CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law

 
CONTINUE READING
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
CHASE
 NORTHERN KENTUCK Y UNIVERSIT Y SALMON P. CHASE COLLEGE OF L AW | SPRING / SUMMER 2018

ALSO     Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
THIS IS MORE THAN A DIPLOMA

                        IT’S A
CHASE DIPLOMA
  Your gift to the Chase Annual Fund before June 30
 will help ensure there will be more Chase diplomas in
            the legal profession in the future.
            Give online at supportnku.nku.edu/CHS
                or use the envelope in this issue
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
FROM THE INTERIM DEAN

The Lawyer’s School is also the
leadership school
A CHASE EDUCATION    Names are important to an identity, and the         “Structurally, I believe I was prepared for my
INVOLVES MORE THAN   name of Salmon P. Chase College of Law clearly      argument, and intellectually I believe I was
THE OBVIOUS FOR      identifies what students are learning here, but     prepared, and that was because of my class-
PRACTICING LAW       they are also learning about more than law. By      room experience,” she wrote.
                     nurturing an environment that emphasizes legal
                                                                         Preparing students through classroom and
                     knowledge and experiences outside the
                                                                         other activities to be leaders permeates a
                     classroom, Chase is preparing students to
                                                                         Chase education. Each student completes fifty
                     become lawyers and leaders – leaders in
                                                                         hours of pro bono work – such as writing wills
                     practices, the profession, business, govern-
                                                                         for police officers or teaching at-risk youth
                     ment, communities, and anywhere people have
                                                                         about legal rights – all designed to enhance
                     a common goal.
                                                                         legal skills and develop self-confidence.
                     Some of our lessons for leadership are in           Students in experiential learning programs
                     black-letter law, to be sure. They are in the       complete additional, non-law-related volunteer
                     cases cited by names of appellants and              work to expand awareness and social-interac-
                     appellees and in the names of judges who            tion skills. They do it in activities such as
                     decided them. Outside of Nunn Hall, the             volunteering at an underserved kindergarten,
                     lessons are identified with names of students       working with recovering drug abusers, or
                     who immerse themselves in opportunities to          helping with a youth basketball team.
                     develop both lawyering skills and strategies to
                                                                         Through the combination of classroom
                     work cooperatively with people of varied
                                                                         preparation, pro bono work, and experiential
                     backgrounds and interests. From those
                                                                         learning, Salmon P. Chase College of Law is
                     combined experiences, students learn to
                                                                         more than the name of a law school. It is a law
                     understand their strengths, their development
                                                                         school from which we are proud to graduate
                     paths, and their perspectives that guide their
                                                                         lawyers and leaders.
                     leadership.

                     This past spring, for example, graduating 3L
                     Brittany Grigery was second-chair in a murder
                                                                         Michael Whiteman
                                                                         INTERIM DEAN AND PROFESSOR OF LAW
                     trial with the San Diego County (California)
                     Public Defender. She participated in trial
                     preparation, directed client communications,
                     and examined witnesses as an extern through
                     our experiential learning program. The rigors of
                     the Chase classroom, she tells people, pre-
                     pared her to experience the type of courtroom
                     leadership she will utilize in the public defend-
                     er’s office after graduation.

                     Sabre Price, another graduating 3L, this past
                     summer stood before a three-judge panel of
                     the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth
                     Circuit and argued the case of a prisoner she
                     represented through the Chase Constitutional
                     Litigation Clinic. Like Brittany, her classroom
                     preparation was her foundation for a ca-
                     reer-building opportunity in leadership.

                                                                                                        SP RING/ SUMME R 2 0 1 7 1
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
CONTENTS

In this issue
-------------------                         ------------------------------

The Interim Dean’s                          Cover Story
Message
                                            Chase alumni are using
Chase is preparing students
to be lawyers and leaders                   their experience to run
through experiences in and
out of the classroom
                                            for elected offices
1                                           8
---------------------                       ———                                       ---------------------                        ———
                                            Chase offers its expertise                                                             Two alumni receive
News from Chase                             in a national continuing
                                                                                      Education                                    Northern Kentucky
Michael Whiteman is                         legal education program                   Alumni who are adjunct                       University awards
serving as interim dean                                                               professors learned their
                                            6                                                                                      26
3                                                                                     lessons at Chase
                                            ———                                                                                    ———
———                                         A law review symposium
                                                                                      18                                           CLASS ACTION
The law library goes                        explores racial profiling                 ———                                          Professional and personal
retro for a movie cameo                                                               Developing law-related
                                            7                                                                                      accomplishments
3                                                                                     computer apps takes its
                                                                                                                                   27
                                            ---------------------                     place with briefing cases
———                                                                                                                                ———
A 3L student plays a key                    Anniversaries                             20                                           Alumni stay connected
role in a murder defense                    A fortieth: The first                     ———                                          to Chase
4                                           graduation class of day                   Intense preparation
                                                                                                                                   30
                                            and evening students                      steels students for appel-
———
                                            builds on four decades                    late court appearances                       ---------------------
Chase stages a pre-ABA
Techshow seminar                            of experience that began                  22                                           Faculty
                                            at Chase
5                                                                                     ---------------------                        FACULTY NEWS
                                            13                                                                                     Publications and
———
                                            ———
                                                                                      Alumni                                       presentations
Barbara Wagner steps
                                                                                      Alumni make notable gifts
away from clinic role                       The 125th: A memoir recalls                                                            31
                                            how Chase came to be –                    25
5                                                                                                                                  ———
                                            and almost didn’t
                                                                                                                                   Professor Ursula Doyle
                                            16                                                                                     receives tenure
                                                                                                                                   32

CHASE is published by Salmon P. Chase College of Law, through the Office of           University, 100 Nunn Drive, Highland Heights, KY 41099 or by email to brunj1@nku.edu.
Communications in the Office of the Dean. Please send change of mailing address and   CHASE is edited by Kerry Klumpe, Chase director of communications, and designed
alumni news to CHASE magazine, Salmon P. Chase College of Law, Northern Kentucky      by Paul Neff of Paul Neff Design.

2 C H A S E M A G A Z I NE
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
Briefs
         LEADERSHIP

Michael Whiteman
will be Interim Dean
Michael Whiteman, who has been              upcoming 2018-19 academic year.
Chase College of Law co-acting dean
                                            “We can be confident of the future for
since November, will serve as interim
                                            Chase because of how involved our
dean, effective June 1.
                                            faculty and alumni are in helping to
In announcing his appointment,              shape it,” Dean Whiteman says. “Their
Northern Kentucky University Provost        dedication helps ensure that the next
Sue Ott Rowlands said, “I believe that      academic year will be another year of
with Mike in the role of interim dean       achievement for students and the
Chase will benefit from a continuity of     college.”
stable leadership and forward-facing
                                            Dean Whiteman has spoken at national
energy.”
                                            and regional conferences on topics
                                                                                      Michael Whiteman
Dean Whiteman, who has taught               involving law libraries and legal
criminal law and legal research and is      research, and has published law review
                                                                                      University. He was admitted to practice
associate dean for law library services     articles in the Northwestern Journal of
                                                                                      in Massachusetts.
and information technology, has been a      Technology and Intellectual Property
faculty member since July 2002. His         and the UCLA Law Review Discourse.        A committee of Chase and Northern
range of experiences – teaching,            He holds a Juris Doctor from the          Kentucky University professors and
chairing committees, and overseeing         University of Louisville, a Master of     administrators, a Chase graduate, and a
aspects of day-to-day operations – will     Science in Library and Information        Chase student will conduct the search for
allow him to have immediate impact in       Science from Simmons College, and a       a dean. An appointment is expected to be
guiding the college through the             Bachelor of Arts from Concordia           made for the 2019-20 academic year.

