THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - $4.50 - Australian Museum

 
CONTINUE READING
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
$4.50

  THE
SCOTT
SISTERS
 ART FROM
THE ARCHIVES

 CAMELS IN
  -
 AUSTRALIA
'ROO
 HARVES TING
 PIG-NOSED
 TURTLE
 SOLOMON'S
 VOLCANOES
WHAT'S
'NATURAL'l

WINTER 1987 VOL. 22 N0.5
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
YouthSho Id Not be
 Wastedo the Youn

 P     eople of all ages belong to
       Youth Hostels.
       From an old church at
 Carrington to a colonial pub at
 Narrandera, a schoolhouse at
                                                           swim at Springwood or bushwalk
                                                           at Bundanoon: Youth Hostels are
                                                           located in the most scenic parts of
                                                           NSW. Many are near national parks
                                                           like the Warrumbungles, Blue
 Scone to a modern lodge at                                Mountains, Snowy Mountains,
 Thredbo, Youth Hostels are cosier                         Kuringai and Barrington Tops.
 than a caravan and cheaper                                There are hostels throughout
 than a hotel.                                             Australia and the world that YHA
 Canoe at Coffs Harbour, birdwatch                         members can use.
 at Bega, cycle round Canberra,                            Join now.
 YOUTH HOSTELS ASSOCIATION OF NSW GPO Box 5276 Sydney
 NSW 2001 176 Day Street, Sydney Phone: (02) 267 3044
 Other YHA Offices: Brisbane (07) 831 2022 Adelaide (08) 51 5583 Hobart (002) 34 9617 Darwin
 (089) 84 3902 Melbourne (03) 67 7991 Perth (09) 325 5844
                                                                                               YHA•NSW
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
Australian
   Natural History
                                               EDITORIAL                                   Discoveries Diverse

                                             D
              Published by                           iscovery. The word usually            ly to the early exploration of this coun­
     The Australian Museum Trust                     refers to finding something new.      try (p. 220). But discoveries are not
           6-8 College Street,                      In this issue we adopt a different     always 'large'. Small things are easily
         Sydney, N.S.W. 2000
         Phone: (02) 339 8111                slant by looking back to discover some­       overlooked. The stunning close-up pho­
    Trust President: Robyn Williams          thing old-some of the magnificent 19th        tographs of bryophytes-miniatures of
   Museum Director: Desmond Griffin          century illustrations by Harriet and          the plant world (p. 238)-will ensure
                                             Helena Scott (p. 194). These two sisters      that your eyes are kept well to the
                 EDITOR                      worked as scientific illustrators and their   ground when next out in the bush. Dis­
                Fiona Doig                   paintings have been cloistered in the         cover also in this issue what it is like to
           SCIENTIFIC EDITOR                 library archives of the Australian            live at the base of an active volcano in
         Georgina1iickey, B.Sc.              Museum for well over a century. Also          the Solomon Islands. Find out how this
             CIRCULATION                     looking back at Australia's past, Gordon      affects the people who live there (p.
              John McIntosh                  Grigg salutes the camel: the capabilities     210) and if Australia really is volcanically
            ART DIRECTION                    and endurance of this large, arid­            dead. You might be surprised!
           Watch This! Design
                                             adapted species contributed enormous-                              -Fiona Doig, Editor
              TYPESETTING
   Love Computer Typesetting Pty Ltd
               FILM WORK                                                                    Contents
    South Sea International Press Ltd
                PRINTING                                                                   Scott Sisters -                        194
            RodenPrint Pty Ltd                                                             Art Treasures of the
              ADVERTISING                                                                  19th Century Revealed
               Jean Barnet                                                                 Marion Ord
              (02) 939 6263
              (02) 339 8234                                                                Palm Cockatoos-Drumming to             199
                                                                                           a Different Beat
            SUBSCRIPTIONS                                                                  Graham Wood
      Annual subscription (4 issues)                                                       Solomon's Volcanoes-Life               210
       Within Australia $A 13.00                                                           on the Verge
       Other Countries $A 15.00                                                            Bill Gladstone
     Two-year subscription (8 issues)
       Within Australia $A25.00                                                            Camels-Humpbacks of the                220
        Other countries $A30.00                                                            Desert
                                                                                           Gordon Grigg
  For renewal or new subscription please                                                   Warradjan-The Pig-nosed                230
  forward credit card authority or cheque                                                  Turtle
               made payable to:                                                            Arthur Georges
           The Australian Museum
         P.O. Box A285 Sydney South                                                        Bryophytes-Exquisite Miniatures        238
            N.S.W. 2000, Australia                                                         of the Plant World
  Subscribers from other countries please                                                  Patricia Selkirk, Alison Downing
      note that money must be paid in                                                      and Helen Ramsay
             Australian currency.
     All material appearing in Australian
                                                                                           WILD FOODS
          Natural History is copyright.                                                    Ground Orchids-Salute to Saloop 202
   Reproduction in whole or in part is not                                                 Tim Low
  permitted without written authorisation
               from the Editor.                                                            FORUM
  Opinions expressed by the authors are                                                    Kangaroo Harvesting-A                  204
      their own and do not necessarily                                                     New Approach
    represent the policies or views of the
                                                                                           Gordon Grigg
             Australian Museum.
       The Editor welcomes articles or                                                     RARE & ENDANGERED
   photographs in any field of Australian
                natural history.                                                           Classifying Australia's                208
                                                                                           Threatened Fishes
                                                                                           John Harris
             Published 1987                                                                PHOTOART
             ISSN-0004-9840                                                                Outback Sentinels                      235
                                                                                           Marianne Porteners
               Front Cover
                                                                                           REGULAR FEATURES
 The Dingy Swallowtail, Papilio anactus.                                                   Books                                  206
 This painting, by Helena Scott,                                                           Quips, Quotes & Curios                 215
 complete with foxing spots and                                                            Vincent Serventy                       218
 correction marks, is from the library
 archives of the Australian Museum.                                                        Letters                                227
                                                                                           Robyn Williams                         228
                                                                                           Poster Article                         229

AUSTRALIAN NATURAL HISTORY                                                                                                         193
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
/

·\
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
The
         Scott Sisters
               Art treasures
           of the 19th century
                revealed
                           By Marion Ord

               "O       h! you cannot think how
                        thankful I am that my dear
                        father allows me to place my
               name to the drawings! It makes me feel
               twice as much pleasure while I paint
               them!"

                    Helena Scott was 30 when she
               wrote those words to her childhood
               friend Edward Pierson Ramsay, who
               later became Curator of the Australian
               Museum. It was 1862 and she and her          Bombay, "a naturalist's paradise" not un­
               elder sister, Harriet, were already well    like Ash Island. His father, Dr Helenus
               launched on their careers as profession­    Scott, was botanist and physician to the
               al artists and natural science collectors    East India Company for almost 30 years
               and illustrators. They were acquainted      and Walker inherited his father's in­
               through their father with scientists        terests. As well as his botanical studies,
               around the world, and with many in the      however, Walker took his MA at Cam­
               colony of New South Wales. These in­        bridge, studied law briefly, pioneered
               cluded the Macleays; Dr George Ben­         several industries and institutions in        vi
                                                                                                         0
               nett, who was the first Secretary, and      Newcastle, and was a Liberal member           u::
               Gerard Krefft, an early Curator, of the     of the first Legislative Assembly for         �
               Australian Museum.                          Northumberland and Hunter in 1856.            ::c
                    Harriet and Helena were the            He was also a trustee of the Australian       �
               daughters of Alexander Walker Scott of      Museum in 1864-66 and 1867-79.                �
               Ash Island at Hexham, on the Hunter               "I've entered into a very stimulat-     2
                                                                                                         0
               River. Walker Scott, "entomologist and      ing association with a Mr. Robert Scott       11::
               entrepreneur", was one of a large and       and his brother, Walker Scott", wrote         z
               influential family who had migrated to      Ludwig Leichhardt in June 1842, soon          Q
               New South Wales from England in the         after his arrival in Australia. "Their sis-   �
               1820s. He was born in India, on the         ter is married to a doctor named Mitch-       �
               reclaimed island of Salsette north of       ell [Dr James Mitchell of the Rum             ::::l

