Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners

Page created by Derek Crawford
 
CONTINUE READING
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
Art Lending
             Presentation    FundforLLC
                          prepared      (ALF)Lynch
                                      Merrill
            Fine Art-Secured Lending

December 2019
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
Important Disclosures

                         This presentation is for discussion purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer
                         to buy an interest in Art Lending Fund LLC (“ALF”). Any offer to sell or solicitation of an offer to buy an interest in
                         ALF may be made only by the delivery of ALF’s Confidential Private Placement Memorandum (the “Memorandum”)
                         specifically addressed to the recipient thereof. In the event that the terms of this document and the Memorandum
                         are conflicting, the Memorandum’s terms shall control. You must be an “accredited investor” to receive a copy of the
                         Memorandum, but only investors that meet all of ALF’s investor suitability requirements will be allowed to invest.

                         The limited liability company membership interests in ALF are speculative securities and their purchase involves a high
                         degree of risk. You should consider all risk factors set forth in the Memorandum before investing in ALF. Specifically, you
                         should be aware that:

                                  •       ALF may rely on its third-party loan originators, advisory board and sub-managers (if any) to meet
                                          its investment objectives.
                                  •       You could lose a substantial portion, or even all, of your investment.
                                  •       Tax-exempt investors should consult their tax, legal and financial advisers regarding the specific tax
                                          consideration of an investment in ALF.
                                  •
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                          Withdrawals and transfers are restricted; no market exists or is expected to exist for the limited
                                          liability company membership interests.
                                  •       ALF is not a mutual fund and is not subject to regulation under the Investment Company Act of 1940,
                                          as amended.

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                    Shinnecock Partners   1
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
The Opportunity

                         ALF is an institutional-grade, diversified portfolio of loans secured by fine art from
                           a mix of artists, genres, and media, providing investors multiple advantages.

                                                             Attractive & Consistent Yield
                                                                       Principal Protection
                                                           Uniquely Appealing Collateral
                                                              Strong Collateral Protection
                                                                Immediate Diversification
                                                                             Short Duration
                                                       Presentation
                                                              Liquidity prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                                         Tax-Advantaged Legal Structure
                                                   Institutional-Grade Service Providers
                                                                                                                        Constantin Brancusi             Simon Hantaï
                                                                                                                      Une Muse, 2016 (front)             Blancs (back)

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                            Shinnecock Partners       2
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
What is Fine Art-Secured Lending?

                                                                                  Fine art-secured lending is hard asset lending against
                                                                                  museum-quality, auction-worthy art. (e.g. Sotheby’s,
                                                                                  Christie’s, Phillips, Bonhams)

                                                                                  Art dealers and collectors borrow against their art to:
                                                                                                    Fund art acquisitions/finance dealer inventory
                                                                                                    Pursue other opportunities

                                                                                  Taking out a loan instead of selling individual artworks
                                                                                  allows borrowers to:
                                                                                                    Avoid taxes and transaction fees associated with sales
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch      Retain ownership and any appreciation in value

                         Georgia O’Keeffe
                         Black Mesa Landscape, New Mexico / Out Back of Marie's II, 1930

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                            Shinnecock Partners   3
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
A Vibrant and Growing Market

                        High Growth
                                          Global art sales were $67.4 billion in 2018, 6%
                                          increase over the previous year.1
                                          Outstanding art-secured loans: $21 - $24 billion
                                          in 2019, up from $17 - $20 billion in 2017.2
                                          Loans to art dealers and galleries represent 8% - 10%
                                          of the total.2
                        Capital Short
                                          Room for further growth: 87% of art dealers are
                                          searching for acquisition finance, and 28% claim
                                          lack of credit has hampered growth.3
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                          69% of collectors surveyed in 2019 were interested in
                                          using their art as collateral for loans, up from 57% in
                                          2017.2
                        1 McAndrew,  Clare. The Art Market 2019. Art Basel and UBS.
                        2 DeloitteTouche Tohmatsu Limited, and ArtTactic. Art & Finance Report 2019.
                        3 The European Fine Art Foundation. Art Dealer Finance 2018.
                                                                                                                                      Henri Matisse
                                                                                                                      Olive Trees at Collioure, 1906

