Oris Caliber 400 - American Watchmakers - Clockmakers ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
TM March 2021 HOROLOGICAL TIMES Oris Caliber 400 AMERICAN WATCHMAKERS-CLOCKMAKERS INSTITUTE · SETTING SERVICE STANDARDS AND EDUCATING THE HOROLOGICAL COMMUNITY Single Rollers, Double Rollers, and Their Roller Jewels Restoration Projects Done at WOSTEP in 1991 Part 1: Gold Pocket Watch with Carillon
Since 1920 CYCLOMOTION STOCK # ELMA-CYCLOMOTION $1,599 (arms not included) Winds up to 12 to 24 watches Winding speed 1 or 4 rpm Features automatic on & off timer Left or right winding rotation CYCLOMOTION + 6 ARMS ELMA-CYCLO/5190 $1,929 HOLDS 12 WATCHES (as pictured) CYCLOMOTION + 6 ARMS ELMA-CYCLO/5192 $2,109 HOLDS 24 WATCHES JULES BOREL & COMPANY PHONE 800-776-6858 WEB JULESBOREL.COM FAX 800-776-6862
IN THIS VOLUME 45, NUMBER 3, March 2021 Official Publication of the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute AWCI News eBay’s Luxury Watch Market- TM March 2021 EXECUTIVE & EDITORIAL OFFICES Board of Director’s place Exceeds Revenue Goals American Watchmakers- By Kathleen Cardwell Oris Caliber 400 Nominations HOROLOGICAL TIMES AMERICAN WATCHMAKERS-CLOCKMAKERS INSTITUTE · SETTING SERVICE STANDARDS AND EDUCATING THE HOROLOGICAL COMMUNITY Clockmakers Institute (AWCI) page 4 page 30 701 Enterprise Drive Harrison, OH 45030 President’s Message Show Dates: LVMH Watch 866-FOR-AWCI (367-2924) By Justin Harrell, CW21 Week, Watches and Wonders or 513-367-9800 page 5 Geneva, and More Fax 513-367-1414 By Kathleen Cardwell awci@awci.com • www.awci.com www.facebook.com/MyAWCI Affiliate Chapter News page 31 Single Rollers, Double Rollers, and Their Roller Jewels page 41 Restoration Projects Done at WOSTEP in 1991 In Summary Part 1: Gold Pocket Watch with Carillon Donna Hardy Managing Editor New Members/ELM Trust Oris Adds a Small Seconds The Oris Caliber 400. See page 15. Ext. 305 donna@awci.com Donors/Memoriam Complication to the Caliber 400 page 43 By Donna Hardy Janette Torres-Gomez page 32 Columns Graphic Designer & Assistant Technical Support Technical Discussions Watchfinder Collects Watches from From the Workshop Ext. 302 jgomez@awci.com Restoration Projects Done at Single Rollers, Double Rollers, Sellers’ Homes and Their Roller Jewels WOSTEP in 1991 By Donna Hardy By Jack Kurdzionak, CW21, FAWCI Jason Champion, CW21 Part 1: Gold Pocket Watch with page 32 page 23 Education Director and Watchmaking Specialist Ext. 303 jason@awci.com Carillon By Bernhard Stoeber, CW21 Mike Carpenter, CC21 page 9 Patek Philippe Discontinues Nautilus Reference 5711/1A Classifieds Clock Director By Donna Hardy Buy, Sell, Trade, and clocks@awci.com Oris Caliber 400 page 32 Employment Opportunities By Jordan P. Ficklin, CW21 page 44 HOROLOGICAL TIMES page 15 The Deep Space Resonance Watch ADVISORY COMMITTEE Bob Little, CC, CW, Chair Industry News By Donna Hardy AWCI Directory Daniel Benson, CMW page 33 Advertisers’ Index Paul Corn Industry Embraces Online page 46 Andrew DeKeyser, CW21 Platforms Education & Dale LaDue, CMW21 Jason Ziegenbein, CW21 By Andrew DeKeyser, CW21 page 29 Certification Board of Directors page 46 AWCI Educational Calendar Fewer Jewelers Closed Doors in page 6 Fellows 2020, Despite the Pandemic page 46 By Kathleen Cardwell Horological Education Around the World Industry Advisory page 29 Kelloseppäkoulu Reprinting and reproduction is prohibited without written The Finnish School of Watchmaking Board Members permission from the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Espoo, Finland page 46 Institute. Copyright © 2021 by the American Watchmakers- By Kathleen Cardwell Clockmakers Institute. page 35 Horological Times (ISSNO 145-9546) is published monthly and copyrighted by the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers OUR VISION: Institute, 701 Enterprise Drive, Harrison, OH 45030-1696. AWCI’s vision is to have an educated and passionate horological community practicing Subscription price for the public is $175.00 per year the highest standards and with the resources to provide quality goods and services. ($15.00 per copy). Members subscription is $99.00 which is included with annual dues of $175.00. Periodicals post- OUR MISSION: age paid at Harrison, OH 45030 and additional entries. Setting service standards and educating the horological community. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Horological Times, 701 Enterprise Drive, Harrison, OH 45030. Like us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter! Follow us on Instagram! www.facebook.com/HorologicalTimes www.twitter.com/AWCInstitute www.instagram.com/americanwatchmakers Like us on Facebook! Check out our educational videos! www.facebook.com/MyAWCI www.youtube.com/awci/videos 3
You can shape the future of AWCI and the horological industry. The Nominating Committee is now accepting nominations for individuals who would like to serve on the AWCI Board of Directors. Deadline to submit your nomination: April 12, 2021 Who can I nominate? Members may nominate themselves or others they feel are qualified to represent the membership on the board. What are the qualifications? Board members must be willing to serve, have been a member of AWCI for at least one year, and attest to the duties of loyalty, confidentiality, and care. What is required of board members? ; Board members must have email access and check it on a regular basis. They must be able to attend monthly conference calls and travel to attend in person the midyear meeting and the annual meeting of AWCI. ; Before they take office, board members should become familiar with the Constitution & Bylaws of AWCI as well as the basics of parliamentary procedure. ; Board members serve for a term of 3 years. Are board members compensated for their time? Board members are not paid for their time but are compensated for travel and lodging expenses related to their efforts to carry out their duties. It is hard work to serve on the Board of Directors and it takes commitment. However, participating in shaping the future of AWCI and the industry can be incredibly rewarding. How to submit your nomination: Go online: www.awci.com/nomination Scan QR Code: Nomination Form Mail to: Board of Directors Nominating Committee American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute 701 Enterprise Drive Harrison OH 45030 Or email to: nominatingcomm@awci.com Or call: 866-367-2924/513-356-9800 ext. 303 www.awci.com/nomination 4 March 2021
