Seychelles - Threat Assessment 2020 - Page of 1 - Financial Crime News
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
modern day slaves in Seychelles or the GSI Seychelles incidence, yet the country is considered to have a “B” response. In the US Traffi cking in Section 1 - Executive Summary Persons report, Seychelles has a Tier 2 rating. Grey Lists: Seychelles is not listed by FATF, EU Sanctions & Terrorism: There are no sanctions nor by the US as a “Country of Primary against the country. Seychelles is a Tier 3 (Low Concern” in respect of ML & FC threat) PPI 2019 (Proliferation) Index country with a “Moderate” response score of NRA: The NRA was published in 2017. The 426/1,300. Seychelles has a “0” impact score overall ML threat was rated “Medium High” (0/10) in the Global Terrorism Index 2019 with vulnerability level for ML as “Medium High” & ML risk for Seychelles rated overall at Response & Resilience: FATF MER 4th round “Medium High.” The potential threat level in results by ESAAMLG were 55/100 for technical respect of TF risk was rated as “Low”. Based on compliance (40 Recommendations), & 3/100 an assessment of ML threats from 2013-2015, for effectiveness (11 Outcomes). Seychelles estimated prevalence and proceeds of crime scored 5.38/10 for resilience (Moderate), generated were identifi ed as drug traffi cking, ranked 11/54 for Africa in the OC Index. which came fi rst, followed by (in order), tax Indices: Seychelles scored 72/100 and was evasion, smuggling, corruption, company rated “partly free” in the 2019 Freedom in the fraud, fraud/forgery, theft & robbery. World report, and 64.3/100 for economic Organised Crime: According to the OC Index, freedom (Heritage Foundation) described as Low Criminality - High Resilience. Criminality “moderately free ”. The Mo Ibrahim Index of 3.93/10, (ranked 42nd lowest of 54 African African Governance (IIAG) scored Seychelles countries. Main markets are drugs (heroin 2nd in Africa at 73/100. The Basel AML Index (6.5/10), wildlife crime (6/10), human 2016 scored Seychelles 6/10. traffi cking (4/10) and drugs (synthetics (4/10). Overall Ratings: Seychelles is rated 2nd best The main “Criminal Actors” are “Foreign out of 40 in SSA and 2nd best out of 10 in East Actors” (6.5/10), “Criminal Networks” (4.5/10), Africa, with an overall risk score of 72/100 - “State Embedded Actors” (4/10), and “Mafi a “Low” risk, 83/100 “Very Low” level for Threats, Style Groups” (2/10). and 60/100 “High” level for Response, with an Corruption: TI CPI - 2019 - ranked 27/198, “Improving” trend. with a score of 66/100, an improvement from 2017, where Seychelles had a score of 60/100. FCN Rating:”Low” Risk 72/100 Modern Slavery: The 2018 GSI Index doesn’t “Improving” include data about the number of estimated Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 2 of 35
Section 2 - Country Dashboard Seychelles ➡ Neutral Capital & Population: Victoria / 96,800 approx Political Leader: Danny Faure, President (since 2016) GDP: US$1.498 billion (2017) - 1.7% of the SSA economy. Economic Sector Breakdown: Agri (2.5%), Ind (13.8%), Services (83.7%). Exports: canned tuna, frozen fi sh, petroleum products (re-exports) to UAE 28.5%, France 24%, UK 13.8%, Italy 8.9% and Germany 4.6% (2017) Imports: machinery and equipment, foodstuffs, petroleum products, chemicals, other manufactured goods from UAE 13.4%, France 9.4%, Spain 5.7% and South Africa 5% (2017). Score: 72/100 “Low” FCN Risk Rating Proceeds / Laundering (Average Country Score is 43 - SSA) Rank: 2/40 SSA - 2/10 Region EA range 4.5% - 7.5% GDP / 70 - 76% of Proceeds Organised Crime Costs of Corruption range up to approx 24 - 26% of Proceeds range up to approx 5 - 10% of Proceeds (State Embedded 4/10, Criminal Actors 4.5/10, Foreign Networks 6.5/10 & Mafia Style 2/10) Seychelles Higher (Inherent) Risk Factors Total Criminal Proceeds in Sub Saharan Africa in US$ Billions - FCN Customer Sector Geography 2020 (not including fraud and Risks Risks Risks corruption and tax evasion) Customers with elevated Banks (in particular commercial Major export / import partners exposures to criminal activities banks with international (trade mispricing via IFFs) such as: business - offshore links drug trafficking, and Drug trafficking threat from - Luxury real estate; Afghanistan Pakistan, SE Asia smuggling, company fraud, Mining Fishing and Western Europe, as source fraud/forgery, theft & robbery 10 2.5 Dealers in motors vehicles, and destination countries. Also along with corruption (e.g yacht’s and boats; trans-shipment point for heroin Wildlife 2 Goods Piracy PEPs) which also help facilitate for East Africa including Kenya TCPS - international / offshore Madagascar, Mozambique and 9 these crimes & tax evasion as a business South Africa and from Dubai to high risk concern also to Higher Seychelles - (heroin). Risk Sectors and/or Geography Bureaux de change. Logging Risks Migrant workers—including 12.5 from Bangladesh, India, China, Modern Slavery Kenya, Madagascar, and 8.3 countries in South Asia - some have working conditions akin Drugs to forced labour 3 Theft Illegal Fishing - China 15 TF Threat from - Somalia, Madagascar and Yemen FCN SSA Country Risk Rating - “Very Low” Threats - " SR C r I I I TIP ex life ex F’s ll FO ro GT CP GS era INC Ter TI US FI nd ild Ind I IF Ov WE US W OC GF IUU END US FCN SSA Country Risk Rating - “High” Response - " anc e do m very Ind ex Ind ex ratio n sU S$ NRA ists F4 0 F1 1 rall ern Free - Sla ML OC life ure F/ EU L FAT FAT Ove Gov GSI el A Pro Seiz FAT Bas Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 3 of 35
3. Country Information People & Geography: The Seychelles is an Economy & Trade: In 2017, the GDP was archipelago country in the Indian Ocean US$1.498 billion with government revenues consisting of 115 islands. It has a population of amounting to US$593.4 billion. The GDP per almost 100,000 people which is the smallest capita in 2017 was US$29,300. The population of any African country, yet it is one Seychelles’s economy is made up of of the wealthiest, classifi ed as a “High Income agriculture 2.5%, industry 13.8%, services Economy” by the World Bank. Seychelles is a 83.7% and these sectors encompass the beautiful country, who’s diverse landscape coconuts, cinnamon, vanilla, fi shing as well as encompasses coral reefs, beautiful boulder- fi nancial services, information and strewn beaches, virgin jungles and UNESCO- communications technology, education, listed nature reserves. The island of Male is hospitality and property development. home to Seychelles capital Victoria. Of its Seychelles exports canned tuna, frozen fi sh, 96,800 population, Seychelles counts some petroleum products (re-exports) to UAE 28.5%, 12,900 migrants for 2019, and 36,800 France 24%, UK 13.8%, Italy 8.9% and emigrants. Germany 4.6% (2017) .The country imports machinery and equipment, foodstuffs, Recent History & Leadership: Whilst the petroleum products, chemicals, other French claimed possession of the Seychelles manufactured goods from UAE 13.4%, France islands in 1756, the Seychelles was ceded