           FACILITIES

Library Takes on Retro Look for Movie Role
The Chase College of Law library will       Other scenes shot at Northern             hillside. Filming has been completed,
make a cameo appearance in a movie,         Kentucky University used the exterior     but no release date has been set.
starring Zac Efron and Lily Collins,        of Steely Library and a snow-covered      Bundy was executed in 1989 in Florida.
which was filmed this past winter in
Northern Kentucky and Cincinnati.

A section of the library was staged to
stand in for a 1970s law school library –
cue the bulky microfilm reader – for a
scene in the movie about serial killer
Ted Bundy, told from the perspective
of his girlfriend, Elizabeth Kloepfer.
Efron, best known for the “High School
Musical” franchise, portrays Bundy in
“Extremely Wicked: Shockingly Evil
and Vile.” Collins, who was Snow White
in “Mirror Mirror,” is Kloepfer.

                                                                                                         SP RING/
                                                                                                   The Chase         SUMME
                                                                                                              law library,     R 2for
                                                                                                                           staged  018   3
                                                                                                   filming with a microfilm reader and
                                                                                                   desk lamps.
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
Briefs

Extern has Key Role
in Murder Trial Defense
            EDUCATION                       The public defender’s office selected
                                            Brittany for the trial through a compet-
Experiential learning does not get          itive process involving other externs
much more real than this: 3L Brittany       from other law schools. “At Chase, I
Grigery this past March sat sec-            gained the mental endurance that is
ond-chair in a murder trial, working        necessary not only to gain a Juris
with the lead lawyer from the San           Doctor, but also apparently to finish a
Diego County (California) Public            month-long trial,” she says. “Staying
                                            focused, organized, and diligent for              Brittany Grigery
Defender. She examined witnesses,
managed client communication, and           such a long period of time was key to
assisted with trial strategy and            our success. Chase prepared me well        The trial ended in a hung jury, with ten
preparation.                                for this experience.”                      jurors voting for acquittal.

             STUDENTS

     Student Bar Association                  The 2018-19 officers, and their          The 2017-18
                                              upcoming class years, will be: Tarah     Chase enroll-
     Leadership Achieves a First              Rémy, 3L, president; Sarah Hall, 3L,     ment of 397
     With a predominantly female              vice-president/full-time student;        students was
     enrollment this past academic year,      Sheree Weichold, 4L, vice-presi-         composed of
     Chase College of Law students            dent/part-time student; Emily            201 women, or
     elected women to all of the Student      Robbins, 2L, secretary; Kati Massey,     51 percent, and
     Bar Association offices for the          2L, treasurer; and Hope LeMaster,        196 men, or 49
     upcoming year, apparently a first in     2L, ABA representative.                  percent.                           Tarah Rémy,
     the college’s history.                                                                                       2018-19 Student Bar
                                                                                                                 Association president

        COMPETITIONS
                                            Client Counseling Competition. They        3Ls Michael Bromell, Tory Finley, and

Student Teams Rise                          reached the championships at Durham,
                                            North Carolina, by finishing second in
                                                                                       Alex McKenzie, and one team was
                                                                                       made up of 2Ls Molly Bramble, Demi
in Regional, National                       regional competition in February. A team
                                            of 4L Rich Lom and 3L Tina Keller placed
                                                                                       Messer, and Tanner Duncan. Professor
                                                                                       Jack Harrison coached the teams, with
Contests                                    third in the regional, giving Chase
                                            back-to-back finishes. Ryan Wheeler, who
                                                                                       additional coaching by adjunct
                                                                                       professors Zac Anderson, Melissa
Chase College of Law students tested        was graduated from Chase in 2017 and is    Bodner, Ken Foisy, Mark Gerano, Ian
their emerging lawyering skills this past   an associate in the Cincinnati firm of     Mitchell, Tim Spille, Carrie Masters
winter against students from other law      Thompson Hine, coached the teams.          Starts, Jesse Taylor, and Del Weldon.
schools in regional competitions and a
                                            Both teams in the National Trial           A team of 3Ls Bill Wilson and Jason
national championship:
                                            Competition advanced to the regional       Rainey won the in-person negotiating
A team of 3L Alex Cardosi and 1L            semifinal round at Knoxville, Tennessee.   sessions of the regional Transactional
Katelynn McDaniel placed in the top         Each dominated preliminary rounds          LawMeets competition in Chicago.
twelve among more than 110 teams from       with teams from law schools in             Barbara Wagner, former director of the
more than sixty law schools in the          Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, and         Chase Small Business and Nonprofit
national championships of the ABA           Missouri. One team was composed of         Law Clinic, coached the team.

4 C H A S E M A G A Z I NE
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
FACULTY                      basics, and taught courses in ethics for    at Chiquita, she was also a vice
                                            transactional lawyers.                      president, associate general counsel,
Small Business Clinic                                                                   assistant secretary, and chief
                                            “I talked with students a lot about
Director Turns to New Role                  client service, and how the 24-hour
                                                                                        compliance officer.

                                            rule [to respond] is evolving into a        She has been succeeded as clinic
Barbara Wagner, who was director of         24-minute rule,” she says. “Students        director by Robert Furnier, who is also
the Small Business and Nonprofit Law        needed to learn how to manage client        director of the W. Bruce Lunsford
Clinic and an assistant professor of law    expectations and to keep clients            Academy for Law, Business +
for five and a half years, has resigned     informed about the status of their          Technology.
from the full-time faculty to teach as an   work. I tried to impress that slow
adjunct professor and to work with the      service when they are in practice
Pro Bono Partnership of Ohio to             would not lead to a lot of repeat
provide free legal advice to nonprofit      business. The students who managed
organizations.                              to turn drafts quickly (often those with
                                            full-time jobs and other law school
The clinic enrolled about ninety            courses) always impressed me.”
students during her time as director
and provided more than 7,000 hours of       Prior to joining the faculty in 2012, she
legal work to about 200 small               practiced for more than thirty years as
businesses, nonprofits, or start-ups.       a corporate and securities lawyer,
She also oversaw the Transactional          including ten years in private practice
Law Practice Center, directed the           and more than twenty years as an
                                                                                          Barbara Wagner and 2014 clinic students
Business Boot Camp program to give          in-house lawyer with Chiquita Brands
                                                                                          Lauren Van Sickle ’15 and Joseph Schwamb ’15.
students an immersion in business           International, in Cincinnati. While

Chase Professor                             Professor David Singleton has been          thoroughly for appellate oral arguments
                                            recognized with the Northern Ken-           that judges rarely ask them questions
is Outstanding                              tucky University outstanding professor      they had not anticipated. In the
University Professor                        award for his work that reflects the        classroom – this past year he taught
                                            university’s mission.                       Voir Dire Strategies and Criminal
                                                                                        Procedure – he is known for engaging
                                            His selection for the Frank Sinton
                                                                                        students with examples from contem-
                                            Milburn Outstanding Professor Award
                                                                                        porary, high-profile cases.
                                            for 2018 spotlights his accomplishments
                                            as a law clinic mentor and a classroom      The university award was created in
                                            professor. As director of the Chase         1970 and later endowed by Dr. Carol
                                            Constitutional Litigation Clinic, in        Swarts Milburn, a Northern Kentucky
                                            which students gain courtroom               oncologist, and renamed the Frank
                                            experience by representing prisoners        Sinton Milburn Outstanding Professor
                                            and former prisoners in claims of civil     Award to honor the life of her husband,
  David Singleton
                                            rights abuses, he prepares students so      an entrepreneur and inventor.

