The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities

Page created by Terrance Neal
 
CONTINUE READING
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
ISSUE 14 | JUNE–JULY 2021

                                              The Road to
                                              Sustainable
                                                    Cities

ISSN 2721-8058
                 THE INSIDE VIEW      SHIFTING CURRENTS     CONVERSATIONS
                 ASEAN Smart Cities     COVID-19 Response    An Urban Renewal
                                             Updates
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
ts of
                                                                                            Righ n and
                                                                                             o me              Women and Gender
                                                                                            W       ren
                                                                        re                    Child                                                               Lab
                                                                    elfa ent                                                                                         our
                                                                 lW
                                                            o cia elopm                                                ACW
                                                           S     ev
                                                             dD                                  ACWC
                                                           an                                                                                            SLOM
                                        t
                                      en n
                                    m atio                                SOMSWD                                                                                                                          Ci
                                  op dic                                                                                                                                                                    vil
                                                                                                                                                                                                                S
                                    ra                                                                                                                                                                              e

                               er el
                             ov ev
                                    E

                                                                                                                                                                                                                    rv
                           dP lD

                                 ty

                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ice
                         an Rura

                                           SOMRDPE                                                                                                                                                   SOM-ACCSM
                                                                                                                    AMMW
                                                                                              AMMSWD                                      ALMM

                                                               AMRDPE                                                                                                             ACCSM
                                                                                                ASEAN SOCIO-CULTURAL

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Hea
                   rts
                Spo

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         lth
                         SOMS                                                                       COMMUNITY                                                                                                                 SOMHD

                                                                                                           Ministerial Bodies

                                                                                                                                                                                          ou tion
                                                                                                                                                                                               il
                                                                                                                                                                                            ns
                                                                                                                                                                                        C ora
                                                 AMMS                                                     and Senior Officials                                                                       AHMM

                                                                                                                                                        am SCC Co ommittee fo collab
                                                                                                                                                                                         C
                                                                                                                                                                                    r AS
                                                                                                                                                                  uncil and facilitate
                                                                                                                                                                    sectoral bodies
    Education

                   SOM-ED
                                        ASED                                                                                                                                                           AMMDM

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 e nt
                                                                                                                   ASCC

                                                                                                                                                                    C
                                                                                                                                                              ASSC
                                                                                                                                                              ials’

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ana gem
                                                                                                                  Council

                                                                                                                                                ef ort fc

                                                                                                                                                          ong
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ACDM

                                                                                                                                              of upp ior O
                                                                                                                                                  or s A

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ster M
                                                                                                                                                 S en

                                                                                                                                                     ts
                                                                                                                                                                                                      COP-

                                                                                                                                                   S
                                                 AMMY

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Disa
                                                                                                                                                                                                     AADMER
                         SOMY
                You

                                                                                                                                     SOCA
                   ht

                                                                    AMRI                                                                                                           AMME

                                               SOMRI                                                                                       COP-                                                        ASOEN
                                                                                                AMCA
                                                                                                                                          AATHP

                                                                                                                                                                                                                         t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        en
                                                                                                                                                                                                               nm
                                    fo
                                  In

                                                                                                                                                                                                                 o
                                       r   m
                                               at
                                                               COCI*                                                                                                                                          vir
                                                  io                                                                                                                                                        En
                                                       n
                                                                                        SOMCA                                                             COM
                                                            Cu
                                                               lt   ure
                                                                          a nd                                                                                                                 aze
                                                                                 Ar t                                                                                                  yH
                                                                                        s                                                                     un             dar
                                                                                                                                                 Tra    nsb o

   Ministerial Bodies                      Sectoral Bodies                       *) takes guidance from and reports to both AMCA and AMRI

AMRI-ASEAN Ministers Responsible for Information                                            AHMM-ASEAN Health Ministers Meeting                                           SOMS-Senior Officials Meeting on Sports
AMCA-ASEAN Ministers Responsible for Culture and Arts                                       AMMDM-ASEAN Ministerial Meeting                                               SOMRDPE-Senior Officials Meeting on Rural
                                                                                            on Disaster Management                                                        Development and Poverty Eradication
AMMY-ASEAN Ministerial Meeting on Youth                                                     COP-AADMER-Conference of the Parties to the ASEAN                             SOMSWD-Senior Officials Meeting on Social
                                                                                            Agreement on Disaster Management and Emergency Response                       Welfare and Development
ASED-ASEAN Education Ministers Meeting                                                      AMME-ASEAN Ministerial Meeting on Environment                                 ACWC-ASEAN Commission on the Promotion
                                                                                                                                                                          and Protection of the Rights of Women and Children
AMMS-ASEAN Ministerial Meeting on Sports                                                    COP to AATHP-Conference of the Parties to the ASEAN                           ACW-ASEAN Committee on Women
                                                                                            Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution
AMRDPE-ASEAN Ministers on Rural Development and                                             SOMCA-Senior Officials Meeting on Culture and Arts                            SLOM-Senior Labour Officials Meeting
Poverty Eradication

AMMSWD-ASEAN Ministerial Meeting on Social Welfare and                                      COCI-The ASEAN Committee for Culture and Information                          SOM-ACCSM-Senior Officials Meeting
Development                                                                                                                                                               on ASEAN Cooperation on Civil Service Matters
AMMW-ASEAN Ministerial Meeting on Women                                                     SOMRI-Senior Officials Meeting Responsible for Information                    SOMHD-Senior Officials Meeting on Health Development
ALMM-ASEAN Labour Ministers Meeting                                                         SOMY-Senior Officials Meeting on Youth                                        ASOEN-ASEAN Senior Officials on the Environment

ACCSM-The Heads of Civil Service Meeting                                                    SOMED-Senior Officials Meeting on Education                                   COM to AATHP-Committee under the Conference of Parties
for ASEAN Cooperation on Civil Service Matters                                                                                                                            to the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
Contents     3

  11

                                                                                                           Secretary-General of ASEAN
                                                                                                           Dato Lim Jock Hoi
                                                                                                           Deputy Secretary-General of
                                                                                                           ASEAN for ASEAN Socio-Cultural
                                                                                                           Community (ASCC)
                                                                                                           Kung Phoak

                                                                                                           EDITORIAL BOARD
                                                                                                           Directors of ASCC Directorates
                                                                                                           Rodora T. Babaran,
                                                                                                           Ky-Anh Nguyen

                                                                                                           Assistant Directors of
                                                                                                           ASCC Divisions
                                                                                                           Benjamin Loh, Ferdinal Fernando,
                                                                                                           Jonathan Tan, Mega Irena,
IN THIS ISSUE                                                                                              Riyanti Djalante, Sita Sumrit,
                                                                                                           Vong Sok
THE ROAD TO                                                                                                EDITORIAL TEAM
SUSTAINABLE                                                                                                Editor-in-Chief
                                                                                                           Mary Kathleen Quiano-Castro
CITIES
                                                                                                           Associate Editor
                                                                                                           Joanne B. Agbisit
Dato Lim Jock Hoi
Secretary-General of ASEAN     6                                                                           Staff Writer
                                                                                                           Novia D. Rulistia
Promoting Smart and
                                                                                                           Senior Officer, Analysis Division
Sustainable Urbanisation
in ASEAN: Progress                                                37     46                                Kiran Sagoo
                                                                                                           Officer, Analysis Division
and Challenges                 8
                                                                                                           Pricilia Putri Nirmala Sari
Capturing the Urban                                                                                        EDITORIAL ADDRESS
Opportunity in Southeast Asia 11
                                   Viewpoints                           Snapshots                          The ASEAN Secretariat
Shaping Smarter ASEAN                                                                                      ASEAN Socio-Cultural
Cities: The Path Towards                                                                                   Community Department
                                   Hugh Lim                             Building Greater                   Jalan Sisingamangaraja 70A
Environmentally                    Executive Director,                  Understanding and Tolerance        Jakarta 12110, Indonesia
Sustainable Cities            17   Centre for Liveable Cities      14   in a Troubled World         45     Tel: 62-21-7262991
Confronting Urban Transport        Non Arkaraprasertkul, PhD            Fostering Greater                  E-mail: ASCCAD@asean.org
Woes in Southeast Asia      23     Senior Expert, Smart City            Understanding: Tolerance
                                                                                                           ISSN 2721-8058
10 Things to Know About            Promotion Department                 and a Sense of Regional
Southeast Asian Cities       27    Digital Economy Promotion            Agendas Among
Southeast Asian Cities in the      Agency (DEPA), Thailand         20   the Peoples of ASEAN         46
UNESCO World Heritage List 28
                                   Conversations                        Bridges
Shifting Currents
                                   Kotchakorn Voraakhom                 The Land of Gold, Spices
ASEAN Health Ministers             Landscape Architect             37   and Coconuts: India’s Voyage
Vow Stronger Regional              Muhammad Agung Saputra               to Southeast Asia            49
Cooperation on COVID-19            Founder and CEO, Surplus        40   Understanding India’s
Response and Future                (Food Rescue App)                    Ties to Southeast Asia
Preparedness                  31   Han Jing Toh                         through Literature           50
Old Threat, New Threat:            Sustainability Educator         42   The Beats of Indian-Southeast
Fighting Dengue in                 Bjorn Low                            Asian Tunes                   54
a Pandemic                    32   Urban Farmer and Executive
The Shape of Things to Come 34     Director, Edible Garden City    43