to 9.4%, Spain 5.7% and South Africa 5% (2017). Britain after the Napoleonic Wars in 1814. From then until 1903, it was administered from Environment: Seychelles is home to an array Mauritius. In 1964 the Seychelles Democratic of wildlife, including giant tortoises and sea Party (SDP), led by James Mancham, was turtles. Much of the land is protected as part of founded, although Seychelles would only nature reserves. become independent in 1976, with Mancham as President and rival Albert Rene of the SPUP Tourism: The total contribution of Travel & as Prime Minister. The SPUP staged an armed tourism GDP was SCR9,220.9 million coup in June 1977, and Seychelles became a (USD657.5mn), 40.5% of GDP in 2019. The socialist state, with René as its president, and labour force for this sector is more than 20,600 the SPUP was renamed the Seychelles People’s in direct employment, representing 43.8% of Progressive Front (SPPF) - the sole political the total employment rate in country. party. Thereafter there was extensive The main tourist attractions include: Anse nationalisation of enterprises, including hotels Lazio, La Digue, Morne Seychellois National and industries. There were also a number of Park, Cousin Island and Silhouette Island threatened coup plots against the René government. In December 1991, the Finance: In terms of remittances, the country government passed laws to provide for has estimated infl ows of US$23 million (1.4% multiparty democracy. Danny Faure has been of the GDP) for the year 2019 according to the president since 2016, after previously holding World Bank. Connectivity-wise in 2019, there is the position of fi nance minister and the an internet penetration rate of 76% & 170,700 governor of the IMF, the World Bank and the mobile connections. African Development Bank. Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 4 of 35
4. Country Ratings Available information from leading sources produce over 60 ratings for Seychelles, covering both threats and responses in fighting financial crime, sanctions, proliferation finance and terrorism & terrorism finance. Source Seychelles Source Seychelles Source Seychelles World Economic Forum 63.9/ 100 Transparency International (TI) 66/ 100 Proliferation Index - PPI Tier 3 Organised Crime Index* Corruption Perceptions Index* (27/198) Threat Low Threat Level OC Index 3.93/10 TI & Afrobarometer Not Included Proliferation Index - PPI 426/ 1300 Criminality* Citizens Views and Experiences of Corruption Controls* Controls score Report OC Index 4.25/10 TRACE 49 Global Terrorism Index Not Included Criminal Actors Bribery Risk Matrix (87/200) GTI - Impact* OC Index 4/10 Global Slavery Index Not Included US Dept of State Not Included State Embedded Actors GSI Incidence* Country Reports on Terrorism* OC Index 4.5/10 Global Slavery Index Not Included Global Cybersecurity Index 0.259/10 Criminal Networks No of estimated Modern Day Slaves 2018 (110/175) OC Index 6.5/10 Global Slavery Index Not Included Mo Ibrahim Governance Index 73/100 Foreign Actors Country Response Rating* (49.9 - All Africa)* (Increasing improvement) (2/54) OC Index 2/10 US Dept of Labor Not Included Freedom House 72/100 Mafia Style Gangs Child Labour Freedom Index* “partly free” OC Index Heroin 6.5/10 & Synthetic’s 4/10 US Dept of State Tier 2 Rated Heritage Foundation 64.3/100 Drugs Trafficking Cannabis 3/10 & Cocaine 2.5/10 Trafficking in Persons* Economic Freedom Index “Moderately free” OC Index 2.5/10 IOM Migration I - 12,900/E - 36,800 Basel AML Index* 6/10 Arms Trafficking E - Emigration / I - Immigration (2016) OC Index 3.5/10 Illegal Unreported and Unregulated 2.13 FIU Egmont Yes People Smuggling (IUU) - IUU Fishing Index 107/152 Member OC Index 4/10 EU Listing of Countries for Illegal No Interpol Yes Human Trafficking Fishing Member OC Index 3/10 US DoS - Wildlife Trafficking Not Included Asset Confiscations No Illegal Timber Focus / Countries of Concern* over 1% of Proceeds* OC Index 6/10 Environment Performance Index Not Included Country National Risk Assessment* Yes Illegal Wildlife (2017) OC Index 1/10 EUIPO & OECD Counterfeit Goods 0.000 Financial Information Sharing No Illegal Mining Propensity of Exports (2016) Partnership OC Index 5.38/10 70 US Dept of State No Resilience* Tax Justice Network 95/133 INCSR Vol I & Vol II* Financial Secrecy Index OC Index 3.5/10 EU List of None Co operative Non co operative European Union List* Yes AML Jurisdictions for Tax purposes OC Index 7/10 OECD - Global Forum Partially Compliant FATF Standards 55/100 Law Enforcement on Transparency & Exchange Info for Tax Purposes 40 Recommendations* OC Index 6/10 Global Financial Integrity US$72million - 16.76% (2017) FATF Standards 3/100 International Co- operation Illicit Financial Flows* 11 IO’s on Effectiveness* OC Index 3.5/10 Embassy’s from N Korea, Syria, Iran Yes - Cuba FATF Standards 50/100 Economic Regulatory Environment or Cuba Core 10 Recommendations Illegal Drug Dependency / Disorders 772,060/0.79% Embargoes - Country Sanctions None FATF Standards 8/100 Number/Share (Comprehensive - UN, US, EU, UK) Core 4 IO’s on Effectiveness Numbeo Crime Survey 2020 Not Included OFAC Listed Parties 8 FATF No with Local Addresses Counter - Measures Strategic Deficiencies List* * Symbol Indicates the information is included in the FCN Country Index Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 5 of 35
Section 4 Continued - Country Threats Heat Map There are many threats that effect Seychelles, which are in most part targeted towards its resources, be they its natural resources, the people, it’s forests, crops and fish. The effect of corruption increases the threats and reduces the ability to effectively respond. For more details in summary form see the figure below. Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 6 of 35
TI - Corruption Perceptions Index (Scores out of 100) - (Scores out of 10 - higher scores are better) 66.0 60.0 60.0 52.0 54.0 2012 2014 2016 2018 2019 Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 7 of 35
