ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London

 
CONTINUE READING
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
Imperial
                           ENGINEER

                                                    FINANCE FOR
                                                UNDERGRADUATES
                                                   CARIBBEAN GOLD
                                                            BEST PROJECT
                                                              HANDLING?
                                                  NUCLEAR FUTURE

                                                         ISSUE SIXTEEN SPRING 2012
For members of The City & Guilds College Association and The Royal School of Mines Association
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
ISSUE SIXTEEN SPRING 2012

    In this issue...                                                                                                  10

ASSOCIATION NEWS & REVIEWS                                            FACULTY NEWS
3        Presidents report                                            8, 9       Developments around the Engineering
4        Decade Lunch                                                            Faculty
4        New Indian alumni association
5        On-line student help                                         FEATURES
5        Historic Bottle win                                          10, 11     Electric land-speed record
5        Graphene lecture                                             12         An appropriate process?
6        Diary dates                                                  13         Prince Philip retires from City & Guilds
6        CGCA dinner                                                  14, 15     21st century Caribbean gold
6        RSMA dinner                                                  16, 17     Investigating the desert
7        Student unions report                                        18–21      Small reactors and a nuclear future
22–27    Alumni news and views                                        21         Comment & Review
26–27    Obituaries

                                                                      COVER: Above luxuriant vegetation in the
                                                                      Dominican Republic. Below, gold is being mined.
                                                                      Picture by Robert Hildebrand. Article page
             12		                     22		                   24       14 to 15.

    Imperial ENGINEER
    EDITORIAL BOARD                                            CORRESPONDENCE and ENQUIRIES
    Bill McAuley (Managing Editor)                             Teresa Sergot
    Bill Bradford                                              Engineering Chapter
    Paul Holmes                                                Level 2, Faculty Building
    Chris Lumb                                                 Imperial College, London SW7 2AZ
    Colleen Shilstone Richardson                               Tel: +44 (0) 20 7594 1184
    Teresa Sergot                                              Email: t.sergot@imperial.ac.uk
                                                               Website:
    PRODUCTION EDITOR                                          www.imperial.ac.uk/engineering/alumni/
    Lynn Penfold                                               CGCA website: www.cgca.org.uk
    PRINTING                                                   RSMA website: www2.union.ic.uk/rsm/rsma/
    Bishops Printers, Portsmouth

                    STORY IDEAS FOR THE NEXT ISSUE BY AUGUST 13 2012
                    FINAL COPY DEADLINE: SEPTEMBER 28 2012
                    The editorial board of Imperial Engineer reserves the right to edit copy for style and length
                    Imperial Engineer is printed on Forest Stewardship Council registered paper

2                                                                                       IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
THE END of my term as president is approaching fast and this is the last time that I will be writing
the welcome in Imperial Engineer. It has been a great honour to be your president for the last
two years. Particular highlights for me have included the many opportunities I have had to meet
members at the City & Guilds Association’s (CGCA) social events and the opportunity to work
closely with the members of the General Committee – a group of volunteers who work tirelessly
on your behalf.
    As I hand over to my successor, I am pleased to see that our attempts to boost membership,
particularly amongst fresh graduates, are beginning to take shape. Largely thanks to Nigel Cress-
well’s enthusiasm, the CGCA is beginning to embrace social media as a vehicle for maintaining
contact with the membership and to foster more active participation in topical debate. Our new
approach to student membership is almost certainly going to result in more fresh graduates retain-
ing their links to CGCA after they graduate. I am also happy to report that, after some difficult
times during the last few years, we now have a very constructive relationship with the College’s
alumni office.
                                                                                                         Chris
    The annual dinner this year was, as always, very enjoyable. Professor Sir William Wakeham
(Bill) gave an entertaining and very interesting talk (see report on page 6). I apologise to those
who missed out on tickets due to the restricted numbers at Cutlers’ Hall.
                                                                                                         Hankin
    Next year is the 100th dinner and we hope to have a venue that will accommodate about twice the normal number of
guests. I hope to see many of you there and look forward to enjoying the Association’s excellent wines and port – some-
thing that, as president, I never quite managed to do (because of my speaking responsibilities)!
    We have enjoyed a very close relationship with CGCU over the last year. We would like to continue to build on this and
the students have asked if we could provide Association speakers for student events. They are keen to have experienced
alumni who can talk about their careers and give advice to current students. If you are interested in doing this, please con-
tact Nigel Cresswell.
    Thank you for your support over the last two years and best wishes to my successor. The Annual General Meeting will
be on June 13 this year and I hope to see many of you there.

                                 PRESIDENTS REPORT
                                  THE RSMA has been very active over the last few months. Our annual dinner, where Richard
                                  Lloyd gave an amusing speech, was well-attended. At the dinner, the Peter Harding medal was
                                  awarded to Alan Dickson for his work keeping alumni together in Australia. (See article, page
                                  6) Edoardo Borgomeo (Earth Sciences and Engineering) also received the prize for his essay
                                  on ‘Science and Enginering in the Future of Venice’. RSMA also sponsored, and some alumni
                                  attended, the first Materials Society dinner.
                                      You will also be pleased to know that we won the Bottle Match again with an amazing
                                  margin. (See page 5) We have also continued to make progress in encouraging more member-
                                  ship and will be conducting another drive for this later this year.
                                      The new London Sundowners ran successfully at the start of the year and John Sykes is

Mark                              working on setting up a regular programme. The students have also asked for a joint event, so
                                  John will look into this too. In the longer term, John is looking for a London-based alumnus
                                  to organise these event on an ongoing basis.

Burridge                              There has been less progress in organising international Sundowners, due to some prob-
                                  lems accessing the database, but John is intending to produce an international calendar to be
                                  printed in the autumn Imperial Engineer.
     Turning to electronic means of keeping in touch, membership of the Linkedin Group is now approaching 1,000 members
and John is open to suggestions on how to make the best of the Group. He’s also looking for a student to run the Facebook
group(s) and a Twitter account. Meanwhile, junior vice president Elly Jay is recreating the RSMA website.
     Another initiative being launched this year is the 1851 Club. Initially, its target will be to raise enough money from mining,
oil, materials, engineering and finance companies so that the annual interest can fund the DLB fieldtrips and symposium, the
new (and to be annual) Materials Society dinner, support students in gaining practical experience and a new activity (maybe a
symposium or industry visit). Although these ambitions seemed fairly modest, we feel that having some small-scale early suc-
cesses would get the ball rolling. We’ll let you know more about this at the annual dinner.
     We have now set the dates for the AGM/summer barbecue and the dinner. They will be held on Thursday June 28 and
Friday November 30 respectively. Please save the dates. Please also reach out to your fellow alumni to let them know in case
they are not on the mailing list (and if they are not on the mailing list, ask them to update their details and, if necessary, ‘re-
join’ the RSMA). For those in the mining field, you will note that the annual dinner is the Friday before the Mines and Money
week so hopefully this will make it more convenient for overseas members to attend.

IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012                                                                                                    3
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
NEWS
CGCA alumni                          New alumni association in India
links grow                           IMPERIAL’S Rector Sir Keith              Alumnus Vibin Joseph, who      the younger alumni to look up
‘THE CGCA LinkedIn group             O’Nions launched a new chap-        graduated from the Business         to the older generations for
has passed the 370 members           ter of the Imperial College         School in 2008, is the new          guidance and advice. This club
mark, drawn from alumni, staff       Alumni Association of India,        chair of the Bangalore chap-        could become an aspiration for
and current students,’ writes hon    Bangalore, during his visit to      ter. Speaking at the event, he      the next community of Impe-
sec Nigel Cresswell. It is one       the country in December. It         said: ‘The Bangalore alumni I’ve    rial students who are applying
of the channels CGCA uses to         incorporated stops in four cit-     met tonight are extremely keen      and will hopefully become part
communicate with members and         ies in five days. He hosted a       about the new chapter. It will      of this community.’
prospective members.                 reception on December 2.            provide a great opportunity for     http://bit.ly/w3QjG9
    ‘We’ve had a number of dis-
cussions about engineering and
the future direction of CGCA,
as well as announcing events
                                     Civil servant joins management
and helped in tracking down the      NEW COLLEGE secretary and                Previously, John Neilson was   of the College’s principal admin-
supplier of CGCU scarves!’ con-      registrar, John Neilson, started    director of financial management    istrative officers, and John is now
tinued Nigel.                        work on May 1. He replaces          in the Ministry of Defence. He      responsible for the registry, the
    ‘All members of the group        Dr Rodney Eastwood, who gave        also spent six years as director    central secretariat, health and
are able to start discussions and    almost 25 years service to the      of research based in the Depart-    safety, risk management, legal
post comments, so please take        College, taking Imperial through    ment for Business, Innovation       matters and internal audit.
advantage of this to interact        many key moments in its history.    & Skills, where he advised on       Alongside these he is clerk to
with other members. It’s free        He has headed into retirement       the £6 billion spent annually on    the Imperial College Court and
to register on LinkedIn. To do so,   with the gratitude and fond ap-     public research in universities     Council, and joins the College’s
search the groups’ list for City &   preciation of the entire Imperial   and institutes.                     management board and the sen-
Guilds College Association’ and      community,                               The college secretary is one   ior management committee.
submit a request to join. Make
clear your connection with the
Faculty of Engineering.’

Wine tasting
THIRTY alumni, students and
guests enjoyed a wine tasting in
March, sponsored by the CGCU
and CGCA. The wines were
both new and old world, priced
from £9 to £40 a bottle giving
a good impression of what one
gets for one’s money. Winner of
the tasting was Rudolf Umla and       Four decades hear about present
then it was off to Bill Wyman’s        ALUMNI from four different decades – 1961,          group of 1981 graduates who meet most
Sticky Fingers restaurant to           1971, 1981 and 2011 – gathered at the Polish        years. Alan was followed by two members
complete the evening.                  Club in November. The decades would have            from the Civils class of 1971 - David Sorton
                                       been one greater if John Macara, who gradu-         and Tony Atkins. Next came Professor Ron
Thinking alike                         ated in 1941, hadn’t been prevented at the          Lawes (Elec 61), who ended his remarks with
                                       11th hour from making the journey from his          a passionate plea for the reinstatement of the
REPRESENTATIVES from
                                       home in Beaconsfield.                               ‘City & Guilds College’ name, demanding ‘Give
CGCA recently met Imperial’s
                                            The 53 attendees included some 38 alum-        us our College back!’. For the current students,
Office of Alumni Development
                                       ni, accompanied by 11 partners and friends          CGCU president, Jacky Kwan, gave a run-down
(OAD) to discuss improving
                                       and four current students, who all enjoyed          on student affairs, before calling on all alumni
cooperation. One area that
                                       an extended catch-up session over a drink           and students to share in a Boomalaka.
would work well for all parties
                                       before sitting down for a hearty lunch, with            Once the meal was over, some members
is to encourage CGCA mem-
                                       Spanner and Bolt in attendance.                     were taken on tours of the campus, whilst
bers to attend OAD events
                                            Once all were seated Professor Chris           others repaired to the rear of the Club, in
around the world.
                                       Hankin, CGCA president, set the scene by            Princes Gardens, where Bo was waiting to
                                       extending a warm welcome and gave a brief           give rides around the locality.
    More to follow?                    resumé of CGCA news, and of current life in             As has often been the case, the success of
    FOLLOW computer                    the Faculty of Engineering and College as a         this event could be judged by the reluctance
    links at the end of ar-            whole. As the meal got under way, organiser         of many to drag themselves away. Even on
    ticles throughout this             David Law (MechEng 73) called on representa-        leaving, most were already making plans to
    issue to read more. Or             tives of each of the decades present to share       attend again in 2021! Chris Lumb
    go to www.imperial.                their own particular reminiscences during the
    ac.uk/engineering/ to              gaps between courses.                               Top left, David Sorton. Centre , in the
    read more of articles                                                                  foreground, David, Lizzie Ackers and
                                            First to speak was Alan Higginson (Elec
    marked at the end with
    an asterisk *.                     81), one of the organisers of a very active         Tony Atkins. Right, Professor Ron

4                                                                                                      IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
NEWS & REVIEWS

On-line student help CGCA date for AGM
AN online calculator has been       government sources.
launched by Imperial to help             Rector Sir Keith O’Nions          THE DATE of CGCA’s AGM is starting at 17:30, on Wednesday
                                                                           June 13, in the Pippard Theatre, Level 5, Sherfield Building. (Re-
prospective students get a bet-     said: ‘It gives anyone consider-
                                                                           freshments will be available from 17:00 on the Level 5 Concourse
ter grasp of financial support      ing study at Imperial clear ad-
                                                                           area, outside the theatre.)
available.                          vice on what support they may
                                                                               After the election of officers, the new president, David Neth-
    They and their parents          be eligible for. It reinforces our
                                                                           ercot, will speak about ‘Stealing the Mind’ . This will be followed
can input details about their       message that if you have the           by supper in the Senior Common Room, on the first floor of the
financial circumstances and get     ability to manage our courses,         Sherfield Building for which a charge will be made.
tailored information on the         we will help you manage your               See the enclosed flyer or contact Teresa Sergot for more
support they may be entitled        costs.’                                details and bookings.
to, from both Imperial and          http://bit.ly/tyadu0

IN ITS 110th year and play-
ing away in Cornwall, this
year’s Bottle Match was al-
                                    RSMU gains an historic victory
                                    all great performance from the       slightly off-guard by a surpris-      since 2005.
ways going to be something
                                    RSM students.                        ingly strong CSM team, tak-                Finally the focus moved on to
special. This is the biggest
                                         Ladies’ hockey was first on     ing a heavy beating in the first      rugby, with a chance for the RSM
weekend of the year for any
                                    the agenda, but after a hard-        quarter and eventually losing         to turn around a weekend which
Royal Miner and it always
                                    fought game CSM emerged              38-29, a shock result and the         had begun to look a little sour.
delivers high-tension, heav-
                                    victorious with a 2-1 win.           first time that RSM has lost in            The game kicked off and
ily-contested matches, too                                               this competition.
many streakers, banter and               Next up was the men’s                                                 showed the Camborne miners’
sore heads the next day.            hockey where two equally                                                   distinct lack of preparation and
    With 150 people on board        matched teams were locked at         Best result                           control and they earned a yellow
                                    1-1 at half time.The final quar-     In a stark contrast to the usual      card after just three minutes play.
the coaches left London and
                                    ter yielded two goals for the        progression of Bottle Match foot-     RSM used this opportunity to ap-
made it to Cornwall in record
                                    home side and left a score line      ball, the RSM lads put in a stellar   ply pressure, maintaining posses-
time, before becoming stuck
                                    which did not reflect the qual-      performance and worked out a          sion and field position but being
up a country lane and one hav-
                                    ity of RSM 3 – CS 1 RSM.             0-0 draw against a quality CSM        unable to score until a 35th minute
ing to be pushed out of the
mud!                                     RSM netball were caught         side. This marks RSM’s best result    try was capitalised upon to bring
                                                                                                               the score to 7-0 at half time.
Good start                                                                                                          After this, the CSM side grew
We arrived at the caravan site                                                                                 tired and the skill and fitness of the
a little late but had the com-                                                                                 RSM shone through. After three
forting news that during our                                                                                   more tries for the RSM without
travels the Squash and Golf                                                                                    reply from the home side., our
teams had won and drawn their                                                                                  boys walked off the pitch with
respective contests. So the first                                                                              heads held high, chalking up an
two trophies of the weekend                                                                                    historic 22-0.
were returning to London (or                                                                                        After a successful weekend
would have done if the Golf                                                                                    the Bottle remains to grace the
captain hadn’t got theirs stuck                                                                                Union Bar for another year, and
up a tree).                                                                                                    the Royal Miners returned to Lon-
     Saturday saw the bulk of                                                                                  don victorious. Richard Simons,
the weekend’s action and over-                                                                                 RSMU president

