UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online

Page created by Kathryn Taylor
 
CONTINUE READING
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
Palo                                                            Vol. XLII, Number 25 Q March 26, 2021

                 Alto                                                                 County enters
                                                                                        orange tier
                                                                                                            Page 5

     w w w. P a l o A l t o O n l i n e.c o m

 UNDER ATTACK
& SPEAKING OUT
ASIAN AMERICANS, SUPPORTERS RALLY AGAINST RECENT VIOLENCE
                                                PAGE 5

                     Read up-to-the-minute news on PaloAltoOnline.com
                                                QUpfront Fire Department fails to recruit women              Page 5
                                                QA&E New doc sheds light on admissions scandal              Page 22
                                                QEating Out Pastry pop-ups open in Palo Alto                Page 27
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
exceptional
  health care in
  the new normal
                                                       Stanford Health Care is ready to care for you, now and always.
                                                       We continue to adapt and adhere to the most up-to-date safety guidelines,
                                                       so you can feel confident getting the care you need.
                                                       To ensure your safety, we are:
                                                       • Screening both staff and patients for COVID-19
   U.S. News & World Report recognizes
   Stanford Health Care among the top                  • Requiring and providing masks for all
     hospitals in the nation, based on
        quality and patient safety.
                                                       • Staggering visits to allow for physical distancing in common areas
                                                       • Ensuring separate screening areas for symptomatic patients
                                                       • Sanitizing exam rooms after every patient

                                                       Don’t delay your care. Appointments are available at our locations across
                                                       the Bay Area and remotely by video visit.

  stanfordhealthcare.org/resumingcare
Page 2 • March 26, 2021 • Palo Alto Weekly • www.PaloAltoOnline.com
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
     
                     

        
 Indoor/outdoor living with abundant privacy     Large screened-in patio right of the kitchen -
 Spacious courtyard entry with mature, serene     ideal for outdoor dining
  landscaping                                     Mature landscaping provides privacy and areas
 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms:                         for entertainment, relaxation and play
   spacious master suite                         Ideally located near parks, schools, shopping,
 Large living room featuring:                     transportation, the Mitchell Park Library and
    hardwood floors                               much more!
    walls of windows overlooking beautifully     Home size: 1,406 square feet (approx.)
     landscaped grounds                           Lot size: 5,905 square feet (approx.)
    recessed lighting

           Listing Agent: Tim Foy
           CalBRE# 00849721
           Cell: 650.387.5078
                                                      OFFERED AT $2,350,000
           tim@midtownpaloalto.com

                                                             www.PaloAltoOnline.com • Palo Alto Weekly • March 26, 2021 • Page 3
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
Perfection in Pebble Beach
                                                                                         PERFECTIONINPEBBLE.COM

                                Rarely does a property become available in Pebble Beach that truly distinguishes itself from the rest.
        Situated on the coveted 13th fairway of the Pebble Beach Golf Links with panoramic views of the ocean and golf course from Carmel Beach to the 6th
          and 8th holes, the setting is serene, and breathtaking. Located in Pebble’s sunbelt, this 6 bedroom, 6 full, 2 half bath Contemporary Mediterranean
                                masterpiece presents a sophisticated, clean elegance and the highest level of craftsmanship and quality.

                                                                                                                                                                                         New Price

            Ocean View Oasis in the Heart of Pebble                                                                              Ocean Views Near Cypress Point
                           3333SEVENTEENMILE.COM                                                                                          1139PORTOLAROAD.COM
       Nestled on a sunny knoll overlooking Stillwater Cove, this classic Pebble                                       Perfectly positioned on a pristine 1.3 acre lot that’s nestled amongst
                      Beach home embodies grace and comfort.                                                              beautiful redwoods, Monterey Pine and Cypress trees awaits
                                                                                                                                                your dream home.

       Mike Canning | Jessica Canning | Nic Canning | Ellen Krausse | Brian Keck | Dave Reese
       team@canningproperties.com | 831.238.5535
       CanningProperties.com
       © MMXX Sotheby’s International Realty, Inc. All data within this document is pulled from the Monterey Peninsula MLS from 1/1/20 to 10/9/20. Sotheby’s International Realty and the Sotheby’s International Realty
       logo are registered (or unregistered) service marks used with permission. Operated by Sotheby’s International Realty, Inc. Real estate agents affiliated with Sotheby’s International Realty, Inc. are independent
       contractor sales associates and are not employees of Sotheby’s International Realty, Inc. Equal housing opportunity.SIR DRE License Number: 899496 Mike Canning DRE: 01004964, Jessica Canning DRE:
       01920034, Nic Canning DRE: 01959355, Ellen Krausse DRE:02046046, Brian Keck DRE: 02070480 and Dave Reese DRE; 02121762

Page 4 • March 26, 2021 • Palo Alto Weekly • www.PaloAltoOnline.com
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
Upfront               Local news, information and analysis

Asian Americans demand change amid racist attacks
  ‘This is not acceptable to have violence against                           against the Asian American and           “We can no longer suffer in si-                                                 she began spreading the word on
                                                                             Pacific Islander community. For        lence,” he said. “This is not accept-                                             various social media apps. Wong’s
     any race. A lot of people are very angry.’                              Ng and more than 100 people who        able to have violence against any                                                 family history in Palo Alto goes
                          by Sue Dremann                                     took part in a demonstration at        race. We need to build together to                                                back to the early 1900s. Three
                                                                             the corner of El Camino Real and       solve these problems. A lot of peo-                                               generations of her family gradu-

T
      he first time he encountered     Caucasian student came up to me       Embarcadero Road in Palo Alto          ple are very angry with this. This is                                             ated from Palo Alto High School.
      racial violence, Nelson Ng       and slapped me on both sides of       on Sunday, the recent attacks on       the problem with this society. They                                               But recently, she was targeted as a
      was 13 years old. He had         my face and ran away. I didn’t        Asian elders in the Bay Area and       pick on the weakest. We are in this                                               “foreigner” in her own town while
recently come to the U.S. from         even speak English. I didn’t know     the mass shooting at spas near At-     together. We cannot let people be                                                 putting up flyers downtown for
Hong Kong, and it was his first        what to think,” Ng said.              lanta, Georgia, are the last straw     mistreated across any race.”                                                      an art exhibit in late January for
day in ninth grade at Encinal            Ng, now 58 and a computer           in a long list of injustices they        Kimberley Wong, Ng’s wife,                                                      three Asian artists at the Pacific
High School in Alameda.                software scientist, is standing up    have largely borne silently. But no    said as soon as she saw a post
  “The first time in the hall, a       against racial hatred, particularly   more, Ng and others said.              about Sunday’s demonstration,                                                                   (continued on page 9)

                                                                                                                                                                                                            PUBLIC HEALTH

                                                                                                                                                                                                       Orange is
                                                                                                                                                                                                      the new tier
                                                                                                                                                                                                       Also, county arranges to
                                                                                                                                                                                                        continue to get vaccine
                                                                                                                                                                                                       doses directly from state
                                                                                                                                                                                                              by Sue Dremann
                                                                                                                                                                                                               and Eli Walsh

