A Blueprint for Racehorse Ownership in the UK: Making retention and acquisition of owners the number 1 goal of a Racing Recovery Plan - July 2020 ...

Page created by Kevin Santiago
 
CONTINUE READING
A Blueprint for Racehorse Ownership in the UK: Making retention and acquisition of owners the number 1 goal of a Racing Recovery Plan - July 2020 ...
July 2020
                        A Blueprint for Racehorse Ownership in the UK:
                         Making retention and acquisition of owners the
                               number 1 goal of a Racing Recovery Plan

Ged Shields | Jon Hughes
  © Copyright 2020, Ged Shields and Jon Hughes, All Rights Reserved.
A Blueprint for Racehorse Ownership in the UK: Making retention and acquisition of owners the number 1 goal of a Racing Recovery Plan - July 2020 ...
Expect a Major                Demotivation of   A Two-Factor   Improving the        Economic Impact       A Phased Recovery      An Agenda for
                     Contraction                   Owners            Approach       Financial Return     of Owners             Plan, 2020-2025        Stakeholder Action

Racing needs a post-pandemic Recovery Plan with the
retention and acquisition of owners as its number 1 goal.                                               For every pound spent by owners, £7 is generated across the industry for
Owners matter. The financial strength of racing is inextricably linked with the
                                                                                                 3      bookmakers, breeders, trainers, racecourses and sales houses. This 1:7
                                                                                                        multiplier amplifies the £124m financial loss to racing to a significantly
continued commitment of owners to keep funding it. The Covid-19 crisis has                              more damaging £868m. We are alarmed about the negative impact of this
put this commitment under unprecedented pressure while accelerating the                                 multiplier on all stakeholders and their staff. Cutbacks will be painful.
pre-existing challenges that both owners and racing were already facing.
                                                         \
Think of the pandemic as a kind of “time machine” that is rushing us towards
                                                                                                        Racing needs a strategy to attract and retain owners. A co-ordinated and
the end phase of a process that was always likely to happen. Owners are re-
evaluating their ongoing support, with a significant number likely to reduce
                                                                                                 4      well-funded nationwide marketing plan is needed, and for it to be adopted
                                                                                                        particularly by trainers and syndicators. Retaining owners requires radical
their involvement sooner rather than later.                                                             reallocation of prize-money to ensure a better, fairer and more acceptable
Now that the immediate danger of the pandemic has passed, the risk is that                              return, while simultaneously improving the on- and off-course ownership
racing will revert to the “old normal” rather than embrace the “next normal”.                           experience. In the longer term, racing’s funding model has to change.
We believe there is a better approach. A Racing Recovery Plan should be
developed as a matter of urgency with the retention and acquisition of
                                                                                                        75% of all races are Class 4-6. Prize-money should be restructured and
owners as its number one goal. It has to bring the stakeholders together in a                    5      reallocated to grass-roots racing. Minimum prize-money for a Class 6 race
way that puts aside discord and disagreement – collaborate to succeed.                                  should be £7,500, distributed 50% for 1st, 25% for 2nd, 15% for 3rd and 10%
                                                                                                        for 4th . This would mean that all these owners, as a minimum, recoup
                                                                                                        (just) their racing expenses for the day. This is at least an important start.
             Without a Recovery Plan there will be a major contraction in ownership
   1         over the next five years. We believe the impact of the pandemic will be
             worse than the financial crisis of 2008/9, when the number of owners fell
                                                                                                        The financial damage to racing of a significant contraction in owner
             by 1,889 (17%) and horses in training by 2,621 (12%). We predict that
             owners will decline by 2,244 (20%) and horses in training by 3,531 (15%).
                                                                                                 6      numbers will be considerable. A phased Racing Recovery Plan needs to
                                                                                                        commence immediately. Owners want to see rapid and positive changes.
             The immediate financial loss to racing will be £124m.
                                                                                                        Task teams fully representing the whole industry should be put in place,
                                                                                                        reporting to a stakeholder-led Recovery of Racing Group. Accountability
             Once the initial excitement of ownership has faded, poor prize-money                       for success sits with these stakeholders. A first phase of immediate action
   2         is the major factor that drives owners out of the sport. The median                        is required throughout Q3 / Q4, 2020, focused on retaining owners.
             return on investment is 8p on the Flat and 6p for NH, after deductions.
             Owners lose between 92p and 94p in the £. In 2019/20, owners spent
             £527m and lost a collective £428m. While owners don’t expect to make a               Two postscripts: (1) The first race back after resumption on 1st June generated
             handsome return on their racing investment, they increasingly feel short-            £600k in bookmaker profits. The winning owner received a miserly £2,782
             changed. An inconvenient truth is that other stakeholders in the industry            before deductions. (2) Royal Ascot made a dramatic reduction in top prize-
             do rather well out of owners’ annual expenditure … and their losses.                 money. It had no negative impact on entries or horse participation on raceday.

