THE BEST-SELLING ENGINE OF ALL TIMES IN AVIATION HISTORY - 8.92 MB
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
ISSUE The Periodical of TUSAS Engine Industries, Inc. (TEI). TEI IS NOW GLOBALLY THE BIGGEST SUPPLIER OF “LEAP” ENGINE, THE BEST-SELLING ENGINE OF ALL TIMES IN AVIATION HISTORY The ÖRS project blaze a trail for our country and industry We all together have had great time at TEI's picnic organization TEI continues to establish new cooperation with universities
TABLE OF CONTENTS EDITORIAL 05 / MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT & CEO Dear TEI Post Readers, 06 / COVER STORY We are happy to meet you with our 131st issue in early TEI IS NOW GLOBALLY THE BIGGEST SUPPLIER OF “LEAP” 2017. ENGINE, THE BEST-SELLING ENGINE OF ALL TIMES IN AVIATION HISTORY Our "Cover Story" in this new issue features Advanced Manufacturing Technologies Building, which was 09 / ACTIVITIES & PROJECTS inaugurated on September 21, 2016. PROJECTS We appreciate your valuable participation in "TEI Post HR PROCESSES Satisfaction Survey" which was held for the first time to 13 / NEWS ABOUT TEI learn about your opinions on our magazine. We remain committed to improving our magazine in light of the 20 / TECHNICAL ARTICLE feedback from you. 26 / NEWS ABOUT THE AVIATION INDUSTRY In this issue, we have covered Eskisehirspor, the football 32 / NEWS ABOUT OUR EMPLOYEES team of our city, based upon your requests. In addition, as per your requests, we present posters with this issue for 35 / VISITORS the first time in our history. 38 / EXHIBITIONS AND ORGANIZATIONS Burak Balci and Mujdat Aslan again will take part in 40 / ENVIRONMENTAL AND OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY this issue with articles on sports and aviation safety on our column “By TEI Staff”; we would like to take this 42 / EVENTS opportunity to thank them once again and remind you all that all TEI staff are welcome to contribute our magazine 46 / SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY with their articles. 48 / BY TEI EMPLOYEES See you in our 132nd issue... 56 / HOBBIES OF OUR EMPLOYEES ILKER KURTULUS - “MUSIC REPRESENTS MY IDEA OF LIFE” SEMIH KOSEOGLU - PALUDARIUM BRINGS NATURE INTO For and On Behalf of TEI Head Office Address YOUR HOME! Prof. Mahmut F. Aksit TUSAS Engine Industries, Inc. 58 / ACHIEVEMENT BOARD Executive Editor Esentepe Mah. Cevreyolu Bulvari No: 356 26003 59 / SOCIAL CLUBS K. Levent Tufekci Tepebasi / Eskisehir - Turkey Managing Editor Tel: +90 (222) 211 21 00 60 / TRAVEL Duygu Gokduman Pilatin Fax: +90 (222) 211 21 01 LET'S TAKE A HISTORY, CULTURE AND NATURE TOUR www.tei.com.tr Editorial Board IN THE BALKANS BY SAMET ASLAN Senay Dortkasli Publisher GOYNUK, TARAKLI, YEDIGOLLER BY FATIH OZCAKIL Doruk Kocer Dumat Ofset Matbaacilik San. Tic. Ltd. Sti. Tugba Onder Bahcekapi Mah. 2477 Sok. No: 6 70 / PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT Erkan Balk Sasmaz / Ankara PROF. ACAR BALTAS - CAREER SUCCESS, SATISFACTION, Editor Tel: +90 (312) 278 82 00 HEALTH AND LONGEVITY Kadriye Yuzeroglu Edition Period Jan - June 2017 73 / HEALTH Visual Director Emre Ergul Publication Type ACIBADEM INSURANCE - NECK PAIN MAY BE A SIGN OF Regional Periodical Production CERVICAL DISC HERNIATION! Published Date 75 / ANNOUNCEMENTS FROM TEI 24 Nisan 2017 All rights are reserved on behalf of TUSAS Engine Industries, Inc. 04
MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT & CEO TEI: THE LEADING SUPPLIER OF LEAP ENGINE I 'm happy to meet you again with the 131st issue of projects at a quick pace. As we sustain the TEI our corporate magazine TEI Post. First, I would like Intelligence Workshops project, which was launched in the to thank all TEI employees for their contributions first half of 2016, we have also entered the second term of throughout 2016, which turned out to be successful Vocational High School Coaching Program, a collaborative year on our way to accomplish our vision of "To be initiative with Private Sector Volunteers Association. I globally competitive, original power systems OEM". In would like to thank all TEI employees who volunteered to the second half of 2016, we saw numerous significant support these projects. achievements and developments, including inauguration of our Advanced Manufacturing Technologies Building in Besides all these good news, we also experienced a particular. Thanks to this investment, we are now one of deep sorrow in 2016 at TEI family. Our beloved colleague the two facilities, manufacturing blisk parts of the LEAP Serhan Kurt passed away. I extend my sincerest engine, along with GE. Furthermore, we have become condolences to all TEI staff and his family. the largest global supplier for the LEAP engines, the most preferred next generation commercial engine to power With your invaluable supports, I believe that 2017 will be Boeing 737Max and Airbus 320Neo commercial aircraft. a milestone for our company. I have absolute faith that our success in parts manufacturing will be reinforced Also, during this period, we attended the Farnborough with our successful initiatives in R&D projects, which International Airshow, one of the most prestigious trade will contribute, to the targets of our company, and we shows in global aviation industry, and Istanbul Airshow, move forward with firm steps toward being a globally the most prominent aviation organization in Turkey, to competitive company and the one in the national market. display the 1:1 scale models of Turkey’s first indigenous TS1400 turbine engine to power the Original Turkish I hope 2017 turns out to be a year of happiness, health Helicopter and PD170 engine being developed for and well-being for the entire TEI family. Medium-Altitude Long-Endurance (MALE) unmanned aerial vehicles. Greetings and best regards, In addition to the achievements we demonstrated in our Prof. Mahmut F. Aksit activity areas, we also maintained our social responsibility President & CEO, TEI 05
COVER STORY TEI IS NOW GLOBALLY THE BIGGEST SUPPLIER OF "LEAP" ENGINE, THE BEST-SELLING ENGINE OF ALL TIMES IN AVIATION HISTORY T EI, the leading aviation engines manufacturer in "Next generation" digital building Turkey, inaugurated its Advanced Manufacturing TEI President and CEO Prof. Mahmut F. Aksit gave the Technologies Building with an opening ceremony on keynote speech at the opening ceremony, underlining September 21. Fikri Isik, Minister of Defense, Nabi TEI's position as the leading supplier of LEAP engine Avci, Minister of Culture and Tourism, Azmi Celik, Governor parts globally thanks to this new investment in Advanced of Eskisehir, General Hasan Kucukakyuz, Commander Manufacturing Technologies Building. He also noted of Combatant Air Force, Harun Karacan, AKP Member that the building, which cost USD 110 million in total of the Parliament for Eskisehir, Prof. Yilmaz Buyukersen, including the manufacturing equipment it accommodates, Metropolitan Mayor of Eskisehir, Ferhat Kapici, Chief Public is a "next-generation" digital building, and it features Prosecutor of Eskisehir, Prof. Naci Gundogan, President a software system, which enables monitoring lighting, of Anadolu University, Lt. Gen. (R) Orhan Akbas, Director heating and cooling system as well as all machines General of Turkish Armed Forces Foundation, Koksal Liman, through a network. Chairman at TEI, Muharrem Dortkasli, former CEO of TAI, Mike Wilking, Chief Marketing Officer for Military Systems In his keynote speech, Aksit also shared that exports and Business Development at General Electric Aviation and revenue of USD 2 billion is expected from the parts to be many high profile delegates attended the ceremony which produced at the Advanced Manufacturing Technologies represents a significant milestone for both TEI and the Building over the next two decades, and reminded that at industry. least one in every two civil aircraft currently in operation 06
