COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...

Page created by Melvin Diaz
 
CONTINUE READING
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
P U B L I S H E D BY T H E A M E R I CA N F O R E I G N S E R V I C E A S S O C I AT I O N   OCTOBER 2018

                     COMBATING
                 TRANSNATIONAL CRIME
                                     CONFESSIONS OF
                                     A RECENT RETIREE

               JESSICA’S JOURNEYS
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
FOREIGN
                                                             SERVICE                                                     October 2018 Volume 95, No. 8

                                                     Focus on
                                           Combating Transnational Crime
                                                                                                                          FS Know-How
                                                22                                            33
                                Illicit Trade and                                     Khetha:
                              Our Global Response                               Bringing “Choices”
                      Illegal trade is a growing threat
                     to the community of nations, the
                                                                                 to Help Address                                    39
                                                                                Wildlife Trafficking                     10 Things I Wish
                       world’s population and earth’s
                       environment. Recognition that
                                                                               An innovative USAID-supported              I Had Known:
                                                                                program invites communities              Confessions of a
                    criminals don’t stovepipe is the key                           around protected areas
                          to an effective response.                                 to play a critical role.              Recent Retiree
                                     By Louise Shelley                                                                     By Dolores Brown
                                                                                         By Lara Rall

                                                26                                            35
                                The “Place-Based                              Wildlife Trafficking Is a
                             Strategy” in Honduras                            National Security Issue
       Transnational crime syndicates have
                                                                               By Re p. Ed Royce ( R - C a l i f. )
          exacerbated illegal immigration
        problems at our southern border. A
       State initiative aims at undercutting
         the migration push at the source.
                                        By Jim Nealon

                                                29
                        The FRONT-Line
                      Initiative: Combating
                     Transnational Criminal
                          Organizations
                              Transnational street gangs are a
                             growing problem for communities
                                and law enforcement across
                                     the United States.
                                State’s Bureau of Diplomatic
                               Security is part of the solution.
                             B y C h r i s t o p h e r “ K a i ” Fo r n e s
                                                                                                                               Feature

                                                                                                                                    41
                                                                                                                       Jessica’s Journeys
                                                                                                                       Not just tales of many travels
                                                                                                                      during a too-short life, they are
                                                                                                                      the story of an FS community
   ISTOCKPHOTO.COM/BYRDYAK

                                                                                                                        that supported Jessica—
                                                                                                                            and supports us all.
                                                                                                                           By Leslie Bassett

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | OCTOBER 2018                                                                                                                5
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
FOREIGN
                                               SERVICE

         Perspectives                                           76
                                                         Reflections                          Departments
                   7                          Playing Squash with Arlen Specter
          President’s Views                             By Alexis Ludwig                      10 Letters
            Taking Stock
       By Barbara Stephenson                                                                  12 Letters-Plus

                                                                                              14 Talking Points
                   9
       Letter from the Editor                                                                 59 In Memory
         Borderless Crime
                                                                                              68 Books
          By Shawn Dorman

                 46
      Family Member Matters                                     78                            Marketplace
       Making It in Mongolia                               Local Lens
    By Nicole Schaefer-McDaniel                            Say, Niger                         70 Classifieds
                                                       By Gemma Dvorak
                                                                                              72 Real Estate

                                                                                              75 Index to Advertisers

    AFSA NEWS                          THE OFFICIAL RECORD OF THE AMERICAN FOREIGN SERVICE ASSOCIATION

    47	
       USDC and AFSA Join Forces for
        Remembrance of 1998 East Africa
                                                           47
        Embassy Bombings
    48 Diplomacy Through Music
    49	
       AFSA Welcomes Newest
        Foreign Service Members
    49 Announcing the 2018 AFSA Award Winners
    50	
       State VP Voice—We Work Hard for the
        Money
    51	
       USAID VP Voice—FSOs Need to Support
        Diversity and Inclusion
    51 AFSA Governing Board Meeting, August 16                     55	
                                                                      Summer and Fall Outreach:
    52 FAS VP Voice—Mission (Almost) Impossible                          Baseball and California Visit

    52 Appreciation: Willard Ames “Bill” De Pree                   57 Inside the World of Diplomacy
    53 Where We Stand—Rebuilding Our Economic Strength             58	
                                                                      AFSA Honors National High School
                                                                        Essay Contest Winner
    54	
       Retiree Corner—Life After the Foreign Service:
        Jim Bullington                                             58 Coordination of FEHB and Medicare
    54 AFSA President in Williamsburg
On the Cover—Today crime knows no borders. Photo: iStockphoto.com/scyther5. Below: The sundial dedicated to Jessica El Bechir in
Embassy Rangoon’s garden. Photo: Hannah Dufford.

6                                                                                                 OCTOBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
PRESIDENT’S VIEWS

Taking Stock
BY BA R BA R A ST E P H E N S O N

A
             t this time of year—summer
                                                             I thank AFSA’s members for taking
             transfer cycle wrapping up,
             new school year beginning,
                                                               us to a recent critical milestone:
             Jewish New Year approach-                    an all-time record high for membership.
ing—I spend time reflecting and taking
stock, looking back at the previous year to       than it was in April 2017, when AFSA set its         How did we generate the support that
prepare to make the most of the next one.         previous membership record.                      made renewal and rebuilding possible? In
    The next one will be a big year for me—           Former Secretary of State Rex Tillerson      our ongoing effort to help fellow Ameri-
my last year as AFSA president. When my           told the Senate Foreign Relations Com-           cans understand what we do and why it
second term ends July 15, 2019, I will pass       mittee in June 2017 that he planned to cut       matters, we have made real progress.
the baton to a new president and Govern-          the Foreign Service at State by 4 percent. A         Please take a moment to read the
ing Board elected in the spring by you, the       year later, that stated goal had largely been    AFSA News section, including the report
members of AFSA.                                  reached—with the number of Foreign Ser-          on AFSA at the Chautauqua Institution.
    What do I hope to pass on to that new         vice officers and specialists at State down      When the Foreign Service is invited to
president and Governing Board? For start-         by well over 3 percent.                          occupy such a prime speaking slot—
ers, a strong American Foreign Service                In taking stock, the loss of Foreign         which has welcomed Supreme Court
Association—one with good governance,             Service talent is hardest to accept. But we      Justices and former U.S. presidents—that
sound finances and an unprecedented               now see signs of rebuilding, of restoring        is a watershed moment.
base of support from members. While it            the strength of the Foreign Service. Con-            At that one event, we were able to share
is too early to declare victory and rest on       gress not only fully restored funding but        with more than 3,500 fellow Americans
our laurels, I thank AFSA’s members for           gave clear direction to resume hiring, and       what diplomats do and why it matters.
taking us to a recent critical milestone: an      that is cause for celebration.                   Thousands more viewed the event online.
all-time record high for membership.                  We celebrate every time we can wel-          We are reaching more people in more
    The one metric I present at each AFSA         come a new class for lunch at AFSA head-         ways than ever before.
Governing Board is a membership snap-             quarters, as we did three times in August:           This year we can take pride in AFSA’s
shot. I do that because nothing indicates         the “Resurgent 194th” A-100 class; an FS         success making the connection between
the health of our organization as clearly as      specialist class; and a Consular Fellows         our work—the enduring platforms we
that single metric. And I do that because it      class. And we look forward to welcoming          build and operate around the globe—and
helps remind all of us at AFSA that we are        additional classes—including another             U.S. global leadership, which is, I remind
ultimately—and directly—accountable to            large A-100 class and a USAID class—in           you, supported by well over 90 percent of
you, the members.                                 the weeks ahead.                                 Americans.
                              This mile-              Many of us remember what a disaster              It is easy to be distracted by what
                          stone—record-high       it was to slash new-entry hiring during          divides us as Americans. I encourage all
                          AFSA member-            the 1990s. We can now register relief and        of us, as we prepare to make the most of
                          ship—is all the         gratitude that the recent hiring freeze has      the year ahead, to build on what unites
                          more remarkable         been lifted and we are bringing in the new       us. And maintaining America’s global
                          given that the          members of the Foreign Service who will          leadership—for which we in the Foreign
                          Foreign Service as      sustain our country’s global leadership in       Service bear such central responsibil-
                          a whole is smaller      the decades to come.                             ity—unites us. n

