VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...

Page created by Dave Greene
 
CONTINUE READING
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
vector                              POINTING TO SAFER AVIATION
November/December 2013

                         Taking Off in a Microlight
                         Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights
                         Summer Flying
                         VFR Transit Lanes – Avoid the Traps
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
In this issue...
                                                                                                                                               Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights                                   3
                                                                        Adventure Flights are
                                                                                                                                               Taking Off in a Microlight                                                4
                                                                        not Trial Flights
                                                                        Some operators are conducting                                          Summer Flying                                                             8

                                                         3
                                                                        adventure aviation operations without a
                                                                        Part 115 certificate. We explain why                                   SIGMET Changes                                                        10
                                                                        calling them a ‘trial flight’ is not an
                                                                        option and encourage certification.                                    Help Shape New Zealand’s Airspace
                                                                                                                                               and Air Navigation System                                             10

                                                                                                                                               SIDs for ‘Re-start’ Cessnas                                           11
                                                                        Taking Off in a Microlight
                                                                                                                                               Airspace Review Plan                                                  12
                                                                        Flying microlight aircraft has become

                                                        4
                                                                        a popular form of recreational flying                                  VFR Transit Lanes – Avoid the Traps                                   14
                                                                        in New Zealand. We explain the
                                                                        requirements to fly, own, and
                                                                        maintain these aircraft.
                                                                                                                                               Keep Out of Restricted Areas                                          17

                                                                                                                                               Low-g Effects – A New Perspective                                     18

                                                                                                                                               New CAA General Managers                                              22
                                                                        Summer Flying
                                                                                                                                               Group Established to Discuss
                                                                        Summer is back with us after a                                         Medical Certification System                                          23
                                                                        particularly vigorous winter, and brings

                                                        8
                                                                        its own set of challenges. For pilots and
                                                                        aircraft that have hibernated through the
                                                                                                                                               How to Get Aviation Publications                                      23
                                                                        winter, we offer some considerations, as
                                                                        well as repeating some summer                                          Planning an Aviation Event?                                           23
                                                                        reminders for all aviators.
                                                                                                                                               Aviation Safety Advisers                                              23

                                                                                                                                               Accident Briefs                                                       24
                                                                        VFR Transit Lanes
                                                                        – Avoid the Traps                                                      GA Defects                                                            26

                                                                        VFR transit lanes make your job as a pilot                             Summer Traffic Busy Spots                                             28

                                                   14
                                                                        easier, but don’t let that make you
                                                                        complacent. We identify some transit lane
                                                                        related incidents and provide advice from
                                                                        CAA and industry experts.

    Cover: This type of microlight aircraft is based on developments of the hang glider wing. As a group these are referred
    to as ‘trikes’ (this is an overseas photo so registration letters are not visible). See “Taking Off in a Microlight”, page 4.
    Cover photo: ©istock.com/sierrarat

    Published by                                        Publication Content                                    Free Distribution                                   Change of Address
    Safety Promotion Unit of the Civil Aviation         Unless expressly stated as CAA policy,                 Vector is distributed automatically to all          Readers receiving Vector free of charge
    Authority of New Zealand, PO Box 3555,              the views expressed in Vector do not                   New Zealand flight crew, air traffic controllers,   should notify info@caa.govt.nz of any change
    Wellington 6140.                                    necessarily reflect the policy of the Civil Aviation   aircraft maintenance engineer licence holders,      of address, quoting your CAA Client Number.
    Tel: +64 4 560 9400,                                Authority. Articles are intended to stimulate          aircraft owners, most organisations holding         Paying subscribers should notify Vertia.
    Fax: +64 4 569 2024,                                discussion, and nothing in Vector is to be taken       an aviation document, and to certain other
    Email: info@caa.govt.nz.                            as overriding any New Zealand civil aviation           persons and organisations interested in             Paid Subscriptions
                                                        legislation, or any statements issued by the           promoting safer aviation.                           Vector is available on subscription only from
    Published six times a year, in the last week        Director of Civil Aviation, or the Civil Aviation                                                          Vertia, www.vertia.co.nz, email: info@vertia.co.nz,
    of every odd month.                                 Authority of New Zealand.                              In the case of flight crew and air traffic
                                                                                                                                                                   or freephone 0800 GET RULES (0800 438 785).
                                                                                                               controllers, a current aviation medical
    Manager Safety Promotion Bill Sommer.               Reader comments and contributions are                  certificate must be held, and a current             Copyright
                                                        welcome and may be published, but the Editor
    Editor Peter Singleton.                                                                                    New Zealand address given, to ensure                Reproduction in whole or in part of any item in
                                                        reserves the right to edit or abridge them,
                                                                                                               magazine entitlement.                               Vector, other than material shown to be from
    The Vector Team                                     and not to publish those that are judged not to
                                                        contribute constructively towards safer aviation.      Holders of Pilot Certificates issued by             other sources or named authors, is freely
    Charlie Brimmicombe, Alister Buckingham,
                                                        Reader contributions and correspondence                Part 149 certificated organisations can also        permitted, providing that it is intended solely
    Lakshmi Guda, Mark Houston, Rose Wood.
                                                        regarding the content of Vector should be              apply to receive a free Vector (see the CAA         for the purpose of promoting safer aviation,
    Design Gusto.                                       addressed to: Vector Editor, PO Box 3555,              web site for details). Vector also appears on       and providing that acknowledgment is given
                                                        Wellington 6140, or email: info@caa.govt.nz.           the CAA’s web site: www.caa.govt.nz.                to Vector.

2                         vector       November/December 2013                                                                                                                                ISSN 1173-9614
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
Adventure Flights
    are not Trial Flights
    A so-called trial flight, or flight instruction, should not be used as a
    backdoor method for conducting commercial activities such as adventure
    or scenic flights without certification.

    I
        n fact, there is no provision in the Civil Aviation Rules for           (3) an A to A flight in a Class 2 microlight aircraft:
        “trial flights” in the adventure aviation context. However,
        the CAA is receiving reports of operators charging for                  (4) a flight in a hot air balloon:

    adventure aviation style activities under the guise of trial flights.       (5) a flight in a glider:

    An adventure aviation operation involves carrying passengers                (6) a parachute-drop aircraft operation that is not
    for hire or reward, where the purpose of the operation is for                   conducted under the authority of an air operator
    the “passenger’s recreational experience of participating in the                certificate issued by the Director under the Act and
    flight, or engaging in the aerial operation”.                                   Part 119:

    This is defined in Part 1:                                                  (7) a tandem parachute descent operation:

         Adventure aviation operation means the following                       (8) a tandem hang glider or paraglider flight.
         operations for the carriage of passengers by air for hire or
                                                                            To carry out these activities for hire or reward requires
         reward where the object of the operation is for the
                                                                            certification under Part 115.
         passenger’s recreational experience of participating in the
         flight, or engaging in the aerial operation—                       Certification requires a number of measures to ensure the
                                                                            standard of safety that the paying public demands.
          (1) an A to A flight in an aeroplane or helicopter issued
              with a standard category airworthiness certificate            Some operators have argued that the person being carried on
              conducting formation flight, aerobatic manoeuvres,            such flights is a “crew member” as defined in Part 1. For this
              and similar non-standard flight manoeuvres such as
                                                                            to apply, the sole purpose of the flight must be for instruction,
              steep climbs, steep descents, and steep turns:
                                                                            and not for “recreational experience”.
          (2) an A to A flight (including an interim water landing for
              amphibious aircraft) in an aircraft issued with an            It isn’t too difficult to become certificated, and there are many
              appropriate special category - primary, special               benefits for a business through developing their exposition and
              category - LSA, or special category - limited                 putting quality control procedures in place.
              airworthiness certificate including formation flight,
              aerobatic manoeuvres, and similar non-standard                There is information on the CAA web site to help you,
              flight manoeuvres such as steep climbs, steep                 www.caa.govt.nz, “Adventure Aviation”. This includes the
               descents, and steep turns:                                   forms and an Advisory Circular (AC115-01).

