News - Singapore Medical Association
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
news CON T E N T S Vol. 52 No. 6 2020 EDITORIAL BOARD Editorial 04 The Editors' Musings 20 COVID-19 in Singapore Editor Dr Tina Tan and Dr Jipson Quah Dr Kenneth Lyen Dr Tina Tan Deputy Editor 24 COVID-19 Pandemic: Dr Chie Zhi Ying A Life-Changing Experience Editorial Advisors Dr Cheryl Chang, Dr Lucas Lim, A/Prof Daniel Fung Dr Eugene Fidelis Soh and Anonymous A/Prof Cuthbert Teo Dr Toh Han Chong Members Reflections Dr Ganesh Kudva Dr Lim Ing Haan 27 Love in the Time of Corona(virus) Dr Jipson Quah Dr Ada Ngo Dr Tan Tze Lee Dr Jimmy Teo 28 Caring for COVID-19 Heroes (Part 1) Dr Alex Wong EX-OFFICIOS Dr Tan Yia Swam Feature Dr Ng Chew Lip 06 Apollo’s Arrows and Sun Tzu’s EDITORIAL Stratagem OFFICE Dr Gan Wee Hoe Senior Manager Sarah Lim Assistant Manager President's Forum Sylvia Thay 10 Adjustments and Adaptability Editorial Executive Dr Tan Yia Swam Daryl Lai ADVERTISING AND Council News PARTNERSHIP 12 Highlights from the Li Li Loy Tel: (65) 6540 9174 Honorary Secretary Allan Kuek Dr Ng Chew Lip Tel: (65) 6540 9175 Email: adv@sma.org.sg 13 Timeline of Events PUBLISHER Singapore Medical Association 2985 Jalan Bukit Merah AIC Says #02-2C, SMF Building Opinion 34 Launch of AIC eServices for Singapore 159457 14 Preparing for COVID-19 Pandemic: Tel: (65) 6223 1264 Financing Schemes (eFASS) Perspectives and Lessons Learnt Agency for Integrated Care Fax: (65) 6252 9693 Email: news@sma.org.sg from the Surgical Department URL: https://www.sma.org.sg Dr Chew Min Hoe UEN No.: S61SS0168E 18 Keeping the Mobile Phone Charged DESIGN AGENCY Oxygen Studio Designs Pte Ltd During a Blackout Dr Christopher Cheok PRINTER Sun Rise Printing & Supplies Pte Ltd Cover photos: Changi General Hospital Opinions expressed in SMA News reflect the Tan Tock Seng Hospital views of the individual authors, and do not National University Health System necessarily represent those of the editorial board of SMA News or the Singapore Medical Association (SMA), unless this is clearly specified. SMA does not, and cannot, accept any responsibility for the veracity, accuracy or completeness of any statement, opinion or advice contained in the text or advertisements published in SMA News. Advertisements of products and services that appear in SMA News do not imply endorsement for the products and services by SMA. All material appearing in SMA News may not be reproduced on any platform including electronic or in print, or transmitted by any means, in whole or in part, without the prior written permission of the Editor of SMA News. Requests for reproduction should be directed to the SMA News editorial office. Written permission must also be obtained before any part of SMA News is stored in any retrieval system of any nature.
editorial Dr Tina Tan Dr Jipson Quah Editor Guest Editor COVID-19 Avengers Assemble! Dr Tan is a consultant at the Institute Dr Quah is a GP and pathology clinical The COVID-19 pandemic has officer in private practice. He enjoys of Mental Health and has a special struck the world with unprecedented interest in geriatic psychiatry. She is music-making, fitness activities and force and is a deadly challenge like also an alumnus of Duke-NUS Medical editorial work in his spare time. no other in our generation. At this School. Between work and family moment, there have been over life, she squeezes time out for her six million cases and over 360,000 and Logistics Division (S.H.I.E.L.D) and favourite pastimes – reading a good deaths. In comparison, during the our MOH/Public Health leadership is (fiction) book and writing. 2003 SARS outbreak from November Nick Fury. Our surgeons, especially 2002 to August 2003, there were a the orthopods, are characterised by total of 8,422 cases and 916 deaths. the mighty Thor (powerful lightning COVID-19 continues to dominate our As a result, governments have been and mythical weapons) and Hulk lives with its widespread impact. As scrambling to control the outbreak (smash!). Our infectious diseases such, I hope readers understand and treat the ill. Different countries specialists and physicians are Vision SMA News’ emphasis on related have adopted a variety of approaches. and Hawkeye, due to their incredible articles, from the clinically practical Some of these measures include clinical acumen and ability to provide to the very personal. It is my desire widespread lockdowns, closure of life-saving care. Spiderman represents to give a voice to as many doctors as businesses, deploying and training our eager young colleagues (house possible, to hear their perspectives medical personnel, and building officers and junior residents). Doctors and to share lessons learned. temporary medical facilities. For from the pathology and laboratory This month, we take stock and the medical fraternity, this means departments are like Doctor Strange! look back at how the pandemic has increased personal protective (They provide crucial diagnostic unfolded in Singapore. Looking equipment measures, deployment in services which guide our diagnosis forward, we anticipate much effect COVID-19 facilities and cancellation of and policies). Radiologists are on the mental health of doctors, and clinics, operations, leave, conferences probably Black Panther (usually in we are glad to have worked with the and fellowships. We also have to adapt dark rooms and very technologically Singapore Psychiatric Association to quickly to government policies and advanced). Psychiatrists have got highlight this issue for our readers. Ministry of Health (MOH) circulars. to be Scarlet Witch, with powers In this issue of SMA News, we have of hypnosis and telekinesis. The Last, but certainly not least, I am GPs and family physicians are the invited colleagues to detail their also delighted to welcome Dr Lim unique experiences in fighting against Guardians of the Galaxy, running Ing Haan to the Editorial Board. public health preparedness clinics COVID-19. If I may borrow references from the Marvel Universe, we (The and Swab And Send Home schemes. Avengers) are battling COVID-19 I hope you have an enjoyable (Thanos), a plague that threatens to read and would spend some time wipe out swaths of the population and pondering about which Avenger completely change the way we live. you might be as we continue the Akin to The Avengers, we have the fight against COVID-19. As part of courageous public sector (Captain a team, we all have different roles America) and private sector (Iron Man) to play in order to complete the doctor-heroes. MOH is the Strategic Infinity Gauntlet and eradicate Homeland Intervention, Enforcement COVID-19 from the world. 04 JUN 2020 SMA News
Welcome On Board Dr Lim Ing Haan is an interventional cardiologist in Mount Elizabeth Hospital where she shares a clinic with her twin – Dr Lim Ing Ruen, an otorhinolaryngologist. After her return from Duke University in 2005, she coordinated the set-up of the Primary Percutaneous Coronary Intervention Service in Tan Tock Seng Hospital in 2007, and remains on its Acute Myocardial Infarction Service till today. She is committed to innovation and was the course director of a number of regional courses in cardiology intervention. She often gets invited to lecture at international meetings. Dr Lim and her sister are the only set of twins to graduate from NUS School of Medicine (1995) and she was the only female interventional cardiologist in Singapore for 17 years. Her favourite pastimes are jogging and travelling. SMA News is looking for writers to contribute! If you have a burning desire about a certain topic, or an intense passion for something you have to get out, send your thoughts to news@sma.org.sg and let them be seen by the world! JUN 2020 SMA News 05
