EXPANDING HORIZONS - GEOSCIENTIST
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
T H E M A G A Z I N E O F T H E G E O L O G I C A L S O C I E T Y O F L O N D O N SUMMER 2021 EXPANDING HORIZONS THE GROUND ENGINEERING INSAR REVOLUTION CITIZEN FRESH SUBSURFACE SOCIAL SCIENCE GROUND SCIENCE VOLCANOLOGY Breathing fresh life Finding Earth science Subsurface research Q&A: the Saint into geoscience in a coffee cup labs and net zero Vincent eruption
Editor’s welcome SUMMER 2021 VOL. 31 | NO. 02 A S I WRITE, at pace, promising news a helicopter of a malaria vaccine The magazine of the Geological Society of London just took off has just broken, and the and landed on Mars. Biden administration The Geological Society Trustees of the Geological A helicopter! On Mars! has announced that the Burlington House Society of London Stories like this make US will work to halve Piccadilly 2020-2021 me think of a response emissions by 2030. London W1J 0BG Dr Michael Daly (President) I saw once – I’ve long Optimism seems to T +44 (0)20 7434 9944 Mrs Joanna Alexander forgotten when and who from – to be in the wind – I’m writing this enquiries@geolsoc.org.uk Mr Thomas Backhouse a complaint about a lack of wifi on outside a café, in the real world, (Not for Editorial – Please Mr Andrew Bloodworth a long-haul flight. “You’re sitting in wearing sunglasses! Underneath contact the Editor) Mr John Booth (Vice a chair, thousands of feet above the it, though, there remains a ripple President) ground, travelling at hundreds of of uncertainty and unease. The Publishing House Dr Jennie Gilbert miles an hour – and you’re unhappy pandemic continues to spread The Geological Society Dr Joel Gill (Secretary, about the wifi?!” rapidly in many parts of the world, Publishing House, Unit 7 Foreign & External Affairs) It’s easy to take science and its and our hesitant emergence Brassmill Enterprise Centre Mr Graham Goffey (Treasurer) miracles – I do think we can call from months of lockdown feels Brassmill Lane Dr Kathryn Goodenough them that, the true, real-world fraught with uncertainty, as well as Bath BA1 3JN Prof James Griffiths miracles of the modern era – for optimism, about what lies ahead. T +44 (0)1225 445046 (Secretary, Professional granted. Never more so than in the Fellows may well be feeling E sales@geolsoc.org.uk Matters) past year, when we’ve witnessed a similar mix of optimism and Dr Michael Kehinde the extraordinary development uncertainty in relation to their Library Prof Chris King of coronavirus vaccines at vastly Society and its future. In the last T +44 (0)20 7432 0999 Mr Andrew Moore accelerated speeds in what, to my issue, we reported news of the E library@geolsoc.org.uk Prof Bryne Ngwenya mind, is one of the most amazing Society’s campaign to remain at Dr John Perry scientific achievements of our age. Burlington House, where we’ve EDITOR-IN-CHIEF: Mr Nicholas Reynolds (Vice been based since 1874. The Prof. Andy Fleet President) situation remains unresolved, DEPUTY EDITOR-IN-CHIEF: Mrs Sarah Scott and with it, as reported in this Mr David Shilston Ms Gemma Sherwood We’re grateful issue, comes uncertainty over a EXECUTIVE EDITOR: Miss Jessica Smith to all of you who’ve future home for our extensive and Dr Amy Whitchurch (Vice President) taken the time to valuable Library collections. At the EDITOR: Dr Helen Smyth same time a new Open Access Ms Sarah Day Prof Robin Strachan get in touch with us Journal, a vibrant programme E geoscientist@geolsoc.org.uk (Secretary, Publications) with feedback for the 2021 Year of Space, the Dr Alexander Whittaker reopening of our Library to visitors EDITORIAL ADVISORY (Secretary, Science) and a whole host of other good PANEL Mrs Lucy Williams And now they’ve gone and flown a news stories in this issue speak to Mrs Natalyn Ala Dr Keith Myers (co-opted helicopter on Mars. an optimistic future. Mr Steve Branch – Treasurer designate) In our summer issue, Jennifer There’s been a lot of changes to Dr Robin Cocks Scoular and colleagues report on this magazine as well – and we’re Dr Howard Falcon-Lang The Geological Society the development and potential of grateful to all of you who’ve taken Dr Hazel Gibson of London is a Registered InSAR – a radar technique with the the time to get in touch with us with Prof. Tony Harris Charity, number 210161. potential to measure millimetre- feedback, from enthusiastic thumbs Mr Edmund Nickless ISSN (print) 0961-5628 scale changes in deformation, up to constructive suggestions. Dr Alan Roberts ISSN (online) 2045-1784 with applications ranging from Rest assured, we’re taking the latter Prof. Peter Styles monitoring of natural hazards on board, and we’re delighted by Dr Colin Summerhayes Subscriptions: for non- to tunnelling projects. Like the the former! In the meantime, don’t Prof. Frances Wall member subscriptions, please figure sitting in a chair in the sky, forget an important part of our Dr Jan Zalasiewicz contact the Publishing House. worrying about wifi, it’s incredible role as an editorially independent to think that there are satellites magazine is to provide a forum for Cover image: View of the London skyline beyond the Earth’s atmosphere Fellows to feedback on the Society with the ability to detect the tiniest more broadly – if you have any Geoscientist is published four times per year on behalf of changes, down to millimetres, on questions, concerns or comments The Geological Society of London by the Earth’s surface. about any of the above, please do www.jamespembrokemedia.co.uk Meanwhile, back on Earth, further get in touch. miracles are occurring. The UK’s © 2021 The Geological Society of London vaccination programme continues S A R A H D AY, E D I T O R GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 3
CONTENTS VOL . 32 | NO. 02 | SUMMER 2021 19 24 3 UNEARTHED EDITOR’S WELCOME 40 FRESH GROUND 6 Finding Earth science in a coffee cup NEWS Updates from the Society and the community 42 SAFEGUARDING RIGHTS 19 Recommendations for protecting indigenous rights VIEWPOINT Physical fitness in geology, geodiversity, testing text 44 32 and more F E AT U R E S SCIENCE IN THE S U B S U R FA C E Subsurface research laboratories 24 and net zero E X PA N D I N G H O R I Z O N S The InSAR revolution in ground 46 engineering S O C I A L VO L C A N O L O GY AT SAINT VINCENT 32 Q&A with Jazmin Scarlett on the eruption of La Soufrière B R E AT H I N G F R E S H L I F E INTO GEOSCIENCE A citizen science project in Nepal REGULARS 48 38 BOOKS & ARTS YO R K T O T E N BY Latest recommendations The advantages of 19th century train travel 51 O B I T UA R I E S John R. L. Allen, Paul Francis Worthington, Frank Harold Trevor Rhodes 54 FIVE MINUTES WITH… Anjana Khatwa, science 54 presenter and museum learning professional The Geological Society of London accepts no responsibility for the Every effort has been made to trace copyright holders of material All advertising material is expected to conform to ethical views expressed in any article in this publication. All views expressed, in this publication. If any rights have been omitted, the publisher and trading standards, and reasonable care is taken to ensure except where explicitly stated otherwise, represent those of the offers their apologies. that advertisers are reputable and reliable. However, inclusion author, and not the Geological Society of London. All rights reserved. in this publication or as an insert does not constitute a guarantee No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury or endorsement of the quality or value of such products or No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products services, or of the claims made by its manufacturer. Geoscientist transmitted save with written permission. Users registered with liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation and the Geological Society of London can give no assurance Copyright Clearance Center: the Journal is registered with CCC, of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained that an advertiser will fulfil its obligation under 27 Congress Street, Salem, MA 01970, USA. in the material herein. all circumstances. GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 5