Photos: ©istock.com/Elemental Imaging, Peter Masson, Scotto72

                                                                                                       vector   November/December 2013          3
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
Taking Off
                                 in a Microlight
                                 Flying a microlight can be great fun, and for many it’s an affordable means
                                 of getting into flying. There are some rule requirements covering pilot
                                 certification and airworthiness, so here’s an introduction to taking off
                                 in a microlight.

                                 T
                                       here has been rapid growth in the number of                Microlight Organisations
                                       microlight registrations over the last 10 years
                                                                                                  Microlight organisations are able to issue pilot certificates
                                       as the graph on the next page shows.
                                                                                                  and carry out certain airworthiness functions under
                                 The range of aircraft covered by the microlight category         delegations from the Director of Civil Aviation.
                                 includes aeroplanes, powered parachutes, autogyros, and          This is enabled by certificating them under Part 149 of the
                                 small helicopters.                                               Civil Aviation Rules.

                                 There is a great variety within the aeroplane category alone,    Once certificated, they are audited regularly to make sure
                                                                                                  safety standards are maintained.
                                 from the early wire-braced types costing a few thousand
                                 dollars, to modern composite types costing well over             To become certificated, they must submit an Exposition or
                                                                                                  Operations Manual. This gives details of pilot certificate
                                 $100,000.
                                                                                                  classes and requirements, and microlight airworthiness
                                 The factor that makes it affordable, regardless of which         requirements.
                                 aircraft you fly, is that the administration is carried out by   The main source of detailed information is the manual of the
                                 organisations of enthusiasts.                                    organisation you decide to join.

                                                                                                                     Sportcruiser
                                                                                                                     This Sportcruiser is an example of the top end of the range
Photo courtesy of Gavin Conroy

                                                                                                                     of microlight aircraft. It can cruise at 115 knots and has a
                                                                                                                     range of 1000 km.

                                                                                                                     Powered parachutes
                                                                                                                     (see next page)
                                                                                                                     Powered parachutes come under the microlight category.
                                                                                                                     This is an overseas photo so the registration is not visible.
                                                                                                                     There are also powered paragliders but they do not come
                                                                                                                     into the microlight category – they are administered by the
                                                                                                                     New Zealand Hang Gliding and Paragliding Association.
         4                                vector   November/December 2013
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
Microlight numbers from 2003 to 2013
 (on 1st January each year)

 1200

 1000
                                                                                                                              Class 1
  800
                                                                                                                              Class 2
  600
                                                                                                                              Total
  400

  200

    0
          2003     2004     2005     2006     2007     2008        2009    2010      2011     2012       2013

There are currently three microlight organisations:                  microlight organisation about this as you may need a check
»» Recreational Aircraft Association of New Zealand Inc,             flight with a microlight instructor.
   www.raanz.org.nz,                                                 There are type ratings for various aircraft, and a requirement for
»» Sport Aviation Corp. Ltd, www.sportflying.co.nz, and              a Biennial Flight Review (BFR), just as for ‘conventional’ aircraft.

»» Royal New Zealand Aero Club Inc. (also known as
   Flying NZ), www.flyingnz.co.nz.
                                                                     Operations and Limitations
                                                                     As mentioned before, Part 91 is critical to flight operations.
It is important to remember that the Civil Aviation Rules apply,
as for any aircraft. Of particular importance is Part 91 General     Microlight flying has many freedoms in New Zealand, but
Operating and Flight Rules.                                          with these privileges there are also some limitations in the
                                                                     interest of safety.
Part 103 Microlight Aircraft – Operating Rules has some
exemptions from the other rules.                                     You can fly microlights only under Visual Flight Rules (VFR)
                                                                     and during daytime.
Gaining Your Pilot Certificate                                       You cannot fly microlights over a congested area.
You don’t need to own a microlight to fly one, as many               You also cannot fly them in controlled airspace, or within 5.5
organisations have their own aircraft for members to fly.            km of a certificated aerodrome, unless you have passed the
Contact one of the organisations above to start your flight          air law examination, or are under the direct supervision of the
training. They have branches around the country.                     holder of a microlight instructor certificate.

At the outset, you need to be considered fit and proper to           The air law exam refers to the Part 61 exam, or your organisation
hold an aviation document. This is a requirement of the Civil        may have an air law exam approved by the Director.
Aviation Act 1990. The organisation will assess this under
their delegation from the Director.
                                                                                                                       Continued over   »
There are exams to take in:
»» Aviation Law and Publications,
»» Air Navigation and Flight Planning,
»» Aviation Meteorology,
»» Aeroplane Technical Knowledge, and
»» Flight Radio Telephone Operator Certificate.
You will also require a medical certificate issued by your
organisation. Your GP can carry out the examination using a
                                                                                                                                            Photo ©istock.com/ jkbowers

form issued by the organisation.
Microlight certificates are issued as your training progresses.
You will start with a Novice certificate, then Intermediate, and
Advanced. There is a separate Instructor Certificate.
If you currently hold a Part 61 licence, you can also fly a
microlight providing some conditions are met. Consult a

                                                                                                vector   November/December 2013                                           5
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
You can do Flight Training
    You can use a Class 2 microlight for flight training if you have
    the relevant type rating for the aircraft and hold a microlight
    instructor certificate.
    If you hold a Part 61 Instructor Rating and wish to do flight
    training using a microlight, you should have a type rating and
    demonstrate your competence to a microlight instructor.

    Adventure Aviation Operations
    You can use Class 2 microlights in adventure aviation

                                                                                                                                                   Photo ©iStock\Dr-Strangelove
    operations for hire or reward, only if your operation has been
    certificated under Part 115 Adventure Aviation – Certification
    and Operation.
                                                                         Typical Microlight
    Aircraft Requirements                                                This Quicksilver is typical of the early decades of the hobby in
                                                                         New Zealand. It is open-air, wire-braced, and cruises at around
    The definition of a microlight is in Part 1 and is “a basic low      50 knots. This is an overseas photo so the registration is not visible.
    performance aircraft designed to carry not more than two
    persons which meets low momentum parameters that are
    acceptable to the Director”.                                       Buyer Beware
    The parameters that are acceptable to the Director                 These days, many microlight aircraft are advertised for sale
    are in Advisory Circular AC103-1 Microlight Aircraft –             on web sites. If you are new to flying and microlights, it would
    Operating Rules.
                                                                       be best to seek advice before making a purchase.
    A single-place microlight is called a Class 1 and a two-
    place, Class 2.                                                    There are a number of requirements to be met before you
                                                                       take to the skies in your dream machine. If these are not in
    In brief, an aircraft defined as a microlight by some other
                                                                       place, you will incur extra expense and delay.
    States qualifies as a microlight in New Zealand.
    Or some weight and stall speed specifications need to be met.      There is also a process to follow when buying and selling
    For a two-place land aeroplane, for example, it must not exceed    an aircraft. There is guidance for this on the CAA web site,
    600 kg and must have a stall speed no greater than 45 knots.       www.caa.govt.nz, “Aircraft – Change of Possession”.