Cover Illustration by Fahrizal Aryanto | Composed by Kramakata
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
4   Editorial Note

    A Note from the Editorial Team

    This issue takes stock of ASEAN initiatives to turn cities—home                                                                                                                                                                          UN-Habitat Executive Director Maimunah Mohd Sharif outlines
    to half of the region’s populace—into habitable, sustainable,                                                                                                                                                                            the various forms of assistance—from urban policy development
    and resilient urban environments.                                                                                                                                                                                                        to technical support—that the UN-Habitat has rendered to improve
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             living conditions in cities across Asia. ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community
    In an interview, ASEAN Secretary-General Dato Lim Jock Hoi                                                                                                                                                                               Department’s Vong Sok and Dwight Jason Ronan discuss ongoing
    highlights that transforming cities into smart ones, i.e. data-                                                                                                                                                                          programmes, projects, and partnerships to promote clean and green
    driven and technologically-enabled, represents a vital step                                                                                                                                                                              urban spaces. Our editorial team looks at regional and national plans
    towards improving people’s quality of life in cities and addressing                                                                                                                                                                      to solve road transport-induced air pollution and health issues.
    a multitude of urban problems, including disasters and pandemics.
    ASEAN Connectivity Division’s Lim Chze Cheen and Benazir Syahril                                                                                                                                                                         Our Conversations section features remarkable individuals
    provide an overview of the regional frameworks and strategies                                                                                                                                                                            who launched their own initiatives to make their cities more
    developed to guide Member States in carrying out smart and                                                                                                                                                                               liveable and sustainable. These include an app to address food
    sustainable urbanisation.                                                                                                                                                                                                                waste, projects to transform “wasted” spaces like rooftops and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             abandoned infrastructures into organic farms and public green
    Non Arkaraprasertkul of Thailand’s Digital Economy Promotion                                                                                                                                                                             spaces, and urban garden projects.
    Agency Digital discusses the progress and challenges of establishing
    digital connectivity in the region, a key component of smart cities,                                                                                                                                                                     Our Shifting Currents and Snapshots sections provide updates on
    and the opportunity-in-crisis that the COVID-19 pandemic presents                                                                                                                                                                        ongoing ASEAN initiatives related to COVID-19, dengue, and cultural
    for engineering a digital shift. Centre for Liveable Cities’ Hugh Lim                                                                                                                                                                    understanding. We also have a reflective essay from the University
    talks about ways to create pandemic- and climate-resilient cities,                                                                                                                                                                       of the Philippines’ Clement Camposano on how education
    emphasising the role of smart solutions and an innovative                                                                                                                                                                                administrators can make remote learning work for teachers
    population in swift pandemic response and recovery.                                                                                                                                                                                      and students, even post-pandemic.

    Along with mainstreaming smart technologies into urban systems,                                                                                                                                                                          The issue rounds off with four articles exploring the historical,
    ASEAN also recognises the need to address the range of challenges                                                                                                                                                                        literary and musical ties between Southeast Asia and India.
    caused by rapid urbanisation, including competition for limited
    resources, environmental degradation, and health problems.

                                                                                           Issue 1                                                                                                Issue 2                                                                                                        Issue 3                             Issue 4
                                                                                           https://bit.ly/                                                                                        https://bit.ly/                                                                                                https://bit.ly/                     https://bit.ly/
                                                                                           TheASEAN_V1                                                                                            TheASEAN_V2                                                                                                    TheASEAN_V3                         TheASEAN_V4

                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ASEAN
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     The
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      SPECIAL EDITION
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      NOVEMBER - DECEMBER 2020

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Issue 7 & 8
                                                                                           Issue 5                                                                                                Issue 6                                                                                                        Special edition                     Issue 9
                                                                                           https://bit.ly/                                                                                        https://bit.ly/   ISSN 2721-8058
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     THE INSIDE VIEW      CONVERSATIONS                VIEWPOINT
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 http://bit.ly/                      http://bit.ly/
                                                                                           TheASEAN_V5                                                                                            TheASEAN_V6                                                                                                    TheASEAN_SP                         TheASEAN_V9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     The ASEAN Regional     Living Through       WHO DIRECTOR-GENERAL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     COVID-19 Response      The Pandemic     Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, PhD

     ASEAN                                                                                                   ASEAN
                      The                                                                                                       The
                                                                     DOUBLE ISSUE                                                                                             DOUBLE ISSUE
                                                                     FEBRUARY–MARCH 2021                                                                                      APRIL–MAY 2021

                                                                                                                   VE
                                                                                                                        RSARY
                                                                                                                                                                        Gender
                                                                                                                    1st
                                                                                                                              ISS
                                                                                                             ANNI

                                                                                                                                                                       Equality
                                                                                                                                  UE

                                                                                                                                                                       Bridge to Progress

                                                                                                                                                                                                  Issue 12 & 13                                                                                                               @theaseanmagazine      www
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           www.asean.org
    ASEAN
    YOUTH:                                                                                 Issue 10 & 11                                                                                          http://bit.ly/
    POWERING THE FUTURE
    WITH INNOVATION
                                                                                           http://bit.ly/                                                                                         TheASEAN_
     ISSN 2721-8058
                      THE INSIDE VIEW       SHIFTING CURRENTS      WOMEN’S MONTH
                                                                                                             ISSN 2721-8058
                                                                                                                                 THE INSIDE VIEW
                                                                                                                                  A Year in Review
                                                                                                                                                     GENDER EQUALITY
                                                                                                                                                      Transformational and
                                                                                                                                                                              VIEWPOINT
                                                                                                                                                                             Mari Elka Pangestu                                                                                                                               @theasean_magazine           @asean_magazine
                                                                                           TheASEAN_V10                                                                                           AnnivEdition
                       Nurturing Creative     Mental Health Care    Women and Girls                                                                   Feminine Leadership    Managing Director
                           Learners             in a Pandemic         Who Code                                                                                                  World Bank

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
The Inside View   5

                                                                               T h e
                                                                              In s i d e
                                                                               Vi e w
                                                                                 ASEAN works towards smart
                                                                                 and sustainable urbanisation
Photo Credit: © Imanuel Kristianto/Shutterstock

                                                  Hotel and office towers
                                                  viewed from Waduk Melati,
                                                  Jakarta, Indonesia
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
6   The Inside View

                     Viewpoint:
                     Dato Lim Jock Hoi
                     Secretary-General of ASEAN
    ASEAN Secretary-General Dato Lim Jock Hoi talks to The                                    generating new sources of growth.
                                                                                              This may invigorate more cities to make
    ASEAN on the qualities and benefits of smart cities, as                                   smart development the foundation of
    well as the ongoing initiatives to support the region’s                                   long-term urban planning. Technology
    26 major cities in developing, updating,                                                  is often considered an enabler, but
                                                                                              today, technology will also be a
    and implementing their smart city action plans under                                      differentiator and an accelerator.
    the ASEAN Smart Cities Network initiative.
                                                                                              It is critical for ASEAN to put in place