NEWS TURN TO PAGE 32 Find out how citizen science projects can benefit researchers and communities S O C I E T Y A N D CO M M U N I T Y U P D AT E S (L-R): Titan’s Kraken Mare, Mars’ Osuga Valles, Earth’s Xingu River (Image credit L-R: NASA/JPL- Caltech/ASI/Cornell; NASA Earth Observatory images by Joshua Stevens; ESA/DLR/FU Berlin (CC BY-SA 3.0 IGO)) Spacescapes: postcards high-definition images of the landscapes and geological features seen around our from our solar system The exhibition solar system. The exhibition will open on Friday 20 August and will run for seven weeks, until Friday 8 October, A free, outdoor, public exhibition is coming to will run from 20 August until with opening times of 9am until the Burlington House Courtyard this summer! 8 October at 6pm daily. Burlington House Courtyard Let us take you on a journey WE ARE INCREDIBLY EXCITED Burlington House as part through our solar system, stopping off to announce that this summer the of our 2021 Year of Space. to visit the Perseverance rover on Mars, Geological Society will be holding ‘Spacescapes: postcards from impact craters on the Moon, mountains on a free, outdoor, public exhibition at our solar system’, will feature incredible, Pluto and storms on Jupiter. 6 GEOSCIENTIST | SUMMER 2021
NEWS Curiosity’s Selfie at Mont Mercou MORE ONLINE (Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS) Keep up-to-date with the latest news and discussion, and view additional geoscience-related reports, videos and more at www.Geoscientist.Online The exhibition will explore the ways in which understanding Earth can help us uncover the history of planetary bodies across our solar system and beyond. By comparing Earthly geological features with similar vistas found on other planets, we can piece together the history of the solar system and look to answer some of WORKSHOPS the mysteries of our universe. Alongside the exhibition, we will be Many of the landscapes on other offering an educational programme, planets appear alien compared to the featuring workshops for school environments we are familiar with on students, free resources on our website Earth. But if we look closely, we can and loan boxes of items to facilitate recognise Earth-like features that we can learning. Workshops will focus on study and interpret. Just like on Earth, the comparative geomorphology rivers run into seas, mountains rise up of Earth and planets in our solar from horizons, and vast plains are dotted system, linking to curriculum topics in with volcanoes or meteorite craters. Yet, Geology, Geography and Science. as we travel further into space, mountains The exhibition will are composed of ice; rivers flow with PUBLIC LECTURES liquid methane, rather than water; and We continue to run our free virtual explore the ways in which volcanoes reach heights of 25 km, public lectures on ‘The Geology of understanding Earth dwarfing Earth’s tallest volcano. Other Planets’ throughout 2021. Talks can help us uncover Throughout the history of space on the Moon, meteorites, Titan, Pluto the history of planetary and more are still to come! You can exploration, we have sent missions and bodies across our solar probes to a staggering eight planets in find information about all of our Year of Space activities on our website: system and beyond our solar system, as well as numerous missions to the asteroid belt and other www.geolsoc.org.uk/space21. planetary bodies. Today, our ability PARTNERS to send automated rovers to Mars The exhibition wouldn’t have been has ushered in an exciting new era volcanoes on Venus, storms on Jupiter possible without our collaborative for space exploration. The ability to or ice caps on Mars, prepare to be partners. Our main partner is collect and analyse Martian air and soil spellbound by the images in this unique Bluewater, with design support from samples remotely from Earth, or on display. We invite you to come along, take Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners Earth in the future, is the true frontier of a selfie with NASA’s Perseverance Mars architectural practice and additional space science. These ground-breaking funding support from SRK Consulting, rover and learn about the fascinating missions help us observe and understand Michael Davies Charitable Settlement, features of our planetary neighbours. processes on distant planets like Imperial College London’s Department Flo Bullough (Head of Policy and never before. of Earth Science and Engineering, Engagement), Megan O’Donnell The similarities and differences and the Open University. We would (Communications and Policy Officer), between our world and others are also like to thank our neighbours in Rose Want (Education Officer), what enable planetary geologists to the Burlington House Courtyard for Alicia Newton (Director of Science & understand how other planets formed agreeing to the use of space. Communications) & Jenny Boland and have changed over time. Whether it’s (Head of Development) GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 7
NEWS Fabian Wadsworth (William Annual General Smith Fund); Dr Finnigan Illsley-Kemp (President’s Meeting Award); and Dr Jazmin THE AGM will be conducted Scarlett (President’s Award). virtually again this year The Awards will be on Friday 25 June 2021. presented at President’s In line with bye-law 9.2, Day on 25 June 2021 in the agenda for the AGM is a virtual ceremony. The presented as follows: presentations will be AGM agenda President’s Day update followed by talks from some of the medallists (see • Apologies THE SOCIETY (Dewey Medal); Prof Chris information box below). • Minutes of the Annual ANNOUNCED the Jackson (Coke Medal); All Fellows are welcome General Meeting held winners of its medals Dr Helen Reeves (Coke to attend the events of on 4 June 2020 and funds for 2021 in Medal); Dr Sheila Peacock President’s Day, in whole • Appointment of the Spring edition: Prof (Distinguished Service or part. Scrutineers for the ballots David Pollard (Wollaston Award); Dr Anjana Khatwa (R for Council and Officers REGISTRATION: Medal); Prof Nicholas H Worth Award); Prof Marie • Ballot for Council The link for registration is White (Lyell Medal); Edmonds (Bigsby