Best Practice Guidelines - The management of lipoedema WUK BPG

Page created by Clara Walsh
 
CONTINUE READING
Best Practice Guidelines - The management of lipoedema WUK BPG
WUK BPG

 Best Practice Guidelines
 The management of lipoedema
2017

               Diagnosis and assessment
               Lipoedema management
               Life style support and
               self care
               Compression therapy
               Non-surgical and surgical
               interventions
Best Practice Guidelines - The management of lipoedema WUK BPG
BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES:              EXPERT WORKING GROUP:
THE MANAGEMENT OF                      Tanya Coppel, Specialist Lymphoedema Physiotherapist,
LIPOEDEMA                              Belfast Health & Social Care Trust, Belfast

PUBLISHED BY:                          Julie Cunneen, Macmillan Clinical Lead for
                                       Lymphoedema Service/Nurse Consultant, Moseley Hall
Wounds UK
                                       Hospital, Birmingham
A division of Omniamed,
1.01 Cargo Works                       Sharie Fetzer, Chair, Lipoedema UK, London
1–2 Hatfields, London SE1 9PG, UK
Tel: +44 (0)203735 8244                Kristiana Gordon, Consultant in Dermatology and
Web: www.wounds-uk.com                 Lymphovascular Medicine, St George’s Hospital, London

                                       Denise Hardy, Lymphoedema/Lipoedema
                                       Nurse Consultant, Kendal Lymphology Centre,
                                       Kendal, Cumbria; Nurse Adviser, Lipoedema UK/
                                       Lymphoedema Support Network (LSN), Cumbria; Co-
                                       Chair of the Expert Working Group
© Wounds UK, March 2017
This document has been developed       Kris Jones, Patient; Joint Managing Director & Nurse
by Wounds UK and is supported
                                       Consultant, LymphCare UK; Nurse Consultant,
byActiva Healthcare, BSN
Medical, Haddenham Healthcare,         Lipoedema UK
Lipoedema UK, medi UK, Sigvaris
and Talk Lipoedema.                    Angela McCarroll, Trustee, Talk Lipoedema; Patient,
                                       Northern Ireland

                                       Caitriona O’Neill, Lymphoedema Care Lead Nurse,
                                       Accelerate CIC, London

                                       Sara Smith, Senior Lecturer in Dietetics and Nutrition,
                                       Queen Margaret University, Edinburgh

                                       Cheryl White, Lymphoedema Specialist Physiotherapist,
                                       Cheshire

                                       Anne Williams, Lymphoedema/Lipoedema Nurse
                                       Consultant, Lecturer in Nursing, Queen Margaret
                                       University, Edinburgh; Trustee, Talk Lipoedema,
                                       Edinburgh; Co-Chair of the Expert Working Group
This publication was coordinated
by Wounds UK with the Expert
                                       REVIEW PANEL:
Working Group. The views
                                       Rebecca Elwell, Macmillan Lymphoedema CNS, Univer-
presented in this document are
                                       sity Hospitals of North Midlands NHS Trust, Staffordshire
the work of the authors and do not
necessarily reflect the views of the   Peter Mortimer, Professor of Dermatological Medicine,
supporting companies.                  Consultant Dermatologist, St George’s University of
                                       London
How to cite this document:
Wounds UK. Best Practice               Alex Munnoch, Consultant Plastic Surgeon and Clinical
Guidelines: The Management of          Lead, Ninewells Hospital, Dundee
Lipoedema.
London: Wounds UK, 2017.               Dirk Pilat, General Practitioner; Medical Director for
Available to download from:            ELearning at the Royal College of General Practitioners
www.wounds-uk.com                      (RCGP), London

                                       Melanie Thomas MBE, National Clinical Lead for
                                       Lymphoedema, NHS Wales and the
                                       Lymphoedema Network Wales
Best Practice Guidelines - The management of lipoedema WUK BPG
INTRODUCTION

Developing best practice guidelines for the
management of lipoedema
People with lipoedema in the UK face              The meeting participants recognised a
significant challenges. Many are not              general paucity of clinical evidence relating   GUIDE TO USING THIS
                                                                                                  DOCUMENT
recognised by healthcare professionals as         to the management of lipoedema. The
                                                                                                  Each section of the
having the condition or are misdiagnosed.         conclusions of the meeting formed the basis
                                                                                                  document helps
Awareness of lipoedema among medical              for this document, which draws, where
                                                                                                  healthcare practitioners
practitioners is poor, and little clinical        possible, on relevant literature. Where
                                                                                                  to provide appropriate
research is focused on the condition. To          evidence is lacking, expert opinion has been
                                                                                                  support and effective
date, no good quality guidelines for the          used to inform the guidelines and make
                                                                                                  treatment and care for
management of the disease have been               recommendations. The content was subject
                                                                                                  patients with lipoedema.
published, resulting in inconsistent and          to review by the Expert Working Group and
                                                                                                  The key points for each
frequently inappropriate care for people          additional reviewers before being finalised.
                                                                                                  section summarise
with lipoedema.
                                                                                                  the information most
                                                  This document will be of interest to anyone
                                                                                                  relevant to clinical
Even when lipoedema is diagnosed correctly,       involved in delivering support and clinical
                                                                                                  practice
accessing appropriate care within the NHS         services to people with lipoedema, including
may be difficult because of poor                  general practitioners, lymphoedema
understanding of treatment and referral           therapists, community nurses, plastic
routes, and geographical variations in clinic     surgeons, dietitians, commissioners,
availability, funding and capacity.               third-sector organisations and more.

Lipoedema is a chronic, incurable disease         There is still a considerable amount to learn
that can have a severe impact on quality of       about lipoedema. Undoubtedly, the next few
life, and physical and psychosocial               years will bring rapid advances in
wellbeing. Some patients are so seriously         understanding of the pathophysiology of
affected that they lead very restricted lives,    lipoedema and the most effective ways of
sometimes to the extent of being unable to        managing the condition. As a result, the
leave their homes. The complexity of the          Group recognises that this document is likely
issues faced by patients with lipoedema           to need to be reviewed within three years.
necessitates interprofessional,
multidisciplinary care with an emphasis on        The Group hopes that the document will be
supporting self management and working in         useful to people with lipoedema, and the
partnership with the person to identify           wide range of professionals who have
realistic goals and to manage expectations.       contact with them. This document is an
                                                  early step towards achieving tangible
These best practice guidelines on lipoedema       benefits for patients, enhancing recognition
were inspired by a group of clinicians who        and diagnosis of the condition by
first started discussing the need for clear       professionals and the public, improving
guidance in 2015. The discussions                 access to best practice management, and
culminated in a meeting in September 2016         providing scope for future development of
that had the specific aim of developing           lipoedema services in the UK.
guidelines on management that improve the
lives and outcomes of people with                 Anne Williams and
lipoedema. The meeting was ground                 Denise Hardy
breaking: not only did it bring together key      Co-Chairs
opinion leaders and experts involved in the
treatment of lipoedema from all around the
UK, but, significantly, it also included people
with lipoedema representing UK third
sector organisations.