FEATURE A & pollo’s rrows Sun Tzu’s Stratagem Text by Dr Gan Wee Hoe | Photos by SingHealth and SGH The culprit causing COVID-19 has been This is an infection where the fallout Another epochal event was the 1918 described as a “very smart virus [that] will – in terms of mortality, socio-economic influenza pandemic. It started at the tail find ways to remain in the human pop- consequences and the profound impact end of World War I (WWI), when the four ulation”.1 An infected patient recounted on the way of living as we know it – is years of war prior had already resulted how battling the disease was akin to of monumental proportions. By many in insufferable hardship and depletion “running a marathon on the bed”.2 accounts, we may only be at the end of of resources. These are just two of the many the beginning. The H1N1 virus infected one-third crippling accounts of COVID-19 that of the world’s population and was have emerged since the tentacles of this Pandemics in human history associated with at least 50 million pandemic first surfaced at the turn of The bubonic plague in the 14th century deaths. The epidemiological observation the decade. wiped out almost a third of Europe’s of the high mortality in the 20- to On 31 December 2019, the Wuhan population. Caused by Yersinia pestis 40-year-old age group (apart from the Municipal Health Commission reported and spread by infected fleas carried by young and the elderly) was surprising to the World Health Organization (WHO) rodents to humans, the disease was so to many. During WWI, the US had joined China Country Office on a cluster of pneu- contagious that it has been described to aid the Allies’ eventual victory against monia cases occurring in the capital city by the Italian poet Giovanni Boccaccio Germany. Of the US fatalities on the war of Hubei province. Subsequent reports that “the mere touching of the clothes front, half were due to influenza and not suggest that the first case could be traced appeared to itself to communicate the attributed to direct enemy action.6 back to as early as 17 November 2019.3 malady to the toucher”.4 Ironically, WWI also shaped the social Much has been postulated, re- Ships were sailing into ports with attitudes among the citizenry in many searched and written about COVID-19. crew either severely ill or dead. To countries, who were by then used to At the time of writing, global case count stem the spread of infection, officials restrictions in their daily lives. This, has crossed the five-million mark with kept sailors in isolation on their ships together with the advent of science the infection claiming more than 331,000 for 30 days (trentino), which was later and technology propelled by the war, lives. As countries gradually ease lock- lengthened to 40 days (quarantino).5 ensured equanimity and acceptance as down restrictions, reports of second and This public health concept has proven its public health measures were applied on third waves are already surfacing. effectiveness even up to the present day. a large scale. 06 JUN 2020 SMA News
Rain of Apollo’s arrows The Art of War by Sun Tzu is one of of large-scale swab and serological the most well-known guides on military testing to ascertain their COVID-19 Even with humankind’s experience warfare. A general from the 5th century BC, status, and the setting up of community with past pandemics, it remains almost Sun Tzu has been widely acknowledged as care and recovery facilities to allow the unfathomable how a contagion such as a master strategist. The Art of War is said to recuperation of those infected. a virus, measured only in nanometres, have shaped Mao Zedong’s thinking and One may question the political has thrown the order of life of almost the Chinese communists’ actions against everyone topsy-turvy. wisdom of the State taking the lead the Japanese.9 at great cost, given that the majority With COVID-19, WFH and HBL (which of migrant workers come under the stands for work from home and home- The art of war is of vital importance to the State. It is a matter of life and employment of private companies. based learning, respectively) are now instantly recognisable acronyms with death, a road either to safety or to ruin. The political will for Singapore to take thematic associations with Singapore’s The contemporaneous application these extraordinary measures is because circuit breaker measures. Global losses of Sun Tzu’s teaching on battle first and foremost, it is the right thing to are estimated at up to USD 8.8 trillion7 preparation is to recognise that political do. Migrant workers have contributed to (SGD 12.5 trillion) and economic considerations, policy decisions and our nation building and development. ground actions are inextricably linked Until recently, they belonged to a repercussions have become a leitmotif and deterministic to success or failure. segment of the workforce in Singapore’s of a COVID-19 Black Swan event. society that was not often talked about. In modern day Singapore and much Singapore has long relied on migrant workers for infrastructure building and Our Government is also keenly of the developed world, our usually very other essential services. Today, we have aware of the policy consideration low mortality rates from communicable about 200,000 of them housed in 43 that without addressing the problem diseases threw the hard truth of purpose-built dormitories, 95,000 in 1,200 of infection in the migrant worker COVID-19 deaths into sharp relief. The factory-converted dormitories, 20,000 population, we cannot win the war five countries with the highest number against COVID-19. Many of them work of fatalities are all in North America and in construction temporary quarters and 85,000 in Housing and Development in the community and share the same Europe, with the US leading the pack. It social and recreational spaces as fellow is a surreal situation. Board flats and other private residential premises across the country.10 Singaporeans. The position statement Apollo, a god in the ancient Greek that Singapore has “a responsibility to pantheon, shot arrows of plague at the While much has been debated on our migrant workers”12 dictated the Greek army for nine continuous days whether we can afford to reduce our decisive actions that unfolded over the because King Agamemnon captured dependence on migrant workers, last couple of months. and refused to release the daughter of what is clear and present today is the disproportionate impact of COVID-19 In many aspects, the “dormitory Chryses, who was Apollo’s priest. operation” is not only a whole-of- on this group of residents in Singapore. Some scholars in Greek mythology Since the first cases were diagnosed in Government endeavour, but a whole- have drawn a link between plagues migrant workers in early February 2020, of-society effort. Ultimately, Singapore and leadership. King Agememnon’s dormitory residents now (as at 24 May is aware that we can overcome our ill-considered decision resulted in 2020) account for 29,363 of 31,616 cases current public health crisis only if our devastating losses in his army. It was of COVID-19 infections in Singapore.11 migrant workers, too, win the fight said that “…he [King Agememnon] rages against COVID-19. Close, communal living and the with baneful mind, and knows not at all pattern of life are probably significant If you know the enemy and know to look both before and after…”. 