Te Mātātaki 2021 - Findings from the 2019/2020 survey of tamariki and rangatahi in care - Oranga Tamariki

Page created by Mitchell Wang
 
CONTINUE READING
Te Mātātaki 2021 - Findings from the 2019/2020 survey of tamariki and rangatahi in care - Oranga Tamariki
Te Mātātaki 2021

Findings from the 2019/2020 survey
  of tamariki and rangatahi in care
Aurora Centre, 56 The Terrace, Wellington              Disclaimer
                                                       Oranga Tamariki has made every effort to ensure
The Voices of Children and Young People team and
                                                       the information in this report is reliable but does not
Oranga Tamariki – Ministry for Children supports the
                                                       guarantee its accuracy and does not accept liability
organisation to understand the experiences, needs
                                                       for any errors.
and aspirations of tamariki and rangatahi.
                                                       Acknowledgements
Email
                                                       The Voices of Children and Young People team
voices@ot.govt.nz
                                                       wish to acknowledge all tamariki and rangatahi who
Author                                                 helped us design the survey, took part, and helped us
Oranga Tamariki                                        identify priorities for action. Thanks also to Oranga
Voices of Children and Young People Team               Tamariki staff who assisted with development and
Published                                              delivery of the survey, with special acknowledgement
May 2021                                               to the social workers who supported tamariki and
                                                       rangatahi to participate. This report is strengthened
ISBN
                                                       by the Foreword from our youth advisors and we
978-0-9951498-3-0
                                                       acknowledge their contribution. We also appreciate
Citation guidance                                      those who assisted with peer review of this report.
This report can be referenced as: Oranga Tamariki
                                                       Finally, we express our gratitude to the group of
Voices of Children and Young People Team (2021).
                                                       Oranga Tamariki staff who developed the identity
Te Mātātaki 2021. Wellington, New Zealand:
                                                       of Te Tohu o te Ora and Te Mātataki. Ngā mihi nui ki
Oranga Tamariki – Ministry for Children.
                                                       a koutou.
Copyright
This document Te Mātātaki 2021 is licensed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
License http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/
by/4.0/.

Please attribute © New Zealand Government,
Oranga Tamariki—Ministry for Children 2021.

Te Mātātaki 2021                                          2
Foreword from youth advisors with care experience

                    Te Mātātaki reflects the voices of our
                    most precious tamariki and rangatahi
                         - these voices are taonga.

To respect this precious gift, this is your invitation to          Te Mātātaki is also a snapshot of the lives of a generation
now leave behind your preconceptions of who you think              of people who will one day be adults. This underscores
care-experienced tamariki and rangatahi are and what we            the responsibility—advocated for by generations of
are capable of. Above all, this includes remembering that          care-experienced adults—that the state has to employ a
the findings of Te Tohu o te Ora go beyond metrics and             lifelong investment approach for tamariki and rangatahi in
describe real lives. For this reason, it’s also important to       care. This means going beyond what is simply achievable,
awhi the voices of tamariki and rangatahi who chose not            and actively supporting tamariki towards aspirational
to take part, as well as the past generations of those in          futures. We remind you again to challenge your own
care who have not had the opportunity to be heard.                 assumptions of what you believe us to be capable of.
                                                                   Changing the discourse requires addressing the stigma
The monumental nature of this work lies in its potential
                                                                   care-experienced people face both during and after
to create meaningful change for tamariki and rangatahi
                                                                   care. Addressing this lies first within the operation of the
in care. The positive findings presented here should be
                                                                   Ministry, but more broadly is a societal challenge that the
acknowledged. However, we must also be cognisant
                                                                   whole of Aotearoa must respond to. There is therefore
of what it means to collect data from a population who
                                                                   an obligation on all readers — whoever you may be — to
are so marginalised within society, especially given that
                                                                   pick up the challenge that the findings of Te Tohu o te
we are constantly denied our right to agency and self-
                                                                   Ora present. Respecting and honouring mana tamaiti
determination within the care system. The data contained
                                                                   demands taking action. Whether it be challenging your
within this report is precious and forever belongs to the
                                                                   own preconceptions of tamariki in care or using your
1,545 tamariki and rangatahi who took part in the survey.
                                                                   privilege and influence to actively improve the lives of
There are great risks that go along with asking tamariki
                                                                   tamariki, change must happen. Above all, the state must
to divulge their knowledge and experiences to the very
                                                                   do better, and to truly give respect to our voices, must
institution that is responsible for causing so much harm.
                                                                   make space for us to enact self-determination over our
It is therefore incumbent upon the Ministry for Children
                                                                   own futures. Only then will our voices be truly valued.
to now respond to Te Mātātaki - He mānuka takoto,
kawea ake. Otherwise, the collection of data is simply an
exercise of surveillance and re-traumatisation.

The findings presented in Te Mātātaki must be seen
within the frame of the rights that we have as care-
experienced tamariki and rangatahi. Rights to whānau
connection, safe and supportive homes, and promising
futures, are just that — rights. Not simply ‘needs’. This                 Tahirah Moton                  Injy Johnstone
is particularly so for us Māori and Pasifika tamariki and               (Ngāti Maniapoto)
rangatahi, given the obligations the Ministry has under Te
Tiriti o Waitangi and Section 7AA of the Oranga Tamariki                         Former and current members of
Act. The inequitable outcomes presented in this report                        Oranga Tamariki Youth Advisory Group
show that the state is not meeting all of these obligations.
This must be addressed immediately as inequities further
entrench once rangatahi leave care. Included in this is the
damning observation that we who have been through the
system are more likely to be remanded in prison than to
graduate from university.

                                                               3                                               Te Mātātaki 2021
Foreword from Associate Minister for Children

                    E ngā mana, e ngā reo, mai ngā hau e whā
                       puta noa i te motu. Tēnā koutou katoa.
                   Te mana o te tamaiti, o te rangatahi. He mana
                      atua, he mana tīpuna, he mana tuku iho.

Tamariki and rangatahi are taonga, for they not only               I would like to acknowledge the contribution of the 1,545
embody the resilience of past generations but also the             tamariki and rangatahi who chose to participate in Te
aspirations for an equitable New Zealand for future                Tohu o te Ora. I would like to thank you for your wisdom
generations. Their voices, and those of their whānau, are          and courage in sharing your personal experiences and I
vital in informing the important work of Oranga Tamariki–          want to assure you that we are listening. Your responses
Ministry for Children.                                             will shape and enable a care model that is centred on
                                                                   tamariki and whānau approaches.
It is in this spirit that the Government has laid a pathway
for New Zealand to be the best place in the world for all          I warmly acknowledge the talents and dedication of social
tamariki and rangatahi to live and thrive; this is reflected       workers who supported tamariki and rangatahi to take
within the vision of the Child and Youth Wellbeing                 part. You, along with the whānau and caregivers who
Strategy.                                                          support tamariki and rangatahi every day, have a critical
                                                                   role in bringing the voice of tamariki and rangatahi to life.
The unfortunate reality is that high numbers of tamariki
and rangatahi within the care of Oranga Tamariki are               We all have a part to play in ensuring tamariki and
Māori. I am confident that the findings from the inaugural         rangatahi are happy, safe and thriving. Let us all learn
Te Tohu o te Ora survey will assist Oranga Tamariki in             from what tamariki and rangatahi in care have shared
making the changes necessary to improve outcomes for               with us and work together to ensure our country’s most
tamariki Māori. It will also ensure that the voices of all         important taonga are protected, valued and embraced.
tamariki and rangatahi in care, regardless of background
and cultural heritage, are at the heart of Oranga Tamariki.        He taonga te tamaiti, he taonga te rangatahi,
                                                                   he taonga te mokopuna.
Unique in its framing, Te Tohu o te Ora captures the
                                                                   A child, young person and mokopuna are taonga.
experiences of tamariki and rangatahi in care. It speaks
to the desire to provide care that enhances their wellbeing
and upholds their mana, and to hear the collective voices
of them and their whānau.

