Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL

Page created by Paula Maldonado
 
CONTINUE READING
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
ASLEF                                                    JOURNAL
The magazine of the Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers & Firemen
                                                                           AUGUST 2020

Taking a knee,
making a stand

   The train drivers’
   union since 1880
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
railway enginemen’s tax free saver plans

tax free savings plans
for anyone who
works on the railways...
we don’t mean just train drivers..!
tax free policies from 70p per day, £5 per week
and £20 per month

for further information call us on freephone 0800 328 9140
visit our website at www.enginemens.co.uk
or write to us at Railway Enginemen's Assurance Society Limited,
727 Washwood Heath Road, Birmingham, B8 2LE

     @RailwayEnginemens
                                                       Authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority.
                                                       Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority.
                                                       Incorporated under the Friendly Societies Act 1992
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
ASLEF                                                       JOURNAL
    The magazine of the Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers & Firemen
                                                                                       AUGUST 2020
                                                                                                                    GS Mick Whelan
                                                                                                                 Heart of recovery
                                                                                                                           AILY I spend most
                                                                                                                  D        of my time talking
                                                                                                                           about the
                                                                                                                 pandemic, its impact, what
                                                                                                                 we need to do, and arguing
                                                                                                                 about the safest and best
                                                                                                                 ways to deal with the
                                                                                                                 myriad issues that
                                                                                                                 continually crop up. To add ‘Chance to build
                                                                                                                 to the lexicon of phrases        a green economy’
                                                                                                                 that are grating on me,
                                           5                                                           8         along with ‘ramping up’, is ‘the new normal’. For
                                                                                                                 many, including the government, it looks like a
News                                                                                                             rush to the old normal.
l Covid-19: latest news from the GS and the EC
                                                                                                                     We have a vested interest in a successful
                                                                   4
                                                                                                                 transport sector and have worked, with sister
l Frank Rimmer and Bob Moran stick it to Boris                     5                                             trade unions, companies, and government, to
  plus Off the Rails: Meg Hillier; John Bolton;                                                                  increase capacity to encompass a rise in
  Gavin Williamson; Ruth Davidson; Julia Sawalha                                                                 passenger traffic to maintain the various steps in
l PM is living with Mr Roarke on Fantasy Island                    6                                             social distancing. But as the Prime Minister
l Transport Secretary signals the way ahead to the 7
                                                                                                                 encourages people back to work and to use
                                                                                                                 public transport (between 9am and 4pm) from 1
  Williams review set to be published next month
                                                                                                                 August I am fearful, as with the pictures we saw
l Happy Shapps? Grant takes a journey to the
  east (coast) and makes an ideological U-turn
                                                                   8
                                                                                                     10          when pubs reopened, and beaches were
                                                                                                                 inundated, that such mixed messaging will be
                                                                                                                 detrimental. If this backfires the message of key
Features                                                                                                         workers running essential services for key
l Gregor Gall reveals how Munira Mirza and other 10                                                              workers and a greater good will be much
  former members of the RCP have quietly moved                                                                   diminished.
  into positions of power and influence in Britain                                                                   We want the economy to recover and only
l Racists in my face: Ed d’Bell on being black in    11                                                          real investment will drive the growth we need,
  Britain. Taking a knee, raising a fist, and making                                                             otherwise wholesale unemployment will be a
  a stand: the powerful stories of Colin Kaepernick;                                                             reality. Our industry, some experts say, will take
  Tommie Smith; and Josiah Wedgwood                                                                  11          five years for passenger growth to return. I am
l Black lives matter: Shekhar Bhatia on football, 12-13
                                                                                                                 not so sure as we were previously
                                                                                                                 oversubscribed and unable to deal with
  fascism and National Front boot boys; and                                                                      population growth. Travel patterns will change,
  Steve Crowley on why we need to Kill the Bill                                                                  and the model may not be the Williams
l Katy Proctor reveals the dos and don’ts of data                14                                              approach, but we will campaign for rail to be at
  protection and the tricky old world of GDPR                                                                    the heart of the opportunity to build the green
l Roger Galloway-Smith on the demonization                       15                                              economy that was so popular and right before
  and destruction of GRT communities                                                                             the pandemic.

Regulars
                                                                                                     12              We have been trialing bubbles where drivers
                                                                                                                 work together after testing to facilitate in-cab
l    Branch Lines: We want your photographs         16                                                           training for handling and traction conversions
l
                                                                                                                 and those pilots have been successful so
     Points and Crossings: Kurdistan and TfL        17                                                           companies are seeking to do their own
l    Double Heading: Ian Prosser; and Andy Kitson 19                                                             reviewable trials. Work has also been done to run
l    Letters and Classified Advertisements       20-21                                                           a pilot for the needs of the sandite and other
l Chris Proctor lifts the lid on the tawdry history
                                                                                                                 needs and other workshops are reporting back
                                                                 22
                                                                                                                 on the industry efforts in partnership to find
  of pay to play: how British businessmen have
  persuaded politicians to do what they want                                                         15          solutions to safe working in confined spaces.

l On Track: Brian Jackman fondly recalls family
                                                                                                                 Previous work had already been completed on
                                                                 23                                              socially-distanced classroom and static training.
  hols that began on the Cornish Riviera Express;                                                                The measures are all reviewable and at this time
  our Prize Crossword; ASLEF’s Legal Services;                                                                   there is no intention to move away from our
  and members’ Change of Address form                                                                            policy and best practice in bulletin eight.
                                                                                                                     There will be many challenges, but we will
      The ASLEF Journal is published every month by:                                                             not allow opportunism by bad actors to
      ASLEF, 77 St John Street, London, EC1M 4NN                                                                 unreasonably undermine our terms and
      Tel: 020 7324 2400 l email: journal@aslef.org.uk
      website: www.aslef.org.uk l twitter: @ASLEFUnion                                               22          conditions or agreements. Finally, my thanks to
                                                                                                                 all the branch secretaries, reps, officers, EC, and
                                                                                                                 staff for going the extra yard for us all. Please be
EdiToR Mick Whelan l dESiGNER Michael Cronin l PRiNTER College Hill Press, London, SW19 4HE
AdvERTiSiNG ASLEF Journal, 77 St John Street, London, EC1M 4NN. Contact Keith Richmond on 020 7324 2407 or
                                                                                                                 safe and well.
richmondk@aslef.org.uk l ClASSiFiEd AdS journal@aslef.org.uk or call 020 7324 2400. The acceptance of a          Yours fraternally
display or classified advertisement does not necessarily imply endorsement of that product or service by ASLEF
CHANGE oF AddRESS Please post your details to ASLEF, 77 St John Street, Clerkenwell, London, EC1M 4NN            Mick Whelan, general secretary

                                                                                                                         August 2020 l The ASLEF Journal           3
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
News