a message from the president JUSTIN HARRELL, CW21 A nother month has passed, There are opportunities and jobs for horologists and our headquarters in available all over this country. How can someone Harrison, Ohio, is gearing start at ground zero in this industry and become up to host one of the largest a clockmaker or watchmaker without attending a cat-herding events of the last full-time program? It is not impossible, but almost. decade. Many famous feline Before the lockdown, both the watch and clock wranglers will be in atten- education committees and the Board of Examiners dance and have met all the were developing tiered programs that would ulti- Justin Harrell jharrell@awci.com flying-saucer vaccination re- mately lead to certification. In the past, a mentor 828-551-0741 quirements. Now, if you’re would be willing to take on an apprentice to get still reading this, you might wonder just what in the started in this field. That meant the mentor would heck is going on. I just wanted to see who, if anyone, be willing to teach the apprentice at a slow pace, is paying attention. and the apprentice would be willing to give his or This month’s message is going to sound like her time to the mentor usually without compen- a broken record, but here goes. I/WE sation. Labor laws and the squeeze of WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU!!! How the American economy have prevented is it possible that only two members have I would many opportunities like that. So, how contacted me after pleas for participation love to see can we sidestep this obstacle? If a men- and input for three months? I’ve put my at least six tor or jewelry store owner could send cell phone number in a magazine for a reason. I/WE WANT TO HEAR FROM candidates an apprentice to AWCI first to get the fundamentals down, then the apprentice YOU!!! This organization is only as good on the could return to the business as an asset. as the level of participation it elicits. Send ballot. That is how tiered certification will work me a note, a question, an idea, anything! for AWCI and the industry. It is all about Please consider running for the Board of Direc- the money. Invest in the right candidate, and AWCI tors. Our nominating committee is looking for vol- will turn that person into a profitable employee for unteers to run as two spots need to be filled. On you. We also planned to have more advanced class- the page opposite, you’ll find all the information you es for those who already hold certifications and need to nominate someone or yourself. Our elec- want to push their skills to the next level. We must tion is going to be slightly delayed this year due to get back on track with both of these goals as soon the inactivity of the institute. If you have run in the as possible. The pendulum has stopped and needs past, please try again. I would love to see at least six some impetus to start again. candidates on the ballot. Since I have been involved Spring is on the horizon, vaccines are rolling out, with AWCI, our Board of Directors has consisted of and watch lovers are as itchy as every other shop- the same few people. It is great that these same peo- per to get back out there, spend a bit, and return to ple are always willing to contribute. However, that some sense of normalcy. Let’s get ready together to does not mean that it’s a “good old boys club” that is take our businesses to the next level after this dark not open to change or new direction. If you have any season. We are the best resource for each other, our interest in contributing to AWCI’s future, I implore industry, and the future of horology. Send me a text, you to put your name in the hat. will ya? Horological Times 5
educational calendar Check out AWCI’s complete line of courses for watchmakers and See our catalog for more! clockmakers! We can use your help AWCI will not be holding classes in Harrison, Ohio, We are always looking to expand our course cata- or on its mobile classroom until projections of the log and educational resources as well as increase our virus subsiding have become more predictable or team of instructors. During this downtime, we want there is a vaccine widely available. In the mean- to develop new courses and find new instructors who time, we invite you to browse our course catalog, will collaborate with us. Reach out to us at education www.awci.com/course-catalog, which offers 46 class- @awci.com if there is a class you would like to col- es for watchmakers, including classes for beginners, laborate on as an instructor. technicians, and, of course, experienced watchmakers We look forward to receiving your class requests who want to sharpen their skills. and we hope to have a new list of classes to offer In the catalog, you’ll find classes on: when the pandemic is under control. h Introduction to Watchmaking h Quartz h Vintage Watch Repair h Tool Making h Precision Timing We also have 46 classes for clockmakers, including classes on: h American Time-and- Strike Movement h Advanced Clock Repair h Introduction to the Lathe 6 March 2021
Reserve your spot today. Contact the education director, Jason Champion, CW21, at 866-FOR-AWCI (367-2924), ext. 303. Prices reflect members’ discount! Contact us so we can help you find the best course suited to your skill level, expertise, and interests. $595 N August Michael will share his knowledge gained from 40 years of experience through his Herschede Tubular Bell Clocks extensive PowerPoint presentation with over 200 photos focusing on examples E 11-13 Instructor: Michael Gainey, CC21 of issues before and after a rebuild that are unique to most common Herschede AWCI Headquarters, Harrison, Ohio Tubular Bell movements. W Come to AWCI’s well-equipped machine shop to join David Lindow for this prac- $595 tical, hands-on class where gearing and gear cutting will be practiced. Students D August Practical Gear Cutting for the Horologist Session 1 will not only learn the basic setups for cutting horological gears, but they’ll also learn multiple approaches to tooling as well as theory from a practical stand- A 11-13 Instructor: David Lindow AWCI Headquarters, Harrison, Ohio point. Students will learn about wheel and pinion engagements and gain a fuller understanding of horological gearing in general. While the focus of the class will be on making gears and pinions, the skills taught will transfer to general repair T and improve the success rate of all clock repairers. E August $595 Practical Gear Cutting for the Horologist S 14-16 Session 2 Instructor: David Lindow See description above. AWCI Headquarters, Harrison, Ohio October WATCH 420S: Vintage Chronograph Short Course $595 Back by popular demand. In this course, you will go through, theoretically and practically, different vintage chronograph calibers with emphasis on trouble- 5-7 Instructor: Bernhard Stoeber, CW21 AWCI Headquarters, Harrison, Ohio shooting, repair, and adjustments to each mechanism. Lemania, Landeron, and Valjoux calibers will be covered. https://www.awci.com/webinars Free/discounted webinars for AWCI members! You asked for it, you got it! Many of you have asked for online education. While AWCI’s in-person education is on a hiatus, you can still learn from our excellent instructors—Tom Schomaker, CMW21; Jason Champion, CW21; Jordan Ficklin, CW21; Bernhard Stoeber, CW21; David LaBounty; and Ken De Lucca. Missed a webinar? No worries, check out the on-demand webinars. Choose a topic from a list of pre-recorded webinars. Here are some of the topics we cover. 5 Watch Basics for Beginners and Collectors 5 Explore Watchmaking 5 Professional Essentials (A Hands-On Digital Webinar for Beginners) 5 Basic Watch Repair Skills 5 Tool Maintenance 5 Hairsprings 5 Workshop 5 Clocks And more! Stay involved, sharpen your skills, ask questions, and so much more! Have a topic in mind for a webinar? Send your suggestions to awci@awci.com! For additional details about specific courses in comprehensive syllabi form, including complete tool lists, visit: www.awci.com/classes or contact the education director, Jason Champion, CW21, at 866-FOR-AWCI (367-2924), ext. 303. For additional calendar events visit: www.awci.com/calendar. Horological Times 7
