UNI NOVA - Universität Basel
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
UNI NOVA University of Basel Research Magazine — N°137 / May 2021 Remembering and forgetting. In conversation Debate Album Essay Democracy in the Can Switzerland Virtual The philosophy digital maelstrom. stamp out COVID-19? papyrus puzzle. of the crisis. UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 1
Ihr monatlicher Kulturüberblick für Basel und Region. Jahresabo 11 Ausgaben, CHF 88.– Schnupperabo 4 Ausgaben, CHF 20.– Jetzt Abo bestelle n. www.programmzeitung.ch/Abos 2 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
Editorial Team Contributors to this issue What we retain. 1 Do you remember how natural, how comparatively tranquil everyday life was before the coronavirus pandemic? What parts do you recall most fondly? Is it your travels, your gatherings with friends, complete with a hug and 2 a kiss on the cheek, or is it the concerts, parties and festivals? And when the global crisis is finally over, what will you remember from this time? Nobody is going to forget this pandemic. It will become a facet of our memory, a part of our past that shapes 3 the picture we paint of ourselves. It is to this ability we possess – to retain experiences and information as well as to tidy up the archives of our minds – an ability so 1 Astrid Nippoldt has been drawing por- central to our lives, that we dedicate our current issue. traits for UNI NOVA since 2015. In this Here, we examine research projects on early childhood issue, she has provided an illustrated memory and on people who are unable to forget. infographic to accompany the dossier. She is a video artist and illustrator at We showcase methods and means of bolstering our Studio Nippoldt in Berlin, which she co- working memory as we age or if we are affected by founded in 2012 together with her mental illness and explore tests that can detect demen- brother and sister-in-law. Pages 14 – 35 tia in its earliest stages. But memory encompasses more than just the storage capacity of our brains. For 2 Andreas Papassotiropoulos is Professor of Molecular Neuroscience and heads up example, how can the body remember past infections the Transfaculty Research Platform Mo- in order to mount an immune response? How is our lecular and Cognitive Sciences together justice system shaped by the statute of limitations and with Dominique de Quervain. One of his by forgetting? And is there really such a thing as col- current research projects focuses on lective memory? people who remember every single day of their lives. He also provided research support for the infographic in the dos- We hope this proves to be an enjoyable – and memorable – sier. Pages 19, 14 – 35 issue. 3 Isabelle Marthot-Santaniello researches Angelika Jacobs, ancient history in the Department of UNI NOVA editor Ancient Civilizations. For this issue, she agreed to a photo shoot on her first day back from maternity leave and showed us her work with ancient papyrus frag- ments. Pages 40 – 49 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 3
Contents e-ID, e-voting, e-democracy? Legal scholar Memory: an archive constantly expanding, shifting and shrinking Nadja Braun Binder in conversation, page 8 Dossier 6 8 Kaleidoscope In conversation Remembering and Fake news and lies spread like wild- fire online. This poses legal chal- lenges for a democratic society, says forgetting. legal scholar Nadja Braun Binder. 12 News 16 Lost years of infancy. 28 Risky surgeries. Biozentrum, less air travel, doctoral Hot on the trail of early childhood Sometimes memory problems can program in immunology and new memories buried in the brain. follow after surgery. A set of key structures in the President’s Office. questions and answers provides an 19 The woman who never forgets. overview of this phenomenon. Some people can remember every- thing they have ever experienced. 31 No statute of limitations on Researchers are now scouring their serious crimes. DNA for an answer to the question An interview with criminal law of why we are able to forget. expert Christopher Geth on statutes of limitations and on forgetting in 22 Seeking support for the working the justice system. UNI NOVA University of Basel Research Magazine — N°137 / May 2021 memory. Our working memory declines as we 32 Collective memory – a myth? get older or if we are affected by Historian Erik Petry doesn’t believe mental illness. Two approaches to that societies can share memories. improving short-term memory. Rememberin ring and 34 Catching memory loss before it’s forgetting. ng. 25 When the virus returns. too late. In conversation Debate Album Essay Democracy in the digital maelstrom. Can Switzerland stamp out COVID-19? Virtual papyrus puzzle. The philosophy of the crisis. Our immune system remembers The earlier dementia is diagnosed, Cover illustration previous infections. Researchers the more can be done about it. Remembering is a complex are, however, still struggling to Researchers are working to identify achievement of the brain. However, understand exactly how this works. the very first signs. it is just as important that some things disappear again. (Drawing: Astrid Nippoldt) 4 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
Contents Impressum UNI NOVA, University of Basel Research Magazine. Published by the University of Basel, Communi- cations & Marketing (Head: Matthias Geering). UNI NOVA is published twice a year; the next edition will be published in November 2021. Subscriptions are free of charge and can be ordered by email via uni-nova@unibas.ch. Free copies are available at several locations throughout the University of Basel and at other institutions in the Basel region. CONCEPT: Matthias Geering, Reto Caluori, Urs Hafner EDITORS: Reto Caluori, Christoph Dieffenbacher, Angelika Jacobs. Contributor: Stephanie Kirchmayr ADDRESS: University of Basel, Communications & Marketing, PO Box, 4001 Basel, Switzerland. Tel. + 41 61 207 30 17 Email: uni-nova@unibas.ch DESIGN CONCEPT: New Identity Ltd., Basel LAYOUT: STUDIO NEO, Basel TRANSLATION: Sheila Regan and team, UNIWORKS (uni-works.org) PICTURES: Page 4/9: Oliver Hochstrasser; Page 5: Christian Flierl; Page 6/7: Julie Johnson; Page 12: Under inspection: handwriting on antique papyrus fragments, page 40 Christian Flierl; David Gubler, Wikimedia Commons CC BY-SA 3.0; Page 23: Faculty of Psy- chology, Department of Cognitive Neuroscience; Page 26: Swarnalekha et al., Science Immunol- ogy; Page 34: Derek Li Wan Po; Page 43: P.BaPage inv. 42., Universität Basel; Page 50: Zentrum für Populäre Kultur und Musik, Albert-Ludwigs- Universität Freiburg, LP 2887 and LP 2015; Page 53: Andreas Zimmermann; Page 54: Oliver Fink; Page 61: Daniel Winkler, BRCCH; Page 62: Franziska Bühler; Page 64: Metabolic Health Summit 2020 in Long Beach; Page 65: Divine Fuh. 36 My workspace 54 Research ILLUSTRATION: Studio Nippoldt, Berlin PROOFREADING: Birgit Althaler, Basel (German Researchers are developing a novel Emotions as key to the Middle East edition), Lesley Paganetti, Basel (English edition). endoscope tip for minimally invasive conflict. PRINT: Birkhäuser+GBC AG, Reinach BL ADVERTISING: University of Basel, Head of bone surgery. Many consider the conflict between Marketing & Event, Email: bea.gasser@unibas.ch PRINT RUN: Israel and Palestine as intractable. 