LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE $7

Page created by Daniel Davidson
 
CONTINUE READING
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
#68

SUMMER 2018 • A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE • $7

LOUISIANA
ADAPTS
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
career as a cookbook collaborator. In the Louisiana with Marcelle as a guide, they
                     late 1960s, Sarah Brash, a researcher for knew the subject was worthy of its own
                     Time-Life’s Foods of the World series called book. After Time-Life published Amer-
                     the Picayune. She needed help researching ican Cooking: Creole and Acadian in 1971,
                     Acadian foodways for a cookbook.             Marcelle left journalism for Command-
                        “I didn’t even know I lived in Cajun er’s Palace. She learned the intricacies
                     Country,” Marcelle told me, laughing at of the restaurant industry, working in
                     her twenty-five-year-old self. ‘That was the front of the house, keeping invento-
                     before Paul Prudhomme said there was ry, and catering. In 1984, she began a
                     such a thing as Cajun Country. And I told column, Cooking Creole, for the
                     them I knew everything there was to Times-Picayune.
                     know about it, and they could hire me,         In the months since I traveled to Thi-
                     and they did.”                               bodaux, nine other female food journal-
                        Marcelle, a native of St. Martinville in ists have opened their homes and offices
                     the Bayou Teche region, proved the to me. They have given me time, spare
                     perfect choice. With a photographer, she batteries, cookbooks, and brownie
                     traveled through New Orleans, eating mixes. They have cooked for me. And
                     oysters at Acme and visiting Ella Brennan they have shared stories of their lives
                     at Commander’s Palace. In Cajun country, and extraordinary careers. As a young
                     she procured pigs for boucheries and woman documenting Southern food-
                     crawfish for boils. When Marcelle joined ways, I am grateful for the paths they
                     the project, the Time-Life editors carved, and for the opportunity to follow
                     thought of Cajun and Creole food as a their leads.
                     chapter in a larger book about Southern
                     food. After seeing and tasting south Annemarie Anderson is SFA’s oral historian.

                                               Gravy is a publication of the Southern      JOHN T. EDGE, Editor-in-Chief
                                               Foodways Alliance, a donor supported        info@southernfoodways.org
                     FE AT UR E S              02 First
                                               institute of theHelpings
                                                                Center for the Study        62 The Queer Pleasures
                                                                                           MARY BETH LASSETER, Publisher
                                               of Southern Culture at the University             of Tammy Wynette’s
                                                                                           marybeth@southernfoodways.org
                           28                  of Mississippi.
                                               08 Mixed History
                                               The SFA documents,
                                                     Osayi        studies, and
                                                            Endolyn
                                                                                                 Cooking
                                                                                           SARA CAMP MILAM, Editor
                                                                                                 Mayukh Sen
                      Italian Heaven
                                                                                           saracamp@southernfoodways.org
                                               explores the diverse food cultures of
                                                                                           OSAYI ENDOLYN, Deputy Editor
                        Justin Nystrom         the changing American South. We
                                                14 The
                                               reframe       Riseabout
                                                        dialogues    andtheFall    ofand
                                                                               region       65 Barbekue
                                                                                           osayi@southernfoodways.org
                                               catalyze
                                                     theconversations
                                                            South’s aboutACPracism,
                                                                                  Kings    DANIELLEDaniel  Vaughn
                                                                                                     A. SCRUGGS, Image Editor
                           42                  gender inequity, class discrimination,
                                                     Gustavo Arellano
                                               and other challenges. We curate a
                                                                                           danielle@southernfoodways.org

                      The Taking of            beloved community that gains strength         72 Marcelle
                                                                                           RICHIE             Bienvenu’s
                                                                                                   SWANN, Designer
                                                                                           richieswann@gmail.com
                      Freret Street            22 voice
                                               and   Dare      to Look
                                                          at a well-set table.                   Cajun Chronicles
                                                                                           KATHERINE
                     Maurice Carlos Ruffin            W. Ralph
                                               Your donation  makesEubanks
                                                                    our work possible.            SFAW.Oral
                                                                                                        STEWART,
                                                                                                            History
                                                                                           Fact Checker
                                               Visit southernfoodways.org to make a
Annemarie Anderson

                                               donation or become a member.                MONIQUE LABORDE, Intern
                           52                  ABOVE: Sandy Ha Nguyen, executive director of Coastal
                                               Communities Consulting, Inc. (CCC) speaks to a group of
                      An Industry’s            fisherfolk in Buras, Louisiana. Photo by Claire Bangser.
                            SFA MEMBERSHIP IS OPEN TO ALL. NOT A MEMBER?
                       Heartbeat
                         Join us at southernfoodways.org • info@southernfoodways.org • 662-915-3368
                           Simi Kang           Cover photo by CLAIRE BANGSER
                                                                                                    Summer 2018 | 73
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
First Helpings

                                                                                                                                              FEATURED CONTRIBUTOR

                                                                                                                                              MAURICE
                                                                                                                                              CARLOS RUFFIN

  Lucky Ryan, a
  Vietnamese restaurant
  in Buras, Louisiana

                                                                                                                                       EAST NEW ORLEANS NATIVE          of its kind. Some churches      someone on the street. It’s

             GO AHEAD, SURPRISE ME
                                                                                                                                       Maurice Carlos Ruffin is a       would regularly serve ‘dinner   important, so be aware of the
                                                                                                                                       graduate of the University of    plates,’ a plate piled high     little things like that. Listen
                                                                                                                                       New Orleans MFA program          with fried fish, peas, mac      more than you talk. And if

W
                                                                                                                                       in creative writing. Ruffin is   and cheese, cornbread, for      you want a good meal, make
             ords brought me to               I always urge them to put people and                                                     a nonfiction columnist at the    five or seven bucks. Since      a good friend. Hang around
             food, not the other way          places ahead of flavors.                                                                 Virginia Quarterly Review        Katrina, most of those church   their cousin’s house or aunt’s
                                                                                                                                       and a contributing editor to     congregations have gotten       house. That’ll be where you
             around. I’m a reader before         Of course, there are readers and editors
                                                                                                                                       Know Louisiana magazine.         smaller, and others have        can get a good meal.
I’m an eater. (And I’m definitely a reader    whose tastes run counter to mine. And                                                    His writing has also appeared    disappeared altogether.
before I’m a cook. Ask my husband.) So I      there are writers, from critics to poets                                                 in the LA Times, The Bitter                                      Was there a specific event or
take extra pleasure in this year’s SFA pro-   to novelists, who deliver those gustatory                                                Southerner, Kenyon Review,       What would you say to           news item that motivated you
gramming theme, Food and Literature.          descriptions with precision and beauty.                                                  and Massachusetts Review.        someone who is not from         to write about gentrification
   I care how food tastes. But when I’m       They’re not the primary focus of these                                                   One World Random House           New Orleans and thinking        in New Orleans?
reading, that’s not usually what I’m          pages. And that’s intentional.                                                           will publish Ruffin’s first      about moving to the city?       It wasn’t one moment, but
reading for. Delicious means something           The features in this issue conjure South                                              novel, We Cast a Shadow, in      New Orleans is as welcoming     I’ve been noticing how rapidly
different to everyone, and so it effec-       Louisiana, past, present, and future. They                                               January 2019.                    as it is complex. It’s such a   the change is happening.
tively means nothing. Your savory, your       remind us that the region is constantly                                                                                   unique place, and it can give   I thought I’d see a new
delectable, even your crispy—they might       evolving and adapting—demographically                                                    What’s a dish, from a            you so much. Be prepared        restaurant once a month. It’s
                                                                                                                                       particular restaurant or         to give back. Have a plan       more like once a week. Every
be different from mine. So I’d rather         and even topographically. The ground
                                                                                                                                       kitchen, that you can’t get      for how you can contribute      week, one place is opening
a writer take me to a place I haven’t         shifts beneath the feet of those who make                                                anymore in New Orleans?          to the community and to         and another is closing. They
been, or help me see a familiar place in      it their home. This shifting is sometimes                                                I’m going across the city        disadvantaged people. One       open with a big fanfare and
a new light. Or introduce me to a person      tragic, sometimes triumphant, and it all
                                                                                                         credit

