LETTER FROM CANBERRA - Roy Morgan
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
LETTER FROM CANBERRA Saving you time. A monthly newsletter distilling public policy and government decisions which affect business opportunities in Australia and beyond. 18 June to 22 JulY 2010 issue no. 26: Pre-election edition Latest Roy Morgan Election Finding: What the Federal Government Letter from Canberra, established 2008, is a sister publication of Leter From Melbourne, established 1994 should do to benefit electors and their families. - Pages 11 - 14 Our fascinating language inside Editorial by Alistair Urquhart Letter From Canberra is a publication about distilling public policy and the government decisions which effect business op- Gillard moves forward (to the right) portunities in Australia, and we provide the surrounding political context. One purpose of the magazine is to keep much of the unproductive political chatter away from the mind of the busy business reader. In this pre-election edition, we wrap up the Rudd rumbles around the globe… political debate/activities in the first five pages. Back when Tom Roberts painted the iconic Shearing the Rams in 1898, in that woolshed in the Riverina, a strong union move- Refugee policy battle. East Timor, ment was being born, and not long after that the Australian Labor Party. The founders would be proud of today’s union power, Nauru… strongly represented by the government and, seemingly, in this election, without competition from the Opposition. Abbott stumbles on IR laws It is difficult to remember a federal election characterised by so many imponderables, including a prime minister who has only been in the job for a few weeks. The economy is the main issue for most marginal seat voters, and for their jobs, but it is far from clear what state the economy is really in, or how it will fair over the next few years. We provide a snapshot of the The Greens may win balance of issues on page 3. power in Senate Do you want some fun? Take some time away from your busy life and sit quietly, alone in front of the TV, perhaps LateLine. Health Identifiers passed Listen hard to the choice of words these political fighters are actually using at the moment on TV and try to figure out exactly what they are saying, in the context of their particular party’s traditional or even more recent ever-changing policies, and those of their competitor. The fun side of not switching off, and just focusing on listening to their words, is that one can hear some Telstra deal on National Broadband PB of the silliest nonsense for a very long time.
18 JUNE to 22 JUly 2010 14 Collins Street aBOut tHe editOr AlIStAIR URQUHARt Melbourne, 3000 Alistair Urquhart graduated from the Australian National University in Canberra, in Law, Victoria, Australia History and Politics, was admitted as a barrister and solicitor of the Supreme Court P 03 9654 1300 of Victoria, and remains a (non-practicing) member of the Law Institute of Victoria. F 03 9654 1165 Before that, he graduated from high school in Bethesda, Maryland, and had many info@affairs.com.au opportunities to become aware of the workings of Washington DC. For 30 years, he www.letterfromcanberra.com.au listened every Sunday evening to the late Alistair Cooke and his Letter From America. His early career was mostly in the coal industry, where he became involved with energy, environmental and water issues, and later in the SME finance sector. editor Alistair Urquhart associate editor Hamish Brooks His public affairs firm works with many engineering and information technology firms, other professional subscription Manager Juliette Biegler association and industry groups, on a wide range of issues, in Victoria, Canberra and overseas. Urquhart visits advertising Manager Eddie Mior Canberra regularly. He may hold the record for miles rowed on Canberra’s Lake Burley Griffin. editorial consultant Rick Brown design Steph Dang indeX IN APPRoxIMAtE oRDER oF INtERESt oVER tHE PASt MoNtH WelcOMe Ms PriMe Minister 3 fOreign affairs 19 iMMigratiOn 4 infrastructure 19 Letter from Canberra is focused on the interface of business and government, with resOurces 6 educatiOn 20 enough politics and bureaucracy to understand HealtH 7 Justice 20 the, or any, relevant business opportunities. BrOadBand. ict. innOVatiOn 8 defence 21 We have been publishing Letter from Canberra’s industrial relatiOns. eMPlOYMent 15 agriculture. Water 21 sister publication Letter From Melbourne, a gOVernance 15 Manufacturing 22 public policy digest, for 16 years. Commencing Business. ecOnOMY. taX 16 cOalitiOn dOings 22 with the Kennett era corporatisation and privatisation of energy and other utilities and cliMate cHange. enVirOnMent. energY 18 sOcietY 22 the other fresh broom approach of a new government, where we focused on business a snaPsHOt Of WHat tHe 2010 federal and very hopeful forecasts of China’s growth, and opportunities. Increasingly, we included matters electiOn POrtends hence China’s demand for our resources. in the other states and adopted a more federal the leaders focus. The Coalition points to the surplus they left Labor Prime Minister for little more than a month, by virtue of the dramatic deposition of her predeces- in 2007 and what has happened since. It says its the recent change in federal government opens up new business opportunities, particularly the sor, Kevin Rudd, Julia Gillard is 48, Welsh born, no wonder Labor picked the slogan ‘moving for- government’s new emphasis on climate change, Adelaide-raised and educated in Melbourne. She ward’ for the simple fact is they would hardly want carbon trading, water, industrial relations, is a lawyer, worked in industrial relations law prior to look backwards at their recent record. Abbott education, information technology and the to becoming a politicall staffer and was elected says he will reject the revamped mining deal and traditional sectors. to Parliament in 1998 for a Melbourne Western still deliver a surplus by halting Labor’s profligate suburbs seat. Since Labor’s victory in the 2007 spending spree, cutting a range of pet Labor proj- For many years, our other publications have ects (including the elaborate and hugely expensive included the well-known federal government election, until her elevation as PM, she served as Deputy PM and held a host ministries simultane- broadband network) and by stimulating growth in Departmental Wall Chart. (NoW AVAIlABlE at 03 ously including employment and education. the small business sector. 96541300 or letterfrommelbourne.com.au)) We conduct seminars and informal luncheons and meetings in Melbourne, Canberra and Sydney. Tony Abbott, 52, was born in England, raised in Industrial Relations: Labor are committed to fight- Sydney, was a Catholic seminarian before he ing the last election on ‘work choices’, not least Most people have their clipping services and a decided it wasn’t for him, took an arts degree at because they won that one, even if Abbott has range of email products/newsletters/etc. At the declared work choices totally irretrievably dead end of the month, Letter From Canberra gives a Sydney Univ and then went to Oxford as a Rho- des Scholar. Worked as a jounalist for the Bulletin, (at least for the next three years). Labor will keep broad overview of what has been going on, not hammering on this open door because they figure just in one industry but across all industries and a staffer for John Hewson in oppostion, ran the monarchist campaign during the referendum, and there are votes in it, not to mention a lot of union the world of business and government generally. held several ministries in the Howard government money. Abbott wants to neutralise the issue as objective. Independent. Read it on the plane. or including health and education. quickly as possible, but his fierce rejection won’t at a coffee shop in New york. And then give it to a