Too much
too soon
           SLEF has criticised the government’s
 A         decision to ditch its covid-19 working
           from home guidance – in place since
March – and tell millions of people to start
using public transport again and return to
their offices as ‘too much, too soon’.                                                                     QUOTE…
    Boris Johnson used his regular coronavirus                                                             ‘We’re working hard to get the virus,
crisis press conference on Friday 17 July to beg                                                           I mean, the vaccine’ – Matt Hancock,
Brits to get back to work to boost the country’s                                                           Today, Radio 4, Wednesday 15 July
economy. He unveiled a new ‘contain
                                                                                                                                    …UNQUOTE
framework’ designed to show that the virus is
under control.
    The Prime Minister urged people to use               Mick: ‘We cannot deliver safely                   that this is the right time to relax procedures
public transport between 9am and 4pm,                    anywhere like the peaks of the past’              designed to keep passengers, and staff, safe
rather than travel during peak times, saying:                                                              from covid-19 on public transport in Britain.
‘There is a lot of spare capacity that is not        ensure the increase in capacity that allows safe         ‘As train drivers we believe in public
being used.’                                         travel and operation with proper social               transport – we love trains! – and we want
    GS Mick Whelan said: ‘We need clarity and        distancing.                                           people to use trains and buses. But we want
we are not getting clarity from this                    ‘Mr Johnson must be careful not to send            passengers to be able to travel safely and this
government. Mr Johnson and his ministers             out more mixed messages that compromise               seems to be too much, too soon.’
have become the masters of mixed messaging           the safety of key workers travelling or                  Mick added: ‘We look forward to the time
and misleading information.                          operating all modes of transport.                     when we can safely get back to normal and rail
    ‘We have worked with the industry and the           ‘We cannot deliver safely anywhere like the        forms the backbone of a green economic
government throughout this pandemic to               peaks of the past and we are not convinced            recovery for Britain.’

                                                                                 by Ron Greenwood in
England dropped Jack                                                             the boot room at West
                                                                                                              TWEETS OF THE MONTH
                                                                                 Ham where he
because he was black                                                             cleaned the boots of,
                                                                                                                  So glad the government found the
                                                                                                                  magic money tree…phew.
                                                                                 among others, Clyde
                                                                                                              @raygarland70
Plymouth branch is         inside-left who scored                                Best, then one of the
backing a campaign         137 goals in 401                                      few black footballers
                                                                                                                   Chris Grayling fails to become
to erect a statue in       appearances for                                       in the top flight of
                                                                                                                   intelligence and security chair.
honour of a footballer     Plymouth Argyle.                                      English football (see
                                                                                                              Conservative colleague Julian Lewis
picked to play for             Bob Jack, the                                     page 12).
                                                                                                              humiliates PM’s pick.
England in 1925 –          Argyle manager, called                                    The Jack Leslie
                                                     Jack leslie                                              @guardiannews
then dropped by the        Jack into his office to                               Campaign, run by fans
selectors when they        tell him he was           0-0 draw in Belfast,        of Plymouth Argyle,
                                                                                                                  ‘Chris Grayling fails’ the new
discovered he was          playing for England       Jack scored twice as        Exeter City, and
                                                                                                                  dystopian children’s party game.
black.                     against Ireland; but      Argyle beat                 Torquay United, is
                                                                                                              @SimonWeller
    Jack Leslie, born at   when the selectors        Bournemouth 7-2 at          trying to raise
Canning Town in the        realised he was black     Home Park.                  £100,000 to put up a
                                                                                                                 Nigel Farage hired by Fox News as a
East End of London in      they replaced him             After Jack retired as   statue of Jack in
                                                                                                                 political anal cyst [sic]
1900, to an English        with Billy Walker of      a boilermaker back in       memory of the man,
                                                                                                              @BBCNews
mother and Jamaican        Aston Villa. While        the East End, he was        to celebrate diversity,
father, was a prolific     England struggled to a    offered a part-time job     and combat racism.
                                                                                                                   I’m not planning to prepare for Brexit,
                                                                                                                   instead I’m going to let it creep up on
ASLEF remembers                         THE GS: PLEASE EMAIL US YOUR DETAILS                                  me and surprise me, like dementia does.
                                        ‘Last month we asked you to update or provide your email              @Trump_ton
GS Mick Whelan paused on                addresses so we can get virtual branches up and running.
Tuesday 7 July to reflect on events     We now have in excess of 13,000 on file – so thanks! – but if
15 years ago. He said: ‘We must         you have not done so I would encourage you to do it. We
never forget those impacted by          shall be issuing guidance and support to make this
the loss and tragedy of 7/7 and be      happen. All members will have to download the Zoom app                         our hip, hot and very much
vigilant to ensure that it does not     (it’s free) while branch secretaries will be asked to subscribe                happening red baseball cap
happen again. As we remember            to Zoom, reclaimable from head office. Please engage                           will keep the sun out of
the victims and families we all         when it is up and running; it’s your union, and your voice.                    your eyes this summer.
give thanks to the staff and            The system has been trialed by district councils, internal                     Price £5 (inc p&p); email
emergency services that not only        meetings, and the executive committee, in the past few                info@aslef.org.uk or visit our online
gave succour but prevented              months but, inevitably, there will be some teething                   shop at www.aslef.org.uk
much greater loss of life and hurt.’    problems over our 170-plus branches as we introduce this.’

4 The ASLEF Journal l August 2020
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
News

                                                         that Bob Moran, lead
‘Speak, hands, for                                       political cartoonist at
                                                         the Daily Telegraph,       off the Rails
me!’‘Et tu, Brute?                                       who used to work for
                                                         The Guardian and
                                                                                                    MEG HILLIER, Labour MP for Hackney South &
                                                         Morning Star,
Then fall, Caesar!’                                      portrayed the Prime
                                                         Minister on Saturday
                                                                                                    Shoreditch, and chair of the House of Commons
                                                                                                    Public Accounts Committee, has warned that
           RANK            from the letter E in          11 July as ‘dead as a                      England’s taps could well run dry within 20

 F         Rimmer, a
           driver with
                           ‘letdown’.
                                ‘The original is sold,
                                                         dodo’. The payoff line
                                                         is telling: ‘Can be
                                                                                                    years. She urged the Department for
                                                                                                    Environment, Food & Rural Affairs, together
TransPennine Express,      but I have prints             viewed by many             with the Environment Agency, and the regulator Ofwat, to
and a member of our        available,’ says Frank.       today as being stuffed’.   act to prevent a country with so much rainfall running out of
Preston branch, is a            Things are not               For the Torygraph –    water. Privatisation of the water industry – like privatisation
talented artist to boot.   going well for the            a paper for whom the       of Britain’s railways – has been a complete disaster, with the
    In this, his latest    Prime Minister who is         PM still writes – to       privatised water companies refusing to invest in
painting, the Prime        nervous that Tory MPs         have a pop shows           infrastructure, refusing to repair leaks, jacking up prices, and
Minister is portrayed      are about to do to him        how vulnerable his         taking as much money as possible out of the system in profits
as Bumbling Boris, in a    what they did to              position now is. It’s      and dividends. More than 3 billion litres of water a day are
neat visual and verbal     Theresa May. Johnson          not just Dishy Rishi,      lost in leaks – a situation Meg describes as ‘wholly
pun, a bumble bee          spent years plotting          who many see as not        unacceptable’. A spokesperson for Environment Secretary
struggling – within a      and planning against          only more popular,         George Eustice could only mutter, ‘We recognise the need to
green and yellow           first, David Cameron,         but more decisive,         safeguard water supplies for future generations’. Which, like
border rather              and then, Mrs May,            and more successful,       ‘Useless’ Eustice, comes up woefully short.
reminiscent of a           and knows how it’s            but Michael Gove,
Norwich City football      done.                         ever disloyal, is out on                       JOHN BOLTON, former US National Security
shirt from the 1990s –          He also knows that       manoeuvres, too.                               Adviser, pulls few punches in his book The
with Brexit, the NHS,      – like Cassius, Cinna,                                                       Room Where It Happened (Simon & Schuster,
and the coronavirus        Brutus, and the other                                                        £25). The problem, he says, is not so much
crisis. Dominic            conspirators in Julius                                                       having a boss with whom he disagreed as
Cummings, the              Caesar – Conservative                                                        having a boss – the President – so
Premier’s evil goblin,     MPs smell weakness                                                           dysfunctional that it wasn’t possible to
who got away with          like sharks smell blood                                                      construct coherent policies. Donald Trump is,
lying about breaking       and are quick to turn                                    he says, exceedingly rude; meetings resemble ‘college food
the government’s           on bumbling leaders                                      fights’; and he’s ignorant, asking if Finland is part of Russia.
lockdown, hangs on         they see as losers.                                      Well, to be fair, it was from 1809 to 1917, but, sadly, that
an opened padlock               Things are so bad                                   wasn’t what the Donald meant. And, although treaties take
                                                                                    years to negotiate, Trump believes he can solve every
                                                                                    problem in a face to face meeting in a couple of hours.