Medal); Dr available on the Awards • Annual Report and Prof Graham Pearson Caroline Gill (Aberconway pages of the Geological Accounts for 2020 (Murchison Medal); Dr Medal); Dr Emma Liu Society website and • President’s Report in our newsletters. Philip Christie (William (Wollaston Fund); Dr • Secretaries’ Reports Alternatively, please Smith Medal); Prof Sanjeev Luke Parry (Lyell Fund); • Treasurer’s Report email christina.marron@ Gupta (Prestwich Medal); Dr Andrew Thomson geolsoc.org.uk • Comments from Fellows Prof Kenneth McCaffrey (Murchison Fund); Dr • Report of Scrutineers on the ballot for Council P R E S I D E N T ’ S D AY 2 5 J U N E 2 0 2 1 • Ballot for Officers 3.30pm-4.45pm BST – Awards Ceremony • Revised Fellowship 5pm-6.30pm BST – Senior medalists talks: Prof Graham Pearson category and fee (University of Alberta, Canada); Prof Nicholas White (University of Cambridge, UK); structure proposals and Prof David Pollard (Stanford University, USA) • Deaths • Appointment of Auditors • Report of Scrutineers on the ballot for Officers • Any other business FUTURE N O T I F I C AT I O N Provisional date of next MEETING OF OFFICERS Annual General Meeting: D AT E S FOR 2021/2022 7 June 2022 ORDINARY GENERAL At the AGM, Fellows will be asked to elect Information on how to MEETINGS: 30 June the following members of Council as register to attend the AGM 2021, 22 September Officers for 2021/22: will be sent to all Fellows 2021, 24 November 2021, President: Dr Michael Daly for whom we have a 2 February 2022, 20 April Vice-President: Jessica Smith registered email address. 2022, Secretaries: Prof James Griffiths If you do not receive an 8 June 2022 Prof Robin Strachan email or if you would like COUNCIL: 30 June 2021, Dr Alexander Whittaker further information on how 22 and 23 September 2021 Secretary, to register, please email (residential), 24 November Foreign & christina.marron@geolsoc. 2021, 2 February 2022, 20 External Affairs: Dr Joel Gill org.uk April 2022, 8 June 2022 Treasurer: Dr Keith Myers 8 GEOSCIENTIST | SUMMER 2021
NEWS E L E C T I O N R E S U LT S THE ADVISORY BALLOT for Council, conducted by Civica Election Services, closed on 31 March 2021. The turnout was 20.4%. A total of 2,173 valid votes were cast in favour of Ruth Allington for the role of President and her name will now go forward for election at the Annual General Meeting on 25 June 2021. SOCIETY’S AWARDS A total of 2,132 valid votes were cast for the other seven 2022: INVITATION vacancies on Council. Of the 14 candidates who took part, the seven who received the most votes will go forward to the Annual TO NOMINATE General Meeting for election as Council members. These are: FELLOWS OF THE all of our awards with CANDIDATES NO OF VOTES % OF TOTAL VOTES SOCIETY are invited the exception of the Lucy Thomas 1,587 74.4% to submit nominations President’s Award, which Amanda Owen 1,195 56.1% for the Society’s awards has its own form. Please Martin Griffin 1,028 48.2% for 2022. visit: www.geolsoc. Mark Allen 952 44.7% We are committed to org.uk/About/Awards- Keith Myers 920 43.1% ensuring diversity of our Grants-and-Bursaries/ Pete Loader 900 42.2% awardees and expanding Society-Awards Neil Frewin 749 35.1% the demographics of The guidance those put forward for documents and PDF Andrew Dobrzanski, Tim Good, Benjamin Lepley, David our medals and funds. booklet give the criteria McNamara, Stuart Mills, David Neave and Paul Winrow were We are particularly keen and explain how to unfortunately unsuccessful in this year’s Council ballot. We to receive nominations go about nominating thank them for their interest in serving on Council and hope for the funds that a person you feel is that they will consider reapplying on a future date. recognise excellent deserving of a Society We also warmly thank the Council members standing contributions by early award. If you have down at the next AGM: Tom Backhouse, Dr Andrew career scientists. any further questions, Bloodworth, John Booth, Graham Goffey, Prof Chris King, There is one standard please contact christina. Prof Bryne Ngwenya, Mr Nik Reynolds and Dr Helen Smyth. nomination form for marron@geolsoc.org.uk *Full results available on request ANNUAL FELLOWSHIP RESEARCH GRANTS 2021 SUBSCRIPTIONS FOR 2022 THE RESEARCH GRANTS Jeremy Ingham Fund and the AT ITS MEETING ON 7 APRIL, Council agreed a Committee met on 25 March and Robert Scott Memorial Award. new Fellowship category and fee structure to considered 12 applications from The Committee also be recommended for approval at the AGM. The Fellows and non-Fellows. The considered the shortlisted details of the fee structure will be provided in the committee agreed the applications from Fellows for AGM papers that will be available in early June. A award of 10 Society the Zeiss-GSL scholarship separate email communication will also go out to grants totalling with the 2021 scholarship Fellows. £17,510, including being awarded to Kelsey Since 2015 the annual increase in Fellowship the Robert Scott Archer Barnhill. The Fees has been set with reference to the prevailing Memorial Award Society is very grateful annual rate of Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation to one applicant. for the sponsorship of when proposals are considered for the following The Society is Zeiss GmbH. year in March and April. The Consumer Prices Index very grateful for A full list of winners (CPI) rose 0.7% in the 12 months to January 2021, the contributions is available online. The but Council has recommended that there be no made by the Society offers its warmest increase in 2022 in recognition of the challenging Jeremy Willson congratulations to all the year and financial circumstances for many. Charitable Trust, the recipients. GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 9
NEWS Discovering forgotten histories Cynthia Burek and Bettie Higgs, editors of the Society’s latest Special Publication, chat with Bethan Phillips, Commissioning Editor, and Lucy Pullen, Marketing Executive THE GEOLOGICAL Cynthia and Bettie SOCIETY was founded discuss how inspirational in 1807, but sadly physical geology female geologists teachers, as well as AUTHOR wouldn’t be welcome as childhood holidays NAME CHANGE Fellows for 112 years. In collecting ‘stones’ on May 1919, the first eight the beach and school POLICY female Fellows were field trips motivated their The Geological Society is pleased elected and in 2019, we interest in geology. They to announce a new policy covering celebrated 100 Years of also note how several key requests to change author names Female Fellows. societal changes, such on published works. An author may The Society’s as the introduction of choose to change their name for newest Special compulsory education reasons that include (but are not Publication, number for children, facilitated limited to) gender identity, marriage 506, Celebrating 100 by the Education Act or divorce, religious conversion, and Years of Female Fellows of 1870, were key other personal reasons. For authors of the Geological moments for women in making this choice, the Society now Society: Discovering Forgotten Histories, geology. But there is still work to do, and offers a route