Graphene subject of lecture
A DESCRIPTION of his Nobel               By stacking ultra-thin layers
                                                                           THE RSMA committee is hop-
                                                                           ing that as many alumni as          RSMA
                                                                                                               plans
Prize-winning work on the ‘flat’    of graphene and other two-             possible will attend the AGM
carbon material graphene was        dimensional crystals with dif-         at 18:30 on Thursday June 28.

                                                                                                               student
Professor Sir Konstantin Nov-       ferent conducting and magnetic         The venue is College Room, 58
oselov’s subject for Imperial’s     properties, scientists hope to         Prince’s Gate, Prince’s Gardens.

                                                                                                               send off
Kohn Award Lecture. This an-        develop cheaper and faster,            The meeting will include the
nual event allows the public        more compact and more flex-            election of officers for the 2012
hear a talk by a top scientist.     ible electronics, which could be       – 2013 academic year.               Alumni will welcome them into
    Professor Novoselov, from       used to make discreet hand-                 Following the AGM, at          the RSMA. The barbecue will
Manchester University, ex-          held or wearable devices.              19:00, president, Mark Burridge     be held in the Garden Room and
plained why graphene, with its           In October 2011, the UK           will host a barbecue for alumni     Terrace at 58 Prince’s Gate.
unusual properties, is a promis-    government pledged £50m                and the final year students of           Please see the enclosed
ing candidate to revolutionise      towards more research into             the RSM who have just com-          flyer or contact Teresa Sergot
the telecommunications and          graphene and developing prac-          pleted their academic studies.      for more details and bookings.
electronics industries.             tical applications.

IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012                                                                                                                       5
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
NEWS & REVIEWS
                                     RSMA dinner told importance of contacts
    DIARY                            ‘CONTACTS dear boy, contacts’         thanked Teresa Sergot for her        Australia to receive the Peter
                                     could be the traditional sum-         continuing help and organisa-        Harding Medal. Instituted as a
    Saturday May 12                  mary of the speech by Richard         tion of the evening. He also         tribute to a man who did so
    Imperial College/Chapter         (LLoydy) LLoyd at RSMA’s 127th        spoke of the 1851 Club and           much for RSMA, it is given to
    Imperial Festival – Annual       dinner last November. It was all      the drive to raise sponsorship       someone who has followed his
    Alumni Reunion. Alumni           part of his advice on how to go       of study courses.                    lead. It was received for Alan by
    Hub: Foyer Mech Eng              about getting a job. And always           After senior vice president      John Monhemius.
    Building.                        support friends. he said!             John Sykes had welcomed and               Earth Sciences Engineer-
    Wednesday June 13                    Earlier, president Mark           named the guests and RSMU            ing student Edoardo Borgomeo
    CGCA AGM & President’s           Burridge had begun the speech-        president Richard Simon had          won the prize for the best essay.
    Evening: Pippard Lecture         es by remembering all alumni,         replied on their behalf, two         See the next Imperial Engineer
    Theatre 17:30. Supper:           complimenting his committee           awards were made.                    for his views on science and
    Senior Common Room               on keeping the RSMA going,                Sadly, Alan Dixon was            engineering for the future of
    19:30. Booking form on           welcomed guests and, especially,      unable to travel from Perth,         Venice.
    back of address carrier.
    Tuesday June 19
    Faculty of Engineering
    Teaching Awards Ceremony
    and Reception: RSM
    Building, Room 131, 16:00
    Thursday June 28
    RSMA AGM /Final Year BBQ:
    58 Prince’s Gate, AGM
    18:30, BBQ 19:00.
    Thursday October 25
    Careers Advisory Service/
    Chapter, Engineering                                                                                       Matt Cockayne, Roger
    Careers Fair: Queen’s Lawn                                                                                 Davey, Mark Burridge, Elena
    Marquee.                                                                                                   Clarici, Coen Louwart, listen
    Alumni Networking                                                                                          to speaker Richard Lloyd.
    Reception. Venue: tbc
    Saturday November 24
    CGCA 2012 Decade                 Economy needs engineers – CGCA speaker
    Reunion Luncheon: Polish         THE CGCA’S annual dinner
    Club Ognisko, 55 Exhibi-         followed a traditional pattern
    tion Road,12:00 for 12:30.       against the background of the
    Friday November 30               magnificent Cutlers’ Hall (right)
    RSMA 128th Annual Dinner:        After the guests had processed
    Ballroom, Polish Club            behind the mascots, Spanner
    Ognisko, 55 Exhibition Road,     and Bolt, over 120 sat down for
    19:15 for 20:00.                 an excellent dinner accompanied
                                     by wine from CGCA’s ‘cellar’.
    LONDON WALKS
                                          Also during the course of
    Saturday June 9
                                     the even, presentations were
    Walk around outside of
                                     made by Prof Richard Vinter
    Olympic site and view
                                     (dean of Engineering). They were
    of the site (Despite best
                                     to Hai Ming Tan, winner of the
    efforts, for security reasons,
                                     Holbein Memorial Award for            Prize (QEP) for engineering, Sir     and the Lords’ advisor on edu-
    not allowed inside).
                                     being a ‘sportsman’ in its widest     William Wakeham spoke about          cating engineers, and now chair
    All welcome. Please email
                                     sense, chosen by CGCU.                his belief in the importance of      of the global search committee
    johnsheilabackhurst@tiscali.
                                          This year’s senior Bo driver     educating engineers.                 charged with soliciting nomina-
    co.uk for further details
                                     Robert Goodwill received the              As he said: ‘...it seems that    tions for the QEP, he is in a posi-
                                     Peter Moore Memorial Award,           only recently has our political      tion to help. Apart from helping
                                     while Roger Liew received             leadership recognised that...to      recognise significant engineering
  More information                   the Jessel Rosen Travel Award.        compete in the modern world,         achievements and engineers, it
and booking for any                  Backed by the Award, Roger was        the education of scientists and      is also intended to promote
   events, contact                   student chairman of the E,quinox      especially of engineers must be      engineering in the public mind
                                     project for which students have       maintained and enhanced. Of          worldwide.
    Teresa Sergot                    designed, built and installed so-     course this...has not led yet to          President of Engineering
 t.sergot@imperial.                  lar-powered ‘energy kiosks’, to       a recognition that such enhance-     Faculty Prof Jeff Magee replied
   ac.uk or phone                    provide battery charging facilities   ment merits further investment,      on behalf of the guests. Espe-
                                     in Rwanda.                            but we must travel hopefully.’       cially he thanked Sir William
    020 7594 1184                         Speaking on the evening after        As senior vice president of      for his scientific and humorous
                                     the launch of the Queen Elizabeth     the Royal Society of Engineers       joke about hell freezing over!

