Balancing the value of integrated data and privacy in today's data economy - Talei Parker, ABS University Partnership Manager

Page created by Glen Mann
 
CONTINUE READING
Balancing the value of integrated data and privacy in today's data economy - Talei Parker, ABS University Partnership Manager
Balancing the value of integrated
data and privacy in today’s data
economy
Talei Parker, ABS University Partnership Manager
Balancing the value of integrated data and privacy in today's data economy - Talei Parker, ABS University Partnership Manager
The ABS DataLab
Overview
Balancing the value of integrated data and privacy in today's data economy - Talei Parker, ABS University Partnership Manager
ABS DataLab

            Access is only to approved researchers and ABS or government staff

             Files remain in the secure ABS environment

             Analytical information does not include name and address

             All analytical outputs are checked by ABS staff

3
Balancing the value of integrated data and privacy in today's data economy - Talei Parker, ABS University Partnership Manager
Data access and release
    Five Safes Framework

        Safe people        Is the researcher authorised to access and use the data
                           appropriately?
        Safe projects      Is the data to be used for an appropriate purpose?
                           Does the access environment prevent unauthorised
        Safe settings      use?

        Safe data          Has appropriate and sufficient protection been applied
                           to the data?
        Safe output        Are the statistical results non-disclosive?

4
Balancing the value of integrated data and privacy in today's data economy - Talei Parker, ABS University Partnership Manager
MADIP
Overview
Balancing the value of integrated data and privacy in today's data economy - Talei Parker, ABS University Partnership Manager
Overview of MADIP
     The Multi-Agency Data Integration Project (MADIP) is a secure, person based research data asset
     combining information on health, education, government payments, income and taxation,
     employment, and population demographics to create a comprehensive picture of Australia over time..

                                                            MADIP
                                                             •

               MADIP Uses                                                                       •   Nationally important datasets
           •
                                                       Partner Agencies
                                               • Australian Bureau of Statistics
• Answer policy questions
                                               • Australian Taxation Office
• Program evaluation
                                               • Department of Health
• Empirical research on socio-economic
  issues                                       • Department of Social Services

• No identification of individuals             • Department of Education, Skills and

• Used only for statistical and research          Employment
  purposes (never for compliance)
                                               • Services Australia

      MADIP data is securely held by the ABS – access is only made available to approved researchers for approved purposes.
Analytical content and Enduring data in MADIP
                                                                                         What are the outcomes for job seekers who cease
                                                                                         participating in employment services programs in
                                                                                         remote Australia?
                                What is the impact of Paid Parental
                                leave on income shifting and the health
                                and health care use outcomes of
                                Australian women?                                                                                                             What are the impacts of international
                                                                                          Registries           Skilled                                        migration on Australia?
                                                                          Australian    Death Data            Migration
                                                                      Census Longitudinal                      Points
                                                                                                                                 Traveller
                                                                           Dataset                                                 data
                                                     Census of Population
                                                         and Housing                                                                            Client
              Which
              Australians are                                                                                                                information                                 What factors prevent
              most at risk in                                                                                                                                                            Australians from
              heatwave                                                                                                                                                                   completing tertiary
                                                 Social Security                        FAMILIES &                                                                                       education and
              conditions?
                                                  and Related                          HOUSEHOLDS                                                Visa information &                      transitioning to
                                                                                                                    MIGRANTS
                                                  Information                                                                                    citizenship grants                      employment?

