ROCKETMAN - Royal Aeronautical Society
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
AEROSPACE www.aerosociety.com February 2020 Volume 47 Number 2 ROCKETMAN February 2020 VIRGIN GALACTIC’S CHIEF TROUBLE AHEAD FOR PILOT ON THE COUNTDOWN TO ASIAN-PACIFIC AIRLINES COMMERCIAL SPACE TOURISM RUSSIAN AIR POWER TODAY Royal Aeronautical Society MENTAL HEALTH AND AIRCREW
Don’t forget to renew your membership for 2020 Membership fees were due on the 1st January so don’t forget to renew before your membership expires* As per the Society’s Regulations, unpaid How to renew: memberships will lapse on 31 March 2020 and all memberships will be suspended where a Online: Log in to your account on the Society’s payment for an individual subscription has not website to pay at: been received before this date. This excludes members paying their annual subscriptions by www.aerosociety.com/login Direct Debit in monthly instalments. If you do not have an account, you can register Your membership benefits include: online and pay your subscription straight away. ⚫ Your monthly subscription to AEROSPACE Telephone: Call the Subscriptions Department magazine on: ⚫ Use of your RAeS post nominals, as applicable +44 (0)20 7670 4315 / 4304 ⚫ Access to over 400 global events yearly Cheque: Cheques should be made payable to ⚫ Discounted rates for conferences the Royal Aeronautical Society and sent to the ⚫ Online publications including Society News, Subscriptions Department at No.4 Hamilton blogs and podcasts Place, London W1J 7BQ, UK. ⚫ Involvement with your local Branch BACS Transfer: Pay by Bank Transfer (or by BACS) into the Society’s bank account, quoting ⚫ Networking opportunities your name and membership number. Bank ⚫ Support gaining Professional Registration details: ⚫ Recognition of achievement through the Account Name: Royal Aeronautical Society Society’s Medals and Awards Sort Code: 40-05-22 ⚫ Opportunities for Continuing Professional Account No: 01564641 Development BIC/Swift: HBUKGB4B ... and much more! Find out more ways to get IBAN: GB89HBUK40052201564641 involved and utilise your membership benefits: Bank Address: HSBC Bank plc, Fifth Floor, West End Corporate Centre www.aerosociety.com/membership 70 Pall Mall London, SW1Y 5EZ *An expired membership can incur reinstatement fees Thank you for renewing your membership! With your support, the Royal Aeronautical Society remains the world’s foremost professional institution dedicated to the entire aerospace and aviation industry.
Volume 47 Number 2 February 2020 EDITORIAL Contents All change at the top Regulars 4 Radome 12 Transmission The start of the year saw news that three global aerospace and aviation The latest aviation and Your letters, emails, tweets aeronautical intelligence, and social media feedback. leaders are to move on. It was perhaps no surprise that Boeing chief analysis and comment. Dennis Muilenburg was finally fired over Christmas as the 737 MAX crisis 58 The Last Word continues to drag on – many observers had expected him to be pushed out 11 Pushing the Envelope Keith Hayward talks to Lord earlier. Yet with the aircraft waiting to be ‘ungrounded’ in Boeing’s words Rob Coppinger looks at Heseltine about the UK the application of bio- aerospace industry in the until at least June/July and the MAX production line silent, his successor mimicry in aerospace. 1970s and its relevance to David Calhoun inherits an immense challenge in returning the aircraft to the UK’s post-Brexit future. flight and restoring trust of the public, regulators and airlines in a damaged brand. Unlike Muilenburg, Calhoun is a non-engineer – leading some Features observers to question whether he might be the right choice for a company 24 Caring for pilots Virgin Galactic that needs to put engineering, not shareholder value, back in the pilot’s A report on a RAeS seat. Meanwhile, long standing President of Emirates, Sir Tim Clark, steps conference on the wider down after over 30 years at the helm of the fast-growing Gulf megacarrier. 14 issues of pilot mental health. Having built up the airline into a global force and turned Dubai into a superhub, Emirates now faces headwinds, with slowing traffic, increased Russian President competition and regional tensions all affecting its growth. He thus leaves Plane Speaking giant-sized shoes to fill for whoever takes over. Finally, IAG’s Willie Walsh is An interview with David also to retire later this year as head of the airline group that now includes Mackay, Chief Pilot, Virgin Galactic. British Airways, Iberia, Aer Lingus and Vueling. Working his way up from a 737 pilot at Aer Lingus, it was Walsh who consolidated BA and Iberia into Balance of power 28 Airbus a European airline powerhouse. His successor will thus have to navigate A review of the current capabilities of the Russian turbulence from Brexit and growing pressure on climate change – as well aerospace forces. as an outstanding commitment for 200 Boeing 737 MAXs that Walsh placed last year – at a time when the aircraft was widely expected to be 18 32 Is gender still holding women back in the flying again last month. Turbulent skies aviation industry? Economic, environmental What are the barriers to Tim Robinson, Editor-in-Chief and political problems cause women’s advancement in the tim.robinson@aerosociety.com trouble for the Asia-Pacific aerospace industry and how aerospace industry. can they be overcome? Per Lindstrand Editor-in-Chief Editorial Office 2020 AEROSPACE subscription Tim Robinson Royal Aeronautical Society rates: Non-members, £180 +44 (0)20 7670 4353 tim.robinson@aerosociety.com No.4 Hamilton Place London W1J 7BQ, UK Please send your order to: Wayne J Davis, RAeS, No.4 Hamilton 22 36 +44 (0)20 7670 4300 Place, London W1J 7BQ, UK. Deputy Editor publications@aerosociety.com +44 (0)20 7670 4354 Bill Read +44 (0)20 7670 4351 www.aerosociety.com aerosubs@aerosociety.com bill.read@aerosociety.com AEROSPACE is published by the Royal Any member not requiring a print Behind the scenes of Japanese aerospace − Aeronautical Society (RAeS). version of this magazine should Production Manager contact: membership@aerosociety.com The Aeronauts upping its game Wayne J Davis Chief Executive Sir Brian Burridge CBE FRAeS USA: Periodical postage paid at Veteran balloon pilot Per An analysis of the Japanese +44 (0)20 7670 4354 wayne.davis@aerosociety.com Advertising Champlain New York and additional Lindstrand looks at the aerospace industry and its +44 (0)20 7670 4346 offices. making of the recent film. prospects for the future. Publications Executive partners@aerosociety.com Postmaster: Send address changes Chris Male +44 (0)20 7670 4352 to IMS of New York, PO Box 1518, Unless specifically attributed, no chris.male@aerosociety.com Champlain NY 12919-1518, USA. material in AEROSPACE shall be taken Production Executive to represent the opinion of the RAeS. ISSN 2052-451X Annabel Hallam +44 (0)20 7670 4361 Reproduction of material used in this publication is not permitted without the Afterburner annabel.hallam@aerosociety.com written consent of the Editor-in-Chief. 42 Message from our President Printed by Buxton Press Limited, Book Review Editor Palace Road, Buxton, Derbyshire essage from our Chief Executive 43 M Brian Riddle brian.riddle@aerosociety.com SK17 6AE, UK 44 Book Reviews Distributed by Royal Mail 48 Library Additions 49 Cool Aeronautics at Yeovil Additional content is available to view online at: www.aerosociety.com/aerospaceinsight Including: Women in the aerospace industry, The secret history of Santa interceptions, In the January 52 Diary issue, Caring for pilots, High time for hydrogen, Countdown to CORSIA, Analysis of the Iranian air 54 Obituaries Online force, Spottlight on RAeS fellow Erika Armstrong, Behind the scenes of The Aeronauts. 56 Elections and new member spotlight @aerosociety i Find us on LinkedIn f Find us on Facebook www.aerosociety.com FEBRUARY 2020 13
