Strengthening the Capacity of Indigenous Organizations in the Amazon - Year 5 Work Plan - DEVELOPMENT EXPERIENCE ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Strengthening the Capacity of Indigenous Organizations in the Amazon Year 5 Work Plan Approved Date: Version: 1 Implemented by: Pact, Inc. 1
List of Abbreviations Abbreviation Definition AIRR Amazon Indigenous Rights and Resources APEA Applied Political Economy Analysis AREP Amazon Regional Environmental Program CD Capacity Development CDO Capacity Development Organization CSP Capacity Solutions Platform FH Freedom House HRSM Human Rights Support Mechanism IPOs Indigenous Peoples Organizations ISP Institutional Strengthening Plan ITOCA Integrated Technical Organizational Capacity Assessment OPI Organizational Performance Index OH Outcome Harvesting RCDAM Regional Capacity Development Activity Manager RFA Request for Application SARRA Sub-Awardee Risk and Responsibility Assessment SCIOA Strengthening the Capacity of Indigenous Organizations in the Amazon SI Social Inclusion 2
Table of Contents 1. Introduction 4 1.1 Objective of Work Plan 4 2. Program Overview 4 2.1 Program Objective 4 2.2 Geographic Scope 4 2.3 Theory of Change and Results Chain 4 3. Technical Approach 7 3.1 Strategic Overview 7 3.2 Key Result 1: Activity design adapted by incorporating APEA results, social inclusion strategy, and indigenous organizations’ input. 7 3.2.1 Key Result 1: Description of Activities 7 3.2.2 Key Result 1: Implementation Timeline 8 3.3 Key Result 2: IPO capacity gaps addressed and strengths cultivated 9 3.3.1 Key Result 2: Description of Activities 9 Key Result 2: Implementation Timeline 11 3.4 Key Result 3: IPOs demonstrate improved financial and organizational performance 12 3.4.1 Key Result 3: Description of Activities 12 3.4.2 Key Result 3: Implementation Timeline 14 3.5 Key Result 4: At least one resource generated that can be shared with other organizations supporting human rights of indigenous peoples facing infrastructure development on their lands across the Amazon region 15 3.5.1 Key Result 4: Description of Activities 15 3.5.2 Key Result 4: Implementation Timeline 15 4. Resources 15 5. Activity Management 16 5.1 Staffing and Activity Support 16 5.2 Coordination and Outreach Efforts 16 5.3 Political Environment and Contextual Trends 16 Risks and Mitigation Strategies 16 6. Communications 16 7. Reports Calendar 17 8. Annexes 19 8.1 Annex A: Gantt Chart of Activities aligned with SCIOA Results Chain for FY22 19 3
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Objective of Work Plan The objective of this work plan is to serve as a detailed guide to Activity implementation and represents an agreement as to the nature and timing of discrete tasks and interventions. The following work plan covers the period from October 1st, 2021 through September 30th, 2022. 2. PROGRAM OVERVIEW 2.1 Program Objective Pact’s proposed approach for implementing the “Strengthening the Capacity of Indigenous Organizations in the Amazon” (SCIOA) program, hereinafter referred to as the Activity, will enable us to successfully achieve the overall objective of: At least eighteen selected indigenous peoples' organizations (IPOs) in the Amazon region (at least three each in Colombia, Brazil, Guyana, and Ecuador, two in Peru and four in Suriname) demonstrate improved capacity to manage financial resources and improve their ability to take ownership of their own development planning and priorities. To this end, Pact has designed a set of activities under four Key Results areas: Key Result 1: Activity design adapted by incorporating APEA results, social inclusion strategy, and indigenous organizations’ input. Key Result 2: IPOs' gaps in capacity addressed and strengths cultivated. Key Result 3: IPOs demonstrate improved financial and organizational performance. Key Result 4: At least one key tool or resource identified and developed to be shared with other IPOs facing infrastructure and extractives development on their lands. With the addition of Ecuador to the Activity’s scope of work, Pact expects to primarily rely on a review and analysis of secondary sources of information to adapt the design in this sixth country under Key Result 1. 2.2 Geographic Scope This Activity will strengthen indigenous organizations operating in the Amazon region. Priority will be given to organizations based in the countries of Brazil, Colombia, Guyana, Peru, Suriname and Ecuador. In Year 5, Pact will determine the specific geographic focus within Ecuador based consultations with local and/or regional USAID missions and information gathered through a rapid analysis of secondary information. For Brazil, Colombia, Guyana, Peru and Suriname, the geographic focus has been already defined through the thirteen IPOs that have taken part in SCIOA since Year 1. 2.3 Theory of Change and Results Chain The proposed approach and application of Capacity Development (CD) tools is grounded in a theory of change that underlies Pact’s CD work: If IPOs improve their performance in technical and organizational areas, then they will be able to access external donor funding and take ownership of their own development planning and priorities in a sustainable manner. Three critical assumptions underpin the Activity’s theory of change. These assumptions are: ● IPOs selected to participate are open to internal organizational improvements; possess the political will to enact changes/improvements; and have the time and people necessary to support a capacity development process. The activity will seek to control for this assumption by creating clear expectations among potential IPO participants to avoid a mismatch between the demands of the activity and the abilities of IPOs. 4
● No external barriers exist that are strong enough to impede IPO strengthening. For example, if a natural disaster or unforeseen event (e.g., COVID-19 pandemic challenges beyond what the project has been able to adapt to)1 impacts indigenous people in an area of Activity intervention, an IPO may deprioritize capacity strengthening for the more immediate and important survival of its people. ● IPOs selected to participate are open to self-reflect on their level of inclusiveness and enact changes to address exclusion or discrimination. 1To adapt to the current COVID-19 context, the Activity will ensure IPOs’ access to technological equipment, digital skills, and biosecurity supplies (e.g., masks, sanitizers) to facilitate reasonable levels of participation. 5