                                                                                                                                                                                                      S
                                                                                                                                                                                                              anta Clara County moved
                                                                                                                                                                                                              into the state’s orange tier
                                                                                                                                                                                                              of COVID-19 restrictions
                                                                                                                                                                                                      Tuesday, allowing the county
                                                                                                                                                                                                      to expand indoor capacities for
                                                                                                                                                     Embarcadero Media file photo by Veronica Weber   some businesses and reopen bars
                                                                                                                                                                                                      outdoors starting Wednesday.
                                                                                                                                                                                                         It joins San Mateo County,
                                                                                                                                                                                                      which moved into the orange tier
                                                                                                                                                                                                      last week.
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Santa Clara County Health Of-
                                                                                                                                                                                                      ficer Dr. Sara Cody said the tier
                                                                                                                                                                                                      change reflects the county’s per-
                                                                                                                                                                                                      sistence in reducing its cases and
                                                                                                                                                                                                      hospitalizations.
                                                                                                                                                                                                         The tier change from red to
                                                                                                                                                                                                      orange will allow each county
                                                                                                                                                                                                      to increase indoor capacity from
   Jennifer Krusing, right, helps clear debris after a house fire on Channing Avenue in Palo Alto in June 2013. Krusing, who retired in                                                               25% to 50% for sectors such as
   2019, is one of several high-ranked female firefighters who have left the city in recent years.                                                                                                    places of worship, movie theaters
                                                                                                                                                                                                      and restaurants. Gyms and fitness
                                                                                                                   male firefighters and just five fe-                                                centers will be allowed to raise ca-
                                              PUBLIC SAFETY                                                        male firefighters in 2019. After                                                   pacity from 10% to 25%.
                                                                                                                   the retirement of a female cap-                                                       Orange is the most restrictive
     Fire Department confronts recruiting                                                                          tain last December and staffing
                                                                                                                   reductions due to budget cuts,
                                                                                                                                                                                                      tier in which bars can operate un-
                                                                                                                                                                                                      der any circumstance. (A move to
    challenge as female firefighters opt out                                                                       the city now has 81 firefight-
                                                                                                                   ers, four of whom are women,
                                                                                                                                                                                                      the looser yellow tier would allow
                                                                                                                                                                                                      a county to resume indoor opera-
                                                                                                                   Fire Chief Geo Blackshire told                                                     tions at bars at 25% capacity or
                      City Council vows to spend more money,                                                       the City Council on March 15                                                       100 people, whichever is fewer,
                    ramp up effort to increase diversity in agency                                                 during a discussion of the report.                                                 according to the California De-
                                                                                                                     The grand jury surveyed                                                          partment of Public Health.)
                                             by Gennady Sheyner
                                                                                                                   four fire agencies in the county                                                      Under the orange tier, business

   W
             hen Catherine Capriles     department in the state, going to    decisions toward recruiting mi-       — the Palo Alto Fire Depart-                                                       sectors like family entertainment
             was hired by the Palo      as high as 13 women at its apex.     norities and women.”                  ment, the Mountain View Fire                                                       centers, cardrooms, offices and
             Alto Fire Department       The chief who hired her, Ruben          Today, the Palo Alto Fire De-      Department, the San Jose Fire                                                      wineries will be allowed to re-
   in 1994, she was part of a group     Grijalva, prioritized recruit-       partment is one of many across        Department and Santa Clara                                                         sume indoor operations after be-
   of 10 incoming firefighters: five    ment of women and minorities,        the nation that is struggling —       County Central Fire Protection                                                     ing limited to opening outdoors or
   men and five women.                  she said. The class before hers,     and failing — to recruit female       District — and issued a set of                                                     being closed altogether in the red
     Capriles, who retired as           she noted, had seven women and       firefighters. According to a re-      recommendations to remove or                                                       and purple tiers.
   deputy chief in 2018, said that      three men.                           cent Santa Clara County civil         reduce existing barriers for fe-                                                      On April 1, counties in the or-
   during the earlier part of her         “He made it a priority,”           grand jury report — titled “Why       male firefighters, including the                                                   ange tier can allow 33% capacity
   tenure, Palo Alto had a higher       Capriles told the Weekly. “He        aren’t there more female fire-                                                                                           crowds at outdoor professional
   proportion of women than any         fought for and made specific         fighters?” — Palo Alto had 90                     (continued on page 30)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   (continued on page 10)

                                                                                                                         www.PaloAltoOnline.com • Palo Alto Weekly • March 26, 2021 • Page 5
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
Upfront
                                                                      450 Cambridge Ave., Palo Alto, CA 94306
                                                                                 (650) 326-8210
                                                                                                                                                          QUOTE OF THE WEEK
                                                                      PUBLISHER
                                                                      William S. Johnson (223-6505)

                                                                      EDITORIAL
                                                                      Editor Jocelyn Dong (223-6514)
                                                                      Associate Editor Linda Taaffe (223-6511)
                                                                      Sports Editor Rick Eymer (223-6516)                             We are not going to win this battle if
                                                                      Assistant Sports Editor Glenn Reeves (223-6521)
                                                                      Arts & Entertainment Editor Karla Kane (223-6517)               we do not stop scapegoating each other.
                                                                      Home & Real Estate Editor
                                                                      Heather Zimmerman (223-6515)                                                —Lydia Kou, Palo Alto City Council member,
                                                                      Express & Digital Editor Jamey Padojino                                     on denouncing xenophobia and anti-Asian
                                                                      (223-6524)                                                                  discrimination. See story on page 9.
                                                                      Staff Writers Sue Dremann (223-6518), Elena
                                                                      Kadvany (223-6519), Gennady Sheyner (223-6513)

                                                                                                                                      Around Town
                                                                      Chief Visual Journalist Magali Gauthier (223-6530)
                                                                      Editorial Assistant/Intern Coordinator
                                                                      Lloyd Lee (223-6526)
                                                                      Contributors Chrissi Angeles, Mike Berry,
                                                                      Carol Blitzer, Peter Canavese, Edward Gerard Fike,
                                                                      Yoshi Kato, Chris Kenrick, Jack McKinnon,                       ALL HANDS ON DECK ... The               during the interview that she
                                                                      Sheryl Nonnenberg, John Orr, Monica Schreiber,
                                                                                                                                      need for community service has          became immersed in housing
  OUR T EAM IS IN MOT ION FOR YOU                                     Jay Thorwaldson

                                                                      ADVERTISING
                                                                                                                                      been unprecedented during the           and transportation issues as a
                                                                                                                                      COVID-19 pandemic. But laboring         result of frustrations that she had
                                                                      Vice President Sales & Marketing
                                                                                                                                      behind the scenes, the Boys &           experienced while driving her
                D E L E O N R E A LT Y, I N C .                       Tom Zahiralis (223-6570)
                                                                                                                                      Girls Clubs of the Peninsula and        children to school, which included
                                                                      Multimedia Advertising Sales
  Michael Repka | CEO & Managing Broker | DRE #01854880               Elaine Clark (223-6572), Connie Jo Cotton (223-6571)            its roughly 1,800 volunteers have       seeing kids almost get run over on
            650.900.7000 | Info@deleonrealty.com                      Real Estate Advertising Sales                                   worked over the past 12 months          Charleston Road. A former lecturer
                                                                      Neal Fine (223-6583)                                            to serve more than 435,000 meals        at Stanford, Chang said it’s critical
           www.deleonrealty.com | DRE #01903224
                                                                      Digital Marketing Representative                                to locals in need. The Boys & Girls     for the city to make sure that local
                                                                      Rosemary Lewkowitz (223-6585)
                                                                                                                                      Clubs has served hot meals each         schools can accommodate its
                                                                      Legal Advertising Alicia Santillan (223-6578)
                                                                                                                                      night and delivered groceries           growth plans. “We’ve got to think
                                                                      ADVERTISING SERVICES                                            every week since March 2020,            about schools,” Chang said. “That
                                                                      Advertising Services Manager                                    the organization highlighted in a       type of housing is going to bring
                                                                      Kevin Legarda (223-6597)
                                                                                                                                      video published on March 18. The        families in and how are these
                                                                      Sales & Production Coordinator
                                                                      Diane Martin (223-6584)                                         effort began as a nightly pop-up        kids going to get to where they’re
                                                                                                                                      that provided 200 meals and has         supposed to go?” Mayor Tom
                                                                      DESIGN
                                                                                                                                      evolved into 2,000 meals. Along         DuBois, Vice Mayor Pat Burt and
                                                                      Design & Production Manager
                                                                      Kristin Brown (223-6562)                                        the way, the organization found         council members Lydia Kou and
                                                                      Senior Designers Linda Atilano, Paul Llewellyn                  support through local families who      Greer Stone voted for Chang on
                                                                      Designers Kevin Legnon, Amy Levine,                             sponsored community meals, 367          Monday. Council members Eric
                                                                      Douglas Young                                                   individual donors and assistance        Filseth and Greg Tanaka voted
                                                                      BUSINESS                                                        from foundations, according to          for volunteer Kathy Jordan, while
                                                                      Assistant Business Manager                                      James Harris, senior director of        council member Alison Cormack
                                                                      Gwen Fischer (223-6575)                                         operations. “What does this mean        supported architect Jessica
                                                                      Business Associates                                             to our community? When you look         Resmini. Chang is filling a seat that
                                                                      Nico Navarrete (223-6582), Suzanne Ogawa
                                                                                                                                      at the city of East Palo Alto we’re     has been vacant since January
                                                                      (223-6543)
                                                                                                                                      just thankful for the work that the     when William Riggs resigned from
                                                                      ADMINISTRATION
                                                                                                                                      Boys & Girls Club has done,” East       the commission.
                                                                      Courier Ruben Espinoza
                                                                                                                                      Palo Alto City Council member
                                                                      EMBARCADERO MEDIA                                               Lisa Gauthier said in the video.        RETURN TO THE FARM ...
                                                                      President William S. Johnson (223-6505)                         “We have been able to put this          Stanford University students

