TRAINING Dental nurse - ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE FOR DENTAL PROFESSIONALS IN SCOTLAND FEBRUARY 2021 - Scottish Dental magazine

Page created by Carlos Love
 
CONTINUE READING
E S S E N T I A L K N OW L E D G E F O R D E N TA L P R O F E S S I O N A L S I N S CO T L A N D

FEBRUARY 2021                                                                         RRP £5.50

                          Dental nurse
                  TRAINING
                   New ap p ro ache s to p re - regis tration sup p or t
                                         p42
FEBRUARY 2021

              E N S U R E YO U CO N T I N U E TO R E C E I V E S COT T I S H D E N TA L M AG A Z I N E
              Sign up to receive email notifications from Scottish Dental magazine
              including the latest issues in digital format, news, and Show updates.

              V i s i t W W W. S D M A G .C O. U K / E M A I L - S U B S C R I B E

   05 Editorial
   07 Insider
   09 News
        FEATURES
   22	Shetland’s outstanding
       oral health performance
   26	Dundee finds ‘hope’
       amidst challenge

                                                    22
   32	Dental settings for public
       health monitoring
   36	Running for mental health
   38	Scottish Orthodontics Conference
   42	Pre-registration dental
       nurse training
   44	Spotlight: Tariq Bashir
        MANAGEMENT
   45 Susie Anderson Sharkey
   46	
      Alun K Rees
   47	
      Richard Pearce
   	CLINICAL
   50	
      Dentistry during COVID-19
   	PROFESSIONAL FOCUS
   51	
      Advice, expertise and supplies
   64 Dental Laboratories
   69	
      Focus on Orthodontics

                                                    26
   73	
      Rep Profiles
   77	
      Product News

   FOLLOW US
     SDMAG.co.uk
     @scottishdental
     scottishdental

                       MANAGING EDITOR         ADVERTISING           EDITORIAL BOARD                                          © Connect Publications
                       David Cameron           Ann Craib             Tony Anderson                Peter Ommer                 (Scotland) Ltd
                       david@connectmedia.cc   Tel: 0141 560 3021    Roger Currie                 Andrew Paterson             The copyright in all articles
                                               ann@connectmedia.cc   Ulpee Darbar                 Professor J Mark Thomason   published in Scottish Dental
                       EDITOR
                                                                     Dr Michael Davidson          Dr Donald J Thomson         magazine is reserved, and
                       Will Peakin             DESIGN
                                                                     Toby Gillgrass               Professor Angus Walls       may not be reproduced
                       Tel: 0141 560 3019      Scott Anderson
                                                                     Professor Mark Hector                                    without permission. Neither
                       editor@sdmag.co.uk
                                               SUBSCRIPTIONS         Professor Richard Ibbetson                               the publishers nor the editor
                                               Will Peakin           Gordon Morson                                            necessarily agree with views
                                               Tel: 0141 560 3019                                                             expressed in the magazine.
connectmedia.cc                                editor@sdmag.co.uk                                                             ISSN 2042-9762

                                                                                                                                      February 2021 | 3
Editor
                                                             Will Peakin editor@sdmag.co.uk
                                                   Follow Scottish Dental on Twitter at: @ScottishDental

Lockdown: an opportunity taken?

O
                       n 11 March last year, Scottish Dental magazine sat       and take forward a new model of preventive oral health care for NHS
                       down with Tom Ferris, the Chief Dental Officer,          patients”. The General Dental Service budget has been increased by
                       to hear from him an outline of the work being            0.6 per cent, or £2.4 million. A spokesperson for the British Dental
                       carried out to create a ‘new model of care’ for NHS      Association (BDA) said: “This will go some way towards supporting
                       adult dentistry in Scotland; a model intended to         the service in this tumultuous time; we are concerned that it does
                       fundamentally shift the focus from treatment of          not go far enough.” The Scottish Dental Practice Committee (SDPC)
                       disease to prevention. A little over a week later, the   has a working group collating views on a funding model to replace
UK went into lockdown, as COVID-19 took hold. In those early days,              the Statement of Dental Remuneration; a “workable solution to be
many in the profession wondered whether they would still have a job             presented to Scottish Government”.
or a business coming out of lockdown – let alone what kind of NHS care             The BDA and SDPC have been told that they will be invited to
they might be contracted to provide in years to come.                           take part in discussions with the Scottish Government to consider
   While NHS dentistry has since been remobilised, the capacity for             a new funding model. Where this leaves the fledgling Scottish Dental
treating patients remains severely limited. The profession, like society        Association (SDA) remains to be seen. It is conducting a survey via the
in general, has become more reconciled to being in this for the long            Scottish Dental Network, a Facebook-based group.
haul. Alongside this acceptance, it is wondering exactly what kind                 Work on the new model of care comprises three streams: looking
of care it can provide long-term, and how – as a group of healthcare            at the framework for an ‘oral health risk assessment and care pathway’,
providers – it will make ends meet.                                             creating a ‘treatment toolbox’, and funding. Early adopter practices
   Last month (28 January), the Scottish Government published its               were envisaged to ‘go live’ from this autumn. It has been said that
Budget for 2021-22. It included a commitment to “provide £431 million           lockdown has presented people with an opportunity to make changes
for general dental services [in 2021-22], helping to support their              that everyday life had somehow prevented; the coming months will
recovery, accelerate the reform programme for NHS dental services               reveal how those good intentions have fared.

                                                                                                                                     February 2021 | 5
Insider
                                                 Arthur Dent is a practising NHS dentist in Scotland
                                        Got a comment or question for Arthur? Email arthurdent@sdmag.co.uk

Prepare to recover slowly
The drive in the profession to throw out the NHS payment system – can I suggest we put the brakes on that?