Blueprint INTELLIGENCE / ANALYSIS / COMMENT Precise control The production Airlander now features a bow thruster for precise manoeuvring during ground operations. In addition, the front ducted propulsors have been replaced by unducted propellers. These reduce weight and improve vectoring control. HAV is now working with Collins Aerospace to develop an all- electric propulsion system. Larger cabin HAV has made changes to the cabin module − moving fuel and services into the airship’s hull. This means that the cabin can now be up to 46m long, with 2,100ft2 of floor space. The cabin Hybrid Air Vehicles can also be offered in shorter lengths, depending on customer requirements. The flightdeck cabin has also been streamlined compared to the prototype. 4 AEROSPACE
Streamlined shape Flight test, CFD and wind-tunnel data has led HAV to subtly change Airlander’s hull shape to reduce drag and improve performance. The airship is now 5m longer and features a more rounded nose and a revised tail section. All told, HAV says the changes amount to a 75% reduction in emissions over comparable aircraft. Retractable landing gear HAV has changed the Airlander’s previous fixed twin landing gear ‘skids’ to six retractable landing gear ‘legs’ to significantly reduce drag, improve passenger views and increase ground clearance. W AEROSPACE Updated Airlander unveiled The UK’s Hybrid Air Vehicles has released details of design changes for the production version of its Airlander 10 next-generation airship. The tweaks include lessons from the first prototype, customer requirements resulting in enhanced maintainability, increased efficiency and performance. HAV says it now has letters of intent (LoI) for over ten aircraft and is now negotiating the first four production slots. First deliveries of the revamped airship could be in 2024. FEBRUARY 2020 5
Radome SPACEFLIGHT DEFENCE ESA announces space LM delivers 134 F-35s in 2019 − as debris removal mission Singapore signs up for F-35Bs The European Space The upper stage has a Agency (ESA) has mass of 100kg, making it a announced plans to suitable first target for the conduct the world's first mission − before moving space debris removal on to larger objects. The mission in 2025. Called mission will be conducted ClearSpace-1, the mission by a consortium headed by will rendezvous and Swiss startup ClearSpace USAF deorbit the ESA Vespa established by a team of (Vega Secondary Payload space debris researchers Lockheed Martin finished 2019 by beating its goal of F-35 deliveries to US customers Adapter) upper stage based at Ecole and allies with 134 airframes handed over. It exceeded its target of 131 by three aircraft which was used for the Polytechnique Fédérale de – with a goal of 141 deliveries in 2020. second flight of ESA’s Lausanne (EPFL) research Meanwhile, the US State Department has approved a potential $2.75bn foreign military Vega launcher in 2013. institute. sale of up to 12 Lockheed Martin F-35B Lightning IIs for Singapore. AEROSPACE AIR TRANSPORT Iranian SAM shoots down Wizz Air to launch Abu Ukrainian 737 with 176 killed Dhabi subsidiary Iran is reported to have made Low-cost Eastern Airbus A321neos − with a number of arrests following European carrier Wizz Air future plans to reportedly the accidental shootdown Holdings has announced expand this to 50 in the of a Ukrainian International plans to set up a next decade. The venture Ukrainian Presidential Press Office Airlines Boeing 737-800 subsidiary in the UAE, is Budapest-based Wizz by a Tor-1M SAM after the in conjunction with the Air’s first low-cost airline aircraft had taken off from Abu Dhabi Development outside Europe and Tehran airport with the loss of Holding Company will be 51% Abu Dhabi 176 lives on 7 January. The (ADDH). Subject to owned. Initial routes will shootdown occured while the approval from the UAE focus on connecting Iranian air defence system General Civil Aviation its existing network in was on high alert after Tehran Authority, Wizz Air Abu Europe, before moving on had attacked a US military base in Iraq with ballistic missiles. The missile attack was Dhabi could begin flying to new markets in India, in retaliation for a US drone strike which killed Iran’s top general Qassim Suleimani in in the second half of 2020 Africa and the Middle Baghdad on 3 January. using a small fleet of three East. NEWS IN BRIEF UK flights against carbon media said that the with the ISS. The capsule seater passenger EHang Aerospace suppliers emissions. The airline aims accident was caused by was launched using 216 urban air mobility Hexcel and Woodward, to be carbon-neutral by a flight control system an Atlas V rocket from vehicle. The autonomous which supply parts 2050. failure. The jet also was Cape Canaveral on 20 aircraft was flown without including actuators and the first production December, returning two passengers on 7 January composites for both On 24 December, a example of the Su-57 and days later via parachute to as part of the North Airbus and Boeing, are Sukhoi Su-57 stealth was set to be handed a landing in New Mexico, Carolina Transportation set to merge creating a fighter crashed in the over to the Russian Air US, after 33 orbits. The Summit. $13.7bn super-supplier. far east of Russia, with Force by the end of the failure to dock with the The new company, to be the pilot ejecting safely. year. ISS was said to be linked Twelve people including called Woodward Hexcel, Russia’s UAC announced to a software glitch which the captain were killed would have combined that the aircraft had Boeing’s commercial took incorrect timings for when a Fokker 100, sales of $5.3bn and gone down 111km crew transport, Starliner thruster burns. operated by local airline employ 16,000 workers. from its home airfield at CST-100 landed back Bek Air, crashed on Komsosolsk-on-Amur in on Earth early after an Chinese manufacturer take-off from Almaty British Airways has begun the Khabarosk region. unpiloted test flight failed EHang has made the first in Kazakhstan on 27 offsetting all its domestic Reports from Russian to rendezvous and dock flight in the US of its two- December. Nearly 100 6 AEROSPACE