                          Ambassador Barbara Stephenson is the president of the American Foreign Service Association.

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | OCTOBER 2018                                                                                                   7
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
FOREIGN

                                                              CONTACTS
             SERVICE

                                                                                          www.afsa.org
Editor in Chief, Director of Publications
Shawn Dorman: dorman@afsa.org
Managing Editor
Susan Brady Maitra: maitra@afsa.org
Associate Editor
Donna Gorman: gorman@afsa.org                                  AFSA Headquarters:                               ADVOCACY
Publications Coordinator                                         (202) 338-4045; Fax (202) 338-6820             Director of Advocacy
Dmitry Filipoff: filipoff@afsa.org                             State Department AFSA Office:                       Kim Greenplate: greenplate@afsa.org
                                                                 (202) 647-8160; Fax (202) 647-0265             Legislative Fellow
Advertising Manager
                                                               USAID AFSA Office:                                  Drew Donaher: donaher@afsa.org
Allan Saunders: saunders@afsa.org
                                                                 (202) 712-1941; Fax (202) 216-3710
Art Director                                                   FCS AFSA Office:                                 BUSINESS DEPARTMENT
Caryn Suko Smith                                                 (202) 482-9088; Fax (202) 482-9087             Director of Finance and Facilities
                                                                                                                   Femi Oshobukola: oshobukola@afsa.org
Editorial Board                                                GOVERNING BOARD                                  Controller
Alexis Ludwig, Chair                                           President                                           Kalpna Srimal: srimal@afsa.org
James “Jim” Bever                                               Hon. Barbara Stephenson:                        Controller, Accounts Payable and
Fred Boll
                                                                stephenson@afsa.org                                Administration
Angela Bond
                                                               Secretary                                           Cory Nishi: cnishi@afsa.org
M. Allyn Brooks-LaSure
Karen Brown Cleveland                                           Hon. Tom Boyatt: tdboyatt@gmail.com             Administrative Assistant and Office Manager
Shawn Kobb                                                     Treasurer                                           Ana Lopez: lopez@afsa.org
Harry Kopp                                                      Hon. Earl Anthony “Tony” Wayne:                 Scholarships and Events Coordinator
John G. Rendeiro Jr.                                              WayneEA@gmail.com                                Theo Horn: horn@afsa.org
Priyadarshi “Pri” Sen                                          State Vice President
Dinah Zeltser-Winant                                            Ken Kero-Mentz: keromentzka@state.gov           COMMUNICATIONS AND MEMBERSHIP
                                                               USAID Vice President                             Director of Communications and Membership
                                                                Jeff Levine: jlevine@usaid.gov                     Ásgeir Sigfússon: sigfusson@afsa.org
THE MAGAZINE FOR FOREIGN AFFAIRS
                                                               FCS Vice President                               Online Communications Manager
PROFESSIONALS
The Foreign Service Journal (ISSN 0146-3543),                   Daniel Crocker: Daniel.Crocker@trade.gov           Jeff Lau: lau@afsa.org
2101 E Street NW, Washington, D.C. 20037-2990 is               FAS Vice President                               Communications and Marketing Manager
published monthly, with combined January-February               Kimberly Svec Sawatzki: kim.sawatzki@usda.gov      Allan Saunders: saunders@afsa.org
and July-August issues, by the American Foreign Service
                                                               Retiree Vice President                           Awards Coordinator
Association (AFSA), a private, nonprofit organization.
Material appearing herein represents the opinions of the        John K. Naland: nalandfamily@yahoo.com             Perri Green: green@afsa.org
writers and does not necessarily represent the views of        State Representatives                            Manager, Retiree Outreach and Engagement
the Journal, the Editorial Board or AFSA. Writer queries        Karen Brown Cleveland
and submissions are invited, preferably by email. The
                                                                                                                   Christine Miele: miele@afsa.org
Journal is not responsible for unsolicited manuscripts,         Don Jacobson                                    Retirement Benefits Counselor
photos or illustrations. Advertising inquiries are invited.     Deborah Mennuti                                    Dolores Brown: brown@afsa.org
All advertising is subject to the publisher’s approval.         Roy Perrin                                      Member Accounts Specialist
AFSA reserves the right to reject advertising that is not
                                                                Lilly Wahl-Tuco                                    Ashley Dunn: dunn@afsa.org
in keeping with its standards and objectives. The appear-
ance of advertisements herein does not imply endorse-          USAID Representative
ment of goods or services offered. Opinions expressed in        William Hansen                                  LABOR MANAGEMENT
advertisements are the views of the advertisers and do         FCS Alternate Representative
not necessarily represent AFSA views or policy. Journal
                                                                                                                General Counsel
subscription: AFSA member–$20, included in annual               Lola Gulomova                                     Sharon Papp: PappS@state.gov
dues; student–$30; institution–$40; others–$50; Single         FAS Alternate Representative                     Deputy General Counsel
issue–$4.50. For foreign surface mail, add $18 per year;        Thom Wright                                       Raeka Safai: SafaiR@state.gov
foreign airmail, $36 per year. Periodical postage paid
                                                               BBG Representative                               Senior Staff Attorneys
at Washington, D.C., and at additional mailing offices.
Indexed by the Public Affairs Information Services (PAIS).       Steve Herman                                     Zlatana Badrich: BadrichZ@state.gov
                                                               APHIS Representative                               Neera Parikh: ParikhNA@state.gov
Email: journal@afsa.org                                         Jeffery Austin                                  Labor Management Counselor
Phone: (202) 338-4045                                          Retiree Representatives                            Colleen Fallon-Lenaghan:
Fax: (202) 338-8244                                             Hon. Alphonse ‘Al’ La Porta                       FallonLenaghanC@state.gov
Web: www.afsa.org/fsj                                           Philip A. Shull                                 Senior Labor Management Advisor
© American Foreign Service Association, 2018                                                                      James Yorke: YorkeJ@state.gov
                                                               STAFF                                            Labor Management Coordinator
PRINTED IN THE U.S.A.
                                                               Chief Operating Officer                            Patrick Bradley: BradleyPG@state.gov
Postmaster: Send address changes to                               Russ Capps: capps@afsa.org                    Grievance Counselors
AFSA, Attn: Address Change                                     Chief of Strategic Initiatives                     Ayumi Hasegawa: HasegawaA@state.gov
2101 E Street NW                                                  Linnea Gavrilis: gavrilis@afsa.org
Washington DC 20037-2990                                                                                          Heather Townsend: TownsendHA@state.gov
                                                               Executive Assistant to the President             Labor Management Advisor
                                                                  Jennie Orloff: orloff@afsa.org                  Michael R. Wallace: WallaceMR2@state.gov
                                                               Office Coordinator                               Law Clerk
                                                                  Therese Thomas: therese@afsa.org                Benjamin Phillips: PhillipsBE@state.gov
                                                               Staff Assistant
                                                                  Allysa Reimer: reimer@afsa.org                PROFESSIONAL POLICY ISSUES
                                                                                                                Director of Professional Policy Issues
                                                                                                                   Julie Nutter: nutter@afsa.org