6                                                                                                       IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
NEWS & REVIEWS

   RSMU spirit still strong within students
                                    by RSMU president Richard Simons
THIS YEAR has seen another               Changes to several Impe-       provide social and sporting          MatSoc (Materials Student So-
great intake for the RSM, with      rial College Union policies have    relief for the students of Ma-       ciety) annual calendar reached
huge amounts of interest from       changed how we run bar nights       terials and Earth Science and        its zenith with its first formal
first year students as well as      and other events, but the spirit    Engineering as it has done for       dinner with alumni held at the
continued involvement from          of the RSMU still lives strongly    many years.                          Rembrandt hotel, Knights-
students returning from sum-        within its students.                     In recent years the RSMU        bridge. The event was coordi-
mer vacation.                            The RSMU continues to          has been growing in influence        nated between MatSoc, with
                                                                        and responsibility, following re-    president Jim Hickey, and the
                                                                        acknowledgement as a constitu-       Materials department. Current
                                                                        ent union in 2010 and the recent     and past members of the de-
                                                                        changes to allow greater repre-      partment were in attendance.
                                                                        sentation of the welfare needs of         The evening was an out-
                                                                        RSM students.                        standing success and it was
                                                                             This has occurred whilst the    fantastic to see so many alumni
                                                                        students of the RSM still sit (in-   come from far afield to join
                                                                        correctly in my opinion) within      us for an evening of meeting,
                                                                        the jurisdiction of the CGCU.        greeting, eating (and drink-
                                                                             In short, we are in good        ing!).
                                                                        health as an institution, our             I would like to thank the
                                                                        students feel welcome and at         RSMA and the Department of
                                                                        home. It is hoped that the work      Materials for their support of
                                                                        to bring the RSMU to bigger          the evening. As the dinner will
Junior vice president Elly Jay (left) with colleague Emily
                                                                        and better things will continue      be held annually from now on,
Warriss, enjoyed the RSMA dinner last Novembeer (Picure
                                                                        for many years after.                we can’t wait to see what next
and those of RSMA dinner by Douglas McIlraith).
                                                                             On Friday March 9, the          year brings.

    CGCU has record-breaking year
                                       by CGCU president Jacky Kwan
THE CGCU has had an ex-             in a record-breaking six hours      extremely delighted to have              These wonderful events are
ceptional year in academic and      flat with no mechanical faults      strengthened a close relation-       found to be highly popular (judged
welfare representation as well      or failures!                        ship with CGCA.                      from number of attendees and
as social events.                        A more career-orientated           Examples of our successful       feedbacks received) and would
     We kick-started the year       networking dinner proved to         joint-organised events are a         not have happened without gener-
with the welcome dinner and         be extremely popular in late        CGCU-CGCA dinner at Med              ous supports from the CGCA.
after-party at Café de Paris, in    November with 10 companies          Kitchen, Gloucester Road and             On a final note, the Union has
Piccadilly Circus, marking the      mixing with 150 bright-minded       wine tasting night at Rober-         become bigger and better than
flagship event of the year. The     students.                           son’s wine merchants in High         ever and we are keen to continue
party attracted over 600 stu-            Social events continued        St Kensington.                       the on-going success.
dents, testing the 700 capacity     strongly in the spring term
of the venue.Tickets were sold      with a club night in Kensington
out even before term began.         and a boat party which was
     Notable guests among           held jointly with the RCSU and
attendees included former           RSMU. A group of enthusiastic
CGCU presidents, CGCA               students attended the CGCA
president Prof Chris Hankin         annual dinner in late February
and Engineering Faculty princi-     (pictured).
pal Prof Jeff Magee. The event
was concluded with a tradi-         Record turn-out
tional Boomalaka and short          Finally the term finished with
speeches.                           a remarkable election. CGCU
     A string of fantastic events   is thrilled to announced that,
filled the winter term, including   as a result of the phenomenal
the annual London to Brighton       year, we had a brilliant, record-
Run. This year’s Bo team man-       breaking election turnout, 45%
aged to carry the CGCU presi-       of the 6000 students faculty
dent and guest, head of Elec-       participated, up from the 35%
trical & Electronic Engineering     last year!w
Prof Peter Cheung, to Brighton           Last, but not least, we are

IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012                                                                                                               7
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
NEWS & REVIEWS

      DEVELOPMENTS AROUND THE ENGINEERING FACULTY
Water use affecting
                                    Machine could be prescription for success
India’s climate?
                                    SOME of the nation’s leading sci-     scientists will work alongside     would have died from their
RESEARCHERS from Civil and          ence, defence, engineering and        military doctors, supported by     injuries. Now military protec-
Environmental Engineering are       health journalists came to Imperial   charitable funding, The aim is     tion, medical science and prac-
part of a £1.1 million UK and       in December to hear about the         to reduce the effects of road-     tice has improved greatly so
Indian academic collaboration       launch of an £8 million research      side bombs or Improvised Ex-       that there is a greater prospect
working to determine if water       centre to combat the devastating      plosive Devices (IEDs) which       of survival,’ says Professor An-
usage in northern India over        effects of roadside bombs.            are the leading cause of death     thony Bull (Bioengineering).
the last 50 years is affecting           The Royal British Legion         and injury for service person-         ‘We urgently need to
the climate.                        Centre for Blast Injury Studies       nel on operations in Afghani-      know more, so that we can
    To do this, they are devel-     at Imperial is the first collabo-     stan and Iraq.                     protect and treat people more
oping the most comprehen-           ration of its kind in the UK,             ‘Previously, servicemen        effectively,’ he added.
sive computer models yet of         where civilian engineers and          and women, wounded by blasts,          http://bit.ly/uDlbde
the water cycle in the Ganges
basin to determine if overuse
of ground water resources is           A NEW carbon capture
impacting on the fragile mon-          pilot plant, the most              Pilot plant captures carbon
soonal climate in the region.          sophisticated in a uni-
                                       versity anywhere in the
Doing what                             world, opened at Imperi-
                                       al in April. The £2 million
comes naturally                        unit, in collaboration
A PROTOTYPE system for re-             with ABB, gives chemi-
covering drinkable water and           cal engineering students
harvesting hydrogen energy             the chance to train in a
from human faecal waste is             state-of-the-art facil-
being worked on in Materials,          ity. The plant separates
                                       1.2 tonnes of CO2 a
It could provide an inexpensive
                                       day from other emitted
way for people in the devel-
                                       gases, then stores and
oping world to improve their
                                       recycles it.
life-styles.                               The plant’s controls
      ‘In the future, we may see       can be accessed remotely
homes in the UK generating             from phones and iPads,             before they begin their            ees that they are crying
their own clean water, energy          and students will learn            careers, we aim to give our        out for all over the world,’
and fertiliser simply by doing         how to manage emergen-             graduates the best possible        said Dr Daryl Williams
what comes naturally once              cies by taking part in             start and provide industry         (Chemical Engineering),
or twice day,’ said Dr Martyn          simulations. ‘By provid-           with the type of high-cali-        director of the Pilot Plant
McLachlan (Materials).                 ing this intense training          bre, well-trained employ-          Project.
http://bit.ly/yRtTgC

