Paying the Iron Price? - Exploring the tourism potential of Game of Thrones for Northern Ireland Matthew Kearney, University of Ulster Peter ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Paying the Iron Price? Exploring the tourism potential of Game of Thrones for Northern Ireland Matthew Kearney, University of Ulster Peter Bolan, University of Ulster Karla Boluk, University of Waterloo
Introduction ‘Different roads sometimes lead to the same castle’ (Martin, 1996, 362). If that castle is tourism success through the medium of film and television, then which road should we take? Which road will lead us there in an efficient and safe/sustainable manner? The aim of this paper is to investigate the potential that ‘Game of Thrones’ could create for Northern Ireland if positioned appropriately as a television/film tourism destination. The investigation of potential opportunities for destination development and enhancement through global online research, mainly netnography, undertaken with the fan-base of the show, as well as exploring best practice from a well-established film tourism destination New Zealand. This is further supplemented with analysis of key informant interviews conducted with a number of industry stakeholders who have recently begun Game of Thrones tours and activity based experiences. The paper will proceed with a review on the film tourism phenomenon and the growth of the film and television industry in Northern Ireland before examining the key findings under study. The film tourism phenomenon Kim and Richardson (2003, 218) note that ‘Motion pictures are an important element of popular culture. They impact on many people in a short period and few would deny that movie-going is a major activity throughout the world’. As watching films (at the cinema, and through television, DVD, blu-ray and digital download) is part of popular culture on a global basis its ability to influence people is wide-reaching and potentially enormous in its scope and impact. This is supported by Hudson and Ritchie (2006, 257) who state ‘a typical movie with international distribution can now reach over one hundred million consumers as it moves from box office, DVD to television’. Whilst awareness of films influencing tourism and by extension the study of such is relatively new, film has always had an intrinsic connection to travel. From the earliest times film has had such a connection. ‘Lumiere’s films of natural vistas extended film into the realm of travel, connected to practices of mobility and taxonomy found in the discourse of colonialism’ (Friedberg, 1993, cited in Harbord, 2002, 22). As early as the late 19th and early 20th centuries the power of the medium was becoming evident. Film-induced tourism or screen tourism can be defined as ‘. . . tourist visits to a destination or attraction as a result of the destination being featured on television, video, DVD or the cinema screen’ (Hudson and Ritchie, 2006, p. 256). Today we can add to this the formats of blu-ray and digital download as yet further ways in which people engage with and consume their film and television. A growing body of evidence from authors such as Busby and Haines (2013), Hudson et al. (2011), Heitmann (2010), Hudson and Ritchie (2006), Beeton (2005), Tzanelli (2004), Grihault (2003), Riley et al. (1998), Tooke & Baker (1996) and Butler (1990) support this phenomenon of tourists visiting particular destinations because of their association with particular films and television shows. According to Bolan et al. (2011, 105) ‘National Tourist Organisations (NTO’s) while slow to acknowledge this are now beginning to recognise that movies and television shows can enhance awareness of their locale and affect the tourist’s decision-making process’. Marketers and those involved in destination branding in some destinations are therefore increasingly working with film bodies to help promote their destinations. Film production in the UK contributes over £4.6 billion to UK GDP and supports over 117,000 jobs (up from 100,000 in 2009). The UK film industry directly employs almost 44,000 people (up from 36,000 in 2009). Most notably in relation to this study films depicting the UK are responsible for generating around a 10th of overseas tourism revenues, with estimates that around £2.1 billion of visitor spend a year is attributable to UK film (Oxford Economics, 2012). This is echoed around the world. In New Mexico film tourism is estimated to be worth $124 million
