THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte

Page created by Rita Goodman
 
CONTINUE READING
THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2021, 11(1): 129 - 142
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7708/ijtte.2021.11(1).08                                                   UDC: 656.71.072.5:614.38
                                                                                                          616.98-083:578.834

THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT
PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN
Igor Štimac1, Jelena Pivac2, Matija Bračić3, Miroslav Drljača4
    Faculty of Transport and Traffic Sciences, University of Zagreb, Zagreb 10000, Croatia
1,2,3

1,4
   Zagreb Airport Ltd., Rudolfa Fizira 1, 10410 Velika Gorica, Croatia
4
  Department of Sustainable Mobility and Logistic, University North, Koprivnica, Croatia
Received 30 October 2020; accepted 8 December 2020

Abstract: The COVID-19 pandemic has had a huge influence on air transport. For the first
time two thirds of the global aircraft fleet were grounded; airports recorded a decrease of
70-95% in passenger traffic, and many airlines went bankrupt. The negative trends of air
traffic operations automatically decrease airport aeronautical and non-aeronautical revenues,
bringing airports to the very bottom level of financial survival. However, after several months
and after implementing the World Health Organization anti-COVID-19 measures, a small
positive trend starts to be seen. The measures that need to be implemented have presented an
additional problem for passenger terminal planning and design, especially if the introduction
of new subsystems into the existing traffic flow, such as health control, is taken into account.
Considering that current international recommendations from IATA ADRM are no longer
valid, it is necessary to redefine the traffic flows inside the terminal and adjust the procedures
of passengers and baggage handling to the new conditions of social distancing. Following
that, ICAO Annex 9 recommendation that passengers need to be processed on departure
traffic flow in 60 minutes went under question. New requirements for terminal space to keep
passengers on safe distance, the implementation of new contactless technology for quick
passenger processing, a thermal camera and health checkpoints, as well as other measures
are now “new normal” for the airport business.

Keywords: COVID-19, world pandemic, airport, air travel, level of service, passenger terminal,
anti-virus measures.

1. Introduction                                                           to the World Health Organisation (WHO)
                                                                          measures recommended to prevent the
Due to t he coronav ir us (COV I D-19)                                    spread of the COVID-19 pandemic and to
pandemic, airports are trying to adapt to                                 avoid further virus transmission via travelers,
the “new normal” situation. Based on the                                  air traffic has become one of the sectors most
current research on this topic, there are no                              affected by the coronavirus. This paper
reliable data on how long this pandemic will                              refers to the future adjustment of the main
last, so it is hard to predict its final impact                           airport passenger terminals components in
on airport business. The emergence and                                    the conditions of the COVID-19 pandemic.
rapid spreading of the coronavirus have                                   The COVID-19 pandemic impact on the air
forced airlines to cancel many flights. Due                               transport sector will be presented, and the

1
    Corresponding author: istimac@fpz.unizg.hr

                                                                                                             129
THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte
Štimac I. et al. The Impact of Covid-19 Pandemic on the Future Airport Passenger Terminals Design

