PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA

Page created by Carl Rodriguez
 
CONTINUE READING
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
Punjabi Love Story

  A STUDYGUIDE by Marguerite O’Hara

             www.metromagazine.com.au

            www.theeducationshop.com.au
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
Overview               > This is a story about love and marriage, loyalty and
friendship, customs and traditions, set in a place many Australians know little about.
In following the developing relationships between two young couples in the Punjab
region of Pakistan, universal values of love, friendship, family tensions and marriage
are shown against the background of a country where change can be rapid and
sometimes difficult for people of different generations to accept.

Synopsis                                    Narrated by Jocelyn, the story seam-       tween him and the anti-American lobby,
                                            lessly moves from the upstairs to the      now emboldened by their support in

A
        n Australian woman, Joce-           downstairs, from the lounge room into      Parliament. There are daily reports of
        lyn Ortt-Saeed, lives with her      the kitchen. This soap opera of love       Anti-American rallies in Lahore and
        Pakistani husband, Mohammed         affairs and youthful angst happens         Karachi, and ever-growing resentment
Saeed, in their home of many years in       against a backdrop of deep-rooted          against the Presidency. This political
the Husain Sugar Mill, in the Punjab        political change in Pakistan.              unrest adds a new dimension to the
region of Pakistan. Saeed is general                                                   daily life of the Sugar Mill compound.
manager of the sugar mill, and Jocelyn      For the first time in the history of Pa-
has set up a school. Two young people,      kistan, hard-line religious parties have   The Filmmaker:
Nawaz the cook and Mehnaz the maid,         been voted into power in the general       Kay Rasool
look after their house, and live nearby.    elections. The new Government is
                                            sworn into Parliament in December          Kay Rasool graduated in Journalism
The Sugar Mill compound is sur-             2002. Pro-American Military chief Gen-     in 1998 at the University of Technol-
rounded by a high wall, topped with         eral Musharraf is still the President of   ogy, Sydney, and has since produced
barbed wire. The only access is             the Nation, but the struggle erupts be-    and directed several award-winning
through a gate manned by guards,                                                       documentaries in Australia that have
keeping out all but the residents and                                                  screened at major film festivals around
legitimate visitors, making it a world in                                              the world. She is currently developing
itself. Outside these walls is the dusty                                               her first feature film.
and ramshackle town of Jaranwala,
                                                                                                                                 SCREEN EDUCATION

and beyond that, the farms which                                                       Curriculum Links
supply sugarcane to the mill.                                                          Using Punjabi Love Story in
                                                                                       the classroom
Filmed over eighteen months, this
observational documentary captures                                                     This documentary will be of specific
the lives and loves of this household.                                                 interest and relevance to teachers and
                                                                                                                                 