8 The yourself, you need not fear the result factors in disease propagation. There ability to understand cause and effect of a hundred battles. are countries facing the same issues unpins the ability for effective prevention, which compartmentalise them away and preparation and prosecution of an Shortly after their report of atypical choose to do nothing, but Singapore is pneumonia cases to the WHO China operation. This is manifestly projected in one of the few governments in the world the management of a public health crisis. Country Office, Chinese scientists which has arguably done the most to isolated and fully sequenced the virus in contain COVID-19 in migrant workers. early January 2020. The gene sequencing Sun Tzu’s stratagem Additional housing arrangements data was submitted to Virological.org, Most people will agree that handling were onboarded to de-densify living a forum for analysis and interpretation a public health crisis is akin to waging quarters. Significant resources were of virus molecular evolution and a war against an invisible enemy. deployed from the public and private epidemiology. This early access was Strategies and tactics therefore need to healthcare sectors to ensure timely pivotal in allowing scientists around the be employed, overlaid by political will access to healthcare for every migrant world to kickstart research in diagnostics and underpinned by unity of the people. worker. These also include the conduct and therapeutics. JUN 2020 SMA News 07
from COVID-19 can be avoided if there were timely access to intensive care resources to support those with severe disease through their most critical periods of illness. Hospitals have concurrently been ramping 2 1 up their intensive care capacities. Refresher training for healthcare workers with previous experience in WHO also activated its R&D scientists from the National University critical care has been conducted to Blueprint soon after. The Blueprint of Singapore’s School of Public Health scale up more teams. Ventilators, other improves coordination among has enabled us to better understand the life support equipment and medications scientists, clinicians and public health transmission dynamics and apply the are stockpiled to enable hospitals to professionals in research priorities right interventional strategies. go into surge capacity when infections and the development of public health To leverage our strengths and exploit peak nationally. response standards – absolutely vital as the enemy’s vulnerabilities is a time- To date, Singapore’s fatality rate the world comes to grips with a highly tested stratagem that applies to both from COVID-19 stands at 0.1%, among infectious novel pathogen. conventional warfare and the non- the lowest in the world. In comparison, It is estimated that from January to conventional battleground, such as the countries such as the UK, Italy and April, more than 23,000 scientific papers COVID-19 pandemic. Belgium have fatality rates in excess on COVID-19 have been published of 13%.16 The good fighters of old first put at a doubling time of 20 days!13 This themselves beyond the possibility Even for our migrant worker is an astounding pace that left many of defeat, and then waited for an population, generally of the young- “drowning in COVID-19 papers”. opportunity of defeating the enemy. to-middle age groups and largely free While Singapore may be a small nation, of serious chronic diseases, additional Merely five months into the pandemic, we punch above our weight and are an we are still a distance away from measures have been put in place undisputed powerhouse for translational developing an effective cure or vaccine. to reduce morbidity and prevent research in biomedical sciences. While the “enemy” is holding the mortality. They are equipped with From the early days of the pandemic, higher ground, one should bid for time, health monitoring devices, such as our hospitals and research agencies minimise unnecessary confrontations thermometers and pulse oximeters; actively participated in multi-centre and losses, and await the right they also have round-the-clock access clinical trials on different modalities of opportunity for a decisive strike. to medical care, including after-hours COVID-19 treatment. We also made major telemedicine services. Primary prevention has been the breakthroughs in developing the first- mainstay of public health strategy In the absence of effective in-the-world rapid COVID-19 detection against COVID-19. Whether it is safe therapeutics or vaccines, COVID-19 system employing the surrogate virus distancing, the wearing of masks or remains a significant threat to public neutralisation test,14 and using serological the practice of hand hygiene, these health. We need to buy time for scientists testing to establish a link between two measures seek to minimise infections in to do their work. Before we reach there, local COVID-19 clusters.15 the general populace, especially those the preventive strategy is the best we from the vulnerable groups. have in our limited armamentarium. In foreign worker accommodation, the pattern of disease spread differs Flattening the curve is what we seek depending on local ecological, to achieve epidemiologically, which will Concluding thoughts environmental and social factors translate into lower peaks of infected A Gallup poll of the most important specific to each dormitory. Working cases that could otherwise overwhelm events in the 20th century featured, with infectious disease modelling our healthcare system. Many fatalities among others, the World Wars and Neil 08 JUN 2020 SMA News
Armstrong’s 1969 historic landing on the moon.17 Pandemics did not make Dr Gan is Head and Senior References Consultant, Department of it to the list. COVID-19 may just be the 1. Tan A. Covid-19 caused by a ‘smart virus’ that Occupational and Environmental historic event to tilt the equation. can find blind spots, crucial for system to be Medicine at the Singapore General flexible to overcome challenges: experts. Available The auntie from the nasi padang Hospital. He was seconded to the at: https://bit.ly/3d161H3. Ministry of Health (MOH) from April store which I frequent predicted that 2. Lee LY. ‘Running a marathon on the bed’: to June 2020 and served as the MOH it would take “at least three years” for policy member in the interagency COVID-19 survivors describe their struggles with the Singapore’s economy to turnaround to task force to manage and contain coronavirus. Available at: https://bit.ly/3d7IS5L. the pre-COVID-19 state. A friend, who is the spread of COVID-19 in foreign 3. Ma J. Coronavirus: China’s first confirmed a freelance sports coach, has not been worker dormitories. The opinions in COVID-19 case traced back to November 17. working since the shutters came down this paper are those of the author’s Available at: https://bit.ly/2LZNTkO. and do not reflect the positions or on sports halls throughout the country. views of MOH or SingHealth. 4. Mark JJ. Boccaccio on the black death: Text and commentary. Available at: https://bit.ly/2LXx9Lg. Yet, there are positives out of this. COVID-19 has accelerated revolutionary 5. History.com Editors. Black death. Available at: https://bit.ly/2X2gf4l. disruptive technology. My neighbour, a lawyer, shared with me how he has 6. Billings M. The influenza pandemic of 1918. Available at: https://stanford.io/2TEzfE8 adapted to working from home using different platforms for teleconferences 7. Asian Development Bank. COVID-19 economic impact could reach $8.8 trillion globally – new and virtual meetings. Instead of meaning ADB report. Available at: https://bit.ly/36ydmeJ. to go speedily, “Zoom” has taken on a whole new dimension. 