                                                                                                      One of Boris Johnson’s many faults is that he
                                                                                                      is famously thin-skinned. Which you cannot
                                                                                                      say of RUTH DAVIDSON. The former leader
                                                                                                      of the Scottish Conservative Party cheerfully
                                                                                                      sent herself up after comments, less than
                                                                                                      flattering, about her appearance. ‘I once
                                                                                    accepted an award saying it had been a brilliant day because,
                                                                                    earlier, I had come second in a Kim Jong-un lookalike
                                                                                    competition. So it is kind of my own fault…’

                                                                                                     GAVIN WILLIAMSON, the over-promoted,
                                                                                                     under-achieving, Secretary of State for
                                                                                                     Education, was given six of the very best by
  Bob’s BoJo dodo (above) and Frank’s bumbling bee (above right)                                     John Crace in The Guardian. ‘Most Education
                                                                                                     Secretaries end up sounding like
                                                                                                     headteachers. Not Williamson. He is firmly
   QUOTE…                                                                                            stuck at the level of an out-of-his-depth sixth
   ‘We were promised a New Deal but got a Meal Deal’                                former. Nothing he says comes with any real conviction. He’s
   – Anneliese Dodds, Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer                            even lost the elan he once had of twice winning fireplace
                                                           …UNQUOTE                 salesman of the year (2006 and 2008). He just aspires to the
                                                                                    dull monotone of the supply teacher praying for class to end.’
500 CLUB: Malcolm Dixon, with number 218, won the July draw,
scooping the Retired Members’ Section jackpot of £480.                                              JULIA SAWALHA, who played Saffy in
                                                                                                    Absolutely Fabulous, Lydia Bennet in Pride and
                                                                                                    Prejudice, and Dorcas Lane in Lark Rise to
              Our smart black leather wallet – with embossed                                        Candleford, had a bit of fun on Twitter when told
              ASLEF logo on the front – has three fold-out and                                      she had been axed from the sequel to Chicken
              removable plastic inserts (ie, the wallet can hold six                                Run – she voiced Ginger – because, at 51, she’s
              credit cards). Price £10 inc p&p; email                               ‘too old’. ‘I have been plucked, stuffed, and roasted.’
     info@aslef.org.uk or visit our online shop at www.aslef.org.uk

                                                                                                              August 2020 l The ASLEF Journal           5
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
News

Premier is living
on Fantasy Island
           SLEF reacted angrily        2012 when, as Mayor of London,
 A         after Boris Johnson
           suggested that driverless
                                       Boris Johnson vowed to introduce
                                       driverless trains “within two years”
trains on London Underground           – show he has no grasp of the
should be a condition of the           realities of running a modern
funding settlement for Transport       railway. He is, say those who do,
for London this autumn.                living with Mr Roarke on Fantasy
    The Prime Minister, on a site      Island.
visit to a new £200 million                DO8 Finn Brennan, ASLEF’s
Siemens factory at Goole in East       organiser on London                    The PM, who donned his favourite
Yorkshire on Monday 6 July, said:      Underground, said: ‘As always,         hi-vis jacket for the photo op on his trip
‘You can run these trains without      Johnson is talking nonsense            to Goole, seems to think he’s in a
the need for somebody to be            about driverless trains. Slashing      remake of the once popular telly show
sitting in the driver’s cab the        government funding to TfL              which starred Ricardo Montalbán as Mr
whole time. So what I will be          means they cannot afford the           Roarke and Hervé villechaize as Tattoo
saying to the London transport         signalling upgrade, and other
authority is let’s take advantage of   technology, that would be              coronavirus crisis, these very same    the spirit of co-operation to me.’
this technological leap forward,       needed for “driverless trains”.        workers are being treated with             Driverless trains are simply not
let’s not be the prisoners of the      While pretending to support a          contempt and told they’re now          viable in the deep tunnels and on
unions any more, let’s go to           “great leap forward” the Prime         not needed.                            the Victorian infrastructure of the
driverless trains, and let’s make      Minister’s policies are actually           ‘For the Prime Minister to claim   London Underground. It would
that a condition of the funding        preventing any progress with           that rail unions are holding the       not be safe to run services
settlement for Transport for           transport in the capital; they         country as “prisoners” after we’ve     without a trained member of staff
London this autumn.                    mean that Londoners will suffer        all worked closely with the            on board in case of emergency.
    ‘That’s the way forward for this   years of delays and overcrowding       government and DfT to keep our         Even the Docklands Light Railway,
country and we want to make use        in the future.’                        network working throughout the         which was purpose-built to be
of the fantastic technology we’ve          And a furious Mick Whelan          crisis, is nothing short of            driverless, is staffed with a train
got and provide a better service       said: ‘Train drivers on London         scandalous. Perhaps he should          captain able to drive the train if
for people in the capital and take     Underground have continued to          speak to his own Transport             necessary.
the whole economy forward.’            work throughout this pandemic          Secretary who, last month, was             The GS dryly concluded: ‘This is
    As the trade union which           to make sure fellow key workers        thanking us for working with him       desperate stuff which is
represents 96% of the train drivers    can get to work and back. It’s         and said, “I look forward to           unworkable and unnecessary.
in England, Scotland, and Wales,       quite disgraceful that, whilst we’re   continued collaboration in future,     People will be making driverless
ASLEF was quick to respond to          still in the midst of this pandemic,   because co-operation will be key       car journeys to Barnard Castle
remarks which – although in line       partly due to this hopeless            to setting the country on the road     before taking a driverless Tube
with an ambition he first voiced in    government’s slow reaction to the      to recovery.” This doesn’t look like   train to Elephant & Castle.’