11,600 copies (German), 1,900 copies (English) 38 Debate A researcher investigates the role that All rights reserved. Copies and reproduction of Can Switzerland beat COVID-19 ? emotions such as humiliation and any kind require the permission of the editor. ISSN 1661-3147 (German print edition) Assessing the country’s handling empathy play in this. ISSN 1661-3155 (German online edition) ISSN 1664-5669 (English print edition) of the pandemic so far. ISSN 1664-5677 (English online edition) ONLINE: 57 Books unibas.ch/uninova facebook.com/unibasel 40 Album The latest publications by researchers instagram.com/unibasel twitter.com/unibasel_en The papyri code. at the University of Basel. Isabelle Marthot-Santaniello and her team use digital methods to try 58 Essay Platzhalter Platz- my climate to piece back together fragments of Crisis and capacity. halter FSC ancient papyrus. In times of crisis, the incompleteness Platzhalter gedruckt in der Schweiz of the world often becomes manifest. 50 Research Time to get involved. Kitsch speaks straight to the soul. 60 Portrait “Ave Maria“ from Franz Schubert Standing the test. to Helene Fischer. Georg Holländer is Director of the Botnar Research Centre for Child 52 Research Health in Basel. It was not always Therapy straight from the certain that he would be able to take chicken coop and the pigpen. on this role. Visiting sheep, pigs and UNI NOVA chickens helps patients return 62 Alumni is also available in German and online. to normal life. issuu.com/unibasel 66 My book unibas.ch/uninova Molecular biologist Michael Podvinec on science and the culinary arts. UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 5
Kaleidoscope Evolution “ Frankenfish” paintings. Professional-quality photographs are often only a shutter click away. In research, however, drawings sometimes trump even the highest-resolution images, as they are often better able to capture the colora- tion and characteristic features of the species being studied. The illustrator who drew these cichlid fish from Lake Tangan- yika in Africa for the Basel University research group “Animal Diversity and Evo- lution” likes to call them “Frankenfish”. Like Frankenstein’s monster in the famous Gothic novel, each one is assembled from a number of different sources: speci- mens from Professor Walter Salzburger’s collection, underwater photos taken by researchers in which the fish are often at an awkward angle or out of focus, and photos of fish immediately after being cap- tured. Based on this material, scientific illustrator Julie Johnson was able to accen- tuate the particular features highlighted by the research team. The result is a set of 240 breathtaking watercolor paintings of cichlids from Lake Tanganyika. UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 7
In conversation “ The hype has given way to skepticism.” On social media, lies, half-truths and accusations spread like wildfire. That means it poses legal challenges for a democratic society, says Nadja Braun Binder, Professor of Public Law at the University of Basel. Interview: Urs Hafner Photo: Oliver Hochstrasser UNI NOVA: Professor Braun Binder, this it comes to our democracy, we would be BRAUN BINDER: I’m afraid that’s the wrong March at the ballot box, the Swiss public putting public trust at stake, so there is question. As a legal scholar, I neither sup- roundly defeated the proposed measure no room for error. Over the past few port nor oppose measures such as e-vot- to introduce e-IDs, or electronic identifi- years, the media have become increas- ing. cation. Were you surprised by this deci- ingly critical of these changes. Mean- UNI NOVA: So, you draw a strict line in the sion? while, the hype has given way to skepti- sand between your work as a scholar and NADJA BRAUN BINDER: I was expecting this cism, and that was a contributing factor. your personal opinions. But don’t your question, and I hate to disappoint you, UNI NOVA: Does this skepticism extend to political persuasions inevitably have an but as a public law specialist, I have to say the e-ID, too? impact on your research? that no, I was not. Every vote ends with a BRAUN BINDER: I don’t think so. Even op- BRAUN BINDER: Of course, I have an opinion “yes” or a “no.” ponents of the solution in question sup- on the topics I study, but it’s not the aim UNI NOVA: Well then, let me ask the ques- port the general idea of an e-ID, but here of my research to take a stand on a par- tion to you as a private citizen ... again, the implementation process re- ticular issue. Instead, I focus on the legal BRAUN BINDER: Even then, I’m not partic- mains controversial. It’s clear that a ma- considerations: For me, the question is ularly surprised. Twenty years ago, there jority of voters do not support the adop- whether our democracy will be able to was great hype in Switzerland about tion of a private commercial solution, but safeguard voting and electoral freedoms this new concept of digital democracy. the e-ID itself is on the horizon. The can- even in the era of social media and fake Back then, the focus was on introducing ton of Schaffhausen is already offering news or rather what legal instruments “e-voting” with electronic elections and one. On top of that, at the beginning of need to be put in place to protect those voting. Geneva, Zurich and Neuchâtel the year, their cantonal council approved freedoms. The government has to guaran- launched pilot projects, and in the end, the proposal to introduce collecting elec- tee that voters are able to form their own, some 15 cantons got involved. The legal tronic signatures for initiatives and refer- independent opinions. They shouldn’t be foundation for the process is now clari- endums. The e-ID seems to have paved influenced by illegal practices. When false fied, but it hasn’t yet been implemented the way for digital signature collecting. information makes public discourse im- in any substantial way. We’re still voting Schaffhausen could become a pioneer for possible, the authorities are obliged to by mail and putting pen to paper to sign Switzerland. Federalism often tends to intervene. For Switzerland, which has a referendums or initiatives. promote provincial attitudes and disputes long tradition of holding referendums UNI NOVA: Why wasn’t e-voting successful? between cantons, but it can also spur in- with a significant impact on our national BRAUN BINDER: Due to the technical chal- novation because of the freedom it grants political apparatus, it is crucial for the au- lenges and the difficulty in testing the the individual cantons. thorities to uphold their responsibilities electronic voting systems for conformity. UNI NOVA: Would you call yourself a propo- to provide voters with the information Both aspects were underestimated. When nent of digital democracy? they need and intervene when necessary. 8 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
In conversation “ When society changes the way it communicates, democracy changes with it.” Nadja Braun Binder UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 9
