Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...

Page created by Anita Williams
 
CONTINUE READING
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
Barbriefs
Louisville Bar Association                                      October 2021

                     Not all “months” begin on the 1st.
        What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown
           into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month—a
         commemoration from September 15 to October 15 that
     celebrates the histories, cultures and contributions of citizens
            of Hispanic origin to America’s national heritage.

                                                              This Paper is 100% Recyclable
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
CONTENTS

                                                                                                                                          FEATURES
                         VOLUME 21, NO. 10

                             Editorial Offices:                                                                                                 7
                      600 W. Main Street, Ste. 110
                       Louisville, KY 40202-4917
                                                                                                                  Geospatial Data and Employee Privacy:
             Phone: (502) 583-5314 • Fax: (502) 583-4113                                                        What do Kentucky Employers Need to Know?
                admin@loubar.org • www.loubar.org
                                                                                                       Employees currently have few privacy protections from employers who use technology
          Shannon Greer                  Kimberly E. Kasey                                                                    to track their activities or productivity.
           Managing Editor                 Graphic Designer                                                                            By Alexandra Dunn

    Editorial Board
    Bruce A. Brightwell, chair        Anne K. Guillory
                                                                                                                                                12
    Bonita K. Black                   Lindsy Lopez                                                               COVID-19, Labor Shortages and Reasonable
    Courtney L. Baird                 Kristin E. McCall                                                             Accommodations under the ADA
    Dorothy J. Chambers               Charles E. Ricketts Jr.
                                                                                           As they struggle to maintain a workforce during the pandemic, some employers may be required to provide
                                                                                                        reasonable accomodations to qualified applicants and employees with disabilities.
                                                                                                                      By Calesia Henson, Paul Goatley & Amy Miles
    Louisville Bar Association Board of Directors
    Deena G. Ombres — President
    Seth A. Gladstein — President-Elect
    Kate Lacy Crosby — Vice President & Treasurer
    Bryan R. Armstrong — Secretary
    Peter H. Wayne IV — Past President

    M. Beth Anderson                 Caroline G. Meena
    Colleen English Balderson        Anuj G. Rastogi
    Bonita K. Black                  Hon. Shelley M. Santry
    Thomas C. Gleason
    Jennifer Ward Kleier
                                     Aleah Schutze
                                     Thomas B. Simms
                                                                         Departments
    Hon. Angela McCormick Bisig — Jefferson Circuit Court                6   Public Service
    Amy D. Cubbage — KBA Vice President
    Kate A. Dunnington — Women Lawyers Association
                                                                             Thanks to our Back to School Drive Participants!
    Maria A. Fernandez — ABA House of Delegates
    Hon. Lori Goodwin — Jefferson Family Court                           8   Legal Aid Society
    Ashlea Nicole Hellmann — Young Lawyers Section                           A Very Pro Booono Halloween
    Demetrius Holloway — National Bar Association
    Theresa Men — UofL School of Law
    Michael J. O’Connell — Jefferson County Attorney
    Susan D. Phillips — KBA Board of Governors

                                                                                                                                                      5
    John E. Selent — LBF President
    Lars S. Smith — Interim Dean, UofL School of Law                     In this issue
    Leo G. Smith — Louisville Metro Public Defender
    J. Tanner Watkins — KBA Board of Governors                           4   Jeopardy Category Potpourri – Jury Trials are Back
    Hon. Erica Lee Williams — Jefferson District Court                       By Chief Judge Angela McCormick Bisig
    Thomas B. Wine — Jefferson County Commonwealth’s Attorney

    Kent Wicker — Counsel                                                9   Call for Papers
    James B. Martin Jr. — Tax Counsel                                        Mental Health and the Legal Profession Symposium
    D. Scott Furkin — Executive Director
                                                                         14 Classifieds
    Louisville Bar Foundation Board of Directors                         15 Members on the Move
    John E. Selent — President
    Philip C. Eschels — President-Elect
    Gretchen C. Avery — Vice President & Treasurer                       15 Call for Nominations
    Charles H. Stopher — Secretary
    Angela McCorkle Buckler — Past President

    Deena G. Ombres — LBA President
                                                                                                                                                      7
    Seth A. Gladstein — LBA President-Elect                              Events
    Peter H. Wayne IV — LBA Past President
                                                                         5 LBA Night at Rabbit Hole Distillery
    Kelly White Bryant               Sara Veeneman Judd
    Kevin C. Burke                   Benjamin J. Lewis
    J. Christopher Coffman           Jessica R.C. Malloy                 5 Meeting Schedules
    Nicole T. Cook                   Loren T. Prizant
    Cynthia B. Doll                  John O. Sheller                     7 Lawlapalooza
    Gregory T. Dutton                Lars S. Smith
    Ingrid V. Geiser                 Virginia H. Snell
    Hon. Angela Johnson              Joseph C. Ventura
                                                                         10 Kentucky Commercial Real Estate Conference
    Samuel E. Jones
                                                                         11 CLE
    Samuel G. Graber — Tax Counsel
    Jeffrey A. Been — Executive Director                                 13 From Students to Lawyers
                                                                             Celebrating 20 Years of the Central High School Pipeline Program
BAR BRIEFS is a monthly paper published by the Louisville Bar
Association. The LBA does not necessarily share or endorse any
particular views expressed in this paper by contributors thereto.
The views are those of thoughtful contributors. Advertising does
not imply endorsement by the LBA of products or services or any
statements made concerning them.

                                                                                                                                                      13
The mission of the Louisville Bar Association is to promote justice,
professional excellence and respect for the law, improve public
understanding of the legal system, facilitate access to legal services
and serve the members of the association.

2           Louisville Bar Briefs                                                                                                                                                                    www.loubar.org
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
PRESIDENT’S PAGE

Musings
Just recently, we commemorated the 20th anniversary of the World Trade Center terrorist at-          the 1918 influenza pandemic: schools opening and
tack. I thought back to that day—I remember what a beautiful blue sky we had in Louisville           closing, temperature changes (change of seasons)
that morning as I drove to the Judicial Center. It was what you hope for in September: the hint      and human behavioral changes in response to the
and promise of cool, crisp and bright fall days without the miserable humidity of August. I was      outbreak.
at my desk in what used to be Division 16 in Jefferson Circuit Court, researching cases for a
                                                                                                     Today’s COVID public health crisis is polarizing,
pending motion, when shortly before 9 a.m., the sheriffs on the 9th floor back hallway started
                                                                                                     which surprises me to a certain extent. The different
running and when they start running, you know that cannot be a good thing.
                                                                                                     schools of thought about it cover the spectrum, from
We gathered around the TV in Judge Ann Shake’s chambers and watched the breaking news. As            the people who do not believe it exists to those who
we watched flames and smoke bellow from the North Tower of the World Trade Center, I saw             think it is a judgment from God. Conventional sci-
another plane fly by only to watch the live footage as it hit the South Tower. Within minutes, the   ence tells me that COVID exists and it evolved from
Judicial Center went on lock down and we were glued to the TV in disbelief, confusion and shock.     other viruses. We can debate its specific origins in
                                                                                                     another 20 years.
As the minutes ticked by, we learned a third plane hit the Pentagon and then a fourth plane went
down in a field outside of Shanksville, Pennsylvania when its passengers attempted to subdue         Masking mandates and now vaccination mandates
the hijackers; those passengers had learned through phone calls that the other three flights had     have created a further divide among our society.
already been crashed into buildings. Investigators later determined that the fourth plane’s target   But what I had hoped to see from our community and society at large was the same kind of
was either the White House or the U.S. Capitol. I continued to watch the television coverage         come together moment (OK, now it would be several moments) we experienced 20 years ago
that day as the 110-story Towers collapsed, killing those who were unable to escape as well          in order for us to stop the pandemic “bad guy” within our country. The mindset that we’ll do