to updating published presents the often untold stories of Cynthia and Bettie highlight the importance works and the relevant supporting pioneering female geoscientists from of building resources that document the systems and services. across the world — women who stories, achievements and contributions of The introduction of this policy navigated male-dominated academia and women in geology — which is one of the is part of the Society’s broader learned societies, experienced the harsh objectives of the new Special Publication. commitment to supporting author realities of Siberian field-exploration, or Read the full discussion with Cynthia inclusion, respecting the rights of responded to the strategic necessity of and Bettie on the Geological Society’s authors to their own identities, and the ‘petroleum girls’ in early American oil blog page here: https://blog.geolsoc.org. ensuring that authors receive credit exploration and production. uk/2021/03/18/celebrating-a-centenary/ for all their work. Lucy Pullen and Bethan Phillips interviewed Special Publication 506, Celebrating To find out more and for details of the editors of the volume, Cynthia Burek 100 Years of Female Fellows of the the policy, please visit the Society’s (Professor of Geoconservation, University of Geological Society: Discovering Forgotten website: www.geolsoc.org.uk/ Chester) and Bettie Higgs (Senior Lecturer in Histories, is available to purchase here: Publications/Publishing-policies/ Geology, University College Cork) and asked https://www.geolsoc.org.uk/SP506 and Author-name-change-policy them about their experiences in geology, can be accessed via the Lyell Collection raising awareness of female geoscientists, at: https://sp.lyellcollection.org/ David Boyt (Head of Editorial editing the volume and future plans. content/506/1 Development) US honour for Brian Williams Professor Brian P J Williams has been awarded the Grover E. Murray Memorial Distinguished Educator Award by the American Association of Petroleum Geologists (AAPG), in recognition of his ‘distinguished and outstanding contributions to geological education’. Congratulations to Brian for this prestigious award. 10 GEOSCIENTIST | SUMMER 2021
NEWS J O I N T H E D E B AT E Has a news item got you thinking? We welcome readers’ letters and feedback. Share your views by emailing geoscientist@geolsoc.org.uk Geological mapping of our world and others The Society welcomes oral and poster abstract submissions to the 2021 William Geoscience and the Smith Meeting ‘Geological mapping: of our worlds and others’, which will hydrogen economy be held as a virtual event on 19 – 21 THE DECARBONISATION of knowledge are particularly relevant to October 2021. electricity production, industry, the use of hydrogen as a low-carbon This conference is an international transport and heating to meet both alternative fuel, with the potential to celebration of geological mapping, UK and international climate change reduce emissions from heavy industry, its historical importance and future targets is a major challenge, and domestic heating, and transportation. directions, and its use to deduce Earth geoscience has an important role to We also recently hosted an and planetary evolution and processes. play. We are working to understand – online webinar about the storage of The programme seeks to explore Earth’s and raise awareness of – the various hydrogen in caverns in collaboration surface to subsurface realms, and beyond ways that geoscience will underpin the with Supergen and Energy Research to extra-terrestrial bodies. energy transition. The Society does this Accelerator. If you missed this, you Email: conference@geolsoc.org.uk work in collaboration with an advisory can catch up in your own time at Website: www.geolsoc.org.uk/wsmith21 group of experts who make up our www.era.ac.uk/Hydrogen-Storage-in- Abstract submission deadline: 18 June 2021 Decarbonisation Working Group. Caverns-2021. As part of this work we are pleased Read more at www.geolsoc.org.uk/ to announce the publication of our hydrogen-economy The Geological latest policy and technology explainer Megan O’Donnell (Communications Society Library ‘Geoscience and the hydrogen & Policy Officer) & Flo Bullough (Head economy’. Geological skills and of Policy and Engagement) It is now possible to visit the Library at Burlington House, however visits are by appointment only, REOPENING OF be considered before Burlington House can be reopened. The situation remains due to the ongoing Covid BURLINGTON HOUSE uncertain and it is not yet possible to guidance. To book an appointment, please We are eager to reopen Burlington fix a firm date for reopening. email library@geolsoc.org.uk or call us on House at the earliest opportunity to Please refer to the Society webpage +44 (0)20 7432 0999. staff, Fellows, Friends and visitors, and for the latest updates: www.geolsoc. For the latest updates on services visit to see a steady resumption of ‘in- org.uk/About/Press-Office/Press- www.geolsoc.org.uk/library person’ services. Many factors have to Releases/covid-19-closure GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 11
NEWS THE 2020 LIBRARY REVIEW At the end of 2019, Council commissioned a review of the Society’s Library and Information Services, and one year later approved a wide-ranging report on the future of those services. Neal Marriott, who served on the Library Review Working Group, explains the background to the review and outlines some of its recommendations. 12 GEOSCIENTIST | SUMMER 2021
NEWS VI S I TORS W HO S PE N D In exploring any amount of time in the challenges Burlington House will find it of running the hard not to be struck by the Society’s Library collections. service, we have Both the first floor Main Library also identified and the ground floor Lower opportunities: Library are impressive in their to digitise and extent and presentation, promote the best and those setting foot in the of our heritage Map Room may feel they have entered an Aladdin’s collections; to cave of geological treasures. increase digital Largely behind the scenes are access for all extensive archive and special collections, and many more books and journals are held on the brink of the 2020s, it in storerooms, with material was clear to Council that the incapable of being stored in- Society faced a range of new house being securely retained and significant challenges (and, offsite. Supporting all of this perhaps, opportunities) that is a professional staff who force us to question how we provide the experience and can best deliver these services expertise required to enable to Fellows in the future. users to get the very most from the Library. Challenges Library collections comprise In common with many over 300,000 volumes of learned and professional books and serials, 40,000 societies, the Geological map sheets and a wide range Society is undergoing a of historical and archival period of financial pressure material. Operating such and uncertainty. Since 2017 extensive collections, and our membership numbers associated services, brings its have fallen slightly with a own challenges and comes at consequent loss of revenue; considerable cost, so in 2010 a our established and profitable wide-ranging review of Library publishing model is facing the services was undertaken, with challenge of Open Access; and the resulting recommendations we have entered a period of for change having largely been escalating rent demands. implemented in the intervening The challenges, however, years. However, as we stood are not solely financial. GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 13