  Punjabi Love Story is an observational documentary written, directed and produced by Kay Rasool. It was filmed in 2002-2003.
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
secondary students from years 7-12              is Pervez Musharraf, Head of               generally 2.5 per cent of the total
studying:                                       Government and Prime Minister is           savings for a rich man working in
                                                Shaukat Aziz.                              trade or industry, and ten or twenty
•   Studies of Society and Environ-         •   With Western borders to Iran and           per cent of the annual produce
    ment (SOSE/HSIE)                            Afghanistan, Pakistan has been             for agriculturists. This money or
•   International Studies                       under pressure from Western                produce is distributed among the
•   Studies of Asia                             countries including America not            poor. Also, one may give twenty-five
•   Cultural Studies                            to allow militants to hide in the          per cent of found treasure such as
•   Political Studies                           country. In some parts of Pakistan         money won in a non-gambling lot-
•   Media Studies                               society, there is strong anti-Ameri-       tery. You must give to the needy.
•   English                                     can feeling, particularly concerning    Fasting (Sawm) – refraining from eating,
•   Religion and Society                        General Musharraf’s perceived              drinking or satisfying sexual needs
                                                close relationship with the Ameri-         from dawn to dusk in the month of
Learning Outcomes                               can government.                            Ramadan, the ninth month in the
                                            •   In October 2005, a massive                 Islamic lunar calendar.
The themes and activities developed             earthquake devastated many areas        The Pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj) – this
in this study guide will have interest          and communities in the North-              is done during the month of Zul
and relevance for students from the             West Province and Kashmir areas.           Hijjah, and is compulsory once in a
junior to senior years of secondary             73,000 people were killed and              lifetime for one who has the ability
school and relate to the following              thousands of families were made            to do it. If the Muslim is in ill health
learning outcomes:                              homeless. A massive relief effort is       or in debt, he or she is not required
                                                still underway to help the people          to perform Hajj.
•   Understanding the core values of            rebuild their towns and lives.
    groups and societies                    •   Australia imports goods from Paki-      Education
•   Exploring the nature of marriage in         stan including fine bed and table
    different cultures and societies            linens, floor coverings, a range of     While boys and girls may attend the
•   Explaining how diverse cultures and         woven textiles and rice.                same school they are generally taught
    groups value family relationships       •   The Punjab region where this            in separate classes.
•   Developing an understanding of              documentary is set produces many
    the changing attitudes towards              crops including wheat, cotton, rice     Women and girls often wear a hijab/
    caste and class in countries such           and sugarcane.                          headdress or veil to cover their face.
    as Pakistan                             •   Until March 2006 there was an           In some Western countries like France,
•   Exploring the roles of women in an          official ban on showing films from      female students are not permitted to
    Islamic society.                            neighbouring India which has an         wear the hijab in government schools,
                                                enormous popular film industry,         or indeed any religious attire that may
Jaranwala, the small town where the             producing amongst others, roman-        be part of their faith. This issue has
story is set, is two hours drive from           tic singing and dancing stories         also been debated in Australia.
Lahore, in the Punjab Region. Lahore            known as Bollywood films.
is a large city south of the capital                                                    Glossary
Islamabad.                                  Understanding religious
                                            and social traditions in                    •   Sufi – a Muslim Holy man, usually
Information about                           Pakistan                                        a mystic
Pakistan                                                                                •   Chapattis – flat bread eaten with
                                            With ninety-six per cent of the popula-         most meals, generally made in
•   Islamabad is the capital city of        tion Muslim, it is helpful when watch-          home kitchens
    Pakistan.                               ing this film to understand the basic       •   Caste – groups often defined and
•   Lahore, a city of 8.5 million people,   beliefs of the people, as they govern           identified by a particular occupa-
    is the provincial capital of the        many aspects of daily life.                     tion. People are expected to mix
    Punjab region.                                                                          and marry within their family caste.
•   Pakistan’s population is 165 million.   The five pillars of Islam are:                  This social system originated in
•   Religion: Ninety-six per cent of        The profession of faith in Allah (Sha-          India but is also still followed in
    population Islamic, four per cent          hadah) – the declaration that there          other countries.
                                                                                                                                      SCREEN EDUCATION

    Christian, Hindu and others.               is none worthy of worship except         •   NGO – non-government organiza-
•   In 1947 the country achieved inde-         Allah and that Muhammad is his               tion, generally involved with health,
    pendence from Great Britain.               messenger.                                   education and welfare
•   Pakistan is an Islamic Republic         Prayer (Salat) – establishing of the five
    with an elected government.                daily Prayers.
•   Head of State and President             The paying of alms (Zakat) – which is
                                                                                                                                      
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
Student
Activity 1

   Before Watching Punjabi Love Story > Read the following questions and
   record your answers. Sharing responses to these questions should assist you to
   understand and respond to some of the issues explored in this documentary.
                                                                                                                            SCREEN EDUCATION

   1. In the words of an old song, do you believe that ‘love    4.   Why do you think women wear the hijab or veil?
      and marriage go together like a horse and carriage’?      5.   Which country has the largest Muslim population?
   2. Do you believe that getting married and having children   6.   Write down five things you know about Pakistan.
      is the most important thing people can do?                7.   What range of educational opportunities do you think
   3. What is your understanding of ‘an arranged marriage’?          are open to women in Pakistan?
                                                                                                                            
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
Student
Activity 2

   Pre-viewing research > Working in small groups, select one of these topics and
   using internet resources, (some of which are referenced at the end of this guide),
   prepare a report for the rest of your class.