                                                             BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA 3
Best Practice Guidelines - The management of lipoedema WUK BPG
EPIDEMIOLOGY AND
    PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
      OF LIPOEDEMA

SECTION 1: EPIDEMIOLOGY AND
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF LIPOEDEMA
Lipoedema was first described in 1940 and         suggests: cases may be ‘hidden’ because of       Box 1. Synonyms for
is a chronic incurable condition involving a      their mild nature or because the person is       lipoedema (Schmeller &
pathological build-up of adipose tissue           reluctant to contact health services. Other      Meier-Vollraith, 2007;
(Allen & Hines, 1940). It typically affects the   cases may be unrecognised or misdiagnosed        Langendoen et al, 2009;
thighs, buttocks and lower legs, and              by health services. Common misdiagnoses          Herbst 2012a; Cornely,
                                                                                                   2014)
sometimes the arms, and may, although not         include obesity or lymphoedema (Box 2)
always, cause considerable tissue                 (Goodliffe et al, 2013), although both           ■■ Adiposalgia
enlargement, swelling and pain. It may            conditions may co-exist with lipoedema.          ■■ Adiopoalgesia
significantly impair mobility, ability to                                                          ■■ Lipalgia
perform activities of daily living, and           Cause                                            ■■ Lipedema (American
psychosocial wellbeing. Current                   The precise mechanisms responsible for the          spelling)
conservative management involves                  development of lipoedema are unknown,            ■■ Lipohyperplasia dolorosa
encouraging self-care, managing symptoms,         but it is likely that multiple factors are       ■■ Lipohypertrophy
improving functioning and mobility,               involved (Okhovat & Alavi, 2014).                   dolorosa
providing psychosocial support, and                                                                ■■ Lipomatosis dolorosa of
                                                                                                      the legs
preventing deterioration in physical and          Lipoedema often first presents during
                                                                                                   ■■ Painful column legs
mental health and wellbeing.                      puberty, although oral contraceptive use,        ■■ Painful fat syndrome
                                                  pregnancy and the menopause also appear          ■■ Riding breeches
Lipoedema is predominantly a chronic              to be triggers. These observations suggest          syndrome
adipose tissue disorder (the word lipoedema       that hormonal change may be involved             ■■ Stovepipe legs.
means ‘fat swelling’), with clinically apparent   in initiating the characteristic build-up of
oedema due to fluid accumulation in the           adipose tissue (Fonder et al, 2007; Bano et
tissues occurring as a secondary feature in       al, 2010; Godoy et al, 2012). Onset of the
some individuals (Todd, 2010; Herbst,             disease after periods of significant weight      Box 2. Lymphoedema and
2012a; Reich-Schupke et al, 2013; Herbst et       gain have also been reported (personal           lipoedema (Harwood et
al, 2015). Although most commonly called          communication, K Gordon).                        al, 1996; Lymphoedema
                                                                                                   Framework, 2006;
lipoedema, the condition has a variety of                                                          Goodliffe et al, 2013)
other names (Box 1).                              There is also evidence of a genetic
                                                  predisposition to lipoedema. A family            Patients with lipoedema
Prevalence                                        history of the condition has been found          may be misdiagnosed as
Lipoedema almost exclusively affects              in 15%–64% of patients (Harwood et               having lymphoedema.
women, but a few cases have been reported         al, 1996; Child et al, 2010; Schmeller &         Lymphoedema results
in men (Chen et al, 2004; Langendoen et al,       Meier-Vollrath, 2007). The genetic variants      from malfunction of the
2009). Relatively little epidemiological          involved have not been identified fully,         lymphatic system, whereas
research has been carried out on lipoedema        but research suggests that autosomal             lipoedema is thought to
and so it is unclear exactly how many             dominance with male sparing is the most          primarily be a disorder
people are affected and to what extent.           likely mode of inheritance (Child et al,         of adipose tissue (a
The research so far has produced widely           2010). Investigations into the genetics          lipodystrophy). Confusingly,
varying figures. In the UK, the minimum           of lipoedema are ongoing, and include            however, patients with
prevalence of lipoedema has been estimated        researching whether men may act as               lipoedema may develop
to be 1 in 72,000 (Child et al, 2010).            carriers for the associated genetic factor(s).   lymphatic dysfunction.
However, the authors noted that this is                                                            This combination of
likely to be an underestimate (Child et al,                                                        lipoedema and secondary
2010). In Germany, the prevalence of                                                               lymphoedema is
lipoedema has been estimated to be 11% in                                                          sometimes referred to as
women and post-pubertal girls (Földi et al,                                                        lipolymphoedema.
2006; Szél et al, 2014).

Further research is needed to establish
clearly the proportion of the population
affected by lipoedema. It is likely to be more
common than the limited evidence available

4    BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA
Best Practice Guidelines - The management of lipoedema WUK BPG
VENOUS LEG                                                                                           EPIDEMIOLOGY AND
                                                                                                          PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
     ULCERATION                                                                                             OF LIPOEDEMA

Enlargement of fat tissue                       joint problems, may act to decrease the
The characteristic increase in subcutaneous     effectiveness of the venous and lymphatic                 Key points
fat tissue seen in lipoedema may be due to      systems (Harwood et al, 1996; Cornely,                    1.   Lipoedema is
adipocyte hypertrophy (increase in size but     2006; Langendoen et al, 2009). As a result,                    underdiagnosed and
not necessarily number of fat cells) and/or     the rate of interstitial fluid accumulation                    almost exclusively
hyperplasia (increase in number of fat cells)   may exceed the rate of clearance, and                          affects women
(Suga et al, 2009; Schneble et al, 2016)        oedema may occur.                                         2.   Although lipoedema is
(Figure 1). In addition, there is evidence of                                                                  often misdiagnosed as
an increase in the rate of adipocyte death,     In patients with lipoedema who also have                       simply being obesity,
possibly due to hypoxia induced by excessive    chronic venous insufficiency (CVI) the                         lipoedema and obesity
tissue enlargement, and infiltration of fat     tendency for interstitial fluid accumulation                   can co-exist
tissue by scavenger inflammatory cells          may be compounded.                                        3.   Hormonal and
(macrophages) (Suga et al, 2009).                                                                              genetic factors are
                                                Age-related changes that cause the                             likely to contribute
By inducing growth of new fragile capillaries   lymphatic vessels to harden                                    to the adipose
in the fat tissue, it has been suggested that   (lymphangiosclerosis) and become less                          tissue enlargement
hypoxia may contribute to the easy bruising     effective at removing fluid may also                           characteristic of
often reported by patients with lipoedema       contribute to the development of                               lipoedema
(Fife et al, 2010). Other tissue changes that   lipolymphoedema (Cornely, 2006).                          4.   Patients with lipoedema
may occur include reduced elasticity of the                                                                    may develop secondary
skin and connective tissue (fascia)             Some women with lipoedema report                               lymphoedema
(Jagtman et al, 1984; Herbst, 2012a).           premenstrual fluid retention that can have a                   (lipolymphoedema),
                                                considerable cyclical impact on the size and                   which may be
The cause of the pain and hypersensitivity      shape of lipoedematous areas.                                  compounded if chronic
often mentioned by patients with lipoedema                                                                     venous insufficient is
is unclear, but may relate to compression of                                                                   also present.
nerve fibres by enlarged fat deposits,
inflammation and/or central sensitisation (a
process which involves changes in the brain
and spinal cord that are associated with the
                                                                                                     Genetic, hormonal
development of chronic pain) (Langendoen                                                             and other factors
et al, 2009; Peled & Kappos, 2016).

Development of oedema
In many patients, lipoedema is
accompanied by the formation of fluid
                                                                              Hypertrophy and/or hyperplasia         Reduced connective
oedema. It has been suggested that the                                               of adipose tissue                 tissue elasticity
oedema may result from overloading of an
essentially normal lymphatic system (see
Appendix 1, page 32 for information on the
lymphatic system). Although, changes in                   Compression
the structure and function of the lymphatic              of nerve fibres,
system have been observed in some                        inflammation,
                                                                            Increased capillary   Impaired
                                                                                                                   Impaired functioning
                                                         and/or central                                              of the venous and
patients, much research is needed to                      sensitisation
                                                                                  fragility        mobility
                                                                                                                    lymphatic systems
discover whether these changes are a
common feature of lipoedema and whether
they relate to the pathophysiology of the
condition (Amann-Vesti et al, 2001;                                                                              Increased interstitial fluid

Bilancini et al, 1995).