INNOVATION COMES ONCE. INNOVATING GOES FOREVER. PRECISION IS PRECIOUS. witschi.com Distributed by: Jules Borel & Company: julesborel.com Have you recently renovated your retail store? If your retail store has undergone a transition over the past couple of years, making your watch repair workshop attractively visible from the retail sales floor, we want to hear from you! Send us a couple photos and let us know approximately how much you invested in the renovations and what the impact has been on sales and service revenue. Email Editor@awci.com. 8 March 2021
Technical Discussion: Restoration Projects Done at WOSTEP in 1991, Part 1 Restoration Projects Done at WOSTEP in 1991 Part 1: Gold Pocket Watch with Carillon By Bernhard Stoeber, CW21 Introduction The following series of articles was initially pre- in Neuchatel whenever I traveled to Switzerland. pared as a presentation to be given at AWCI’s 60th- During the following years, our paths also crossed anniversary convention in Cincinnati last March. As a few times in the US. For instance, when we both we all know, the onset of the COVID-19 pandem- were presenters at AWI’s Mid-Atlantic Conference ic forced the convention to be canceled. Late last in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, and at other events. year, HT’s managing editor, Donna Hardy, asked if I grew up in West Germany where my family I had ideas for articles that could be published in owned a watch and jewelry business that my HT. Since it is unclear when it will again be possible grandfather had founded in 1894. Later, my Uncle to have in-person meetings and conventions, I sug- Josef took over. Following his death in 1958, my gested that I write articles based on the presentation parents continued the business. Unfortunately, my that I was going to give at the convention: four res- father passed away in 1965, when I was 12 years old. toration projects done at WOSTEP in 1991. My mother was able to run the business (with the The origin of this story goes back to the summer assistance of a great team of dedicated employees) of 1986 when Antoine Simonin (Tony) and his wife, because she had been involved for many years and Josiane, came to New York to promote WOSTEP. handled the overall sales activity. She was able to This was the first time we met in person, though I put my two brothers through college, and I was had heard a lot about them and their great work at designated next-generation watchmaker, who would WOSTEP. Subsequently, I went to visit WOSTEP continue the business. Fig. 1. Antoine Simonin (right) and the author Fig. 2. My parents’ engagement in 1941 with my at AWI’s Mid-Atlantic Conference in Lancaster, hometown in the background. Pennsylvania. Horological Times 9
Technical Discussion: Restoration Projects Done at WOSTEP in 1991, Part 1 Fig. 3. The family of Theodor Stoeber Sr., ca. 1930. Three watchmakers in one photo: Uncle Josef (top left); my father, Theodor Stoeber Jr. (top right); and my grandfather, Theodor Stoeber Sr. (middle row). Well, life had other plans for me. I did be- After our mother passed away in 1988, my broth- come a watchmaker and passed my German Master ers and I decided to sell the house and family busi- Watchmaker exam in 1975, the same year I started ness to that young couple who had taken over earlier. working for the West-German central service work- I thought about how to honor my family. Eventually, shop of Omega and Tissot. In 1978, I did a three- I decided to invest in my professional training and month internship at Omega in Biel/Bienne, followed applied to WOSTEP for the Course on Complicated by a six-month work stay at Omega in Paris to im- Watches. prove my French. In early 1991, I attended WOSTEP after my In 1980, our mother retired from the business employer at the time, North American Watch and leased it to young a couple with a background Corporation (today The Movado Group), granted in watches and jewelry. In 1983, Omega Switzerland me a five-month leave of absence under very favor- organized an inter-company transfer for me to join able conditions. the Omega affiliate in New York City, and I moved to the US. 10 March 2021
Fig. 4. At the bench at WOSTEP in Neuchatel in May 1991. Gold Pocket Watch with Carillon Description This small, open-face pocket watch with car- illon (music box) was made before 1800 by Antoine Favre in the Vallée de Joux. The push button in the pendant activates the music box on command, and the watch also has an alarm system. The alarm time is indicated by the large, blue hand. The case is made of 18 karat gold and bears a hallmark used after 1797. The white enamel dial has Arabic numerals and an inner track for the alarm. The move- ment has a cylinder escapement and a three- armed brass balance wheel with flat hairspring. Fig. 5. Front view of the watch with chain and Breguet key to wind and set the watch. Horological Times 11
Technical Discussion: Restoration Projects Done at WOSTEP in 1991, Part 1 Fig. 6. The This carillon was described by Alfred back cover Chapuis in his book Histoire de la Boîte à Musique opened. et de Musique Mécanique published in 1955. It There is one appears to be the first time that the drum is arbor to wind vertical instead of horizontal, as is common in the carillon music boxes. barrel and one for the The movement is highly decorated with a going train. floral pattern and has two distinctive sections: the going train wheel (on the right) and the train wheel for the music box (on the left), Figure 9. Fig. 7. Side view of the carillon drum with reeds. Fig. 8. A drawing from the book Histoire de la Boîte à Musique et de Musique Mécanique by Alfred Chapuis. 12 March 2021
Work Performed • Complete service including refinishing of all steel parts and polishing/bluing screws. • New crystal and polished case. According to Tony Simonin, Antoine Favre had left the Vallée de Joux for the Val-de-Travers to ap- prentice as a watchmaker. Upon his return, he and other students who had moved back to the Vallée de Joux started their own watchmaking businesses. The pocket watch described here could be consid- ered one of the first complicated watches produced in the now famous Vallée de Joux, the “Cradle of Complicated Watches,” in Switzerland. Photo Credits Fig. 1—Courtesy of Peter Wittle. Figs. 2 and 3—From the author’s personal archives. Fig. 4—From the author’s WOSTEP reports. Figs. 5 and 6—Histoire de l’horlogerie à la Vallée de Joux by Marcel Piguet. Used with Editions Simonin’s permission. Fig. 7 and 8—From the author’s WOSTEP reports. Fig. 9—See Figures 5 and 6. Figs. 10 and 11—From the author’s WOSTEP reports. Fig. 9. A view of the superbly decorated movement. Fig. 10. The carillon section of the movement without Fig. 11. Under-dial view of the movement. the going train. Bernhard Stoeber is an experienced watchmaker who has worked for more than 40 years for the Swiss watch industry in Europe, the US, and China (with Omega, Movado Group, and Rolex). He retired from his corporate activities in 2018 and now lives in Mount Joy, Pennsylvania. Horological Times 13