                                                                                                                       Gutter credit

                                                                                                                                       in my head thinking about        of the worst things I see is    close with a whimper. I hardly
                                                                                                   Bangser

whose story will surprise, or delight, or     but ensures that rich and complex stories                                                places I used to go all the      when people come down           have time in my schedule
                                                                                                                  Tad Bartlett
                                                                                            ClaireGutter

inspire me. When I get the chance to          will never stop tumbling to the surface.                                                 time. Barrow’s catfish was       here and don’t know that        to go to some places before
offer advice to writers of food or drink,     —Sara Camp Milam                                                                         really one of a kind, the best   we say hello when we pass       they close.

2 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                                                                      Summer 2018 | 3
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
First Helpings
                                                                                                                                                                     their freedom and go on to
                                                                                                                                                                     open shops of their own.

        FROM BLACK HANDS TO                                                                                                                                          CP: Another interesting
                                                                                                                                                                     component of your work is the

     WHITE MOUTHS: CHARLESTON’S                                                                                                                                      use of sales ads for enslaved
                                                                                                                                                                     cooks. Can you tell me about
                                                                                                                                                                     these ads, how you found

           ENSLAVED COOKS                                                                                                                                            them, and what you learned?

                                                                                                                                                                     KM: The ads were given
                                                                                                                                                                     to me by David Shields [of
Kevin Mitchell, a chef and culinary instructor from Charleston,   professions were closed off to                                                                     the University of South
South Carolina, earned his MA in Southern Studies from the        blacks. And the professions                                                                        Carolina]. These ads are
University of Mississippi this spring. SFA foodways professor     that were seen as more                                                                             interesting because not only
Catarina Passidomo advised Mitchell’s thesis, “From Black         feminine—cooking and                                                                               are they looking for specific
Hands to White Mouths.” Here, a peek into his research.           cleaning and sewing—were                                                                           levels of skilled cooks, these
                                                                  the things that were left open                                                                     skilled cooks were of course
CATARINA PASSIDOMO:              professional cooking for         to blacks. That particular                                                                         enslaved. Just the fact of

                                                                                                                                                                                                                 BUD BREAK
You trace the lineage of         enslaved and free people of      lineage is important to me                                                                         an ad being published in a
black chefs and caterers         color during the antebellum      because it allows me to see                                                                        newspaper for the sale of a
in Charleston back to the        period in Charleston.            where I came from.                                                                                 human body.... I was able to
early nineteenth century.
Discuss the importance of        KEVIN MITCHELL: A lot of         CP: You highlight the ways
                                                                  in which some black cooks
                                                                  used cooking as an avenue
                                                                                                                                                                     go through the ads and see
                                                                                                                                                                     those levels of cooks and
                                                                                                                                                                     understand the amount of
                                                                                                                                                                     skill that each one of them
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 IN VIRGINIA
                                                                  to their freedom. But there                                                                        had. There was a French
                                                                  are complexities, too. Can                                                                         cook, a complete cook, and a     k i r s ty h a r m o n, t h e w i n e m a k e r f o r
                                                                  you talk about Sally Seymour,                                                                      pastry cook. So I was trying     Blenheim Vineyards who studied microbiology
                                                                  a free woman of color who                                                                          to decipher which were           in college, pours rkatsiteli, her pineapple-scent-
                                                                  ran a catering business and                                                                        the most valuable to their
                                                                                                                                                                                                      ed white wine made with grapes first grown in
                                                                  owned slaves?                                                                                      slaveholders and why. Those
                                                                                                                                                                     three types of cooks were
                                                                                                                                                                                                      the Republic of Georgia, and talks about how a
                                                                  KM: I discovered that because                                                                      highly sought after by the       side gig as a calligrapher led to her vocation. Over
                                                                  of the labor market in                                                                             slaveholders. Being able to      lunch at Gabriele Rausse Winery, on a creek bank
                                                                  Charleston at that particular                                                                      have these particular cooks      outside Charlottesville, Virginia, Ian Boden, chef
                                                                                                   LEFT: Courtesy of Kevin Mitchell; RIGHT: Marta Locklear/Stocksy

                                                                  time, those were the only                                                                          gave the slaveholder a certain   and owner of the Shack in nearby Staunton, plates
                                                                  people available to her.                                                                           status, especially when they     a riff on the Lao dish known as larb. It’s made
                                                                  Someone like Sally Seymour                                                                         entertained guests.              with Hickory King grits, Allan Benton’s bacon
                                                                  who would become free and                                                                                                           from Tennessee, and dried shrimp from Louisiana.
                                                                  open up her own restaurant                                                                         Through my research, it          A rhubarb sorbet and a Stinson Vineyards late
                                                                  or pastry shop, of course,                                                                         seems like the pastry cook       harvest petit manseng, flush with tangerine and
                                                                  needed laborers. She needed                                                                        was the most valued and the
                                                                                                                                                                                                      honey, follow cold fried chicken and a killed
                                                                  people to help her run that                                                                        most skilled, because they
                                                                                                                                                                     not only dealt with the sweet
                                                                                                                                                                                                      lettuce salad tossed with fiddleheads. “French
                                                                  shop. And so someone like her
                                                                  was able to, in a sense, reap                                                                      things, but they had to know     winemakers now come here from Burgundy,” says
                                                                  those economic benefits to                                                                         the savory side as well. They    Peter Rausse, son of pioneering Virginia wine-
                                                                  having slave labor. Hopefully,                                                                     also seemed to be the ones       maker Gabriele Rausse. “In Burgundy they make
                                                                  some of those slaves would                                                                         who trained other cooks          Burgundy. Here, we can make anything and ev-
                                                                  have been able to purchase                                                                         behind them.                     erything.” —JTE

4 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                                                                                            Summer 2018 | 5
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
First Helpings

                                                                                                                                                                  SFA EVENTS
                                                                                                                                                                  For details and ticket information, visit southernfoodways.org

                                                                                                                                      JUL 12
                                                                                                                                  Julian Rankin reads and signs
                                                                                                                                                                            AUG 12
                                                                                                                                                                                2018 Egerton
                                                                                                                                                                                                              AUG 13
                                                                                                                                                                                                            Brown in the South Dinner
                                                                                                                                 Catfish Dreams at Square Books                Award Ceremony                       Volume 2
                                                                                                                                      OX FO R D, M S                        NASHVILLE, TN                    NASHVILLE, TN