TEI POST Advanced Manufacturing Technologies Building is put into service with a ribbon-cutting ceremony at the stage. Fikri Isik, Minister of Defense, Nabi Avci, Minister of Culture and Tourism. TEI, the leading supplier of LEAP engine parts globally, inaugurated its Advanced Manufacturing Technologies Building with a splendid ceremony. Export revenue of nearly USD 2 billion is expected by 2035 from the engine parts to be produced at this "next generation" building. worldwide is equipped with the parts produced by TEI. Prof. Mahmut F. Aksit He also briefly mentioned about TEI's targets, noting: "We aim to increase this ratio to 3/5 and 4/5 from 1/2 and position TEI at the top place in global aviation industry. We also aim to double and triple our total sales revenues, which was USD 260 million as of the year-end of 2014, in the next 10 and 20 years, respectively. Currently the total value of the firm orders we received is around USD 3 billion. Considering that our total revenues for the previous year realized at USD 300 million, we can say that we have guaranteed our company's future for the next 30 years. We are going to make a giant leap thanks to our new investments." "Future investments are on the way" Mike Wilking, Chief Marketing Officer for Military Systems and Business Development at General Electric Aviation spoke after Prof. Mahmut F. Aksit, expressing their 07
COVER STORY happiness to see TEI become a leading engine part At the opening ceremony, company ID cards were presented manufacturer globally during their partnership for over 30 to 31 new employees who completed the On-the-Job Training years, and noting that future investment are on the way. Program conducted by TEI in coordination with the Ministry Nabi Avci, Minister of Culture and Tourism and Member of Education and Ministry of Labor and Social Security and of the Parliament for Eskisehir was also present at the joined TEI. ceremony and gave a short speech, highlighting the importance of TEI to Eskisehir. He underlined that besides its valuable contributions to the industry, TEI also created ADVANCED MANUFACTURING TECHNOLOGIES a great value for social life in Eskisehir with the social and educational projects it undertook. BUILDING FOR THE FUTURE OF MANUFACTURING "TEI is a source of pride for Turkey" Minister of Defense Fikri Isik gave the final speech at the • One of the two plants capable of producing compressor opening ceremony, underlining TEI's achievements so blisks for the LEAP engine worldwide, far: "TEI is a source of pride for Turkey as it has become • USD 10 million invested in building. Investments in 100 a leading global engine part manufacturer and turned machines with a total cost of USD 100 million to be Eskisehir into an important center in this area. completed by 2019, Companies which have faith in Turkey always win; and • 300 people will be employed, General Electric represents a good example of this fact," • More digital application for paperless manufacturing, he noted and went on to say: "This opening ceremony • Sales revenue of around USD 2 billion by 2035. marks a very important milestone. We are also engaged in some good and promising investments. We have built a fully indigenous diesel engine for our national unmanned aerial vehicles. Now, we aim at a production of an indigenous aircraft engine, which will not be subject to any restrictions by third parties and exported worldwide. Turkey will have built a fully indigenous original aircraft engine within the next five years. And TEI will make it happen in Eskisehir." Minister Isik congratulated TEI President & CEO Prof. Mahmut F. Aksit and all TEI managers and employees on their outstanding efforts before ending his speech. Finally, the Advanced Manufacturing Technologies Building was put into service with a ribbon-cutting ceremony at the stage. Minister of Defense Fikri Isik and Minister of Culture and Tourism Nabi Avci visited the manufacturing site and together they pushed the button to launch production of blisk parts for use in next generation engines. 08
ACTIVITIES TEI POST AND PROJECTS ACTIVITIES IN THE SECOND HALF OF 2016 PROJECTS LEAP ENGINE BLISK MANUFACTURING TEI continues its activities under LEAP engine blisk manufacturing project. The following works were completed in the second half of 2016 or are still in progress as part of the project: • B1000 Building, which has been designed by using lean manufacturing principles and supported with digitization applications under industry 4.0 scope to provide high level productivity, was opened in September 21, 2016. • As part of the project, new part introduction processes have been completed for all blisk stages and serial production started in B1000 building. • Inertia welding, vertical turning, 5-axis milling, CSM (Curved Slot Mill), grinding, balancing and CMM machines were installed and put into service as part of the project. LEAP Engine Stage 1-5 Blisks Advanced Manufacturing Technologies Building - LEAP Blisk Line 09
ACTIVITIES AND PROJECTS DEVELOPMENT PROJECT FOR THE TITANIUM The national forging industry in Turkey supplies over 150 K AND NICKEL SUPER ALLOY FORGING tons of forged parts per year to domestic and international companies, operating mainly in automotive industry. The TECHNOLOGIES IN AVIATION (ÖRS) ÖRS Project will enable the establishment of a competitive supply network for titanium and nickel-based superalloy forged parts that can serve national and international The ÖRS Project was launched on March 17, 2016 under engine programs in the mid- and long-term, and thus the sponsorship of the Undersecretariat for Defense dependence on foreign sources will be significantly Industries (UDI) with the aim of gaining titanium and nickel reduced in national aviation industry. super alloy forging technologies, which are not currently available in Turkey despite their frequent use in gas turbine engines worldwide. FULL AUTOMATION AND FAILURE PREVENTION Robot-aided marking application has been introduced with the Full Automation and Failure Prevention Project in "dot peen" marking operation, the most widely used part marking method in manufacturing. The project was designed by leveraging on TEI's know-how and realized in collaboration with a local company, providing 65% average reduction of operation hours. The following applications, classified in four main groups, were also put in place under the project. Occupational Safety • Security fence meeting applicable standards • Security door w/ automatic locking system Hot-Forged Sample Part • Light barriers Failure Prevention Systems Impellers made from Ti6Al4V (UNS R56400) and • Fully automated data entry with QR code prototypes