READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition

Page created by Ryan Francis
 
CONTINUE READING
READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition
January 2019 | Vol. 6, Issue 1                                                           Sustainable Organics Management

                                          READY, RE-SET, GO
SB 1383 is entering the formal regulatory process and is          CNG fleet on the way to electrification.
coupled with a dedicated new Administration that will not         Procurement of Recovered Organic Waste Products in
back down on SB 1383, but instead will double down on             SB 1383 recognizes the importance in developing RNG
banning diesel pollution; now is the time to get Ready,           demand and compost use, CalRecycle has presented a
Re-set, and Go!!! We are not partying like it’s 1989 with AB      fair share calculation with flexibility of procuring compost
939, which set up the infrastructure we have today. Instead,      or RNG. Requiring, through a written contract, that a direct
we have fallen on the China Sword while seeking rate              service provider to the jurisdiction procure recycled organic
increases on both recycling and organics at the same time         waste products and provide written documentation of such
from local governments that have been distressed dealing          evidence to the jurisdiction. This will allow the jurisdiction to
with an array of other priority issues. Significantly adding to   delegate the RNG use to the local franchise hauler and/or
the green bin while the blue bin is suffering is posing huge      other managed fleets, to fulfill the procurement requirement.
challenges as the new reality of recycling is being re-set        This is an elegant community-scale fit where the franchise
after 30 years.                                                   hauler could produce and utilize their own RNG without
                                                                  the need for expensive and restrictive pipeline injection,
As the industry is scrambling with recycling markets and
                                                                  but could also draw RNG from a pipeline at a CNG fueling
contemplating more organic waste diversion, the new
                                                                  station where RNG is not being produced locally.
Administration will leap-frog over any need to reform SB
1383 as Governor Newsom banned food waste from                    SB 1383 is about climate change and not landfill space,
landfills 10 years ago as Mayor of San Francisco with his         parlaying the use of the AB 939 infrastructure, with the
Program Director, now the new Cal-EPA Secretary, knowing          same shared responsibility tenets with local government
that it can be done. Without a hint of backsliding on AB          and industry, but now generators may be on the hook
32 or SB 1383, Newsom proposes to ban diesel pollution            by local ordinance. AB 939 inspired billions of dollars of
statewide by 2030. Mayor Garcetti of Los Angeles plans            investment to meet the 50% waste diversion mandates to
to ban diesel by 2028, in time for the Summer Olympics.           develop the collection and processing operations. Many of
While local government and the industry are struggling with       these recycling facilities are being transformed by adding
how to permit the SB 1383 facilities, we should also be           organics processing capacity and are ready to step up to
strategizing about our fleets, where 75% of the costs and         the new challenges and opportunities.
90% of the carbon emissions are embedded.
                                                                  The SB 1383 regulations will be Ready soon. The Re-
SB 1383 offers a closed loop system fuels, where internal         Set button has been hit for recycling and now organics.
off-take agreements can be realized by using your own             It is time to Go forth in partnership with the same spirit of
carbon negative RNG fuel, in your CNG fleet, produced             AB 939. A lost garbage barge and a landfill capacity crisis
from your organic wastes, while cutting NOx to near-zero          touched the nation to re-set recycling in 1990 and we
with the new CNG engines. One ton of organic waste can            answered the call with collection and processing, but lacked
produce 19 diesel gallon equivalents (dge). The average           domestic manufacturing. Since climate change impacts
collection truck uses 13,000 dge per year. With 8 million         of today far surpass the landfill scarcity of yesteryear, you
tons of food waste and green waste targeted for diversion         would think a greater call to arms would transpire among
by 2025 and with one-third allocated to AD and two-thirds         local government, generators, and the industry to go forth
allocated to composting, over 50 million dges can be              now with our California markets for compost and RNG
produced per year to fuel 4,000 CNG trucks. As diesel is          to continue to increase our gross domestic product while
being phased out, the new Administration will need to carve       significantly decreasing our carbon intensity to attain the
in RNG use on the organic highway and not bypass the              40% GHG reduction by 2030.