                                                                              Stagecoach loses High Court battle
    Work practices ‘archaic’                                                                              The Department for Transport has
                                                                                                          welcomed a High Court verdict that the
    Two rail workers killed while working on the track at                                                 government’s decision to block
    Margam, in south Wales, on 3 July 2019, lost their lives                                              Stagecoach from bidding for three rail
    because working practices ‘aren’t fit for purpose’ according                                          franchises – in a row over pensions –
    to the family of one of the men who died.                                                             was lawful. The bus company was
       An investigation by Network Rail found that Gareth                                                 trying to wriggle out of its obligations
    delbridge, 64, and Michael lewis, 58, had been using a tool               to employees. The judge found that the franchise process was
    with a petrol engine, and wearing ear defenders, meaning                  ‘fair and transparent’ and the block on Stagecoach
    they could not hear an approaching train travelling from                  ‘proportionate’. The firm said it ‘was disappointed [but] we accept
    Swansea to Paddington. The report said six staff working                  the decision and move on.’
    on the line had separated, of their own accord, into groups
    of three, meaning there was no official lookout. it also said
    that the Port Talbot depot’s management’s ‘habitual ways                                                                       Carry all your
    of working had normalised behaviour inherently non-                          QUOTE…
                                                                                                                                   stuff – papers,
    compliant with company standards’.                                           ‘Bolsonaro, Trump and
                                                                                                                                   sandwiches, keys
       Mr delbridge’s son-in-law, Adrian Grant, called the                       Johnson: these are men you
                                                                                                                       – in style with our smart
    company’s working practices ‘archaic’. He said: ‘They’ve got                 wouldn’t put in charge of
                                                                                                                       new sturdy black ASlEF
    men with flags and whistles or horns in front of                             containing an outbreak of
                                                                                                                       bag. Price £17.50 (inc p&p);
    locomotives travelling at 120mph.’                                           acne.’ – Ferdinand Mount,
                                                                                                                       email info@aslef.org.uk or
       The company said it is working hard to improve the                        London Review of Books
                                                                                                                       visit our online shop at
    safety of workers on the railway.                                                         …UNQUOTE                 www.aslef.org.uk

6 The ASLEF Journal l August 2020
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
News

Shapps to bring railways
back under public control
           RANT Shapps has told          ‘failed franchise system’ and
 G         MPs that the coronavirus
           crisis has created an
                                         replace it with management
                                         contracts. Instead of bidding for a
opportunity to run ‘a different          franchise, and taking the fare box,
type of railway’.                        operators would receive a fixed
    The Secretary of State for           fee for running a service while the
Transport told the House of              Treasury would collect the cash
Commons Transport Select                 and the government would own
Committee on Wednesday 24                the routes.                           Grant Shapps has admitted that John Major got it wrong and 26 years
June that the government will use            The new system will be            of rail privatisation hasn’t delivered for passengers, staff, or taxpayers
emergency covid-19 measures to           overseen by a new board of
take control of Britain’s railways.      control, which is likely to be        a three-way dog fight between          together’ – and compared it to the
    While he is not proposing a          chaired by the Transport Secretary,   Williams, the DfT, and Downing         Transport for London model
return to full public ownership –        giving the DfT greater control of     Street, and then the covid-19          where an operator is awarded a
for which ASLEF has long                 timetables and fares. It would also   crisis, has seen his review put on     contract to run London
campaigned and which was                 give the network the ‘guiding         the back burner.                       Overground.
promised in the last Labour Party        mind’ which Keith Williams has            Williams’ proposals will provide      The Williams review should
manifesto – it is, nonetheless, a        called for in his rail review in      Shapps with cover if he comes          now be published in September.
remarkable volte face by a               leaked criticism of the ‘fragmented   under attack from the TOCs, the
Conservative government.                 nature of our privatised railways’.   RDG, or some of the ideologically-
    Because it is an admission that          That review was ready to be       driven, uber free market, ‘swivel-
the privatisation of the UK rail         published before last Christmas –                                               QUOTE…
                                                                               eyed loons’ on the government’s
network by John Major in 1994 –          when Williams briefed ASLEF                                                     ‘We would welcome Prince
                                                                               backbenches.
which even Margaret Thatcher,            about it in November he told the                                                Andrew coming in to talk
                                                                                   The Transport Secretary told
that arch advocate of                    GS that the structure he would                                                  with us’ – New York
                                                                               the committee he would ‘bring
privatisation, famously described        propose could work whether the                                                  prosecutor Audrey
                                                                               the railway back together’ –
as ‘a privatisation too far’ – was       railway was in public ownership,                                                Strauss after charging
                                                                               ironically, nicking a phrase from
utterly wrong-headed and simply          under Labour, or still privatised,                                              his pal Ghislaine Maxwell
                                                                               our GS, as Mick has often called
hasn’t worked.                           under the Tories – but the general    on the government to ‘bring the                       …UNQUOTE
    Shapps is proposing to end the       election in December, followed by     wheels and the steel back

Warner slams TOCs
Alex Warner, chair of the West
Midlands Grand Rail
                                             Dawlish 2.0
Collaboration, which brings                  Plans have been submitted to Teignbridge
together TOCs, FOCs, Network                 district council in south Devon for the rest
Rail, and the West Midlands Rail             of the £80 million sea wall to protect the
Executive, has lashed out at the             vital rail artery to the south-west of
attitude of the privatised train             England from rough weather, and rising
operating companies.                         sea levels, for the foreseeable future.
    ‘Professionals seem to be                   Work on the first section of the wall, at
designated into one of two                   Marine Parade, should be finished this
categories – operations or                   summer. The second section, a 415 metre
customer service,’ he said. ‘I’ve            stretch between the Coastguards and
always been thrown into the “He’s            Colonnade breakwaters, will ‘return the
Mr Customer Services, pink and               waves to the sea and reduce the amount of          These panels in the new sea wall are designed to
fluffy, we’ll come to customer               water and spray reaching the tracks’.              deflect the power of the waves back out to sea
service once we’ve sorted the
operations out” type category.
You go away and play and make            NETWORK RAIL ON TRACK IN EAST ANGLIA
staff be friendly and smile and          Network Rail has started a six month programme of track improvements                           Time for a
we’ll do the real stuff of running       in the Anglia region. It includes track renewal and signalling work at                         brew? This
trains from a to b.                      Colchester and Needham Market on the Norwich to London main line;                              red ASlEF
    ‘I’ve stumbled across this kind      near Elmswell on the Ipswich to Bury St Edmunds line; and on the                               mug is just
of sentiment over the years and it       Clacton on Sea branch line. Overhead wires at Stratford are also being                         the job for
does bemuse me. Because,                 replaced to improve reliability, especially in very hot weather.                tea or coffee in the mess
actually, customer service is a big                                                                                      room or at home. £3.50
part of the operation. I think this is   TOGETHER IN ELECTRIC DREAMS                                                     (inc p&p); email
something they do see in the             Hitachi Rail has begun building five all-electric intercity Class 803s for      info@aslef.org.uk or visit
West Midlands but, historically,         the open access operator East Coast Trains at its Newton Aycliffe plant in      our online shop at
across parts of the industry, it’s       County Durham. The trains are set to enter service on the main line             www.aslef.org.uk
not always been the case.’               between Edinburgh and London in autumn 2021.

                                                                                                               August 2020 l The ASLEF Journal         7
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
News

                                                                                                                                         infrastructure, should
Happy Shapps on                                                                                                                          be run as a public
                                                                                                                                         service, not as an
journey to the east                                                                                                                      opportunity for a few
                                                                                                                                         people to plunder a
          SLEF has        2023, with an option                                                                                           private profit.
 A        welcomed
          news that
                          to extend until 2025.
                              ‘We welcome this
                                                                                                                                         Especially as these
                                                                                                                                         profits – cash which
East Coast main line      announcement,                                                                                                  leaks from our railway
services will continue    which is a sensible                                                                                            system – is made off
to be run by the state    decision, and which                                                                                            the back of an
for up to five more       offers clarity and                                                                                             enormous public
years. The                security in the short-                                                                                         subsidy!’ Mick added:
government has            term to both                                                                                                   ‘As the government
announced that the        passengers and staff,’                                                                                         has indicated it is
publicly-owned train      said GS Mick Whelan.                                                 ‘Good news about lNER,’ said Mick.        moving from the
operator London               ‘But we think the                                                ‘Now let’s make it permanent!’            failed franchise
North Eastern             government should                                                                                              model to a new
Railway will run          announce that this         what passengers                after survey, that it’s    opinion, want, too.       concession model,
services on the line      line will stay in public   want, it’s what rail           what voters, of all            ‘Because the          why do we need the
between London and        ownership                  staff want, and we             political parties and      railway, which is a key   involvement of these
Edinburgh until June      permanently. It’s          know, from survey              shades of ideological      part of this country’s    privateers, anyway?’