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.       Shinnecock Partners          4
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
Boutique Lender Advantages

                                                      Competitive edge over private banks and auction houses
                                        Speed                                    Complete the loan process and provide funds in a short timeframe

                                     Flexibility                                 Tailor each loan to the borrower’s specific needs

                                                                                 Leverage experience and relationships in the fine art market for market
                                      Insights                                   insights, valuation expertise, and advisory services
                                                                                 Allow the borrower to remain independent from auction houses
                              Independence                                       and banking relationships

                        Lender Market Shares:
                               Private Banks (81% of market)
                                          Loans underwritten based on overall creditworthiness of the
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                          borrower and his/her relationship with the bank.
                                          Auction Houses (8% of market)
                                          Loans underwritten based on the art, but may require the purchase
                                          of other services provided by the auction house.
                                          Boutique Lenders (11% of market)1
                                                                                                                                                   Fernando Botero
                        1 Deloitte   Touche Tohmatsu Limited, and ArtTactic. Art & Finance Report 2016.                                                     Pájaro

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                          Shinnecock Partners     5
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
ALF Investor Benefits

                               Attractive &                                                    7% - 8% net unlevered return
                              Consistent Yield                                                 Prepaid interest

                                                                                               Asset-weighted average duration of six to nine months
                               Short Duration                                                  for seasoned portfolio
                                                                                               Interest rate flexibility from frequent reinvestment rollovers

                                                                                               Low loan-to-value ratio (“LTV”) of 50% safeguards against risk
                                       Principal                                               of collateral price declines
                                      Protection                                               Additional backstop in the form of a personal or
                                                                                               corporate guarantee

                                                       Presentation  prepared
                                                                 Appreciating collateral:for  Merrill
                                                                                          8% annual
                                                                 Moses Art Index from 1965 – 2017
                                                                                                    growth inLynch
                                                                                                              the Sotheby’s Mei
                            Uniquely
                                                                                               Global asset: transportable, reflecting currency
                        Appealing Collateral                                                   depreciation/appreciation
                                                                                               Low correlation to equities and global interest rates

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                Shinnecock Partners   6
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
ALF Investor Benefits

                                                                                              First-priority security interest
                            Strong Collateral                                                 Possession of the collateral: art is stored in a facility controlled
                               Protection                                                     by lender
                                                                                              Insured for the loan amount, at a minimum

                                 Immediate                                                    Multiple artists, genres, and media
                                Diversification                                               Multiple borrowers

                                        Liquidity                                             Short duration loans offer true liquidity

                                      Presentation
                             Tax-Advantaged                                                               prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                                                                              100% deductible investment expenses
                                                                                              Tax-qualified investors enjoy no UBTI
                             Legal Structure                                                  Offshore investors benefit from no ECI or offshore feeder
                                                                                              expenses

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                  Shinnecock Partners   7
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
Thorough Investment Process

                                                                         Underwrite the art against our detailed criteria
                              Collateral                                 Complete the valuation using past sales prices, recent sales prices of comparable works,
                              Evaluation                                 and insights from outside appraisers, valuation experts, and advisory board

                                                                         Review available records and historical documents
                             Provenance                                  Engage advisory board and independent experts for counsel on provenance concerns
                              Research                                   Search the Art Loss Register and the FBI’s National Stolen Art File (NSAF)

                                                                         Search public records for liens, judgements, and bankruptcies
                              Borrower                                   Perform credit and background checks
                             Assessment

                                                       Presentation           prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                                           Negotiate loan terms
                                                           Verify existence and extent of insurance coverage
                            Documents                                    File a UCC Financing Statement and secure storage for the art
                            and Funding                                  Execute loan documents and remit funds to the borrower

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                              Shinnecock Partners   8
Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch - December 2019 - Shinnecock Partners
Compelling Value Proposition

                             Investment                                                Rising Rate                    Downside                  Correlation to
                                                               Yield                                                                Liquidity                     Volatility
                                Type                                                   Protection                     Protection                   Market

                                   ALF                         High                          Yes                         Yes       Moderate         Low             Low

                            High-Yield
                              Bonds                            High                          No                       Moderate     Moderate     Moderate         Moderate

                                 REITs                   Moderate                        Maybe                           No          High       Moderate           High

                                 MLPs                          High                          No                          No          High       Moderate           High

                          Closed-End
                          Bond Funds                           High                          No                          No          High           Low            High

                                 BDCs                  Presentation
                                                         High    No prepared
                                                                        No   for
                                                                               HighMerrill  Lynch
                                                                                      Moderate  High

                              Income
                             Property                    Moderate                        Maybe                           No          Low            Low            Low

                        Investment time horizon and the relative importance of each characteristic is investor determined. This chart is meant to be a generalized view.