                                                                      “
as others who were in the vicinity of the World Trade Center.                                                                        what we need to do as long as we need to do it, so we protect
                                                                                                                                     and care for our friends, family and neighbors. You know, the
The attacks resulted in 2,977 fatalities. More than 90 countries
                                                                                                                                     part where we are nicer and more considerate to each other.
lost citizens in the attack. Over 1,100 victims still have not been
identified from the remains. It was the deadliest terrorist attack                                                                   As the COVID pandemic drags on, I am just as weary and
in history. The smoke, dust and debris from the collapse of                                                                          fatigued by it as the next person. I recognize that not everyone
the World Trade Center Towers was seen and felt for months.                                                                          can or will be vaccinated, which is their personal decision. I
Exposure to the toxins in the debris caused negative health ef-                                                                      respect that. It just adds into my calculus of where I go, who
fects to first responders, residents and office workers in Lower
                                                                      What I’d like to see is a little less societal and politi-     I go with and my decision to wear a mask when inside public
Manhattan. The World Trade Center Health Program, created                                                                            spaces, especially with this latest spike in COVID cases. Our
in 2010, continues to provide testing and treatment for people
                                                                      cal polarization and a lot more working together,              behavior choices can impact the spread of the virus, which is
suffering from long-term health issues related to the attack.                                                                        what was seen in the 1918 influenza pandemic, as well as with
                                                                      not just to stop the spread of COVID, but for a whole          any other infectious disease be it chicken pox, whooping cough
Immediately after the attacks, there was a cultural shift in this
                                                                                                                                     or a norovirus/stomach bug.
country. There was a greater focus on friends, family and              host of other issues that plague our society, like
neighbors. And let’s face it, we were nicer to each other. We                                                                          Objectively, I see the different sides of the mandate coins,
recognized that our lives could be changed in the blink of an eye       homelessness and socio-economic imbalances. and there are multiple coins. The mask mandates seem much
by forces outside of our control. We set aside our differences                                                                         easier for me to support, maybe because they are not quite as
and focused on our commonalities. We helped each other when                                                                            permanent, and they make common sense in terms of stopping
we saw someone struggling or needing an extra boost. Attor-                                                                            the spread of the virus. You can remove your mask when you
neys volunteered to assist victims and their families through                                                                          are alone, at home or perhaps outside. It is a temporary and
the quagmire of the compensation fund process; there are at-                                                                           minor inconvenience. As I write this, however, I am not sure
torneys who continue that pro bono work today to ensure that the victims and their families         yet how I feel about mandating COVID vaccinations. Again, I believe that is a personal choice
are compensated for their losses.                                                                   that an individual should be able to make about their own body and health, which also applies
                                                                                                    to other health decisions a person may make about her own body. I’d like to think, however,
The aftereffects of the World Trade Center attack live on today. The Homeland Security Depart-
                                                                                                    that if a person decides not to vaccinate that they will then use some common sense and take
ment was born. Airport security changed and we learned to take off our shoes, jackets and belts
                                                                                                    other precautions, like wearing a mask and social distancing, to stop the spread of the virus.
as we walked through the metal detectors, pull out our laptops and other electronic devices,
and only bring three ounces of liquids in a quart-sized clear bag in our carry-on luggage. But      What I’d like to see is a little less societal and political polarization and a lot more working
we accepted these changes because they made us safer and protected us from the “bad guys.”          together, not just to stop the spread of COVID, but for a whole host of other issues that plague
                                                                                                    our society, like homelessness and socio-economic imbalances. I’d like us to revisit the time
Fast forward to 2021. One of today’s “bad guys” is COVID, I hope we can agree on that.
                                                                                                    20 years ago when everyone was nicer to each other as we came together as a nation in our
The impact that it has had on our society, culture and economy over the past 19 months is
                                                                                                    grief from the World Trade Center attack. Let’s stop judging people for the decisions that they
astounding. If history is an indicator, we can and should look to the 1918 influenza pandemic
                                                                                                    make and consider that there may be good reasons for those decisions. Differences of opinion
as a potential guide. I read The Great Influenza by John M. Barry at the start of COVID and
                                                                                                    are expected, but to silence or “cancel” a person because their decision or opinion differs from
highly recommend it.
                                                                                                    yours is not only unfair but also undermines the ability to problem-solve for an issue. Look for
Contrary to its other name, Spanish flu, the first confirmed cases originated in Kansas. Scientists the commonalities and agreement on issues and build upon that foundation.
still do not agree how the virus originated but suspect that it was passed from birds to swine to
                                                                                                    Kentucky’s state motto is “United we stand, divided we fall”—we do better when we work to-
humans. The 1918 flu had an unusually high mortality rate for young adults. Two years after
                                                                                                    gether, focus on our commonalities and goals and help each other through the tough times. I
the first confirmed cases and four successive waves of the virus (sound familiar?), an estimated
                                                                                                    cannot say it better than Todd Beamer did: Let’s roll.
500 million people had been infected. Approximately 25 – 50 million people died, with infection
hastened by the close quarters and troop movements of World War I.
The public health response was similar in October 1918 as it has been today. Quarantines,                                                                                             Be well,
curfews and social distancing were implemented and wearing face masks became common.
Mass gatherings were restricted. Businesses opened and closed on staggered shifts to avoid
overcrowding. Like today, there was resistance to wearing face masks and the enforcement of
various restrictions was varied. At the time, there were no anti-viral vaccinations or drugs to                                                                            Deena G. Ombres
treat the Spanish flu. A study done in 2013 showed that there were three factors that impacted                                                                                LBA President

www.loubar.org                                                                                                                                                                 October 2021        3
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
Jeopardy Category Potpourri – Jury Trials are Back
Chief Judge Angela McCormick Bisig

