Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...

Page created by Joel Mcdonald
 
CONTINUE READING
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
Melville Douglas
                                                          Focused
                                                          Quarterly Commentary
                                                          / Q1 2021

Staying the course
It has been just over a year since global equity markets reached their
lows on 23rd March 2020. A period when the outlook for not only
global growth but also humanity was extremely uncertain and difficult
to quantify. Companies around the world swiftly laid off employees in
the tens of millions as lockdown measures were enforced to contain
one of the worst humanitarian crises since the 1930s as COVID-19
became a global pandemic. Commodity prices collapsed whilst
companies’ capital expenditure programs were shelved as access to
funding at one stage became near impossible before central banks           Bernard Drotschie
stepped in. Over this period companies had to rapidly adapt to a very      / Chief Investment Officer
fast changing environment as consumers changed their spending
patterns and priorities and supply disruptions became the order of the
day. The burden of the health crisis has fallen unevenly across sectors,
with the non-tradable services sector most negatively affected –
tourism, hospitality and the high street bricks and mortar retail trade.
The impact on vulnerable income groups (women, the informal sector,
young workers, migrant workers and the less well-educated segment)
has also been significant as poverty levels have sadly increased.

The response by central banks and Governments has been a highly
effective coordinated effort of unconventional and unprecedented
monetary and fiscal support to stave off what was sure to be a
prolonged recession. The fiscal impetus alone has so far amounted to
more than 5% of Global GDP and more is on its way with the recently
approved $1.9 trillion support package in the US, which looks set to be
followed by Europe’s own fiscal stimulus program.
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
GLOBAL DEBT CONTINUES TO RISE SHARPLY

$ Trillion                                                               % of GDP, weighted avg.

290                                                                                         360

280
                                                                                            350
270

260
                                                                                            340
250
                                                                                                         Global debt (in USD)
240                                                                                         330
                                                                                                         % of GDP (rhs)
230
                                                                                            320
220

210
                                                                                            310
200

190                                                                                         300
       2013       2014         2015       2016     2017        2018   2019    2020

Source: IIF, BIS, IMF, National sources

In addition, the Biden administration has requested an additional $2 trillion which has been earmarked for
infrastructure projects over the next eight years. These are truly gigantic numbers, which combined with very
accommodative monetary (low interest rates) policies, the success of the inoculation programs globally,
pent up consumer demand and record high savings ratios should result in a very strong recovery in the global
economy, to a growth rate which has not been experienced since 2007. Over the longer term however, the
question of how governments plan to fund the increased levels of debt remains, and in time higher taxes or other
forms of austerity measures are a given. For now, policymakers have their foot on the economic accelerator
and are unlikely to ease off until economies are sustainably back on their feet and COVID-19 is under control.

VACCINE-POWERED STRENGTHENING
IMF NOW PROJECTS 2021 WILL BE THE BEST YEAR FOR GLOBAL GROWTH SINCE 2007

                                                                                                   5%
                                                                                                   4%
                                                                                                   3%
                                                                                                   2%
                                                                                                   1%    Annual GDP (YOY)
                                                                                                   0%
                                                                                                         Projections
                                                                                                   -1%
                                                                                                   -2%
                                                                                                   -3%

1980           1986             1992        1998             2004     2010      2016       2022

Source: International Monetary Fund World Economic Outlook
Note: 2020 is an estimate

Investment markets have quickly turned their attention to the change in the growth and inflation outlook and many are
starting to be concerned that central banks might be behind the curve, meaning that interest rates and quantitative
easing programs are perhaps too loose and accommodative at this stage of the economic cycle. This debate is not
going to disappear any time soon; inflation is bound to increase significantly over the next few months partly due to
supply constraints / bottlenecks (COVID-19 restrictions and more recently the Suez Canal traffic jam), but mostly
due to base effects. From the lows reached a year ago, the price of oil has more than tripled and industrial commodity
prices have also reached new highs. Furthermore, the price of certain goods such as apparel, as well as non-tradable
services, are expected to bounce back to pre-crisis levels once mobility restrictions have been fully relaxed.
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
INFLATION EXPECTATIONS DERIVED FROM 5-YEAR BREAK-EVEN RATES