In conversation UNI NOVA: So, the state is obligated to cen- UNI NOVA: Is democracy taking place on sor Facebook, for example, if a user posts social media now? false claims about the number of women BRAUN BINDER: We’re not in China, and who wear burqas in Switzerland? we’re not in the United States, either. Nadja Braun Binder BRAUN BINDER: The state isn’t licensed to Most people still consider the explanatory has served as Assistant Professor simply curb free speech as it is in China. of Public Law at the University pamphlet published by the Federal Coun- Switzerland’s voting and electoral free- of Basel and as a member of the cil as one of their most valued sources of doms, together with our fundamental Diversity Committee for the information; there are very few people rights on communication (such as free- Faculty of Law since 2019. Prior to who get all of their information online. that, she was assistant professor dom of speech etc.) are designed to pro- But that’s an area that needs further re- at the University of Zurich and at tect both democracy as a whole and pri- the Centre for Democracy Studies search. vate citizens individually. Of course, indi- Aarau. The main body of her UNI NOVA: You’re on Twitter, too. Have you viduals aren’t permitted to make criminal research focuses on state and ad- ever experienced hate speech? claims or infringe on the personal rights ministrative law as well as BRAUN BINDER: No, fortunately not. It is European law in the age of digital- of others, but in the context of a political distressing to see how quickly a throw- ization. Nadja Braun Binder debate, they are allowed to simplify or earned her postdoctoral degree at away statement can turn into a scandal exaggerate their opinions, to express the German University of Ad- and a justification for bullying – and how those opinions anonymously and even to ministrative Sciences Speyer. much hate is brewing away online. lie. Braun Binder is currently carrying UNI NOVA: Do we need a new law to regu- out a study on digital democracy UNI NOVA: Where do we draw the line be- late the contents of social media? on behalf of TA-SWISS and tween the legal expression of an opinion conducting another study on the BRAUN BINDER: When it comes to safe- and infringement on electoral freedoms? use of artificial intelligence in guarding our democratic processes and BRAUN BINDER: That is the question we public administration on behalf of mechanisms prior to elections and refer- have to address when it comes to social the canton of Zurich. endums, I don’t see the need for addi- media. Up to now, the law tended to draw tional regulation at present. Our systems that line at the point where false and mis- are working just fine and are subject to leading information was presented so late legal protections. In my opinion, it’s more in the course of a political debate that vot- an election. This kind of treatment could proportionate for us to apply existing le- ers no longer had enough time to garner end up being preventative and help stop gal provisions within the margin of ap- a factual, reliable understanding of the the spread of highly misleading informa- preciation that is there rather than to in- issues. In 2009, the Federal Supreme tion in the first place. troduce general prohibitions, for example Court of Switzerland decided that an er- UNI NOVA: We’ve been living with the In- a ban on anonymous posting. Anonymity roneous document, which first surfaced ternet for almost thirty years now, but provides members of marginalized during the municipal assembly, hindered political lies are nothing new. Before, groups with the freedom to share their the ability of the voters to form balanced they were simply disseminated through opinions in electoral debates without hav- opinions and consequently impinged traditional partisan media. ing to fear repressive retaliation. upon their electoral freedom. The deci- BRAUN BINDER: Correct. That’s why law- UNI NOVA: Does social media pose a threat sion of the municipal assembly in ques- makers introduced the partial ban on to democracy as an institution, or does it tion was repealed. political advertising in radio and televi- open up new opportunities? UNI NOVA: Of course, social media has its sion, which has been in place for some BRAUN BINDER: Both! Democracy is not a own concept of timeliness. An old post time now, to prevent wealthy groups rigid concept; it’s designed to change. can surface out of nowhere and unleash a from influencing the democratic deci- When society changes the way it commu- whole new wave that reaches enormous sion-making process. Furthermore, the nicates, democracy changes with it. That numbers of people. law penalizes defamatory, discriminatory can be an opportunity. For example, so- BRAUN BINDER: That’s very true. It’s why and slanderous claims as well as hate cial media gives groups of people without we have to reconsider the precedent that speech. The difference with the Internet significant financial resources a platform the misinformation in question must be is that social media now provides people where they can be heard. And paradoxi- shared close to the date of an election. with an unprecedented platform for dis- cally, the Internet not only lends itself to Even more crucially, in my opinion, is the seminating lies and half-truths – tradi- the dissemination of false information – issue of whether, after being exposed to tional media never had that kind of reach. it’s also very well suited for correcting misinformation, voters are even able to On top of that, social media hosts both false statements. It is a space for lively form an undistorted opinion when pre- private users and users acting on behalf debates and offers endless information. sented with information from other of state agencies. The last US president But these opportunities need to be accom- sources. If not, in some cases, the court used Twitter to bombard the world with panied by the appropriate legal measures. may be obligated to annul the results of innumerable lies. Digital development is an unstoppable 10 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
In conversation force, just like the introduction of wom- couraged by the results of those referen- understand this fact – was it the academ- en’s suff rage, thankfully! dums, but here, too, it’s important to ics or the politicians? UNI NOVA: Of course, Switzerland was very differentiate between two separate issues: BRAUN BINDER: Parliament saw a number late to implement that particular change. the commitment to the democratic pro- of early proposals on the topic of elec- Do you think we’re struggling with the cess itself and the results of that process. tronic participation and digital democ- same inertia when it comes to digital de- Of course, every system can be improved. racy. The political establishment is sensi- mocracy? For example, we could certainly discuss tive to the way social developments can BRAUN BINDER: I don’t think so. We were the way we currently incorporate the ma- affect democratic processes. At the same ahead of the game when it came to e-vot- jority vote of the cantons in the referen- time, since the very birth of the Internet, ing, and now we’re well on our way to dum process. However, if a particular researchers have been discussing its po- deciding how best to handle the impact of mechanism is sanctioned by the constitu- tential for democracy. social media on political processes prior to tion, we have to live with the decision, UNI NOVA: What first piqued your interest elections or referendums. I’m heartened whether we like it or not. And in retro- in the subject? by the fact that we aren’t being hasty in spect, some decisions take on new mean- BRAUN BINDER: This is an issue I’ve been our decisions to impose regulations; we’re ings that would have been impossible to studying for twenty years, since I started making sure that any measures are sound see at the time the referendum was writing my licentiate thesis on e-voting at and well-founded. That’s consistent with passed. I think it’s good that we have the University of Bern. That paper was our tradition of direct democracy. We are popular initiatives to serve as a pressure likely the first legal treatment of the topic accustomed to the idea that we have to valve in our democracy. in Switzerland. It brought me into contact take a nuanced approach to problems. UNI NOVA: Is social media a pressure valve, with the Federal Chancellery, where I UNI NOVA: Sometimes the Swiss public too? started my first job after I finished my isn’t very amenable to nuance; when it BRAUN BINDER: Absolutely. Any means of studies. My dissertation focused on secret comes to questions such as the ban on sharing opinions publicly constitutes a ballots and e-voting, and I did postdoc- minarets and head scarves, those deci- type of pressure valve. toral research in Germany, where I stud- sions seem rather irrational indeed. UNI NOVA: Social media also poses a chal- ied digitalization in state and administra- BRAUN BINDER: Personally, I was very dis- lenge to democracy. Who was the first to tive agencies. helvetia.ch/danke i r s a gen W e! Dank Heute. Morgen. Sicher bei uns. Über 1.3 Mio. Kundinnen und Kunden vertrauen uns bei Versicherung und Vorsorge. FI_CH_BR_PR_UniNova_INS_A4-quer_d_21-04.indd 1 09.03.2021 10:57:53