NEWS We are seeking to extend Library access Scarcity, value and usage and usage by exploiting technology The Library’s holdings are extensive and complex, ranging all the way from rare or unique physical items on the one hand to cutting- edge electronic content on the other. Copies of William Smith’s maps are an obvious example of valued historical material, but there is much else besides: rare books dating as far back as the 16th century; special collections of prints, drawings and illustrations; geological maps from all areas of the world, many of which would be difficult or impossible to source elsewhere; and an extensive range of deposited For well over a century undetermined, a new review context of the Society’s papers from dozens of the Geological Society has was an urgent requirement. charitable activities. notable individuals. At the occupied its apartments in Work commenced other end of the spectrum is Burlington House and has The brief from Council early in 2020, examining current content, published enjoyed the space within At the end of 2019, Council existing evidence (relating electronically and delivered which its Library collections commissioned a new review to cost, usage, visitors etc.), online to libraries across can grow and be readily of Library and Information interviewing expert witnesses the world – where, in many accessed by anyone visiting Services, which was announced and conducting a survey of the instances, subscribers do not London. Now, our future to Fellows early in 2020. Fellowship. Council was kept even receive print copies of occupation of Burlington A Library Review Working informed of progress and the the published content. House is in question and we Group was assembled and report and recommendations What is equally evident is must plan for the possibility approved by Council, and were received at its final the difference in usage levels of relocating to alternative comprised eight members meeting of 2020. The report of the Library collections, accommodation elsewhere. As drawn from both within and was not considered in isolation, especially in relation to the Library currently occupies outside the Geological Society. however, but in the context journals. Of the 600 or 47% of Burlington House Members were chosen from of a range of issues and so journal titles listed as floor space, and the size and learned society, university and new Society initiatives: the received by the Library, location of possible future commercial backgrounds, evolving financial situation 30 or so titles accounted for accommodation is as yet and were selected for their and consequent redundancies around 80 percent of 2019 experience and expertise in late in 2020, including two usage, while over half of library use, management and members of Library staff; the titles received no usage at all development, publishing, the emerging impact of COVID-19 in that year. While many of Many users have geosciences and finance. on the Society and its Fellows; our little-used titles incur no already made the The emphasis of the review the review of the Society’s direct subscription charge shift to accessing was on considering future strategic priorities; and the (being received by exchange content online, service provision, both in the ongoing review of Fellowship or as gifts), they do incur an but there are many case of remaining at Burlington categories and benefits. It was overhead to receive, process, other possible House and of moving to a new in the context of these many manage and store. Similarly, location; the development of challenges and opportunities many of our older (though not applications of cost-effective services in light of that Council considered necessarily rare) stored books technology that we changing Fellowship needs; and the review findings and and journals receive little have not yet taken on future financial sustainability recommendations and gave its or no use while occupying advantage of and affordability in the wider approval on 25 November 2020. considerable space. GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 15
NEWS patterns and seek to extend Our Library staff are already access and usage by current offering support on this front non-users by exploiting the and we should carefully opportunities afforded by new consider how this can be and emerging technologies. further developed. Digital opportunities The journey to change Many users have already made The full report of the the shift to accessing content Library Review Working online, but there are many Group contains a very wide other possible applications range of observations and of technology that we have recommendations, only a few not yet taken advantage of which are reflected in this of. Increased digitisation brief article. The Society should of valuable and historical take great pride in its Library material may not only assist and the expertise of its staff. with their preservation, but In exploring the challenges of would enhance opportunities running the service, we have The Society’s Library is a geological for education and outreach, also identified opportunities: treasure trove as well as being potentially to digitise and promote revenue generating. the best of our heritage These issues of scarcity, Burlington House bookshop. Digitisation can be costly collections; to increase digital value and usage present us However, the number of visits but might be an area where access for all; and to enhance with significant challenges by Fellows is in decline and Fellows’ bequests could make Fellows’ experience of online to be addressed both in those visits are very unevenly a real difference. Similarly, Society services. the context of financial spread – in 2019 visits were systematic digital capture of The report, however, is not a sustainability and the made by approximately modern records would secure blueprint for action and further management of any move 600 unique Fellows (~5% of these records for the future work is required to create out of Burlington House. membership), but with only a and reduce the need for a detailed implementation The number of journals tenth of this number visiting physical filing and storage. plan. At the time of writing, subscribed to has already been five or more times. There is evidence of some recruitment of a new Head appreciably reduced in line However, the decline in frustration from Fellows in of Library and Information with the review’s findings of physical visits does not tell their interaction with Society Services is underway and, once limited usage and in relation the full story. For many years information systems, and it in post, a priority will be the to a challenging 2021 budget. the Library has been operating is