Source: Bloomberg

The key message from central banks however, is that these factors should be transitory in nature and that they will
allow inflation to overshoot targeted levels to make up for a sustained period of disinflation since the Global Financial
Crisis, when inflation consistently surprised on the downside. Capacity utilisation remains low whilst unemployment
is still well above pre-crisis levels which would indicate that there is still substantial slack in the system to prevent
inflation from spinning out of control on a sustained basis, thus reducing the need for a more restrictive monetary
policy over the next couple of years. For now at least, policy makers are adamant that more stimulus is required to
safeguard the economy from “a longer, more painful recession now – and long-term scarring of the economy later”.

However, investment markets have become more concerned that excessive growth fueled by overly high levels of
monetary injections and fiscal support may at some stage lead to an inflation problem that needs to be addressed
by tighter monetary conditions (higher real interest rates) than expected - something markets haven’t really had
to contend with for quite some time. Evidence of how markets might react to a less supportive monetary policy
environment is clear and in line with previous cycles. Stocks that have run ahead of themselves and especially those
whose share prices have benefited from increased speculation on the back of cheap financing and easy access to
online trading and derivative platforms have experienced larger drawdowns than the rest of the market. The same
holds true for Emerging Market equities which have until recently benefitted from the “risk-on” cyclical trade, and
although these corrections are trivial compared to the gains over the past few years, they are starting to reconfirm a
familiar dynamic – central bank and, in particular, US Fed interest rate normalisation rarely unfolds without meaningful
asset price disruption somewhere.

PLUG POWER AND TESLA’S SHARE PRICES

                                                                                              Tesla Inc - Price

                                                                                              Plug Power Inc. - Price

Source: Factset

The examples above are not unique but do highlight the potential for more volatility ahead as interest rates (cost of
money) normalise and, at the same time, serves as a good illustration of some of the unintended consequences of very
cheap money, which instead of being deployed in the real economy to create employment is finding its way into short
term speculative investment bets.
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
Higher bond yields a headwind
While risk assets such as equities have continued to gain ground this year, government bonds have been on the backfoot
for a change, with bond investors suffering losses. Bond yields have adjusted to a much-improved economic outlook
and higher inflation expectations and we would expect this normalisation in bond yields, alongside the steepening of
yield curves, to continue as the global economy transitions from recession to expansion.

US YIELD CURVE
                                                                                     3.0

                                                                                     2.5

                                                                                     2.0
                                                                                                  Now
                                                                                                  One Week Ago
                                                                                     1.5
                                                                                                  One Month Ago
                                                                                     1.0          One Year Ago

                                                                                     0.5

                                                                                     0.0

                                                                                     -0.5
 6M 1Y 2Y 3Y        5Y     10Y          15Y          20Y                       30Y

Source: Bloomberg

      Conclusion
       The rebound in global economic activity is expected to be strong for 2021. A continuation of loose monetary
       and fiscal policies will underpin growth and together with the re-opening of economies provide a backdrop
       that is conducive for real (risk) assets. Inflation is sure to increase from recessionary lows and is expected
       to overshoot in the near term, which is likely to result in some volatility along the way as investors reposition
       their portfolios. Investors are concerned that increased inflation will result in higher interest rates and a
       less supportive monetary environment. While this is possible, central banks have been communicating a
       much more patient approach given the severity of, and uncertainties related to, last year’s pandemic crisis.
       Higher global bond yields (discount rates) will be a headwind for equity valuations, but this is expected to
       be more than offset by accelerating earnings growth.