Capital punishment                                                                                             Up on the roof
After Sadiq Khan, the     failure to help.
Mayor of London,              GS Mick Whelan
revealed the crushing     said: ‘London is not
financial cost of the     just Britain’s capital,
coronavirus crisis on     but one of the world’s
the capital on            biggest and most                                 Finn: ‘We will fight to defend
Thursday 18 June,         exciting cities, with a                          our pay, t&cs, and pensions’
predicting a £500         public transport
million shortfall over    system essential for                                      working conditions,
the next two years,       helping people move        lifted, play. It is also the   not more cuts.
ASLEF condemned           about for work and,        only major metro                   ‘Government
the government for its    when lockdown is           system in the world            incompetence has led       Mayor Marvin Rees (left) and Mike Gallop of
                                                     with zero central              to some of the worst       Network Rail (centre) join a socially distanced
                                                     funding. And that is a         public health              (and a very carefully gender balanced)
Are subs tax deductible?                             disgrace.’                     outcomes in Europe,        restoration team pic at Temple Meads
Mark Kennerley, of Manchester Piccadilly,                 DO8 Finn Brennan,         coupled with huge
wrote to the Journal last month: ‘Whilst filling     our organiser on the           economic damage.           The famous Grade 1 listed Victorian roof of
in my tax return it came to my attention that        Underground, said:             But they still find no     Bristol Temple Meads station is to be
union subscriptions could be tax deductible. I       ‘Deep cuts to essential        difficulty in organising   restored to its former glory in a £24
found a list of HMRC approved organisations          public services in the         a multi-billion pound      million three year restoration scheme.
for deducting tax against subs but,                  capital are on the way.        quantitative easing           ‘This is a great moment for Bristol, and
regrettably, ASLEF is not on the list.’              For months essential           programme that             the whole of the West of England,
    ‘Thanks, Mark, for bringing this to our          workers have been              benefits those who         providing a brighter station for
attention,’ said GS Mick Whelan, who                 called “heroes” but            are already wealthy.       passengers worthy of Isambard Kingdom
promised: ‘We will look into this.’                  now they will have to              ‘We don’t need         Brunel,’ said Mike Gallop, Western route
    Nikki Newing, ASLEF’s finance manager,           fight to protect their         applause for low-paid      director at Network Rail. ‘We’re ambitious
has. ‘HMRC has defined subscriptions that can        jobs, their pay, and           essential workers. We      about our plans, and this is the first step in
be used for tax relief,’ she reports. ‘ASLEF subs    their conditions of            need strong and            providing a world class station to enable
are not one of them. We have raised this but it      employment.                    determined trade           more people to get to their jobs and
is in the hands of HMRC. If you look on the               ‘The London               unions that will fight     encouraging more investment in the area.’
HMRC website there are definitions and they          Mayor has decided to           to defend them if the         Marvin Rees, Mayor of Bristol, who
stem around being professionals (Institute of        cut his own salary but         government is not          addressed AAD at the Marriott Hotel in the
Directors, ICAEW, ACCA, etc). HMRC is not,           public service workers,        prepared to properly       city in 2017, added: ‘This is a much-needed
sadly, particularly forthcoming with non-            and millions of others,        fund our public            step forward in the enhancement of the
professional associations and trade unions!’         need better pay and            services.’                 station and a significant boost for Bristol
                                                                                                               during this really difficult time.’
                ASLEF’s young members                    QUOTE…                                                   The project is part of a programme of
                are driving the future. If               ‘Housing Secretary Robert Jenrick                     rail upgrades designed to improve
                you’re 35 or under, wear                 sweated under the glare of the                        reliability and capacity which includes the
                our badge with pride for                 Commons lights like a saveloy in a chip               remodelling of a crucial junction just
                just £3 (inc p&p); email                 shop’ – Henry Deedes,                                 outside Temple Meads station, complete
  info@aslef.org.uk or visit our online                  parliamentary sketch, Daily Mail                      rewiring, and the construction of a new
  shop at www.aslef.org.uk                                                                                     entrance for a new Bristol University
                                                                                       …UNQUOTE
                                                                                                               campus and the east of the city.

8 The ASLEF Journal l August 2020
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
The ASLEF RMS 500 Club
Colleagues

The 500 Club is a fundraising venture for ASLEF’s Retired Members’ Section.

Conditions of Membership: Only retired and working members of ASLEF, including district councils and branches,
plus permanent staff employed by ASLEF, can make an application to join the RMS 500 Club. The application form
and standing order form can only be completed and submitted by the ASLEF member, or staff member.

Numbers in the draw cost £4 each per month. To begin making payments into club funds, all you have to do is
complete the standing order form and return it to your bank. Alternatively, you can pay by cheque a year in
advance; the cheque should be made payable to ASlEF RMS 500 Club. Payments need to reach the club account
by 1st of every month and the draw takes place on 12th of every month – with the winning number, name, and
prize printed on page 5 of the ASLEF Journal. Once you have arranged your method of payment just complete the
form and return it to Peter J Smith, Treasurer, RMS 500 Club, 6 devonia Gardens, london, N18 1AF.

The Retired Members’ Section committee would like to thank you for your support and wish you luck in the draw!

Yours fraternally, Peter J Smith, treasurer, ASlEF Retired Members’ Section 500 Club

                                                                                                                                   STANDING ORDER MANDATE
   ASLEF RMS 500 Club
                                                                                        To              ______________________________               Bank
   application form
                                                                                        Address         ______________________________

                                                                                         ________________________________________
   Name.....................................................................
                                                                                         ________________________________________
   Address.................................................................
                                                                                                                           BANK                     BRANCH TITLE (NOT ADDRESS)                 SORTING CODE NO.
   .................................................................................
                                                                                        Please pay                 Unity Trust Bank                         Birmingham                           08-60-01
                                                                                                                                                                                                60-83-01
   ..................................................................................
   .................................................................................                                            BENEFICIARY’S NAME                                  ACCOUNT NUMBER

   Postcode...............................................................              For the credit of             ASLEF RMS 500 CLUB ACCOUNT                       2     0      2      0    1     1      9        3

   Telephone............................................................                                       AMOUNT IN FIGURES                   AMOUNT IN WORDS

   ..................................................................................   The sum of             £

   email......................................................................
                                                                                                               DATE AND AMOUNT OF FIRST PAYMENT                                         DUE DATE AND FREQUENCY
   ..................................................................................   Commencing                                     £                    and thereafter every        1ST OF EVERY MONTH
   Each number costs £4. You can
   purchase as many numbers as you like.                                                                       DATE AND AMOUNT OF LAST PAYMENT
   I confirm that I wish to purchase ____                                               *Until                                        £
                                                                                                                                                            *Until you receive further notice from me/us in writing
                                                                                        Quoting the
   numbers as part of the 500 Club.                                                                                                                         and debit my/our account accordingly
                                                                                        reference