friend who is interested in Australia. assist in convincing his small business constitu- ency that he is still their man. the issues Published by A.B Urquhart & Company Pty ltd trading as Affairs The Economy: the question at the heart of the cam- Population and Immigration: Gillard has given the of State. Disclaimer: Material in this publication is general paign is who can be trusted with the economy? comment and not intended as advice on any particular matter. thumbs down to a ‘Big Australia’, a proxy PC ver- Labor claims much credit for steering the country Professional advice should be sought before action is taken. sion of ‘stopping the boats’, in order not to lose Material is complied from various sources including newspaper through the rapids of the GFC, but rather tarnished votes on this volatile issue to Abbott whose claim articles, press releases, government publications, Hansard, trade that achievement by mishandling the stimulus journals, etc. © this newsletter is copyright. No part may be to stop them has more credibility. package to insure us against the GFC’s worst reproduced, stored\ in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, consequences. The schools building program has photocopying, recording or otherwise), without the prior written been a disaster of waste and incompetence and the Wild cards. A fleet of boats arrive off WA; permission from the publisher. Affairs of State respects your the insulation scheme not much better. The great China’s economic forecast takes a serious dive; privacy. While we do believe that the information contained in hope for meeting Labor’s promise to put the econ- Abbott blows it and figuratively falls off his bike; letter from Canberra will be useful to you, please advise us if omy back in surplus in three years rests above all Gillard’s raving lefty past catches up with her. you do not wish to receive any further communications from us. on their new, revamped mining tax and their new 22 2
LETTER FROM CANBERRA jettisoning work choices, implementing hospitals a warning that China’s economic growth and the Ms PriMe Minister reform and getting Australia into the Group of 20 among those achievements. Photos in the papers demand for Australian mineral resources will be no free ticket to easy prosperity. a night of wildness showing Rudd on the backbench provided a What? In The Age, shaun carney wrote that Kevin strange sight. The Financial Review reported that the leadership rudd’s most senior adviser alister Jordan a kind of stability challenge was a shock to many cabinet ministers, had, during the month in the lead up to Julia The Financial Review reported that shortly junior ministers, Parliamentary secretaries and gillard’s leadership challenge, sounded out before being sworn in as Prime Minister by backbenchers throughout the Caucus – the very half the Labor caucus, checking if they were the Governor-General, Quentin Bryce, Julia people who are normally involved or contacted considering shifting their support away from the gillard said ‘I believe that we [the Government] about a leadership spill. Key factional leaders Prime Minister. To Julia Gillard, who had insisted have on several issues not delivered the kind of had devised their moves carefully but most of all through this time that she had no interest in stability and certainty and good management Caucus was left in the dark. Evidently, even when replacing Rudd, this was an act of spectacular that Australians seek’. She launched her prime she went to meet Kevin rudd on the evening of disloyalty. Michelle grattan wrote that Rudd’s ministership by promising a more consultative 23 June, Julia gillard was still telling people that leadership was trashed in an extraordinary and style of government, quite different from the she had not made up her mind to challenge him. unprecedented manner. The man obsessed with ‘gang of four’ kitchen cabinet that wielded power A source close to Gillard said she only took the control lost control of his government, his party under Kevin rudd. decision during their meeting. and his prime ministership in a night of wildness. The day before there was to be a vote on Rudd’s a safe pair of hands choosing between destructions leadership, support for him had evaporated Shortly after taking the leadership, Gillard phoned The Age reported that research that showed with the Australian Workers Union backing Julia Trade Minister simon crean and offered him her Labor would suffer a total wipeout under Kevin Gillard. In the face of the challenge, Rudd stood old mega-portfolio of education, employment, rudd prompted the Australian Workers Union’s on his record and criticised factionalism, before workplace relations and social inclusion, which decision to switch to Julia gillard. National resigning on the morning of June 25, without a Crean accepte, The Age reported. Crean, who secretary Paul Howes said he feared the leadership vote. The Financial Review reported served as a cabinet minister in the Hawke, situation was so dire the Coalition would be able that the short and sharp transition was vastly Keating and Rudd governments, will be called to reintroduce WorkChoices. If that happened, different from the lengthy brawl in 1990 that upon to prosecute the Government’s claim the union movement faced being destroyed, damaged the Labor government of Bob Hawke that Opposition Leader tony abbott will try to he said. The Financial Review reported that and Paul Keating. reintroduce WorkChoices. The Financial Review the leadership change demonstrated that Bill reported that Foreign Minister stephen smith shorten, Communications Minister stephen Poll bounce gained Crean’s portfolio of trade and all other conroy and Senator Kim carr were a powerful In an Age/Nielsen poll taken on Gillard’s first two ministries were left unchanged. combination and in effect created a new creature days as Prime Minister, more than half of those in the federal caucus number crunch. However, surveyed said they approved of her ascension. Moving forward it is important to remember that the killer blow The government’s two-party vote leapt eight As she grapples with three issues the government came only when the New South Wales right, points in three weeks, taking it to a 55-45 per must neutralise – mining tax, asylum seekers stung by a crushing by-election loss at Penrith, cent lead over the opposition, The Age reported. and climate change – Julie gillard has a broader led by Mike arbib and Howes, decided enough On the same day, the Herald Sun reported that challenge, wrote Michelle grattan in The Age. was enough. So while the initial push might have the ALP leads the coalition 52-48 on two-party She needs to fit her solutions into a story that come from Victoria, the real shove was provided preferred terms. Nearby, at the end of June, The defines, rather than confuses, her political identity. from further north in the traditional powerhouse Australian reported that primary support of the This became ‘moving forward’. However, she is of Australian Labor. The Australian reported that New South Wales Labor government dropped six struggling to shed the immediate past. A major Gillard’s elevation eases the jitters for Labor in percentage points to a record low of 25 per cent. scene setting speech on the economy at the key marginal seats. On the opinion pages of The change in leadership has caused the Labor National Press Club in mid-July veered off course The Australian, Michael costello wrote that the party machine to go into overdrive rebuilding its when Gillard was asked by veteran journalist unions and factions don’t deserve all the credit in election campaign with Julia gillard front and laurie Oakes whether she had in effect reneged Gillard’s ascension. Only she had the power and centre and the throwing out thousands of dollars on leadership succession deal with Rudd on popularity in