My family and I are avid Jeopardy watchers.       lectively, we pivoted with the use of confer-         deliberation rooms. The sole exception to           an “audio-conference” function that allows
From my conversations with other “law             ence calls, Zoom, Skype and other remote              the mask mandate is made for an arguing at-         our phone to broadcast over the courtroom
types,” many of you are as well. My husband       platforms. As a result, hearings and other            torney or witness on the witness stand behind       microphones and speakers. The individual
and I record all Jeopardy episodes and watch      case conferences continued, the exception             a piece of plexiglass. An effort has been made      on the phone is also captured directly into
them together with some of our grown chil-        was the important jury trial.                         by attorneys to use courtroom technology for        the court record. I am told this technology
dren in intense competition in the evenings.                                                            publishing exhibits rather than passing them        creates a slight “echo” effect for the remote
                                                  Jury trials were discontinued during the pan-
We engage in smack-talk and know our                                                                    around in the jury box. We also conduct juror       users, but it does allow communication be-
                                                  demic because of the inability to gather large
strengths and weaknesses in typical catego-                                                             orientation in smaller groups down in the jury      tween all participants. I commend the bar for
                                                  crowds of 200 to 300 people in the jury pool
ries. Our unique family tradition is regardless                                                         room. Overall, these 26 trials have been suc-       its adaptability and flexibility in functioning
                                                  room. Further, gathering 40 to 50 people
of who gets the most correct answers during                                                             cessfully held without Covid complications.         in these challenging circumstances.
                                                  in a venire panel in a single courtroom also
the game, anyone who guesses the answer
                                                  created a situation that was untenable when           Who Is Working Towards a New                        The circuit judges have received feedback
to the final Jeopardy question from the an-
                                                  it was necessary to keep six to eight feet of                                                             that many of you prefer the option to appear
nouncement of the category alone, without
                                                  social distance. As of the end of May 2021, we        Larger Courtroom?                                   at motion hour remotely. As a result, we are
the actual clue, wins that night’s game.                                                                Prior to 2020 and the onset of the Covid
                                                  resumed jury trials here in the court system.                                                             all allowing either remote or in-person at-
If you regularly watch Jeopardy, you know         We have successfully conducted 26 trials in           pandemic, we in circuit court had discussions       tendance by civil attorneys at motion hour.
that occasionally the writers make a “pot-        circuit court. Of those, 14 have been criminal        about converting the large jury pool room           Prior to Covid, attorneys were able to obtain
pourri” category. This category means they        trials and 16 have been civil trials. We have         currently used for gathering jurors, master         future court dates or schedule trials off docket
have a number of interesting questions that       also safely conducted four bench trials.              commissioner sales, investitures, retirements       with the court administrative staff. With this
fit no particular theme. For this month’s col-                                                          and other activities around the courthouse to       new hybrid method, be aware motion hour
                                                  I’ve held quite a few jury trials in my own           a large courtroom. The emergency protocols
umn, I have several updates for the readers,                                                                                                                may take more time as scheduling issues are
                                                  court. In my experience, the juries have been         established during the Covid pandemic made
so the Jeopardy potpourri category came to                                                                                                                  resolved, and dates are given, in real time
                                                  hearty and hardworking. In the early days we          it more obvious that we needed a large multi-
mind. While I will not be asking questions                                                                                                                  during the motion hour docket.
                                                  conducted voir dire spread out six to eight           purpose courtroom in Jefferson County.
at the end of this article, the following is my
                                                  feet in the large jury pool room on the second                                                            Why ARe Business Court Rules
version of legal potpourri. In true homage                                                              Judge Haner’s courtroom in Division 1 is the
                                                  floor. Currently we are conducting voir dire
to Alex Trebek, I will give my categories in
                                                  and the trial process in our courtrooms with          largest courtroom. However, being the largest       Being Evaluated?
question form.                                                                                          jurisdiction in the Commonwealth, it is abun-       Finally, in a previous column, I provided an
                                                  all jurors and attorneys wearing masks. In
                                                  my early post-pandemic trials, we allowed the         dantly clear that we need a larger courtroom        update regarding the Business Court Pilot
What Is Jury Trials Are Back?                                                                           space both for major trials and for other           Project we began in Jefferson County in
Attorneys are aware that the Courts of the        jurors to deliberate in the courtroom to allow
                                                  for greater space to socially distance correctly.     court activities. We are currently working          January 2020. The Business Court cases are
Commonwealth in large part continued                                                                    with the Administrative Office of the Courts        proceeding, and the new rules are in use. Two
throughout the pandemic to hear cases. Col-       The jurors are currently using the regular
                                                                                                        to have the second-floor large multi-purpose        members of the Business Court Advisory
                                                                                                        Shobe jury room reworked to function as an          Committee are overseeing two separate com-
                                                                                                        actual courtroom with a recording system for        mittees: 1) to solicit feedback from practitio-
    Your UNDUPLICATED Office Technology,                                                                keeping a court record. We are in preliminary
                                                                                                        meetings for this project, and we are hopeful
                                                                                                                                                            ners; 2) to review recommendations for revi-
                                                                                                                                                            sions to the rules. Attorney Janet Jakubowicz
      Equipment and Service Professionals                                                               it will become a reality. This would provide a
                                                                                                        larger space for multi-party litigation as well
                                                                                                                                                            is overseeing review of the Business Court
                                                                                                                                                            rules and attorney Libby Gray is organizing
                                                                                                        as a more formal environment for citizens           a survey to solicit feedback. If you’ve had the
                                                                                                        who serve on our juries.                            opportunity to participate in this type of litiga-
                                                                                                                                                            tion, please give us your feedback.
                                                                                                        What Are Hybrid Court Appearances?
                                                                                                        If your law practice doesn’t bring you regu-        I hope you have found these updates help-
                                                                                                        larly to the courthouse, we are requiring that      ful. I’m open to input from Bar Association
                                                                                                        masks be worn in the building regardless of         members as to any of
                                                                                                        vaccination status. In general, the majority        the issues raised here.
                                                                                                        of criminal proceedings are being held in           With any luck, you’ll
     LOUISVILLE • LEXINGTON • ELIZABETHTOWN • LONDON                                                                                                        be able to make it a true
                                                                                                        person with some parties and attorneys ap-
                                                                                                                                                            Daily Double.
      (502) 589-5555 | (800) 633-8921                                                                   pearing remotely depending on the type of
                                                                                                        proceeding. In civil matters, we are proceed-       Chief Judge Angela Mc-
                                                                                                        ing in a hybrid format. Some hearings are           Cormick Bisig presides in

        Quality with Service...                             • Office Equipment
                                                                                                        in person, while others remain remote. The
                                                                                                        circuit courtrooms have been equipped with
                                                                                                                                                            Division 10 of Jefferson
                                                                                                                                                            Circuit Court. n
                                                            • Professional Printing
                                                            • Document Management
                                                            • Managed I.T. Services
                                                            • Corporate Mailing Systems                    In Memoriam
                                                            • Integrated Technology Services                                      David S. Mejia, age 71, died on July 8 after a bitter battle with can-
                                                            • Managed Print Services                                              cer. A graduate of Loyola University Chicago School of Law, Mejia
                                                                                                                                  was admitted to both the Illinois and Kentucky bars. He practiced
                                                                                                                                  law in Chicago before coming to Kentucky to head the trial divi-
                                                                                                                                  sion at the Department of Public Advocacy. He later established a
            duplicatorsales.net                                                                                                   solo practice in Louisville focused on criminal and post-conviction
                                                                                                                                  defense in state and federal and courts.
                                                                                                                                 In addition to five adult children, Mejia is survived by his wife, Dr.
                                                                                                           Kathy Novota, who advises that he loved baseball, ballroom dancing, woodworking,
                                                                                                           world travel and telling a good joke. In lieu of memorial gifts, she urges everyone to at-
                                                                                                           tend a baseball game, go dancing, tell a good joke or do something kind for a stranger.
                                                                                                           “These are the ways you can best give a memorial gift,” she adds. “These are the things
                                                      SENTRYFILE                                           that would make David smile.” n

    5x6.5 ad.indd 1                                                                    3/8/19 1:09 PM
4        Louisville Bar Briefs                                                                                                                                                             www.loubar.org
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
MEETING SCHEDULES

                                                                          Federal Courts Section Meeting
                                                                          The first meeting of the Federal Courts Section meeting will be
                                                                          held via Zoom on Friday, October 8 at noon. To register for
                                                                          this virtual meeting, please visit our online calendar at www.
                                                                          loubar.org, e-mail lanspach@loubar.org, or call (502) 583-
                                                                          5314. Guests are welcome to attend a meeting before joining
                                                                          the section. n
                                                                          Louisville Association of Paralegals
                                                                          Check out upcoming educational programs and special
                                                                          events on the Louisville Association of Paralegals website at
                                                                          www.loupara.org. The LAP offers joint membership with
                                                                          the Louisville Bar Association for voting members and joint
                                                                          LAP/LBA members may attend most LBA CLE programs at
                                                                          the discounted rate of $15. To learn more about the benefits of
                                                                          LAP membership, visit www.loupara.org. n

                                                                          Association of Legal Administrators
                                                                          The Kentucky Association of Legal Administrators invites your
                                                                          administrator to join its October chapter meeting via Zoom on
                                                                          Thursday, October 14 at 11:45 a.m. The guest speaker is Juan
                                                                          Pena, a human rights specialist for the Kentucky Commission
                                                                          on Human Rights. Pena will speak on equal employment op-
                                                                          portunity laws in Kentucky.
                                                                          Summary: The Kentucky Civil Rights Act (KRS 344) prohibits
                                                                          discrimination in employment on the basis of age (40 and over),
                                                                          color, disability, national origin, race, religion, sex, or because
                                                                          the individual is a smoker or not a smoker. KRS 344 covers
                                                                          employment agencies, labor unions, licensing agencies and
                                                                          employers with 8 or more employees. The training goes into
                                                                          detail about each protected class, provides examples of unlaw-
                                                                          ful discrimination, and much more. For more information on
                                                                          how to join the meeting, please contact us at: KYALAchapter@
                                                                          gmail.com.