of turbine disks made Inconel718 (UNS • Part verification system N07718) will be produced within the scope of project. In • Automatic program retrieval system that respect, these materials will be forged by conventional • Positioning of workpieces at loading stations w/ high- closed die hot forging, heat treated after forging and precision servo-controls machined to get ultrasonic envelope geometries. • Pneumatic actuators for angular alignment of Following the production processes, prototypes will workpieces be subjected to mechanical and metallurgical tests • Identification of previously marked serial numbers and inspections to determine whether the required • Record retention of the person performing the marking specifications are achieved or not. Impeller and turbine process disk geometries, belonging to TEI Turboshaft engine • Record retention of alarms design, are selected as project target. • Probe system for marker pin length verification Prime Contractor TEI TEI taking the lead position as the prime contractor for the project, subcontractors will be responsible for development of hot forging and heat treatment processes for the impeller and turbine disk. Metal Forming Center of Excellence of Atilim University will also be supporting the project team as project consultant on process modeling and raw material characterization for prediction of forging parameters. With the ÖRS Project, titanium and nickel-based superalloy forging capabilities will be acquired by national industry for the production of aforementioned turboshaft engine parts first, then other similar parts in different gas turbine engines. Robotic Part Marking Station 10
TEI POST Traceability ON-THE-JOB TRAINING PROGRAM • All marked serial numbers stored in database • Alarm function if same serial number marked previously This first phase of the on-the-job training program, • Database containing operator, date and time records which was launched in January 2016 under the • Password-authenticated administrator authorization for collaboration of TEI and Turkish Employment Agency to special setting and program changes help inexperienced individuals gain some professional and work experience, was completed. The second Productivity phase was launched in August with 45 trainees from six • Smart and common fixture design for loading of branches. Covering a six-month period, the program different parts ended on December 31, 2016. The trainees will undergo • Quick connection systems between fixture and loading an assessment process for recruitment based on their station performances and current vacancies. • One operator-double loading station configuration Furthermore, 27 trainees were selected as part of the • Diameter, top surface and bottom surface marking of "Qualified Airmen" program launched in July under the workpieces in one set-up leadership of Sabiha Gokcen Vocational and Technical Anatolian High School, and the trainees started to attend on-the-job training after completing the theoretical training HR PROCESSES sessions at school. These trainees will be assessed for recruitment based on their performances in 2017. "TURBOSHAFT ENGINE DEVELOPMENT PROJECT" RECRUITMENT PROGRAM TITLE-BASED PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT TRAINING PROGRAMS Program posters were hung on the notice boards of relevant departments of universities to attract new- graduates and experienced engineers to take part in Turboshaft Engine Development Project and join TEI and applications are collected under the theme "My National Helicopter Engine". A personal development training program was designed for all white-collar employees in 2016. All personal development processes were planned by title, matching the competencies to be acquired as a result of the trainings with the competency level required for each title. 7781 hours of training were delivered in total under the program. An Outdoor Training was organized for leaders as an outdoor activity called the "Future in the Skies" to encourage teamwork and increase motivation. 11
ACTIVITIES AND PROJECTS TEI DEVELOPMENT CENTER PROJECT up a more fair and transparent system. A performance committee, consisting of volunteering white- and blue- TEI Development Center, a project for high-performing collar employees, has been formed for the project, and the senior employees, continues with 3 modules and 72 relevant actions are executed by the senior management trainees between October 2016 - February 2017. The and the committee in coordination. The project is expected "Assessment Center" is applied at the beginning and end to be completed by 2017 including the software process. of the program. AWARD-APPRECIATION-RECOGNITION A new Award-Appreciation-Recognition system was put in place in 2016 with a special budget. In this respect, Management and Employee Awards were defined and put into practice. With the new system, the award and recognition practices have shown a significant increase across the company compared to previous years. EXECUTIVE TRAINING The Mini MBA program organized for our senior management and executives ended and the participants received their certificates. Personal development and outdoor training programs were also organized for our executives. ORGANIZATIONAL RESTRUCTURING OF WORKSHOPS In 2015, lean manufacturing cells were created with the part groups transferred under the responsibility of Manufacturing Management and the engineers from other relevant managements; and distribution of blue-collar personnel was organized accordingly. In 2016, in addition to this structure, a reorganization process was initiated to enable monitoring of the workshop in a more controlled LIFE COACHING manner and elaborate annual targets and performances We have put in place a half-day long "life coaching" of blue-collar personnel. As part of the process, current program to be organized two times a week to support technical assistance specialists were assigned as employees professionally. As part of the program, an workshop supervisors so that six workshop supervisors expert psychiatrist continues to provide consulting will be present in total in every shift. Supervision of services at our On-Site Physician's Office. six blue-collar personnel has also been vested in six technical leads working at Manufacturing Managements in CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT addition to their existing responsibilities. Technicians and workstations under the responsibility of Manufacturing We have rolled out the "Continuous Improvement Managements have been revised accordingly to reinforce Project" to improve the performance system and set the workshop-based restructuring process. 12
