Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt - Wagner College
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Why Sears Holding Corp. Will
Go Bankrupt
Wagner College
Bryan Maley
Edward Wolf
Frank AbtWhy Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
1
Which company will file for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy by 2020? We feel that it will be
Sears Holding (Sears).
Sears is a company with an ever increasing amount of debt and an ever decreasing amount of
equity. Unfortunately Sears has an organizational structure that is not geared for the competitive
retail environment. Sears equity price reflects these problems. Edward Lampert the CEO of
Sears, a seasoned financier, will be looking towards an exit strategy in order to avoid the type of
litigation revolving around an inevitable bankruptcy. It is our opinion Sears will eventually
devolve into an equity “death spiral”. A visit to any of their stores confirms this, they have more
retail clerks than customers, and the aisles are depressingly empty. Sears’ fate seems unavoidable
and Lampert must strategize a plan to file for a Prepackaged Chapter 11 Bankruptcy in order to
escape even worse consequences.
The situation at Sears is clearly presented in their financial statements. Revenues have
fallen from $41.6 billion in 2012 to $39.8 billion in 2013, and now stand at $36.1 billion as of
year-end 20141. The sale of Lands’ End, a thriving brand, confirms to us that management is
jettisoning good cargo in order to save the sinking ship. The company’s balance sheet is a
complete disaster. Sear’s burned through $714 million dollars last year2. Sears' asset base has
declined by $1.27 billion dollars in Q4 of 20143. In November Sears raised $2.2 billion in part
from a loan from ESL Investments, and the partial sale of the company’s stake in Sears Canada.4
Sears Canada, like Lands End, represented robust assets. This partial liquidation is another
1
http://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/financials/financials.asp?ticker=SHLD
2
http://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/shld/financials/balance-sheet/quarter
3
http://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/shld/financials/balance-sheet/quarter
4
http://www.wsj.com/articles/sears-considering-forming-reit-to-boost-liquidity-1415362718Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
ominous sign. Additionally Sears’ debt is weighing heavily on management as they have $1.3
2
billion in due in 12 months as well as their increasing unfunded pension obligations to retired
workers.5 All told, Sears has $4.9 billion dollars in debt which leaves them with a debt to equity
ratio of approximately 40 to 1.6 We feel these figures confirm an inevitable insolvency. Sears
equity has been extremely volatile. At one point Sears looked like a solid revenue producing
company. Lampert, who was chairman of Kmart engineered the purchase of Sears in 2004.
Given the tailwinds prior to 2008, Lampert’s strategy of leveraging real estate assets proved
brilliant. However like many of the other failed financial firms during this period, over
leveraging proved fatal as the real estate market crashed.
Sears dismal performance is reflected in its share price which currently trades in the high
30’s. It once sported a price handle in the 170’s less than ten years ago when there was more
confidence in Lampert and his team7. Lampert was well known for squeezing money out of
poorly managed businesses. In the first year the combined company produced revenue in 2005 of
$48.9 billion. The balance sheet was strong with liabilities to equity ratio of 1.6 to 18. While
Kmart and Sears employees were productively operating the retail stores during a challenging
environment, top level management implemented a “hedge fund like strategy”. They, in effect,
strip mined its balance sheet. This approach proved ruinous and weakened the company.
Combined with equity buybacks its debt to equity ratio was severely diminished. As ugly 3Q
results were announced in December 2014 Lampert still spoke to the public in a positive tone. A
share buyback program which was supposed to enhance shareholder value has done the opposite.
5
http://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/shld/financials/balance-sheet
6
http://ycharts.com/companies/SHLD/debt_equity_ratio
7
http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=SHLD+Interactive#%7B%22range%22%3A%22max%22%2C%22scale%22%3A
%22linear%22%7D
8
http://www.lewrockwell.com/2015/02/eric-englund/the-sears-death-spiral/Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
Management failed to foresee the economic decline of the traditional retail industry which is
3
constantly confronted by ever increasing online sales. Ironically it was Sears Roebuck’s use of
mail order catalogs that revolutionized the retail industry in the United States. Internet based
shopping which can be viewed as a progeny of that technique is fiercely working against Sears.
