Advertisement and Emotions - Emotional Journey as an Indicator of Advertising Effectiveness
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Advertisement and Emotions Emotional Journey as an Indicator of Advertising Effectiveness Complete Report – June 2016
Table of Content 1• Research Overview 3 2• Emotional Results 7 3• Survey Results 20 4• Conclusion 26 5• Annexes 32 2
While Advertisers Are Less Interested in Television, Pre-Roll Ad Format is Trending. In 2017, online ad spending will surpass TV in the United States for the first time.1 If this trend continues, it will be larger by over 10% in 2020. Video ads are more popular than ever as online consumers are getting used to static banner ads. This “banner blindness” cannot be ignored by advertisers. Many are now focusing their energy on pre-roll advertising2, short video commercials that typically appear before free online content (e.g., video). United States TV Digital Ad Spending as a Percent of Total Media Ad Spending, 2014-2020 Pre-roll is the type of digital display ads 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 with the second best TV 39% 38% 37% 36% 35% 34% 33% clickthrough rate (0,52%) in North Web3 28% 33% 36% 38% 41% 43% 45% America, right after mobile banners.4 1 eMarketer (2016). “US TV Digital Ad Spending as a Percent of Total Media Ad Spending, 2014-2020” 2 Often referred to as “in-stream” video ad format, and appears before YouTube videos. 3 Includes advertising on computers, smartphones and other smart devices. 4 eMarketer (2014). “CTR for Digital Display Ads in Select Countries/Regions, 2014” 4
Advertising Effectiveness of 10 Video Ads in a Pre-Roll Format Considering the current popularity of pre-roll advertising, we chose 10 video ads from various industries and assessed their performance. Most are 15-second ads1 and short enough to be presented before online content. Click to watch the ads.2 Toyota : Une vraie bonne raison #32 – Le petit chien RE/MAX : André Sauvé et émotif avec un courtier Kijiji : Ok va donc sur Kijiji, y’a des vieux chars pis des neufs Banque nationale : Réalisez que le temps passe vite – Cheveux blancs St-Hubert : Sugar Sammy aime la variété Proprio Direct : Yves P. Pelletier présente l’offre Proprio Direct Desjardins : Offre verte – un toit vert et un toit noir Honda : Honda Pièces et Service – Rendez-vous Nutrilait : Un pêché mignon et enfant Aldo : Place à l’inspiration – Hiver 2015 1 Aldo’s ad is a 30-second one. 2 5 The links point to the French versions of the ads used in our survey.
imarklab and Leger Studied the Emotional Response to Video Advertising. To collect consumers’ impression toward the ads, imarklab and Leger conducted an online survey from April 4th to 11th 2016 with a sample of 200 consumers 18 years or older. The sample was split into two groups that each viewed five of the ten ads before answering a series of questions on each ad. Results were weighted based on demographic profile to allow for comparison between groups1. In a second phase, the same respondents received an invitation to an aided brand recall survey between 5 and 10 days after viewing the ads to see if they could recognize the brands they saw. During the viewing of each ad, facial expressions were captured with a webcam to be analyzed by FaceReader software2. + + 1 For a detailed profile or respondents, refer to Annex 1. 2 6 To learn more about facial expressions analysis, refer to Annex 2.