   1. Research the recent history of Pakistan over the past         and wife of Saeed
      100 years, explaining how the tensions with neighbour-     Mohammed Saeed – Manager of the local Sugar Mill, hus-
      ing India have developed.                                     band to Jocelyn
   2. What is the West’s current relationship with Pakistan?     Mohammed Nawaz – cook to the Saeed family and sugar
                                                                                                                          SCREEN EDUCATION

   3. Research how the institution of marriage has changed          cane plant worker
      over the past 100 years.                                   Habiba – Nawaz’ wife
                                                                 Mehnaz Anwar – maid to the Saeeds
   The main characters in this story                             Shahzad – Mehnaz’ husband

   Jocelyn Ortt-Saeed – founder/patron of a local school, poet
                                                                                                                          
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
Student
Activity 3

   Running sheet for viewing the program > These questions ask you to look closely
   at the three central relationships in this documentary, between Jocelyn and Saeed,
   between Nawaz and Habiba, and between Mehnaz and Shahzad. The story develops
   over eighteen months. It is narrated by Jocelyn Saeed and moves between the three
   pairs of couples, each relationship and life contrasting with the others.

   As you watch the film, think about        (1) Opening scenes                            and Mehnaz from the scene in
   how being filmed and recorded might                                                     the kitchen of the Saeed house?
   influence the way people behave and       The opening sequence of the film              Do they seem to get on together?
   speak in this film.                       shows the sugar mill in Jaranwala,            What does Nawaz predict for
                                             and then cuts to an Australian woman          Mehnaz from reading her palm?
   Is it possible to be natural, spontane-   singing. We see two young Pakistanis      2. Where does Mehnaz live?
   ous and honest when you know your         arriving at the house. Jocelyn Saeed      3. What do we find out about
   words and actions are being filmed?       then tells us something about her life.       Mehnaz’ mother?
                                                                                       4. What is Mehnaz’s mother’s attitude
   Think about programs you may watch        1. How did she come to be living in           towards her daughter and mar-
   on television, often called ‘reality TV      Pakistan?                                  riage?
   programs’ and consider how the style      2. How long has she been there?           5. How long has Nawaz been work-
   and substance of this film is both        3. How is Jocelyn dressed?                    ing for the Saeeds?
   similar to and different from the more    4. What is her husband Saeed’s job?       6. Where does he live?
   artificially created households we may    5. How many children do Jocelyn and       7. Who is he married to?
   see on Big Brother or Survivor.              Saeed have?                            8. Where does his wife live?
                                             6. How are the two young people,          9. How does Nawaz describe his
   These questions break the film up into       Nawaz and Mehnaz, part of the              marriage?
   ten sections, or episodes. You may           Saeed household?                       10. How much privacy is there for the
   decide to divide your class into small    7. What are their jobs?                       people in the household where
   groups with each group responsible        8. Describe the Saeed’s house and             Habiba lives?
                                                                                                                               SCREEN EDUCATION

   for making notes on a couple of sec-         the grounds and gardens in which       11. How would you respond to the
   tions.                                       it is set.                                 teasing of Habiba that happens
                                                                                           amongst the women?
   You could write catchy titles for each    (2) Nawaz, Mehnaz and their               12. Describe the personalities of
   ‘episode’ which give a flavour of the     families                                      Nawaz and Mehnaz.
   episode, such as ‘(1) Is everything
   sweet at the sugar mill house?’           1. What do we learn about Nawaz                                                   
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
(3) The Saeed’s life                      13. In what sense might the Saeed’s      6. How did you respond to Jocelyn
                                              marriage be described as ‘mixed’?        reading one of her poems at the
1. What is Saeed’s job?                   14. What do you think Jocelyn is hand-       committee meeting? What is the
2. How many workers are there at the          ing out to the compound workers          poem about?
    sugar mill?                               in her living room?                  7. Why do Nawaz and Habiba travel
3. Why did Saeed not retire from                                                       to Lahore with Jocelyn?
    managing the sugar mill?              (4) Mehnaz heartbroken,                  8. How do they spend their time in
4. What do we learn about people’s        Habiba not happy                             Lahore?
    attitudes to President Musharraf                                               9. What do we learn about each of
    from the television news footage?     1. Why is Mehnaz ‘heartbroken’?              their expectations of marriage?
5. What is the immediate background       2. Why can’t she marry Suhail?           10. Why do you think there is an off-
    in world events that might help to    3. How does Nawaz react to Mehnaz’           season in summer at the sugar
    explain the hostility to Musharraf?      news?                                     mill?
    (This is 2002 and Pakistan’s posi-    4. Why is Nawaz’ wife Habiba             11. What is the purpose of the Sufi’s
    tion in the world is difficult both      unhappy?                                  visit to Saeed?
    politically and geographically)       5. The two young women in this story     12. What does Jocelyn’s household do
6. What did Jocelyn say to Saeed             are unhappy for different reasons.        on 11 September 2002?
    in her telegram of 1959? (before         How recognizable and universal
    emails and long-distance phone           are their responses and how far       (6) Mehnaz in love again
    calls, telegrams were the quickest       are they particular to the lives of
    way of contacting people)                young people in Pakistan?             1. Why does Mehnaz’ mother
7. Describe the school Jocelyn                                                        disapprove of her new boyfriend,
    Saeed established. Who attends it     (5) More about marriage;                    Shahzad?
    and how many students are now         Jocelyn and Saeed, Nawaz                 2. What caste does he come from?
    enrolled?                             and Habiba                               3. What caste does Mehnaz’ family
8. Who is Jocelyn meeting off the                                                     belong to?
    train in Lahore?                      1. Where do Jocelyn’s visitors come      4. How do we know how strongly
9. Why are these visitors coming to          from to visit her?                       Mehnaz’ mother is opposed to the
    Jaranwala?                            2. What is the purpose of their visit?      match between her daughter and
10. In what religion were the Saeed       3. How did her marriage to Saeed            Shahzad? What does she threaten
                                                                                                                           SCREEN EDUCATION

