Impact Assessment of Covid-19 - The Case of Eastern Africa UNECA Sub-Regional Office for Eastern Africa - United Nations Economic ...

Page created by Douglas Robinson
 
CONTINUE READING
Impact Assessment of Covid-19 - The Case of Eastern Africa UNECA Sub-Regional Office for Eastern Africa - United Nations Economic ...
Impact Assessment of Covid-19
      The Case of Eastern Africa

         UNECA Sub-Regional Office for Eastern Africa
Impact Assessment of Covid-19 - The Case of Eastern Africa UNECA Sub-Regional Office for Eastern Africa - United Nations Economic ...
Eastern Africa one of the fastest growing regions in the world
                                  Average Growth Rates (%), 2014 - 2020
8%                                                                                                                 In 2019, the fastest
                                                                                            Eastern Africa-12
             7.0                 7.0                                                                            growing economies were:
7%                                                                       6.6        6.6                  6.4
                                                                                           6.1
6%                                                   5.7

5%

             3.8                                                                                       Africa
4%
                                 3.1                                      3.2                            3.2
                                                                                    3.0    2.9
3%                                                  2.5
                                2.7                                       2.9       2.7
             2.8
2%                                                                                         2.3           2.5
                                                    1.6                                               World
1%

0%
             2014                2015                2016               2017        2018   2019*        2020*
Source: National sources, UNDESA, ECA calculations
Note: Eastern Africa average excludes Somalia and South Sudan; *Estimate/forecast
Impact Assessment of Covid-19 - The Case of Eastern Africa UNECA Sub-Regional Office for Eastern Africa - United Nations Economic ...
Despite high levels of growth, Severe economic vulnerabilities still
remain in Eastern Africa as a whole…

                         Slow paced structural change

                            Demographic pressures
                           Lack of job opportunities
                   Reduced trade performance in recent years
Demographic pressures are real…
                            Working Age Population (millions)
                           Annual Increase between 2015 and 2030
  2.5
                                2.1
     2
                                                                                Each year, these economies
  1.5                                                                           need to create an aggregate
                                                                                of
                                                                                   7   million new jobs
                                                                      1.2
                                      1                                     1
     1

                                          0.5
  0.5                                                     0.3
                                                0.2
                                                                0.1
                       0    0                         0
     0
                             lia
                    yc a
                               ti

                    So s
                              ia

                               a

                              ia
                   Et a

                             da
                  Ta n
                    Rw r
                           ca

                           lle
               M en y
                             e

                            d

                          da
                          ou

                         op

                         an
               So ma
                        an
                        itr

                        an
                        as

                       he

                      Su
                       ib

                      nz
                      hi
                     Er

                      K

                    Ug
                    ag
             Dj

                    h
                 ad

                 Se

                 ut

Source: UNdata & ILO
Yet job creation has not kept pace with economic expansion
                                                            GDP vs. Employment Growth Rates
                                                                Average between 2006 and 2016
                              8%
     Employment Growth Rate

                              6%
                                                                                                                                  6% growth required
                                                                                                                                  simply to absorb new
                                                                                                                                  entrants to job market
                              4%
                                        Madagascar                        Kenya     D.R. Congo
                                                     Comoros
                                                                                                                  Ethiopia
                                          Burundi     Africa         Uganda                 Rwanda
                                                                         Djibouti    Tanzania
                              2%                  Eritrea   Seychelles
                                                                              XX

                                        Somalia                                                  Job creation rate well below
                                                                                                 rate of economic expansion
                              0%
                                   0%      2%                  4%                   6%               8%           10%           12%
                                                                              GDP Growth Rate
Source: UNdata & ILO
Intra-regional trade has stopped growing and stagnated over the
  past decade in Eastern Africa
                                Intra-Regional Trade (USD m)
                          EAC                                  IGAD
 3500                                            3500

 3000                                            3000

 2500                                            2500

 2000                                            2000

 1500                                            1500

 1000                                            1000

  500                                            500

    0                                              0
      95
      96
      97
      98
      99
      00
      01
      02
      03
      04
      05
      06
      07
      08
      09
      10
      11
      12
      13
      14
      15
      16
      17
      18

                                                      95
                                                      96
                                                      97
                                                      98
                                                      99
                                                      00
                                                      01
                                                      02
                                                      03
                                                      04
                                                      05
                                                      06
                                                      07
                                                      08
                                                      09
                                                      10
                                                      11
                                                      12
                                                      13
                                                      14
                                                      15
                                                      16
                                                      17
                                                      18
    19
    19
    19
    19
    19
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20
    20

                                                    19
                                                    19
                                                    19
                                                    19
                                                    19
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
                                                    20
Source: ECA; UNCTADstat
Covid-19 brings a whole new level of vulnerabilities…

    In Africa as a whole and Eastern africa in particular, some
    economic effects are expected in the Service sector:
    • Slow-down in economic activity due to preventive and restrictive measures
    • Will result in

    • Losses to regional Airlines
    • Loss of public revenues and houselholds income through tourism-related
      activities;
Regional exports heavily dependent on services, so if economic activity
  slows down and services are hit, effects could be substantial
                                            Transport Services
                                                  14%

                                                       Travel Services
                                                             5%

                                                           Other Services
                     Merchandise Trade                         20%
                           61%