8. Homer. The Iliad. Available at: https://bit. ly/2M2nEKE. We need to get ahead of the curve in Legend 9. Kuiper K. Sunzi: Chinese strategist. Available at: order to secure order back to our lives. 1. Providing primary care medical services to https://bit.ly/2Xz3hu4. Sure, there will be new norms to adapt migrant workers at their place of residence 10. Ng JS, Ong J. The Big Read: Solving Singapore’s to. Old habits like queuing for bak kwa 2. SingHealth deployed medical and dental foreign workers problem requires serious soul at People’s Park will have to change. teams to swab migrant workers in dormitories searching, from top to bottom. Available at: to ascertain their COVID-19 status Employment landscapes will evolve. https://bit.ly/2XsfsJ2. However, what is immutable is the 3. Donning personal protective equipment 11. Ministry of Health, Singapore. 24 May 2020 (PPE) before commencing clinical duties resilience of the human spirit and our daily report on COVID-19. Available at: https://bit. 4. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation ly/2ZDIAzB. fortitude in the face of adversity. simulation training with full PPE 12. Ministry of Manpower. Ministerial statement We will overcome. by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister for Manpower. Available at: https://bit.ly/3c5Yzcq. Information is accurate as at time of writing. 4 13. Brainard J. Scientists are drowning in COVID-19 papers. Can new tools keep them afloat? Available at: https://bit.ly/36wbZgC. 14. Duke-NUS Medical School. Duke-NUS, 3 GenScript and A*STAR launch first-in-the-world SARS-CoV-2 serology test to detect neutralising antibodies without need of containment facility or specimen. Available at: https://nus.edu/2LXFOx8. 15. Channel NewsAsia. Duke-NUS used COVID-19 antibody tests to establish link between church clusters in a world-first. Available at: https://bit. ly/3c7cbUC. 16. Rajendran S. Singapore’s COVID-19 death rate low, but seniors vulnerable. Available at: https:// bit.ly/2ZEQoRL. 17. Newport F, Moore DW, Saad L. The most important events of the century from the viewpoint of the people. Available at: https://bit. ly/36v0XbA. JUN 2020 SMA News 09
PRESIDENT’S FORUM Adjustments and Adaptability Text by Dr Tan Yia Swam First, I want to say a warm hello to of contacts? How is the rest of the world coronavirus-related articles free for all our youngest colleagues – the newly doing? Are the new clusters of infections to access! graduated doctors who are now in the in China and South Korea under control? Social updates: using the social workforce. Some of you have reached One thing that I can now fully media of our choice, we can keep in out to me personally in the past months appreciate is the fact that history touch with friends and families, and even to share your hopes and dreams for the repeats itself. We can look back at past make new friends! Home bakers flourish future, as well as your concerns during pandemics,1,2 and learn from them. and MasterChefs are born! this COVID-19 pandemic. The clinical behaviour of the virus may Entertainment: Youtube, or TikTok for I hope that you are settling into your be different, but the human reactions those who like to perform. work. Housemanship isn’t easy at the best are predictably the same. Heck, even of times. With COVID-19 hanging over our watching zombie and apocalypse Work: Zoom, Microsoft Teams and heads, this poses an additional challenge. movies will give you pretty much the Cisco Webex – for meetings, presentations Some of you would have received a same spectrum of reactions! and conferences. Home-based learning forwarded message from one of the was the bane of many parents working Perhaps COVID-19 is a wake-up call from home, but it did allow for the doctors who was a houseman during for the whole world.3,4 Are humans SARS. I hope that you derived some children to continue with lesson plans. overpopulating the world? We need to comfort and inspiration from seniors be better custodians of the earth. We Online shopping, food and grocery who went through a similar challenge. need to respect animals, their living deliveries: there are so many new players These are uncertain times for spaces and their boundaries. People in the market with better deals and better everyone and it can be very stressful need to give each other space. We need services. Even hawkers are using social having to face so many unknowns and to live in the present moment. I hope media to reach out to customers. potential dangers. But I can assure you that everyone here has found some kind Contact tracing: apps and QR that you are not alone. Together, we can of inner peace during the circuit breaker codes allow for more efficient, accurate overcome this. – with introspection – and picked up contact tracing. some form of mental resilience. We may Telemedicine (TM) is something that Uncertainties also have learnt how to make do, and to has been talked about for a few years, be thankful for what we have. Having been in the Editorial Board for but I don’t think there is widespread use more than a decade, and being the of it, as yet. Guidelines are in place and SMA News Editor for five years, I have Positive aspects in 2020 many providers exist – yet some of us are always felt that the challenge of SMA This is as good a time as any for a very hesitant. I see the pros and cons of it, News is that we are not able to have real- pandemic; I don’t mean this frivolously. and while I see the great potential, I am time updates. I am now penning this in The Internet has allowed the world to be wary of the pitfalls as well. The SMA TM early May, for the June issue! Like many connected in a way never seen before. Workgroup hopes to bridge the gap, to of you, I have so many questions about I grew up in the 90s, and I remember ensure that TM is utilised appropriately. the future. I don’t have answers – but I what life was like before the Internet. I have read many good articles by others choose to look at the positive aspects Leadership that may help to shed some light. of technological advances in helping us Leadership in healthcare, businesses I’m postulating that, by the time you cope amid COVID-19. and politics:5 Thanks to social media, are reading this, Singapore should have Daily news updates: the challenge there is a lot more transparency and lifted the circuit breaker on 1 June, and is knowing how to differentiate reliable accountability. Journalists and bloggers perhaps we will be seeing the effects of sources from tabloids or fake news. critique leadership everywhere, and these it. Have the numbers of new infections Gov.sg gives daily abbreviated updates, articles are made available to any reader. gone up? Have we identified the sources while key medical journals have made Anyone can comment, and those of us 10 JUN 2020 SMA News