         TECHNOLOGY                         Technology at Chase College of Law          counsel, innovators, private-practice
                                            organized a companion program to            lawyers, and educators, including Chase
Lunsford Academy Takes Stage                the ABA Techshow this past March in         Adjunct Professor Helen Bukulmez –
with ABA Techshow                           Chicago to help women become                was straightforward: Develop mentors,
                                            developers of law-related computer          build a team, do not be intimidated. For
Like the corporate glass ceiling, female
                                            applications and lawyers for technolo-      men who want to help women break
lawyers and entrepreneurs are facing a
                                            gy companies.                               through the ceiling, the advice was to
silicon ceiling in law-related technolo-
                                                                                        believe the experiences of women and
gy. To help crack it, the W. Bruce          The advice from nine speakers – includ-
                                                                                        to invite their opinions.
Lunsford Academy for Law, Business +        ing technology-related in-house

                                                                                                          SP RING/ SUMME R 2 0 1 8 5
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
College of Law News

Chase Offers its Expertise                                                                A continuing legal education
                                                                                          program in Florida provides

to Lawyers Nationwide                                                                     training for practice, business,
                                                                                          and technology

The lessons of the W. Bruce Lunsford Academy for Law, Business     Just as the academy’s name defines its focus on law, business,
+ Technology at Chase College of Law are as important for          and technology, the CLE sessions concentrated on related
lawyers as they are for law students. The academy, which           topics such as legal ethics in a digital age, understanding
emphasizes multidisciplinary training for problem-solving, took    financial statements, working with in-house lawyers,
some of its core subject matter to St. Pete Beach, Florida, this   online client development, and efficiently using law-related
past winter to offer lawyers from throughout the nation three      technology. Here is some of the ground Chase faculty
days of continuing legal education.                                covered in various sessions:

____________________             ____________________              ____________________             ____________________

Business Basics                  Ethics for                        Online Marketing                 Effective Use of
Professor Chris Gulinello        Transactional                     Essentials | Ethics              Technology
Lawyers and business             Lawyers | Working                 Adjunct Professor Helen          Adjunct Professor William
clients must utilize the same                                      Bukulmez                         Lunceford
business terms and
                                 with In-House
                                                                   Even though the screens on       Being a lawyer in the digital
fundamental skills. For          Counsel                           devices potential clients        age involves gathering
lawyers, that may mean           Adjunct Professor                 might use to view                information, managing
knowing what a balance           Barbara Wagner                    information about a lawyer       information, and presenting
sheet shows about a              Lawyers with a corporate          are often small, it is           information. Knowing how
business, and where to look      client represent the              important to remember the        to use common
in it for information such as    corporation, but interact         big picture of client            information-processing
assets, liabilities, and         with employees, officers,         development online:              software can simplify those
equity. Other good-to-have       or directors. That means          provide helpful information      tasks and complete them
knowledge: how to                issues of confidentiality         on a website, utilize social     more efficiently. In the
understand a company’s           and of an individual’s role       media, and pay attention to      evolution of technology,
valuation, what present          in a corporation can arise.       online reviews. That big         computing power is
value and future value           For an effective working          picture might need               increasing dramatically –
mean, and how to read a          relationship between              fine-tuning to comply with       there is more in a
graphic representation of a      outside counsel and               ethics rules. In Kentucky, for   smartphone than in early
general ledger account,          in-house counsel, outside         example, a lawyer may not        manned space missions –
known as a T account.            counsel must understand           solicit professional             and is costing less.
                                 the client’s business             employment by real-time
                                 environment, pay attention        electronic means.
                                 to the budget for legal
                                 services, and maintain
                                 regular and timely
                                 communication.

6 C H A S E M A G A Z I NE
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
College of Law News

Symposium on Racial Profiling
Explores Far-Reaching Impact
The ramifications can                                                                                 ALEXANDRIA LUBANS-OTTO,
                                                                                                      A SOLO PRACTITIONER, ON
divide families and                                                                                   PROFILING OF IMMIGRANTS
strain perceptions                                                                                    “It affects people born outside
                                                                                                      the United States in every-
Racial profiling has a lot of                                                                         thing from access to basic
faces. It is faces of people of                                                                       needs to their ability to
color. It is faces of immi-                                                                           maintain custody of their
grants and people who look                                                                            children. Too many Ameri-
like they might be immi-                                                                              cans rely on the ‘sound bite’
grants. It is a face of                                                                               regarding immigrants in this
technology that can help                                                                              country and overlook the
constrain it.                                                                                         contributions of, and
                                                                                                      necessity of, immigrants.
The Chase College of Law
Northern Kentucky Law Review let people look at those faces          “Taxpayer monies are directed to detaining, processing, and
during a symposium in early March at Northern Kentucky               removing noncriminal immigrants at a time when our
University. Symposium panels brought together eight lawyers          economy feels strained, and there are more useful and
from law schools, private practice, and a nonprofit law center.      compassionate ways to direct these funds.”
Among them were Chase alumna Janaya Trotter Bratton,                 ______________________________________________
Northern Kentucky immigration lawyer Alexandria
                                                                     ROBERT FURNIER, ACADEMY DIRECTOR, ON TECHNOLOGY
Lubans-Otto, and Robert Furnier, director of the W. Bruce
                                                                     AND RACIAL PROFILING
Lunsford Academy for Law, Business + Technology at Chase.
Here are the faces each put on aspects of racial profiling:          “Polls show that a significant percentage of African Americans
______________________________________________                       believe that racial profiling is real and, worse, that explicit
                                                                     racism is behind police decision-making. Although police
JANAYA TROTTER BRATTON ’08, ASSOCIATE IN THE CINCINNATI              target African Americans disproportionately during traffic
FIRM OF GERHARDSTEIN & BRANCH, ON RACIAL PROFILING OF                stops, they do not believe that racism drives their decisions to
BLACK CHILDREN AND TEENAGERS                                         pull drivers over.
“The immediate impact of ‘growing up a suspect’ through
                                                                     “Technology like Hello, Officer – a virtual traffic stop app that
racial profiling of black youth is a society that sees and treats
                                                                     permits officers and drivers to use smartphone video commu-
black children as adults at a very early age. This translates into
                                                                     nication to conduct traffic stops without police or citizens
a juvenile justice system in which black children are overrep-
                                                                     leaving their vehicles – has a greater chance of decreasing the
resented. The profiling of black children not only impacts
                                                                     use of racial profiling during policing than non-technological
whether they go through the system, what they are charged
                                                                     means because videoconferencing captures interactions in real
with, and their sentences, but it has dire consequences for
                                                                     time and gives citizens and police the ability to preserve
their health. The suicide rate among black children has
                                                                     interactions. This allows for the real-time collection of data so
increased as rates for children of other races have declined or
                                                                     that individual police officers, or their departments, can better
remained steady.
                                                                     understand whether African Americans are being dispropor-
“We all have implicit biases that can cause us to treat people       tionately targeted and, if so, under what circumstances.
differently, even if consciously we would never discriminate         Because profiling is likely the product of implicit bias – by its
against another person. Everyone who has the opportunity to          nature, an unconscious process – police officers will not
impact a child’s life has to be cognizant of his or her uncon-       appreciate, or correct, their behavior without a tool to help
scious decision-making. Treating black children like adults          them appreciate when implicit biases have translated into
and second-class citizens has long-term consequences.”               conscious decision making.”