       Learn from home with                                           Vice President Michael I. Naar (223-6540)
                                                                      Vice President & CFO Peter Beller (223-6545)
                                                                                                                                      out every day on social media to
                                                                                                                                      make sure that individuals who are
                                                                                                                                                                              coming back to campus for the
                                                                                                                                                                              spring quarter starting March 29
                                                                      Vice President Sales & Marketing                                in need of meals are able to show       missed their chance to run into
      Senior Planet at Avenidas                                       Tom Zahiralis (223-6570)
                                                                      Director, Information Technology & Webmaster
                                                                                                                                      up and it is making a difference in
                                                                                                                                      their lives everyday.” The nonprofit
                                                                                                                                                                              actress Issa Rae, who returned
                                                                                                                                                                              to her alma mater last weekend to
                                                                      Frank A. Bravo (223-6551)
                                                                                                                                      organization is showing no signs        film an episode of her HBO show
     Make friends, discover new skills,                               Director of Marketing and Audience
                                                                      Development Emily Freeman (223-6560)                            of stopping as the pandemic             “Insecure,” according to The
          UVC[ƂVCPFJCXGHWP                                      Major Accounts Sales Manager
                                                                      Connie Jo Cotton (223-6571)
                                                                                                                                      continues.                              Stanford Daily. Rae, one of the
                                                                                                                                                                              main stars of the series, plays Issa
                                                                      Circulation Assistant Alicia Santillan                          NEW TO THE CREW ... Bryna               Dee, “who struggles to navigate
                    "Meet Me Mondays"                                 Computer System Associates Chris Planessi,                      Chang, a longtime school                the tricky professional and
                                                                      Mike Schmidt
                  Connect with others online                          The Palo Alto Weekly (ISSN 0199-1159) is published every
                                                                                                                                      volunteer whose resume includes         personal terrain of Los Angeles
                                                                      Friday by Embarcadero Media, 450 Cambridge Ave., Palo           running the MBA program at              along with her best friend Molly,”
                     6GEJKG6WGUFC[U                                Alto, CA 94306, (650) 326-8210. Periodicals postage paid at     Stanford University Graduate            according to HBO. The show
                                                                      Palo Alto, CA and additional mailing offices. Adjudicated a
                                                                                                                                      School of Business, was                 took the duo back to their alma
                Learn digital & internet basics                       newspaper of general circulation for Santa Clara County.
                                                                      The Palo Alto Weekly is delivered to homes in Palo Alto,        appointed this week to serve            mater, Stanford, for a reunion,
                                                                      Menlo Park, Atherton, Portola Valley, East Palo Alto, to
                                                                                                                                      on Palo Alto’s Planning and             according to the Daily article
                   "Wellness Wednesdays"                              faculty and staff households on the Stanford campus and
                                                                      to portions of Los Altos Hills. POSTMASTER: Send address        Transportation Commission.              published on March 21. The
                  Stay healthy with tech tools                        changes to Palo Alto Weekly, 450 Cambridge Ave., Palo
                                                                                                                                      Chang’s candidacy received an           student publication shared photos
                                                                      Alto, CA 94306. ©2021 by Embarcadero Media. All rights
                                                                      reserved. Reproduction without permission is strictly           unexpected boost March 10, when         of the decorated campus that
                  6JQWIJVHWN6JWTUFC[U                              prohibited. The Palo Alto Weekly is available on the Internet   Arthur Keller, a former planning        had “welcome alumni” signs and
                                                                      via Palo Alto Online at: www.PaloAltoOnline.com
                Expand your creative pursuits                         Our email addresses are: editor@paweekly.com,
                                                                                                                                      commissioner, abruptly withdrew         a post with arrows pointing to the
                                                                      letters@paweekly.com, digitalads@paweekly.com,                  his candidacy from consideration        Main Quad and Memorial Church.
                                                                      ads@paweekly.com                                                for the open seat and threw his         “The project is fully compliant
                                                                      Missed delivery or start/stop your paper?
                                                                                                                                      support to Chang. “I originally         with state, county and Stanford
        Since March 2020, older adults have participated              Email circulation@paweekly.com. You may also subscribe
                                                                      online at PaloAltoOnline.com. Subscriptions are $120/yr.        applied to be on the Planning           guidelines and is rigorously
       in Senior Planet from AARP virtual programming at                                                                              and Transportation Commission           following strict COVID-19
             the Avenidas location over 5,000 times!                                                                                  because I thought you needed            safety protocols,” university
                                                                                                                                      a candidate who had a diverse           spokesperson E.J. Miranda said
                                                                                                                                      point of view,” Keller said during      in a statement to the Daily. Rae,
   ,QKPWUCVYYYUGPKQTRNCPGVQTICXGPKFCU                                                                                           the council’s interview. “But I think   who graduated in 2007 with a
                                                                               Become a                                               Bryna Chang has a diverse point         bachelor’s degree in African and
                                                                       Paid Subscriber for as low                                     of view, so I am withdrawing my         African American Studies, also
                                                                            as $5 per month                                           name today so she can ... get           serves as an executive producer
                                                                               Sign up online at                                      your nod.” Chang told the council       and writer for the show. Q
                                                                          www.PaloAltoOnline.com/join

Page 6 • March 26, 2021 • Palo Alto Weekly • www.PaloAltoOnline.com
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
Upfront
                                                                                                                                             useless, he said. Nobody he has         The mix of high demand and short
                                              PUBLIC HEALTH                                                                                  ever signed up through My Turn          turnaround time means avail-
                                                                                                                                             has received a notification.            able appointments are published
          Can’t get a vaccination? Bay Area                                                                                                     Underscoring the desperation,
                                                                                                                                             Aggarwal said people who do
                                                                                                                                                                                     online and quickly snatched up,
                                                                                                                                                                                     creating the dynamic that Aggar-
          vaccine hunters are here to help                                                                                                   score an appointment are willing
                                                                                                                                             to travel anywhere in the greater
                                                                                                                                             Bay Area and beyond to get the
                                                                                                                                                                                     wal said is driving people to find
                                                                                                                                                                                     workarounds.
                                                                                                                                                                                        Aggarwal, who works for Intuit
       Local tech worker is among those leading the grassroots effort                                                                        shot.                                   in Mountain View, said his pro-
                                              by Kevin Forestieri                                                                               “There are so many people who        gram is a work in progress and
                                                                                                                                             are ready to go at a moment’s no-       must constantly be updated as