FREE on-demand webinars! Take advantage of this great benefit. Once you download the link, you can watch the webinar any time, any place, as often as you like. You’ll also get the PowerPoint slides to keep as well as other handouts. Here are just a couple of the great webinars you have at your disposal. See www.awci.com/educationcareers/webinars/ for more! Lubrication 1: General Principles of Lubrication This webinar, presented by Jason Champion, CW21, is the first in a series of webinars on lubrication for professional watchmakers. Topics include the latest insights from the industry about types of lubricants and their application and general guidelines for applying lubricants when technical documentation is not available. Also covered: • History of watch lubricants • Sliding friction • Capillary action • Best practices • Surface tension • Creeping • Where and when to use lubricants • Stiction • Viscosity • Oils for faster/low-torque and slower/ • Importance of cleanliness • Specific uses for lubricants high-torque situations Handouts • General Lubrication Chart • Moebius Technical Data Sheet—SYNT-HP1300 9104 • Lubrication table • PowerPoint slides • Moebius Technical Data Sheet—SYNT-A-LUBE 9010 AWCI Members—FREE Everyone else—$25 The Chronograph Presented by Jordan Ficklin, CW21, this webinar presents information on the chronograph, including: • The history of the chronograph • Types of chronograph dials • Types of chronograph scales • Types of mechanisms • Operation of the chronograph—including demonstra- tions with slow-motion video • Identifying common chronographs, including ETA 7750 and variants, Omega 861 and 1143, modular chrono- graphs, and Rolex Daytonas 4030 vs 4130 Handout PowerPoint slides AWCI Members—FREE Everyone else—$25
Technical Discussion: Oris Caliber 400 Oris Caliber 400 By Jordan P. Ficklin, CW21 As a watchmaker, I often ignore the hype when a brand announces the release of a new cali- ber. Especially since I know that most brands prob- a solution to a problem that existed when the watch was shipped from the factory. Also, the watch has some interesting innovations I had not seen before. ably won’t sell parts, and I probably won’t get the A full video review of the caliber is available at www. opportunity to ever work on one. For the past cou- youtube.com/prowatches. ple of weeks, however, I have had the opportunity When Oris announced the Caliber 400, one to handle the new Oris Caliber 400. I have put it of the first things I noticed was the interesting through its paces, partially disassembled it, and ana- way they chose to attach the oscillating weight. It lyzed some of the concerns raised by collectors since caught my attention because so many brands are it appeared in the Aquis Date last year. I’m sharing using ball bearings these days, and this movement my experiences with other watchmakers because clearly did not. I was also a little nervous because a what I’ve learned may prevent them from chasing two-dimensional picture doesn’t tell the whole story. Fig. 1. Oris Caliber 400. Photo used with permission https://www.oris.ch/en/press/detail/184/oris-aquis-date-calibre-400 Horological Times 15
Technical Discussion: Oris Caliber 400 Depending on how the clip inter- acted with the movement, it could have been disastrous. They did it right. The oscillating weight is rem- iniscent of so many of the early au- tomatic weights from the 1950s and 1960s that are still around today. The weight is rigidly connected to a tube that slides over a post that is fixed to the watch movement. The clip (as ar- tistic as it is) merely keeps the weight from rising up, and it does that job beautifully. I feel that the overall quality of the Caliber 400 is better than should be expected for a brand’s first in- house caliber. It isn’t perfect, but it is a well-built machine. The finish is quite industrial, which is fitting for a movement that will probably be a workhorse in the Oris lineup. I be- lieve the movement will be durable. Fig. 2. Arrows indicating how to release the stem. One of the items that immediate- ly caught my attention was the detent mechanism for the winding stem. The Caliber 400 Timekeeping features a stem held in place by two posts opposite First and foremost, a watch must keep time. Before each other, one secured with a screw and the other opening up the watch or dismantling the movement, held in place with spring tension. This double mech- I put it on the timing machine to observe its perfor- anism reduces the likelihood that the stem will ac- mance. The watch had an average daily rate of +5 cidently come out of the watch. To release the stem, with a maximum deviation between positions of six loosen the screw first and then press down on the seconds at full wind. detent while pulling on the stem. It looks as if they designed the Caliber 400 with after-sales service in mind. Often brands don’t think about what will happen when the watch needs to be serviced. In this case, how- ever, it is apparent that the needs of the watch- maker were considered. The watch comes apart and goes together easily. Anything that is out of the ordinary is clearly marked to aid the watchmaker while servicing it. For exam- ple, if a watch has two barrels, it can be more difficult to figure out how to release the pow- er stored by the mainsprings before servicing the watch. The click is clearly labeled with an arrow. Also, the double release for the wind- ing stem (a feature exceedingly rare in watch- making) is also well marked. Servicing these watches should be straightforward for any watchmaker. Fig. 3. Arrow indicating how to let down the power. 16 March 2021
watch is capable of storing enough energy and oper- Position Rate ates with sufficient efficiency to deliver the full five- Dial Up +3 day power reserve with a little left in the tank. This Dial Down +5 is important because it means that any issues with Crown Up +9 power reserve are a result of insufficient winding. The quality control test demonstrated that a day of stan- Crown Left +6 dard motion is not enough to fully wind the watch. Crown Down +3 It is, however, enough to both maintain and add ap- proximately an additional day of reserve to the watch, Satisfied with those numbers, I decided to put which varies depending on the customer’s level of the watch through a full quality-control timing check activity. Having run down 48 hours, one day on the while I examined the movement in more detail. For final test only wound up the watch enough for it to the next seven days, I observed the watch’s perfor- run for 95 hours after removing it from the final test. mance, testing both timing and the automatic wind- This may or may not be a deficiency in this watch. ing system. The test consisted of the following: Since the design of an automatic winding system has to balance the need