Two Types of Emotional Data Emotional Summary Emotional Journey 0.25 Neutral 0.15 Happy Sad 0.05 Angry Surprised 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Scared -0.05 (Seconds) Disgusted -0.15 Refers to the average proportion of each of the Refers to the positive or negative variation of the six basic emotions and neutrality expressed by emotion intensity throughout an ad. It relates to respondents during an ad. As an example, in the the emotional valence which varies from -1 to 1. A chart above, respondents have shown an equal -1 valence indicates 100% negative reaction, 1 proportion of each emotion and neutrality. 100% positive reaction, and 0 neutral reaction. 8
Ads Ranking Based on Positive Intensity of Emotional Response We ranked the ads based on average emotional valence. • 1 St-Hubert 6• RE/MAX • 2 Desjardins 7• National Bank • 3 Nutrilait 8• Proprio Direct • 4 Toyota 9• Aldo • 5 Honda • 10 Kijiji Ads from St-Hubert, Desjardins and Nutrilait are the only ones to generate a globally positive emotional reaction. Ads from Toyota, Honda and RE/MAX caused a light negative reaction close to neutrality while National Bank, Proprio Direct, Aldo and Kijiji caused negative emotions. We should however note that consumers have a natural tendency to react negatively to advertising. According to eMarketer, 87% of digital video viewers have a negative primary attitude to digital video ads. * eMarketer (2015). “Viewers in China Not Loving Digital Video Ads” 9
St-Hubert, Sugar 6% 1% 3% Neutral Sammy and Mom Happy 10% Based on emotions, St-Hubert’s ad Sad performed best. It has the highest Angry proportion of joy and globally caused the 17% 63% Surprised most positive emotional reaction. Scared There is a positive rise of emotion in the Disgusted last 9 seconds starting when Sugar Sammy’s mom enters the room shouting. Emotion reaches a positive peak when butter chicken is mentioned in the last 5 seconds. For this portion of the video, 0.25 average valence is + 0,181. 0.15 Positive rise of emotion in the last 9 seconds 0.05 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Sugar Sammy aime la variété -0.05 (Seconds) View ad -0.15 Average valence: + 0,068 1 10
Desjardins, Green 6% 1% 2% Neutral and Black Roofs Happy 11% Desjardins ranks just behind St-Hubert Sad with a slightly lower proportion of joy Angry (15% vs. 17%). As St-Hubert, it caused a 15% 65% Surprised globally positive reaction. Scared There is a positive rise of emotion in the Disgusted last 10 seconds of the ad. However, valence stabilizes in the last 5 seconds. It was not the case with St-Hubert where the rise kept until the end. For this last segment of the video, average valence is + 0.25 0,083 (vs. + 0,181 for St-Hubert). 0.15 Stability from 10 to 5 seconds Gradual rise from 5 to 10 seconds 0.05 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Offre verte - Maison -0.05 (Seconds) View ad -0.15 Average valence: + 0,035 2 11
1% 3% Nutrilait, a Guilty 5% Neutral Pleasure 9% Happy Nutrilait ranks right behind St-Hubert and Sad Desjardins for joy (11% vs. 17% et 15%). 11% Angry It globally generated a positive emotional Surprised reaction. 70% Scared There is a positive rise of emotion Disgusted between 6 and 14 seconds starting when the little girl screams. The rise is more intense than in Desjardins. Even with emotion droping slightly when the brand is shown at the end, average valence for the 0.25 last 5 seconds is + 0,087 which is higher than Desjardins (+ 0,083). Slight decrease 0.15 at 14 seconds Positive rise from 0.05 6 to 14 seconds 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Boire à même la bouteille de lait -0.05 (Seconds) View ad -0.15 Average valence: + 0,022 3 12
1% 2% Toyota and the 6% Neutral Little Dog’s Excuse Happy 12% Toyota’s ad caused a globally negative Sad emotional reaction very close to 11% Angry neutrality. Still, proportion of joy is the Surprised same as Nutrilait (11%). 69% Scared The emotional state becomes positive after Disgusted 10 seconds when the “little dog” is mentioned. The rise occurs quickly between 11 and 12 seconds and emotion stabilizes when the brand is presented. Average valence for the last 5 seconds of 0.25 the ad is positive (+0,024). 0.15 Positive rise of emotion after 10 seconds 0.05 (Seconds) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Une vraie bonne raison -0.05 View ad -0.15 Average valence: - 0,013 4 13