    children raised?                         come about?                              to have done?
11. What is Jocelyn Saeed’s religious     4. What type of marriage ceremony        5. Why does Saeed ask Mehnaz and
    background and beliefs?                  did they have?                           Shahzad to leave the compound?
12. What evidence is there that she       5. What is the purpose of the meeting    6. What is Shahzad’s job and finan-
    still observes her own religious         of the Health, Education and Lit-        cial position?
    traditions?                              eracy Committee Jocelyn attends?      7. What was Nawaz’ advice to
                                                                                                                           
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
Mehnaz about how to win                     Habiba. What are some of the dif-      5. What is the atmosphere like when
    Shahzad?                                    ficulties they are facing?                 Nawaz visits Mehnaz and Shahzad
8. Where are Mehnaz and Shahzad             5. What does Nawaz do in response              after their marriage? Why do you
    now living?                                 to Habiba’s claims of ill-treatment        think the social situation seems
9. Which members of Mehnaz’                     at the hands of his family?                awkward between the three?
    immediate family are supportive         6. Why does Nawaz say it is too dif-       6. Why does Shahzad tell Mehnaz to
    of her wish to marry Shahzad and            ficult to have Habiba at the Saeed         put on her veil?
    which are opposed to it? Does this          compound?                              7. What did Mehnaz and Nawaz fight
    indicate a difference in attitudes      7. In response to her uncles’ threats          about when they were both back
    between the generations?                    to attack Mehnaz, where does               working at the Saeed house?
10. Shahzad believes he will eventually         Shahzad take her to live until         8. What was Saeed’s response to
    be accepted by Mehnaz’ mother               things quieten down?                       Mehnaz’ complaints about Nawaz?
    and uncles. He says ‘Why does           8. Why do the Saeeds hire a new            9. Nawaz says he has a reputation
    caste matter so much to you? The            cook and find Nawaz a job at the           for being ‘a ladies’ man’, and that
    world has moved on but not you’.            sugar mill?                                Mehnaz as a working girl is not
    Is this the main problem?               9. What advantages does Nawaz’                 someone he would marry, but
11. Mehnaz’ mother says she will not            sugar mill job have over being the         rather ‘someone to have fun with’.
    visit her younger daughter or have          Saeed’s cook?                              He says that ‘Habiba has led a
    her attend her funeral. What do         10. Why is Habiba happier now?                 restricted life … that’s what we
    you think are the reasons for her       11. What do Mehnaz and Shahzad                 like – someone who is untouched,
    attitude?                                   squabble about?                            not the free ones’. What do these
12. Mehnaz, although she is living with     12. What is the final outcome of               remarks tell us about his attitudes
    Shahzad, says she won’t have a              Mehnaz’ family’s attitude to her           towards women?
    proper wedding until her mother             marriage?                              10. Mehnaz says of her marriage to
    accepts her choice of husband.                                                         Shahzad, ‘I think I’ve done the
                                            (9) Meanwhile back at the                      right thing … now we have to
(7) Jocelyn, Nawaz and                      Saeeds                                         put up with each other, whatever
conflict                                                                                   happens’. What signs are there in
                                            1. Jocelyn tells us about her own              these scenes in the film that their
1. Nawaz talks about the bombings              family’s response to her marriage           marriage will or won’t last?
   in Pakistan and says that ‘Muslims          to Saeed. How did her father refer      11. Saeed and Jocelyn are in Lahore.
   are selling out’. To what is he refer-      to Saeed?                                   He says that people did not believe
   ring?                                    2. Who are Jocelyn’s latest visitors           their marriage would work. What
2. After her swim in the lap pool,             from Australia?                             does Saeed attribute its success
   Jocelyn seems rather cranky with         3. What is her daughter intending to           to? Jocelyn acknowledges that as
   Nawaz, her cook. What are some              do during her visit?                        a poet she is idiosyncratic and can
   of her complaints and criticisms of      4. Jocelyn’s daughter says, ‘I am              be difficult to live with. Yet they
   him?                                        trying to fit into my mother’s              have been together for more than
3. How does Nawaz respond to these             space’. How does this remark                forty years. Why do you think this
   criticisms?                                 contrast with Habiba and Mehnaz’            marriage seems to be so enduring
4. How can we tell that the row                situation with their families?              and happy?
   seems to have blown over?                5. How are the physical circum-
5. Can you imagine being in a                  stances, including space and ame-       Ending
   master/servant relationship? What           nities in their houses, different for
   would be the difficulties on each           each of the three sets of families?     Mehnaz tells us that she is pregnant
   side?                                       In what ways does this matter?          and frames this story by saying ‘we
                                                                                       came together in that house. Now
(8) Troubles for young lovers               (10) The rhythms of marriage,              there’s a film about the story in that
                                            children and changes                       house’. Like many people, the record-
1. What are Mehnaz and Shahzad                                                         ing of this story is important to her
   shopping for in Lahore?                  1. Why does Nawaz want his old job         sense of herself and her place in the
2. What does this trip suggest about           back, as cook for the Saeeds?           world. The film ends with Jocelyn’s
                                                                                                                                  SCREEN EDUCATION