to wind the watch sufficiently Day 1: Fully wind the watch by hand and place dial up. while not causing too much wear, this may be by de- Day 2: Crown left. sign. I mention it because some customers have com- Day 3: 1 rpm final test simulator. plained, and I want to quantify the actual efficiency Day 4: Crown left. of the winding. Having run down 48 hours, one day Day 5: Dial up. on the final test only wound up the watch enough for Day 6: Dial up. it to run for 95 hours after removing it from the final Day 7: Watch stopped. test. But why? Over the first five days of the test, the watch It seems that the automatic winding mecha- averaged just under +5 seconds per day. However, nism on this watch is not as efficient as it needs to when the watch was on the final test, which simu- be (based both on my tests and on the experiences lates the constant motion of a watch on the wrist, of some owners). Two key factors in the design con- the watch neither gained nor lost time. During the tribute to this. First, this watch has a unidirectional sixth day of the test, as the watch wound down, it winding system: winding in one direction and idling gained 17 seconds. or “free-wheeling” in the other direction. Plenty of watch brands and horological textbooks indicate that Position Daily Gain (Loss) unidirectional systems are equally as efficient as bidi- rectional winding systems, but they have the advan- Dial Up +4 tage of being simpler and comprised of fewer parts.1 Stem Left +8 Final Test Simulator +0 Stem Left +11 Dial Up +1 Dial Up +17 Average (five days) +4.8 seconds/day Average (six days) +6.8 seconds/day Power Reserve This seven-day test brought to light one of the com- plaints I have heard from individuals who have pur- chased this watch—they don’t seem to get the full five-day power reserve as advertised by Oris. I fully Fig. 4. The oscillating weight mounted to the wound the movement and observed that it ran for 125 movement. hours before coming to a stop, so we know that the 1. Charles-Andre Reymondin, et al, The Theory of Horology (Neuchâtel: Swiss Federation of Technical Colleges, Watchmakers of Switzerland Training and Educational Program, 2003). Horological Times 17
Technical Discussion: Oris Caliber 400 Fig. 5. Comparing the oscillating weight of the Oris Caliber 400 (bottom) with the ETA 2824 (top). If this is the case, why do so many brands spend move the hand) before pushing the crown back in, the extra money on more complicated bidirectional the hand will not jump. All of this has nothing to do winding systems? Clearly there must be advantages with the five-day power reserve or double barrels. If to a bidirectional winding system. Second, the os- anything, it may be related to their desire to keep the cillating weight is light. In an effort to reduce the watch as slim as possible. Ultimately, this is a result height of the movement, it appears that Oris has of the engagement of the intermediate setting wheels. chosen a weight with limited mass around its perim- When you pull out the crown on most watches, the eter. The weight does have a larger diameter, allow- sliding pinion moves straight in to engage with the ing it to achieve the same moment of inertia as a setting wheel. Or it may swing in on an arc that tran- smaller weight using less mass. But this weight falls sects the center of the setting wheel’s axis of rotation, short. I’m not sure the watch would wind at all if you Figure 6, red circle. In this watch, the arc is too shal- placed it on the inclined table used by Rolex to test low, and the intermediate setting wheel swings in on the function of their winding system. an arc that transects the teeth of the setting wheel, For customers who wear the watch daily, this Figure 6, blue circle, which causes the wheel to ro- won’t be a problem. They can take it off on Friday tate as the two wheels engage or disengage. (This is night, and it will still be running on Monday morn- much easier to see in the video, www.youtube.com ing. By mid-week it should be back up to full wind. /prowatches.) The rotation can be mitigated by having If, however, they have a full box of watches and plan a narrower or shorter tooth profile. to wear it for just one day and then wait four or five days and wear it again for one day, they will likely be disappointed. As a watchmaker, you can’t resolve this. It is inherent in the design of the caliber. Hand Setting Another concern raised by watch owners is the hand setting. When you pull out the crown to set the watch, the minute hand jumps as much as three or four minutes. Even more concerning is that some- times when you push the crown back in after having set the time, the minute hand will jump again (about one minute.) It can be frustrating when, after you have meticulously set the time and made sure that all the hands are in sync, the minute hand jumps! Oris has indicated that this is a result of design decisions made to accommodate the five-day power reserve and the two barrels. Oris has also indicated that the hand jump can be avoided by turning the Fig. 6. Setting mechanism of the Caliber 400. The crown slightly backward before pushing it in. They red circle shows the ideal arc for the engagement are right about the work-around. If, after setting the without rotation. The blue circle shows the arc of the time, you turn back the crown a little (not enough to intermediate setting wheel. 18 March 2021
I believe this problem could have been avoided At first glance, this is a Swiss lever escapement during the design phase and can probably be resolved constructed of silicon. Both the escape wheel and the (or reduced) with some component updates. Ideally, pallet are made from silicon, which offers some ad- Oris would accomplish this without redesigning the vantages in escapements, namely: main plate. Until Oris comes up with an update for the components, turning the crown backwards releas- 1. Silicon has a low coefficient of friction, es the tension and positions the teeth so that they can which means the escapement, without separate without forcing rotation. needing any lubricants, will perform ex- actly the same on the first day of the ser- The Escapement vice interval as it will on the last. For a watchmaker, the most exciting thing about this 2. Silicon is antimagnetic. new watch is the escapement design. It caught me by 3. It can be manufactured to very precise tol- surprise, and I love what they have done. Oris claims erances. to have designed an “entirely new escapement”—and they did. Yes, it is still a Swiss lever escapement, but it Since the first advantage is probably the most im- has some new and innovative features. portant, I was surprised to see lubrication on the es- capement. I can’t say for certain why Oris decided to lubricate the silicon escapement. Perhaps they found it performs even better when lubricated and found that the degradation over time had no significant im- pact on the performance. Maybe the coefficient of friction for this particular formula of silicon isn’t as great as advertised. Ultimately, I think watchmakers know that the main reason the brands are using sil- icon more often is that it is inexpensive and easy to produce. Fig. 7. Illustration of the Caliber 400 escapement. Used with permission https://www.oris.ch/en/press/detail/184/oris-aquis-date-calibre-400 Fig. 8. The escapement of the Caliber 400 with lubrication poorly applied. Horological Times 19