Te Mātātaki, the report that presents the findings from Te
Tohu o te Ora, is an important step forward in ensuring
that tamariki and rangatahi influence policies, practices
and services that affect them and their whānau.                                            Hon Poto Williams

Te Mātātaki 2021                                               4
Table of contents
SECTION 1                                              Having friends to talk to                          31
Introduction to this report                   6        Learning about culture                             31
Te Tohu o te Ora                              7        Having hope for the future                         32
Te Mātātaki                                   7        Views of Oranga Tamariki                           32
A note for readers                            7        Social worker relationships                        33
                                                       Overall pattern of responses                       34
SECTION 2
The identity of Te Tohu o te Ora                       Subgroup differences                               36

and Te Mātātaki                               8        Summary of differences by age group                36

Te Tohu o te Ora                              11       Summary of difference by gender                    37

Te Mātātaki                                   12       Summary of differences by ethnicity                38
                                                       Summary of differences by care status              40
SECTION 3
Reasons for doing the survey                  15       SECTION 6
Tamariki and rangatahi are experts in their            Priority areas for action                          41
own experiences                               16
                                                       SECTION 7
We are committed to our Treaty partnership    16
                                                       Initiatives that support tamariki
Tamariki and rangatahi have a unique voice
                                                       and rangatahi experiences in the
within whānau                                 17
                                                       priority areas                                     50
Tamariki and rangatahi have rights
to be heard                                   17       Practice change programme for
                                                       social workers                                     53
Te Tohu o te Ora supports tamariki and
rangatahi to be heard                         17       Partnerships with Māori                            54
                                                       Whānau Care partnerships                           54
SECTION 4
                                                       Support for caregiving whānau                      55
Survey approach                               19
                                                       Strengthening Family Group Conferences             56
Survey population                             20
                                                       Implementation of the National
Survey delivery                               20
                                                       Care Standards                                     57
Questionnaire                                 21
                                                       Support for transition to adulthood                58
Participation                                 22
                                                       Improving responses to tamariki and
Analysis                                      25       rangatahi with Māori and Pacific identify          59

SECTION 5                                              SECTION 8 Conclusion                               60
Survey results                                26
                                                       SECTION 9 Appendices                               62
Feeling settled                               27
                                                       Appendix 1: Survey strengths and limitations       63
Feeling well looked after                     27
                                                       Appendix 2: Summary of subgroup
Feeling accepted                              28
                                                       differences                                        65
Relationships with whānau                     28
                                                       Appendix 3: Understanding the visual
Having a say in important decisions           29       elements of this project                           66
Having a sense of belonging                   29
                                                       SECTION 10 Glossary                                69
Knowing whakapapa                             30
Feeling loved                                 30

                                                   5                                               Te Mātātaki 2021
SECTION 1

  Introduction
                   to this report

Te Mātātaki 2021          6
Te Tohu o te Ora                                                          A note for readers
Te Tohu o te Ora is an annual survey conducted by Oranga                  We have prepared this report with a range of audiences
Tamariki that seeks to better understand the experiences                  in mind. This includes those working in the Oranga
of tamariki and rangatahi in care. It was delivered for the               Tamariki system and associated government agencies,
first time in 2019/2020.                                                  community and iwi partners, as well as organisations
                                                                          with Oranga Tamariki monitoring, oversight and advocacy
The survey was designed with input from tamariki and
                                                                          responsibilities.
rangatahi to ensure it is engaging, accessible and focuses
on aspects of care experiences that are important to                      Readers are invited to approach this report with an
them. Expert advice was also sought to guide our use of                   understanding that, although research findings are
appropriate ethical and privacy measures in the design                    presented, Te Mātātaki is not a traditional research report.
and delivery of the survey.
                                                                          First and foremost, Te Mātātaki is a voice for tamariki and
Te Tohu o te Ora helps Oranga Tamariki fulfil its legislative             rangatahi in care. We have not provided an interpretation
responsibilities to assist tamariki and rangatahi to                      of the survey findings, choosing instead to allow the
express their views on matters that affect them. The                      results to speak for themselves.
survey findings will be used by Oranga Tamariki to drive
                                                                          Some of our readers might also expect to see
high quality, culturally responsive improvements to
                                                                          recommendations for action. Instead, for this first
policies, practices, and services.
                                                                          publication of Te Mātātaki we are sharing with the
                                                                          public an overview of the approach Oranga Tamariki has
Te Mātātaki                                                               taken to make best use of the findings. This includes
                                                                          identifying the areas where we need to prioritise action
Te Mātātaki is the annual report on the findings of Te                    and attention, and then describing initiatives in place and
Tohu o te Ora. Through this report, Oranga Tamariki                       in development that collectively hold the most potential to
makes public our commitment to listen to the voices of                    achieve the shifts required.
tamariki and rangatahi in care and our accountability to
                                                                          We take our commitments to these priority areas
act on what we hear.
                                                                          seriously. In subsequent publications of Te Mātātaki we
In this first publication of Te Mātātaki, we outline how                  will report on the latest survey findings, how tamariki
findings from Te Tohu o te Ora 2019/2020 were used                        and rangatahi experiences have changed, and provide
to identify priority areas where focused action and                       commentary on how identified initiatives and work
engagement is required across Oranga Tamariki to                          programmes may have contributed to these changes.
improve experiences for tamariki and rangatahi.
                                                                          For readers with a particular interest in the technical
An overview is provided of initiatives that are either                    aspects of survey design and delivery, please refer to the
currently in place, or are being developed, that we believe               supplementary Methodology Report1 which is available on
provide the best opportunities for Oranga Tamariki to                     the Oranga Tamariki website.
contribute to the shifts required.

1. Oranga Tamariki Voices of Children and Young People team (2021).
Te Tohu o te Ora: 2019/2020 Methodology Report. Wellington, New Zealand: Oranga Tamariki – Ministry for Children.

                                                                      7                                               Te Mātātaki 2021
SECTION 2

                   To
       uphold                                       a special
                    the mana
                    of the voices of tamariki and
                    rangatahi and acknowledge
                                                     identity
                                                      has been created for
                    the legacy they have created      the survey and the
                    by sharing their voices,          accompanying report.

Te Mātātaki 2021             8                                  9            Te Mātātaki 2021
Te Tohu o te Ora is the overarching name
 of the survey programme. It represents
   the purpose and intent of the survey,
     which is to capture the voices and
  experiences of tamariki and rangatahi.
 Te Tohu o te Ora comes from the words
   “tohu” (symbol) and “ora” (wellbeing).
     The survey is a snapshot in time of
    tamariki and rangatahi experiences,
   informed by the journey that tamariki
  and rangatahi have taken leading up to
 the moment they completed the survey.
    The name Te Tohu o te Ora reminds
    us that tamariki and rangatahi want
   assurance from Oranga Tamariki that
  their “oranga” (wellbeing) is prioritised.

                                               Te Mātātaki 2021   11
Te Mātātaki

                                   Te Mātātaki is the name given to
                                 the report that presents the findings
                                     from Te Tohu o te Ora and the
                                       Oranga Tamariki response.
                                 Te Mātātaki comes from the process
                                    of close observation performed
                                      by kaiwero during pōwhiri, to
                                  understand and confirm the intent
                                     and purpose of manuhiri. The
                                  survey is likened to the kaiwero as
                                  it gathers the lived experiences of
                                  tamariki and rangatahi in care and
                                   challenges Oranga Tamariki and
                                      others to act based on what
                                            has been shared.