© Copyright 2020, Ged Shields and Jon Hughes, All Rights Reserved.                                                                                                              2
A Blueprint for Racehorse Ownership in the UK: Making retention and acquisition of owners the number 1 goal of a Racing Recovery Plan - July 2020 ...
Expect a Major             Demotivation of           A Two-Factor             Improving the                 Economic Impact        A Phased Recovery        An Agenda for
                               Contraction                Owners                    Approach                 Financial Return              of Owners              Plan, 2020-2025          Stakeholder Action

 Expect a major contraction in ownership in the UK over the next                                                                           And ten years from now, the landscape could be
 five years. It could be worse than after the 2008/9 financial crash.                                                                      hugely different, according to John Gosden.

                                     Forecast of total number                  Forecast of total number                                         The first thing that will change is due to what has happened
                                     of horses in training,                    of owners (Flat & NH),                                           to the economy, not just in our country but all around the
                                     2020-2025                                 2020-2025                                                        world. That is going to have a significant impact. We’re an
                                                                                                                                                entertainment business but also a luxury goods department
                                                                                                                                                and, as everyone knows, it’s very expensive for anybody to
                     25,000                                                                                    11,500                           have a horse. Syndicates will become a far bigger part of the
                                              11,218 owners raced                                                                               industry but unless you have proper prize-money you won’t
                                                 horses in 2019                 After the financial
                                             (Source: Racing Post)         crash of 2008/09, owner                                              encourage too many of them.
                                                                         numbers dropped by 17% and
                     24,000                                           horses in training by 12%. This time     11,000                           I think we’ll see a dramatic restructuring of racing. I believe a
                                                                       we predict 2,244 (20%) of owners                                         number of the racecourses will not survive and I particularly
                                                                        will leave, together with 3,531                                         worry for the small independents. It’s also clear to me the
                                                                      horses (15%). The immediate loss                                          horse population will shrink because people won’t be able to
Horses in Training

                     23,000
                                                                           will be £124m, but with a
                                                                                                               10,500                           afford to own horses in the way we see now.

                                                                                                                        Number of Owners
                                                                      considerably greater impact due to
                                                                                 the multiplier of                                              There’s another huge factor. A lot of the big owners aren’t
                                                                               owners’ investment                                               young people any more.
                               There were 23,537                               across the industry.
                               horses in training in                                                                                            Racing Post interview with John Gosden by Lee Mottershead, 13th June 2020.
                     22,000                                                                                    10,000
                               2019 (Source: BHA
                                   Data Book)
                                                                                                                                           “The trend is your friend” is a phrase often used in the investment
                     21,000
                               2019: 19,433 horses raced (£25k p.a. cost
                                                                                                               9,500
                                                                                                                                           world. It won’t be for racing in this decade, due to three factors:
                               excl. bloodstock = £486m), 4,104 did not
                               (£10k p.a. cost = £41m) = £527m. 3,531                                                                       1. Economic contraction: the UK faces the worst recession since the
                               horses = £88.27m training fees (£25k p.a.) &
                               £35.31m bloodstock, so a £124m loss.                                                                            War, rapidly rising unemployment and the collapse of many
                     20,000                                                                                    9,000                           smaller companies, particularly in leisure and hospitality.
                               2019        2020        2021       2022        2023        2024       2025                                   2. Owner demographics: average age of owners is around 60, and
                                                                                                                                               with substantial numbers over 70 there was always likely to be a
                              Note: Trend lines are based on the actual declines in owners and horses                                          reduction in their investment. Also, they remain wary of Covid 19
                              in training between 2009 and 2014. We fear that the contraction will be                                          and this may inhibit future investment in ownership even further.
                              far worse than this. Substantial numbers of horses went out of training
                              during lockdown. Throughout this blueprint, we assume that owners will                                        3. Disposable income: balance sheets, both personal and company,
                              decline by 20% and horses in training by 15% over the next five years.                                           will have to be rebuilt. As that happens, owners will cut back if
                                                                                                                                               the lessons from the last financial crisis are anything to go by.
 © Copyright 2020, Ged Shields and Jon Hughes, All Rights Reserved.                                                                                                                                                      3
A Blueprint for Racehorse Ownership in the UK: Making retention and acquisition of owners the number 1 goal of a Racing Recovery Plan - July 2020 ...
Expect a Major             Demotivation of               A Two-Factor                Improving the                            Economic Impact        A Phased Recovery       An Agenda for
                                           Contraction                Owners                        Approach                    Financial Return                         of Owners              Plan, 2020-2025         Stakeholder Action