A
                      s I sat, pondering the announcement of a           back to normal. Well, I know that’s not true; the first cut might not
                      second national lockdown in Scotland,              be perfect but after a couple we’ll all be back in the usual pattern and
                      I felt void of emotion. At least this time         the hair just keeps growing. It will be interesting to see how much
                      round we won’t have multiple changes of            dentistry varies from that. There will inevitably be those who have
                      rules or guidance in a short period. We won’t      been fine and will remain so. Equally, there will be those who stayed
                      have to create new operating procedures            at home and have eaten and drunk their fill, with the associated
                      or re-train our staff, build screens or source     dental fallout. It will probably inform the debate over recall periods
bucket-loads of PPE. This is something we have done before,              very well, though.
something we were probably expecting post-Christmas anyway,                 I think the big battle will be how quickly we can get things under
new variant or not. Even in the first few months of COVID, there         control. The longer our restricted practice carries on, the greater the
was an inevitability that the following winter would bring stress        volume and complexity of need will be. In turn, the longer the waiting
to the NHS systems, regardless of the uncertain outcome of               times will be as we programme this work into our schedules. Some
SARS-CoV-2.                                                              practices may choose to work from a zero point with examinations
   Dentistry should remain unaffected, as we have reached a              and others may have lists of postponed treatment plans.
static level of guidance regardless of the effects on the world             Whichever method, the order books will get longer and longer.
around us. This point, it could be argued, should have been              This creates clinical and financial problems. Clinically, if people
reached a few days or weeks into the first lockdown. However,            have to wait longer for treatment, that treatment changes and
I am not myopic; I recognise the enormous struggles the                  becomes more complex; fillings become RCTs, RCTs become
profession faced with the uncertainty of transmission and the            extractions requiring dentures, bridges or implants. People also
lack of evidence which resulted in the cautious approach taken.          return for emergencies in between appointments because temporary
We are in a different place now. Our systems protect us from             dressings fail; we are probably all seeing that just now. From the
patients with COVID. We just need to maintain high levels of             business perspective, cash flow gets stretched, especially if we wait
control to avoid inter-staff transmission.                               for the end of plans to submit claims and get paid. This can put
   We have adapted to the vastly different professional and              enormous pressure on businesses at a time when many are teetering
community landscape we find ourselves in. Humans adapt,                  on the brink.
dentists adapt. Even if someone rips up the rule book, we will              I’m trying to look forward, yet I only see greater travails, not great
write a new one. However, let’s ask ourselves a question; what           times. In the meantime, I pray for us to be used in the vaccination
are we doing differently? Our processes have altered a little; PPE       programme that will (hopefully) set us free. I hope that it is well
is the biggest shift. Our control of people entering our buildings       organised and voluminous in both its administration and uptake.
is quite high at the moment when there was virtually none                I hope that dentists get to help out and avoid further burden on our
before. We have probably changed the material we use to clean            stretched healthcare system. However, whilst this last year has been
slightly. But what else has changed? We still drill and fill, access     tough for most; I see 2021 as a far tougher prospect for dentistry. I
pulp chambers and make dentures. I grant you, in nothing like            fear it will be several years before our patients get back to the levels
the normal numbers, but the processes are the same. We have              of clinical consistency that we were at just a year ago. Dentistry, and
not had to change the way we perform dentistry; just get used to         healthcare in general, is in for a bumpy few years.
doing it with a couple more layers of plastic in the way.                   So, the thoughts for the year: use our services to accelerate the
   That said, there seems to be a drive in the profession to throw       vaccination process; prepare our recovery and think hard about the
out the NHS payment system. Can I suggest we put the brakes              level of work we are prepared to endure and for how long; get fit
on that? We have been supported (to varying degrees, according           enough to cope with longer hours and harder work than we have
to NHS commitment); as has the country by the Job Retention              done before. Be prepared to recover slowly; ‘Long-COVID’ is likely
Scheme and Self-Employment Income Support Scheme. We can                 to affect dentistry too.
all see how expensive that process has been, and we can imagine
how long it’s going to take to pay for it. I cannot see the benefit in
trying to renegotiate a contract at a time when the Government,
(UK or devolved or independent Scottish), has no money and
will be trying to cut left, right and centre. Now isn’t the time
to ask for more money or create an arrangement in which we
receive less.
   I also think we’re going to be a bit busy (understatement of the
millennium). I think there’s going to be a huge backlog of work
                                                                         THE BIG BATTLE WILL BE HOW QUICKLY
which will be more complex and time consuming than normal.
I don’t think that we are like a hairdresser; after one cut, we are      WE CAN GET THINGS UNDER CONTROL”
                                                                                                                                    February 2021 | 7
8 | Scottish Dental Magazine
NEWS

                                                                                                   Guidance
                                                                                                   updated, but
                                                                                                   ‘unchanged’
                                                                                                   THE Scottish Dental Clinical
                                                                                                   Effectiveness Programme
                                                                                                   (SDCEP) has issued an update
                                                                                                   to its Rapid Review of the
                                                                                                   Mitigation of Aerosol Generating
                                                                                                   Procedures in Dentistry within
                                                                             The pods at Dundee    a new appendix and as a
                                                                                Dental Research
                                                                                                   standalone document1.
                                                                             Hospital and School
                                                                                                      SDCEP published its review in
                                                                                                   September last year and it was
                                                                                                   noted that it was a ‘living

Dental hospital                                                                                    document’ and that the working
                                                                                                   group would continue to assess
                                                                                                   emerging evidence to maintain

installs pods for AGPs                                                                             its currency in the following
                                                                                                   months. The working group
                                                                                                   met again on 13 January this year.
                                                                                                   New members present included
Using standalone negative pressure isolation can                                                   the Chair of the SAGE
drastically reduce fallow time between patients                                                    Environment and Modelling
                                                                                                   Group, who is an expert in
                                                                                                   healthcare ventilation, and
SPECIAL pods are being installed at           NHS, the firm has moved into the health              additional representatives from
Dundee Dental Research Hospital and           sector and is installing its new range               the National Physical Laboratory.
School, allowing aerosol generating           of products in hospitals in Dundee and                  The four-nation working group
procedures (AGPs) to be undertaken            across the UK. The units are made in                 considered the implications of the
safely in otherwise open clinics.             Dundee using locally sourced materials,              substantial increase in prevalence
   Twenty SafeClinic pods, made by Starn      including flame-retardant PVC made by                of COVID-19 infections in recent
Group, the Dundee-based energy services       Angus firm Montrose Rope and Sail.                   months, the emergence of more
company specialising in hazardous                 James Downie, a project manager at               transmissible variants of
working environments, are in the process      Starn, told the Dundee Courier: “The                 SARS-CoV-2, no reports of
of being set up after £248,000 in funding     Safehouse habitats we provide to the                 transmission associated with
from NHS Tayside was secured by the           energy sector are used for welding                   dental care and the greater
hospital and school management.               activities offshore and we have inline               availability of testing and the
   A spokesperson told Scottish Dental        gas monitoring systems, so the air                   vaccination programme that has
magazine: “Dundee Dental Research             that’s fed into the habitat is monitored             recently commenced.
Hospital and School is in the process of      continuously. We create an overpressure                 However, the working group
having 20 SafeClinic pods installed to        in the habitat where hot work or welding             agreed that at present, despite
allow AGPs to be undertaken in a safe         is taking place, and this pushes any                 these developments, the agreed
environment on open clinics. Each pod         hydrocarbons away from the ignition                  positions and other conclusions
has a metal frame with flame-retardant        source, which protects the person                    within the Rapid Review remain
PVC walls and ceiling and an airlock door,    working within them.                                 unchanged. The latest standard
converting the dental unit into a Class N         “It also keeps the air free from                 operating procedures2 are
negative pressure isolation room.             toxic and flammable gases, so if any                 therefore unchanged and the
   “Each unit takes around eight hours        hydrocarbons are detected in the clean               dental IPC guidance remains the
to install and is compliant with NHS          air, the sensor closes the damper and                benchmark for safe practice and
guidelines, WHO guidelines and hospital       maintains the integrity of the habitat. We           quality care.
design and installation standards with a      harnessed this technology and adapted                   The working group was keen
key aspect being that the air changes per     it to provide safe environments for                  to re-emphasise the importance
hour can be varied from a minimum of 12       healthcare staff and patients.”                      of staff and patients continuing
per hour, which drastically cuts the fallow       Work on novel ways of allowing dental            to adhere to the precautions
time between patients.                        practice to continue during the pandemic             which are specified in current
   “Dr Brian Stevenson, Acting Clinical       is increasing. Last month, researchers               national guidance.
Director, and Joanne Cowburgh, Clinical       at New York’s Cornell University
Care Group Manager, secured funding for       published proposals for a helmet “to                 1
                                                                                                    www.sdcep.org.uk/wp-content/
this project from NHS Tayside in recent       contain pathogen-bearing droplets in                 uploads/2021/01/SDCEP-
months to allow AGPs to continue during       dental and otolaryngologic outpatient                Mitigation-of-AGPs-in-Dentistry-
the COVID pandemic.”                          interventions”1.                                     Update-25-Jan-2021.pdf
   Starn Group makes a range of                                                                    2
                                                                                                     www.bda.org/advice/Coronavirus/
equipment to deliver safe working                                                                  Pages/faqs.aspx#latest
environments in traditionally hazardous       1
                                               https://aip.scitation.org/
areas. Working in collaboration with the      doi/10.1063/5.0036749