Figure 1. Updated SCIOA Results Chain 6
3. TECHNICAL APPROACH 3.1 Strategic Overview The overall purpose of the Activity is for at least eighteen selected IPOs in the Amazon region demonstrating improved capacity to manage financial resources and improve their ability to take ownership of their own development planning and priorities. To this end, Pact has designed a set of activities under four Key Results areas: Key Result 1: Activity design adapted by incorporating Applied Political Economy Analysis (APEA) results, social inclusion strategy, and indigenous organizations’ input. Key Result 2: IPO’s capacities gaps addressed and strengths cultivated. Key Result 3: IPOs demonstrate improved financial and organizational performance. Key Result 4: At least one key tool or resource identified and developed to be shared with other IPOs facing infrastructure and extractives development on their lands. With the addition of Ecuador to the Activity’s scope of work, Pact expects to primarily rely on a review and analysis of secondary sources of information to adapt the design in this sixth country under Key Result 1. 3.2 Key Result 1: Activity design adapted by incorporating APEA results, social inclusion strategy, and indigenous organizations’ input. During years one and two, SCIOA commissioned and conducted an Applied Political Economy Analyses (APEAs) for Colombia, Peru, Brazil, Guyana and Suriname. The findings and recommendations of the APEAs helped to inform activity adaptations that included the use of local Capacity Development Organizations (CDOs) instead of individual consultants or teams of consultants, to provide the on-the-ground support to IPOs. Based on learnings from APEAs in the these five countries, during Year 5, the Activity will carry out a rapid review and analysis of secondary information for Ecuador. This rapid analysis will help refine the Social Inclusion Strategy (SI) and apply it with the IPOs in the country’s context. SCIOA will continue to have two SI indicators included in the MEL plan. The SI strategy provides guidance, framing questions, and practical tools that allow participants in the Integrated Technical Organizational Capacity Assessment (ITOCA) workshops to reflect on how their organizations can improve how they include, promote, or attend to the needs of marginalized or under-represented groups. In addition, the SI strategy will be used in the design and monitoring of the small grants that each of the participating IPOs will develop and implement. 3.2.1 Key Result 1: Description of Activities Activity 1.1.1 Rapid analysis of secondary information for Ecuador. During Year 5, the Activity will carry out a lighter analysis of secondary information for Ecuador, which will primarily focus on the economic and political context of the country, as related to the operations of the IPOs; threats to the rights, property and environmental conservation activities of indigenous peoples; the role of the IPOs in dialogue and advocacy efforts with the national, regional and/or local governments; the level of involvement of indigenous communities in decisions related to development projects in the Amazon, such as mining and roads. The analysis will use information organized by external and recognized sources, such as government agencies, media, chambers of commerce, among others. This exercise will help identify the CDO that the Activity will work with to strengthen capacities of IPOs, as well as the three of IPOs the Activity will select to strengthen. Finally, based on the results from the rapid analysis, SCIOA will update, if necessary, the SI strategy before its application in Ecuador’s context, engaging the selected CDO from Ecuador to incorporate approaches from the 7
SI strategy into the planned CD activities. Activity 1.1.2 Disseminate and apply findings. During Year 4, SCIOA carried out a self-assessment to reflect on the Activity’s impact to date, founded on the Outcome Harvesting (OH) methodology. The OH exercise sought toidentify changes - positive and negative, intended and unintended - that have occurred as a consequence of the implementation of the Activity, both in the experience of IPOs and in the experience of the CDOs. . This qualitative self-assessment was built on a series of change statements to assess the effects of the Activity. During Year 5, SCIOA will consolidate the results of the assessments into a single report to be shared with IPOs, CDOs, USAID, Amazon Regional Environmental Program (AREP) partners, and other SCIOA stakeholders to communicate valuable findings and recommendations and consider how they can be applied in SCIOA’s last years of implementation, as well as any other relevant current and future programming. Activity 1.2.1 Apply Social Inclusion Strategy. During Years 1 through 4, the SCIOA team supported the implementation of several prioritized activities of the ISP with the thirteen IPOs in Colombia, Brazil, Peru, Guyana and Suriname. In Year 5, through an RFA process open to those thirteen IPOs, Pact will select a maximum of five to continue strengthening their capacities through the design and development of small grants which will also incorporate relevant elements of the SI strategy. Activity 1.2.3 Monitor Social Inclusion Strategy’s Progress. Two custom SI indicators have been added to the SCIOA MEL Plan at the beginning of the Activity to track progress on the Social Inclusion strategy. Data reflecting this progress will continue to be included in annual reporting and in the Activity’s final report. The SI strategy and the resulting progress achieved through implementation of the Activity will be made available to key stakeholders in the region and will serve to inform broader USAID strategy. Below are the descriptions of the two mentioned SI indicators in the current MEL Plan: ● C.1 Number of selected IPOs that include at least two statements of excellence in their ITOCAs that assess the organization’s policies or practices related to the inclusion of women, youth, and/or other relevant population groups: The Integrated Technical Organizational Capacity Assessments (ITOCAs) provide information on capacity areas or functions carried out by the organizations that are considered critical to achieving high performance as an organization. This indicator will track the development of statements of excellence within the ITOCAs that specifically address the participation of women and youth. ● C.3 Number of selected IPOs that include at least one action in their ISPs to improve the involvement of women, youth, and/or other relevant population groups: This indicator measures the extent to which participating IPOs are including specific actions that promote the involvement of women and youth as part of their institutional strengthening plans. Actions are specific time-bound activities (one year or less) to be carried out by the IPO without external aid/funds and activities that are facilitated by Pact and local CDOs, and are directly linked to the results of capacity assessments. Indicators C.1, C.3, and indicator DR 6.1-2 keep track of the number of women and youth who participate in trainings, and thus, are strengthening their individual capacities as much as those of their organizations. 