                                                        Offering over 35 years of judicial experience

       Due to their continued growth, a multi-office
       national law firm is seeking ATTORNEYS
       ˆ‘” its Louisville and Lexington offices. The
       litigation department seeks individuals with
       experience in civil trial and/or insurance
       defense litigation.

       Portable book of business is a plus.
                                                         Judge Jerry Bowles                         Judge Joan Byer
                                                                 (Ret.)                                         (Ret.)
       E-mail resume to resume@qpwblaw.com.                    502-558-6142                            502-216-9030
       Please reference “Louisville Bar Association”   judgejerrybowles@gmail.com                  judgebyer@gmail.com
       on the subject line when sending your
       resume.
                                                       . . . your first choice in family law mediation.

www.loubar.org                                                                                                        October 2021         5
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
6   Louisville Bar Briefs   www.loubar.org
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
Geospatial Data and Employee Privacy:
What do Kentucky Employers Need to Know?
Alexandra Dunn

Geospatial surveillance technologies such as radio frequency identification (RFID), Global Po-         have no reasonable expectation of privacy while driving, so GPS vehicle surveillance is not a
sitioning System (GPS), smart phone applications and wearable tracking devices have created            Fourth Amendment violation. See Azam v. D.C. Taxicab Comm’n, 46 F. Supp.3d 38 (D.D.C.
opportunities for employers to move beyond traditional timecards to track their employees’             2014); El-Nahal v. Yassky, 993 F. Supp.2d 460, 464 (S.D.N.Y. 2014). Though these challenges
activities and productivity. These technological innovations raise questions regarding work-           have been unsuccessful, the legal theory is in its nascency, and it remains possible that Fourth

                                                                                             “
ers’ rights to privacy. However, the legal privacy protections                                                                        Amendment law will evolve as geospatial surveillance becomes
for employees have not kept pace with emerging technologies                                                                           more prevalent.
used to surveil them.
                                                                                                                                       Do collective bargaining agreements restrict
Employers are generally permitted to digitally track employees                                                                         geospatial tracking?
in the workplace with few restrictions in Kentucky. Employers                                                                          Collective bargaining agreements may restrict the use of geo-
can prevent liability by utilizing best practices, including in-                                                                       spatial data in the workplace. For example, the United Parcel
forming employees that they are being monitored and tracking                   Employers are generally permitted to                    Service Teamsters Union agreement restricts the ways in which
employees only while on the clock. For the most part, employees                                                                        employees may be disciplined based on GPS data. This type of
do not have a reasonable expectation of privacy at work, and                   digitally track employees in the work-                  provision is not yet common, but may become more prevalent
employees objecting to employer geospatial data collection will                                                                        with the expansion of geospatial data use in the workplace.
have limited grounds to file legal claims in Kentucky. There is               place with few restrictions in Kentucky.
little Kentucky case law involving employers’ use of geospatial                                                                        What is the key takeaway for employers using geospatial
data and employee privacy. However, with the expansion of                                                                              data in the workplace?
monitoring technology and the use of artificial intelligence                                                                          Tort claims for invasion of privacy are currently the most viable
in data analytics, a review of the current laws protecting the                                                                        avenue for personnel to challenge geospatial monitoring by
geospatial data of employees is warranted and will be outlined                                                                        employers in Kentucky. But this remedy will only be available
in the next sections.                                                                                  where the employee has a reasonable expectation of privacy. Although employees generally
Do federal statutes limit the use of employee geospatial data?                                         do not have a reasonable expectation of privacy at work, employers can
No, but a statutory framework exists to create federal protections for employees’ geospatial data.     protect themselves by putting employees on notice that GPS, RFID or
The Electronic Communications Privacy Act (“ECPA”) includes protections against employers              smartphone applications are being used to monitor location data.
intercepting employee telephone and electronic communications. 18 U.S.C. § 2510. The ECPA              Alexandra Dunn is a third-year law student at the University of Louisville
protects employees’ private communications on personal electronic devices and e-mail accounts.         Brandeis School of Law. Special thanks to Professor Ariana Levinson for
While the ECPA does not provide any protections against geospatial surveillance, it is likely          inspiring this article. n
congress will look to regulate geospatial data privacy in the future.

Does geospatial tracking implicate the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA)?
NLRA Section 7 guarantees employees’ rights to “engage in concerted activities, for the purpose
of . . . mutual aid or protection.” 29 U.S.C. § 157. NLRA Section 8 makes employer interference
with Section 7 rights an unfair labor practice. 29 U.S.C. § 158(a)(1). So far, there have been no
challenges to employer geospatial data gathering under the NLRA. However, the NLRA would
likely be applicable in circumstances where an employer’s geospatial monitoring chilled Section
7 rights. See Robert Sprague, Survey of (Mostly Outdated and Often Ineffective) Laws Affecting
Work-Related Monitoring, 93 CHI.-KENT L. REV. 221, 234–35 (2018).

Do Kentucky statutes protect employee geospatial privacy?
Kentucky law does not prohibit geospatial data surveillance, but some states have enacted
statutes prohibiting certain kinds of geospatial tracking. The only statute implicating employee
surveillance in Kentucky is KRS § 526.010 et seq, which criminally sanctions eavesdropping,
and requires at least one party to consent to the recording or dissemination of private oral or
wire communications. However, most geospatial tracking does not fall within the eavesdrop-
ping definition, and when employees consent to monitoring as a condition of employment,
employers cannot be held liable.

Does tort law provide any redress for employees?
Employees could potentially file an invasion of privacy suit against their employer for the tort
of unreasonable intrusion upon seclusion. Kentucky law recognizes the cause of action and
requires the plaintiff to establish three elements: (1) an intentional intrusion; (2) into a private
matter; (3) that a reasonable person would find highly offensive. See McKenzie v. Allconnect,
Inc., 369 F. Supp.3d 810, 819 (E.D. Ky. 2019). Courts have found there is no invasion of privacy
when a person is in a public area and does not have a reasonable expectation of privacy. See
Pearce v. Whitenack, 440 S.W.3d 392, 400–01 (Ky. Ct. App. 2014).
In Zhang v. Western Kentucky University, the Kentucky Court of Appeals dismissed an intru-
sion on seclusion claim, finding that a search of an employee’s desk was not an invasion of
privacy because the employee had no reasonable expectation of privacy in items on their desk.
No. 2011-CA-000287-MR, 2012 WL 4464448, at *10 (Ky. Ct. App. Sept. 28, 2012). This case
is an example of the difficulty in proving a reasonable expectation of privacy in the workplace
setting. Employees have no reasonable expectation of privacy in most workplace settings.
However, employers using geospatial surveillance against unwitting employees when they are
not at work or on the clock could potentially face liability.