News New premises Biozentrum poised Climate action to relocate. From planes to trains. Before the pandemic, air travel accounted for around half of the total greenhouse gas emissions caused by the university. Accordingly, this is an area with huge po- tential for carbon savings. The university has pledged to slash its greenhouse gas emissions from official flights by 30 per- cent – and intends to do so by reducing the number of flights taken rather than by recourse to offsetting schemes. To achieve its goal, the university is working closely with the faculties and departments to develop measures to re- duce air travel without compromising exchange between researchers. Besides virtual meetings and conferences, the al- ternatives under consideration include taking short and medium-distance trips by rail instead of air. The finishing touches have yet to be completed, but the end is Transparency and in sight. At the start of this year, ownership of the new Biozen- natural light abound in the de- trum building was transferred from the two Basel cantons to the sign of the spacious University of Basel, bringing the three partners’ largest building entrance hall of the construction project to date a step closer to completion. The first new Biozentrum. occupants to take up residence in the new premises will prob- ably be scientific instruments. In order for research to proceed seamlessly at the new location, the sensitive equipment will first of all have to be tested and optimized. The long-awaited relocation to the ultra-modern research building will then also begin for staff in the summer: In stages, around 400 researchers will move into their individually equipped laboratories distributed over ten floors. At the start of the fall semester, teaching rooms and lecture halls with a capac- ity for 900 students will also be ready for use. 12 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
The magazine that tells you Doctoral program EU cash injection for even more. immunology. Subscribe for free. A new doctoral program launched by the Eucor alli- ance will enable 28 researchers to continue investi- gating the fundamentals of how our body fights pathogens. The European Commission has approved around 3 million euros in funding for the initiative. Besides the University of Basel, participants in the UNI NOVA University of Basel Research Magazine — N°137 / May 2021 “Eucor Upper Rhine Immunology doctoral pro- gramme” (EURIdoc) include a number of universities and hospitals in Freiburg, Strasbourg and Karlsruhe. In addition, the doctoral candidates can undertake research placements at leading pharmaceutical com- The University of Basel’s panies and medium-sized firms. The program focuses research magazine can on the development of the immune system, innate Remembering in and be delivered quickly and forgetting. g. and acquired immunity and immune disorders. EU- conveniently to your door. RIdoc is also devoted to fighting the most pressing In conversation Democracy in the Debate Can Switzerland Album Virtual Essay The philosophy Simply order free online. digital maelstrom. stamp out COVID-19? papyrus puzzle. of the crisis. immunological problem of our time – COVID-19. unibas.ch/uninova Please cut out the coupon and send to: Reshuffle University of Basel, Communications, Petersgraben 35, P. O. Box, 4001 Basel New subdivisions for UNI NOVA is published twice a year. the President’s Board. Please send me the edition of UNI NOVA in: German English The start of the fall semester will bring a realignment of responsibilities within the President’s Board. The Please deliver my copy of UNI NOVA to: current administrative office will be replaced by three new subdivisions of the President’s Board: a third vice president’s office for “People and Culture”, Surname, first name a “Finance” directorate and an “Infrastructure and Operations” directorate. As a result, the President’s Board will comprise six members instead of four. By Street, number or PO box establishing the Vice President’s Office for “People and Culture”, the university aims to ascribe the nec- ZIP code, town/city essary importance to diversity issues and the contin- ued development of a strong university community. “This Vice President’s Office will be wholeheartedly Email devoted to addressing the concerns of the people at our university,” emphasized University President An- drea Schenker-Wicki. Date, signature 13
Dossier Remembering and forgetting. Our memory can transport us back to the past just like a time machine: Previously stored experiences and information are brought to the surface; whereas other memories have long since been deleted to make room for new ones. Our memory is imperfect, which makes it all the more remarkable. 14 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
Dossier 41–0 weeks before due date Early brain structures. The first neural precursor cells form just days after the egg is fertilized. After around two weeks, the first brain structure emerges in the form of the neural tube. After approximately 14 weeks, the hippocampus and the temporal lobes – important brain structures with a key role in memory processes – have already begun to form. UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 15
Dossier Lost years of infancy. Our earliest childhood memories are buried deep within us. But a number of clues indicate that we continue to store them throughout our lives. Why, then, are we unable to recall them? Flavio Donato and his team are hot on the trail of early memories in the brain. Text: Fabienne Hübener I n the beginning, there was E.T. At least that’s how that feels as if it has been erased. Researchers refer to Flavio Donato remembers it. Back in 1986, at the the phenomenon as “childhood amnesia”. “Our expe- tender age of three, he was excitedly awaiting the riences from early childhood can influence us for the return of his elder brother, who always brought back rest of our lives,” explains Donato. “And yet we don’t a gift for Flavio when he was away on extended trips. even remember them. I find that fascinating.” This time, his brother pulled a tiny figurine from his Donato’s research is based on two groundbreak- bag. It was E.T., the Extra-Terrestrial. Donato is 38 ing discoveries. Around 20 years ago, research teams years old now and a neuroscientist at Basel Univer- learned that young children who had had half of sity’s Biozentrum, and that is his earliest memory. their brain removed as a treatment for epilepsy were Many