                                                CaliforniaCompostCoalition.org
READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition
Governor’s Update                                                       Healthy Soils
    Cap-and-Trade                                     New                                          DOUBLE DOWN
                                                                                                  ON COMPOST USE
   Budget 2019-2020                             Cal-EPA Director                         The January 2019 Draft California 2030
As the 2019-2020 Budget was                 Governor Gavin Newsom appointed              Natural and Working Lands Climate
released, California became the             Jared Blumenfeld, 49, of San                 Change Implementation Plan (Plan) is
5th largest economy in the world.           Francisco, Secretary of the Cal-             now available and after two years the
Since 2001, California’s GDP has            EPA, the state cabinet-level                 State finally included CCC metrics to
increased by 41% as GHGs have               agency established in 1991 to                double down on compost and mulch use
been reduced by 38%. Proceeds from          oversee CalRecycle, CARB, State              by 2030 and made compost application
the Cap-and-Trade Program have              Water Board, DTSC and OEHHA.                 a priority after being silent. Comments
                                                                                         are due on Feb 8, 2019. Where the
facilitated approximately $9.3 billion in   Blumenfeld is widely recognized as
                                                                                         preliminary draft Plan did not include
investments throughout California that      one of America’s most innovative             compost use on irrigated cropland at
further the state’s climate goals. The      environmental leaders. In 2016,              all, now compost application is being
Budget proposes a $1 billion Cap-and-       he founded his own private firm              targeted, adding 31,000 to 62,000 acres
Trade Expenditure Plan to support           advising clean tech companies in             each year to 2030, and mulching over
programs that reduce or sequester           best practices after serving eight           cropland also increasing at 10,400 to
greenhouse gases, including                 successful years as the west coast           20,800 acres per year.
programs that benefit disadvantaged         Regional Administrator of the United         The analysis to support this Plan used
and low-income communities, and             States EPA, under Obama.                     a sampling method to combine COMET
support training and apprenticeships                                                     Planner outputs from twelve agricultural
necessary to transition the state’s         Previously, he was Director of the San       counties into a statewide average. While
workforce to a low carbon economy.          Francisco Department of Environment          specific levels of activity for each practice
                                            for nine years, where he and then-           were required to generate the estimated
CalRecycle stays at $25 million,            Mayor Newsom worked effectively              climate benefits, CDFA will target imple-
where $100 million per year is needed       to make San Francisco the most               mentation acres for healthy soils prac-
to invest the $2-3 billion into compost     sustainable city in the nation and           tices generally, rather than on practice
                                                                                         specific acreages. Additionally, because a
and AD facilities. Dairy AD goes            banned food waste from landfills.
                                                                                         statewide average was used, the acreage
down from $99 million to $25 million.                                                    target is a statewide rather than regional.
There is $132 million for clean trucks      With the new administration, its AB
                                                                                         Considering historic funding levels, imple-
to carve out the voucher program of         1045 and we need to let Jared know
                                                                                         mentation at the scale assessed would
$45,000 per truck with RNG use to           where our compost is. It’s still siloed in   cost approximately $18 – $36 million per
replace those diesel trucks, where the      the reports and studies by the Water         year, reducing GHG by 5.3 to 10.7 million
governor wants to ban diesel pollution      Board, the Air Districts, and CDFA;          metric tons.
by 2030. There is $230 million in           and the recently released AB 1045
                                                                                         This Plan aims to integrate management
community air pollution protection          Report in December 2018 is two years         objectives wherever possible,
that will place more pressure on            late and inadequate. The important           coordinating all natural and working lands
compost facilities. Specific bioenergy      concept of designating compost               programs under a united approach. The
development using urban wood waste          facilities as an ‘essential public           implementation will significantly increase
is nowhere to be found.                     service’ is not even mentioned by            and improve conservation, restoration,
                                            CalEPA, which could be the solution          and management of California’s natural
Healthy Soils increases to $18 million      to complex air permitting by allowing        and working lands through State
to provide incentives to farmers for        a net-benefit of diverting organic           programs and other means, to enhance
                                                                                         their resilience to worsening climate
agricultural management practices           from landfills to be fully realized. The
                                                                                         change impacts, sequester carbon, and
that sequester carbon, including            Program EIR for SB 1383 will be a            reduce GHGs, and create healthy soils.
cover cropping, reduced tillage, and        nice opportunity to fully analyze this.
compost application. Annual funding         Whereas CARB has tried to integrate          Goals for Natural Climate Solutions:
of $18 million was identified through       all agencies in the AB 32 Scoping            Compost application rates to 2030:
a modeling tool that CCC was able           Plan, CalEPA has been ineffective
to heavily participate in (in the de-       over the years on permit coordination.       • On annual cropland
                                                                                           10,300 - 20,700 acres/ year each year
velopment of the Natural and Work-
ing Lands Implementation Plan) to           Jared seems like the right person at         • On perennial cropland
achieve soil conservation practices on      the right time to take AB 1045 to the          21,000 - 41,900 acres/ year each year
500,000 acres by 2030, where com-           next level and will not back down on         • On non-irrigated rangeland
post use is slated to cover 350,000 of      SB 1383. But, will he step up to make          2,100 - 4,200 acres/ year each year
those acres, for a benefit of 5.3 million   it happen in partnership with industry
                                                                                         • On irrigated pasture
tons of carbon sequestration.               and local government?                          2,100 - 4,200 acres/ year each year