                                                                                                           SP RING/ SUMME R 2 0 1 8 7
CHASE - Student-Designed Apps | Winning Appellate Arguments - Chase College of Law
Cover Story

   STUDENT

                              LAWYER

                                 CANDIDATE

8 C H A S E M A G A Z I NE
THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL FOR ALUMNI ON BALLOTS THIS
YEAR BEGINS AT CHASE                                          Now, in a year of surging political interest, more than
                                                              seventy alumni, most of them in Kentucky and Ohio,
Ten years after graduation from Chase College of Law,         are seeking election as legislators, judges, or prosecutors.
Graham Trimble decided the time is right to run for           Some are first-time candidates; many are incumbents.
elected office. He wants to become Commonwealth’s             For each of them, the map for the campaign trail begins
Attorney for McCreary and Whitley counties, in                at Chase.
southeast Kentucky.
                                                              Putting aside the obvious connection between having
Mr. Trimble, who was graduated in 2008, is approaching        a personal interest in law and the legislation that
the campaign with perspective and purpose. “Elections         creates it or law and the administration of it, law school
are costly, both financially and in time away from family     in general and aspects of Chase in particular are ideal
and friends. If someone is going to step into the political   preparation for elected service. There are experiences
arena, the desire to make an office better needs to be        in identifying and communicating issues, understanding
the driving force,” he says.                                  responsibility for a greater good, refining leadership
                                                              traits, and developing lawyering skills that also apply
Venturing into politics places him in the long history
                                                              to a political campaign.
of Chase alumni seeking and holding elected public
offices. Alumni serve, or have served, in the United          From law school to Election Day, Chase professors
States House of Representatives, in state legislatures,       and alumni with political involvement explain on the
on state supreme courts, appellate courts, and trial          following pages how experiences at Chase prepare
courts, as prosecutors, and in just about any local           alumni for the fast track of the campaign trail.
office for which citizens have a vote.

                                                                                                       SP RING/ SUMME R 2 0 1 8 9
Cover Story

THE CHASE POLITICAL ADVANTAGE

       Civic engagement begins early
       What Professor Jennifer Kinsley, director of experiential learning, says:
       “Chase emphasizes civic engagement through its outstanding clinics, where law students
       work on real cases, ranging from child victim protection to government accountability
       to small business start-ups. In this way, Chase brings the community into its classrooms
       and sends its students out into the community. Students are taught from day one
       that lawyers exist to serve society, so by the time they graduate, the idea of public
       leadership is deeply ingrained in who they are as professionals and as people.”

       Leadership training runs                                                    Tensions between what the
       throughout courses                                                          law is and ought to be help forge
       Professor Kinsley:                                                          commitments to a cause
       “Chase prepares students for participation in                               Professor John Bickers, who teaches
       public life by providing diverse curricular offerings                       Constitutional Law:
       that allow students to hone their leadership skills.                        “Successful law students are invariably both
       For example, Chase offers a panoply of simulation                           smart and hard working. Some of them, though,
       courses, ranging from trial advocacy to client                              have a passionate sense of ‘what the law ought to
       counseling, that encourage students to hone                                 be’ that you can hear when they participate in
       their communication skills, to work with                                    discussions about ‘what the law is.’ It is those
       stakeholders from all walks of life,                                        students who I often see moving into
       and to build consensus through                                              government, whether by running for office
       persuasive advocacy.”                                                       themselves or helping those who do.”

       Knowing how to connect with a jury works for voters, too
       Professor Jack Harrison, trial team coordinator and previously a congressional staff member and campaign manager:
        “One of the most important skills from law school, particularly for attorneys who have done trial work, is the ability to
       connect with an audience through story. Attorneys must effectively communicate with clients and with juries in much the
       same way a political candidate must connect with potential voters. These are skills that are developed throughout law
       school, from first-year oral arguments through trial advocacy classes through competing as a member of a moot court or
       mock trial team. One pitfall that law students and lawyers in practice and lawyers in politics always struggle to avoid is
       ‘sounding like a lawyer.’ Luckily, law school professors, law school classmates, clients, judges, and constituents are always
       present to remind us to talk like a normal human being – something lawyers are not always good at doing.”

1 0 C H A S E M A G A Z INE
COVER STORY

Attention to nuance
helps avoid policy                      Networking lessons pay off in a campaign
and issue pitfalls                      Joe Cunningham ’14, candidate for the U.S. House of
                                        Representatives in South Carolina:
Professor Michael
Mannheimer, author of                   “Through different cases and clients, practicing
numerous law review                     attorneys build extensive networks throughout the           Clinic
articles on constitutional              community and various fields of employment. These           experiences
                                                                                                    make public
interpretation:                         relationships allow attorneys to ask for advice from
                                        professionals that, if not for the law field, would not
“Criminal Law – for most                be available. This has benefited my campaign greatly.       service second-
                                                                                                    nature
law students, their first               It has allowed me to gain new perspectives on
encounter with the art of               community issues, as well as seek guidance on
reading and drafting                                                                                Professor Amy
                                        how to better serve my future constituents.”
statutes – is largely about                                                                         Halbrook, director
statutory interpretation.                                                                           of the Children’s Law
One of my main goals for                                                                            Center Clinic:
the class is having students
                                                                                                    “Students who gain
discover how minor
changes in the language,                Training in scholarship and decision-                       real-life experience
                                                                                                    with clients and the
syntax, or punctuation of a             making carries forward for judges                           public – whether in
statute can have tremen-
                                        Judge Karen Thomas ’85,                                     clinics or in pro
dous real-world conse-
                                        Campbell County (Kentucky) District Court:                  bono positions –
quences. Some of my
                                                                                                    begin to develop
favorite moments in                     “There is more to becoming a judge than running for
                                                                                                    their lawyering skills,
criminal law come from                  election. To be a good judge not only do you have to be
                                                                                                    their professional
having students try to                  willing to be a constant student of the law and strong
                                                                                                    identities and their
re-draft statutory lan-                 enough to make the hard decisions, but to a large
                                                                                                    commitment to
guage. Hopefully, those                 degree temperament plays a huge part in what makes
                                                                                                    justice. Students
who end up in legislatures              a good judge. A judge must be able to represent the
                                                                                                    become, as one
carry this skill with them.”            fair and impartial nature of justice while tempering
                                                                                                    clinic student noted,
                                        that justice with compassion and respect for each
                                                                                                    ‘public service
                                        individual who appears before her.”
                                                                                                    minded.’ Their
                                                                                                    preparation and
                                                                                                    their abilities to
                                                                                                    think practically and
                                                                                                    critically will help
The rigors of law school are preparation for handling                                               them serve as
a campaign and a career                                                                             competent and
                                                                                                    ethical elected
Wil Schroder II ’08, Kentucky state senator and practicing lawyer:
                                                                                                    officials.”
“Law school helped prepare me for being able to manage my time. As a third-year law
student, I was president of the Student Bar Association and Christian Legal Society, and
   was also a member of the trial advocacy team. Learning how to balance the demands
      of a hectic and often stressful schedule has benefited me greatly in my career.
         Running for office is a major commitment, not only for the candidate, but also
            those around him or her. When deciding to run for office, the most important          Alumni seeking
               and first vote you need to get is from your spouse, if you have one. A close       federal or state
                   second is that of your firm or colleagues. Having the support back
                      home and at the office is crucial to being able to have the flexibility
                                                                                                  offices
                         to campaign and hold an elected position.”

                                                                                                  SP RING/ SUMMER 2 0 1 8 1 1
Cover Story

ALUMNI ON THE BALLOT
These Chase alumni who filed to seek federal or state offices in 2018 were identified in Kentucky
through an online database of candidate filings made with the Kentucky Secretary of State, in southwest
Ohio through filings with boards of elections in Butler, Clermont, Hamilton, Montgomery, and Warren
counties, and elsewhere through an online politics database, in which candidates could be identified as
Chase graduates, and through news reports in which a candidate was identified as a Chase graduate. The list
is not exhaustive, and does not include candidates for municipal or county offices for which candidates filed with
a county clerk or board of elections in any of the 120 counties in Kentucky or 88 counties in Ohio or elsewhere.
An (i) following a name in the list indicates an incumbent and a (j) indicates a judge seeking a different judgeship.