   (A) I have set up my standing order (£48                                                       Please cancel any previous standing order or direct debit in favour of the beneficiary named above
   per annum or £4 per month)
                                                                                                               SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
   (B) I enclose a cheque for advance
   payment (£48 per annum).
   Delete (A) or (B) accordingly.                                                                                           ACCOUNT TO BE DEBITED                                   ACCOUNT NUMBER

   Signed..................................................................
                                                                                        Signature(s) ________________________________________                                Date __________________________

   Date............................................                                                     ________________________________________

   Please return this coupon to:
                                                                                        Note: The Bank will not undertake to:      (i)      make any reference to Value Added Tax or other indeterminate element
   Peter Smith, Treasurer, RMS 500 Club,                                                                                           (ii)     advise payer’s address to beneficiary
   6 Devonia Gardens, London, N18 1AF                                                                                              (iii)    advise beneficiary of inability to pay
                                                                                                                                   (iv)     request beneficiary’s banker to advise beneficiary of receipt
   and the standing order mandate
   (right) to your bank (or via your                                                    * Delete if not applicable
                                                                                        If the amounts of the periodic payments vary, they should be incorporated in a schedule overleaf
   internet bank)

                                                                                                                                                                       July 2020 l The ASLEF Journal                      9
Taking a knee, making a stand - ASLEFJOURNAL
Firebox

Take a long day’s
journey into night
             GREGOR GALL, an affiliate
             research associate at
             Glasgow University, and
             editor of the Scottish Left
             Review, reveals how
Munira Mirza and several other                                                                                                           if you’re glad,
members of the Revolutionary                                                                                                             i’ll be Frank.
Communist Party have quietly moved                                                                                                       Richards or
into positions of power and influence                                                                                                    Furedi. Mirza
                                                                                                                                         or Fox
           UNIRA Mirza is a name you may not –      dissolved in 1997.
 M         but should get to – know. Because
           she may end up as powerful as
                                                        RCP politics – often described as ‘typically
                                                    Trot’ – were originally based around opposition
Dominic Cummings although she is less keen          to the intervention of the capitalist state in the
on being in the public eye. She was appointed       lives of working-class people, fierce criticism of
director of Boris Johnson’s Downing Street          Labour as a reformist party, and the rejection
policy unit last summer, having previously          of state controls over immigration and imports.
worked for him as a Deputy Mayor when he                In 1983 it launched its general election
was Mayor of London.                                manifesto called, somewhat optimistically,           desirability of minimal government
   But it was her appointment as head of a          Preparing for Power. Its four candidates, led by     intervention and control. This ranges from
government commission on racial                     Furedi, got just 581 votes.                          climate change and vaccinations to fox
inequalities, following the Black Lives Matter                                                           hunting and paedophilia, amongst many other
protests this summer, that really got her           THINK TANK OF SWIVEL-EYED LOONS                      subjects.
noticed.                                            The RCP’s far-left politics slowly morphed into          The story of progressive young lefties
   ‘Why?’ you may ask. Well, Johnson was cute       opposition to any form of state intervention.        becoming crotchety old Conservatives is not
enough to appoint a young Muslim woman of           Seizing their chance, right-wing libertarians        new. The International Socialists, which
Pakistani descent rather than an old white          welcomed these ‘Johnny-come-latelies’ into           became the Socialist Workers’ Party, once
man who used to be a judge. But, troublingly,       their ‘advanced disruptor’ fold, railing against     boasted Garry Bushell, who went on to The Sun
Munira Mirza is on record, and on message, as       the ‘nanny state’ and calling for more neo-          and promoted the proto-fascist Oi movement;
a critic of multiculturalism which, she believes,   liberal deregulation. Mirza worked for Policy        Peter Hitchens, who now writes a column for
‘fuels a sense of exclusion’.                       Exchange, favourite think tank of the ‘swivel-       the Mail on Sunday; Wendy Henry, who
   She has also attacked the anti-racism            eyed loons’ – as David Cameron called them –         became editor of the News of the World; and
movement as a ‘bogus moral crusade’ and             between 2005 and 2007.                               Rod Liddle, who writes racist columns for The
casts doubt on whether institutional racism             She is not the only fellow traveller to tread    Spectator and Sunday Times. In fairness to this
exists. Which, of course, is just what Whitey in    this path from the RCP to a position of power        motley crew, they did renounce their former
Westminster wants to hear.                          and influence in the UK today.                       politics.
                                                        Claire Fox founded the Institute of Ideas,           And therein lies a key difference. While the
MIRZA’S MADE AN EXTRAORDINARY                       got a regular spot on Radio 4’s Moral Maze,          SWP crowd turned their backs on their former
POLITICAL JOURNEY FROM FRANK                        and, briefly, became a Brexit Party MEP. She is      comrades, the RCP crew have not. They are far
FUREDI TO BORIS JOHNSON                             also a climate change denier. And was co-            more influential now, as entryists and
But lying underneath this BLM controversy is        publisher of Living Marxism which closed in          infiltrators, than they ever were before. Some
the extraordinary political journey Munira          2000 after falsely accusing ITN of faking            say they will end up as a Tory version of those
Mirza has undertaken from one end of the            evidence of Bosnian genocide.                        thinkers behind the Communist Party’s
political spectrum – as a far-left Trotskyist           Her sister Fiona Fox runs the Science Media      Marxism Today magazine who later provided
revolutionary – to the other – as a far-right       Centre, a ‘pro-science’ organisation that lobbies    the intellectual ballast for Tony Blair’s New
libertarian reactionary – because she used to       aggressively – and not always accurately, say        Labour project.
be an active member of the Revolutionary            critics – for industry, on controversial subjects
Communist Party which has exerted a                 such as genetically modified crops and               MAKE THE LONG MARCH THROUGH
profound influence on her ideological               ‘Frankenstein food’.                                 THE INSTITUTIONS JUST LIKE RUDI
thinking and political actions.                         Other former RCP members – such as James         Calling them entryists may be unfair. Antonio
    Mirza was born and brought up in Oldham,        Heartfield, Mick Hume, and Brendan O’Neill –         Gramsci, the Italian Marxist imprisoned by
went to state schools, and read English at          have become influential writers and                  Mussolini, developed the idea of establishing a
Mansfield College, Oxford, before doing a PhD       commentators or – like Kenan Malik –                 counter-hegemony through a ‘war of position’
at the University of Kent under the supervision     broadcasters. Spiked, backed by the US oil           – in other words, developing alternative values
of Frank Furedi, a former member of the             billionaire Koch brothers, is still going.           and an alternative ideology to those that
International Socialists – where he used the            The common thread is the acquisition of          dominate present society.
nom de guerre Frank Richards – and then             power and influence in the media, academia,              And Rudi Dutschke, the German
founder and leader of the RCP.                      or at the heart of the state – the tarnished state   communist student leader, turned this, in the
    She wrote articles for its magazine, Living     they wish to not just downgrade but dismantle        late 1960s, into ‘the long march through the
Marxism, its website Spiked, and was well-          and destroy as Dominic Cummings’ Praetorian          institutions’ as a way of establishing the
acquainted with the RCP’s network of                guard of ‘great disruptors’.                         conditions for political change by joining the
influencers even after the party was formally           They disseminate a libertarian belief in the     leading organisations of society.