recommended measures which need to be                    on movement and travel bans, resulting in
applied in the passenger terminals will be               a sharp drop in air traffic. By the ICAO, an
listed. Considering the risk of the COVID-19             overall reduction of air passengers (both
virus infection and the implementation                   international and domestic) ranging from
of the WHO-recommended measures, it                      52% to 59% in 2020 compared to 2019
is necessary to redefine the capacity of                 (ICAO, 2020b). International Air Transport
passenger terminals, which presents a                    Association (IATA) reports a 54.7% decline
huge challenge for the airport planners and              in revenue passenger kilometres (RPKs,
management. Each airport must have an                    both international and domestic) in 2020
individualized approach to dealing with                  compared to 2019 (IATA, 2020b). Two-
the consequences, considering its business               thirds of the World’s Passengers Jets are
model, the existence of credit commitments,              grounded due to COV ID-19 Pandemic
income, number of employees, and many                    (Kotok y et al., 2 02 0b). Accord i ng to
other factors.                                           Bloomberg calculations, about 400.000
                                                         airline workers have been fired or told they
Given that, IATA’s current recommendations               might lose their jobs due to the situation
about t he ter m i na l space, ma x i mu m               w ith grounded aircraf t caused by the
queuing time, and occupancy defined in                   coronavirus (Kotoky et al., 2020a). Airport
Airport Development Reference Manual                     Council International (ACI) announced that
(ADRM) are not applicable, thus a model                  related to the passenger traffic, the European
with customized parameters including                     airports lose over 886 million passengers
COVID-19 measures within the passenger                   (ACI, 2020a). The same ACI estimated a loss
terminal should be developed. To define                  of 57% or over $97 billion airport revenues
an appropriate new approach for terminal                 in 2020 compared to business as usual (ACI,
capacity planning in the “new normal”, it is             2020b). Eurocontrol announced that under
necessary to analyse current available space,            its new “Current Status Scenario”, the total
technology, and traffic flows. Based on that,            number of flights expected in Europe in 2020
it is crucial to see how WHO guidelines can              is anticipated to be 55% lower than in 2019
be implemented into passenger terminal                   (Eurocontrol, 2020b). Many airlines such as
planning and design. Using this way of                   Chile’s LATAM, Air Italy, Virgin Australia,
approach, the airport will maintain adequate             British Flybe, Air Mauritius, Thai Airways,
service levels and prevent possible delays.              NokScoot, and South African Airways went
                                                         bankrupt, and it remains to see which other
2. Analysis of the Impact of COVID-19                    airlines will not be able to overcome this
Virus Pandemic on the Air Transport                      crisis. Potential airline bankruptcies pose a
                                                         major risk to the airports business. Airlines
The aviation industry is one of the major                have been forced to reduce their capacity,
sectors contributing to global economic                  which led to a sharp drop in revenues in
growth. The emergence and the spread                     the entire sector. W hen evaluating the
of coronavirus have had many negative                    importance of airports for the economic
consequences for the entire air sector. The              development of the regions, the impact of
COVID-19 virus pandemic led to restrictions              the COVID-19 virus is even greater.

         130
THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2021, 11(1): 129 - 142

2.1. Impact of COVID-19 on Airport                                        they also expect government support and
Operations                                                                financial assistance to ensure their survival
                                                                          while reducing costs to save revenue.
One of the airport business characteristics is                            Airports are forced to reduce variable costs
the high cost of infrastructure maintenance.                              wherever possible, such as closing part of
The sudden loss of traffic has led to a                                   the infrastructure (runways, parts of the
complete decline in aeronautical and non-                                 passenger terminals), reducing staff, cutting
aeronautical revenues that greatly influence                              salaries, and other measures. Historically,
airport business. The reduction in capacity                               aviation has recovered relatively quickly
of airlines greatly influences the aeronautical                           from major crises such as 9/11 or SARS,
revenues that airports collect from airlines,                             within approximately half a year. Airport
such as aircraft landing fees, parking fees,                              recovery will depend on many factors such
centralized infrastructure fees, passenger                                as the pandemic’s duration and intensity,
fees, and ground handling fees. Following the                             the discovery of vaccines, and the speed of
above, as airline traffic decreased; there was                            economic recovery after the pandemic.
a simultaneous decline in non-aeronautical
revenues generated by restaurants, duty-free                              As shown in Figure 1, the outbreak and
shops, or parking lots.                                                   spread of the COVID-19 virus is one of the
                                                                          largest global crises that has directly affected
During the pandemic, most airports remained                               the global GDP growth. Airports are facing a
open for cargo operations, which was a relief                             crisis of this magnitude for the first time and
for airport business and sustainability.                                  have to solve problems on how to restart its
However, there was a small decline in air                                 operations with the airlines and guarantee
cargo demand (10-15%) as well. Since the                                  safe and healthy passage through passenger
airports are very affected by the pandemic,                               terminal.

Fig. 1.
World Passenger Traffic Evolution 1945-2020
Source: (ICAO, 2020a)

                                                                                                             131
THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte
Štimac I. et al. The Impact of Covid-19 Pandemic on the Future Airport Passenger Terminals Design

To adapt quick ly to the new situation,                   Currently, most airports have temporarily
IATA has issued guidelines, stating that                  halted investment projects because the
each government should assist the aviation                recovery phase is projected to take a long
industry in financial support, tax relief,                time. In this situation, modern technology
or loans. Such assistance helps airports to               such as self-service and contactless technology
alleviate financial stress and to focus on                can help manage airport processes. These
a recovery strategy. Figure 2 shows the                   technologies can help optimize airport
measures/initiatives that governments                     operations by reducing operating costs,
should take as soon as possible to achieve                improving the travel experience, and, most
airport sustainability.                                   importantly, reducing the virus’s spread.