U.S. House                    Adam Cart ’10, District       Kentucky Circuit Court,      Douglas J. Grothaus ’87,       Karen A. Thomas ’85,
Steve Chabot ’78,             46 (Breckinridge,             Family                       District 16 (Kenton) (i)       District 17 (Campbell) (i)
                              Grayson, Meade)
Cincinnati (i)                                              Dawn Gentry ’86,             W. “Skip” Hammons              Marcia Thomas ’93,
                              J. Kelly Clarke ’94,          District 16 (Kenton) (i)     ’91, District 27 (Knox,        District 54 (Boone,
Joe Cunningham ’14,
                              District 19 (Bracken,                                      Laurel) (i)                    Gallatin)
Charleston, South                                           Pete Roush ’02, District
                              Fleming, Mason) (i)
Carolina                                                    16 (Kenton)                  Charles W. “Chuck”             Don Thompson Jr. ’87,
                              Sean Fitzgerald ’06,                                       Hardin ’96, District 25        District 51 (Henderson)
Kentucky legislature          District 16 (Kenton) (i)      Terri King Schoborg ’85,     (Clark, Madison) (i)
                                                            District 16 (Kenton)                                        H. Rupert Wilhoit III
Abigail Barnes ’09,           John Gardner ’04,                                          Jarrod Jackson ’05,            ’91, District 37 (Carter,
House District 4              District 43 (Barren,          Kentucky District Court      District 56 (Caldwell,         Elliott, Morgan) (i)
(Western Kentucky)            Metcalfe)                                                  Livingston, Lyon, Trigg)
                                                            Howe Baker ’89, District                                    Robert F. Wright ’95,
Greg Coulson ’10,             Samuel Herald ’99,            24 (Johnson, Lawrence,       Luke Lawless ’10,              District 35 (Pike)
House District 78             District 39 (Breathitt,       Martin)                      District 11 (Green,
(Northern Kentucky)           Powell, Wolfe)                                             Marion, Taylor,                Robert “Robby” Yoakum
                                                            Don Blair ’75, District                                     ’99 District 44 (Bell) (i)
Chris Harris ’96,             Melvin Leonhart ’00,          21 (Bath, Menifee,           Washington)
House District 93             District 20 (Lincoln,         Montgomery, Rowan) (i)       James M. Lawson ’82,           Ohio Court of Appeals
(Eastern Kentucky)            Pulaski, Rockcastle)                                       District 40 (Clinton,
                                                            John Chafin ’81, District                                   Robert C. Winkler ’87,
C. Ed Massey ’92,             Louis Kelly ’07, District     24 (Johnson, Lawrence,       Russell, Wayne) (i)            Hamilton County (j)
House District 66             54 (Boone, Gallatin)          Martin) (i)                  William “Bo” Leach ’03,        Ohio Court of Common
(Northern Kentucky)           Rob Sanders ’98,                                           District 23 (Estill, Lee,      Pleas
                                                            Elizabeth Chandler ’96,
Diane St. Onge ’01,           District 16 (Kenton) (i)                                   Owsley) (i)
                                                            District 15 (Carroll,                                       Richard P. Ferenc ’77,
House District 63             Michelle Snodgrass-           Grant, Owen) (i)             Keith McMain ’89,              Clermont County (i)
(Northern Kentucky) (i)       Deimling ’98, District                                     District 54 (Boone,
                                                            Brian Crick ’04,                                            J. Gregory Howard ’87,
Wil Schroder II ’08,          17 (Campbell) (i)                                          Gallatin)
                                                            District 45 (McLean,                                        Butler County (i)
Senate District 24            Jackie Steele ’01, District   Muhlenberg) (i)              Bill Oliver ’88, District
(Northern Kentucky) (i)       27 (Knox, Laurel) (i)                                      13 (Garrard, Jessamine,        Donald E. Oda II ’95,
                                                            Deborah Hawkins              Lincoln) (i)                   Warren County (i)
Robin Webb ’86, Senate        Graham Trimble ’08,           Crooks ’85, District 52
District 18 (Eastern          District 34 (McCreary,        (Graves) (i)                 Billy L. Oliver ’87,           Ohio Area Court
Kentucky) (i)                 Whitley)                                                   District 39 (Breathitt,
                                                            David Curlin ’08,                                           Robert H. Lyons ’80,
                                                                                         Powell, Wolfe)                 Butler County Area I (i)
Ohio legislature              Judicial                      District 51 (Henderson)
                                                                                         Sam C. Potter ’84,             Ohio Juvenile Court
Adrienne Buckler ’15,         Kentucky Court of             Tracy Davis ’12, District    District 8 (Warren) (i)
House District 90             Appeals                       30 (Jefferson)                                              E. Gerald Parker ’07,
(Southern Ohio)                                                                          Dennis B. Prater ’00,          Montgomery County
                              Kevin Sinnette ’88,           Kenneth L. Easterling ’88,   District 36 (Knott,
Matthew Robinson ’00,         District 7 (Eastern           District 16 (Kenton) (i)     Magoffin) (i)                  Colorado County Court
House District 28             Kentucky)
                                                            Joe Friend ’81, District     William “Willie”               Julie Huffman ’07,
(Northeast Hamilton           Larry E. Thompson ’87,
County)                                                     35 (Pike)                    Roberts ’84, District 21       west-central Colorado (i)
                              District 7 (Eastern                                        (Bath, Menifee,
                              Kentucky) (j)                 Thomas M. Funk ’81,                                         Indiana Superior Court
Kentucky                                                    District 15 (Carroll,        Montgomery, Rowan) (i)
                              Kentucky Circuit Court                                                                    Sally A. McLaughlin ’90,
Commonwealth’s                                              Grant, Owen) (i)             Ann Ruttle ’84, District
                                                                                                                        Dearborn County (i)
Attorney                      Derek R. Durbin ’03,          Kenneth Goff II ’88,         16 (Kenton) (i)
                              Circuit 17 (Campbell)                                                                     Missouri Circuit Court
Ronnie Bowling ’12,                                         District 46                  Jeff Schumacher ’92,
District 34 (McCreary,        Daniel Zalla ’74, Circuit     (Breckinridge,               District 19 (Bracken,          Thomas Swindle ’81,
Whitley)                      17 (Campbell) (i)             Grayson, Meade) (i)          Fleming, Mason) (i)            southeast Missouri (i)

1 2 C H A S E M A G A Z INE
Anniversaries

                                        hase
                            , w h ere C
                          l
                    s Hal          1978
              Hankin ocated in
                was l                   Profes
                                                sors Ro                          Hankins Hall view to downtown
                                         and Fre         ge
                                                 derick S r Billings
                                                         chneide
                                                                 r