AUSTRALIAN NATURAL HISTORY                                                                                       195
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
Australian Lepidoptera

                                                ...,;::i;;;-
Hospital]. These people have been in­
terested in natural history since their
childhood and have been keen collec­         representation from life. Scott was a         where he had emigrated, was prema­
tors of everything that seemed worthy        talented artist and his closest friend in     ture. The Lepidoptera book, lacking
of remark. I have certainly found their      England was the painter Edwin Land­           funds, was not published in Australia
collection of minerals and shells instruc­   seer, whose portrait of Alexander Walk­       but in England 12 years later, in 1864.
tive in the extreme."                        er Scott resides in the Art Callery of        Five hundred copies were then printed.
     Leichhardt visited Ash Island later     New South Wales.                              Swainson noted:
in the same year:                                 From early childhood the sisters         "Of the execution of these drawings I
"Mr. Scott has very kindly come with         had visited the family of Dr David Ram­       am almost afraid to write lest the pub­
me on some of my tramps. He . ..is in­       say of "Dobroyd" at Ashfield, another         lic may think that the desire of com­
clined to proceed briskly, like a nimble     Scottish emigrant obsessed with natur­        plimenting the fair artists . ..may have
huntsman, and his sharp eyes notice the      al science and new plant species. His         biased my judgment. I am willing,
less conspicuous of the new varieties of     wife, Sarah, was the daughter of eman­        however, to hazard that scrupulous
plants more easily than mine do . ..It's     cipist Simeon Lord.The mix of scientists      regard for veracity which the scientific
a romantic place which I like well           and emancipists formed a more liberal­        public has long given me credit for,
enough to think that-perhaps-I'd be          minded community than that of the ex­         when I state that these drawings are
content to live and die there."              clusives in the colony, who wanted to         equal to any I have ever seen by
     In 1846 Walker Scott married Har­       live like the English gentry and hated        modern artists... Whether we look to
riet Calcott, daughter of a convict "freed   convicts, emancipists, the Catholics and      the exquisite and elaborate finishing,
by servitude", with whom he had been         the Irish. The friendship of the Scott sis­   the correct drawing, or the astonishing
living. She was the mother of his daugh­     ters with E.P.Ramsay began at this time,      exactitude of the colours, often most
ters Harriet and Helena, then 16 and 14.     continuing throughout their lives. Let­       brilliant, and generally indescribably
After the marriage he took them all to       ters to him remain their only surviving       blended, there is no poetic exaggera­
live on Ash Island, a grant of 2,560 acres   correspondence. "You are one of the           tion in saying: The force of painting can
 which he had been developing since          very few to whom I scribble just as I         no further go'."
1829. Ash Island oranges were famous         think so you may be sure I have confi­              Swainson then discussed the
in the colony and Scott experimented         dence in you ", wrote Helena ("Nellie")       Lepidoptera species under their differ­
with flax and tobacco crops and grew         in 1862.                                      ent families, noting those not seen be­
grapes for wine. In 1847 he imported              In the Sydney Morning Herald of 30       fore and others which were important.
five German vine dressers to work for        August 1851 appeared a long review of         "Commencing then with the diurnal or
him.                                         a work on moths and butterflies soon          day-flying tribe, we have in Plate 52 the
     To Harriet and Helena, who had          to be published: Australian Lepidoptera       newly discovered Amprisius Australis
been born in Harrington Street in Syd­       and their Transformations, drawn from         [Ornithoptera australis, today known as
ney's Rocks area, Ash Island introduced      the Life by Harriet and Helena Scott,         0. richmondia] a large insect of surpas­
a freedom in which they could develop        with Descriptions General and Sys­            sing beauty, recently discovered in the
 and indulge their talents, at their own     tematic, by A.W. Scott M.A. The               neighbourhood of the Richmond River.
pace. Already their father had taught        review, by the eminent botanist W.            In its general colour it strongly resem­
them his skills in observation and exact     Swainson on a visit from New Zealand          bles the famous Priam butterfly of Am-

196                                                                                                VOL. 22 NO. 5, WINTER 1987
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
SCOTT FAMILY TREE

                                                                  Dr Helenus Scott m. Augusta M.an.a Frederid 1796 (Bomb.ly)

                                              August.a M.an.a      Robert            AUX.WAl.KER                                          Patrid
                                              b. 1798              b. 1799 d. 1&44   b 1800 d. 1883         1802-79                       1806-117
                                              m 1833 Dr J Mitchell                   m 1846 HARRIET CALCOTT
                                              d 1871                                         b 1804 d 1866  m Sar.1nna R..,

                                              A M.uia       David Scott    Margaret      HARRIIT            HB.ENA
                                              b 1834        b. 1836        b 1837          ��
                                                                                         1830-1907          1832-1910
                                              10 children   d. 1907        m. Quigley    m. Dr C.W. Morg.tn m. Edward Forde 1864
                                              m. Ch                        3 children    1882
                                              Merewether
                                                                                                                            \
                                                                                                               9 surviving children induding
                                                                                                                        Rose
                                                                                                                        b 1847
                                                                                                                        d 1925

boyna and the Indian isles . .. That an
                                                 ,---
insect of such dimensions and so strik­
ingly beautiful should only just have
been discovered, is but one of the
many proofs how little is yet known of
Australian entomology beyond a short
distance from the capital."
    Under Noctuidae, Swainson wrote:
"The present series . .. contains one of
the most beautiful species known,
which see[T)s to be the same . .. or
closely allied to others found in India.
It is the Catocala Menispermi, Plate 17
of our author, and is as richly coloured
in its larvae as in its perfect state. This
drawing is one of the most beautifully
executed in the whole collection."
     Many of the Lepidoptera were
drawn against landscapes of Sydney in
the style of Conrad Martens, a friend of
the Scott family and best-known of the
colony's painters. As a result of their
work, the sisters were elected honorary
members of the Entomological Society,
a unique honour for women of their

                                                 I
                                                 l_
time.
     Later in 1864 Helena Scott married
an Anglo-Irish artist and navigator, Ed­
ward Forde, who was working for the
Department of Harbours and River

                                                       ,,
Navigation. They were married on Ash
Island and a young cousin, Rose Scott,
who was later to become famous as a                                                                                                   ----)
social reformer, was one of the wit­
nesses.
     The couple moved to Sydney and
in 1865 sailed for Adelaide. Dr Lionel
Gilbert wrote:                                                                                  4

"Edward Forde was sent to survey the                                                 [7�,:

AUSTRALIAN NATURAL HISTORY                                                                                                                           197
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
the Mr. Scott that has the clever

      r
                                                                                                 daughters?'"
                                                                                                        But early in 1866 Mrs Scott died.
                                                                                                 Walker, Harriet and Mary Ann moved
                                                                                                 to Sydney. Walker, inept in business
                                                                                                 matters, was made bankrupt and the
                                                                                                 Ash Island property sold, although
                                                                                                 Scott's books and personal belongings
                                                                                                 were returned to him by his creditor!i.
                                                                                                 Harriet now gladly embraced the life of
                                                                                                 the city "where we can be much hap­