8                                                                                                                      OCTOBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
LETTER FROM THE EDITOR

Borderless Crime
B Y S H AW N D O R M A N

I
   llicit trade, human trafficking, wildlife          DS Special Agent Kai Fornes
   trafficking, drugs and arms trade,             describes how an enhanced criminal
   cyber crime, piracy, counterfeiting,           gang vetting program helps block legal
   money laundering—these illegal                 travel to the United States by gang
transnational activities do not stop at           members from the Northern Triangle of
borders.                                          El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras.
     They grow in scope and impact as the             Turning to wildlife trafficking, Lara
world gets smaller, as globalization cre-         Rall of World Wide Fund for Nature–
ates a world where crime can no longer            South Africa offers a look at this
be stopped by border posts, ports and             complex problem and how the USAID-
checkpoints. Transnational crime today            supported Khetha program is tackling
is more sophisticated and more danger-            it. We also hear from Representative Ed
ous and so much of it is virtual, hidden in       Royce (R-Calif.), sponsor of the END
dark ungovernable corners of the web.             Wildlife Trafficking Act, on the national
     Wherever it originates, the impact           security implications of this problem.
of transnational crime is felt at home                In FS Know-How, Dolores Brown
in the United States. The U.S. Foreign            shares “10 Things I Wish I’d Known:
Service is and must be at work doing              Confessions of a Recent Retiree.” This is
battle against transnational crime, from          news you can use.
Washington and from U.S. missions                     Elsewhere, Ambassador (ret.) Leslie
around the world.                                 Bassett tells the story of the tragic death
     This is our focus for October. Profes-       of beloved FSO Jessica el Bechir, and
sor Louise Shelley offers the 30,000-foot         how in the aftermath, in grief and trib-
view in “Illicit Trade and Our Global             ute, the FS community came together
Response,” arguing that U.S. efforts must         as family.
be broad and cross-cutting, requiring                 FS family member Nicole Schaefer-
cooperation across borders, expertise             McDaniel reflects on “Making It in
and specializations.                              Mongolia” for the Family Member Mat-
     Jim Nealon describes his work on             ters column.
the “Place-Based Strategy” in Hondu-                  And FSO Alexis Ludwig takes on
ras, where he served as ambassador                Arlen Specter on the squash court at
from 2014 to 2017. This initiative, which         Embassy Guatemala City circa 1996.
helped to reduce the homicide rate in             Our parting shot this month is from
                     three pilot communi-         Niger.
                     ties, shows how going            Please be in touch. Send your letters,
                     to the local source of       Speaking Outs, articles and story ideas
                     a problem can help           over to journal@afsa.org. n
                     mitigate the pull of
                     illegal migration.

                      Shawn Dorman is the editor of The Foreign Service Journal.

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | OCTOBER 2018                                                      9
COMBATING TRANSNATIONAL CRIME CONFESSIONS OF A RECENT RETIREE - JESSICA'S JOURNEYS - American Foreign ...
LETTERS

Civil Society                                                    The full report can be       The second intervention option
Credibility Gap                                               viewed at: www.gao.gov/     could come through AFSA’s Consulta-
    How ironic that the authors                              assets/700/692560.pdf.       tion Rights and Request for Information
of “Supporting Civil Society                                    While AFSA’s push for     Privileges. In both these instances, “As
in the Face of Closing Space”                              added State funding may        the exclusive employee representative,
(May FSJ) referenced a                                     be commendable, experi-        AFSA may request information from
CIVICUS report that identi-                               ence has shown that the         agencies which is necessary for full and
fies 13 countries as having                              case must first demonstrate      proper understanding of subjects within
fully open civic space—but                              that the existing funding is      the scope of collective bargaining.”
did not identify those countries or                    being both effectively and effi-       The time is past for AFSA to be sitting
note that the United States is not one     ciently utilized. The long-outstanding         on the sidelines. It should promptly
of them. While they prescribed ways        GAO findings and recommendations               fulfill its fiduciary responsibilities by
to open civic space, their own country     suggest otherwise.                             actively raising these DS shortcomings
shamefully is closing it.                      Since the department accepted              with the department and demonstrate
    Why would we be surprised that         the findings and recommendations               to all, including Congress, that the
other countries look askance when poli-    for implementation, an earlier AFSA            requests for added department funding
cies the United States promotes abroad     delegation that met with senior DS staff       are truly justified.
are not being exercised at home? I’m       was surprised to hear them deny that               James (Jim) Meenan
disappointed that the FSJ’s editors did    the GAO findings existed and show no               FSO, retired
not challenge such blatant hypocrisy.      interest in acting on the recommenda-              Ashburn, Virginia
    Rex Moser                              tions.
    FSO, retired                               In December 2014, an AFSA update           The Passing of
    Santa Barbara, California              cable reported: “Most strikingly, six          Donna Hartman
                                           out of seven survey respondents noted             I read with regret of the passing of
Shortcomings in                            that it is important for AFSA to be at         Donna Hartman, widow of Ambassador
DS Remain                                  the table when the department makes            Arthur Hartman, who served with her
   On June 15, the Government              decisions that impact employee security        husband at Embassy Moscow from 1981
Accountability Office reported thus: “At   or exposure to risk.” Unfortunately, that      to 1987 (In Memory, July-August FSJ).
the request of Congress, GAO reviewed      has not taken place.                           Ambassador Hartman passed away in
the status of all open recommendations         AFSA has among its “Labor Manage-          2015.
we made to the Department of State …       ment Responsibilities” (for details visit         While Ambassador Hartman’s
in 2015 and 2016. During that period,      www.afsa.org/afsa_labor_management_            brilliant service in Moscow has been
we made 132 recommendations to State       responsibilities.aspx) at least two            well-documented, Donna Hartman’s
and USAID. As of June 7, 2018, of the      significant options to follow in formally      contributions were also remarkable. The
82 recommendations made to State, 37       raising the matter of diplomatic security      Hartmans’ long tenure in Moscow was
(about 45 percent) were still open, and    as it pertains to GAO findings and rec-        notable in many respects, including an
10 of those were priority recommenda-      ommendations.                                  intense focus on human rights.
tions.                                         The first and most important option           For many years the Hartmans hosted
   “Of particular concern are: GAO-15-     is to raise the GAO recommendations            an open house on Saturday afternoons.
700, Diplomatic Security: State Depart-    as a “Mandatory Bargaining Subject,”           The program often included the show-
ment Should Better Manage Risks to         which covers such items as “policies           ing of an American film in the ambas-
Residences and Other Soft Targets          related to the work environment.” Under        sador’s residence, the spacious Spaso
Overseas; and GAO-17-124, Diplomatic       this category, respective agencies must        House. The event drew dissidents,
Security: State Should Enhance Its         negotiate with AFSA, thus enabling the         artists and others.
Management of Transportation-Related       employee representative to fulfill its            Soviet personnel were often posi-
Risks to Overseas U.S. Personnel.”         fiduciary responsibilities.                    tioned outside Spaso House to intimi-