Eyes right
 A TEAM in Bioengineering, led      Helping Russia’s                      ing CO2 emissions. Professor       Dig deep on Mars
by Aldo Faisal, has developed                                             Sandro Macchietto (Chemical
                                                                                                              ‘FUTURE NASA and ESA mis-
low-cost eye tracking technol-      sustainability                        Engineering) said: ‘Imperial has
                                                                                                             sions planned for Mars will have
ogy to help people with limited                                           a strong track record of working
                                    A £9.3 million project has been                                          to dig deep for evidence of life,
mobility to interact with de-                                             with industry around the world
                                    established to make oil refining                                         which may still be taking ref-
vices, such as a computer mouse                                           to find innovative solutions to
                                    in Russia more efficient and en-                                         uge underground,’ Dr Tom Pike
or wheelchair, using only eye                                             make the refining process more
                                    vironmentally sustainable. The                                           (EEE) told a recent European
movement.                                                                 efficient and sustainable.’
                                    Skolkovo Foundation has given                                            Space Agency meeting.
    The eyes are directly wired     official approval for the estab-                                              He and his team, tak-
to the brain stem so are not        lishment of a Centre of Applied       Paralympic future                  ing part in the 2008 NASA
affected by spinal cord injuries.   Research on Heat Exchange and         A MIND-controlled bobsleigh        Phoenix mission, found that
http://bit.ly/vpcMEU                Catalysis, involving Imperial, the    and a sport in which players       despite an abundance of ice,
                                    Boreskov Institute of Catalysis       fly using magnetic propulsion      Mars has been experiencing
    The source of most              and British Petroleum.                were among Imperial students’      a super-drought that may well
    of these articles is                 Researchers at the Centre        inventions for the Paralympics     have lasted hundreds of mil-
    the College’s press             will run the UNIHEAT project,         of the future.                     lions of years.
    releases. For more on           which will focus on increasing            The equipment devised by            ‘We think the Mars we
    these stories go to             energy efficiency and reducing        Innovation Design Engineering      know today contrasts sharply
    www3.imperial.                  heat loss in oil refining by up to    students,from Mech Eng was         with its earlier history. This had
    ac.uk/news or use               15% through improving refining        on display in the College main     warmer and wetter periods
    the links at the                operations, enhancing oil pro-        entrance.                          and may have been more suited
    end of some articles.           duction processes, and reduc-         http://bit.ly/y69Nl4               to life’, Tom said.

8                                                                                                      IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
NEWS & REVIEWS

     DEVELOPMENTS AROUND THE ENGINEERING FACULTY
RESEARCHERS from Materials
are in a race against time to
                                    timated. We’ve been analys-
                                    ing fragments already brought
                                                                        Challenge to save bomber
help save the last remaining        to the surface. It’s absolutely
intact World War II German          fascinating to see how this
light bomber – a Dornier Do-        bomber, which crash-landed
17 – known as The Flying Pencil     more than 70 years ago, has
(Fliegender Bleistift).             been so well-preserved until
     Lying underwater off the       now by the layers of sand. We
Kent coast, it is now exposed       are relishing the challenge to
to the corrosive effects of         find a way to help save this his-
seawater which threaten to          torical treasure, so that it can
destroy the plane entirely.         be raised and put on display
     Dr Mary Ryan (Materials)       for future generations.’
said: ‘This is the last remaining         Materials will also work
intact Flying Pencil of its kind    with the Royal Air Force Mu-
in the entire world, so the         seum to prevent the aircraft
significance of this project to     from corroding further after        Dr Mary Ryan and Dr Amy Cruikshank with a piece of the
our history can’t be underes-       lifting from the Channel.           Flying Pencil.

Microphones on a mission                                                                                        eas including future cities,
ELECTRICAL Engineering re-          crophone technology, which           Nuclear benefits                       mobility, digital innovation
searchers are using an elec-        is allowing us to integrate mi-      THE House of Lords Science
                                                                                                                and smart energy systems.
tronic compass, microphones         crophones within clothing fab-       and Technology Committee,
                                                                                                                http://bit.ly/smihvs
and a microchip to work out         ric because they’re very small,      for which Prof Robin Grimes
                                                                         (Materials) is a special advisor,
the direction and distance of       lightweight and very low power.
                                                                         has criticised the government
                                                                                                                Oil future?
gunfire.                            Military personnel don’t even
                                                                         for failing to invest in nuclear       DURING a debate on Radio
    Dr Dylan Banks said: ‘We’re     notice the difference in weight
                                                                         energy.                                3, ‘What is the Future of
using MEMS (micro-electrome-        wearing 10 microphones in the
                                                                              ‘Building reactors is an          Civilisation as the Oil Runs
chanical systems)-based mi-         cover of their helmets.’
                                                                         international process now...           Out?’, Neil Hurst (Grantham
                                                                         and we have companies with             Institute) drew attention to

    Brighton involvement                                                 intellectual property rights
                                                                         appropriate for this sector.
                                                                                                                the fact that the future hing-
                                                                                                                es on whether we can solve
 IMPERIAL academics, students             Dr Ricardo Martinez-Botas                                             two problems. ‘Can we find
                                                                         Investing in research could
and alumni were on hand at          (MechEng) who was one of the                                                the increasing energy de-
                                                                         generate jobs later.
the London to Brighton RAC          technical judges, said: ‘This is                                            manded in developing coun-
Future Car Challenge. They          the second year of the Future                                               tries and control the impact
lent a hand assessing, judging      Car Challenge and it’s great        Biofuels boost                          this will have on our climate
and competing, with more than       to see Imperial so involved at      A STUDY at Imperial has found           and global warming. ‘
60 cutting-edge, low-emission       all levels. Imperial has a strong   that a key part of biomass pro-         http://bbc.in/rraJOz
vehicles. Others present will       track record in low emission        cessing could be made much
use data recovered from the         vehicle research. ‘                 more energy-efficient by taking         Molly on BBC4
cars, for their PhD research.        http://bit.ly/t5NQoC               advantage of the slippery proper-       PROFESSOR Molly Stevens
                                                                        ties of fluids called ionic solvents.   (Materials) was the subject
                                                                        This could bring down the cost          of Radio 4’s The Life Scien-
                                                                        of biofuels by around 10%.              tific in November. Profes-
                                                                             Tree wood is a mine of re-         sor Jim Al-Khalili discussed
                                                                        ally valuable chemicals fixed in a      with her how she became
                                                                        safe that needs unlocking before        interested in tissue engi-
                                                                        the different components can            neering and what she hoped
                                                                        be used.                                her work would achieve.
                                                                                                                http://bbc.in/ttN8cQ
                                                                        Cities of the future
                                                                        LONDON is becoming a glo-                Pit stop
                                                                        bal leader in future cities’ re-        SEVEN-TIMES Formula 1
                                                                        search, since Imperial Cisco            world champion, Michael
IMPERIAL College Robotics Society (ICRS) is preparing to                and UCL have entered into               Schumacher, surprised stu-
enter the third Eurobot contest, with the ambitious goal                a three year initial agree-             dents when he appeared at
of coming in the top third of teams worldwide. The Old                  ment to create a Future                 Imperial to share some in-
Centralians’ Trust helped sponsor their entry last year,                Cities Centre in London’s               sights into his experiences
when their competing robot (above) had to move chess                    Shoreditch. The Centre                  on the track.
pieces. It had already won the UK round and went on to                  will focus on thematic ar-              http://bit.ly/uk9lcQ
take 20th place out of 50 in Astrakhan.

IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012                                                                                                                    9
ENGINEER - FINANCE FOR UNDERGRADUATES CARIBBEAN GOLD BEST PROJECT HANDLING? NUCLEAR FUTURE - Imperial College London
FEATURES

Guildsmen help students break
electric land-speed record

                                                                                            Buckeye Bullet 2.0 – 2005-2008,
                                                                                            hydrogen-HeLox fuel cell source,
                                                                                            achieved 308 mph in 2008.