   Once the initial excitement of being an owner has faded, the total amount and allocation of prize-money quickly becomes a
   demotivator. It is one of the key factors that drive owners out of the sport. Consider the returns from National Hunt, 2019/20.

   NH prize-money won by owners soon falls off a cliff …                                                                                                         … with the majority of owners winning < £2,000 per season

                                                                                                                                                                             56% won                            Miserly Returns for NH Owners &
                       £2.5m
                                       1                                                                                                                           40%       less than                                       Trainers
                                                                                                                                                                           £2,000 after                     Unfortunately all these owners actually
                                                                          National Hunt 2019/20 Season                                                                                                      lost money in the season, once raceday
                                                                                                                                                                            deductions
                                                                      It was a miserable season for owners,                                                                                                  costs of c.£600 are deducted. Owners
                                                                            with dreadful weather and                                                              35%
                        £2m                                                                                                                                                         36%                     have to pay all these costs regardless of
                                                                     abandoned meetings. Even before the                                                                                                    where the horse finished. Even if it won
                                                                        national tragedy of Covid-19, prize-                                                       30%                                      or was placed, they made nothing. It is
                                                                           money returns were dire and
Total NH Prize-Money

                        £1m                                                                                                                                                                                  this dismal return which erodes owner
                                                                        demotivating, with NH even worse                                                                                                             enthusiasm to continue.
                                                                                   than the Flat.                                                                  25%
                                                                                                                                                                                                               It was equally bad for trainers and

                                                                                                                                          Percentage of Owners
                       £250k                                                                                                                                                                                    permit holders, with 136 of them
                                             2
                                                                                                                                                                   20%                                        winning precisely zero prize-money.
                                                                                                                                                                           20%
                        100k
                                                                                                                                                                   15%
                                                                                                                                                                                                     14%
                        £50k                                                                                                                                       10%                      12%
                                                                                       3                                                                                                                      9%
                        £10k                                                                                 4    5                                                 5%
                                     Data source:                                                                                                                                                                      6%      2%
                                     Racing Post                                                                                                                                                                                        1%
                                                                                                                                                                    0%
                            £0
                                      1          100       500       1,000    2,000        3,000     4,000       5,000

                                           UK NH Owners Ranked by Total Prize-Money

                        1        #1 Owner on prize-money:        2     These 44 owners ran 692           4       984 owners (20%)                                 Total NH Prize-Money won vs. Actual Received per Owner, 2019/20
                                 J.P. McManus, £2,138,544,             horses and lost £7.5m.                    won no prize-money
                                 but with 141 horses racing
                                 he lost an estimated £1.81m.                                                                                                     Estimated raceday costs: assume horse transport £250, stakes entry fee at the lowest
                                 44 owners won £100k+ but        3     The majority of owners won        5       136 trainers / permit                            level £29, administration fee £32.90, NH jockey fee £173.59, NH riders’ insurance
                                 had substantial losses.
Expect a Major                Demotivation of           A Two-Factor            Improving the          Economic Impact          A Phased Recovery        An Agenda for
                     Contraction                   Owners                    Approach                Financial Return       of Owners                Plan, 2020-2025          Stakeholder Action

The factors that bring owners into the sport are not those that drive them out. This is why racing needs a proactive ownership
strategy that deals simultaneously with both acquisition and retention of owners. It is the top priority for racing.