Section 5 - Key Threats in Detail In this Section 5, the most important criminal 5.3 Corruption: Corruption is not only a markets, are assessed and summarised based signifi cant generator of illicit funds, but also an on available sources. enabler of other serious crimes which protects those involved from investigation, prosecution 5.1 National Risk Assessment (NRA): and/or conviction. Seychelles published its AML/CFT NRA in 20171. The report , covering the period 1 TI - Corruption Perceptions Index (Scores out of 100) - (Scores out of 10 - higher scores are better) January 2013 to 31 December 2015, found that based on assessing threats and vulnerabilities, the overall threat level for 66.0 60.0 60.0 money laundering (ML) for Seychelles was 52.0 54.0 “Medium High”. The terrorist financing (TF) risk was assessed “Low”. and the threat from 2012 2014 2016 2018 2019 abroad as “Medium Low”. Transparency International’s (TI) Corruption Medium High Risk Perceptions Index (CPI) in 2019 rated National Risk Assessment 2017 Seychelles 66/100 and ranked 27/198, an improvement from 2017, where Seychelles Despite “there being no data set reflecting the had a score of 60/100 (scores are from zero amount of money earned from criminal activity, (highly corrupt) to 100 (very clean). “Several the NRA found that the predicate offences anti-corruption laws, including a recent access which were generating the most proceeds of to information law, and a newly established crime were drug trafficking, Tax evasion, anti-corruption commission have helped Smuggling of goods, Corruption and Fraud”. strengthen the country’s anti-corruption For more details on specific threats see framework. In addition, despite some separate sections on for example, drug restrictions, dialogue between civil society and trafficking, corruption, environmental crimes government occurs through a national civil and tax evasion below. society platform”2. 5.2 US INCSR: Seychelles is not listed in Seychelles considered one of the least Volume 1 or in Volume 2 as one of 80 corrupt nations in Africa OC Index 2019 countries categorised by the US State Department as a Country/Jurisdiction of Notwithstanding the international perspective Primary Concern in respect of Money and high scores for managing corruption, the Laundering and Financial Crimes in its 2019 Seychelles NRA considered that corruption Report. Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 8 of 35
was a significant generator of illicit funds, and Africa Integrity Indicators scores Seychelles a was rated “Medium High”. 57.7/100 (“Increasing Improvement” - ie progress over the last 10 years, with the rate of According to the NRA, “people who hold improvement increasing) under transparency positions of authority in Government, the and accountability 2019 (Global Integrity general public sector as well as private sector 2019)5. players are viewed perpetrators of the offence. The lack of transparency in relation to the 5.4 Organised Crime: The OC Index states award of contracts, tenders, land from the land that “Seychelles is rated as Low Criminality bank, the operations of companies fully owned and High Resilience, (as opposed to High by the government, no audit having been Criminality - High Resilience, High Criminality - carried out on capital projects, and the lack of Low Resilience and Low Criminality - Low capacity on the oversight and governance Resilience) alongside other Sub-Saharan mechanisms put in place by government are countries such as: Botswana, Ethiopia, Ghana, contributors to the high rating given to Mauritius, Namibia, Rwanda, Senegal and corruption as a predicate offence to ML”. Cape Verde. The OC Index report highlighted that “Seychelles was noted for being a centre The NRA went on to say that “state-embedded for money laundering and illicit fi nancial fl ows, actors have a moderate influence in the yet committed investment has reduced those Seychelles, but are known to be involved in the fl ows and made it a signifi cant partner in illegal fishing industry. Although levels of regional maritime security efforts All of this corruption in the country are not insignificant, indicates that the quality of governance and state- embedded actors do not control any of determined political will can produce the illicit markets in Seychelles. Nor do they considerable results, even in the case of weak have any discernible links with domestic states”. criminal actors.” Low Criminality - High Resilience The 2018 TRACE Bribery Risk Matrix places Africa’s OC Index 2019 Seychelles in the “moderate” risk category, According to the 2019 OC Index “Seychelles ranking it 87 out of 200 surveyed countries has a high resilience to organised crime, with a risk score of 493. ranking 11th in Africa. The government is vocal TI also reported on the importance and and open about its stance against organised correlation between the lack of freedom and crime, particularly regarding piracy and drug corruption, citing Freedom House, in its 2019 trafficking. Seychelles is also considered one of Freedom in the World report, which accords the least corrupt nations in Africa.” the status of “partly free” to Seychelles with an aggregate freedom score of 72/1004. Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 9 of 35
“Mafia-style groups are virtually non-existent in synthetic dugs trafficking (4/10) and human Seychelles. Criminal networks, with a score of smuggling (3.5/10), with illegal logging, and 4.5/10, have a moderate influence on cannabis trafficking (3.0/10), cocaine and arms organised crime the country. They also state trafficking (2.5/10) and illegal mining at that “Foreign actors are the highest-scoring 1.0/10). The main “Criminal Actors” are criminal actor type in Seychelles, with 6.5/10, “Foreign Actors” (6.5/10), “Criminal and are deeply involved in drug trafficking. Networks” (4.5/10), “State Embedded Foreign nationals are also responsible for a Actors” (4/10), and “Mafia Style Groups” (2/10). large proportion of the illegal fishing that occurs in Seychelles’ national waters; and are OC Index - Criminal Actor Types - Importance - (Scores out of 10 - lower scores are better) involved in human trafficking, primarily for forced labour, within the Seychelles.” 6.5 OC Index Criminal Markets - Importance - (Scores out of 10 - lower scores are better) 4.5 4.0 2.0 Criminal Networks State Embedded Foreign Actors Mafia Style 6.0 5.5.1 Environmental Crimes: Illegal Wildlife 4.0 4.0 3.5 3.0 3.0 2.5 Crimes: According to the 2019 OC Index, “As 1.0 Synthetics Wildlife HT Mining Logging Arms Cannabis People Smugg an island nation, Seychelles is largely protected According to the 2019 African OC Index, from the wildlife traffi cking that affl icts many Seychelles scores Criminality at 3.93/10 and other African nations, such as ivory and rhino ranks 42nd (out of 54 African countries) and horn traffi cking”. However, Seychelles is 7/13 in Southern African countries in the Index mentioned in a TRAFFIC report as a nation that for levels of criminality, with criminal networks conducts wildlife trade with China6. In 2016 Air having a “moderate influence on organised Seychelles signed the Buckingham Palace crime the country. They are involved in the drug Declaration pledging support for the United trade, acting as an interface between foreign for Wildlife Task Force. players in transnational drugs markets and A media article7 reported that in 2013 a domestic users. These loosely organised Seychellois woman was caught with 60kg of criminal networks are often based on family hawksbill turtle shells, with an estimated value ties”. of USD$8,300, in her luggage by Singapore The main markets, according to the OC Index, customs authorities. Wildlife trafficking is not with highest criminality scores were illegal included in the the NRA. drugs, with heroin (6.5/10) and environmental 5.5.2 Environmental Crimes: Illegal crimes the most important, Illegal wildlife and Logging: According to the Food and Illegal fishing (6/10), human trafficking and Agriculture Foundation of the United Nations Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 10 of 35
Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 11 of 35
(FAO)8, “The main challenges facing the deplete fi sh stocks. Local people are forced to forestry sector are poaching of protected fi sh illegally to make a living.” palms, illegal felling of protected trees, social Seychelles scores 2.13/5 overall on the 2018 housing development, invasive species, bush IUU Fishing Index10, measured against fires, climate change and management of vulnerability, prevalence and response (1 = protected areas. good/strong; 5 = bad/weak). Seychelles has a The main challenges facing the forestry high vulnerability score (3.12) but a high sector are poaching of protected response score (1.64). palms, illegal felling of protected trees, Seychelles has a vast Exclusive Economic Zone social housing development, invasive of 1.4 million square kilometres, and has been species, bush fires, climate change and been plagued by Sri Lankan fishing vessels11 management of protected areas OC Index 2019 that have allegedly been illegally fishing in Seychelles waters.12 The main contributing factors are deforestation and forest degradation, limited land for social Illegal fishing in Seychelles poses a housing development, and natural disasters significant problem and is costly to the such as bush fires and landslides. The coco-de- economy and environment OC Index 2019 mer serves as an example – on account of its economic value both locally and on the Seychelles is piloting a project using new international market, there have been recent approaches to reduce fisheries crime using increases in poaching incidents which are now “analytical capacity-building in combination threatening the coco-de-mer trees in the Vallée with drones equipped with artificial de Mai. The coco-de-mer has been listed as intelligence (AI)” to detect illegal fishing13. In critically endangered by the IUCN”. According 2019, the Ministry of Fisheries and Agriculture to the World Bank in 2016, Seychelles was the has also published a “Fisheries 4th greenest country in the world with 88.4% Comprehensive Plan”14 to “guide the future of the land area as forests9. actions and spearhead the development for the fisheries sector for the next three years…..This 5.5.3 Environmental Crimes: Illegal Fishing: Comprehensive Plan covers a wide spectrum of The 2019 OC Index reports that “illegal fi shing activities overlapping those of other Ministries poses a signifi cant problem and is costly to the and institutions not necessarily affiliated with economy and environment. Seychelles ranks the Ministry of Fisheries and Agriculture. As 21st in the IUU Fishing Index on the prevalence such, it requires great collaboration, but most of illegal fi shing. The primary driver of illegal importantly, financial resources to implement fi shing in the country is extreme overfi shing, the policy. While the responsibility to finance predominantly by Chinese trawlers, which the implementation generally rests with the Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 12 of 35
Government, most of the interventions could According to the NRA, drug trafficking also be materialised with support of our generated USD$1.5 million of the value of stakeholders.” the proceeds between 2014 - 2015. This figure is considered to be a conservative figure as Seychelles has embarked on a Blue Economy other information obtained suggests that “a Strategic Roadmap, which is “an integrated large number of investments being financed approach to ocean-based sustainable from proceeds of drug trafficking are invested development which brings together economy, overseas in neighbouring countries and locally environment and society, consistent with the using domestic companies and legitimate Sustainable Development Agenda 2030 businesses”. (SDG’s)”. One of the expected outcomes of this initiative is “Improved prevention of ocean/ OC Index - Drug Trafficking - Importance - (Scores out of 10 - lower scores are better) blue economy risks including illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing, marine pollution and climate change through 6.5 integrated approaches to effective regional 4.0 2.5 3.0 cooperation on maritime security”15. Cocaine Synthetics Cannabis Heroin According to Defenceweb16, “The Seychelles The NRA rated drug trafficking as “Medium has a fishing traceability policy that allows High”. global consumers to see the origination of tuna caught by Seychellois fishing boats. This market Drug trafficking “Medium High” transparency adds value to legal catches and NRA 2017 discourages illegal fishing.” Drugs from Kenya and Dubai are smuggled 5.6 Drug Trafficking: According to the 2019 into Seychelles using trade mechanisms and OC Index, “The most pervasive criminal market couriers. The importation of heroin is in Seychelles is the heroin trade, which scores reportedly “monopolised by different clusters 6.5/10 in the Index, due to high domestic use of groups of people, mostly constituting of the drug. The island nation is a destination families”. Increased maritime patrols in the country for heroin traffi cked from East Africa Indian Ocean have led to the increased use of and the Asian subcontinent. Seychelles is also Seychelles waters “being used as a transit route an important maritime trans-shipment point for for the drug trade from North to South”. The heroin from Afghanistan destined for East drugs are thought not to be intended for Africa, Madagascar, Mozambique and South Seychelles consumption. According to Africa. Its role is growing as maritime routes investigations performed, proceeds from drug shift in response to military interdictions at sea.” trafficking are laundered in the Seychelles through the “use of the banks, the BDCs, the Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 13 of 35
real estate sector and the motor vehicle sector”. The UN Office on Drugs and Crime announced It was also reported that “apart from incidences in 2018 its intent to reestablish a presence in of piracy, the only recorded illegal activity on Seychelles to increase drug trafficking security some of the ‘outer’ islands is poaching and measures, reduce the demand for drugs, and drop offs for drug traffickers”. enact prison reform. Among the reforms enacted is consideration of drug addiction as a Seychelles has an estimated 772,060 people17 disease rather than a crime, allowing greater with illegal drug use disorders (2017), possibilities for treatment and rehabilitation representing 0.79% of the population. among drug abusers. A BBC media article claims that Seychelles has In 2018, a media article on illegal fishing in the world’s worst heroin problem, with Seychelles reported that one of the resource “between 5,000 and 6,000 people out of a total challenges for the fishing sector was population of 94,000 - the equivalent of nearly highlighted as “getting local manpower and 10% of the working population - are addicted this is largely related to drug abuse, which is to heroin, according to the Agency for the especially affecting the younger population”20. Prevention of Drug