Increased interstitial fluid formation due to                 Pain               Bruising                      Oedema (lipolymphoedema)
capillary fragility and possible mechanical
obstruction of small lymphatic vessels by
adipose tissue enlargement, combined with
reduced skin and connective tissue
elasticity, reduced mobility due to pain or      Figure 1: Possible pathophysiology of lipoedema

                                                            BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA 5
Best Practice Guidelines - The management of lipoedema WUK BPG
DIAGNOSIS AND                                                                                    ASSESSMENT
      ASSESSMENT

SECTION 2 : DIAGNOSIS AND ASSESSMENT
Lipoedema is often not recognised in             the early stages or in mild forms as the
primary care, and awareness and                  symptoms and signs may be subtle. The             Lipoedema UK and the
understanding of the condition among             characteristics of lipoedema become more          Royal College of General
medical professionals is limited (Goodliffe      obvious as the disease progresses and in          Practitioners (RCGP)
et al, 2013; Evans, 2013).                       more severe forms (Table 4, page 11).             have partnered to develop
                                                                                                   an online course called
A diagnosis of lipoedema is made on clinical     Although the lower limbs and buttocks are the     Lipoedema — An Adipose
grounds that are based on the history and        most commonly affected areas, it is suggested     Tissue Disorder. The Royal
examination of the patient. Currently, there     that lipoedema may occur in any part of the       College of Nursing (RCN)
are no known blood or urine biomarkers,          body (Herbst et al, 2015) and there is a great    has endorsed the course,
nor are there any specific diagnostic tests,     deal of variation between individuals in areas    which takes about 30
for lipoedema (Herbst, 2012a).                   affected. In one study, about 30% of patients     minutes to complete and
                                                 with affected lower limbs also had affected       can be accessed at: www.
In the absence of definitive diagnostic tests,   arms (Fife et al, 2010). However, anecdotal       elearning.rcgp.org.uk/
clinicians need to have a clear understanding    reports suggest the proportion of patients with   lipoedema
of the unique characteristics of lipoedema and   affected lower and upper limbs is much higher,
how they differ from other apparently similar    particularly in established lipoedema (stage 2
conditions such as lymphoedema and obesity       onwards). In about 3% of cases of lipoedema,
(Fife et al, 2010) (see pages 8–9).              the arms alone are affected, usually with
                                                 sparing of the hands (Fife et al, 2010).
Diagnosis of lipoedema may be delayed due
to poor recognition of the condition by          In patients with lower limb lipoedema, the
health professionals. Making an accurate         lower body will often be disproportionately
diagnosis may be challenging, particularly in    large: individuals may require clothes for
the early stages or when a patient has           their lower body that are several sizes
co-existing obesity.                             larger than those needed for their upper
                                                 body (Fife et al, 2010).
The course of lipoedema over time is not
fully understood, but is highly variable and     The adipose tissue enlargement may be
unpredictable. The condition may progress        accompanied by bruising without apparent
relentlessly in some patients, and yet in        cause or due to minor trauma only. Many
others the only symptom is a relatively          patients with lipoedema also often mention
minor increase in subcutaneous fat that          pain and extreme sensitivity/tenderness to
remains stable for many years (Langendoen        touch and pressure in the affected areas.
et al, 2009; Dutch Guidelines, 2014).            They also report that the affected areas are
                                                 cooler than unaffected areas. (The skin over
History and symptoms                             obese tissue may also feel cooler because of
Typically, a patient with lipoedema is           the insulating effect of fat.)
female and reports onset at puberty or at
another time of hormonal change. Only a          Patients with lipolymphoedema may
handful of male cases have been reported         mention that standing for long periods, hot
in the literature: all were thought to have      environments or weather, and aeroplane
developed lipoedema secondary to                 journeys may exacerbate pain, swelling and
hormonal disturbances, with reduced              feelings of heaviness in the limbs, probably
testosterone levels being a common factor        due to fluid accumulation in the tissues.
(Child et al, 2010).
                                                 Mobility may be restricted due to pain,
The development of tissue enlargement is         mechanical hindrance, and/or hip and
often insidious (Todd, 2016). It is usually      knee joint problems, particularly in
bilateral and symmetrical, and most              patients with severe lipoedema. There are
commonly affects the legs, thighs, hips          anecdotal reports of a possible association
and/or buttocks, with sparing of the feet.       between lipoedema and hypermobility
Diagnosis of lipoedema may be difficult in       (Willams & MacEwan, 2016; Lontok et al,

6   BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA
Best Practice Guidelines - The management of lipoedema WUK BPG
ASSESSMENT                                                                                             DIAGNOSIS AND
                                                                                                              ASSESSMENT

  Box 3. Areas for discussion with a patient suspected of having lipoedema

  ■ Age at onset and association with potential hormonal              ■ Clothing sizes for upper and lower body
    triggers, e.g. puberty, oral contraceptive use, pregnancy,        ■ Impact on:
    weight gain                                                         - Daily living
  ■ Areas of the body affected, and whether and how the degree          - Mobility (e.g. need for aids such as walking stick or wheel-
    and extent of enlargement or swelling have changed over time           chair)
  ■ Effect of dieting, calorie restriction and physical activity/       - Personal relationships
    exercising on weight and limb size                                  - Work
  ■ Presence and severity of pain, discomfort or hypersensitivity       - Emotional state
    to touch                                                          ■ Family history
  ■ Presence, extent and triggers (if any) of bruising                ■ Previous investigations and management (including surgery
  ■ Presence of knee or hip pain, and related mobility issues           such as liposuction)
  ■ Differences in skin texture and temperature between affected      ■ Other medical and surgical history (e.g. comorbidities,
    and unaffected areas                                                regular medication, allergies, previous episodes of cellulitis
  ■ Effect of rest or leg elevation on leg size and pain/discomfort     and previous surgery)
    in patients with lower limb enlargement                           ■ Reasons for presenting now, understanding of disease, and
  ■ Effect of prolonged standing, heat or hot weather on swelling       expectations of treatment outcomes.
    and pain/discomfort