                                                                                                                                                           National
                                                   Personal
                                                 Income Tax
                                                                          INCOME &                  MADIP                                                   Health
                                                                          TAXATION                  2006 to 2018/19                                         Survey

                                                   Australian
       What risk and protective factors         Apprenticeships                EDUCATION                                                          Pharmaceutical                       What is the impact of mental
       influence student learning       Incentives Programs & Training                                               HEALTH                      Benefits Schedule                     disorders on students?
       trajectories through school?
                                                    Contracts

                                                           Higher Education                                                                   Medicare
                                                             Information                                                                     Enrolments
                                                            Management                                                                        Database
                                                                System                                                                                                     What factors are important to
                                                                            Australian                                           Medicare                                  consider when targeting
                 What are the benefits of                                                                     Centralised
                 educational attainment?                               Early Development     Survey of                           Benefits                                  interventions in relation to
                                                                                             Disability,       Register                                                    opioid misuse?
                                                                             Census                                              Schedule
                                                                                                              of Medical
                                                                                            Ageing, and
                                                                                                             Practitioners
                                                                                              Carers           Provider
                                                                                                               Directory

                                                                                                                                                 What are the health and social
                                             What are the differences in health care
                                                                                                                                                 outcomes of individuals that
                                             usage of people from culturally and
                                                                                                                                                 have co-morbid mental and
                                             linguistically diverse backgrounds?
                                                                                                                                                 physical health issues?
What research questions can MADIP answer?

 What is the impact of Paid Parental leave    What are the benefits of educational
 on income shifting and the health and        attainment?
 health care use outcomes of Australian
 women?                                       What risk and protective factors
                                              influence student learning trajectories
 What are the impacts of international        through school?
 migration on Australia?

 What are the outcomes for job seekers who    What factors are important to consider
 cease participating in employment services   when targeting interventions in relation
 programs in remote Australia?                to opioid misuse?

                                              What are the differences in health care
 What factors prevent Australians from        usage of people from culturally and
 completing tertiary education and            linguistically diverse backgrounds?
 transitioning to employment?
Case Study:
Helping vulnerable Australians survive heatwaves

• National mortality increases by 2%
  during heatwaves
• Large rural towns have the highest
  elevated risk for heatwave deaths

 See MADIP case studies and visit the MADIP Research Projects for the full list of projects
BLADE
Overview
Business Longitudinal Data Analysis Environment
     The Business Longitudinal Analysis Data Environment (BLADE) is an economic data tool combining tax,
     trade, and intellectual property data with ABS data to provide a better understanding of the Australian
     economy and business performance over time…

           BLADE Uses
           •
                                                       BLADE Partnerships
                                                       •
                                                                                                 Nationally important datasets
                                                                                                 •

• Insights on business performance          • Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS)
  and dynamics                              • Australian Taxation Office (ATO)
• Answer policy questions                   • Department of Industry, Science,
                                              Energy and Resources (DISER)
• Program evaluation                        • IP Australia
                                            • Treasury
• No identification of individuals
                                            • Department of Agriculture, Water
• Not used for compliance (only for
                                              and the Environment (DAWE)
  statistical and research purposes)
                                            • Department of Home Affairs (DHA)

      BLADE data is securely held by the ABS – access is only made available to approved researchers for approved purposes.
Business Longitudinal Analysis Data Environment
                                                                              How does the use of digital
                                                                              technologies vary by sector and
                                                                              by business size?
                                 To what extent is there an                                                                  What is the relationship between
                                 energy productivity gap?                                                                    management capability and firm
                                                                                         Business
                                                                            Private
                                                                                       Characteristics
                                                                                                                             performance?
                                                                          Non-Profit
                                                                                          Survey:
                                                                        Expenditure on
                   Why has the number of                                               Management           ABR
                                                                         Research and
                                                           Energy, Water Development    Capabilities     Indicative
                   entrepreneurs declined?                      and                       Module           Items
                                                            Environment                                                 Intellectual
                                                               Survey                                                    Property
                                                                                                                                                How does trademark use impact the export
                                                    Business                                                           Longitudinal             behaviour and performance of Australian
                                                 Expenditure on                                                       Research Data
                                                  Research and          ABS      SURVEYS        ABR                                             businesses?
 How do the effects of collaborative R&D          Development
 accumulate in the years following R&D                                                                    IP
                                                                                                                            Merchandise
 activity?                                   Survey of Research                       BLADE                                 Imports Data
                                              and Experimental
                                                                                                         TRADE
                                                                                    2001-02 to
                                               Development,
                                                Government                           2018-19                                                     What is the impact of Austrade
                                                                                                                            Merchandise
                                                                                                                            Exports Data
                                                                                                                                                 programs on trade and
       Do manufacturing firms in                   Economic                                                                                      investment?
       Australia have (or develop) a
                                                    Activity                             INCOME AND
                                                    Survey
       productivity advantage?
                                                                                             TAX                        Business
                                                                                                                        Locations
                                                            Business
                                                                                                                          (BL)
                                                          Characteristics
                                                                                                          Business
                                                             Survey
                                                                              Business     Payment        Activity
                                                                            Income Tax    Summaries      Statement
                                                                                (BIT)                       (BAS)                      What are the characteristics of businesses entering
                        What are the pathways for                                           (PAYG)
                                                                                                                                       the tourism industry compared with those leaving
                        farmers experiencing prolonged
                                                                                                                                       the industry?
                        drought?