     12       Te Mātātaki 2021
Te Mātātaki 2021   14
SECTION 3

Reasons
for doing the
   survey
 Te Tohu o te Ora has been developed
and delivered by the Voices of Children
and Young People team within Oranga
   Tamariki. The team has a special
   mandate to serve as advocates for
   tamariki and rangatahi in care, to
    support their voices to be heard
   and their needs and aspirations to
  be understood and acted on. In this
  section we outline the key positions
  that underpin the work of this team,
       including Te Tohu o te Ora.

                   15                     Te Mātātaki 2021
V E RYONE
              E
                      under

                   18
                    the age of
                                                     Tamariki and rangatahi
                                                     are experts in their
                                                     own experiences
                                                     Oranga Tamariki plays a significant role in the lives of
                                                     tamariki and rangatahi throughout their care journey.
                                                     When there is a need for Oranga Tamariki to enter the
                                                     lives of tamariki and rangatahi, we have a duty to make
                       HAS A
                                                     things better for them. To ensure we get it right, we must
                       RIGHT
                                                     listen to those who are experts in their own experiences of
                                                     care - tamariki and rangatahi themselves. Te Tohu o te Ora
                                                     provides direct feedback to Oranga Tamariki on how well
                                                     we are meeting our responsibilities, identifying where we
               To have     a say
                   have a say about
                   things that affect them
                                                     are making things better for tamariki and rangatahi, and

               about things                          where we need to improve.

                                                     We are committed to our
                    TH AT                            Treaty partnership
                   AF F E CT                         As a Crown agency, Oranga Tamariki is committed to
                    TH E M                           upholding the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi/Te
                                                     Tiriti o Waitangi (Te Tiriti). Principles of Te Tiriti that are
                                                     critical for Oranga Tamariki include, but are not limited to,
                                                     partnership, active protection, equity, kāwanatanga and
                                                     rangatiratanga.

                                                     In addition to our broader obligations to Te Tiriti, the
                        AND
                        FOR                          Ministry’s practical commitment to the principles of Te
                                                     Tiriti is outlined in section 7AA of the Oranga Tamariki
                                                     Act 19892, which is specifically for tamariki and rangatahi
                                                     Māori. This commitment of Oranga Tamariki includes
                   A D U LT S TO

           listen
                                                     that the Chief Executive, through the actions of the
                                                     Ministry, must have regard to the mana and whakapapa of
                                                     tamariki and rangatahi Māori, and the whanaungatanga
                                                     responsibilities of whānau, hapū and iwi. This
                                                     commitment makes explicit the importance of ensuring
                                                     tamariki, rangatahi and whānau Māori are supported to be
                                                     heard and that their views, experiences and perspectives
                                                     influence decisions.
            and take their
          opinions seriously
                   UNCROC Article 12

                                             2. New Zealand Government 1989, The Oranga Tamariki Act 1989. Available
                                             at: Oranga Tamariki Act 1989 No 24 (as at 01 April 2021), Public Act Contents
                                             – New Zealand Legislation

Te Mātātaki 2021                                16
The
                                                                                               RIG HTS
Tamariki and rangatahi
                                                                                                of
                                                                                                havetamariki          &
have a unique voice
                                                                                                     a say about

                                                                                                 rangatahi to
                                                                                                things that affect them

within whānau                                                                                   be heard are
Tamariki and whānau are inextricably linked. One does
not exist without the other. However, the voices and
experiences of tamariki and rangatahi are valid and
                                                                                  G UA R A NTE E D
unique. Te Tohu o te Ora is one way in which Oranga
Tamariki creates space and opportunity for tamariki and                                                 under

                                                                                          Te Tiriti o
rangatahi to share their views and experiences. It does
not seek to separate the voices of tamariki and rangatahi

                                                                                          Waitangi
from their whānau, instead it seeks to strengthen their
participation, as whānau members, in the decisions
and processes that affect them. By focusing on the
experiences of tamariki and rangatahi in care, we gain
insights that will improve policy, practices and services
for the benefit of all whānau.

Tamariki and rangatahi                                                       Te Tohu o te Ora supports
have rights to be heard                                                      tamariki and rangatahi to
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child
(UNCROC)3 is an international treaty that enshrines the
                                                                             be heard
rights of tamariki and rangatahi in law. It was ratified                     While Te Tohu o te Ora serves as a vehicle for tamariki
by New Zealand in 1993 and sets out the fundamental                          and rangatahi to share their unique experiences and
principles and standards for the treatment of tamariki                       perspectives, it also provides a tool by which Oranga
and rangatahi so they can experience a safe, happy and                       Tamariki can be held accountable for whether changes
fulfilling childhood. UNCROC recognises that in addition                     to policies, practices and services to support tamariki
to the Human Rights that apply to all people, tamariki                       and rangatahi and their whānau are achieving their
and rangatahi are afforded specific rights that recognise                    intended effect.
their need for protection and wellbeing. One of the core
                                                                             The first year of the survey has provided a baseline
principles of UNCROC, supported by Te Tohu o te Ora, is
                                                                             understanding of how tamariki and rangatahi are
respect for the views of te tamaiti. Specifically, UNCROC
                                                                             experiencing care. As each year of data is gathered and
affirms that everyone under the age of 18 has a right to
                                                                             provides new information, this understanding will deepen
have a say about things that affect them and for adults to
                                                                             and provide greater insights to help us determine what is
listen and take their opinions seriously (Article 12).
                                                                             working well and where to prioritise action and attention.
The rights of tamariki and rangatahi to be heard are also
guaranteed under Te Tiriti.

The duty to listen and respond is outlined in the Oranga
Tamariki Act, which states that wherever possible all
policies adopted by the department must have regard to
the views of tamariki and rangatahi.

3. United Nations General Assembly. (1989). Convention on the Rights of the Child. United Nations, Treaty Series, 1577(3), 1-23.

                                                                        17                                                         Te Mātātaki 2021
Te Mātātaki 2021   18
SECTION 4

      Survey
Approach
  The 2019/2020 survey was conducted
  across Aotearoa New Zealand in four
  separate rounds between March 2019
    and September 2020. This section
 provides a brief overview of the survey
   approach. More detailed information
   about the survey design and delivery
 is available in the Methodology Report.
   Survey strengths and limitations are
         described in Appendix 1.

                    19                     Te Mātātaki 2021
Survey population
The survey used a census approach so that all tamariki                      The Oranga Tamariki client database was used to draw up
and rangatahi in the legal care of the Chief Executive who                  a list of eligible tamariki and rangatahi. There were 2,659
met the eligibility criteria, could be offered the chance                   tamariki and rangatahi in the original list drawn from the
to take part in the survey and have their voices heard.                     Oranga Tamariki database. Following updates to confirm
Tamariki and rangatahi were eligible to take part if they                   eligibility and ensure accuracy there were 2,327 tamariki
were aged between 10 and 17 years old, had been in the                      and rangatahi listed.
custody of the Chief Executive under a Care or Protection
order for longer than 31 days, and were not living in a
youth justice residence or community home.