who read such posts see the potential community – your family and your staff References toxic effects of “keyboard warriors” or look to you for guidance. “trolls”. Free speech online may seem like 1. History.com Editors. Pandemics that changed history. Available at: https://bit.ly/2WNb2x6. a basic right, but the anonymity allows The future for cowards and bullies – those who do 2. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Past Finding meaning in the new world:7 pandemics. Available at: https://bit.ly/2zfcIGI. not take any personal responsibility, and Everyone would have suffered some relish in the attention and resulting chaos 3. Cafaro P. A lesson from the COVID-19 pandemic kind of loss. Those families who have on the perils of density. Available at: https://bit. – to be at their worst. lost a loved one to COVID-19 and its ly/2Zkkaex. In SMA News, the Editorial Board takes complications. Patients who may be 4. Hamwey R. Environmental impacts of great efforts to curate the articles written living with the sequelae of this illness. coronavirus crisis, challenges ahead. Available at: to try and reflect accurately what is Healthcare workers who continue to face https://bit.ly/2AO1pG4. happening on the ground. We are glad daily stress when looking after infected 5. D’Auria G, De Smet A. Leadership in a crisis: that many doctors have been sharing patients. Business owners who are Responding to the coronavirus outbreak and meaningful reflections on work, and trying to keep their businesses running. future challenges. Available at: https://mck. personal anecdotes on how COVID-19 co/2zSgm9A. Workers who have been retrenched. has affected their practices and personal People who are struggling to make ends 6. Gates B. Responding to COVID-19 – a once-in- lives. We stay true to our core mission – meet. The lost months – of work, income, a-century pandemic? Available at: https://bit. to have an SMA for doctors, for patients. ly/3bRF9Yu. time and relationships – we will never get back. 7. Berinato S. That discomfort you’re feeling is grief. Healthcare and technology:6 The Available at: https://bit.ly/36gES0a advances are remarkable. Sequencing Experts have been sharing their of the viral genome by various groups opinions about how long-lasting is happening at a speed never before COVID-19 may be, and are urging world Dr Tan is a mother to three kids, possible, and the free sharing of wife to a surgeon; a daughter and leaders to rethink the way we run our a daughter-in-law. She trained as scientific knowledge has allowed daily lives. I hope for the best, but am a general surgeon, and entered scientists and doctors to be even more prepared for the worst. How will this private practice a year ago, focusing effective in understanding this illness. affect my practice and my patients? on breast surgery. She treasures The unscientific mind would criticise this How do I look after my children and my her friends and wishes to have as, “how come you all still don’t know more time for her diverse interests: elderly parents and in-laws? How do I anything”. The fact is, the explanation is cooking, eating, music, drawing, keep in touch with friends? writing, photography and comedy. just too complex to share in a few lines. Doctors should keep up to date with In the coming months, each and every the scientific literature and not just be one of us has to rethink and redefine our reading popular news articles for their role in society, and find meaning in what knowledge. Critical analysis and thinking we do. remains our key weapon. Speculation “We are in the same storm, but not in and extrapolations just confuse every- the same boat.” But together, we will ride one. Every doctor is a leader in our out the storm. Illustration: Dr Justinian Zai
council news From the Honorary Secretary Report by Dr Ng Chew Lip Dr Ng is an ENT consultant in public service. Government indemnity coverage for healthcare After a day of doctoring and cajoling his workers deployed to WOG COVID-19 efforts two princesses at home to finish their food, his idea of relaxation is watching a Netflix SMA is glad that the Ministry of Health (MOH) has clarified, serial with his lovely wife and occasionally via an advisory on 26 April 2020, to the extent not covered throwing some paint on a canvas. by any existing insurance, indemnity or compensation schemes, the Government of the Republic of Singapore will indemnify anything done or omitted to be done in good faith and with reasonable care by all medical practitioners and healthcare workers, in the discharge or purported discharge of their functions and duties in relation to Whole-of-Government (WOG) efforts to prevent and reduce the spread of COVID-19. Members are reminded that in any incident, you must notify both your indemnity provider and MOH. SMA Secretariat Office – operations from 19 June 2020 onwards SMA wrote to MOH to request a Point of Contact (POC) from which doctors can obtain urgent advice and notify Despite the reopening of more workplaces in Phase 2, details of incidents to. We have been informed that the first the Multi-Ministry Taskforce has reiterated that safe POC should be the Healthcare Institution (eg, public sector management measures and telecommuting must remain cluster) that deployed you. The Institution will assist in the default for all businesses. The SMA Secretariat Office investigating and managing incidents, as well as informing will thus remain closed until further notice. the Institution’s indemnity providers and MOH. We are also advised that for any other queries, you may email Nonetheless, the Secretariat will continue to provide the moh_qsm@moh.gov.sg. more essential membership services, as it has been during the circuit breaker. For general enquiries, you can contact us at: https:// Childcare arrangements for healthcare workers www.sma.org.sg/general/contactus.aspx. Members can also call our main line at 6223 1264 or the staff’s direct line. Many doctors’ care arrangements for their children were disrupted by schools/pre-schools closures and Professional indemnity the disallowing of children from being dropped off at PS: 800 616 7055 (toll-free) / mps@sma.org.sg M grandparents’ homes announced on 10 April 2020. SMA Income MMI: 6223 1264 / sma@sma.org.sg formally wrote to the Multi-Ministry Taskforce on COVID-19 JLT Medefend Scheme: 6411 9002 / website: http://www. to express our concerns and propose arrangements for the medefend.com.sg Taskforce’s consideration. Membership matters SMA was heartened that the Taskforce subsequently granted exemptions to parents who are essential service E mail membership@sma.org.sg, or call the following workers or healthcare professionals to continue to tap on numbers grandparents for childcare support on a daily basis. Cases New sign ups, renewals and Medik Awas: 6540 9193 eligible for exemptions include: Clinic assistant courses, update of personal information and other general queries: 6540 9194 • Both parents are essential service workers and are unable to work from home; SMJ • One parent is a healthcare professional (eg, doctor, Email smj@sma.org.sg nurse, allied health professional, support care staff ) and is unable to work from home; SMA News • One parent is an essential service worker who is unable Email news@sma.org.sg, or call 6540 9181 to work from home, and has a child/children below the For the latest updates, please visit https://www.sma.org.sg. age of three. 12 JUN 2020 SMA News