F
       aced with endless frustra-                                                                     appointment or not,” Aggarwal          tice to get the vaccine and are         vaccine providers change their
       tion and fruitless searches                                                                    said. “All of that work is com-        willing to drive to Sacramento to       websites — some even putting up
       for COVID-19 vaccine ap-                                                                       pletely wasted if there isn’t.”        get it,” he said. “A lot of people      barriers to keep it from working.
pointments, Bay Area residents                                                                           Aggarwal joined the Bay Area        have lost their loved ones, and         It takes a lot of work, but he said
have launched a grassroots effort                                                                     vaccine hunters and has since          they know that this is serious,         it’s worth it to hear people are fi-
to help one another sign up to get                                                                    developed his own workaround:          especially for folks who are high       nally able to get an appointment,
immunized — all without having                                                                        a program that automatically           risk.”                                  protecting themselves and others.
to camp out in front of a computer                                                                    checks more than 100 vaccine              Since vaccinations began in             The app is free to use, but he
all day.                                                                                              sites across the Bay Area, scrap-      December, roughly 500,000 peo-          said anyone who gets an appoint-
   The Facebook group “Bay Area                                                                       ing data once per hour to ping         ple in Santa Clara County have          ment through his program is en-
vaccine hunters” has been a hub                                                                       people when appointments are           received at least one dose of the       couraged to pay it forward and
                                                                           Courtesy Mukesh Aggarwal
for residents in search of the CO-                                                                    available. It’s done through an        COVID-19 vaccine, including             help others — particularly those
VID-19 vaccine, who trade tips,                                                                       app called Telegram and searches       over half of all those age 65 and       who may not be tech savvy or
workarounds and other tools to                                                                        everything from private pharma-        older. About 10,000 of those im-        have access to a computer.
get an appointment when they                                                                          cies like Rite-Aid and Walgreens       munized have received the John-            “If you are able to get help from
become available. Leaders of the                                                                      to public vaccination sites like the   son & Johnson vaccine, which            the app, reach out to underprivi-
Facebook group say vaccine pro-                                                                       Moscone Center in San Francisco.       requires only one dose.                 leged people and help them get
viders have made it difficult to        Mukesh Aggarwal is part of a                                     As of Monday, there were 3,000         Vaccination rates are higher in      the vaccine too,” he said.
get the shot and that it falls to the   team helping people find vaccines.                            people using the program and 200       San Mateo County, which has vac-           Anyone interested in signing
community to help one another.                                                                        more joining each day.                 cinated 235,000 people — more           up for the notifications can
   One member of the group is           periodically throughout the day                                  It’s unreasonable to expect         than one-third of all residents age     download the Telegram app
Mukesh Aggarwal, who said his           for available appointments, and                               people to sit hunched in front of      16 and older — and administered         for Android or iPhone. Users
story is all too common. His fa-        some are designed to make people                              a computer all day constantly re-      over 355,000 shots.                     can then either search for
ther is older and has conditions        sign up only to later reveal no vac-                          freshing web pages in search of           Despite the progress, state and      BayAreaVaccineNotification in
that put him at high risk of get-       cines are available.                                          the vaccine, Aggarwal said, but        county health leaders say there         the app or click the link https://t.
ting severely ill and dying from          “Most of them are set up in a                               people are desperate to protect        remains a severe vaccine supply         me/bayareavaccinenotification. Q
COVID-19, but finding him an            way where you have to enter all                               themselves and loved ones from         shortage and that the unpredict-           Mountain View Voice Staff
appointment was an exhausting           your personal information over                                the virus. Yet the alternative —       able allocations from week to           Writer Kevin Forestieri can
chore. Each provider has its own        two or three pages, and after that                            using California’s “My Turn”           week make it difficult for provid-      be emailed at kforestieri@mv-
website that must be checked            they tell you whether there is an                             sign-up system — is practically        ers to plan ahead for appointments.     voice.com.

                                                                                                                                             identified about $2.7 million in        million in contracts for the proj-
                                                CITY BUDGET                                                                                  cuts from this year’s capital plan,     ect, which includes new median
                                                                                                                                             which includes savings in catego-       islands, bulb outs, bike lanes, traf-
                  Federal funds brighten                                                                                                     ries such as sidewalk repairs, City
                                                                                                                                             Hall renovations, maintenance of
                                                                                                                                                                                     fic signal improvements and street
                                                                                                                                                                                     trees.
             Palo Alto’s bleak budget outlook                                                                                                parking lots and enhancements to
                                                                                                                                             downtown garages. On Monday
                                                                                                                                                                                        This third phase of the project
                                                                                                                                                                                     is focusing on major intersections
                                                                                                                                             night, the council directed staff       at El Camino Real, Middlefield
      City is eligible for $12.5M in grants from American Rescue Plan                                                                        to trim an additional $2.5 million,     Road, Louis Road and Fabian
                                             by Gennady Sheyner                                                                              though it did not specify which         Way, according to staff.
                                                                                                                                             projects should be scaled back,            Numerous residents, includ-

A
        fter a year of budget cuts,     which considers factors such as                               requirements for timing.               deferred or scrapped entirely.          ing bike advocates and students,
        service reductions and          population, poverty and housing                                  “We will continue to monitor           “I think we’re all sick of cutting   urged the council on Monday
        staff layoffs, Palo Alto        needs. For smaller municipali-                                and will be reporting that infor-      services, which means we’ve re-         to move ahead with the project,
is preparing to get $12 million         ties, the allocations are based on                            mation to the council,” Shikada        ally got to dig hard on the capital     which they said would bring criti-
from the federal government —           population.                                                   said.                                  plan now,” Council member Eric          cal safety improvements to a busy
money that the city is banking on          Under the approved plan, Palo                                 Shikada said the city is also       Filseth said at the Monday meet-        corridor that serves 11 schools, in-
to smooth its path to economic          Alto stands to receive $12.5 mil-                             looking for any opportunities that     ing, noting that some projects          cluding Gunn High and Fletcher
recovery.                               lion in federal aid, while Moun-                              local nonprofits and businesses        would likely need to be postponed       Middle. Robert Neff, a longtime
   The money, which will be re-         tain View would get $14.8 million                             may have to take advantage of          by many years.                          bike advocate said these portions
leased through grants over the          and Menlo Park would be eligible                              the programs that are part of the         Council member Greg Tanaka           of corridor are “long, long, long
next two years, can be used to pay      for $6.5 million. Atherton and                                stimulus bill, which also included     called the recent announcement          overdue for improvements.
employee salaries, restore ser-         Woodside are eligible for $1.3                                direct payments of $1,400 to indi-     of federal funding great news,             “The goal of our bicycle net-
vices that were slashed because         million and $1 million, respec-                               viduals earning up to $75,000 and      though he also acknowledged that        work is to make it easy to get to
of plummeting revenues over the         tively, while Portola Valley could                            couples earning up to $150,000,        the stimulus aid is not enough to       destinations safely and comfort-
past year and invest in critical        receive up to $860,000.                                       extension of unemployment ben-         overcome the city’s ongoing fi-         ably on fairly direct routes,” Neff
infrastructure. The allocation is          For Palo Alto, federal funds are                           efits and child tax credits, $128      nancial challenges.                     said. “These two sections will fi-
part of the $42.6 billion that the      expected to provide a measure of                              billion in grants to education            “Sure, we’re going to get money      nally make important connections
state of California and the various     relief after a year during which its                          agencies and $350 billion in aid       from the federal government, but        safer and more comfortable for all
counties and cities in the state are    hotel- and sales-tax revenues have                            to state and local governments.        our revenue is still down a lot, and    cyclists.”
set to receive through the Ameri-       plummeted precipitously, prompt-                                 While the stimulus bill is ex-      there are a lot of needs that we           The list of projects that could
can Rescue Plan, a $1.9-trillion        ing the council to make $40 mil-                              pected to help the city balance        have,” Tanaka said. “I think we         see less funding include improve-
stimulus bill that federal lawmak-      lion in budget cuts last spring and                           its budget in the fiscal year 2022,    need to start looking at this and       ments to the newly rebuild Junior
ers approved earlier this month.        to eliminate about 80 full-time                               the City Council is still looking      try to do some value engineer-          Museum and Zoo, resurfacing of
   This total includes $8.3 billion     positions. The council has been                               at ways to cut costs in the current    ing, try to really prioritize what is   the synthetic turf at the Magical
for cities and smaller munici-          planning for another $6 million                               year, particularly from its capital    truly needed.”                          Bridge playground at Mitchell
palities, as well as $7.6 billion for   in budget cuts in fiscal year 2022,                           improvement plan. The current             One near-term project that the       Park, the replacement of Fire Sta-
counties. Santa Clara County is         which begins on July 1.                                       budget includes $174.4 million         council has shown no inclination        tion 4 at Mitchell Park and roof
slated to receive $373.9 million in        City Manager Ed Shikada                                    for infrastructure spending, which     to postpone is the completion of        replacement at the Municipal
relief, while San Mateo County          said at the March 15 meeting of                               includes $102.8 million for a new      the Charleston-Arastradero street       Services Center on East Bayshore
would get $148.7 million.               the City Council that he is still                             public-safety building, a project      improvement project, which is           Road. Q
   Allocations to individual cities     waiting for additional informa-                               that the council approved last         about to enter its third and final         Staff Writer Gennady Sheyner
are based on the Community De-          tion about restrictions for the use                           month after decades of planning.       phase. The council is preparing         can be emailed at gsheyner@
velopment Block Grant formula,          of the federal funds, as well as                                 In recent weeks, staff had          to approve later this spring $6.6       paweekly.com.