                            I PAT I                                                                       tamariki and
             A RTIC                    ON                                                                   rangatahi
            P
                        WAS                                       and a
                                                                                              U N D E RSTOO D
    Voluntary
                                                                 carefully
                                                                designed                           that taking part was

                                                                                               Optional
                                                                informed
                                                                 consent
                                                                 process
                                                                was used
                                                                to ensure
         YUP                         NAH                                                                     YOU
                                                                                                            CHOOSE

Survey delivery
The survey was delivered in four rounds with between two                    Tamariki and rangatahi were given the option of
and four regions participating in each round.4 The paper-                   completing the survey in te reo Māori. They were also
based survey was administered via Oranga Tamariki                           given the option of seeking help to complete the survey
sites, with social workers offering the survey to eligible                  from their social worker. Social workers remained
tamariki and rangatahi during routine visits. Social                        nearby to provide assistance and support to tamariki
workers were encouraged to offer the survey to as many                      and rangatahi if asked, but otherwise gave tamariki
eligible tamariki and rangatahi as possible. Participation                  and rangatahi space to complete the survey in private.
was voluntary, and a carefully designed informed consent                    To ensure anonymity, tamariki and rangatahi were
process was used to ensure tamariki and rangatahi                           given a survey-specific unique identifier that was not
understood that taking part was optional. Social workers                    connected to their name, and they sealed their completed
went through the informed consent process with tamariki                     questionnaires in an envelope to send to the survey team
and rangatahi and tamariki and rangatahi gave their own                     at Oranga Tamariki for data entry.
consent to take part. Caregivers were informed about the
survey and could choose to opt out – that is, they could
choose for the tamariki and rangatahi they care for to not
take part.

4. There are 12 Oranga Tamariki Services for Children and Families regions. All regions were included in the 2019/2020 survey.

Te Mātātaki 2021                                                       20
Questionnaire                                                    TABLE 1: Domains of experience identified as important by
                                                                 tamariki and rangatahi and how they described them

The questionnaire and its content were
formed around the experiences tamariki and                                                     What the domain meant to
rangatahi in care said were most important                                    Domain            tamariki and rangatahi
to them. Through a programme of formative
qualitative research that included 110                                                    The people you live with look after
                                                                    Feeling cared for
interviews with care experienced tamariki                                                 you and make you feel at home
and rangatahi, we identified the domains
of experience that were most important
                                                                    Feeling accepted
to tamariki and rangatahi, what those                                                     The people you live with making
                                                                    for who you
experiences meant to them, and why they                                                   an effort to understand you and
                                                                    are by the people
were important. These insights were used to                                               being kind and caring
                                                                    you live with
build the survey questions (see Table 1).

In addition to the domains of experience                            Having good
                                                                                          Knowing your family and whānau,
                                                                    relationships
tamariki and rangatahi identified as                                                      getting along with them and
                                                                    with your whānau,
important to them, the final questionnaire                                                getting to see and talk to them
                                                                    hapū and iwi
(19 questions in total) included questions on:
sociodemographic characteristics, domains
                                                                    Having a say in       Feeling listened to and being
of experience that have been shown in                               important             able to say how you feel
international research to relate to positive                        decisions             about things
outcomes for tamariki and rangatahi in
care, experiences with Oranga Tamariki and
                                                                    Having a place
social workers and awareness of VOYCE-                                                    Having somewhere
                                                                    where you feel
Whakarongo Mai, an advocacy service for                                                   you can just be yourself
                                                                    like you belong
care experienced tamariki and rangatahi.5

The draft survey was tested with tamariki,
                                                                    Knowing               Knowing your whānau,
rangatahi and social workers to ensure it                           your ancestry         knowing their history and
was crafted using language that tamariki and                        (whakapapa)           knowing where you come from
rangatahi use and understand.

                                                                                          Someone caring for you deeply,
                                                                    Feeling loved         supporting you and being there
                                                                                          for you no matter what

                                                                    Knowing your          Learning about your background
                                                                    culture and where     and the things that make you
                                                                    you come from         who you are

                                                                    Feeling hope          Feeling like you will have a
                                                                    for the future        good life when you grow up

5. Results to questions about VOYCE – Whakarongo Mai are not reported here.

                                                                    21                                           Te Mātātaki 2021
Survey
                            DESIGNED
                              a nd

                          D E V E LO PE D
                                                   WITH
                                                 INSIGHTS
                                                   FROM
                                                                       100
                                                                                 O V E R

                                                                          INTERVIEWS
                                                                                                                                               1,545tamariki and rangatahi
                                                                                                                                                    PA R TI C I PAT E D
                                                                                                                                                                                                      THIS
                                                                                                                                                                                                       IS

                                                                                                                                                                                                                     84%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 of those
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          offered
                                                                            with tamariki and
                                                                                rangatahi
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   to take part

                                                         TABLE 2: Response rates for each sociodemographic group.

                                                                                                                                   Number of tamariki and             Number of tamariki and              Response rate among
                                                                     Sociodemographic group
 Participation                                                                                                                     rangatahi offered survey         rangatahi who participated            those offered survey

                                                                                        10 to 12                                             660                               598                                 91%
 Social workers offered the survey
 to 1,847 (79%) of the 2,327 eligible                                                   13 to 15                                             659                               587                                 89%
                                                                    AGE
 tamariki and rangatahi across
                                                                                        16 to 18                                             408                               351                                 86%
 Aotearoa New Zealand. Of those,
 1,545 agreed to take part resulting in                                                 No age recorded                                      120                                 9                                 8%
 a response rate of 84% among those
                                                                                        Male                                                 892                               775                                 87%
 offered the survey and 66% among all
 eligible tamariki and rangatahi.                                                       Female                                               802                               732                                 91%
                                                                 GENDER
 Table 2 shows the response rates by
                                                                                        A gender not listed                                  18                                 17                                 94%
 sociodemographic group. Despite
 small differences, the overall age,                                                    No gender recorded                                   135                                21                                 16%
 gender, ethnicity, and care status
 distributions for the groups who                                                       Māori and Pacific                                    140                               125                                 89%
 participated were similar to those                                                     Māori                                               1,019                              896                                 88%
 in the overall offered sample.
                                                               ETHNICITY                Pacific                                              323                               284                                 88%

                                                                                        Non-Māori and non-Pacific                            520                               479                                 92%

                                                                                        No ethnicity recorded                                125                                11                                 9%

                                                                                        Care services                                       1,389                              1182                                85%

                                                             CARE STATUS                Care and Youth Justice servicesa                     106                                95                                 90%

 6. This indicated that weighting the data by                                           None recorded                                        352                               268                                 76%
 sociodemographic characteristics -
 to account for potential disparities in those
 who were offered the survey but did or did              a. This group included tamariki and rangatahi who were under a Care and                        NOTE: For further information about response rates, see the Methodology report.
                                                         Protection order and received youth justice services in the community.
 not take it - was not necessary.

 Te Mātātaki 2021                                   22                                                                                                                                           23                                       Te Mātātaki 2021
WERE
                                  19%                                                               58%               WERE

                                                1,545
                   PACIFIC
                                                                OF THE                                                MĀORI

                                                     tamariki and rangatahi
                                31%                                                                     8%
   WERE NON-MĀORI                                                                                                         WERE MĀORI
   AND NON-PACIFIC
                                                         WHO TOOK
                                                                                                                          AND PACIFIC

                                                           PART

Table 3 shows the sociodemographic characteristics                           The majority of tamariki and rangatahi (79%) answered
of the 1,545 tamariki and rangatahi who took part in the                     all survey questions. Of those, 93% answered in English,
survey. Of the tamariki and rangatahi who took part, 58%                     1% answered Māori and 7% answered in both English
were Māori, 19% were Pacific, eight percent were Māori                       and Māori.
and Pacific and 31% were other ethnicities (non-Māori
and non-Pacific).