to the economy, whilst in Sweden, the media coverage gained from the Millennium films has been calculated at some EUR 106 million (Connell, 2012). The majority of film tourism studies since 2002 have made at least some mention of ‘The Lord of the Rings’ (LOTR). The film trilogy which began with ‘The Fellowship of the Ring’ in 2001 was based on J.R.R. Tolkien’s famous novel. Director Peter Jackson brought to the cinema screen what many had thought to be un-filmable and produced a series of movies which received popularity and acclaim from film critics and the cinema-going public alike. New Zealand was the filming location which was used to represent the fictional setting of ‘Middle-earth’ where the fantasy story takes place. Research carried out by Tourism New Zealand in 2004 surveying over 2 million tourists revealed the financial value of those tourists stating LOTR was their main or only reason to visit was estimated to be NZ$32.8 million (Tourism NZ, International Visitors Survey, 2004). Clearly, a huge economic impact directly from the film for the New Zealand economy, not to mention those who were also partly influenced by the movies, even if it was not a main motivational reason. According to Carl et al. (2007, 49) ‘The representation of New Zealand’s landscapes in the films of The Lord of the Rings (LOTR) has led to the construction of new tourism spaces, thus, new landscapes of pleasure tailor-made for film tourists’ consumption’. Jones and Smith (2005, 924) not only support these views on the tourism success from the film trilogy but go further in remarking that ‘The LOTR project has become the poster child for a new kind of New Zealand national identity’. In other words not only did the films boost tourism to New Zealand, the effect actually went deeper and created a view of New Zealanders as creative, entrepreneurial and filled with ingenuity. The intention of this paper is to investigate if ‘Game of Thrones’ could create a similar effect for Northern Ireland. Methodology The study took an interpretivist approach, employing qualitative methods of enquiry to examine critical factors at play with regard to the Game of Thrones fan base and the views of industry stakeholders in Northern Ireland who are now using association with the television show to attract tourists. Netnography was employed as a key technique to obtain opinions and feelings of a qualitative nature from the fan-base of the television show. Specifically, the methodology utilised the online observation strand of Netnography as discussed by Veer (2013), whereby data from publicly accessible, online forums was viewed and analysed. According to Kozinets (2002), Netnography is the research method of choice with regards to studying online communities, and in particular, understanding meanings that they derive from their shared experiences and consumption practices. Kozinets (2010) highlights five key reasons that make netnography ideal for interpretive, qualitative research. Namely, netnography is natural in that it allows you to encounter these communities of consumption where they have come to be of their own accord. This also allows netnography to remain true to one of the central tenets of ethnography itself (Willis & Trondman, 2000). Kozinets (2010) goes on to state that netnography is also immersive and descriptive – that successful netnographic research will provide rich, dense datasets for the analysis of consumption patterns and practices within the communities in question. Finally, he highlights the practical advantages of netnography due to the fact that it allows (and encourages) mixed method approaches, and that it is adaptable. Online observation also offers the advantage that it is an unmediated way of collecting data. As the researchers do not have direct contact with the bloggers there is no opportunity to influence the responses, which contributes to the reliability and validity of the data collected.
Given the focus of ethnography (and by extension, netnography) on being a theory-focussed research method (Willis & Trondman, 2000), grounded theory has been utilised for the analysis of the data in this research project. Specifically, a combination of classic (Glaser & Strauss, 1967) and constructivist (Charmaz, 2000) grounded theory has been utilised in order to provide the greatest understanding of the consumption experiences and demands of the community in question – namely Game of Thrones fans. Pettigrew (2000), building most notably on the work of Belk (1987; 1988) who advocated the greater study of the entire consumption experience, argues that the naturalistic and theory-driven nature of the two methodologies (ethnography and grounded theory) means that they can be utilised with one another to great success. Specifically, ethnography provides the rich, descriptive dataset for which grounded theory is best suited to explore, with the ultimate aim of developing a theory based on the issue in question. Research Design Early in the research design process, a number of leading Game of Thrones forums were identified for netnographic