Timeline of Events council news Government releases in Singapore sma’s actions February 2020 03 February 03 February • Published SMA e-News on COVID-19 (formerly 2019-nCoV) • Ministerial statement on Whole-of-Government response to 2019-nCoV 12 February • Visitor Resource Pamphlet 07 February • Guides on using telemedicine during an outbreak • DORSCON level raised to Orange 13 February 08 February • SMA initiated the #sgartforhcw to encourage our • Advisory on large-scale events healthcare workers 13 February 21 February • Support for healthcare workers whose leave and holiday • SMJ calls for COVID-19 papers with fast-track review plans have been cancelled and publication to enable timely dissemination of important information March 2020 25 March 10 March • Update on Whole-of-Government response to COVID-19 • SMA collated and shared resources for psychological support by Mr Gan Kim Yong and wellness for doctors and other healthcare workers 31 March 13 March • Time-limited extension of CHAS chronic subsidy and • “Bring Your Own Bottle” Hand Sanitiser Distribution Exercise MediSave to video consultation April 2020 01 April • Exclusive food & beverage promotions for healthcare workers 07 April 03 April • In line with circuit breaker, SMA closes physical office • Announcement of circuit breaker but continues to provide support and services for 10 April Members remotely • Changes to childcare arrangements during circuit breaker 10 April 21 April • SMA writes to Multi-Ministry Taskforce on childcare • Circuit breaker extension and tighter measures arrangements for healthcare workers 13 April • SMA writes to SMC to suggest fine-tuning measures for CME requirements May 2020 05 May • SMA aids in distributing donated face shields to PHPC, SASH, ILI and private clinics 13 May 22 May • SMA clarifies with MOH and our three preferred indemnity • End of circuit breaker phased approach to resuming partners regarding coverage for doctors volunteering healthcare services during the COVID-19 pandemic 15 May • SMA’s survey on impact of COVID-19 on doctors in the private sector JUN 2020 SMA News 13
OPINION Preparing For COVID-19 has been a greatest leveller of society. Dr Chew has learnt to be grateful for the simple things in life. Covid-19 While he does not take bubble tea, he is excited with the re-opening of McDonalds. He is also very proud of all the enormous sacrifices many healthcare workers have contributed in this war. He wishes everyone well and to stay safe. Pandemic Perspectives and Lessons Learnt from the Surgical Department Text and photos by Adj A/Prof Chew Min Hoe 14 JUN 2020 SMA News
Introduction some of the key components in the disease behaviour was and what the initial phase were focused on measures were needed for the safety COVID-19 originated in late managing the individual surgeons. of staff. As collective analysis of the December 2019, from Wuhan in data was done by all members, there Hubei province, China, and has since rapidly spread throughout Task force creation was better understanding of the situation, and the corollary effect was the planet, resulting in the World A department task force (TF) was the that confidence was disseminated Health Organization declaring it an first important conceptualisation among our staff members as well. international pandemic on created. While many departments Having confidence was vital for staff 11 March 2020. At the time of relied entirely on the head of attendance and workforce unity writing this article, over 509,164 department (HOD) to organise and despite the fears of the disease. This people had been infected worldwide implement measures enforced by the effect is still present today. More with 23,335 deaths (case fatality-rate hospital administration, there were importantly, a business continuity 4.6%).1 Currently, there are more several benefits in having a TF. plan (BCP) within the department than 4,000,000 confirmed cases with Information gathering and could be organised effectively to over 280,000 deaths (case fatality confidence building ensure that work could continue rate 6.9%).2, 3 even if a staff member was to be Singapore confirmed its first case In the SARS-CoV 2003 era, information quarantined or infected, with 100% of COVID-19 on 23 January 2020,4 and was mainly disseminated through confidence among all staff that local transmission was subsequently traditional newspaper print and everyone was unified in response. reported on 4 February 2020. The broadcast media such as radio and Disease Outbreak Response System television mediums. Medical infor- Messaging and communication Condition alert level was raised to mation was also only available via The TF consisted of staff across ranks. Orange on 7 February 2020. When this hardcopy journals and thus reporting Messaging and communication article was prepared in March, the pace new advances was slow with a time- within the TF was bi-directional of disease was slow and the milestone lag bias, with a limited reach among rather than a pure top-down of 1,000 infections was crossed more medical personnel due to access approach. Measures implemented than two months after, with majority issues. In the year 2020, the presence had been discussed with the junior due to importations. The epidemic’s of social media and internet availa- staff, with feedback sought and bility on all smart devices meant that trajectory, however, surged thereafter opinions heard, and changed where everyone would be receiving informa- with outbreaks noted in foreign worker necessary. This was important, but tion at the same time. Online medical (FW) dormitories. At the time of managed within a tight bandwidth journals also ensured that quality writing, there are 23,787 local to avoid laborious and prolonged information from high impact journals COVID-19 cases.5 discussions with delayed conclusions. were quickly and readily available. Surgical safety has fallen under the In the department, discussions An unpleasant consequence were efficiently conducted and spotlight as the pandemic has shifted however, was that this information conclusions made within 45 to 60 epicentres from China to Europe and was also available to the general mins. The HOD reserved the right to the US. Surgeons are called upon public. As noted from worldwide make the final decision even against to cancel elective procedures with universal panicked hoarding of food popular opinion and consensus, and a focus on maintaining emergency and sanitation essentials by the the TF understood that some of the operations and elective cancer public with graphic imagery of long decisions were made with different surgeries, with additional precautions queues and fights in supermarkets, it considerations in mind. needed for surgical staff.6-8 is apparent that fear of the unknown The surgical department at Moreover, hospital operational and self-preserving behaviour could Sengkang General Hospital (SKH) instructions were rapidly evolving rapidly degenerate into chaos. For developed disease outbreak response as the intensity of disease outbreak healthcare workers, reports of death measures in coordination with of doctors and a high number of progressed. Timely and clear hospital administration, the operating healthcare workers (3.8%, n=1,716 dissemination of information to theatre management unit (OTMU), of 44,672)9 getting infected in the department was important to nursing staff and other surgical China also initially sowed doubts avoid confusion or misinterpretation departments. The aims were to ensure and uncertainty. YouTube videos of of instructions. In messaging and that all staff were ready to perform overwhelmed hospital staff, family communication to the entire surgery on any positive or suspected separations and tearful workers went department, there were several COVID-19 cases, to reduce risk of viral and were shared repeatedly, principles adopted: nosocomial infection for the surgical leading to a sense of dread and • All critical information was teams and to ensure continuity of impending doom. disseminated via the HOD; care for all surgical patients. The TF creation was thus • Information disseminated While the hospital measures were instrumental in sieving much of the included explanation of the being discussed and implemented, data available, determining what current international and national JUN 2020 SMA News 15