6            vector   November/December 2013
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
You could also import a new aircraft. For Class 2 microlights,              issued by the Director. A basic microlight will not have many
    you will need to know if the type is accepted in New                        to check, but if you own one of the more sophisticated
    Zealand. If it is a first of type, you will need to provide                 aircraft, you may need to check several AD Schedules.
    evidence that it is acceptable as a microlight here.
                                                                                There is a specific schedule called “Microlight”. A large
    If you plan to import, it is best to contact the CAA for                    percentage of microlights use Rotax engines, and they
    advice early in the process, email info@caa.govt.nz.                        have their own Schedule. Others to consider are
    Another option is to build your own microlight. In this case,               Components (this may cover electronic equipment, etc),
    you should follow the advice above. It would also be                        Engines, and Propellers.
    beneficial to contact the Sport Aircraft Association of New
                                                                                You can seek advice from an aircraft maintenance engineer or
    Zealand. This organisation is based around people who
                                                                                a Part 149 Inspection Authority (IA). The Part 149 IA
    build their own aircraft. They will be able to provide advice
    and may offer mentoring from experienced builders.                          is authorized by the Director through your microlight
                                                                                organisation.
    All microlight aircraft must be registered with the CAA
    and display the registration letters. If you are buying a                   All Class 2 microlights and all microlight helicopters require a
    new aircraft, allow for the cost of initial registration in                 Flight Permit. This is originally issued after an inspection by a
    your budget.                                                                CAA surveyor, and is non-terminating.
    If you are buying an existing aircraft in New Zealand, make                 The Flight Permit must be re-validated every year. The
    sure the registration fee is paid up to date, otherwise the                 inspection for this can be carried out by a microlight inspector
    aircraft could be de-registered.                                            approved by one of the Part 149 organisations.

    Continuing Airworthiness                                                    More Information
    The aircraft owner             or   operator      is   responsible    for   All Rules, Advisory Circulars, and Forms are available on the
    airworthiness.                                                              CAA web site, www.caa.govt.nz. Also see the “Sport and
    Part 103 requires you to maintain your aircraft in an airworthy             Recreation” section.
    condition (this is defined in Part 1).
                                                                                The Aircraft Operator Requirements poster gives
    The aircraft should have logbooks for the: aircraft, engine,                information on the pilot, operations, and maintenance
    propeller, and Airworthiness Directives.                                    requirements for different types of aircraft. For a free copy,
    Airworthiness Directives (ADs) are mandatory requirements                   email: info@caa.govt.nz.

Autogyro
Autogyro aircraft (also known as gyroplanes or gyrocopters) have been
around since the 1920s, but the development of powerful and lightweight
engines has led to growth in numbers of this type.

Photo courtesy of John Milburn

                                                                                                          vector   November/December 2013           7
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
Summer Flying
    After a winter that was particularly vigorous in many parts
    of the country, summer has returned, bringing a different
    set of challenges and considerations for aviators.

    Seasonal Pilots                               »» Other wildlife may have decided on a        Remember though, that the summer
                                                     new home as well. Rats and mice are         weather will draw out many other
    Seasonal pilots, or fair-weather flyers,
                                                     also occasional tenants in idle aircraft,   aviators,    in    all    conceivable
    whatever you like to call them. These
                                                     and may do considerable damage to           contraptions. Take particular note of
    are the pilots who have given flying
                                                     wiring, hoses, and upholstery, in           chart symbols for hang gliders,
    away for the winter, and are now ready
                                                     addition to building nests in hard-to-      gliders, and model aircraft, although
    to get back into it again. After a long
                                                     reach places.                               these can all be encountered in
    break, a certain degree of skill and
                                                  »» Possums also can adopt aircraft, and        unmarked locations as well.
    knowledge ‘rustiness’ is very likely.
                                                     one helicopter pilot recalls being          Be alert for traffic at all times,
    Some things for these pilots to
                                                     startled on startup when a possum           particularly in the vicinity of parachute
    consider are:
                                                     appeared      from    the    engine         landing areas (PLAs). Not only will
    »» The currency of your pilot medical,           compartment and scrambled over the          there be more intense activity, it may
       pilot licence or certificate, and flight      top of the canopy.                          go on for longer with the extended
       publications (including charts, and in                                                    daylight hours.
                                                  All of these considerations point up
       some cases, the GPS database).
                                                  the need for a diligent preflight              If flying during the evening hours, do
    »» When you last flew, and how you plan       inspection before the first flight of the      be aware of the cumulative effects of
       to get current again. A dual check is      season. That minor oil leak may have           fatigue if you have been working at
       always a good idea if you haven’t          added up to a substantial loss, and the        your regular job during the day.
       flown for a while.                         fuel will need a thorough check for
    »» The due date of your next biennial         water and other contaminants. Top it           Warm Temperature
       flight review.                             up with fresh fuel in case it has gone
                                                                                                 Warm temperature is one of the
                                                  ‘stale’. Not a bad idea too, to check
    »» The I’M SAFE checklist (available on                                                      reasons we like summer, but if not
                                                  the maintenance status of the aircraft
       the CAA web site or on request from                                                       properly managed, heat can be very
                                                  (and any emergency equipment), as
       info@caa.govt.nz).                                                                        debilitating.   Some     cockpits    are
                                                  some components may be due for
                                                                                                 notorious hothouses, so adequate
                                                  calendar-time inspections, rather than
    And Aircraft                                  in-service time. Better to think about
                                                                                                 ventilation and hydration are important.
    If your aircraft has been in hibernation      these aspects while the aircraft is            A useful article on hydration, “Need a
    for the winter, think about:                  idle, rather than having to make short-        Drink?”, can be found in the
                                                  notice arrangements.                           November/December 2005 issue of
    »» Accumulated dust, dirt and guano.
                                                                                                 Vector, available on the CAA web
    »» Tyres losing pressure and the battery                                                     site under “Publications”.
       losing its charge over time. Also, the
                                                  Planning for Flight
                                                  Still a trap for even experienced pilots       Warmth helps the grass grow, and
       tyres may have developed flat spots.
                                                  is the conversion from NZDT to UTC.            what was short grass at a strip last
       These will ‘iron out’ with use, even
                                                  Double-check your flight planning to           week may well be a hazard this week.
       though the initial bump-bump-bump
                                                  make sure you haven’t converted the            Braking action and takeoff roll can be
       might be a little disconcerting if you
                                                  time wrongly; a simple error could             adversely affected by long grass, and
       don’t know what’s causing it.
                                                  have your day VFR flight arriving at           if the grass has gone to seed, be
    »» The aircraft may have been home to a                                                      aware that grass seeds can find their
                                                  your destination after dark.
       family of birds, particularly starlings.                                                  way just about anywhere, even into
       These skilful nest-builders can fill any   Refer to the “Summer Traffic Busy              carburettors.
       open orifice on the aircraft with their    Spots” reminder on the back cover of
                                                  this issue, as well as NOTAMs and              Extended hot weather may turn grass
       nesting materials in very short order.
                                                  AIP Supplements, for information on            brown, and at some affected
       Even though the young may have
                                                  events with likely high concentrations         aerodromes, the boundaries of the
       flown the nest, the nests themselves
                                                  of aircraft activity.                          usable runways or vectors may be
       will need removing.
                                                                                                 hard to distinguish at first glance.