Fig. 2.
Five Measures/Initiatives from Government for Airport Operator
Source: (ALG, 2020)

2.2. Current Situation and Recovery                       After reaching 69% below the level of August
Forecast                                                  2019 in August 2020, passenger traffic began
                                                          to decline from mid-August and reached
In early May 2020, air traffic slowly began to            2.3 million passengers on 29 September (-
recover from the first wave’s effects in March            72% compared to 2019). In total, since 1st
2020. Given the current situation (and facing             January 2020, Europe has experienced a loss
the second wave), it can be concluded that                of 1.3 billion passengers over 2019 (80% less
the next period will be extremely difficult               traffic). Furthermore, business aviation is
for the airports. Due to the occurrence of the            recovering rapidly (only 10% below the 2019
second wave of the pandemic in late August                level), while cargo flights are 3% above the
2020, air traffic decreased again. The impact             2019 level.
of coronavirus on the European air traffic for
the past period and the change in the traffic             In the Figure 3, according to the Eurocontrol
situation when compared to 2019 are shown                 report, several types of scenarios can be
below (Eurocontrol, 2020a).                               seen (actual, previous scenario and current

         132
THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2021, 11(1): 129 - 142

scenar io), which predict traf f ic until                                 of traffic 40% below the level of 2019, but
February 2021. For example, the previous                                  in the real situation it was even 54% lower.
scena r io produced on Apr i l 2 4 2 02 0                                 As previously mentioned, the reason for this
predicted a gradual recovery and remained                                 is the emergence of the second wave of the
ver y accurate from April to the end of                                   pandemic, for which in April 2020 it was
August 2020. This prediction was correct                                  not known whether it would occur and if so,
(+/- 1% each month). In September 2020,                                   when exactly. For this reason, the previous
the previous scenario predicted a movement                                scenario is somewhat more optimistic.

Fig. 3.
Draft Traffic Scenarios - 19 November 2020 (base year 2019/2020)
Source: (Eurocontrol, 2020b)

Due to the fact that after the summer 2020,                               guidelines, there is a lack of coordination
COVID-19 has again halted the economy                                     among countries on how to manage air travel
of many countries, especially in Europe                                   (ALG, 2020). This uncoordinated approach
where many countries have announced                                       leads to confusion and loss of passenger
the “lockdown”, it is now under question                                  confidence. The introduction of common
if this new Eurocontrol forecast is still too                             criteria for the quarantine measures and a
optimistic or the forecast line will decrease                             better coordination between countries could
again. Eamonn Brennan, CEO of Eurocontrol,                                improve the current scenarios. Although
said, “We are going backward now, and it                                  Eurocontrol is very cautious now, the ICAO,
is really worrying for the entire industry”.                              ACI, and IATA have announced that they
Despite the European Union Aviation Safety                                expect traffic recovery in 2024 when the
Agency (EASA) and the European Center                                     traffic will be on the same level as the one in
for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC)                                 2019 (IATA, 2020a).

                                                                                                            133
THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte
Štimac I. et al. The Impact of Covid-19 Pandemic on the Future Airport Passenger Terminals Design

                                                          comfort to passengers and relatively fast
3. Methodology for Passenger Terminal                     boarding into the plane, it is necessary to
Planning and Design Pre-COVID-19 and                      design the passenger terminal space and
Post-COVID-19                                             its technological capacity properly. When
                                                          dimensioning the main components of the
The designers of the airport passenger                    terminal, it is recommended to leave the
ter mina ls must meet a w ide range of                    possibility of expanding them, without major
different needs. Although the efficiency                  modifications, due to the projected growth of
and f lexibility of the passenger terminal                traffic in the future. Figure 4 shows the steps
remain a priority, designers must rethink                 in the traffic flows that every passenger must
the ways of designing and construction of                 go through when departing and arriving at
the terminal and environment that support                 the passenger terminal (Figure 4). Available
the highest level of service to passengers. All           space per passenger, processing time and
the above mentioned should be realized in                 waiting time have been identified as key
order to build the adequate infrastructural               factors that influence the perception of the
and operational efficiency of the passenger               Level of Service by passengers. In general,
terminal (TRB, 2010). In order to achieve an              the quality of service is assessed at peak
operationally efficient passenger terminal,               times, i.e. at the time when the demand is the
various security requirements, procedures                 greatest. The optimal scenario for the airport
and activities from different stakeholders                has a uniform distribution of passengers
must be implemented in the correct way.                   during the day where there is no occurrence
To ensure that passenger terminal provides                of longer queues and waiting.