    W
                                                                                              policies that boost digital connectivity
                hat characterises a smart city?      ecosystem remains an important           and encourage an innovative ecosystem.
                Secretary-General Lim:               foundation of its development and        There is also a need to develop open data
                A smart city harnesses               competitive advantage, a smart city      cooperation and strengthen digital data
    technological as well as digital solutions and   should be designed according to its      governance in the region. This aims to further
    other innovative means to address urban          unique characteristics and potential.    enhance data management, facilitate
    challenges, create new opportunities, and                                                 harmonisation of data regulations
    continuously improve the quality of life of      Why is technology considered the         and promote cross-data flows.
    its people.                                      enabler to improving people’s lives in
                                                     cities? What other aspects constitute    Smart city initiatives need more than
    A smart city also promotes social                sustainable urban development?           just technology to succeed. It requires
    and economic development alongside               Secretary-General Lim: The COVID-19      people-centred approaches, as well as
    environmental sustainability through             pandemic has created an impetus for      close collaboration between different
    effective mechanisms to meet current             smart cities to embrace technology       levels of government, the general public
    and future challenges. As a city’s natural       in addressing urban challenges and       and the private sector. Collaboration
                                                                                              on the design and implementation of
                                                                                              smart city initiatives will help authorities
                                                                                              to understand and incorporate the needs
                                                                                              of various stakeholders, particularly
                                                                                              vulnerable groups, and, instil a greater
                                                                                              sense of ownership and stewardship
                                                                                              of smart city projects.

                                                                                              At the regional level, the ASEAN
                                                                                              Smart Cities Network (ASCN) provides
                                                                                              a collaborative platform where cities
                                                                                              work together towards the common
                                                                                                                                               Photo Credit: © jamesteohart/Shutterstock

                                                                                              goal of smart and sustainable urban
                                                                                              development. Through this platform,
                                                                                              the ASCN also continues to develop
                                                                                              synergies with other relevant ASEAN
                                                                                              initiatives, such as the ASEAN Sustainable
                                                                                              Urbanisation Strategy, and strengthen
                                                                                              smart city partnerships beyond the region.
                                                                                              Such collaborations can bring about more
                                                                                              tangible outcomes by pooling together
                                                                                              the knowledge, expertise and resources
                                                                                              on the requisite hardware and software
                                                                                              for digital connectivity.

                                                                                                                  The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
The Inside View     7

                                                                                                                                   Plans (SCAPs); and (ii) the Guidelines for
                                                                                                                                   ASCN Engagement with External Partners
                                                                                                                                   which serves as reference to the terms
                                                                                                                                   and modalities for ASCN engagements
                                                                                                                                   and partnerships.

                                                                                                                                   Different cities encounter different
                                                                                                                                   challenges. These could include the
                                                                                                                                   need for integrated planning, evidence-
                                                                                                                                   based planning, access to alternative
                                                                                                                                   sources of project finance, social
                                                                                                                                   inclusion, capacity building and
                                                                                                                                   technical feasibility, among others. Cities
                                                                                                                                   will need to find the right combination
                                                                                                                                   of technologies, policies, and partners
                                                                                                                                   to suit their own starting points and
                                                                                                                                   priorities. Collaborative partnerships
                                                                                                                                   involving public and private sectors as
                                                                                                                                   broader stakeholders, through the ASCN
                                                                                                                                   and other relevant platforms, can help
                                                                                                                                   bring about better solutions and value
                                                                                                                                   to the development of smart cities.

                                                                                                                                   What are the priorities of the ASCN
                                                                                                                                   this year?
                                                                                                                                   Secretary-General Lim: The ASCN has
                                                                                                                                   continued to strengthen the monitoring of
                                                                                                                                   progress for SCAPs, facilitate partnerships,
                                                                                                                                   develop projects that further improve the
                                                                                                                                   lives of ASEAN people, and promote new
                                                                                                                                   business opportunities in smart city
                                                                                                                                   development. This year, the ASCN has been
                                                                                                                                   looking into the possibility of developing
                                                                                                                                   an online portal and an ASEAN smart city
                                                                                                                                   investment toolkit.

                                                                                                                                   The ASCN online portal aims to function
                                                                                                                                   as a common platform for ASCN cities
                                                                                                                                   to take stock of their SCAPs and update
                                                                                                                                   their priorities, build partnerships, and
                                                                                                                                   access important resources for smart
                                                                                                                                   city development.

                                                                                                                                   The ASEAN smart city investment toolkit is
                                                                                                                                   envisaged to help cities understand various
                                                                                                                                   funding and financing options, assess the
                                                                                                                                   advantages and disadvantages of each,
                                                                                                                                   and identify strategies that best fit cities’
Photo Credit: © ASEAN Secretariat

                                    What has the network accomplished               projects, foster existing partnerships,        respective contexts.
                                    so far since it was created? What are           explore untapped potentials and build
                                    the challenges to building smart cities,        capacity to deliver smart city projects.       In November 2021, the Ministry of
                                    and how are these being addressed?                                                             Transport and Infocommunications
                                    Secretary-General Lim: Since its                In 2020, the ASCN has endorsed: (i) the ASCN   of Brunei Darussalam will be hosting
                                    establishment, the ASCN has grown from          Monitoring and Evaluation Framework which      the ASCN Conference with the theme
                                    strength to strength. Around 50 projects        provides a standardised approach to support    of “The New Normal.” The conference
                                    have been developed and 40 partnerships         ASCN cities by monitoring progress and         will focus on sharing experiences around
                                    have been forged. The ASCN has strengthened     preparing annual updates on the status of      how cities will address the new normal
                                    its institutional mechanisms to monitor these   implementation of their Smart City Action      in a post COVID-19 environment.
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
8   The Inside View

    Promoting Smart and Sustainable Urbanisation in ASEAN

    Progress and Challenges
              LIM CHZE CHEEN                    BENAZIR SYAHRIL
              DIRECTOR, CONNECTIVITY DIVISION   PROJECT OFFICER, CONNECTIVITY DIVISION,
              OFFICE OF SECRETARY-GENERAL       OFFICE OF SECRETARY-GENERAL

    Cities are at the frontline of key global trends and
                                                                             P
                                                                                     ursuing smart and sustainable
                                                                                     urbanisation in ASEAN can help
    challenges affecting the region, from pandemic to                                cities to recover from and adapt
    climate change and digitalisation to inclusive growth.                   to current challenges and better prepare
    Around half of ASEAN’s people already live in urban                      for future problems, whether these are
                                                                             internal or external, short-term or
    areas, and by 2025, a further 70 million people in this                  long-term, expected or unexpected.            Photo Credit: © Muhammad Syahid/Shutterstock
    region will be city dwellers. Rapid urbanisation would                   Smart and sustainable urbanisation has
    place increasing pressures on most of these cities that                  therefore become an important part of
                                                                             ASEAN’s efforts to raise the standards of
    may not be adequately equipped to deal with a growing                    living of its peoples and empower them
    range of potential threats.                                              to seize opportunities and tackle head
                                                                             on whatever challenges may arise in the
                                                                             coming years. Connecting urban areas
                                                                             can also strengthen regional production
                                                                             networks and promote inclusive growth.

                                                                             Above
                                                                             Johor Baru, Malaysia. One of 26 ASEAN
                                                                             Smart Cities (ASCN) Pilot Cities