Abuse and Rehabilitation (APDAR) in the Seychelles”18. The drugs from 5.7 Modern Slavery: The 2020 US Traffi cking Afghanistan are reportedly smuggled to the in Persons (TIP) report21 rates Seychelles as a island via East Africa taking advantage of Tier 2 country, upgraded from the 2018 Tier 2 porous borders. Watchlist rating. The 2019 Trafficking in Person Report22 advised that “human traffickers exploit According to the US Government (OSAC19), domestic and foreign victims in Seychelles. the Seychelles suffers from the highest rate of Traffickers exploit some Seychellois girls and, heroin abuse in the world; nearly 10% of the according to some sources, boys in child sex working population is addicted to heroin, trafficking, particularly on the main island of according to the Agency for the Prevention of Mahe; peers, family members, and pimps Drug Abuse and Rehabilitation (APDR). exploit them in bars, guest houses, hotels, Importation of Afghan heroin is difficult to brothels, private homes, and on the street. stop, given the porous nature of national Young drug addicts are vulnerable to sex borders in a country comprising more than trafficking, and sex traffickers have exploited 100 islands. The popularity of synthetic drugs Eastern European women in hotels. In 2017, is also on the rise. Police have increased there were reports of possible high-level enforcement of drug trafficking and drug corruption, which allowed wealthy citizens from abuse since 2016. Authorities strictly enforce Gulf countries to coordinate the travel of young drug possession laws. Penalties for possession women aboard private planes, some of whom of any amount include fines and possible jail may have been trafficking victims. Traffickers time. may subject Malagasy women who transit the Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 14 of 35
Seychelles to forced labor in the Middle East. According to the 2018 Global Study on However, the government still does not Smuggling of Migrants23, “The authorities of acknowledge the occurrence of sex trafficking Madagascar report smuggling of migrants out in Seychelles. Migrant workers—including from of the country. This smuggling activity is Bangladesh, India, China, Kenya, Madagascar, directed mainly to the countries of the Gulf and countries in South Asia—make up 20 Cooperation Council, as well as to other percent (21,000) of the working population in countries in the Middle East. This smuggling Seychelles and are primarily employed in flow makes use of the Comoros, Seychelles or fishing, farming, and construction; credible Mauritius as transits to the final destinations.” reports indicate traffickers subject migrant 5.8 Goods Piracy: According to the Trends in workers to forced labor in these sectors. NGOs Trade & Pirated Goods Report 201924 by the report migrant workers also face exploitative EUIPO & OECD, 3.3% of world trade in 2016 conditions in fish processing plants, and was made up from trade in counterfeit goods. fishermen aboard foreign-flagged fishing Seychelles is estimated as having a low vessels in Seychelles’ territorial waters and propensity to export counterfeit products with ports are subjected to abuses indicative of a score of 0.000/1 (2016) with export trade to forced labor, including nonpayment of wages the rest of the world & for export trade with the and physical abuse. Labor recruitment agents EU at 0.000/1. based in Seychelles will exploit migrant workers in labor trafficking, oftentimes with the According to a local media agency25 in 2018, assistance of a local Seychellois accomplice. the Cabinet of Ministers in Seychelles Migrant workers often sign their employment “approved procedural guidelines for border contracts upon arrival in the Seychelles and measures to deal with infringement and frequently cannot read the language, which counterfeit goods entering the country”. There increases their vulnerability to fraudulent is acknowledgement on the part of the recruitment tactics. There were reports of government that there is “an element of employers routinely retaining migrant workers’ importation of counterfeit and infringing passports to prevent them from changing jobs goods, and as such, it is important that we take prior to the expiration of their two-year necessary steps to facilitate its control”. The contracts, increasing their vulnerability to director general at the Trade Division in the forced labor”. Ministry of Finance has further advised that “It needs to be noted that the provisional law only There was insufficient statistical records and applies to marks and brands that have been systematic data collection to include the registered in Seychelles and to importation that predicate offence of human trafficking in the are being done on a commercial basis. If NRA. somebody is coming with it in their baggage allowance, that will not be covered”. Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 15 of 35
5.9 Theft /Stolen Goods and Smuggling: and Madagascar, cigarettes are smuggled According to the NRA, smuggling is rated using containerized sea freight and air cargo”. “Medium” and was one of the predicate The Seychelles case studies in the report offences that generating the most proceeds of highlighted the following techniques used to crime. Unfortunately, due to a lack of statistics, smuggle the cigarettes: no granular information was provided. The • Cigarettes were contained in large items NRA documents the recommendation that such as speaker casings and air “checks and controls are strengthened at the conditioning units delivered through air different points of entry to detect, investigate cargo. The total amount of cigarettes and take enforcement actions against seized by Customs totalled 59,200 sticks. individuals involved in smuggling of goods”. An aircraft engineer was involved; The NRA further highlights that due to • A frequent traveler attempted to smuggle resource and technology restraints that 7,400 sticks of cigarettes in his luggage customs officials are unable to screen for cash through the airport; and at Seychelles entry points. • A traveler attempted to smuggle 2,400 Theft and smuggling rated “Low” sticks of cigarettes in chocolate and NRA 2017 Theft was rated as “Low” in the NRA, saying cornflakes boxes in his luggage through that “From statistics provided by LEAs, petty the airport. theft is prevalent in Seychelles but this offence The value of cigarettes smuggled/laundered does not generate substantial proceeds of was USD$ 384,299. crime in comparison to other predicate offence”. 5.10 Financial Fraud: The NRA links fraud, counterfeit and forgery into a single category. This view is echoed in the 2019 OSAC Using statistics provided in relation to fi nancial Report26 which advised of “a decrease in services, fraud risk was rated as “Low”. “From incidents of petty theft, burglary, robbery, and reported cases on fraud, it was indicated by the other crime of opportunity. In 2018, robbery Police that the types of fraud perpetrated in and burglary cases decreased by 45% and 17% Seychelles that generate substantial proceeds respectively compared to 2017”, according to of crime are perpetrated by foreigners who police statistics. Theft from vehicles was also operate in groups. Recently there has been an noted in areas frequented by foreigners. increase in such groups coming into Seychelles In the 2018 ESAAMLG Report27 on Smuggling focusing on ATM or skimming related fraud, of Cigarettes and Associated Money fraud over the internet and cyber-crime. Laundering in the ESAAMLG Region, they According to the Police, these represent 90% of highlighted that “In the case of the Seychelles cases reported over the period under review. It Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 16 of 35