       Our approach is to continue backing quality companies with secular and structural growth drivers,
       supported by strong balance sheets, while ensuring that we do not overpay for them. In addition, these
       companies tend to have pricing power given the uniqueness of their offering, something that will become
       very important once higher costs start to surface or in the (unexpected) event of an economic downswing.
       Many other companies do not have the same ability to weather the storm from higher inflation (and interest
       rates) and will thus find it difficult to maintain their profit margins and dividend growth.

       We cannot be exactly sure when interest rates will normalise given that the US Federal Reserve (FOMC),
       along with many other central banks, are adamant that monetary conditions will remain ‘ultra-loose’ for
       the foreseeable future, but we do expect lower investment returns and perhaps more volatility in future for
       multi-asset mandates and have positioned portfolios accordingly.
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
Light at the end of the tunnel
The South African economy is slowly recovering from a devastating 2020 during which the economy shrunk by 7%.
This was the second-largest annual contraction since 1920, when real GDP fell by 11.9% and was also about five times
larger than the contraction of 1.5% that followed the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) in 2009. Despite all the despair and
uncertainty, investment markets have more than recovered their losses over the period and the outlook for investors
remains positive given the strong recovery in earnings expected this year and undemanding valuations.

SA ASSET CLASS PERFORMANCE
TOTAL RETURN, YEAR-TO-DATE

                                                                                                 Cash

                                                                                                 All Share Index

                                                                                                 MSCI World in ZAR

                                                                                                 All Bond Index

COVID-19 remains a risk, but companies and individuals have successfully adapted to the new environment.
The impact of the second wave on the economy was much smaller than the original outbreak and we would expect
an even smaller impact should a third wave of infections materialise post the April public holidays. Technology has
played an important part in making this transition possible. Furthermore, the intervention by government and the SA
Reserve Bank has been equally important. Lower interest rates together with significant liquidity injections and tax
breaks have allowed many households and companies to survive. Unfortunately, there were casualties along the way,
with the travel and leisure industries worst affected. The full extent of the crisis will only be revealed in time as many
smaller companies simply do not have the liquidity or ability to service the higher debt levels incurred over the period .

Although many of us still work from home, activity levels in the economy have picked up a gear and this will continue
as vaccines are rolled out, paving the way for a more “normalised” environment. The mining industry has benefitted
hugely from higher metal prices, which have been brought about from supply disruptions and strong demand out
of China. Similarly, a strong rainfall season had a positive effect on agriculture. Other sectors/companies have also
benefitted from the stay-at-home theme, such as DIY/Hardware sales as individuals have either been renovating their
homes or added rooms to earn an extra source of income during the crisis. These benefits may well not be sustainable,
but for now many companies will be making hay while the sun shines. For the rest of the economy, continued support
from government intervention policies and improved service delivery will remain of utmost importance.

In this regard, there are more signs of government slowly getting its mojo back after it had to deal with one of the worst
crises in history. Even though government was found wanting in so many respects, there is no doubt that President
Cyril Ramaphosa has gained more support from within the party. This is an important development that should open
the door for improved execution and implementation of the government’s growth and recovery initiatives, which
primarily relate to improved infrastructure, service delivery, reducing the costs of doing business and eradicating
corruption. The task at hand is immense given the lack of capacity and experience within government and so therefore
closer collaboration with the private sector is of the utmost importance.
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
The recently awarded contracts announced by the Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy to supply 2,000
megawatts of emergency power to address the gap in electricity generating capacity is a step in the right direction and
illustrates what can be achieved. The power will be produced from a range of sources including solar, wind, liquified
natural gas and battery storage. Government has also released a request for proposals for the procurement of a
further 2,600 megawatts of renewable energy from independent power producers. Over the next 12 months, four
more requests for proposals for new power generation projects in renewable energy, gas, coal and battery storage
respectively will be released.