AEROSPACE GENERAL AVIATION Look − no hands (on take-off) Nissan boss escaped using bizjet box swap Former Nissan CEO was too large for the Carlos Ghosn was security scanners. Ghosn smuggled out of Japan was then flown to Istanbul, where he was awaiting before switching to a trial for financial second private jet and misconduct inside a crate flying to his home country designed for musical of Lebanon. A Turkish instruments. The box private jet operator, MNG Airbus reportedly escaped Jet, whom two bizjets Airbus has conducted what it describes as the 'first fully automatic vision-based take-off' normal security screening were leased from, has using an A350-1000 test aircraft on 18 December at its HQ in Toulouse. Eight take-offs at the private terminal claimed no knowledge of were performed using the system, with the pilots not touching the sidestick. The system, at Kansai International the escape plot, blaming part of Airbus' Autonomous Taxi, Take-Off & Landing (ATTOL) project, uses image Airport, Osaka, on 29 a rogue employee for recognition technology to maintain the runway centreline. December, because it falsifying records. DEFENCE AIR TRANSPORT Leonardo wins US Navy Flybe rescued by Government chopper trainer order Leonardo has won an type will begin in 2020 order for 130 of its light, and continue to 2024. single-engined TH-119 In total, the contract is helicopters from the US worth $648m. The aircraft Navy. The Navy will use will be built in the US in Flybe the helicopter as a basic Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. rotary trainer to replace The contest to supply its aging fleet of 117 Bell the Advanced Helicopter The UK Government has stepped in to rescue struggling regional carrier Flybe. The airline, TH-57B/C Sea Rangers. Training System saw Europe’s largest regional carrier, was reported to be near to collapse on 12 January − In naval service the type Leonardo’s TH-119 beat despite being acquired by a Virgin Atlantic-led consortium in 2019. The Government will will be classified as the competitors Airbus with its defer part of its tax liabilities, as well as examine exempting it from air passenger duty (APD) TH-73A. Deliveries of twin H135 and Bell which for domestic flights to help its finances. Its owners are also to provide a cash injection. The the Pratt & Whitney was offering the single- rescue plan has provoked criticism from British Airways and Ryanair’s Michael O’Leary − PT6B37A-powered engine 407GXi. who has demanded that the same APD tax holiday be extended to his airline. people were onboard an order for 18 Airbus the Longitude will enter a Delta Air Lines Boeing the aircraft and dozens A320neo narrowbodies. SpaceX has launched a service in early 2020. 777 fell on two schools were also injured in the The aircraft are set to be payload of 60 more small in the Los Angeles accident, when the aircraft delivered in 2022/23. satellites for its Starlink China’s COMAC has area. Flight 89 from Los scraped its tail on take-off, global Internet network. flown the sixth prototype Angeles to Shanghai and then crashed into a The US DoD has agreed The satellites were lifted of its new C919 single- experienced an engine building. Some 49 people to acquire up to 50 into orbit aboard a Falcon aisle airliner. The flight on issue shortly after take-off were taken to hospital C-130J Super Hercules 9 rocket on 6 January 27 December, took place requiring the aircraft to following the crash. aircraft for the USAF, from Cape Canaveral. from Shanghai Pudong return to LAX. Kazakhstan authorities USMC and US Coast Airport with the aircraft have now grounded Guard. The multi-annual Fractional ownership staying aloft for 2hr and On 30 December, the airline and Fokker contract includes operator NetJets has taken 5mins. Indonesian Aerospace 100 aircraft while an orders for extended- delivery of its first Cessna rolled out the first investigation is underway. range, special forces Citation Longitude super- Up to 60 adults and prototype of its 16m and inflight refuelling midsize business jet on children are reported to wingspan Elang Hitam Singapore-based lessor, variants, and comes with 31 December 2019. have had medical attention (Black Eagle) indigenous BOC Aviation, has placed a discount on list prices. NetJets anticipates that after fuel dumped from MALE UAV. FEBRUARY 2020 7
Radome SPACEFLIGHT DEFENCE US stands up new Space Military battles Australian wildfires Force On 20 December, the US Operations Command formally stood up a new (SPOC). SPOC will sixth branch of its military provide capabilities such − United States Space as domain awareness, Force (USSF) − the first electronic warfare, Australian DoD new armed service since satellite communications, the USAF was formed missile warning, nuclear in 1947. USSF, created detonation detection, out of Air Force Space environmental monitoring, Australia has deployed aircraft to assist in evacuation and fire-fighting operations as the Command, comes under intelligence, surveillance country is gripped by immense wildfires. Firefighters have been flown in using RAAF the Department of the and reconnaissance, C-130J and C-27J transports, while Army Black Hawks, Chinook and NH90 helicopters Air Force. Meanwhile, navigation warfare, and Navy S-70 choppers have been used to evacuate residents cut off from rescue due the US Fourteenth Air command and control, and to the ongoing bushfires and deliver emergency supplies. Force has been officially positioning, navigation and On 23 January, three civilian US aircrew aboard a Coulson Aviation C-130 redesignated as Space timing. waterbomber were killed when their aircraft crashed in New South Wales. AEROSPACE AIR TRANSPORT Hyundai, Toyota get into eVTOLs Air freight down 1.1% in Joby Aviation 13th consecutive fall The global air freight considering that the market contracted by fourth quarter is usually 1.1% in November air cargo’s peak season,” 2019 compared to the said Alexandre de same period in 2018, air Juniac, IATA’s Director transport trade body IATA General and CEO. Hyundai has announced. Despite the contraction in “Demand for air cargo demand, IATA recorded Two car companies have unveiled Urban Air Mobility projects. At the Consumer in November was down that capacity rose by Electronic Show (CES) exhibition in Las Vegas, South Korea’s Hyundai revealed a 1.1% compared to the 2.9% year-on-year. model of its S-AI five-seat eVTOL (top left) which it is developing in partnership with previous year. That’s better Capacity growth has ridesharing service Uber as a future air taxi. Meanwhile, Japan’s Toyota has invested than the 3.5% decline now outstripped demand $294m into California-based Joby Aviation, which has also released images of its four- posted in October. But it growth for 19 consecutive seat eVTOL, (top right) current in development. is a big disappointment months. NEWS IN BRIEF a new partnership with the first time since 2012. A320 family aircraft − was and a King Air were also Arianespace launched iconic British sportscar In 2019 Airbus delivered temporarily grounded on reported to have been a Russian-built Soyuz manufacturer Aston 863 aircraft while 13 January for unspecified