                                                                                 '
                                                                                                 pier than at so very quiet a place."
                                                                                                        For several years Harriet and Hele­
                                                                                                 na executed almost all the artwork for
                                                                                                 scientific literature produced in Sydney,
                                                                                                  including J.C. Cox's Monograph of Aus­
                                                                                                  tralian Land Shells (1868) and Krefft's
                                                                                                 Snakes of Australia (1869) and Mammals
                                                                                                 of Australia (1871). They also designed
                                                                                                 the first Australian Christmas cards,
                                                                                                 printed by Turner & Henderson in 1879.
                                                                                                       In 1882 Harriet married Dr Cosby
                                                                                                 William Morgan, recently widowed,
                                                                                                 who was an old friend from the days
                                                                                                 at Newcastle. They lived for several
                                                                                                 years at Pambula on the south coast.
                                                                                                 Harriet did little work after her marri­
                                                                                                 age although she illustrated the 1884
                                                                                                 and 1886 editions of the Railway Guide.
                                                                                                       After Walker Scott's death in 1883,
                                                                                                 Helena persuaded the Australian Muse­
                                                                                                 um to publish the second volume of his
                                                                                                 Lepidoptera in five parts (1890-98). As

                                                                                 '
                                                                                                 a freelance with no other capital, she
                                                                                                 had to earn her own living. "I must try
                                                                                                 and earn a little money somehow to
                                                                                                 keep the wolf from the door", she
                                                                                                 wrote to a cousin in 1904 when she was
                                                                                                 72. She had applied to the Museum for
                                                                                                 "some scientific work which is all I am
                                                                                                 fit for ...".
                                                                                                       Harriet Scott died at Granville, Syd­
                                                                                                 ney in 1907 and Helena at Harris Park,
Darling River between Wentworth and          "Hers was probably the most represen­               a few streets away, in 1910. They were
Bourke for obstructions to river naviga­     tative collection of plants from the low­           bypassed in history until Nancy Gray be­
tion. Helena Forde accompanied her           er Darling brought to Sydney up to this             gan to collate the Scott family papers
husband and by August 1865 she was           time." Part of it later found its way into          in the Mitchell Library some years ago.
collecting and painting specimens            the collection of Yon Mueller in Mel­               Fortunately their extraordinary work
around the survey camp near Went­            bourne.                                             survives to speak for them, and to recall
worth, a noteworthy effort for a wom­             Meanwhile Harriet or "Hattie" lived            the painstaking hours spent on Ash ls­
an in such a remote area at that             on at Ash Island with her parents and               land recording the life cycles of moths
time . . . By March 1866 she had a           half-sister Mary Ann. There were visits             and butterflies. D
reasonable amount of material on hand        to Wollongong where she painted
for her proposed illustrated 'Flora of the   several landscapes, and to Sydney, and              The Ash Island Series, the work of Har­
Darling'. In the vicinity of Menindee,       commissions for Ramsay and others.                  riet and Helena Scott, is scheduled for
however, both husband and wife con­          Harriet, who longed to have been "Har­              publication in 1988 by The Craftsman's
tracted fever. Helena recovered but Ed­      ry Scott instead of Hattie Scott"and to             Press. The books, arranged and in­
ward died on 20th June, 1866 'of low         have had a university education, was                troduced by Marion Ord, are: Histori­
fever and exhaustion'."                      delighted and a little in awe of her own            cal Drawings of Moths & Butterflies,
     On the return to Sydney, Helena         success:                                            Vol. 1. From the Collections of The Aus­
gave her material to William Woolls for      "Fancy Mr. Krefft introducing Papa to a             tralian Museum; and Historical Draw­
his work A Contribution to the Flora of      friend of his . . . a Mr. Pitt . . . and the said   ings of Native Flowers, Vol. 2. From the
Australia (Sydney, 1867). Gilbert wrote:     Mr. Pitt accosting Papa with 'Are you               Collections of The Mitchell Library.
198                                                                                                      VOL. 22 NO. 5, WINTER 1987
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
THE SCOTT SISTERS ART FROM - .50 - Australian Museum
worth further investigation!
                                                                                               So began a fascination with a truly
                                                                                          remarkable bird. I had come to Iron
                                                                                          Range, on north-eastern Cape York
                                                                                          Peninsula, to familiarise myself with
                                                                                          changes in the fauna, particularly the in­
                                                                                          sects, brought about by the wet season.
                                                                                          But the course of my studies was about
                                                                                          to take a radical change in direction.
                                                                                               Several days later I woke to the
                                                                                          same sound. Moving along the edge of
                                                                                          the forest, guided by the drumming, I
                                                                                          found myself peering up through a
                                                                                          break in the canopy. Silhouetted against
                                                                                          a sombre sky was a Palm Cockatoo,
                                                                                          wings outstretched, turning from side
                                                                                          to side and beating the top of the hol­
                                                                                          low trunk on which he was perched.
                                                                                          The large bill and superior size suggest­
                                                                                          ed to me it was male. All too quickly
                                                                                          he departed, leaving me with the puz­
                                                                                          zle of how such volume was produced.
                                                                                          Certainly he could not just have been
                                                                                          beating with his foot.
                                                                                               Several days passed until I wit­
                                                                                          nessed the next, although brief, perfor­
                                                                                          mance. The other member of the pair,
                                                                                          which was standing sentry, raised the
                                                                                          alarm and they were gone. But, on
                                                                                          departing, the performer dropped the
                                                                                          piece of branch he had been using as
                                                                                          a drumstick. This bounced noisily down
                                                                                          the interior of the stump, unfortunate­
                                                                                          ly beyond my retrieval.
                                                                                               Being now familiar with this haunt,
                                                                                          I was determined to observe the whole
                                                                                          performance. Reward came quickly,
                                                                                          with the arrival of the pair before dawn
0                                                                                         one morning. Following several minutes
0                                                                                         of preening, the male flew to a nearby
0
3                                                                                         tree. Clamping his beak around a two­
�                                                                                         centimetre-thick branch, he rocked
:r:                                                                                       back and forth in pipe-cutter fashion. A
�
I.J                                                                                       'snap' heralded success, a second 'snap'
                                                                                          and the foliage end was gone, leaving
      Male Palm Cockatoo engaged in an early morning drumming performance using
                                                                                          a length of about ten centimetres. Fly­
      a Grevillea glauca seed capsule.
                                                                                          ing to the top of the display trunk he
                                                                                          spent several minutes chewing the
                                                                                          branch, removing pieces of bark. He
                                                                                          then beat the hollow trunk loudly with
                                                                                          the stick, which he held in his foot. This
                                                                                          time I was able to retrieve the
                                                                                          drumstick.
                                                                                               The drumstick produced by the
                                                                                          Palm Cockatoo is certainly the most
                                                                                          complex tool used by any bird and ar­
                                                                                          guably the most complex used by any
0                                                                                         animals other than humans. Only the
0
0                                                                                         tools used by primates rival it in com­
3
�                                                                                         plexity. Few of the devices used by
<                                                                                         other animals are actually produced
:r:
�                                                                                         and modified, as the drumstick is. The
I.J
                                                                                          drumstick is also the only tool produced
                                                                                          by a non-human animal that is not used
      Drumming implements used by Palm Cockatoos. The round objects are the seed          in procuring food and, to my
      capsules of the Grevillea glauca tree. These were used by bushmen as clothespegs.   knowledge, the only musical imple-

