Motivation: Have we got the cart before the horse? - Växjökonferensen 28 januari 2019 - Växjökonferensen
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
How can we motivate students… • … to work harder … take on challenges … take risks? • By making them more successful. • Learning requires motivation, but motivation does not necessarily lead to learning.
‘Poor proxies’ for learning • Students are busy: lots of work is done (especially written work) • Students are engaged, interested, motivated • Students are getting attention: feedback, explanations • Classroom is ordered, calm, under control • Curriculum has been ‘covered’ (i.e. presented to students in some form) • (At least some) students have supplied correct answers (whether or not they really understood them or could reproduce them independently) Robert Coe, Improving Education: a triumph of hope over experience
Effects and causes?
We can’t see causality Is motivation an effect or a cause?
A definition of learning • Learning is the long-term retention of knowledge and the ability to transfer it to new contexts. • Retention = durability • Transfer = flexibility
Performance Learning
Warszawa
The illusion of knowledge • Can you draw a bicycle? Lawson (2006)
A simple model of memory Environment n it o n A tte Learning Remembering Working memory Long-term memory We can only process about 4 ‘chunks’ of information at once. Cowan 2001
How knowledge organises in memory
Is it better to be told or to discover it for yourself? • Novices learn best with explicit instruction and worked examples (the worked example effect) • Experts learn best when direction is minimised (the imagination effect)
The problem with problem solving “Solving a problem requires problem-solving search and search must occur using our limited working memory… Thus, problem- solving search overburdens limited working memory and requires working memory resources to be used for activities that are unrelated to learning. As a consequence, learners can engage in problem-solving activities for extended periods and learn almost nothing.” Kirschner, Sweller & Clark (2006) p. 80
The expert Rapid retrieval helps deal with complexity Lots of relevant facts, Working similar memory Long-term examples and memory experiences Complex problem, minimal guidance Learned concepts
The novice Little useful to retrieve Working memory Few relevant Long-term facts, memory examples or Complex experiences problem, minimal guidance Learning stops or is negative Cognitive overload
The novice Little useful to retrieve Working memory Few relevant Long-term facts, memory examples or Guided experiences instruction Learned concepts
The curse of knowledge • Try explaining how to do something you are skilled at to someone who is not • ‘Tappers’ and ‘listeners’ • Listeners guessed correctly 3 out 120 times. • Tappers estimated listeners got over 50% right. Newton, E. (1990) “Overconfidence in the Communication of Intent: Heard and Unheard Melodies.”
Building motivation Beginning of a End of a course course Encode success Promote Independence Cognitive load internalisation theory; Explicit Desirable difficulties; instruction; spacing, interleaving, modelling, retrieval; Purposeful scaffolding practice
Summary 1. Learning and performance are not the same thing; the goals of education are long-term 2. Working memory limits what can be learned; knowledge stored in long-term memory helps overcome the limits of working memory 3. We can be intensively engaged in something with little or no resulting change in long-term memory 4. If we want to motivate students success must precede struggle
There’s nothing good or bad but thinking makes it so. @DavidDidau learningspy.co.uk ddidau@gmail.com
You can also read