                                                                                                                     February 2021 | 9
NEWS

Streamline vaccinator
recruitment, boards told
Government steps in after dentists tell of bureaucracy in the way of their involvement in programme

                                                                                                           out of the vaccination programme should
  Cabinet Secretary
  Jeane Freeman
                                                                                                           not be undermined by the number of
                                                                                                           vaccinators available to deliver the jabs.
                                                                                                           The UK’s Health Secretary has committed to
                                                                                                           reduce the bureaucracy faced by vaccinators
                                                                                                           and we urge the Scottish Government to
                                                                                                           do likewise.”
                                                                                                              Freeman responded by saying that she
                                                                                                           was sorry to read of his concerns. She
                                                                                                           added: “We recognise the important role
                                                                                                           that dentists across Scotland can play
                                                                                                           in delivering vaccinations and we are
                                                                                                           committed to utilising your members
                                                                                                           as the programme progresses.”
                                                                                                              The Cabinet Secretary said that officials
                                                                                                           had now written to health boards requesting
                                                                                                           that steps be taken to ensure the process
                                                                                                           for contractors to participate “is as simple
HEALTH boards have been instructed                    unnecessary elements and obstacles I                 as possible”.
to take steps to ‘diversify’ the COVID-19             faced”. He said: “As experienced medical                Health boards have been told to register,
vaccination workforce, including reducing             practitioners, dentists are fully capable of         within their staff bank, all independent
the amount of bureaucracy facing dentists             delivering vaccines and while I acknowledge          contractors – dentists and optometrists –
applying to join.                                     that some training is required, especially           within their areas who want to take part.
   It follows concerns raised by David                as the vaccines are new, the current                    In a letter, officials at the Scottish
McColl, Chair of the Scottish Dental                  training programme is overly complicated             Government’s Health Workforce
Practice Committee, in a letter to Jeane              and bureaucratic.”                                   Directorate laid out a series of steps to
Freeman, the Cabinet Secretary for                       McColl added: “While there may be some            streamline the process. They were described
Health and Sport. He set out his personal             factors limiting the vaccination of people in        by an observer as “clear, direct instructions
experience of the training “including the             Scotland, such as vaccine supplies, the roll         for boards, and not [just] guidance”.

                                                                                                      Free case evaluation
  Scanners value limited                                                                              Chrome offers pioneering full-arch stackable
                                                                                                      guide technology and was developed for dentists
  Making people stand in front of a scanner to     disease - not all who have the virus have a        who desire a pre-planned, predictable guided
  have their body temperature read can result      fever and many who do, develop one only            ‘All-On-X’ type of surgery.
  in a large number of false negatives, allowing   after admission to hospital; Measuring skin           If you would like to try Chrome for yourself, for a
  people with COVID-19 to pass through             temperature doesn’t give an accurate               limited period the Quoris 3D team is inviting dentists
  airports and hospitals undetected. Leading       estimation of deep body temperature                to take up their offer of a free case evaluation. Simply
  experts in physiology have suggested instead     (raised in a fever). A direct measure of deep      send a CBCT and retracted side-on and face-on
  that taking temperature readings of a            body temperature is impractical; A high            photos and they will evaluate the case with you.
  person’s fingertip and eye would give a          temperature, even one taken from deep                 In its entirety, the Chrome service delivers anchored
  significantly better and more reliable reading   body, does not necessarily mean a person           bite verification, anchored bone reduction, anchored
  and help identify those with fever.              has COVID-19; and taking two temperature           site drilling, accurate anchored provisionalisation, and
     The study1, co-led by a human                 measurements - one of the finger, the other        a method of transferring all surgical and restorative
  physiologist and an expert in temperature        of the eye - is likely to be a better and more     information for the final restorative conversion phase.
  regulation, Professor Mike Tipton, is            reliable indicator of a fever-induced              Data suggests that 95 per cent of all clinicians who
  published in Experimental Physiology.            increase in deep body temperature.                 try Chrome go on to use it a second, third and fourth
  Professor Tipton, of the University of              Professor Tipton said: “We think we can         time, so what are you waiting for?
  Portsmouth, said: “If scanners are not giving    improve the identification of the presence
  an accurate reading, we run the risk of          of fever using the same kit but looking at         For further information, please contact
  falsely excluding people from places they        the difference between eye and finger              Orla Sheehy, Sales Manager
  may want, or need, to go, and we also risk       temperature – it’s not perfect, but it is          Ireland & Scotland, on
  allowing people with the virus to spread the     potentially better and more reliable.”             +353 874512000 or Amanda
  undetected infection they have.”                                                                    Williams, Sales Manager England
     The study found four key factors:             1
                                                    physoc.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/               & Wales, on 07769 353598.
  Temperature alone isn’t a good indicator of      abs/10.1113/EP089260                               Alternatively, visit quoris3d.com or
                                                                                                      email chrome@quoris3d.com

10 | Scottish Dental Magazine
February 2021 | 11
NEWS

A clear vision of
                                                                                                    oral health workforce to adapt and remain
                                                                                                    equipped to deliver consistent care.
                                                                                                       “Vision 2030 outlines the ways in which
                                                                                                    we can integrate our profession within

health for 2030
                                                                                                    global development agendas, including the
                                                                                                    UN Sustainable Development goals and
                                                                                                    the implementation of universal health
                                                                                                    coverage, that determine important health
Latest FDI report outlines key strategies to improve                                                priorities,” said Professor David Williams,
                                                                                                    FDI Vision 2030 Working Group co-chair.
oral healthcare worldwide over the next decade                                                         Professor Michael Glick, FDI Vision
                                                                                                    2030 Working Group co-chair, added:
ORAL conditions such as tooth decay,                                                                “How can we anticipate transformational
gum disease, tooth loss and oral cancer are                                                         changes and trends in the global
the most widespread noncommunicable                                                                 healthcare environment? How do we
diseases worldwide – impacting 3.5 billion                                                          seize opportunities to become productive
people – and have severe and significant                                                            members of healthcare teams delivering
health, societal and economic impacts.                                                              person-centered care? These are some of
   The FDI World Dental Federation is                                                               the questions we strive to answer.”
campaigning for oral health professionals to                                                           Achieving optimal oral health for all
be actively included in all efforts to improve                                                      requires strong advocates, said the FDI.
health for all, so that population-level                                                            Through the steps laid out in Vision 2030,
prevention efforts are effective and those in                                                       the oral health profession will be well-
need receive quality care.                                                                          equipped to argue for the better integration
   Coinciding with the 148th session of          improve oral health and reduce inequalities        of oral health within overall health, it added.
the World Health Organization Executive          over the next decade,” said the FDI.                  The authors of the Vision 2030 report, an
Board in January, where an oral health              The report recommends strategies                expert team of professionals from diverse
resolution was on the agenda for adoption by     to address the oral disease burden that            sectors within the healthcare community,
governments, FDI released its Vision 2030:       communities can adapt to their own                 emphasised the need to engage with the
Delivering Optimal Oral Health for All1, “a      needs and circumstances, enabling them             public, as well as other stakeholders.
timely report that offers a comprehensive,       to implement relevant solutions. It also
inter-disciplinary roadmap on how to impact      considers how broad societal shifts, such          1
                                                                                                     www.fdiworlddental.org/resources/toolkits/
health policies and tackle challenges to         as ageing populations, will require the            vision-2030-delivering-optimal-oral-health-for-all

