RESILIENCY: WHAT IS YOUR 96-HOUR PLAN? - WILLIS MCCULLOUGH, DIRECTOR OF KEY ACCOUNTS, UNISON ENERGY
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
The Need for Resiliency • California has experienced more power outages than any other state – in fact, more than double of any other state in 2018 • Extreme weather has made utility outages and rolling blackouts the new normal for Californians • 2022 Summer power shortfall may be worse than predicted • Aging utility infrastructure contributes to the problem • Droughts have impacted hydroelectric production, with 2021 dropping 48% below the 10-year average – a problem for a state that relies on renewable power Onsite power solutions, including microgrids, can be part of the solution – both for the hospital & freeing up grid capacity
California Energy Commission “In an online briefing with reporters, the officials forecast a potential shortfall of 1,700 megawatts this year, a number that could go as high as 5,000 MW if the grid is taxed by multiple challenges that reduce available power while sending demand soaring, state officials said during an online briefing with reporters. Supply gaps along those lines could leave between 1 million and 4 million people without power. Outages will only happen under extreme conditions, officials cautioned, and will depend in part on the success of conservation measures. In 2025, the state will still have a capacity shortfall of about 1,800 MW, according to officials from the California Energy Commission, Public Utilities Commission, California Independent System Operator and Newsom's office. They also projected annual electricity rate increases of between 4% and 9% between now and 2025.” 1. Quote from Podcast with Governor Newsom, the California Energy Commission, California Independent System Operator, and the Public utilities Commission
Codes: Configurations / Sources (Current) Current Requirements (2019 CEC/2018 NFPA 99/2016 NFPA 110) CEC 517.30 requires (2) Independent Power Sources (normal and emergency) CEC 700.10 Wiring from an emergency source shall be kept entirely independent of all other wiring and equipment CEC 700.12 lists: Batteries, Generators, UPS, Fuel Cells and Unit Batteries as sources of Emergency Power (not for hospitals) NFPA 99 allows either Generator, Batteries or Fuel Cell as EPS
Codes: Configurations / Sources (Upcoming Changes) Upcoming Changes (adoption date 1/1/2023) (2022 CEC/2021 NFPA 99/2019 NFPA 110) No change: CEC 517.30 requires (2) Independent Power Sources CEC 700.10 Wiring from an emergency source shall be kept entirely independent Changes: CEC will allow generators, batteries and fuel cells as EPS’s NFPA 99 will allow generator, batteries, fuel cells and Microgrids as EPS’s NFPA 99 states that Microgrids can be used as Emergency Power Sources if “Designed with sufficient reliability to provide effective facility operation consistent with the facilities emergency operations plan.”
Codes: Seismic Certification OSP’s and seismic bracing of the microgrid components will be required if part of the EPS. This would apply to applicable “parts and pieces” of the following on-site power producers and controllers: Fuel Cells Photovoltaics Battery Storage Systems CoGen Equipment Natural Gas Turbines Natural Gas Reciprocating Engines . . . etc
Codes: Fuel Storage Onsite fuel requirements: OSHPD 1 (Hospitals) – 96 hrs per NFPA 110 OSHPD 2 (Skilled Nursing Facilities)- 6 hrs if more than 7 beds SB 1207 would extend to SNF back-up requirements to 96 hrs OSHPD 3 (Clinics) Ambulatory Surgery Clinics - 4 hrs otherwise 90 min OSHPD 4 (Correctional Facilities) - 6 hrs if more than 7 beds OSHPD 5 (Psychiatric Facilities) - 6 hrs if more than 7 beds
California’s Power Makeup
U.S. Delivered Energy 1. Source: EIA
U.S. Power Consumption 1. Source: EIA
What is a microgrid? Microgrids provide hospitals with on-site, resilient power to ensure they have the energy they need when the grid goes down Typically operates in parallel with the electric utility, but during a power outage can isolate itself (“island model”) from the grid & produce its own power Can power a single or multiple buildings Can be comprised of a variety of technologies, including: • Solar • Energy Storage • Combined Heat and Power (CHP) • Fuel Cells
Microgrid Technologies Solar: • Useful for covering peak electricity needs during the day • Typically supply about 15% of a hospital’s power • Can reduce onsite emissions by at least 10-20% • Can be limited by facility space constraints • No thermal applications (boiler or other thermal needs) Battery Storage: • Can help extend solar capacity • Overcoming intermittency requires 8x the solar generation and 16x the battery supply • Batteries rely on non-renewable lithium • Cost constraints can prevent a large-scale solution (expensive)