Honda, Teenagers 2% 5% 5% Neutral and a Date Night Happy 9% Honda follows Toyota closely with a Sad negative emotional reaction close to 8% Angry neutrality. It did not do as well for joy (8% Surprised vs. 11%). 70% Scared The emotional state is negative during the Disgusted first 10 seconds. There is a well-defined positive peak when the sentence “Don’t open your hood to strangers” appears as a closing punch line. Emotional valence is positive in the last 5 seconds because 0.25 of this (+ 0,019). 0.15 Positive peak in the last second 0.05 (Seconds) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Honda Pièces et Services – Rendez-vous -0.05 Negative emotion during 10 seconds View ad -0.15 Average valence: - 0,014 5 14
RE/MAX, André 5% 1% 2% Neutral Sauvé and a Broker Happy 14% Despite a joy proportion similar to Sad Nutrilait and Toyota (12% vs. 11%), Angry RE/MAX ranks sixth. As for Toyota and 12% Surprised Honda, emotions are mainly negative but 66% still very close to neutrality. Scared Disgusted In opposition to the first ads in our ranking, emotional journey is unstable and does not include a positive peak at the end. Emotion reaches its peak between 5 and 7 seconds when André Sauvé says“Ah wow, 0.25 ah ouin, ah ouash!”. The ad ends neutrally with a slogan. 0.15 Postive peak from 0.05 5 to 7 seconds (Seconds) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Courtier RE\MAX, on serait fou de s’en passer -0.05 Mostly negative emotion View ad -0.15 Average valence: - 0,018 6 15
Banque Nationale 2% 3% 6% Neutral and White Hair Happy 11% Sad Seventh in our ranking, Banque Nationale is the first to cause a negative emotional 6% Angry reaction throughout the ad. Surprised 72% Scared The emotional journey is relatively stable. There is a negative drop of emotion Disgusted between 7 and 10 seconds after a few moments of silence. Emotion slightly rises when we hear “Realize that time flies” and stabilizes with the brand’s presentation. As for Honda, the punch line is essential to understand the ad. (Seconds) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 -0.05 Slight rise after Mostly negative and 10 seconds unstable emotion Réalisez que le temps passe vite View ad -0.15 Average valence: - 0,043 7 16
2% 2% Proprio Direct and 5% Neutral Yves P. Pelletier Happy 11% Proprio Direct ranks eighth with a globally Sad negative emotional reaction. 6% Angry Surprised Despite a negative average valence, there 73% Scared is a positive rise of emotion from 4 seconds to the end which finishes on a Disgusted positive peak when Yves. P. Pelletier says “1-844-Proprio”. The emotional journey in terms of general shape (positive rise to reach a peak) is similar to our top ads. It explains why majority of respondents declared they liked the ad (Seconds) (65%). 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 -0.05 Positive rise of emotion from 4 seconds to the end Vous pouvez faire les deux. Vous comprenez ? View ad -0.15 Average valence: - 0,047 8 17
1% 2% Aldo and Trendy Neutral Young People 7% Happy 13% Sad Aldo is the only 30-second ad. Still, its emotional summary resembles the last 7% Angry four ads in our ranking. Again, the Surprised emotional reaction is negative. 70% Scared Aldo’s emotional journey is the most Disgusted unstable of all. The emotional state is always negative. Three minor emotional peaks occur at 7, 14 and 22 seconds when a face is shown. The fact that Aldo’s ad does not tell a story like the others can explain this distinct emotional journey. (Seconds) 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 Positive peaks at 7, 14 and 22 seconds -0.05 Negative and unstable emotion Place à l’inspiration – Hiver 2015 View ad -0.15 Valence moyenne : - 0,048 9 18