SMOKE AND MIRRORS                                                                                                                    AUG 16
                                                                                                                                        Barbecue Digest
                                                                                                                                                                         SEP 10-11 OCT 11-13
                                                                                                                                                                              Southern Foodways              2018 Southern Foodways
                                                                                                                                           Volume 2                          Graduate Symposium                  Fall Symposium
                                                                                                                                      M E M P H I S, T N                     OX FO R D, M S                    OX FO R D, M S

b a r b e c u e nat i o n , c u r at e d by   Condensed Smoke, made in Kansas City
the Atlanta History Center, charts a          around 1900, promised: “This bottle will
cultural timeline of this fabled American     smoke a barrel of meat, cheaper, safer,
craft. Twenty years in the making, the        and quicker than the old way.”
inclusive and expansive exhibit opened
this May and closes next June. Here are       Women get the last laugh                                                                                            In 2018, the SFA explores literature and
highlights:                                   Printed in block letters across one wall is
                                              a bold declaration: outdoor cooking is
                                                                                                                                                                      food, twinned cultural expressions.
The material culture game                     man’s work. The curators —Jonathan
is strong                                     Scott, Jim Auchmutey, and Craig Pascoe—
Ogle a chopping block, worn concave
from cleaver work, loaned from Skylight
Inn of Ayden, North Carolina; a burn
                                              have subversively positioned that quote,
                                              from a 1941 James Beard book, above a
                                              majestic image of a woman pitmaster, her
                                                                                                                                                                                                BECOME A
barrel, rusted to a beautiful auburn,
signed by Rodney Scott of Charleston,
South Carolina; and a fleet of portable
                                              arms raised high at a 1970s Harlem
                                              community barbecue.                                                                                                                               MEMBER          AT
                                                                                                                                                                                                SOUTHERNFOODWAYS. ORG
patio smokers, including an aluminum          As a bonus, the Atlanta History Center
                                                                                            Jason Hales/Atlanta History Center

Char-Broil model from 1948 that               has tapped a variety of SFA work for the
resembles a wheeled trash can and             exhibit, including a documentary film on                                                                                                          SFA members receive a
features a chopping block rear spoiler.       Helen’s Bar-B-Que in Brownsville, TN.
                                              To watch Helen Turner work, step to one                                                                                                            subscription to Gravy
Honest barbecue has long                      of the woodsmoke-perfumed viewing
been imperiled                                theaters, set in a makeshift pit bank (or
                                                                                                                                                                                                  and other benefits.
The wrapper on a bottle of Wright’s           visit southernfoodways.org). —JTE

6 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                                                                        Summer 2018 | 7
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
Future South
                                                                                                           Blood on the Leaves, a Mai Tai twist,      the restaurant opened, after he’d honed
                                                                                                        featured St. Croix rum and pecan orgeat.      skills at the high-volume Proud Larry’s
                                                                                                        Bullock & Dabney was a mash-up of the         (and geeked out on liqueurs and infusions
                                                                                                        Corpse Reviver and Mint Julep, flushed        at home).
                                                                                                        with bourbon, Bénédictine, rhubarb, and          His bar program is one of many bright
                                                                                                        citrus. The Clyde began with blanco           spots at Saint Leo, named a 2017 Best
                                                                                                        tequila, mellowed by pinot noir, and floral   New Restaurant semifinalist by the James
                                                                                                        rooibos tea. (I’m Not Your) Negroni riffed    Beard Foundation. They grew popular
                                                                                                        on the classic, boasting gin infused with     serving wood-fired pizzas—the burrata
                                                                                                        West African grains of paradise. Black        and soppressata with chili flakes is my
                                                                                                        Wall Street blended the Black Manhattan       standing order when I’m in town.
                                                                                                        and Whiskey Sour with bourbon, amaro,            Early on, I fell for Stinchcomb’s Golden
                                                                                                        lemon, and a wine float.                      Rule, made with blanco tequila, yellow
                                                                                                           Eleven days later, after Saint Leo re-     Chartreuse and dry Curaçao. The Grown
                                                                                                        ceived multiple calls threatening protest,    Simba, an early drink, referenced a song
                                                                                                        owner Emily Blount and Stinchcomb, the        by rapper J. Cole. If you were in on the
                                                                                                        restaurant’s beverage director, pulled the    head nod, snaps to you. If you liked the
                                                                                                        special cocktail menu. A bar guest had        flip-style drink—gin, sweet and dry ver-
                                                                                                        posted an image of the menu on Snapchat;      mouths, orange juice, egg yolk, and
                                                                                                        others posted to Facebook. People were        grated nutmeg—great. If you inquired
                                                                                                        offended. Observers wondered who wrote        about the name so Stinchcomb could
                                                                                                        the menu and what was meant by it. The        nerdily quote lyrics as he’s apt to do, all
                                                                                                        comments were swift. How could they?          the better.
                                                                                                        Whose idea was this? Boycott! Blount and         He’s dropped a hip-hop or pop-culture
                                                                                                        Stinchcomb surveyed the sudden change         drink reference on every seasonal menu
                                                                                                        of events. How did this happen? The Black     since the first day of service. Almost two
                                                                                                        History Month menu had seemed like a          years into his tenure, he took the next
                                                               The Clyde at Saint Leo                   good idea.                                    step. Joe Stinchcomb presented a portrait
                                                                                                                                                      of America as seen through the eyes of
                                                                                                        stinchcomb, twenty-eight years                a black man.
                                                                                                        old, is a passionate man. His words

                   MIXED HISTORY
            Can cocktails serve up more than booze?
                                                                                                        tumble into each other; his bespectacled
                                                                                                        eyes brighten when he talks. He grew up
                                                                                                        an Air Force brat, and spent time in
                                                                                                                                                      stinchcomb had studied Louis-
                                                                                                                                                      ville-native Tom Bullock’s The Ideal
                                                                                                                                                      Bartender, the first cocktail recipe book
                                                                                                        Germany, Croatia, Colorado Springs. For       published by an African American. He’d
                                                                                                        a time, he lived in Fayetteville, Georgia,    read W.E.B. Du Bois’ 1903 classic tome
                            BY OSAYI ENDOLYN                                                            where his father had been born. His           The Souls of Black Folk, an underread

O
                                                                                                        grandfather, for whom he is named, was        masterpiece. Stinchcomb was especially
         n february 1 of this year, saint leo, an italian-inspired                                      a Montford Point Marine, one of the all-      taken with Du Bois’ term “double con-
         restaurant in Oxford, Mississippi, introduced five drinks to its seasonal                      black recruitment group that integrated       sciousness.” He understood the idea of
         menu. The heading read black history month cocktails february                                  the Corps in the early 1940s.                 dividing his identity on the basis of race,
2018 by joe stinchcomb. Informed enthusiasts might have read what followed                              After Stinchcomb graduated from the           as a black man in a service role in a pre-
                                                                                        Osayi Endolyn

as a curious and challenging lineup. But then, generally speaking, most diners                          University of Mississippi in 2013, he took    dominantly white Mississippi restaurant.
aren’t informed enthusiasts.                                                                            up bartending. Blount hired him when          He’d been inspired to think of his role as