destroyed in the attack rocket from its French Martin with a custom Boeing’s deliveries up reasons. – with eight insurgents Guiana spaceport on 18 edition of its single-engine to the end of November being killed in return. The December, carrying a ACH130 helicopter. The stood at just 345 aircraft. One US serviceman and AFRICOM base provides payload of five satellites. ACH130 Aston Martin However, Boeing did two contractors were ISR and support for US The satellites included Edition features a choice deliver 225 widebodies in killed on 5 January when special operations forces the Italian COSMO- of interiors and exteriors 2019, compared to 147 Al-Shabab insurgents involved in countering SkyMed radar sat and – with the bespoke VIP from Airbus. attacked a US forward Islamic terror groups in the ESA CHEOPS version being customised operating base at Manda East Africa. (Characterising at Airbus Helicopters’ UK Italian authorities are to Bay Airfield in Kenya. Exoplanet Satellite) HQ in Oxford. suspend the operating The attack also saw six China launched a solid- probe. licence of Milan-based aircraft either destroyed fueled Kuaizhou 1A Airbus has overtaken low-cost Ernest Airlines. or damaged, including a rocket from the Jiuquan Airbus Corporate Boeing as the world’s top The airline, which operates secretive US Army Dash 8 space base on 16 Helicopters has revealed aircraft manufacturer for a small fleet of four Airbus spyplane. Two helicopters January. The launcher 8 AEROSPACE
AEROSPACE SPACEFLIGHT Boeing reverses course of 737 MAX sim training In a reversal from its previous requirement, there being only 34 737 MAX simulators in service SpaceX Boeing is to mandate full flight simulator training for worldwide. The 737 MAX has yet to receive approval conducts all returning and new 737 from the FAA. Crew Dragon MAX pilots. Previously the Wichita-based Spirit abort test SpaceX company had claimed that AeroSystems, which pilots would not need flight supplies 737 MAX simulator time to convert fuselages to Boeing, has On 19 January, SpaceX performed the final uncrewed test of its human-rated Crew to the MAX from 737NG laid off 2,800 workers Dragon spacecraft, with an in-flight abort test on launch. The flight, from Kennedy Space models. The move is in January as Boeing’s Center, Cape Canaveral, Florida, saw the Crew Dragon successfully clear the Falcon 9 expected to add additional 737 MAX production line booster − which was then exploded deliberately as part of the escape test. The Crew cost and time to the shutdown ripples through Dragon then splashed down in the Atlantic by parachute. The test clears the path for the MAX’s return to flight, with the global supply chain. first piloted Crew Dragon mission to the ISS with two NASA astronauts. GENERAL AVIATION DEFENCE Europa launches Elite kitplane Naval Tejas makes first landing at sea On 11 January the service as being too navalised variant of unpowered for carrier India’sHindustan operations. Instead it is Aeronautics Limited aiming to leverage this (HAL) Tejas Light Combat experience into a larger, Aircraft (LCA) made its more capable follow-on first arrested landing and twin-engine LCA Navy Europa Aircraft take-off on the Indian Mk2, with more powerful Navy’s aircraft carrier INS GE F-414 engines. First Vikramaditya. However, flight of this twin-engine UK GA manufacturer Europa Aircraft has announced the launch of a new kitplane for the Indian Navy has naval fighter is being 2020. The Elite is an all-composite, two-seat VLA-catergorised home-built aircraft. The rejected the single-engine targeted for 2025-26, with aircraft includes a ballistic recovery parachute and choice of engines. Tejas Mk1 for operational entry into service in 2031. was carrying the Yinhe 1 commercial broadband certain requirements in order to operate. Those Avion Express is to wet- ON THE MOVE communications satellite with unregistered drones lease four Airbus A320s David Calhoun has taken as President of its for commercial company may face prosecution. to the Polish flag carrier over as President and Commercial Engines GalaxySpace, which is Singapore introduced LOT. The first two aircraft CEO of Boeing from business. planning to launch up mandatory registration for entered service on 14 Dennis Muilenburg. to 144 spacecraft for a UAVs weighing more than January, following by the IAG Chief Executive Willie space-based 5G network 250g on 2 January. second two on 1 February. Emirates President Sir Tim Walsh is to step down over the next few years. Clark is set to step down on 30 June. He will be Rolls-Royce has opened The Finnish Air Force in June 2020. succeeded by the Chief Drone owners and a new facility for civil has begun in-country Executive of Iberia, Luis operators in India need to aircraft engines in Bristol evaluations of contenders Virgin Galactic has Gallego. register with the Ministry UK. The £25m composite for its next fighter to appointed Enrico Palermo of Civil Aviation by the technology hub will replace its F/A-18s. In as Chief Operating Officer. James A Viola is to be the end of January. They develop components for the fly-off are the F/A-18 next President and CEO of will be given a unique R-R's next generation Super Hornet, Rafale, Pratt & Whitney has the Helicopter Association identification number and UltraFan turbofans and Eurofighter, F-35 and appointed Carroll Lane International (HAI). a permit, and must meet employ 150 workers. Gripen. FEBRUARY 2020 9
By the Numbers Understanding the world of Aerospace through data Air Cargo in 2019 IATA Economics Airports Council International REGIONAL CONTRIBUTION TO INTERNATIONAL PASSENGER TRAFFIC GROWTH 2018–2040 Annual World Airport Traffic Europe Forecasts 2019-2040 31.5% North America 8.8% Middle East GLOBAL AVERAGE ANNUAL GROWTH RATE 2018–2040 12.2% Asia-Pacific 37.3% Latin America Africa 3.7% PASSENGER 2.3% AIR 2.0% AIRCRAFT TRAFFIC CARGO MOVEMENTS Caribbean 3.2% 7.0% CHANGING AVIATION MARKET SHARES OVER TIME FASTEST GROWING COUNTRIES TOP PASSENGER TRAFFIC AIR CARGO AIRCRAFT MOVEMENTS FOR PASSENGERS 2018–2040: (Over 50 million passengers per annum) 10 2018 2040 2018 2040 2018 2040 BY 2023 PASSENGER TRAFFIC IN EMERGING ECONOMIES TO Vietnam 1 6.2% US CHINA US US US US SURPASS ADVANCED ECONOMIES 20.4% 17.8% 27. 2% 21.0% 30.2% 23.0% India2 6.1% Emerging economies Advanced economies Saudi Arabia 3 5.5% CHINA US CHINA CHINA CHINA CHINA 14.4% 15.1% 13.6% 17. 1% 11.1% 15.7% 2018 47. 3% 4.2 billion 4.6 billion 52.7% Philippines 4 5.3% INDIA INDIA JAPAN UAE FRANCE INDIA 2024 50.5% 5.7 billion 5.6 billion 49.5% Indonesia 5 5.2% 3.9% 6.4% 4.8% 4.9% 4.2% 4.2% Colombia 6 5.1% 2040 58.4% 11.5 billion 8.2 billion 41.6% United Arab Emirates 7 4.9% BY 2040 INTERNATIONAL PASSENGER TRAFFIC WILL APPROACH PARITY WITH DOMESTIC TRAFFIC Mexico 8 4.7% International Domestic China 9 4.7% 2018 41.4% 40.4% 3.6 billion 5.1 billion 58.6% FIND OUT MORE AT Malaysia 10 4.4% www.aci.aero/watf All are emerging and 2040 45.7% 8.9 billion 10.6 billion 54.3% developing economies 10 AEROSPACE