people’s first memories are of a particu- still largely capable of living normal lives. Young larly emotional event that took place when they were brains are so plastic that they can compensate for between the ages of two and five. Anything before even serious defects. The second breakthrough was lauded with the 2014 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. Scientists May-Britt Moser, Edvard Moser and John O’Keefe identified specialized nerve cells in the brain that are responsible for creating a map of “ Our experiences from the environment. With this insight, the researchers paved the way to understanding how experiences are early childhood can encoded deep within the brain through the activity influence us for the rest of ensembles of nerve cells. of our lives. And yet Stellate cells control brain development we don’t even remember Flavio Donato experienced that second discovery up close and in person; starting in 2013, he spent around them. I find that six years working in the laboratory of May-Britt Mo- fascinating.” ser and Edvard Moser in Trondheim, Norway. It was there that he first observed that during the early Flavio Donato stages of brain development, the nerve cells charged with creating a universal map of the environment drive the maturation of those forming memories. This switch allows for different classes of nerve cells to mature according to a regulated process. The 16 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
Dossier maturation procedure is directed by “stellate cells”, ever, the mouse hesitates to explore the dark corner. star-shaped cells located in an important hub for This stimulation reactivates the engram, thus reviv- memory tucked between the cortex and the hip- ing a lost memory. Astonishingly, the nerve cell that pocampus. Donato’s study, published in Science, has been artificially stimulated does not even have to earned him the renowned Eppendorf & Science Prize be a central part of the engram in question. The for Neurobiology in 2017. memory also can be triggered via a back alley, so to In 2019, he returned to Basel, where he founded speak. Earlier studies involving this type of research his own working group at the Biozentrum. Aided by have led to the hypothesis that these early memories a Starting Grant of 1.5 million euros from the Euro- are not lost after all, even in humans. We are simply pean Research Council, he continued his research unable to access them under normal circumstances. into early childhood memory through studies on mice. “My plan is to label the nerve cells involved in Two paths to memory memory formation during the early stages of devel- Based on that hypothesis, Donato and his team have opment and track them as they mature,” explains Flavio Donato spent the last couple of years studying whether there Donato. has been Professor are differences in the way young and mature brains of Neurobiology at form memories. It turns out that the process displays Artificial memory the Biozentrum both qualitative and quantitative differences depend- since 2019 and was Scientists have already partially pieced together the ing on age. Young brains, for example, recruit differ- awarded a Starting process by which memories are made in adult brains: Grant from the ent nerve cells and require less stimulation to estab- An experience activates a group of nerve cells in the European Research lish a memory pathway. “We were surprised to see brain and leaves behind a physiological mark, a net- Council to fund his how little information young mice need in order to work of new connections also known as an “engram”. research into child- learn effectively,” reports the neuroscientist. The hood memory. Our memory is made up of countless millions of such brains of young animals and adult animals may also engrams working in concert. The more frequently process information differently. we repeat an experience, the stronger the connec- But there are still a few missing pieces left in the tions between the nerve cells in this network be- puzzle when it comes to understanding the way come, and a seldom-trodden footpath is transformed memories form in the young brain. “We’re still put- into a bustling street. ting the pieces together, and we’ve already come to To trace the path of a memory through a develop- some surprising conclusions,” reveals Donato. But he ing brain until it reaches maturity, researchers must and his team want to be completely certain of their first locate the specific engram in question. For ex- results before taking them public. They are currently ample, they may start by taking mice that are just a conducting comprehensive control trials. If their few days old and allowing them to begin gathering findings prove to be correct, they will provide a solid experiences. The animals might learn that they hear foundation for charting the course of early childhood an unpleasant sound whenever they sit in a dark cor- memories all the way to the adult brain. ner. Days or weeks later, researchers observe the behavior of the mouse as it approaches the dark cor- ner. The mouse’s demeanor – whether it appears hesitant or assertive – helps the scientists gauge how well the animal remembers the initial experience. Normally, a mouse that is no more than a few days old forgets the unpleasant event after only one or two days. When scientists artificially stimulate the nerve cells involved in the creation of the memory, how- UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 17
Dossier 0–6 months Facial recognition. Babies de- velop the ability to recognize the faces of close family mem- bers early on, thereby demon- strating complex memory. The brain starts to form connec- tions between neurons on the basis of perception. In the first years of life, the brain pro- duces a surplus of these con- nections (synapses), although many of them are subse- quently pruned. 0–2 years Improving recall. In the first two years of life, the amount of time babies remember things for increases steadily. At six months, they are able to imi- tate an observed action after 24 hours, although not after 48 hours. At nine months, they can already retain what they learn for four weeks, and at 20 months for over a year. 18 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
Dossier The woman who never forgets. There are only about 60 people in the world who can remember everything they have ever experienced. For many of them, this is a source of considerable suffering. Researchers are now scouring their DNA for an answer to the question of why we are able to forget. Text: Angelika Jacobs I ’m having problems with my memory,” ory (HSAM) with some 60 other people in it read. James McGaugh had received the entire world. Similarly scarce is any numerous emails of this sort back in hard data about the condition. Minute dif- the summer of 2000. In response to the ferences have been pinpointed in certain message from 34-year-old Jill Price from brain structures. “However, they don’t ex- Andreas Papassotiropoulos Southern California, he wrote that he was plain why some people go on to develop has been Professor of Molecular a research scientist, not a doctor, and sug- HSAM,” says Andreas Papassotiropoulos, Neuroscience at the University of gested she turn to a medical institute Professor of Molecular Neuroscience at the Basel since 2007. He heads up the Transfaculty Research Platform instead. But her reply grabbed his atten- University of Basel. Papassotiropoulos has Molecular and Cognitive Neuro- tion immediately: “I run my entire life spent