8 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                                  Summer 2018 | 9
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
Future South
an African American bartender in the                                                                    Blood on the Leaves. It references Billie      was saying, ‘I’m free! I’m my own person!’
South as more than a job. He saw his
work as a continuation of a rich cultural        “I wanted people                                       Holiday’s 1939 haunting classic, Strange
                                                                                                        Fruit, which confronts the legacy of
                                                                                                                                                       The focus was not ‘Negro.’”
                                                                                                                                                          Negro can be fraught, despite its
legacy. He’d recently attended BevCon           to feel how I feel,”                                    lynching in America. With the new Na-          ongoing use in black vernacular among
in Charleston, where he heard historian
David Wondrich and bartender Duane               Stinchcomb said.                                       tional Memorial for Peace and Justice in
                                                                                                        Montgomery, we have just begun to do
                                                                                                                                                       select company. Some of this is cultural,
                                                                                                                                                       and some is generational. New Orleans
Sylvestre present on underreported                 “I didn’t get a                                      the necessary societal work to heal from       chef Leah Chase recently told me, unre-
drinks history. Stinchcomb aimed to use
his station at Saint Leo, which borders         blueprint on this.”                                     this terrorism.                                lated to this incident, that she preferred
                                                                                                                                                       the term. In her day, she said, they were
the Courthouse Square in Oxford, to                                                                     Southern trees bear strange fruit              just colored. “But anyone could be
acknowledge and celebrate African                                                                       Blood on the leaves and blood at the root      ‘colored,’” she told me. “At least with
American heritage in all its complexities.   received more eyes on it than Stinchcomb                   Black bodies swinging in the southern          Negro, it felt like something.”
He developed this menu, which he taught      had anticipated. Some of the most vocal                    breeze                                            For others, the most objectionable
to a receptive and curious staff, to high-   critics were liberal arts faculty at the                   Strange fruit hanging from the poplar          drink was Black Wall Street, which ref-
light the achievement, struggle, and         University of Mississippi. The cocktail                    trees                                          erences the early-twentieth-century
sacrifice of black people in the United      menu had no glossary, summary, or ad-                                                                     black community in the Greenwood
States. He hoped it would encourage all      ditional context, leaving intention open                     Stinchcomb used rum to evoke the             district of Tulsa, Oklahoma. (It was once
people to sit up, sip slowly, and reflect.   to interpretation. Online, people couldn’t                 enslavement of Africans in the Caribbe-        called Negro Wall Street.) Black Wall
                                             discern that the menu author was a black                   an. Blood orange symbolized the exoti-         Street was one of the most notable and
through snapshots of the menu                man—and when they found out, it just                       cism of blackness. It is constantly desired,   successful examples of African Ameri-
and paraphrased status updates on Face-      complicated the narrative. Stinchcomb                      for example, in sports—but also forbid-        can–led business districts in the country,
book, Instagram, and Snapchat, Saint         admits a written statement might have                      den. He chose pecans to make orgeat in         replete with physicians, realtors, lawyers,
Leo’s Black History Month cocktail menu      been useful, but he had his reasons for                    place of almonds because pecans are            and other fixtures of a vibrant, up-
                                             leaving one out.                                           native to the South. Stinchcomb told me        ward-bound economy. But, as the elders
                         Joe Stinchcomb        “I wanted people to feel how I feel as                   that a university instructor said the drink    say, we can’t have nothin’. Between May
                                             a black person in America,” Stinchcomb                     commodified black pain and suffering.          31 and June 1, 1921, police and Tulsa na-
                                             said. “I didn’t get a blueprint on this. I                   (I’m Not Your) Negroni rankled, too.         tional guardsmen, with help from neigh-
                                             wasn’t told how to navigate these waters.”                 Stiff and complex, the drink relies on a       boring white residents, razed the neigh-
                                             Those waters run deep: White patrons                       cherry-infused Campari that rounds out         borhood. Black businesses and homes
                                             sometimes call him “boy” to get his at-                    the peppery cardamom of the grains of          were looted and burned. Hundreds of
                                             tention. He is a rare black bartender on                   paradise. Thematically, Stinchcomb was         people were killed. Thousands were
                                             the Square in a town where many black                      referencing the Raoul Peck film I Am Not       rendered homeless. It’s still sometimes
                                             laborers work in food service. There’s                     Your Negro, a 2016 documentary based           called a “race riot,” but it was an envy-fu-
                                             the psychic stress of seeing people who                    on James Baldwin’s unfinished manu-            eled massacre. Colson Whitehead’s most
                                             look like you constantly hauled off and                    script. Some black people were disturbed       recent novel, The Underground Railroad,
                                             communally policed for golfing slowly,                     by the play on “Negro”—some later ad-          features a scene that mimics this devas-
                                             for behaving age appropriately in grade                    mitted they didn’t realize Negroni was         tating event.
                                             school, for waiting on friends at Star-                    also the name of an Italian cocktail,             A common complaint about the menu
                                             bucks, or for pushing one’s infant in a                    which, given the context of the beverage       and its uncomfortable references was
                                             stroller in a public park—in daylight. “I                  menu, might seem obvious. But it under-        that people don’t go to bars to learn about
                                             wanted people to think, ‘why do I have                     scores how quickly emotions around race        mass murder. No one wants racial ani-
                                             this awkward feeling, this discomfort?’”                   can blind us to closer reads. Stinchcomb       mosity with their $10 cocktail, some
                                                                                          Timothy Ivy

                                               For some black people, their shock was                   says they missed the point. “I was hoping      argued. But Stinchcomb hoped the drink
                                             formed by the first drink on the menu,                     people would focus on ‘your.’ Baldwin          would spark awareness in the pride and