3.2.2 Key Result 1: Implementation Timeline Target Completion Activity Timeline Milestone(s) Date Activity 1.1: APEAs in Brazil, Colombia, September- December 2021 Guyana, Peru, and December 2021 Suriname. Activity 1.1.1: Rapid Reports in English and Spanish with analysis of secondary October 2021 December 2021 recommendations finalized. information for Ecuador. 8
Consolidated and disseminated report with Activity 1.1.2: September- OH findings developed with information Disseminate and apply December 2021 October 2021 from Peru, Colombia, Guyana, Brazil, and findings Suriname in English and Spanish Activity 1.2: Social March-September September 2022 Inclusion Strategy 2022 Small grants include SI strategy for five Activity 1.2.2: Apply March-September IPOs in Colombia, Brazil, Peru, Guyana September 2022 Social Inclusion Strategy 2022. and Suriname, as well as for three IPOs in Ecuador Activity 1.2.3: Monitor March-September Data on SI indicators to track SI Strategy Social Inclusion September 2022 2022 progress Strategy’s Progress 3.3 Key Result 2: IPO capacity gaps addressed and strengths cultivated With the addition of Ecuador to SCIOA as part of the project expansion approved in August 2021, some activities included under Key Result 2 will only involve this country as these have already been completed in Brazil, Colombia, Peru, Guyana and Suriname over the course of Years one through four. Nevertheless, once the IPOs from Ecuador complete their ISPs, there will be opportunities that allow IPOs from all the countries to take part in joint activities. Additionally, SCIOA will roll out a competitive process for the selection of five IPOs from the original group to participate in an additional small grants program for continued strengthening of their capacities, as well as application of their learnings to date. All activities under Key Result 2 will continue to be founded in Pact’s participatory approach to CD. The experience applying the ITOCA methodology with IPOs in Brazil, Colombia, Peru, Guyana and Suriname has been positive, with participants highlighting the ease with which they have understood the process; the ownership they feel throughout each step in the assessment design, application, and development of ISPs, the possibilities of adapting the ITOCA methodology for use by the IPOs with their own communities. In Year 5, SCIOA expects to bring this experience to Ecuador, including the application of the adapted ITOCA toolkit developed with input from the current participating IPOs (see Key Result 4). 3.3.1 Key Result 2: Description of Activities Activity 2.1 IPOs' understanding of strengths and weaknesses increased. In Colombia, Peru, Brazil, Guyana and Suriname, during Year 5, SCIOA will issue a request for applications (RFA) to invite the thirteen IPOs the Activity currently works with to submit applications for continued engagement with the Activity. The RFA process will allow IPOs to put into practice some of their learnings and capacities strengthened through SCIOA and take into account recommendations from the Outcome Harvesting (OH) exercise conducted by SCIOA during Year 4. The Activity will select a maximum of five IPOs from these countries to continue strengthening their capacities. During the same period, through similar small grants mechanisms, Pact will also begin supporting the implementation of prioritized activities in the ISPs of the three organizations identified in Ecuador. Activity 2.1.1 Adaptation of ITOCA tool and training of CDOs on ITOCA. In Q2 of Year 5, Pact will carry out an orientation and methodology transfer to the CDO in Ecuador on the Activity’s organizational capacity tools, activity monitoring approaches, and grant management requirements, using the adapted ITOCA toolkit based on insights from the first group of CDOs and IPOs who participated in the Activity. Pact may invite CDOs from Colombia, Brazil and Peru to share their experiences with adapting and implementing the ITOCA in their relevant country contexts. The adaptation process with the CDO from Ecuador will take into consideration the main institutional capacity challenges facing IPOs in the country, the need to promote and ensure participation of women and youth at all 9
levels of decision-making, as well as communications plans and strategies. The rapid assesstment (Activity 1.1.1) will also help inform additional contextual considerations that require unique adaptations of the ITOCA to Ecuador’s context. Activity 2.1.2: ITOCA Contextualization and Organizational Capacity Assessment Workshops. Following the orientation in Ecuador, the CDO, with technical assistance from the RCDAM, will hold a contextualization and capacity assessment workshop with each participating IPO in Ecuador. These workshops, planned for Q3 of FY22 (Year 5), will allow the IPO representatives to first narrow the capacity areas to be assessed and customize their own statements of excellence, to more appropriately respond to their contexts. The contextualization process is an activity in which all organizations customize their tool, thereby facilitating ownership of the process and results. This participatory tool customization process will be used as a CD activity in and of itself, enhancing strategic thinking and joint planning. Participants will next complete their contextualized organizational capacity assessment. Participants begin by exploring important areas of organizational capacity via in-depth facilitated discussions and anonymous individual scoring of statements of excellence under each capacity area. Statements of