status to give context for the frequency identification tags to hospital measures; track movement within the hospital • Regular briefings were conducted setting. This would simplify contact at a paced fashion (once every tracing if there were staff exposure two weeks) to avoid information to COVID-19 patients. Staff were fatigue. Frequency would be reminded to carry tags while on duty, increased to weekly as the disease and those who developed a fever or outbreak severity worsened; respiratory symptoms were screened and advised to only seek medical • Briefings were conducted to all consultation within the hospital staff staff regardless of rank; clinic. Travel advisories and leave • TF members would reinforce policies were adhered to strictly. information and clarify directives to ensure compliance after Staff preparation briefing; and 1 PPE and PAPR training • 360 degrees feedback was sought from all ranks to ensure all concerns A hospital-wide mask fitting and and blind spots were addressed. refresher of personal protective of the virus beyond the OR. A unique equipment (PPE) donning and COVID-19 workflow and protocol Discipline doffing was conducted by staff from was designed by the OTMU team. Infection Control. Refresher training The best measures planned would A FDR was first conducted by the for the use and maintenance of the be irrelevant if staff attitudes did HOD, and two cases on real patients powered air-purifying respirator not view these measures seriously. It with consent – an elective surgical (PAPR) by educators from the was crucial for the senior staff in the procedure and endoscopy – were Department of Occupational and department to lead by example. Prior used to confirm the workflow. All Environmental Medicine was also experience in the SARS 2003 outbreak members of the surgical team then provided to all staff. In our institution, lent weight to the seriousness of this did a physical walkthrough of the all healthcare workers were mask outbreak and none of the measures isolation OR to ensure familiarity of fitted with the PAPR CleanSpace® were criticised by the senior staff. surroundings as surgery on infectious HALO™ (CleanSpace Technology Pty Ensuring senior staff compliance to cases are not routinely performed. Ltd, Artarmon, NSW, Australia). All measures, refraining from spreading FDRs were subsequently conducted surgeons and junior staff completed rumours and abiding with the by every consultant and associate training within one week. leadership of the department were consultant over the following two to key to a successful implementation. Full dress rehearsals (FDR) three weeks to reinforce workflows The seniors would also supervise SKH has a purposeful built operating and ensure familiarity. juniors, provide feedback if needed, and monitor staff health and welfare. room (OR) with a negative pressure In this phase, it was also department environment designated as an BCP policy that any positive or suspected isolation OR. This is in contrast to the standard OR with positive pressure Staff segregation COVID-19 cases would only be reviewed and procedures performed relative to the surrounding air. The These were done on two tiers. At the isolation OR reduces dissemination first tier, senior staff were advised by senior staff. on segregation between the tertiary Department discipline also hospital (Singapore General Hospital) involved compliance with hospital 2 and our hospital. This was to reduce measures of temperature monitoring cross infection between hospitals and all staff were reminded to do and also ensured that there was no so twice daily by administrative confusion in adhering to institution staff. Oral digital thermometers workflows, policies and guidelines. were issued to all staff and there Surgical procedures that had been were also easily accessible digital forehead thermometers within pre-booked were allowed to proceed department offices. All temperatures but non-essential clinic services were were electronically recorded and suspended or transferred over to the entered into a hospital server; tertiary hospital specialists for follow- web-based forms were created up care. to facilitate ease of entry using For the second tier, the department personal smartphones. The hospital developed a “hot” and “cold” team had also issued individual radio- concept. The risk assessment matrix 16 JUN 2020 SMA News
determined that inpatients were replace the duties (ie, hot team A Conclusion the highest risk. Thus, the hot team replaced by cold team A). The hot The COVID-19 pandemic battle was designated to handle all acute team would then undergo risk affects all healthcare workers. There admissions and to perform ward matrix assessment as per hospital are multiple considerations in how rounds on elective patients that were policy, and be quarantined and a surgical unit functions and the post-surgery. The cold team was undergo testing till given clearance phases of planning will require hard assigned to the specialist outpatient by hospital administration to decisions, strong leadership and clinics. There were two subsets return to active duty. decisive communication. It is prudent (team A and team B) of hot teams In addition, all large-scale meetings to maintain a robust BCP to ensure that handled the emergency roster. were cancelled and department that surgical patients receive quality These include the comprehensive education programmes, such as care especially during this difficult coverage of acute admission, trauma, mortality rounds, tumour boards and time, and to reduce any compromise bleeder and endoscopic retrograde journal clubs, were to be confined in care as best as possible. cholangiopancreatography. It was within the hot or cold teams. All also decided that a seven-day hot medical students, foreign fellow and seven-day cold format would attachments and observerships were Information is accurate as of time of be implemented with overall team also cancelled. writing swapping after each seven-day cycle. There were several planning Reduction in elective work Legend rationales to this: Elective work is defined as elective 1. Elbow bump and thumbs up. Individuals, • All surgical staff had undergone surgeries, elective endoscopies and departments, whole of Singapore prepared the necessary PPE training and outpatient specialist clinics. There for COVID-19 war! were expected to have minimal were several planning considerations 2. Step by step visual aids to remind breaches that needed quarantine. to determine the extent of reduction donning and doffing protocols. In PPE and stress, such reminders are important to • There was a need for manpower in elective work: avoid mistakes and contamination to be deployed to high need areas • Based on our initial hot/cold in the event there was a spike of team divisions, there would be a References cases (eg, ICU or the emergency reduction of manpower. 1. World Health Organization. WHO department). • There was a need to anticipate a Coronavirus Situation Report 67. Available at: • A 14-day cycle was felt to possible increase in admissions https://bit.ly/2z4TZ0g. potentially lead to fatigue and from COVID-19 cases requiring 2. World Health Organization. WHO burnout, which could lead to PPE ward, high dependency or ICU beds. Coronavirus Situation Report 112. Available at: https://bit.ly/3bowQ6y. breaches. Hence a seven-day work For elective surgery, all cancer cycle was preferred. 