The Class of 1978 Reaches a Milestone
The fortieth anniversary of the first graduation class of day and evening students is a time
for some of its members to reflect on how Chase prepared them for the future
The year was 1978.
                                                                                          Gary Cohen
Diane Keaton was the Academy Awards’ Best Actress, with
                                                                                          Now: Producer and investor in
the Annie Hall-look that forty years later still influences street
                                                                                          theatrical productions, following
fashion.
                                                                                          retirement as chief administrative
The Eagles’ “Hotel California” was Record of the Year, with                               officer of Finish Line, an athletic
lyrics such as “check out any time you like / but you can never                           shoe and apparel retailer; after
leave” cited decades later in reflections on issues such as                               graduation as an evening student:
politics and economics.                                              deputy prosecutor in Indianapolis.
And in the Supreme Court of the United States, Regents of the        “Probably the most important aspect of my Chase
University of California v. Bakke allowed race as a factor in        experience was the practical legal training I received. I
college admissions, and immediately became a landmark                was able to leave law school and immediately handle
decision for law school students the next forty years.               legal matters with full confidence. In the later years of
                                                                     my career, especially when I transitioned from general
Now the year is 2018, the fortieth anniversary of the first
                                                                     counsel in a billion-dollar, publicly traded company to
Chase College of Law graduation class of both part-time
                                                                     the business side, as chief administrative officer, I was
evening students and full-time day students. The evening
                                                                     able to apply the strong legal analysis I learned at
students had enrolled in 1974; the first day students in 1975.
                                                                     Chase as a member of the business team of the
Together, they were the Class of 1978, and the start of a new
                                                                     company. I am now on my third career, as a Broadway
era for Chase.
                                                                     producer, and I am using my strong legal and business
In the forty years since graduation, the Class of 1978 has           sense to determine which production opportunities
become partners in regional law firms, successful solo               will make good strategic and business sense in the
practitioners, corporate officers, judges, elected officials, and    very risky theatrical world. I feel that I am one step
has affected the lives of countless individuals and institutions.    ahead of others who do not have a practical legal
For some of its members, these are the memories of how               background dealing with these theatrical business
Chase laid the foundation for their success:                         transactions.”

                                                                                                   SP RING/ SUMMER 2 0 1 8 1 3
Anniversaries

                         Daniel                Legal Writing and Research class. His       combined not only to encourage us to
                         Stratton              admonition to write in a clear, concise,    spend the time and effort needed, but
                                               and precise manner will always stay         also to instill confidence in our abilities
                      Now: Partner in
                                               with me. Professor Eugene Youngs and        once we graduated. The excellent legal
                      the Stratton Law
                                               Professor Ovid Lewis exhibited their        education provided by those professors
                      Firm, Pikeville,
                                               love of the law during every class          and Chase was the foundation for
                      Kentucky; after
                                               session, and you had to remain              anything I accomplished in my career
                      graduation as a
                                               prepared and on your toes. Professor Ed     thereafter.”
day student: associate in the Pikeville
                                               Goggin was a friend and trusted adviser
firm of Stratton, May & Hays, founded
                                               to every student, regardless of whether
by his grandfather, in which his father
                                               or not you were a student in his class.                            Alan
also practiced.
                                               Lastly, the admiralty class taught by                              Hartman
“The day Class of 1978 had no juniors          Adjunct Professor Bill Schroeder                                  Now: Corporate
or seniors to look up to, or to assist us in   opened doors to the career path that I                            practice focused
anything when we entered. According-           have followed for nearly forty years. He                          on information
ly, the freshman day Class of 1978             exemplified, in many ways, the selfless                           technology and
became very supportive of each other.          dedication of the Chase faculty.”           intellectual property law at Ulmer &
Because we were mostly on our own, we                                                      Berne, Cincinnati; after graduation as a
learned to solve our own problems. I                                                       day student: solo practice.
think this part of the experience taught                             Bea Wolper
                                                                                           “At Chase, I learned how to critically
us to be more self-reliant, which better                               Now: President of
                                                                                           analyze legal problems and develop
prepared us to begin practice. The                                     Emens & Wolper
                                                                                           creative solutions for those problems.
school had made a strategic decision to                                Law Firm, which
                                                                                           I’ve gone from solo practice to a small
recruit students from all across the                                   concentrates in
                                                                                           firm to general counsel of two software
commonwealth, so the first class                                       family-owned
                                                                                           companies to practicing in a large
represented students from Pikeville to         business and energy law, in Columbus,
                                                                                           regional law firm. All along that path,
Paducah, and all points in between.            Ohio; after graduation as an evening
                                                                                           my education at Chase has served me
This started the Kentucky base of              student: associate in a small firm.
                                                                                           well. That education was the foundation
alumni we enjoy today.”
                                                “Dean Jack Grosse was an incredible        that enabled me to become an excellent
                                               mentor, as well as a great professor.       business attorney contributing to my
                         Stephen               My contracts class experiences,             clients’ success. I will always be grateful
                         Little                working as his assistant, and applying      for my Chase experience.”
                     Now: President            what he taught me enabled me to
                     and chief execu-          succeed in my career by thinking
                     tive officer of           rationally and striving to find                                    Mary Healy
                     Grouse Corp.,             solutions to problems.                                            Now: Partner in
                     privately held                                                                              the Cincinnati
operator of towboats and barges, based                                                                           firm of Dinsmore
in Paducah, Kentucky; after graduation                               Jeffrey                                     & Shohl, concen-
as a day student: counsel to the                                     Raines                                      trating in estate
Merchant Marine and Fisheries                                        Now: Of counsel,      planning and business succession
Committee of the United States House                                 Raines, Dusing &      planning; after graduation as an evening
of Representatives.                                                  Sutton, Florence,     student: associate with the Cincinnati
                                                                     Kentucky; after       firm of Paxton & Seasongood, where she
 “The faculty of full-time professors was
                                               graduation as a day student: practiced      had worked as a student and which later
very dedicated and always accessible. In
                                               with William P. McEvoy, Burlington,         merged with Thompson Hine, where she
addition, the adjunct professors were
                                               Kentucky.                                   was a partner.
practicing attorneys with substantial
experience. As a result, we had a great        “The quality, skills, and commitment of     “Working while attending Chase led to
mix of the scholarly as well as the            the professors at Chase, along with the     a full-time position at a firm which,
practical side of the law. I benefited         fear they instilled by suggesting that a    forty years ago, had not typically hired
greatly from Professor Edward Ziegler’s        third of the class would not graduate,      Chase graduates. I am very pleased to

1 4 C H A S E M A G A Z INE
note that Cincinnati law firms, large        ployed by the Hamilton County Public
and small, now welcome Chase grads.          Defender and started in private
With the ability to work full-time while     practice. After two years, I left and
attending evening classes I quickly fell     focused on my practice.”
in love with estate planning, tax, and
trust work, to which after forty years I
still devote the majority of my practice.”                         Fred Stine
                                                                    Now: Retired
                      Bernie                                        judge of the
                      Robinson                                      Campbell County
                                                                    (Kentucky) Circuit
                      Now: Partner and
                                                                    Court; after
                      co-owner of The
                                             graduation as an evening student:
                      Livingston Group,                                                   Professor Edward Goggin
                                             private practice for eighteen months,        taught the Class of 1978
                      a bipartisan
                                             followed by twenty-three years as an
                      lobbying firm in
                                             Assistant United States Attorney for the
Washington, D.C.; after graduation as
                                             Eastern District of Kentucky.
an evening student: director of govern-
ment relations for Philip Morris USA.        “I was very fortunate during my career
                                             to be in the right place at the right time
 “While I never practiced law, learning
                                             at least twice. Being an evening student
during law school how to find the law
                                             required that I had the ability to
and to more fully understand key legal
                                             maintain a tough schedule, since I
provisions substantially enhanced my
                                             worked full-time. The work day would
ability to successfully navigate chal-
                                             start early in the morning and wouldn’t
lenging decisions and situations later in
                                             be over until late at night, usually
life. Fortunately, friendships and
                                             somewhere between 11 p.m. and 1 a.m.
working relationships during law
                                             A few hours later it would start again.”
school continue, and these valuable
resources help achieve personal and
professional objectives and often add                              Fran
value to the result.”                                              Niehaus                Chase occupied Hankins Hall
                                                                                                   1972-1981
                                                                  Now: Practices
                      Steve                                       with two other
                      Schuh                                       lawyers in the
                      Now: Partner in                             Niehaus Law
                      the Cincinnati                              Office, Cincinnati,
                      firm of Schuh &        and owns Niehaus Financial Services,
                      Goldberg,              and Niehaus Tax Services; after
concentrating in transactional law; after    graduation as an evening student: solo
graduation as an evening student:            practice.
lawyer in the Office of the Hamilton
                                             “Because I hung out my shingle from
County Public Defender.
                                             day one, the practical education I
“Chase facilitated my career as an           received at Chase was vital to my
attorney. As I was married and               career-start in law. Some of my
working full-time in support of my           professors practiced during the day and
family, the opportunity to become a          taught in the evening, and their
                                                                                          Dean W. Jack Grosse oversa
lawyer was not otherwise available. At       recounting of their experiences in             creation of day classes
                                                                                                                     w
Chase, I had access to lawyers as            practice were beneficial and gave me
teachers, and met some of the finest         confidence. Several of them became role
people I’ve had the pleasure to know.        models and post-graduation mentors,
Fresh out of law school, I was em-           as did some of my fellow students.”