      200                                                                                         VOL. 22 NO. 5, WINTER 1987
the urge to nest came the lining of a
                                                                                             number of hollows with a bed of shred­
                                                                                             ded sticks. At this time the hollows
                                                                                             were most jealously guarded. There
                                                                                             was considerable competition for suita­
                                                                                             ble nest hollows and disputes arose
                                                                                             when a rival pair approached too close.
                                                                                             The encroaching male was chased by
                                                                                             the resident male and attacked
                                                                                             whenever he landed. The resident flew
                                                                                             directly at the intruder, lunging feet first
                                                                                             and throwing his wings back prior to im­
                                                                                             pact. The victim was usually knocked
                                                                                             off his perch by the blow but, on the
                                                                                             occasions that he managed to hold on,
                                                                                             his attacker flapped wildly in a persis­
                                                                                             tent effort to drag him off the branch.
                                                                                             This attack was repeated until the en­
                                                                                             croaching pair departed. Beaks were
                                                                                             never used in these conflicts-a sensi­
                                                                                             ble restraint when one considers their
                                                                                             power. During the attacks the resident
                                                                                             females flew beside their partners,
                                                                                             screeching raucously but never making
                                                                                             physical contact.
0                                                                                                 Following the departure of the en­
0
0                                                                                            croaching pair the male prepared a
:!:                                                                                          drumstick and provided one of the best
�
<                                                                                            renditions I have witnessed. During this
I
�                                                                                            performance the female perched near­
I.)                                                                                          by, in silence.
      ment produced by any animals other               Each pair of Palm Cockatoos had a          During the last days before the
      than humans. Its purpose is to acousti­     number of hollows that were regularly      young bird left the nest many drum­
      cally delineate territory and probably      visited at the beginning and close of      ming displays were performed. On a
      has a pair-bonding function.                each day. A morning visit usually com­     number of occasions both parents
           Months passed without the hint of      menced with preening, followed by an       drummed at the same time. As if on cue
      a performance. As the 'dry' season          examination of the hollow and the oc­      the young bird, a male, left the nest hol­
      progressed I moved toward the coast,        casional drumming performance. In this     low during one of these performances
      setting up camp in open woodland­           open country the drumming imple­           and flew to a nearby branch. Immedi­
      main habitat of the Palm Cockatoo.          ment, rather than being a stick, was       ately he was attacked and knocked off
      Here I identified many potential display    usually the nut of the Crevillea g/auca    his perch by his father. Although visibly
      sites, which invariably focused on a tree   tree, the so-called 'Bushman's             shaken by this experience, he followed
      hollow with possible use in nesting. To     Clothespeg'.                               his parents, who departed immediate­
      avoid disturbing their performances I            Drumming performances were            ly after the attack. This established his
      built hides at selected sites. From these   most intense during nest preparation       position in life until the next nesting sea­
      I was able to observe closely their mu­     and just prior to the single young (only   son, still following his parents but keep­
      sical performances.                         one egg is laid) leaving the nest. With    ing a respectful distance. D

      AUSTRALIAN NATURAL HISTORY                                                                                                     201
AUSTRALIAN WILD FOODS                                                                                 by Tim Low

      Ground Orchids-Salute to Saloop                                                            cooking. These 'tubers' are actually
                                                                                                 large fleshy roots, which accounts for
                                                                                                 their fibrous texture. These were the

      G
                                                                                                 only orchids that required cooking to
               round orchids are enchanting        of globular tubers, 12 millimetres broad,     improve the taste; the others I was able
               plants. Each spring they bright­    with a watery bitter taste. The fourth or­    to eat raw.
               en the forest floor with dainty     chid, Pink Fingers (Caladenia camea)               Incidentally, Hyacinth Orchids are
      blooms of the oddest colours and             had two pea-sized white tubers, tasting       mysterious plants. lacking leaves, they
      shapes. Enjoy them while you can, for        sweet and juicy.                              grow only beneath certain kinds of eu­
      they flower but fleetingly; each summer           I was intrigued by this hilltop orchid   calypts and are said to be parasitic on
      the leaves, stems and flowers die away.      entree. The tubers of these four plants       a fungus. They seem to have the largest
            My fascination with ground orchids     were as varied in flavour and form as         tubers of any ground orchid, apart from
      blossomed last spring, during a long­        were the flowers in colour and shape.         those of Cinnamon Bells, also called
      term study of the traditional foods of       Although some of the tubers were not          Potato Orchid (Castrodia sesamoides),
      Aborigines. Most ground orchids              appealing, together they afforded a           another leafless saprophyte, once eat­
      produce 'tubers' and early colonial          most interesting wild food snack.             en by Aborigines in Tasmania.
      writers listed these as Aboriginal foods.         Since then I have sampled the                 Hyacinth Orchids flower through
      For years I paid them no heed, for I en­     tubers of 12 genera and more than 20          summer but most orchids bloom in
      countered ground orchids infrequently        species of ground orchid. Some were           spring, which is when the leaves ap­
      and the tubers I dug up were tiny. But       quite unpalatable although all were ob­       pear. Ground orchids are not very leafy
      then I came upon an intriguing article       viously edible, and a few were excep­         plants, and many produce only a single
      on Aboriginal diet by Melbourne              tionally       tasty-especially         the   leaf, others two or three. These soft,
      botanist Beth Gott. She wrote:               walnut-sized 'potatoes' of Brown Beaks        succulent leaves cannot withstand the
      "Accustomed as we are to the total pro­      (Lyperanthus suaveolens) and the              scorching summer sun, and the plants
      tection of orchids in most states of Aus­    fragrantly flavoured starch of the            'gestate' through summer in the form
      tralia, we tend to dismiss the               Horned Orchid (Orthoceras strictum).          of those starch-filled tubers, so impor­
      Orchidaceae [orchid family] as an im­        Most filling were the glutinous tubers        tant as foods.
      portant food source, considering them        of donkey orchids (Diuris spp.) and sun            Tuber-producing is a common tac­
      to be rare; yet orchids are widespread,      orchids (Thelymitra spp.) and I have no       tic of small plants with soft leaves grow­
      even in quite dry areas, and are often       doubt that these were important               ing in a harsh climate with seasonally
      locally abundant. They were widely ex­       Aboriginal foods.                             dry soil. Besides orchids, many of the
      ploited as a food source."                        Although most of the tubers were         smaller lilies and the Murnong or Yam
            Beth wrote of finding Nodding          tiny, those of the common Hyacinth Or­        Daisy (Microseris scapigera) depend on
      Greenhoods (Pterostylis nutans) at the       chid (Dipodium punctatum) were big.           tubers. These plants often grow
      extraordinary density of 440 plants per      One plant had six long tubers, each be­       together in shallow soils and Aborigines
      square metre, yielding 800 tiny tubers,      tween seven and eight millimetres thick       no doubt harvested them in large
      although with a combined weight of           and longer than my fingers. The tubers        numbers.
      only 126 grams. Orchid tubers are easy       were watery and, for an orchid, un­                The tiny tubers could have served
      to dig and, at densities like this, could    usually fibrous although less so after        as staple foods in spring, when these
      serve as important foods.
            I began to look out for orchids, and
      last spring reaped a bountiful reward.
      It began on a small knoll in southern
      Australia where I chanced upon four or­
      chid species flowering side by side. The
      first, a Common Waxlip (Clossodia
      major), sported a single egg-shaped
      tuber with a pointed tip. This tuber tast­
      ed watery and slightly sweet, with a bit­
      ter aftertaste. It was not nice. The
      second, a leopard Orchid (Diuris
      maculata), had two bullet-shaped
�     tubers three centimetres long and six to
__,   seven millimetres wide, with a glutinous
!     sticky taste. The arrowroot-like starch,
8     although filling, stuck cloyingly to my      The dark-flowered form of the Hyacinth Orchid flourishes in a patch of bushland
o     gums. The third orchid, a Tall Green­        in Brisbane's western suburbs, close to a main highway. The roots measure up
it    hood (Pterostylis longifolia), had a pair    to 13 centimetres in length.
      202                                                                                                VOL. 22 NO. 5, WINTER 1987
plants are in flower, but I was curious                                                     scanned the nearby forest and realised
to know if Aborigines would have har­                                                       there were dozens of these dried pods,
vested them in other seasons, when the                                                      all signalling tiny stores of food hidden
plants are less obvious.                                                                    in the hot earth. These tubers were so
     At first it seemed unlikely. Last Oc­                                                  common that a forager could have lived
tober, in the granite mountains near                                                        happily off the land. The different
Stanthorpe, I found colonies of Brown                                                       shapes and tastes of the tubers con­
Beaks within which only half the plants                                                     firmed that several orchid species were
were flowering. This orchid has a sin­                                                      present.
gle leaf remarkably similar to Blady                                                              Elsewhere in south-eastern Austra­
Grass (lmperata cylindrica), and both                                                       lia it was the same. In southern Victor­
plants often grow together so that the                                                      ia, in coastal New South Wales,
orchid is extremely difficult to locate                                                     wherever I looked I found tubers­
without its flowers. On open ground                                                         sometimes by spotting a dainty flower
the leaf is noticeable but still easily over-                                               but more often by finding dried cap­
1 ooked. Could Aborigines have                                                              sules in the wiry grass. Occasionally I
gathered an orchid like this outside the                                                    made a mistake, confusing the capsules
flowering season?                                                                           of trigger plants (Stylidium spp.) with or­
      Last summer I stumbled upon the                                                       chids. But there could be no mistaking
answer. I was photographing Hyacinth                                                        the significance of my find-that, for the
Orchids in disturbed bush in suburban                                                       Aborigines, orchids were a source of
 Brisbane where, surprisingly, this orchid                                                  sustenance all year round.
is locally common. Many of the orchids                                                            Ground orchids are no longer on
were past flowering, and I took note of                                                     my menu. I cannot justify the continued
their distinctive oval capsules. Two                                                        harvest of these beautiful plants. Nor
weeks later, in South Australia, I was                                                      would I want others to follow my ex­
 tramping through the hills behind                                                          ample. Orchids are protected in some
Adelaide when I spotted a similar egg­                                                      States, and rightly so. There is, however,
shaped capsule on a dried stalk. Could                                                      an interesting appendix to my tale. Dur­
this be an orchid? I clawed into the dirt                                                   ing my reading on orchids I came upon
and, to my astonishment, unearthed a                                                        several old references to white people
shiny white tuber shaped like a grape.          The flower of the Spider Orchid             eating the tubers, both here and
This came from no Hyacinth Orchid but           (Caladenia dilatata X patersoni,) is too    overseas.
 was obviously of orchid origin. Its crisp      spectacular to justify the harvest of its          Consider the following comment
white starch tasted sublime. Excitedly I        tubers, which are tiny and watery.           by colonial Australian botanist Joseph
                                                                                             Maiden, writing in 1898:
                                                                                            'There is hardly a country boy who has
                                                                                            not eaten so-called Yams, which are the
                                                                                            tubers of numerous kinds of terrestrial
                                                                                            or ground-growing orchids."
                                                                                                 Even more surprising is Anne Pratts
                                                                                            description of 'salep' {orchid starch, also
                                                                                            called saloop) in her 1891 book Flower­
                                                                                            ing Plants, Grasses, Sedges and Ferns,
                                                                                            of Great Britain:
                                                                                            "Salep is little used now in this country;
                                                                                            but less than a century since, the
                                                                                            Saloop-house was much frequented,
                                                                                            and the substance was a favourite
                                                                                            repast of porters, coal-heavers, and
                                                                                            other hard-working men. It is said to
                                                                                            contain more nutritious matter, in
                                                                                            proportion to its bulk, than any other
                                                                                            known root, and an ounce of salep was
                                                                                            considered to afford support to a man
                                                                                            for a day; hence those who travel in
 The tubers of Brown Beaks resemble small waxy potatoes, and have a juicy and               uninhabited countries have greatly
 fragrant flavour. The flowers are shown at left.                                           prized so portable a vegetable food." D