The base that the economy comes from is low after years of mismanagement and elevated corruption that have
resulted in hardship, unemployment and social unrest, but therein lies the opportunity. An improvement in confidence
is essential to lift the declining investment cycle and will go a long way to get the economy on its feet again and end
the continued outflow of capital by foreign investors. It’s now up to all stakeholders in the economy to pull together in
a concerted effort to change its growth trajectory.

Monetary support to continue amid fiscal restraint
In a unanimous decision, the Monetary Policy Committee members left the repo rate unchanged during their March
meeting. The outlook for inflation remains subdued and although the impact of a higher oil price, electricity prices and
other administrative prices will result in higher headline inflation, the expectation is that the second-round effects on
core inflation will be temporary and contained in nature, given the underlying weakness in final demand. Furthermore,
governor Lesetja Kganyago also reiterated that the Reserve Bank stands ready to inject additional liquidity as and
when required. This is crucially important to keep the funding lines open for companies in need.

SA INFLATION: HEADLINE AND CORE

                                                                                                     CPI, Headline
                                                                                                     CPI, Core

The support from the Reserve Bank is important at this juncture of the country’s economic cycle given that National
Treasury will be focused on rebuilding fiscal buffers through countercyclical fiscal tightening after years of unnecessary
countercyclical fiscal expansion. Government’s finances are dire and although the National Budget Speech delivered
a positive surprise in term of government’s debt trajectory over the next few years, compared to what was expected
at the Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement in October last year, execution risks remain high as the bulk of the
proposed savings are expected to come from the public sector wage bill over the medium term. Government cannot
afford to loosen the reins at this stage as any evidence of further deterioration is sure to result in further downgrades
by the international credit rating agencies. In such an event, South Africa will be rated as highly speculative (from
speculative), which will immediately result in an even higher cost of capital for the country. It is alarming to think that
the yield differentiation between a South African and an American 10-year bond is nearly 8% - an illustration of the
country’s debt predicament.
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
SOUTH AFRICA’S SOVEREIGN CREDIT RATING

 5

4
      Levels above Investment Grade
 3

 2

 1
                                                                                                S&P
0
                                                                                                Fitch
-1                                                                                              Moody’s
-2
      Levels below Investment Grade
-3

-4
 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020

Under the difficult circumstances, Minister of Finance Tito Mboweni delivered a reasonable budget. The reallocation
of spending from public sector compensation while staying committed towards infrastructure spend is encouraging.
An improvement in basic service deliveries such as water and electricity, improved road and railway, port and
telecommunication infrastructure, student housing and upgrading of ports will provide the necessary infrastructure
that will allow domestic companies to grow and compete internationally.

Another key feature of this budget was the determination by government to contain spending and optimise revenue
collection by adopting tax efficient ways of doing so. It was therefore encouraging that government has decided to opt
for growth and fiscal consolidation through putting a lid on public sector wages, instead of putting additional pressure
on households and corporates, after one of the deepest recessions in history. The minister pledged to reduce the
corporate tax rate to 27% for companies with years of assessment commencing on or after 1 April 2022. In our view,
this is a good move on the part of government as one of the objectives for government is to lower the cost of doing
business and to make South African companies more competitive. With that in mind, this will certainly assist and
should be a step in the right direction. In time and when business confidence improves, this reduction in tax rate
should afford companies the opportunity to invest and potentially employ more people.

The JSE delivers the best Q1 performance in 15 years
Q1 PERFORMANCE
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
The domestic equity market has de-rated relative to emerging
markets and is currently trading at the lower end of its historical
range – an attractive entry point for patient investors

The JSE All Share Index produced its best Q1 performance in 15 years by
returning 13% and is one of the best performing equity markets this year. A
good result given the economic backdrop but does speak to the underlying
value in locally listed equities. Although the returns were reasonably broad
based, domestic financials continued to lag the rest of the market on the back
of poor results and weak guidance from management. Platinum group metals
(PGMs) in particular had another strong quarter and some of the stocks that
were under significant pressure a year ago in the leisure, retail and chemical
industries have rebounded sharply. Naspers, which makes up more than
20% of the index, contributed positively as its share price forged ahead.