                                                                                                 SP RING/ SUMMER 2 0 1 8 1 5
Anniversaries

In the Words of the Founder
Robert M. Ochiltree, who                          After my graduation from the Cincinnati Law School in 1892, I returned to
                                                  my father’s farm in [southeast] Indiana to harvest a field of wheat I had
 in 1893 founded the law                          sown, and to teach school to pay an indebtedness incurred in my law school
school that would later be                        course. I returned to Cincinnati in May 1893, and followed what I thought
 named Salmon P. Chase                            was the usual procedure of recent law graduates, going from office to office
                                                                                             in an endeavor to locate.
College of Law, tells in an
                                                                                                  In one of the offices, the lawyer’s
excerpt from his memoir                                                                           son was reading law, and on
 the story of a college that                                                                      learning that I was a recent
  almost did not come to                                                                          graduate, the lawyer inquired
                                                                                                  about the [Cincinnati Law
    be, but for a chance                                                                          School] course and whether I
 meeting on a Cincinnati                                                                          knew about a Virginia law school
street. Here are the words                                                                        which he said had a summer
                                                                                                  term; and that he was considering
     of Dean Ochiltree,                                                                           having his son attend it to prepare
published in 1943 in The                                                                          for advanced standing in the
   Y.M.C.A Night Law                                                                              Cincinnati Law School. Later, it
                                                                                                  occurred to me that perhaps I
 School, Cincinnati, that                                                                         could form a class with his son
  recount his founding of                                                                         and others as students in a
    Chase 125 years ago.                                                                          summer course that would
                                                                                                  prepare them for the examination
                                                                                                  for advanced standing.
                                                                                             I called on the Hon. Jacob D. Cox
                                                  (his students called him “Governor”), dean of the Cincinnati Law School,
                                                  and he gave me a letter of recommendation and the names of those who had
                                                  inquired about advanced standing in his school. [Cox had been an Ohio
                                                  governor and a United States Secretary of the Interior. The Cincinnati Law
                                                  School was a private program from its founding in 1833 until its merger
                                                  with the University of Cincinnati in 1897.]

           ­ —                What happened at Chase while
                              Robert M. Ochiltree was dean,
                              from late 1893 to mid-1916:
                                                                October 17, 1893 Seventeen
                                                                students attend the first class,
                                                                conducted by Dean Ochiltree in
                                                                                                         May 1895 First class, of five
                                                                                                         students, is graduated.

        The early
                                                                                                         Autumn 1895 With 106
                                                                the tower room of the YMCA
                              ------------------------                                                   students enrolled in three class
                                                                building at Seventh and Walnut
                                                                                                         years, Dean Ochiltree enlists
                              September 18, 1893 Plans for      streets, downtown Cincinnati.

         years
                                                                                                         teaching help from a Hamilton
                              the Night Law School as an        [The site is now an office building.]
                                                                                                         County Common Pleas Court
                              education program of the
                                                                October 1893 through                     judge and from a graduate who
                              Cincinnati and Hamilton

             —                County YMCA are reported in a
                              daily newspaper.
                                                                mid-1895 Dean Ochiltree
                                                                teaches all courses.
                                                                                                         had been admitted to the Ohio
                                                                                                         bar.

1 6 C H A S E M A G A Z INE
Within a few days, I had canvassed the           board. … Shortly afterwards, a               learned [legal] writers on the common
Cincinnati prospective students and              newspaper item with large headlines          law of England and America, and some
written to the non-residents with the            appeared, announcing “A NIGHT LAW            leading cases, and laid the foundation
result that I procured a number of               SCHOOL. One to Be Established as a           of a course of study to be extended to
students. The resident students met              Branch Adjunct to the Y.M.C.A. It Will       include all the subjects taught in
daily and the non-residents received a           Be on Popular [Streetcar] Lines and Is       standard law schools. …
weekly letter, until the [Cincinnati] law        Deserving of Success.” … Information
                                                                                              Thus began work that was to amuse
school opened in October.                        regarding the proposed night law
                                                                                              and exercise many hours of my life
                                                 course had been given out at the Associ-
I liked the work, and it seemed to be                                                         during the succeeding twenty-three
                                                 ation office, and whether the course
satisfactory to the students. I realized,                                                     years. A work that was to enroll
                                                 would be on commercial law or the
however, that when they entered the law                                                       hundreds of law students; in a few years
                                                 more pretentious one described in the
school in the fall my work would end.                                                         to engage the service and cooperation
                                                 news item was left open. …
This led me to consider the possibility                                                       of more than a score of lawyers and
of a night law course for young men              Seventeen prospective students were          judges and to become an institution
employed during the daytime; but the             present the first night, October 17, 1893.   known and honored as the pioneer
question presented itself, how to get the        In my opening talk, I outlined two           night law school.
students and a meeting place for the             courses, in which I felt they might be
class. … In a general way, I knew the            interested; one to consist of lectures or    Robert M. Ochiltree was dean of the Y.M.C.A
Y.M.C.A. had night classes for young             talks on commercial law, the other to be     Night Law School, renamed Salmon P. Chase
men, and that its building was the               modeled as nearly as possible after the      College of Law in 1943, from his founding of
meeting place for its members during             course then pursued in the Cincinnati        it in 1893 until 1916. He subsequently
the evening …                                    Law School. They expressed a willing-        practiced law in Cincinnati, where he lived
                                                 ness to undertake the latter course …        until his death in 1948.
I called on Mr. George T. Howser, then
                                                 [My experience teaching
general secretary [of the Y.M.C.A.], and
                                                 public school in Indiana,
offered to conduct a night course in the
                                                 teaching the summer law
study of law. He referred my offer to the
                                                 course in Cincinnati, and
[Y.M.C.A.] board, who said to him that
                                                 access to the Cincinnati
probably no one would attend, except
                                                 Law School library] led me
those who would be attending other
                                                 to feel or hope that a three
classes conducted by the Association,
                                                 years’ or longer night
and that the small tuition the students
                                                 course, with admission to
paid was needed to pay the teachers of
                                                 the Bar as the goal, was
the other classes.
                                                 possible. …
Apparently Mr. Howser felt that ended
                                                 Thanks to the interest and
the matter, and only by chance meeting
                                                 enthusiasm of the class, we
him on the street, did I learn the result
                                                 stuck strictly to the study
of his [favorable] conference with the
                                                 and discussion of …