AUSTRALIAN NATURAL HISTORY                                                                                                          203
pastoral country in central New South
                                                                                                   Wales is to electrify existing fences so
                                                                                                   as to raise goats, which eat everything!
                                                                                                   Look at northern Africa!
                                                                                                         Something must be done.
                                                                                                         The best hope for restoration and
                                                                                                   conservation of our fragile arid lands is
                                                                                                   for the removal of sheep and cattle­
                                                                                                   not just to reduce grazing pressure, but
                                                                                                   to reduce foot pressure as well. Kinche­
                                                                                                   ga National Park, a formerly over­
                                                                                                   grazed sheep property south-east of
                                                                                                   Broken Hill, provides a practical exam­
                                                                                                   ple that many will be familiar with.
                                                                                                   However, for stock to be removed,
                                                                                                   there needs to be an alternate econom­
                                                                                                   ic base. If kangaroos can provide that
z                                                                                                  alternate base, there will be a revolu­
0
V,
z                                                                                                  tion in land use in many of the areas
;;;;
f­                                                                                                 now only marginally useful for grazing
<                                                                                                  and, wherever it happens, there will be
u.J

                                                                                                   habitat restoration on a grand scale.
                                                                                                         Graziers raise sheep deliberately
                                                                                                   and kangaroos inadvertently on most

                          KANGAROO
                                                                                                   sheep properties. They regard sheep as
                                                                                                   a source of income, kangaroos as pests.
                                                                                                   A property might have 6,000 sheep and

                          HARVESTING:
                                                                                                    3,000 kangaroos. The grazier reaps a
                                                                                                    financial benefit from the former, but
                                                                                                   calls in a licensed kangaroo shooter to
                                A new approach                                                     kill and sell the latter. This is a paradox.
                                                                                                   Its persistence is cultural (kangaroo
                  By Gordon Grigg , School of Zoology, University of Sydney                        work is, in many cases, beneath the dig­
                                                                                                   nity of most graziers) and financial (kan­