Fig. 4.
Process of Passengers and Baggage Handling
Source: (IATA, 2014)

3.1. Pre-COVID 19 Passenger Terminal                      the source of any capacity problems in order
Design                                                    to implement corrective actions. Globally,
                                                          there are many airports that have huge
In the latest ADRM, IATA states that airports             problems with balancing positive passenger
should regularly conduct infrastructure and               trends and lack of the airport capacity,
operational capacity assessments to identify              resulting in frequent significant congestion

         134
THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2021, 11(1): 129 - 142

and low service levels. When planning the                                 had shown certain weaknesses during the
airport passenger terminal, the two main                                  years, and in the year 2014, IATA published
elements profoundly influence its efficiency                              a new version of the ADRM (IATA, 2014),
and profitability:                                                        which includes a complete revision of the LoS
1. Terminal capacity optimization (space                                  Concept. From the previous methodology
    and time per subsystem);                                              and LoS scale from “A-F”, IATA defines
2. Clea rly def ined tra f f ic f lows (its                               4 new levels as following: Over-Design,
    complexity depending on State rules).                                 Optimum, Sub-Optimum, Under-Provided,
                                                                          where previously LoS “C” correspond new
Following the aviation industry, I ATA                                    LoS Optimum. In line with those LoS, IATA
develops g u idel ines for desig n ing or                                 defines four Key Performance Indicators
evaluating service quality within terminals.                              (KPIs) on which a new LoS is calculated:
Level of Service (LoS) Concept is initially                               Space, Maximum Queuing Time (MQT),
developed in IATA’s ADR M. During the                                     Seating ratio, and Occupancy. Based on
years, IATA worked with ACI and other                                     those measurements and quantitative results,
aviation consulting companies to upgrade                                  IATA has defined a recommendation range
its methodology so as to provide the aviation                             for those 4 levels. The data on acceptable
industry with a clear and available model for                             square meters, waiting times and occupancy
airport terminal planning and design. From                                rates per each subsystem are shown in Figure
2004, IATA proposed a method where the                                    5 (IATA, 2014).
Level of Service scale for passenger terminal
ranked from A/B/C/D/E/F. In this scale,                                   At the global level, airports aim to achieve/
LoS “A” showed that terminal has over-                                    maintain the LoS Optimum with all its
provided space necessary for passengers                                   default parameters, otherwise the Level
and resulting in an inefficient and costly                                of Ser v ice is reduced. Wa it i ng t i me,
infrastructure to build, operate and maintain.                            processing time and throughput of the main
This ty pe of the terminal sub-systems                                    components of the terminal are just some of
results in substantial operational expenses                               the requirements that must be considered
for cleaning, air conditioning, heating, etc.                             to achieve a balanced LoS. The goal is to
which has a significant negative impact on                                provide an optimal terminal space that will
the life-cycle cost analysis. On the other                                meet passenger requirements. Many airports
side, LoS “F” shows that the terminal has                                 use this concept to help them determine
unacceptable LoS. Till the year 2014, IATA                                the requirements on the facilities for the
recommended LoS “C” as an appropriate                                     projected throughput. If the facilities are
Level of Service for designing new facilities                             designed to meet the demand in the peak
or rating the operational performance of                                  hour, all subsystems will work in accordance
existing facilities. LoS “C” denotes the                                  with the optimal LoS, which is compatible
overall good service to passengers while                                  with the throughput. As long as the airport
balancing economic terminal sizing with                                   does not reach the predicted level of activity,
passenger expectations. This methodology                                  the facilities will function at a better LoS.