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                              Shinnecock Partners   9
Uncommon Principal Protection

                        Portfolio LTV Example

                         Value of                                                                        In case of default, a low loan-to-value ratio helps to:
                        Collateral
                                                                                                               Protect against changes in collateral value

                                                                 50                                            Cover default interest owed
                                                                 %                                             Absorb fees and expenses associated with selling the art,
                                                                                                               including sales commissions that may be shared with ALF
                          Loan                                                                                 Allow the collateral to be sold at a reduced price to
                         Amount*                                                                               facilitate a quick sale, if preferable

                                                                 50
                                                                 %
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch

                        * Actual exposure is lower given any prepaid interest.
                        If portfolio collateral value decline matched the worst annual loss of the Sotheby’s Mei Moses Index since 1980
                        (next slide), a portfolio loan buffer of 50% would decline to 24.5% yet remain substantial

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                           Shinnecock Partners   10
Historical Principal Protection

                                                                                                Art Index Annual Returns1
                        60%
                                                                                                                                 24 of 37 Years Positive
                        50%
                                                                                                                             Compound Annual Return: 5.6%
                        40%

                        30%

                        20%

                        10%

                          0%

                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                       -10%

                       -20%
                                                                           1990                                                    2008
                                                                          –25.5%                                                  –21.9%
                       -30%
                                1980                       1985                      1990                      1995   2000      2005        2010           2015

                        1 Sotheby’s    Mei Moses Art Index, calendar years

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                Shinnecock Partners   11
Art’s Correlation with Other Asset Classes

                                                   DM eq              EM eq                      IG               HY         EM     Cash     HF       PE      RE Commod             Art

Developed Equities                                           1             0.69               0.25              0.72        0.31    0.13    0.78    0.84    0.61        0.19       0.13

Emerging Market Equities                                0.69                    1           -0.04               0.62        0.54    0.08    0.66    0.74    0.55        0.47       0.14

Invt. Grade Fixed Income                                0.25              -0.04                    1            0.32        0.10    0.34    0.45    0.14    0.28       -0.23       -0.15

High Yield Fixed Income                                 0.72               0.62               0.32                      1   0.45    -0.13   0.71    0.78    0.66        0.21       -0.37

Emerging Fixed Income                                   0.31               0.54               0.10              0.45           1    -0.06   0.46    0.43    0.53        0.57       -0.03

Cash                                                    0.13               0.08               0.34             -0.13        -0.06      1    0.43    -0.14   -0.16       0.05       0.34

Hedge Funds                                             0.78               0.66               0.45              0.71        0.46    0.43       1    0.71    0.49        0.27       -0.11

Private Equity                                          0.84               0.74               0.14              0.78        0.43    -0.14   0.71       1    0.75        0.21       -0.08

Real Estate                                             0.61               0.55               0.28              0.66        0.53    -0.16   0.49    0.75       1        0.14       0.01

Commodities
                                                         Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                                        0.19               0.47             -0.23               0.21        0.57    0.05    0.27    0.21    0.14           1       0.21

Art                                                     0.13               0.14             -0.15              -0.37        -0.03   0.34    -0.11   -0.08   0.01        0.21          1

Source: Citi Private Bank Global Asset Allocation Team, as of 31 Oct 2018. Art represented by the Masterworks.io Total Art, Contemporary Art ,and
Impressionist Art Indices © 2019 Masterworks.io LLC; All rights reserved. Indices revised as of November 2019

  Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                        Shinnecock Partners     12
ALF Tax-Efficient Structure

                                                                                                          Taxable, Tax-Exempt & Offshore Investors
                                                                                                                 (Including Shinnecock Income Fund L.P.)