In May 2000, students at the Center for Automotive Research, Ohio State University,         the start, the experience is quickly
USA, had a dream of building an electric car, with the intention of breaking the existing   brought to an abrupt end by the
land-speed record. They turned to two Imperial College Guildsmen – Tony David and Nigel     deployment of the two parachutes.
McQuin – to design, manufacture and deliver the electrical drive train components for           Although the operating time
this world-class project. One of them, Nigel McQuin tells the story of their involvement    of the power train is short, the
                                                                                            components are exposed to espe-
IN 2004, the land-speed record was            salt-packed lake bed with a limited
                                                                                            cially severe conditions. The salt
held by White Lightning which                 maximum travel distance of just sev-
                                                                                            grinds into a fine powder that gets
achieved a mile-averaged speed of             en miles. This constraint imposes
                                                                                            into every opening and adheres to
245 mph in October 1999, at the               special design considerations for an
                                                                                            every surface. Combined with only
Bonneville Speedway, Utah, USA.               electric car. The three timed miles
                                                                                            traces of moisture, the salt becomes
The objective was to be the first              begin after just two miles. Our
                                                                                            electrically conductive and attacks
to break the 300 mph barrier. This            target was to enter the first timed
                                                                                            electrical connections and metal
would require a careful selection             mile at 250 mph – a speed already
                                                                                            components more aggressively that
of aero-dynamics, chassis, suspen-            in excess of the previous record.
                                                                                            conventional road dirt and debris.
sion and drive train design compo-                Such a rate of acceleration, zero
                                                                                            Also, the air temperature on the
nents to propel the electric car and          to 250 mph in 45 seconds, and
                                                                                            speedway course can reach 40oC
driver safely along the speedway              under two miles, surpasses any pro-
                                                                                            in the full afternoon sunlight and
course.                                       duction car and requires a massive
                                                                                            enclosed vehicle spaces can reach
    The huge strength of the Ohio             delivery of power to the wheels to
                                                                                            55oC. These temperature conditions
University team project has been              convert the limited energy source
                                                                                            must be accounted for in the design
their multi-discipline student team           on board into kinetic energy. At the
                                                                                            of the vehicle systems, especially for
members, drawn from aero, elec,               same time, the aerodynamic losses
                                                                                            the energy storage devices that may
mech, business and accounting                 are growing. At a final speed in
                                                                                            be very temperature sensitive.
faculties. This has allowed them to           excess of 300mph, the driver sees
design/build/race the electric car            mile markers flash by at intervals of          Buckeye Bullet 1.0 – 2000-2004,
and also to run the whole effort in           less than 12 seconds. However, at             NiMH battery source, achieved
a small business start-up structure.          only 90 seconds and five miles from            315 mph in 2004.
A very large number of sponsors
contribute to the project, bringing
in expertise, hardware or just plain
dollar donations. This has contribut-
ed to the remarkable success of the
team over many successive years.
    Bonneville Speedway is a white
salt plain, spread across 30,000
acres, 90 miles west of Salt Lake
City. The racing surface is a flat

10                                                                                           IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012
FEATURES
    In Buckeye Bullet, 1.0 vehicle
power source is a NiMH 900 Vdc
battery pack, configured in series
and parallel strings. The dc bus is
fed into a high-power, pulse-rated,
PWM inverter which produces a
variable frequency three-phase AC
power feed. An AC high-speed, in-
duction motor drives a race-proven
mechanical drive train including
a five-speed dragster-class manual
transmission.
    The gear ratios are selected to
maintain the inverter and motor
drive running at the most favour-
able operating speed to maximise        BB-2.5 – 2009-2010, Li-Ion battery       sign could be made total-enclosed
efficiency and acceleration. The         source, achieved 306 mph in 2010.        with a passive cooling system.
final drive is a compact differential
coupling which powers the 300           shock loading on the drive train.        Conclusions
mph class rubber tyres at the drive         Another important feature of         The Buckeye Bullet 1.0 became the
axle. Braking is achieved by dual       the drive inverter is the synchro-       first electric powered vehicle to
spring-launched parachutes, with        nized dynamic braking used during        exceed 300 mph when it achieved
mechanical disc braking at lower        gear shifting. This rapidly retards      314.93 mph on August 16, 2004
speeds.                                 the motor from approximately             claiming the new US record. The sub-
    In the later version 2.0 and 2.5    10000 rpm to 7400 rpm to lessen          sequent version 2.0 and 2.5 vehicles
vehicles, hydrogen-Helox fuel cells     the shock to the transmission when       have both achieved speeds over 308
and Li-Ion power sources were also      the next gear is selected.               mph in 2009 & 2010 respectively.
successfully employed. These deliv-         Through McQuin Electrical            The authors acknowledge the hard work and
ered a lower voltage of 550Vdc and      Power Consulting Inc, I have             dedication of the 60+ students of the Ohio State
required the motor and inverter to      been responsible forthe design/          University team, and the contributions of the
                                                                                 numerous project sponsors in the development
operate at higher currents.             construction of the traction drive       of these vehicles. A complete list of the project
    The liquid-cooled inverters were    motor that accelerates the vehicles      contributors can be found on the official team
designed by Tony Davis and built        and supervision of the ongoing           websites, www.buckeyebullet.com, and www.
                                                                                 roadtobonneville.com.
by Saminco Electric Traction Drives     maintenance/upgrades. We pro-
Inc.and American Traction Systems       vided a three-phase AC induction          NIGEL MCQUIN
of Fort Myers, Florida. They use in-    cage machine with four poles, 0 –         (EE77) lives in
sulated gate bipolar transistors (IG-   10500 rpm operating speed range           Pittsburgh and
BTs) switching at a frequency of 8      and a maximum mechanical over-            runs his own
kHz, and are designed to withstand      speed of 12,000 rpm. The stator           independent
                                        and rotor laminations were manu-          electric-power
typical engine bay conditions.
                                                                                  consultancy
    The inverter is designed to         factured of high-frequency grade,
                                                                                  which specialises
deliver 300 hp continuously but it      low loss magnetic material, to            in the design of
is able to deliver more than twice      minimise the total iron losses from       specialty motors/generators and
the rated power for short bursts. In    both hysteresis and eddy currents         special instrumentation systems, as
the 2.5 vehicle, a 500kW inverter       at operating frequencies up to 360        well as providing forensic services
designed for a locomotive traction      Hz. The rotor cage construction is        for electrical equipment failure,
                                        of reinforced cast copper, which          accidents and injury investigations.
system was used.
                                                                                  NPMcQuin@iee.org
    The inverters were tuned to         minimises the rotor heating losses
obtain optimum performance and          and provides a stiff motor charac-
                                                                                  TONY DAVIS
efficiency from the motor under          teristic well suited to inverter drive    (EE74) lives in
peak output conditions. They are        applications.                             Fort Myers and
configured in a torque-control               To minimise the total weight          is the director of
mode with motor currents regu-          of the drive motor, an aluminium          engineering at
lated by closed-loop flux-vector con-    housing was used. Based on previ-         Saminco Traction
                                        ous vehicle experience, bearings,         Drives and also
trol. A torque reference is derived
                                                                                  American Traction
from the driver’s accelerator pedal     shaft seals and terminal box con-
                                                                                  Systems. Both
that provides an analog signal to       figurations were selected for the          companies specialise in the design
the inverter. A gain adjustment and     necessary power rating and operat-        and manufacture of drive systems
also a rate-of-change limitation are    ing speeds. In view of the harsh salt     and motor management controls
applied for the purpose of control-     environment and the limited duty          for industrial haulage and transport
ling the maximum acceleration and       cycle of operation, a detailed ther-      applications.
                                        mal study determined that the de-         Tdavis@samincoinc.com
jerk rate. This limits tyre slip and

IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012                                                                                                   11
FEATURES

                   Steve King outlines two different ways to approach a contract,
 following the article about London Underground contracts in the last edition of Imperial Engineer

An appropriate process?
THE NEED to achieve more for each              contractor has to consider the risk that       local judgement, so more experienced
pound of public money spent is a               the design is to obsolete codes of prac-       staff will be needed.This approach
continual theme of politicians, even in        tice, or cannot be built because of other      presumes that it will be possible for
the best of times. During the last four        changes made in the intervening years.         experienced, specialist staff to save
years it has been the theme of endless             This, combined with the use of the         the project more than their additional
speeches and policy initiatives.               New Engineering Contract (NEC) and             remuneration costs.
    Railway expenditure has been in            around 80 pages of amendments, is in-              I favour the second approach and
the order of £8bn per annum since              tended to give LU certainty of outturn cost.   feel we need to speak up about the
2006 (Source – HMT PSEA). It is seen               Projects are managed to a single           value of knowledge and judgement in
as a suitable way to balance out the           centralised model which must cater for         delivering projects on time, to quality
economy as a high proportion of the            project values from just a few thousand        and at a good price.
money spent is in the form of wages.           pounds right up to the £400m+ Crossrail
    To obtain better value from infra-         and Victoria Station contracts.                High initial cost, low outturn?
structure construction, the client, con-                                                      The use of single point responsibility
sultant and contractor costs all need          Network Rail                                   and NEC contracts gives greater surety
to be considered. All client bodies            Network Rail (NR) are looking at a             of outturn cost. Contractors often do not
are looking at this, but there are some        completely different model. The whole          even cover the costs of a variation (com-
distinctly different approaches being          business structure is being rethought,         pensation event – CE), as the process is
considered. London Underground and             and power is being devolved to the             long-winded and costs of preparing the
Network Rail illustrate two of the dif-        regions and aligned with train lines. As       CE are often not recovered. This helps
ferent approaches                              Network Rail does not run trains, they         the client, particularly on refurbishment
    .                                          are also aligning themselves with the          contracts where there can be many low
London Underground                             Train Operating Companies (TOCs).              value CEs.
London Underground (LU) have adopted                They will also be going to the market         The negative aspects of this ap-
a very strict set of procedures. Contrac-      at an earlier stage, with contractors and      proach are that it locks in high delivery
tors are expected to take single-point         consultants involved in the development        cost from day one. Contractors know
responsibility for all matters that might      of options.                                    that they will have to put large numbers
affect the works – including, potentially,          NR use a wider range of contracts         of people on the project to manage the
when things are known to LU but not dis-       than LU. They also have more tailoring         reporting and deal with the CE process.
closed at tender stage. All risk is supposed   of the project management model to suit        This leads to higher preliminaries. Pre-
to be included in the tender, although         the project size.                              liminaries are the costs that are incurred
contractors will be forced by competition           Each approach has some positives          in delivering the project. On a typical
to take a highly optimistic view.              and negatives.The LU approach helps            £0.5m project with no direct impact on
     Contractors are expected to adopt         to keep down the client costs. One             the railway itself, I would expect prelimi-
as their own designs prepared directly         standard set of processes means staff are      naries of 30%+ on an LU project using
for LU by consultants.These designs may        following uniform rules. Fewer staff are
                                                                                                        (continued opposite)
have been prepared years before, so the        needed, and they do not need to be as
                                               experienced, or even have a construc-
                                               tion background.
                                                    The NR approach requires more

12                                                                                                  IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012
FEATURES

HIS ROYAL Highness,The Duke of
Edinburgh was delighted when he was
presented with a handmade display
                                                Duke retires from
cabinet on December 14 at Buckingham
Palace to mark his nearly 60 years as
president of City & Guilds. He retired on
                                              leading City & Guilds
his 90th birthday last June.The cabinet
was made by bespoke fine furniture-
maker, Nick Gutfreund. Nick was
highly-commended in the 2010 Prince
Philip Medal awards.
    Making the presentation was C&G
chairman (since 2006) Michael Howell
and Morton Neal (Civil 53, chairman
1979-91).
    Prince Philip is using the cabinet to
display the personal regalia of his par-
ents, Prince Andrew of Greece and Den-
mark and Princess Alice of Battenberg,
side by side.‘We are touched that he has      50 years as president. It is presented to
chosen such personal memorabilia to be        the lecturer or trainer of City & Guilds
displayed,’ said Michael Howell.              qualifications who has obtained the over-
    Prince Philip made an enormous            all highest marks based on the evidence
contribution to City & Guilds over the        supporting his or her City & Guilds
years, including establishing The Prince      ‘Medal for Excellence’ nomination.
Philip Medal in 1962. This honours                 The Prince also used to present priz-
those who started at the bottom of the        es to some City & Guilds learners who         FROM LEFT: Michael Howell, Nick
career ladder and have reached highly         were notable for the success they had in      Gutfreund, Morton Neal and Prince
responsible management positions. Win-        their qualifications and, in 1995 opened      Philip. Inset, Nick with the cabinet.
ners hold senior appointments in a wide       C&G’s headquarters at 1 Giltspur Street.      on the site of Imperial’s current main
variety of industries, public services and
                                                                                            entrance and business school. In 1907,
academic organisations and have one
thing in common – they ‘ve all been
                                              Historical note                               it became part of the new Imperial
                                              Imperial maintains close links with           College and was re-named the City &
helped on their way by City & Guilds
                                              the City & Guilds of London Institute,        Guilds (Constituent) College.
certificates.
    The President’s Award was first           which in 1885 opened its ‘Central                 Princess Anne has replaced her
presented in 2003 to mark the Prince’s        Institution’ for technical education          father as president.

            (from opposite)                        Network Rail is championing part-        on the pros and cons of the different
                                              nerships, although the emphasis seems         approaches. As they are so polarised,
NEC and 18% on a Network Rail project         to have shifted from the larger scale         it will be interesting to watch the
on a JCT or similar contract.                 frameworks to more modest or shorter          industry develop over the next couple
    Is the additional 12% in initial cost     term partnerships.                            of years. No doubt each will claim that
worth it for the greater outturn cost             Does best value come from being           their approach is more successful, and
certainty?                                    very cautious, or more open? As a cli-        a careful sifting of the evidence will be
                                              ent, you can assume that your suppliers       needed.
Local processes                               are out to take advantage of you. You
The Network Rail model allows a degree        can take steps to protect yourself, and
of flexibility in developing local proc-      potentially spend quite a bit of money        STEVE KING (Civils 90) worked on
esses. The LU model is strongly against it.   on that protection. You can deal firmly       projects from power stations to
     However, too strong a drive to cen-      with any claims and drag out payment          grade1-listed buildings after College.
tralise the management of the project         to the last possible time.                    He then concentrated on estimating,
delivery can lead to an excess of local           A more open approach does bring           value engineering and bid manage-
arrangements to work around bottle-                                                         ment for contractors, as head of
                                              the risk of a contractor trying to take ad-
                                                                                            department. Over the last six years
necks in the system. This will lead to        vantage or failing to perform in some way.
                                                                                            he’s spent much of his time as con-
additional cost as the effort is dupli-           However, despite that risk, the                        tractor’s engineering
cated. It may also lead to errors if the      industry needs experienced contractors                     manager and design
information is not correctly merged           who know how to deliver projects well                      manager for railway
afterwards.                                   and at a good price. Yes, the contractor                   projects for Network
                                              does want to make money, but if they                       Rail and London Un-
Enemy or friend?                              are delivering good value, should they                     derground.
As noted above, London Underground            be treated with suspicion for doing so?                    SKing2@amco.co.uk
use an amended form of the NEC.                   Clearly much more could be said

IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012                                                                                                     13
FEATURES
                                           Andrew Cheatle (Geol 83), president and CEO of Toronto-based Unigold In

       Finding Caribbean gold in the 21s

Exploration in the Dominican Republic.