NEWS ABOUT TEI MAIN ENGINE PROGRAMS USING PARTS MADE BY TEI GEnx TEI produces 42 different parts including disks, spinners, seals, bearing housings, casings and blisks for GEnx engines. The GEnx is the fastest-selling, high-thrust jet engine in GE Aviation history with more than 1600 engines on order. In addition to powering the four-engine Boeing 747-8, the GEnx engine is also the best-selling engine for the Boeing 787 Dreamliner. The GEnx engine represents a giant leap forward in propulsion technology, using the latest materials and design processes to reduce weight, improve performance and deliver a more fuel-efficient commercial aircraft engine. The GEnx engine is also the world's first commercial jet engine with both a front fan case and fan blades made of carbon-fiber composites. TEI produces 18 different parts including shafts, disks and seals for the CFM56 engine, the best-selling CFM56 jet engine in the world. The CFM56 engine set the standard for single-aisle commercial jet engines. With more than 30,000 engines delivered to date, it powers Airbus A318, A319, A320 and A321 aircraft for more than 550 operators worldwide. F110 The F110 engine, which has a special meaning for TEI, currently continues to power best-in-class fighter aircraft in 13 countries. TEI produces 60 different parts for this engine family including seals, disks, shafts, mixing ducts, augmenter liners and flame holders. The F110 family provides industry-leading power for F-15 and F-16 fighter aircraft and continuously infuses state-of-the-art enhancements for added mission accomplishment. 13
NEWS ABOUT TEI GE90 TEI produces 20 different parts including seals, disks, impingement rings and seal supports for the GE90, world’s largest turbofan engine built exclusively for Boeing 777 aircraft. The GE90 engine is also the first-ever commercial aircraft engine using carbon-fiber composite fan blades. LEAP TEI produces 41 different parts, notably disks and blisks, for the new generation LEAP engines. The LEAP delivers a 15% improvement in fuel consumption, compared to today’s most fuel-efficient engine and will replace CFM56 engines as the most preferred commercial engine by airline operators. The LEAP engine will power Airbus A320 Neo, Boeing 737 Max and COMAC 919. CF6 For more than 40 years, the CF6 engine family has established an impressive operational record and compiled nearly 400 million flight hours since they first entered commercial revenue service. TEI produces 34 different parts for this engine family, including spools, disks and shafts. 14
TEI POST TP400 TP400 is the most powerful Western turboprop engine producing 11,000 LM2500 shp. TEI not only contributed to the design process, but also produces five main parts including FBS module, exhaust cone, primary nozzle and The LM2500 is the most widely applied gas turbine, IMC for the TP400 engine. derived from CF6-6 aircraft engines, to power marine platforms and for industrial applications. For the LM2500 engine, TEI produces 36 different parts in total including shafts, dome plates and torque shafts. CF34 In early 1990s, the CF34 opened a new period in regional aviation; and recording over 100 million flight hours and more than 80 million flight cycles since then, it sets the standards for performance, durability and reliability in this area. 8 different parts for CF34 jet engines, including shafts and seals are produced by TEI. Considering the increasing demand, CF34 engines are expected to power more than 7500 regional aircraft by 2020. GP7200 The GP7200 engine design comes from the historic collaboration of two industry giants, General Electric and Pratt & Whitney to power Airbus A380. TEI produces 3 parts for this engine including casings and stub shafts. 15
NEWS ABOUT TEI DESIGN, MANUFACTURING AND ITERATIVE METHODOLOGY OF CATHODE TOOLS DEVELOPED FOR ELECTRO-CHEMICAL MILLING PROCESS Parametric modeling technique has been developed for but cause pitting due to irregular electrolyte flow, should be design and geometric adjustment of the cathode tool used smoothed by experience. in processing of final geometry for the fan blades of the blisks adapted to Electro-Chemical Milling (ECM) process. After taking cross-sections of the fan blade, modeling process for the immeasurable sections of cathode is completed, enabling supply of a smooth electrolyte flow to Figure 3. Set up for the fan blade through the most outer platform. (Figure 1) part and ECM cathode Figure 1A Figure 1B positioning on the machine. ECM process is a highly fast process; processing a blisk with 70 fan blades takes around six hours. Following ECM, vibratory finishing is applied to smooth the surface and remove the layer of mud to make the part ready for shot peen process. Then, the material of the surfaces where the part contacts the ECM fixture is removed by a turning process after the ECM; seal holes should also be drilled after final Figure 1A: Cross-sections from fan blade geometry turning operation. Figure 1B: Core modeling of the gap between the cathodes in the Proper fan blade sizes and measures are obtained with ECM cross-section taken. process, and generally, no additional processing is necessary. However, there might be some uneven surfaces on platform A solid-state model is obtained through surface modeling profile, which need additional processing. These areas by using all the cross-sections. This model is used to should be smoothed with robotic deburring process. Robotic develop the concave and convex surface geometries of the deburring is more repetitive compared to manual deburring as fan blade. it is more precise and programmed, and it is used to achieve Once the fan blade geometry is developed, the platform the designed measurements for the platform profile. surface between two fan blades and the radius of the concave and convex bottom surfaces where the fan blade The cathodes are tried in ECM process and the measurement meets the platform, are also modeled, giving the model its results obtained are assessed, and if any revisions are to final form. be made on the cathode, the preset parameter values are changed and the cathode model is updated. The cathode Minimum 5-axis milling machines should be used for of the new project is not ready for production after the first cathode manufacturing. The machine should have a fast- revision but requires several revisions for the adjustment of rotating spindle, a high positioning repeatability and angular the fan blade geometry and correction of the platform profile. milling capability. (Figure 2) After each revision, a trial cut should be performed and the measures should be verified with CMM measurements. This Figure 2A Figure 2B new method assigns 20 parameters to check concave and convex profile of each cross-section and modify other length and thickness measures. Considering that fan blade geometry involves 12-15 measurable and 6-8 measurable cross- sections, it is clear that there are at least 300 parameters to check. All these parameters are recorded in a built-in sheet and every iteration is also recorded on another sheet to create Figure 2A: Machine set up for milling. a macro where all iterations are complied to check the model Figure 2B Concave and convex cathodes processed by milling. geometry. Cathodes produced by milling should be rubbed with felt Process development of stage-5 blisks for LEAP 1A/C and 1B and sandpaper for deburring and edge finishing. Especially is completed was completed with this methodology before those areas, which cannot be read through measurements proceeding to mass production. 16