                                           Investment                                                                     Art Lending Fund LLC
                                          Manager & GP                                                  Feeder Fund (Delaware Limited Liability Company)

                                                                                                            Cash to Purchase
                 Shinnecock                                                                                                                  Interest +
                                                                                                            Debt + Equity of
                 Partners L.P.                                                                                                               Dividends
                                                                                                              Master Fund

                                              Investment
                                               Manager                                                                       Art Lending, Inc.
                                                                                                                      Master Fund (Nevada Corporation)

                                                       Presentation
                                                         (Max. 1/3 of   prepared
                                                                      Cash      Principal Merrill
                                                                                 for
                                                                                   Loan
                                                                                          + Collateral Lynch
                                                                                                        Financial
                                                                                                       Guarantee
           Potential Leverage                                       Capital)                                                      Interest
               Provider

                                                                                                                                Borrowers

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                        Shinnecock Partners   13
30 Months of Strong Historical Performance

      This art-secured lending strategy was incubated for 22 months in our Shinnecock Income Fund
                                   prior to the launch of ALF in May 2019

Pro forma art-secured lending returns from the incubation period shown in blue                                                                    ALF actual returns shown in black

                     Jan            Feb             Mar             Apr            May              Jun               Jul    Aug    Sep    Oct      Nov     Dec       YTD      CAGR
   2017                 -              -               -               -               -               -              0.7%   1.4%   0.7%   0.7%    0.7%     0.7%      5.0%      10.2%

   2018             0.7%            0.6%            0.7%           0.7%            0.7%            0.6%               0.7%   0.7%   0.7%   0.7%    0.5%     0.6%      8.2%      8.2%

   2019             0.6%            0.5%            0.6%           0.6%            0.3%            0.4%               0.6%   0.6%   0.6%   0.6%    0.6%     0.6%      6.6%      6.6%

Pro forma returns from the incubation period
Shinnecock Income Fund L.P. (“SIF”), a fund managed by the same general partner as ALF, began investing in art-secured loans in July 2017. Pro
forma returns shown were calculated by deducting estimated ALF expenses (1% annual), a 1% annual management fee and a 10% incentive fee
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
from the actual gross returns of the art-secured loans held by SIF. For loans that were made after the first day of the month, or exited prior to the
last day of the month, the return for that loan was adjusted to reflect the expected return that would have been achieved for the entire monthly
period. SIF transferred its art-secured loans to ALF at ALF’s launch and became an LLC member with no special liquidity provision (SIF has ceased
making any direct art-secured loans).
Because SIF is already a widely diversified alternative-lending portfolio, its art-secured lending allocation was more concentrated than ALF’s
portfolio diversification guidelines of no more than 15% to any borrower or artist. August 2017 performance was an outlier due to the collection of
a prepayment penalty. Because the pro forma returns reflect the performance of the SIF art-secured loan portfolio as a whole, and because partial-
month loan returns are adjusted to reflect full-month returns, the pro forma performance shown does not reflect the actual or theoretical impact of
any uninvested portions of the portfolio (i.e., “cash drag”). SIF is audited annually by Deloitte & Touche.

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                               Shinnecock Partners   14
Portfolio Overview (December 31, 2019)

                                Collateral spanning antiquities, old masters, contemporary, and modern artworks
                                                            (paintings and sculptures)

                           Gross Yield                                      10.3%
                              (Incl. Cash)

                              Duration                               5.0 months

                                     LTV                                       41%

                        Insured Value                                $39 million

                            Number ofPresentation                                                         prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                           37
                             Artworks
                     Yield, LTV and duration are calculated on a weighted-average basis. The LTV is calculated based on the total loan amount
                     before interest is deducted from the loan proceeds. In addition, the loan amount used for calculating the LTV is the total
                     senior loan amount even if ALF only holds a fractional interest in the senior loan.