caucus to depose Kevin rudd. worth of newsletters, pamphlets and other the night he was toppled. It is understood that material featuring Rudd as the leader. Gillard initially signalled she would not challenge shorten’s hand his leadership during a meeting on the night of The Herald Sun reported that two of the Victorian resigning but not quitting June 23 in the then PM’s office, The Age reported. ALP’s heavy hitters, MP Bill shorten and former The Herald Sun reported that a single tear ran She refused to comment on what she said ALP state secretary Senator david feeney have down Kevin rudd’s face as he delivered an were confidential conversations. The Australian been linked to the push to end Kevin rudd’s emotional farewell to the nation. Flanked by his reported that Labour figures are blaming Kevin leadership. For years they have worked in wife Therese and their three children, Rudd was rudd for the leak of what happened on that tandem to influence the direction of the party, but overcome several times as he spoke about his night. Rudd confirmed that he believed Gillard in recent times have had their differences within passion to fight cancer, promote organ donation last month reneged on arrangement that would the complex power structures of the Victorian and the apology to the Stolen Generations. He have saved his job as prime minister. Meanwhile, ALP Right wing. The Australian reported that the will not quit politics and wants a senior role in the Herald Sun reported that a pledge of active Victorian right faction took the unprecedented the Gillard government, but at the moment would microeconomic reform and prudent economic step of offering Julia gillard, a member of the spend some time on the backbench. The Age management spearheaded Gillard’s first major Victorian left, the leadership of the Labor Party. reported that Julia gillard rejected Rudd’s bid pitch to business. Gillard sought to establish to become foreign minister, instead promising Bolt’s view her credentials as a fiscal conservative by him a senior cabinet post if the government In the Herald Sun, andrew Bolt wrote an article committing to protecting the budget surplus is re-elected. Rudd paused scores of times explaining why Julia gillard can win where forecast for three years time. And she sounded as he tried to keep his composure and list the Rudd lost, but not before noting that our new government achievements he was proud of. He prime minister should be able to get away with nominated: riding out the global financial crisis, taking the leadership the way she did. Whilst 23 3
18 JUNE to 22 JUly 2010 she conceded she bore her fair share of the would appeal to a broader range of Australians. 24-hour news channel to break news. What the blame for the government’s failures, she did tick And Catholic priest Bob Maguire claimed that public does not need is more programs in which off on every government policy, and personally Abbott’s extreme Catholic views would scare off ABC journalists interview other ABC journalists. led the Building Education Revolution, the most voters, ‘Australians are not religious, we are the Just a damn popularity contest rorted government program in history. Still, Bolt world’s leading secularists,’ he said. A week or Former Labor leader Mark latham said the believes, her superbly executed assumption of so later, the Herald Sun reported that Julia Gillard move against Kevin rudd showed the Labour power may just work. It’s not just that she has told ABC radio that she is not a religious person leadership was only about popularity, and no what Rudd fatally lacks – a secure sense of self, and will not pretend a faith that she doesn’t longer about policy, values or ideology. which makes her so much easier to work with. feel. For people of faith, she said the greatest What she now adds to the bargain is the excuse compliment she could pay them is to respect not even married of the new – and an astonishing reinvention of their genuinely held beliefs and not engage in A letter of the editor in The Age, from a lifetime herself as a Labor Margaret thatcher. Rudd some pretence about hers. Although Gillard was Labor voter, expressed disgust at the dumping had performed so many backflips that he could brought up a Baptist, and won prizes as a child of Kevin rudd as Prime Minister. In the same not risk one more. But within hours of taking for remembering Bible verses, she says she has paper, Michelle grattan wrote that Rudd his job, Gillard offered miners true negotiations. found a different path as an adult. The Australian received the harshest of reality checks. After his What was even more remarkable about Gillard reported that the Australian Christian Lobby has election triumph, he tried to force everyone and as she assumed the top job was the tone she said that, whilst being honest and true to herself, everything else to adapt to him. struck. She started politics on the far Left of Gillard may have alienated Christian voters by the Her partner Labor, but pitched her spiel right at Australia’s declaring she does not believe in God. Julia gillard’s partner, tim Mathieson, has more conservative heart. In a brilliantly crafted Won’t lodge until elected lived with her in Altona for three years. He is not acceptance speech, she declared she’d work New Prime Minister Julia gillard declared intimidated by his partner’s star power. Mathieson for those who play by the rules and love their she would not move into The Lodge until she recently made a career switch from hair stylist country. Also in the Herald Sun, in the same was elected by the people. ‘I’m very happy in to a sales position with real estate development opinion section but on a different day, Jill singer my home in Altona… very happy in my flat in company ubertas, where he has been since wrote that tony abbott is yesterday’s man when Canberra,’ she said. Not since Ben chifley in November. The Age reported that friends of the it comes to the policies and issues that matter to the 1940s – who lived and died in Canberra’s couple, who say they are affectionate with each everyday Australians. Kurrajong Hotel – has the Prime Minister lived in other in public, believe Mathieson will be keen to abbott surrounded lodgings other than those provided by the state, be by Gillard’s side more openly. Opposition leader tony abbott moved quickly The Age reported. A follow-up report by the same some way back story to paint his new opponent as an interim leader paper said that the first broken promise of Julia The Age reported that Victorian Premier John who lacked a mandate from the Australian Gillard’s rein may be on the cards, with security Brumby picked Julia gillard as his chief of people, as the Coalition took aim at Labor over experts and a government bodyguard describing staff about 15 years ago, to help take on then asylum seekers and the resources super profits her plan to live in her modest homes in Canberra Premier Jeff Kennett. After two years running tax. ‘They’ve changed the salesman but haven’t and Melbourne as untenable. As the Herald his office in the mid-90s, Brumby helped Gillard changed the product,’ Abbott said. Also, on Sun puts it: a security assessment will shortly win preselection for the western suburbs federal the Insiders, Abbott noted (playing down the be carried out by officers from the Protective seat of Lalor, believing she had what it takes to significance of Julia gillard being the first female Services Co-ordination Centre to ascertain if the become prime minister. Gillard is close to deputy prime minister) that he had a female Premier, a Altona home is fit for a national leader. An old Premier rob Hulls (another former Brumby female Governor, a female Prime Minister with a police caravan was parked opposite Gillard’s chief of staff). Brumby, who fell out with Rudd female Governor General and a female monarch. house in