analysis. The forums were chosen based on a number of factors including the frequency of posts by members, the number of posts on the forum, and the level of discussion amongst members. Online observation (Veer, 2013) of these forums then took place over a number of months. As key discussion themes became apparent to the researcher, these were used for first-stage coding in the grounded theory analysis. Following this, axial coding took place to establish links between the aforementioned themes, before further analysis eventually led to a theory of what Game of Thrones fans want from a tourism experience. The approach was also iterative in nature, whereby particular forums, discussions, or posts were re-examined in light of new information that had become apparent through the coding process. Whilst the netnographic study was taking place, primary research was also carried out on key stakeholders within the Northern Ireland tourism industry, including GTO’s and tourism activity providers. This qualitative research was conducted using depth interviews with the parties involved to gain a greater understanding of what they currently offered these tourists, what they could potentially offer them, and what they would hope to gain from such activities. The findings from these two strands of research were then combined to offer a theory about the tourism demands of Game of Thrones fans, and the feasibility of making such an offering in a sustainable manner, within Northern Ireland. Research Findings Location – Northern Ireland as Westeros The development of Game of Thrones for television began in 2007 with Northern Ireland chosen as the main location for filming; commencing in 2009. According to the GOT Location Manager ‘Northern Ireland provides a wealth of dramatic scenery that really fits with what HBO wanted for Game of Thrones ... the forests and the historic places like Castle Ward were perfect for Winterfell .... the spectacular coastlines and beaches were an ideal fit for what we needed in season two and season three for the Iron Islands etc’. The opinions and expectations of the fans The blogging activity by Game of Thrones fans mediate between the similarities and differences between the books and the television adaptation. The blogs demonstrated that the show was inclusive as people from all walks of life could find something appealing to
captivate their attention. Such inclusion created adoration among fans; a connection to the story line, its place, meanings and/or set/costume design and the unique food presented. Consequently, fans expressed intense feelings in their posts demonstrating their connection/attachment with characters and sometimes an obsessive interest in the show as shocking story lines unravelled and surprised international audiences. One blogger had this to say ‘I love every character in this series, they make viewers glued to the next scene and wait in awe with every blow’ (female, India, Blog 1). Another blogger put it like this ‘EastEnders will always have my heart but Game of Thrones is deep, it’s heartfelt. I’ve always liked Medieval films; all knights and swords before guns…it’s proper man stuff (male, Blog 3). Some particularly shocking Game of Thrones episodes created a heighted interest among fans to blog. One memorable episode was titled the ‘Red Wedding’ which resulted in a number of powerful responses expressed by fans demonstrating the emotive connection between fan and show. For example, “I've never cried so hard. I hate Game of Thrones right now. I don't know if I'll ever recover from this” (female, Blog 2). Similarly, another fan said this, “I wanted to tweet five minutes ago about watching this weeks game of thrones. BUT I COULDN'T BECAUSE I WAS SOBBING AN OCEAN OF TEARS” (female, Blog 2). The ‘Red Wedding’ episode caused so much shock that one fan confessed that she was “having a deep Game of Thrones-related depression and psychological distress (female, Blog 2). Whilst a male fan admitted, “IVE NEVER FELT SO HEART BROKEN OVER A FICTIONAL FAMILY. GAME OF THRONES QUIT PLAYING GAMES WITH MY HEART, DAMN YOU!” (male, June 3rd, 2013, Blog 2). Consequently, the comments presented similar discourses by the fans and demonstrate that they are true fans, significantly affected by the storylines and continually shocked by some of the outcomes. Seemingly, they await the next disappointment. Interestingly, in the final depiction illustrated above, the fan explains that he is fully aware that Game of Thrones is fictional however this knowledge does not lessen the shock and emotive surprise. Clearly, what the comments highlighted above indicate is that there is an international cult-like following of Game of Thrones and harnessing this could create and strengthen a variety of Game of Thrones tourism