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                    Shinnecock Partners   15
Investment Terms and Service Providers

                                Launch Date                                                                           5/1/2019
                                Structure                                                                             Delaware limited liability company

                                Target Net Return                                                                     7% - 8% (unlevered)

                                Management Fee                                                                        1%
                                Incentive Fee                                                                         10%, subject to a high water mark
                                Minimum Capital Commitment                                                            $100,000*

                                Redemptions                                                                           Quarterly after one-year lock, with 90 days’ notice

                                Investor Qualifications                                                               Accredited Investor/Qualified Client
                                Auditor                                                                               Deloitte & Touche LLP
                                Administrator                                                                         SS&C GlobeOp
                                Cash Custodian         Presentation prepared      forBankMerrill Lynch
                                                                        First Republic
                                General Counsel                                                                       Faegre Baker Daniels LLP / Buchalter PC / Paul Hastings LLP

                        *ALF uses a capital call structure in order to balance cash inflows against investible loans and other cash needs. ALF may call any portion of an
                        investor’s capital commitment at any time with reasonable prior notice within six months of the initial commitment date. If after six months the total
                        amount committed has not been called, the remaining commitment amount is released.

                        Available to taxable, tax deferred and tax-exempt investors

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                             Shinnecock Partners   16
Shinnecock’s Edge

                        Over 30 years successfully managing money
                        with a focus on niche strategies
                        Advisory board providing sophisticated
                        counsel on art-related matters
                                          Members offer insights on collateral pricing,
                                          sourcing, deal structure, and overall investment
                                          management assistance
                                          Biographies of the advisory board members can be found in the appendix

                        Direct loan sourcing from our www.ArtLending.com
                        Skin in the game: largest individual investors in what we do
                                    Presentation
                        Intense, transparent           prepared
                                             due diligence           for Merrill Lynch
                                                           process (www.shinnecock.com)
                        Team of dedicated professionals
                        Institutional-quality outside service providers
                                                                                                                       Museo Picasso Málaga
                                                                                                                      Málaga, Andalucia, Spain

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.   Shinnecock Partners        17
APPENDIX

                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.   Shinnecock Partners   18
Case Study

Transaction:                                                                                                          Result:
One of the largest dealers of Western American Art                                                                    While the collateral was stored in our warehouse and
purchased Abstraction, a sculpture by Georgia                                                                         insured at the borrower’s expense, the art dealer
O’Keeffe, after recognizing that it was underpriced.                                                                  continued to market the sculpture along with the rest
Seeking to finance the purchase of additional art                                                                     of the art remaining in their gallery.
(inventory), the dealer sought out a loan backed by
                                                                                                                      The dealer found an art collector who was eager to
this sculpture.
                                                                                                                      purchase Abstraction less than six weeks after the
After completing our thorough pre-investment                                                                          start date of the loan. The dealer requested that we
process (Appendix A of the FAQ), we elected to                                                                        unwind the loan and return the sculpture. Because
extend a loan with the following terms:                                                                               the buyer was willing to pay significantly more than
                                                                                                                      the dealer’s original purchase price, the dealer was
   Term:                                       One Year
                                                                                                                      willing to pay four months’ interest as a prepayment
   Interest Rate:                              11.11% cash-on-cash return                                             penalty.
   Collateral                                  $1,500,000 (third-party                                                As a result of the prepayment penalty, Shinnecock
   Valuation:                                  appraisal)                                                             Income Fund (SIF) earned 3.7% on its original

   Loan Amount:                                $825,000
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch                        investment in 41 days.

   Loan-to-Value
                                               55%
   (LTV):

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                                       Shinnecock Partners   19
Susan Ginsburg – Advisory Board Member