                                                                                                                           What drives owners out of the sport (the “churn rate” factors)
           Strategies to Boost                                                                                             1.   Cost of keeping a horse in training
           Owner Acquisition                                                                                               2.   Poor prize-money
                                                                                                                           3.   Need to redirect money on to other things
                                                                                                                           4.   Facilities and treatment of owners on and off the racecourse
                                                                           Acquisition                                     5.   Limited success
                                                                           Strategies                                      6.   Not a good trainer experience
                                                                                                                    Examples of Proactive Strategies to Boost Owner Retention
                                                                                                                    •   Improve the funding model, with extra sources of prize-money coming into the sport
                                                                                                                    •   Reallocate prize-money with higher minimum race values for grass-roots racing
   What attracts                                                                                                    •   Rationalise and reduce all the registration fees and administrative charges
   owners into the sport                                                                                            •   Improve the off-course ownership experience with high-quality communication
   1.   Enjoyment of watching the horse run                                                                         •   Improve the on-course ownership experience with more flexible owner benefits
   2.   The non-raceday elements
   3.   Dream of winning races
   4.   Social aspect of racing with friends                                                                                                                            Strategies to Reduce
   5.   Love of horses and association with them
   6.   Enjoyment of racing with the family
                                                                                                                                                                           the Churn Rate
   Examples of Proactive Strategies to Boost Owner Acquisition
   •    Develop and implement an innovative UK-wide marketing plan
   •    Proactive promotion by all stakeholders nationwide                                          Understand
   •    Expand shared ownership with a major campaign on syndication                                the Tipping                             Retention
   •    Showcase ownership on TV and through ownership ambassadors                               Points in Owner                            Strategies            Note: These conclusions on owner acquisition and
   •    Introduce a nationwide series of prospective owner days at stables                   Acquisition and Retention                                            retention are our interpretations of the BHA and
                                                                                                                                                                  ROA’s National Racehorse Owners Survey, 2016.

               78%                                     53%                               73%                            80%                               65%                               82%

 The excitement of watching                 Visiting trainers and their        Most owners start off with     Being on the racecourse is         Poor prize-money drives         Owning is expensive. High
    your horse gives the                   yards is crucial for bringing        others. Make it easier to     the highlight of ownership.       out owners, particularly at        cost drives churn rates.
emotional return. Acquisition               in new owners. It needs            locate and join syndicates        Provide more flexible            the grass-roots level.          Syndicates reduce them.
    marketing sells that.                        more promotion.              that are properly regulated.         benefit packages.                  Address this.                 Cut irritating charges.
© Copyright 2020, Ged Shields and Jon Hughes, All Rights Reserved.                                                                                                                                          5
Expect a Major                Demotivation of   A Two-Factor        Improving the           Economic Impact      A Phased Recovery      An Agenda for
                     Contraction                   Owners            Approach            Financial Return        of Owners            Plan, 2020-2025        Stakeholder Action

As a minimum any owner whose horse finishes in the first four should cover the costs of the raceday. Plan A on minimum race
values addresses that need. In addition, implementing a more radical Plan B assumes a substantial contraction in total racing.

             NH                                  Flat                        Number of NH & Flat Races Analysed by Class in the 2019 Season
           2019/20                               2019
                                                                                            NH           %          Flat         %        Total         %        75% of races
                                                                             Class 1           210      5.6             293     4.6            503     5.0       across both codes are
                                                                             Class 2           236      6.3             459     7.2            695     6.9       at Classes 4-6, which is
    Owners who won less than their annual costs                              Class 3           683     18.3             567     8.9          1,250    12.4       where the vast
                                                                             Class 4         1,731     46.5           1,405    22.0          3,136    31.0       majority of the grass-

          98%                                97%                             Class 5
                                                                             Class 6
                                                                             Class 7
                                                                                               826
                                                                                                35
                                                                                                 0
                                                                                                       22.2
                                                                                                        0.9
                                                                                                         0
                                                                                                                      2,050
                                                                                                                      1,564
                                                                                                                         37
                                                                                                                               32.1
                                                                                                                               24.5
                                                                                                                                0.6
                                                                                                                                             2,876
                                                                                                                                             1,599
                                                                                                                                                37
                                                                                                                                                      28.5
                                                                                                                                                      15.8
                                                                                                                                                       0.6
                                                                                                                                                                 roots owners’ horses
                                                                                                                                                                 race.