10 The ASLEF Journal l August 2020
Black lives Matter

Racists right in my face
          ED D’BELL, Black & Minority             matter’; this, too, should be applauded.
          Ethnic Representatives’                     Because how will change come if we
          Committee member for                    cannot argue that black lives matter to
          District 1, and a member of             highlight our cause and our call for change?
                                                  it won’t. Change does not – and will not –
          Southampton Northam
                                                  come of its own accord. But, after pressure
branch, on why the BLM movement is                from BlM, the leaders of countries have                   Black and white
an important vehicle for change                   taken these concerns seriously, something                  together unite
                                                  that, frankly, in this day and age shouldn’t            against the fascist
          ll livES MATTER’. of course they        have to be a concern.                                      and racist right

 A
 ‘
          do! i’m sure no one disagrees but
          say ‘black lives matter’ and, for
                                                      i’ve heard people say ‘racism doesn’t
                                                  exist any more’. Back in the day, it was ‘just        anything, i said my good-byes, and carried
some reason, there will be several people         one of those things’. i’ve been called the            on. Something i probably should not have
who disagree!                                     usual: ‘Pak*, nigg*r, black c**t’. Anyone who         done.
    George Floyd, a black American, was           knows me knows i’m a pretty mellow chap                  Being racially abused is unacceptable
killed in custody by police officers in           so, when i’ve been racially abused, i don’t           but it still happens in Britain today and
Minneapolis, Minnesota, on Monday 25              take it personally, to me, but i do for my            people suffer discrimination because of the
May. A knee was placed upon his neck by an        family, to a point where i may lose my job            colour of our skin.
officer, resulting in asphyxiation and death.     over it!                                                 So i am saddened when i hear people
This was not the first time this has been             i’ve had racism right in my face. Having a        condemn movements that are trying to
done and, even when other officers                car stop abruptly in front of me on the way           change society for the better for minorities.
attended, and heard George pleading ‘i            home by cycle, a bottle thrown at me and              Should we try and find ways to stop black
can’t breathe’, nothing was done to stop it.      called a ‘Pak*’. Being laughed at when i put          people from being treated equally? is it
    Since George Floyd’s death the Black          my head out of the cab window. i’ve even              wrong to say that black lives matter and
lives Matter movement has gained                  rolled into a station on a red, heard ‘nigg*r’        offend the far-right?
momentum, not only in America, but right          by a couple of lads who jumped in the train,             The BlM movement highlights the
across the world. it wants fair and equal         carried on to the next station, where i got           unacceptable deaths of black people in the
treatment for black and minority ethnic           out and followed them into the waiting                US by the hands of law enforcement as well
men and women in all walks of life and this       room, and asked them ‘not politely’ what              as the wider inequality against the BAME
should be applauded. Just like ‘all lives         they said to me? They denied they had said            community in societies across the world.

Taking a knee, Cry for freedom                                                                                                                An iconic
                                                                                                                                              image of
                                                                                                                                              the ’60s
making a stand one
               This Black Power salute,
                    of the most
                                        who had pinned an
                                        Olympic Project for
                                                                                                                                              protest
                                                                                                                                              movement
Josiah                                  powerful protest images         Human Rights badge on
Wedgwood, a                             of the 20th century, was        his tracksuit, suggested
prominent                               taken by Life magazine          they share.
abolitionist as                         photographer John                   The photograph was
well as a                               Dominis after US                a progressive slingshot
potter, who                             sprinters Tommie Smith          which went right around
specialised in                          and John Carlos stepped         the world, capturing all
stoneware and                           onto the podium at the          the agony, anger and        Olympic rules, added: ‘I     walked to the podium
earthenware                             Olympics in Mexico City         angst of the civil rights   fingered my beads and        very slowly, as if in
                  Wedgwood’s
at his factory                          in 1968. Smith had just         movement.                   thought about the            mourning, hands
                  poignant plea
in Stoke-on-                            won gold, and Carlos                ‘It was a cry for       pictures I’d seen of the     clasped behind their
Trent, made this medallion for the      bronze, in the 200              freedom,’ said Smith.       “strange fruit” – black      backs, each holding a
anti-slavery campaign in 1787. He       metres. Peter Norman, of        Carlos, who wore a long     men lynched by the Ku        running shoe. They
donated hundreds of his ‘Am i not       Australia, took silver.         string of beads around      Klux Klan – swinging         walked across the grass
a Man and a Brother?’ cameos for            As the PA started to        his neck, his jacket        from the poplar trees.’      in socks, to protest about
distribution by the Society for         play The Star-Spangled          unzipped in defiance of         The runners had          poverty back home.
Effecting the Abolition of the Slave    Banner, Smith lowered
Trade. ‘ladies wore them in             his head and raised his
bracelets, and others had them          right fist. Carlos raised his                                                San Francisco 49ers
fitted up in an ornamental manner       left. Dominis raised his                                                     quarterback Colin Kaepernick
as pins for their hair,’ wrote Thomas   lens and his shutter                                                         (centre), linebacker Eli Harold
Clarkson. ‘At length the taste for      captured a shattering                                                        (left), and free safety Eric Reid
wearing them became general,            moment of silent                                                             (right) take a knee during the
and thus fashion, which usually         protest.                                                                     American national anthem
confines itself to worthless things,        The reason Carlos                                                        before the NFl game with the
was seen for once in the                wore a glove on his left                                                     dallas Cowboys at levi’s
honourable office of promoting          hand was that they only                                                      Stadium, Santa Clara,
the cause of justice, humanity and      had one pair of gloves                                                       California, in 2016
freedom.’                               between them. Norman,

                                                                                                             August 2020 l The ASLEF Journal          11
Black lives Matter

   Then like my dreams they fad
                  SHEKHAR BHATIA is a
                  journalist and television
                  documentary maker
                  who has worked for the
                  Evening Standard,
                  Sunday Mirror, BBC,
                  NBC, C4 and Mail Online.
Shekhar was brought up in the East End
of London and here he reflects on his
love of football, his passion for one team,
and the racism he encountered at
grounds around the country

          T WASN’T only the wonderful sight of
   I      Bobby Moore lifting the World Cup on
          30 July 1966 that plunged me into a life
of suffering with West Ham United and, of
course, England, too. I was just a schoolboy aged
seven when he and two other West Ham legends
– Geoff Hurst and Martin Peters – ensured the
Jules Rimet trophy stayed in England after the
tournament with that famous 4-2 victory over
West Germany at Wembley.
    But there was more – much more – to it than
West Ham’s terrific World Cup winning trio.
    West Ham was a club where, subconsciously, I
felt my support belonged largely because the
club paraded a couple of talented young black
players in Clyde Best and Ade Coker.