Technical Discussion: Oris Caliber 400 Certainly, the escapement continues to be antimag- Without the escape wheel in the watch, the pallet netic (a fact they advertise heavily), but the third advan- can swing freely from side to side, well beyond the tage is where Oris has made some drastic changes. normal travel of a pallet in a watch. This is because In a traditional Swiss lever escapement, the pal- the banking is built into the pallet itself. Instead of let has two adjustable ruby stones. The only reason an oversized locking face, they have designed a pre- they are adjustable is because with traditional meth- cise locking notch in the pallet. The tooth bottoms ods, it would be nearly impossible (or at least in- out in this notch, limiting the pallet’s travel. This is credibly expensive) to machine the escapement with the first time I have seen this feature in an escape- enough precision to eliminate the need for adjust- ment, and I don’t even know what we should call ments. With silicon components, however, you can it. It fills the role of both the locking face and the achieve amazing precision very inexpensively. Think banking surface. about it: every year the computer industry manufac- I am curious to see how these escapements will tures billions of silicon chips, each with millions of hold up over time. The banking action is the most capacitors etched onto the surface with precision forceful of all the escapement actions. Normally that that rivals anything required in a mechanical device. force is exerted away from any of the critical areas of Using photoetching, two-dimensional components the escapement. In this design, however, the force is like the escape wheel and pallet can be inexpensively absorbed by the escape wheel teeth. Will they hold and precisely produced. Precision is the key word. It up? Only time will tell. is easy to achieve precision of better than 1 micron Overall, it is exciting to see this type of innova- with photoetching. In addition to the adjustable tion in a brand’s initial caliber. I think the Caliber pallet stones, the traditional escapement has either 400 will withstand the test of time. It seems to be de- banking pins or banking surfaces that limit the mo- signed with modularity in mind. We have already seen tion of the pallet. This new escapement from Oris Caliber 401 with a sub-seconds, and I expect we will does not have any traditional banking surfaces. see more complications added to this watch as well. Fig. 9. The notch for locking and banking. Fig. 10. The escapement showing the tooth locked in the notch of the exit stone. Jordan P. Ficklin graduated from the Lititz Watch Technicum with a WOSTEP diploma in 2006. He is a co-owner of the Cincinnati Watch Company where he designs and assembles watches, and the owner of Cincinnati Watch Repair, an indepen- dent watch service center meeting the needs of the microbrand and collector communities. 20 March 2021
RAPIDLY GROWING COMPANY VORTIC WATCH COMPANY SEEKING The Smithsonian Magazine ranked Columbia, PA, among the top 20 best small towns to visit in the United States, in part, because of its strength in history. The National Watch & Clock Museum provides a wealth of information about the art and science of timekeeping. When you can’t visit the museum, Visit NAWCC.ORG check out the webinars and and click EVENTS podcasts about horology to view upcoming for everyone who loves events and classes. watches, clocks, and all things to do with keeping Contact the Education time. Listen on Spotify, Department iTunes, and Sound Cloud. at 717.684.8261, ext. 237 or education@nawcc.org. Lititz Precision Products offers high quality equipment for the watch repair MATADOR 4000 Watch Freedom Ultrasonic Lititz Precision Lititz Wet Pressure Cleaning Machine Small Parts Cleaner Preciso 47 Watch Tester Introducing the ultimate Lititz Precision's NEW Preciso 47 heat Wet Pressure Tester for in manual watch cleaning Freedom affordable source for testing watches, made in the USA machines. Matador 4000 ultrasonic small parts condersation , 120v, by Lititz Precision. Tests up from Lititz Precision Products cleaner saves you made in the USA by to 125 Bar. consists of four stainless steel thousands of dollars! Lititz Precision. 550.000 $3,29500 cleaning/rinsing cups with 590.985 $7,49500 590.767 $43900 one movable ultrasonic transducer head and a variable speed/variable temperature dryer. 590.874 $2,99900 590.874 590.985 590.767 550.000 1-800-487-0408 | CASKER.COM SERVING JEWELERS & WATCHMAKERS SINCE 1927 Horological Times 21
WHY CHOOSE ECKCELLS? STEP UP to the ultimate, fully programmable six-jar cleaning machine. “I have been a watchmaker since 1983, and the Wellner THE WELLNER L1 CLEANING MACHINE Customer Comment: MADE IN GERMANY cleaning machine has the widest range of programmability, best cleaning ability, most complete drying ability, and quietest operation of any cleaning machine I’ve had the One machine opportunity to use. Superior engineering is evident at does it all! every point in both software and hardware. The fact Quietly cleans, that it keeps track of how many washes for each jar of rinses, and dries! solution makes for the greatest ease of serviceability. It is as if a watchmaker designed the machine to suit modern For more information on pricing, options, and production efficiency and the highest performance standards. ” delivery, please contact ~Stan, an AWCI member Jack Kurdzionak 603-726-7646 eckcells@gmail.com Order line open 9 a.m.- 4 p.m., Mon-Fri, 603-726-7646 Email orders and/or questions ANYTIME to eckcells@gmail.com www.eckcells.com Show off Your Passion for Horology-and AWCI! Wear These with Pride! SHOP NOW www.awci.com/online-store while supp lies la st! Horology T-Shirt Become a m ember and save! Cotton/Polyester Blend AWCI Shoulder Bag Available in S, M, L, XL Regular $30 $25.00 – members get free shipping Members $27 The AWCI shoulder bag is the perfect companion to keep everything organized, secured, and readily accessible when away from the shop. Constructed with 600 denier polyester fabric for long-term durability, there Patches is a roomy main compartment with pockets and storage slots for electronic devices, Sew on your apron or lab coat pens/pencils, small tools, business cards, and $5.00 – Members Only supplies. Handy outside storage pockets can carry larger items. A key clip, durable snap buckles, and a removable shoulder strap add additional versatility. The AWCI logo is embroidered directly onto the Rocker $2.00 – Certified Members Only main flap, so it will remain visible for many, many years without peeling or chipping away. Membership Pin Check out our website $12.95 for these and other great items! If you need assistance, contact AWCI at 513-367-9800. 22 March 2021