products in Northern Ireland. Trying to make sense of characters and philosophy Some fans demonstrated an interest in interrogating the complex characters presented in Game of Thrones. For instance, “I disagree with Danerys' character being complicated. She comes across as stereotypical delusional do-gooder. George R. R. Martin knows that and having read the books I am not surprised at where she is headed, post season 3” (male, India, Blog 1). In the third season entitled ‘Crowdsurfing’ one fan reflected on the broader social messages of the television show. For instance, “I think the creators of this world are trying to tell a story about statesmanship, justice, and what it takes to be a good king, a good queen, a good lord. The game we've been watching will end when someone manages to rule Westeros wisely and well (male, June 10, 2013, Blog 4). The interrogation of the meaning of the books and television series could possibly be integrated into a tourism product via trivia and scattered puzzels on a Game of Thrones site trail, similar to the notion of geocaching. Perhaps there could be a final stop where all of the puzzles collected could be realised and a traditional ceremony could follow. Costume, Hair and Set Design Several blogs were found to discuss the intricate costumes designed with hand embroidery, the sophisticated hair styles and set designs. As such, some fans were keen to explore how the costumes assisted in the story development revealing ‘devious’ and ‘demented’ characters (Greenfield, 2014). Michele Clapton, the costume designer had the goal of presenting a
‘fantasy reality’ to fans (Greenfield, 2014). For example one blogger posted ‘ How fascinating! Clapton is clearly very good at her craft and takes great care to present these characters so thoroughly’ (female, Blog 5, April 2014). 130 comments were made on a blog focused on the embroidery of the costume designer Michele Clapton. Most of the posts identified that many of the fans were not aware of the time and effort that went into creating the costumes, as well as the fine detail on some of the costumes. One fan said for instance, ‘these are blowing my mind. There are so many tiny things that never come across on camera but together they make the world so much more detailed’ (female, February 15, 2014, Blog 7). Other bloggers similarly stated ‘I actually feel guilty not having noticed it (the costumes) while watching’ and ‘It makes me wonder what other details I’ve missed’. Furthermore, one fan pointed out “I would totally wear Margery' dress. I love unusual wedding gowns. I am bored at the standard wedding dress. My own wedding dress was white but was covered with grape leave lace. So Margery's style is right up my alley” (female, April 20, 2014, Blog 6). Perhaps an interest in seeing the costumes worn by the characters on the television screen could create an opportunity for product development in Northern Ireland. A tour of the HBO set including an opportunity to view and/or possibly try on the costumes may create an appeal of potential Game of Thrones travellers. Aesthetics was a significant theme in the various posts by Game of Thrones fans. Another interest put forth by fans in their on-line blogs was the interest in the food eaten by the characters. Food A number of blogs were recognised to highlight the authenticity and creativity brought to the television series as a result of the food prepared and eaten by the characters. ‘The Inn at the Crossroads’ was widely referred to by bloggers as a significant reference in aiding with recipe ideas. As a result fans were keen to try the various medieval and contemporary recipes. The interest in the food presented in Game of Thrones resulted in two cook books written by the same author as the ‘Inn at the Crossroads’ website. The first was an ebook entitled Game of Thrones Party Planning Guide (Monroe-Cassel, 2013). The contents of the book prepared the reader to plan a medieval event providing ideas and instructions for decorating, invitations, menus and activities. The second book was deemed the official cook book including a forward by the author of the Game of Thrones books George R.R. Martin (Monroe-Cassell and Lehrer, 2012). A number of bloggers described their excitement in attempting key dishes in for example France, United States and India. Others described their developments in planning and organising themed parties. One blogger had this to say; We’re planning a premiere party for Season 2 on Sunday and we’re using a whole bunch of your recipes. I think I’m going to dress up as a Ghiscari (minus the funky hair, unless I can find a suitable wig) to look appropriately fantastical when I serve the food. Thanks so much for creating this fabulous cookbook! (Female, Indian, March 27, 2012, Blog 9). Another blogger said, Our group split up the cooking and baking, and our menu was: Bread & Salt, Chestnut Soup, Sansa Salad, Oatbread, Spiced Squash, Honeyed Chicken, Pease Pie, Beef & Bacon Pie, Candied Ginger, Roman Sweets, Lemon Cakes {altered recipe}, and of course, Weirwood Cake {I tried, but your artistic skills couldn’t be matched!}. Everything was divine! My co-hostess and I also went all out and decorated the apartment, printed out the menus on vellum paper and sealed them with wax, and gave out chalices full of candied ginger as parting gifts. A good friend printed out