                                                                                                The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
The Inside View    9

                                            This is where enhancing ASEAN Connectivity     (ACRF) adopted by ASEAN Leaders                and well-being; security; quality
                                            and increasing investments in infrastructure   at the 37th ASEAN Summit in November           environment; built infrastructure;
                                            are critical.                                  2020. The ACRF underscores the need            and industry and innovation.
                                                                                           to synergise ASEAN’s initiatives in
                                            The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted          sustainable urbanisation and smart             Connecting cities across ASEAN through
                                            the promise and possibilities of smart and     city development through the ASEAN             exchange of knowledge and expertise is
                                            sustainable urbanisation. One key              Sustainable Urbanisation Strategy              one way to promote sustainable actions
                                            development is the need to use                 (ASUS) and the ASEAN Smart Cities              and solutions. In addition, cities’ varying
                                            technology. Whether it is sustainable          Network (ASCN).                                capacities and journeys in managing
                                            public transport options or low carbon                                                        urban challenges provide opportunities
                                            technology solutions, innovation and           The establishment of ASCN and ASUS             for enhanced collaboration.
                                            technology will shape the future of cities     in 2018 provided a platform to share
                                            in ASEAN. With technology redefining           best practices and generate more               The prioritisation of actions and the
                                            what is possible for cities to achieve,        opportunities for growth, innovation,          development of ASUS toolkits had
                                            it is essential to build the capacity          capacity-building, and inclusive sustainable   emerged from the finding that many cities
                                            and capability of the region’s human           urban development. The ASCN and ASUS           in ASEAN lack a comprehensive long-term
                                            capital to seize this opportunity.             share a similar framework and focus on         strategy to guide them in implementing
                                                                                           six areas, namely: civic and social; health    their sustainable urbanisation actions or
                                            A mid-term review of the Master Plan
                                            on ASEAN Connectivity (MPAC) 2025
                                            conducted in 2020 showed the increasing                      The establishment of ASCN and ASUS
                                            relevance of connectivity in supporting                      in 2018 provided a platform to share
                                            the socio-economic recovery and
                                            strengthening the resilience of the                          best practices and generate more
                                            ASEAN Member States and their cities                         opportunities for growth, innovation,
                                            as they emerge from the pandemic.
                                            This is also emphasised in the ASEAN
                                                                                                         capacity-building, and inclusive
                                            Comprehensive Recovery Framework                             sustainable urban development.
Photo Credit: © metamorworks/Shutterstock
The Road to Sustainable Cities - THE INSIDE VIEW ASEAN Smart Cities
10   The Inside View

     lack the capacity to develop financially          partners for further technical assistance,    Achieving smart and sustainable
     viable proposals. Cities can use the ASUS         financing, and implementation.                urbanisation will not be easy. The cities
     toolkits to prioritise their sustainable                                                        need to look at their key threats, priorities,
     urbanisation actions as well as develop           In addition, ASEAN is working with the        and goals and identify what resources
     action plans or project proposals relevant        UN-Habitat in preparing for the ASEAN         are required to deliver their smart and
     to their unique contexts. Moreover,               Sustainable Urbanisation Forum in the         sustainable urbanisation vision. It is also
     funders and investors often consider              third quarter of 2021 and the Report on       useful to assign roles and responsibilities
     small-scale city projects unattractive            the State of Urbanisation in ASEAN to be      for individual and collective actions over
     due to the high transaction costs of              completed by the end of the year. The Forum   time and in the event of a shock. The
     evaluating proposals.                             will serve as a multi-stakeholder platform    implementation of ASEAN smart and
                                                       for policy discussions and knowledge          sustainable urbanisation initiatives will
     Developing smart and sustainable                  sharing. The Forum will also provide an       continue to complement other ASEAN
     urbanisation requires a holistic approach.        opportunity for cities to engage partners     efforts on infrastructure, digital connectivity,
     Every city is different. It is essential to       to explore potential cooperation for city     the fourth industrial revolution, and
     appreciate the underlying fabric of a city,       projects, refine and finalise the cities'     mainstreaming gender equality and
     the systems they are in, and the risks they       technical proposals. Meanwhile, the           the rights of persons with disabilities.
     face. Understanding the specific challenges       Report on the State of Urbanisation
     to a particular city and their potential          in ASEAN is intended to give a more           Through collaborations and partnerships,
     impacts is vital for ensuring that the city can   in-depth understanding of where               ASEAN will develop a strong network of
     effectively respond to them. We can learn         ASEAN cities are in terms of sustainable      cities with a pipeline of smart and sustainable
     from the good practices around the world,         urbanisation efforts and what can be          urbanisation projects that will benefit
     which are emerging and evolving. There is         done further to support national and local    the peoples of ASEAN.
     thus a need for concerted multi-sectoral          government endeavours in responding to
     collaboration and partnerships among              the challenges and opportunities within
     different government institutions, private        the ASUS priority actions.                    Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
     sector, non-governmental organisations,
     international organisations, and other
     external partners.

     Hence, ASEAN has collaborated with
     various partners, through ASCN and
     ASUS, to support cities across the region
     in developing action plans, undertaking
     city diagnostics, and developing technical
     project proposals, among other initiatives.

     For instance, in collaboration with
     the United Nations Human Settlements
     Programme (UN-Habitat), ASEAN has been
     working with cities to undertake city
     diagnostic exercises towards developing
     city technical proposals. The city technical
     proposals will help cities in engaging
                                                                                                                                                        Photo Credit: © neoneyesriver/Shutterstock

                                                                                                                          The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Inside View           11

                             Capturing the Urban
                             Opportunity in Southeast Asia
                             MAIMUNAH MOHD SHARIF
                             EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, UNITED NATIONS HUMAN SETTLEMENTS PROGRAMME (UN-HABITAT)

                             Executive Director Maimunah Mohd Sharif shares with
                                                                                        C
                                                                                                 ities worldwide are urbanising at
                                                                                                 a rapid rate. Since 2007, cities have
                             The ASEAN how good urban governance is crucial to ensure
                                                                                                 been home to more than half of the
                             urbanisation leads to equitable and sustainable growth.    world’s population. That share is projected
                                                                                        to rise to 60 per cent by 2030 and to 70 per
                                                                                        cent by 2050, making urbanisation one of
                                                                                        the most significant and defining trends
                                                                                        of the 21st century.

                                                                                        The speed and scale of urbanisation in ASEAN
                                                                                        are quite striking. Today, more than half of the
                                                                                        people in ASEAN live in urban areas, and an
                                                                                        additional 70 million people are estimated to
                                                                                        live in ASEAN cities by 2025, which is equivalent
                                                                                        to more than the current population of all
                                                                                        capital cities in ASEAN. Moreover, urbanisation
                                                                                        in Southeast Asia is taking place across the
                                                                                        urban-rural continuum, from the smallest
                                                                                        and most remote communities to
                                                                                        burgeoning megacities.

                                                                                        How we plan for, manage, and anticipate
                                                                                        urbanisation will shape development
                                                                                        trajectories and the lives of millions. To meet
                                                                                        the needs of our planet and people, cities must
                                                                                        be supported and governed to be sustainable,
                                                                                        resilient, green, healthy, just, inclusive, and safe.

                                                                                        Having had the honour of serving
                                                                                        as the Mayor of Penang, Malaysia, I have
                                                                                        seen firsthand the urban transformations
                                                                                        taking place in my home city and across
                                                                                        Southeast Asia.

                                                                                        The ASEAN Sustainable Urbanisation
                                                                                        Strategy, launched in 2018, is grounded
                                                                                        on a deep understanding and forward-
                                                                                        looking perspective that no country has
Photo Credit: © UN-Habitat

                                                                                        yet achieved high-income status without
                                                                                        high levels of urbanisation. Consequently,
                                                                                        the prosperity of ASEAN is intimately
                                                                                        linked to the prosperity of its cities.

                                                                                        Urbanisation has been a propeller of economic
                                                                                        growth in Southeast Asian cities. Much of this
                                                                                        growth occurs not only in mega-cities such as
12   The Inside View

     Bangkok, Jakarta, and Manila but also in smaller
     and intermediary cities with populations
     between 500,000 and five million.

     Across the region, cities are fulfilling
     their promise as engines of national
     and regional growth, continuing to attract
     households and individuals while offering
     countless economic, social, and cultural
     opportunities. This promise is captured
     in UN-Habitat’s World Cities Report 2020:
     The Value of Sustainable Urbanization, which
     affirms that well-planned, managed, and
     financed cities create unquantifiable value
     that can vastly improve the quality of life.

     However, urbanisation is making
     development challenges more complex,
     not only in terms of demand for better
     housing and basic services provision
     but also with regard to environmental,
     public health, and climate change issues.
     Poverty, informality, and inequality are
     still prevalent across the region. Indeed,
     urbanisation is exerting serious pressure
     on freshwater supplies, resource extraction,
     ecosystems, biodiversity, and health and
     sanitation systems.                                multi-level governance frameworks, and           Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam
                                                        partnerships with relevant national and
     The resource footprint of cities across            local agencies and stakeholders help
     the region is expanding. According to the          deliver results.                                 To understand what is happening in our cities
     ASEAN Sustainable Urbanisation Strategy,                                                            and how we can act, we also must build smarter
     by 2025, waste volume in Southeast Asia            Integrated and inclusive strategic planning      cities that are able to gather and manage data
     is expected to increase by 150 per cent            that responds to and anticipates the needs       for sustainable urban development at the
     from 1995 levels. Many cities in Southeast         of cities can mitigate future challenges and     local level. In collaboration with ASEAN,
     Asia face the existential threat of rising         deliver better urban environments.               UN-Habitat is providing technical support
     sea levels and the increased frequency                                                              to cities in developing viable technical project
     of natural disasters.                              UN-Habitat has supported 56 countries            proposals focused on digital solutions to
                                                        globally in different stages of their national   enhance safety and security in urban areas, in
     So, what are some of the important elements        urban policy development, including              alignment with the priorities indicated by the
     that make up a sustainable city?                   Myanmar and the Philippines.                     ASEAN Sustainable Urbanisation Strategy.