excellence describe the ideal criteria for any given capacity area. Upon completing the assessment, each participant receives a report that includes scores on a scale of 0-100 for the existing capacity for each of the capacity areas assessed, as well as a score for the level of consensus among respondents for each individual capacity area. The capacity score provides an indication of how strong or weak the organization is in meeting the performance indicators for each capacity area, whereas the consensus score is primarily used to reveal to what extent is there agreement or disagreement on how the organization is meeting those performance indicators. Within the same report, participants will receive individual reports for each of the capacity areas that allow for a more detailed analysis of each area and the respective scores for the individual indicators or statements of excellence under each capacity area. Participants review the report and take part in a facilitated discussion that will serve to identify the areas or functions that require immediate attention and that will be included in the IPO’s institutional strengthening plans. In the five countries that will continue to have IPO participacion in SCIOA, this activity was completed through workshops and virtual meetings in Years 1 and 2 with IPOs in Brazil, Colombia, and Peru, and in Year 3 with IPOs in Guyana and Suriname. Activity 2.2: Development of Institutional Strengthening Plans. As mentioned in Activity 2.1.2, ITOCA results, including the capacity and consensus scores for each capacity area, are debriefed during the ITOCA workshop and fed into the ISPs, which prioritize capacity strengths and gaps and identify appropriate actions to address gaps. These may include areas such as financial management, strategic planning, advocacy, communications, and resource mobilization. During Q4 of Year 5, the CDO from Ecuador, with technical support and guidance from Pact’s RCDAM and Knowledge Specialist will facilitate the process through participatory sessions, while the IPOs lead the prioritization and action planning, thereby enabling alignment and ownership of the process. Specifically, IPOs are tasked with prioritizing strengths and weaknesses, identified through the ITOCA, around which they will generate specific actions. IPOs then prioritize the actions, considering which can be achieved in the short versus long term and which they can achieve themselves versus with community or external assistance. Throughout the ISP’s implementation, Pact will continuously check in with the CDO and IPOs they are working with to provide technical guidance, track progress and refine ISPs accordingly. In the five countries that will continue to have IPO participacion in SCIOA, the development of ISPs took place during Year 2 for IPOs based in Brazil, Colombia and Peru, and Year 3 for IPOs based in Suriname and Guyana. Activity 2.3: Addressing Capacity Gaps and Cultivating Strengths. In Q4 of Year 5, the CDO and IPOs from Ecuador will decide on the mechanisms to employ to address their capacity strengths and gaps. These may include in person and/or virtual workshops and trainings; direct technical assistance; and other forms of knowledge exchange. Most activities will serve multiple purposes and, as applicable, will be tied to the small grant efforts to maximize learning by doing and effective grant design and implementation. Using a variety of methodologies better addresses a need from multiple angles and factors in diverse ways in which people and 10
organizations learn. These various activities will commence in Ecuador upon the application of the ITOCA and the creation of the IPOs’ institutional strengthening plans. During Years 1 through 4, SCIOA supported the implementation of prioritized activities of the ISP among thirteen IPOs in Colombia, Brazil, Peru, Guyana and Suriname. In Q3 of Year 5, through an RFA process open to those thirteen IPOs, Pact will select a maximum of five applications to continue strengthening their capacities for the remainder of the Activity. Activity 2.4: Input results of ITOCA and OPI into CSP and capture SARRA baseline. In Ecuador, baseline data will be collected in Q4 of Year 5 primarily at the organizational level and through two main tools: the Organizational Performance Index (OPI) and the Sub-Awardee Risk and Responsibility Assessment (SARRA). Baseline and midline data have already been collected for IPOs in Brazil, Colombia, Peru, Guyana and Suriname. For IPOs that do not present applications in response to the RFA or are not selected for additional grant funding, the midline data will serve as the enline. For those who receive additional funds, Pact will carry out endline data to track performance. The OPI captures an organization’s performance across four domains: effectiveness, efficiency, relevance, and sustainability. Each domain is composed of two sub-domains. Effectiveness: achieving results and meeting standard; Efficiency: delivering services and increasing reach; Relevance: engaging target populations and promoting learning; Sustainability: mobilizing resources and increasing social capital. Pact will continue using the Sub-Awardee Risk and Responsibility Assessment (SARRA) throughout implementation as a proxy benchmark assessment of a local organization’s readiness for direct funding. For Ecuador, Pact will administer the SARRA with each organization as part of the IPO’s selection process (refer to Activity 3.1.2), providing Pact with a benchmark upon which to respond to remaining capacity gaps. Pact also will continue using its Capacity Solutions Platform (CSP)2, a global platform designed to administer, measure, and report on OPI results, to capture CD inputs, including training and mentoring events, and ITOCA results. The CSP allows Pact, USAID/Peru, and other USAID Missions to easily compare and track CD inputs and assessment results across the Activity, including analysis at individual partner, country, and entire program levels. Results will remain accessible and available through the user-friendly platform even after the program ends, enabling all partners to continue monitoring progress and to have access to their data and documentation. Key Result 2: Implementation Timeline Target Completion Activity Timeline Milestone(s) Date Activity 2.1: IPOs' January-September understanding of strengths September 2022 2022 and weaknesses increased Orientation in Ecuador. Development of adapted ITOCA Activity 2.1.1: Adaptation of for customization at ITOCA tool and training of January- March 2022 March 2022 contextualization workshop by CDOs on ITOCA selected IPOs and application of ITOCA with participating CDO. Activity 2.1.2: ITOCA Contextualization and April-June 2022 for Defined capacity areas and Organizational Capacity IPOs based in customized statements of June 2022 Assessment Workshop with Ecuador excellence for IPO’s ITOCA. IPOs 2 Capacity Solutions Platform: http://pact.capacitysolutionsplatform.com/home 11