Does the Fourth Amendment protect government employees from geospatial monitoring?
Courts in several states have rejected Fourth Amendment challenges to government agencies
tracking geospatial data in the employment context. One of the most common types of geospa-
tial surveillance is the monitoring of vehicles via GPS. Most courts have found that employees

www.loubar.org                                                                                                                                                                      October 2021     7
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
A Very
    Pro Booono
    Halloween
    SUNDAY                        Celebrate
    OCTOBER                    Pro Bono Month!
    24, 2021
                               Dine-in or take-out at
    5 pm to 10 pm             Le Moo and a portion of
    Le Moo
    2300 Lexington Rd.       your meal will support our
                              civil legal aid programs!

                             Mention Legal Aid Society
    Reservations are           when you make your
    encouraged! Call          reservation, speak to a
    502-458-8888 or             server, or order out!
    use the OpenTable
    app!
8    Louisville Bar Briefs                         www.loubar.org
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
Call for Papers
                                    Mental Health and the Legal Profession – Law Review Symposium
    The University of Louisville Law Review is pleased to invite article proposals for its annual    health access, equity, and/or justice; limitations of current mental health laws and poli-
    Symposium, which will occur on February 25 and 26, 2022. The event will be held in               cies; therapeutic jurisprudence; problem-solving courts; treatment diversion programs;
    person in Louisville, Kentucky, but a virtual option will remain available for those who         how the legal profession can uniquely assist those experiencing mental illness in terms of
    are unable to travel. This Symposium is titled Mental Health and the Legal Profession. It        intervention, treatment, and/or advocacy; possible ways to reduce disproportionate rates
    will highlight not only the mental health crisis that exists in the legal profession, but also   of incarceration and recidivism in those who are connected to the criminal justice system
    how the legal profession can assist those who are connected to the criminal justice system       and experiencing mental illness; how mass incarceration implicates the mental health issues
    and experiencing mental illness. The Symposium aims to offer possible solutions the legal        of those incarcerated; lack of sufficient mental health treatment for those incarcerated; or
    profession can embrace to address mental health concerns and spark positive change in            any other topic related to mental health and the legal profession. The editors actively seek
    the legal community and culture.                                                                 diverse, intersectional viewpoints and innovative scholarly approaches that address timely
                                                                                                     issues. Although the Symposium is not a historical or comparative project, the editors
    The Law Review will partner with the Louisville Bar Association’s Health & Wellness
                                                                                                     welcome articles with historical or comparative features.
    Committee to host selected authors to present their articles during an in-person, all-day
    Symposium open to the public on Saturday, February 26, 2022. David Jaffe, Associate              The Call for Papers is open now and will close on October 15, 2021. Interested in-
    Dean of Student Affairs at American University and a zealous mental health advocate,             dividuals should submit an abstract of roughly 500 words or a full article to the Senior
    will be the keynote speaker during this event. Authors will be assigned to panels and given      Symposium Editor, Meredith Harbison, at meredith.harbison@louisville.edu.
    20 minutes to present their articles, followed by a brief question and answer period. The
                                                                                                     The Law Review will choose submissions to present at the Symposium and subsequently
    Symposium will be preceded on Friday, February 25, 2022, with a business casual cock-
                                                                                                     publish. Selected authors will be notified by November 5, 2021. The editors and members
    tail hour and dinner to welcome the authors and keynote speaker, as well as kick off the
                                                                                                     will work with authors over the winter and spring of 2022 to prepare and edit the articles
    Symposium. These events are intended to bring together law students, law faculty, lawyers
                                                                                                     for publication. First drafts will be due no later than January 1, 2022. A second draft
    and judges from around the nation to discuss the future of mental health, the practice of
                                                                                                     will be due no later than February 18, 2022, which will allow the Symposium editors to
    law and the judicial system.
                                                                                                     prepare for the events held on February 25 and 26, 2022. Finished articles of approxi-
    Submissions on the following topics are encouraged: prevalence of mental illness in the          mately 5,000 words will be due no later than March 12, 2021, which will allow authors
    legal profession; barriers to seeking treatment and possible solutions; compassion fatigue;      time to incorporate feedback offered by students, representatives of nonprofits, and local
    vicarious or secondary trauma; mental health resources available to members of the legal         practitioners in the field at the Symposium. All selected articles will be published in the
    community; mental health issues caused/exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic; mental              University of Louisville Law Review’s third issue of Volume 60 in late spring of 2022. n

www.loubar.org                                                                                                                                                                  October 2021        9
Not all "months" begin on the 1st. What began as a one-week event back in 1968 has grown into what is known as Hispanic Heritage Month-a ...
10   Louisville Bar Briefs   www.loubar.org
CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION

 LBA Litigation Section One-Hour                                                                                                                              LBA Health Law Section
 What Kanye West Can Teach Us About Litigation                                                                                                                Information Blocking Final Rule
 Thursday, October 7                                                                                                                                          Thursday, October 14
 Over the past decade, Kanye West has run the gamut when it comes to civil lawsuits. From copyright and trademark infringe-                                   After a couple of pandemic-related delays, certain provi-
 ment cases to class action litigation, West has seen it all. In this presentation, Texas litigator Brent Turman analyzes Kanye’s                             sions of the Information Blocking Final Rule, a provision
 “greatest hits” in the courtroom and shares lessons other attorneys can learn from his experiences.                                                          of the 21st Century Cures Act, went into effect on April 5,
                                                                                                                                                              2021. Additional provisions will go into effect next year.
 Speaker: Brent Turman, Bell Nunnally & Martin LLP (Dallas, TX)
 Time:      Noon – 1 p.m. — Program
                                                                                                                                                              The Rule is geared towards ensuring that patients and their
 Place:     Online – a link will be sent prior to the seminar program                                                                                         providers have access to all their electronic health informa-
 Price:     $40 LBA Members | $36 Sustaining Members | $15 Paralegal Members | $15 for qualifying YLS Members | $25 Solo/Small Practice Section Members,      tion (EHI), including lab reports, provider notes and other
            Government or Non-Profit Members | $180 Non-members                                                                                               data that patients may not find in the mobile health apps
 Credits:   1.0 CLE Hour — Pending in Kentucky / Pending with Indiana                                                                                         supplied by their provider. Health plans and healthcare
                                                                                                                                                              providers, regardless of their status as a HIPAA covered
                                                                                                                                                              entity, must comply. HIPAA also provides patients with a
 LBA Appellate Law Section One-Hour                                                                                                                           right of access.
                                                                                                                                                              This webinar will address what the right of access rules
 Avoiding Common Missteps in Appellate Brief Writing                                                                                                          require of providers and health plans under both the In-
 Friday, October 29                                                                                                                                           formation Blocking Rule and HIPAA.
 This presentation will highlight recent emphasis from Kentucky’s Appellate Courts about the importance of complying with                                     Speakers: Wyatt, Tarrant & Combs attorneys Kathie
 rules governing appeals. The presentation will also identify common missteps made in brief writing and provide practical,                                    McDonald-McClure and Jennifer L. Wintergerst
 easy to follow suggestions for how to avoid these missteps in the future.                                                                                    Time:      1 – 2:30 p.m.
 Speaker: Dorislee Gilbert, Attorney at Law                                                                                                                   Place:     Online — a link will be sent prior to the seminar
                                                                                                                                                              Price:     $50 LBA Members | $45 Sustaining Members |
 Time:      Noon – 1 p.m. — Program                                                                                                                                      $15 Paralegal Members | $15 for qualifying YLS Members |
 Place:     Online – a link will be sent prior to the seminar program                                                                                                    $25 Solo/Small Practice Section Members, Government or
 Price:     $40 LBA Members | $36 Sustaining Members | $15 Paralegal Members | $15 for qualifying YLS Members | $25 Solo/Small Practice Section Members,                 Non-Profit Members | $100 Non-members
            Government or Non-Profit Members | $180 Non-members                                                                                               Credits:   1.5 CLE Hour — Approved in Kentucky / Pending with Indiana
 Credits:   1.0 CLE Hour — Pending in Kentucky / Pending with Indiana

www.loubar.org                                                                                                                                                                                             October 2021          11
COVID-19, Labor Shortages and Reasonable Accommodations under the ADA
Calesia Henson, Paul Goatley & Amy Miles