     To provide a fertile ground for sustainable        Strengthening capacity to deliver basic urban    We must also strive for sustainable cities
     growth, cities require holistic approaches         services such as water and sanitation, waste     by exploring critical and emerging policy
     integrating sectoral solutions. Urbanisation       management, mobility, and energy, is critical    opportunities and new ways of thinking
     cannot be addressed in silos.                      to securing improved livelihoods, particularly   and working. The Future of Asian and Pacific
                                                        for marginalised communities. In 2020 alone,     Cities report, produced in collaboration with
     Irrespective of a city’s profile and               500,000 people were reached globally             the United Nations Economic and Social
     demographics, good urban governance                through UN-Habitat’s Urban Basic Services        Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP),
     is a critical enabler of sustainable urban         Trust Fund, set up by UN-Habitat to support      identifies 15 policy pathways that can guide
                                                                                                                                                            Photo Credit: © Holger Mette

     development. Strengthening policies,               member states in addressing the increasing       future urbanisation in the region to deliver on
                                                        deficit in urban basic services in the face of   the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development
                                                        rapid and unplanned urbanisation. In this        and the New Urban Agenda.
                                                        regard, one of our initiatives is the Waste
                                                        Wise Cities Campaign, which brings               These elements for achieving sustainable
                                                        together over 200 cities committed               urbanisation demand greater attention as
                                                        to promoting the 5Rs: Rethink,                   countries globally face the seminal wake-up
                                                        Refuse, Reduce, Reuse, Recycle.                  call of the COVID-19 pandemic. Many cities

                                                                                                                              The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Inside View      13

                                           We must also strive for sustainable
                                           cities by exploring critical and
                                           emerging policy opportunities and
                                           new ways of thinking and working.

                             across Southeast Asia have been hit hard by     The report provides guidance to local,
                             recent waves of COVID-19 cases. Nevertheless,   regional and national governments, and
                             the pandemic must be an opportunity to          practitioners on designing coordinated
                             build more sustainable cities, not just         policies from the local to national levels that
                             in overcoming the current and future            are based on strong local data of more than
                             pandemics but also in responding to             1,700 cities and well-documented evidence.
                             other long-term global stresses.
                                                                             It is encouraging to see the great efforts
                             The UN Secretary-General’s policy brief,        of ASEAN to support cities in achieving           Australia Development Cooperation Program-
                             COVID-19 in an Urbanizing World, and the        sustainable urbanisation and harnessing           Phase II (AADCP II) and collaboration with
                             UN-Habitat COVID-19 Response Plan, aim to       this collective potential.                        various partners.
                             support local government and community-
                             driven solutions in informal settlements;       Sustainable and inclusive urbanisation            Cities across Southeast Asia have an
                             provide urban data, evidence-based              is a key priority to achieve the objectives       immense wealth of lessons and experiences
                             mapping and knowledge for informed              of the Master Plan on ASEAN Connectivity          to share with the world. One example is the
                             decisions; mitigate economic impacts,           2025 and to raise the living standards of         growing effort of ASEAN cities to complete
                             and initiate recovery.                          communities all over Southeast Asia.              their Voluntary Local Review (VLR) of the
                                                                                                                               SDGs. The VLR approach complements
                             The recent UN-Habitat report, Cities            Since 2020, UN-Habitat has been                   Voluntary National Reviews (VNR),
                             and Pandemics: Towards a More Just, Green,      collaborating with ASEAN to accelerate            represents a valuable instrument for
                             and Healthy Future, suggests that there         the implementation of the ASEAN                   cities to monitor their progress towards
                             is an opportunity from the pandemic for         Sustainable Urbanisation Strategy,                sustainable development, and offers fertile
                             cities to seize the moment and enhance          providing technical support to pilot              ground for fruitful exchanges with partners
                             their inclusiveness and sustainability.         cities and bridging knowledge and                 and cities at the national, regional, and
                                                                             lessons learned to regional-scale                 global scale.
                                                                             initiatives. This work is being conducted
                             Urban slum in the Philippines                   with the generous support of the ASEAN-           It gives me great pleasure to welcome
                                                                                                                               cities from across Southeast Asia to the
                                                                                                                               next World Urban Forum 11 (WUF11),
                                                                                                                               to be held in Katowice, Poland, from
                                                                                                                               26 to 30 June 2022, with the theme
                                                                                                                               of Transforming Our Cities for a Better
                                                                                                                               Urban Future.

                                                                                                                               WUF11 presents a timely opportunity
                                                                                                                               for us to come together and share the
                                                                                                                               invaluable lessons learned from the
                                                                                                                               ongoing pandemic, accelerate sustainable
                                                                                                                               urbanisation, and suggest ways cities can
                                                                                                                               be better prepared to address future
                                                                                                                               shocks and challenges.

                                                                                                                               In this spirit of transformative change, we
Photo Credit: © UN-Habitat

                                                                                                                               must continue to look for and implement
                                                                                                                               innovative ways to plan, build, and govern
                                                                                                                               our cities.

                                                                                                                               UN-Habitat stands ready to work in partnership
                                                                                                                               across Southeast Asia towards sustainable
                                                                                                                               urban development and a better quality
                                                                                                                               of life for all.
14   The Inside View

     Viewpoint:

     Hugh Lim
     Executive Director, Centre for Liveable Cities
     Hugh Lim, Executive Director of Centre for Liveable Cities,   He discusses the benefits of transforming
     weighs in on what it takes to build pandemic-proof and        Southeast Asian cities into smart cities,
                                                                   particularly the role that smart solutions
     resilient cities based on the practices that worked and       play in accelerating post-pandemic
     deficiencies that emerged during the COVID-19 pandemic.       recovery and ensuring urban resilience
                                                                   to future crises.

                                                                   COVID-19 spread rapidly in cities
                                                                   and caught the urban population
                                                                   off-guard. What changes—especially
                                                                   in infrastructure, human settlements,
                                                                   and urban systems and logistics—should
                                                                   cities make to keep urban dwellers
                                                                   safe from and more resilient against
                                                                   similar public health emergencies
                                                                   in the future?
                                                                   Lim: Singapore entered the COVID-19
                                                                   pandemic with the benefit of prior
                                                                   experience dealing with the severe acute
                                                                   respiratory syndrome (SARS) outbreak in
                                                                   2003. However, the COVID-19 crisis
                                                                   brought with it even greater risks from
                                                                   the asymptomatic spread, which was
                                                                   different from our previous battle with
                                                                   SARS. This experience has shown us that
                                                                   any new disease outbreak could be very
                                                                   different from the last one.

                                                                   Notwithstanding this, there are steps
                                                                   we can take to build up resilience in the
                                                                   face of future crises, including public
                                                                   health emergencies.

                                                                   First, cities should invest in whole-
                                                                   of-society resilience.
                                                                                                                  Photo Credit: © Centre for Liveable Cities

                                                                   When the pandemic first struck,
                                                                   cities needed to rapidly roll out
                                                                   infrastructure for treatment and
                                                                   quarantine whilst rolling out interventions
                                                                   to promote safe distancing and a clean
                                                                   and safe environment. Such just-in-time
                                                                   responses require cities to invest in
                                                                   building resilience, such as identifying
                                                                   and preparing just-in-case facilities and
                                                                   spaces and developing emergency
                                                                   preparedness mechanisms.

                                                                                       The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Inside View     15

                                                        As an island-city-state, Singapore has limited land to produce
                                                        much of its goods and food, and leverages its connectivity and
                                                        global trade to facilitate supply flows. Keeping supply chains
                                                        resilient is something we pay constant attention to.