       W
                                                                                                    garoos are not worth enough at
                  hat can be done to repair the     overseas markets for kangaroo meat             present).
                  habitat damage done by 100        and hides, and selling them at prices                But, if the value of kangaroos in­
                  years of overgrazing? A solu­     that do justice to their quality, instead      creases, then graziers might think twice
       tion in the marginal pastoral areas may      of at prices that reflect their current sta­   before giving them away. There are iso­
       be to promote kangaroo products, in­         tus in Australia as pests.                     lated examples of this now, even at the
       creasing their value so that it becomes           You think I'm crazy? Hear me out,         present low-market value of kangaroos.
       more profitable to harvest kangaroos         point by point.                                 During 1986, when sheep prices were
       there instead of sheep and cattle.                 Flying low over most of Australia,        low, many graziers in central Queens­
            Consider what would happen if the       as I have been doing regularly for more        land harvested their kangaroos them­
       value of kangaroos suddenly jumped           than ten years on kangaroo surveys, I          selves. A dramatic price increase would
       three- or four-fold. Many people would       am always appalled by the extent of            see more graziers doing this and fewer
       immediately think that this is the worst     habitat damage I see inflicted by sheep        graziers would be forced off their land
       thing that could happen; that the large      and cattle grazing. The land is criss­         in times of drought and increasing in­
       species of kangaroos would come un­          crossed by tracks and beaten to pow­           terest rates.
       der such harvesting pressure that extinc­    der. Much of our marginal grazing land               How much of a price rise would be
       tion would surely follow. I disagree. I      is already well on the way to becom­           necessary? This question was addressed
       believe that a big increase in demand        ing desert. Just try to imagine what the       by Michael Young and Allan Wilson of
       for kangaroo products would not only         country will look like in another 50           the CSIRO Division of Wildlife and Ran­
       ensure their conservation but would          years, let alone another 200.                  gelands Research (personal communi­
       lead also to the rehabilitation of areas          Or do you think we know better            cation). Even including the costs of
       now becoming deserts under the pres­         now; that the lessons of the past have         constructing and maintaining kangaroo­
       sure of hard-hoofed stock. This Forum        been learned well and that pastures are        proof fencing, which I consider to be
       article will argue that, with conservation   better managed nowadays? Well think            counter-productive, they estimated that
       motives, we should be finding better         again! The latest trend in clapped-out         a three- to four-fold increase in the price
       204                                                                                                 VOL. 22 NO. 5, WINTER 1987
of kangaroo meat would make farming            these old chestnuts. After all, the sta­     should be able to work together.
profitable, first as a supplement to and       tus quo is hardly anything to be proud             In an article in this magazine in
then as a replacement for traditional          of, and I'm sure I'm not the only one        1984 (vol. 21 no. 4, p. 123) I discussed
stock.                                        who sees a need for new directions.           the kangaroo question at length, includ­
      How could such a price rise be                First of all, I'm not suggesting con­   ing population data and ethics. The ar­
achieved? A basic principle of econom­         ventional farming, but free-range har­       ticle concluded that Red and Grey
ics is that if supply remains constant and    vest of a natural resource (something         Kangaroos were not threatened by con­
demand rises, then price also rises. The      closer to fishing than to farming). Fences    trolled harvesting. This conclusion is ac­
supply of kangaroos is limited by quo­         would not be needed. Indeed, fences          cepted by most people nowadays.
tas set to ensure their conservation (as      would probably be deleterious because         What that article said, essentially, was
it should be), so we need only to in­         kangaroos need freedom of movement,           that there are no reasons not to harvest
crease the demand. At present, kan­           particularly during droughts. So how          kangaroos; what this present article is
garoos are undervalued, their present         would you establish ownership over            saying is that there are good conserva­
price reflecting their status in Australia    your kangaroos? Why would you need            tion reasons to harvest.
as pests instead of something very spe­       to? Your kangaroos are the ones on                  Of course, if this proposal is put
cial on which, we should remember,            your property. Next week they may be          into effect, there will have to be many
we have a complete monopoly. The              on your neighbour's but, if you look af­      changes in the structure of kangaroo
leather is excellent and is sought by         ter your land better than he does (that       marketing and stricter controls to en­
manufacturers of many specialised             is, by reducing or removing hard­             sure that the resource is managed
products, particularly sport shoes and        hoofed stock), then they may stay on          properly. Regular monitoring of popu­
other sporting equipment. The meat,           yours. Mustering? Not necessary. Shoot­       lations should continue, with effective
with less than one per cent fat com­          ing has already proved to be an effec-        and intelligent control over the num­
pared to 40 per cent for mutton, is a                                                       bers taken. There would need to be ef­
nutritionist's dream. With better mar­                                                      fective ways to be certain that only
keting, particularly in countries that                                                      legally-taken skins (tattooing?) and meat
have a protein shortage (such as Japan),             "... if the value of                   enter trade markets, and there would
where there is a tradition of eating                                                        have to be a much higher level of su­
                                                 kangaroos increases, then                  pervision than at present. This will be
game (such as Germany), or in any
country with a 'health food' industry,
                                                 graziers might think twice                 crucial, otherwise there will be exten­
prices will inevitably rise. Even the moti­      before giving them away."                  sive poaching by unlicensed shooters,
vation for the harvest-that of reversing                                                    with all its unsavoury aspects. Many op­
our grazing-induced desertification­                                                        ponents of the industry have claimed
could be.a selling point in Australia and                                                   that there is considerable corruption
in all other conservation-conscious           tive and humane method of harvest             and that rules and regulations are not
countries.                                    and doesn't require the process of            policed. But, with a higher dollar value
      In brief, my scenario is that kan­      mustering. Indeed, kangaroos could not        on the resource, adequate controls and
garoos should be marketed at higher           be mustered because they are prone to         higher penalties are much more likely
prices, reflecting the special product        post-capture myopathy, a stress-in­           to be implemented than they are at
they are. Graziers in marginal country        duced deterioration of the muscles that        present. While the proposal is aimed
will then see a benefit in encouraging        degrades the value of the meat.                mainly at the marginal grazing areas, I
kangaroo populations by reducing and,         Worms, parasites, health aspects? In          see no reason why the kangaroo indus­
in some instances, replacing entirely         South Australia, the only State where         try should not continue in other areas,
their traditional hard-hoofed stock. This     kangaroo meat can now be sold for hu­          as it does now, but with better regula­
will result in a sounder economic base        man consumption, it passes regular in­         tion. The greater value of kangaroos
in many areas and will promote the            spections with flying colours. Note also       would lead to more energetic controls
restoration of land that is turning into      that overheads fall, there being no need      in these places too.
desert under present land use.                to maintain fences, to brand, drench,               I am not so naive that I think this
      You still think I'm crazy, don't you?   crutch or spray.                              proposal is a cure-all for the problems
I can imagine many of the criticisms:               And the Greenies? Well, I think this    in our arid lands, or for the problems
"just another academic in his ivory tow­      proposal will be supported by more            surrounding the commercialisation of
er, flogging his hobby horse"; "doesn't       conservation groups than will oppose          kangaroos. However, I am urging con­
know anything about the bush"; "every­        it; after all, economically valuable spe­     structive discussion. I hope this article
body knows you can't farm kangaroos";         cies are those that everyone wants to         will start some. The spread of deserts
"you'll need a big fence to keep them         conserve and habitat restoration be­          is a problem in many countries. Perhaps
in, mate"; "what about the worms?";           comes a bonus. If there is local support,     in Australia we may be able to do
"the Greenies'II never let you do it, any­    support from overseas will likely follow      something about it. If switching to kan­
way"; "you can't muster them" and so          for the same reasons. In my view, this         garoos works effectively even in just a
on.                                           is a proposal on which producers,             few areas, then that will be a good start.
      Well let's concentrate on some of       governments and conservationists               How far it might go, who can tell?D

AUSTRALIAN NATURAL HISTORY                                                                                                        205
BOOK REVIEWS                                                  Boles on Birds, Recher on Wrens