                                                                                                                                                 www.PaloAltoOnline.com • Palo Alto Weekly • March 26, 2021 • Page 7
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
Upfront

  News Digest
                                                                                                                               YOUTH

                                                                                 Longtime East Palo Alto youth
  State expands vaccine eligibility to ages 50+
    Gov. Gavin Newsom announced Thursday that all Californians
  50 and older will be eligible to be vaccinated on April 1, while
                                                                              nonprofit scrambles to avoid eviction
  everyone 16 and older will qualify two weeks later.                                          YUCA must secure $1.2M in loans or donations
    The governor also said that starting Thursday, the state will
  loosen requirements for doctors and other health care providers to                              to purchase its house on Clarke Avenue
  use their discretion to vaccinate anyone they think should get one,                                                     by Elena Kadvany
  regardless of age or medical condition.

                                                                            F
    The state expects a surge in supply next month: approximately                  or 11 years, Youth United
  2.5 million first and second doses of COVID-19 vaccinations per                  for Community Action
  week in the first half of April, and more than 3 million in the                  (YUCA) has trained young
  second half of the month.                                                 leaders of color out of a cozy,
    That is a substantial increase from the 1.8 million doses the state     humble yellow-brick house on
  receives per week. Health officials have long said supply was the         Clarke Avenue in East Palo Alto.
  biggest constraint and that the state has capacity to administer             That house is now up for sale,
  about 3 million vaccines per week and should be able to adminis-          and the community nonprofit is
  ter up to 4 million by the end of April.                                  scrambling to preserve its roots
    As of Wednesday, California had administered 15.5 million               in East Palo Alto by raising
  doses. About 5.4 million people have been fully vaccinated.               enough funds to purchase the
    Even with this expansion in eligibility and supply, it will take        2135 Clarke Ave. building. But