SOUTH AFRICA VS EM FORWARD P/E

                                                                                   MSCI South Africa
                                                                                   MSCI EM

While returns have been positive, the domestic equity market has de-rated
relative to emerging markets and is currently trading at the lower end of its
historical range – an attractive entry point for patient investors. The derating
can be explained by the surge in earnings growth (+50%) expected this year.
What is perhaps most surprising is that earnings increased by 5% during
2020. However, this is not a true reflection of how domestic companies
performed last year. Strong earnings growth from materials (resources),
which benefited from the windfall of higher commodity prices, combined
with another strong performance in profits from Naspers (Tencent), explains
the positive outcome. Domestic orientated companies that are reliant on
South Africa’s economic developments have experienced a much tougher
environment as illustrated in the table below, which provides a summary of
last year’s earnings growth and the consensus forecasts over the medium
term.
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
EPS GROWTH (%)
                                                                  2020           2021E          2022E           2023E
MSCI SA                                                             5.0           56.0             11.9                7.4
Consumer Discretionary                                             21.1           37.7            30.2                11.8
Retailing                                                           21.1          37.7            30.2                11.8
Multiline Retail                                                  -54.4           65.6             19.1               15.8
Internet & Direct Marketing Retail                                 -4.9           26.0            37.5                32.2
Speciality Retail                                                  -8.3           19.0              9.4                8.5
Consumer Staples                                                  -19.2           23.4             18.9                9.6
Food, Beverage & Tobacco                                          -29.2           52.2             12.5               14.8
Food & Staples Retailing                                           -17.6          19.3             20.1                8.7
Energy                                                              0.4           28.6            -19.0                2.2
Oil, Gas & Consumer Fuels                                           0.4           28.6            -19.0                2.2
Financials                                                        -34.4           39.3             23.9               17.7
Banks                                                             -50.5           60.1             27.3               16.9
Insurance                                                         -23.0           26.0             20.4               15.6
Diversified Financials                                             -13.8          26.9             21.8               21.0
Health Care                                                       -10.3            -5.6            14.1                8.2
Pharmaceuticals                                                   -10.3            -5.6            14.1                8.2
Industrials                                                       -23.7            18.0            16.9                9.2
Capital Goods                                                     -23.7            18.0            16.9                9.2
Materials                                                         96.7           109.7             -2.3               -3.5
Metals & Mining                                                  285.2            78.7             -4.4               -7.6

Communication Services                                             37.7             7.3            11.3               16.5
Real Estate                                                       -37.0            52.7            10.4                8.2

SA equity valuations are attractive and as economic momentum gathers; domestic orientated stocks are well
positioned to outperform. Resources have delivered exceptional returns over the past few years, but with profits
expected to peak this year, returns may well be more challenging in the future.

    Conclusion
     Investors will be pleased with the rebound in investment markets over the past 12 months. Returns from
     South African assets (equities, bonds and the domestic currency) have outperformed global assets
     handsomely over the same period – base effects did play an important role, but it does illustrate the
     importance of focusing on absolute and relative valuations even when the chips are down.

     The global economy is on the mend with strong growth expected over the next two years. South Africa
     will benefit from the upswing as global trade accelerates. An improved global backdrop coupled with low
     inventory levels and a very accommodative monetary policy bode well for South Africa’s recovery once
     confidence returns. Now that the worst of the pandemic, with all of its uncertainties, is behind us, companies
     will shift their focus from survival mode to growing profits again. Similarly, government will also be in a
     better position to execute on its growth and recovery plan, which if successfully implemented, will assist in
     improving the country’s long-term growth outlook.