IPOs’ Institutional Strengthening Activity 2.2: Development of July- September 2022 Plan with prioritized action areas Institutional Strengthening for IPOs based in September 2022 to be addressed, developed with Plans for IPOs Ecuador support from CDOs and Pact July September 2022 September 2022 for for IPOs based in IPOs in Ecuador. Activity 2.3: Addressing Ecuador. Capacity Gaps and April-June 2022 for June 2022 Cultivating Strengths IPOs based in (Colombia, Brazil, Colombia, Brazil, Peru, Peru, Guyana and Guyana and Suriname Suriname) Activity 2.4: Input results of July- September 2022 ITOCA and OPI into CSP Baseline scores for ITOCA, OPI, for IPOs based in September 2022 and capture SARRA and SARRA for IPOs Ecuador Ecuador baseline for IPOs 3.4 Key Result 3: IPOs demonstrate improved financial and organizational performance In Year 5, participating IPOs across the six countries (including all three from Ecuador and selected five from the other five countries) will manage and implement a small grant activity developed with support from the local CDOs. The small grant activity is intended to provide IPOs with an opportunity to learn about and apply financial management capabilities and create the space to pursue concrete actions that advance priorities conducive to protecting indigenous community rights and mitigating impacts of extractive or infrastructure industries. Pact uses grant making as a hands-on opportunity to provide coaching and other technical support to local organizations for planning, implementation, donor reporting, and financial management, among other CD goals. As such, as IPOs implement their small grants, the Activity will build the capacity of these IPOs through the CD activities outlined under Key Result 2. In Ecuador, Pact will conduct the selection of local CDO and IPOs during Q2 and Q3 of Year 5 (see Activity 3.1). As was the case in Peru, Colombia, Guyana, Suriname and Brazil, the CDO and IPOs’ selection process in this country will incorporate lessons learned from the APEAs and the rapid analysis carried our in Ecuador. With the addition of Ecuador to SCIOA’s scope, as part of the project expansion approved in August 2021, some activities included under Key Result 3 will only involve this country, as these have already been completed in Brazil, Colombia, Peru, Guyana and Suriname over the course of year one to four. Nevertheless, once the IPOs from Ecuador complete their ISPs, there will be opportunities that allow IPOs from all six countries to take part in joint CD activities. 3.4.1 Key Result 3: Description of Activities Activity 3.1: CDO and IPO Selection and Risk Assessment. 3.1.1. CDO Selection. The selection of CDOs in Brazil, Colombia, Peru, Suriname and Guyana was completed in Year 3. In Year 5, Pact will prioritize the selection of the CDO in Ecuador, largely informed through the rapid secondary analysis, as well as any relevant engagements with key stakeholders in country. The selected CDO from Ecuador will determine to a large extent the IPOs that will participate in the Activity. Additional factors will be considered in the selection process, such as a CDOs’ existing relationships with local communities, their prior experience providing capacity development support to IPOs, and their physical presence or ability to access specific geographic areas. This activity will be completed by Q2 of Year 5. 12
Based on lessons learned during the CDO selection process in Brazil, Colombia, Peru, Guyana and Suriname, the RFA process for Ecuador will request that the CDO includes at least five letters of interest from IPOs that would be considered for participation in the activity. Activity 3.1.2: Shortlisting and inviting IPOs to participate in Activity. Previous experience has shown that CDOs who included letters of interest from potential IPOs in their responses to the CDO RFA were more likely to have the established relationships with IPOs necessary to ensure the proposed IPOs were committed to participating in the activity and its CD process. Therefore, Pact will follow this process for Ecuador, and during Q3, with the the selected CDO, work together to finalize the selection of the three IPOs. The indigenous organizations proposed in the CDO’s response to the RFA and other IPOs identified through the rapid analysis (Activity 1.1) will be engaged directly, and a determination will be made regarding which IPOs to invite to participate in the initial risk assessment (see Activity 3.1.3 below). Pact and the selected CDO in Ecuador will utilize the Activity’s selection criteria in the selection of the IPOs. The established criteria are the same as was used in the selection of the IPOs in Colombia, Brazil, Peru, Guyana and Suriname: ● Level at which the organization operates (local, national) Minimum level of institutional capacity so the Activity can build on strengths and achieve its objectives within time and resource constraints ● Alignment of organizational priorities to the broader USAID Amazon Vision ● Extent of concurrent CD from other organizations and ability to absorb additional CD activities ● Demonstrated understanding of the value of social inclusion as it relates to organizational effectiveness, or interest in increasing social inclusion within the IPO ● Logistical concerns (such as economies of scale achieved by working in certain geographies) IPO selection will need to carefully consider coordination with other donors working with IPOs due to the number of actors involved in the Amazon. Coordination efforts will be achieved through regular communication and consultation with stakeholders, commencing with initial national-level meetings led by Pact’s RCDAM and continuing through involvement of the selection committee, yearly reflection activities, and regular communications with USAID and other donors supporting CD activities. Selected IPOs will be approached by the CDO