                                                                  What are the social benefits of Government
                                                                  investment in private R&D by different
                                                                  types of R&D activity?
BLADE research
         Understanding entrepreneurship dynamics in Australia
         Using BLADE microdata to create a better picture of the drivers behind firms’ productivity and performance

BACKGROUND                                                       DATA SOLUTION
• Recent data indicate that:                                     • Enables longitudinal study of business performance, innovation,
 - Australia’s productivity performance has weakened               job creation, competitiveness and productivity
 - Entrepreneurship rates are declining
                                                                 • Firm-level microdata in BLADE presents increased opportunity to
• We need a better understanding of the key drivers of             use empirical economic research to improve policies
  productivity and their impact on industry and firm
                                                                 • Increases the evidence base on productivity-related dynamics,
  performance
                                                                   by analysing the drivers of the decline in entrepreneurship

     OUTCOMES
     • More effective and better targeted policy design, encouraging a productive and efficient Australian economy
     • Practical advice to businesses to develop strategies and practices for growth
BLADE Data Modules
                                        BLADE Taxation Modules
     ABS Survey Data Modules                                              Other Modules
                               BCS
                                              ABSBR
                      EAS             MCM                                        EXPORTS
                                                          BIT
                               BERD                                 IPLORD
                                               BAS
                    PNPERD            GOVER
                                        D                                        IMPORTS
                                                         PAYG
                               Ag
                                                BL
                                      EEH
                                                  •   All datasets can be linked by a common key
                                                  •   Full data item list available upon request

14                                                                                                 25/11/2020
Enhancing BLADE

•   ATO datasets are being updated with 19-20 financial year data. Estimated timeframe is
    April/May 2021.
•   Improved methodology – BLADE logic is being redesigned to facilitate different levels of
    output (ABN level, different linking methods)
•   Quarterly data – Changes in method now allow for quarterly updates for some data
    inputs, this will be phased-in during 2021
•   Work is underway to utilise new data sources such as:
     i.   Single Touch Payroll (at the ABN level)
     ii. Indicative data for agricultural businesses
     iii. Survey of Employee Earnings & Hours

A range of other Federal and State agencies are currently being engaged for inclusion of
additional data into the BLADE asset
Integrated Person and Business Data

•   ABS has enabled the integration of some BLADE datasets with information about
    employer characteristics to employee data within the
    Multi-Agency Data Integration Project (MADIP) asset over time

•   Business and person-level data are brought together via the ABN of a person's
    employer, where this is recorded on a MADIP dataset

•   BLADE data linked with MADIP is limited to BLADE Core and the Business
    Characteristics Survey (BSC) with limitations on the use of BCS and Business
    Income Tax to the creation of flags

•   Standard governance arrangements apply and costs are subject to project
    technical assessment by ABS
Keeping data safe

           We have many protections in place to keep your data safe, including:

                   Separation       Data         Data       Safe access:      Data
     Legislation                                                            security
                    principle    minimisation   storage    the Five Safes

                    Functional
                    separation

17
Legislation
                       The Census and
                        Statistics Act
                            1905                                                   • Data collection, use, and disclosure is authorised by
                                                                 The Privacy Act     law
     Information cannot be released in a manner likely to             1988         • There are protections for data against unauthorised
          enable the identification of individuals and                               access and disclosure, or loss.
                        organisations
    • ABS and seconded officers are legally bound to
      uphold the confidentiality of MADIP information.