TABLE 3: Respondent characteristics.

                                                                                                 Percentage of
       Sociodemographic group                                           Number                    respondants

                        10 to 12                                             598                        39%

       AGE a            13 to 15                                             587                        38%

                        16 to 18                                             351                        23%

                        Male                                                 775                        51%

    GENDER b            Female                                               732                        48%

                        A gender not listed                                  17                          1%

                        Māori and Pacific                                    125                        8%

                        Māori                                                896                        58%
  ETHNICITY a,b
                        Pacific                                              284                        19%

                        Non-Māori and non-Pacific                            479                        31%

                        Care services                                     1,182                         77%
                        Care and Youth Justice
  CARE STATUS                                                                95                          6%
                        services
                        None recorded                                        268                        17%

                    a. The age, gender, and ethnicity figures total fewer than 1,545 because some respondents did
                    not record all their sociodemographic characteristics.
                    b. Ethnicity is categorised according to total response (rather than prioritised), so there is some
                    overlap between the Māori & Pacific, Māori, and Pacific groups.

Te Mātātaki 2021                                                        24
Analysis
For each experience question, we calculated the                                 When interpreting the results in this report, it is important
proportion of respondents who chose each                                        to note that any difference described as ‘higher/more
response option.7                                                               likely than’ or ‘lower/less likely than’ was statistically
                                                                                significant (i.e., the difference was not within the margin
To assess whether responses differed across each of
                                                                                of error). In this report, the word ‘significant’ specifically
the key sociodemographic subgroups, we combined the
                                                                                refers to statistical significance and does not mean ‘large’
two positive response options for each question (‘all
                                                                                or ‘meaningful’. Finally, some percentages may not total
the time/most of the time’; ‘yes, definitely/yes I think
                                                                                exactly 100% due to rounding.
so’). We then used statistical tests (logistic regressions)
to compare the total proportion of positive responses                           Appendix 2 provides a full overview of survey results by
between subgroups, to see whether responses differed                            subgroup (age, gender, ethnicity, care status).
by age, gender, ethnicity, or care status. We ran these
subgroup analyses for each subgroup that had at least
30 respondents (all except the ‘gender not listed’ gender
group).8 See Table 4 for specific subgroup definitions.

TABLE 4: Subgroup definitions used in analysis.

     Group type                              Subgroup                                                        Description

                        10 to 12
                                                                                     Age in years was recorded on the survey, and then
       AGE a            13 to 15
                                                                                        grouped into three categories for analysis.
                        16 to 18b

                        Male
                                                                                         Gender was analysed as it was recorded on
    GENDERa             Female
                                                                                          the survey (i.e., in these three categories).
                        A gender not listed

                        Respondents/social workers could choose as many ethnicities as applied. For analysis, we used
                        total (rather than prioritised) ethnicity and as a result, the groups were not mutually exclusive.

                        Māori and Pacific                                             Māori and at least one Pacific ethnicity selected

  ETHNICITYa            Māori                                                        Māori selected as one of respondent’s ethnicities

                        Pacific                                                             At least one Pacific ethnicity selected

                                                                                            Selected ethnicities other than Māori
                        Non-Māori and non-Pacific
                                                                                                    or a Pacific ethnicity

                        Care services                                                    Those without a care status recorded were
     CARE                                                                                analysed as their own group to see whether
                        Care and Youth Justice services
    STATUS c                                                                            there were any differences with those whose
                        None recorded                                                     social worker did record their care status.

                     a. Ethnicity, age and gender were self-identified if tamariki and rangatahi agreed to participate, and social worker-identified if
                     they declined.
                     b. Tamariki and rangatahi aged 10 to 17 years were the target sample of the survey, but there were some respondents aged
                     18 years because we did not exclude those who turned 18 between sample identification and fieldwork completion.
                     c. Care status was always social worker-identified.

7. Those who skipped the question or provided an ambiguous answer (e.g., ticked multiple boxes, wrote a spontaneous answer instead of
ticking a box) were excluded from the analysis for that question only.
8. All response options were included in the base, except for three questions which included a ‘don’t know’ or ‘other’ response option that
was qualitatively different from the other responses and could not reasonably be combined with the non-positive responses (Q5-7).

                                                                           25                                                        Te Mātātaki 2021
SECTION 5

                   Survey
                   Results
                     In this section we present a
                      summary of the results by
                     question, as well as results
                     where there is a statistically
                   significant difference based on
                    demographic characteristics.

Te Mātātaki 2021                 26
Feeling
                                FIGURE 1. Feel settled where I live now (%).

                                                         64
 settled                           Yes definitely           Yes I think so      No not really
                                                                                                26               7
                                                                                                      No not at all

                                Base: All respondents (n = 1,513), excluding those who skipped this question.
                                                                                                                      3

Tamariki and rangatahi were     The majority of tamariki and rangatahi (90%) indicated they felt
asked, “Do you feel settled     settled (chose ‘Yes, I think so’ or ‘Yes, definitely’). Six in 10 said
                                they ‘definitely’ felt settled, one in 10 did not feel settled.
where you live now?” to
assess how comfortable          There were no significant differences by age, gender, ethnicity,
and stable they feel in their   or care status.

current care placement
(Figure 1).

Feeling                 well looked after
                                FIGURE 2. Adults I live with look after me well (%).

Tamariki and rangatahi

                                                                  81
were asked, “Do the
adults you live with now                                                                                   16         2
look after you well?” to
assess how well they
                                   All of the time          Most of the time        Not much of the time          Never
feel cared for in their
                                   Don’t live with adults
current care placement
(Figure 2).                     Base: All respondents (n = 1,518), excluding those who skipped this question and who
                                answered ‘don’t know’.
                                Note: Proportions are not labelled for response options chosen by ≤ 1% of respondents.

                                Most tamariki and rangatahi (97%) indicated the adults they live
                                with look after them well, with eight in 10 indicating they did so ‘all
                                of the time’. There were no significant differences by age, gender
                                or ethnicity, but those with no care status recorded (95%) were less
                                likely than those with care status recorded (98%) to say the adults
                                they live with look after them well.

                                                    27                                                 Te Mātātaki 2021
FIGURE 3. Adults I live with accept me for who I am (%).

Feeling
accepted                               Yes definitely
                                                            69
                                                                 Yes I think so     No not really
                                                                                                       26
                                                                                                         No not at all
                                                                                                                         3

                                       Don’t live with adults

                                   Base: All respondents (n = 1,516), excluding those who skipped this question and who
                                   answered ‘don’t know’.
                                   Note: Proportions are not labelled for response options chosen by ≤ 1% of respondents.

 Tamariki and rangatahi were       Most tamariki and rangatahi (95%) felt the adults they live with
 asked, “Do the adults you         accept them for who they are, with seven in 10 saying they
                                   ‘definitely’ accept them for who they are.
 live with now accept you for
 you who are?” to assess how       There were no significant differences by age, gender, ethnicity
 well they feel the adults they    or care status.

 live with accept, respect, and
 believe in them (Figure 3).

 Relationships with                                                whanau
                                  FIGURE 4. Get to keep in touch with my birth family/
                                  whānau as much as I would like to.