10                                                                                              OCTOBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
date those Soviet citizens attempting            I suspect I’m not the only reader
to enter. Several FSOs who worked on         to find that interpretation of events
human rights issues, often joined by         strange, on several levels.
other FSOs, would attempt to run inter-          Let’s start with the inconvenient
ference for Soviet friends trying to get     fact that Ambassador Huntsman is a
past the official harassment at the gate.    political appointee, not a career Foreign
    On one Saturday afternoon when           Service officer. Why Mr. Lawson finds
Ambassador Hartman was out of town           it courageous for a political appointee
the Soviet thug force was particularly       to defend the man who gave him his
aggressive. When Donna learned of the        job is baffling. (If I were going to praise
situation, she raced out of Spaso House      Mr. Huntsman for anything, it would be
and confronted the Soviet harassers                    bipartisanship: He previously
shouting “scandalous,                                   served as President Barack
scandalous!” in Russian.                                 Obama’s ambassador to
Her vociferous efforts                                   Beijing.)
caused the harassers to                                      We all support Amb.
back off in short order,                                  Huntsman’s desire to “focus
allowing the guests to enter.                              on the work that needs to
    On another occasion,                                    be done to stabilize the
shortly after the Hartmans                                   most dangerous relation-
arrived in Moscow, Donna                                     ship in the world, one that
brought an enormous bouquet                                   encompasses nuclear
of roses into the street, greeting             weapons, fighting terrorism, stopping
each passer-by and introducing herself       bloodshed in Ukraine and seeking a
as the wife of the new American ambas-       settlement of the seemingly intractable
sador. As she did so, she handed each        Syrian crisis.” But how did the Helsinki
a rose.                                      summit advance any of those objec-
    Donna was a class act, a friend to the   tives? If anything, it set them back.
common people and a special friend to            Nothing in Amb. Huntsman’s state-
artists and victims of the Soviet system.    ment indicates he has ever heard of our
Her human outreach touched many              institution’s long and honorable tradi-
hearts.                                      tion of dissent (which AFSA rightfully
    Edmund McWilliams                        continues to celebrate). In contrast, I’d
    FSO, retired                             be willing to bet Mr. Lawson is quite
    White Oaks, New Mexico                   familiar with it, but has no use for it
                                             when someone he likes occupies the
Defining “Foreign Service                    White House. n
Leadership” Downward                             Steven Alan Honley
    Writing in the September FSJ, Timo-          Former FSO
thy C. Lawson hails Jon M. Huntsman,             Washington, D.C.
President Donald Trump’s ambassador
to Russia, for boosting Foreign Service         Share your thoughts about
morale. And just how did Huntsman                  this month’s issue.
accomplish that remarkable feat? By stay-      Submit letters to the editor:
ing on the job after the July 16 Helsinki          journal@afsa.org
fiasco sparked calls for him to resign.

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | OCTOBER 2018                                                 11
LETTERS-PLUS

Response—
East Africa Embassy Bombings 20 Years Later

About Compensation                            I am struck by the common themes and

T
           hank you for the July-August FSJ
           highlights on remembering the
                                              emotions expressed by many survivors,
           1998 embassy bombings in East      and how they relate to my own.
           Africa, 20 years after.
    I just want to express my personal view
as one of the many survivors who were             Many times over the years I have            the small subsequent delay for the correct
not affected physically (bodily harm),        searched for first-person accounts by           breakfast probably saved our lives.
but went through a very trying moment         other people who were there on that                 We set off , heading to the ExTel
and later suffered emotional trauma. Our      dreadful day, in attempt to make sense of       Comms office, which was next door to
colleagues were affected differently—the      what happened and move on. I am struck          Cooperative House. We were planning on
healing process was very long, and some       by the common themes and emotions               phoning home to the U.K. and were late.
haven’t fully recovered yet, though the       expressed by many survivors, and how            I wanted to catch my mother who left for
majority have moved on through very           they relate to my own.                          work at about 8:45 a.m. (10:45 Kenyan
painful experience.                               Reading these accounts has helped to        time), and it was already 10:30.
    I want to raise the compensation issue.   somehow legitimize my own emotions. It              We hurried along Moi Avenue, and
I know it’s a very hot and difficult topic    happened so long ago, so far away from          were about to turn down a side road just
to discuss here, but I want to make a pas-    home and for many years felt unreal,            before the U.S. embassy that led past
sionate appeal to the private attorneys       almost made up. Thank you for asking me         Ufundi House to Cooperative House. We
to finalize all matters of compensation,      to submit my own story.                         then heard an almighty crack and stopped
so that this chapter can be closed (some          In the summer of 1998, I was 21 and         in our tracks, as did everyone else. There
people are still waiting for compensation).   had just finished pre-clinical medicine         was a banker’s strike on, and my immedi-
    I am aware that no amount of money        at the University of Cambridge. I was           ate thought was that it was a gunshot, and
can replace the loss of loved ones from       volunteering with the charity Link Africa,      there was a hold-up at the nearby bank.
America, Kenya, Tanzania and all              in a school in Mokomoni, a rural village            We later found out that this was a hand
locations in between.                         of the Kisii district in Western Kenya. My      grenade thrown at the embassy guard.
    From the heart, these are my personal     fellow project worker and friend, Alice,        Suddenly a man sprinted out of that side
thoughts and opinions. Thank you.             had a few days in Nairobi to purchase           road and ran toward us. He was run-
    Francis Ywaya                             some essential science equipment for the        ning for his life. I instinctively took cover
    FSN                                       secondary school in Mokomoni.                   behind a taller Kenyan who was wearing a
    USAID/Kenya & East Africa                     We were staying at a hotel in the River     black leather jacket.
    Nairobi, Kenya                            Road area. We were still students, and it           The fleeing man got to within a few
                                              was cheap. On the morning of Aug. 7, I          metres of us, and then the bomb was
The First Healing Step                        ordered poached eggs on toast for break-        detonated. Bizarrely, both Alice and I
    I was very grateful to stumble upon the   fast. Scrambled eggs arrived. I sent them       forgot about the existence of this man;
article “Reflections on the U.S. Embassy      back—I am usually fairly laid back about        only when he (terrorist Mohammed
Bombings in Kenya and Tanzania” (July-        these things, but after existing on a diet of   Al-Owhali) was captured and his face
August FSJ) for the recent 20th anniver-      mostly Ugali for months I really was very       was plastered over the Daily Nation did
sary of the tragedy.                          keen on those eggs. That decision, and          we remember those moments before the