8            vector   November/December 2013
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
Photo ©iStock/cdwheatley
A   quick     refresher on    aircraft      Aerodromes near the coast are          beneath fair-weather cumulus, and
performance may be in order – refer         often affected by sea breezes on       the ride can get a little rough.
to the GAP booklets Takeoff and             warm days, which can result in         For your own and your passengers’
Landing Performance and Helicopter          crosswinds in many cases. This is      comfort, flying above the cloud level
Performance for more detail, but just       another item to consider on your
                                                                                   may be an option depending on the
a couple of tips:                           currency plan.
                                                                                   height of the tops, controlled
                                            The warmer temperatures don’t          airspace considerations, and the
»» Every 1° C increase in temperature
                                            mean that carburettor ice will take    amount of cloud cover. What might
   will increase density altitude (DA) by
                                            a holiday. It can still catch pilots
   120 feet, and every 1 hPa decrease in                                           look like a solid layer ahead might
                                            unawares, particularly on a fine
   atmospheric pressure will raise DA by                                           turn out to be only two or three
                                            day with developing cumulus
   30 feet.                                                                        oktas’ cover when you look at the
                                            clouds. Flying close under one of
»» For example, for a sea-level             these clouds puts you into air very    cloud shadows on the ground.
   aerodrome at 25° C and 1003 hPa,         close to its dew point, ideal
   the density altitude works out to 1500   conditions for carb ice. See the
   feet. It’s worth checking those          carb ice chart in the GAP booklet      This Summer’s Mission
   performance charts again if you have     Winter Flying.                         Get out there and enjoy it while it
   any doubts about the takeoff distance.   You   may   encounter   carb   icing   lasts – but enjoy it safely!

                                                                                     vector   November/December 2013              9
VectorPOINTING TO SAFER AVIATION - Taking Off in a Microlight Adventure Flights are not Trial Flights Summer Flying VFR Transit Lanes - Avoid the ...
SIGMET Changes
     From 14 November 2013, the positional information contained in SIGMET
     messages will be given in latitude and longitude coordinates only. For pilots on
     domestic operations, however, SIGMETs including geographic references can still
     be obtained.

     T
              he change is due to Amendment 76 to ICAO Annex 3            coordinates into place names for domestic use.
              Meteorological Service for International Air
                                                                          In practice, this means that any NZ FIR SIGMET messages
              Navigation, and applies to all States and all flight
                                                                          transmitted to pilots on domestic operations by air traffic
     information regions (FIRs). Previously, Annex 3 provided for
                                                                          services will have the coordinates translated back to place
     the issue of SIGMET applicable to domestic FIRs to relate            names for transmission. A similarly translated SIGMET may
     the positional information to known geographical points,             be available through the MetFlight GA site.
     using plain language.
                                                                          Note that SIGMET applicable to the NZ FIR and transmitted to
                                                                          aircraft on international operations will have all positional
     “The CAA recognises that the change is necessary for
                                                                          information expressed in latitude and longitude.
     operator and airline machine readability for direct use within
     flight    planning    and    operations,”     says   CAA’s   Chief   More information can be found in the document SIGMET
     Meteorological Officer, Peter Lechner.                               Reference Material on the CAA web site, under
                                                                          “Meteorology”. The document includes useful tables for

                                                                                                                                            Photo ©istock.com/ olada
     “We also recognise that this would impose some interpretive
                                                                          conversion of coordinates to geographical place names.
     difficulties for domestic general aviation and some third-
                                                                          The web page Changes to New Zealand Meteorological
     level airline operations.”
                                                                          Services – 14 November 2013 in the same location gives
     Peter advises that the CAA has worked with Airways and               details of additional but minor changes resulting from the
     MetService to establish a system to dynamically translate the        Annex 3 amendment.

     Help Shape New Zealand’s
     Airspace and Air Navigation System
     Your feedback is invited on the draft National Airspace and Air Navigation Plan,
     now available on the CAA web site.

     Y
              ou now have the chance to help develop a plan to            »» Radio will remain the primary communication medium but
              modernise our use of airspace and the air navigation           data-link (messaging) and satellite phone technology may
              system.                                                        be expanded.
                                                                          »» Aeronautical and weather information will be integrated,
     The Plan outlines the practical steps we all need to take to
                                                                             digitised, and ultimately provided direct to the cockpit.
     transition to next generation technologies. The benefits will
                                                                          »» There will be ongoing efficiency improvements in air traffic
     be enhanced safety, improved efficiency, and orderly
                                                                             management.
     management of increasing demand.
                                                                          »» Airspace will be redesigned to reflect the new PBN routes
     The proposed changes could affect you, for example:
                                                                             and surveillance systems. Controlled airspace is likely to
     »» The current radar network will reach the end of its life by          be simplified and reduced.
        2021. ADS-B (Automatic Dependent Surveillance –                   »» Aerodrome planning will be integrated with the rest of the
        Broadcast) is intended to become New Zealand’s main                  transport system (including land-use management)
        surveillance system. Aircraft will need to be equipped               through greater collaboration.
        appropriately to use airspace covered by ADS-B.
                                                                          See the draft National Airspace and Air Navigation Plan on the
     »» Pilots wishing to take advantage of performance-based             CAA web site, www.caa.govt.nz, “National Airspace and Air
        navigation (PBN) procedures will need to have approved            Navigation Plan”. Consultation closes 3 February 2014, email:
        equipment, operating procedures, and training.                    consultation@caa.govt.nz

10              vector    November/December 2013
SIDs for ‘Re-start’ Cessnas
The Supplementary Inspection Documents (SIDs) programme is applicable to all
‘Re-start’ (from 1996 onwards) Cessna aircraft. Owners need to be aware that once
the aircraft reach certain hours or calendar periods, these inspections need to be
carried out for the aircraft to remain airworthy.