From the Workshop By Jack Kurdzionak, CW21, FAWCI Single Rollers, Double Rollers, and Their Roller Jewels Previously, the study of roller tables and their jewels the large roller and can be used as a single roller or was included in the curriculum of every watchmak- as part of a double roller which is comprised of the ing school with good reason. A roller was, and still large roller and a small (safety roller). The American is, a component of a balance complete that needs to watch factories used single rollers, one-piece double be removed from the balance complete whenever a rollers, and two-piece double rollers. Some factories balance staff is replaced or when a roller jewel be- called the large roller a roller table while others called comes loose and must be secured with fresh shellac. it the roller. If a roller jewel is broken or missing, the roller jewel needs to be replaced with a properly sized new one, An Evolution of Skills in Roller Jewel and and that involves removing and replacing the roller. Roller Table Services A loose roller table also must be removed so it can be Because the skills needed to be a competent watch- tightened to secure it to the balance staff. maker are constantly evolving, roller jewel and roll- Roller table service was an integral skill needed by er table services have now moved from mainstream a successful watchmaker, and it was a skill supported watchmaking to what I define as traditional or her- by material houses and watchmaking tool suppliers. itage skills. There are numerous reasons for this evo- At that time, material houses could supply roller lution. Watch manufacturers that supply spare parts jewels in every size that a watchmaker would usually are no longer supplying every discreet movement com- need. In addition to roller jewels, rollers complete ponent to watchmakers. Instead, they supply a larger with roller jewels were available for just about every component of the watch that contains more than one application. Tool suppliers contributed their support part. In the past, watchmakers could buy an individ- with an array of specialized tools for servicing rollers. ual roller jewel. As time progressed, they had to buy There were tools for measuring slots on pallet forks a complete roller with a jewel even if only the jewel to determine the size of a needed roller jewel; roller was needed. Now, in many instances, the roller is no table warmers for cementing roller jewels in place longer available except as part of a balance complete. with melted shellac; special stakes and stumps for in- Possible rationales for this change might include stalling roller tables onto the balance staff; and roller requiring fewer items for the spare parts department tightening tools for adjusting loose double rollers. to stock, and a faster, simpler repair for the watch- As I was writing this article, I realized that roller maker. If you need to buy a roller table for a modern nomenclature could be confusing, so before proceed- movement made by ETA or Sellita, I can tell you ing any further I will clarify what a roller is. Unlike that part is no longer available except as a component the Swiss Ebauche Cartel, the American watch fac- of a complete balance.2 A missing or broken roller tories did not have a unified system to either name jewel necessitates the purchase of a complete balance or number their spare parts. Each factory used its except for a few luxury watch manufacturers that own name and numbering system. While there were still supply a roller. It is no surprise that, because of many commonalities in terminology, there were also these changes in material, many watchmakers have numerous variations. Donald de Carle1 defines the little or no experience with roller service. The “tra- roller as a disc with an impulse jewel (roller jewel or ditional” skills are just not required to service most pin) that is attached to a balance wheel. This disc is mechanical watches produced in the past 30 years. 1. Donald de Carle, Watch and Clock Encyclopedia (Bonanza Books, 1977). 2. The same can be said for balance staffs, which are no longer available for ETA or Sellita balances. Horological Times 23
Column: From the Workshop But for those watchmakers Fig. 1 who wish to service vintage and antique watches, there is no substitute for those skills. You cannot call your favorite material supplier and order a new single roller for an 18 size Hamilton movement. You need to repair it. Types of Rollers and Roller Jewels As part of this larger story, it helps to explain the var- ious types of rollers and roller jewels. At one time I assumed that every watch- maker was familiar with the various configurations for rollers until a watchmaker, with decades of experience, Fig. 2 called to place an order for an American pocket watch balance staff. This staff was made in both single and double roller variations, so I asked for the type of roll- er in his watch. He replied that it had a single roller, so I supplied a staff for a single roller balance wheel. After he received it, he called to tell me I had supplied an in- correct staff. I was certain I had sent the correct staff so upon further conversation, I realized he had a one-piece combination double roller rather than a single roller. I exchanged the first staff I had sent for the correct staff and was once again reminded that accurate terminolo- pocket watches and wristwatches, Figure 1.3 These gy is critical when ordering parts. In this case, a double were gradually phased out beginning in the late 19th roller was a single part rather than a single roller. century until they finally became obsolete around Perhaps better than detailed, written explanations, 1925. Double rollers were first used exclusively in a series of pictures can illustrate the various roller the top-grade watches of most companies before configurations and their matching pallet forks. Single they gradually replaced the single rollers in all other rollers were most commonly found in old American grades and sizes of watches, Figure 2.4 3. Waltham Watch Company, Watchmaker’s Handbook. (Waltham, 1945), 11. 4. Waltham Watch Company, Watchmaker’s Handbook. (Waltham, 1945), 12. 24 March 2021