is seen that 95 % of those cases, with fraud which makes it a very desirable country to cases over the internet, the fraud is initiated in register companies in and funnel profi ts countries such as South Africa, Ghana, Guinea through. This makes it very appealing to and Nigeria and the funds are transferred to syndicates and groups involved in organised those countries though Money Services crime, especially those based relatively close in Bureaus. East Africa and on the Asian subcontinent. Fraud is perpetrated by foreigners who The EU lists Seychelles as one of the top 30 operate in groups non- cooperative tax jurisdictions, though the NRA 2017 country has committed to reforms to become According to the NRA, “the predicate offence tax-compliant. The formal labour market is not representing the most proceeds of crime is fully established, which allows exploitative company fraud with a total value of USD 2.4 practices – particularly involving foreign, often million. This figure was obtained from the smuggled, labourers – to persist.” Police and the elements of company fraud “Partially compliant” were not broken down further”. For the 2014 to OECD Peer Review Report 2020 2015 period, the NRA documents 19 cases The OECD Global Forum on Transparency and reported under the category of “Fraud / Exchange of Information for Tax Purposes Forgery” ,and 5 cases under “Company Fraud”. published a Peer Review Report for Seychelles In a media release28 in February 2020, the in April 202029, and rated Seychelles as Central Bank of Seychelles and Seychelles “Partially Compliant”. Seychelles had previously Bankers Association warned of an increase in been rated “Non-Compliant” in 2013 “because in the number of scams and people falling of serious gaps in the enforcement of victims to them through social media provisions on the availability of ownership and platforms. These included phishing, spoofing, accounting information in the offshore sector”, takeover scams, Ponzi schemes, romance as well as difficulties in entering into exchange schemes, lottery scams, pyramid schemes and agreements Seychelles - as reported by Global fake loan scams. “Individuals and local Forum members. In 2015, the Seychelles business persons have also been impacted by improved significantly enough to secure a the scams, most of which are thought to “Largely Compliant” rating. originate from the Western Africa region, The drop in rating to “Partially Compliant” in namely, Ivory Coast, Benin as well as South 2020 was attributed to failure to reply to 88% Africa and Nigeria, as the majority of payments of requests for accounting information and are remitted to such countries” . 62% of the requests for beneficial information 5.11 Tax Evasion: According to the 2019 OC over a three year period. The main concerns Index, “Seychelles is a well-known tax haven, were highlighted as “the overall effectiveness Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 17 of 35
of supervision and enforcement activities to • Other custom related offences. ensure the availability and access to information in practice. Of particular concern is Tax evasions “Medium High” NRA 2017 the fact that while more than half of the approximately 200 000 international business In the 2014 - 2015 period, the ESAAMLG companies are currently struck off, the Mutual Evaluation Report (MER) noted only effectiveness of this procedure remains recorded four reported cases of tax evasion uncertain, since struck off companies maintain valued at USD$ 32,000. According to the their legal personality and can be restored for a MER, tax evasion is not recognised as a period of up to 12 years.” predicate offence under the Seychelles laws, Tax Evasion - Medium High however banks have being identifying NRA - 2017 business transactions routed through personal accounts to avoid taxes due. Seychelles has The NRA rates tax evasion as “Medium High”, information exchange agreements with and stated that “The statistics provided by SRC multiple countries and is also a party to the in respect of reporting, investigating and Multilateral Convention on Mutual prosecuting of tax evasion cases is insufficient Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters. “The to determine whether this is a real issue for Tax and Customs Department liaise with the Seychelles”. The NRA refers to suspicious World Customs Organization and through transaction report statistics that highlighted the Double Taxation Agreements (DTAs) in relation “prevalence of personal accounts being used to tax matters, which may be predicate offences for business purposes potentially as a to ML and TF”. mechanism to evade tax and large out of the norm cash transactions being paid by owners According to the US Government (OSAC30), of legitimate businesses for purchase of other Seychellois enjoy a lower tax rate due to the assets in Seychelles including land”. offshore financial services industry’s significant Mechanisms used for tax evasion are: economic contributions to the country, which has the second highest per capita income in • Non-registration or non-remittance of tax Africa. The flexibility of the international tax due to the State; system and the lack of legislation concerning • Understatements of income, and/or high-value transactions have enabled overstatement of deductible expenditure; international crime organisations to engage in money laundering using these offshore • An element of forgery where records are industries. falsified; • Transfer pricing; and Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 18 of 35