to complete their SARRA. The CDO will provide additional information on concurrent or recent CD support received by IPOs and will help verify the information presented in the IPO’s SARRA results. The selection of IPOs from Ecuador will take place between April and June 2022. During Q2, Pact will open an RFA process for the CDOs and the thirteen IPOs from Colombia, Peru, Brazil, Guyana and Suriname, and select a maximum of five IPOs for additional small grant funding to continue strengthening their capacities based on their ISP and the progress made during Years 2 through 4. Activity 3.1.3: Assessing IPOs’ Level of Risk. Once the IPOs from Colombia, Peru, Brazil, Guyana, Suriname and Ecuador have been selected, the CDOs, with support from Pact, will contact the selected IPOs and carry out Pact’s internal risk assessment, the SARRA, a tool that Pact has developed to assess a potential sub- awardee’s readiness for grant funding. The SARRA tool will be used to determine the appropriate award instrument for new subawards/grants and inform the design of the subrecipient monitoring plan. SARRA can also be used to define any special award conditions that may need to be incorporated into the subaward to mitigate risk and support ongoing monitoring requirements. Pact designed the SARRA specifically for nascent and developing local organizations, and the tool serves principally to screen out only those organizations that represent an unacceptable level of risk. Pact will continue to assess applicants in order of technical merit, as ranked by the selection committee, until at eighteen pass this baseline risk assessment. Activity 3.2: Small Grant Design. Selected IPOs in Ecuador, with support from the CDO in that country and Pact, will lead a design of their own small grants in Q4 of Year 5 through a multi-step process that includes a concept note and a co-design workshop. As in the other countries, the grants will focus on advancing each organization’s priorities in relation to protecting their rights and mitigating the impacts of extractive industries and infrastructure development in the Amazon. For example, an organization may design a grant that focuses on strategic litigation 13
or sustainable forest management practices, the implementation of which will involve the application of financial management, advocacy, and M&E skills, among other capacity areas. Activity 3.2.1: Drafting Concept Notes. Upon completing the ISPs (see Activity 2.2), the IPOs in Ecuador, with support from the CDO and Pact, will submit concept notes that present the activities that will receive support through the small grants. The development of a concept note will serve as an important learning opportunity because many funding mechanisms require the submission of a concept note before a full proposal. The CDO in Ecuador will lead the review of the concept notes and provide mentorship and coaching as needed to ensure a solid concept serves as the basis for a subsequent co-design workshop. This activity will be finalized in in Q4 of Year 5. Activity 3.2.2: Facilitating Co-Design Workshops. Co-design workshops will take each IPO’s concept and expand it into a fully designed grant activity that has a clear scope of work, a defined work plan, and realistic deliverables. Pact and the selected CDO from Ecuador, will lead a workshop with each IPO. This process reflects the Activity’s guiding principle of participatory approaches and places power and control in the hands of IPOs. Co -design processes can produce more original ideas, a final product that is more responsive to a given community’s needs and interests, and can support greater agency and confidence among participating community members. By ensuring IPOs exercise agency over the design process, the small grant activities can further serve to improve ownership of development planning and priorities. This activity will be finalized in September 2022 with the participating IPOs in Ecuador. Activity 3.3: Grant Monitoring. Due to the high transaction costs, Pact will not issue grants directly to the participating IPOs. Instead, the CDOs for the transfer of the funds to the IPOs in each of the countries. As such, Pact has established clear reporting and monitoring protocols in collaboration with the CDOs to ensure that financial and programmatic reporting is completed. Depending on the nature of the grant, this may include monthly or quarterly financial and programmatic reporting, in-person monitoring visits, when possible, or virtual meetings. Monitoring visits by the CDOs will be coupled with institutional capacity building activities, and as with all other interventions in the Activity, grant monitoring will serve as a learning opportunity. For example, during a meeting to check on ISP progress, the CDOs will consult on the progress of grant deliverables and assess the need for additional or different institutional support. By enabling IPOs to check their own progress, self-reflect, and adapt their ISPs to better serve the scope and requirements of the grant activity, grant monitoring will serve as an important driver for increasing institutional capacity across each IPO, further ensuring alignment between grant activities and institutional strengthening interventions. 3.4.2 Key Result 3: Implementation Timeline Target Completion Activity Timeline Milestone(s) Date Activity 3.1: IPO Selection January-September and Risk Assessment for 2022 IPOs CDOs selected and Activity 3.1.1: CDO Selection January-March 2022 March 2022 subawards issued April-June 2022 June 2022 (Ecuador) (Ecuador) Activity 3.1.2: Inviting IPOs IPOs selected in each country March 2022 to participate in Activity March 2022 (Colombia, Brazil, Peru, (Colombia, Brazil, Peru, Guyana and Suriname) Guyana and Suriname) Activity 3.1.3: Assessing Level of risk for each IPO as July-September 2022 September 2022 IPOs’ Level of Risk. reflected by Pact’s SARRA 14