Microgrid Technologies Fuel Cells • Can run continuously to cover up to 100% of electric load • If sized correctly, can provide both electric and thermal • Can typically cut a site’s emissions by around 20% with 50% efficiency Combined Heat and Power (“CHP”) • Can run continuously to cover up to 100% of electric load • Can include thermal applications • Can use a variety of fuel sources, including natural gas, hydrogen, or biogas – and can transition from one fuel source to another • Can reduce facility emissions by 10-20%
Microgrid Technologies Hospital Campus Wind Microgrid solution: Microgrid maintenance controller Solar array H2/Biofuels Battery Storage Convertible CHP units Transportation Electrification System will normally operate in grid parallel but would shift to island mode during grid outages
CHP Thermal Applications
Renewable Fuels Microgrids can be designed to transition to biogas and hydrogen and these fuels become economically feasible and available. 19
How to pay for it? Private financing Government / Utility Incentives: Self Generation Incentive Program (SGIP) • Requires 100% biogas for fuel cells, internal combustion engines, microturbines, gas turbines • Wind Turbines are eligible • Pressure Reduction Turbines are eligible • Battery storage (this is a major part of the program) • Solar is not eligible ZEV Incentives – for installing EV Charging Others Energy as a Service (EaaS) model: partnering with a third party, using a 15-25 year Energy Services Agreement (ESA)
Microgrid vs. Diesel Backup Microgrid with ESA Model All capital costs are included in ESA Natural gas, RNG from underground pipeline
Additional Microgrid Benefits In addition to providing resilient power, on-site microgrids support hospital ESG initiatives and allow hospitals to take control of their energy future: Microgrids with Combined Heat and Power (CHP) provide reliable, cost- effective electricity and can operate in island mode to provide power to the hospital when the utility is down Using the waste heat to offset boiler usage improves efficiency and reduces the carbon footprint of the hospital Adding in solar and battery storage where possible, including in parking lots, increases renewable energy Including EV charging stations for hospital staff and patients supports the energy transition If using an Energy as a Service model, capital improvements like boiler upgrades and VFDs can be included in the long-term cost.
What’s it all means? While the state has aggressive plans to achieve carbon neutral by 2050, the current in-state electric generation makeup may pose some challenges: Natural gas makes up the lion’s share – and is not going anywhere, regardless of best intentions Solar and wind, while renewable, come with size and weather constraints: • For 1MW of solar, 4 acres of land are needed. EV charging stations add up to an additional 30% to a facility’s electric load
Peninsula Regional Medical Center Salisbury, MD Client goals: Provide patients and staff affordable and sustainable power, especially during weather- Winner of 2019 related outages Association of Energy Engineers, Region 2 Microgrid owner installed a 3.2 MW CHP microgrid system: Energy Project of the Year Two 1,560 kW engines operating at 65% efficiency Load following and island mode capabilities Covers over 81% of the building’s energy needs Carbon footprint reduced by 58% or 16,800 tons per year* 25 kV operating voltage with 3750 kVA step-up transformer Microgrid owner installed a custom thermal solution to connect the CHP system and boiler room: Over 4,000 linear feet of pre-insulated hot water piping with leak detection Pipes routed underground, on the roof, and along walls, with decorative covers Heat exchangers, pumps, valves, and digital controls “By installing the CHP, we achieve both environmental and economic stewardship that is a benefit to our community.” — Dr. Naleppa, President, PRMC 24 *EPA non-baseload emissions data (eGRID 2016)
California Hospital Example Northern California Client goals: Add redundancy to hospital’s existing backup generators, provide resilient power during California rolling blackouts and other long-term utility outages (wildfires, etc) Facility is installing a 420kW CHP-based microgrid system: One 420kW engine operating at 65% efficiency Load following and island mode capabilities Covers over 80% of the building’s energy needs Carbon footprint reduced by 15% or 16,800 tons per year* 25 kV operating voltage with 3750 kVA step-up transformer Other client benefits: Project contracted under an Energy Services Agreement at no capital expense to the client Projected lifetime energy savings of approximately $1.6M Anticipated Y1 electricity cost reductions from a utility cost of $.146 to onsite microgrid cost of $.119/kWh Redundant, reliable power during utility outages 24/7/265 Operational and Monitoring support; no maintenance by client 25
Thank you! Willis McCullough Unison Energy, LLC Director of Strategic Accounts Willis.McCullough@UnisonEnergy.com (704) 634-4071 www.unisonenergy.com
You can also read