In many ways Sears Roebuck and Company was the grandfather to Amazon. Now it is being
undone by the same sales strategy it once championed.
The company has seen 4 different CEO’s since the merger, yet many have said that
Lampert has been running the show. Critics have commented for years that Lampert’s style of
operating a retail organization like a hedge fund portfolio is wrong headed. One cannot run a
company like Sears in the same manner one would run a hedge fund portfolio. With multiple
business segments competing with one another for Lamperts attention he now has an
organizational structure which is decentralized. Instead of cooperating with each other, which is
crucial in retail given inventory and sales complexities, they are competing with one another
over a scarce resource base. One particular detractor, Shaunak Dave, who left Sears in 2012, said
that Lampert created “warring tribes” and “cooperation and collaboration aren’t there”. Yet
Lampert still refutes this by stating that decentralized systems can appear messier than
centralized systems, but they still tend to work better and produce better information over time.
Lampert is no doubt a talented business person with a proven track record. However, as
many management experts will agree, the strengths of the entrepreneur do not easily translate to
the operational structure. One must ask, could anyone have saved Sears? Brick-and-mortar
retailers have been struggling from declining economic activity for years, while losing market
share from online retailers. These companies cannot afford the real estate overhead. The latest
proof of this is Radio Shack’s decision in 2014 to close more than 1000 stores. Sears HoldingWhy Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
closed 300 stores as part of a larger strategic refurbishment in order to free up more capital and
4
reduce risk9. As the equity value lurches its way to zero, we feel that a Prepackaged Bankruptcy
may be the best alternative. The challenges facing this company are too great. It is for this reason
that we are confident that Sears is the answer to your question.
Bankruptcy Prepackage; A Primer
Any conversation revolving around a Prepackaged Bankruptcy for Sears must include a
review of the prepackaged process. The following paragraphs explain the procedures used in a
“prepack”. As one reads through this progression it more clearly demonstrates that this is the best
course of action for Sears. As long as Lampert is willing to live with an inevitable diminished
equity value, he can help his lien and debt holders realize a partial return of their investment and
quite possibly emerge as a relevant retail presence once again. In many ways the restructuring of
General Motors, who embraced a similar strategy, serves as a template to companies like Sears.
Chapter 11 bankruptcy, also called reorganization or rehabilitation bankruptcy, allows a
firm the opportunity to reorganize its debt and to try to re-emerge as a healthy organization. It is
strategically, a company’s way of retaining control of their bankruptcy. A Chapter 11 case begins
with the filing of a petition with the bankruptcy court serving the area where the debtor has a
domicile or residence. A petition may be a voluntary petition, which is filed by the debtor, or it
may be an involuntary petition, which is filed by creditors that meet certain requirements. Unless
the court orders otherwise, the debtor also must file with the court: (1) schedules of assets and
9
http://www.dailyfinance.com/2014/04/14/sears-just-doesnt-look-like-it-wants-our-business-anymore/Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
liabilities; (2) a schedule of current income and expenditures; (3) a schedule of executory
5
contracts and unexpired leases; and (4) a statement of financial affairs.
Essentially, the main goal of the indebted firm by contacting its creditors is to attempt to
change the terms of its debt but must continue to pay it back through future earnings. Upon filing
a voluntary petition for relief under Chapter 11, or in an involuntary case, with the entry for an
order of relief, the debtor automatically assumes an additional identity as the “debtor in
possession”. The term means that the debtor keeps possession and control of its assets while
undergoing the reorganization strategies of Chapter 11, without the appointment of a case
trustee. A debtor will remain a debtor in possession until the debtor's plan of reorganization is
confirmed, dismissed, converted to a Chapter 7 liquidation bankruptcy, or a Chapter 11 trustee is
appointed.