2 | January 2019                                                                                  California Compost Coalition
READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition
SB 1383 Regulatory Affairs                                                   Regs Watch
       Program EIR                          SRIA for SB 1383 Regs                          SB 1383 REGULATIONS

      Net-Zero Now                          $330 Million Per Year                     CalRecycle’s proposed regulations were
                                                                                      officially noticed by the Office of Adminis-
CalRecycle will prepare and circulate       The Standardized Regulatory Impact        trative Law (OAL) on January 18, 2019.
an Environmental Impact Report              Assessment (SRIA) is a required           The proposed regulations implement the
(EIR) to disclose potential significant     element of the initial rulemaking doc-    department’s responsibilities established
adverse effects on the environment          uments that must be submitted to the      by SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes
                                                                                      of 2016) Public Resources Code (PRC)
as a result of the planned adoption of      Office of Administrative Law (OAL).
                                                                                      Sections 42652-42654, and 41780.01,
the SB 1383 Regulations. The results        The SRIA is a 58-page document that       and Health and Safety Code (HSC) Sec-
of the EIR will disclose information        provides a macro statewide analysis       tions 39730.5 - 39730.6. This rulemaking
on potential significant impacts and        of the potential costs and benefits       implements regulatory requirements to
mitigation measures, and is expected        of the regulatory requirements. The       reduce landfill disposal of organic waste
to assist state and local agencies with     estimated direct statewide costs is ap-   in order to achieve the greenhouse gas
information for future site-specific        proximately $20.9 billion, from 2019 to   emissions reductions required by SB
CEQA reviews that may be required           2030, and the direct economic benefit     1383. This action initiates the formal 45-
for new or expanding local projects         is approximately $17 billion over the     day comment period.
that may directly or indirectly result      same time period. With an average         45-Day Formal Comment Period:
from the SB 1383 regulations. The           net cost per year of approximately        January 18, 2019 – March 4, 2019
Notice of Preparation (NOP) was held        $330 million, the average increased       Comments must be submitted by 5
on January 22, 2019 in Sacramento.          cost per household would be approx-       PM March 4, 2019. Comments may be
CCC was there and presented                 imately $17 per year, or $1.42 per        submitted via e-mail to: SLCP.Organics@
comments that were posted on                household per month, and the in-          calrecycle.ca.gov (additional methods
January 8, 2019.                            creased cost to business is estimated     for submitting written comments are
                                            at $662 per year, or $55 per month.       identified in the NOPA). Comments must
CCC will work hard to make this be                                                    be submitted during the appropriate com-
the Program EIR for compost facilities      Reviewing several scenarios, the          ment period in order to be considered.
that we have been advocating for            SRIA estimates there could be 60          Please note: to ensure accurate guid-
CalRecycle to prepare for years.            new or expanded compost facilities        ance and consistent responses, CalRe-
CalRecycle certified the Program EIR        at 100,000 tons per year, costing         cycle staff will not be providing written