                                          This pandemic has also highlighted           it is clear that COVID-19 has accelerated      Above
                                          the importance for cities to invest          digitalisation in our cities. Digitalisation   Singapore
                                          in sufficient social infrastructure such     presents opportunities for greater agility
                                          as healthcare services to support all        in how we plan and programme our               ensure food security, and provide
                                          communities. Otherwise, a crisis may         cities—more spaces can serve multiple          essential goods and services for its
                                          result in uneven outcomes, as well as        purposes, and digital platforms can be         population in the pandemic? What
                                          unwelcome competition for resources.         leveraged to enable places to be more          lessons can cities learn from
                                                                                       flexible in use.                               Singapore’s experience?
                                          Achieving environmental health also                                                         Lim: As an island-city-state, Singapore has
                                          requires a whole-of-community effort.        Similarly, hyper-local living patterns         limited land to produce much of its goods
                                          Aside from investing in cleaning services    observed across cities during lockdowns        and food, and leverages its connectivity
                                          and technology, cities need to think about   highlighted the important role that            and global trade to facilitate supply
                                          how to sustain public hygiene habits and     neighbourhoods play in liveability.            flows. Keeping supply chains resilient is
                                          behaviours, and more generally, build        Cities will need to consider how               something we pay constant attention to.
                                          the trust that is required for adherence     to create better, healthier, more inclusive
                                          to health and safety measures, such          neighbourhoods, with a mix of uses that        Since SARS, Singapore has kept a certain
                                          as the wearing of masks.                     support work and leisure and access to         level of stockpiles for essentials such as
                                                                                       nature, near the home. Planning and            medical supplies. However, the speed
Photo Credit: © Travelpixs/Shutterstock

                                          Important elements like trust and            activating a city for the health of its        and scale of border closures, disruptions
                                          collaboration across society need            residents is not a new theme, but it is        to supply chains and imposition of export
                                          to be built up over time.                    certainly one that has come to the fore        restrictions due to the COVID-19
                                                                                       because of the COVID-19 pandemic.              pandemic were unprecedented.
                                          Second, there is a need for us
                                          to rethink planning paradigms.               The pandemic disrupted the food supply         There are five observations from
                                                                                       chain, affecting farm production, food         our experience.
                                          COVID-19 has shifted the way we live,        processing and manufacturing, transport
                                          work, play, and learn. It is too soon to     and logistics, and consumption. This           First, given the global disruption
                                          conclude the eventual landing for trends     impacted cities the most. How does             in supply chains, keeping a certain
                                          such as working-from-home, but               Singapore handle these disruptions,            amount of stocks for essential goods
16   The Inside View

     like food and medical supplies is a            Fourth, cities need to understand and          Cities should accelerate their
     necessity. Cities may also need flexibility    address risks and interdependencies in         digitalisation plans to better serve
     in land and space usage to cater for surge     essential supply chains. Key strategies to     citizens and residents across age
     requirements. For instance, parts of           mitigate such risks include diversification    groups and income brackets.
     the recently decommissioned                    from any single source, assessing
     Tanjong Pagar Terminal were                    interdependencies in supply chains,            In a post-pandemic recovery, cities
     retrofitted and repurposed into                working closely with different nations to      will need to consider how physical
     a dedicated cold storage facility              keep borders open, and leveraging on the       infrastructure should be planned to
     for vegetables and protein.                    resources of private and non-profit sectors.   include digital infrastructure, to support
                                                                                                   remote working and schooling. Such
     Second, to prepare for future crises,          Fifth, in the medium-term, cities must         digital infrastructure may also support
     cities may need to expand their scope          seek to move towards greater circularity.      remote healthcare and services for
     in stockpiling and have an emergency           Supply chain disruptions highlighted           the elderly at home.
     procurement strategy. Expanding the            the need to promote a more sustainable
     scope of stockpiling will have implications    way of living. A circular system would         There is an increasing opportunity
     on space and infrastructure needs —cities      mean that cities could make resources          for greater digital innovation to meet
     will need to consider how to enlarge the       last longer. Reusing discarded items or        the need for urban services. To respond
     capacity of current storage spaces and         refurbishing is an effective way of reducing   to the challenges of COVID-19 in
     the logistics needed for effective last-mile   dependency on imports. Singapore is            Singapore, for example, applications
     distribution of items. Cities also need to     investing to identify innovative ways to       such as TraceTogether and SafeEntry
     consider emergency procurement strategies      improve recycling and reuse rates such         were extremely important to support
     to respond to disruptions quickly.             as repurposing its incinerator bottom          contact tracing efforts, whilst the
                                                    ash to be used as road construction            Space Out and Safe Distance @ Parks
     Third, land-scarce, high-density cities        material (i.e. NEWSand).                       platforms provided information on
     need to make innovative uses of land                                                          crowd levels so that people could
     and space to ramp up local production          Countries have developed strategies            make informed decisions on their
     to achieve some degree of self-sufficiency     to recover from the COVID-19 crisis and        outdoor visits during periods of
     for essential items. For example, Singapore    emerge even stronger. What role do smart       heightened risk.
     encouraged the development of Integrated       cities development play in post-pandemic
     Construction and Prefabrication Hubs—          recovery and reconstruction?                   The private sector and civil society
     multi-storey manufacturing facilities for      Lim: Technology and digital services           also responded by rolling out new
     building components with a high degree          have become crucial in providing              platforms and apps such as e-payments
     of automation, for more efficient land and     new and safe ways to connect and               for hawkers, delivery services and cloud
     space utilisation, and to reduce wastage       access urban services, and will                kitchens, and community-based apps
     of raw materials.                              continue to do so.                             to match volunteers with seniors
                                                                                                   needing help. Some of these new
                                                                                                   solutions have potentially long-
                                                                                                   lasting implications for how we plan
                                                                                                   and operate our cities in the future.
                                                                                                   For instance, cloud kitchens are not
                                                                                                   new, but their growth has been
                                                                                                   accelerated by COVID-19, as more
                                                                                                   people make use of food delivery
                                                                                                   services in Singapore.

                                                                                                   Importantly, while smart city
                                                                                                   technologies are key enablers
                                                                                                                                                   Photo Credit: © kandl stock/Shutterstock

                                                                                                   for liveable, sustainable, and resilient
                                                                                                   cities of the future, they must be
                                                                                                   accessible to all. The effectiveness
                                                                                                   of digital solutions for the health
                                                                                                   and resilience of a city often depends
                                                                                                   on their acceptance and use by a large
                                                                                                   part of the population. In Singapore,
                                                                                                   “digital ambassadors” assist small
                                                                                                   businesses and the elderly to get
                                                                                                   comfortable with smartphones and
                                                                                                   applications, among other initiatives.

                                                                                                                        The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Inside View       17

                                              Shaping Smarter
                                                                                                                                               Da Lat, Viet Nam

                                              ASEAN Cities
                                                                                                                                               affected by these climate-induced
                                                                                                                                               disasters will come from the region.

                                                                                                                                               The competition for limited resources,
                                                                                                                                               unmanaged waste production, and
                                              The Path Towards Environmentally                                                                 vulnerability to climate risks bring about
                                                                                                                                               serious socioeconomic and governance
                                              Sustainable Cities                                                                               implications, including to key sectors
                                                                                                                                               such as health, employment, and other
                                                                                                                                               social services. Recent efforts towards
                                                           VONG SOK, PHD                                   DWIGHT JASON RONAN                  greener cities recognise the increasing
                                                           HEAD, ENVIRONMENT DIVISION,                     SENIOR OFFICER, ENVIRONMENT
                                                           ASEAN SOCIO-CULTURAL                            DIVISION, ASEAN SOCIO-CULTURAL
                                                                                                                                               importance of maintaining the vital
                                                           COMMUNITY DEPARTMENT                            COMMUNITY DEPARTMENT                ecosystem services of urban environments.
                                                                                                                                               Smart and climate-resilient cities require
                                                                                                                                               an integrated and holistic approach to
                                                                                                                                               urban planning, especially in adopting
                                              The last few decades saw the dramatic expansion                                                  mechanisms to control inputs needed
                                                                                                                                               and outputs produced in these
                                              of megacities in Southeast Asia. The region has one                                              human settlements.
                                              of the fastest growing rates of urbanisation, with more
                                              than half of its residents living in urban areas.                                                Several initiatives have been implemented
                                                                                                                                               by ASEAN to tackle these emerging urban