Kijiji, a Rap Song 2% 4% Neutral and Some Cars 7% Happy Kijij ranks last for the emotional results with 12% Sad the most negative reaction based on Angry average valence. 6% Surprised 69% Even though the emotional journey is Scared negative, as for Proprio Direct, there is Disgusted positive rise of emotion between 6 and 13 seconds while the rap song is on. After, emotion drops when Kijiji’s logo appears on the screen. We should note that according to our survey, respondents like Kijiji’s ad better than Banque nationale (Seconds) and Aldo. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Positive rise from -0.05 6 to 13 seconds Drop after 13 seconds Sur Kijiji, y’a des vieux chars pis des neufs View ad -0.15 Average valence: - 0,057 10 19
3. Survey Results
Phase 1 – Four Key Elements Measured After Respondents Viewed Each Ad After viewing each ad, respondents answered four standardized questions to measure appreciation of the ad, intention to share on social media, impact on opinion toward the brand and perception as a pre-roll ad (before online content). Appreciation of the ad “Globally, did you like this ad?” Impact on opinion toward the brand “Does this ad had a positive impact on your opinion toward…” Intent to share the ad on social media “What is the probability that you share this ad on social media?” Perception of the ad if it was a pre-roll ad “If you were forced to watch this ad before accessing content on the Internet (for example, before watching a video on YouTube, a television show on a website, music, etc.), how would you consider this ad?” 21
Appreciation of the Ads In general, participants preferred ads from St-Hubert, Nutrilait and Desjardins. The majority of respondents also liked the ads from RE/MAX, Proprio Direct and Banque nationale. Kijiji’s, Toyota’s, Honda’s and Aldo’s ads were not as appreciated. Like Did not like St-Hubert 90% 6% Nutrilait 84% 13% Desjardins 72% 24% RE/MAX 68% 28% Proprio Direct 65% 31% Banque nationale 61% 37% Kijiji 51% 46% Toyota 51% 47% Honda 49% 49% Aldo 45% 54% * For each ad, the complement to 100% corresponds to the answer “I don’t know”. 22
Impact on Opinion Toward the Brand Ads from St-Hubert and Nutrilait had the most positive impact on respondents’ opinion toward the brands. RE/MAX, Proprio Direct, Desjardins and Kijiji also had a favorable but less intense impact. Honda, Banque nationale, Toyota and Aldo ranked last. Positive Negative No impact St-Hubert 54% 1% 42% Nutrilait 49% 5% 44% RE/MAX 43% 8% 47% Proprio Direct 42% 7% 46% Desjardins 41% 4% 51% Kijiji 39% 11% 49% Honda 28% 12% 61% Banque nationale 27% 8% 64% Toyota 24% 8% 67% Aldo 23% 12% 64% * For each ad, the complement to 100% corresponds to the answer “I don’t know”. 23
Intent to Share on Social Media It’s unlikely respondents will share any ad on social media. These results are not surprising considering consumers are not generally prone to sharing ads on social media platforms. St-Hubert is the only one to stand out. It is significantly more likely to be shared than the others. Likely Not likely St-Hubert 37% 60% Nutrilait 26% 71% Toyota 26% 72% Kijiji 25% 74% Desjardins 23% 75% Honda 23% 77% RE/MAX 22% 73% Proprio Direct 22% 72% Aldo 15% 81% Banque nationale 12% 88% * For each ad, the complement to 100% corresponds to the answer “I don’t know”. 24
Perception as a Pre-Roll Ad Again, St-Hubert’s ad stands out. It would be the most pleasant pre-roll ad according to respondents. Nutrilait, Desjardins and RE/MAX come after St-Hubert. Ads from Banque nationale and Aldo would be the most unpleasant pre-roll ads for respondents. Pleasant Unpleasant Indifferent St-Hubert 80% 3% 13% Nutrilait 61% 12% 24% Desjardins 57% 15% 24% RE/MAX 51% 20% 26% Proprio Direct 41% 18% 36% Kijiji 39% 37% 20% Toyota 39% 24% 34% Honda 36% 28% 36% Banque nationale 34% 20% 42% Aldo 33% 31% 34% * For each ad, the complement to 100% corresponds to the answer “I don’t know”. 25
Phase 2 – Aided Brand Recall An aided brand recall survey* was sent to half of respondents 5 days after they viewed the ads, and to the other half 10 days after.** As in our initial survey, St-Hubert performed best for brand recall. The brand was recalled by 74% of respondents. Even if Aldo’s ad is the least appreciated, the brand was recalled by 66% of respondents. St-Hubert 74% Aldo 66% Kijiji 62% RE/MAX 60% Desjardins 56% Nutrilait 53% Proprio Direct 51% Toyota 49% Banque nationale 37% Honda 32% * Respondents had to identify which brands they saw in the ads among twenty brands. 26 ** 177 out of 200 respondents completed this second phase of the survey.