Generally a written disclosure statement and a plan of reorganization must be filed with
the court. The disclosure statement is a document that must contain information concerning the
assets, liabilities, and business affairs of the debtor sufficient to enable a creditor to make an
informed judgment about the debtor's plan of reorganization. The information required is
governed by judicial discretion and the circumstances of the case. The contents of the plan must
include a classification of claims and must specify how each class of claims will be treated under
the plan. Creditors whose claims are "impaired," (i.e., those whose contractual rights are to be
modified or who will be paid less than the full value of their claims under the plan) vote on the
plan by ballot. After the court approves the disclosure statement and the ballots are collected and
tallied, the court will conduct a confirmation hearing to determine whether to confirm the plan.
In regards to the above aforementioned appointment of a Chapter 11 trustee, Section
1107 of the Bankruptcy Code places the debtor in possession in the position of a fiduciary, withWhy Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
the rights and powers of a Chapter 11 trustee, and it requires the debtor to perform of all but the
6
investigative functions and duties of a trustee
To give the debtor some breathing room, the automatic stay provides a period of time in
which all judgments, collection activities, foreclosures, and repossessions of property are
suspended and may not be pursued by the creditors on any debt or claim that arose before the
filing of the bankruptcy petition. As with cases under other chapters of the Bankruptcy Code, a
stay of creditor actions against the Chapter 11 debtor automatically go into effect when the
bankruptcy petition is filed. The filing of a petition, however, does not operate as a stay for
certain types of actions listed under 11 U.S.C. § 362(b). The stay provides a breathing spell for
the debtor, during which negotiations can take place to try to resolve the difficulties in the
debtor's financial situation.
However, in a Chapter 11 case, a liquidating plan is also an option. Such a plan often
allows the debtor in possession to liquidate the business under more economically advantageous
circumstances than Chapter 7 liquidation. It also permits the creditors to take a more active role
in fashioning the liquidation of the assets and the distribution of the proceeds than in a Chapter 7
case. Moreover, in accordance with Chapter 11 Bankruptcy rules and regulations, once a plan is
confirmed, the debtor is required to make plan payments and is bound by the provisions of the
plan of reorganization. The confirmed plan creates new contractual rights, replacing or
superseding pre-bankruptcy contracts.
An outstanding question that many companies have before filing a Chapter 11 bankruptcy
is what will happen to their securities. According to the SEC, a company's securities may
continue to trade even after the company has filed for bankruptcy under Chapter 11. In most
instances, companies that file under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code are generally unable toWhy Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
meet the listing standards to continue to trade on the NASDAQ or the NYSE. However, even
7
when a company is delisted from one of these major stock exchanges, their shares may continue
to trade on either the OTCBB or the Pink Sheets. There is no federal law that prohibits trading of
securities of companies in bankruptcy.
Finally, when trying to give a valuation of a company’s debt, there are many components
one must take into consideration. These components are ones such as but not limited to, Capital
Structure, Debt & Coverage Ratio’s and Outstanding Bonds. Provided below are charts, graphs
and tables of these different components.Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
8
BONDS OUTSTANDING
10
11
10
Bond Prices are not reflective of current prices (morningstar.com)
11
Bond Prices are not reflective of current prices (morningstar.com)Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
9
As a result, Sears Holding Corporation should file for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy based on a
general rule of thumb that they have much more debt than income. Typically, companies who are
overextended but have steady income streams are good candidates for Chapter 11. Employing
this strategy, given the precipitous drop in Sears’s equity value is clearly its best alternative. A
person with Lampert’s vast financial experience can undoubtedly see this.
Aftermath
We have no doubt that Sears will be filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the next few
years. We would be surprised if they survived through the 2020 deadline. With earnings
continuing to nosedive and the company selling off assets, as stated before, this will be
forthcoming. Even though Lampert continues to express optimism about the retail business, the
forecasts are leading to the gradual end of the longtime giant. However, Sears still owns
commercial property of considerable value. This property is arguably worth much more than
Sears’ market value today.Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
In an event of a Prepackages Bankruptcy, key investors like Bruce Berkowitz’s
10
Fairholme Capital and Horizon Kinetics should benefit. Lampert’s own hedge fund, ESL
Investments, can recoup a portion of its investment. While there is still the slight possibility that
Eddie Lampert will try to hold out on filing for bankruptcy, this will eventually lead to the
demise of Sears Holdings. There are very few people willing to buy Sears’ stock. In fact, the
stock has lost more than half its value in the past five years. Sears is still losing money, and its
response to aggressively sell stores has not worked. In 2013, Sears lost $1.4 billion, which was
worse than the $930 million loss the previous year. Going into 2014, management’s strategy was
to sell off the underperforming stores, in which they sold 235. Sears lost $548 million just last
quarter, proving that their strategy is a dead end.