    • The MADIP is collected under this Act, which requires                        • Each agency is authorised by law to collect personal
      the ABS to publish and disseminate compilations and        Other agencies’     information as part of its core functions, to share that
      analyses of statistical information and to maintain          legislation       information with the ABS for MADIP in order to use it
      the confidentiality of information collected                                   for policy analysis, research, and statistical purposes.

When passed, this  Act Sharing
                 Data  will:     and Release Act
• Promote   better  sharing  of public sector data Future Data                     • Strong security arrangements for all IT systems:
         https://www.pmc.gov.au/public-data/data-                  Australian
• Build trust in use of public data                Sharing and                       Australian Government Information Security Manual
                  sharing-and-release-reforms                     Government
• Dial up or down appropriate safeguards           Release Act                     • Strict control of access to premises: Commonwealth
                                                                   standards
• Maintain integrity of the data system and        (DS&R Act)                        Protective Security Manual
• Establish institutional arrangements.
 18
The separation principle

                   SEPARATE                                       SEPARATE                                      SEPARATE
                   TRANSFER                                       STORAGE                                        ACCESS

                                                                                               No-one can access both personal identifiers and
     Receipt of analytical information and               Personal identifiers are stored
                                                                                                   analytical information at the same time.
     personal identifiers is in separate files          securely and separately from the
               at separate times.                            analytical information.           Each person working on the project is assigned a
                                                                                               role, and is only able to access the information
                                                                                                       necessary to perform that role.

                                                                                       Analytical information
                                                                                     Such as:
                                         Personal identifiers                          • Occupation
                                     Such as:                                          • Income
                                       • Name                                          • Health services use
                                       • Address
                                                                                       • Types of Government
                                       • Date of birth
                                                                                          payments
19
Functional separation

                               A person working on a project can only hold one role at a time.

         This means that personal information and analytical information cannot be accessed at the same
           time, and no person can ever see all of your information together at any point in the process.

             Librarian                       Linker                     Assembler                       Analyst

     The Librarian prepares             The Linker links          The Assembler creates          The Analyst analyses
     information for linkage         information together            files for analysis           linked information

                                                                                                  Only accesses data
                                                                                                    without direct
                                                                                                      identifiers
20
MADIP data linkage, assembly and storage
              Separate datasets are able to be brought together for specific projects
     Source datasets (analytical data)   Person Linkage Spine             Project analytical datasets

                                               Linkage
                                               results

        SEPARATE STORAGE                    Mechanism for       Assembly of analytical   Access to analytical data in
         of analytical data                    linkage                 data                     ABS DataLab
21
MADIP data security

                                                  Clear accountabilities                Secured internet
                                                  and risk management                   gateway
                                                  processes                                                Data supply via
               Regular independent                                               Assessed under the        secure transfer
               reviews of security                                               Information Security      methods (e.g.
               arrangements and an                                               Registered Assessors      Secure Deposit
               ongoing program of                                                Program (IRAP)            Box)
                                          Logging and monitoring of
               security audits
                                          access and use of
                                          information
     IT security arrangements                                               Information is only
     that conform with                                                      combined in a secure
     government standards for                                               environment within the
     information security (the                                              ABS, by a dedicated team
     Australian Government           Staff security checks and restricted
     Information Security            access to data
     Manual)
22
Data Availability and Transparency Act
Permitted Purposes

24                        25/11/2020
Layers of Defence

25                       25/11/2020
Questions?
You can also read