During the COVID-19 pandemic, many businesses found them-                       job-related requirements of the employment posi-              spect to the number of its employees and the number, type
selves with no other choice but to minimize their workforce                     tion such individual holds or desires and, with or            and location of its facilities;
due to lack of work and/or government shut-down mandates.                       without reasonable accommodation, can perform
                                                                                                                                           (iv) The type of operation or operations of the covered entity,
Now, in a world where businesses are trying to bounce back,                     the essential functions of such position. 29 C.F.R.
                                                                                                                                                including the composition, structure and functions of the
many employers are struggling to increase their workforce due                   § 1630.2(m). The term essential functions means the
                                                                                                                                                workforce of such entity, and the geographic separateness
to lack of workers. Across the nation, the shortage of chefs,                   fundamental job duties of the employment position
                                                                                                                                                and administrative or fiscal relationship of the facility or
waiters, truckers, warehouse operators, school bus drivers and                  the individual with a disability holds or desires. 29
                                                                                                                                                facilities in question to the covered entity; and
more are leaving businesses with small staffs, barely able to                   C.F.R. § 1630.2(n). The statute states that “consid-
cover their scheduled shifts and even working alternating shifts                eration shall be given to the employer’s judgment as       (v) The impact of the accommodation upon the operation of
to fulfill the needs of the business. As a result, many employers               to what functions of a job are essential, and if an            the facility, including the impact on the ability of other
are struggling, not only with increasing, but also maintaining                  employer has prepared a written description before             employees to perform their duties and the impact on the
their current workforce.                                                        advertising or interviewing applicants for the job,            facility’s ability to conduct business.
                                                                                this description shall be considered evidence of the
Unfortunately, one of these struggles may include determining                                                                              29 C.F.R. § 1630.2(p).
                                                                                essential functions of the job.” 42 U.S.C. § 12111(8).
whether an employee is entitled to a reasonable accommodation
                                                                                                                                           In addition, employers might also assert the direct threat
for his or her disability under the Americans with Disabilities Act          ¾ The term disability means, with respect to an in-
                                                                                                                                           defense if an individual’s disability poses a direct threat to the
(ADA). Indeed, even in the midst of widespread labor shortages,                dividual (i) A physical or mental impairment that
                                                                                                                                           health or safety of the individual or others. A direct threat
employers are not relieved from their statutory obligations under              substantially limits one or more of the major life
                                                                                                                                           means a significant risk of substantial harm to the health or
the ADA. In some instances, the matter may be easily resolved                  activities of such individual; (ii) A record of such an
                                                                                                                                           safety of the individual or others that cannot be eliminated or
by making existing facilities accessible; acquiring or modify-                 impairment; or (iii) Being regarded as having such
                                                                                                                                           reduced by reasonable accommodation. 42 U.S.C. § 12113(b);
ing equipment; or providing qualified readers or interpreters,                 an impairment i.e. an individual who is believed to
                                                                                                                                           29 C.F.R. § 1630.2(r). The determination that an individual
depending on the request. However, how must an employer re-                    have a physical or mental impairment that is not
                                                                                                                                           poses a direct threat must be based on a reasonable medical
spond when the accommodation requires the employee to work                     transitory (lasting or expected to last six months or
                                                                                                                                           judgment that relies on the most current medical knowledge
a modified or part-time schedule amidst an already small staff?                less) and minor (even if they do not have such an
                                                                                                                                           and/or on the best available objective evidence regarding the
                                                                               impairment). 29 C.F.R. § 1630.2.
Employers’ Obligations under the ADA                                                                                                       individual’s present ability to perform essential job functions.
Title I of the ADA prohibits discrimination on the basis of             • May ask the individual for information about the extent          See EEOC: The ADA: Your Responsibilities as an Employer,
disability in employment and requires that covered employers              of the impairment and request a medical assessment               Additional Questions and Answers on the Americans with Dis-
(employers with 15 or more employees) provide reasonable                  relevant to the accommodation at issue. The employer             abilities Act; 29 C.F.R. § 1630.2(r). Factors to consider when
accommodations to qualified applicants and employees with                 may also (and should) inquire as to how long the accom-          assessing whether an individual poses a direct threat include:
disabilities if the employer can do so without an undue hard-             modation may be needed;                                            • The duration of the risk.
ship. 42 U.S.C. § 12112(a)-(b).                                                                                                              • The nature and severity of the potential harm.
                                                                        • Should confer with the employee and identify potential
                                                                                                                                             • The likelihood that the potential harm will occur.
When an applicant or employee requests an accommodation                   accommodations and assess each accommodation’s
                                                                                                                                             • How soon the potential harm may occur.
due to a disability, the employer has a duty to engage in the             effectiveness. Remember, an employer is not bound to
interactive process. The interactive process is an informal in-           providing one specific or preferred request;                     29 C.F.R. § 1630.2(r).
dividualized inquiry between the parties to identify the precise        • Should document receipt of any requests, the discussion          Employers should be aware that the ADA direct threat require-
limitations resulting from the disability and potential reason-           and the final determination about the accommodation.             ment is a high standard. See EEOC: What You Should Know
able accommodations that could overcome those limitations.                                                                                 About COVID-19 and the ADA, the Rehabilitation Act, and
29 C.F.R. § 1630.2(o)(3). The employer and the applicant or           However, employers may be able to deny accommodation
                                                                                                                                           Other EEO Laws, Question G.4.
employee must participate in the interactive process in good          requests that impose an undue hardship on the employer.
faith. [Note: There are some situations where employers may           Undue hardship means, with respect to the provision of an            Responding to an Employee’s Request for a Modified
have an obligation to provide an accommodation without a              accommodation, significant difficulty or expense incurred by         or Part-time Schedule
request to do so. See EEOC: Enforcement Guidance: Rea-                an employer, when considered in light of the following factors:      While engaging in the interactive process, an employer should
sonable Accommodation and Undue Hardship Under the                    (i) The nature and net cost of the accommodation needed              consider whether adherence to a particular schedule is an
Americans with Disabilities Act, Question 40.]                            under this part, taking into consideration the availability      essential function of the job and whether accommodations to
During the interactive process, the employer:                             of tax credits and deductions, and/or outside funding;           that schedule would impose an undue hardship. (Note: A direct
                                                                                                                                           threat analysis is not discussed in this article.)
  • Should determine whether the individual seeking the ac-           (ii) The overall financial resources of the facility or facilities
    commodation is a qualified individual with a disability;               involved in the provision of the reasonable accommoda-          An employer should first ask whether adherence to the sched-
                                                                           tion, the number of persons employed at such facility and       ule is an essential function of the position. As stated earlier,
       ¾ The term qualified, with respect to an individual                 the effect on expenses and resources;                           any written descriptions prepared by the employer before
         with a disability, means that the individual satisfies                                                                            advertising or interviewing applicants for the job shall be
         the requisite skill, experience, education and other         (iii) The overall financial resources of the covered entity, the     considered evidence of the essential functions of the job. Thus,
                                                                           overall size of the business of the covered entity with re-

                                                                                                            William F. McMurry & Associates, PLLC
                                                                                                                  Trust us to handle your clients’
                                                                                                                   Legal Malpractice Claims
                                                                                                                                       William F. McMurry
                                                                                                                         Board Certified as a Legal Malpractice Specialist
                                                                                                                       by the American Board of Professional Liability Attorneys
                                                                                                                                           (ABPLA.ORG)