Pushing the Envelope Exploring advances on the leading edge of aerospace Robert Coppinger Flying with nature W hether evolution or intelligent either side of an aircraft’s wake vortex core can provide design made the animal kingdom a smooth updraft for the aircraft that can position the way it is has been a debate itself there, three kilometres behind. Airbus declined to since Charles Darwin’s 1859 say what technology would be used for the airliner to book The Origin of Species was detect the location of this smooth updraft. published. There has been no such debate about Mimicking a bird wing’s in-flight flexing to reduce how humanity’s intelligent designs can be aided by drag is another Airbus idea. The firm’s engineers the animal kingdom. The application of evolutionary stated last June that in February 2019 they had flown principles to design has gone on for decades, and a scale-model remote-controlled aircraft based on the adoption of technical solutions based on Mother the Airbus A321 which they called AlbatrossOne. It Nature’s way of doing things is emerging as a force has in-flight flapping wing tips that act like a semi- potentially as powerful as natural selection itself. aeroelastic hinge that reacts autonomously during turbulence. Its movements can reduce drag and overall Feathers will fly wing weight because it lessens the aerodynamic wing loading allowing for lighter wing boxes; while also When those magnificent men in their flying machines combating turbulence and wind gust effects. In theory threw themselves off jetties with bird-like wing the wing tips can be as much as a third of the wing designs, they could not have imagined that a century length. The idea came from the albatross which locks later there would be an aerofoil concept that literally its wings at the shoulder for long-distance soaring but has a feather-like design. Revealed at the 2019 Royal unlocks them when wind-gusts occur, or manoeuvring International Air Tattoo, the visionary Bird of Prey is required. Airbus concept uses avian-like wing and tail structures, along with a blended wing-to-fuselage joint, to deliver Reducing friction the sorts of beneficial aerodynamics that nature’s flyers are born with. These bird-like features would be Aircraft can also benefit from the biology of mammals. used by a theoretical hybrid-electric turboprop regional The skin of cetaceans is rippled to reduce friction airliner design. Airbus hopes to fly a sub-scale Bird of with that more viscous of fluids, water. Airbus has Prey demonstrator to prove the concept. been aware of this and studied it in the past, how a rippling airliner skin could deliver reduced friction Formation flying and fuel savings. The challenge of many biomimicry proposals, such as bird like tails, is that the engineering Another avian biomimicry concept is Airbus’ fello’fly is fiendishly hard. Animals are molecular machines with which would see two aircraft flying in formation over multifunctional materials and structures that grow into THE ADOPTION oceanic airspace for a 10% fuel saving. Announced being, defying humanity’s manufacturing techniques. OF TECHNICAL last November, a chase airliner gains a 10% fuel Can intelligent design also find the manufacturing saving thanks to the energy of the preceding aircraft’s solutions to realising, for aviation, the benefits of SOLUTIONS BASED wake. Referred to as wake energy retrieval, the air millions of years of evolution? ON MOTHER NATURE’S WAY OF DOING THINGS IS EMERGING AS A FORCE POTENTIALLY AS POWERFUL AS NATURAL Airbus SELECTION ITSELF FEBRUARY 2020 11
Transmission LETTERS AND ONLINE @aerosociety i Find us on LinkedIn f Find us on Facebook www.aerosociety.com Gender equality and aerospace I was tempted to have enter. Women don’t need to groups and individuals recommend a woman If you have an idea, a comprehensive moan learn from men. We need active online promoting instead. Look into ways of write in too. Put yourself about being told by yet to change the system and women in the industry. providing financial support or a colleague forward another man ‘to adopt some make it work for us. All of us Interact with organisations for younger women to to promote the industry important habits used by should play our part. A stall such as the UK’s Fawcett attend events. Support in the media. Visible men to raise my profile’(1) at a university careers fair is Society for advice and women of colour and representation matters. Join (p 32). However, I thought simply not enough. Schools guidance on practical LGBTQ+ groups – they are with others and integrate that enough readers were always look for speakers ways to change your own facing additional barriers. As programmes. It isn’t enough similarly eye-rolling, and and universities for mentors. workplace. Contact women’s an industry we need to set to just network; we need to decided to move on to more From a very young age, officers and outreach up more coordinated peer actively coordinate schemes positive matters. girls need to discover the programme leaders from circles to encourage women and events. We need to Schemes to address career paths available to other industries to share and of all ages to give each shape a new debate and the problems of gender them and see that every gain advice. Conferences other advice and support. move it forward. Make a inequality – and let us job, at every level, is open highlighting the work of Leadership grows from a commitment to doing one accept that this is a to them. Children know women and outreach strong base. Until all women additional thing this year significant problem – are what a pilot does but how programmes to engage and are well represented in all to further the careers of unco-ordinated and often many could explain what the invite in the next generation aspects of the industry, women in aviation. We have outdated. In an age of role of an engineer is? Go are crucial. Seek them out, given the hiring practices to fundamentally change or Instagram influencers, back to school – they are support them and offer to at senior levels, it is unlikely yet another generation of we also have a visually always looking for speakers join a panel. Organisers the situation will improve. It’s women will read the same beautiful industry to show to inspire. Ask if your old should no longer have too late if we only focus on article again in the next off and encourage the next university had a mentoring unrepresentative panels the boardroom; we need to decade. generation of women to scheme or a women’s and, if you find you are focus on how people reach alumni group. Seek out on one, see if you can that boardroom. Dr Jasmina Lijesevic Titan Airways The Titan factor Bob Boulton and the Merlin 102 The December issue of AEROSPACE has an historic photo of a Rolls- Royce Merlin engine line(3), mentioning production in the UK and US (Packard Merlins) but fails to mention Merlin Mk 102s produced by the Commonwealth Aircraft Corporation (CAC) Titan Airways A320 at Turin Airport. at its facility in Sydney. I have attached a photo First of type Merlin 102 engine manufactured at CAC Lidcombe Interesting article in I believe its own availability (right) of the first type circa 1940. Left to right: Arthur Marshal – Assistant Engine January’s AEROSPACE was limited and so the vast manufactured at Lidcombe Superintendent; Roy Hollis – Foreman Engine Department; Bob Boulton – Engine and Test Superintendent; Bert Clifton – Engine regarding the Thomas Cook amount of flying was sub- circa 1940, with four of the Inspection and Don McCorquodale – Machine Shop Superintendent. collapse and the CAA’s chartered to the carriers your staff (and several others two-week ‘airline’.