   Mehnaz’ mother’s changing atti-          2. What reason does Nawaz give for         daughter Maryam singing one of her
   tude?                                       his friendship with Shahzad?            mother’s poems, Moon of Memory.
3. Which members of Mehnaz’ family          3. What is the pre-nuptial agreement
   are still opposed to her marriage           Mehnaz has got from Shahzad?            Did you find this ending satisfactory or
   and threatening violence?                4. Why do you think this was impor-        did you want to know more?
4. Nawaz is worried about his wife             tant for her?
                                                                                                                                  
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
Student
Activity 4
   Student Activity 4

   Style and content – deconstructing a film text > The way in which a film is put
   together is important in shaping viewers’ responses to the themes and issues. In
   Punjabi Love Story the filmmaker moves between the three sets of relationships,
   aspects of each mirroring and contrasting with the others. They are all set within the
   world of the Saeed household and the immediate world outside, on the outskirts of
   Jaranwala and in Lahore.

   1. Sometimes the people in this                  ing of people’s lives in this film?      ent in the relationships?
      film seem to be like characters            3. As the film develops, we learn        4. What part does caste and class
      in a soap opera, playing out their            more about Jocelyn and Saeed’s           play in people’s lives in this film?
      own dramas. How far might this                life together in Pakistan, intercut   5. Does the filmmaker make either
                                                                                                                                    SCREEN EDUCATION

      be a consequence of the slightly              with the developing dramas in the        explicit or implicit judgements
      artificial process of filming daily life      lives of two of their employees,         about either the society and/or the
      and love and people’s awareness               Nawaz and Mehnaz. Does this              individuals in this film? Consider
      of being recorded?                            technique of moving between the          what she chooses to film and what
   2. How important is place, context               three sets of families help us to        remains private.
      and background to an understand-              understand the differences appar-
                                                                                                                                    
PUNJABI LOVE STORY - WWW.METROMAGAZINE.COM.AU A STUDYGUIDE BY MARGUERITE O'HARA
Student
Activity 5
   Student Activity 5