                                                                                                                                                                           Summer 2018 | 11
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
Future South
                                                                                                                                   Blood on the Leaves
ingenuity that preceded the bitter end            friend in the whole world.                                                                                history of genocide and enslavement.
to Black Wall Street. Why does black              Damn, I love Clyde! So does                                                                               The piece earned him a Pulitzer Prize.
achievement vex so many white people?             everybody else, coloreds and                                                                              In 2014, contemporary artist Kara Walker
Stinchcomb leaned back in his chair,              whites. What would this town                                                                              was praised for her large-scale installa-
reflecting on the drink and why it con-           be without him? If we didn’t like                                                                         tion at the site of Brooklyn’s old Domino
jured so much anger. “It’s big, it’s black,       the ol’ mayor so much, we’d run                                                                           Sugar factory, A Subtlety, or The Marvel-
and it’s rich.”                                   Clyde. Hell, still may.”                                                                                  ous Sugar Baby. In The New Yorker, Walk-
   By way of the Bullock & Dabney drink,                                                                                                                    er’s seventy-five-foot-wide, nude, sug-
Stinchcomb aimed to introduce guests          we’re primed to note matters of race                                                                          ar-coated sphinx was “triumphant.”
to Tom Bullock and John Dabney. A             and privilege like these. And we should.                                                                         Stinchcomb was scolded for using the
veteran of the St. Louis Country Club in      In 2015 at a Berkeley, California café,                                                                       bar as a tableau to discuss difficult sub-
Missouri, Bullock published his drinks        wait staff “shooed” comedian W. Kamau                                                                         jects in black history. But the works by
manual in 1917. Dabney, born enslaved         Bell from talking to a white woman                                                                            Marsalis and Walker, and countless
in Richmond, Virginia, was a celebrated       holding a baby, and her friends. He wrote                                                                     others, also interpret historical pain.
caterer and social figure. A master bar-      about it, the post went viral, and the                                                                        That pain, while not wholly defining, is
tender known for his Mint Juleps, he          business was soundly critcized. Bell is a                                                                     integral to the multigenerational black
used his bartending tips, which his owner     black man who had just dined at the                                                                           experience in America. We grapple with
allowed him to keep, to secure his wife’s     restaurant; the white woman was his                                                                           it because it’s alive, right now.
freedom, his mother’s, and finally his        wife, the baby their child. Citing a failure
own. That’s a hell of a lot of drinks. And    to rebound from the bad press, the café                                                                       w e e k s a f t e r t h e buzz quieted,
it’s a nod to the double-edged role that      closed this past April. Bell had initially                                                                    Stinchcomb was in the alley behind Saint
tipped wages played during slavery—and        received widespread support, but he says                                                                      Leo when a thirtysomething black man
still play now.                               some of those supporters, many of them                                                                        rolled up on his bicycle. He wanted to
   The Clyde is named for Clyde Goolsby,      white, now blame him for the closure.                                                                         bum a cigarette; Stinchcomb found him
who owned the Prince Albert Lounge at           From my computer screen, Saint Leo’s                                                                        one. The man asked if he was that bar-
the Oxford Holiday Inn. In the 1980s,         harshest critics seemed to be people who                     knowing of the limits between black and          tender. He’d never been to the restaurant,
Goolsby was famous for his Singapore          had never been to the restaurant; a                          white people. Blackness in America has           but had heard of the ordeal. He asked
Slings and margaritas. “I had to pay          number of them appeared never to have                        always been judged by degrees, but I’ve          Stinchcomb why he’d write a “fucked-up-
homage to the trendsetter in this town        visited Oxford. Stinchcomb said black                        never considered regionalism as a mitigat-       ass menu” and said that he was boycotting
for me,” Stinchcomb says. The pinot noir      people told him that his menu couldn’t                       ing factor of black identity. A few days after   the restaurant because of their insensi-
in the Bullock & Dabney pairs beautiful-      have any positive impact in a town like                      pulling the menu, Stinchcomb reinstated          tivity. Stinchcomb retrieved the old cock-
ly with the rooibos, lime, and bitters.       this. “Maybe Memphis or Jackson. Maybe                       Bullock & Dabney and The Clyde. The              tail menu and walked the man through it.
Stinchcomb identifies with Goolsby and        Brooklyn. Not in Oxford,” he recounted.                      drinks were celebratory and broadly per-         The man was attentive. “Is this a fucked-
what he must have overcome to own a bar       People said he should have hosted a                          ceived as noncontroversial. And, he felt,        up-ass menu?” Stinchcomb asked.
in town. In Willie Morris’ essay collection   dinner, a pop-up, maybe off-site and away                    they were damn good recipes.                        “I don’t know. It’s still kind of fucked
Shifting Interludes, an unnamed custom-       from Saint Leo and the Square, where he                                                                       up though,” the man replied.
er describes his relationship to Goolsby      could present his themed menu.                               if food and beverage is the cul-                    “Our history always has been,” Stinch-
in a piece called “Coming on Back.”             Others questioned his background. In the                   tural laboratory we’re saying it can be,         comb said.
                                              hubbub, a black writer friend from this                      then why do we struggle with the idea               Stinchcomb invited the bicyclist to
    “I don’t quite know how to say            region argued that Stinchcomb’s menu and                     that drinks can serve as a text for complex      come see him sometime—at the bar. He
    this,” a white merchant tells me,         my openness to it were a result of our not                   ideas? We give music, art, and television        said to him, “You can’t boycott a place
    “because I’m an old country boy           being born and raised in the South (I’m from                 plenty of leeway. Trumpeter and com-             you’ve never been.”
                                                                                             Timothy Ivy

    and I grew up the way it was              California). She felt that being black and                   poser Wynton Marsalis’ 1997 epic, Blood
    down here, but Clyde’s my best            from the South afforded her an inherent                      on the Fields, dealt with America's              Osayi Endolyn is deputy editor for Gravy.

12 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                                      Summer 2018 | 13
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
Good Ol' Chico

THE RISE AND FALL OF THE
SOUTH’S ACP KINGS
How one town’s restauranteros built an empire
BY GUSTAVO ARELLANO

O
          f f t h e i n t e r s t at e 2 8 5      Over the past forty years, men and
          Buford Highway exit in Dora-          women from the pueblo have opened hun-
          ville, Georgia, stands Monterrey      dreds of Mexican restaurants across the
Mexican Restaurant. Business is brisk           South and beyond. The names of the
on a Saturday evening as waiters deliver        chains change across the country, but the
steaming platters of enchiladas, burritos,      menus remain nearly the same, with
and fajitas to mostly non-Latino diners.        entrées like the Speedy Gonzales (a taco,
   This type of sit-down Mexican spot,          an enchilada, and either beans or rice) and
with its bingo-card menu of combo plat-         ACP (arroz con pollo, made with grilled
ters swimming in cheese sauce, is déclassé      chicken and rice, drowned in a cheese
among Mexicans but still popular in small-      sauce somewhere between paste and
town America. A bartender pours frozen          pudding.) The latter is a uniquely Sur-Mex
margaritas into giant glasses. Televisions      dish rarely found outside the region.
broadcast soccer matches. Christmas               Back in San José, as the exodus began,
lights hang across the ceiling. The rest of     a pattern emerged: A man moved to el
the decor is similarly “Mexican”—maps           Norte for a guaranteed job at a restaurant
of states, sombreros, neon beer signs.          owned by a fellow townsman. He worked
   A framed painting depicts a tree-filled      for a couple of years, learned the business
plaza and a looming Catholic church.            from sink to safe, and saved his money.
Customers may not think much of it. But         He opened a Monterrey Mexican Restau-
this art is a hieroglyph; to the trained eye,   rant in a Southern town where Mexican
it reveals the history of the Mexican           restaurants were rare, and called his
restaurant industry in the South, and the       family to come and help. One restaurant
saga of the two men who started it.             often led to more. The owner joined the
   The painting depicts San José de la          American middle class and gave jobs to
Paz, a town of just over one thousand in        new arrivals. Repeat.
the state of Jalisco. To make their for-          San José became so well known in
                                                                                              Illustrations by Ran Zheng

tunes in the United States, natives have        Jalisco that the demonym for its towns-
left it nearly empty. Instead of working        people became restauranteros. Today, as
stereotypical immigrant jobs in factories       newer arrivals spread their cuisines
or fields, San José de la Paz residents         across the South, the San José de la Paz
build American dining empires.                  model slowly fades. Forty-five years ago,