                                                                                                                                                                                              Courtesy Youth United for Community Action
  several months to vaccinate everyone who wants a vaccine, health          with an ambitious goal of secur-
  officials warn. Q                                                         ing $1.2 million by the end of
                                       — Ana B. Ibarra/CalMatters           this month, and $500,000 in aid
                                                                            pledged by two local funders, the
  Elementary schools to reopen 5 days a week                                group’s GoFundMe campaign
    For the first time in a year, Palo Alto Unified elementary school       has raised only $43,000 to date.
  students will be able to return to school five days a week in person         Since 1994, YUCA has worked
  starting in April, Superintendent Don Austin announced on Tues-           to empower young people of color
  day evening.                                                              in East Palo Alto, many of whom
    His announcement followed several critical changes driving              have gone on to serve on local
  school reopenings. Santa Clara County moved into the state’s or-          boards, commissions and other          Ingrid Yasmine Ruiz Alvarado, left, a student at East Palo Alto
  ange tier of public health restrictions on Tuesday. The Califor-          decision-making bodies. The            Academy and YUCA member, works with another teenager at the
  nia Department of Public Health adopted over the weekend new              nonprofit is a social justice hub      East Palo Alto nonprofit.
  guidance from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention              that’s advocated for restorative
  that halved the recommended spacing between masked students in            justice in schools, immigration        YUCA is continuing to talk with           Julisa Carriel-Lopez, a junior
  classrooms from 6 to 3 feet, allowing schools to increase capacity.       policy and tenant rights. YUCA         other funders, Najar said, and         at East Palo Alto Academy, said
  And in the district, 90% of employees are either fully vaccinated         staff visit middle schools and lead    is hopeful there will be further       she and her friends don’t call the
  or have received their first COVID-19 vaccine shot, Austin said.          tours of the city to educate young-    contributions. The GoFundMe            Clarke Avenue house the YUCA
    Third through fifth graders will return first on April 19 and kin-      er generations on East Palo Alto       campaign will cover the remain-        office.
  dergarten through second graders on April 26. This only applies to        history — and hopefully plant a        ing amount. Anything beyond the           “We say, ‘the YUCA home,’”
  students who are already attending school for hybrid learning. Stu-       seed that will inspire them to be-     fundraising goal would go toward       she said.
  dents in full distance learning will continue taking classes remotely     come community activists.              “badly needed” repairs for central        Carriel-Lopez has been in-
  for the rest of the school year. A handful of elementary classrooms          The nonprofit’s leadership          heating and the house’s roof.          volved with YUCA since 2018.
  have since February been piloting a five-days-a-week model.               says its location, embedded in            “We’ve been essential in ad-        She was drawn in by the nonprof-
    Currently, about 600 students each are at Palo Alto and Gunn            the community it serves, is es-        vocating for what’s right in our       it’s focus on restorative justice, or
  high schools each week, Austin said. He anticipates more students         sential to its success and impact.     community for 27 years,” Najar         working to examine the traumas
  will be interested in coming back to school after spring break and        The building also serves as a sec-     said. “There’s a lot of revolution-    underlying students’ misconduct
  in light of the county moving into the less-restrictive orange tier.      ond home for teenagers, many of        ary history that comes from East       rather than penalizing them with
    The principals of Palo Alto and Gunn high schools also an-              whom live in the neighborhood          Palo Alto that we follow and that      discipline. She also saw herself in
  nounced Tuesday that, with Santa Clara County in the orange tier,         and can easily walk there to par-      we live by. To not have a YUCA         education advocacy projects for
  there will again be open campuses starting this Wednesday, March          ticipate in activities or do home-     or to not have a revolutionary         elementary school students not
  24. This means students will be allowed to leave campus during            work. Staff members deliver free       space just doesn’t seem possible       receiving adequate support for
  prep periods and lunch. Q                                                 produce from a backyard garden         for East Palo Alto.”                   special needs.
                                                    — Elena Kadvany         to people who live nearby.                YUCA youth are currently               “I got to understand more
                                                                               “We walk out of our office to       working on two primary cam-            about my background, the harm
  Police investigate spray-painted hate message                             serve the community that’s liter-      paigns: promoting environmental        that was caused to me that either
    Police are investigating a spray-painted racial ephithet discovered     ally next door. That’s why it’s es-    health, justice and anti-displace-     affected me in a negative way or
  in Heritage Park on March 21 as a hate crime. Officers found the          sential that we stay in a place like   ment principles in land use poli-      affected my social upbringing,”
  blue spray paint in several areas of the downtown Palo Alto park,         this that’s very homey and very        cies; and increasing high school       Carriel-Lopez said. “It grew this
  including the bark of a tree.                                             connected to the community,”           graduation rates and preparing         confidence (in me). It pushed me
    “Of most concern was a short sentence that included a racial            YUCA Program Director Kenia            students for college or careers.       to grow from my past and not let
  epithet written in about 5-inch-tall letters on a concrete curb set in    Najar said. “We’re a part of it.       Through the campaigns, which           my insecurities take over.”
  the ground that separates grass from dirt,” police said in a state-       We’re in the middle of it. We’re       involve running meetings and              She feels empowered by YUCA
  ment on Tuesday.                                                          a resource.”                           speaking at public hearings, the       staff, also all young people of col-
    The racial slur was directed at African Americans. On a nearby             Najar said the building owner       nonprofit aims to help young           or, who treat her as an equal, not
  wall with decorative tiles, police found images of male genitalia.        notified YUCA in January that he       people improve their writing and       as a child. She relished being able
  Two first names were also painted — one on the tile, one on the           wanted to sell the house. YUCA         public speaking skills and in-         to correct an uncle who assumed
  ground. Police also found 15 to 20 empty cans of alcohol that had         quickly started conversations          crease their self-confidence.          she was a babysitter, telling him
  been spray painted. They collected the discarded cap of a blue            with EPA Can Do and the Pahali            Ingrid Yasmine Ruiz Alvarado,       that she’s working as a commu-
  spray-paint can as evidence. A Public Works crew removed the              Community Land Trust, which            an East Palo Alto Academy stu-         nity organizer.
  paint, police said.                                                       both work to maintain and cre-         dent, first joined YUCA to com-           “I’m helping my community
    The crime likely occurred overnight from Saturday into Sunday,          ate affordable housing in East         plete community service hours.         because I care about it. This is
  police said. Investigators don’t have any suspects at this time. The      Palo Alto. The two organizations       But eventually, it became a sec-       something that motivates me to
  department said the city will not tolerate hate crimes in the city        agreed to partner with YUCA to         ond home. She now spends a lot         get out of my house every day,”
  toward any group.                                                         acquire the house and make it a        of time at the yellow house, both      Carriel-Lopez said.
    “In the wake of recent national events and increased attention          community land trust. There’s          for YUCA activities and to do             Ruiz Alvarado added: “YUCA
  on hate crimes, the personnel of the Palo Alto Police Department          also an accessory dwelling unit        schoolwork, particularly during        has inspired us to be more power-
  continue to show their commitment to thoroughly investigating any         on the site that could be used for     the pandemic.                          ful and to be out there. Youth don’t
  reported hate crimes in Palo Alto,” the department stated.                affordable housing.                       “It’s a quiet, safe space for me.   get that recognition. Youth have
    The city of Palo Alto strongly is encouraging members of the               EPA Can Do has pledged a            I can concentrate. At home I don’t     power. This should be known.” Q
  community to promptly report incidents like these by calling the 24-      $250,000 loan toward the pur-          have that space,” she said. “The          Staff Writer Elena Kadvany
  hour dispatch center at 650-329-2413, or 9-1-1 if it is an emergency. Q   chase and another private funder       youth and staff empower me.            can be emailed at ekadvany@
                                                        —Sue Dremann        has also pledged $250,000.             That’s something I need daily.”        paweekly.com.

Page 8 • March 26, 2021 • Palo Alto Weekly • www.PaloAltoOnline.com
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
Upfront

Asian                                  recognize the ongoing racism and
                                       xenophobia that Asian Americans
(continued from page 5)                face, she said.
                                          “In seventh grade when we
Art League.                            were learning about civil rights,
   She said a man approached her       one of the units was about Japa-
and asked, “Why are you showing        nese-American internment. The
art here? Why don’t you go back        teacher said ‘Asian Americans no
where you came from?”                  longer face racism and prejudice
   The remark, she said, surprised     today,’” Ling said.
her: both that anyone would make          “We are seen as a model minor-
the assumption she is an immi-         ity — almost white,” she said.
grant and that they would be so           Many students are missing Pa-
hateful.                               cific Islander and Asian Ameri-
   Other native-born residents         can role models at school. “We
have had similar experiences.          need to have more representa-
Adrienne Lee said that shortly         tion,” she said.
after the COVID-19 pandemic               Ling is hopeful that events over
began last spring, her husband         this past year are helping people
and daughter were taking a walk.       to recognize the racist and implic-

                                                                                                                                                                                                     Courtesy photo
When they passed a church that         it biases experienced by Asians in
helps homeless people, a man           America, she said.
standing nearby hollered, “You            “We are not your model minor-
get away from me,” and spat at         ity. We are not your virus. We are
them, she said.                        not your fetish. We are not your           Three girls hold a sign in support of a protest against discrimination toward the Asian community held
   There’s been enough of a histo-     wedge. We are not your sidekick.           at Embarcadero Road and El Camino Real on March 21.
ry of racism against Asian Amer-       We are not your scapegoat,” Ling
icans and enough bad rhetoric          said.
since the pandemic began to sow           People speaking out gives her                                                               RACE
seeds of fear and doubt, she said.     hope. “I do believe if we start be-
   Lee said she has been qui-
etly donating to groups that help
                                       ing together in fighting hate, we’ll
                                       be able to create a better world
                                                                                     City leaders denounce xenophobia, vow
families who are victims of racial
hatred against Asian Americans
                                       where Asian Americans will also
                                       be seen as Americans,” she said.                to combat anti-Asian discrimination
and Pacific Islanders. Coming out         Kalee Whitehouse, a Juana
to demonstrate is a departure for      Briones Elementary School PTA                                     Council members adopt resolution calling
her, but perhaps it’s the next step,   member, has struggled with the                                     for more partnerships to curb hate acts
she said.                              rise in violence.
   “I’m trying to get away from the       “It’s all very, very fresh. It’s hard                                               by Gennady Sheyner