4. Conclusion
St-Hubert and Nutrilait Are Best Everywhere. Desjardins Follows Closely. St-Hubert takes it all followed by Nutrilait. Both ads ranked first in the survey for the four key elements we measured and stood out in the facial expressions analysis. In addition to causing a globally positive emotional reaction, they generated an emotional journey with a constant positive rise. As St-Hubert and Nutrilait, Desjardins did well in the emotional results. However, RE/MAX and Proprio Direct outperformed it in the survey for the impact on the opinion toward the brand and intent to share on social media. Visually, we notice on the charts below that the positive rise of emotion is less intense for Desjardins than for St-Hubert and Nutrilait. These results are further justified by a positive correlation between average emotional valence and appreciation of the ad. St-Hubert, who takes it all, is also the most recalled brand in our brand recall survey. * Peason’s correlation coefficient is 0,808 for average valence and appreciation. 28
Proprio Direct, RE/MAX and Kijiji Did Better Than Expected in the Survey. Ads from Proprio Direct, RE/MAX and Kijiji respectively ranked sixth, eighth and tenth out of ten for the positive intensity of the emotional reaction. Nevertheless, they often ranked in the top five ads in our survey. Surprising? This gap between emotional and survey results can be explained by emotional journeys. Even if they generated a globally negative emotional reaction, Proprio Direct, RE/MAX and Kijiji all caused well-defined positive emotional rises. This is why they are close to Banque nationale and Aldo, and behind Toyota and Honda in terms of average valence. However, in their case, there is a positive rise of emotion starting right after the first third of the ad. 29
Toyota and Honda Take Too Long to Make Respondents React to Stand Out. Toyota, followed closely by Honda, did not stand out for emotional results with an average valence close to neutrality. Except for intent to share on social media where Toyota ranked third, both brands never figured in the top five ads in our survey results. As with many others, there is a positive rise of emotion in their emotional journey but it comes too late. It only occurs in the last third of the ad. In our top ads (St-Hubert, Desjardins and Nutrilait), the rise begins in the first third. 10 seconds 13,5 seconds 30
Banque nationale and Aldo Cause Little Reaction and Do Not Impress Respondents. Banque nationale and Aldo finished last in the survey and emotional results. Their emotional journeys are the only ones with no marked positive rise of emotion. In Banque nationale’s emotional journey, emotion is relatively stable during the whole ad in addition to being globally negative. This atypical journey explains why the ad was outranked by Proprio Direct and Kijiji in our survey even if it has a slightly more positive average emotional valence. Aldo’s emotional journey is more unstable, with a few peaks not related to well-defined rises like in other ads. However, it does seem like Aldo’s ad is easier to remember. It ranked second in our aided brand recall survey. 31
The 5 Last Seconds of the Ad Have the Biggest Overall Impact on Respondents. Our best performing ads are the ones who end on a positive emotional peak. The statistical analysis showed that emotional valence during the last segment is almost perfectly correlated* with the ad’s appreciation, intent to share on social media and perception as a pre-roll ad. The more positive the emotions in the last five seconds of the ad, the more it may be appreciated, shared and accepted when shown before online content. St-Hubert, who did best in the survey, has an average valence of + 0,181 during its last segment. Nutrilait and Desjardins, who also performed well, has respectively an average valence of + 0,087 and + 0,083. St-Hubert stands out from the other ads with an average emotional valence of + 0,181 in the last third of the ad. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 * Pearson’s correlation coefficients are 0,842 for apprection of the ad, 0,877 for intent to share the ad on 32 social media and 0,880 for perception of the ad as a pre-roll ad.