long nights discussing the syndrome sciences together with his colleague through my head every day and it drives with his colleague, Dominique de Quervain. Dominique de Quervain. me crazy!!!” “A couple of years ago, we initiated a Two weeks later, the researcher was search within the German-speaking coun- meeting Price in person on the campus of tries and received thousands of replies,” the University of California in Irvine. Mc- explains the researcher. But they were not Gaugh tested her memory using a book of able to isolate a single case of HSAM. The 20th century historical events and other vanishingly small number of people diag- sources. She could remember each event nosed with the syndrome further compli- clearly and tell him where she was when cates this puzzle. However, one approach she first heard about it. She knew who seems promising: People like Jill Price she was with, whether or not it was sunny learn new information just as efficiently as out and what else had happened to her those without the condition. The differ- that day. Price merely had to think of a ence is that the brains of people affected by specific date, and the scene would unfurl HSAM do not delete experiences or impres- in her mind’s eye. sions. That means that while they are able to lead relatively normal lives, they are Memory as a burden dogged by the persistent presence of their Today, Jill Price is recognized as the first memories – and forced to relive every sad person to be diagnosed with something or unpleasant moment they’ve ever expe- called hyperthymestic syndrome. She rienced. Jill Price views her memory as a shares this diagnosis, which is also known burden, and many others diagnosed with as Highly Superior Autobiographical Mem- HSAM suffer from psychiatric problems. UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 19
Dossier “In order to function properly, your mem- started by looking at the musashi gene in solely on the sections of DNA that actu- ory needs to be able to disregard trivial people affected by HSAM, but in this re- ally code for proteins, and we sequence information,” explains Papassotiropoulos. spect they’re no different from other peo- them down to the smallest detail. If This is an active process of tidying up the ple,” admits the neuroscientist. His voice there’s something that can be traced back memory archives, not the gradual degrada- almost seems to catch in a pang of regret. to a single gene, we’ll find it,” underlines tion of unused archival materials. In 2014, Irvine-based researcher James Mc- Papassotiropoulos. the research team headed up by Papassoti- Gaugh – “Jim” to his friends – offered to But it is a risky bet. HSAM could just ropoulos, de Quervain and Attila Stetak collect DNA samples from 21 people with as easily result from interactions between was able to prove this fact by identifying a HSAM and some of their blood relatives multiple genetic anomalies that produce gene in roundworms that is key to the pro- back in the early 2000s. “We went ahead the syndrome only when one specific cess of forgetting. The “musashi gene,” as with it even though we didn’t know what combination occurs. It might also be it is called, is present in humans, too. to do with that information at the time,” caused by a mutation in a gene that does A stack of magazines sits atop the sofa he recalls. That all changed just a few not code for a protein at all, but instead table in Papassotiropoulos’ office; the years later with the advent of the gene carries out a regulatory function in cel- memory researcher has amassed a small sequencing revolution. It had finally be- lular processes. Papassotiropoulos admits collection of the scientific journal Cell, come both technically and financially that their probability of success is slim which published the team’s highly re- feasible to analyze in detail the wealth of compared with other projects. Their garded study. Beside it lie an orderly col- hereditary data. study was made possible thanks to financ- lection of other journals bearing his pub- ing from the FreeNovation Award granted lications. The professor has a fondness for A risky venture by the Novartis Research Foundation; the order, not just when it comes to memory, At the Transfaculty Research Platform in award is designed to fund speculative but in his office, too, and the space re- Basel, researchers have been looking for ideas just like this one. flects that fact: His large, clearly organ- gems in this data source. They can detect ized desk is set against a shelf lined with the tiniest deviations in the genes of Initial promise punctiliously labeled files and crowned by those with HSAM, unique sequences that Risk aside, if Papassotiropoulos’ team the framed certificate proclaiming him do not occur in the same place in 100,000 were to pinpoint a genetic cause for hy- the winner of the 2013 Cloëtta Prize. “We other people. “We are concentrating perthymestic syndrome, it would be a revolutionary discovery. A finding like that could completely transform our un- derstanding about how we forget. Not only would it shed light on the cause of the extraordinary abilities of people like Jill Price, it would also boost research into more common phenomena in which the “I run my entire life brain forgets too much or too little. This through my head includes conditions such as Alzheimer’s or post-traumatic stress disorder, in every day and it drives which sufferers experience persistent me crazy!!!” memories of traumatic events. Papassotiropoulos concedes that he is Jill Price trying to rein in his expectations. The data often seems to suggest an imminent breakthrough, but that initial promise is frequently thwarted upon closer scrutiny: “I always think I’ve finally got the answer, but then it slips through my fingers again.” Should his team strike upon a dis- covery capable of bearing up to the most rigorous testing, it would be a dream come true for Papassotiropoulos. If and when that day finally comes, he would like to travel to the United States to meet Jill Price and others with HSAM – and fi- nally give them the answers they are hop- ing for. 20 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
Dossier ≈1 year Triathletes in the making. Learning to walk involves a type of memory known as proce- dural memory, which stores the movement patterns required to walk – and later to cycle or swim. This kind of memory does not need to be conscious- ly retrieved. Accordingly, pro- cedural memory is a subset of implicit memory, which oper- ates at the unconscious level. 2–3 years Earliest memories. In this stage, explicit memory – the con- scious recall of events – im- proves. Many people’s earliest childhood memories date back to this period or a little later, and are mostly of a spe- cial event such as a birthday party. Language acquisition is also closely linked to the un- folding of memory, allowing a child to repeat information either to itself or out loud, aid- ing retention. UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 21