                                                                                    T
doom scrolling,” she said of be-       to process. I think for me, growing                 he Palo Alto City Coun-       community, even in a liberal city    grocery stores,” despite the fact
ing absorbed by news stories and       up mixed race in the U.S., I was                    cil added its voice on        like Palo Alto. Tanaka, whose        that they make up about 33% of
social media posts about hate and      saddened to see the hatred expand.                  Monday to a growing           grandfather died of tuberculosis     the local population. The recent
violence. “It’s sad and we need to     Our grandmothers and grand-                  chorus of cities and public          in a Japanese internment camp,       shootings in Atlanta have made
elevate our voices to be heard.”       fathers are being killed on the              agencies denouncing xenopho-         said he was well aware of the        it “difficult for me to feel safe in
   Black and white people also         streets. It is beyond imaginable.            bia, racism and discrimination       history of racism in California.     a community that I’ve grown up
came in support of the Asian and          “Having a New England, old,               against members of the Asian         His father was 10 when he left       in my entire life.”
Pacific Islander communities. As       white family, I was insulated by a           American and Pacific Islander        the internment camp and was             “Just like Black and brown
drivers in passing cars honked         lot. My parents could buy a house.           communities.                         subject to discrimination that       communities can be discrimi-
their horns in solidarity, a video     The reality is when you are a per-              Responding to a national up-      was so bad that he dropped out       nated against, so can Asians,”
of the demonstration captured          son of color — and I’m a Daugh-              tick in violence against Asian       of high school, Tanaka said.         Yang said.
the failure of some Americans to       ter of the American Revolution               residents since the start of the        On Sunday, Tanaka attended           Gunn High student Aadi
grasp the seriousness of racism        — you’re not seen as American,”              COVID-19 pandemic — includ-          a rally denouncing anti-Asian        Mehndiratta agreed and said
against Asian Americans.               she said.                                    ing the March 16 deadly shoot-       hate. He said he was struck by       southeast Asian residents of-
   A Caucasian man in a mask              “It’s time to put our feet down           ings in Atlanta, where six of        the stories he heard from those      ten experience prejudice in all
heckled a group of young wom-          and say: ‘That’s enough. It just             the eight people who died were       around him. Just about everyone      spheres, from school to their
en, demanding to know how              can’t be acceptable.’”                       Asian women — the council            had a story about being discrim-     workspace. This often stems
they were personally harmed by            Last June, Whitehouse orga-               unanimously passed a resolution      inated against.                      from preconceived notions
racism.                                nized a Black Lives Matter march             vowing to combat racism and af-         “In Palo Alto, we’re probably     about their faith, he said.
   “Give me an example,” the man       for elementary school children               firming the city’s “commitment       one of the most liberal cities          “I’ve heard many stories of
could be heard saying.                 called “The Littlest March.” She’s           to the safety and well-being of      in the country, the most open-       families and local friends be-
   “What?” a woman asked.              now working to organize a similar            citizens, noncitizens and visi-      minded city,” Tanaka said. “But      ing harassed for their clothes
   The man again demanded an           march for Saturday, March 27, on             tors with ancestry from the Asia     as I was walking with my fellow      or complexion, including my
example of harm that had been          Ramona Street to University Av-              pacific region.” The resolution      protesters there, I was surprised    mom,” Mehndiratta said. “So
done to the women.                     enue that would end with a rally             cites the recent increase in anti-   to hear many firsthand accounts      Palo Alto isn’t as immune as
   “You just believe what CNN          at City Hall. The time has not yet           Asian harassment, including the      of racism, of discrimination to-     we’d like to believe.”
tells you to believe,” he said be-     been approved by the police de-              use of anti-Asian terminology        ward Asian Americans. ... The           Council member Lydia Kou
fore walking away.                     partment, she said.                          when discussing COVID-19,            amount of racism that people         recalled on Monday the his-
   Moments later, a young woman           City Council members Greg                 rhetoric that perpetuates anti-      have felt was quite alarming.”       tory of racism against the Asian
responded: “What you’re doing          Tanaka and Lydia Kou also at-                Asian stigma. According to the          In most cases, these incidents    community by citing the various
right now.”                            tended Sunday’s rally. Last March            Stop AAPI Hate Project, there        go unreported, Tanaka said.          laws that the U.S. had enacted
   Sydney Ling, a ninth grader         as the pandemic took hold, Tanaka            had been about 3,795 anti-Asian      When he asked the Police De-         in the 19th century to curb im-
at Harker School, said she’s felt      was riding his bicycle on Middle-            bias incidents in the United         partment about hate incidents        migration from Asian nations,
lucky to live in the Bay Area,         field Road when he stopped for a             States between March 2020 and        against the Asian community,         including the Chinese Exclusion
which has a large Asian popula-        light. A car with four young white           last month.                          he was told that not a single one    Act of 1882 and the Page Act of
tion. Although she hasn’t experi-      males pulled up beside him and                  The council approved the          had been reported. Many people       1875.
enced violence and hatred, she has     they jeered, “Hey — did you bring            resolution after hearing from        simply ignore the discrimination        Kou, who was born in Hong
experienced bias.                      the virus here?” he recalled.                numerous residents and two           until things escalate.               Kong and who had co-signed the
   “I feel like it’s an almost clas-      “I hadn’t felt threatened like that       council members, who made it            “If someone throws a cup of       memo with Tanaka and Mayor
sic experience to have your food       in some time,” said Tanaka, who              clear that anti-Asian discrimina-    water on you, is that a crime?       Tom DuBois, called for unity
made fun of,” she said.                grew up in Los Angeles and said              tion isn’t just a national problem   Should you report it or ignore       and education to combat racism.
   In fifth grade, a classmate said    he faced a rough time because he             but a local one as well.             it?” Tanaka said. “A lot of the         “We are not going to win this
her moon cakes, a pastry filled        is of Asian descent. He knew from               Council member Greg Tanaka,       times, a lot of Asians just ignore   battle if we do not stop scape-
with sweet bean, lychee or other       past experience not to respond               one of the authors of the memo       it. We don’t make it a big deal.”    goating each other and raging
flavors, “tasted disgusting.” An-      when he was outnumbered.                     calling for the resolution, said        Alan Yang, a Gunn High            against each other,” Kou said. Q
other student one year made               “I couldn’t wait for that light to        Monday that he was somewhat          alumnus, said Asian Americans           Staff Writer Gennady
disparaging remarks about her          change,” he said.                            surprised by the prevalence of       in Palo Alto have been “verbally     Sheyner can be emailed at
noodle lunch.                                                                       discrimination against the Asian     harassed on the streets and in       gsheyner@paweekly.com.
   Some educators also fail to                        (continued on page 10)

                                                                                                                            www.PaloAltoOnline.com • Palo Alto Weekly • March 26, 2021 • Page 9
UNDER ATTACK & SPEAKING OUT - Palo Alto - | Palo Alto Online
Upfront

Asian
(continued from page 9)

   For Tanaka, the current vio-
lence is just an escalation of a long
history of abuses leveled at Asian
Americans. As a youth in Los An-
geles, he used to complain to his
father about how bad the racism
was at school, but he was met with
the response, “You haven’t seen