                                                                           New wellbeing resource
                                                                           available to dental teams
                                                                           LAUNCHED in January, the              we recognise the importance of
                                                                           Wellbeing Support for the             mental health and wellbeing for
                                                                           Dental Team guide has been            our patients. We may not
                                                                           created for all team members,         always recognise or prioritise
                                                                           including students and                our own needs. Stress is
                                                                           non-clinical roles. It outlines       common and a key driver of
                                                                           how to assess your own mental         burnout and mental ill health.
                                                                           health and wellbeing and                 “These problems can affect
                                                                           provides resources for self-care,     individuals at any stage of their
                                                                           including support organisations.      career. For a variety of reasons,
                                                                              in February 2020,                  there has been a reluctance
                                                                           stakeholders from dentistry           among the profession to speak
                                                                           and beyond came together to           about and seek support for
                                                                           discuss the wellbeing of              personal problems. Wellbeing
                                                                           dentists and their teams. Since       Support for the Dental Team,
                                                                           then a group of colleagues have       offers simple and practical
                                                                           been collaborating to bring           steps to know where you can
                                                                           together wellbeing resources in       find the support you need.”
                                                                           a single document.
                                                                              A spokesperson said: “The          www.supportfordentalteams.org
                                                                           truth is, as dental professionals,    to download your free copy.

12 | Scottish Dental Magazine
February 2021 | 13
NEWS

                                                                                                                  When time
                                                                                                                  is precious
Calls for guidance                                                                                                THE Planmeca Emerald™ S
                                                                                                                  digital intraoral scanner is a

on ventilation
                                                                                                                  smart choice.
                                                                                                                     Infection control is already
                                                                                                                  a big consideration for dental
                                                                                                                  surgeries up and down the
Government admits action needed as NSS reassures on PPE                                                           country, but now with the
                                                                                                                  addition of fallow time in
                                                                                                                  between patients, and in an
                                                                                                                  effort to minimise time in the
THE new year brought a flurry of updates on                                                                       surgery for both the patient and
key issues facing practices dealing with the                                           First Minister pledged     dental team, the Planmeca
pandemic, including PPE supply, funding                                                   to look into funding    Emerald™ S scanner is the ideal
                                                                                                   for dentists
for ventilation upgrades and guidance for                                                                         choice to get things moving.
private practices.                                                                                                   The whole process is clean
   Regarding PPE, NHS National Services                                                                           and simple. Digital scanning with
Scotland (NSS) has confirmed that the current                                                                     a handheld device leaves you less
arrangements for supplying dental practices with                                                                  open to cross infection –
a limited amount of free PPE will be extended                                                                     compared to using materials
to the end of June. This should provide some                                                                      with trays – as digital files of
reassurance about the continued supply of PPE                                                                     the scan data can be sent direct
to practices. It comes after our extensive work                                                                   to a lab. No visiting the practice
with NSS on PPE supplies for dentists, including                                                                  to collect models and discuss
reported problems with local communication                                                                        case plans.
and provision.                                                                                                       It’s also fast. Scan a precise full
   Regarding ventilation, the Scottish                   we can treat. At the very least, dentists need clear     arch in two to five minutes (less
Government has admitted that ventilation                 guidance from the Scottish Government about              for an experienced user) with a
is a fundamental part of the “COVID armoury” –           what they should be doing about ventilation.”            preheated tip that prevents
despite recent suggestions that the new                    The status of, and restrictions on, wholly             fogging. Tips come in different
Health Minister is unwilling to set aside                private practices were also confirmed. The               sizes so smaller mouths or
dedicated funding.                                       National Clinical Director and Chief Dental              interproximal areas aren’t a
   Funding of £450,000 made available by                 Officer issued a joint letter to confirm that            problem, and they are fully
the Welsh Government help cut fallow time                dentistry is essential healthcare and that               autoclavable too, lasting up to
considerably and allowed more patients to be             wholly independent or private practices can              300 cycles.
seen. Dentist leaders have called for similar            deliver a comparable service to that available
leadership in Scotland. When asked about this            through the NHS.                                         Light, fast and accurate, visit
issue, First Minister Nicola Sturgeon said: “I’m           This letter also clarified that cosmetic or            www.planmeca.com to find
unsure if the funding arrangements around                aesthetic procedures are not regarded as                 out more about the Planmeca
dentists are exactly the same in Scotland and            essential and must not be provided by any                Emerald S, or call 0800 5200 330
Wales but we will look into it.”                         practice in level four areas. We had received
   David McColl, chair of our Scottish Dental            queries from members about an apparent
Practice Committee, has made its position clear:         contradiction between what could be provided
“Dental practices still face tight restrictions that     under private and NHS dentistry, and this letter
have radically reduced the number of patients            should help to clarify the issue.

    The new standard in adhesive dentistry
    LEADING the way in adhesive                                                                                   waste and ultimately saves
    dentistry, new G2-BOND                                                                                        costs. The viscosity of the bond
    Universal with GC’s proprietary                                                                               makes it easy to apply, limiting
    Dual H-Technology brings                                                                                      the risk of pooling of the
    clinicians everything they expect                                                                             bonding layer.
    from self-etch and etch-and-                                                                                     G2-BOND Universal is ideal
    rinse gold standard products.                                                                                 for use in a multiple range of
       The Dual H-Technology of                                                                                   indications including direct
    G2-BOND Universal enables                                                                                     restorations, Immediate Dentine
    optimal bonding of tooth and                                                                                  Sealing (IDS), repair of indirect
    composite by the smooth                 The optimal thickness and         layer prevents microleakage,        restorations and treatment of
    transition from hydrophilic to       flexural strength of G2-BOND         leading to remarkable sealing       exposed root surfaces and
    hydrophobic characteristics.         Universal may act as a shock         effectiveness and virtually no      hypersensitive teeth.
    The HEMA-free composition            absorbing layer to avoid gap         post-op sensitivity.
    and hydrophobic bond layer           formation and debonding,                G2-BOND Universal’s              For more information on
    lowers the occurrence of water       especially with high shrinkage       modern, ergonomically               G2-BOND Universal contact
    sorption, decreasing the risk of     and bulk-fill composites. Its        designed two-bottle system          GC UK Ltd on 01908 218999,
    degradation while ensuring           unmatched marginal quality           allows precise dispensing,          email info.uk@gc.dental or
    superior durability.                 and strong, aesthetic bonding        prevents dripping, eliminates       visit www.gceurope.com