to assess the environmental effects of      $13.5 million dollar each and 26 new      responses directly to individual com-
AD facilities in California in 2011. That   AD facilities at 100,000 TPY, costing     menters at this time. Instead, all com-
                                                                                      ments submitted during the appropriate
Program EIR provided background on          $46 million each, for a total of 86
                                                                                      rulemaking comment periods will be
technologies, potential impacts, and        facilities by 2025 with a total capital   catalogued and responded to as a part of
mitigation measures that has been           costs of $2 billion. The SRIA estimates   the final rulemaking package submitted
used to expedite the CEQA process at        the costs for all aspects of SB           to the Office of Administrative Law.
the local level.                            1383 from education, enforcement,
                                                                                      Any substantial changes to the initial
                                            contamination monitoring, reporting,      regulatory language will be subject to
CCC comments included a better              capacity planning, and procurement,       additional notice and public comment.
definition of landfill baseline             starting at $665 million in year one
operations; provided the math for                                                     A Formal Hearing will be held on March
                                            and levels out at $350 million per
VOC reductions which that are 53%                                                     12, 2019, where stakeholders and the
                                            year thereafter. The SRIA relies on       public can make comments on the regu-
less than landfilling but would still       projections of potential infrastructure    latory text.
need to purchase off-sets costing           scenarios that are consistent with the
up to $54 million statewide if off-         projections made in 2017 by CARB.
sets are even available; requested                                                           AB 901 REGULATIONS
essential public service analysis as        The SRIA described $17 billion in         After 1,130 comments and several
evaluated by CAPCOA; assessed               economic benefits and NOx reduction       years, at the December 18, 2018
that GHG and NOx benefits that the          of almost 17,000 tons per year, and       monthly meeting, CalRecycle staff
RNG procurement delivers. The SRIA          could have also brought in the VOC        have determined that no additional
provided public health benefit and          reductions from baseline. There could     modifications to the proposed rulemaking
needs to be included here as well.          be 11,700 new permanent green jobs        text implementing the AB 901 Recycling
                                                                                      and Disposal Reporting System (DRS)
CCC will provide the CARB definition        and 4,500 temporary construction
                                                                                      are needed and have delivered a
of ‘Net-Zero GHG’ where these               jobs. The value of avoided damages        completed package to the Office of
facilities are Net-Zero Now, and can        calculated using the social cost of       Administrative Law for approval on
soon become 40X to 50X Net-Zero by          carbon could range from $40 million to    January 18, 2019 for publication in the
2020 and 2025.                              $100 million per year.                      California Regulatory Notice Register.

CaliforniaCompostCoalition.org                                                                              January 2019 | 3
READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition
CCC Coalition Building