5.12 Emerging Threats: Cybercrime: present a low risk to Seychelles fi shing lanes According to the 2018 Global Cybersecurity and tourism, as they no longer have the Index (GCI)31, Seychelles scored 0.259/10 and capacity to operate so far east. In 2010, in the is described as having a “Low” level of last reported incident, six Seychellois were commitment rated 110th globally out of 175, captured by pirates southeast of the island of and 20th out of 44 in Africa in terms of Mahé, but the government has since cybersecurity. implemented a military strategy with EU and US support, and improved its legal framework Low level of commitment to dealing with piracy offenders”33. Seychelles is cybersecurity considered have “some of the world’s leading Global Cybersecurity Index 2018 expertise at this point in terms of the According to the NRA, the Department of mechanics of actually taking a piracy case from Information & Communications Technology wherever — anywhere on the high seas — to trial (DICT), has started to put in place the and all the way through to prosecution, Government of Seychelles Cyber Emergency conviction, appeal and the eventual Readiness Team (GOS CERT) (with equipment / imprisonment”34 training obtained from a COMESA project). It is 5.14 Other Crime Threats: According to the envisaged in the near future to place US Government (OSAC35), there is “minimal dedicated people to man the GOS CERT. risk from crime in Seychelles,” and according However, the 2019 OSAC Report32 states that to official police figures, “there continues to be “Seychelles does not have an officially a decrease in violent crime, but there has been approved national cybersecurity roadmap or a slight increase in incidents of petty theft. internationally recognised Computer Incident Burglary, robbery, and other crimes of Response Team. The government has created opportunity have also decreased.” several legal measures in recent years (e.g. 5.15 FCN Overall Country Threat Ratings: Computer Misuse Act, the Electronic Seychelles is rated the 4/40 in SSA and 2/10 in Transactions Act, and the Data Protection Act) East Africa, with an overall “Very Low” Threats in an effort to address cybersecurity issues. The score of 83/100. country signed agreements with India and Cyprus in 2018 to bolster cybersecurity, but has not implemented wider security measures on public systems”. 5.13 Maritime Piracy: Seychelles is probably one of the most secure countries in Africa and confl ict and terrorism risks are low. Somali pirates pushing out across the Indian Ocean Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 19 of 35
Section 6 - Sanctions & Terrorism In this Section 6, the focus is on Sanctions and According to the NRA, “the potential threat Terrorism threats. level in respect of TF risk is rated as “Low” as there are no reported cases to date of TF in 6.1 Sanctions: Seychelles is not subject to Seychelles “other than the alleged case of the international sanctions. The 2019 Peddling graphite shipment to Iran”, where an individual Peril Index36 (PPI), focussed on proliferation, was prosecuted and found guilty in prepared by the Institute for Science and Germany42. International Security, which classifies Seychelles as a Tier 3 country (lowest threat), There are no known cases of funds and a country with a “Moderate” controls score generated in Seychelles being used to of 426 out of 1,300 points, and ranked 106th finance terrorism domestically or among 200 countries. abroad, and no known cases of Seychellois foreign terrorist fighters. Tier 3 Country - Moderate level of NRA - 2017 Controls PPI - 2019 The NRA further advises that “there are no known cases of funds generated in Seychelles Seychelles has an embassy in Cuba, but does being used to finance terrorism domestically or not have embassies for North Korea, Syria, Iran abroad, and no known cases of Seychellois or Cuba in Seychelles37. According to North foreign terrorist fighters. Internationally, Korea in the world38, Seychelles does not have Seychelles is also perceived as a low-risk any bilateral relations with North Korea. jurisdiction in the terrorist financing context. There are 8 entries, all entities, listed by US From a geographical perspective, the main TF OFAC with addresses in the Seychelles39. threat, if any, would most probably emanate from Somalia, Madagascar and Yemen where 6.2 Terrorism / Extremism: Seychelles is not there is evidence of terrorism and deficiencies included in the 2019 Global Terrorism Index40 in AML/CFT emanating from a lack of robust 2019 or in the 2019 US Department of State institutional control. Controls are in place in Country Reports on Terrorism41. Seychelles to mitigate these risks”. No terrorism and TF cases in According to the 2018 FATF Mutual Evaluation Seychelles, nor has there been any TF Report43, “Seychelles has demonstrated a good cases in which a Seychellois was understanding of the country’s low TF risk involved profile. FATF MER 2018 Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 20 of 35
Seychelles Higher (Inherent) Risk Factors Customer Sector Geography Risks Risks Risks Customers with elevated Banks (in particular retail and Major export / import partner exposures to criminal activities corespondent banks) countries (trade mispricing via such as: IFFs). drug trafficking,,illegal fishing, Boat and yacht dealers, money human trafficking remitters, casinos, dealers in Piracy in waters with threats & people smuggling, fraud, precious metals & stones, forex from Somalia finance & along with corruption dealers, real estate & lawyers, (e.g PEPs) which also help test and company service E Africa and Asia (source facilitate these crimes & tax providers, country drugs), Afghanistan, E evasion as a high risk concern Africa, Madagascar, also & Mozambique and South Africa (Seychelles used as trans- to Higher Risk Sectors and/or Motor vehicle dealers (very shipment point for drugs), Geography Risks high) A Sri Lanka (illegal fishing, ). Bangladesh, India, China, Kenya & Madagascar (modern slavery) Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 21 of 35
Section 7 - Money Laundering In this Section 7, the focus is on Uganda’s • Commercial banks with operations in the vulnerability to money laundering. international financial centre space; 7.1 Higher Risk Areas: Higher risk areas • Luxury real estate; (including from the NRA) are set out below. In • Dealers in motors vehicles, yachts and many cases a single risk factor may not be boats; evidence of actual higher risks. • TCSPs in the international financial centre Seychelles Higher (Inherent) Risk Factors activities; and Customer Sector Geography Risks Risks Risks Customers with elevated Banks (in particular commercial Major export / import partners • Bureaux de change exposures to criminal activities banks with international (trade mispricing via IFFs) such as: business - offshore links drug trafficking, and Luxury real estate; Drug trafficking threat from - Afghanistan Pakistan, SE Asia In 2017, the MER documented that “Banking smuggling, company fraud, and Western Europe, as source fraud/forgery, theft & robbery along with corruption (e.g Dealers in motors vehicles, and destination countries. Also dominates the financial sector in Seychelles, yacht’s and boats; trans-shipment point for heroin PEPs) which also help facilitate these crimes & tax evasion as a TCPS - international / offshore for East Africa including Kenya Madagascar, Mozambique and and, as a result, the majority of transactions are business South Africa and from Dubai to high risk concern also to Higher Risk Sectors and/or Geography Bureaux de change. Seychelles - (heroin). conducted through it. In 2016, banking Risks Migrant workers including from Bangladesh, India, China, comprised nine (9) commercial banks, of which Kenya, Madagascar, and seven (7) were either owned or controlled by countries