Source: UNCTADStat
African services trade generate more than 150 Bn USD per year
                                          African Services Exports, USD Billions
200

150

100

 50

  0
       2005   2006   2007   2008   2009     2010         2011         2012          2013   2014   2015   2016   2017   2018

 -50

-100

                                               imports      exports      Trade balance
Trade deficits are less present in services than in Merchandises
                       Ethiopia

                         Kenya

                      Tanzania

                       Uganda

                Madagascar
                                                 Merchandise trade balance
                     Seychelles
                                                 Service trade balance
                       Rwanda

                       Somalia

                       Djibouti

                       Burundi

                 D.R. Congo

                             -15,000   -12,000           -9,000              -6,000    -3,000   0   3,000
                                                                         USD million

Source: UNCTADStat
The Contribution of Tourism sector in some Top Tourism destinations in Africa
amount to 140 bn USD in 2019. In a scenario where the sector looses 20% of
revenues, that will correspond to a 28 bn USD loss from COVID.

                 GDP (USD bn) % share   of Visitor      % share   of International
                               GDP         exports      exports      arrivals (mn)
 South Africa            32.1            9          9.7            9            10.5
 Egypt                   29.6           12         12.2           27            11.3
 Morocco                 22.7           19          9.6           20            12.3
 Nigeria                 18.6            5          1.6            3               -
 Kenya                       8           9          1.7           15             1.5
 Ethiopia                  7.4           9          2.5           38             0.9
 Tanzania                  6.7          12          2.5           28               -
 Tunisia                   6.5          16          2.2           11             8.3
 Cote d’Ivoire             4.6          10          0.5            4             1.8
 Mauritius                 3.5          24          2.2           37             1.4
Air transports provide substantial revenues to several economies
(about 9 bn USD in total for countries listed below). With flights
suspended because of COVID 19, important losses ahead.
Top African Air transport exports, USD Millions, 2017
                    Ethi opia                                                                                           2,576

                   Morocco                                                                        1,598

                      Egypt                                                               1,439

                      Kenya                                                  828

                     Tunisia                                           580

                Madagascar                                 337

                  Mauritius                          274

                     Algeri a                        256

                    Rwanda                     183

                  Seychelles              156

 United Republic of Tanzania              155

                       Togo              139

               Côte d'Ivoire             125

                     Ghana           122

                   Namibi a          114

                Cabo Verde          86

                                0                                500               1000   1500            2000   2500           3000
Some African economies dependent heavily on tourism: Among the top 10
in this category, 3 are from Eastern Africa (Toursim share of GDP, %)
                  Botswana                  13

                    Rwanda                       14

                Madagascar                             16

                     Tunisia                           16

                   Morocco                                  19

                    Gambia                                       20

                   Mauritius                                          24

       Sao Tome and Principe                                                28

                 Cape Verde                                                           46

                  Seychelles                                                          67

                               0   5   10         15         20        25        30
In Eastern Africa the contribution of tourism to the economies varies across
countries, and so COVID 19 will have different effects via this sector
                                              EA Tourism Percentage Share of GDP

      Democratic Republic of Congo

                          Uganda

                         Tanzania

                        Seychelles

                          Rwanda

                      Madagascar

                            Kenya

                          Ethiopia

                         Comoros

                          Burundi

                                     0   10            20           30             40   50   60   70
For the continent, the number of tourists coming from African countries
is growing, but that might not be enough to protect the sector from
experiencing important losses as travel bans are in the rise

    70,000,000

    60,000,000

    50,000,000

    40,000,000

    30,000,000

    20,000,000

    10,000,000

            0
                 2013        2014                                      2015   2016

                                    Africa Arrivals   Total arival s
Indeed, the origin of Toursists is well diversified for several countries,
but still COVID is likely to affect substantially the revenues
Distribution of Tourists by region of origin (in %)

  Kenya, 2019

     Tanzania

  Cote d'Ivoire

  South Afri ca

     Morocco

    Seychelles

         Egypt

                  0   10   20                     30                     40                 50                60                   70                   80   90   100

                           Tourists from Africa        Tourists from Asia-Pacifc   Tourists from Americas   Tourists from Europe        Not specified
the region is a net commodity importer…

                                                                                  Ethiopia
                                                       South Sudan

                                                                                              Somalia

                                                              Uganda
                                                                                Kenya

               Net Exporter              Congo (DRC)

               Net Importer                                          Tanzania

 ...and so the overall impact of CODIV
 is likely to be more ambiguous as
                                                                                             Madagascar

 prices of oil and other commodities
 are goind down                                                                                                      Powered by Bing
                                                                                                          © GeoNames, HERE, Microsoft
Conclusions

 1. Regional growth likely to be very negatively impacted by Coronavirus

 2. Measures to prevent spread of disease will slow down economic activity and
    hit severely the Service sector, across the board.

 3. Commodity Price shock will hit hard the net commodity exporters in the region
    – but will be more ambiguous on other countries.

 4. Disruption to trade likely to be severe – but will require creative responses by
    regional governments to scarcities in some sectors.

 5. Over the mid-to long-term, disruption in supply chains (particularly with China)
    could lead to filling the gap by regional producers – need to implement the
    AfCFTA!
Andrew Mold
Chief, Regional Integration and AfCFTA Cluster
  UNECA Sub-Regional Office for Eastern Africa
               Kigali, Rwanda
              www.uneca.org
You can also read