The California Compost Coalition                            OMG . . .
 is a registered Lobbying Coalition with
the Fair Political Practices Commission
                                              The Organics Management Group is Here!
(FPPC), created in 2002 by a group
of compost operators in response to        Thirty years ago, AB 939 was signed        Force, RCRC, CASA, CSAC, and the
demands for increased recycling of         into law to divert 50% of waste by         League of Cities linking SB 1383 to lo-
organic materials & production of clean    2000. With much fanfare, it was            cal Climate Action Plans and transpor-
compost, bioenergy, anaerobic digestion,   answering the call to a lost garbage       tation emissions, while addressing the
renewable natural gas, and biochar.
                                           barge and dwindling landfill space. Lo-    issues of disadvantaged communities.
CCC Members                                cal government, environmental groups,      BAC and the RNG Coalition have been
                                           and industry all stepped up in partner-    pushing RNG procurement at the Leg-
Agromin
American Refuse                            ship to build the recycling infrastruc-    islature, with BAC supporting SB 1383
Atlas Disposal                             ture we have today. If only California     RNG procurement. Sean Edgar will
Burrtec Waste Industries                   could have attracted the manufactur-       continue his CARB loading on carving
Caglia Environmental                       ing capacity for paper and plastics to     out vouchers for CNG vehicles using
California Waste Recovery Systems          match the collection and processing        RNG fuel, when it replaces a diesel ve-
California Wood Recycling                  industry. With SB 1383 entering the        hicle. With Governor Newsom propos-
CleanFleets.net
Clean Fleets Advocates                     formal regulatory process coupled with     ing to ban diesel pollution by 2030, the
Clover Flat Compost                        a dedicated new administration that will   RNG demand and fueling infrastructure
Cold Canyon Compost                        not back down, but will double down on     needs to be developed in conjunction
GreenWaste Recovery                        diesel pollution and renewable energy,     with required SB 1383 facilities.
Marin Sanitary Service                     the call for partnership and coalition
Mt. Diablo Resource Recovery               building is greater than ever.           The political landscape of SB 1383
Napa Recycling Compost                                                              is far reaching into climate change
Northern Recycling Compost                 AB 939 with Federal Subtitle D landfill  mitigation, with connectivity beyond the
Phoenix Energy
Quackenbush Mt. Compost                    liner regulations in the early 1990s     institutionalized waste industry. AB 939
Recology Blossom Valley Organics           disrupted the direct haul to disposal    did not delve into the collection fleet,
Recology Feather River Organics            model and attempted to create markets fuel production and dispensing, edible
Recology Jepson Prairie Organics           for all waste streams, and was a huge food recovery, or incentive funding in
ReFuel Energy Partners                     success in launching new collection      relation to disadvantaged communities.
Soiland Co, Inc.                           practices and processing techniques.     With 75% of the costs and 90% of the
Sonoma Compost
Tracy Material Recovery Compost
                                           AB 939 set the platform for SB 1383,     carbon emissions attributed to trans-
Upper Valley Recycling                     which is now focused on organics with portation, SB 1383 offers a closed-loop
Vision Recycling                           a circular economy model, tapping into system where internal off-take agree-
Zanker Road Resource Management            internal and regional markets. With      ments are realized by using self-pro-
Z-Best Compost Facility                    composting and anaerobic diges-          duced carbon negative RNG fuel in
Zero Waste Energy Development              tion facilities as the center piece, the the company’s own CNG fleets, while
Zero Waste Energy, LLC
                                           California Compost Coalition proposes cutting NOx to near-zero with the new
CCC Executive Committee                    to launch the ad-hoc Organics Man-       CNG engines. OMG!!! Is that possi-
                                           agement Group to create a coalition to ble?!
Bill Camarillo, Agromin
Vince Colvis, Mt. Diablo Recycling         agree on the good of SB 1383 and fix
Greg Kelley, Northern Recycling            what needs to be fixed in the collabora- Dairy Cares has a common voice
Eric Potashner, Recology                   tive spirit that has been lacking during and got $99 million in Cap-and-Trade
Greg Pryor, Recology                       the informal workshops while reviewing funding to implement SB 1383. We all
Will Bakx, Sonoma Compost                  the draft language.                      care and need to come together where
Christy Pestoni Abreu, UVR Compost                                                  we can speak in a common voice, as
Michael Gross, Z-Best Compost              Justin Malan, with his agricultural      the waste recycling industry has been
CCC Team                                   contacts, will continue to push the      fragmented based on private vs. public
                                           Healthy Soils Initiative for private     interests, urban vs. rural, north and
Neil Edgar, Executive Director
                                           markets. Neil Edgar, wearing both his    south markets, and Wall Street to Main
Evan Edgar, Regulatory Affairs
Steve Peterson, Financial Advisor          USCC and CORC hats, will continue        Street business models. The Organics
Monica White, Sustainability Advisor       to seek out public sector procurement    Management Group can hit the re-
Sean Edgar, Fleet Advisor                  with state and local agencies; he will   set button and be an ad-hoc working
                                           work with CRRC, ACP, and CAW on          group/coalition focusing on SB 1383
CCC Legislative Affairs                    the facility regulations and AB 1045     regulations to support common themes
Justin Malan, EcoConsult                   implementation. Evan Edgar plans         and comment on key issues to the
Neil Edgar, Edgar & Associates Inc.        to visit the SWANA Legislative Task      benefit of the entire industry.