recommended that single development of such a plan, Recommendations have also the OpenAthens system, sign-on is implemented to building on the report and been made to review the entire enabling remote access to simplify Fellows’ access across drawing on the expert views Library and archive collection online journals. Not only the website, Lyell collection of staff. to prioritise all materials held has the number of Fellows and Library services, reducing Importantly, the Library is should the Society move from registering for this system the need to establish multiple a service for Fellows and the Burlington House to smaller been increasing steadily, logins for accessing these views of Fellows are important. premises where the space but the number of articles various online services. So, please do take the time available for our collections accessed is climbing, too. As technologies develop to read the report and send may be substantially reduced. These trends in remote (especially some of those your comments to the email versus in-person use of the applied by content publishers), address given below. Library visitors and users Library are in opposition user behaviour will continue The Library is visited around to each other, but when to evolve, too. In particular, 3,000 times each year. While combined it is thought that content users are on a The report to Fellows was published on March 11 2020 in many of these visits are to around 10% of the Fellowship trajectory of increasing both full and concise forms and consult collections, others are make use of the Library. independence in their research can be accessed at www.geolsoc. in search of a workspace to The final balance of service behaviour and should be org.uk/Library-and-Information- Services/review. Fellows can catch up on emails, prepare provision will need to take supported in this journey submit comments to library.review for meetings or to consult the into account this shift in user by training and education. @geolsoc.org.uk. GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 17
VIEWPOINT S EN D YO U R L E T T ER S TO G EO S C I E N T I S T@ G EO L S O C .O RG .U K A N D T W EE T U S AT @ G EO S C I E N T I S TM AG . F O R G U I DA N CE O N S U B M I T T I N G A CO LU M N , S EE G EO S C I E N T I S T.O N L I N E Want to join COLUMN the debate? Email “Physical fitness in geoscientist @geolsoc.org.uk geology is rarely discussed” Geoscientist is now plastic free Since moving to Switzerland , Simran is more confident in her physical fitness in the field LET TER We need more open discourse on the physical challenges of fieldwork, aiming for greater inclusivity for aspiring geoscientists, suggests Simran Johal The little T here has been a lot of important discussion recently around inclusivity the tough Hebridean conditions on Cape Wrath in October led me to pass up that project for field excursions require it. It took me years to build my strength, agility, mobility things in fieldwork, in particular my independent geological and, most importantly, DEAR EDITORS, highlighting the barriers field-mapping component. mental confidence. To help Can I take a moment faced by LBGTQ+ and After a few more field trips, provide a more welcoming to congratulate you disabled geoscientists. Even I gained confidence in my and supportive environment for sending across my for those who do not face physical abilities, but I regretted for students new to the magazine in a paper such barriers, it can be hard to not taking that mapping geosciences, there should be envelope and ditching adapt to the fieldwork element opportunity and knew I’d more open discussion of the the old plastic covers of many courses. missed out on a fundamental physical challenges associated that the magazines When I first began my degree geological experience. with fieldwork, tips on how to used to come in. It in geology, I was stepping into For my Master’s degree, prepare and reassurances that is little things like the unknown, but felt I was I moved to Switzerland – a no student will be left behind. this that will make a up for the physical challenge. country where exercise is great difference to However, while I was able embraced and where I had free sustainability in the to scrape through my first- access to every sports facility long run, and cutting year fieldwork on unforgiving imaginable. I took up strength out unnecessary Cornish cliffs unharmed, I training and swimming, and plastic waste. struggled to keep up. finally felt like I was making The next hurdle – a rite of progress. For the first time, DAVI D H U L L passage for almost every UK the physical element of field SIMRAN JOHAL Chartered Senior Simran is currently completing geology student – was facing excursions didn’t faze me and Engineer at her MSc in Engineering Geology Scotland. I walked the escalators I was eager to take part. at ETH Zurich Card Geotechnics on the London underground in Physical fitness in geology simran0589@hotmail.com Limited an attempt to train, but my fear of is rarely discussed, yet most @girlTravertine GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 19
VIEWPOINT Visit Geoscientist. Online to read the latest discussions in full LET TER Testing text? DEAR EDITORS, The new quarterly Geoscientist is superficially attractive, but causes us eye strain. We were unable to Geikie uses the geology of Scotland to appreciate the interesting show how geology determined the cultural articles up to page 18, differences between that country and England where the main narratives COLUMN are in unusually faint print. This is somewhat ironic, “Geodiversity defines human too, as two articles were interesting and important: and cultural diversity” about minorities and discrimination in geology. Those who are visually Geodiversity is the foundation upon which biodiversity and society were impaired, or just elderly, are and continue to be built, argues Andrew Abraham certainly disadvantaged in this new print magazine. T he other day, I went to my bookshelf and pulled out a small book, with a simple dark was way ahead of today’s proponents of geodiversity: “Probably few readers civilisation, to maintain them down to the present day.” Whilst Geikie did not coin The faint print on the opening pages is too difficult to attempt for one green cover. The gold lettering realise to how large an the phrase geodiversity, he of us, and caused eyestrain read, Geological Sketches; its extent the events of history recognised that geology in the better-sighted other. author was Archibald Geikie. have been influenced by the played a huge part in the Do please use more ink The copy I have was published geological structure of the development of nations and next time, or you’ll be in 1892, almost 130 years ago. ground whereon they have not just from a resource accused of discriminating The first edition was published been enacted.” perspective. If we read his against older readers and ten years before. He uses the geology of statements, geodiversity is the sight-impaired. I was searching for whether England and Scotland as more than the cradle for Geikie said anything about an example to show how biodiversity and far more than DR