     South African assets offer good value. Government bonds are offering real income yields in excess of 6%
     and the equity market is trading at depressed levels. Not unexpected given the enormous challenges faced
     by the fiscus and domestic economy. But a turn in global confidence combined with a strong earnings
     recovery are expected to underpin returns this year.
Melville Douglas Focused Quarterly Commentary - 522 Origin ...
Domestic Asset Allocation
                                                                 inflation. South African bonds were not spared and followed
 Domestic Equity                                Overweight
                                                                 suit. This development, aside from the risk of potential
 Domestic Cash                                      Neutral      further credit downgrades, poses the largest near-term
                                                                 risk to the asset class. Income yields are attractive relative
 Domestic Bonds                                     Neutral      to cash and long-term expected inflation. We would expect
                                                                 that returns from current levels will predominantly be
 Global Equities                               Underweight       derived from the income (coupons) earned. The outlook for
                                                                 South Africa’s government debt profile remains a concern,
 Offshore Bonds                                Underweight
                                                                 but government remains steadfast in its objective of
                                                                 keeping costs under control. In addition, an improvement in
                                                                 tax collections bodes well for the coming year as economic
Domestic Equities – Overweight. Domestic equities                growth improves.
delivered a very strong return during the first quarter of
the year. Expected returns from both a bottom up and             Cash – Neutral.
a top down perspective remain attractive with double
digit returns expected over the next 12 months. This is a        Offshore Fixed Income – Underweight. Even after the
function of attractive valuations and a rebound in earnings      recent sell-off in developed market bonds, income yields
from depressed levels, which will further be supported by        remain unattractive in both absolute and inflation adjusted
an improving economic backdrop. Any tangible signs of            terms and we would expect yields to continue to normalise
reforms in South Africa or an improvement in the domestic        to higher levels as inflation increases and the global
growth outlook will unlock significant value for investors. A    economy recovers.
return to dividend payments by many domestic companies
will also be welcomed as cash earnings improve.

Offshore Equities – Underweight. Although we expect
positive returns from offshore equities over the next 12
months, we find domestic equities at current valuations
more attractive. Elevated valuations in offshore listed
equities are however expected to be supported by low
interest rates in developed markets. Strong and positive
earnings growth will continue to underpin returns, but
this should to some extent be hampered by the fairly rich
starting valuations. In other words, a de-rating in valuations
is our base case.
                                                                 Bernard Drotschie
Domestic Fixed Income – Neutral. Global bonds have sold          / Chief Investment Officer
off this year on an improved global backdrop and higher
Domestic Equity
                                                                 peers measured in US Dollars over the quarter as
 Basic material                                Underweight
                                                                 valuations catch up to the rest of the world. The JSE
 Industrials                                   Underweight       capped swix returned 12.0% in USD over the quarter
                                                                 whereas the MSCI AC World Index and the MSCI
 Consumer goods                                 Overweight       Emerging Market Index returned 4.6% and 2.3% in
                                                                 US Dollars respectively. Globally, macro-economic
 Healthcare                                         Neutral
                                                                 factors continue to be supportive of risk assets, with
 Consumer services                             Underweight       unprecedented monetary and fiscal policy in place. This
                                                                 should be supportive of South African equities in the near
 Telcos                                             Neutral      term given that our equities look relatively cheap when
                                                                 compared to global peers. We do however need to be
 Financials                                     Overweight
                                                                 cognisant of global yields reversing off very low levels.
 Technology                                     Overweight       This was evidenced in the first quarter of 2021 where
                                                                 we witnessed some short sharp sell offs as the threat of
                                                                 rising yields emerged.