                                  1822 21st Street, Sacramento, CA 95811 | 916.739.1200
READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition
Compost Markets

CAFF
    Justin         Neil
                CalTrans
                                   Edible Food
                                      (Monica)
                                Waste Not OC
                                                                                SB 1383 Coalition Building                                                      Compost Facilites (Neil)
                                                                                                                                                                CCC
                                                                                                                                                                CRRC
                                                                                                                                                                               CORC
                                                                                                                                                                               CAW
CalCAN          CalFire                                                                                                                                         ACP
                                                                                                                  Env
                                Food Bank of Contra
CCOF            CDFA             Costa & Solano
                                                                                      a p a n d Trade Market         iron
                                                                                                                                                                USCC
Sustainable     CORC            Waste-Free Ventura
                                                                                    C                        s
                                                                                                                                    me
 Conservation                   Sacramento Food Bank
Farm Bureau
                                                                                                                                       nta
                                            od                                                                                            l
                                          o
                                   leF                        ke ts                                                            Pu
                                                                                                                                    bl
                                 b                          ar
                               di
                                                                                                                                      ic
                                                        M                                                                                  Co
                           E            p
                                                 os
                                                    t
                                                                                                                                              m

                                                                                                                                                 po
                                       m

                                                                                         Compost
                                    Co

                                                                                                                                                   st
                                                                                                                                                        Ma
                                     te
                                   va

                                                                                                                                                         rke
                               Pri

                                                                                                                                                           ts
  RN

                                                                                      A na               t i on
                                                                                             erobic Diges

                                                                                                                                                                           e
      G

                                                                                                                                                                       tic
                  el
             Fu

                                           riv

                                                                                                                                                  nt
                                                                                                                                                    e
                                          P

                                                                                                                                                                   us
                    in                         a   te                                                                                            e m
                                                                                                                                                                  J
                      g                                                                                                                     ur                  l
                               In
                                  fra
                                                        RN
                                                          G                                                                         Pr
                                                                                                                                         o c
                                                                                                                                                             nta
                                      s                        Pr
                                                                 oc                            Landfill                        NG                         me
                                          tru                      ure                                                        R                         n
 Fleets (Sean)
                                              c     tur               m   ent                                       u bli
                                                                                                                            c
                                                                                                                                       vi ro
                                                       e                                                          P
                                                                                                                                     En
CleanFleets                                                                                                                                                            Local Gov’t (Evan)
Republic              RNG (Evan)                                                                                                                                       CRRA     BAC
WM
                      BAC                                                                                                                                              SWANA    LASAN
WCI

                                                                                               Fleets
                      CASA                                                                                                                                             RCRC     StopWaste
CalSTART
                      RNG Coalition                                                                                                                                    CASA     Rethink
NVG America
                      Clean Energy                                                                                                                                     CSAC     MRWMD

                                                                                                                                                             Edgar Inc. Version 1.1 12/10/18
READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition
ZERO HERO PROGRAMS OF THE RECYCLING INDUSTRY
                                                         READVANTAGING COMMUNITY-SCALE SYSTEMS
                                                                               THROUGH SUSTAINABLE FACILITY, FUEL, FLEET, FEEDSTOCKS & FARMING
                             NET ZERO                                         CARBON                                                        NEAR ZERO                                                      ZERO                                                    ZERO                                      DISADVANTAGED
                             FACILITIES                                    NEGATIVE FUEL                                                      FLEET                                                        WASTE                                               PESTICIDE USE                                  COMMUNITIES
                                  Greenhouse                                        Carbon Intensity                                         Heavy-Duty Vehicle                                             Disposal                                                 Pounds of selected                              CalEnviro Screen
                                    Gases                                          Transportation Fuel                                        NOx Emissions                                             Solid Waste Tons                                              active ingredients                                3.0 results