THE CARIBBEAN, famed for its sun-          7 million metric tonnes (Mt) copper,     between 1975 and 1996 and contains
soaked islands, exotic flora and palm       1Mt lead, 3Mt zinc, 14Mt nickel,         an additional 35Moz of refractory
tree-fringed bays and white sand           1Mt cobalt, 2Mt chromium, 3.5Mt          mineralisation at a one gram per
beaches, is re-awaking as a significant     manganese, and 706Mt aluminium.          metric tonne (g/t) gold cutoff grade.
gold producing region.                         It is the re-emergence of gold       From 2013 onwards the mine is
    Gold exploration in the region is      mining, at the world-class Barrick       planned to produce over a million
accelerating as the islands’ treasures     Gold/Goldcorp’s Pueblo Viejo mine        ounces of gold a year, making it one
take on a new promise. But these           in the Dominican Republic, that has      of the largest gold producers in the
are not the treasures of the Pirates       spawned recent interest and activity     western hemisphere.
of the Caribbean fame, but those of        in the broader region. The former            The Caribbean hosts some of the
modern-day miners and those found          mine produced 5.3Moz of gold and         world’s most important deposits of
by exploration geologists.                 24.4Moz of silver from oxide ore         bauxite and lateritic nickel, as well as
    The long history in the region
captures the true romance of                                                                             The Dominican
discovering the unknown. When                                                                            Republic shown
Christopher Columbus fortuitously                                                                        by 50,000 soil
discovered the Caribbean islands,                                                                        samples
Europe was alerted to the potential of
the Americas as a whole.
    Gold was, indeed, found on
Hispaniola soon after its discovery and
briefly extracted from primitive mines.
    Since that time, estimates of gold
endowment (past production plus
known resources) of the Caribbean’s
Greater Antilles totals 36 million
ounces (Moz) gold. Other mineral
wealth (extracted ore) in known
resources is estimated as 277Moz silver,

14                                                                                IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012
FEATURES
d Inc                                            sedimentary rocks and all are              Corporate social
                                                 intruded by andesitic sills.               responsibility

1st century                                          These rocks, and their andesitic
                                                 basement, were overthrust by high-
                                                 magnesium basalts, related terrestrial
                                                                                            Excellent geology or ‘street address’
                                                                                            is only part of a modern successful
                                                                                            exploration play. In today’s world of
                                                 sediments and ophiolitic rocks. They       instant communication, texting, cell
                                                 were deformed several times to             phones, Facebook and environmen-
                                                 create complex fault patterns and          tal monitoring it is also important to
                                                 three different sets of folds. The two     have the ‘social license to operate.’
                                                 older sets of folds are recumbent to       Sincere corporate social responsibil-
                                                 isoclinal and are crudely coaxial with     ity (CSR) is a key component of a
                                                 W-NW trends. The third set of folds        geologist’s work.
                                                 are broad open folds of northerly              In many respects the exploration
                                                 trend, which provide down-plunge           geologist is the first contact that
                                                 views through the older folds and          a community will have with a
                                                 thrust faults. Economic values of gold     corporate entity. Being a good
                                                 mineralization at the property occur       corporate citizen, especially in areas
                                                 within the dacitic breccias.               where unemployment is high and
                                                     Exploration in this region is,         infrastructure is less well-developed,
                                                 therefore, focused within the 75km-        is as much a state of mind and
                                                 wide Cretaceous-age tireo-formation        philosophy as it is action. For example,
                                                 volcano sedimentary rocks which            Unigold owns its own drilling rigs and
                                                 host the world-class Pueblo Viejo gold     has trained a large number of local
                                                 deposit.                                   people to operate them.
                                                     Gold exploration today is                  Unigold prefers to employ staff
                                                 sophisticated and a highly-technical       from the local community and keep
                                                 profession. The rich, gold-bearing,        them on its own payroll. Over 100
                                                 Cretaceous-age volcanic belt, which        locals are currently employed, ranging
                                                 extends in a band across the island, is    from drilling and soil sampling
                                                 giving rise to some exciting new gold      technicians through to mechanics
                                                 discoveries.                               and electricians and from IT experts
                                                     Unigold’s announcement on              and security guards through to
                                                 January 16 sent share prices surging.      cooks and financial administrators.
        aforementioned significant resources      That week was perhaps the busiest of       Consequently, Unigold is now the
        of gold and silver, copper, zinc,        my life!                                   major employer. Involvement in the
        manganese, cobalt and chromium. A            Unigold’s concessions extend           local communities runs deeper too.
        brief understanding of the geological    over four contiguous properties in             At Christmas, for example, over
        evolution, as understood for the         western Dominican Republic, close to       400 food hampers are donated to
        island of Hispaniola helps us to         the border with Haiti.                     families, especially those with young
        understand how this happened.                Over the past 10 years, the company    children. In addition Unigold is always
                                                 has completed a comprehensive              willing to lend a hand in odd jobs
        Geological setting                       geological survey across the properties,   that it has the equipment and skills
        The Dominican Republic, part of the      taking and analysing over 50,000 soil      to perform, such as local road repairs
        island of Hispaniola where Columbus      samples for gold, silver and multiple      or facilitating water pipe installation
        set up his first headquarters, has a      elements as either pathfinders or           from the village well to the school.
        promising geology. Gold mineralisa-      to define underlying geological             This relationship takes time, effort and
        tion is located within the Central       formations. We have also performed         sincerity. It is one of ongoing trust and
        Cordillera of Hispaniola. In the most    a range of induced polarisation            support and flows in both directions.
        general sense, the rocks of Hispaniola   geophysical and magnetic surveys. By       Over 95 percent of the local
        represent Cretaceous arc complexes       analysing this rich data, Unigold has      landowners have signed agreements
        that migrated eastward, along with an    been able to establish a pipeline of       to allow the company access their land
        oceanic plateau, from the Pacific to      targets for future exploration.            for exploration purposes.
        the Atlantic ocean. Here they collided
        with the southern margin of North        ANDREW CHEATLE (Geology 85) is president and CEO
        America. The geology of the island       of Unigold Inc and Councilor at Large for the Association
        reflects this complex history.            of Professional Geoscientists of Ontario (APGO), Canada.
            Locally gold mineralisation varies   His career spans 27 years and has focused on gold mining
        with local geology, for example at       and exploration in Africa, Australia, Canada and, most
        Unigold’s Neita property in western      recently, in the Caribbean. In his role with the APGO, he is
                                                 a regular speaker on geology and ethics in seminar series to
        Dominican Republic. Diffusely-
                                                 undergraduates. Andrew lives in Thunder Bay and Toronto,
        bedded dacitic tuff and hyaloclastite    Canada. (www.unigoldinc.com and www.apgo.net).
        breccia are intercalated with marine

              IMPERIAL ENGINEER Spring 2012                                                                                       15
You can also read