Activity 3.2: Small Grant July - September 2022 September 2022 Design Activity 3.2.1: Drafting July-August 2022 Design and development of September 2022 concept notes (Ecuador) concept notes by IPOs April-June 2022 June 2022 (Colombia, (Colombia, Brazil, Peru, Finalized grant activity Brazil, Peru, Guyana Activity 3.2.2: Co-design Guyana and Suriname) including a scope of work, and Suriname) workshops work plan, and defined July- September 2022 deliverables September 2022 (Ecuador) (Ecuador) Reporting and monitoring Activity 3.3: Grant February 2022- protocols customized to each Monitoring September 2022 IPO, such as quarterly or monthly programmatic reports. 3.5 Key Result 4: At least one resource generated that can be shared with other organizations supporting human rights of indigenous peoples facing infrastructure development on their lands across the Amazon region During year one to four, the SCIOA team complemented the ITOCA tool, by developing audiovisual content for facilitators, building a toolbox with SCIOA’s journey map, a roadmap to present every stage and remind of the purpose of the exercise, simplifying the tool´s language and include specific recommendations for the facilitators. During year five, SCIOA team will design a toolkit for facilitators and develop visual content from the IPOs of Ecuador adapting and implementing the ITOCA. This might be done with the help of youth from the IPOs. 3.5.1 Key Result 4: Description of Activities Activity 4.2: Design and Dissemination of Resource(s). In Year 4, after consulting with the CDOs and the IPOs from the first five countries of the Activity, Pact developed a series of resources to complement the ITOCA tool in more visual and interactive ways. During Year 5, Pact will collaborate with CDOs and IPOs to launch and share the complementary ITOCA tools with other IPOs, national and regional bodies, and other stakeholders. Pact’s RCDAM and Knowledge Specialist will lead this initiative, including developing a strategic communications plan to support the dissemination of the resources, tapping into Pact’s and other HRSM partners’ communications resources for support, as needed. 3.5.2 Key Result 4: Implementation Timeline Target Completion Activity Timeline Milestone(s) Date Activity 4.2: Design and Dissemination ITOCA complementary April-June 2022 June 2022 of Resource(s) tools disseminated 4. RESOURCES The activity budget includes anticipated level of effort of key staff members, both from Pact’s Washington, DC based staff and those based in the countries of implementation; estimated costs per activity; estimated travel costs; and other cost elements relevant to the implementation of the work plan. 15
5. ACTIVITY MANAGEMENT 5.1 Staffing and Activity Support The project extension and expansion to include Ecuador will also require additional administrative support from Pact’s Colombia office. This includes, the support of Pact Colombia’s Grants Officer in the issuance and monitoring of additional subgrants, as well as facilitation of travel and other logistics by the Procurement and Logistics Analyst, with a portion of their level of effort covered by the SCIOA project. In addition, to realize cost efficiencies in grants management (i.e., transaction costs for direct cash transfers to IPOs, travel costs associated with monitoring IPOs in remote areas), CDOs in each country will continue to serve as the conduits to transfer the sub-awards to the IPOs. 5.2 Coordination and Outreach Efforts During Year 5, SCIOA staff will continue to proactively seek opportunities to engage with other USAID projects under AREP and USAID partners in the region working with indigenous peoples and related issues. Emphasis will be placed on sharing lessons learned and creating opportunities for participating IPOs to expand their professional networks in the region. SCIOA will also seek to attend relevant events hosted by regional indigenous peoples organizations, research institutions, NGOs, foundations, bilateral institutions and government agencies to raise awareness of the activity and the work of the participating IPO’s. 5.3 Political Environment and Contextual Trends The activity will monitor the political and security context across the six countries, sharing any pertinent information gathered with USAID missions, other USAID partners, and project stakeholders. Coordination with the individual CDOs and USAID missions will be critical to ensure that any proposed activities, outreach efforts, and communication materials do not generate risks for participating IPOs. Additionally, the Activity will closely monitor COVID-19 developments and advisories in each of the countries to ensure that any presential activities take into account the trends and risks in each country and take measures to mitigate them. Risks and Mitigation Strategies Throughout the implementation of SCIOA, the Activity will monitor and adaptively manage around several ongoing risks. Of primary consideration is the COVID-19 context context in each country of implementation, which is expected to continue to evolve and require regular monitoring in light of new variants, government mandates and emergency responses. Additionally, the project will continue to closely monitor the political contexts in the six countries, as well as developments related to the rights of IPs, the state institutions that support or inhibit their missions, and the state’s relations to ongoing or planned large-scale development projects are all linked to politics. The Activity will monitor ongoing changes to the political context in each country, as relevant, and maintain communication with bilateral USAID missions to ensure programming continues to respond accurately to evolving environments. 6. COMMUNICATIONS During Years 3 and 4, SCIOA made significant strides in communication efforts to: a) share Activity updates with relevant stakeholders; b) convene and share outcomes with key project stakeholders, including CDOs and IPOs; and c) make visible IPOs’ success stories within the Activity. The SCIOA team proactively developed content to meet these objectives and continued to foster exchange spaces for exchange and reflection to take place among Activity participants and stakeholders. During Year 5, SCIOA’s communication strategy will aim to transfer the voice to tell stories to the IPOs themselves, in the spirit of the capacity development focus of this Activity. In addition to directly developing content for different audiences, the Activity team will also involve IPOs and CDOs in their development and 16