                                                                    100

                                                                                                                        2.4

                                                                                                                                                                                  80

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               1,241
                   The Net Zero Facilities in recycling sec-                           Diesel 102.01                                        Diesel Engines - 2002                                                                                                      Predominently
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Predominently                                        91-100%
                   tor including material recovery facilities
                   processing recyclable materials, compost
                                                                                         CNG 88.60                                                                                                                                                                  Central Valley
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Central Valley Farming
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Farming
                   facilities, anaerobic digestion facilities,                                                                                                                                         90% Disposal -1990                                                                                                    81-90%
                   and biomass conversion facilities. The
                   new composting facilities are covered
                   aerated static pile systems using the                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     71-80%
                   best available control technologies and
                   the anaerobic digestion facilities are en-
                   closed closed-loop system without high
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             61-70%

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Lbs/Square Mile
                   temperature incineration. The avoided
                   GHG emissions for these facilities com-                            Hydrogen 55.61                                                                                                                                                                                                                         51-60%
                                                                                                                                            Diesel Engines - 2007                                      56% Disposal - 2016

                                                                                                                        grams/bhp-hr
                   pared to landfilling fully offset the project
                                                                    g CO2/KJ

                                                                                                                                                                                  Million Tons
                   emissions including collection, hauling,
                   processing activities and the landfilling of                 Landfill Gas 33.89 to 65.64                                                                                                                                                                                                                  41-50%
                   residuals. Landfills and garbage Transfer
                   Stations are in the waste sector and are
                   not Net Zero Facilities.                                              ZEV 38.95                                                                                                                                                                                                                           31-40%

                                                                           Renewable Diesel 19.65 to 39.33                                                                                             25% Disposal - 2020                                           Sustainable Farming
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Sustainable Farming                                     21-30%
           CO2e/ton

                                                                                 Biodiesel 11.76 to 83.25                                   Diesel Engines - 2010                                                                                                                                                            11-20%
                            Scope 1 Transportation

                                                                                                                        0.02
                                 Scope 2 Energy                                Wastewater Gas 8.61 to 34.36
                                                                    0.0

                                                                                                                                                                                  0.0

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            0.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             0-10%

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               0.1
                                                                                                                                             CNG Engines - 2016                                        10% Disposal - 2030                                              Organic Farming
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Organic Farming
ZERO                                                                                                                                                                                       Community-Scale Carbon Negative Near Zero Emissions at Net-Zero Facilities
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ZERO
              15x -20x

                                                                                                                                   The Short-Lived Climate Pollutant Plan (SLCP) was adopted on March 23, 2017 and the SB 32 Scoping Plan Update with 2030 goals is being consider by CARB on June 23, 2017. The
                                                                               Organic Waste Biogas -25.48                         community-scale anaerobic digestion facilities model is at the intersection of the SLCP, SB 32, and the Governor’s Five Pillars that California will: (Pillar 1) reduce today’s petroleum use in cars
           25x - 15x

                                                                                                                                   and trucks by up to 50%; (Pillar 2) increase from one-third to 50% our electricity derived from renewable sources; (Pillar 3) double the efficiency savings from existing buildings; (Pillar 4) reduce
                                                                                                                                   the release of methane which includes diverting organics from the landfill by 2025; and (Pillar 5) manage farms, rangelands, forests and wetlands so that they can use compost and store carbon.
                         Scope 3 Recycling Benefits                                Organic Waste -100.0                            RNG produced at these anaerobic digestion (AD) facilities has been deemed to be carbon negative and when utilized in CNG trucks with the near zero emissions will be a game changer today
                                                                                                                                   by reducing heavy duty diesel emissions now while striving for zero waste. The digestate can be composted to produce organic materials to reduce pesticide and fertilizer use to produce healthy
                                                                                   Dairy Biogas -303.30                            soils. A 25,000 ton per year, or 100 tons per day, AD-to-RNG project is designed as a community-scale model, and can serve a population of approximately 100,000 people. This model can
                                                                                                                                   produce 333,000 diesel gallon equivalents per year of RNG with a carbon intensity of negative 22.9 g CO2e/MJ for a fleet of 45 heavy-duty trucks with near-zero NOx emissions.