J
     ohn Bushell, Team Leader Airworthiness, says,                   »» 32-13-02 Main landing gear fittings inspection.
     “Maintenance programmes for ‘Re-starts’ were
                                                                     »» 32-13-03 Main landing gear axle inspection.
     initially amended to include ageing aircraft inspection
(SIDs) in July 2012, and are now an integral part of the             »» 32-20-01 Nose landing gear and torque link inspection.
maintenance programme.                                               »» 53-12-02 Firewall inspection.
“However, anecdotal evidence from the aviation community             »» 53-47-01 Seat rails and seat rails structure corrosion
suggests that some ‘Re-start’ owners are still under the                inspection.
impression that these ageing aircraft inspections are not
                                                                     »» 57-12-01 Wing root rib corrosion inspection.
applicable to their aircraft.
                                                                     »» 57-51-01 Aileron support structure inspection.
“The individual SID inspection items applicable to each model
need to be listed in the Out of Phase section of the                 »» 57-53-01 Flap tracks corrosion inspection.
Airworthiness Directives (AD) logbook. Depending on calendar         “Some of these inspections would not be any more detailed
time and hours’ time in service, the transition period for the       than those required for the regular scheduled inspection for
inspections to be carried out is 31 August 2014,” says John.         the particular area. But some will require additional work to
The difference between the ‘Legacy’ (pre-1986) and the ‘Re-          gain access,” says John.
start’ series is that the one-off baseline SIDs inspection is not
required for the ‘Re-starts’. When the ‘Re-starts’ come up to        For a 2013 Cessna 172S
their hours or calendar periods (whichever is sooner), the           On the other hand, a 2013 Cessna 172S with nil hours on
inspection of the specific part or component is done on a            issue of a New Zealand Airworthiness Certificate, will have
when-required basis, not as an overall aircraft inspection.          the individual SID inspections identified and listed in the Out
Here are two examples to illustrate the ‘Re-start’ SIDs              of Phase section of the AD logbook. These inspections are
requirements:                                                        then required to be carried out at the periods listed in the
                                                                     individual SID document.
For a 2004 Cessna 172S
A Cessna 172S manufactured in January 2004 has 21 SIDs               More Information
applicable to it. If the aircraft has accumulated a total time of,   Contact John Bushell,        Team       Leader     Airworthiness,
say, 4000 hours, it would need the following SID inspections to      John.Bushell@caa.govt.nz.
be carried out by 31 August 2014:                                    Rule 91.603 General maintenance requirements, on the
»» 27-30-01 Elevator trim pulley bracket and actuator                CAA web site, www.caa.govt.nz, “Rules”. Cessna web site,
   inspection.                                                       www.cessna.com.

                                                                                              vector    November/December 2013           11
Airspace Review Plan
     The 2014 to 2016 Airspace Review Plan is now under way. The review looks
     at New Zealand domestic airspace. As an airspace user, it is your chance to
     have your say.

     The Review Aims To                             airspace across New Zealand, for                From this it was seen that:
     Simplify Airspace                              example low flying zones and danger             »» Control Areas (CTA) would need
                                                    areas. Special use airspace requests               minimal review, mainly to do with PBN.
     The CAA objectives for the review are to:      also led to a ‘bolt-on’ solution that
                                                    has, over time, resulted in complex             »» Control Zones (CTR) are mostly
     »» De-clutter,   simplify    and     clarify
                                                    and cluttered airspace. This means                 dated and need amending. A full
        airspace;
                                                    continuous change and can get                      review is required especially VFR
     »» Take a regional approach to airspace                                                           transit lanes and General Aviation
                                                    confusing for ATC and pilots.
        review and change;                                                                             Areas (GAA).
                                                    “For the 2014 to 2016 airspace
     »» Reduce confusion in some airspace           review period, it is intended to take a         »» Uncontrolled and special use
        areas to improve safety;                    good look at the country divided up                airspace (SUA) was found to be
     »» Address identified ‘hotspots’ of            into regions. This will allow for all              complex and cluttered and will
                                                    local participants to be a part of the             require a full review.
        airspace incidents or occurrences;
                                                    consultation process. We look                   »» CTR and SUA airspace reviews and
     »» Involve stakeholders to ensure all
                                                    forward to getting a valuable                      consultation will involve CAA,
        issues are assessed;
                                                    overview of all airspace in each                   Airways, aerodrome operators, user
     »» Take a long term strategic approach         particular region,” says Paula.                    groups, military users, and all
        to airspace so changes are less                                                                airspace users.
                                                    The review coincides with performance
        frequent.
                                                    based navigation (PBN) procedures               Based on the assessment, geographical
                                                    being progressively introduced at               areas of priority and focus are made. The
     New Zealand has a diverse aviation             controlled aerodromes over the next             visual navigation charts (VNC), 1:250 000
     system that requires many different            few years. Control zones and control
                                                                                                    series, have been used to set the
     airspace     considerations.   When            areas may need to be re-designed to
     paragliders and jumbo jets operate in                                                          boundaries.
                                                    protect the new IFR flight paths.
     the same areas, the competition for
                                                    The PBN system in the southern
     limited domestic airspace increases.
                                                    region, south of Christchurch, was              Setting the Priority
     Changes need to be made.
                                                    completed    in  2012.   Controlled             and Focus
     These changes could affect your                airspace was re-designed to protect
     operation. We need to hear from all            new instrument flight paths. (Read              Auckland
     operators, including sport aviation            more about PBN procedures in Vector,            The Auckland region was given the
     groups, air transport operators, flight        November/December 2012).                        highest priority for review due to the
     training organisations, and aerodrome          The review will look closely at any             pressures on the airspace, especially
     operators.                                     changes to make sure they work now              the control zone.
     This is your chance to have a say about        and in the future. This will reduce the         The Auckland airspace is that shown
     changing airspace.                             need for continuous change of charts            on VNC C3, excluding the Bay of
                                                    and publications during the period.             Plenty. Also excluding aerodromes at
     We’re Taking a                                                                                 Tauranga, Matamata, and Hamilton.
     Regional View                                  How We Assess Airspace                          This region’s review is well under way.
                                                    The CAA identify areas of concern to help       The CAA produced a consultation
     This is the first time we have reviewed
                                                    set up the priority list for the review plan.   paper in September 2013. The closing
     airspace region by region.
                                                    This process looks at airspace based on:        date for all submissions was
     Paula Moore, CAA Aeronautical Services                                                         29 November 2013.
                                                    »» Airspace related incidents;
     Officer, is the contact for the review, and
                                                    »» Volume of aircraft;                          Consultation will be completed by
     explains some of the issues involved.
                                                                                                    April 2014.
     “In the past, airspace reviews                 »» Complexity of airspace;
     concentrated on particular types of            »» Type of air traffic mix.

12             vector   November/December 2013
Hamilton                                  Meetings to discuss the Auckland
Hamilton Control Zone is the second       region submissions will be held at 1800
region to undergo review. The focus is    hours on Monday 9 December 2013 at
on intensive flight training operations   the Auckland Aero Club, and 1800
issues in the CTR. Consultation           hours on Tuesday 10 December 2013 at
started in October 2013. The closing      the North Shore Aero Club.
date for submissions is Friday 20         Your views, comments, suggestions
December 2013.                            and operational requirements are                      C1
Other areas begin their review process    important to the overall plan and the
in May 2015 and completion is scheduled   shape of airspace in your region.
for April 2016.
                                          More Information
Consultation and Review                   If you have any questions regarding                                   C3
                                          the     review     process,     please
When each region is reviewed, all
                                          contact Aeronautical Services Officer –
identified stakeholder organisations
                                          Airspace,    Paula    Moore,    email:
including aerodrome operators and
                                          Paula.Moore@caa.govt.nz.
aerodrome/airspace user groups, will
receive a review document.
                                          You can see the Airspace Review Plan                                        C5
The review document will be published     on the CAA web site, www.caa.govt.nz,
on the CAA web site and will be sent to   “Airspace”.                                         C6
CAA email notification subscribers to
Parts 61, 71 and 91.
This is your time to make comment and
suggestions for airspace use and to
request any airspace changes.
When the consultation is completed,
and all proposals and requests have
been received, the CAA will conduct a                                                                                  C4
                                                                               C9
meeting in each region.