The single roller did double Fig. 3 duty by supporting the roller jewel and preventing the es- capement from overbanking, Figure 3.5 The roller jewel itself is similar in profile to what is used in a double roller, but it may be somewhat longer. The roller jewel’s function is to unlock the escape wheel and transmit energy from the pallet fork to the balance wheel. The passing crescent6 at the edge of the roller provided the safety to prevent overbanking. The Fig. 4 upright guard pin on the pal- let fork blocks the pallet from accidentally moving from one banking pin to the other when the roller jewel is not in the pal- let fork slot. The double roller serves the same dual purpose but sep- arates the two functions. The large disc of the double roller also supports the roller jewel, and the overall appearance of the disc is similar to a single roller, but without the passing crescent on its edge. The small- er disc is the safety roller, which is circular with a passing cres- cent on its edge. The two rollers are mounted in parallel planes on the balance staff. Older watches often had two-piece double rollers, the discs of which were separated by a times, the safety roller blocks the pallet fork from bushing or a shoulder on the balance staff, Figure 4.7 accidentally moving and overbanking. If both roller One-piece double rollers have the two discs separated types perform the same function, why did the manu- by a bushing integral to the two rollers, Figure 3. facturers transition to the double roller, which is more Either execution—single roller or double roll- expensive to manufacture and not as easy to adjust? er—performs the same function, which is to prevent The answer is clear: a double roller is far more reli- overbanking of the escapement. The small safety able than a single roller. Due to the geometry of the roller also has a passing crescent which is positioned two designs, the single roller guard finger was likely directly in line with the axis of the roller jewel. The to bind on the edge of the roller table and stop the passing crescent permits the dart (guard pin), po- watch more often than it would on a double roller. sitioned beneath the pallet fork slot, to pass as the Also, the single roller guard finger could bend slight- roller jewel is engaged with the fork slot. At all other ly and cause the escapement to overbank. 5. Henry B. Fried, The Watch Repairer’s Manual (New York: Van Nostrand, 1961), 96. 6. De Carle defines this as, “The hollow cut into the edge of a roller to permit the passage of the guard pin.” 7. Henry B. Fried, The Watch Repairer’s Manual (New York: Van Nostrand, 1961), 96. Horological Times 25
Column: From the Workshop Asking the Right Questions roller to the staff. On occasion, a small piece of hair Whenever I service an antique or vintage watch has been used to tighten a roller onto a staff. None movement, I always pay close attention to the roller of these methods are acceptable. The roller must be jewel and work through a series of questions. Is it either properly tightened for a secure friction fit or the correct width? Too wide and it will bind in the replaced with a new one. fork slot. Too narrow and power will be wasted. Is its length OK? Too long and it could touch the dart Then and Now of a double roller and stop the watch. The length of Please do not, for one moment, believe that every old- the roller jewel for a single roller is not as critical as time watchmaker was a highly skilled craftsman or, it is for a double roller. It needs to be long enough in today’s lingo, a highly skilled craftsperson. There to function and a little extra length is not detrimen- were skilled watchmakers then and there were others tal. Is the roller jewel secure or loose? A loose roller who probably wished to have been doing something jewel wastes power and causes very erratic timekeep- else besides watchmaking. The late Irving Cohen, a ing. Eventually if it falls out of the roller, the watch watchmaker as well as Boston’s most knowledgeable will stop. Is it even a jewel? Although not common, material dealer, told me that the majority of Boston’s someone has occasionally installed a steel needle or a watchmakers of his era (1912-1994) could not install filed brass pin into the roller table to replace a jewel. a roller jewel. When they needed a roller jewel in- Although these substitutes will function, they will stalled, they went to Cohen or one of a handful of not work well or for an extended period. They need other watchmakers8 who had the necessary skills. to be replaced with a proper roller jewel. Is the sin- Irving and his contemporaries who had those skills gle roller table cracked? Old steel rollers were often have all passed away. For today’s watchmakers who very hard and hence quite brittle. If they were forced wish to service vintage and antique watches, the onto a staff that was slightly oversize, they often skills needed for roller and roller jewel service are a cracked and could become loose on the balance staff. necessity. Cracked rollers must be replaced. Finally, is the roller During the past several months, I have received cemented to the balance staff? If so, it should not several requests from readers to explain how to select, be. An adhesive, such as crystal cement, Super Glue, fit, and cement roller jewels. Watch for these topics epoxy, or shellac, may have been used to cement the in an upcoming issue. 8. Irving’s father, Abraham (1885-1968), worked with Irving and was known in Boston as “The Watchmaker’s Watchmaker” because he possessed almost every special skill needed by watchmakers of his era and was always willing to assist his clients with difficult repairs. Jack Kurdzionak, watchmaker and watch material specialist, owned a Boston-area watch sales and service shop for 40 years. He has a BS (Northeastern University, 1967) and has studied at ETA, WOSTEP, BHI, SGUS, and AWCI, and works for Eckcells Watch Materials. 26 March 2021
Make a Fresh Start! Let AWCI’s resources refresh your business. Referrals. A great benefit of being an AWCI member is being in the Find a Professional directory. Customers can find you simply by visiting www.awci.com or calling AWCI’s office. Let people know your specialties and your certifications. It’s time to update your directory listing now! Technical Guides and References. Don’t waste valuable time searching for the information you need to complete a repair. The Technical Guides and References database is comprehensive, with everything from Accutron to Zenith. No need to search all over the Internet for a tech guide when we’ve got them all in one place—easy to download or view on screen. Marketing Materials. Downloadable marketing materials on the website, such as an AWCI window sticker and an AWCI Certified logo, will let customers know that you are honest, reliable, and the best! Horological Times. HT not only keeps you informed about changes in the industry, it also is the best place to advertise. Use the classifieds to find a job, hire an employee, or buy or sell equipment. Or use a display ad to advertise services and products watchmakers and clockmakers use. www.awci.com is the website you should be using in 2021! would you like to read what makes brits tick? The Horological Journal – published monthly without fail since 1858 – gives you exclusive technical articles and practical updates on clock and watch making. You’ll find news on the latest issue and how to get it at www.bhi.co.uk Horological Times 27
Your watch or clock is valuable. Why take chances? Your local AWCI Certified watchmaker and clockmaker are dedicated to competent and professional service. For more than 60 years, the members of the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute (AWCI) have been providing the highest quality of care and service for watches and clocks. Please use our professional directory to find a watchmaker or clockmaker near you. www.awci.com/find-a-professional Find your local AWCI Certified watchmaker or clockmaker by visiting www.awci.com. American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute Phone: 513-367-9800, ext. 303 * Toll-Free: 866-367-2924 www.awci.com
You can also read