                          AB 32 Scoping Plan 2014 Update                             LCFS Pathway CARB                                       CARB and EPA certified                                 90% or more Waste Reduction                                        Healthy Soils Initiative                      CalEnvironScreen 3.0
                                   Waste Sector                                   Certified Carbon Intensities                            ISL G NZ (8.9) L CNG engines                              from Landfills and Incineration                                     with Compost Use                           Cap-and-Trade Investments
                       Net-Zero GHG Emissions from the                     The wide range of carbon intensities is                     In 2015, Cummins Westport certified                       Zero Waste is a goal that is ethical,                         Communities near agricultural fields,          The California Communities Envi-
                       Waste Sector by 2030. Reduce Scope 1                due to the lifecycle emissions method-                      the world’s first heavy-duty engine at                    economical, efficient and visionary, to                       primarily farm worker communi-                 ronmental Health Screening Tool
                       emissions with alternative fuels. Reduce            ology of the Low Carbon Fuel standard                       near-zero-emission levels (90 percent                     guide people in changing their lifestyles                     ties, may be at risk for exposure to           (CalEnviroScreen) helps us to address
                       Scope 2 emissions with roof-top solar               (LCFS); variation of feedstock types,                       below the existing federal standard)                      and practices to emulate sustainable                          pesticides. Drift or volatilization of         environmental threat challenges. The
                       and on-site bioenergy. Avoid Scope                  origin, raw material production, process-                   for Class 7 refuse trucks and will be                     natural cycles, where all discarded                           pesticides from agricultural fields can        objective in developing this tool is to
                       3 GHG emissions with recycling and                  ing efficiencies, and transportation all                    available for Class 8 transfer trucks                     materials are designed to become re-                          be a significant source of pesticide           use it to assist California communi-
                       composting. To achieve Net-Zero, the                contribute to the producers’ fuel pathway                   in 2018. To complement the NOx                            sources for others to use. Communities                        exposure. The use of most synthetic            ties by directing state and potentially
                       direct GHG emissions from the Waste                 carbon intensity. The certification of                      reductions provided by this landmark                      that have a Zero Waste goal and are                           pesticides and fertilizers is prohibit-        local government resources toward a
                       Sector would have to be fully offset by             carbon negative fuel for the production                     engine, conventional (fossil) natural                     working towards or have reduced their                         ed from organic production. Organic            common purpose: the revitalization of
                       avoided GHG emissions. Avoided GHG                  of renewable natural gas (RNG) from                         gas provides significant GHG reduc-                       waste to landfill, incineration and the                       farming with certified organic compost         disadvantaged communities and the
                       emissions are reductions in life-cycle              organic waste anaerobic digestion is                        tion benefits. However, renewable                         environment by 90% or more. Dozens                            use and a zero pesticide goal makes            pursuit of environmental justice.
                       GHG emissions that would occur be-                  based on the biogenic feedstocks of                         natural gas with carbon negative fuel                     of large cities have adopted zero waste                       healthy soils. The multiple co-benefits        Cap-and-trade proceeds have funded
                       cause waste is shifted from landfilling to          food waste and green waste, and the                         completes the game changing prop-                         goal by 2025. California is at a 45%                          of enhanced soil organic matter on our         projects where over $3.3 billion has
                       alternative non-disposal pathways. Most             avoided methane emissions from the                          osition by providing the lowest carbon                    recycling rate as compost facilities are                      agricultural lands, include improved wa-       been appropriated with 50% of the fund-
                       material recovery facilities are 15 to 25           landfilling of the material. The CNG truck                  intensity of any heavy duty transporta-                   curtailed by NIMBYism.                                        ter retention, soil stability and nutrient     ing benefitting DACs and 34% located
                       times offset over their GHG emissions.              collect food waste to make RNG.                             tion fuel available in the market today.                                                                                use efficiency to reduce fertilizer use.       in DACs.

                              NET ZERO                                                  OFF                                                KNOCK OFF                                                     OFF                                                          OFF                                    GREENING YOUR
                                NOW                                                    DIESEL                                                 NOx                                                     LANDFILLS                                                    PESTICIDES                                 COMMUNITY
Edgar & Associates | evan@edgarinc.org | 916-739-1200 | www.edgarinc.org                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Version 2.0 7/16/18
READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition READY, RE-SET, GO - California Compost Coalition
You can also read