 During the formative work

                                                      49
 for the survey, tamariki and
 rangatahi defined having                                                           22                18           6     5
 good relationships with
 birth family/whānau as
                                     Yes definitely             Yes I think so     No not really        No not at all
 “I know my family and get
                                     Don’t want to
 to see and talk to them”. To
                                  Base: All respondents (n = 1,494), excluding those who skipped this question
 assess their views of their      and who answered ‘don’t know’.
 relationships with birth
                                  The majority of tamariki and rangatahi (71%) indicated they get to keep in
 family/whānau, tamariki and      touch with their birth family/whānau as much as they would like to and five
 rangatahi were asked, “Do        in 10 indicated they ‘definitely’ did. Around two in 10 said they did not get to
 you get to keep in touch with    keep in touch with their birth family/whānau as much as they would like to,
 your birth family/whānau as      and one in 20 indicated they did not want to see their birth family/whānau.
 much as you would like to?”      There were no significant differences by gender or care status, but there
 (Figure 4).                      were differences by age and ethnicity:

                                  • Those aged 10 to 12 years                     • Those who identified as both
                                    (72%) were less likely than 16 to               Māori and Pacific were less likely
                                    18-year-olds (79%) to say they get              (66%) than all others combined
                                    to keep in touch with their birth               (76%) to say they get to keep
                                    family/whānau as much as they                   in touch with their birth family/
                                    would like to.                                  whānau as much as they would
                                                                                    like to.

Te Mātātaki 2021                                     28
Having a say in
                       important decisions
                                FIGURE 5. Get to have a say in important decisions about my life (%).

Tamariki and rangatahi were

                                                                            47
asked, “Do you get to have a
say in important decisions
about your life?” (Figure 5).
                                         31                                                              18           4

                                   All of the time       Most of the time      Not much of the time        Never

                                Base: All respondents (n = 1,493), excluding those who skipped this question.

                                A majority of tamariki and rangatahi (78%) indicated that they get to
                                have a say in important decisions about their life. Three in 10 said
                                they get to have a say ‘all of the time’, five in 10 said ‘most of the time’
                                and two in 10 said ‘not much of the time’ or ‘never’.

                                Responses varied by age, with tamariki and younger rangatahi (10
                                to 12-year-olds, 74%, and 13 to 15-year-olds, 78%) less likely than 16
                                to 18-year-olds (84%) to indicate they got to have a say in important
                                decisions about their life. There were no significant differences by
                                gender, ethnicity or care status.

  Having a                      FIGURE 6. Have somewhere I feel I belong (%).

  sense of                                               60                                     28              9
belonging
                                                                                                                      3

                                   Yes definitely         Yes I think so        No not really         No not at all

                                Base: All respondents (n = 1,500), excluding those who skipped this question.

Tamariki and rangatahi          Most tamariki and rangatahi (88%) indicated that they have somewhere
were asked, “Do you have        they feel they belong, six in 10 said they ‘definitely’ did. There was no
                                significant difference by gender or care status but there were differences
somewhere you feel you
                                by age and ethnicity:
belong?” to assess their
sense of belonging and          • Rangatahi aged 16 to 18 years               • Non-Māori and non-Pacific
                                  (86%) were less likely than 10 to             tamariki and rangatahi (91%)
whether they feel that they
                                  12-year-olds (90%) to say they                were more likely than all others
have somewhere they can           have somewhere they feel                      combined (87%) to say they
just be themselves                they belong.                                  have somewhere they feel
(Figure 6).                                                                     they belong.

                                                    29                                                 Te Mātātaki 2021
Knowing                        whakapapa
                                FIGURE 7. Know my ancestry (whakapapa) (%).

Tamariki and rangatahi were

                                                                                      30
asked, “Do you know your
ancestry (whakapapa)?”                 25                      28                                              14    3
(Figure 7).
                                   Yes definitely         Yes I think so        No not really        No not at all

                                   Don’t know meaning

                                Base: All respondents (n = 1,507), excluding those who skipped this question
                                but included those who answered ‘don’t know’.

                                Just over one-half of tamariki and rangatahi (53%) indicated they
                                knew their ancestry (whakapapa), with one-quarter confident they
                                ‘definitely’ knew it. There were no significant differences by age or
                                care status, but there were by ethnicity and gender:

                                • Males (50%) were less likely than females (57%) to say they know
                                  their ancestry (whakapapa).

                                • Tamariki and rangatahi who identified as Māori (59%) were more
                                  likely than all others combined (44%) to say they know their
                                  ancestry (whakapapa), while non-Māori and non-Pacific tamariki
                                  and rangatahi (41%) were less likely than all others combined
                                  (58%) to say they know their ancestry (whakapapa).

                                FIGURE 8. People in my life who love me no matter what (%).

 Feeling
                                                            77                                          20
    loved
                                                                                                                     2

                                   Yes definitely         Yes I think so        No not really        No not at all

                                Base: All respondents (n = 1,514), excluding those who skipped this question.
                                Note: Proportions are not labelled for response options chosen by ≤ 1% of respondents.

Tamariki and rangatahi were     Almost all tamariki and rangatahi (97%) indicated they had people
asked, “Do you have people      in their life who love them no matter what, with eight in 10 indicating
                                they ‘definitely’ did.
in your life who love you no
matter what?” to assess the     There were no significant differences by age, gender, ethnicity or
extent to which they felt       care status.

loved unconditionally
(Figure 8).

Te Mātātaki 2021                                30
Having                         FIGURE 9. Friend(s) I can talk to about anything (%).

 friends                                                64                                     22              9     6

  to talk to                      Yes definitely         Yes I think so        No not really         No not at all

                               Base: All respondents (n = 1,516), excluding those who skipped this question.

Tamariki and rangatahi were    Most tamariki and rangatahi (86%) indicated they had friends they
asked, “Do you have a friend   could talk to about anything; six in 10 said they ‘definitely’ did.

or friends you can talk to     There were no significant differences by age, gender, ethnicity, or
about anything?” to assess     care status.
friendship relationships
(Figure 9).

  Learning                     FIGURE 10. Opportunities to learn about my culture (%).

   about                                   43                                 32                       19

 culture
                                                                                                                     6

                                  Yes definitely         Yes I think so        No not really         No not at all

                               Base: All respondents (n = 1,491), excluding those who skipped this question.

Tamariki and rangatahi         A majority of tamariki and rangatahi (75%) indicated they had opportunities
were asked, “Do you get        to learn about their culture; four in 10 said they ‘definitely’ did. Two in 10
                               indicated they did not have opportunities to learn about their culture (‘not
the chance to learn about
                               really’ or ‘not at all’).
your culture?” to assess
the extent to which            There was no significant difference by gender, but there were differences
                               for some age, ethnicity, and care status groups:
they have the chance to
connect with their culture     • Rangatahi aged 16 to 18 years                  were non-Pacific (74%) to say
(Figure 10).                     (70%) were less likely than 10                 they had the chance to learn
                                 to 12-year-olds (77%) and 13 to                about their culture.
                                 15-year-olds (76%) to say they
                                                                             • Non-Māori, non-Pacific tamariki
                                 had the chance to learn about
                                                                               and rangatahi (63%) were less
                                 their culture.
                                                                               likely than all others combined
                               • Tamariki and rangatahi who                    (80%) to say they had the chance
                                 identified as Māori (79%) were                to learn about their culture.
                                 more likely than those who
                                                                             • Those who were receiving Care
                                 were non-Māori (69%) to say they
                                                                               and Youth Justice services (66%)
                                 had the chance to learn about
                                                                               were less likely than those in the
                                 their culture.
                                                                               Care services only group (76%) to
                               • Tamariki and rangatahi who                    say they had the chance to learn
                                 identified as Pacific (81%) were              about their culture.
                                 more likely than those who

                                                   31                                                 Te Mātātaki 2021
Having                hope for the future
                             FIGURE 11. Good life when I get older (%).