12                                                                                                  OCTOBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
blast. I now understand that the erasure        and bandaged it up. They had seen it all        vigilant and have an astonishing startle
of key memories in trauma is common, as         before, they told us; they had lived in a       reaction.
some sort of protective mechanism.              war zone. Upstairs, we showered to get rid          As a doctor, I recognise that these
    The sound was so loud that it could         of the debris and dust. I paced the room        are symptoms of post-traumatic stress
be heard up to 10 kilometers away. But          for hours in a panic, not knowing quite         disorder (PTSD), but have so far failed to
despite being within 10 to 15 meters of the     what to do.                                     get help. I was working in London on the
truck bomb, I don’t remember the sound              I felt guilty for years that I didn’t go    day of the 7/7 Tube bombs and helped to
at all. I do remember a feeling of pres-        back to help, but in a medical sense I was      treat several victims, compounding the
sure and being knocked off my feet. The         too junior to be of any use. We were young      feeling that these events are more com-
air filled with thick smoke and dust. The       and terrified and all alone. Luckily we had     mon and that nowhere is safe.
pavement was covered in shattered glass         just enough money hidden in another bag             Despite this, I have been able to carve
and debris from the nearby buildings.           to escape on the night bus back to Kisii.       out a life full of meaning, with a happy
    I don’t know what happened to the           I didn’t sleep at all for several nights; the   family and many wonderful friends,
man in the leather jacket. I looked around      adrenaline was too overwhelming.                and have developed a strong sense of
and saw Alice lying on the ground. Her leg          We went back to our village for another     altruism. I strongly feel the only way to
was bleeding. I pulled                                                                                                overcome such sense-
her up by the hand, and                                                                                               less evil is to try and
we ran away from the                                                                                                  live your best life, and
blast area as fast as we                                                                                              build communities
could. We bumped into                                                                                                 with your actions.
a police officer, whom                                                                                                    I feel strong ties to
we quizzed about what                                                                                                 Kenya and my Kenyan
on earth had just hap-                                                                                                friends. I have visited
pened. Of course, he                                                                                                  many times in the
was just as confused                                                                                                  years following the
as we, and was looking                                                                                                bombings and hope to
back in the direction of                                                                                              take my children one
the embassy.                                                                                                          day soon.
    By this point there was a vast mush-        six weeks to finish the project. We moni-           Going forward, I am learning that hav-
room cloud of smoke reaching up to the          tored the news daily, and The Nation was        ing a mental illness is not a weakness that
sky. Matatus were being loaded up with          full of stories of people trapped for days,     needs to be hidden away. In fact, I believe
severely injured and maimed people to be        the ramifications of the blast and the sub-     it to be a sign of strength to acknowledge,
driven to the hospital.                         sequent allied attack on al-Qaida bases in      talk about and seek help for these feel-
    We ran all the way back to our hotel.       Sudan and Afghanistan.                          ings.
I was mugged on River Road by a petty               Nightmares started soon after—some-             More than 60 percent of people
thief—he stole my wallet with almost all        times replaying the events of Aug. 7,           exposed to mass violence develop
the schillings we had. We saw several           sometimes more generic threats to life. I       PTSD, and professional help is needed
other muggings happen in those short            always woke up in a panic, often leaping        to recover. It has been easier for me to
minutes. It was chaos on the streets sud-       out of bed or hitting out at my long-suf-       pretend that I am fine than to admit to
denly, and it felt strangely post-apocalyp-     fering husband.                                 my own doctor that I am struggling, but
tic, like the world was about to end.               Even now, I suffer with nightmares          that is about to change.
    For some, it had of course. We were         and insomnia. I still avoid central Lon-            Writing this down has been the first
very lucky, considering where we were           don, crowded events, and have had panic         part of that process. n
standing, to only have minor, flying glass-     attacks in places where I feel unsafe (e.g.,        Sarah McKelvie
related injuries. At the hotel, some friendly   the Underground, at a concert or visiting           Oxford, U.K.
Bosnians cleaned Alice’s leg with alcohol       overtly touristy venues). I am hyper-

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | OCTOBER 2018                                                                                                  13
TALKING POINTS
Cuba Illnesses                                    Smith, said in a recent interview that            where none exist. His discovery led the
Back in the News                                  microwaves are now considered a “main             Soviets, Americans and others to begin

D     octors continue to search for an
      explanation for the mysterious ill-
ness that has stricken diplomats in Cuba
                                                  suspect.”
                                                      A scientific paper published in Janu-
                                                  ary 2018 by James Lin of the University
                                                                                                    experimenting with using microwaves as
                                                                                                    weapons.
                                                                                                       When asked about the microwave
and China since late 2016. On Sept. 1             of Illinois first suggested that targeted         theory, a State Department official
The New York Times reported that the              microwave beams could have caused the             told ABC News: “The situation has not
cause may have been an unconventional             illnesses.                                        changed: There is no known source or
weapon using microwaves.                              The Times also interviewed retired            cause.”
    In a report published in The Journal          biologist Douglas Frey, who in 1960                  On Sept. 6, The Washington Post
of the American Medical Association last          identified a neural phenomenon                    wrote that microwaves likely weren’t the
March, the medical team did not men-              now called the “Frey effect,” in which            cause, quoting skeptics such as Kenneth
tion microwaves as a possible culprit.            microwaves can be used to trick the               Forster, a bioengineering professor at the
But the study’s lead author, Douglas              brain into perceiving ordinary sounds             University of Pennsylvania, who called