South African equity continued its strong momentum from          Crucially, South Africa needs to execute on the vaccine
the fourth quarter of 2020 into the first quarter of 2021,       rollout and manage the fiscal situation which has
with the JSE capped swix delivering a first quarter return of    deteriorated dramatically as GDP slumped and the
12.6%, bringing the rolling twelve month return to 54.2%,        required sovereign borrowings increased in 2020. Longer
admittedly off a low base given where the trough of the          term the country requires investment to stimulate growth
market was on 23rd March 2020.                                   and job creation. The current GDP forecasts will not be
                                                                 enough to meaningfully reduce the unemployment rate,
Most sectors showed very strong performances for the             crucial to company earnings growth and sustainable
quarter, with telecommunications leading the way and             equity returns.
basic materials not far behind as the strong performance
from 2020 continues into 2021 for the cyclical sector. Other     Many listed South African companies have, however,
notable sectors were the technology, industrials, consumer       managed their way through a very difficult 2020 and the
services and healthcare sectors which are all benefitting        balance sheets for the most part appear to be resilient,
from a better economic outlook than initially anticipated.       despite falling earnings. These strong balance sheets
Some of the sectors that lagged the overall performance          should allow companies to recover and many who cut
in the first quarter include financials and property, where      or did not pay dividends in 2020 should resume the
greater uncertainty exists in terms of the earnings recovery     distributions in 2021.
into 2021 and beyond.
                                                                 We expect more volatility for the rest of 2021.The opening
Despite the second wave of COVID-19 cases, which started         of the economy and capacity utilisation are of utmost
in December 2020 with the full effects coming through in         importance. Many share prices have recovered strongly
January and February 2021, equities appear to be looking         in anticipation of the earnings recovery. Earnings misses
through the near-term virus impacts. South African               could therefore have a significantly negative impact off the
government imposed restrictions to curb the spread of the        current valuations. Now, more than ever, stock selection
virus are less restrictive on the economy than the lockdowns     and diversification are paramount.
imposed in 2020. Unfortunately, the social and economic
impact will have long-lasting effects on the country and
many of the companies’ earnings will not recover to the 2019
base for several years.

Despite an improvement coming off record lows, business
confidence has improved, however, not to the required level
to promote investment and job creation given the ongoing
policy uncertainty and lack of reliable electricity. We should
however, experience a positive effect from short term
inventory restocking as most companies drew down on
inventory in 2020 to conserve cash.
                                                                  Paolo Senatore
Despite these factors, South African equities significantly
                                                                  / Head: Domestic Equity Strategy
outperformed global equities and our emerging market
Domestic Fixed Income
                                                                Early this quarter, the country, just like the rest of the globe
 Government                                         Neutral
                                                                began the ambitious programme to inoculate its population
 Inflation Linked                              Overweight       to combat the spread of COVID-19. The R100 billion
                                                                reduction in the tax deficit estimates that were announced
 State Owned Enterprise                       Underweight       in the budget will go a long way in funding this programme
                                                                without stretching the fiscus further.

Budgeting in South Africa has proven to be a difficult          The central bank in its two meetings this quarter has kept
juggling act for the Finance Ministry over the last few years   interest rates on hold and, significantly in the last meeting
due to the deteriorating fiscal metrices of the country.        held in mid-March, all five members of the MPC voted
This coupled with the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic,           unanimously to keep rates on hold. This is significant as
from the beginning of last year, have compounded the            it may be signalling that members of the monetary policy
economic and financial problems faced by South Africa.          committee are now in agreement that the interest rate
As a result of these economic and financial difficulties, all   cutting cycle has bottomed.
three rating agencies eventually downgraded the country’s
sovereign rating to non-investment grade. It was against        Conclusion
this backdrop that the FY2021/22 budget was delivered at
the end of February.                                            / We believe that the interest rate cutting cycle by the
                                                                  central bank has bottomed, however, there is a very long
In the budget speech Minister Tito Mboweni minister               way to go before interest rates are adjusted higher.
succeeded in delivering a more realistic and achievable           Risk to the interest rate trajectory remains tilted to the
debt and fiscal consolidation trajectory, revising the            downside
matrices slightly down from the October forecasts.
                                                                / Mboweni’s budget was well received by the market and
                                                                  rating agencies have taken a cautious approach awaiting
In the budget                                                     implementation of the ambitious plans in the budget