                                                                                                            135
THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 PANDEMIC ON THE FUTURE AIRPORT PASSENGER TERMINALS DESIGN - Ijtte
Štimac I. et al. The Impact of Covid-19 Pandemic on the Future Airport Passenger Terminals Design

Fig. 5.
Space and Maximum Queuing Time (MQT) Recommendation
Source: (IATA, 2014)

Proper si z i ng of pa ssenger ter m i na l              have had two different approaches to the
components requires a combination of                     COVID-19 pandemic:
research, calculation, modeling (simulation)             1. Permanent action - activities that need
and, primarily, experience. It is essential                  to be done “overnight” in line with all
to have a complete understanding of the                      WHO recommendations;
operational parameters necessar y for                    2. S hor t- t o me d iu m - t e r m a c t ion -
passengers and aircraft handling. Each of the                modification at passenger terminal
functions that support passengers’ movement                  infrastructure and implementation
from the landside towards the aircraft                       of new contact less technolog y in
requires special attention. This functional                  subsystems over entire traffic flows.
understanding is especially complex due to
the continued development of the airline                 The first “overnight” actions that airports
industry. Improvement, process innovation,               undertook were related to implementing
and contingencies affect many key functional             the “soft” recommendation from the WHO
areas of today’s passenger terminals.                    to minimize the r isk of SA R S-CoV-2
                                                         transmission. European Commission,
3.2. Post-COVID 19 Passenger Terminal                    EASA, and ECDC have jointly developed
Design                                                   detailed technical, operational guidelines
                                                         for the aviation sector. Consequently, the
The pandemic of COVID-19 has influenced                  airports have adopted the recommended
air traffic rapidly, challenging airport                 measures to preserve health and safety of
infrastructure and operational procedures.               their passengers and staff. Several prompt
Due to the lack of time, airports management             proactive and protective measures have been

         136
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2021, 11(1): 129 - 142

introduced to enable the safe and effective                                      mostly found on the counters in each
passenger screening process at checkpoints                                       subsystem in traffic f low to avoid
in a COVID environment. These measures                                           t ra nsm ission of COV I D -19 f rom
are:                                                                             passengers to airport stuff. These
• Social Distance - related to the WHO                                           physical barriers are mostly made from a
     recom mendat ions, a i r por t s have                                       transparent material, such as plexiglass
     introduced the rule of maintaining a                                        (Figure 6);
     social distance of 1-2 meters in all the                             •      Ventilation System - one of the important
     areas in the terminal. This measure                                         measures is ventilation to ensure a
     mainly applies to places where people                                       frequent change of air in the passenger
     are waiting in lines or lingering for                                       terminal;
     a longer period of time (e.g. check-                                 •      Measurement of Body Temperature - this
     ins, security check, passport control,                                      measure is important, especially at the
     baggage retrieval, waiting rooms, cafes,                                    passenger terminal entrance, to see if
     restaurants, shops, toilets, elevators).                                    some airport users have COVID-19.
     Social distancing is mostly maintained                                      This activ it y is done w ith a hand
     with stickers on the f loor, walls, or                                      thermometer, although some airports
     benches that instruct passengers where                                      also implement the Thermal Imaging
     to stand or sit (Figure 6);                                                 Camera;
• Disinfection and Cleaning - cleaning                                    •      Disinfectant Booths - several of airports
     involves the physical removal of dirt and                                   (e.g. Hong Kong) also implement full-
     impurities, while disinfection destroys                                     body disinfectant booths CLeanTech
     organ isms at t he m icrobiolog ica l                                       that sanitize passengers’ clothing and
     level. The emphasis is placed on the                                        bodies in 40 seconds (Fox et al., 2020).
     areas exposed to a frequent contact by
     passengers, such as check-in counters                                In addition to the previously mentioned
     and baggage, boarding, passport control,                             measu res, passengers a re consta nt ly
     doors, and trolleys;                                                 encouraged to use as much as possible the
• Using Personal Protective Equipment                                     Internet and mobile applications for their
     - depending on State polic y, it is                                  registration on the flight in order to minimize
     recommended or mandatory to wear                                     contacts. During the passengers’ stay at the
     personal protective equipment at the                                 passenger terminal, it is necessary to minimize
     airport terminal and during the flight.                              the interaction with the ground staff.
     It involves wearing protective masks or
     visors that also reduce the possibility of                           Related to the shor t-to-medium-term
     droplet transmission of the pathogen;                                action, from the airport terminal planner
• Information Boards for Passengers and Stuff                             perspective, all the recommendations
     - putting up visible notices (posters,                               and KPI’s published in IATA ADRM due
     displays, floor stickers) at the entrance                            to this COVID-19 “New Normal” are no
     and exit of passenger terminals, as well                             longer useful. Primarily, they refer to area,
     as in the terminal. The staff must take                              maximum queuing time and seating ratio.
     care to monitor compliance with the                                  Due to the passenger social distance, an
     prescribed measures;                                                 area for passengers waiting in the queue for
• Physical Barriers - physical barriers are                               Check-In, Security or any other subsystem