      Owners who won
Expect a Major               Demotivation of              A Two-Factor                Improving the                Economic Impact           A Phased Recovery              An Agenda for
                      Contraction                  Owners                       Approach                    Financial Return             of Owners                 Plan, 2020-2025                Stakeholder Action

The economic impact of owners’ expenditure on the whole racing industry is huge, and is the prime driver of financial success of
all other stakeholders. Every pound spent by owners generates £7 elsewhere across the industry.

                                 Owners                                                                 Racehorse Trainers                                                         Syndicates & Syndicators
    ?    High net worth sole owners            There were 23,537 horses in          3     Trainers with 201-300 HiT           There were 23,537 horses in         100    Racing clubs                         Analysis based on estimates
                                               training in 2019 (BHA Data                                                     The figures on the number of                                                    from the Racehorse
                            20+ different      Book) & 11,218 owners raced                                                    trainers and horses in training                                                 Syndicates Association (RSA).
    ?      Owner breeders owner segments       their horses (Racing Post).         20        Trainers with 101-200 HiT        (HiT) are from the National         250       Commercial syndicators
                            & marketing                                                                                       Trainers Federation, June                                                       Racing clubs: c.100, some
                                               Owners on the Flat 2019.                                                                                                                                       with thousands of members.
                           propositions to     6,255 owners raced 11,524                                                      2020. There are also 59
    ?        Partnerships    be defined                                            225          Trainers with 21-100 HiT                                          300          Trainer-led syndicates         If 50 members per club, 5,000
                                               horses. 144 won £100k+ in                                                      permit-holders.
                                                                                                                                                                                                              participants. Average of x 3
                                               total but with 2,545 horses,                                                   There were 676 trainers in                                                      horses per club = 300.
  20%             Syndicates & racing clubs    lost a net £5.95m. Few broke      278 (53%)         Trainers with
Expect a Major                 Demotivation of              A Two-Factor               Improving the                Economic Impact          A Phased Recovery            An Agenda for
                      Contraction                    Owners                       Approach                   Financial Return             of Owners                Plan, 2020-2025              Stakeholder Action

The economic impact of owners’ expenditure on the whole racing industry is huge, and is the prime driver of financial success of
all other stakeholders. Every pound spent by owners generates £7 elsewhere across the industry.