     State Needs a                     Heard on the Hill                    Intrepid Professionals
     Full Team on the                                                       Since the founding of our country, our diplomats have
     Field                                                                  served America in some of the most difficult and dangerous
     During his May 24 appear-                                              places on earth. Our embassies and consulates are plat-
     ance before this Committee,                                            forms of U.S. influence and vigilance and our diplomats are
     Sec. Pompeo said: ‘With so                                             often the first to spot threats to our national security before
     many challenges before us,                                             they arrive on our shores. These intrepid professionals
     the State Department needs                                             defend our national security, enforce our laws, and protect
     a full team on the field from                                          our fellow citizens overseas.
                                                                     JOSH

     locally employed staff around                                                —Chairman Ed Royce (R-Calif.), newsletter to constituents
     the world to senior leaders in                                             from House Committee on Foreign Affairs, honoring the vic-
     Washington.’ Sec. Pompeo expressed concern about vacancies                         tims of the 1998 East Africa embassy attacks, Aug. 6.
     in key positions and said: ‘We need our men and women on
     the ground executing American diplomacy with great vigor and           Coming Up from Within
     energy and representing our great nation.’ I completely agree,         I want to thank you, again, for your willingness to serve, and
     and that’s why I’m excited to have five nominees before the            just on a personal note, to have someone who is coming
     Committee today.                                                       up from within the department to be in this position, for
                —Sen. Todd Young (R-Ind.), Senate Foreign Relations         someone who cares about institutions and building institu-
                            Committee Nominations Hearing, Aug. 23.         tions that will last, it’s heartening to me that someone from
                                                                            within is coming in this position. My guess is with some of
     The Good Work That FS Members Do                                       the turmoil that we have had within the State Department,
     I just want to say that it makes me so proud, and one of the best      it also is something that, really, the many members of the
     things we get to do as members of the Senate is to travel around       Foreign Service who have committed their lives to Foreign
     and see the good work that Foreign Service officers are doing          Service, I’m sure are cheering you on today.
     around the world.                                                          —Chairman Bob Corker (R-Tenn.), Senate Foreign Relations
         —Sen. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.), Senate Foreign Relations Committee        Committee, nomination for David Hale to be under secretary
       Hearing, in reference to the nomination for the Honorable Earl                       for political affairs (now confirmed), on Aug. 16.
            Robert Miller to be ambassador to Bangladesh, on Aug. 23.

14                                                                                                         OCTOBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
the microwave theory “crazy” and said
that while he can’t explain what hap-        Contemporary Quote:
pened to the diplomats and their fami-
lies, “it’s sure as heck not microwaves.”
    On Aug. 30, the State Department
released the results of an Accountability
Review Board convened in January 2018
to review the circumstances surrounding              I want to tell you a story about the art of the deal—the Iran deal,
the medical problems in Havana. The                  for which I was the lead negotiator. 1/14
ARB found that “the department’s secu-
                                                We negotiated the deal at the Palais Coburg Hotel in Vienna. I thought
rity systems and procedures were overall
                                             I’d be home in short order. 2/14
adequate and properly implemented,
                                               By day 25 I had barely left the hotel and had eaten only 1 meal outside the
though there were significant vacancies
                                             Coburg. Every rod and rack in my bathroom had hand-washed laundry. 3/14
in security staffing and some challenges
with information sharing and communi-          We called our side the P5+1: US, England, France, Germany, Russia,
cation.”                                     China and the EU. 4/14
    The ARB issued 30 recommendations           Diplomacy can test your patience. There were so many interlocking issues
in the areas of accountability, inter-       to cover: how to verify Iran’s compliance, how to limit its centrifuges, how to
agency coordination, medical issues,         ‘snapback’ sanctions if needed, etc. 5/14
communication and information shar-            Every time one element of the deal changed, we had to renegotiate within
ing, risk/benefit analysis and diplomatic    the P5+1 and EU, then go back to the Iranians again. It was like a Rubik’s Cube.
security. All 30 recommendations were        Solve one side and you’ve jumbled the others. 6/14
accepted by the department.                    After dinner on the 25th day, I met with Abbas Araghchi, Iran’s lead
    Brian Mazanec, acting director of        negotiator, with his partner, Majid Takata-Ravanchi, to go over one final
international affairs and trade at the       UN resolution. 7/14
Government Accountability Office,
                                                Araghchi agreed to key points, but then leaned forward and began
explained the delay in convening an ARB      to dispute a previously agreed upon point. 8/14
thus, according to Federal Times: “The
                                               This was familiar Iranian negotiation style: just as consensus seemed
offices in State weren’t communicating
                                             imminent, there would be one more point of contention. We’ve given
the way they should have. When these
                                             you what you want; now give us something of ours you’ve taken. 9/14
incidents were occurring, several State
offices were responding, but the office        I lost it. I began to tell, and to my frustration and fury, my eyes began to well
                                             up with tears. I told them how their tactics jeopardized the entire deal. 10/14
responsible for initiating the process
to consider whether or not to convene          Women are told early in life that it’s not socially acceptable to get angry.
an accountability review board was not       And it’s a sign of weakness to let people see you cry. 11/14
aware of the incidents.”                       Aragchi and Ravanchi were stunned. For a first time in a month,
                                             they were silent. 12/14
The Return of the                               Something in the sincerity of my frustration broke through. After a long
Special Envoy                                silent moment, Aragchi dismissed his objection. That tearful reckoning

O    n Sept. 4 Secretary of State Mike
     Pompeo confirmed the appoint-
ment of Zalmay Khalilzad as special
                                             became the final substantive turn of the Rubik’s cube. 13/14
                                                That’s when it clicked into place for me. When you bring values like authen-
                                             ticity, persistence, and commitment to the negotiating table, both in work and
adviser for Afghanistan.                     personal life, you are enormously powerful. 14/14
   Khalilzad, who served as U.S. ambas-
sador to Afghanistan, Iraq and the United                        —Tweet by Wendy R. Sherman, Sept. 5, www.bit-ly/WShermanAStory.
Nations during the George W. Bush

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | OCTOBER 2018                                                                                     15
administration, accompanied the Secre-        vice president of international govern-       pendently of the State Department’s
tary on his recent visit to Pakistan and      mental affairs, was named special rep-        geographic bureaus.
India. He has been tasked with bringing       resentative for North Korea on Aug. 23.          “Special envoys can offer much more
about a political solution in Afghanistan.    Biegun served in a number of national         consistent focus on an issue,” Steven
    It was the fourth special envoy           security and foreign policy roles prior       Heydemann, a professor of govern-
appointment in a month by an admin-           to joining Ford in 2004, including as         ment at Smith College and fellow at
istration that has so far avoided naming      an adviser to former Senate Majority          the Brookings Institution, told AP. But
high-level diplomats to focus on special      Leader Bill Frist (R-Tenn.).                  he said that without a clear division of
problem areas, AP observed on Sept. 5,            And on Aug. 17, Career Ambassador         labor between a special envoy and other
and part of Pompeo’s effort to restore        James Jeffrey was appointed Special           diplomats at State, the positions “can be
“swagger” to the State Department,            Representative for Syria Engagement.          a source of confusion and mixed mes-
which suffered significant losses to its      The career diplomat is a three-time           saging.”
senior ranks under his predecessor, Rex       U.S. ambassador, to Albania (2002-               Department spokeswoman Heather
Tillerson.                                    2004), Turkey (2008-2010) and Iraq            Nauert said special envoys bring a “sin-
    On Aug. 16, Secretary Pompeo named        (2010-2012), and also served as deputy        gular focus” to complex foreign policy
Brian Hook, senior policy adviser to the      national security advisor (2007-2008).        challenges and “the authority to cut
Secretary of State and head of the Policy         Many in the foreign policy com-           across agencies and regions in order to
Planning Staff at State, special represen-    munity are skeptical of the value of          advise the secretary on the overarching
tative for Iran. Hook will lead the newly     special envoys. With their own staffs,        strategy.” They ensure that all expertise
established Iran Action Group.                they tend to create a separate foreign        within the department is brought to
    Stephen Biegun, former Ford Motor         policy bureaucracy that operates inde-        bear, she said.