TEI POST PRODUCT LIFE CYCLE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) is the process of just like operating system managing numerous software managing all data and processes for a product throughout that we upload on it to use, PLM software manages its the entire lifecycle from inception to end-of-life. The term various data by associating them with each other through PLM originally comes from the design process of Rockwell integration with all software used across the company. International's B-1B bomber, while its first application was in 1895 at American Motors Corporation (AMC). [1] A common database is the main component of PLM solutions. It creates a common database for all the data The global PLM market has generated revenue of USD 40 generated for the same product by different teams within billion as of 2015 and is projected to reach a market size the company. Thus, all the data for that product are of USD 75 billion by 2022. [2] generated once in a single database and all teams can access such data through a single platform whenever they Globally, many leading companies in aircraft, aerospace need it. and automotive industry, including General Electric, Boeing, Daimler-Chrysler, General Motors, BAE Systems, PLM systems enables data generation, management and Agusta Westland and Lockheed Martin apply PLM association through all processes including requirement solutions. In Turkey, on the other hand, PLM is widely management, design, product identification, Bill of used in by large companies operating in white goods and Material (BOM) management, change management, defense industries. [3] production planning, CAM, equipment and human resources management, project and time management, Advantages of PLM purchasing and procurement and MRO operations. Studies show that a typical engineer spends almost 25- It manages such processes by enabling access by 20% of his or her time in search of part details. Nearly teams to the required data only on a shared database 80% of the works done in an engineering department integrated with other software such as CAD, CAM, CAE, consists of the same and similar works that have been ERP, through management of access authorizations done before. Product data management addresses by following necessary workflows for approval. [4] To these issues by enabling that all data are kept in a single give an example, it manages all data regarding a part location structured with robust and flexible methods and designed in line with a client's request including for which can be searched. [3] requirements the project was created during late stages, its CAD model and technical drawing, purchase orders, for which engine assemblies it is used, CAM program, the machines and tools used for its production, the changes made on it and which client used it for how long etc. Figure 1. Results of PLM practices [3] PLM represents the digital backbone of a company Figure 2. PLM System [5] Computers we use everyday can serve as a good example to understand PLM system. In a computer, various PLM at TEI subsystem, each having a different function, such as TEI Design Engineering Directorate used Teamcenter, a power supply, processor, memory, cooling system etc. PLM software by Siemens with nearly 165 licenses. The are combined to serve one specific purpose through a system was put in place in 2010 and has been used for operating system software and enables the user operate many projects to date with many improvements made it through an interface. Likewise, PLM system creates on it since then. Currently, it is mostly used for product an infrastructure for data management between all data management, as it is only available within Design departments of a company, providing employees with an Engineering Directorate. The CAD program used by TEI is interface to access this management system. Besides, integrated with Siemens NX software. 2D and 3D models 17
NEWS ABOUT TEI developed under Design Engineering Directorate and the technical reports, engineering communication sheets, testing and installation process and documentation, interface control CONTINUED COLLABORATION documents etc. issued under product data management WITH UNIVERSITIES are created on this system and released after following the respective workflow for approval. Engineering change management is also managed through PLM system, enabling traceability among all iterations realized in design process. PLM system, which enables time and cost saving, reduces failure rates and use of time for non-engineering purposes and serves development of TEI's know-how in its activities in line with its vision of "having globally competitive, original power systems", which is highly important also for our country, is used at TEI in a basic sense. We are planning to make it much more efficient by making necessary improvements and integrations. As PLM system is put in place in other operations across TEI, transition to product lifecycle will become possible The Researcher Development Program for Defense in real terms and the system will function as a digital spine. Industries (SAYP) has been launched in 2011 in lead of Undersecretariat for Defense Industries in order to References: establish a more systematic transfer of knowledge [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_lifecycle between defense companies and universities, and to [2]http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/product-lifecycle-management- plm-market---global-industry-analysis-and-forecast-to-2022-for-the-75-billion- ensure that the postgraduate dissertations studies of industry-300109518.html employees from defense companies are structured [3]http://www.makinamagazin.com.tr/haber/urun-yasam-dongusu/3270 so as to support the companies R&D requirements [4]https://www.plm.automation.siemens.com/en_us/products/teamcenter/plm- and focus on the priority areas in the industry. TEI and platform-capabilities/index.shtml several other defense companies executed separate [5]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_lifecycle protocols with Anadolu University, Gebze Technical University, Atilim University, Kirikkale University and Uludag University as part of the program. The CONSTRUCTION MAINTENANCE negotiations are also ongoing for execution of a protocol with Sabanci University, Sakarya University, LEADERSHIP NOW ADDRESSES TOBB and Eskisehir Osmangazi University. In addition, OFFICE NEEDS TEI identified the technical subjects than can be addressed with universities under SAYP and shared Construction Maintenance Leadership unit of TEI Facilities & them with SAYP-member universities. Currently, Logistics Services Management has set to work to meet the various project proposals received from several need for office furniture across the company for the first time. universities are under assessment process. To that end, production of some of the furniture to be used in B1000 Advanced Manufacturing Technologies Building, which was inaugurated on September 21, 2016, has been completed. As the production process goes on, nearly 55% savings have ISTANBUL CUSTOMS OFFICE been achieved with the completed furniture. The need for ENTERS INTO SERVICE furniture that arose when TEI Engineering Office in Ankara was TEI Istanbul Customs Office entered into service in the moved to Hacettepe Teknokent has been met by spending second half of 2016 at Turkish Airlines Agencies Block 60% less than expected. Renovation of the apartments in near Atatürk Airport Customs Management, where over the mass housing facilities at TEI Eskisehir Premises is also 90% of customs clearance operation are carried out, to performed by Construction Maintenance Leadership staff. enable performance of customs clearance processes of the company through direct representation. 3 staff members, including one with a license (assistant customs broker), were recruited for the Office which started operations on April 4, 2016. At the same time, TEI Customs Office in Eskisehir started to issue customs declaration forms to support TEI Customs Office in Istanbul so that it can perform customs clearance procedures. TEI Customs Office performs over 40% of customs clearance procedures for import, which provided cost savings for the company in the commission fees paid for customs brokerage. 18