                                                                                                                C2

                                                               C12                                   C7

                                                 C10
                                                                                    C13

                                          C14

                                                                          C8

                                                                  C11               vector   November/December 2013         13
VFR Transit Lanes –
     Avoid the Traps
     We investigate some VFR transit lane incidents.

     V
            FR transit lanes are created for your benefit – they help             using one, focus on aviating – keep your eyes out the window
            you fly through controlled airspace without a clearance.              and look out for aircraft leaving and entering controlled airspace,
          They make your job as a pilot easier, but don’t let that                particularly near visual reporting points.
     make you complacent.                                                         When flying over any congested area (city, town, or settlement),
     VFR transit lanes change portions of controlled airspace during              you must remain at least 1000 feet above the surface (rule
     daylight hours to Class G. This allows transiting VFR aircraft to            91.311). The CAA receives complaints about low flying aircraft
     operate in airspace not normally used by IFR aircraft without                that exit transit lanes, and then fly over residential areas at less
     obtaining a clearance first.                                                 than 1000 feet.

     We identified some incidents and talked to a few of the pilots               VFR transit lanes can be used only in daylight hours.
     involved, but first, here’s some general advice.                             For Daylight Tables, see AIP New Zealand, GEN 2.7, available
                                                                                  on the AIP web site, www.aip.net.nz.

     Pay Attention and Plan                                                       Planning with the Right Chart
     At the start of any flight, always plan using the Visual Navigation
                                                                                  Plan your flight using the orange (1:125 000) or green (1:250
     Charts (VNCs). Make a note of the transit lane altitude,
                                                                                  000) VNCs, says Carlton Campbell, CAA Standards
     frequency, (if applicable), and any landmarks you can use to
                                                                                  Development and Training Officer.
     help you determine where the airspace boundaries lie.
                                                                                  “The navigation charts have different colour titling to help
     Where there is a recommended transit lane frequency, this will
                                                                                  indicate their mapping scale. The larger scale blue (1:500 000)
     be shown on the VNCs (see example below).
                                                                                  and yellow (1:1 000 000) charts omit some airspace details
     When planning, make sure you identify the hazards associated                 relating to VFR transit lanes, in order to reduce clutter. Some
     with entering and leaving a transit lane (see the West Melton                pilots use only the larger scale planning charts when flying,
     example).                                                                    then get themselves into trouble,” says Carlton.
     VFR transit lanes create a natural choke point for aircraft. When            The following three locations deserve further attention.

                                                                                  Near Misses at West Melton
                                                                                  Airspace Occurrence – Near Miss
                                                                                  An unknown aircraft transited West Melton airspace at
                                                                                  circuit height and without radio calls. Another aircraft
                                                                                  operating in the circuit needed to take avoiding action.
                                                                                  West Melton airfield is bordered by two VFR transit lanes:
                                                                                  T856 and T858. These transit lanes extend from the surface to
                                                                                  1000 feet.
                                                                                  We’ve reported a few near misses in recent times,” said Jay
                                                                                  Peters, Chief Flying Instructor at Canterbury Aero Club.
                                                                                  “Pilots transiting the area need to be better prepared, because
                                                                                  unless attitudes change, accidents will happen.
                                                                                  “West Melton has a 1100-foot circuit altitude (795 feet
                                                                                  above ground level). The transit lanes and danger areas
     This example from VNC C2 shows the recommended T354 frequency 124.1          that surround it tend to funnel traffic right through the
     MHz (this is the Feilding aerodrome and CFZ frequency). Note the change to   circuit. Pilots come charging through the downwind and
     122.6 MHz in the Manawatu CFZ to the south of T354.                          base leg,” says Jay.

14              vector    November/December 2013
This section of VNC C13 shows the West Melton MBZ and the two transit lanes either side. There is a tendency for pilots to fly through
the circuit at West Melton - see the article for advice.

Transmit when Transiting                                                           suggest that pilots transiting the area give the airfield a wide
“It’s basic stuff – pilots should not enter West Melton MBZ                        berth where possible. The easiest way to transit Christchurch
unless intending to join overhead. Joining traffic should                          airspace from the north or south is to track east or west of
make a standard overhead join and must communicate on                              the CTR. Caution the high volumes of training traffic in the
119.2 MHz.                                                                         adjoining common frequency zone,” says Jay.

“Many pilots are either unprepared, or on the wrong
frequency. They tend to be listening out on the Christchurch
                                                                                   Busting Airspace at Wellington
tower frequency, or ATIS, to determine the Christchurch
                                                                                   Controlled Airspace Infringement – January 2013
runway in use and the corresponding VFR arrival and departure
procedures. Pre-flight preparation can save a lot of paperwork.                    An aircraft entered controlled airspace without a clearance,
                                                                                   tracking above transit lane T656 at 2500 feet.
“West Melton operations have intensified recently so I
                                                                                                                                              Continued over   »

This section of VNC C2 shows the transit lane in the Wellington CTR. T656 is surface to 1500 feet and pilots often fly above that without clearance.

                                                                                                                   vector     November/December 2013               15
The pilot said:                                        unfamiliar airspace. I had a lot on my mind.
     “I did all my preflight planning on the                “My advice to other pilots: use a sticky                    Airspace
     green VNC. I knew the transit lane altitude            note on the chart, or make a special
     restriction was there.                                 reminder. This will keep you from
                                                                                                                        Changes at
     “However, when I was flying, I used the                forgetting the transit lane altitude when                   Dunedin
     blue chart that has a larger scale. These              you get busy.”
     don’t depict the Wellington transit lane                                                                           Heads up – Dunedin’s Taieri
     altitude, so I just assumed that the transit           Transit Lane Dimensions                                     VFR Transit Lane T957 has
     lane upper altitude limit was the same as                                                                          been    extended.      These
                                                            The Wellington VFR transit lane T656
                                                                                                                        changes are reflected in the
     the control zone – 2500 feet.”                         wraps around the top of the control zone
                                                                                                                        latest VNCs, effective 14
                                                            and extends from the surface to 1500 feet.
                                                                                                                        November 2013.
     Controlled Airspace Infringement –                     Before reaching T656, you must either
                                                                                                                        Paula       Moore,         CAA
     March 2013                                             descend, or receive a clearance from
                                                                                                                        Aeronautical Services Officer,
                                                            Wellington tower to enter controlled
     Aircraft entered controlled airspace without                                                                       says the changes to T957 were
     a clearance, tracking above the upper limit            airspace. This will keep you clear of any
                                                                                                                        made as the result of a request
     of transit lane T656 at 2100 feet.                     IFR traffic on approach for runway 16
                                                                                                                        submitted by the Taieri
                                                            (Inbound aircraft on a visual approach are
     The pilot said:                                                                                                    airspace user group. These
                                                            cleared as low as 2000 feet).
                                                                                                                        changes       will       reduce
     “I forgot about the transit lane altitude
                                                                                                                        congestion in the area.
     requirement.                                           Use the Right Frequency
                                                                                                                        “This extension widens the
     “During the previous Cook Strait crossing,             When using T656, you should be on the
                                                                                                                        corridor around Mount Hyde.
     I’d transited at 1000 feet due to cloud                FISCOM frequency 121.3 MHz, with your
                                                                                                                        It also gives Taieri circuit traffic
     and this left me apprehensive when                     secondary frequency tuned to Wellington
                                                                                                                        more space,” says Paula.
     crossing for a second time. This was also              Tower – 118.8 MHz.