/ Estimated peak for total debt was reduced to 88.9% of         / We are concerned that in the budget implementation risks
  GDP in 2025-26 compared with the 95.3% forecast in              remain as the bulk of the proposed savings will still come
  October’s mid-term budget                                       from the wage bill

/ Consolidated fiscal deficit was seen at 14% of GDP vs.        / At current levels, bond yields are attractive and offer us
  15.7% in the MTBPS                                              an opportunity to increase the duration of the fund

/ The deficit is now expected to narrow to 9.3% in the
  fiscal year through March 2022 and to 6.3% of GDP by
  2023-24

/ Tax brackets were adjusted by more than inflation and
  as a result giving back to taxpayers about R2.2 billion in
  relief

/ Determination by government to contain spending and
  optimise revenue collection by adopting tax efficient
  means to do so

                                                                    Mzimasi Mabece
                                                                    / Head of Fixed Income
Domestic Market Performance / as at 31 March 2021
EQUITY                               MARCH      QTR       12M
All Share Index                       1.6       13.1      54.0

Capped SWIX Index                     3.7       12.6      54.2

Resources                             1.2       18.7      92.5

Financials                            0.8       2.5       37.6

Industrials                           1.9       13.0      38.2

All Bond Index                        -2.5      -1.7      17.0

MSCI US                               1.1       5.9       31.1

MSCI UK                               0.0           7.1   15.3

MSCI Emerging                         -4.0      2.8       31.0

MSCI AC World                         0.1           5.1   27.8

US DOLLAR RETURNS                    MARCH      QTR       12M
MSCI US                               3.7       5.4       58.6

MSCI UK                               2.6       6.5       39.4

MSCI Japan                            1.1           1.6   39.7

MSCI Emerging                         -1.5      2.3       58.4

MSCI AC World                         2.7       4.6       54.6

Citigroup WGB Index                   -2.1      -5.7      1.8

CURRENCY VS. US DOLLAR               MARCH      QTR       12M
Rand                                  2.3       -0.5      20.7

Euro                                  -2.9      -4.0      6.3

Yen                                   -3.8      -6.7      -2.9

Sterling                              -1.1      0.8       11.0
Melville Douglas
Melville Douglas Investment Management (Pty) Ltd is a subsidiary of Standard Bank Group Limited.
Melville Douglas Investment Management (Pty) Ltd (Reg. No. 1962/000738/06) is an Authorised Financial Services Provider. (FSP number 595).

This summary brochure has been prepared for information purposes only and is not an offer (or solicitation of an offer) to buy or sell the product. This document and the information in
it may not be reproduced in whole or in part for any purpose without the express consent of Melville Douglas.

All information in this document is subject to change after publication without notice. While every care has been taken in preparing this document, no representation, warranty or
undertaking, express or implied, is given and no responsibility or liability is accepted by Melville Douglas as to the accuracy or completeness of the information or representations in this
document. Melville Douglas is not liable for any claims, liability, damages (whether direct or indirect, actual or consequential), loss, penalty, expense or cost of any nature, which you
may incur as a result of your entering into any proposed transaction/s or acting on any information set out in this document.

Some transactions described in this document may give rise to substantial risk and are not suitable for all investors and may not be suitable in jurisdictions outside the Republic of South
Africa. You should contact Melville Douglas before acting on any information in this document, as Melville Douglas makes no representation or warranty about the suitability of a product
for a particular client or circumstance. You should take particular care to consider the implications of entering into any transaction, including tax implications, either on your own or with
the assistance of an investment professional and should consider having a financial needs analysis done to assess the appropriateness of the product, investment or structure to your
particular circumstances. Past performance is not an indicator of future performance

                                                                                                                                                                 Q1 2021        |     2021-031
You can also read