14 | Scottish Dental Magazine
February 2021 | 15
NEWS

Dentists honoured during
‘exceptionally tough year’
East of Scotland Branch member John Glen among those recognised

SIXTEEN individuals are being celebrated           Roz McMullan                                    guidance development groups for SIGN
in the latest round of the prestigious BDA         calling for                                     and SDCEP.
Honours and Awards, for their outstanding          award                                           • Gill Greenwood has been a member of the
                                                   nominations
achievements, their commitment to the BDA,                                                         BDA for over 30 years and was nominated for
and their work for the dental profession.                                                          her substantial contribution to dentistry and
   Roz McMullan, chair of the BDA’s Honours                                                        the Community Dental Services (CDS) Group.
and Awards Committee, said: “It is fantastic to                                                    • Pam Norman worked as a GDP since
see such a wide range of dentists nominated                                                        qualifying in 1979 has given many years of
for our awards this year. The COVID-19                                                             support to the South Wales Branch, holding
pandemic has impacted right across dentistry,                                                      many roles on the committee and currently is
and we know this has been an exceptionally                                                         acting chair, even though she has now retired.
tough year for everyone, so we feel it is just                                                     • Neil Oastler is a very modest, hard-working
as important as ever that we recognise those                                                       hospital and community dentist who has been
who have gone the extra mile for dentistry.                                                        ever present in the oral surgery department
   “We know so many members, and not just                                                          of the John Radcliffe hospital, Oxfordshire’s
those with official roles at the BDA, have                                                         Community Dental Service and its LDC for
given long hours and expert knowledge                                                              many years.
during the pandemic, and we are keen to           on subjects relevant to clinical practice in     • Dr Ivan Simmonds has given unstinting
ensure their achievements and efforts are         primary care, where he also founded the UK’s     service to the profession, the BDA and to his
acknowledged. During 2021, we want to find        leading practice-based research network.         colleagues and patients, and in his 80th year
dentists who have shown a commitment to           Trevor is a massively influential teacher,       continues to take an active role, including
advancing dentistry. We strongly encourage        editorial director, researcher and examiner      being an almoner for the BDA’s Benevolent
nominations from all areas of the profession      from undergraduate to PhD level and has          Fund since 1990.
– please consider putting forward a colleague     supervised many of the research projects         • Professor Damien Walmsley is the author of
you think deserves recognition.”                  carried out by the students enrolled on one      many textbooks and scientific peer-reviewed
                                                  of the country’s longest running master’s        articles and as an excellent communicator,
Fellowship                                        programme at the University of Birmingham.       he is always keen to share his knowledge and
• Eddie Crouch has been a consistently            Alongside his career as a university educator,   further the profession’s learning, especially in
strong voice for dentistry, appearing on          Trevor acts as a friend, mentor and advisor      the field of IT and social media.
national and local radio, particularly            to countless clinicians throughout the UK        • Brian Williams has been an outstanding
through the coronavirus pandemic,                 and around the world, and he is a key            volunteer for the BDA’s Museum, following
voicing dentists’ concerns.                       opinion leader for most global dental            a long and successful career in dentistry as a
• Martin Fulford was a renowned lecturer          manufacturing companies.                         hospital dentist and a GDP.
on cross-infection control in dental practice
and gave more than 100 lectures across the        Life Membership                                  Certificate of Merit for
UK, helping to support dentists provide the       • Jude Anderson, now retired, continues to       Services to the Profession
highest levels of health and safety.              lend her support, helping colleagues through     • Shareena Ilyas qualified in 1998 and is
• Jonathan Randall takes an active role           the COVID-19 pandemic, and plans to chair        currently a GDP working as an associate in
in dental politics and has met with local         the CDS Group session at the British Dental      a mixed NHS practice in London. She was
MPs, as well as other stakeholders, to            Conference and Dentistry Show in May.            elected to the BDA’s board in April 2020, the
represent dentistry.                              • Bridget Ashton has been a lifelong member      first Asian woman to sit on the board since
• Peter Ward’s mentoring skills have helped       of the BDA and while she was a member of         its inception.
to develop ‘deep-thinking’ dentists and staff     the Plymouth Section, became the first female
which has been invaluable to many of our          section chair in 1996, as well as serving as     Roll of Distinction
elected officers and representatives.             section treasurer for 20 years.                  • Ian Morley’s long career at the BDA began
                                                  • John Glen has always been active in the        in 1992 as a legal adviser. He later took on the
John Tomes Medal                                  East of Scotland Branch, working as a            role as the BDA’s first HR Manager in 2001,
• Professor Trevor Burke is one of the UK’s       GDP for over 30 years. He has served the         and devised many of the BDA’s policies and
most well-respected and popular clinical          branch continuously both as a Branch             procedures, enabling the organisation to
academics. He is a sought-after lecturer, both    Council member and as a member of the            ensure transparent, equitable and consultative
nationally and internationally, and is famous     Scottish Dental Practice Committee               processes. Ian has been a fundamental part
for his hugely entertaining, evidence-based       (SPDC) from 1998–2019 and the SDPC               of the fabric of the association over such
lectures and hands-on training courses.           Executive Committee from 2008 to 2019. He        a long period of time, providing much
Trevor brought 20 years of experience in          has served twice on the BDA Scottish Council     wise counsel for colleagues and elected
general dental practice to his remarkable         and was instrumental in the creation of a        representatives alike.
academic career, via Manchester, Glasgow,         Young Dentists Group in the East of Scotland
and Birmingham dental schools. His almost         Branch. During his career, he always             The deadline for the next round of nominations is
unprecedented 370-plus peer-reviewed              had a professional interest in children’s        28 May. Find out more and nominate here:
papers and textbooks are entirely focused         dentistry and was a member of two                www.bda.org/about-the-bda/honours-awards

16 | Scottish Dental Magazine
February 2021 | 17
NEWS

Practice confidence sustained
Martyn Bradshaw, of PFM Dental, reflects positively on sales and prospects for 2021

AFTER a hugely disruptive 2020, COVID           survived largely due to the continued          a lower value for their practice as a result
continues to impact on daily life but now       payments. The value of this security is not    of the missing months of lockdown.
in 2021, as the vaccine rollout continues,      lost on the current generation of associates   Put simply, and due to the exceptional
hope is certainly on the horizon. Healthcare    and shrewd corporate buyers who make up        circumstances, the answer is no. Values
businesses and, not least, dentistry have       the bulk of interested and motivated buyers.   remain the same as they did pre-lockdown.
been at the sharp end of the pandemic,             Despite the safety net granted to the NHS   This is because it is widely accepted that
however confidence in the dental sector has     sector, private practices have also been       practices are being valued based on the
been highly resilient.                          selling well in recent months. It has become   financial income and expenses to February
   This was reflected in dental practice        apparent (from the data we examine when        2020 (pre-lockdown). Therefore values are
values as we emerged from lockdown 1.0 in       valuing) that most private practices are       no different to a practice marketed on
the summer. After a brief hiatus, practices     now generating between 70–100 per cent         1 March 2020. So the EBITDA (profit) is not
came on the market as normal and sold with      of pre-COVID income. A documented              affected, and we use the same pre-COVID
relative ease. In fact, for the five months     rise towards normal turnover is therefore      multiples of EBITDA to determine the
from July to November we had 32 practices       reassuring for buyers. Furthermore, most       value as previously. For private practices,
that were sold subject to contract with         buyers appreciate that the sale process for    we do however need to show the income
legal work commenced, which is roughly          private practices takes on average four to     generated from July, month by month,
on par with what we would expect under          six months from offer to completion and        so that we can establish that the income
normal circumstances.                           the financials of practice during this time    is on an upward trajectory. This gives the
   There is no doubt that there is confidence   should get even stronger.                      buyers of private practice the confidence
in the viability and long-term value of NHS                                                    to purchase.
practices. It is hard to think of a worse       Valuations
scenario for dentistry than the one that        A question that we are frequently asked
unfolded in March 2020, yet practices           by vendors is whether they might achieve       martyn.bradshaw@pfmdental.co.uk