preparation for her return to Melbourne over the former Prime Minister’s national health What’s new? he asked. for the first time as Prime Minister. Nearby, Kevin reform plan, said that he would pressure Gillard rudd left the lodge five days after losing the international well-wishers to reopen the debate. He said he would urge leadership. Julia gillard has personally assured US President the Prime Minister to do more in mental illness, Barrack Obama of her commitment to the military entertainment news preventive health care and aged care. mission in Afghanistan. The new Prime Minister On the opinion pages of The Australian, Janet Happy as larry in Barry spoke to a host of international leaders during a albrechsten wrote that an agile commercial The Age reported that the front page of the local busy round of phone calls. Indonesian president operator showed the ABC how it should be done paper in the small Welsh port of Barry was susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, Malaysian PM when covering a news item as big as Julia rewritten to make way for the big news that najib razak and Canadian PM stephen Harper gillard’s challenge to Kevin rudd. Albrechsten one of their own had become Prime Minister of were among foreign leaders to congratulate her, wrote that the ABC’s chris uhlmann and Mark Australia, even though most of the 40,000 locals the Herald Sun reported. simkin did a brilliant job breaking the big story had not previously heard of the child from their on the 7 PM news, which reported leadership c’mon eileen town who had left for Australia 44 years ago, rumblings within the Rudd government. But if MX reported that Kevin rudd took his oath of having been born in Barry in 1961. you wanted more news about Rudd’s swift and office in December 2007 holding the Bible and dramatic downfall, you needed to channel surf concluding ‘So help me God’. Julia gillard took a Bible free affirmation. ‘I, Julia Eileen Gillard, do over to Sky News. That night, Sky News became the default national broadcaster. An editorial in iMMigration. PoPulation solemnly and sincerely affirm and declare that I Prime Minister for sustainable Population the same paper expressed a similar sentiment will well and truly serve the Commonwealth of Prime Minister Julia gillard declared she does asking: is the national broadcaster ready for Australia…’ In a poll of the religious beliefs of not believe in a ‘big Australia’, signalling a 24-hour news? ABC viewers were left frustrated federal and shadow cabinet ministers last year, major shift in policy on the nation’s burgeoning and baffled as to why an event unprecedented Gillard said she was a non-practising Baptist and population growth, in a move to neutralise an in the nation’s history, the move against the not religious. Despite her stance, Baptist Union attack on the government over population, The Prime Minister in his first term, received such of Victoria Director of Ministries alan Marr said Age reported. Pointedly targeting her comments scant attention. The ABC’s flat-footedness on she had the respect of the church. RMIT social to marginal voters in outer suburban seats, Gillard the biggest news night of the year provides little science senior lecturer andrew scott said Gillard said ‘I don’t support the idea of a big Australia confidence that it is ready to use its forthcoming 20 4
LETTER FROM CANBERRA with arbitrary targets of, say, a 40 million-strong tough new policy agenda to deter boatpeople. about the planned processing of asylum seekers Australia or a 36 million-strong Australia. We The following day, The Age reported a United in East Timor, with some critics saying it is John need to stop, take a break and develop policies Nations report cleared the way for the Gillard Howard’s Pacific Solution with another name, for a sustainable Australia.’ tony Burke, who government to take a tougher stance on sending The Australian reported. There is hope in the was appointed Population Minister by Kevin Sri Lankan asylum seekers home, saying key Christmas Island community who that Gillard’s rudd to develop a strategy, will now be known groups in the country were no longer entitled plans to process asylum seekers offshore as the Minister for Sustainable Population. The to automatic protection. In the Financial Review, could reduce rising rents, end short-term food Government’s intergenerational report estimated geoff Kitney wrote that Gillard may have helped shortages and bring back cheap alcohol to the that on present trends Australia would have 36 the Coalition by putting asylum seekers in the tiny Australian territory. million people by 2050. spotlight. Immigration Minister chris evans stand up admitted the asylum seeker debate was ‘killing nearby Cambodian-born Victorian state Labor MP Hong the government’, in frank remarks seized on by The Government’s new population policy is to be lim wrote an email to a concerned constituent, the Opposition to claim Labor was only interested decided after community consultation but will which he copied to state Labor MPs, expressing in a political fix. focus on where people live and environmental shame over the ALP’s treatment of asylum effects. tony Burke said the debate on population the first foray into diplomacy seekers. Lim, who is a special adviser to Victorian should be refocused to where people live, instead The Age reported that Prime Minister Julia Premier John Brumby on Victoria-Asia business of the number of immigrants or total population. gillard began retreating from plans for a refugee relations, said his community and party should be The government has appointed three panels to processing centre in East Timor, amid widespread standing up for people fleeing danger, the Herald advise it on population policy. hostility to the proposal in the island nation amid Sun reported. claims that she bungled the announcement. Gillard solution does not pacify a fraction of votes and boats insisted she had never nominated a location. ‘I’m The above two items represent the first small Barrister and human rights advocate Julian not going to leave undisturbed the impression I steps towards neutralising another election issue Burnside wrote in The Age that we do not need to made an announcement about a specific location,’ causing headaches, that of illegal boat people be protected from asylum seekers: they need to she said in a radio interview. But on the ABC’s arrivals. gillard broadly invited Australians to be protected from their persecutors. We receive Lateline, East Timor’s President ramos-Horta about 240,000 migrants each year, so one year of say what they feel in the asylum seeker debate indicated clearly that Gillard had been talking asylum seekers arriving by boat is equivalent to without being constrained by self-censorship or about a centre in East Timor. Michelle grattan about one week of new migrants. political correctness, The Age reported. In the wrote that Gillard’s claim she did not announce same paper, Michelle grattan wrote that by a specific location for her proposed regional going overboard urging people to vent their views about the boats processing centre is bizarre and a political The Herald Sun reported that under a ‘get tougher’ blunder. The fallback options after East Timor are policy on boat people unveiled by opposition without worrying about political correctness, few and far between for the Gillard government, leader tony abbott, asylum seekers who dump Gillard is taking a gamble. She is sanctioning if it sticks to its criteria. The Australian reported their passports or documentation before arriving the escalation of a difficult and explosive debate that Gillard’s backtrack on the plan came after in Australia would be refused refugee status. The that turned bitter in 2001, and always has the East Timor’s Parliament formally condemned the power to rubberstamp applications will also