dissemination. Type of Responsible Audience Content Objective Content Parties USAID, Freedom Quarterly reports, - SCIOA Team Activity- House, other USAID written success stories, Communicate SCIOA’s (produces) driven Activities, external learning pieces, progress and learnings - CDOs (inform) public (success stories) research products - Explicitly integrate Activity Pause and reflect - SCIOA Team objectives with IPOs’ missions events, experience and CDOs - Convene Activity Shared exchanges (in (organize) stakeholders to reflect on person/virtual) - IPOs (share) accomplishments and priorities for next period Quarterly newsletter, -Empower IPOs, with focus on - IPOs – youth Results/ CDOs, IPOs, USAID, virtual events (e.g., “The youth to tell their own stories (produce) outcomes- other USAID Activities, Amazon proposes”) -Make visible IPOs’ actions - SCIOA Team driven NGOs, external public audiovisual stories, -Learn from others’ (supports) learning pieces experiences Activity-driven content: This content will seek to update relevant stakeholders on the Activity’s progress, including providing updates on upcoming events and activities, key challenges and successes, as well as share Activity achievements and lessons learned. SCIOA will also produce photo stories or case studies to highlight participating IPOs’ small grant activities, and allow external stakeholders to better understand the specific CD priorities of IPOs in the region. Additionally, Activity research products, such as the Outcome Harvesting results report, will be shared with USAID missions and resource partners, among other stakeholders. Shared content: The Activity will continue to hold annual pause and reflect events, bringing together CDOs, representatives from the participating IPOs, and other relevant stakeholders. These sessions will be designed to help capture and share information on CD activities, discuss contextual events and factors that influence the ongoing activities of IPOs in their communities, and offer opportunities for ongoing learning and adaptation of the Activity. During Q4 of Year 5, SCIOA expects to hold an in-person pause and reflect event if safe during the COVID-19 pandemic at the time, which can be easily adapted to a virtual format if more appropriate. The SCIOA team will also foster exchange activities among IPOs to share experiences and knowledge and strengthen their networks with peers in their and other countries. Results/outcomes-driven content: This new approach aims to empower IPOs, especially youth, to tell their own stories. During Year 5, SCIOA will support and foster audiovisual trainings and meetings among interested youth from IPOs of all six countries, ideally with engagement from USAID. This strategy serves a dual purpose: a) making it easier for the Activity team to gather content and stories from the six countries; and b) ensuring the sustainability of the communications strategy of the Activity over time through CD of IPOs on this topic. Youth will create audiovisual contents (e.g. videos, podcats, photo stories) with SCIOA team’s support, and will find local and/or national spaces/channels to share them, making visible their organizations’ and communities’ efforts, successes and challenges. 7. REPORTS CALENDAR Report Coverage Due Date FY22 Q1 Quarterly Report October 1, 2021 – December 31, 2021 January 31, 2022 FY22 Q2 Quarterly Report January 1, 2022 – March 31, 2022 April 30, 2022 17
FY22 Q3 Quarterly Report April 1, 2022 – June 30, 2022 July 31, 2022 FY22 Annual Report October 1, 2021 – September 30, 2022 October 30, 2022 18
8. ANNEXES 8.1 Annex A: Gantt Chart of Activities aligned with SCIOA Results Chain for FY22 Fiscal Year 22 Result Activity Outputs Outcomes FY22 – Q1 FY22 – Q2 FY22 – Q3 FY22 – Q4 1. Activity design adapted by incorporating APEA results, social Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep inclusion strategy, and indigenous organizations’ input. 1.1.1: Rapid Consolidated and analysis of disseminated 1.1.2 Disseminate secondary report with OH and apply findings information for findings in English Ecuador. and Spanish 1.2.2 Apply Social Activity design Inclusion Strategy adapted Activity 1.2: Small grants Social Inclusion include SI strategy Strategy for IPOs 1.2.3 Monitoring the Social Inclusion Strategy’s Progress 2. IPO capacity gaps addressed and strengths cultivated 2.1.1: Adaptation At the end of of ITOCA tool and September training of CDOs on IPOsfrom ITOCA designed ITOCA Ecuador have 2.1 IPOs' for IPOs; ITOCA developed an understanding contextualized with 2.1.2: ITOCA ISP. IPOs from of strengths and selected IPOs; Contextualization Colombia, Peru, weaknesses ITOCA workshop and Organizational Brasil, Guyana increased conducted; ISPs Capacity and Suriname developed Assessment continue Workshop with addressng IPOs capacity gaps 19
based on their 2.2 ISP. Development of 2.2 Institutional Institutional Strengthening Plan Strengthening co-developed Plans for IPOs 2.3 CDOs and 2.3 Addressing IPOs jointly decide Capacity Gaps on the mechanisms and Cultivating to employ to Strengths address capacity strengths and gaps All selected 2.4: Input ITOCA results IPOs show an results of analyzed and increase in ITOCA and OPI 2.4 CDOs and Pact socialized; OPI organizational into CSP and input CD results score recorded and performance capture SARRA into CSP system SARRA scores over baseline baseline for all recorded as as measured IPOs baseline measures through the OPI. 3. IPOs demonstrate improved financial and organizational performance 3.1.1: CDO CDO selected and Selection subawards issued By the end of 3.1: IPO 2022, five IPOs' Selection and are Risk IPO selection 3.1.2: inviting IPOs implementing at Assessmentfor process defined; to participate in least 2 more IPOs IPOs selected; Activity actions on their SARRA conducted ISPs. And three IPOs join the activity 20
Identified level of risk for each 3.1.3: Assessing SARRA scores IPO as reflected IPOs’ Level of Risk. recorded by Pact’s SARRA 3.2.1: Concept notes drafted with support from CDOs By the end of 3.2: Small Small grant the fiscal year grants design activities IPOs will have developed and 3.2.2: Co-design designed and proposals workshops held start submitted for implementing review and activities of their approval small grants. 3.3: Pact and Quarterly or 3.3: Grant CDOs monitor programmatic Monitoring small grant reports. activities 4. At least one tool or resource need identified and developed At least one resource 4.2 Pact designs developed and and shares 4.2 Design and shared with At least one resource(s) with dissemination participating IPOs, resource CDOs, IPOs, and of resource(s) national and disseminated other project regional IPOs, and stakeholders other project stakeholders 5. SCIOA Events 5.1 Hold SCIOA Annual Pause and Reflect event 21
You can also read