                                                                                                                 The ABPLA is Accredited by the ABA to certify Specialists in the field
                                                                                                                                       of Legal Malpractice

                                                                                                                                    Bill@courtroomlaw.com
                                                                                                                                         (502) 326-9000

12     Louisville Bar Briefs                                                                                                                                                              www.loubar.org
an employer’s job description requiring adherence to certain
schedules may support an argument that attendance during
particular hours or shifts is an essential function of the job.                                                                                In fall 2001, the Brandeis School of Law
However, simply indicating such is not enough.                                                                                                 formed a partnership with Central High
In Hostettler, the Sixth Circuit held that simply because an                                                                                 School. This fall celebrates the 20th anniver-
employer indicated that a function was essential was not                                                                                      sary of that partnership which built on the
enough, if the employer could not articulate why. Hostettler v.                                                                            existing Summer Law Internships that the Lou-
Coll. of Wooster, 895 F.3d 844, 857 (6th Cir. 2018). The court                                                                              isville Bar Association had developed in 1992.
explained, “A full-time presence at work is not an essential                                                                                On October 13, the LBA’s Diversity & Inclu-
function of a job simply because an employer says that it is. If                                                                             sion Committee will host a program featur-
it were otherwise, employers could refuse any accommodation                                                                                 ing the stories of the 15 Central High School
that left an employee at work for fewer than 40 hours per week.”                                                                             graduates who have received law degrees or
Id. Furthermore, “an employer cannot deny a modified work                                                                                   who are currently in law school. The program
schedule as unreasonable unless the employer can show why                                                                                    will coincide with a celebration of Hispanic
the employee is needed on a full-time schedule; merely stating                                                                                              History Month.
that anything less than full-time employment is per se unreason-
able will not relieve an employer of its ADA responsibilities.”
Id.; see also Sepulveda-Vargas v. Caribbean Restaurants, LLC,
888 F.3d 549, 553 (1st Cir. 2018) (holding that rotating shifts
were an essential function of the job with the employer as they
were necessary for the equal distribution of work among the
managerial staff); Turco v. Hoechst Celanese Corp., 101 F.3d
1090, 1094 (5th Cir. 1996) (although not specifically indicating
that rotating shifts were an essential function, the court noted
that “all operator positions [for the employer were] on rotating
shifts” and “moving one operator to straight day shift would place
a heavier burden on the rest of the operators in the plant”). As
such, employers should be sure they can articulate why adher-
ence to the schedule is an essential function of the job.
                                                                                         The Louisville Bar Association Honors
Next, an employer should consider whether implementing the                                    Hispanic Heritage Month
requested accommodation(s) would impose an undue burden on                Hispanic Heritage Month is an annual celebration of the history and culture of the U.S. Latinx
it. According to the ADA, one of the factors to consider when
                                                                          and Hispanic communities. The event, which spans from September 15 to October 15, com-
assessing whether an accommodation will impose an undue hard-
ship is the impact of the accommodation upon the operation of
                                                                          memorates how those communities have influenced and contributed to American society at large.
the facility, including the impact on the ability of other employees      The observation started in 1968 as Hispanic Heritage Week under President Lyndon Johnson
to perform their duties and the impact on the facility’s ability to       and was expanded by President Ronald Reagan in 1988 to cover a 30-day period starting on
conduct business. For example, if modifying the schedule will             September 15 and ending on October 15. It was enacted into law on August 17, 1988.
substantially increase the workload of other employees or
substantially disrupt the employer’s business operations, this            The day of September 15 is significant because it is the anniversary of independence for Latin
accommodation may pose an undue hardship. In Siekaniec, the               American countries Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras and Nicaragua. In addition,
court ruled on a similar matter. The court explained that even            Mexico and Chile celebrate their independence days on September 16 and September18, respec-
though an on-call system (i.e. where other dispatchers were               tively. Also, Columbus Day or Día de la Raza, which is October 12, falls within this 30 day period.
called into work whenever the plaintiff’s headaches prevented her
from coming to work or staying at work) may have provided a               As we mark the second half of Hispanic Heritage Month, the LBA is proud to celebrate the
reasonable accommodation generally, with no specific cut off for          cultures, contributions and resilience of Latinx, Hispanic and Latino-identified communities
the on-call system, it imposed an undue hardship on the defendant         around the world.
given the small size of the dispatcher staff. Siekaniec v. Columbia
Gas Co., 48 F. App’x 173, 175–76 (6th Cir. 2002)(unpublished).
Accordingly, employers may consider its
capacity to cover shifts when assessing

                                                                                      Nomination & Election of LBA Officers
the reasonableness of an accommodation.
In short, employers should imple-
                                                                       NOTICE

ment procedures to adequately address                                                        It’s time to nominate and elect officers of the Louisville Bar Association for 2022.
situations that arise under the ADA and
develop processes to ensure good faith                                                                                      Offices to be Filled:
attempts to provide reasonable accom-                                                                                         • President-Elect
modations.                                                                                                                • Vice President/Treasurer
                                                                                                                                 • Secretary
Calesia Henson is an attorney with Stites &
Harbison where she is a member of the Busi-                                                                                     Nominations
ness Litigation and Employment Law Service                                      • Nominations for these offices are made by written petition signed by not less than ten (10) active LBA members;
Groups. Henson is Vice-Chair of the LBA’s                                                            • Nominations for multiple offices can be made on a single petition;
Labor & Employment Section.
                                                                                                    • All petitions must be filed with the secretary by November 1, 2021.
Paul Goatley is an attorney with Fisher Phil-
lips. He is a member of the firm’s SBA Loan
                                                                                                                            Send Petitions to:
Team. Goatley is chair of the LBA’s Labor &                                                                                  Bryan Armstrong
Employment Section.                                                                                                              c/o the LBA
                                                                                                                          600 W. Main St., Ste. 110
Amy Miles is an attorney with Stoll Keenon
                                                                                                                         Louisville, KY 40202–4917
Ogden and is in the Labor, Employment &
Employee Benefits practice. She is a member                                      For more information and petition forms, contact LBA Executive Director Scott Furkin at (502) 583-5314.
of the LBA’s Labor & Employment Section. n

www.loubar.org                                                                                                                                                                October 2021      13
CLASSIFIEDS