(2) However, article mentions, mostly flying not in the picture) still being and pilot (he flew with Croydon aerodrome. Bob you have overlooked a key under a Titan flight number. employed there when I Australian National Airways was a gentle and most process in the repatriations Titan is a competitor of joined the company (by then and Kingsford Smith Air unassuming man, who I – that of Titan Airways who mine and so I don’t want to part of Hawker de Havilland) Services), the early years was privileged to know were broker and airline for sing their praises too much! in 1966. The photo is taken being alongside Sir Charles as a work colleague the entire operation, not However, to omit mention of from a limited edition (about Kingsford Smith. He also and family friend for the CAA. The CAA had their pivotal role from your 100 only) of Bob Boulton’s prepared the Lockheed several years. His arranged for Titan’s services article is rather like telling memoirs (Aviators of the Altair Lady Southern Cross significant contribution some weeks before under the story of the sinking of Charles Ulm and Kingsford for Kingsford Smith in to the establishment a cloak of secrecy (so as the Titanic without mention Smith Era), which was the US and UK, before and development of not to cause concern over of the iceberg. Nonetheless, published by his family in its final ill-fated flight to aviation in Australia is TC’s financial crisis) and had your publication is always 1991, some years after Australia. The cover of largely unknown and tendered the role to several a good read over a huge his passing in 1982. Bob Bob’s book has a photo of unrecognised. other charter brokers. variety of topics. had a remarkable career him with KS and Tommy Titan won it and began (which later earned him Pethybridge standing Mike Cuming preparations well in advance. Tim Proctor FRAeS an MBE) as an engineer in front of the Altair at CEng MRAeS 12 AEROSPACE
f Iranian Tomcats @cydney0071 [On Could Iranian F-14 Tomcats still surprise the US in any conflict?(4)] Can’t believe they’ve got any F-14s serviceable. NG have had a parts embargo for years. It put all the vintage flyers out In praise of the F-14 Regulations post Brexit of business too sadly. IRIAF Tony Stevens [On Iranian @GbhvfRon [On UK and @KompositeVision air force article(4)] It may EASA divergence after OSINT is scarce on Iranian IRIAF F-14A Tomcats. be outclassed but most Brexit] So, what are the deployments. I do know people have a soft spot for RAeS and CAA positions on there’s a dedicated F-14 @AsiaJetWatch Good @CoffeeAndPaul Iran the Tomcat. It is still one Raab’s attitude to ‘not being squadron for defending story but how many hours has access to additive cool machine outdated, rule takers’ from the EU, in airspace over Tehran; a are Iranian pilots getting? manufacturing. 3D printing outclassed, tired but still a view of the close integration friend of mine in the Iran And how realistic is their means you can remake fantastic aircraft. of EASA standards and military was actually present a part that even matches training for a foe like the regulations in respect of as a translator when Russian the manufacturing USA? A good move for i aircrew licensing, design techs were overhauling the IRIAF could well be to discrepancies found in the certification and many F-14s in Merhbad. There’s maintain most of its strength original. other aspects affecting another F-14 Sqn in Isfahan. deeper in Iran’s interior. As aerospace? If I had to guess perhaps much as I, and everyone backup F-14 squadron that @NZAircraftFan I would else, loves the F-14A, it Preserving history rotates between Tehran, love to see a F-14 operate really belongs in a museum Bandar Abbas and Shiraz. from a motorway. I am also along with the other super @Satcomm_guru [On Primary airspace threats to cool types like the F-8, A-5, sure they would be spotted What can companies Iran come from West+Gulf, A-6 ... and so many more... by satellite very quickly, as and organisations do to so these areas are priority there is no cover out in the preserve aviation history?] for F-14 Patrols. Iran only Hydrogen power desert. I agree HASs are Get everything online. has a fleet of around 70 @peterryhshughes It will no protection from modern Scan, digitise and share F-14s; half of which are be another Marianas Turkey Clifford Chan [On weapons. The Iraqis found freely. Encourage writers serviceable at any given shoot. hydrogen-powered that out during the First to use the material. point. aircraft(5)] Amazing fuel. Gulf War. Create searchable text to accompany any recording. Embry-Riddle approval So much information is locked up in audio but it is Alex Walker [On Embry- not accessible unless you can take the time to listen, Boeing concept airliner design RAeS Specialist Groups Riddle Aeronautical @BurkhardDomke [On @Spaceman_pete Boeing which does not scale. University Worldwide Boeing truss-braced- [On Specialist Group Campus receiving RAeS wing airliner − a possible Mobilisation Day] Interesting approval of six training Helicopter girl 737 MAX replacement?] strategy and review day programmes] Great news! Academic and capability @AeroSociety. Multi- @PeteZaccagnino [On research usually need at disciplinary. Space to think helicopter-mad eight year least a notional product and discuss how we could old girl invited to visit application context for Jonathan Cooper Great work better. Good example Leonardo in Yeovil] Great budget justification. This news – looking forward to Boeing’s Transonic Truss- promoting diversity and to see stories like this. Love is not well understood by visiting in January. Braced Wing concept. inclusion: ALTA mentoring her ambition! PR departments and the scheme for women in media. Hence the notion is @BernieBaldwin For a aerospace aerosociety.com/ Ameen Budagher An inevitably turned into ‘This is 180-230 seat family? get-involved/ @SouthernFairy16 Girl the future of –’ headlines. amazing aviation institution. I doubt it. after my own heart 1. https://www.aerosociety.com/news/is-gender-still-holding-women-back-in-the-aviation-industry/ 2. AEROSPACE, January 2020, p 34, Organising Operation Matterhorn 3. AEROSPACE, December 2019, p 41, Afterburner contents page 4. https://www.aerosociety.com/news/the-iranian-air-force-unexpectedly-sharp-teeth/ 5. AEROSPACE, January 2020, p 14, High time for hydrogen @aerosociety i linkedin.com/raes f facebook.com/raes www.aerosociety.com FEBRUARY 2020 13