JACK TREAGUS geodiversity. I was not geology determined the geoheritage. Geodiversity has, DR SUSAN TREAGUS disappointed. The title of the cultural differences between and still does, define human Jack and Susan worked at last chapter is The Geological the two countries: and cultural diversity. the University of Manchester Influences that have affected “But we should find that and are now retired. the course of British History. fundamentally the differences A statement in the chapter’s have arisen from the originally DEAR EDITORS, first paragraph tells us Geikie utterly distinct geological I agree that the new structures of the region.” Geoscientist is extremely Geology played He concludes the hard to read, and not only paragraph with: by those who are visually a huge part in the “This diversity of structure impaired. The faint grey is development of initiated the divergences in difficult to parse from the nations and not just human characteristics even D R A N D R E W P. G . A B R A H A M white background, the sans An independent consultant who from a resource in far prehistoric times, and serves as volunteer Director External serif font does not lead the perspective it continues, even in spite of Engagement for the Canadian eye, and the print size is blending influences of modern Federation of Earth Sciences 20 GEOSCIENTIST | SUMMER 2021
VIEWPOINT Follow us @geoscientistmag YOUR TWEETS Birkbeck Earth and Planetary Sciences @BBKEPS: Fantastic cover for the new look @geolsoc @geoscientistmag featuring Birkbeck’s @joshammond and colleagues research on #paektu #volcano. Where #geoscience and #diplomacy meet. @BirkbeckScience @BirkbeckUoL Gareth Farr @GarethFarr1: Pippin says, “I really like the look of the new @geoscientistmag – very professional, looking forward to reading this.” Dr Anjana Khatwa @jurassicg1rl: Some really great reading in @geoscientistmag concerning #Equality #Diversity #Inclusion this month. Many issues raised in these articles translate too small – leaving too much structure affords accessibility. and link to issues of BAME disenfranchisement with white area around leading to Serifs, the small decorative natural heritage and #Geography. Please see links headaches. lines used on letters in below, Happy Friday! Serif font is acknowledged fonts such as Times New to better connect letters into Roman, can distract the eye Digital Civics words. Sans serif is useful for and are overly complex. Replying to @geoscientistmag non-English speakers who Additionally, serif fonts can @DigitalCivics: Congratulations @geoscientistmag might not recognise the odd be problematic in digital A terrific issue, and the new website is a fantastic complement to the work you’re doing. Looking constructions of ‘a’ and ‘g’, publications because the forward to more of your future successes! etc. It is also clean and so pixilation on screen can distort is preferred for maps. But, the edges of letters. Fiona Connor please, if you want us to read Specifically, we opted to use Replying to @seis_matters @geolsoc your articles, then give us the the ‘Museo Sans’ font because and @geoscientistmag educationally best, not the it is considered a highly legible @WorkingFiiOut: Loving this edition of avant-garde aesthetic, font. typeface, well suited for GeoScientist though.... Of late there’s been alot any display and text use. In less things I’m not able to engage with/aren’t GINA BARNES particular, this font has good relevant and a lot more interesting and accessible content. I approve. Emeritus Professor at character recognition, in that Durham University the upper-case ‘I’ (eye), lower- case ‘i’ (lower-eye), lower-case Prof. Andy Fleet, ‘l’ (el) and number 1 (one) can LET TER Editor-in-Chief; be distinguished from one David Shilston, Deputy Editor- in-Chief; Dr Amy Whitchurch, another with relative ease, as can the lower-case ‘a’ (aye), ‘C’ Thought-provoking Executive Editor; Sarah Day, Editor, Geoscientist magazine, (see) and ‘O’ (owe). However, the weight of content write in response: font used on some of the DEAR EDITORS, Thank you for your feedback printed pages in the Spring I really enjoyed both the new look and the new content and for flagging these issues issue was unnecessarily of the Spring issue. Well done on including some really with some of the text in the faint. We have corrected this challenging and thought-provoking material. printed magazine. for the Summer 2021 issue We opted for a sans-serif and hope the problems are JASON CANNING font because their simplified now resolved. Geoscience advisor at RPS Energy and Chartered Geologist GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 21
VIEWPOINT LET TER The name British Geological British Geological Survey Survey (BGS) was introduced in 1984 and that of its and the Royal School of Mines (now part of Imperial The predecessor the Institute of College London). It seems impossibility Geological Sciences (IGS) in 1965. By the 1980s, the De la Beche’s mistake was to have inherited a slave of undoing BGS was a very different plantation in Jamaica, and, the past organisation from that ironically, when he lost its started by De La Beche 150 income, he made himself the DEAR EDITORS, years earlier, wide-ranging first paid geologist, essentially I found the title of the in its activities, both onshore establishing our profession as article Decolonising and offshore, and of global we know it today: no more a Geoscience in the extent. Let us be clear that hobby of the ‘idle rich’. Spring 2021 issue to be LET TER De la Beche began officially Ironic too, in the ongoing problematic because Of their colouring in Ordnance maps of Devonshire for the Board battle against misogyny, is the role played by our ‘toppled you can’t decolonise the past! As a white Pakeha time of Ordnance in 1835, thus heroes’ in the Mary Anning New Zealander living in initiating the Geological story, shortly to be portrayed Europe, I come from a Survey of the United in the film Ammonite. In country that is still tackling DEAR EDITORS, Kingdom. Subsequently the that early 19th century problems resulting from In the informative article Geological Survey Act of 1845 society, where women were colonisation and I have ‘Decolonising Geoscience’ was passed to “facilitate the essentially either adornments worked in a number of (Geoscientist, Spring 2021), Completion of a Geological or drudges depending on their countries that have been the piece rightly concludes: Survey of Great Britain social standing, Henry De la colonised, dealing with “All people are products of and Ireland”. Sir Roderick Beche was a true friend from indigenous and vulnerable their time.” To this statement, Murchison was appointed Mary’s youth, encouraging her people. My first thought one might add ‘organisations’, Director in 1855. in the science and helping her on reading the article was since these are the institutions All this might seem financially with the proceeds ‘this is not enough’. in which people carry out irrelevant or simply a matter of Duria Antiquior, his all- After discussion with their work. of semantics, but in the action painting – the first Society staff, it seems Clearly, organisations context of