                    Thoroughbred Breeders                                                                     Racecourses                                                                  Bookmakers
  3,318 Breeders in the UK                      The number of breeders in the        17    Dual purpose courses                 Income / costs are based on     £948m Off-course betting (OCB) on dogs       Data sources: Betting Industry
                                                UK is in decline: down from                                                     our estimates of growth since                                                of the UK, Statista.
                                                3,400 (2013) to 3,318 (2018).                                                   a 2013 Deloitte study and the
  3,500    Number of direct employees           About 4,800 foals born p.a. to       19      Flat courses                       recently disclosed c.£600m      £972m     OCB on numbers                    Enormous changes are
                                                c. 9.000 active broodmares.                                                     income p.a.                                                                 impacting the gambling
                                                                                                                                                                                                            industry – a combination of
  4,778        GB-born foals in 2017            Rewards are enormous at the          23          National Hunt courses          Revenue: £478m to £600m.        £1.57bn       OCB on football               huge growth as well as
                                                top of the pyramid but 66% of                                                   Outflow: £484m to £605m.                                                    regulatory constraints. For
                                                breeders are unprofitable and                                                   Entries: £114m to £143m.                                                    some, market capitalisation is
  9,100           Total connected jobs          this situation is worsening. 1-      59             Total number of courses     Food: £100m to £125m.           £4.22bn          OCB on horseracing         rocketing while others
                                                2% of breeders are leaving the                                                  Sponsors: £31m to £39m.                                                     struggle with consolidation
             Yearling Sales                     industry p.a.                                 Five-Year Goal for Attendance     Media: £88m to £147m.                      Racing Turnover                  costs. There is huge scope for
                                                                                                                                                                                                            innovation, e.g. the “Super
 £250m       Aggregate of the top five 2019    Return on capital employed             7m      Strategy for Growth in 2015 set   Raceday costs are high:         £4.2bn     For the year to March 2019, this
             yearling sales in England, France for the industry is 1-3%.                      a target for raceday attendance                                              is the amount wagered on         Pools” at Royal Ascot in 2020
                                                                                                                                £173m to £216m. So are                                                      generated total co-mingling
             & Ireland.                                                                       of 7m.                            overheads: £110m to £137m.                 horseracing off-course.
                                               Considerable economic                                                                                                                                        betting of an average of $4m
                                                                                                                                Substantial capital                                                         per race, with 20 jurisdictions
             Top Stallion Income               impact on the UK economy,                      Declining Attendance              expenditure of c.£1bn over                 Gross Gambling Yield
                                               particularly in rural areas with                                                                                                                             involved.
 £200m       Annual income earned from top an extensive network of                  5.62m     There has been little             the decade drives interest      £522m      This yield reflects the profit
             stallions at Coolmore,                                                           improvement in five years:        charges of £30m+ p.a.                      made on bets excluding           Race 1, Newcastle, 1st June,
                                               suppliers and 19,000 jobs.                                                                                                                                   Class 6 Handicap x 12 runners.
             Godolphin & Juddmonte.            This contributed £427m in                      7.8% annual decline.              JCR and ARC account for 60%                associated costs.
                                                                                                                                                                                                            Matched bets on Betfair =
             Potential Decline in Foals        2017.                                          Median Raceday Crowd              of revenues and independents               Net Profit from Racing           £1.2m (part of Flutter with
                                                                                                                                40%. Typical top course
   30%       4,800 foals are born each year     The last economic crash
                                                                                    1,567     Apart from festivals, raceday     revenue £45m+ per year vs.      £282m      Estimated as a margin of 6.72% 38% of the online market.
             in the UK. Could be a 30%          following 2008/9 reduced the                  crowds are low. Sometimes         smaller track £4-5m.                       on the total amount wagered of Assume Betfair accounts for
             decline (worse than 2008/12).      foal crop by 26%.                             paying customers are
Expect a Major                Demotivation of                A Two-Factor              Improving the             Economic Impact            A Phased Recovery                   An Agenda for
                     Contraction                   Owners                         Approach                  Financial Return          of Owners                  Plan, 2020-2025                     Stakeholder Action

Racing should not underestimate the financial damage likely to occur as a result of a reduction in owner numbers. Action is urgently
needed. Phase 1 of an Owner Retention Plan should be launched this summer. Phase 2 then follows in 2021-2025.

          Accountable for Action                                                                                  A
                                                                                                                                                                                            Prioritised & Focused
A Recovery Plan needs to be designed and                                                                        Unified                                                       The critical actions to retain and grow
implemented by action-oriented task teams.                                                                      Vision                                                        ownership need to be prioritised against
Key stakeholders should be represented and                                                                                                                                    required deliverables, i.e. target number of
accountable. The BHA’s role is to facilitate it.                                                                                                                              owners to be retained and acquired.
                                                                                     A stakeholder-led Recovery of Racing Group should be
                                                                                formed to develop, own and implement a recovery strategy with
                                                                              owner retention and acquisition as the number 1 focus of endeavour.                                       Very
                                                                                                                                                                                        High                                  Top 5
                        BHA                                                                                                                                                                                            Longer Term
          Owners                   Trainers                      Owner Retention Plan, Phase 1:                                                                                                                       Strategies for
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Implementation

                                                                                                                                                                                   Impact on Owner
                                                                 Immediate Actions, Q3/Q4, 2020                                                                                                                          2021-2025

                                                                                                                                                                                     Acquisition &
                                                                                                                               Owner Retention & Acquisition Plan,