Dossier Seeking support for the working memory. We only tend to notice how heavily we rely on our working memory when it is no longer functioning properly, like when we age or if we are affected by mental illness. Researchers are currently looking for ways to improve short-term memory in everyday life. Text: Santina Russo W hile you are busy reading this sentence, ments can be applied on a practical level. Higher your working memory is making sure you performance can be measured using specially de- do not forget the beginning by the time signed tests, but it does not always translate into in- you reach the end. It is also responsible for helping Dominique de creased aptitude in everyday skills. “If you practice you temporarily retain addresses or pin codes and Quervain memorizing strings of letters, you’ll get better at it, is Professor of Cog- remember where you put your shopping list just mo- but that won’t help you log in to your online ac- nitive Neuroscience ments ago. Thanks to your working memory, you are and Co-Director of counts or understand what you’re reading,” explains able to follow along in complex discussions and the Transfaculty de Quervain. address the arguments of your fellow interlocutor Research Platform Recently, a doctoral researcher in his team, even several minutes later. In short, your working Molecular and Priska Zuber, developed a training app that is the first Cognitive Neuro- memory serves as the brain’s temporary storage, or tool of its kind to attempt to apply training for work- sciences at the RAM, and makes it possible for you to seamlessly University of Basel. ing memory to real-world activities. In her new app, navigate countless commonplace activities – without users complete different types of tasks that train spe- ever noticing it is there. cific components of their working memory, includ- But this temporary storage can start posing prob- ing the part responsible for colors, shapes and spatial lems for us early on in life. Our memory performance orientation and another part, which manages what starts dropping after the age of 25 and by the time we we hear or read. The tasks are playful but challeng- reach 50, these changes become apparent. In addi- ing, and they all take place in outer space. Users can tion, some mental illnesses such as schizophrenia or train their memory, for example, by watching satel- depression often negatively impact working mem- lites light up in a certain order and then entering the ory. “This can severely impede the daily lives of those correct order in the app. To add an additional level of affected,” says Dominique de Quervain, neuroscien- Priska Zuber difficulty, there are built-in distractions between the tist at the University of Basel. He and his research is a doctoral can- memory portion and the recall portion. These may group are searching for different ways to kick-start didate and serves take the form of unrelated sounds or images. on the Faculty the working memory, for example through specific of Psychology and exercises or drugs. the Transfaculty Distraction is a good training tool Research Platform In a clinical study of around 90 participants, Zuber Training working memory the right way MCN at the Univer- tested the results of this training strategy and com- The researchers aim to do more than just train the sity of Basel. pared it with a conventional, established training working memory, they want to improve other cogni- method. Over the course of three weeks, the partici- tive functions, too. On its own, boosting the working pants – all over the age of 55 – practiced four times a memory is not terribly useful unless these improve- week using one of the two training methods. A con- 22 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
Dossier trol group used a tablet to perform tasks that tested less”? “No, that’s highly unlikely,” says de Quervain their fine motor control without training their work- with a smile. “A pill with those kinds of extreme ef- ing memory. Prior to and following the main task, fects is pure science fiction.” Reality looks a little participants were given cognitive tests to evaluate different. “We are happy to observe even a moderate their working memory and also to establish whether improvement in the daily lives of the people we the training had been effective in improving other treat,” he acknowledges. Whether those improve- cognitive functions. ments come from drugs or training, the techniques Only the method that included built-in distrac- are simply not suitable for doping. Yet, one day, they tions was shown to significantly improve partici- may give sick and older people the chance to change pants’ memory performance. “Clearly, the distrac- their lives for the better. tions help teach the working memory to differenti- ate between relevant and irrelevant information. And that improved memory,” Zuber elucidates. That same type of training sometimes boosted other cog- Identify the order in which the satellites nitive functions as well. The participants in this light up white. Partici- group also performed better when it came to visual- pants who enter the spatial learning. Zuber is planning to conduct a fol- right answer are pre- sented with a longer low-up study exploring how these distractions help sequence in the next to train the working memory. round. The task trains the spatial subcom- ponents of the work- Helping people with mental illness ing memory. In the future, people affected by mental illness may also be able to receive medications to improve their In this task, participants working memory. To this end, de Quervain is cur- hear sequences of rently investigating a pharmaceutical known as fam- letters and are asked to type them in without pridine (4-aminopyridine), which is used to treat being distracted by re- multiple sclerosis. He and his team uncovered its peated noises. potential to influence working memory as part of a genomic comparison study. The researchers com- pared the results of a study which scoured the DNA of 100,000 people for genetic risk factors for schizo- phrenia with the team’s own genetic data on working memory. Along the way, they identified a gene in- Here, the task is to recognize a specific volved in both schizophrenia and working memory. symbol from a line- The gene in question codes for a potassium chan- up while entering nel. These molecules play a key role in the brain, whether the note be- ing played is low or where they help to transfer signals between nerve high pitched. This task cells and thereby influence how information is trains the so-called stored as part of the working memory. Fampridine central executive of the working memory, targets exactly these potassium channels: In the case which is responsible of multiple sclerosis, it helps control the way move- for coordinating dif- ment signals are transferred through the nerves, ferent inputs at the same time. making it easier for patients to walk. To test whether fampridine also improves the agility of working memory, de Quervain is planning a clinical study with healthy participants aged 18 to 30. Not another brain-doping drug Should fampridine truly prove to augment the power of the working memory, could it also be used by healthy people to bolster their concentration while working or studying? Could fampridine even be des- tined to become a wonder drug with the power to turn us all into intellectual superhumans like Brad- ley Cooper in the Hollywood blockbuster “Limit- UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 23
Dossier 6 years From school age Acquiring facts. Semantic memory – the ability to retain facts – improves noticeably ≈4 in this phase, as does long-term memory. This is also the life years stage in which children learn Planning ahead. This is the to deliberately suppress stage in which children memories. develop prospective memory – the ability to remember to perform a given action at the right time. This kind of memo- ry does not refer to events in the past, but to future intentions, and is the basis for all considered action. 12–18 years Unforgettable teenage years. Memories of experiences, songs, places and people from this phase of growing up are very likely to endure for 20 years – or an entire lifetime. 30-year-olds have the most vi vid memories of their teenage years. In re- search, this is known as the “reminiscence bump”. 24 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