                                              A
                                                                                                                                               challenges. The ASEAN Socio-Cultural
                                                        SEAN cities, like Manila, Bangkok,     Similarly, metropolitan areas leave larger      Community Blueprint 2025 outlines
                                                        and Jakarta, are also some of the      ecological footprints. Recent estimates from    strategic measures in mainstreaming
                                                        world’s most densely populated         the United Nations suggest that while cities    green growth in urban areas, including
                                              cities with numbers still expected to grow       occupy just 3 per cent of the Earth’s land,     (a) promoting sustainable urbanisation
Photo Credit: © Hien Phung Thu/Shutterstock

                                              due to rapid industrialisation and the influx    they consume about 75 per cent of natural       through participatory and integrated urban
                                              of locals migrating from the countryside. By     resources, produce 50 per cent of all wastes,   planning approaches; (b) enhancing local
                                              2050, six out of 10 people in the region will    and account for 75 per cent of carbon           capacities to promote more liveable cities;
                                              be urban dwellers, according to the UN           emissions. On top of these, many ASEAN          (c) improving multi-stakeholder cooperation
                                              Environment Progamme. This significant           cities are some of the most vulnerable          to ensure equitable access to vital resources;
                                              demographic shift will redefine how the          to natural disasters and climate change.        (d) supporting the development of greener
                                              cities of the future will look like.             Rising sea levels and global warming put        infrastructures; and (e) putting in place
                                                                                               many of the region’s metropolises at risk       enabling policies and institutional
                                              As cities expand, the demand for resources       to more frequent floods, stronger tropical      mechanisms to realise these goals.
                                              also increases, creating a heavier burden on     storms, and prolonged drought. A study
                                              the environment. Larger urban population         cited in the ASEAN Sustainable                  Complementing this, the Master Plan on
                                              translates to a higher demand for clean          Urbanisation Strategy revealed that             ASEAN Connectivity 2025 was also adopted
                                              water, air, energy, and other vital resources.   almost 80 per cent of those worst               to serve as a blueprint for building up regional
18   The Inside View

     Recipients of the ASEAN Environmentally Sustainable Cities Award
                                                                                   connectivity by enhancing infrastructure,
       First ASEAN ESC Awards (2008)
                                                                                   promoting innovations, and boosting people’s
       Brunei Darussalam                Temburong                                  mobility, among other initiatives. In 2018, the
       Cambodia                         Phnom Penh                                 ASEAN Sustainable Infrastructure Strategy
       Indonesia                        Palembang                                  was adopted and the ASEAN Smart Cities
       Lao PDR                          Luang Prabang                              Network was established to support ASEAN
                                                                                   cities in building resilient and sustainable
       Malaysia                         North Kuching City Hall
                                                                                   cities. Both initiatives highlight the value
       Myanmar                          Taungyi                                    of enhancing environmental protection
       Philippines                      Puerto Princesa                            and strengthening urban resilience.
       Singapore                        South West Community Development Council
       Thailand                         Bangkok
                                                                                   Over the years, significant progress has
                                                                                   been made to further support sustainable
       Viet Nam                         Ha Long
                                                                                   urbanisation through the work coordinated
       Second ASEAN ESC Awards (2011)                                              and spearheaded by the ASEAN Working
       Brunei Darussalam                National Housing Scheme Rimba              Group on Environmentally Sustainable
       Cambodia                         Phnom Penh                                 Cities (AWGESC). Specifically, AWGESC
       Indonesia                        Surabaya
                                                                                   has coordinated and implemented
                                                                                   various projects in the region addressing
       Lao PDR                          Xamneau
                                                                                   two priority programmes on Sustainable
       Malaysia                         Perbadanan Putrajaya                       Urban Planning, Development, and
       Myanmar                          Pyin Oo Lwin                               Implementation and Increasing Climate
       Philippines                      Puerto Princesa                            Resilient and Low Carbon Cities.
       Singapore                        South West Community Development Council
                                                                                   Notably, the ASEAN Environmentally
       Thailand                         Phuket
                                                                                   Sustainable Cities (ESC) Award Programme
       Viet Nam                         Danang                                     was launched in 2008 to recognise ASEAN
       Third ASEAN ESC Awards (2014)                                               cities that have adopted eco-friendly policies
       Brunei Darussalam                Bandar Seri Begawan                        and programmes. The ESC Award is held every
                                                                                   four years to encourage urban environmental
       Cambodia                         Battambang Municipality
                                                                                   sustainability in the region by recognising
       Indonesia                        Balikpapan
                                                                                   exemplary efforts and sharing best local
       Lao PDR                          Luang Prabang                              practices in keeping ASEAN cities clean
       Malaysia                         Melaka                                     and green. Forty cities from all 10 ASEAN
       Myanmar                          Yangon                                     Member States have been awarded since this
                                                                                   initiative was launched. In 2011, ASEAN also
       Philippines                      San Carlos
                                                                                   started issuing Certificates of Recognition to
       Singapore                        North West District
                                                                                   small cities (with population size of 20,000–
       Thailand                         Chiang Rai City                            750,000) and big cities (with population size
       Viet Nam                         Hue City                                   of 750,000–1.5 million) for their laudable
       Fourth ASEAN ESC Awards (2017)                                              achievements in three specific criteria: Clean
                                                                                   Air, Clean Land, and Clean Water. Additional
       Brunei Darussalam                Bandar Seri Begawan
                                                                                   consideration is given to those that adopt
       Cambodia                         Kep City
                                                                                   innovative solutions in promoting urban green
       Indonesia                        Tulung Agung                               spaces. To date, 21 ASEAN cities have been
       Lao PDR                          Luang Prabang                              awarded under these categories. The latest
       Malaysia                         Putrajaya                                  set of ASEAN ESC Awards and Certificates of
                                                                                   Recognition will be awarded by October 2021
       Myanmar                          Nay Pyi Taw
                                                                                   back-to-back with the 16th ASEAN Ministerial
       Philippines                      San Carlos
                                                                                   Meeting on Environment in Indonesia. Both
       Singapore                        North West District                        these awards underscore the importance
       Thailand                         Nan Municipality                           of maintaining clean air, land, and water
       Viet Nam                         Da Lat                                     while ASEAN cities pursue sustainable
                                                                                   development. These further support the
                                                                                   AWGESC priorities of strengthening local
                                                                                   capacities in urban planning and building
                                                                                   climate resilient cities.

                                                                                                        The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Inside View           19

                                                              Since 2010, ASEAN has been organising the         to address emerging urban environmental         ASEAN Environmentally Sustainable
                                                              High-level Seminars on Environmentally            issues in the region. EU support also targets   Cities Award 2017
                                                              Sustainable Cities (HLS-SC) for the mutual        promoting sustained green investments and
                                                              exchange of best practices and to foster          forming stronger partnerships among ASEAN
                                                              collaboration among green cities in the           and European cities. Similarly, the ASEAN       Moving towards more environmentally
                                                              region. Every year, this activity gathers         Municipal Solid Waste Management                sustainable and climate-smart cities is
                                                              policymakers, experts, and practitioners          Enhancement (AMUSE), funded by the              increasingly becoming more essential
                                                              from East and Southeast Asian countries to        German Federal Government, is about to be       as urban centres continue to support
                                                              share innovative urban development initiatives,   rolled out soon. Scheduled to be implemented    an ever-growing population. ASEAN cities,
                                                              deepen city-to-city collaboration, and develop    from 2021–2024, this project aims to improve    through the initiatives led by AWGESC, target
                                                              specific recommendations for the East Asia        waste disposal and recycling capabilities of    to further realise these priorities by initiating
                                                              Summit (EAS) Environment Ministers Meeting        key tourist cities in Cambodia, Lao PDR,        activities that will maintain safe and equitable
                                                              to improve the region’s urban resilience. The     Thailand, and Viet Nam.                         access to vital resources; build local urban
                                                              September 2020 EAS HLS-SC, held virtually,                                                        planning capacities; and further enhance
                                                              was attended by more than 100 participants        Going forward, ASEAN is closely working         cities’ climate resilience.
                                                              and yielded significant accomplishments.          with other development partners to finalise
Photo Credit: © Ministry of Development (Brunei Darussalam)