                                                                                                              137
Štimac I. et al. The Impact of Covid-19 Pandemic on the Future Airport Passenger Terminals Design

are no longer adequate, resulting in the                  it can be stated that waiting rooms have
passenger line going outside the dedicated                limitations now. The total capacity of seats
queueing area and consequently, affecting                 is reduced by approx. 50%. The only solution
ot her subsystems. I n add it ion, when                   for this is to increase the area of the waiting
implementing the preventive measures, it                  rooms, which causes certain infrastructure
is necessary to consider the real risk factors,           problems. However, many airports do not
such as family members or individuals                     have the ability and financial resources to
travelling together as part of the same                   modify their terminal in a short-medium
household. In this case, it is not necessary to           time.
require social distancing between them. Due
to the lack of synchronization of terminal                Furthermore, the challenge for the airport
subsystems capacity caused by the new anti-               planners is that they will need to add an
COVID-19 measures, the MQT can also be                    additional important subsystem - health
prolonged, directly influencing the passenger             control, which is introduced w ith the
Level of Service.                                         appearance of the COVID-19 virus. This
                                                          additional checkpoint will challenge airport
The third important element is the seating                terminal planners, especially in cases where
ratio and the occupancy of chairs in a waiting            the passenger terminal already lacks space
room. Due to the recommended distance,                    and capacity.

Fig. 6.
Anti COVID-19 Measures
Source: (MZLZ & Škof, 2020.)

         138
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2021, 11(1): 129 - 142

In the future, airports will need to conduct                              departure flights, flight cancellations, etc., for
new capacity assessments while aware of                                   which reasons the flow of passengers is slowed
COVID-19 risks. It is necessary to make new                               down and the concentration of passengers in
estimates of the number of passengers, as                                 a limited space increase. These recommended
well as to analyse and understand the nature                              measures will be regularly updated in line
of the queues and movements of people in                                  with the evolution of the pandemic. Airports
these areas, what equipment they use and                                  must constantly follow the recommendations
the like. The question is how to deal with a                              of the relevant organizations and apply them
larger number of passengers while respecting                              in their operational processes.
the recommendation of social distancing
when additional space is not easily available                             T he Ger m a n compa ny A RC m ade a
(either it is expensive or impossible to ensure).                         simulation that clearly showed how passenger
Therefore, it is necessary to reconsider how the                          terminal subsystems looked before and
airport can handle the number of passengers                               during the COVID-19 pandemic (Figure 7).
as in the period before COVID-19, adhering to                             The simulation was made for the following
the recommended physical distance of 1.5 m,                               subsystems: Entrance to the Terminal,
especially in some situations such as delayed                             Check-in and Gate (TRB, 2010).

  Subsystem                          Pre-COVID-19                                          Post-COVID-19

   Terminal
   Entrance

   Check-In

      Gate

Fig. 7.
Pre-COVID-19 vs Post COVID-19 Simulation (Simulation Developed by ARC on CAST Terminal)
Source: (ARC, 2020)

                                                                                                               139
Štimac I. et al. The Impact of Covid-19 Pandemic on the Future Airport Passenger Terminals Design