Office Space                                       Help Wanted                                                                                             Services
                                                   Through the LBA Placement Service
Office Space Available:                                                                                                                                    KBA Disciplinary Complaints:
One Riverfront Plaza – river view; 1 to 3          Insurance Defense Attorney:                       Civil Litigation Attorney:                            Cox & Mazzoli, PLLC
offices available on 20th floor; library/confer-   The LBA’s Placement service is currently          The LBA’s Placement Service is currently work-        Michael R. Mazzoli is accepting a limited
ence room; secretarial services and/or space       working with a small to medium size down-         ing with a well-established law office, located in    number of attorney disciplinary matters. Mr.
available. (502) 582-2277.                         town Louisville defense litigation firm that      Middletown, that is seeking to add an Associate       Mazzoli is talented, experienced and discreet
                                                   seeks an attorney with 0–5 years of expe-         Attorney with 1–3 years of civil litigation expe-     (502) 589-6190 • mazzolicmlaw@aol.com
Attorney Office Space for Rent in Old              rience. Practice specializes in defending         rience. Insurance Defense experience would be         600 West Main Street, Suite 300 Louisville,
Louisville Area.                                   personal injury, products liability, trucking,    ideal, but not required. Must be licensed in Ken-     KY 40202
(S. 4th Street)                                    mass tort, wrongful death, and worker’s           tucky and in good standings with excellent refer-     THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT
1 large office approximately 16’ x 16’             compensation cases for a number of large          ences. Salary is based on experience, plus full
1 office approx. 8’ x 10’                          insurance carriers and corporations. Can-         benefits. Send resumes in MS Word format to the       False Claims Act / Qui Tams /
1 office approx. 8’ x 10’ – with adjoining         didate should exhibit a superior work ethic,      LBA Placement Service Director, David Mohr,           Whistleblower:
Room that can be used for secretarial office       strong research and writing skills, and enough    dmohr@loubar.org.                                     Cox & Mazzoli, PLLC
Or storage/copy area                               confidence to assist in taking cases to trial.                                                          Scott C. Cox and Michael R. Mazzoli, both
1 large open space with enough room for            The ideal candidate will adapt to a fast-moving   Medical Malpractice Litigation Attorney:              former Assistant United States Attorneys,
3 - 4 desks for support staff                      litigation environment and be able to assume      The LBA Placement Service is currently work-          are accepting new clients who have knowl-
Access to conference rooms, copy, fax and          growing responsibilities for cases in a short     ing with a medium size firm located in downtown       edge of fraud and false billing claims against
postage machines and kitchen.                      time frame. KY license is required, and IN        Louisville that is seeking to add an Attorney         the federal government (502) 589-6190 /
Free Parking. Rent one or all four – all on        license is preferred. Competitive compensa-       to their Medical Malpractice Defense practice.        mazzolicmlaw@aol.com 600 West Main
3rd floor.                                         tion and benefits package commensurate with       Candidate must have excellent writing and ver-        Street, Suite 300 Louisville, KY 40202
Call Laura Garrett @ 502-582-2900                  experience of applicant. Send resumes in MS       bal communication skills, at least 2–4 years of       THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT
                                                   Word format to the LBA Placement Service          litigation experience, licensed to practice in Ken-
                                                   Director, David Mohr, dmohr@loubar.org.           tucky and have excellent references. Competitive      Missing Witness Service:
                                                                                                     salary and benefits are offered to the right can-     Will locate your missing witness anywhere
                                                   Associate Attorney:                               didate. Send resumes in MS Word format to the         in the country for the flat fee of $180 plus
                                                   The LBA Placement Service is currently            LBA Placement Service Director, David Mohr,           database expenses. Using our proprietary
                                                   working with a growing law firm located           dmohr@loubar.org.                                     databases and the telephone, we will locate
                                                   on the east-side of Louisville that is seek-                                                            and talk to the witness and ask them to call
                                                   ing to add an Associate with a minimum of         Estate Planning Attorney:                             you. If you don’t want them contacted, we will
                                                   1–2 years of civil litigation experience and      The LBA Placement Service is currently                furnish you their current address and cell
                                                   licensed to practice in Kentucky. The firm        working with a well-established and respected         number. Call Capital Intelligence, LLC 502-
                                                   primarily does a variety of defense for the       law firm located in downtown Louisville that          426-8100 or email jsniegocki@earthlink.net.
                                                   public sector throughout Kentucky. Candidate      is seeking to hire a seasoned Attorney for
                                                   must have excellent references and be in good     their Estate Planning group. Candidate must           QDRO Preparation and Processing for:
                                                   standings. The firm offers a competitive sal-     have at least 5 years of experience with Estate       Defined Benefit and Defined Contribution
                                                   ary and benefits package commensurate with        Planning matters and be licensed to practice          Plans. Military, Municipal, State and Federal
                                                   experience. Send resumes in MS Word format        in the state of Kentucky. Candidate must be in        Employee Plans. Qualified Medical Child
                                                   to the LBA Placement Service Director, David      good standings and have excellent references.         Support Orders. Collection of past due
                                                   Mohr, dmohr@loubar.org.                           The firm offers a competitive salary package          Child Support and Maintenance. Charles
                                                                                                     to right candidate. Send resumes in MS Word           R. Meers, 2300 Hurstbourne Village Drive,
                                                                                                     format to the LBA Placement Service Direc-            Suite 600, Louisville, KY 40299 Phone:
                                                                                                     tor, David Mohr, dmohr@loubar.org.                    502-581-9700, Fax: 502-584-0439. E-mail:
                                                                                                                                                           Charles@MeersLaw.com.
                                                                                                                                                           THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT

                                                   Help Wanted                                                                                             Immigration Consultant:
                                                   Through the Legal Aid Society                                                                           Dennis M. Clare is available to practice im-
                                                                                                                                                           migration and nationality law. Member of the
                                                   Staff Attorney –                                  Paralegal Eviction Pro Bono Project                   American Immigration Lawyers Association.
                                                   Expungement and Consumer                          LAS has received a Pro Bono Innovation                Law Office of Dennis M. Clare PSC, Suite
                                                   LAS is seeking a staff attorney to work in the    Fund Grant from the Legal Services Corpora-           250, Alexander Bldg., 745 W. Main St., Lou-
                                                   area of expungement and consumer services.        tion to support a staff attorney and paralegal        isville, KY 40202, (502) 587-7400.
                                                   The attorney will work closely with LAS           to work in the area of eviction. The successful       THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT.
                                                   clients who are seeking reparations for con-      candidate will demonstrate a strong commit-
     Bar Briefs is a national award                sumer issues such as tax debt, expungement,       ment to public service, an ability to effectively     Discrimination Issues & Other
     winning monthly publication of                and economic stability. To apply please visit     provide excellent paralegal services, and the         Related Matters:
     the Louisville Bar Association.               https://yourlegalaid.org/careers.                 skills to serve LAS clients with the highest          Samuel G. Hayward is available for consul-
     With a circulation of more than                                                                 level of care and professionalism. To apply           tation of discrimination and other related
                                                   Staff Attorney Eviction Pro Bono Project          please visit https://yourlegalaid.org/careers.        matters for either plaintiff’s or defendant’s
     2,700 readers, Bar Briefs offers
                                                   LAS has received a Pro Bono Innovation                                                                  practice. Mr. Hayward has over forty years’
     informative articles on current               Fund Grant from the Legal Services Corpora-       Social Worker – Bargaining Unit                       experience in this area with Title 7, 1983, and
     issues of interest in the law.                tion to support a staff attorney and paralegal    Legal Aid Society is pleased to announce the          sexual harassment cases. Samuel G. Hay-
     Bar Briefs relies heavily on                  to work in the area of eviction. The attorney     addition of a social worker position to sup-          ward, 4036 Preston Hgwy, Louisville, KY
     contributions by generous vol-                will work closely with LAS clients who are        port work with clients impacted by opioid,            40213, (502) 366-6456.
                                                   at risk of eviction, working to provide direct    stimulants, and substance abuse. New funding          THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT.
     unteers. The LBA welcomes
                                                   services to clients as well as to match clients   to support this project is part of a statewide
     article submissions from at-                  with pro bono volunteer attorneys. The staff      grant to the four legal aid programs (Legal Aid
     torneys, paralegals and other                 attorney will work to recruit and train volun-    Society, Kentucky Legal Aid, Legal Aid of the
     professionals.                                                                                                                                        Advertising copy is carefully reviewed, but publication herein
                                                   teers while working alongside other eviction      Bluegrass, AppalReD Legal Aid). To apply              does not imply LBA endorsement of any product or service.
     Get published! Contact Shannon                staff at LAS to address the eviction crisis       please visit https://yourlegalaid.org/careers.        The publisher reserves the right to reject any advertisement of
                                                   in LAS’s service area. To apply please visit                                                            questionable taste or exaggerated claims or which competes
     Greer, sgreer@loubar.org.
                                                   https://yourlegalaid.org/careers.                                                                       with LBA products, services or educational offerings.

14      Louisville Bar Briefs                                                                                                                                                                     www.loubar.org
You can also read