TEI POST “WE WEAR OUR NEW BUSINESS UNIFORMS WITH PLEASURE AND COMFORT” We have mentioned in our last issue that new business clothes have been designed to ensure that TEI's employees work with comfort and that corporate identity is achieved in an integrated manner. In this issue, you can find the remarks of our employees who are working with their new business clothes. Halime Ozkaya serving as CNC Kazim Topuz serving as Senior Technician at Manufacturing Technical Leader at Quality Management (Turning): Management: “We work with comfort thanks to "This is the first time for white-collar cotton and soft texture of our new employees to be provided with corporate business clothes. Our coats well clothes. So, I think it filled a huge gap. protect us from cold weathers. We I show ultimate attention to wear my can use our waistcoats for several T-shirt, sweatshirt and shirt by turns purposes; for example, while we are every other day. These clothes provide a working inside the workshop or while great convenience. I should also say that we go out for a break or lunch. I think designs of the clothes are very pretty, the colors of these designs and the so I wear them with a great pleasure. business clothes are in an excellent What is more, I think they provide great harmony, and I wear them with love." contributions to the corporate culture." “COMFORT OF USE AND HIGH-QUALITY BECAME OUR KEYWORDS” New business clothes, designed dedicatedly for TEI's employees, bear the signature of SUR CORPORATEWEAR. We have interviewed with Cem Kaprol, General Manager of SUR CORPORATEWEAR, to learn what has happened in the design process of the new business clothes which have been delivered in three months and acclaimed by our white-collar and blue-collar employees. Which processes have you gone through while What were the other consideration points you designing the clothes dedicatedly for TEI's employees? addressed while designing the clothes? We set off to work by getting to know TEI more closely. As I have said shortly before, we have attached our priority to We examined the clothes of employees, and determined design corporate clothes that fit well the corporate identity. the needs. Then, we prepared a new collection with the But of course, we have considered several things such as inspiration we drew from the corporate identity and logo corporate departments and appropriateness of the clothes of TEI. “Comfort of use" and "high-quality" became our for these departments, as well as the weather conditions, keywords while preparing the collection. We managed geographical location and comfort of employees. to ensure a healthy communication, resulting in a highly pleasant preparation process. How many different clothes were designed for white-collar and blue-collar employees? What were the expectations and priorities of TEI with We have worked on 44 different models for white-collar and respect to the clothes? blue-collar employees of TEI. Cem Kaprol TEI expected us to prepare a comfortable, high-quality and modern collection to emphasize its corporate Are you satisfied with the outcome and the feedback identity without any deviation from this identity. Thanks you get? to the industry-wide confidence we have proved, the size We are quite satisfied with the outcome and the feedback we determination processes were left to our expertise. We get. As we have carried out this project with TEI on mutual came up with these processes with the size samples we have satisfaction basis, we keep on working together on the new prepared together with our expert team. projects. 19
TECHNICAL ARTICLE COUPLED CFD AND HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS FOR A SMALL SCALE GAS TURBINE COMBUSTOR ABSTRACT Gas turbine combustor design process has significant number of complex design phenomena, one of the most complicated parameters of which is the heat transfer process of combustor liners. Heat transfer studies are performed in preliminary design phase by the help of one-dimensional tools; however, in the detail design phase, use of 3D CFD analysis is required. In that sense, conjugate heat transfer stands out as a powerful but computationally expensive analysis method. On the other hand, coupled analysis of Finite Element Analysis (FEA) and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) can provide a quick alternative solution. Coupled analysis offers faster results with lower mesh size, which provides an advantage iterative design process. In this study, a series of coupled CFD and heat transfer analyses were conducted for a small scale gas turbine combustor, and the results were presented and compared with relevant rig test thermal paint results. ALTUG PISKIN Senior Engineer INTRODUCTION Chief Engineering Office Coordination - TEI Coupled heat transfer analysis is briefly based on sequential analysis between CFD and FEA models. The AHMET TOPAL limit determined in such analyses is solved through Staff Engineer exchange of data between these two models. Near Aerothermal Engineering Management - TEI liner gas temperatures, obtained through CFD analyses is transfered to FEA model to compute liner metal temperatures. The liner metal temperatures computed is resent to CFD model and line wall temperature is defined a limit condition. The analysis process is ended depending The article is the summary of the on the convergence of the metal temperatures monitored research paper numbered GT2016- at certain positions during iterations. 57944 which was presented at "TurboExpo 2016". NUMERICAL ANALYSES Flow chart of the overall analysis process is provided in Figure 1. As it can be understood from this chart, CFD model starts with the definition of a baseline wall temperature for liners. Combustion model is analyzed based on these wall temperatures, and the wall edge gas temperature results are transfered to thermal model. Wall temperatures obtained through analysis of the thermal model is re-converted into CFD model, and this sequential process continues until a convergence is obtained, after which the solution is completed. 20