Five Good Practices for Advertisers 1 Go for a positive surge of emotion Go for a positive surge of emotion in the first part of the ad. The sooner the rise begins, the more effective the ad will tend to be. Such was the case for our top 3 ads (St-Hubert, Nutrilait, Desjardins). 2 End on a positive emotional peak To fully benefit from the positive surge of emotion, end your ad on a positive emotional peak. Such was the case with St-Hubert, whose ad was the best performer 3 Work on how the brand is presented at ad’s conclusion Intensity of emotion tends to drop in the last second of a video ad. To end on a positive emotional peak, work on how the brand and slogan are presented in the conclusion. 4 Collaborate with spokespersons to improve ads How can you generate positive emotions during an ad? By using spokespersons as St-Hubert, RE/MAX and Proprio Direct did. 5 Integrate your brand in the story To end on a positive peak, integrate the brand in the story. In Honda’s ad, the brand presentation generates a positive peak that lasts till the end because it is shown with a punch line in the story. 33
5. Annexes
Annex 1: Profile of Respondents Base : All respondents (n = 200) Base : All respondents (n = 200) Gender Annual household income Male 49% Less than $40 000 25% Female 51% $40 000 to $59 999 14% Age $60 000 to $79 999 18% 18 to 24 years old 21% $80 000 to $99 999 13% 25 to 34 years old 22% More than $100 000 18% 35 to 44 years old 17% Education 45 to 54 years old 18% Primary / Secondary 21% 55 to 64 years old 10% College 39% 65 years and older 12% University 39% Area Minor children in the household Montreal CMA* 38% Yes 36% Quebec CMA* 12% No 64% Other areas 50% * Census metropolitan area * For each category, the complement to 100% correspond to the answer “I don’t know” and “Refusal”. 35
Annex 2: Additional Information on our Facial Analysis Tool (FaceReader Software) FaceReader is a program for facial analysis*. FaceReader has been trained to classify expressions in one of the following categories: happy, sad, angry, surprised, scared, disgusted and neutral. These emotional categories have been described by Ekman as the basic or universal emotions. Obviously, facial expressions vary in intensity and are often a mixture of emotions. In additions, there is quite a lot of inter-personal variation. How does FaceReader work? 1. The first step in facial expression recognition is detecting the face. FaceReader uses the popular Viola-Jones algorithm to detect the presence of a face. 2. The next step is an accurate modeling of the face using an algorithmic approach based on the Active Appearance method described by Cootes and Taylor. The model is trained with a database of annotated images. It describes over 500 key points in the face and the facial texture of the face entangled by these points. The key points include (A) the point that enclose the face (the part of the face that FaceReader analyzes); (B) points in the face that are easily recognizable (lips, eyebrows, nose and eyes). The texture is important because it gives extra information about the state of the face. The key points only describe the global position and the shape of the face, but do not give any information about, for example, the presence of wrinkles and the shape of the eye brows. These are important cues for classifying the facial expressions. 3. The actual classification of the facial expressions is done by training an artificial neural network. As training material over 10 000 manually annotated images were used. * The information presented on this page was extracted from a public document provided by FaceReader: 36 Noldus (2015). “FaceReader Methodology”, 6 p.
Annex 2: Additional Information on our Facial Analysis Tool (FaceReader Software) In addition to neutrality, FaceReader detects six basic emotional categories described as universal. According to scientific research, there are facial expressions of emotion common to all cultures based on how face muscles move. The six basic emotional categories detected by FaceReader include most of the emotional concepts identified through past research on universal facial expressions (Ekman, 1970)1. They are the following : “Happy”; “Surprised”; “Scared”; “Sad”; “Angry”; “Disgusted”. “Happy” is the only positive emotion. “sad ”, “angry”, “scared” and “disgusted” are considered to be negative emotions. “Surprised” can be either positive or negative. In some cases, negative emotions are not unpleasant (Ekman, 2007)2. Some people enjoy being “angry” when they argue while others enjoy crying during a sad movie. Therefore, it is essential to understand the context in which an emotional reaction occurs before qualifying it as positive or negative. Each basic emotion reported by FaceReader consists of a family of emotions. For example, anger (“angry”) can vary in intensity, ranging from contrariety to rage, and type. Anger can be internalized and take the form of grudge, indignation, frigidity, and so on. Joy also comes in many forms ranging from amusement to relief. Science does not yet allows us to distinguish emotions from a same family with facial expressions. 1 Ekman, P. (1970) : “Universal Facial Expressions of Emotion” 2 37 Ekman P. (2007). Emotions Revealed, Holt Paperbacks, 2nd edition, 320 p.
Contact Questions? Comments? info@imarklab.com www imarklab.com facebook.com/imarklab 514 833-0767 linkedin.com/company/imarklab twitter.com/imarklab Creators of the index Our partners 38
You can also read