Tamariki and rangatahi

                                         42                                30
were asked, “Do you think
you will have a good life                                                                    42        22
when you get older?” to
assess their hope for the
                                Yes definitely         Yes I think so        No not really         No not at all
future (Figure 11).
                                Don’t know

                             Base: All respondents (n = 1,500), excluding those who skipped this question.

                             A majority of tamariki and rangatahi (72%) indicated they expect to have
                             a good life when they get older; four in 10 said they ‘definitely’ expect
                             to. Two in 10 tamariki and rangatahi said they ‘don’t know’ whether they
                             expect to have a good life when they get older.

                             Responses differed by age group, with 10 to 12-year-olds (67%) less likely
                             than 13 to 15-year-olds (75%) and 16 to 18-year-olds (76%) to expect to
                             have a good life when they get older. However, it is important to note that
                             this difference was due to the younger age group being more likely to say
                             ‘I don’t know’ rather than choosing more negative response options.

                             There were no significant differences by gender, ethnicity, or care status.

    Views
                             FIGURE 12. Oranga Tamariki helps make things better for me (%).

                                         39                                   45
 of Oranga
                                                                                                         12        5

  Tamariki
                                Yes definitely         Yes I think so        No not really         No not at all

                             Base: All respondents (n = 1,445), excluding those who skipped this question.

Tamariki and rangatahi       Most tamariki and rangatahi (84%) indicated that Oranga Tamariki
were asked, “Does Oranga     helps make things better for them; four in 10 said they ‘definitely’ did.

Tamariki help make things    Responses did not differ by ethnicity or gender, but they did by age
better for you?” to assess   and care status.
their overall satisfaction   • 13 to 15-year-olds (79%) were            • Those with no care status
with the organisation          less likely than 10 to 12-year-            recorded (78%) were less
(Figure 12).                   olds (88%) and 16 to 18-year-              likely than those with care
                               olds (85%) to indicate that                status recorded (85%) to say
                               Oranga Tamariki helps make                 that Oranga Tamariki makes
                               things better for them.                    things better for them.

Te Mātātaki 2021                                 32
Social worker                           relationships
                               FIGURE 13. My social worker does what they say they will do (%).

Tamariki and rangatahi

                                            43                                      45
were asked two questions
to assess their relationship                                                                                   10   2
with their social worker:
“Does your social worker do
                                  All of the time      Most of the time       Not much of the time        Never
what they say they will do?”
                               Base: All respondents (n = 1,469), excluding those who skipped this question.
and “Do you feel you can
talk to your social worker
                               FIGURE 14. Can talk to my social worker about my worries (%).
about your worries?”
(Figures 13 and 14 show the
results for both questions).
                                            44                                     38                     13        5

                                  All of the time      Most of the time       Not much of the time        Never

                               Base: All respondents (n = 1,487), excluding those who skipped this question.

                               Most tamariki and rangatahi gave              For the second question, “Do you
                               positive responses to the questions           feel you can talk to your social
                               about their relationship with                 worker about your worries?”
                               their social worker (88% and 82%              responses did not differ by gender,
                               respectively), although only four             but there were differences by age,
                               in 10 indicated their social worker           ethnicity, and care status:
                               does what they say they will do
                                                                             • 13 to 15-year-olds (78%) were
                               ‘all of the time’ and that they can
                                                                               less likely than 10 to 12-year-olds
                               ‘definitely’ talk to their social worker
                                                                               (84%) to say they can talk to their
                               about their worries.
                                                                               social worker about their worries.
                               For the first question, “Does your
                                                                             • Those who identified as both
                               social worker do what they say they
                                                                               Māori and Pacific (73%) were
                               will do?” responses did not differ
                                                                               less likely than all others
                               by age, gender, or care status, but
                                                                               combined (82%) to say they can
                               there were differences by ethnicity:
                                                                               talk to their social worker about
                               • Tamariki and rangatahi who                    their worries.
                                 identified as Māori and Pacific
                                                                             • Those with no care status
                                 (77%) or Pacific (84%) were less
                                                                               recorded (74%) were less likely
                                 likely than all others (89%) to
                                                                               than those with care status
                                 say that their social worker does
                                                                               recorded (84%) to say that they
                                 what they say they will do.
                                                                               can talk to their social worker
                                                                               about their worries.

                                                33                                                    Te Mātātaki 2021
Overall pattern of
FIGURE 15: Overall pattern of responses (%) for each of the experience questions
                                                                                            responses                                              To demonstrate the overall pattern of responses, Figure 15 shows the results for all
                                                                                                                                                   experience questions, sorted from those with the most positive to least positive responses.

Have people in my life who
love me no matter what
                                                                                                   77                                                                                                                        20                          2

Adults I live with accept
me for who I am
                                                                                                   69                                                                                                             26                             3

Have friends I can talk
to about anything                                                                           64                                                                                                         22                          9                 6

Feel settled
where I live now                                                                          64                                                                                                           26                                   7            3

Have somewhere
I feel I belong
Get to keep in touch with
                                                                                      60                                                                                                               28                                   9            3

                                                                                                   49
my birth family/whānau
as much as I want to                                                                                                                                                       22                                   18                      6            5

Can talk to my social
worker about my worries                                                                         44                                                                              38                                              13                   5

Get the chance to learn
about my culture                                                                            43                                                                           32                                             19                           6

Think I will have a good
life when I get older                                                                    42                                                                         30                                4     2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                22
Oranga Tamariki makes
things better for me                                                                   39                                                                                   45                                                    12                 5

Know my ancestry
(whakapapa)                                                          25                                                                 28                                                30                                       14                    3

                                         Yes definitely     Yes I think so      No not really      No not at all           Don’t know/other

Adults I live with look
after me well
                                                                                                 81                                                                                                                              16                      2

My social worker does what
they say they are going to do                                                               43                                                                                      45                                                   10                  2

Get to have a say in important
decisions about my life                                                      31                                                                                             47                                               18                          4

                                         All of the time     Most of the time       Not much of the time           Never        Don’t know/other

Base: All respondents excluding those who skipped the question (n = variable, depending on the question; ranged from 1,445-1,518).
Note: Responses selected by ≤ 1% of respondents are not labelled.

Te Mātātaki 2021                                                     34                                                                                                                               35                                    Te Mātātaki 2021
Summary of differences
                             age group
                                                              SEVERAL

    by               9

                                                              differences

       10 12         -
            year-olds were

                    less
                   likely
                                          13 15       -
                                              year-olds were

                      THAN                         less
                                                  likely
       16 to 18-year-olds to say                        THAN
       they get to see their birth
        family/whānau as much
            as they want to
                                          16 to 18-year-olds to feel
                                            they get to have a say
                                           in important decisions
       16 to 18-year-olds to feel
                                                about their life
         they get to have a say
        in important decisions
             about their life
                                           10 to 12-year-olds and
                                          16 to 18-year-olds to feel
                                            that Oranga Tamariki
         13 to 15-year-olds and
                                             makes things better
          16 to 18-year-olds to
                                                  for them
          think they will have a
         good life when they get
        older (because more 10
        to 12-year-olds said they           10 to 12-year-olds to
       ‘don’t know’, not because          feel they can talk to their
       they were choosing more              social worker about
          negative responses)                    their worries

Te Mātātaki 2021                     36
O
                                                                                               N
                                                                                               E
                                                                                         difference

                                                              Summary
                                                              of difference
                                                                                gender
       16 18
                                                                     by
                         -
            year-olds were

                 THAN
                       less
                      likely                                                males
                                                                                were

                                                                                 less
          10 to 12-year-olds to feel
           they have somewhere
                                                                                likely
                 they belong
                                                                              THAN