18 | Scottish Dental Magazine
February 2021 | 19
NEWS

                                      22 MARCH                             18-19 JUNE                         1-2 OCTOBER
                                      The new perio classification         Scottish Dental Show               ITI Congress UK & Ireland
   D AT E S                           Dundee & Perth BDA, online           Glasgow                            EICC, Edinburgh
   FOR                                tinyurl.com/y5c4enaw                 sdshow.co.uk                       https://tinyurl.com/yyms8cyw
   YOUR
   DIARY                              25 MARCH
                                      The 1st UK Restorative Dentistry
                                                                           18 JUNE
                                                                           DCP Study Day, RCSE
                                                                                                              12-14 NOVEMBER
                                                                                                              BSP Conference
                                      & Prosthodontic Conference           https://tinyurl.com/y26s8u7n       The Royal College of Physicians,
                                      Better patient care through                                             London
                                      collaboration                        25-26 JUNE                         https://tinyurl.com/yyh2bcq3
                                      Glasgow                              The British Dental
DATE TO BE CONFIRMED                                                       Conference & Dentistry Show        3 DECEMBER
                                      https://jointdentalconference2021.
24th Annual Conference for                                                 NEC, Birmingham                    FGDP(UK) Scotland Study Day
                                      eventbritestudio.
Dental Care Professionals                                                  www.thedentistryshow.co.uk         Updates on treatments for perio
                                      com/127204328571
RCSED, Edinburgh                                                                                              and endodontics.
https://tinyurl.com/y5bfduyt          17 MAY-17 JUNE                       25-26 JUNE                         Glasgow Science Centre
                                      National Smile Month                 Dental Technology Showcase         fgdpscotland.org.uk/book-
15-16 FEBRUARY                                                             NEC, Birmingham
                                      www.dentalhealth.org/national-                                          glasgow-study-day/
International Conference on Oral                                           www.the-dts.co.uk
                                      smile-month
Dermatology and Oral Pathology
                                                                                                              POSTPONED FROM
London                                TBC MAY                              26-27 JULY                         2021 TO 2022
tinyurl.com/y2lqc76u                  National Dental                      Dental Health Forum
                                      Nursing Conference                   CTF, Manchester University         6-9 JULY 2022
25 FEBRUARY                                                                https://manchesterdental.org
                                      (Normally co-located with BDC &                                         EuroPerio10
A guide to MI caries management
                                      DS; see above)                                                          Copenhagen
BDA online                                                                 10 SEPTEMBER
                                      www.badn.org.uk/Public/Events/                                          (Postponed from 2-5 June 2021)
tinyurl.com/y3mv4age                                                       Dental Care for People
                                      National-Dental-Nursing-
                                      Conference.aspx                      with Cancer
26-27 FEBRUARY                                                             https://tinyurl.com/yyav7myx
Hands-on endodontics
BDA, London
https://tinyurl.com/yxjxkxr6

                                                  Dental Compressor specialists
                      Keeping Up The Pressure                              Les Ferguson                   07885 200875
                                                                           Alex Morrison                  07495 838907
                      •   Scottish Based
                      •   Supply                                           Office                         01786 832265
                      •   Repairs
                      •   Service plan
                      •   Installation
                      •   Filtration                                       les@dencompsystems.co.uk
                      •   Inspection & Certification                       www.dencompsystems.co.uk

20 | Scottish Dental Magazine
COMMUNITY HEALTH

How teamwork pays off
Shetland is among the UK’s top performing areas for oral health in children.                                                             WORDS
                                                                                                                                       WILL
Scottish Dental spoke to some of those involved in the programmes achieving results                                                  PEAKIN

T
                    he National Dental          the most deprived areas had obvious dental         which saw Lerwick Town Hall illuminated
                    Inspection Programme        decay, compared with just over 13 per cent in      in blue, the health campaign’s signature
                    (NDIP) looks at the teeth   more affluent parts of Scotland. P1 children in    colour. “The team is so enthusiastic and
                    of two school year groups   the most deprived communities experience           knowledgeable, getting the message across
                    – P1 as children enter      more than four times the level of tooth            effectively and with fun,” he added. Last
                    local authority schools     decay – an average of 1.78 decayed, missing        month, Scottish Dental caught up with some
                    and P7 before they move     or filled teeth per child compared to 0.40 in      of the team on Shetland.
to secondary education. In 2019-20 the          the least deprived areas. The report said the         Morag Mouat, oral health improvement
teeth of more than 3,000 children – 22.5 per    gap had narrowed in recent years, but the          team leader, is responsible for the
cent of the estimated P1 population – were      British Dental Association warned decades of       Childsmile, Caring for Smiles, Open Wide
examined across Scotland.                       improvement could be at risk as a result           and Smiles for Life programmes. A dental
   While the inspections in school are not      of the pandemic.                                   hygienist, she works in clinic two days
necessarily as rigorous as those conducted in      The top performing areas in Scotland            a week. “I travel to satellite clinics, both
a dental surgery, they do record decay where    were Orkney (84.02 per cent of P1 children         require a ferry crossing,” she said. “There
disease has penetrated below the white          had no experience of dental decay) and             are some interesting trips in winter!”
enamel layer. The latest findings, published    Shetland (84 per cent). Antony Visocchi,           Because of the pandemic, Morag has not
by Public Health Scotland (PHS) last October,   director of dentistry for NHS Shetland, said:      been in clinic since March last year. It was
showed that nearly 74 per cent of children in   “Our NDIP figures have been maintained             “all hands-on-deck”, supporting staff and
P1 had no obvious decay in their baby teeth –   at a very high level for some years and I am       devising ways to continue their work.
a three percentage point improvement on the     glad to say we are still there after the results      Morag did her dental nurse training in
previous year. When the programme began in      were recently published. We are aware the          Edinburgh before coming home to work
2002-3, only 45 per cent of P1 children were    lack of access to dental services and the long     for the then community dental team. “I
without evidence of tooth decay. The figures    lockdown could have had a detrimental              was fortunate to be involved in the fluoride
also showed the average number of decayed,      effect on the dental health of all vulnerable      research project in the isles in the 1980s.
missing or filled teeth per child had reduced   groups across the island.” His comments            Professor Ken Stephens, from Glasgow
from 2.76 in 2002-03 to 1.04 in 2019-20.        coincided with the launch by the NHS oral          Dental Hospital, was the lead and through
Despite improvements, PHS highlighted the       health improvement team in Shetland of a           this my interest in prevention grew.” Morag
link between deprivation and poor dental        Facebook1 page and, during Mouth Cancer            completed a hygiene course at Glasgow
health. Almost 42 per cent of P1 children in    Action Month in November2, an initiative           before returning to Shetland to launch