The infrastructure and technology solutions                crisis. At the same time, the airport operators
that are implemented in the COVID-19                       are forced to revise their usual business
situation are the following:                               processes. Operational processes and their
                                                           optimization will be the main priority of
a.   If there is a possibility to increase the             airports in the upcoming period. Although
     queuing area in any subsystem, it is                  airports have had a prompt reaction to
     highly recommended to do so;                          prevent transmission of COVID-19 with
b.   If there is not enough space in front of              simplified solutions, it is expected that they
     a subsystem, the recommendation is                    will invest more in new technology and
     to increase the number of units in the                infrastructure in the future. From the point
     subsystem to increase its capacity, and               of view of terminal planning perspective
     the result will be a decrease in queuing              and technology, the airports will need to
     time and number of passengers in                      invest in fully contactless technology in
     front of the subsystem. W hat needs                   each terminal subsystem to avoid future
     to be considered is that, although the                virus transmission, as probably there will
     number of units is increased, the airport             be similar viruses such as COVID-19. That
     management needs to ensure additional                 technology is invented, so the next step is
     staff who will work on these new units;               to implement it. In addition to that, new
c.   If there are also limitations on the                  subsystems will be added to current traffic
     number of units and (space) area, then                f lows. One important subsystem of the
     a solution can be found in the f light                passenger terminal that will be added is
     schedule modification (if possible). This             health control, which has been introduced
     is the final solution, but it can avoid all           with the appearance of the COVID-19 virus.
     aircraft delays in a certain flight hour.             This additional checkpoint will challenge
                                                           airport terminal planners, especially those
4. Conclusion                                              where the passenger terminal already
                                                           lacks space and capacity. Finally, such new
The Covid-19 pandemic with a sudden loss of                subsystems will also influence the current
traffic and revenue resulted in an existential             ICAO recommendation, where 60 minutes
threat to airports and the aviation industry.              was the ma x imum time for the entire
Given the enormous negative impact of the                  departure passenger and 45 minutes for
COVID-19 virus on the airport business,                    arrival processes. These times will also be
it will take a long time for the situation to              prolonged in the future. It can be said that
return to normal. It is expected that the                  there are technological solutions that can be
economic crisis following the pandemic will                added at the passenger terminals in order to
lead to a lower demand for air transportation.             fight against COVID-19 or any other virus.
The industry experts predict a much slower                 This implies certain changes and innovations
recovery than any other crises such as 9/11                in the process of passengers and baggage
or SARS, where ICAO, IATA, ACI, and                        handling, which includes revision and
Eurocontrol agreed that results from 2019                  change of individual operating procedures
would be achieved in 2025. Currently,                      and additional staff training. However, the
most air ports are implementing their                      time for reaction and implementation of
business continuity plans regarding service                such solutions will be challenging for airport
maintenance and core operations during this                managers and planners.

         140
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2021, 11(1): 129 - 142

References                                                                Fox, A. 2020. Hong Kong’s airport is rolling out full-body
                                                                          disinfectant booths that sanitize passengers’ clothing
ARC. 2020. Airport Challenges in Reacting to Covid-19.                    and bodies in 40 seconds. Available from Internet:
Airport Research Center. Available from Internet:                         .
                                                                          IATA. 2014. Airport Development Reference Manual
ACI. 2020a. Latest traffic data shows disastrous                          (ADRM), 10th edition, International Air Transport
COVID-19 impact on airport industry. Airports Council                     Association, Montréal, Canada.
International. Available from Internet: .                                                                    Association, Montreal, Canada. Available from Internet:
                                                                          .
on airport industr y escalates. A irports Council
International. Available from Internet: .                                 Association, Montreal, Canada. Available from Internet:
                                                                          .
Infrastructure. Available from Internet: .                                        on Civ il Av iation: Economic I mpact A nalysis,
                                                                          International Civil Aviation Organization. Available
Dw yer, M. 2020. Eurocontrol Issues New Draft                             from Internet:.
                                                                          ICAO. 2020b. State of Global Air Transport and ICAO
Eurocontrol. 2020a. COVID-19 Impact on European                           Forecasts for Effective Planning, International Civil
Air Traffic, Eurocontrol Comprehensive Assessment.                        Aviation Organization, Economic Development, Workshop
Available from Internet: .                                   Kotoky, A.; Modi, M.; Turner, M. 2020a. Jobs Are Being
                                                                          Wiped Out at Airlines, And There’s Worse to Come,
Eurocontrol. 2020b. Draft Traffic Scenarios for                           Bloomberg. Available from Internet: .
over COVID-19, Brussels.

                                                                                                                    141
Štimac I. et al. The Impact of Covid-19 Pandemic on the Future Airport Passenger Terminals Design

Kotoky, A.; Stringer, D.; Saxena, R. 2020b. Two-
Thirds of the World’s Passengers Jets Are Grounded
Amid COVID-19 Pandemic. Available from Internet:
URL: .

MZLZ; Škof, J. 2020. Pictures of interior of Franjo
Tuđman passenger terminal during COVID-19, Zagreb
International Airport Jsc, MZLZ archive, Zagreb,
Croatia.

TRB. 2010. Transportation Research Board: ACRP
Report 25. Airport Passenger Terminal Planning and
Design Volume 1: Guidebook, Airport Cooperative
Research Program, Washington, United States of
America.

          142
You can also read