If Lampert of course would like to avoid a Prepackaged Bankruptcy process there are
alternative courses of action. He already loaned Sears $400 million using stores as collateral.
Sears was so desperate for his money that they gave him a great deal. The loan is secured by
liens on 25 properties owned by Sears. This means that each of the 25 stores is valued at $16
million which is either a very good deal for Lampert or signals that the retailers remaining real
estate is not as valuable as they claim. Sears values its real estate at $5 billion and says its 400
most valuable stores are worth at least $18 million each.
Lampert’s next move may be to spin off the retailer’s best real estate into a separate trust.
In November 2014, Sears and its chief executive disclosed plans to form a real estate investment
trust (REIT) that would acquire as many as 300 Sears’ stores and lease them back to the retailer.
According to CreditSights, this was estimated to help Sears raise $2.6 billion. Based on Reuters
analysis of this proposed REIT and interviews with commercial real estate experts, there are
many conflicts with U.S. tax rules that will hold back this strategy. This includes the potentiallyWhy Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
large ownership stakes held by Lampert. Sears has lost more than $6 billion over the past four
11
years. Considering this, Credit analysts have warned of the possibility of Chapter 11 Bankruptcy.
Fitch Ratings, who recently downgraded Sears’s credit rating to a CC, has warned the retailer
that they could run out of money by 2017. So, in order for the REIT to work, the spinoff must be
structured so it could stand up to scrutiny under federal provisions. Given all of these issues we
feel you can basically dismiss this alternative.
Finally Lampert will want to avoid the same consequences faced by another celebrated hedge
fund manager, Phil Falcone. Phil Falcone was a hedge fund manager of Harbinger Group who
has had a tumultuous career. As of December 1st, 2014, Falcone has reportedly stepped down
from his CEO position at Harbinger Group due to a financial debacle in large part to his
investment in the company Lightsquared. Falcone began his illustrious financial career by
gaining substantial wealth through his bet against sub-prime mortgages. However, with his most
recent gamble, his venture in Lightsquared, he came up with a losing hand. Falcone’s plan for
Lightsquared was to establish an untapped telecommunications resource that could compete with
the market leaders, AT&T and Verizon. The venture collapsed as the FCC ultimately rejected his
plan claiming it would interfere with navigational GPS systems. Subsequently Falcone has faced
investor recrimination, and severe regulatory problems.
Edward Lampert could be on the verge of following in the footsteps of Phil Falcone as
he has seemingly put himself in a similar predicament. Like Falcone, Lampert has extended his
hedge fund, ESL Investments, by loaning $400 million dollars to Sears. If the issues concerning
Sears continue to manifest themselves, Lampert could potentially face parallel consequences.Why Sears Holding Corp. Will Go Bankrupt
Conclusion
12
Edward Lampert has been an investor who has always kept his shareholders in mind
when considering his alternatives. If Lampert decides to go through with a Prepackaged
Bankruptcy, he could propose a deal to his equity and debtholders in which they would receive
some value for each dollar invested. On a positive note, Sears owns iconic name brands like
Craftsman, that resonate in the canon of American retail lore. Perhaps a deal struck with an e-
commerce power, such as Amazon, can help revitalize this struggling giant. Sears can then
maintain a significantly reduced commercial real estate presence. Smaller stores can serve as
showrooms, while the bulk of its transactions happen online. This would allow Lampert to
monetize his real estate holdings while keeping his brands alive. In many ways he would be
following the same strategy used by the auto dealers who have proven to remain relevant during
the same period. We feel that this is Sears’ next course of action and thus strongly confirms our
thesis.You can also read