  The Shetland oral health team,
  during Mouth Cancer Action Month

22 | Scottish Dental Magazine
February 2021 | 23
COMMUNITY HEALTH

a preventative programme. She worked
in practice and joined the Public Dental
                                                   and welcome the opportunity to discuss
                                                   their child’s health. Michelle said she found
                                                                                                     Team views
Service, assuming her current role in 2016.        online appointments less bureaucratic,            CLARE BALFOUR is an oral health
   “I have seen how oral health has improved       allowing more time for rapport-building,          support worker and extended duties
since my first days of dental nursing,” she        discussion and advice. “Usually, by the time      dental nurse who, in normal times, visits
said. “I’m aware that projects we start may        the paperwork is complete in a normal             and supports nurseries and schools with
not see the benefits until many years in the       clinic setting, children have lost patience,”     the Childsmile programme and fluoride
future. Oral health was always a poor relation     she said. “Online, we are able to get on with     varnish visits.
of medical health and I hope that during my        the appointment immediately.” Michelle is            “From working many years ago as a
time in this job I have worked hard in making      collaborating with researchers from Dundee        dental nurse and seeing the poor state
sure it is included in all aspects of care.        University’s School of Dentistry on using         of children’s teeth, it made me want to
   “During the pandemic I’ve tried to do the       observational analysis to evaluate Near           help make a difference. Due to hard work
best I could in the ever-changing situation;       Me appointments for potential permanent           by staff – both dental and in educational
supporting staff and encouraging them to           incorporation, into the standard Childsmile,      establishments, as well as by parents –
think outside the box on how we can deliver        Community and Practice appointment                NDIP results have shown the children
oral health messages with new barriers in          system, already well established in Shetland.     here now consistently have among the
place. For the Childsmile team, who are used          Angela Hopwood is an oral health               best teeth in Scotland,” she said.
to daily interaction with children, this was a     improvement nurse who works on all                   “I would like to keep that trend
massive change. Once we settled down and           aspects of Childsmile, as well as liaising with   continuing and keeping parents engaged
Teams came into the equation, they started to      other health professionals and working with       and appreciating how important good
brainstorm on how they could reach children        vulnerable groups. “A small, but important,       oral health is for all and why.” Clare has
and particularly vulnerable families.”             part of my role is in the delivery of local       begun training in Near Me consultations
   Morag added: “Some staff enjoyed                interventions for the national oral health        and is looking forward to holding
working at home, others not so! Once we get        and homelessness project, Smile4Life,” said       Childsmile appointments online.
back to normal we will look at how we can          Angela. Shetland does not have a rough               “The consensus so far is that parents
make this work. We have all become more au         sleeping population per se, but there are         have been finding the appointments
fait with technology. We looked at setting up      people not in settled accommodation.              very useful, so we hope to build on that,”
a Facebook page for a few years, but this time        “Routine dental care is an important           she said.
has allowed the team to set it up and keep         part of building self-esteem and improving           Elizabeth White is also an oral health
it updated. The team, from being nervous           mental health, and supporting a return            support worker who, pre-pandemic like
about appearing in front of a camera, have         to education and employment, which are            Clare, visited nurseries and schools
embraced it. I’m really proud of them.”            important parts of the route back into safe       across Shetland. “Childsmile has greatly
   Her aims for 2021? “To make sure staff are      and settled accommodation,” said Angela.          improved the oral health of children in
well and feel supported. I fear coming out            With the help of specialist colleagues,        Shetland over the past 10 or more years
of this pandemic may be more difficult than        Angela has developed an autism and                – we have been successful in getting to
going into it – a bit like staggering towards      learning disability Patient Communication         see every nursery-aged child in Shetland
your holidays and then ending up with a            Passport for Shetland’s dental service. It        for toothbrushing and oral health
heavy cold. Getting back into schools will be      allows clinical teams to be briefed on a          education – and the aim is to ensure this
a major part of our year for the Childsmile        patient’s needs before they attend, improving     continues. Hopefully we will be able to
team. I know they can’t wait to be able to         compliance in treatment and reducing              get back into nurseries and schools in
engage with the children again. Personally,        missed or delayed appointments. She has           the not-too-distant future.”
this is a time to look at how we engage with       also developed sensory aid boxes for dental          Colleagues Niki Madai and Zdenka
vulnerable, non-engaging families. This            settings, for patents with autism or learning     Mlynarikova both highlighted the
has always been a challenge and although           disabilities and people with dental anxieties.    benefits of thinking differently about
Near Me has been a success we have to                 “Raising awareness around mouth                how to engage people. Niki commented:
understand digital poverty and not everyone        cancers has been a huge driver for me,” said      “While the pandemic meant face-to-
has, or wants, the ability to connect to us.”      Angela. “We have always held campaigns            face appointments and visits couldn’t
   Michelle Sinclair is a senior dental nurse      in Shetland to raise awareness. We include        go ahead, it’s pushed me to be more
tutor and oral health educator. During the         mouth cancer awareness in lessons with            creative. Being able to reach people
pandemic, she participated in webinars             secondary school pupils and more people are       through Facebook has been a huge
provided by allied health professionals            aware of mouth cancers, not just locally but      success. We aim to keep enrolling
and the Near Me video consultation team            across the country, thanks to the Oral Health     children, even if we can’t visit them, and
to explore the use of online appointments          Foundation’s campaign.” She added: “The           to find new ways of encouraging people
for Childsmile Community and (dental)              plan for 2021 is how we deliver programmes        to pay attention to their oral health.”
Practice (CSC&P) appointments. Michelle            under restrictions. We have concerns when            Zdenka, who is also studying music,
hosted weekly appointments, mainly for             schools are closed in regard to the content       agreed: “Creativity seemed to be a way
children from six months to two and a half         of snacks at home and the potential for           forward in everything we have done,
years. “This is the age group who have had         children to graze rather than have break          using our spare time effectively to learn
the least oral health input as they have not       times. This could impact on oral health. Near     new skills, such as video editing or social
started nursery or school,” she said. Older        Me appointments will go a long way to reach       media insights.
siblings can take part and, said Michelle,         families and encourage positive behaviours,          “The Facebook page has been quite a
they have “engaged with the Near Me                but we are mindful that it is going to be         success so far, and our two-minute tooth
process, being honest about their oral health      motivated families engaging with us so            brushing song and video was shared by
regimes”. The frustrations of IT and lack of       finding new ways to target hard-to-reach          many health-related organisations
in-person contact aside, there are benefits        groups is to me paramount.”                       within the isles and sent out to schools
to online appointments, she said. They are                                                           and nurseries, which we believe had
less prone to cancellation if a child is unwell,   1
                                                    www.facebook.com/                                positive impact on children’s oral health.”
or the weather is bad, and even if the child       oralhealthimprovementshetland
becomes distracted, parents remain engaged         2
                                                     www.dentalhealth.org/bluewednesday

24 | Scottish Dental Magazine
February 2021 | 25
INNOVATION

Creating H.O.P.E
from challenge
Collaboration between a dental school and designers has led to a low-cost 3D-printed
device allowing students to practise key skills remotely or socially-distanced in class