                                                                                                                                                                                      Retention
  Breeders                             Racecourses                                                                                            Phase 2: 2021-2025
                Stakeholder Led
                  Recovery of                                               Stakeholder Buy-in to the Top Five Most Critical Strategies                                                                 Top 5
                 Racing Group                                                                                                                                                                           Immediate
 Syndicators                            Levy Board
                                                                     Integrated
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Strategies for
                                                                                          Funding,             Innovative             Off-Course           On-Course                                    Implementation in
                                                                     Ownership          Prize-Money            Marketing &            Ownership            Ownership                   Quite
                                                                      Strategy           & Fixtures          Communications           Experience           Experience                                   2020
          Media                  Bookmakers
                                                                                                                                                                                       High
                                                                                                                                                                                                      Easy                  Challenging
                    Government                                       Develop a            Establish an          Produce and        Lockdown led to a       Develop a new
                                                               segmented plan of       Executive Council     implement British      huge expansion        range of flexible                                      Difficulty of
                                                               action that targets     for the funding of    racing’s first-ever   of, and innovation   on-course benefits                                     Implementation
                                                                all the key owner       British Racing to        Ownership            in, off-course     and privileges for
                                                                  types through            develop an          Marketing Plan       communication.      owners that meet
                                                                multiple channels       innovative five-      that targets each     Racing needs to     the varying needs
                                                                   of media and           year plan of                               accelerate this     of different types       Racing should not delay in forming the
                                                                                                               owner segment.
                                                                communication.           improvement.                                development.            of owner.            task teams. Rapid action is required
                                                                                                                                                                                  throughout Q3/Q4, 2020. Owners need
                                                                                                                                                                                  to be motivated by what is implemented.
                                                                      Four Supporting Capabilities will Need to be Funded and Resourced                                           There will be immediate feedback on
                                                                                                                                                                                  progress or otherwise in the median
                                                                1. Leadership & accountability: with specific strategies led by designated stakeholders                           prices and clearance rates at the
                                                                                                                                                                                  bloodstock sales. Phase 1 of the plan
                                                                2. Project management: a network of teams reporting to the Recovery of Racing Group                               puts a big emphasis on communication
                                                                                                                                                                                  and compensatory benefits to all
                                                                3. Digital technology: harnessing its power to transform owner communication                                      owners, who have been frustrated at
                                                                                                                                                                                  being treated as “non-essential” during
                                                                4. Data-driven decision-making: systematic analysis underpinning all key decisions                                racing behind closed doors.

© Copyright 2020, Ged Shields and Jon Hughes, All Rights Reserved.                                                                                                                                                               9
Expect a Major            Demotivation of            A Two-Factor              Improving the              Economic Impact          A Phased Recovery           An Agenda for
                         Contraction               Owners                     Approach                  Financial Return           of Owners                Plan, 2020-2025             Stakeholder Action

“We face huge challenges across our industry which must be tackled together if we are to ensure the sport we all love can recover
from the current crisis and grow into a more robust model in the future.” New ROA President, Charlie Parker, June 2020.

        A Prioritised & Focused Plan                                                              Phase 1: Immediate Actions, Q3 / Q4, 2020                          Phase 2: More Radical Strategies, 2021-2025
The Recovery of Racing teams will need to                                              1.   Form a virtual Ownership Strategy Team in July to produce an   11. Each owner segment needs a long-term plan: high net worth,
identify and prioritise a wide range of                               An Integrated         action plan for immediate implementation.                          sole, breeders, companies, partnerships, syndicates & clubs.
important initiatives. There is no time to lose.                       Ownership
This calls for agreed goals, clear principles and                       Strategy       2.   Confirm leadership roles & accountabilities of key stake-      12. Each of these strategy workstreams should be led by the most
a collaborative, proactive way of working.                                                  holders: BHA, GBR, NTF, RCA, ROA, RSA. Provide funding.            relevant stakeholder group. Share out these key tasks.

                                                                                       3.   Retain the current reallocation of prize-money and minimum     13. Council addresses two prime subjects: increasing total funds
     Very                                                            Funding, Prize-        race value arrangements. Sort out media rights allocation.         for British racing + size and shape of the race programme.
     High                                Top 5                         Money &
                                  Longer Term                           Fixtures       4.   Form an Executive Council, including the bookmakers, to        14. Address next phase of Levy reform, betting innovation,
                                 Strategies for                                             develop an innovative five-year funding plan for racing.           optimisation of the Race Programme, handicapping changes.
Impact on Owner

                               Implementation
  Acquisition &

                                    2021-2025                                       5.      An industry-wide team to produce racing’s first ever           15. Address the inadequacies of racing’s marketing and digital
   Retention