exploring past ‘palaeoart’ – which brought that the intention of the like the Geological Society patronage and practice it Mary’s fossils to life. article was well founded, of London and the British is wise not to conflate, by Roderick Murchison but more context should Geological Survey have implication, the culture introduced Mary to his wife have been provided for evolved over their long and actions of a modern Charlotte and they formed the reader. histories. In the case of the organisation with those of its a close friendship based In addition to the Survey, it has had many 19th century predecessors. on geologising – apparently ‘decolonial approach’ different masters and changes even closer in the film; and taken with regard to their of name. ANDREW MCMILLAN Louis Agassiz, realising collections, perhaps the I believe it is useful to Andrew was a Principal that Mary would not be Geological Society could refer to contemporary Geologist with the BGS for 36 acknowledged academically, consider forming an organisational terminology years and retired in 2010. named two species of fossil educational scholarship when discussing the past. The fish after her. of some type for article notes that Sir Henry De DEAR EDITORS, indigenous students from la Beche, who had holdings I notice that ‘the winds’ are MART I N LI T HE RL AN D colonised countries? in the West Indies, later finally blowing through OB E became the first director of our Society resulting in the Martin was a field geologist B RYC E L AWR E N CE the British Geological Survey. ‘toppling’ of De la Beche, for the British Geological Managing Director, Global More accurately this should Murchison and Agassiz. This Survey in Botswana, Bolivia Risk Management GmbH read: “… the Geological follows hot on the heels of and Ecuador, before returning The full version of this Survey of the United Kingdom the removal of De la Beche’s to the Keyworth office to letter is available on (presently the British name from those great launch a series of popular Geoscientist.Online Geological Survey)”. institutions he founded: the publications. 22 GEOSCIENTIST | SUMMER 2021
ENGINEERING InSAR has gained recognition in civil engineering as a powerful tool for projects that involve tunnelling, such as London’s Crossrail 24 GEOSCIENTIST | SUMMER 2021
EN G IN EERIN G | T ECH N O LO GY Expanding horizons Jennifer Scoular and colleagues report on the InSAR revolution in geoengineering, which is transforming detection of ground deformations in both urban and rural areas GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SUMMER 2021 25
ENGINEERING G ROUND SURFACE troughs were revealed. In the case of deformation is now Crossrail, this was as a roughly east-west Figure 1: Sketch illustrating multi-interferogram techniques. The black line indicates pre-movement routinely measured to oriented ‘string’ of subsiding areas across ground level and the red line post-movement. millimetric precision central London (Bischoff et al. 2019). The phase shift is ∆R and θ is the incidence angle using a family of InSAR can also be a valuable tool for 1 remote sensing techniques known as engineering geologists to interpret ground Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar conditions during the desk study phase (InSAR; see boxes ‘What is InSAR’ and of a project. After a decade of research, ‘What is interferometry’). The possibilities largely enabled by the British Geological of InSAR first came to the attention of Survey OpenGeoscience service (www.bgs. the wider scientific community when an ac.uk/geological-data/opengeoscience/) interferogram showing ground movement and supported by major infrastructure caused by the 1992 earthquake in Landers, projects, it has been shown that London’s California, appeared on the front cover subsurface is far more complex than of Nature (Massonnet et al. 1993). That previously recognised and contains multiple image was made using data from ERS- geotechnical hazards, which can cause 1, the first European Space Agency SAR significant risks for engineering projects. satellite. Since then, multiple generations These hazards include faulting, sand of SAR satellites have followed, offering channels, drift filled hollows (DFH) and improvements in temporal and spatial shrink-swell behaviour within the London resolution, and opening a diverse range Clay (Scoular et al. 2019). DFHs or ‘buried WHAT IS SAR? of applications. Here, we discuss some hollows’ are steep-sided depressions in the SAR satellites use microwave radiation of those applications, using case studies rockhead surface, caused by a complex that can penetrate through clouds and ranging from central London, to rural interplay of natural processes (e.g. Toms operate day or night, irrespective of Wales and the south coast. et al. 2016). Up to 75 m deep and 90 to weather conditions. The satellite emits a pulse of radar energy, which is reflected 475 m wide, they are typically infilled with by Earth’s surface and the satellite records London’s geology revealed sand and gravel. London’s dense urban the amplitude and phase of the returned Over the last decade or so, InSAR has fabric makes investigation and mapping signal. The amplitude is the strength of gained recognition within the civil of geohazards very challenging and thus the reflected pulse and is influenced by engineering community as a powerful new (previously unknown) DHFs are often the physical properties of Earth’s surface. The phase change between transmitted and cost-effective tool for detecting revealed by site investigations or, in worst- and received signals is proportional to the and monitoring ground deformation case, are encountered during tunnelling two-way travel distance divided by the above tunnelling projects, particularly in and construction. transmitted wavelength, and it contains urban areas. In London, its use gained information from topography plus any recognition following the construction of Spotting geohazards change in the ground surface elevation. Satellite radar sensors have a side-looking the Jubilee Line Extension (1993 to 1999) InSAR could potentially be used to identify geometry and the radar pulse intersects and later during the Crossrail project, these geohazards prior to construction. Earth’s surface at an angle known as the where tunnelling took place between May For example, the presence of a DFH was incidence angle (Fig. 1). 2012 and May 2015, when clear settlement confirmed through the use of InSAR SAR sensors can operate at a variety of wavelengths, often referred to as Table 1: SAR satellite bands bands, in the microwave portion of the electromagnetic spectrum used in each BAND FREQUENCY WAVELENGTH PENETRATION RESOLUTION EXAMPLE SATELLITES case. The wavelength determines how the radar signal interacts with the surface, X-band 8 – 12 GHz 3.8 – 2.4 cm Low High TerraSAR-X, COSMO SkyMed how far it penetrates a medium (such as C-band 4 – 8 GHz 7.5 – 3.8 cm Medium Medium Sentinel-1, Radarsat-2 vegetation, soil and ice) and the spatial resolution of its imaging capability L-band 1 – 2 GHz 30 – 15 cm High Low ALOS-2, SAOCOM (Table 1: SAR satellite bands, left). 26 GEOSCIENTIST | SUMMER 2021
You can also read