                                  for the more irregular               of concern to most people, it      each species on the appropri·
                                  vagrants, are illustrated with       is a disturbing approach to        ate plate. It does not have
                                  one, sometimes more, high            the initial presentation of        the detail of text found in Piz­
                                  quality photographs from the         original information.              zey's book. In this respect it
                                  National Photographic Index              There has been a line of       forgoes its usefulness as a
                                  of Australian Wildlife (NPI­         notable Australian field           more general reference for
                                  AW). This is accompanied by          guides, including the famous       the specific purpose of field
                                  text of variable length, dis­        What Bird is That? by Neville      identification, yet permits the
                                  cussing various aspects of the       Cayley (first published in         smaller size-a reasonable
                                  birds' natural history; a short      1931 and many times since,         trade-off in my opinion.
Reader's Digest                   synopsis of the description,         including revisions) and the      There are some rough edges
Complete Book of                  voice, nesting and distribu­         recent volumes A Field Guide       such as the odd irregularity in
                                  tion; and a range map. These         to Australian Birds by Peter       the presence of range maps,
Australian Birds.                 accounts are supplemented            Slater (1970, 197 4) and Gra­      and the aspects of plates
Richard Schodde and Sonia         by a short section depicting         ham Pizzey's A Field Guide to      mentioned above. There is
Tidemann. Reader's Digest,        the variety of Australian            the Birds of Australia (1980).     also perhaps not enough
Sydney, 1986, 2nd ed.,            habitats and a general section       Each has had its strengths and     contrast in the black and
639 pp. $49.95                    on bird biology and origins,         weaknesses with none obvi­         white plate of underwing pat­
The Slater Field Guide            particularly in the Australian       ously superior overall. Now        terns of birds of prey and
to Australian Birds.              context. The latter has been         Peter Slater has collaborated      ducks; at least one person
Peter, Pat and Raoul Slater.      expanded and moved from              with his wife and son to           who has used the book in the
Rigby Publishers, Sydney,         the rear to the front of the         produce the best field guide       field has remarked on this
1986, 1st ed., 344 pp.            book.                                to Australian birds to date.       point.
$29.95.                               The size is too large for        Previous guides retained out­          A cost· conserving urge
The Birds of Australia.           use anywhere except in the           dated formats in which            may be implicated in
A Book of                         home, and the photographs,           plates, and often maps, were      some striking omissions in
                                  as beautiful as most are, have       divorced from the text, forc­     the Slater Guide. Surprisingly
ldentification-760                drawbacks for identification         ing the observer to refer to      absent is a figure explain·
Birds in Colour.                  purposes. This, however, is          several, often widely­            ing the parts or topography
Ken Simpson and Nicolas           not the function of the book;        separated pages for a single      of the bird used throug hout
Day. Lloyd O'Neil Pty Ltd,        presentation of an attractive        species. The major improve·       the book in the text descrip­
Melbourne, 1986, 2nd ed.,         blend of quality photograph­         ment of the Slater Guide is to    tions. Such a figure is a stan­
352 pp. $35.95.                   ic portraits and interesting         conform to the well­              dard part of most guides,
    The number of newly pub­      text is. In this aim it succeeds     established format used by a      including Pizzey's and Slater's
lished books on Australian        admirably.                           majority of the best overseas     earlier guide. The single most
birds has proceeded at a sub­         In the first edition, the spe­   field guides: for each species    astounding absence is the
stantial rate for several years   cies accounts were written by        the text and maps are on one      lack of an index to scientific
and in the last few months of     a number of authors who              page facing the relevant illus­   names, an unbelievable solu­
1986 reached a rather high        were acknowledged in the             tration. Other improvements       tion to reducing the total
level. Among this outpouring      front of the volume and in           are the size, which is smaller    number of pages. There is no
were several notable              the rear. The second edition,        than Pizzey's (perhaps still      illustration of the introduced
volumes: two new editions of      completely re-written by             slightly too large for easy       Blackbird (rumour has it that
previously published books        Richard Schodde and Sonia            back pocket transport) and        this figure was at the rear of
and one striking replacement      Tidemann, still has these            the single volume, unlike the     the book and disappeared in
for a standard Australian text.   authors' lists, creating the un­     unwieldly two-volume ar·          the company of the scientif­
All were landmarks in Aus­        fortunate impression that            rangement of Slater's earlier     ic names index). My suspi·
tralian bird books when they      they are still responsible for       work.                             cions are that these
first appeared, and continue      comments that few would                  The plates are probably       omissions were beyond the
to be so in their updated         have seen or had any input           the best and most compre·         control of the authors who
forms.                            in. The book frequently con­         hensive (more young               should be congratulated for
    When it first came on the     tains apparently new infor·          plumages included) of any of      giving us the state-of-the-art
market ten years ago, the         mation on species' biology           its immediate competitors         Australian field guide to birds.
Reader's Digest Complete          that has yet to appear in            (despite some occasionally            The 'proper' format uti­
Book of Australian Birds          proper scientific format.            distracting use of marbled        lised in the Slater Guide did
made a major impact.              While the first appearance of        background and subdividing        not first appear in that
  The format remains the          such information in a                the page), with the added         volume. In 1984, Ken Simp­
same: each species, except        popularised book will not be         plus of including the eggs of     son and Nicolas Day
206                                                                                                  VOL. 22 NO. 5, WINTER 1987
produced The Birds of Aus­           the Reader's Digest book is        their biology is therefore an      only that it deals more or less
 tralia set out in this manner.       the best selection. For the        important event.                   systematically with a single
It was also the first work to         middle ground-the occa­                 The Fairy-wrens was pub­      subject. Indeed, until now, I
 attempt to illustrate any sort       sional foray into the bush as      lished in 1982; long enough        had ignored it as yet another
 of range of different                well as a general introduction     to have been reviewed by           of the 'coffee table' genre
plumages beyond the obvi­             to Australian birds-Simpson        others and discussed at            that plagues the world of
ous adult ones. This section          and Day's book suggests it­        length among ornithologists        natural history; I only opened
of the book is followed by            self. If, however, one is not      and keen bird-watchers. The        it to prepare this review. This
"The Handbook", an exten­             working under such con­            review by Ian Rowley in 1985       has been my loss as not only
sive presentation (70 pages)          straints, one could do worse       (Emu 85: 271), doyen of            are the paintings superb, but
starting with a brief introduc­       than to have all three of          malurid biologists, is certain­    the text is engagingly written
tion to the birds' biology, dis­      these worthwhile efforts in        ly the most important and          and informative, and the
tribution, habitats and history       one's library.                     detailed statement yet to          historical accounts of the
in Australia and concluding                              -Walter Boles   appear.                            evolution of malurid taxono­
with accounts of each Aus­                                                    As presented by Rowley,       my are akin to a good detec­
tralian family of birds and
their natural history. The for­
                                             . TheTVL
                                         R'atry-  wrens
                                                                         there are two major criticisms
                                                                         of this book. The first and
                                                                                                            tive story. Unlike Rowley,
                                                                                                            who advises that you 'bor­
mat and quality of paintings               I       ,1.      II.   "      most important is that the         row' and not purchase The
by Day, which remain among                                               author, Richard Schodde, has       Fairy-wrens, I think a copy is
the best in any Australian                                               used it as a vehicle to publish    money well spent. As Rowley
identification guide, ensured                                            ideas and observations             states, "much of the text is or­
this book of a good recep­                                               without submitting them to         nithologically important" but
tion. The second edition fol­                                            the normal review processes        it is also the most detailed
lowed soon after, correcting                                             that one expects for scientif­     (monographic) account of
some of the errors of the                                                ic writings. Thus unsubstan­       this special group of Aus­
original and replacing some·                                             tiated statements and errors       tra I ia n birds available.
of the plates.                                                           of fact or interpretation may      Schodde has exhaustively
     The field guide section                                             enter the literature and be ac­    reviewed the literature, bring­
holds its own in comparison                                              cepted as correct by the less      ing forth information that
                                      The Fairy-wrens. A                 critical or those unfamiliar       most of us would never rea­
with Slater but most obser­
                                      Monograph of the                    with fairy-wren biology. The      lise existed let alone search
vers will find it far too bulky
to be a convenient field com­         Maluridae.                         second is that the artwork, al­    for. If in places his observa­
 panion. "The Handbook" sec­          Richard Schodde. /1/ustrated       beit very nice, does not add       tions are unsubstantiated or
 tion will appeal to a number         by Richard Weatherly.               significantly to the scientific   the text simplified, the risk
of people who are pressed to          Originally published by             content of the text. For a        that it will be misused is
 find this type of information        Lansdowne Editions,                 monograph, Rowley expects         minimal. The author has
in any other source. Com­             Melbourne, 1982. Current            illustrations that show the       made it clear where he is
bined, the two different styles       distribution Connewarran            different plumages of males       speculating on events and
 of content make The Birds of         Press, Mortlake, Victoria.          and females, of young and         has made no pretence of
Australia something between           192 pp. $70.                        old, of breeding and non­         having made any more than
 a field guide and a reference           The fairy-wrens (Maluri­         breeding birds or which           a good naturalist's observa­
 book.                                dae) are a group of 26 species      document egg colour and           tions and study of the birds.
      Anyone having to decide         restricted to Australia and         shape, nests and various          I say 'good on him'-that's
 between these three books            New Guinea. Closely related         aspects of the birds' be­         what books are for.
 and given only a single              to Australian warblers and          haviour. To some extent               The Fairy-wrens is not just
 choice will need to consider         honeyeaters, the fairy-wrens        Richard Weatherly's paintings     a coffee table volume. I
 the role it is intended to ful­      are part of Australia's own,        and sketches do this but,          regret the format which
 fill. If frequent field use is in­   home-grown avifauna. Be­            overall, are basically irrele­    makes reading difficult but it
 tended, there is no doubt            cause one species, the Su­          vant to the text and, Rowley      is probably necessary to
 that the Slater Guide is the         perb Blue Wren (Malurus              suspects, have been used to      show off Weatherly's paint­
 obvious choice. Should there         cyaneus), has made the ad­          sell the book.                    ings to advantage. I regret the
 be little need of an identifica­     justments to suburbia and               Not being a malurid biol­     absence of detailed plates of
 tion guide but an interest in        city parks, fairy-wrens occupy      ogist, I have approached this     morphological and life cycle
 an attractive and informative        a place in Australia's cultural      book less critically than        variation in plumage. But
  book for reference with             natural history along with           Rowley. Nor was I swayed by      mostly, I regret not having
 greater concentration on in­         Kookaburras, wombats and             the labelling of the book as     read this book sooner.
  dividual species' accounts,         gum-nut children. A book on          a monograph, which means                        -Harry Recher