14 | southernfoodways.org
LOUISIANA - #68 SUMMER 2018 A QUARTERLY PUBLICATION FROM THE SOUTHERN FOODWAYS ALLIANCE
Good Ol' Chico
two former friends went to war to rule          brawny; the photo that accompanies                                                         workers to open restaurants in partner-
Atlanta’s Mexican food industry. Their          Macias’ naturalization petition shows                                                      ship with him. In the deals, Raúl retained
tortillas-and-tacos race would transform        him in a sporty V-neck T-shirt, a slight                                                   the rights to the name “Monterrey,” sold
their hometown—and el Sur.                      smile hinting at his confidence.                                                           them ingredients from his wholesale food
                                                   According to family members, Macias                                                     company, made all the collective business
san josé de la paz is in Los Altos,             and a friend drove down to Atlanta to                                                      decisions, and reaped much of the profits.
the highlands of Jalisco. The state is the      accompany a coworker who transferred          with his first Monterrey Mexican restau-     He soon claimed interest in at least six-
birthplace of tequila and mariachi. Los         within the company. Macias, who loved         rant. It opened just off Buford Highway in   ty-five Monterrey companies in North
Altos occupies the same space in the            to cook, asked for a transfer as well. He     the city of Chamblee. He followed two        Carolina and Tennessee.
Mexican imagination that Appalachia does        saw an opportunity. Mexican food options      years later with a Monterrey in Doraville,     “He didn’t care much about the quality
in the American mind. In Los Altos, the         in the city were nearly nonexistent then.     a two-minute drive from El Toro #2. By       of the food,” says Martin. “He opened
people connect their identity to the region’s      José Macias opened Acapulco in 1973        then, Macias had three. Atlanta’s Mexican    and opened places. He was like, ‘Give me
mountains and agave fields. Native hooch        near downtown Atlanta with Raúl León.         restaurant war was on.                       my profit.’ But a lot of people made it
flows freely, and soaring music tells tales     The two knew each other from San José.           The El Toro and Monterrey chains          big,” Martin adds. “They did it with ease.”
of love, adventure, and pride.                  Back home, León had become a delegado         competed for workers, suppliers, loca-
                                                municipal—the Mexican equivalent of a         tions, and especially for customers. They    by the late 1980s, Atlanta journalists
                                                mayoral appointee—in charge of infra-         poached family members from each             began to note the transnational entre-
                                                structure projects. He knew how to build      other. Martin Macias, José’s youngest        preneurial spirit of San José de la Paz
                                                things. Macias invited León to go into        brother, first worked for León because       natives. Mexican restaurant listings in
                                                business with him. The cantina tried to       he paid more. “I stayed until José com-      the Atlanta Yellow Pages, once sparse,
                                                cater to the few Mexicans who lived in        plained to our mom, ‘Make him work for       numbered over a hundred, many founded
                                                Atlanta at the time, but it closed within     us!’” says Martin, now owner of El Rey       by El Toro or Monterrey alumni.
                                                a year. Not too long after, José Macias       del Taco in Doraville. “But Raúl gave us        The Atlanta market became so satu-
                                                and Raúl Leon, business partners and          a lot of opportunities.”                     rated that restauranteros staked out their
   “I’m alteño, of the good guys/by birth-      friends, split. No one knows why.                In the late 1970s, most Mexicans in       own fiefdoms. In 1986, Jesus Arellano
right,” sang Mexican music legend Jorge            In 1974, Macias opened the first El Toro   Atlanta lived in one of a dozen or so        opened El Rodeo in Roanoke, Virginia,
Negrete in his 1940s hit “Esos Altos de         in a former motel diner off Buford            apartment complexes in Grant Park, one       after a San José de la Paz friend in Atlanta
Jalisco” (“Those Jalisco Highlands”).           Highway. He picked the name because           of the city’s oldest neighborhoods. Every    urged him to find an area where there
“And when I talk about my homeland/             it was easy for Americans to pronounce.       Sunday, San José de la Paz natives would     was no competition. Arellano went on
My heart enlarges.” Despite its beauty,         There were several manufacturing plants       relax in a nearby park and grill carne       to own thirty restaurants. One of his em-
life in San José was tough. Many of its         and factories near that stretch of Buford—    asada. Mexicans were a rarity. “Back         ployees, José Isabel Ayala, broke off to
men began to trek to the United States          GM and GE and Frito-Lay. It was a             then, people would tell us, ‘You don’t       start El Dorado in Raleigh, North Caro-
in the 1950s as part of the bracero             perfect place to lure hungry workers who      look Mexican,’” Martin Macias says with      lina, in 1988; there are seven today.
program, which allowed Mexicans to              wanted lunch or an after-shift drink.         a laugh. “‘You have no sombrero. You
legally work under contract. One of them           Macias explicitly changed recipes to       have green eyes. You’re Italian!’”
was Jesús Macias, the father of José            appeal to American palates. His menus            More El Toros and Monterreys opened.
Macias, a grocer who seasonally picked          displayed phonetic pronunciations of          José and Raúl brought in more relatives
avocados and grapes in California.              now-common dishes like chalupas and           and friends to work their outposts. The
   The oldest of ten siblings, José Macias      quesadillas. Flour tortillas superseded       Macias clan opened restaurants in Sa-
joined the wave in 1951 at age fourteen.        corn. Tacos came in hard shells. And          vannah, Charleston, and Orlando. Former
He bounced between the United States            cheese smothered everything.                  employees opened still more with their
and Mexico before he found a factory job           Macias opened a second El Toro a couple    blessings, sticking mostly to the ever-ex-
in Chicago in the 1960s, a gig secured by       of miles up Buford Highway in Doraville       panding Atlanta metro area.
a countryman. At 5'6", he was short but         two years later. In 1977, León responded         Raúl was ambitious. He convinced

16 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                      Summer 2018 | 17
Good Ol' Chico
                                               codified the term los hijos ausentes and       believe in hard work.” By then, the
                                               featured a list of fifty-four restauranteros   Morning News reported, San José de la
                                               who owned a combined one hundred               Paz expats ran at least five hundred forty
                                               ninety-seven restaurants in Georgia,           restaurants across the South and beyond.
                                               North Carolina, and Tennessee. Thir-
                                               ty-eight of the migrants had at least two
                                               locations; Macias and Leon had twelve
                                               and thirty-three, respectively.
                                                                                              “You forget that legacy
                                                  “People from San José de la Paz aren’t      until people remind you.
                                               going to beg for a job [in the United
                                               States],” the Mi Pueblo authors bragged,
                                                                                              You stay in awe that people
                                               because “they come with their country-         know about your family.”
                                               men…And if they give a helping hand to
                                               any Mexicans, they definitely give it to
                                               those from the pueblo.”                        today, business is brisk at El Rey             retired to their homes north of the city
                                                  After building his empire, Leon re-         del Taco on Buford Highway in Doraville.       in Gwinnett County, which they bought
                                               turned to San José in 1986 to serve, again,    On a Sunday afternoon, waiters deliver         at the height of El Toro’s success in the
  José Ibarra, another El Rodeo alum,          as a delegado. Macias, meanwhile, earned       steaming platters of alambres, a hot           1980s. The last El Toro closed a couple
born about forty-five minutes to the           acclaim in the United States. “José is like    skillet of beef, chicken, or chorizo (or all   of years ago.
south of San José, opened his own El           a donkey that learned to play the flute,”      three) with a choice of house-made corn           José died in 2006 of diabetes. The
Rodeos in Raleigh, North Carolina, as          a cousin joked to Nation’s Restaurant          or flour tortillas. The crowd is almost        Atlanta Journal-Constitution did not mark
well as a more upscale restaurant, La          News in a 1990 article. By 1992, his Chara     exclusively Latino.                            his passing with an obituary. Back in 1992,
Rancherita. “A lot of people saw that a        Enterprises (a reference to his nickname,        El Rey del Taco occupies the building        he had asked the family to split up their
lot of people did good,” says Jesús León.      “Charabasco,” a pun on the small fishes        where José Macias opened the second            twenty-one restaurants among themselves
A second cousin of Raúl’s, he founded          he caught as a kid) cracked Hispanic Busi-     El Toro. The owner is Martin Macias,           and give them new names (Martin
the El Caporal chain in the early 1990s        ness Magazine’s Top 500 Latino-owned           José’s brother, who helped create a            renamed his Los Loros—“Parrots”—so he
in Louisville, Kentucky. His sister’s          companies in the United States. Annual         soccer culture in the region when he           didn’t have to pay too much to change his
husband founded the El Nopal chain,            sales hit $5.7 million. He split his time      began sponsoring Latino youth and adult        marquees). His restaurant in San José de
which now has nearly thirty locations          between Mexico and Atlanta, and opened         soccer leagues in the early 1990s. He was      la Paz closed. “He made bad business
across Kentucky and Indiana. “And it           a restaurant in Guadalajara called El Toro     one of Atlanta’s first restaurateurs to        decisions,” Martin stated plainly.
extended and it extended, and slowly           de Don José, with a large outdoor patio,       open a true taquería when he debuted              El Toro’s legacy lives on. When Martin
almost everyone got into the restaurant        traditional Jaliscan food like birria and      Los Rayos in 1995. “My brother was the         moved two years ago to a new house, “All
industry,” says Jesús.                         tacos, and an evening mariachi extrava-        pioneer of Tex-Mex in Atlanta,” Martin         my neighbors were El Toro customers,” he
                                               ganza. When the Georgia Dome stadium           says, “and I was a pioneer of taquerías.”      says in amazement. “When they found out
sa n j o s é t r a ns f o r m e d. Los hijos   debuted in 1992, El Toro opened a stall,         He’s one of the last Macias siblings to      who I was, they said, ‘Oh, we used to go to
ausentes—“the absent sons”—remitted            although the AJC dismissed the skimpy          own a restaurant; nearly everyone else         El Toro #1.’ You forget that legacy until
money to Mexico to improve infrastruc-         chicken fajitas as a “rip-off.”                                                               people remind you,” Martin says. “You stay
ture and renovate ancestral homes. When           The San José de la Paz dynasty became                                                      in awe that people know about your family.”
los Macias returned in the mid-1980s, a        so famous that the Dallas Morning News                                                           Raúl León spent the last years of his
brass band greeted them at the Guadala-        cited the restauranteros as a success story                                                   life appealing a $208,324 civil judgment
jara Airport. In San José, extended family     in a 1999 multipart series on how                                                             against him for breach of fiduciary duty
threw a massive party at the Macias ranch.     Mexican migration had changed the                                                             and fraud, filed by a distant relative who
  In 1994, the town published a book,          United States. “Deep down,” Macias told                                                       opened a restaurant for him in Wise,
San José de la Paz, Mi Pueblo, which           them, “we’re still humble people who                                                          Virginia. A 2006 court decision upheld