TEI POST Table 2 Numerical Results for Thermocouple Positions Model TK-1 (K) TK-2 (K) TK-3 (K) Hot Spot (K) 1 533.3 610.5 858.7 865.7 2 622.5 718.3 982.1 998.6 3 688.6 793.2 1052.7 1076.9 4 572.7 636.5 746.9 750.2 5 723.6 756.9 794.4 803.0 6 611.3 692.5 927.9 946.2 7 693.0 711.4 733.5 744.3 8 710.0 782 997 1015.6 9 691 749 940 960.0 10 762.1 830.3 1026.1 1055.4 Outer liner temperature distribution for Model-10 is provided in Figure 2. The temperature value points defined here correspond to respective thermocouple positions. 830.3 K Figure 1. Coupled Analysis Flow Chart After the computation method is determined, analyses 762.1 K 1026.1 K on conductivity, emissivity and gas radiation effects, two different heat transfer correlations and numerical- experimental model comparison and matching were performed for the study. 10 different analyses were Figure 2. Outer Line Temperature Distribution for Model-10 performed to that end. The analysis matrix is provided in Table 1, where cf means heat transfer correction factor, hf represents heat flux factor, and ɛ represents the outer EXPERIMENTAL STUDY surface emissivity of the liner. Liner meal temperatures were measured in TEI atmospheric combustor test rig. Figure 3 shows Table 1 Analysis Matrix the design model of the test part, thermal paint instrumentation on outer liner and a thermal paint-applied Model No. HTC Correlation cf hf ɛ combustor. 1 Channel 0.5 0 0.5 2 Channel 1 0 0.5 3 Channel 1.5 0 0.5 4 Lefebvre 1 0 0.5 5 Lefebvre 1 1 0.5 6 Channel 1 0 0.9 7 Lefebvre 1 1 0.9 8 Channel 1 1 0.5 9 Channel 1 1 0.9 10 Channel 1.7 1 0.9 Matrix on Table 2 shows the analysis results for the models. Figure 3. Test Part and Thermal Paint-Applied Combustor 21
TECHNICAL ARTICLE Thermal paint results including temperature gradients and Considering the results obtained from Model 10, it was maximum temperature positions as well as Figure 4 for observed that maximum temperature value was nearly the outer liner indicate that outer liner metal temperatures 70 K lower than test results. reach 1123 K. (10) Table 3 Measurement Results for Control Points TK1 (K) TK2 (K) TK3 (K) Hot Spot (K) TP 763-843 1023-1123 883-1023 ~1123 T/C 812 915 863 - Model-10 762.1 830.3 1026.1 1055.4 Figure 4. Thermal Paint Color Distribution SYMBOLS RESULTS To summarize, the study focused on the effects of heat CFD Computational Fluid Dynamics surface emissivity and gas radiation based on analysis FEM Finite Element Model results. In addition, it analyzed different heat transfer HTC Heat Transfer Coefficient correlations and finally, results of the coupled analysis was T/P Thermal Paint compared with the test results of a small scale combustor by using the best numerical model. Table 3 shows a T/C Thermocouple comparison of the analysis model (Model 10) through ɛ Emissivity experimental values obtained as a result of the study. Tg Gas Temperature The paint sequence on the table represents the minimum k Thermal Conductivity and maximum temperatures for the color scale obtained as a result of the test. The other sequences indicate cf Correction Factor thermocouple measurements and analysis results. hf Heat Flux Factor REFERENCES (1) Fitzpatrick, J. N. (2013). “Coupled thermal-fluid analysis with flowpath-cavity interaction in a gas turbine engine.” MSc Thesis, Purdue University. (2) Sun, Z., Chew, J. W. and Hills, N. (2008) “Use of CFD for thermal coupling in aeroengine internal air systems applications.” The 4th International Symposium on Fluid Machinery and Fluid Engineering, NO. 4ISFMFE-IL07. (3) Sun., Z., Chew, J. W. and Hills, N., Volkov, K. N., Barnes, C. J., “Efficient finite element analysis computational fluid dynamics thermal coupling for engineering applications.” Journal of Turbomachinery, JULY 2010, Vol. 132 / 031016-9. (4) Javiya, U., Chew. C., Hills, N., Scanion, T., “Coupled FE-CFD thermal analysis for a cooled turbine disk.” Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, Part C, Proc. IMechE. (5) Verdicchio, J. A., Chew, J. W., Hills, N. J., (2001) “Coupled fluid solid heat transfer computation for turbine discs.” (6) Sieder, E. N., Tate, G. E. (1936) “Heat Transfer and Pressure Drop of Liquids in Tubes”. Industrial Engineering Chemistry, 28, 1429. (7) Lefebvre, A. H., (1998) “Gas turbine combustion.”, Taylor & Francis, 2nd Edition. (8) Poinsot T., Wolf P., Staffelbach G., Gicquel L.Y.M., Muller J.D. (2011) “Identification of azimuthal modes in annular combustion chambers.”, Center for Turbulence Research Annual Research Briefs. (9) Kadoya, K., Matsunaga, N., Nagashima, A., (1985) “Viscosity and thermal conductivity of dry air in the gaseous air.”, Keio University, Department of Mechanical Engineering. (10) Topal, A., Catori, C., Cagan, L., Uslu, S., Turan, O., Piskin, A., (2014). “One dimensional heat transfer analysis and experimental investigation of a gas turbine combustor.”, International Symposium on Convective Heat and Mass Transfer. (11) C.Bates, Stephen, (1997). “High Temperature Transparent Furnace Development”, NASA Technical Reports. 22
TEI POST AERODYNAMIC OPTIMIZATION OF A TRANSONIC FAN BLADE ABSTRACT This study aims to obtain the optimum aerodynamic axial symmetric design of a transonic aero-engine fan blade and flow path. Angle distribution and fan bypass field flow path geometry is optimized using genetic algorithm principle, which is an optimization method inspired by evolutionary processes. A 2D axial-symmetric design tool and optimization software, developed by TEI employees, are used for the study. INTRODUCTION Quasi three-dimensional through-flow modeling (Figure 1) is one of the most critical steps in of turbomachinery design. Using detailed 3D analysis models, the design is only possible by trial-and-error, and takes much longer time, whilst 2D axial-symmetric methods enable direct and fast designs. An axisymmetric solver includes two components. The first component consists of a solver which works in axis-symmetric swirl mode (in the present study, the streamline-curvature method). The second component comprises theoretical and experimental correlations taking DR. ORCUN KOR into account the local pressure, temperature and swirl- Lead Engineer increasing/decreasing effects of 3D blades on the said Aerothermal Engineering Management - TEI 2D (quasi 3D) rotational flow. To estimate these effects, results of the experiments performed on standardized 2D blade cascades are used and the code verification is ASSIST. PROF. SERCAN ACARER demonstrated in references [Acarer, Ozkol, 2016]. Izmir Katip Celebi University ASSIST. PROF. UNVER OZKOL Izmir Institute of Technology This article is a summary of the research paper presented at "National Aerospace Figure 1. Two-dimensional Modeling of Turbomachinery Flow Conference 2016". Optimization of aerodynamic objective functions such as efficiency, standard deviation of total pressure distribution etc. is essential in 2D axisymmetric design stage. This study focuses on optimization of these quantities. 23