GoT inspired wine labels, one for the “Dornish Red”, and another for the “Arbor Gold”. Aside from themed parties some parents posted their intent to cook the various recipes for their families. For example, “my kids will love it I’m going to be happy out making […] and enjoying these meals. Thanks for having them posted” (Female, April 17, 2011, Blog 10). Another fan said this, “It is quite a bit of work, but we love projects, and the reward of delicious food is really terrific. You should definitely give the honeyed chicken a go; it’s received rave reviews at our house and many others”! (male, May 1, 2011, Blog 10). Ultimately, the Game of Thrones books and television series have demonstrated that there is a sizeable fan based that has been recognised by the media. The blog analysis has established that the cult-like following are keen and developing specific Game of Thrones products could help to target the market and turn the international fans of the books and television series into visiting tourists. The Game of Thrones tourist Drawing these various themes together, a clear picture of the Game of Thrones tourist begins to present itself. They are a passionate and demanding tourist who seeks an experience situated at the crossroads between experiential tourism, fandom and fantasy-inspired escapism. They wish to enjoy an experience that fully immerses them in the fantasy world to which the have become accustomed through the books, television series’ and community engagement (in this case, online forums). They demand activities and experiences that require a high level of effort – thus matching their emotional commitment to the romantic & moving fantasy of the story itself. They also demand authenticity, and will not settle for an experience that does not stand up to the scrutiny of their understanding of the series. Smith (2006) would identify these tourists as escapists, whereby they seek active activities that fully immerse them in the experience. The potential for offerings to escapist tourists is at its highest when the providers can support the experience with a strong, consistent theme or message; given the popularity of the Game of Thrones series, this consistent message or theme is already present. Bonnichsen (2011) explains that those consumers who utilise such all-encompassing experiences do so for reasons that extend far beyond simply being entertained. Consumers who have such deeply rooted shared experiences, and who have invested such large amounts of capital – financial, emotional, and social capital – begin to view these activities as an extension of their own self-identity, and not merely activities for entertainment’s sake. These consumers therefore make for deeply committed customers, which carries with it obvious business implications. It does mean however that they will demand much richer experiences from the tourism provider.
Reference List Beeton, S. (2006) Understanding Film-Induced Tourism. Tourism Analysis, Vol. 11, No. 3, pp.181-188. Beeton, S., Bowen, HE. & Santos, CA. (2006) State of Knowledge: Mass Media and Its Relationship to Perceptions of Quality, in Jennings, G. & Nickerson, N.P. (eds) Quality Tourism Experiences, Oxford: Elsevier Butterworth Heinemann. Beeton, S. (2005) Film-Induced Tourism, Clevedon: Channel View Publications. Bolan, P., Boyd, S. & Bell, J. (2011) We’ve seen it in the Movies, let’s see if it’s true: Authenticity and Displacement in Film-induced Tourism. Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes, Vol. 3, No. 2, pp. 124-135. Belk, R. W. (1987). "ACR Presidential Address: Happy Thought." Advances in Consumer Research, eds. Melanie Wallendorf and Paul Anderson. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 14: 1-4. Belk, R. W. (1988). "Possessions and the Extended Self." Journal of Consumer Research 15(2): 130-168. Bolan, P. & O’Connor, N. (2008) Creating a sustainable brand for Northern Ireland through film induced tourism. Tourism, Culture & Communication, Vol. 8, No. 3, pp. 147-158. Bolan, P. & Williams, L. (2008) The role of image in service promotion : focusing on the influence of film on consumer choice within tourism. International Journal of Consumer Studies, Vol. 32, No.4, pp. 382-390. Bonnichsen, H. (2011): Cosplay – Creating, or playing identities? An analysis of the role of cosplay in the minds of its fans. Stockholm University. Available at: http://www.diva- portal.org/smash/get/diva2:424833/FULLTEXT01.pdf Buchmann, A. (2010) Panning and Development in Film Tourism: Insights into the Experience of Lord of the Rings Film Guides, Tourism and Hospitality Planning & Development, Vol. 7, No. 1, pp. 77-84. Busby, G. & Haines, C. (2013) Doc Martin and film tourism: The creation of destination image. Tourism, Vol. 61, No. 2, pp. 105-120. Busby, G., & Klug, J. (2001) Movie-induced tourism: the challenge of measurement and other issues. Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol. 7, No.4, pp. 316-332. Butler, R. (2011) It’s only make believe: the implications of fictional and authentic locations in films. Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes, Vol. 3, No. 2, pp. 91-101. Butler, R. (1990) The Influence of the Media in Shaping International Tourist Patterns, Tourism Recreation Research, Vol 15(2), pp. 46-53. Carl, D., Kindon, S. & Smith, K. (2007) Tourists experiences of Film Locations: New Zealand as Middle-Earth. Tourism Geographies, Vol. 9, No.1. pp. 49-63. Charmaz, K. (2000). Grounded theory: Objectivist and constructivist methods. In N.K. Denzin & Y.S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research (2nd ed., pp. 509–535). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Connell, J. (2013) Film tourism - Evolution, progress and prospects. Tourism Management, 33 (4), 1007-1029. Croy, W. G. (2010) Planning for Film Tourism: Active Destination Image Management. Tourism and Hospitality Planning and Development, Vol. 7, No. 1, pp. 21-30. Friedberg, A. (1993) Window Shopping: Cinema and the Postmodern. Berkeley: University of California Press. Glaser, B.G. & Strauss, A. Discovery of Grounded Theory. Strategies for Qualitative Research. Sociology Press, 1967 Grihault, N. (2003) Film Tourism – The Global Picture. Travel and Tourism Analyst, October, pp. 1-21. Harbord, J. (2002) Film Cultures. London: Sage Publications. Hudson, S. (2011) Working together to leverage film tourism: collaboration between the film and tourism industries. Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes, Vol. 3, No. 2, pp. 165-172. Hudson, S. & Ritchie, JRB. (2006) Promoting Destinations via Film Tourism: An Empirical Identification of Supporting Marketing Initiatives. Journal of Travel Research, Vol. 44, May, pp. 387-396. Iso-Ahola, S.E. (1982) Toward a Social Psychological Theory of Tourism Motivation: A Rejoinder. Annals of Tourism Research, Vol. 9, pp. 256-262. Jones, D. & Smith, K. (2005) Middle-earth Meets New Zealand: Authenticity and Location in the Making of The Lord of the Rings. Journal of Management Studies, Vol. 42, No. 5, pp. 923-945. Kim, H. & Richardson, S. (2003) Motion Picture Impacts on Destination Images. Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 30, No 1, pp. 216 – 37. Kozinets, R. V. (2002) The Field Behind the Screen: Using Netnography for Marketing Research in Online Communities. Journal of Marketing Research: February 2002, Vol. 39, No. 1, pp. 61-72. Kozinets, R. V. (2010). Netnography: The Marketer’s Secret Weapon, How Social Media Understanding Drives Innovation. http://info.netbase.com/wp-netnography.html?o=direct Lefebvre, M. (Ed.). (2006) Landscape and film. London: Routledge. Martin, G.R.R. (1996) Game of Thrones: Book One of A Song of Fire and Ice. London: Harper Collins. Oxford Economics (2012) The Economic Impact of the UK Film Industry (supported by the UK Film Council & Pinewood Shepperton plc), Oxford: UK.
O’Connor, N., Flanagan, S., & Gilbert, D. (2008) The integration of film-induced tourism and destination branding in Yorkshire, UK. International Journal of Tourism Research, 10, 423-437. Papatheodorou, A. (2001) Why People Travel to Different Places. Annals of Tourism Research, Vol. 28, No. 1, pp. 164-179. Pettigrew, S. (2000), “Ethnography and grounded theory: a happy marriage?”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 27, pp. 256-60 Riley, R.W., Baker D & Van Doren, C.S. (1998) Movie Induced Tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, Vol. 25, No 4, pp. 919-935. Shepherd, R. (2003) Fieldwork Without Remorse: Travel Desires in a Tourist World. Consumption, Markets and Culture, Vol. 6, No. 2, pp. 133-144. Smith, W. L. (2006) Experiential Tourism around the World and at Home: Definitions and Standards. International Journal of Services and Standards, Vol. 2, pp. 1-14 Tzanelli, R. (2004) Constructing the ‘Cinematic Tourist’: the sign industry of the Lord of the Rings. Tourist Studies, 4(1), 21-42. Willis, P., & Trondman, M. (2000). Manifesto for ethnography. Ethnography, 1, 5–16.
You can also read