18 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                       Summer 2018 | 19
Good Ol' Chico
the initial ruling, and critiqued Leon’s      continued opening restaurants creating
business philosophy. The plaintiffs “both     what started as a family business into a
regarded Raúl as their ‘patrone,’ or          chain. All restaurants are owned and op-
patron, a person who gives instructions
and tells people what to do, a boss to be
                                              erated mostly by family.” None returned
                                              my requests for comment.
                                                                                                      SUPPORT SFA
followed without question.” The judge           The original Monterrey is now an                sfa is at the forefront of the regional foodways field.
included a disturbing footnote: León died     abandoned building. A new shopping                We lead dialogue about American food culture. Membership
of a methamphetamine overdose in 2001.        plaza dominated by Asian businesses               dollars account for only 5% of SFA’s annual operating budget.
                                              displaced the first El Toro. The parking          Philanthropic gifts fund SFA’s work, including oral history,
many in the second generation of the          lot was pink with the labels of burnt fire-       film, and publishing.
San José de la Paz diaspora continue in       crackers the last time I visited, a day after
their parents’ footsteps. In Louisville,      the Chinese New Year. I try to imagine                                     Please make a gift to SFA.
Fabián León, the son of Jesús, runs The       the area as it was forty years ago, when                                   Of any amount. It all counts.
Ville Taqueria, where he braises carnitas     José Macias and Raúl León were young                                       click the donate button on
in bourbon and mixes margaritas with the      and ambitious yet didn’t know that they’d                                  southernfoodways.org to help us
same. He reaps the transformation that        change the South’s palate and its restau-                                  tell more true and complicated
his ancestral village wrought in the South.   rant landscape forever.                                                    stories about the American South.
   “Back in the 1990s, my dad told me that      Then I recall a stanza to a corrido in-
Preston Highway, where he first opened        cluded in San José de la Paz, Mi Pueblo.
[his] restaurant, was gonna be another        “To my absent brothers/I recommend
little Mexican village, like in Chicago,”     this,” the song goes. “That, although you
Fabián said in a 2015 SFA oral history. “He   may be far away/Don’t forget your
said that we’re gonna bring a lot of people   pueblo.” At this point in the town’s
here. And I didn’t understand it [then],      history, the foods that originated with
but I see [now] what he was talking about.”   the men and women of San José de la
   Monterrey restaurants and their spinoffs   Paz are as signal in the modern-day South
still do business across the country. Each    as Nashville hot chicken. Somewhere, I
sports the same simple logo of a sombre-      think, as I drive to El Rey del Taco for
ro on top of a serape, with “Monterrey”       one more meal before flying home to
above it in red, cursive font. Dozens of      California, José and Raúl must be smiling,
websites for different branches describe      plotting to open more restaurants.
their history this way: “Monterrey Mexican      It’s easy to dismiss San José's restau-
Restaurant was first opened in Doraville      ranteros as men and women who
in the 1970s. From there, Mr. Raúl Leon       watered down their culture for gringos.
                                              Indeed, Mexicans within and outside
                                              the South dismiss ACP as inauthentic
                                              when I describe the dish. But restau-
                                              ranteros proved a valuable lesson: If
                                              Mexicans could become successful and
                                              integrate themselves into the American
                                              South, then there’s cheese-covered hope         Stories about the changing American South through the foods we eat.
                                              for the rest of us.                                                 Available on iTunes or at southernfoodways.org.

                                              Gustavo Arellano is Gravy’s columnist.

20 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                        Summer 2018 | 21
Documentary

                                                                                                                                                        DARE TO LOOK
                                                                                                                                                          Al Clayton and the
                                                                                                                                                        photography of hunger
                                                                                                                                                         BY W. RALPH EUBANKS

                                                                                                       P
                                                                                                               hotographs affect the body as much as they do the mind.
                                                                                                               First an image falls within your direct field of vision, providing all the raw
                                                                                                               details the brain in turn processes. Then the visual impact of what you see
                                                                                                       affects the body on an emotional level, sometimes leading to a descent into per-
                                                                                                       sonal experience or memory, making the image either compelling or repellant.
                                                                                                       In turn, a wounding or personally touching detail in an image might establish a
                                                                                                       strong emotional connection with a photograph. Finally there come the more

                            Photos © Al Clayton, used with permission of Al Clayton Photography, LLC
                                                                                                       cerebral questions of historical context and provenance—when the photograph
                                                                                                       was taken, who took the image, how did they know the subject or place. They
                                                                                                       allow the viewer to reckon with the image in a more analytical way, thus separat-
                                                                                                       ing the visual and aesthetic cues from the emotional ones.