           10 to 12-year-olds and
          13 to 15-year-olds to say                                          females to say
           they get the chance to                                            they know their
          learn about their culture                                            whakapapa

9. See Appendix 2 for a full overview of survey results by subgroup.

                                                                       37                          Te Mātātaki 2021
Summary of differences
                                          ethnicity
                                                                                                            SEVERAL
                                                                                            10
                           by
                                                                                                              differences
      Tamariki and
     rangatahi who
       identified
                                                                         TA M A R I K I &
                                                                         R A N G ATA H I
                                  as

              BOTH
         MĀO R I & PAC I FI C
                                                                                  Maori            were
                           were
                                                                                                   more
                      less                                                                         likely
                     likely
                                                                                                        TO
                                  TO                                                                   S AY
                                 S AY

                                                                                            they know their
              they get to see their                                                           whakapapa
            birth family/whānau as
             much as they want to
                                                                                          that they get the
                                                                                           chance to learn
            that their social worker                                                     about their culture
              does what they say
              they’re going to do

               that they can talk to
                their social worker
                about their worries

10. To test for ethnicity differences, we compared each group identified to all others combined.

Te Mātātaki 2021                                                        38
Pacific                       NON
                             MĀO R I
                                            NON
                                            PAC I F I C
 TA M A R I K I &               TA M A R I K I &
 R A N G ATA H I                R A N G ATA H I
       were                           were

       less                         more
      likely                        likely
             TO                             TO
            S AY                           S AY

  their social worker               they have
 does what they say              somewhere they
 they are going to do            feel they belong

 and                            and
      more                           less
      likely                        likely
             TO                             TO
            S AY                           S AY

    they get the                  they know their
  chance to learn                   whakapapa
 about their culture

                                  that they get the
                                   chance to learn
                                 about their culture

                        39                             Te Mātātaki 2021
Summary of                                               SOME

   differences
      by                care status                       differences

           Compared with those
     in the Care services only group             Tamariki and
          tamariki and rangatahi                rangatahi in the

               whose                        CAR E         YO UTH
           care status was                     and        J U STI C E
                     N OT
                     RECORDED
                                             services group
                                                    were
                             were
                     less                          less
                    likely                        likely
                           TO
                          S AY                          THAN

                 that the adults               those in the Care
               they live with look           services only group to
                 after them well              say that they get the
                                             chance to learn about
                                                  their culture
                     that Oranga
                   Tamariki makes
                    things better
                       for them

             that they can talk to
              their social worker
              about their worries

Te Mātātaki 2021                       40
SECTION 6

Priority
     areas
   for action
 Oranga Tamariki is committed to
using feedback from tamariki and
 rangatahi to drive policy, practice
  and service improvements. This
section identifies six priority areas
where action needs to be focused.

                  41                    Te Mātātaki 2021
Input and advice from tamariki and
                   rangatahi helped us decide what
                   questions to ask in the survey. This
                   means that most of the results presented
                   in this report reflect on experiences that
                   tamariki and rangatahi have already told
                   us are important to them.
                   Positively, the survey results suggest
                   that many tamariki and rangatahi in
                   care feel settled, well looked after, loved
                   and accepted. However, the results
                   also highlight areas where tamariki and
                   rangatahi in care are not having positive
                   experiences, or where particular groups
                   of tamariki and rangatahi are not having
                   positive experiences.
                   To ensure Oranga Tamariki is engaged
                   and active in areas where the need to
                   improve is greatest, we have identified
                   six priority areas.
                   These priority areas are expressed
                   through the Te Mātātaki tohu.

Te Mātātaki 2021                       42
Te Mātātaki

        Supporting                                      Enabling
                         PRIORITY        PRIORITY
       contact with       AREA            AREA        participation

      whanau              1               2                in
                                                     decisions

Strengthening      		                                    Providing
   relationships                                       opportunities
      with                                             to learn about
    social
                        PRIORITY          PRIORITY

                                                     whakapapa
                         AREA              AREA

      workers            3                  4              and
                                                           culture

      Supporting                                      Improving
     tamariki and       PRIORITY
                         AREA
                                         PRIORITY
                                          AREA       experiences
                         5                 6
   rangatahi to have
   confidence in the                                     for tamariki

      future                                         and rangatahi who
                                                     identify as Māori
                                                       and Pacific

                                    43                         Te Mātātaki 2021
Supporting
             contact
               with
whanau                                                          PRIORITY
                                                                 AREA

       All tamariki and rangatahi should be with
       loving whānau and communities where
       their oranga can be realised.
       Tamariki and rangatahi have told us that whānau
       are where they look to for unconditional love
       and acceptance, and that being separated from
       them can be painful. For Māori and Pacific
       tamariki, whānau is where they find belonging
                                                                1
       and connection to whakapapa and culture that is
       critical to their wellbeing.

       When tamariki and rangatahi are not able to live
       with their whānau, they need to be supported
       to be in contact with their whānau, to promote
       and maintain positive identity and belonging
       and the associated wellbeing outcomes. Under
       the Oranga Tamariki National Care Standards11
       (Care Standards), all tamariki and rangatahi in
       care must be supported to establish, maintain
       and strengthen relationships with family, whānau,
       hapū, iwi and family groups, particularly those
       people tamariki and rangatahi identify as most
       important to them.

       11. https://www.orangatamariki.govt.nz/children-
       in-our-care/national-care-standards/

Te Mātātaki 2021                                           44
Enabling
                             participation
                               in
PRIORITY
 AREA
                  decisions
2
           Tamariki and rangatahi are born with inherent
           mana and have their own unique voice and
           experience within their whānau and the
           systems they are a part of.
           To ensure decisions made about tamariki and rangatahi
           are the best ones possible for them, their unique
           perspectives need to be heard.

           Tamariki and rangatahi in care have told us they need
           their voices to be heard, valued, and acted on. When
           tamariki and rangatahi are supported to participate
           in decisions it builds trust in key relationships and an
           understanding of why certain decisions have been made.
           This can help them to feel valued and more settled.
           When tamariki and rangatahi can see their voice has
           been acted on, it encourages them to keep participating
           throughout their journey, building a sense of self-efficacy
           and confidence to take into adulthood.

           Ensuring tamariki and rangatahi are involved and
           empowered, which includes support to contribute,
           be listened to, make positive choices and develop
           autonomy, is one of the key outcomes of the Child and
           Youth Wellbeing Strategy12. The right to express views
           and to be heard is enshrined in the United Nations
           Convention on the Rights of the Child, and it is an
           expectation set out in the Oranga Tamariki Act and
           under the Care Standards.

            12. https://childyouthwellbeing.govt.nz/

           45                                            Te Mātātaki 2021
Strengthening
   relationships
       with
    social
      workers
         The relationship between tamariki
         and rangatahi in care and their
         social worker is critical.
                                                               PRIORITY
                                                                AREA

                                                               3
         Tamariki and rangatahi have told us that they
         need continuity and consistency from their
         social worker. They value social workers who
         are trustworthy, respectful, honest with them,
         show empathy and kindness, are patient and
         understanding, relatable and accept them for
         who they are. When tamariki and rangatahi
         have a consistent, meaningful and trusted
         relationship with their social worker they are
         more able to express their needs, wishes
         and views.

         Social workers who have built effective
         relationships better understand what is
         most important to tamariki and rangatahi
         they are working with. They are equipped to
         advocate for better outcomes whether that
         be addressing safety concerns, connecting
         tamariki and rangatahi with whānau and
         community, or making sure that tamariki
         and rangatahi understand their rights and
         opportunities to participate in important
         processes.

Te Mātātaki 2021                                          46
You can also read