BUS RIDES WERE ALWAYS EVENTFUL
I am black – or brown, if you like – and, if I ever
forgot, people were always there to remind me.
    As an East Ender, I suppose I had little choice
about falling in love with the claret and blue. But
the inclusion of Messrs Best and Coker in the
Hammers’ line-up made it that much simpler.
    I spent those years in the early 1970s being
called ‘Paki’ and ‘Enoch’ and this didn’t exclude
some of the West Ham following when I turned
up at the old Boleyn ground, penniless, and
went in when the gates were opened for the
final few minutes to allow for early leavers.
    The number 58 bus ride home was nearly            women and children they passed on the street.         Upton Park.
always eventful and I would cower at the                 The abuse I suffered did make me turn my               West Ham also played a black left-back, John
menacing sight of some of my fellow West Ham          attention for a while to another East End side –      Charles, and a Turkish forward called Yilmaz
fans.                                                 Leyton Orient – and I marvelled at their young        Orhan and I can remember how excited I was
    They would stand outside the Boleyn tavern        black starlets like Laurie Cunningham and John        when I saw his name printed in the team line-up
on the corner of Green Street and the Barking         Chiedozie. I felt I belonged there, too, and would    in my father’s Daily Telegraph one day.
Road buying and selling copies of National Front      jump over the wall and, later, sell football              There were so few black faces to cheer in
News and Bulldog, the newspaper of the Young          programmes to watch the Os at Brisbane Road.          football, or on television, that anyone who was
National Front, both of which espoused the                                                                  non-white became someone to cheer as
notion that people like me should be ‘sent back       EXCITED WHEN I SAW HIS NAME                           representative.
to where they came from’. In my case, that would      But I had been caught up in the magic of West             When I first worked on Fleet Street at the age
have been Leytonstone, because that was where         Ham’s free-flowing attacking football and I was       of 22, the Falklands War was raging; I was
I was brought up.                                     hooked – despite my fear of the ‘Paki-bashers’ in     mistaken for an Argentine and there was abuse
    The irony was lost on me that those racists I     their bovver boots.                                   to overcome in the newsroom, too. I was once
saw outside the pub, and on the bus home, to             It dawned on me, years later, that perhaps it      called a ‘monkey’ and asked who had cut my tree
whom Clyde Best and Ade Coker were Saturday           wasn’t just the beauty of the game played by the      down. On another occasion, a newspaper
afternoon heroes, out on the pitch in a claret and    boys in claret and blue, but the colour of the skin   executive made a speech referencing ‘wogs’. My
blue shirt, would spit bile at the black men,         of players like Best and Coker that drew me to        true East End spirit came to the fore – and I gave

12 The ASLEF Journal l August 2020
Black lives Matter

de and die                                             Kill the immigration Bill
                                                       At an extraordinary meeting of
                                                       Bakerloo line branch 250 on
                                                       Thursday 18 June the following
                                                       motion, moved by Trevor Robinson,
                                                       and seconded by Mark Gilkes, was
                                                       passed unanimously.

                                                                 RANCH and BAME members
                                                        B        continue to be concerned about
                                                                 the immigration Bill that we
                                                       believe will have a detrimental effect on
                                                       the already underfunded and
 Clyde Best (top row, far left); Ade Coker; and                                                                        The Tories are targeting
                                                       understaffed NHS.
 John Charles; Yilmaz orhan (second row, left); a                                                                      the NHS with this bill
                                                           The House of Commons library
 young Shekhar Bhatia tries on the shirt for size;
                                                       information service provides the              NHS workers and carers under the
 and John Charles (back row, third from right) in
                                                       following statistics. of 1.28 million staff   government promise.
 a team pic with Martin Peters (back row, far
                                                       employed by the NHS, 170,000 are non-            Also contained in the plans is being
 left), Bobby Moore (back row, far right), and
                                                       British. The majority are low paid which      able to speak English to a certain
 Geoff Hurst (front row, second from right)
                                                       limits the quality of life they are able to   standard and having a job offer from a
                                                       afford.                                       government-approved employer. Such
 him what for.                                             BAME groups have been                     moves risk chaos to a health system that
    That West Ham haven’t won anything of note         disproportionately impacted by covid-         struggled to cope as the covid-19
 since landing the FA Cup 40 years ago – beating       19; this was particularly apparent            pandemic swept Britain. An NHS
 Arsenal 1-0 thanks to a header by, of all people,     amongst NHS staff. As the clapping for        devastated by years of cuts and
 Trevor Brooking who, while majestic with his          NHS workers finally ends, Tory hypocrisy      privatisation saw shortages of PPE and
 feet, was rarely known to head the ball – is not      over support for those who put their          workers unable to get tests despite
 lost on me.                                           lives on the line during the crisis is        working on the frontline.
    And it is a stark fact that football has a long,   exposed by the immigration Bill. This            More than 200 health workers have
 long way to go before the game can be truly           racist legislation threatens the very         died from covid-19 so far; 122 of those,
 labelled as all-inclusive and welcoming.              bedrock of the NHS, targeting the non-        61% of the total, are from BAME
    I no longer fear being beaten up, or racially      British staff who make up an essential        backgrounds.
 abused, at a game but that is probably because I      part of the workforce.                           As the world reverberates with global
 am 6ft tall and racist behaviour is now a hate            The immigration Bill edges Britain        protests over structural and institutional
 crime and the police appear keener to enforce         towards an Australian-style points-           racism and inequality we must stand
 the law.                                              based system, placing visa requirements       against legislation that will only serve to
    West Ham should be praised for having              on care workers and NHS staff while           entrench this system and deepen the
 notices around the new ground that racist abuse       repealing EU freedom of movement.             disproportionate impact on those from
 will not be tolerated, though I wish they had         Setting a salary threshold of £25,600 to      the BAME community.
 done that way back when.                              qualify for a visa sends a message to            We must stand together and demand
    I once took a girlfriend to watch West Ham at      anyone earning less than this that they       the scrapping of the legislation in its
 Port Vale when an Ian Bishop goal gave us the         are not welcome in this country. This is a    entirety and stand with all those
 points. A fan next to us made monkey noises           massive Tory slap in the face by those        affected by this racist legislation.
 throughout the whole match against George             who clapped so vigorously on the                 The branch and BAME members
 Parris, a journeyman professional for whom I          downing Street steps just a few weeks         request that the GS and EC lobby the
 always had a soft spot. It spoiled the event for      ago.                                          government to immediately withdraw
 her so much she never went to a game again.               The £425 NHS surcharge for non-EU         the NHS surcharge applied to all foreign
                                                       migrants which it is planned to raise to      nationals and their dependents working
 THE DAY A SIKH SCORES THE WINNER                      £625, including those working in the          and paying taxes in the UK, especially
 Losing fans to racism is a huge own goal for          NHS, is still being paid by large             those working in the NHS; oppose and
 football. As a season ticket holder at the London     numbers, despite a U-turn by the              condemn the immigration Bill that puts
 Stadium, it is still disappointing to see so few      government last month. The date for           working-class families at risk of not
 black and brown faces walking through Stratford       when the fees will be scrapped is still not   being able to afford family reunion
 to the ground.                                        known and guidance has not yet been           visas; lobby the government to remove
     I once saw a Sikh gentleman with his son,         released by the department of Health          the salary threshold requirement that
 both in West Ham shirts, and it made me smile         and Social Care, with conflicting advice      clearly discriminates against working-
 broadly even though we lost. There needs to be        in the new rules. it means migrants           class families; and exert pressure on the
 more people of colour in the seats at all grounds.    working in the NHS pay three times over       government to remove costly visa
     I long for the day a Sikh scores a winning goal   to use it – through their service, their      requirements on health workers who are
 for West Ham and for him to bhangra his way           taxes, and the surcharge.                     the backbone of our National Health
 across the pitch along with his teammates. But            Clarity and assurances are needed         Service.
 then I long for West Ham to be crowned Premier        over the exemption of the families of         Steve Crowley, branch secretary
 League champions.
     I can’t stop dreaming, you see...

                                                                                                          August 2020 l The ASLEF Journal          13
You can also read