2017). Muscle weakness may also play a              clinicians to examine them. In addition to            Box 4. Stemmer’s
part: a study in women with lipoedema and           characteristic signs such as braceleting at           sign (Lymphoedema
women with obesity found that those with            the ankles, reduced skin temperature and              Framework, 2006)
lipoedema had statistically significantly lower     altered tissue texture may be present and
leg muscle strength (Smeenge, 2013). Some           require palpation to detect (Table 1, page 8).         Stemmer’s sign is
people become so restricted that they are           Clinicians should check for Stemmer’s sign             negative or not present
                                                                                                           when a fold of skin can
housebound or unable to care for themselves.        (Box 4), which can assist in differentiating
                                                                                                           be pinched and lifted up
                                                    lipoedema from lymphoedema, and for                    at the base of the second
In addition, patients with lipoedema may            pitting oedema (Box 5, page 8), which if               toe or at the base of the
report family history of relatives with similar     present may indicate lipolymphoedema.                  middle finger.
tissue enlargement. They often mention                                                                     A positive sign (a) in a
repeated attempts to lose weight through            Differential diagnosis                                 patient with lipoedema,
calorie-restricted diets and exercising that        Part of the reason that lipoedema may be               when a fold of skin
have little or no impact on lipoedema-              underdiagnosed is that it may be mistaken              cannot be lifted, indicates
affected areas and result in weight loss from       for other conditions that cause sub-                   secondary lymphoedema.
unaffected areas only (Fife et al, 2010).           cutaneous tissue enlargement/swelling or fat           Stemmer’s sign is usually
                                                    deposition. The two most frequent                      negative (b) in patients
Box 3 lists areas for discussion during history     misdiagnoses are generalised obesity                   with ‘pure’ lipoedema.
taking in a patient suspected of having             (particularly in young, otherwise well
lipoedema. It is important to recognise that        patients) and lymphoedema (Table 2, page 9).
the patient may be presenting for the first time
or may have had investigations and                  Medical causes of bilateral symmetrical
management elsewhere previously. Also, in           lower limb swelling are listed in Box 6 (page
some cases, the patient may have encountered        10). Infrequent causes of unusual fat
dismissive or negative responses during their       deposition include Dercum’s disease,
contact with health services. Ascertaining the      polycystic ovary disease, Cushing’s
patient’s reasons for presenting and their          syndrome, growth hormone deficiency and
hopes for treatment and outcomes will form a        lipodystrophies that cause lipohypertrophy
good basis for a partnership approach to            (e.g. analbuminaemia) (Box 7, page 11).
management.
                                                    Investigations
Examination                                         Currently, there are no diagnostic tests for
As lipoedema is a clinical diagnosis,               lipoedema and the main purpose of
examination is particularly important, and          investigations is to exclude other diagnoses or
individuals appreciate time taken by                to inform lipoedema management strategies.

                                                                 BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA 7
DIAGNOSIS AND                                                                                                               ASSESSMENT
       ASSESSMENT

    Table 1. Characteristic signs of lipoedema that may be found during clinical examination

    Sign                            Description
    Subcutaneous tissue             • Usually bilateral and symmetrical without involvement
    enlargement                       of the hands and feet (at least initially)
                                    • However, the pattern of areas affected and overall
                                      shape may vary between patients

    Cuffing or braceleting at the   • The tissue enlargement stops abruptly at the ankles
    ankles/wrists                     or wrists so that there is a ‘step’ before the feet or hands
                                      which are usually unaffected
                                    • May also be called ‘inverse shouldering’

    Loss of the concave spaces      • Occurs in lower limb lipoedema
    either side of the Achilles     • The concave areas posterior to the malleoli (retromalleolar sulci) and either side of the Achilles tendon are filled
    tendon                            in

    Bruising                        • Bruising may occur anywhere in areas affected by lipoedema,
                                      often with no known cause

    Altered skin appearance,        • The skin of affected areas may feel softer and cooler than unaffected areas
    temperature and texture         • The skin may have the texture of orange peel or have larger dimples

    Abnormal gait and limited       • May be due to bulk of the legs and/or fat pads on the medial aspect of the knees
    mobility                        • May include:
                                      - Reduced or poor heel to toe strike during walking
                                      - Flat feet
                                      - Genu valgum (knock knees)
                                    • Muscle weakness
    Stemmer’s sign negative         • Usually negative
    (Box 4, page 7)                 • A positive Stemmer sign represents failure to pinch a fold of skin at the
                                      base of the second toe, and is pathognomonic of lymphoedema

    Pitting oedema (Box 5) in       • Usually absent in the early stages of the disease
    patients with lipoedema         • Patients with lipoedema may find testing for pitting oedema
    and secondary lympoedema          particularly uncomfortable
    (lipolymphoedema)               • Pitting indicates the presence of excess interstitial fluid and may be
    and/or chronic venous insuf-      present in patients with lipolymphoedema
    ficiency
Pictures supplied courtesy of BSN Medical

                                         Box 5. Pitting oedema (Lymphoedema Framework, 2006)

                                            Pitting oedema is a sign of excess interstitial fluid. It can be detected by applying
                                            a thumb or finger to tissues with pressure that is sustained for at least 10 seconds.
                                            Oedema is present when a dimple or pit remains in the tissues when the pressure
                                            is removed. The depth of the pit produced may indicate the severity of the
                                            oedema. Repetition of the test across the area suspected of involvement can help
                                            to determine the extent of the oedema. N.B. Elucidation of this sign may cause
                                            discomfort or pain and should be performed gently.

8     BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA
ASSESSMENT
                                                                                                                              DIAGNOSIS AND
                                                                                                                               ASSESSMENT

Table 2. Differentiating lipoedema from lymphoedema and obesity (Forner-Cordero et al, 2009; Langendoen et al, 2009; Fife et al, 2010;
Child et al, 2010; Fetzer & Wise, 2015)
Characteristic                   Lipoedema                                  Lymphoedema                                          Obesity
Gender                           • Almost exclusively female                • Male or female                                     • Male or female
Age at onset                     • Usually 10–30 years                      • Childhood (mainly primary); adult (primary or      • Childhood onwards
                                                                              secondary)
Family history                   • Common                                   • Only for primary lymphoedema                       • Very common
Areas affected                   • Bilateral                                • May be unilateral or bilateral depending on        • All parts of the
                                 • Usually symmetrical                        cause                                                body
                                 • Most frequently affects legs, hips                                                            • Usually
                                   and buttocks; may affect arms                                                                   symmetrical
                                 • Feet/hands spared
Effect of dieting on condition   • Weight loss will be                      • Proportionate loss from trunk and affected         • Weight reduction
                                   disproportionately less from               limbs                                                with uniform loss
                                   lipoedema sites                                                                                 of subcutaneous fat
Effect of limb elevation         • Absent or minimal                        • Initially effective in reducing swelling; may      • None
                                                                              become less effective as the disease progresses
Pitting oedema (Box 5, page 8)   • Absent or minor in the early stages      • Usually present but pitting may cease as the       • No
                                   of the disease                             disease progresses and tissues fibrose
Bruises easily                   • Yes                                      • Not usually                                        • No
Pain/discomfort in affected      • Often                                    • May be uncomfortable                               • No
areas                            • Hypersensitivity to touch in affected    • No hypersensitivity to touch
                                   areas
Tenderness of affected areas     • Often                                    • Unusual                                            • No
Skin consistency                 • Normal or softer/looser                  • Thickened and firmer                               • Normal
History of cellulitis            • Unusual (unless lipolymphoedema is • Often                                                    • Unusual
                                   present)
Stemmer’s sign (Box 4, page 7) • Usually negative (unless secondary         • Usually positive                                   • Usually negative
                                 lymphoedema is present)

Laboratory tests                                          Imaging investigations
Routine screening blood tests useful in                   Imaging investigations such as ultrasound
excluding or identifying other or concomitant             scans, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
conditions, especially if weight gain and                 scans and computed tomography (CT) scans
lethargy are present, may include urea and                are usually not necessary to diagnose
electrolytes (U&Es), full blood count (FBC),              lipoedema, but may have a role if there is
thyroid function tests (TFTs), liver function             diagnostic uncertainty.
tests (LFTs), plasma proteins (including
albumin), brain natriuretic peptide (BNP – a              Lymphoscintigraphy, a method of imaging
test for congestive heart failure) and glucose            the lymphatic system that involves injection
(Forner-Cordero et al, 2012; NVDV, 2014).                 of radioactive tracers into the skin, should
                                                          detect lymphoedema (Keeley, 2006).
Even though hormonal factors are thought to
contribute to the development of lipoedema,               Ultrasound measurement of dermal
there is no evidence that endocrinological                thickness may help to differentiate
tests will detect any abnormalities (NVDV,                lymphoedema and lipoedema
2014). Similarly, blood tests to measure the              (Naouri et al, 2010).
levels of inflammatory markers, such as
C-reactive protein (CRP) or erythrocyte                   Venous duplex ultrasound scanning may
sedimentation rate (ESR) are unlikely to                  be indicated if chronic venous insufficiency
provide abnormal results.                                 is suspected (Wounds UK, 2016).