be potential to do so again. The Australian reported idea as unworkable. removed from assessors at Christmas Island, that Pauline Hanson, who led the populist One and the Immigration Minister would be given the Her first stuff-up Nation Party to its high water mark in the 1990s, power to intervene in any case to refuse entry. Julia gillard’s asylum seeker policy ran into revealed she was in total agreement with Julia immediate resistance, with East Timor’s Deputy Where art thou, compassion? Gillard’s call to sweep political correctness from Prime Minister, Jose louis guterres, saying The Age reported that tony abbott’s promise to the debate. the proposal for his nation to house a regional bring back a version of the Pacific Solution has refugee processing centre is very unlikely to be won support from 42 per cent of Labor voters, The Herald Sun reported that pressure was accepted. while only a bare majority of them – 51 per cent – mounting on Gillard over unauthorised arrivals oppose it. In the Herald Sun, andrew Bolt asked after the 75th boat of the year was intercepted in solution doesn’t pacify where are those who mocked John Howard for early July. The Australian reported that hundreds Before it had been unanimously voted down in his tough stance on boat people? Despite more of Afghan and Sri Lankan asylum seekers are the East Timorese Parliament, unions, refugee drownings, the compassion industry is silent. likely to be sent home under Julia gillard’s advocates and the Greens voiced strong concerns E : ING SPAC T H IS A DVERTIS M .A U ESTED IN FAIRS.CO RE INTER INFO@AF IF YOU A 54 13 00 OR EMAIL 96 PHONE 03 10 UGUST 20 BY 30TH A 21 5
16 18 MARCH JUNE toto2214JUly ApRil 2010 2010 Andrew pesce to cut the 40 saidheadline per cent more rate neededof taxtoto be 30 longer Winnersthan four hours for treatment. The donecent per to (the properly fundsector resources medical saystraining, its actualThetax money, The to beReview Financial spreadreported over four the years, will Australia’s U UPP AG AG A A II N NSST T II T? T? Australian rate is morereported. like 22.5 per cent because of where only be delivered fledgeling coal-seamif gas state premiers industry agree would to benefit the Rudd’s new funding model at the Council of Need K-10new impost is applied), raise the threshold from the decision to apply the existing petroleum Need aa report report or or memo memo written written at which The the tax draft takes affect curriculum from for K-10 5 perEnglish, cent to Australian rent tax on theGovernments sector, whichmeeting on April would clear 19. the way last last week week and and havenÕt havenÕt found found the the 12 per cent, change the rules to allow miners to In for all, Rudd on progress has$50b put of a total of $3b projects over four in Queensland, mathematics, science and history is available words or time for it? reduce their taxable income and apply the new years now the of threat fundingof on thethe table, including resource a final super profits tax words or time for it? for public comment until 23 May 2010, www. tax only to a limited number of commodities – not sweetener of $650m to cut waiting has been removed. A later report in the same times for acara.edu.au. across the resources sector as envisaged by the electivefound paper surgery.that taxpayers will effectively We We provide provide aa full full prompt prompt Henry tax review, The Age reported. subsidise A some of the world’s biggest energy list of problems service in Ð we are professionals service Ð we are professionals HealtH companies Kevin Rudd fordelayed their recent the $20b-plus coal seam crucial meeting on in public public affairs affairs with with The renamed Minerals Resource Rent Tax, MRRT, gas acquisitions health reform with under concessions premiers made until April 19,bywith the Handicapped will now apply only to iron ore and coal, with the Government to win industry support international international experience. Just experience. Just In the petroleum nationallyresources televisedrenthealth debate his office insisting the change wasfornottheir duetaxto call existing tax applying to amendments. the uncertainty in the South Australian and call anytime anytime and and we we are are at at your your between tony Abbott and Kevin Rudd, oil and gas, including projects on the North-West service. Abbott had thewasequivalent Tasmanian the electionelection campaign results. The new survey in a nutshell service. Shelf. The deal welcomedofby one footminers the big in a shows that adele one fifth of voters are that prepared to plaster cast,Minerals and accordingly In The Age, ferguson wrote the new and by the Council oflost the debate, Australia – but change their vote over health, The Australian The Age’s Michelle Grattan mining tax is all about taking pressure off some WriteRight WriteRight the backdown put a $1.5b hole reported. The in the budget reported. Nearby, Opposition Leader came out worse on key marginal seats.the states Since the have new compiled deal was Contact Contact Anthony Anthony over the forward estimates. The wider business aofficially list of unveiled, more than 40 been problems withasthea substance and style. The Australian’s paul it has described 0412 community has lost half of their promised tax cut proposed hospital takeover. 0412 281 281 388 388 Kelly in orderwrote to pick Rudd up the won tab. the Great Health compromise, a backflip and a monumental cave Debate with a reminder that he is a smooth, in. It isabout What all of this? these, but most of all it is designed persuasive andreview, formidable Prime Minister to get the Premier Victorian government Johnre-elected. Brumby is promoting After the Henry the Government said the Gillard in December australia’s expressing their concerns biggest market who skates over his weaknesses company tax rate for large firms would and projects go down an alternative health Probably should have happenedplan wheresooner the states aboutFinancial The the overlyReview bureaucratic reporteddemands of the that Families as29a per to constructive leader. cent in 2013-14 Abbott (from 30 perperformed cent) and retain theirBilliton Former BHP power and to controldonand chairman argusdirect has National Minister Partnership Jenny Macklin agreements. said a priority in capably with a bad hand. The then to 28 per cent. Now the promised Opposition had tax stops hospital funding. been appointed In a the to head clear sign policy that Victoria transition group population policy must be to ensure unemployed no hospital policy and this proved a crippling at 29 per cent. The revised tax will likely effect is overfundamentally the new tax withopposed ResourcestoMinister the Federal Martin Bush scholarships laura young The people university 150,000 get the training studentstheyliving needintolimbo help defect. on a 330 Thecompanies, Financial Review’s rather than the tingle 1000+ Government’s proposed hospital ferguson. The two have been close for years takeover, and ameliorate the tonational skills shortage. She wrote originallythat the health mooted. The small debate minershashavegiven not the ArgusBrumby modelto rejects is well-known Treasurerthe notion Wayne of swan. over changes youth allowance have been Labor the chance to slow down a resurgent said the needs of the economy needed to be been included in the new tax. the Financial The Commonwealth directly that Review reported funding the Argus still given some certainty after the Government opposition. considered in future population growth plans local networks owns about $13mthat runof hospitals, worth shares in theThe Age world’s and Opposition struck a deal set to be pushed creative accounting and, in the reported. through thepast, that included Senate. Educationencouraging Minister At the The mercy Review Financial of the worm reported Treasury secretary biggest mining company, raising questions about skilled