in South Asia - some have working conditions akin to forced labour Illegal Fishing - China international financial groups. Only two (2) of TF Threat from - Somalia, the seven (7) commercial banks engage in Madagascar and Yemen international business activities. This means According to the NRA, there was “missing” that the risks of ML/TF in the international information that was not available for the NRA business sector appear to be concentrated in exercise, but nonetheless highlighted that the the two commercial banks. The total assets cash intensive economy, rapid advances in value of the banking sector in 2015 was information technology, reputation as an estimated at USD1.13 billion. The total profit for offshore haven, improper use of Trust and banking in the same period amounted to US 33 Company Service Providers (CSPs), and million. In the foreign currency market, money deficiencies noted within the law enforcement business services providers (bureaux de agencies were all concerning areas. change) transactions were valued at SCR 1.23 The MER highlights inherent ML/TF threats billion compared to SCR0.33 billion conducted “emanating from being an international by banks in 2015. It represents about 78 financial centre, most notably in relation to percent and signals its importance to the drug offences”. Sectors identified as being economy of Seychelles”. The NRA rated the vulnerable to ML/TF risks are: financial sector an overall rating of “Medium”. Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 22 of 35
7.2 Cash Based Money Laundering: 7.5 Cryptocurrency risks: According to the According to the NRA, Seychelles is a “cash 2019 Financial Intelligence Unit Annual intensive economy”. Using data from 2015, the Report45, “in recent years, the country has NRA estimates that that the total proceeds of attracted financial companies in the business crime from undetected sources combined for line of virtual asset. According to the website all the predicate offences identifi ed was SCR coinlore listing, there are currently four 230,351,730 (USD$18,428,138). The buying Seychelles registered IBCs in the top 10 list in and selling of forex as well as remittances are the crypto exchange by 24-hours volume, with to be a Medium High risk, due to the cash BITFOREX topping number one in terms of intensive nature of their activities. In relation to volume.…The Seychelles offshore sector has tax evasions “large out of the norm cash also experienced a rise in the registration of transactions being paid by owners of legitimate Crypto IBCs”. businesses for purchase of other assets in Seychelles including land”. See see Section 9.7 “The 2020-Crypto crime report by Chainalysis for more information on cash threshold indicates that in 2019, 24.7% of illicit bitcoin reports. exchange transaction was done through Seychelles registered IBC. In 2019, the 7.3 Trade Based Money Laundering: Whilst Seychelles FIU received crypto related STRs on cash based money laundering is a popular a regular basis and analysis are being method for laundering funds, trade based conducted.The primary areas of criminal money laundering is likely to be prevalent due activities in cryptocurrency of concern to to use of offshore companies and international Seychelles are tax evasion, money laundering, shipment routes. Seychelles is positioning itself ICO scam, contraband transactions Terrorism, to benefit from enhanced regional trade as theft and extortion.In view of the inherent risk Africa is moving toward the creation of the associated with crypto currency, the Seychelles African Continental Free Trade Area. A multi- FIU is working towards building its capacity to million dollar expansion and modernisation of better regulate and strengthen its internal Port Victoria is expected to create a regional system to detect and deter financial crimes transshipment and trading hub, according to through the use of new technologies”. the CEO of the Seychelles Port Authority44. 7.6 Other Money Laundering: Securities and 7.4 Mobile Money Risks: Although mobile transaction laundering are also important payment services are designated as reporting methods, however laundering through the institutions, very little information could be securities is considered to be “Low” in found in relation to risks identifi ed in Seychelles. Seychelles, other than the input of cash at agents. Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 23 of 35
Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 24 of 35
Section 8 - Illicit Funds including Estimated Criminal Proceeds In this Section 8, the focus is on Malawi’s made up of criminal activity, a significant vulnerability to Illicit Financial Flows and illegal proportion will be. Proceeds and to the laundering of criminal and According to the sources and analysis carried other illicit funds. out in this Threat Assessment, estimates for According to the African Union46 based on criminal proceeds, laundered funds and funds work and data provided by GFI, it is estimated generated by corruption and organised crime, that Seychelles suffered from illicit financial amongst others, are estimated in the following flows from 2004-201347, averaging US$36 ranges: million a year, and US$72 million48 in 2017, •Total estimates for according to Global Financial Total Criminal Proceeds in Sub criminal proceeds Integrity49 (GFI), to have left the Saharan Africa in US$ Billions - combined of 4.5 to country. FCN 2020 (not including fraud and corruption and tax evasion) 7.5%68 of GDP and with Seychelles has a Tax to GDP ratio 5 - 10%69 of this of 29.2%50, which is the 2nd Mining 10 Fishing estimated as costs of highest in Africa, and above the Wildlife 2.5 2 Goods Piracy corruption. average African figure of 16.2%, 9 and rated across Africa as a “High” Logging 12.5 •Total estimates for Tax Collection Country. Modern Slavery 8.3 monies available for Drugs laundering through the According to GFI, the most Theft 3 15 formal sector is 70 - common method for transferring illicit financial funds, is through 76%70 of criminal trade mis-pricing. GFI believe this proceeds and 24 - method or series of techniques may represent 26%71 involving organised crime, with most up to 80%51 of illicit financial flows, and can significant criminal actors being “Foreign involve abusive and or aggressive transfer Actors” followed by “Criminal pricing, trade mis-pricing and mis-invoicing, Networks” ,“State Embedded Actors”, and for example intentionally overpaying for “Mafia Style Groups”. imports of goods or services (or underpaying The largest criminal markets in Seychelles will for exports or services) is a straightforward way include drug trafficking, tax evasion, of illegally transferring monies out of a country. smuggling, corruption, company fraud, fraud/ The risks increase in trade with so-called forgery, theft & robbery and those crimes advanced economies. Whilst not all IFFs are identified as the largest markets across Sub- Saharan Africa (see Pie Chart above). Seychelles - Threat Assessment - 2020 Page 25 of 35
You can also read