                                                                           BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA 9
DIAGNOSIS AND
   ASSESSMENT

Hand-held devices                                     Classification and staging                                      Box 6. Other causes
There is increasing interest in the potential         Lipoedema has been classified according to:                     of bilateral lower limb
role of hand-held devices that measure the            ■ Distribution of the adipose tissue                            chronic oedema (Ely et al,
electrical properties of skin and superficial            enlargement                                                  2006; Trayes et al, 2013)
subcutaneous tissues as a way of                      ■ The shape of the enlargement (Table 3).
differentiating lipoedema and                                                                                         ■■ Chronic venous
lymphoedema. The reading obtained (the                However, these classifications are of limited                      insufficiency (CVI)
tissue dielectric constant) is a measure of           clinical use because neither indicates                          ■■ Congestive cardiac
the amount of water in the tissues. Higher            severity or disease progression, and neither                       failure
readings indicate higher water content.               guides treatment.                                               ■■ Dependency or stasis
Although patients with lymphoedema have                                                                                  oedema
been found to have higher readings than               The first system devised to describe the                        ■■ Obesity
patients with lipoedema, further research is          severity and progression of lipoedema                           ■■ Hepatic or renal
needed to determine the role of this                  comprised three stages. More recent                                dysfunction
technology in diagnosis and management                versions include a fourth stage to account                      ■■ Hypoproteinaemia
(Birkballe et al, 2014).                              for the development of lipolymphoedema                          ■■ Hypothyroidism
                                                      (Table 4, page 11). However, as oedema can                      ■■ Pregnancy and
Another device under development                      arise at any stage of lipoedema (Fife et al,                       premenstrual oedema
examines the effect of a small area of                2010), inclusion of this fourth stage is                        ■■ Drug-induced swelling,
suction over affected tissues. The suction is         potentially confusing.                                             e.g. calcium channel
maintained for 30 seconds and an                                                                                         blockers, steroids,
associated smartphone app videos the skin             The staging system in Table 4 may indicate                         non-steroidal anti-
being tested (Levin-Epstein, 2016).                   a patient’s position in the progression of                         inflammatories.
                                                      lipoedema. However, it does not take
                                                                                                                      N.B. These conditions will usually
In patients with lipoedema, the suction is            account of the severity of symptoms, e.g.
                                                                                                                      cause pitting oedema, and may
thought to produce characteristic skin                pain and impact on lifestyle, neither of                        co-exist with lipoedema
changes that do not occur in patients                 which is necessarily related to the degree
without the disease. A pilot trial is                 of tissue enlargement.
underway (Levin-Epstein, 2016).

Table 3. Classifications of lipoedema (Meier-Vollrath & Schmeller, 2004; Földi & Földi, 2006; Langendoen et al, 2009; Herbst, 2012a)

According to the anatomical areas affected
Type                                                                Anatomical areas affected

  Type I                                                              Pelvis, buttocks and hips (saddle bag phenomenon)

  Type II                                                             Buttocks to knees, with formation of folds of fat around
                                                                      the inner side of the knees

  Type III                                                            Buttocks to ankles

  Type IV                                                             Arms

  Type V                                                              Lower leg
According to the shape of the tissue enlargement
Type                                                                Description

  Columnar                                                            Enlargement of the lower limbs which become column-shaped or cylindrical

  Lobar                                                               Presence of large bulges or lobes of fat overlying enlarged lower extremities,
                                                                      hips or upper arms
 Columnar lipoedema is much more common than lobar lipoedema
                                                                                                             Pictures supplied courtesy of BSN Medical

10 BEST PRACTICE STATEMENT: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA
DIAGNOSIS AND
                                                                                                           ASSESSMENT

 Table 4. Lipoedema staging (Schmeller & Meier-Vollrath, 2007; Herbst, 2012a; NVDV, 2014)               Box 7. Other diseases
                                                                                                        that may have unusual
 Stage                           Description                                                            patterns of fat deposition
                                                                                                        (Sam, 2007; Florenza et
 1                               • Skin appears smooth
                                                                                                        al, 2011; Herbst, 2012a;
                                 • On palpation, the thickened subcutaneous                             Kandamany & Munnoch,
                                   tissue contains small nodules                                        2013; Melmed, 2013;
                                                                                                        Nieman, 2015)

 2                               • Skin has an irregular texture that resembles                          ■■ Dercum’s disease —
                                   the skin of an orange (‘peau d’orange’) or a mattress                    individuals have painful
                                 • Subcutaneous nodules occur that vary from                                fatty nodules often
                                   the size of walnut to that of an apple in size                           accompanied by a wide
                                                                                                            range of other symp-
                                                                                                            toms including fatigue;
 3                               • The indurations are larger and more prominent                            may be on the ‘lipo-
                                   than in Stage 2                                                          edema spectrum’
                                 • Deformed lobular fat deposits form,                                   ■■ Multiple symmetrical
                                   especially around thighs and knees,                                      lipomatosis (Mad-
                                   and may cause considerable distortion                                    elung’s disease) —
                                   of limb profile                                                          painless symmetrical
 4                               • Lipoedema with lymphoedema (lipolymphoedema)                             tumour-like accumula-
                                                                                                            tions of fat in the sub-
                                                                                                            cutaneous tissues
                                                                                                         ■■ Polycystic ovary
                                                                                                            disease — a hormonal
                                                                                                            disorder with increased
Pictures supplied courtesy of BSN Medical                                                                   production of androgen
                                                                                                            hormones often accom-
                                                                                                            panied by generalised
                                                                                                            obesity
     Future developments                                 secondary lymphoedema is present                ■■ Cushing’s syndrome
     Some studies of the impact of liposuction           (i.e. whether lipolymphoedema is present).         — due to excess cortisol
     (see pages 29–31) on patients with                                                                     production; obesity is
     lipoedema have used assessments of                  Such a system would need to be defined             one of a wide range of
     symptoms and functioning to monitor                 fully and formally validated, but could be         symptoms and may be
     outcomes (Schmeller et al, 2012;                    based on a scoring system for each of the          accompanied by a char-
     Baumgartner et al, 2016).                           following items:                                   acteristic dorsal fat pad
                                                         • Degree of limb enlargement                    ■■ Growth hormone de-
     Questionnaires were used to grade                   • Level of pain                                    ficiency — causes may
     spontaneous pain, pain upon pressure,               • Presence and extent of bruising                  include pituitary disease
     oedema, bruising, restricted movement,              • Presence and extent of lymphoedema               or trauma; the accom-
     cosmetic impairment and reduction of                • Alterations in gait                              panying obesity is often
     quality of life on a five-point scale. Scores       • Restrictions to mobility                         centralised
     for individual items as well as a total score       • Restrictions to performing activities         ■■ Lipodystrophies that
     were compared pre- and post-operatively.                of daily living                                cause lipohypertrophy
                                                         • Impact on quality of life.                       (e.g. analbuminaemia)
     The Expert Working Group suggested that                                                                — rare; may be congen-
     a similar approach that considers symptoms          The scoring system would need to be clear          ital or acquired.
     and functioning could be developed to               and simple. Total scores could be used to
     indicate non-surgical treatment needs and           indicate whether the patient falls into the
     response in patients with lipoedema. The            mild, moderate or severe grade. In addition,
     Group also suggested that the terminology           the system could be used for monitoring,
     ‘mild’, ‘moderate’ or ‘severe’ is more intuitive    e.g. changes in total or individual item
     than the use of stages, and that each grade         scores could be used to assess the
     could include scope for indicating whether          effectiveness of management approaches.