PLANE SPEAKING David Mackay Virgin Galactic Virgin Galactic Plane Speaking with: David Mackay On 10 December, ex-RAF Harrier pilot, test pilot and Virgin Atlantic airline captain, DAVID MACKAY FRAeS, Chief Pilot, Virgin Galactic, gave the Royal Aeronautical Society’s 2019 Wilbur and Orville Wright Lecture. As the space tourism company counts down to its first planned commercial services in 2020. AEROSPACE caught up with him to quiz him about preparing for suborbital flights. AEROSPACE: It’s been a long road since Sir major part of what’s going on right now is preparation Richard Branson launched Virgin Galactic at the Royal for our move to New Mexico. This is where Aeronautical Society HQ in 2004. What is the current commercial operations will start once we complete the status of the programme? test programme. So, we are moving the spaceship to David Mackay: The bottom line is that we’re New Mexico and from there we will complete the test planning to be in commercial service in 2020. We programme and then get into commercial operations. had a very successful flight in February last year and that essentially proved out the concept that AEROSPACE: Your background includes military we started with many years ago − fly the vehicle flight testing. How does the adrenaline rush of piloting into space and allow someone to unstrap and float SpaceShipTwo compare to flying a Harrier low level at around in the cabin and get back into their seats for night on NVGs? re-entry. However, the vehicle is still very much in a test programme. On the basis of that successful DM: I think there’s a similarity with flying a rocket- flight in February, we’re now installing the full powered spaceship, in that a lot of people think it’s a commercial interior, completing some planned vehicle rocket motor and something could go wrong. Sure, modifications and maintenance and getting Unity a rocket motor releases a lot of energy in a very ready to relocate to New Mexico. We always look at short space of time and that’s got to be controlled the data that we receive from every flight, obviously, carefully. We go about it in a very safe and controlled and make changes and improvements to make the manner and we have a great deal of safety checks vehicle easier, safer to fly, more reliable and more and balances along the way, including getting in very intuitive to operate. We’re doing all of those things. A experienced external experts. 14 AEROSPACE
AEROSPACE: What is the conversion course for also do a Monte Carlo analysis, with all those vehicle SS2 like? How do you keep currency? variables and atmospheric variations. DM: Yes, we have our own flight simulator and that’s For that, we’ll randomly pick combinations of those hugely important. We have a conversion course variables and we just fly them. We do all of that in which was written many years ago that was based the simulator. That’s hugely valuable, not just for pilot around a kind of ab initio spaceship pilot. That ab training to expose you to combinations which are YOU WILL, initio spaceship pilot, however, would come in with considered extremely unlikely but also to formulate INSTANTLY − the basis of a very experienced background as a test our limitations for the flight. Out of all those simulator pilot. That is our basic building block if you like. We will BECAUSE IT’S evaluations we draw up a set of limitations, which we always (in the short term at least and probably for the will adhere to in flight. If we come up against those ABSOLUTELY foreseeable future) have highly experienced test pilots limits − the vehicle roll rate, or pitch rate, or whatever ENTHRALLING as our basis. it is we feel is a limitation − we will abort, come back, − WANT TO GO The way we have trained ourselves so far is look at the data, and fly again another day. really by going through the test and development TO A WINDOW programme, building up through captive carry flights AND JUST GAWP AEROSPACE: Since the tragic accident of with WhiteKnightTwo, then glide flights and eventually SpaceShipTwo in 2014, what lessons (for example, AT WHAT IS powered flights. What I’ve tried to do for SS2 powered OUT THERE, human factors, HMI design or operations) have you flights is to keep the crews down to a small number because, during the test flight programme it doesn’t fly learned and incorporated? BECAUSE IT’S very often, it doesn’t fly for very long and we don’t want DM: In terms of the changes that were made, we THE MOST to dilute the experience too thinly. We have a small [Virgin Galactic] didn’t have the spaceship at that time, INCREDIBLE core of four SS2 pilots at the moment. In the fullness it was still being tested by Scaled Composites, but we had already instituted our own programme of changes. SIGHT of time, once we start flying regularly and once we get our two additional vehicles, which are under However, what happened in Powered Flight Four was construction right now, and start flying more frequently, not expected by anyone. We were aware that the then we’ll get more pilots in and broaden the support feather was unlocked. There was logic behind doing a little bit. that but we didn’t expect it to be unlocked when the Going back to the simulator, it is absolutely vital to motor was on. No one had seen that coming. us and hugely important. We use it for each part of the As an outcome of that accident, the first thing we test and development programme, verifying that what had to do was to change the [feather lock] system so we are doing is safe. We do that by looking at how that couldn’t happen again. We now have a system the vehicle is predicted to behave as our basis and that can only be unlocked when it is safe to do so. then looking at variations from that basic prediction That was priority number one but similar to other model and we will look at anything up to variations that major accidents that have happened in the past, this are considered extremely unlikely. In addition to that, was the time where you just sit down and go through we will also input variables in the atmospheric model everything. We did that with both vehicles − not just that are also considered to be extremely unlikely. We SS2 but on VMS Eve as well. We went through every Left: SpaceShipTwo Unity’s powered flight in February 2019 saw Beth Moses, Virgin Galactic Chief Astronaut Trainer obtain Virgin Galactic her commercial astronaut wings with a fllight above the 50mile/80km line. FEBRUARY 2020 15