                                                                                                                   Courtesy Sydney Ling
anything yet,” he said.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Sue Dremann
   Tanaka’s paternal grandfather
died of tuberculosis in a World
War II Japanese internment camp.
After the war, there was “incred-
ible Japanese discrimination. If        A woman holds a sign protesting racism at a demonstration in Palo                                 Members of the Whitehouse-Graves and Atkinson families protest racism
you were Japanese living in Cali-       Alto on March 21.                                                                                 and hate crimes against Asian Americans in Palo Alto on March 21.
fornia, it was bad news. Everyone       it, he said.                         getting into a really good school                            consequences, he said.                 different or un-American.
knew someone who died in the               Steven Lee, a former Palo Alto and getting a really good job. Now                                Lee said that Asians haven’t felt      “The Asian American/Pacific
Pacific,” he said.                      human relations commissioner, that I’m older, it’s all about my ca-                               the continual deadly consequences Islander community is struggling
   His father dropped out of high       said by phone that there hasn’t al- reer and starting a family. And                               of other racial and ethnic groups right now with this violence and
school due to the strong anti-          ways been consensus in the Asian- part of that cultural focus also in-                            until now because they are largely phobia, and I’ve been so encour-
Asian sentiment, he said.               American community about what cludes sort of just a reticence to be                               not seen as a threat by police the aged by all of the allies who have
   Racism against the Asian com-        is racism, racist rhetoric or racist just generally engaged. ... It’s one                         way Blacks and Latinos have been. stood up ... and I hope that we con-
munity has also contributed to          actions.                             of the reasons why we don’t see                                But he and Kou said, that while tinue to refine and implement our
the reticence to speak out among           “And usually you see that more enough Asian Americans elected                                  Asians Americans as a demo- solutions to address these issues.
many Asians, he said.                   among minority groups or minor- to office or in different leadership                              graphic group enjoy a greater mea-       “There’s like two competing
   Tanaka’s role as a public figure     ity individuals who have a bit more positions. There’s just a reticence                           sure of economic privilege than forces right now,” he said. “There’s
in politics was met with disap-         privilege and who don’t encounter to put oneself out there, especially                            other racial minorities, they must people who say ‘Enough is enough’
proval when he told his father he       it (racism) or encounter it in a way when it’s something that’s not                               also guard against complacency.        and ‘We don’t want to do this any-
was running for Palo Alto City          that is not as overt or as pervasive focused or beneficial. ... There’s                             “My biggest message is don’t let more. We don’t want to see this
Council.                                as other minority groups,” Lee a reticence to focus on anything                                   the racist oppressors divide us,” done anymore.’ And then there’s
   “I don’t think so. We’re kind of     said. “It’s interesting to see sort that might come at a cost — at a                              Kou said. “This is an opportunity the other side, (with) this hardcore
like guests in this country,” he re-    of how, you know, with the pan- personal cost,” he said.                                          to speak up to power.”                 idea of what an American is, and
called his father said.                 demic ... it really bubble(d) up in    Lee used an employer-employee                                Lee agreed.                          they won’t accept anything else.”
   That perspective was eye-open-       this very overt and very violent analogy to explain the dynamic                                     “I think it helps the Asian/Pa-        Kou said there is no excuse for
ing and baffling.                       way. Whereas, I would say, prior from a racial perspective.                                       cific Islander community to stand attacking people, particularly the
   “Gee. How can we be guests?          to COVID-19 it was probably more       “There’s a huge power asymme-                              up and call out these things when elderly. “These people are cow-
My grandparents had been in this        subtle and not as pervasive and not try, and so, as an employee, even                             we have allies who are willing to ards,” she said, referring to the
country since 1880,” Tanaka said.       as serious, if that makes sense. if you know that your employer is                                do the same. And we’re willing to attackers. Q
But he understands where it comes       Just the kinds of discrimination or doing something wrong or illegal,                             do so first, to both say something,      Staff Writer Sue Dremann
from and how that perspective has       stereotypes you face, it wasn’t as even if the facts are on your side,                            but also do things about it,” he said. can be emailed at sdremann@
led some people to think it’s ac-       bad as what other minority groups the employer has just so much                                     The United States is “defined paweekly.com.
ceptable to attack Asians.              might face, especially on a day-to- more power than the employee,”                                by our differences and by our di-
   “I think Asians have been kind       day basis,” he said.                 he said. “People are not willing                             versity. And so, everyone in this About the cover: Community
of the quiet minority — almost             Lee said there are interesting to speak up due to economic pres-                               community, everyone in this coun- members in Palo Alto on
like a punching bag. We kind of         cultural challenges that have in- sure. They want to keep their job                               try, we are all equally Americans, March 21 hold up cardboard
keep our heads down, and keep           fluenced the Asian community’s and support their family.”                                         regardless of whether we’re an signs during a demonstration
our mouths shut,” he said.              reluctance to speak out.               The same thing happens with                                immigrant or whether we were protesting violent attacks
   Despite being subjected to bias,        “Certainly, you know, when I race, when one race is dominant                                   born here,” he said. “We need to against Asians. Photo courtesy
implicit or overt, many Asians          was growing up, my parents really and another fears that speaking                                 start seeing that and each other as Sydney Ling; cover design by
“just don’t make a ruckus” about        wanted me to focus on academics, out could lead to negative, caustic                              opposed to seeing folks as being Douglas Young.

Orange tier                             we can subgrant the vaccines to
                                        community clinics that are part of
                                                                               The county recently had to trans-
                                                                               fer back to Kaiser 22,000 appoint-
                                                                                                                                             When factoring in the entire
                                                                                                                                          population of residents ages 16 and
                                                                                                                                                                                      either fully or partially vaccinated.
                                                                                                                                                                                      Fenstersheib said. Q
(continued from page 5)                 our network,” county Board of Su-      ments initially made at county                             older, overall, 28.2% have received            Staff Writer Sue Dremann
                                        pervisors President Cindy Chavez       sites, so that patients would re-                          at least one dose. Broken down by           can be emailed at sdremann@
sporting events and 25% capacity        said Wednesday.                        ceive their shots at Kaiser.                               race, 22.8% of African Americans,           paweekly.com. Eli Walsh is
or 500 people, whichever is fewer,         The county also won’t be re-           Meanwhile, county health lead-                          28.4% of Asians, 15.9% of Latinos           a reporter for Bay City News
at amusement parks.                     quired to use the state’s system       ers said they are seeing a flatten-                        and 30.4% of whites have been               Service.
   Guests at outdoor arenas must        for residents to sign up for their     ing of the trajectory of COVID-19
be state residents while amuse-         vaccine appointments until it be-      cases rather than a continued

                                                                                                                                            CityView
ment park guests must live in the       comes more functional, she said.       decline.
same county as the venue.                  The trend in overall vaccinations      Cody told county supervisors on
   Details on which businesses can      by the county health system and        Tuesday she is hopeful that, if there
operate in the orange tier and at       first and second doses decreased       is another surge, it might not be as
what capacity can be found at co-       this week due to continued issues      severe because more people have
vid19.ca.gov/safer-economy.             with allocations by the state, coun-   been vaccinated, but she cautioned                             A round-up          of Palo Alto government action this week
                                        ty leaders told the Board of Super-    that there are many unknown vari-
Vaccination slowdown                    visors Tuesday. The seven-day av-      ables, including the rise of variants                        City Council (March 22)
  Also this week, Santa Clara           erage for county-administered first    of the deadly virus that are known                           Town & Country: The council discussed a proposal from Town & Country to
County entered into a “settlement       doses of the Pfizer-BioNTech and       to make people more sick.                                    allow medical offices on the ground floor and directed staff to bring to the
                                                                                                                                            Planning and Transportation Commission a proposed ordinance establishing a
in good faith” with the state that      Moderna vaccines has plummeted            Cody said that the region is “not                         category for retail medical services. Yes: Burt, Cormack, Stone, Tanaka
will allow the county to work           to 911 compared to more than           out of the woods” yet and should                             No: DuBois, Filseth, Kou
directly with the state to get its      5,000 doses two weeks ago. The         continue to take precautions that                            Resolution: The council approved a resolution denouncing racism, xenophobia
supply of the vaccines, without         number of second doses remains         public health leaders have recom-                            and intolerance against Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders. Yes: Unanimous
signing an agreement with third-        relatively flat. The seven-day av-     mended throughout the pandemic.
party administrator Blue Shield.        erage total for all doses, including      The county has now vaccinated                             City Council (March 23)
                                                                                                                                            Rail: The council held a study session on the Expanded Community Advisory
A memorandum with Blue Shield           the single-dose Johnson & John-        69.1% of residents ages 75 and                               Panel final report, which recommends closure of Churchill Avenue and
would have prohibited the county        son vaccine, has dropped from a        older with at least one dose and                             evaluates the pros and cons of various grade separation alternatives at the East
from transferring vaccine doses         high of about 8,000 two weeks ago      66.2% of residents ages 65 and                               Meadow Drive and Charleston Road rail crossings. Action: None
to its health partners, hampering       to 5,118, according to county data.    older with at least one dose, coun-
efforts to focus on communities            While the county’s allocations      ty COVID-19 testing and vaccine                              Board of Education (March 23)
most impacted by the virus.             have slid, doses allocated to Kai-     officer Dr. Marty Fenstersheib                               Virtual learning: The board discussed virtual learning program options for the
                                                                                                                                            2021-22 school year. Action: None
  “The most important thing is          ser Permanente have finally risen.     said at the board meeting.

Page 10 • March 26, 2021 • Palo Alto Weekly • www.PaloAltoOnline.com
You can also read