                                                                         BEST PRACTICE STATEMENT: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA 11
DIAGNOSIS AND
   ASSESSMENT

Assessment
Assessment of a patient with lipoedema
should be holistic and aim to define the                               Holistic assessment of a person with lipoedema
patient’s current disease severity, to indicate
suitability for management options and                                                  History - including symptoms of lipoedema,
to signal need for referral (Figure 2). In                                                         medical/surgical history

practice, diagnosis and assessment are often                                               Extent, distribution and severity of
conducted concurrently and elements of the                                                    adipose tissue enlargement
two processes often overlap.
                                                                                                          Pain
Degree and extent of adipose
tissue enlargement                                                                                  Mobility and gait
Measurement of the degree and extent of
adipose tissue enlargement in lipoedema
                                                                                                Psychosocial assessment
is not straightforward and is not used
for diagnosis. However, sequential
measurements may be useful for                                                                     Dietary assessment

assessment and monitoring purposes. A
wide range of types of measurement may be                                                            Skin assessment
employed, from bodyweight to limb volume
measurement (Table 5, page 13).                                                                    Vascular assessment

In general, simple methods are likely to be the                                               Assessment of comorbidities
most useful and the easiest to use consistently.
Clinicians may find that they tailor the
measurement method used to the needs of
individuals. Documentation of the details of       Pain                                                           Figure 2: Holistic
the measurement method used is important           Pain is a common and often distressing feature                 assessment of a patient
to ensure that future measurements are             of lipoedema that can impact significantly on                  with lipoedema
performed consistently and that changes            daily life. The pain may take several forms,
detected are not artefacts of differences in       including aching, heaviness, tenderness or
measurement location or technique.                 pain on touch. The cause of the pain is unclear,
                                                   but may be related to compression of nerves
For some patients, tracking measurements           and/or inflammation (Lontok et al, 2017).
is highly motivating. However, the distortion
and flaccidity of the tissues in patients          Pain may also be related to joint problems,
with lipoedema may make measurement                especially of the knees and hips, arising from
impractical. In such situations, serial            increased tissue laxity that may cause joint
photographs may be useful.                         misalignment or hypermobility, or from
                                                   degenerative changes (Hodson & Eaton, 2013).
Body mass index (BMI) is a measure of
the ratio between weight and height. It is         Assessment should aim to determine the
used widely to define and diagnose obesity         cause, nature, frequency, site, severity and
and to monitor efforts to lose weight. In          impact of the pain. Rating scales can be
lipoedema, however, BMI is likely to be            used to ask patients to quantify their pain at
high even when the person is not obese and         the initial and ongoing assessments. Rating
is therefore of limited value (Reich-Schupke       scales include:
et al, 2013).                                      ■■ Numerical rating scale — e.g. individuals
                                                      are asked to rate their pain on a scale from
It should be noted that measurement for               0 to 10, where 0 is no pain and 10 is the
fitting compression garments is a separate            worst pain imaginable
process from measuring for monitoring              ■■ Visual analogue scale (VAS) — e.g.
purposes. Where available, clinicians                 individuals are asked to mark or indicate
should follow the measuring requirements              the level of pain on a 10cm line where
for compression garments as stipulated by             0cm is no pain and 10cm is the worst pain
the manufacturer (see pages 23–27).                   imaginable (Dansie & Turk, 2013).

12 BEST PRACTICE STATEMENT: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA
HOSIERYAND
                                                                                                                         DIAGNOSIS
                                                                                                                         CLASSIFICATION
                                                                                                                           ASSESSMENT
                                                                                                                          AND PRODUCT

 Table 5. Measurement for assessment and monitoring in lipoedema (de Koning et al, 2007; Langendoen                      Box 8. Lipoedema UK’s
 et al, 2009; Lopes et al, 2016; Madden & Smith, 2016)                                                                   Big Survey 2014 key
 Weight                       • The simplest method of monitoring change in body size                                    findings on quality of life
                              • Not a specific measure of body areas affected by lipoedema                               (Fetzer & Fetzer, 2016)

 Waist                        • Waist measurement provides information about the distribution of body fat                The 250 respondents to
                              • Increased waist circumference can be used to indicate whether a person is                Lipoedema UK’s Big Survey
                                overweight or obese, and is associated with increased risk for metabolic syndrome        2014 reported that lipoedema
                                (≥80 cm and ≥94 cm for Caucasian women and men, respectively)                            had a considerable impact on
                              • Not a specific measure of a body area usually affected by lipoedema, but may be useful
                                                                                                                         their lives:
                                in helping to avoid obesity and to monitor efforts to lose non-lipoedematous fat
                                                                                                                         ■■ 95% reported difficulty in
 Waist to hip ratio           • A higher waist-to-hip ratio (waist circumference ÷ hip circumference; using same            buying clothes
                                units) is associated with increased risk for metabolic syndrome and cardiovascular       ■■ 87% reported that
                                disease (≥0.85 for women and ≥0.90 for men)
                                                                                                                            lipoedema had a negative
                              • In lower limb lipoedema waist to hip ratio may be unreliable because of
                                                                                                                            effect on quality of life
                                disproportionate adipose tissue enlargement over the buttocks and upper thighs. A
                                changing ratio may be due to a reduction in waist size or an increase in hip size        ■■ 86% reported low self
                                                                                                                            esteem
 Circumferential              • For example, in lower limb lipoedema: at ankle, calf, knee, thigh
                                                                                                                         ■■ 60% reported restricted
                              • A simple method, but requires consistent use of measurement location for
                                meaningful monitoring over time                                                             social life
                                                                                                                         ■■ 60% reported feelings of
 Limb volume                  • Limb volume measurement is a complicated process
                                                                                                                            hopelessness
                              • Methods include water displacement and the use of computer programs that
                                                                                                                         ■■ 51% reported that
                                calculate volume from circumferential limb measurements taken at 4cm intervals
                                with a spring-tension tape                                                                  lipoedema had an impact
                                                                                                                            on ability to carry out
 Body mass index (BMI)        • A ratio that is calculated by dividing weight by height squared
                                                                                                                            their chosen career
                                (weight (kg) ÷ height2 (m2) )
                              • Widely used to diagnose obesity (BMI ≥30) and monitor weight change                      ■■ 50% reported restricted
                              • Of limited value in patients with lipoedema                                                 sex life
                                                                                                                         ■■ 47% reported feelings of
                                                                                                                            self blame
Mobility and gait                                        contribute to oedema if present by reducing                     ■■ 45% reported eating
Patients with lipoedema should be asked                  the effectiveness of the foot and calf muscle                      disorders
about mobility and observed when walking                 pump on venous return.                                          ■■ 39% felt that lipoedema
so that gait and footwear can be assessed.                                                                                  had restricted their career
Shape distortion and fat pads at the inner               Psychosocial assessment                                            choices.
knee area may alter gait, which in turn may              Patients with lipoedema may suffer
cause other problems in the legs, knees,                 considerable psychosocial distress and have
hips and back. Lipoedema may hinder                      significantly reduced quality of life (Box 8 and
mobility because of tissue bulk, pain or hip             Box 9, page 14). The initial relief of finding out
and knee problems.                                       what is wrong when a diagnosis is received
                                                         is often followed by feelings of frustration
Muscle strength may also be reduced: a                   and despair when the patient realises that
study of quadriceps strength found that                  treatment may not improve symptoms as
patients with lipoedema had significantly                much as they had hoped.
lower strength than people with obesity
(Smeenge, 2013).                                         The social stigma attached to increased body
                                                         size and physical restrictions, coupled with
Asking whether aids are needed for walking               shame and embarrassment can damage
and in what circumstances may highlight                  self-esteem, lead to difficulties with personal
issues that may otherwise have gone                      relationships and work, and cause mental
unmentioned. Patients with lipoedema may                 health issues including anxiety and depression
also have flat feet or genu valgum (knock                (Hodson and Eaton, 2013; Kirby, 2016; Fetzer
knees) and require podiatric biomechanical               & Fetzer, 2016).
assessment. Restricted ankle mobility (e.g.
poor ankle dorsiflexion) and reduced heel to             Practical difficulties, such as those due
toe movement with reduced heel strike may                to reduced mobility and difficulties in
induce a laboured or plodding gait. This may             finding clothes that fit, along with fear of