TECHNICAL ARTICLE The problem addressed by the 2D axisymmetric flow IMPLEMENTATION solver, which constitutes the subject of this study, consists Genetic algorithm (GA) is used as the optimization method of high order, non-linear set of equations. The suggested in this study. Operating principles of GA are available in mathematical model is non-differentiable in local points the references in detail [Kor, 2016]. Tournament method is since it has many singularities. Therefore, gradient- used as selection mechanism in genetic algorithm. Design based methods cannot provide an optimum global result variables are represented with chromosomes, and a 4 [Rao, 1996], [Verstraete, 2012]. On the other hand, the point crossover operation is implemented while creating genetic algorithm method, which imitates the evolutionary new designs. Mutation rate is determined as 1% as processes, is observed to provide significant objective recommended in the literature [Verstraete, 2012]. function improvements in many aerodynamic optimization studies [Shahpar, 2000], [Joly, Verstraete and Paniagua, 2010]. Generic engine geometry addressed in the study is provided in Figure 2. In optimization process, the tip region of fan flow path, hub region of the bypass area To the authors’ best knowledge, the available literature and twist factor are modified with genetic algorithm lacks a study on aerodynamic design optimization of principle, and the objective function given in Equation turbofan blades and bypass region. This study aims to (2) is minimized. In equation (2) w1 and w2 are weight shed light on this untouched area in the literature. factors which are taken as 0.5. η represents fan isentropic efficiency and it is tried to be maximized; and , SYMBOLS represents the normalized value of the standard deviation of total pressure distribution at section B, which is tried to TF Twist factor be minimized. Fq Blade force on quasi-orthagonals (N) H Total enthalpy (kJ/kg) (2) Km Streamline curvature (1/m) m Flow direction o Design Variables P Pressure Figure 2 shows the control points of the Bézier curves q Quasi-orthagonal direction constituting the fan flow path, which take different values Angle between quasi-orthagonal and streamline (o) during optimization. Another design parameter is twist r radius (m) factor (TF), which plays a critical role in axisymmetric s Entropy (kJ/kg K) design. This parameter defines span-wise tangential Vm Meridional velocity (m/s) velocity distribution of the flow leaving the blade. The angle between the tangential velocity component and Vθ Tangential velocity (m/s) engine axis, on the other hand, gives the blade's flow w Weight factor angle at that point. The formulation of speed distribution is T Temperature (K) given in Equation (3). η Efficiency METHODOLOGY (3) The 2D axial-symmetric design tool is described by Acarer and Özkol (2016) in detail. Full radial equilibrium equation The term in equation (3) represents the (Equation (1)) is solved by means of 2D axisymmetric tangential velocity value at meanline ( ). This design tool. quantity is derived from one-dimensional thermodynamic cycle analysis and it is assumed to be known in this study. (1) TF - Twist Factor The software is based on inverse design: tangential velocity (Vθ) distribution at the trailing edge of the blade is provided as input and the corresponding flow field is B solved. Losses for compressible and incompressible flow regimes are modeled by means of correlations. By this mean, results that are compatible with the actual physics A of the flow can be accurately demonstrated. Figure 2. Generic Turbofan Geometry and Design Parameters 24
TEI POST Design variables (geometric parameters) are allowed to CONCLUSION take values within the space restricted by the dashed Aerodynamic design of a generic turbofan engine’s fan line. No changes are made on solid lines provided in module is performed and optimized to provide optimum Figure 4. The twist factor is modified within the range of aerodynamic performance by using the design and . optimization tool developed by TEI. The objective function improved by 4.5% as a result of the optimization process. Outputs Computations are stopped at 13th generation due REFERENCES to time restriction. Figure 3 shows the normalized Acarer, S., Ozkol, U., 2016, An Extension of the Streamline Curvature objective function values of the optimum design for each Through-Flow Design Method for Bypass Fans of Turbofan Engines, generation. The formula for the normalized objective Proc IMechE Part G: Journal of Aerospace Engineering, pp.1-14. Aungier, R. H., 2003, Axial Flow Compressors: A Strategy for function is as follows: Aerodynamic Design and Analysis, ASME Press. Boyer, K. M., 2001, An Improved Streamline Curvature Approach for (4) Off-Design Analysis of Transonic Compression Systems. Dissertation, Virginia Polytechhnic Institute and State University, ABD. Bullock, R. ve Johnsen, I., 1965, Aerodynamic Design of Axial Flow Compressors, NASA SP-36. Creveling, H., 1968, Axial-Flow Compressor Computer Program for Calculating Off-Design Performance, NASA CR-72472. Cetin, M., Ucer, A. S., Hirsch, C., and Serovy, G. K., 1987, Application of Modified Loss and Deviation Correlations to Transonic Axial Compressors, AGARD R-745. Joly, M.,Verstraete, T., Paniagua, G., 2010, Attenuatıon Of Vane Dıstortıon In A Transonıc Turbıne Usıng Optımızatıon Strategıes, Part I – Methodology, ASME TurboExpo, Glasgow, United Kingdom, July 14-18. Joly, M.,Verstraete, T., Paniagua, G., 2012, Full Design Of A Highly Loaded Fan By Multi-Objective Optimization Of Throughflow And High-Fidelity Aero-Mechanical Performances, ASME TurboExpo, Copenhagen, Denmark, July 11-15. Kleppler, J., 1998, Technique to Predict Stage-by-Stage, Pre-Stall Compressor Performance Characteristics Using a Streamline Curvature Code with Loss and Deviation Correlations, Dissertation, University of Tennessee, USA. Koch, C., and Smith, L., 1976, Loss Sources and Magnitudes in Axial- Flow Compressors, J. Eng. for Power, Volume. 98(3), pp. 411-424. Kor, O., 2016, Aerodynamic Optimization of a Transonic Aero-Engine Figure 3. Improvement through Generations by Genetic Algorithm Fan Module, Dissertation, Izmir Institue of Technology, Turkey. Lieblein, S., 1960, Incidence and Deviation-Angle Correlations for Figure 3 shows that normalized objective function is Compressor Cascades, Trans ASME Journal of Basic Engineering, improved by 4.5% through the generations. Constraint Volume 82, pp. 575-87. functions are kept within range of predetermined limits Miller, G., Lewis Jr., G., and Hartmann, M., 1961, Shock Losses in during the optimization period. Figure 4 shows the Transonic Compressor Blade Rows, J. Eng. for Power, Volume. 83(3), pp. 235-241. optimum flowpath for the generic turbofan geometry, Pachidis, V., 2006, Gas Turbine Advanced Performance Simulation, which is obtained at the end of optimization. Dissertation, University of Cranfield, United Kingdom. Petrovic, M., Wiedermann, A., and Banjac, M., 2009, Development and Validation of a New Universal Through Flow Method for Axial Compressors, ASME Turbo Expo, Orlando, USA, June 8-12. Petrovic, M.V., Dulikravich, G.S., Martin, T.J., 2000, Optimization of Multistage Turbines Using a Throughflow Code, ASME TurboExpo, Munich, Germany, May 8-11. Rao, S., 1996, Engineering optimization, theory and practice, John Wiley and Sons Inc., New York. Shahpar S., 2000, A comparative study of optimization methods or aerodynamic design of turbomachinery blades, ASME TurboExpo, Munich, Germany, May 8-11. Sullivan, T. J., Younghans, J. L., and Little, D. R., 1976, Single Stage, Low Noise Advanced Technology Fan. Volume 1: Aerodynamic Design, NASA CR-134801. Figure 4. Optimum Geometry Verstraete T., 2012, Introduction to optimization and multidisciplinary design in aeronatics and turbomachinery, von Karman Institute for Fluid Dynamics Course Book Series. - Rhode St. Genése, Belgium. Wennerstrom, A. J., 2001, Design of Highly Loaded Axial-Flow Fans or Compressors, Concepts Eti. 25
You can also read