SITE OF THE MONTH: MAPPING MILITANTS PROJECT: WEB.STANFORD.EDU/GROUP/MAPPINGMILITANTS/CGI-BIN

     A     cross the map, from the Middle East to
           Southeast Asia, new militant organiza-
     tions continue to appear on the radar, and
                                                                                                   basic descriptions of the vari-
                                                                                                   ous groups, broken down by
                                                                                                   geographic area. The break-
     Stanford University’s Mapping Militants                                                       down includes international,
     Project helps track them. While the                                                           Middle East and North Africa,
     website does not offer actual interactive                                                    Asia, Central Asia, Europe and
     maps, it contains “interactive diagrams”                                                     Latin America. Also on the
     that map out relationships between the                                                       “Map” page, each group listing
     groups and show how they evolve over                                                         has a link to that group’s inter-
     time.                                                                                       active diagram, which opens in
         The Mapping Militants Project seeks                                                     a new page.
     to “find patterns in the evolution of militant organizations                                   The project was developed by
     in specified conflict theatres and to discover the causes       Stanford University’s Center for International Security and
     and consequences of their evolution.”                           Cooperation, which is housed within the Freeman Spogli
         Users can select “Map Options” to display features such     Institute for International Studies. A National Science
     as group leadership, size and ideology. One can view active     Foundation–Department of Defense partnership provided
     and/or inactive organizations, organization events, as well     start-up funding.
     as the rise and decline of different groups over time.             Profiles are updated regularly to keep information
         Select the “Maps” tab at the top of any page to find        current.

16                                                                                                OCTOBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
50 Years Ago

    W       e note with deep sadness the death by assassina-
            tion of John Gordon Mein, Ambassador to Guate-
    mala, long a distinguished Foreign Service officer, for years
                                                                     as a private scholar and commenta-
                                                                     tor on world events, to take a critical
                                                                     attitude towards one or another of
    a reader of these pages, and ever a stout champion of            the policies of my government. Our
    those who have elected to follow the often dangerous and         tradition, as you know, permits this.
    troubled career of serving their country in foreign lands.       But I have never lost my faith in
    His example and his advice will be sorely missed in the try-     the basic goodwill and generos-
    ing months to come. And we cannot escape the conclusion          ity of my people in their approach
    that the coming months and years will surely be trying for       to the other people of this world, or in the
    members of the Foreign Service. …                                decency of the motives and purposes by which American
        But all this, difficult as it is, nevertheless is no cause   statesmanship has been inspired. And I can give it to you
    for despair. Anyone who joined the Foreign Service for           as my conviction, at this sad and anxious moment, that my
    a life of ease and quiet chose the wrong profession. The         people will always be ready, however great the intervening
    overwhelming majority of our Foreign Service people              discouragements and disappointments to take up anew
    are people of good will and competence, persons with             the search for hopeful and constructive solutions to world
    affection and loyalty to their own country who are at the        problems.’ …
    same time interested in learning of the ways of others,              So our task remains; the challenge beckons. In
    professionals who go about their different tasks with skill,     responding with energy, intelligence and good faith, we
    common sense and perspective. Quality is demanded of             will honor the memory of Ambassador Mein and will show
    these persons who are charged with nothing less than car-        ourselves to be deserving inheritors of a worthy tradition.
    rying out the intentions and purposes of the United States               —From an editorial with the same title remembering
    beyond its borders. …                                                 Ambassador John Gordon Mein (assassinated in Guate-
        In a recent speech in Finland, George Kennan said it                mala on Aug. 28, 1968, the first U.S. ambassador to be
    all simply and succinctly: ‘It has sometimes fallen to me,            assassinated while serving in office), FSJ, October 1968.

BBG: New Name—                                 connect people around the world in          cated weekly audience of 278 million people
Same Mission                                   support of freedom and democracy.”          in 100 countries and in 59 languages.”

O     n Aug. 23, the Broadcasting Board
      of Governors announced that,
effective immediately, it would be
                                                  The name change followed
                                               research and consultation with
                                               agency staff and leadership, Congress
                                                                                           Congressional Research
                                                                                           Service Releases Report
rebranded as the U.S. Agency for Global        and the Trump administration.               on Human Trafficking
Media.
   The chief executive officer and direc-
tor of the new
                                                  The newly named USAGM encom-
                                               passes the Voice of America, Radio Free
                                                                         Europe/Radio
                                                                                          O       n July 19 the Congressional Research
                                                                                                  Service published a report, “Trans-
                                                                                           national Crime Issue: Human Trafficking,”
entity, John                                                             Liberty, the      covering both legislative work on the issue
Lansing, stated:                                                         Office of Cuba    and the State Department’s role in ending
“The term                                                                Broadcasting      trafficking.
‘broadcast-                                                              (Television           As part of the Library of Congress, the
ing’ does not                                                            and Radio         Congressional Research Service provides
accurately describe what we do. The new        Martí), Radio Free Asia, and the Middle     nonpartisan policy and legal analysis to
name reflects our modernization and            East Broadcasting Networks.                 members of both the House and the Senate.
forward momentum while honoring our               According to USAGM, these net-               As the report notes, the State Depart-
enduring mission to inform, engage and         works “collectively reach an undupli-       ment leads federal efforts to combat

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | OCTOBER 2018                                                                                            17
human trafficking, and the                                   tection Act of 2000].”       family should only be considered as a
Secretary of State chairs the                                    When the State           temporary last resort. Studies have found
President’s Interagency Task                                 Department released the      that both private and government-run
Force on trafficking in per-                                2018 Trafficking in Persons   residential institutions for children, or
sons. The report also covers                                Report on June 28, it got     places such as orphanages and psychiat-
the department’s annual                                    a bit more attention than      ric wards that do not offer a family-based
Trafficking in Persons                                     usual in the U.S. press. At    setting, cannot replicate the emotional
(TIP) Report.                                             the time, the Trump admin-      companionship and attention found in
    According to the CRS                                 istration was struggling to      family environments that are prerequi-
report, issues of concern                                defend its decision to arrest    sites to healthy cognitive development.”
to Congress “may include                                refugee families trying to            The government failed to meet
monitoring the use of                                   enter the United States at our    a court-ordered July 12 deadline to
anti-trafficking funds by the executive                southern borders, forcibly         reunite all children under age 5 with
branch, examining links between human       separating children from their parents.       their parents. n
trafficking with other transnational           Media outlets such as The New York
issues, including labor and procurement     Times, CNN and Foreign Policy all picked          This edition of Talking Points was com-
practices, and considering legislation to   up on a section of the report that read,      piled by Donna Gorman, Shawn Dorman
reauthorize the [Trafficking Victims Pro-   in part: “Removal of a child from the         and Susan Maitra.