3. Johns Hopkins University. COVID-19 cases and any benign cases that Dashboard by the Center for Systems Science • In the event a hot team subset was were symptomatic or had justifiable and Engineering (CSSE) at Johns Hopkins exposed and needed quarantine, indications were to proceed. Clinic and University (JHU). Available at: https://bit. the cold team subset would endoscopy cases were also reduced. ly/2K5jLDM. 4. Abdullah Z, Salamat H. Singapore confirms first case of Wuhan virus. Available at: https:// bit.ly/3ajfsQ9. Preparation 5. Ministry of Health Singapore. Situation report 11th May. Available at https://bit. ly/35Sa7hN. 6. Pryor A. SAGES and EAES recommendations regarding surgical response to COVID-19 cases. Available at: https://bit.ly/2wGZlhh. Task Force Staff Business 7. American College of Gastroenterology. Creation Preparation Continuity Plan COVID-19 clinical insights for our community of gastroenterologists and gastroenterology care providers. Available at: https://bit.ly/2VyAsg5. 1. Information 1. PPE and PAPR 1. Staff segregation 8. Royal College of Surgeons. Guidance for gathering and training 2. Reduction in surgeons working during the COVID-19 confidence pandemic. Available at: https://bit.ly/3epnji1. 2. Full dress elective work building rehearsals 9. Wu Z, McGoogan JM. Characteristics of and important lessons from the coronavirus disease 2. Messaging and 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak in China: summary communication of a report of 72 314 cases from the Chinese 3. Discipline Center for Disease Control and Prevention. JAMA 2020; 323(13):1239-42. JUN 2020 SMA News 17
OPINION Keeping the Mobile Phone CHARGED During a Blackout Text by Dr Christopher Cheok Dr Cheok is a senior consultant with the Maybe it was just me, but I was fairly that lions and tigers were infected in a Department of Forensic positive at the start of the circuit New York zoo. When was all this going Psychiatry in the Institute of breaker (CB). At that time, SARS-CoV-2 to end? We all need to take a deep Mental Health. He is also the was just thought to cause a respiratory breath, collect our thoughts and look President of the Singapore illness and little else. Then came the at the sky. Psychiatric Association and community CB and continued bad Chairman of Clarity Singapore, Doctors, like everyone else, have a mental health charity news – the virus could cause an auto- immune reaction in children, affect been impacted in some way by the providing psychotherapy. the brain, emerge through different coronavirus, the extent of which fluids below the navel from our bodies, depended on the place of practice. and the last straw came when the New Junior doctors were redeployed to England Journal of Medicine published roles they did not choose, specialists a letter reporting that the virus could were redeployed to emergency transmit between domestic cats and rooms to help screen patients and 18 JUN 2020 SMA News
private practitioners were affected expenses of the business and source there are lots of other good things by the CB. One of the things that hit for PPE, and he was getting really happening in the world. Spending us, but was not spoken much about anxious about the depressed financial time to watch videos on cute animals, was the impact of the reduced social markets. Although still able to work, nature or just non-COVID-19 news can interaction between friends and he had no choice in the matter, so be very therapeutic. For those who colleagues, and also how strange he felt more irritable, on edge and have significant depressed mood, people sounded with voices muffled without peace of mind. He wanted to irritability, anxiety or insomnia, the by their masks. Luckily for Singapore, know what he could do about it as his SMA and Singapore Psychiatric the number of deaths from COVID-19 wine collection was disappearing at a Association (SPA) have collaborated has been relatively low and personal faster rate than usual. to organise a list of our mental health protective equipment (PPE) has been There are many ways to keep our colleagues who are willing to help available to healthcare workers, spirits up for the long COVID-19 run doctors and self-help resources. The which reduced the risk of burnout and different strategies may work list can be found on their respective from having to worry about being for different people. One of the most websites. infected while making tough choices effective ways is to call someone While we await the end of the for patients. Doctors who have gone to chat and keep the chat positive. pandemic, as doctors, we need to through our training and selection Exercise is also important, but in acknowledge our own humanness are a resilient bunch. The Achilles reality not for everyone, though and attend to our physical as well heel is our sense of responsibility to anyone can walk in a park. Acts of as psychological needs. While the patient and need for control of a kindness bring hope to others and uncertainty is the new normal, what situation. The coronavirus disrupted many have been moved by well is certain is we can choose to care for that order. To keep performing at our wishes, small tokens of appreciation, ourselves and those around us. And best in this marathon COVID-19 fight, and food. When one can find quiet when self-care is not enough, we have we really need to pay attention to our time, focusing on our spirituality is family, friends and colleagues that we mental health and resilience. essential. While some have drunk can turn to, who can care for us. No one knew better about being more alcohol, others have snacked lit on two ends of the candle than more – moderating snacking and Alice* who called me the other day. drinking is part of self-care. While the *Names used in the article have been As a resident in training with primary news is inundated with COVID-19, changed school-aged children, she had to cope with seeing patients in the day and powering up again when she got home to help her young kids with Mental health support for our HCWs home-based learning. She candidly Consolidated below are some resources healthcare workers can tap on during the admitted to me that screaming did COVID-19 pandemic for psychological wellness and support. happen from time to time, and that she sometimes just answered the Taking care of my mental health https://bit.ly/3csawt0 questions for the kids so she could (courtesy of Woodlands Health Campus) get to sleep on time. She felt fatigued Burnout infographics yet could not stop worrying about https://bit.ly/2Xod33d (courtesy of Woodlands Health Campus) whether she brought any bugs home from work and whether her kids were Mental health tips keeping up with their education. It (courtesy of Tan Tock Seng Hospital Staff https://bit.wly/2Koj9cI did not help that after two weeks of Support Staff Programme) this punishing routine, she started waking up at 3 am before falling List of psychiatrists/counsellors who can asleep again at 5 am to catch some see doctors either for informal support or https://bit.ly/3dqtMsi more sleep before work. Another medical consultation ex-colleague, Ronald*, also messaged List of psychologists and workshops relating me on the pretext of asking for advice https://bit.ly/2AvYcL0 to COVID-19: for a patient. He had opened his general practice two years ago and National Care Hotline 1800-202-6868 business has dropped significantly during CB. He had to grapple with the To find out more about the resources and https://www.sma.org.sg/covid19 support available JUN 2020 SMA News 19
You can also read