Dossier When the virus returns. Immunological memory is based on complex interactions between different types of cells, and the process involves thousands of genes. Two perspectives on a fascinating phenomenon with which scientists are still struggling to come to grips. Text: Ori Schipper I t’s never happened so fast before. Thanks to the researchers; they are critical to the development and tireless work of countless research groups, it was production of vaccines, too. possible to develop an effective vaccine against the What we do know is that the typical immune SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus within the span of just a sin- response is divided into two phases: The “innate im- gle year. Widespread vaccine campaigns have already mune response” is rapid, attacking many foreign Carolyn King begun to roll out, but the pressing question now is: pathogens just minutes after they enter the organ- is a professor at the Department of How long will the vaccine protect us? Will it be effec- ism. However, this type of response is non-specific Biomedicine and tive against the mutant variants of the coronavirus and fails to form any long-term immunological researches the now emerging in multiple countries around the memory. Memory is formed in the second phase, dur- biology of world? ing the “adaptive immune response,” in which the immune cells. “The aim of every vaccine is to produce an im- immune system launches a targeted assault against munological memory that lasts as long as possible,” a specific pathogen. says Carolyn King, Research Group Leader at Basel University’s Department of Biomedicine. The idea is Quicker and more efficient response to expose an individual to a pathogen that has been Central to this adaptive immune response are the weakened or split up into benign subunits with the interactions between the different types of immune goal of eliciting a response from the immune system. cells, which can be roughly split into three catego- How effective the immune system is at fighting off ries: B cells, helper T cells and killer T cells. B cells Mike Recher this particular pathogen or a related mutant strain are primarily associated with the production of anti- leads a research depends on the interaction between the different im- bodies, which bind to specific pathogens, thereby group at the mune cells that are activated by the defensive re- placing a kind of chemical target on the invader. Department of Bio- sponse – and that remain active after the infection Helper T cells release signal molecules to help sup- medicine and is senior physician in subsides. port other immune cells, and killer T cells are de- clinical immunol- Today, there are a wide range of established vac- ployed to destroy infected cells. ogy at University cines. But many questions regarding the exact role of Humans are born with T cells featuring a multi- Hospital Basel. different cell types in building immunological mem- tude of different receptors, or uniquely shaped sen- ory remain unanswered. This is a point of serious sors located on the outer surface of the cell. So, when contention for experts in the field. The fact of the an infection occurs – or a vaccine is injected – the matter is that these details are not only important to immune system activates only those specific T cells UNI NOVA 137 / 2021 25
Dossier sponse should reinfection occur. King’s experiments also demonstrated the importance of lung resident helper T cells in orchestrating an effective immune response against closely related variants of influenza viruses. Clearly, the body not only maintains a fleet of memory cells that circulate in the blood; it also sta- tions a squad on the frontline – in the tissue where the same or a similar pathogen may reinfect the body – to serve as a memory of the initial infection. “The longevity of these helper T cells in the lungs and their ability to respond quickly to infections by mutated pathogens make them a promyising candi- date in the search for vaccines that offer lasting pro- tection,” remarks King. Like clockwork The immune system’s aptitude for remembering previously-encountered pathogens is also the subject of study by one of King’s colleagues, Mike Recher, who heads up another research group at the Depart- T cells (magenta) and antibody-producing ment of Biomedicine and supervises the Clinic for B cells (cyan) in the lung tissue Immunodeficiency at University Hospital Basel. His of a mouse. clinic serves patients suffering from frequent recur- rent infections. Many thousands of genes are involved in the structure and function of our immune system. So, according to Recher: “It’s no wonder that immune deficiencies often stem from genetic changes.” Re- cher illustrates the effect of a mutation by drawing with receptors capable of binding to the correspond- an analogy: “All these genes are like sprockets in the ing parts of the pathogen. These T cells then multiply complex gear system that make up a mechanical in order to mount a battle against the foreign body. clock. If just one of those sprockets refuses to bite, After their work is finished, most activated defensive the whole clock stops ticking.” cells die off, while a small number remain alive in Even though defects can impact different genes (or the host. These “memory cells” ensure that the or- sprockets), the effect is the same for over half of Re- ganism’s immune system is able to respond quicker cher’s patients: Their immune systems are unable to and more efficiently the next time that same patho- produce a sufficient number of antibodies. This ’im- gen is detected in the body. “Research on T cell munoglobulin deficiency’ often causes recurrent memory has long been focused on killer T cells,” says respiratory infections. However, according to Recher, King. infections can be prevented using immunoglobulin replacement therapy, a treatment method with a The lung’s memory long history and track record of success. King and her team are primarily interested in helper It only takes a few drops of blood to determine T cells. Their main function is support the produc- whether a patient is low on antibodies. The test is tion of antibodies by B cells. It has long been known simple and affordable, adds Recher. “But it takes an that T cell help to B cells takes place in either the average of ten years before doctors are able to isolate spleen or the lymph nodes. However, after conduct- the cause of a patient’s health problems.” By then, ing a number studies on mice and influenza viruses, untreated immune deficiencies can result in irrevers- King’s team was recently able to conclude that T cell ible organ damage. That is why Recher considers it help to B cells also occurs in lung tissue. crucial to focus not only on immunological memory, Surprisingly, helper T cells remain in the mucous but on the memories of medical practitioners, too. membranes of the lungs long after the infection has Doctors must consider the possibility of immunode- been eliminated. There they interact with B cells, al- ficiency early on, so that patients with suspected lowing the body to prosecute a local defensive re- cases can be tested sooner rather than later. 26 UNI NOVA 137 / 2021
You can also read