migration Julia Gillard and in areas where therecounterpart Opposition were skills The Age reported that the Opposition Leader tony whether the pen he has a conflict is mightier thanofthe interest swordas joint head Ken Henry confirmed Government assumed shortages. Thepyne Christopher Australian said reported they hadthat the besta reached Abbott has shifted towards a conciliatory Senior fellow of the GrattantaxInstitute, of the government’s resource consultation and a significant rise in commodity prices, and a student recruiters in China are switching to the Ministerto Kevin group. compromise that meant scholarship funds position change inonexport Primevolumes, claim itRudd’s would former University of Melbourne vice- US and Britain as destinations becausethe Australia hospitals policy as he tries to counter will start flowing shortly. Under deal, sacrifice only $1.5b in revenue under its dealpoll to chancellor towards and medical doctor, David his end has botchedin skilled migration andareas its universities damage students rural and regional will find adjust theapparently caused by planned resources tax.hisThenegativity Coalition pennington wrote ingrattan In The Age, Michelle The Agewrote that that the rudd state ithave a reputation easier to claimforyouthprice gouging, allowance according than the to in the on seized firstthedebate. admission At the end ofWayne to accuse March, the swan should be collaborating rather than was making tactical blunders in prosecuting hisholding veteran agent John findley. ‘All agents [in China] Prime Minister’sdeceitpersonal Government had initially proposed, but to of monumental whensupport was shown he announced the back with fight when theitpowerful comes to Rudd’s mining reforms sector ahead for of are fedtheupchanges with our current government’s attitude to be clearly rising disclosing for the first keep budget-neutral the value of revised tax without the time change after in the ailing health the election. He wassystem. giving hisThere is much opponents to serious to migration,’ the government saidfunded Findley,start-up who attended June’s scholarships months of decline. It was later reported in The be done, but the toPrime Minister criticism has taken revenue assumptions. ammunition to add the deepening of Beijingbeen have International reduced.Education Expo. China Some nationals MPsis important steps. Age that Artful new figures released by Swans showed linkage his character. In an opinion piece in the same Australia’s biggest market.’ were understood to be unhappy that the deal that In an address to the in 2013-2014, the second ADC Citiesyear ofSummit the tax,init paper, Episodeformer 1 Treasurer Peter costello wrote still left students in country areas worse off is expected to raise only $6.5b Melbourne, Kevin Rudd linked his health – compared with that the Treasury chief should chairman never have Gary been Productivity Commission resources than the current rules, The Age reported. $13b inpackage reform its initialtoform. Over the Australia’s first economic future two years, asked to decide tax policy options. Banks told a conference in New Zealand that the expectedarguing prosperity, take would shrink175,000 an extra from $18bpeopleunder the train Open them mines and minds Howlack of a nationally he messed up consistent approach Speaking on the ABC Insiders program, John the old version to $10.5b under could be in the workforce in 20 years if the new. to Julia gillard extended a conciliatory hand to Kevin rudd’s attempts to hospital measuring the cost of make theepisodes mining Roskam, the mininghead of theinInstitute industry of Public her first day inAffairs, office, chronic diseases democracy rules are effectively tackled, The meant a huge amount of industry a budget cash cow have workchallenged needed said the national withdrawing thecurriculum governmentwill only be okay advertising Australian The reported. Coalition has pledged to oppose the tax, so to be done investment international before Rudd’s plan incould confidence be Australia, ifcampaign more teachers on theare trained. mining tax and requesting its fate could Making rest out the stick withofthe Greens party, which carrot implemented, The Australian Financial reported. Review reported. BHP Billiton chairman that the mining industry do so in a gesture of couldGovernment The hold the balance of power in$632m has committed the Senate over Jac nasser said the proposed tax has driven a Shonky foundations Before the worm turned good faith. The Minerals Council of Australia from mid-2011. distinct changeLeader in attitudes Colleges assessed to be at the greatest risk four years to train thousands more doctors, Opposition tonytowards Abbott Australia has agreed to suspend its advertising, with its chief askick it throws from all typesPrime of investors across all industries. of collapse would have to pay higher levies executive Mitch Hooke saying he was optimistic a in the out gutscarrots to woo the states to challenged Minister Kevin Rudd to under a proposed overhaul of Australia’s backAge The its reported hospital that reformthe package. inclusion of Victoria iron-oreis immediately it improved announced 3,500 extra beds for about negotiating with the new Prime Minister, still holding out for more incentives, amid $17b international education sector, The Age in the MRRT along with coal, while every other Australia’s The public hospitals, Age reported that three The Age industry’s of the reported. The Age reported. The Australian reported that warnings reported. Gillard moved swiftly to bury Labor’s damaging commodityfrom sits doctors outside, that is a the kickstate in thestands to guts for biggest gorillas Not good economics – BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto and lose much more form the deal than previously the iron ore producers/developers sitting outside Xstrata – initially issued a joint press release inadequacies brawl with the mining industry by signalling More than a quarter of Australia’s hospitals Medical fundamentalstudents elementsareof emerging its proposedfromnew the tax the proposedHarry estimated. Hemley, BHP-Rio Victorian production president combination in bagging could go thebrokelevel underof government Kevin Rudd’s negotiation activity- nation’s were up foruniversities feelingin Canada negotiation. Swan, inadequately at the the Pilbara. Fortescue chief andrew forestsays of the Australian Medical Association, said over the proposed tax. The Financial based funding model, according to research Review Premier ‘It’s John Brumbythat very disappointing should right demand at the time$1.5b that reported that they dismissed Rudd’s claim prepared G20 summit,toalso dealseemed with more crucial tasks such flexible. for a new hospital or other infrastructure commissioned by the New South Wales as calculating safe drug doses and writing junior and smaller Australian iron ore and coal of being engaged in detailed Government. The research, by University negotiations on she did it upgrades miners havebefore managed agreeing to developto the plan, The a foothold into resource taxation, declaring prescriptions, according to Education Age reported. More incentives are on with the of Wollongong academicthere was no Kathy sign Eagar, After three days of negotiations, Julia gillard had the industry, they are immediately slugged the Government was ofaddressing Department commissioned research. way, including $500m towards ensuring suggests hundreds hospitals the industry’s across rural reached a watered-down compromise deal on a proposed new and additional tax’. STOP PRESS. fundamental concerns. The Australian reported Australian Medical Association president emergency and regional Australia that have 10 or fewer the resources super-profits tax with the mining Junior miners department may yet fight topatients wait deal seek a better no that bedstheand Big Three were originally unpredictable invited towould workloads make industry. In the new deal, the Government agreed from the mining tax negotiation. 66 18