                                                                                                                proposals for more green urban initiatives      Tomorrow’s cities should not only be
                                                              Building on the outcomes of the ASEAN-            in the region. Among these are the ASEAN-       technologically modernised, but should
                                                              Germany Development Partnership’s                 ROK Project on Clean Air for Sustainable        consistently embrace environment-friendly
                                                              Expert Forum in November 2018, the ASEAN-         ASEAN (CASA), which seeks to better             practices to promote urban green spaces
                                                              Germany Project on Urban Climate Resilience       understand the impact of air pollution          and provide clean air, water, and land. Shaping
                                                              also started this year. Designed to build         and propose strategies to minimise its          smarter cities means building economically
                                                              regional and local capacities on climate          impact on the environment and public            productive urban spaces, while ensuring equal
                                                              change adaptation, disaster management,           health, and the China-ASEAN Environment         access to these economic gains and preserving
                                                              and sustainable urban development, this           Outlook 2, which aims to document good          the integrity of its environment.
                                                              initiative involves a series of workshops and     practices of eco-friendly cities in ASEAN
                                                              forums, where outputs will be used to develop     and China and strengthen regional               References:
                                                                                                                                                                UNEP. (2018). Sustainable urban infrastructure transitions
                                                              useful knowledge products.                        cooperation to complement the crucial           in the ASEAN region: A resource perspective. Nairobi:
                                                                                                                role of cities in achieving the Sustainable     UNEP; UN. (2021). Goal 11: Make cities inclusive, safe,
                                                              This year, the implementation of the EU-          Development Goals. Other projects are           resilient, and sustainable. https://www.un.org/
                                                                                                                                                                sustainabledevelopment/cities/; ASEAN Secretariat. (2018).
                                                              supported SMART Green ASEAN Cities is set         also being developed with Member
                                                                                                                                                                ASEAN Sustainable Urbanisation Strategy. https://asean.
                                                              to commence, focusing on promoting the use        States to promote green infrastructure          org/storage/2018/11/ASEAN-Sustainable-Urbanisation-
                                                              of smart technologies and digital solutions       and protect urban biodiversity.                 Strategy-ASUS.pdf
20   The Inside View

     Viewpoint:

     Non Arkaraprasertkul, PhD
     Senior Expert, Smart City Promotion Department
     Digital Economy Promotion Agency (DEPA), Thailand
                                       Dr. Non A serves in the
                                       Smart City Promotion
                                       Department of Thailand’s
                                       Digital Economy Promotion
                                       Agency, where he advocates
                                       the concept and practice of
                                       smart cities. He specialises
                                       in the use of human-centred
                                       design to solve pressing
                                       open-ended problems.
                                       Having lived and worked
                                       overseas, he is constantly
                                       inspired by design,
                                       qualitative research, and
                                       behavioural economics.
                                       Originally trained as an
                                       architect, he holds a
                                       doctorate in anthropology
                                       from Harvard University.

                                       D
                                                r. Non A talks to The ASEAN
                                                about how digital connectivity
                                                transforms and builds sustainable
                                       cities, and what Southeast Asian countries
                                       can do to maximise its benefits, close
                                       the digital divide, and overcome
                                       other barriers.
                                                                                     Photo Credit: © Non Arkaraprasertkul

                                       What are the elements of successful
                                       digital connectivity? How do you think
                                       digital connectivity will transform society
                                       in general and ASEAN in particular?
                                       Non A: Digital connectivity is about
                                       connecting people through digital
                                       means to encourage productive
                                       engagement. We have been living in
                                       the digital age, in which it is difficult
                                       to imagine a life without the convenience
                                       of connecting with people, goods, and

                                                          The ASEAN June-July 2021
The Inside View       21

                                                                                                   the importance of innovation to safeguard
                                                                                                   against so-called “disruption.” Often when
                                                society transforms into one that is efficient      the legacy business is doing well, these
                                                and inclusive, or divisive and vulnerable          organisations and companies take a backseat
                                                depends on the collective measures by              rather than proactively identify the domain
                                                the members of the ASEAN states to                 of risk. The good news is that many
                                                promote digital ecosystems, healthy                organisations are using this moment
services through digital channels.That          competition, and public-private-partnership        to reevaluate their core business, current
said, like all technological advancements,      in the building of a culture of open innovation.   practices, and macroeconomic projections
there are pros and cons. While digital                                                             (e.g., global trends). One obvious example is
technology brings people together,              What stage of the digital connectivity             education, which, though not yet perfect,
it can also divide them, such as through        trajectory do you think most ASEAN                 has never been so flexible and accessible.
the dissemination of false information.         Member States are at today? Do you                 Creators of educational content, too,
So, the goal of digital connectivity is to      agree with the observation that the                have to come up with new succinct and
enhance and expand the scope of its             COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated                  interesting content. Using digital tools to cut
benefits while keeping the negative             countries’ digital transformation?                 down on waste and create new value for
impact in check.                                Non A: In general, ASEAN Member                    consumers, some of these organisations
                                                States are in the expansion stage of digital       are not simply surviving but thriving.
To be connected digitally, you first need       connectivity. Despite news about “unicorn
the proper tools, skills, and infrastructure;   start-ups” being born, bred and heavily            It is remarkable that we have the landmark
the so-called “ecosystem.” Second, a viable     invested in, there is still quite a wide gap       ASEAN Digital Masterplan 2025 (ADM
and competitive market is key to the            on the ground between those who have               2025), the purpose of which is to spearhead
introduction and adoption of superior           and do not have basic access to the digital        the transformation of the ASEAN region
technology. Naturally, both businesses          economy. As the power of digital                   into “a leading digital community and
and consumers are looking for new and           connectivity lies in big data analytics, more      economic bloc, powered by secure and
efficient ways to exchange products and         digital adoption means more diverse sets           transformative digital services, technologies
services. Decades ago, we might have            of data can be collected, analysed, and            and ecosystems.” With the COVID-19
seen some reluctance towards the digital        used to optimise services. Inclusivity, in         pandemic positioned both at the core and
medium because consumers had access             this sense, is not just admirable but has          the periphery of this master plan, it is clear
to a limited amount of information.             the potential to optimise the game for             that the region as a whole has accepted
Moreover, there wasn’t a strong pull of the     the well-being of the citizens.                    the reality of the situation. We need to set
so-called “network effect” to tip the balance                                                      secure, efficient, and inclusive standards
towards digital adoption. Today, both access    Both the market economy and the central            for cross-border exchange and open
to information and the network effect are       governments have played a critical role in         innovation through digital connectivity.
the name of the game. Consumers, therefore,     increasing digital literacy and, therefore,
adapt to means of digital connectivity that     digital activity. With its large population,       What are the roadblocks to digital
provide clear benefits such as convenience,     the ASEAN region has unrivalled potential          connectivity? Do you think that digital
lower cost and environmental friendliness.      to grow, especially if served well by the power    transformation requires a similar cultural
Third, an open innovation platform, such        of digital connectivity. While market forces       shift or changes in societal values and
as open data initiatives, will unleash          should be credited for encouraging many to         norms? How so?
value-based products and services.              learn new skills, governments are mandatory        Non A: As mentioned earlier, the three
                                                enablers in creating a supportive environment      components of digital connectivity are
As the two latest generations of the            through various means such as regulations          the ecosystem, viable market, and open
world’s population (Gen-Z and Gen-Alpha)        and incentives.                                    innovation. These three components
are entering the workforce, they bring a                                                           work synergistically to promote digital
natural inclination towards digitalisation.     There is some truth in the idea that an            connectivity. A delay in establishing any
They will be living in an economic system       unexpected crisis may give rise to an              of these components will certainly result
whereby they act as both informed               essential transformation. Thus, there is           in roadblocks piling up. Looking closely,
consumers and digitally savvy workers.          no doubt that the COVID-19 pandemic                what ties them together is cybersecurity.
It is likely that borderless transactions       has thrown us into the opportunity-in-             Hacking, spamming, and ransomware,
and e-citizenship will become the norm          crisis stage. Organisations and companies          just to name a few, are threats to positive
for these generations. So, whether ASEAN        tend to fail because they underestimate            digital exchange and transaction.
You can also read