                                                                         BEST PRACTICE STATEMENT: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA 13
DIAGNOSIS AND                                                                                                     COMPRESSION
   ASSESSMENT

  Box 9. Quality of life assessment in lipoedema

 Formal quality of life assessment is usually reserved for            For decades, the medical profession was sceptical about
 research purposes or for health economic evaluations                 the veracity of a person’s description of their illness. Yet
 undertaken for regulatory purposes. General tools available          the words of the individual are likely to provide the most
 include the Short-Form (36) Health Survey (SF-36)                    accurate account of what it is like to live with a condition.
 (Lins & Carvalho, 2016). Currently, there is no quality of           Through such narratives the complexity of the illness
 life assessment tool for people with lipoedema, although             experience can be seen. As Hyden (1997) stated: “One
 a tool has been developed for people with lymphoedema                of our most powerful forms for expressing suffering and
 (LYMQOL) (Keeley et al, 2010). A Patient Benefit Index, a            experiences related to suffering is the narrative. Patients’
 scoring system that evaluates the benefit of treatment from          narratives give voice to suffering in a way that lies outside
 the individual’s perspective, has been developed for people          the domain of the biomedical voice.”
 with lymphoedema and lipoedema (Blome et al, 2014).
                                                                      Gathering information using the illness narrative enables
 The illness narrative                                                clinicians to gain a more complete understanding of how
 An illness narrative (Hyden, 1997) is derived from an                the condition is impacting each individual person and
 individual’s explanation of their struggle with a chronic or         therefore how to best meet their needs, in particular, how to
 disabling illness. It is their story of living with the condition.   better address their psychosocial needs.

discrimination or not fitting into seats in             have produced weight loss from non-
public spaces, may discourage a patient                 lipoedematous areas, but may also have
from leaving their home, resulting in                   resulted in disordered eating behaviours,
social avoidance, withdrawal and isolation.             including anorexia nervosa, binge eating and
These issues may be compounded by lack                  bulimia (Fife et al, 2010; Forner-Cordero et
of understanding and fear expressed by                  al, 2012; Williams & MacEwan, 2016; Todd,
family, friends and colleagues. Patients with           2016; Fetzer & Fetzer, 2016). However, up
lipoedema have also reported receiving                  to half of patients with lipoedema may also
verbal abuse from members of the public                 be overweight or obese (Langendoen et al,
(Kirby, 2016).                                          2009; Fife et al, 2010).

Patients with lipoedema should be                       Dietary assessment should be approached
asked about their home situation                        sensitively and include:
(e.g. accessibility, general living standards,          ■■ Current diet, eating habits, and fluid and
household members, involvement of                          alcohol consumption
carers), activities of daily living, social             ■■ Previous attempts to lose weight and
interactions, recreational/physical activities             the effects of these
and exercise. Psychological assessment                  ■■ The patient’s:
should include evaluation of mood for signs                - Beliefs about eating, weight gain
of depression or anxiety, ability to cope,                    and physical activity
energy levels and sleep quality.                           - Willingness to change
                                                           - Understanding of the role of diet in
Assessment should also include gaining an                     the management of lipoedema
understanding of the patient’s insight into                   (NICE CG189, 2014).
the condition and their personal goals and
expectations of the components and                      Skin assessment
outcomes of treatment.                                  Skin should be assessed for general condition
                                                        and the effectiveness of personal care. The
Dietary assessment                                      skin of patients with lipoedema is soft and
Many patients with lipoedema have tried                 easily damaged and some patients develop
repeatedly and often unsuccessfully over                ulceration. It is particularly important to
many years to reduce the size of the                    examine any skin folds as these may develop
affected areas through dieting and physical             friction or moisture-related skin damage,
activity or exercise. These efforts may                 and fungal or bacterial infections.

14 BEST PRACTICE STATEMENT: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA
COMPRESSION                                                                                   DIAGNOSIS AND
                                                                                                      ASSESSMENT

Vascular assessment                                  Furthermore, inflation of a cuff around the
Compression therapy is an important                  limb may be very painful for patients with      More information on
element of the management of lipoedema.              lipoedema.                                      the role of ABPI in
Patients with lipoedema should undergo                                                               determining suitability
vascular assessment according to local               Comorbidities                                   for compression
protocol. Significant arterial disease is a          Comorbidities should be identified and          therapy can be found
contraindication to compression therapy              management optimised to minimise impact         in the Wounds UK Best
(Wounds UK, 2015).                                   on patients with lipoedema. Patients with       Practice Statement on
                                                     lipoedema have self-reported the presence       Compression Hosiery,
The vascular assessment should include               of several conditions: fibromyalgia, gluten     which is available at:
consideration of signs, symptoms and                 allergy (coeliac disease), hypothyroidism,      www.wounds-uk.com
risk factors for arterial disease. Doppler           polycystic ovary syndrome, vitamin D
ultrasound to determine ankle-brachial-              deficiency and arthritis (Herbst et al, 2015;
pressure index (ABPI) is a method often used         Smidt, 2015; Williams & MacEwan, 2016).
for vascular assessment. However, tissue             However, evidence of direct links between
enlargement may make it difficult to get an          lipoedema and many of these conditions is
accurate ABPI in patients with lipoedema.            currently very limited.

  Key points
  1.  The diagnosis of lipoedema is made on clinical grounds: there are no diagnostic tests
      for the condition
  2. Lipoedema is a condition that is distinct from lymphoedema
  3. Lipoedema may have a significant impact on a patient’s physical and
      mental health and wellbeing
  4. Patients with lipoedema generally report a history of bilateral symmetrical limb
      enlargement, with sparing of the hands and feet, which is not responsive to dieting.
      They may also report pain, sensitivity to touch and easy bruising, and a family history of
      similar tissue enlargement and shape disproportion
  5. Affected areas of the body may be softer and cooler, with a texture that is dimpled or
      resembles a mattress
  6. The presence of pitting oedema in affected areas indicates lipolymphoedema
  7. Routine blood tests may be useful to exclude or identify other conditions
  8. Imaging investigations are not used routinely
  9. Further work is required to develop a classification/staging system for lipoedema
      that takes into account disease progression along with symptoms such as pain or
      restrictions to mobility
  10. Holistic assessment should include the degree and extent of adipose tissue enlargement,
      presence and level of pain, mobility and gait, psychosocial assessment, dietary
      assessment, skin assessment, vascular assessment and assessment of any comorbidities
  11. Psychosocial assessment is particularly important in people with lipoedema because of
      the long-term nature of the disease and the importance of self-management.