   Extension Activities

   1. Imagine you return to Pakistan to         When I was growing up nobody                 I’d say ‘Well, the holy prophet [?] mar-
      see what has happened in these            believed a woman could be Prime              ried a working woman and if he could
      peoples’ lives five years on. Write       Minister, nobody even asked the              marry, the messenger of God could
      the next episode in the story of          question that, Can a woman be Prime          marry a working woman isn’t that an
      one or more of these couples.             Minister? Except for my father who           example for us, and people would
   2. Research the practice of ‘arranged        was always telling me that Nehru, the        just sort of roll up their eyes and say
      marriages’. Are they any more or          Indian leader, his daughter became           ‘Be realistic - where does it happen?’
      less likely to endure, be happy           Prime Minister, my daughter’s going          but I’ve always have this deep faith
      or end in divorce than marriages          to become Prime Minister too. I’d say        in me that I would win. And I always
      where individuals choose their            ‘No papa, I’m not going into politics’       tell people that if you want to succeed
      partner more freely?                      and he’d say ‘Yes you are’ and nobody        remember two things: reach for the
   3. ‘A bit of sweet, a bit of sour. There’s   else ever believed that a woman could        stars and be persistent. And I believe
      some arguments in every home.’            ever become Prime Minister. When             it. That’s my prescription for life, that
      (Shahzad). Does the secret to             my father was killed that’s what peo-        one must reach for the star and that
      a happy marriage lie in working           ple said. Particularly in the military.      one must never be dismayed by a
      through arguments, in compromise?         There’s no way that a male dominated         setback but being a woman was more
   4. Choosing a partner with whom to           society like Pakistan, entrenched in         of a threat to my society than I had
      live is one of the most important         it’s traditions, is ever going to vote for   ever imagined. I’d done politics with
      choices many people make all over         a woman and that too a young one.            people who were liberal, who were
      the world. How do people learn            I’d have people telling me ‘Why don’t        enlightened in the Pakistan People’s
      how to make these choices and             you get married and settle down’, I’d        Party. However, when I became Prime
      what part does luck play in getting       have relatives tell me that, I’d have        Minister I entered a whole new world.
      them right?                               friends tell me that ‘Why don’t you          I found from the Mosques sermons
   5. What opportunities do Mehnaz and          get married and settle down, what is         that were given that Pakistan has been
      Nawaz have for expanding their            all this politics?’, ‘When Zia goes you      thrown out of the pail of Islam because
      educational opportunities?                can’t come because of (a) the military       a woman has been elected and every
   6. In the three ‘marriages’ shown in         won’t accept you, (b) you are too            Muslim is pained and has to rise and
      this film, is the male the dominant       young, people don’t - I was, anyway,         revolt before Pakistan can come back
      partner who makes the choices?            under thirty - you were too young and        into the Islamic fold. I had had my
      Look carefully at how these people        you’re a woman so why don’t you let          opponents in the election saying that
                                                                                                                                          SCREEN EDUCATION

      relate to one another.                    the men do it, why do you want to go         anybody who voted for me would
   7. Many women in Pakistan do not             to jail, why do you want to suffer. So       have their marriage dissolved. So it
      enjoy the same rights that women          all the time I was told that the decks       was just an amazing phenomenon to
      in other countries have. Read the         are stacked and that a woman can’t           come against a wall of hate. A wall
      following extract about women in          - it’s never happened in the Muslim          of hate, that was built just on the fact
      Pakistan.                                 world, where has it happened? And            that I was a woman and seen want-
                                                                                                                                         10
ing a man’s job and then I became             Men, Women, and the Division of              people consider a woman – and her
Prime Minister, the Chief of the Military     Space                                        family – to be shameless if no restric-
received me without a hat and people                                                       tions are placed on her mobility.
said that’s because we can’t salute a         Gender relations in Pakistan rest on two
woman Prime Minister. It was just ...         basic perceptions: that women are sub-       Source: http://www.islamfortoday.
I had been brought up by father who           ordinate to men, and that a man’s honor      com/pakistanwomen.htm
believed and taught me to have faith          resides in the actions of the women of
in myself. Who taught that men and            his family. Thus, as in other orthodox       •   To what extent are some of these
women were equal. Who, through                Muslim societies, women are responsi-            constraints on women apparent in
my religious education, taught me             ble for maintaining the family honor. To         the film?
that my religion proclaimed equality of       ensure that they do not dishonor their
men and women and I did my poli-              families, society limits women’s mobility,   References
tics amongst a group of enlightened           places restrictions on their behavior and
people who believed the same but              activities, and permits them only limited    Books
when I began to run for Prime Minister,       contact with the opposite sex. Space is
and I actually became Prime Minster,          allocated to and used differently by men     Bapsi Sidhwa: This young Pakistani
I came across a total wall of hate and        and women. For their protection and             woman has published four novels
since then I’ve come to the conclusion        respectability, women have tradition-           in the 1990s, all written in Eng-
that my most important identity is as a       ally been expected to live under the            lish. They are The Pakistani Bride,
woman because at the end of it, if you        constraints of purdah (purdah is Persian        Cracking India (adapted for screen
take away the politics and the political      for curtain), most obvious in veiling. By       as Water), Croweaters and The
affiliations and everyone takes away          separating women from the activities of         American Brat.
the family affiliations, at the basic point   men, both physically and symbolically,
one becomes a woman. Not just a               purdah creates differentiated male and       Films
person but a different type of person,        female spheres. Most women spend
the male person and the female per-           the major part of their lives physically     Few films made in Pakistan about the
son, and that’s how I see my identity         within their homes and courtyards and           lives of ordinary Pakistanis have
now - as a woman.                             go out only for serious and approved            been shown in the West. In 2006 a
                                              reasons. Outside the home, social life          government ban on showing films
                                                                                                                                       SCREEN EDUCATION