AUSTRALIAN NATURAL HISTORY                                                                                                               207
· . RARE & ENDANGERED                                                                      Classifying Australia's Threat

       T
             he conservation status of Aus­           (Chlamydogobius n. sp.), Swamp Galax­        fluviatilis). Translocation of native fish
             tralian fishes has become a to�i­        ias (Calaxias parvus), Pedder Galaxias       between drainage systems was also
             cal issue, mainly because of dis­        (Calaxias      pedderensis)       and        seen as a threat. Although no species
       cussions among the fisheries scientists,       the Non-parasitic Lamprey (Mordacia          were listed by the conference as 'ex­
       administrators, students and fish en­          praecox); and the three lower classifi­      tinct', it has since been reported that the
       thusiasts who belong to the Australian         cations: 'indeterminate' (two species),      Lake Eacham Rainbowfish may have
       Society for Fish Biology (ASFB). In 1980       'restricted' (32 species) and 'uncertain     been exterminated by the translocation
       a meeting of the ASFB recognised the           status' (15+ species).                       into Lake Eacham of another small na­
       need to provide an authoritative up-to­                                                     tive fish, the 'Mouth Almighty' (Clossa­
       date classification of the conservation        Causes of Fish Conservation                  mia aprion).
       status of Australian fishes. The Society       Problems                                          Fish often depend on the specific
       set up an Endangered Fish Subcommit­                                                        features of a particular habitat type.
                                                           The conference identified a varie­
       tee and circulated discussion papers                                                        Many of the critical features of habitats
                                                      ty of causes of fish conservation
       among its members. When it became                                                           are vulnerable to change. For example,
                                                      problems. Some were due to the high­
       clear that a forum was needed to inte­                                                      the many catadromous species (those
       grate the numerous and diverse pieces          ly localised distribution patterns of spe­
                                                      cies, often in a single locality. Examples   that breed in marine waters and whose
       of information into the best possible                                                       young must migrate upstream) like
                                                      included the Lake Eacham Rainbowfish
       classification of threatened fish, we                                                       Freshwater Herring (Potamalosa rich­
                                                      from northern Queensland, the Blind
        sought the support of other interested                                                     mondia) or Australian Bass (Macquaria
       bodies for a specialist conference. As a       Cave Eel (Ophisternon candidum) from
                                                      a small subterranean location on the         novemaculeata) are critically dependent
       result, funds were contributed by the                                                       on free passage through streams and so
       fisheries authorities of Victoria, South       central western Australian coast, and
                                                      the Swan Galaxias from a single small        can be locally eradicated by impound­
       Australia, New South Wales and the                                                          ments. Other species depend on the
        Commonwealth. Contributions were              Tasmanian stream.
                                                            Biological interactions such as pre­   availability of particular habitats for
       also made by the Australian Freshwater                                                      spawning, such as the sunken logs used
       Fishermen's Assembly, Native Fish Aus­         dation and competition between spe­
                                                      cies were often identified by the            by River Blackfish (Cadopsis sp.) or the
       tralia and ASFB.                                                                            gravel riffles used by Macquarie Perch
                                                      conference as causing the threatened
                                                      status of various fishes. Examples of        (Macquaria australasica).
       The Threatened Fishes
                                                      such interactions included the competi­            The degradation of habitat, espe­
       Conference                                     tive effects on native fish of the in­       cially through river regulation (dams,
             The Society's Conference on Aus­         troduced Topminnow (Cambusia                 weirs, irrigation, etc.), stream siltation
       tralian Threatened Fishes was hosted by        affinist otherwise known as the Mosqui­      and catchment alteration, was recog­
       the Victorian Fisheries and Wildlife Di­       to Fish-an ill-deserved title since the      nised as the greatest factor leading to
       vision in Melbourne in August 1985. It         small native fish it displaces probably      generalised declines in fish abundance
       brought together 52 people represent­          provide better control of insect pests.      and distribution. While such diffuse
       ing a broad range of expertise and             Other examples include predation and         broad-scale forms of habitat degrada­
       made a detailed analysis of the status         competition by the introduced trout          tion undoubtedly increase the vulnera­
       of Australia's fish fauna over two days.       species (Salmo spp.) and Redfin (Perea       bility of many threatened species, only
       Dr Peter Maitland, Head of the Fish
       Group of the International Union for
       Conservation of Nature and Natural
       Resources, was invited from Edinburgh
       to be the conference's Guest Speaker.
       The conference designed a seven-stage
       scheme of classification for threatened
       fishes. Sixty-two species were listed.
       They included four 'endangered' fish:
       Trout Cod (Maccullochella macquarien­
       sis), Swan Galaxias (Calaxias fontanus),
       Eastern Freshwater Cod (Maccullochella
       n. sp.) and Clarence Galaxias (Calaxias
       johnstom); four 'vulnerable' species:
       Flinders Ranges Gudgeon (Mogurnda n.
       sp.), Honey Blue-eye (Pseudomugil me/-
  CS   /i s), Saddled Galaxias (Calaxias
  �    tanycephalus) and the Lake Eacham
  �    Rainbowfish (Melanotaenia eachamen­
  :i   sis); five 'potentially threatened' species:
  �    the Australian Grayling (Prototroctes          The Trout Cod was listed as 'endangered' at the Australian Threatened Fishes
  G    maraena), Elizabeth Springs Coby               Conference, Melbourne, August 1985.
       208                                                                                                 VOL. 22 NO. 5, WINTER 1987
You can also read