                                                                             Ms. Ginsburg has been an advisor to and curator at numerous art galleries,
                                                                             museums and collections. As an art historian, she has been a member of the
                                                                             faculty of multiple institutions and authored or edited a number of
                                                                             publications.
                                                                             Susan earned her MA in Art History from the University of California, Los
                                                                             Angeles. She went on to earn a Ph.D. in Art History from The Graduate Center
                                                                             of City University of New York, specializing in modern European and American
                                                                             art. For her dissertation, Ms. Ginsburg compiled and produced a
                                                                             comprehensive catalogue raisonné of works by Robert Rauschenberg.
                                                                             Ms. Ginsburg has been a member of the faculty of the art history departments
                                                                             of Hunter College of City University of New York, Fordham University, the State
                                                                             University of New York at Purchase, and the University of California, Los
                                                                             Angeles. Susan is currently a member of the faculty of the School of Visual Arts
                                                                             in New York, where she has held various roles since 1974.
                                                                             Concurrently, Ms. Ginsburg has had an extensive professional career. She was
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                                                             curator for the New York Cultural Center and for works by Robert
                                                                             Rauschenberg at the Smithsonian Museum of American Art and the Museum
                                                                             of Modern Art. From 1981 to 2010, Ms. Ginsburg served as an advisor and
                                                                             curator for the Jerrold Perenchio Art Collection, which is now part of the Los
                                                                             Angeles County Museum of Art. Since 1999, Susan has been the curator and
                                                                             advisor for the Paul Fireman Art Collection.

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                         Shinnecock Partners   20
Amanda Langer – Advisory Board Member

                                                                             Ms. Langer currently works as an exhibitions coordinator for Dietl International
                                                                             Services in New York, where she sources and executes fine art packing and
                                                                             transportation solutions for public and private clients. Previously, Amanda
                                                                             served as a project manager with Atelier 4 Inc., where she organized the
                                                                             successful shipment of high value artworks domestically and internationally. As
                                                                             a Design & Decorative Arts Appraisal Assistant with Doyle New York, Amanda
                                                                             evaluated all Furniture & Decorative Arts Department property consignment
                                                                             submissions and worked to create all department sale catalogues
                                                                             and auction marketing materials.

                                                                             Amanda earned her MA in History of Art & Art Market Modern &
                                                                             Contemporary from Christie’s Education in New York. She earned her BA in
                                                                             History of Art from Union College.

                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                         Shinnecock Partners   21
Andrew C. Rose – Advisory Board Member

                         Mr. Rose has over 30 years’ experience in the fine art industry, including time at major auction houses
                         such as Sotheby’s and Christie’s and as an asset-based lender at Citibank, Chase Manhattan and
                         The Boston Company. Andrew has originated over 500 art-secured loans ($1 billion+ total) with no
                         losses of principal or interest. Currently, Andrew manages Art Finance Partners (“AFP”), an art-secured
                         loan originator and consultancy operating out of New York which he founded in 2005. AFP is an
                         experienced but capital-constrained non-bank originator that can provide deal flow for ALF.

                         Andrew brings a wide network of contacts within the art market (galleries, dealers, auction houses,
                         private collectors) which can help confirm valuations and if necessary rapidly find buyers for collateral
                         in default situations.

                         Before entering the art world, Andrew graduated from Princeton University with a BA in Economics.

                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.   Shinnecock Partners   22
Chase W. Rynd – Advisory Board Member

                                                                             Mr. Rynd has served as executive director of the National Building Museum
                                                                             since 2003. Created by Congress in 1980, the National Building Museum
                                                                             commemorates American achievements in architecture, design, construction,
                                                                             urban planning, and engineering. The Museum has achieved a strong national
                                                                             profile through enhanced educational programs, scholarly and visually
                                                                             engaging exhibitions, and numerous outreach efforts. Prior to his work at the
                                                                             National Building Museum, Chase was appointed executive director of the
                                                                             Tacoma Art Museum in 1993, and to the same position at the Frist Center for
                                                                             the Visual Arts in Nashville, Tennessee in 1998.
                                                                             Mr. Rynd was appointed by the mayor to the Seattle Arts Commission in 1988,
                                                                             and served two consecutive terms as the Commission’s chairman. In 1990,
                                                                             Security Pacific Bank recruited Chase to develop a public gallery space that
                                                                             would serve the community with a series of contemporary art exhibitions and
                                                                             programs designed to enhance the city’s arts environment.
                                                                             A graduate of Georgetown University and active in the museum community,
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                                                             Mr. Rynd is a member of the International Council of Museums and American
                                                                             Alliance of Museums. He sits on the Boards of the Association of Architecture
                                                                             Organizations (AAO), American Friends of Chantilly, France; the Downtown DC
                                                                             BID; Penn Quarter Neighborhood Association; and the Havana Heritage
                                                                             Foundation. He also is a member of ACE Mentor Program’s National Advisory
                                                                             Board; the ASCE Industry Leaders Council and serves on committees for St.
                                                                             John’s Lafayette Square and the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C.