                                                                                                          This is a long way of saying that per-           The men, women, and children in Clay-
                                                                                                       ception is not a passive act. What we see        ton’s photographs gaze directly at the
                                                                                                       is equally as important as the way we see        camera. “It was rare for me to not want
                                                                                                       it and the way we feel after seeing it. That     to have eye contact with my subject,” the
                                                                                                       is why it is difficult to look at Al Clayton’s   photographer told NPR’s Michele Norris
                                                                                                       images from Still Hungry in America and          in 2006. As he took his photographs,
                                                                                                       not react emotionally to them. These             Clayton asked his subjects what their
                                                                                                       images don’t tug at your heartstrings—           lives were like, who they were, and who
                                                                                                       they hit squarely in the gut. And they elicit    they wanted to be. Clayton’s engagement
                                                                                                       thought and dialogue about their topic.          with those he portrayed gives these

22 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                                 Summer 2018 | 23
Documentary
images their profound intimacy.                     slowly and cumulatively, to guide the        Robert Coles’ text, but also for Clayton’s
   Clayton’s photographs deal with a topic          viewer through the range of emotional        photographs. Yes, the shacks he photo-
that was difficult for viewers to confront          and cerebral reactions to the images. The    graphs do signal to readers that the topic
in 1968 and is still difficult fifty years later:   reason these images remain relevant today    of this book is poverty. But it’s not until
the existence of hungry Americans who               has everything to do with the intimacy of    more than twenty pages into the book
live in poverty and see no way to escape            their composition and with his desire to     that an image reveals how hunger is en-
from it. Both yesterday and today, the              capture visual truth rather than pure, raw   tangled with poverty. Clayton captured
hungry seem to live on a hidden plane,              emotion or cloying sentimentality. The       an open refrigerator perched on a
whether it’s the homeless person we ca-             power of Clayton’s photographs derives       wooden floor, and its contents include
sually stroll past on a city street or the          from his daring. He commands us to look      little that looks edible, with the exception
rusting house trailers we ignore that               and captures images inside the frame that    of a jar of baby food and pieces of what
punctuate the Southern landscape.                   appeal to both the head and the heart.       looks like crookneck squash. A young
Poverty is still invisible, and Clayton               Clayton begins Still Hungry in America     child stands in front of the door, a spoon
sought to make it visible.                          with a wide-angle examination of the         lying near his bare feet. He looks direct-
   Clayton understood this hidden nature            landscape. The opening lines make this       ly at the camera. The photograph feels
of hunger and poverty. He knew that he              clear:                                       organic in its composition rather than
could not convey this world purely by                                                            intentional.
evoking an emotional reaction with his                The following photographs move from           Clayton often photographed what
images, which would be easy to do by                  neighborhoods to people, from chil-        caught his eye when he walked into a             Clayton commands
filling them with the standard tropes of                                                         room and then what hit his eye next, and
poverty: tattered clothes, dirty faces, dis-
                                                      dren to parents to grandparents, from
                                                      rural areas to cities, from the past—and   kept going in the same manner. On the              us to look and
tended bellies. Yes, you will find those              still present—realities of farm life to    opposite page he captures a few govern-         captures images that
well-known signs and symbols of poverty                                                          ment-issued commodity items in a still
in the pages of Still Hungry in America,
                                                      the new realities that factories and
                                                      urban ghettos present.                     life: flour, perhaps some cornmeal, and          appeal to both the
but Clayton does not lead off with them.                                                         a few canned items. That follows with            head and the heart.
Instead, he builds his visual narrative             That statement sets the tone not only for    an image of a man standing over a
                                                                                                 wood-burning stove, wood stacked pre-
                                                                                                 cariously nearby. In just three images,        of three friends with third-degree burns
                                                                                                 Clayton communicates the daily peril           similar to those Clayton documented
                                                                                                 these families confront of having enough       with his camera.
                                                                                                 to eat, the substandard conditions in             Photographs provide evidence. Clayton
                                                                                                 which they live, and that what little they     sought to provide evidence of hunger
                                                                                                 own could go up in smoke at any moment.        and poverty—as well as the precarious-
                                                                                                    For anyone who remembers wood-              ness of the circumstances of poverty.
                                                                                                 stoves, you probably know they were the        These images urge the viewer to ask two
                                                                                                 culprit in many a house fire. I know this      questions: First, what are the economic
                                                                                                 because several classmates in my small         mechanisms that led to the circumstanc-
                                                                                                 Mississippi town in the 1960s were             es depicted here? And second, what are
                                                                                                 burned out of their homes by the chance        the structures that keep this hunger and
                                                                                                 combination of a stray spark from a wood       poverty in place?
                                                                                                 stove and a highly flammable item                 Robert Coles’ text provides informa-
                                                                                                 nearby. Sometimes it was an item of            tion for readers about the cycle of poverty
                                                                                                 clothing that went up in flames, which         as well as the nutritional and medical
                                                                                                 is why my memory surfaces the names            issues that afflict the men, women, and

24 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                          Summer 2018 | 25
Documentary

      Contemporary photographs of hunger
       would look different: We would see
       how the obesity epidemic threatens
        the lives of our poorest citizens.
children Clayton photographs. He              1930s, documentary photography has
focuses on the voices of the people on        played a role in examining cultural and
the page, which help to shape the way         political issues, whether it was Richard
we see and interpret the photographs.         Wright’s 12 Million Black Voices (1941)
Coles also realizes the limitations of what   on how Jim Crow traveled north with
the written word can do. He writes, “A        the Great Migration, Zora Neale Hur-
published photograph, in contrast to a        ston’s stories of voodoo in Tell My Horse
documentary—whether written or                (1937), or Erskine Caldwell and Margaret
filmed—makes a condition available for        Bourke-White’s Depression-era images
permanent inspection. A doctor’s report,      in You Have Seen Their Faces (1937). Of
no matter how well written and clinical-      course, the most famous of these projects
ly rich, still needs the reader’s imagina-    from the 1930s is James Agee and Walker
tion.” In other words, Clayton’s photo-       Evans’ Let Us Now Praise Famous Men.
graphs serve as a means of getting us to      This work significantly influenced social     wrote about one of the final photo shoots   NPR in 2006. His use of intimacy rather
inhabit the world of poverty that we          documentation and photography. As             with the Hale County tenant farmers:        than detachment gives his photographs
might otherwise overlook. A photograph        James Agee states flatly in the preface,      “Walker setting up the terrible structure   their power.
is the ultimate way of showing, not telling   “the camera seems to me…the central           of the tripod crested by the black square      Contemporary photographs of hunger
us, the narrative of poverty in America.      instrument of our time.”                      heavy head, dangerous as that of a          and poverty would look different. We
   Since it came to prominence in the            Al Clayton’s photography relates to        hunchback, of the camera; stooping          would see how the obesity epidemic—
                                              the work of Walker Evans. Both seek to        beneath cloak and cloud of wicked cloth,    which is a result of providing inexpensive
                                              create a dialectic of the visual and the      and twisting buttons; a witchcraft pre-     and marginally nutritious food to the same
                                              verbal to confront a larger social issue.     paring, closer than keenest ice, and        population that once had a scarcity of
                                              But that is where the similarities end.       incalculably cruel.”                        food—threatens the lives of our poorest
                                              Clayton takes an object lesson from             Agee’s observation of Evans stands        citizens. But Clayton’s images still connect
                                              Evans’ work: Whereas Evans chose to           in contrast to the way Clayton thought      with the present. They provide evidence
                                              make detachment part of the composi-          of his work. “The face of a hungry child    of how we got to where we are today. And
                                              tion of his images—Evans was famous-          or their demeanor just really prints on     they tell us the dangers of looking away
                                              ly realistic, reserved, and reticent in his   me. It’s unforgettable,” Clayton said to    rather than daring to look.
                                              approach to photography—Clayton
                                              made a conscious choice to engage with        W. Ralph Eubanks is a visiting professor of Southern Studies at the University of
                                              his subjects. Over the course of their        Mississippi and author of the memoirs Ever Is a Long Time and The House at the
                                              work together in the Alabama Black            End of the Road.
                                              Belt, Walker Evans withdrew as James
                                              Agee engaged. Evans’s stark images were       The University of Georgia Press published a new edition of Still Hungry in America
                                              sometimes at odds with Agee’s floral          in March 2018, as part of the Southern Foodways Alliance Studies in Culture,
                                              and engaged text. Here is what Agee           People, and Place.

26 | southernfoodways.org                                                                                                                                  Summer 2018 | 27
You can also read