     VFR transit lanes are depicted like this on the
     VNCs (also used for General Aviation Areas).

     This section of VNC C8 shows the new boundaries for the T957 transit lane. The new charts were effective 14 November 2013.

16              vector    November/December 2013
Keep Out of
Restricted Areas
Restricted areas of airspace mean just that. Unless you are authorised
to enter these areas, stay out.

C
        ontrolled airspace and special                 Recent Restricted                                Airspace Information
        use airspace are designated by
        the Director of Civil Aviation
                                                       Area Bust                                        and Flight Preparation
under Part 71 for safety reasons.                      Recently, a temporary restricted area            Before any flight, a pilot should check
Special      use       airspace        includes        was approved for the demonstration,              the AIP Supplements and NOTAMs. Of
permanent or temporary Restricted                      in    a     working     environment,    of   a   course, this will be combined with
Areas (RAs).                                           sophisticated RPAS (Remotely Piloted             weather and route information as part
                                                       Aerial System). The event was held               of planning for a safe flight.
Most permanent Restricted Areas are
                                                       over a five-day period in busy and
conservation sites of importance to
                                                       complex airspace.                                Apart from alerting you to Restricted
New Zealand’s wildlife, such as the
                                                                                                        Areas,   the    AIP      Supplements       and
Royal Albatross colony at Taiaroa on the               As well as applying for special use
                                                                                                        NOTAMs will alert you to other Special
Otago Peninsula.                                       airspace, the operator made sure that
                                                       local       operators    and   the     nearby    Use Airspace, such as Danger Areas
Temporary RAs are put in place in the                                                                   and Military Operating Areas.
                                                       UNICOM staff were briefed on the
interests of aviation safety or security, or
                                                       Temporary RA.
in the public interest.                                                                                 Although aircraft are not prohibited
                                                       During that time, at least one aircraft          from operating within a Restricted Area,
For example, the airshow season is
                                                       entered the Restricted Area without              the pilot must have prior approval of the
about to start. Temporary RAs will be
                                                       authorisation. Observers thought that            designated ‘administering authority’ –
established for a number of events to
                                                       several of these busts occurred during           in our example, this was the operator of
separate display aircraft from other
                                                       the five-day period.                             the RPAS.
aircraft at certain times.

                          Restricted Area                                                               Finding Airspace
        [NZ R...]                                                                                       Information
                                                                                                        »» You    can     download           the   AIP
                                                                                                           Supplements for free from the AIP
                                                                                                           web site, www.aip.net.nz.

                                                                                                        »» For NOTAMs, log onto Airways’
                                                                                                           IFIS web site, www.ifis.airways.co.nz.

                                                                                                        » » See AIP New Zealand, Vol. 1, ENR
                                                                                                           5.1   for    details       of    permanent
                                                                                                           Special Use Airspace, including
                                                                                                           Restricted Areas.

                                                                                                        »» You can get a free New Zealand
                                                                                                           Airspace poster and booklet of
                                                                                                           the    same        title    by    emailing:
                                                                                                           info@caa.govt.nz.
Enter only after authorisation from the administering authority.

                                                                                                           vector   November/December 2013               17
Low-g Effects
     – A New Perspective
                                                   By Simon Spencer-Bower, QSM

                                                   Low-g mast bumping is a subject that tends to
                                                   send shivers up the spine of many a helicopter
                                                   pilot, probably because it is not fully understood.
                                                   The Robinson Helicopter Company’s (RHC) very
                                                   robust low-g education programme, run through
                                                   their Safety Courses over many years, has gone
                                                   a long way to eliminating low-g accidents. From
                                                   time to time, however, the odd low-g accident
        Simon Spencer-Bower
                                                   still seems to occur.

     T
            he intention of this article is to   their Robinson Safety Awareness              fuselage just fell to the ground. Other,
            assist pilots to understand the      training. Due to the lack of any technical   less than ‘classic’ accidents also
            low-g phenomenon and to              material involving low-g conditions and      occurred where the mast was bumped
     make them realize that the subject is       mast bumping, RHC also set about             but not completely severed.
     not as complicated as they probably         investigating the phenomenon. They           However, with the passage of time,
     first thought.                              instrumented an R22 with a recording         more and more has been learnt about
     Importantly, it also informs pilots about   oscillograph with control position           the subject and some of the information
     a new recovery technique variation that     indicators to record torque on the main      in the US Army film is now considered
     is probably more instinctive than the       rotor, the flapping angles of the            incorrect. Nevertheless, there still
     current ‘standard’ recovery method,         retreating blade, the movement of all        appears to be a lot of unhealthy attitudes
     and targets the causes of the problem       controls, the times of control movement      and fears associated with low g, probably
     rather than dealing with the symptoms.      in hundredths of a second, and a             perpetuated      by     misinterpretation,
                                                 number of other parameters. They then        hearsay, and ‘Chinese whispers’. There
                                                 attempted to measure the effects of
     History and Research                        various control inputs during entry to
                                                                                              is even some completely false
                                                                                              information published in a well-known
     Very little was known about the low-g       less than 1-g situations, the effect of      helicopter   textbook,     which      says
     phenomenon in the early days of             different control inputs in the low-g        something along the lines of, “on
     helicopter     operations,   and      no    environment, and the effect of all           entering autorotation, do not lower the
     information was available in any of the     control movements on the right roll, all
     helicopter theory books available at the    at varying power settings and airspeeds
     time. It appears that the US Armed          up to Vne (never-exceed speed) at
     Forces were among the first to identify     maximum power.
     it after they began experiencing low-g
                                                 Using the information gathered, the
     mast bumping during some helicopter
                                                 RHC engineers were able to calculate
     operations.
                                                 potential roll rates of up to 100 degrees
     After 268 mast-bumping accidents, the       per second in the worst of conditions; a
     US Army went on a massive pilot             very quick roll rate!
     information programme for their pilots
                                                 The first Robinson R22 mast-bumping
     and largely eliminated it from their
                                                 accident happened in 1983. It was a
     operations. They also made a training
                                                 ‘classic’, in that the mast was completely
     film on the subject, which has been
                                                 severed, with the intact rotor system
     seen by many of today’s pilots during
                                                 flying off in one direction while the

18            vector   November/December 2013
A Robinson R22 helicopter in normal flight.