18                                                                                              OCTOBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
SPEAKING OUT

What Is It We’re Doing Again? Time to Rethink
How the State Department Communicates
BY P E T E R LO H M A N

I
   magine your typical brown bag                  Imagine if that visiting senior official had
   lunch. Yes, that one. The one where
                                                  outlined his office, bureau or agency’s goals,
   no one actually brings a lunch. The
   speaker is a visiting senior official
                                                  and then began a conversation about how the
from Washington. Staff from across the            embassy in the host country fits in.
embassy come to hear Washington’s
priorities, a senior leader’s view of the
world or ways we can all better execute           hand. Very little was focused on looking     Integrated Country Strategies, Joint
our mission.                                      beyond the most immediate project to         Regional Strategies and the like, we only
    Unfortunately, all too often, the             the overriding principles that help us       compound that error by subsequently
speaker’s remarks are limited to: “You are        achieve our goals.                           putting those strategies on a shelf, where
all doing an excellent job. The relationship          I’m not the only one to notice this.     they sit, never to be spoken of again.
with host country X is extremely impor-           The 2017 Listening Tour Report noted             In my prior service in the U.S. Army,
tant for Washington. It’s really an honor to      the following:                               nearly every commander at the company
be here with you. Now what questions do               • “People say that unclear priori-       level (FS-4 equivalent in rank) and above
you have?” Awkward silence.                       ties leave them seeking guidance that        had what are called “Flat A** Rules.”
    No, this is not an article about how to       for too many does not come from their        (Nothing is official in the Army until it
improve brown bag lunches. The vignette           managers or their chain of command.”         has an acronym, so we called them FARs
I offer above is symptomatic of a larger              • “People report that the frequency      for short.) FARs were the principles by
State Department problem—ineffective,             and coherency of communication—              which each organization operated. They
unclear and infrequent communication.             both top-to-bottom and across the            transcended the next crisis and the one
    One of the aspects of State Depart-           web—needed to inform, coordinate             after that. They applied to all members
ment culture that struck me most                  and inspire action is wildly deficient for   and all tasks. Consider them the core
when I first entered the Foreign Service          what is required.”                           principles of an organization.
was the lack of communication both                    • “People talk about unwritten and           Back to the brown bag example.
between leadership and subordinates               unstated rules about who is allowed to       Imagine if that visiting senior offi-
and among units, offices, embassies,              talk to who[m] in the chain of command       cial had outlined his office, bureau
bureaus and agencies. Most commu-                 … [and] people question their level of       or agency’s goals, and then began a
nication was restricted to the task at            seniority or experience in being able to     conversation about how the embassy
                                                  contribute ideas or concerns.”               in the host country fits in. Or imagine if
                 Peter Lohman joined the              So we clearly have a communication       she had thought about what values her
                 Foreign Service in 2009. He is   problem. What do we do about it?             office, bureau or agency needed to be
                 currently an economic officer                                                 successful, and then discussed those
                 in Jakarta. His previous post-   The Big Picture                              values with the group. Imagine how the
                 ings include Jerusalem, Chen-       First, we need to better communicate      participants would leave feeling like
nai and Washington, D.C. He was a cavalry         our priorities and values. While many        they were part of a bigger team, contrib-
officer in the U.S. Army from 2001 to 2005.       of us bemoan the ritual of producing         uting to a bigger mission.

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | OCTOBER 2018                                                                                            19
To improve the frequency and clarity of our                                              however, the nuance and tone of the
communication, we also need to reward                                                    information are often lost.
                                                                                            Unfortunately, this phenomenon
staff for putting as much work into building                                             works in the other direction, too, as the
contacts within the U.S. government as within                                            most creative, unconventional ideas
host countries.                                                                          often lose their nuance or are stripped
                                                                                         out entirely on their way up the chain.
                                                                                         Leaders can remedy this by following
Breaking Down Stovepipes                    in real time, such as by sharing and         the famously simple “Leadership by
    Second, we need to improve the          editing documents without having to          Walking Around” principle: seek out
frequency and coherence of our com-         email files to each other; create a team     conversations with junior employees;
munication. The department’s tendency       drive for file sharing and storage; or       take the long way back to your office
to work in stovepipes and communicate       design a Google site for posting articles    one afternoon; find an outlet from the
only in our own verticals—rather than       and other up-to-date information—all         isolation of command.
horizontally—is a common weakness of        tools that can facilitate information
large organizations. Because we mostly      sharing and collaboration without the        Breaking Down Walls
transmit and receive information            need for more meetings. Low-tech                 Finally, communicating better as a
through our chains of command, we           solutions also work: copying others on       department means removing obstacles
miss out on how our work affects and is     emails, picking up the phone or walking      to communication, both physical and
affected by others.                         down the hall to talk to a colleague.        cultural. The federal government is
    The economic section misses the                                                      already moving to open workspaces,
anecdote from the political section’s       Leveling Hierarchies                         with the explicit goal of increasing col-
labor officer about illegal foreign work-      To improve the frequency and clarity      laboration and communication.
ers, for example. Or the public diplo-      of our communication, we also need to            As we do so, we should consider
macy section doesn’t get introduced to      reward staff for putting as much work        research from Stanford and University
the promising young businesswoman           into building contacts within the U.S.       of California Berkeley professors who
(and economic section contact) who          government as within host countries.         found that the results of moves to open
would make a great candidate for an         We should emulate the best practices of      office spaces are mixed. Success or
exchange program.                           desk officers who spend their first few      failure, they found, depends on leaders
    More interagency and interoffice        weeks in Washington cultivating the          communicating the vision behind the
communication can help remedy this.         network they need to advance policy          new space and having positive attitudes
Interagency working groups on topics        priorities. Find the staff whose portfolio   about the move, and allowing teams the
such as trade and investment or coun-       overlaps or complements yours, build         latitude to adapt work spaces to their
terterrorism are an excellent start, but    relationships with them and seek them        needs.
working group members need to find          out when making decisions, or when               With this research in mind, I believe
ways to keep up the information sharing     you come across new information that         the department’s move to open work-
between meetings. One way to do this        you know would benefit them.                 spaces can be a net positive. Simply put,
is through better use of technology like       An occasional leveling of our hierar-     you are more likely to talk to people
the Foreign Affairs Network, a Google-      chies would also help promote com-           you see. Why does interagency com-
and cloud-based platform available to       munication. Take the typical senior staff    munication work better in the field than
State Department and all foreign affairs    meeting, for example. These meetings         in Washington? Because in the field we
agency employees that enables sharing       serve to relay information among the         see our interagency colleagues in the
of up-to-SBU (sensitive but unclassi-       unit’s senior leaders. In a well-func-       cafeteria, in the halls and after work.
fied)information, regardless of whether     tioning organization, this information       We develop relationships, which then
the user is on OpenNet.                     and guidance will make its way to those      smooth the flow of information.
    Through FAN, users can collaborate      below the most-senior levels. Even then,         Having more State Department

20                                                                                             OCTOBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
You can also read