LETTER FROM CANBERRA individual representations to Swan and Ferguson. seriously enough in its bid to get the health nearby But they refused. Instead they insisted on a joint identifier legislation through Parliament. The Australian of the Year Patrick Mcgorry has called session with Rudd’s representatives. health identity card is different from e-health upon new Prime Minister Julia gillard to urgently records which are between the patient and others reform Australia’s beleaguered mental health it’s over now government and commercial agencies. This is not sector, warning the crisis could cost Labor votes The Australian reported that Communications patient-controlled. at the looming election. McGorry said Gillard Electrical and Plumbing Union national secretary must commit more funds to the sector and begin Peter tighe, an ACTU executive member, said cross-over benefits a root and branch reform of the system which is some workers were getting concerned about their Before Kevin rudd became an ex-prime minister, failing hundreds of Australian families, The Age job security in the debate over the resources rent he said the requirement to roll out electronic reported. tax because the government had not adequately health and medical records will benefit from rebutted the mining industry’s campaign. South the $11b deal with Telstra to buy access to also, nearby Australian speaker and Labor MP lyn Breuer the carrier’s infrastructure under the National The Age reported that a nine-month government travelled to Canberra to tell Kevin rudd the Broadband Network. Rudd said the future of a inquiry into suicide prevention would be wasted mining tax will kill off the steel-making town of patient controlled electronic health record was unless more was spent on mental health, Suicide Whyalla, The Australian reported. essential to the Government’s wider agenda for Prevention Australia chairman Michael dudley health reforms. said. He said the Senate inquiry report, The spooky Hidden Toll: Suicide in Australia, had forged new Australian Foundation Investment Company the missing e-link ground in recommending a five-year advertising (Australia’s largest listed fund manager) chairman The national president of the Pharmaceutical campaign to de-stigmatise suicide, mandatory Bruce teele was damning in his assessment of Society of Australia, Warwick Plunkett, said training for police, paramedics and emergency the planned resource tax, saying that investors that e-health was the missing link in enabling department staff and the improvement of data had been spooked by the lack of consultation, genuine collaborative primary health care collection, but the government was refusing to The Age reported. teams to work effectively and improve the well- take the issue seriously. being of all Australians. In his budget response, Vale tony abbott turned his back on the Coalition’s forget-me-nots Former BHP iron ore chief executive geoff decade-old commitment to e-health records sophie Pieters-Hawke, the 25-year-old Wedlock and Queensland mining magnate Ken and suggested the money would be wasted and granddaughter of Bob and Hazel Hawke, and talbot were among six Australians confirmed should be retained by the government. ‘Clearly three of her friends, all in their 20s, launched an dead after their light plane crashed in West Africa. the opposition needs to rethink its strategy on the initiative called the Forget-Me-Not project, which The other executives killed were Sundance issue,’ Plunkett said. aims to raise money and awareness of the impact Resources chief executive don lewis, non- of dementia on young people. Hazel, who was executive director craig Oliver, non-executive Predominantly built married to former Prime Minister Bob Hawke for director John Jones and Talbot Group executive The Financial Review reported that the head nearly 40 years until they divorced in 1995, was natasha flason Brian, The Age reported. of the National E-Health Transition Authority, diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease in 2001. Peter fleming, says the Government’s national healthcare identifiers regime is on course to another funding crisis HealtH launch on time, and the NEHTA will soon begin The aged care industry council, the peak council identifying solutions discussions with industry about the technology of Australia’s aged care providers, which includes The Financial Review reported that under the architecture needed to underpin electronic the Aged Care Association of Australia and Aged Health Care Identifiers Bill 2010, new laws are health records. After welcoming the injection of & Community Services Australia, published an being considered that would change the existing $466.7m for e-health in the budget, Fleming said open letter to then Prime Minister Kevin rudd Medicare Act to allow the creation of unique the system behind the introduction of a 16-digit in The Australian newspaper saying that older health identifier numbers, intended to form the unique healthcare identifier was predominantly Australians, the people who made this country cornerstone of patient controlled electronic health built. great, are being let down by the Government’s and medical records that could be transferred failure to address the funding crisis in aged and Mental health hole between clinicians and care providers. While most community care. The Government’s top mental health adviser has large businesses and government organisations resigned. The chairman of the National Advisory the discriminators have had electronic customer records for nearly Council on Mental Health, John Mendoza The Presbyterian Church of Victoria is calling 20 years, similar progress in health has been accusing the government of failing the mentally for paid parental leave schemes to be scrapped, frustrated by the fragmented and complex nature ill with their lack of vision and commitment to saying the Federal Government and Opposition of the sector. Health Minister nicola roxon hopes a problem that affects millions of Australians. schemes discriminate against stay-at-home legislation that will be passed by July 1 (see Most of his council colleagues say they share his mothers. They say the government should provide below) will allow her department to start issuing despair that the Government’s multibillion-dollar a single payment or tax rebate directly to mothers, the new identifier numbers. focus on hospitals is likely to leave crucial mental regardless of their employment status, the Herald health services under-funded. In the May Budget, Sun reported. The Age reported that National Party The Australian reported that patients will have to the government committed to $7.2b to health – MPs will not campaign for tony abbott’s paid wait at least two years before they can access $175m of which was marked as new funding for parental leave scheme at the election, saying it their medical records on line, according to mental health. Professor Mendoza said there was is geared toward city voters and damages the Roxon. Initially, only Medicare would operate a no evidence of any new investment in mental opposition’s economic credibility. secure website portal that would allow patients health, The Age reported. The Australian reported to retrieve their personally controlled electronic answer to our woes? that tony abbott ignited the unofficial election health records. Regulations must be drafted that The Financial Review is holding a national Health campaign by targeting Labor’s policy weak point will allow health care providers to access the conference 2010, on 17 August, that looks at the of mental health with a $1.5b spending package, health-care identification service. question ‘Will e-health be the cure to the woes of including 800 hospital beds. The Opposition Nearby, the chief executive of the Public Interest our ailing health system?’, www.afr.com/events. Leader promised to fund new mental health Advocacy Centre, robin Banks, has accused the treatment facilities, including 60 to serve young Government of making the same mistakes as people. its predecessor, failing to take privacy concerns 19 7