PLANE SPEAKING David Mackay Virgin Galactic Above - Virgin Galactic single system looking for single point failures or things which is called The Gateway to Space, designed customers will begin their that somebody could perhaps do if they were having a by Sir Norman Foster and Partners. It is a fantastic suborbital experience at really bad day, and tried to eliminate every single one space age facility. We’re finishing off the customer The Gateway to Space of those. We haven’t tallied them all up but we’ve made level at the moment, they have the third floor of the spaceport in New Mexico. hundreds of changes to SS2’s instrument panel, it’s a building with fantastic views over the airfield. In there manually flown vehicle so the pilot interaction with the they will learn about the experience, what to expect, vehicle is really important. We made the changes to the what noises, what movements, when and what vehicle to make it more intuitive and simpler to operate. communications they have with the flight crew. That has been, really, one of our main aims as test They will learn how to strap into their seats, how to pilots over the past few years − to make this vehicle as get out of their seats when they’re in weightlessness, safe, simple and as intuitive as possible to operate. how to get back into their seats in weightlessness. How the communication system works, when they can expect to hear from us, what sort of calls they AEROSPACE: What’s the customer sub-orbital can expect to hear on the radio, when we will not talk experience going to be like? Are there weather to them − deliberately so, because we’re focusing on limitations? Is there safety training? other important phases of flight as pilots. DM: Starting with the weather then, yes, obviously Also what they can realistically expect to do there are weather limitations. We haven’t decided in weightlessness. Weightlessness is a wonderful exactly what the crosswind limitation is going to be sensation but if you’re kind of floating around, say in SS2 but we have a good idea and will continue to in the middle of a large room, you would have no test this as we complete our test program. As with any control over your body because you can’t reach out aircraft there are weather limitations but we aim to fly to anything. Luckily our cabin is big enough to float on days when the weather is pretty good. That is one around in but actually small enough such that you of the reasons we’re in New Mexico because they can just gently reach out and touch things and give have this incredible weather factor down there. yourself some control. My own advice to people would The customer experience will be quite be just to float, enjoy this zen-like experience and the extraordinary, as you can imagine. Very few people view. have had the opportunity to travel at three times the In terms of what it actually feels like, there’s speed of sound into space and back and because of the climb up to launch altitude, which is like being that we want them to be prepared for the experience, under any other four-engine airliner and it’s very to get the most out of it. We don’t want them to be comfortable. Then the release itself, you’ll hear the distracted by something they aren’t expecting, some countdown to release as the spaceship is released sounds, some movement or something they are from WhiteKnight. feeling. We want them to be prepared. So that when Release feels like you’re going over the they get in the vehicle, they are going to have the top of a rollercoaster. So you’ve got that slight experience of a lifetime, which I think they will have reduction in G and then it’s silent for just a few anyway! seconds because you’ve left the four engines It will be a three-day training programme and it under WhiteKnight. Then we light a rocket motor all takes place at Spaceport America in our facility, and you get this 3G push in the back and that will 16 AEROSPACE
Virgin Galactic go on for 60 seconds. You hear the noise of the intercom and that kind of thing. The idea is that this Left: Virgin Galactic’s rocket motor, even when you’re supersonic. You experience should be open for as a large a portion of third SS2 vehicle under hear the noise because it’s transmitted back up the population as possible. construction at The Spaceship Company in through the structure. It is actually very smooth Mojave, California. but there’s a tiny little bit of vibration, so you know something’s happening. There really is a big AEROSPACE: There was an announcement last acceleration force. As we start to pitch it up into year that the Italian air force will pay for researchers the vertical we’re still being pushed in the back, to fly microgravity science missions. Do you expect even though we’re in the vertical, we’re being a steady stream of government and scientific pushed upwards with this 3G push, which is just researchers wanting to fly on SS2 too? really amazing. The sky goes from blue to dark DM: Yes, we’ve already flown several payloads under blue very quickly, then to black. You’re still bathed the NASA flight opportunities programme and there in sunlight but you’re looking at a black sky, which are more to come. There is interest from, not only Italy, is a little bit funny for the brain the first time you but from other countries and operators around the see it. world. I think one of the great things about this system Then, at the end of 60 seconds we go from a 3G is that it is so flexible, you can strap SpaceShipTwo push to weightlessness and at that point you’re going to WhiteKnight and fly to wherever in the world you to be allowed to unstrap, unbuckle and float away from have permission to operate from. Almost any country your seat. You will, instantly − because it’s absolutely now can have its own space launch system and it enthralling − want to go to a window and just gawp doesn’t have to be customers that you fly, you can at what is out there, because it’s the most incredible pull the seats out, put payload racks in, which we’ve sight, and enjoy your weightless experience. At the done already, and fly experiments in space and do point of re-entry you go from this silent incredible it frequently. There’s a lot of interest in that from the place with no forces on your body and no sound and scientific community. I believe there is a big market out no motion, to starting to meet the atmosphere again. there. You’ll ride down in the feather configuration to about 65,000ft. At that point the feather is lowered and, as the last few degrees come down, then the AEROSPACE: What would your dream launch vehicle nose pitches down a little bit and glide all the location be then, anywhere in the world? way down to landing. DM: I guess my dream would be Scotland. The UK So that’s really the experience. We get them really is a small island and I think the views that you would familiar with that and we encourage them to go to a get from anywhere in the UK would be fantastic. I’m centrifuge beforehand, if they can. We also encourage biased because I’m from the very North of Scotland them to do Zero G parabolas beforehand, if they can, and I love the north and the west coast. They’re Space Situational but it is not essential. We will offer them flights in an absolutely superb. That’s where I come from. I’d love Awareness Extra aerobatic aircraft, just as an initiation to give to see that from space. That’s me being selfish. I think Conference them a feel for what elevated G level feels like and the views of the Earth wherever you fly from are 14 July 2020 – what zero G feels like. That will also get them used astonishing from space. It’s just an amazing thing to RAeS HQ, London to flying with their pilot and communicating over the see. FEBRUARY 2020 17
You can also read