1900 Ohio approves the YMCA         1906 The library contains 1,000
as a degree-granting institution.   volumes. By 1916 it has 2,000.
June 28, 1900 Sixty-five            1916 Dean Ochiltree leaves the
Bachelor of Law degrees are         law school, with annual
awarded, twenty-two to              enrollment having averaged 126
students in the graduating          students and thirteen lawyers
Class of 1900 and forty-three to    on the faculty.
graduates in the classes of 1895
through 1899.
                                    The former YMCA building at Seventh
                                    and Walnut streets, downtown

                                                                                                             SP RING/ SUMMER 2 0 1 8 1 7
Education

Applying the Law                                                         Students in the W. Bruce Lunsford Academy
                                                                         for Law, Business + Technology are putting
                                                                         high-tech spins on legal fundamentals

Think of it as Old School versus New        device, and two websites. Previous          landlord and others will accept. All of
School.                                     students had created other apps. To         this involves legal issues.”
                                            be sure, the students are not doing
Briefing a case? Old School.                                                            The domestic violence app, named ID
                                            computer programming, although
                                                                                        Redo, was being created for Legal Aid
Designing a law-related computer app        some of them have technology
                                                                                        of the Bluegrass to help domestic
or website? New School. Or more             backgrounds. Code-writing gets
                                                                                        violence victims who have to flee
specifically, part of the new frontier in   turned over to Northern Kentucky
                                                                                        without identification or documents. A
legal education being taught in the W.      University computer students or
                                                                                        website accessibility project was
Bruce Lunsford Academy for Law,             outside coders. What the Chase
Business + Technology at Chase                                                          initially conceived of as an app to be
                                            students do is utilize their law school
College of Law.                                                                         called AccessiBuilder, for lawyers and
                                            experience to identify what an app or
                                                                                        others with disabilities to evaluate the
Other courses help students develop         website needs to accomplish, what
                                                                                        accessibility of law-related websites. It
the fundamental skill of briefing a case.   information or functions it needs to
                                                                                        was recast to be a pair of websites. An
But Law, Business & Entrepreneurship        contain, and how users can best
                                                                                        app students previously created for
is the academy course that teaches          sequentially access or employ
                                                                                        Legal Aid of the Bluegrass – now in
them how to translate their knowledge       information or functions.
                                                                                        field testing and called Startover
of legal doctrines and procedures into      “The first thing they have to do is         Kentucky – helps lawyers and others
computer applications to be used by         identify the legal issues that go along     expedite expungement proceedings.
lawyers and non-lawyers.                    with the app,” Professor Furnier says.      Another app was designed to help
Students in the course, taught by           “For example, for a disability access       Legal Aid of the Bluegrass recruit
academy director Robert Furnier,            app that was being planned, they had        volunteer lawyers.
                      this spring were      to understand the current state of the
                                                                                        While every lawyer understands the type
                      developing an         law for accessibility, and the same for a
                                                                                        of thinking that goes into briefing a case,
                      app, or               domestic violence app that is being
                                                                                        creating a law-related app or website
                      software that         developed. That understanding, in the
                                                                                        requires a much broader approach.
                      performs              case of the domestic violence app,
                      specific tasks        could involve how to get a birth            A first step is to identify the legal
                      on a computer         certificate with minimal or no informa-     issues or process the technology will
                      or mobile             tion, and how to create an identity a       address:

1 8 C H A S E M A G A Z INE
rank websites based on accessibility.        For students who now know not only
                                              The idea is to encourage organizations       how to brief a case, but also how to
                                              with lower rankings to update their          design a law-related app or website,
                                              sites. The major legal issue we foresaw      the combined skills are the profession-
                                              was protecting the identity of a person      al advantage the Lunsford Academy
                                              doing the rating, because he or she          was created to provide:
                                              would likely need to disclose his or her
                                                                                                               Doug Rebok, ID
                                              disability.”
                                                                                                               Redo: “The process
                                              For Startover Kentucky, the                                      of brainstorming a
                                              expungement app: “There are                                      technical solution
                                              multiple examples of legal issues we                             to a real-world
                                              had to identify,” says Charlotte                                 problem allows us
                                              Spencer, a 2017 graduate who worked                              to analyze the law
                                              on the app. “Was it a drug-based                                 to identify both
                                              crime? These sometimes have special          where technology helps us to accom-
For ID Redo, the domestic violence            rules for expungement. Was it a sex          plish our goal and how it hinders the
app: “A primary objective is to solve         crime or crime against a child? We           solution. Thinking like a lawyer means
the problem some abuse victims face           can’t help people with those. How            identifying the many different areas
by not having access to their identify-       recently was the person in trouble with      that are affected under one set of
ing documents, such as a birth                the law, for any reason? How long ago        circumstances.”
certificate and driver’s license,” says 2L    was the specific offense? Was the
                                                                                                              Joe Sgro, Accessi-
Doug Rebok, who is involved in                person convicted as a result of being a
                                                                                                              Builder: “This
development of the app. “We are               victim of human trafficking? Was the
                                                                                                              project was an exer-
looking at the legal requirements for         crime a felony or a misdemeanor? Has
                                                                                                              cise in critical
obtaining those documents, as well as         the person ever gotten an expunge-
                                                                                                              thinking and issue
the potential for some alternatively          ment before?”
                                                                                                              spotting from an
acceptable identification during a
                                              After identifying legal issues, a                               attorney’s perspec-
period of waiting for replacement
                                              subsequent step is to explain to                                tive rather than a
identifying documents. We also have
                                              computer code-writers the task an app        law student’s perspective.”
to consider the risks of [digitally]
                                              needs to accomplish and how individu-
accepting and storing sensitive                                                                                Charlotte Spencer,
                                              als will use it:
personally identifying information.”                                                                           Startover Ken-
                                              ID Redo: “A chief concern for us is                              tucky: “After
For AccessiBuilder, the disability
                                              designing an app that does not                                   finishing the class, I
access app redirected as websites:
                                              compromise the safety of its users,”                             graduated, passed
“The issues are two-fold,” says 2L Joe
                                              Mr. Rebok says. “We are exploring                                the bar, and
Sgro. “One is a call to action for
                                              solutions to eliminate the ability for the                       entered a web
organizations to invest in developing
                                              app or use of the app to be discov-                              development
or changing their websites so individu-
                                              ered. This might include an automatic        school, where I learned to create web
als with hearing, vision, or physical
                                              uninstall, installation outside of normal    pages and apps from the coding side.
disabilities can navigate the sites with
                                              channels of online app stores, and           The Lunsford Academy class exposed
ease. We briefly entertained the idea
                                              mis-directive functionality that hides       me to an area with a lot of opportunity.
of creating an app, but it wouldn’t
                                              the true function of the app.”               I have found that my legal background
work to solve the issue we are trying to
                                                                                           and new tech skills are a good
address. Right now, we are developing         Startover Kentucky: “We came up
                                                                                           combination that can help open the
a website to help create awareness of         with flow charts, based on possible
                                                                                           door to both law jobs and JD-advan-
website accessibility. The goal is to get     app-users’ answers, to give to the code
                                                                                           tage jobs.”
businesses to pledge to develop               writers. Then we had to provide the
accessible websites. A second website,        correct legal forms and filing instruc-      Old School versus New School? Just
with an initial focus on law-related          tions,” Ms. Spencer says. “We also ran       think of it as the Chase College of Law
sites, will be similar to a Yelp or Angie’s   through the app with hypothetical            new-ideas school of preparing for the
List site to allow users who have a           users’ stories and got back to the           future.
physical, visual, or hearing disability to    coders about what needed adjusting.”

                                                                                                         SP RING/ SUMMER 2 0 1 8 1 9
You can also read