                                                                       Innovative           Ownership Marketing Plan targeting each owner segment.             communication capability. Harness external specialists.
                                                                       Marketing &
                                                                     Communications 6.      Identify all these segments, the ownership propositions and    16. Three prime opportunities: high net worth individuals,
                   Top 5                                                                    the most appropriate channels, media and communications.           trainer-led initiatives and syndicates / shared ownership.
                   Immediate
                   Strategies for                                                      7.   Lockdown triggered huge creativity by trainers, syndicators,   17. Scrap all racecourse restrictions on video and audio
                                                                       Off-Course           racecourses and broadcasters. Expand it.                           communication to owners by trainers, jockeys & syndicators.
                   Implementation in                                   Ownership
    Quite          2020                                                Experience      8.   Many owners cannot go racing. Provide a quality package of     18. Create an owners only, privileged-access British Racing portal,
    High                                                                                    compensatory benefits for non-attendance.                          The Owners Club, connecting owners to raceday highlights.
                  Easy                    Challenging
                                                                                       9.  Owners need full, appropriate and safe access to the            19. Syndication is increasing owner numbers. Produce more
                            Difficulty of                              On-course           paddock, hospitality, their horses and trainers ASAP.               flexible packages of owner benefits to accommodate them.
                          Implementation                               Ownership
                                                                       Experience      10. In Q3/Q4, racecourses to do everything possible to make         20. Owners making the greatest financial contribution are not
                                                                                           owners feel special and welcome. “Go the extra mile.”               acknowledged. Develop a Gold Tier of privileges to do this.
             Collaboration on Contested Issues

  1. Collaboration of the stakeholders is vital.
                                                                      Leadership &     Each strategy to have designated leaders, provided by the most      Leadership by all the key stakeholders must be unified and
     They must work together on the plan.                             Accountability   appropriate stakeholder body. Hold them accountable.                collaborative. Remove and replace those who block change.
  2. They should not duck the contentious
     issues. They must find common ground.                              Project        Each task team to operate in line with defined principles and ways Task teams to report regularly on progress to a stakeholder-led
  3. Robust project management is required                            Management       of working. Adopt a four-week rule: urgent action is called for.   Recovery of Racing Group which challenges and approves actions.
     to keep everything on track.
                                                                         Digital       During the pandemic, digital communication has expanded             Produce a digital technology strategy for British Racing that puts
  4. Each task team needs a dedicated leader                           Technology      dramatically. Learn from best practice and expand it.               marketing, promotion and communication centre stage.
     with clear goals and accountabilities.
  5. A transparent approach should be                                  Data-Driven   All key decisions need to be facts- and data-driven. Logic and        Provide funding so that task teams can gather and analyse the
     adopted, with full access to all data.                          Decision-Making analysis of data underpin the required implementation plans.          necessary data, e.g. optimising the race programme.

© Copyright 2020, Ged Shields and Jon Hughes, All Rights Reserved.                                                                                                                                                      10
The Authors of this
          Blueprint for Racehorse Ownership in the UK
                                                  Ged Shields: involved in racehorse          Jon Hughes: an owner since 2004 with 94
                                                  ownership since 2015 and has had 38         winners so far. Current trainers are Karl
                                                  winners so far. Current trainers are Ruth   Burke, Philip Hobbs, Anthony Honeyball,
                                                  Carr, Richard Fahey, Ralph Beckett, Ed      Martin Keighley and Charlie Longsdon.
                                                  Walker and Willie Mullins. At present has   Involved with 21 horses, from foals to
                                                  shares in 18 Flat horses and one National   chasers. Former chairman and co-founder
                                                  Hunt chaser – Gr.1 winner Kemboy.           of specialist management consultancies in
                                                  Former Vice President of The Sherwin-       procurement and supply chain, and visiting
                                                  Williams Company with international         professorships at the University of
                                                  experience in marketing and mergers &       Birmingham and Vlerick Leuven Gent
                                                  acquisitions. Stood for the Racehorse       Business School. Chairman of Martin
                                                  Owners’ Association board in 2020.          Keighley’s yard in Gloucestershire.

                                                  ged.shields@yahoo.co.uk.                    jon@ownersforowners.co.uk.

                                                  01226-495149.                               01451-850780.

© Copyright 2020, Ged Shields and Jon Hughes, All Rights Reserved.
You can also read