                                                                BEST PRACTICE STATEMENT: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA 15
PRINCIPLES OF                                                                                                    COMPRESSION
    MANAGEMENT

SECTION 3 : PRINCIPLES OF MANAGEMENT
 Box 3. Dos and don’ts of hosiery care

Lipoedema is a long-term condition that
has wide-ranging impacts on the health
and psychosocial wellbeing of patients.                                   Facilitation and enhancement
Consequently, an interprofessional or                                  of the patient’s ability to self-care:
                                                                      including education, healthy lifestyle
multidisciplinary approach to management                            (diet/physical activity/weight reduction)
is often required. However, there is
currently inconsistency and inequity across
the UK in referral patterns and care for
patients with lipoedema.

Patients recognised as possibly having                   Optimisation of health and               Management of symptoms:
lipoedema in a primary care setting may                  prevention of progression:              including mangement of pain,
be referred to a lymphoedema service,                  including weight management,             impaired mobility, oedema and
                                                      compression therapy, treatment                  psychosocial issues
where available, for investigation, diagnosis,           of concomitant conditions
management and co-ordination of care.
However, there is variation throughout the
UK in provision of lymphoedema services,
and some services do not have sufficient
capacity to manage patients with lipoedema.
Where there is no provision of lymphoedema
services, a referral to vascular or plastic      Figure 3: Principles of lipoedema management
surgery services may be appropriate.             In keeping with the NHS goal for
                                                 personalised care for people with long-
Even so, the Expert Working Group                term conditions, clinicians should take a
concluded that lymphoedema services are the      collaborative approach to the management
most appropriate setting for the management      of a patient with lipoedema, providing
of patients with lipoedema, not least because    individualised care plans according to need
of the expertise held within these services      and person-centred treatment goals (NHS
in differentiating the two conditions and in     Outcomes Framework; Coulter et al, 2013;
the use of compression therapy. The Group        WHO, 2004; Woods & Burns, 2009; Welsh
considers that improved recognition of the       Assembly Government, 2007).
disease and appropriate referral patterns
are reliant on enhancing awareness and           The main components of lipoedema
recognition of the disease in primary care       management are:
settings, and in the wider provision of          ■■ Psychosocial support, management of
lipoedema/lymphoedema services.                     expectations and education, including
                                                    family planning, pregnancy advice and
Third sector organisations, such as                 genetic counselling
Lipoedema UK (www.lipoedema.co.uk) and           ■■ Healthy eating and weight management
Talk Lipoedema (www.talklipoedema.org),          ■■ Physical activity and improving mobility
provide help with self-management and are        ■■ Skin care and protection
important sources of peer support.               ■■ Compression therapy
                                                 ■■ Management of pain.
Principles of lipoedema management
The management of lipoedema requires a           Each element needs to be tailored according
holistic approach (Figure 3) that includes:      to the severity of symptoms, degree
■■ Facilitating and enhancing the patient’s      and complexity of tissue enlargement,
   ability to self-care and cope with the        whether there has been progression to
   physical and psychosocial impact of the       lipolymphoedema, and the psychosocial
   condition                                     status of the patient.
■■ Managing symptoms
■■ Optimising health and preventing              Patients with lipoedema may be well
   disease progression.                          informed about their condition and possible

16 BEST PRACTICE STATEMENT: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA
COMPRESSION                                                                                                       PRINCIPLES OF
                                                                                                                      MANAGEMENT

management routes following internet              Table 6. Involvement of the multidisciplinary team in the management of lipoedema
searching and participation in social media.
However, the advice and information found         Indication                                          Clinician/service
may not be necessarily grounded in evidence.      • Tissue enlargement ± oedema                       → Lipoedema/lymphoedema specialist clinician
Individuals may be susceptible to                 • Pain, aching, sensitivity to touch
misinformation and may need help in               • Abnormal gait                                     → Physiotherapist
understanding what is best practice and most      • Muscle weakness
likely to be of benefit based on current          • Joint pain
evidence, and what is not yet clear or may be
                                                  • Mobility problems                                 → Occupational therapist
detrimental. Such discussions require a
                                                  • Difficulty with day-to-day activities
sympathetic, non-judgemental approach to
avoid discouraging or offending individuals in    • Advice and education about weight                 → Dietitian
their efforts to improve their condition.           management, healthy eating, disordered
                                                    eating, nutritional supplements, diabetes
Discussions should also bear in mind that         • Flat feet                                         → Podiatrist
individuals are often very vulnerable and         • Abnormal gait
sensitive after a long journey to diagnosis,      • Unmanageable/chronic pain                         → Pain clinic
which may have included disheartening
                                                  • Concomitant conditions                            → Appropriate specialist service (e.g.
and upsetting comments from healthcare                                                                  vascular service, diabetic clinic,
professionals seen previously.                                                                           psychological services)
                                                  • In carefully selected patients, after non-  → Plastic surgeon
Support and encouragement alongside
                                                     surgical approaches have been implemented: → Bariatric surgeon
working in partnership with the patient
                                                    • Severe tissue enlargement causing
and their carer(s) with careful management
                                                       mobility impairment
of expectations, including sensitive
                                                    • Management of severe obesity
discussions about the life-long nature of the
condition, should underpin the best practice      Patient pathway
management of lipoedema.                          Appendix 2, page 33, summarises the patient pathway through assessment and management

Clinicians specialising in the management         ■■ Reduced likelihood of progression to
                                                     lipolymphoedema                                            Key points
of lipoedema have a key role in providing
                                                  ■■ Where present, reduced severity of                         1.     A multidisciplinary
education and support around a healthy
                                                     lipolymphoedema and reduced risk of                               approach to the
lifestyle, and in implementing and managing
                                                     complications such as cellulitis                                  management
compression therapy. Potential roles for
                                                  ■■ Minimisation of secondary joint                                   of lipoedema is
other members of the multidisciplinary team
                                                     problems, such as knee and hip                                    necessary
are listed in Table 6. It should be noted that
                                                     osteoarthritis                                             2.     Management aims to
referral may not always be available within
                                                  ■■ Minimisation of impact on ability to                              manage symptoms,
the NHS; where available, individual services
                                                     perform daily activities, including work                          to facilitate and
may have specific restrictions and criteria for
                                                  ■■ Enhanced ability to self-care                                     enhance the patient’s
referral. Private referrals may be possible for
                                                  ■■ Improved psychosocial wellbeing.                                  ability to self-care and
patients with sufficient financial resources.
                                                                                                                       optimise health and
Primary care and community-based services
                                                                                                                       to prevent disease
have an important role in supporting and          These effects are also likely to result in wider
                                                                                                                       progression
enabling self-care and ensuring referral when     benefits to the healthcare system including
                                                                                                                3.     The main
appropriate (Todd, 2016).                         an overall reduction in healthcare utilisation
                                                                                                                       components
                                                  due to lipoedema and for obesity-related
                                                                                                                       of lipoedema
Benefits of lipoedema management                  conditions such as diabetes.
                                                                                                                       management are:
Lipoedema is a long-term condition that
                                                                                                                       psychosocial support
is not curable. However, management of            Although there is currently no evidence
                                                                                                                       and education,
lipoedema according to best practice has          that early treatment improves prognosis
                                                                                                                       healthy eating,
the potential to produce benefits including:      in lipoedema, the Expert Working Group
                                                                                                                       weight management,
■■ Reduction in pain                              considers that early diagnosis, intervention
                                                                                                                       physical activity, skin
■■ Improved limb shape                            and initiation of self-care would produce the
                                                                                                                       care, compression
■■ Avoidance of impairment or                     greatest health and economic benefits. As yet,
                                                                                                                       therapy and
   improvement in mobility                        no formal health economic analyses have been
                                                                                                                       management of pain.
■■ Management or avoidance of obesity             done on the impact of lipoedema management.

                                                                BEST PRACTICE STATEMENT: THE MANAGEMENT OF LIPOEDEMA 17
You can also read