18 JUNE to 22 JUly 2010 an IT technician from Hobart, became the first customer connected to the national broadband network. His service with Internet provider Internode started about 5pm on July 1, giving him connection speeds more than 30 times faster than before. ‘It’s awesome,’ he said. ‘It’s a major speed increase.’ round two The Australian reported but the government has revealed the locations of the second-round of BroadBand. it. innovation Broad minded The Financial Review reported that AAPT communities in the mainland National Broadband Network rollout. The network will be expanded drum roll please… chief executive Paul Broad felt that Telstra’s into 19 new fibre service areas. Telstra will hand over millions of customers rivals should be allowed to access the former to the Government’s new national broadband monopoly’s infrastructure at the same price as nBn contractors network and close its ageing copper and cable the National Broadband Network if they wish to The Australian reported that NBN Co is a while networks (instead sharing its infrastructure lay competing fibre networks. Broad believes the away from issuing request for tenders to satellite with NBN Co and migrating fixed line customers Government’s non-binding $11b deal with Telstra network operators hoping to get a slice of the to the government’s new fibre network) in an has exposed a weakness in the government’s $43b project. The company has reduced its $11b deal that will fundamentally reshape the competition policy for the sector. satellite shortlist to six or seven operators since communications industry, The Age reported. It issuing requests for capability statements in furthermore January. More than 10 international and domestic will abandon its traditional core business of fixed The Age reported that Telstra, no longer obliged satellite operators pitched their credentials, line communications networks. The deal is a to provide every house with a telephone service, but only a handful were considered serious breakthrough for the $43b national broadband can focus on content delivery and developing contenders. It is understood Optus, Intelsat and network, as it will allow the new services to be new technology, and is already positioned to be a Hughes Network Systems are among the few rolled out faster and more cheaply. winner in a national broadband environment, say named on the shortlist. The provision of satellite industry analysts. The Financial Review reported services in the NBN build – along with wireless Telstra will be a participant in the rollout of the that Telstra chief executive david thodey has technologies – is needed to supply 10 per cent national broadband network. Telstra chairman promised an aggressive expansion in wireless of the nation with 12 megabits per second catherine livingstone said the proposed services after settling the company’s row with broadband connections. The other 90 per cent transaction would deliver payments and financial Canberra, as investors welcomed the imminent of the population will be serviced by a fibre-to- savings to the telco over coming years with a removal of government curbs on the company’s the-home network capable of delivering internet net present value of $11b after tax. Livingstone growth. connection speeds of 100Mbps. emphasised the heads of that agreement needed to be followed by finalisation of detailed and nearby binding agreements, which, in turn, would need In mid-June, The Age reported that the An Australian owned satellite operator has shareholder approval before they could be government appears no closer to getting its condemned the NBN Co for the way it has implemented. The regulatory certainty and high way on a bill to split Telstra, despite listing the conducted the tender process for providing prices are expected to significantly boost Telstra’s legislation for debate in the Senate. The Greens internet services in rural areas. In a letter share price, and could underwrite the company’s have already pledged in principle support for the addressed to major stakeholders, NewSat chief high dividend for several years, according to bill, which pressures Telstra to split its wholesale executive adrian Ballintine said the company one analyst. In a more detailed analysis of the and retail operations as well as strengthening had been shafted without proper consideration deal, The Australian reported that Telstra will the competition watchdog’s powers and limiting or fair notice. NewSat submitted a response to be paid $9b to transfer its voice and broadband payphone removal. Even with the Greens’ votes the NBN Co’s request for a capability statement customers from its copper and cable networks to and the probable support of South Australian regarding the supply of satellite network and NBN Co’s network as it is rolled out. independent nick Xenophon, the Government services, but it was rejected in a two-line e-mail will still need one additional vote, likely to come that simply thanked NewSat for its submission, The Government will grant Telstra a number of from Senator steve fielding. The Australian reported. The Age reported a total regulatory concessions worth about $2b as it of 45 groups responded to NBN Co’s call in March a win for the south takes over Telstra’s universal service obligations for expressions of interest in the construction The Age reported that Melbourne has been through the creation of a new entity – USO Co. project; 21 of them have been selected to make selected as the operations base of the national Telstra also received a written guarantee that a formal bid. broadband network, injecting millions of dollars they would not be barred from bidding for new into the state’s economy. The national operations rocca on wireless spectrum (see below) needed to evolve and test facility will employ 425 professional The Australian reported that Telstra is positioning its mobile broadband business. and technical staff. It comes in addition to the itself to cash in on the growth of internet data approval company’s engineering operations group in services, such as on demand video, by building Telstra shares rose to a four-month high as Elizabeth Street, expected to employ another 290 $14m worth of new network and media centres. investors backed the group’s historical $11b deal people. The new facility will be used by NBN Co They would serve as small data centres in the to participate in the national broadband network. to monitor and manage its national operations, telcos telephone exchanges, where they would Telstra’s stock opened at a year high of $3.44, up including assessing activated services, detecting be used to deliver online content in a more 21c or 6 per cent, before giving some ground to faults and carrying out tests for service providers. cost-effective and efficient manner, Telstra chief close up 3.4 per cent, in mid-June, The Australian The decision is a major victory for the Victorian operations officer Michael rocca said. It will reported. Future Fund chairman david Murray – government. By the end of July, the network’s allow Telstra to bring infrastructure closer to a major Telstra shareholder – says he is carefully first customers, in three small Tasmanian their customers, improve quality and reduce the evaluating the deal. communities, will be connected. At the beginning transmission costs of data across the network. of July, The Age reported that robert Pettman, Telstra has earmarked 12 points on its Next IP 16 8
You can also read