WORDS
CLEMENT SEEBALLUCK, WITH
TUNG HIN LAU AND DESMOND MANANGAZIRA

T
                    wo thousand          of H.O.P.E. - Home Operational
                    and twenty           Practice Equipment (if you have
                    was certainly a      a good acronym, you are halfway
                    trying year for      there). This is a device that has
                    our profession.      the potential to allow students to
                    Virtually all        practice key skills from home or
                    aspects of           remotely for a minimal cost. The
dentistry encountered unique             development of this was accelerated
challenges as we approached              throughout 2020 and it proved to be
uncharted territory; lockdowns,          quite useful in meeting some of the
social distancing, aerosol generating    unique challenges we encountered.
procedures and furlough. At
times, we think it is safe to say        The problem
we all felt much the same as that        I have been interested in the
first day at dental school, a heady      integration of remote teaching and
mix of uncertainty and a drive to        the early development of skills
ultimately become immersed in            applicable to a broad range of dental
patient care. Married to a General       procedures. Students learn skills
Dental Practitioner, and my own          at their own pace; as a student, I
work as a clinical lecturer in           witnessed first-hand that a ‘one size
dentistry, it became apparent to me      fits all’ curriculum did not always     Figure 1 The           These problems have been
how varied were the challenges we        work well. Students experienced         initial equipment   exacerbated in the past year.
                                                                                 set up used for
all faced. However, the solutions to     genuine anxiety when they took a        the early skills
                                                                                                     Capacity of training spaces has been
these challenges all had a common        little longer than their colleagues     development         greatly reduced to accommodate
theme: innovation.                       to develop a clinical skill such as     exercises           social distancing guidelines, with the
    Problematic as 2020 proved to be,    undertaking a composite restoration,                        inevitable consequence of students
it could also be viewed as a catalyst    perfecting the form and function.                           having reduced hands-on experience.
for change. I stress catalyst rather        Developing skills in a safe                                 The opportunities to practice
than instigator. Dentistry, both in      environment is key for dental                               and ‘self-discover’ have also been
training and practice has always been    training. However, with limited                             negatively affected. Additionally,
an adaptive profession, striving to      simulated training resources,                               as teaching moves to more online
improve. The events of the past year     students don’t always get the time                          formats, there is less opportunity
merely accelerated and guided change.    they need to practice and develop                           for impromptu informal discussions
    I have witnessed countless           their skills.                                               between the trainees and trainers.
examples of innovative solutions
implemented by colleagues for
dental training over the past year
as universities have shifted towards
a blended online and practical
approach. It is unsurprising,
given the dedication we all have
to the profession, but nonetheless
                                         A PEN SIMULATED THE ANGULATIONS OF A HANDPIECE TO
impressive.
    I will detail here the development   INSTILL BASIC PRINCIPLES OF INSTRUMENT ERGONOMICS”
26 | Scottish Dental Magazine
this time that we started collaborating
                                                                                                           with Alasdair Napier, a colleague at
                                                                                                           the renowned Duncan of Jordanstone
                                                                                                           College of Art and Design at the
                                                                                                           University of Dundee. For the past
                                                                                                           year, he has provided invaluable
                                                                                                           advice regarding 3D modelling
                                                                                                           development and committed printing
                                                                                                           resources towards the production of
                                                                                                           rapid prototypes, and ultimately the
                                                                                                           final product.
                                                                                                              However, the most surprising
                                                                                                           collaboration, that lead to the final
                                                                                                           product, was with our current
                                                                                                           undergraduate students. We must
                                                                                                           always remember that our students
                                                                                                           come to the course with unique
                                                                                                           talents and an eagerness to shape
                                                                                                           their education. They also have the
All this before we even consider the      (Left) Figure 2        be printed. This had a number of          most contemporaneous insight into
                                          the final 3D
reduced clinical experience.              rendered redesign
                                                                 advantages over simply creating           their training needs.
                                          of our “training       moulds. We were able to create a             Tung Hin Lau and Desmond
Sparking the novel                        pen”                   design that could be modular and          Manangazira had some experience
approach to the challenge                                        adaptive, with an internal screw          in creating and printing 3D models.
                                          (Right) Figure 3
I was fortunate to have been teaching                            thread (Figures 2 and 3).                 I was amazed at how quickly they
                                          The Printed version
during the transition in the Dundee       of the pen being          The second event that really           adapted and developed these skills
Dental School to the new 4D               used with our          accelerated this project would            for this project. Tung was working
Curriculum. I had the opportunity         revised exercise       be the first nationwide lockdown          at home from an apartment in Hong
                                          sheet
to work on the development of a new                              due to the COVID-19 pandemic.             Kong at this uncertain time, with
early rotary instrument clinical skills                          Thus, several factors combined to         limited access to computer resources
course. This course was designed                                 create the perfect environment for           Even with these constraints, he was
using modern educational principles,                             collaboration and creation: a silver      able to produce incredible designs
and executed with less conventional                              lining in the midst of some rather        within short time frames. Their
exercises, some of which required                                dark clouds.                              dedication and commitment, to say
the creation of new equipment.                                                                             the least, continues to impress me.
   It was in 2018 that the initial                               How it developed                             It was important that we made our
concept of instrument analogues was                              With the stay-at-home order in            goals realistic. The functionality of any
implemented. The first iteration was                             effect, the idea of a cheap alternative   training activity, undertaken outwith
a pen that simulated the angulations                             to a phantom head that could be           a clinical skills laboratory, cannot
of a handpiece to instill the basic                              used by students at home or isolating     require suction, rotary instruments
principles of instrument ergonomics       (Left) Figure 4        seemed more relevant than ever.           and pressurised air or water.
in early year students. This was          Initial concept           I collaborated with a former dental       Furthermore, safety considerations
                                          for baseplate
fabricated using expired denture          with features to       student, Yu En Cheah, to convert          regarding potentially unsupervised
acrylic in a silicone mould (Figure 1).   accommodate            my concept drawing into an initial        activities must be considered;
   Using a mirror for indirect vision,    Indirect vision        3D prototype. I had worked with Yu        particulate generating and cutting
students would use these pens             and positioning        En on several teaching resources          exercises were not practically
                                          exercises
to navigate mazes created by my                                  when he was an undergraduate              viable as these would require close
colleague, Roddy Milne. Although          (Right) Figure 5       and had every confidence in his           supervision and access to costly
the course was positively received,       initial print out of   resourcefulness.                          equipment and air compressors and
production times and cost were an         device. This was a        We quickly created an initial          high-volume suction.
                                          single component
issue. There was also the limitation      print, with limited    prototype file and (Figure 4) printed        We decided to focus on three key
of working on a flat surface rather       application.           for testing (Figure 5). It was around     concepts that would provide good
than matching dental arch contours.
   There were really two
serendipitous events that occurred in
the development of our equipment.
Later that year, the University of
Dundee opened a new Creative
Space within the main library,
where staff and students could work
with several crafts, including 3D
modelling and printing. Here I met
Richard Parsons, CIO Director of the
Library Learning Centre.
   We discussed the overall concept
and together explored CADCAM
for streamlining the equipment
and creating a prototype that could

                                                                                                                               February 2021 | 27
You can also read