collective too quickly, as this will cause a   the pilot begins to raise the collective,      opposed to zero g), the horizontal tail
catastrophic low-g rollover situation”.        the cyclic begins to become effective          rotor thrust component is still present,
                                               as the disc becomes loaded. So, if the         but the cyclic will now have a limited
Improving on the                               disc is ‘half loaded’, it will be half as      amount of control because the main
                                               effective as when fully loaded.                rotor disc is partially loaded.
‘Standard Method’                              Likewise, for a helicopter in flight, if the
During the course of many years of                                                            It is this knowledge that forms the basis
                                               pilot were to bunt forward to the point
instructing I have come to the opinion                                                        of the current recovery technique, in
                                               of being partially loaded, (low g) the
that the ‘standard’ published low-g                                                           which pilots are advised to apply aft
                                               cyclic would be half as effective as at
recovery method of gently applying aft                                                        cyclic to ‘reload’ the disc so that the
                                               normal 1-g flight.
                                                                                              cyclic becomes more effective, and
cyclic to load the disc before applying
                                               Anti-torque in a helicopter is provided        they can then control the roll.
lateral cyclic is counter-instinctive, and
                                               by the tail rotor, and the more power in
could be improved on and explained a                                                          However, as we have explained, cyclic
                                               use, the more anti-torque required. The
lot better. Let’s look at the reasons why                                                     control is nil at zero g, it can be seen
                                               thrust of the tail rotor is the reason the
developing this new, more intuitive,                                                          that the closer the helicopter gets to
                                               helicopter drifts in the opposite direction
technique is beneficial.                                                                      zero g, the less effective the cyclic
                                               to this thrust (tail rotor drift). This is
                                                                                              becomes until, at zero g, attempting to
When a helicopter is sitting on the            most noticeable in the hover, but is also
                                                                                              ‘reload’ the disc, (the current method)
ground at full operating RPM with              present in all flight situations when
                                                                                              will not work at all.
collective completely down, ie, no             power is being produced. Helicopter
pitch, and the cyclic is moved, the disc       manufacturers usually build in methods
moves in the direction of the cyclic           to compensate for this drift, and the          Controlling vs
input but the helicopter will not respond.     pilot will also control it with the cyclic.    Eliminating Roll
This is because the disc is not ‘loaded’.      In flight, if a helicopter reaches a           Up to this point we have talked about
In other words, the disc doesn’t have          condition of zero g with power on, the         controlling the roll. Now let’s talk
any weight hanging from it. To achieve         horizontal thrust component of the tail        about reducing or eliminating the roll –
this same unloaded disc condition in           rotor is still present. As we have already     by removing tail rotor thrust. If the tail
flight, the helicopter would have to be        discussed, the cyclic is ineffective at        rotor thrust is removed, then the
bunted forward hard enough to the              zero g and so cannot counteract any roll       helicopter will not roll because no
point that the helicopter became               resulting from that horizontal thrust.         horizontal thrust is being produced.
weightless. This situation is known as         Therefore, the helicopter will continue        Therefore, if the collective is lowered,
zero g. If this were done, movement of         to roll in the direction of the tail rotor     power will be reduced, reducing tail
the cyclic would have no effect on the         thrust (to the right in a counter-             rotor thrust – and the associated roll
helicopter at all, just as in the case         clockwise        rotating   main     rotor)    tendency. If you take this technique to
when it was sitting on the ground as           regardless of what the pilot does with         its logical conclusion, lowering the
described above.                               the cyclic.
Going back to the ground situation, as         However, in a low-g situation (as                                        Continued over   »

                                                                                                 vector   November/December 2013             19
Photo: ©istockphoto.com/HeliRy

                                                                              A typical two-bladed teetering rotor, as used on the Bell 206 series.

     collective completely and entering           will stall in 1.1 seconds if the collective       Raising the collective will in fact make
     autorotation will completely remove all      is not lowered. A lot of pilots interpret         the situation worse and cause even
     tail rotor thrust.                           this as meaning they have 1.1 seconds             more rapid roll because more tail rotor
                                                  to lower the collective. This is not              thrust is being produced.
     A normal conservative cruise manifold
                                                  correct, because once the rotor has               So this begs the question: why not
     pressure (MAP) setting in the R22 is
                                                  stalled on a helicopter, recovery is              use the technique of lowering
     the 20 to 23” range. This power
                                                  impossible. This means that in reality,           collective   and     even     entering
     setting should be considered ‘high’,
                                                  the collective has to be lowered within           autorotation as the recovery method
     with     20”    considered    a    good
                                                  about 0.5 seconds in order to be able             for   low-g    and    especially    for
     demarcation between high and low
                                                  to maintain rotor RPM within                      zero-g situations, as the only
     power. The R22 flight manual advises
                                                  recoverable limits. Lowering the                  technique that will work at zero g?
     pilots to slow down to an IAS between
                                                  collective this fast will result in a low-g
     60 knots and 0.7 Vne (about 70 knots)                                                          Some advocates of the current
                                                  sensation, but it should now be
     when encountering turbulence. The                                                              recovery technique of applying aft
                                                  understood that this is not a problem,
     reason for this is that the power                                                              cyclic and then left cyclic argue that
                                                  as no tail rotor thrust is being
     setting for this speed in the R22 is                                                           this current technique is more
                                                  produced. This makes a mockery of
     typically 17 to 18” MAP (and even                                                              instinctive. I disagree. A good example
                                                  the statement in the well-known
     lower in the R44). This power setting                                                          of this was when RHC inserted the
                                                  helicopter book mentioned earlier, that
     is ‘low’ (below 20” MAP) and therefore                                                         low-g     recognition    and    recovery
                                                  cautions pilots not to lower the
     produces low tail rotor thrust, thereby                                                        manoeuvre into their Safety Course,
                                                  collective too rapidly.
     reducing any roll tendency in the event                                                        which at the time was conducted only
     of a low-g situation being encountered                                                         for flight instructors. After providing
                                                  Making it Worse                                   two days of ground instruction which
     during turbulence. Robinson also
     states that there is no need to be           If we are discussing low-g recovery, the          included a wealth of information on
     concerned about low g when lowering          phrase “the pilot must reload the disc”           low-g mast bumping, showing the
                                                  has      been    misinterpreted       and         Army film, and demonstrating a
     the collective rapidly when entering
                                                  misunderstood to the point that it could          number of various low-g recovery
     autorotation. This is quite correct for
                                                  possibly have contributed to some                 techniques in the flight portion of the
     the reasons explained above, because
                                                  low-g accidents. For example, some                course, the RHC instructors charted
     with no power, there will be no roll.
                                                  instructors and flight schools have               the first movement attendees made in
                                                  actually taught students to raise the             response to the right roll. In 80 per
     Reaction Time                                collective on encountering low g, in the          cent of cases (and this was with
     In the R22, RHC states that in the           mistaken belief that this will reload the         instructors who knew what to expect,
     event of a power loss at maximum             main rotor disc and give them the cyclic          not low-time pilots) the first movement
     continuous power, the rotor system           control needed to counteract the roll.            of the cyclic was to the left. When the

20              vector   November/December 2013
You can also read