Benazir Bhutto in 1998, after she had         generally revolves around the activities        from neighbouring India in Paki-
been twice deposed from the prime             of men. In most parts of the country,           stan was lifted. India has a thriving
ministership of Pakistan.                     except perhaps in Islamabad, Karachi,           film industry.
                                              and wealthier parts of a few other cities,   Water, the third film in a trilogy by

                                                                                                                                      11
Deepa Mehta, is now able to be            http://coombs.anu.edu.au/                        Human Rights Watch site detailing
   seen in Pakistan. The second film             WWWVL-AsianStudies.html                      treatment of women in Pakistan
   in this trilogy, Earth, is a love story       (Accessed 6 April 2006)                  http://web.amnesty.org/library/Index/
   encompassing conflicting religions            Extensive Australian-based directory         engASA330181999
   and politics between India and                of websites related to Asia.                 (Accessed 5 April 2006)
   Pakistan. Water is available for          http://www.pakpositive.                          Amnesty International Report on the
   general release. It is about the plight       com/2006/01/11/karachi                       lives of women in Pakistan
   of widows in India in the 1930s, who          -matchmakers-reveal-changing             http://www.islamfortoday.com/
   often lived in poverty and, without a         -marriage-trends/                            pakistanwomen.htm
   husband, had nowhere to live and              (Accessed 7 April 2006)                      (Accessed 5 April 2006)
   were dependent on charity.                    This site features positive stories          An account of the changing status
                                                 about life in Pakistan, and has some         of women in Pakistan.
Useful websites                                  interesting stories about women and
                                                 marriage.                                Marguerite O’Hara is a freelance writer
http://www.asiaeducation.edu.au/             http://www.infopak.gov.pk/                   from Melbourne
    voices/citizen.htm                           (Accessed 7 April 2006)
    (Accessed 5 April 2006)                      Official government site including       Punjabi Love Story is distributed by
    Information and activities for teach-        information about the geography,         Ronin Films in Australia and New Zea-
    ers and students about citizenship           economy, government, culture and         land.
    in Pakistan                                  news of Pakistan.                        PO Box 1005, Civic Square, ACT 2608
http://www.askasia.org/                      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pakistan        Tel (02) 6248 0851 Fax (02) 6249 1640
    (Accessed 5 April 2006)                      (Accessed 5 April 2006)
    Curriculum resources on Asia.                Information about Pakistan’s history,
http://www.asiasource.org/                       geography, culture and political life.
    (Accessed 6 April 2006)                  http://www.hrw.org/reports/1999/
    Comprehensive listing of online cur-         pakistan/
    rent affairs articles related to Asia.       (Accessed 5 April 2006)                  Prodcution Company Zara Films

          This study guide was produced by ATOM
                      editor@atom.org.au
       For more information on Screen Education
     magazine or to download other free study guides visit
                  www.metromagazine.com.au
       For hundreds of articles on Film as Text, Screen
        Literacy, Multiliteracy and Media Studies, visit
                 www.theeducationshop.com.au
      Notice: An educational institution may make copies of all or part of this Study Guide, provided that it only
      makes and uses copies as reasonably required for its own educational, non-commercial, classroom pur-
                                     poses and does not sell or lend such copies.
                                                                                                                                     SCREEN EDUCATION

                                                                                                                                    12
You can also read