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                        Shinnecock Partners   23
David Paul Steiner – Advisory Board Member

                                                                             Mr. Steiner, principal of David Steiner & Associates PLC, has earned a national
                                                                             reputation as a trusted advisor and counselor in art law and art litigation
                                                                             matters. David did his undergraduate work at Stanford University, graduating
                                                                             Cum Laude. He went to law school at the University of California Hastings
                                                                             College of the Law, where he founded and was Editor in Chief of the Hastings
                                                                             Constitutional Law Quarterly. Mr. Steiner has practiced art law since 1981.
                                                                             David has lectured widely on art law subjects, both in the United States and in
                                                                             Europe, also writing for various magazines and participating in various
                                                                             symposia. Mr. Steiner co-edited The Visual Artist Manual, the first of its kind,
                                                                             which was published in 1981. He also has served as an adjunct professor at
                                                                             University of Southern California Law Center, teaching a class in art law. David's
                                                                             practice has included art lending matters, large private mandate transactions,
                                                                             multiple cases including authenticity of works, auction issues, representation
                                                                             of important artists' estates and committees (e.g., Degas), art insurance issues
                                                                             and cross border transactions.
                                                       Presentation        prepared
                                                            Although his firm                 for
                                                                              specializes in art      Merrill
                                                                                                 law and art litigationLynch
                                                                                                                       matters, it also pursues
                                                            practice areas involving complex business litigation in both State and Federal
                                                                             Courts, intellectual property litigation, and Internet transactions and Internet
                                                                             litigation, and enjoys a specialization in credit card processing litigation. Mr.
                                                                             Steiner, who is a former President of the Beverly Hills Bar Association
                                                                             Barristers, is admitted to practice in the States of California and Colorado. He
                                                                             has been admitted Pro Hac Vice in many states.

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                            Shinnecock Partners   24
Alan Snyder – Founder, CIO
                       43 years of experience in finance and investments

                                                                             Alan Snyder founded Shinnecock Partners in 1988 and serves as its
                                                                             Managing Partner. Alan spent 14 years at Dean Witter (now Morgan Stanley)
                                                                             and finished his career there as an Executive Vice President, Board Member
                                                                             and Executive Committee Member. He formulated the launch of the Discover
                                                                             Card as a member of a three-person management team. Subsequently,
                                                                             he restructured First Executive/Executive Life, a $20 billion life insurance
                                                                             holding company including a $1.5 billion alternatives portfolio, as President
                                                                             and Chief Operating Officer. He was later appointed as Executive-in-Charge by
                                                                             the California State Insurance Commissioner. He has served as a special advisor
                                                                             to Goldman Sachs and Kelso Partners.
                                                                             He founded and was Chairman, President and CEO of Answer Financial, which
                                                                             became the largest independent seller of auto and home insurance in the
                                                                             U.S. Answer was sold to Esurance, who sought its technology and third-party
                                                                             distribution and was more recently purchased by Allstate.
                                                                             Harvard Business School (Baker Scholar, MBA) and Georgetown University
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                                                             (Wall Street Journal Scholar, BSBA). Former Chairman and President of the
                                                                             Western Los Angeles County Council of the Boys Scouts of America.

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.                        Shinnecock Partners   25
Conclusion

                         Art-secured lending is a compelling yield investment, pairing attractive returns
                         with exceptional principal protection. It offers an uncorrelated complement to
                                                a diversified investment portfolio.

                                                              Visit our website, www.Shinnecock.com, for more
                                                              detailed information regarding Art Lending Fund:

                                                                       • Summary Sheet

                                                                       • Overview Presentation

                                                                       • Frequently Asked Questions
                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch
                                                                       • White Paper “Creative Collateral: Lending
                                                                         Against Fine Art”

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.   Shinnecock Partners   26
Founded 1988

                                                       Presentation prepared for Merrill Lynch

Copyright © 2019 Shinnecock Partners L.P. All rights reserved. For exclusive use by clients of Shinnecock Partners.       Shinnecock Partners   27
You can also read