBs the same as we do men’s football.”       grand slam tennis event.                                        more viewers, both
   But Green also understands that              The Boat Race on the BBC adopted                           men and women.”
there is plenty of catching up to do. He     this approach in 2015, with male and                          None of the channels,
knows that high production values do         female crews racing on live TV on the                    it seems, are holding back
not necessarily guarantee big audi-          same day over the same course.                         on raising awareness. Sky
ences or enough commer-                         It took three years of logistical                  Sports has held both a netball
cial interest.                               discussions and the support                           month and a women’s sport
   “Of course, we want to                                of the event spon-                       week (estimated to have
fold women’s sports                                            sors for                          reached almost 3 million
into whatever else we                                                                            viewers).
do and have it be seen                                                                        BT Sport has developed annual
as part of the normal                                                                     Action Woman Awards. And the
agenda of what we put                                                                   BBC put six women on to the Sports
to air, but it’s a sensi-                                                              Personality of the Year shortlist last
tive subject,” he                                                                      December. They were almost 40% of
concedes. “Where                                                                       the finalists, a far higher proportion
we can, we give                                                                        than if the list had been based on hours
marginal sports                                                                        of coverage or size of audience.
– and that means                                                                           Advocates of women’s sport believe
many women’s events                                                                         that, over time, the equality issue
– due exposure, while always main-                                                            will fade and women’s sport will
taining a nod towards the main sub-                                                           not be discussed as a separate
scription drivers – which are men’s          this to                                           issue.
sports.”                                     happen.                                               BT’s Green says the tradi-
   One sport that is very much about         “The                                               tional macho culture of sports
women is netball, and this is receiving      viewing                                            media is breaking down. He
special treatment from Sky Sports. A         figures                                            wants women’s sports organi-
four-year deal to broadcast the Netball      have been                                          sations to work more coher-
Superleague was signed last November.        excellent,”                                        ently to help the broadcasters:
For once, there is no men’s game to          says the BBC’s                                     “Women’s sports need to stop
compare it with. Head of multisport          Slater, “and the                                   acting unilaterally and co-­
Georgina Faulkner says that a strong         programme is a                                     ordinate more across a calen-
relationship with England Netball is         far better proposi-                                dar that has a narrative that the
what makes this kind of deal attractive      tion for having two                                 press can follow in a construc-
to the channel.                              high-quality races                                  tive way.
   “We’ve worked hard with the govern­       rather than just one.”                                 “That would make it easier
ing body to make the coverage more              The British Darts                                for women’s sports to get
creative and we’ve even sold game            Organisation world                                       attention and allow the
tickets,” she says. “There are now 9,000     championships, covered                                       involvement of broad-
or 10,000 people coming to some of           by Channel 4 last month,                                        casters to be con-
the games. They’re certainly not all         adopted the same plan.                                                 structive and
women and nor are the viewers. A full        Meanwhile, the Rugby                                                     realistic.”
                                                                                                                                    Christopher Lee–IDI/Getty

 West Indies Women captain Stafanie Taylor
 at practice in Bangladesh during the 2016
 Women’s Twenty20 championships

Television www.rts.org.uk February 2017                                                                                                                  17
You can also read