Mallow Town Hall Theatre Mallow, County Cork - Architectural Heritage Impact Assessment - Phase 2 - Dr Elena Turk
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Architectural Heritage Impact May 2021 Assessment - Phase 2 Mallow Town Hall Theatre PROJECT: Mallow Town Hall Theatre Mallow, County RMP/RPS RPS 27 Cork RMP CO033- 093-- Historic Town CLIENT Cork County Council Dr Elena Turk
Architectural Heritage Impact Assessment - Phase 2 Mallow Town Hall Dr Elena Turk Blue Brick Heritage 5 Annmount, Friars Walk, Cork web: www.bluebrickheritage.com | email: info@bluebrickheritage.com
Table of Contents Introduction 1 Site location 1 Legal Status 1 Archaeological and historical background 2 Extant Structure record 8 External description 8 Internal description 14 Basement 14 Ground floor 17 First floor 23 Second floor 28 Assessment 36 Date 36 Significance 36 Proposed development 39 Impacts and recommendations. 39 General Approach to Works 42 Conclusion/Summary 43 Bibliography 44 Books, reports and thesis. 44 Archives 44 i
Figure 33: Room GF4 north wall.���������������������������������������� 18 List of Figures Figure 34: View to room GF4 from south.������������������������� 18 Figure 1: Site location within Mallow Town, North Cork.������������������������������������������������������������1 Figure 35: View to room GF5 from north.�������������������������19 Figure 2: HIstoric Environment Mapping, Town Figure 36: Fireplace room GF5���������������������������������������������19 Hall outlined.���������������������������������������������������������2 Figure 37: Room GF6.������������������������������������������������������������19 Figure 3: Speed's Map of Cork 1610 after Cork Figure 38: Room GF7.������������������������������������������������������������19 City Library digital archives.�������������������������������3 Figure 39: View to room GF8.����������������������������������������������20 Figure 4: Taylor and Skinners Road Map, 1777.����������������4 Figure 40: Room GF9.������������������������������������������������������������20 Figure 5: Ordnance Survey Map of the Manor of Mallow, 1831.����������������������������������������������������������5 Figure 41: Fireplace room GF9��������������������������������������������20 Figure 6: First Edition OS map, Mallow c.1840.���������������7 Figure 42: Room GF10.����������������������������������������������������������21 Figure 8: Eason Collection image c.1900 NLI Figure 43: Room GF11�����������������������������������������������������������21 EAS_0900 .�������������������������������������������������������������7 Figure 44: Room GF11 hall.��������������������������������������������������21 Figure 7: 25 inch OS map, c.1900.���������������������������������������7 Figure 45: Room FF1, doors to hall from stairs.���������������23 Figure 9: Detail from 'Town Hall ruins, Mallow' c.1920 (www.rareirishstuff.com).������������������������7 Figure 46: FF1 doors at first floor landing.�������������������������23 Figure 10: View to roof at west gable 'House'.����������������������8 Figure 47: Room FF2.������������������������������������������������������������23 Figure 11: View to roof, hall at rear, from west.������������������8 Figure 48: Room FF2, south wall and southeast corner.�24 Figure 12: Front.�����������������������������������������������������������������������9 Figure 49: Room FF3.������������������������������������������������������������24 Figure 13: East.�������������������������������������������������������������������������9 Figure 50: Room FF3.������������������������������������������������������������24 Figure 14: East.�����������������������������������������������������������������������10 Figure 51: Room FF4 from south.���������������������������������������25 Figure 15: South.�������������������������������������������������������������������� 11 Figure 52: Fireplace room FF4.��������������������������������������������25 Figure 16: West.���������������������������������������������������������������������� 11 Figure 53: Room FF4, door.��������������������������������������������������25 Figure 17: Fire stair detail.���������������������������������������������������� 11 Figure 54: Room FF5.������������������������������������������������������������25 Figure 18: Door to basement from ground floor level..��� 14 Figure 55: Fireplace FF5.�������������������������������������������������������25 Figure 19: Basement stairs.��������������������������������������������������� 14 Figure 56: Room FF6 from south.���������������������������������������25 Figure 20: Room B1.��������������������������������������������������������������� 14 Figure 57: Room FF7.�������������������������������������������������������������26 Figure 21: Room B2.��������������������������������������������������������������15 Figure 58: Room FF8 looking North�����������������������������������26 Figure 22: Door to Room B3.������������������������������������������������15 Figure 59: West wall FF8.������������������������������������������������������27 Figure 23: Room B3 from north end.����������������������������������15 Figure 60: Room FF8 from north.���������������������������������������27 Figure 24: Detail of arches.���������������������������������������������������15 Figure 61: View to room FF9 (understage).�����������������������27 Figure 25: Entrance door (Room GF1).������������������������������ 16 Figure 62: Detail to studwork.���������������������������������������������27 Figure 26: Room GF1 looking north.���������������������������������� 16 Figure 63: Steps FF9 stairs.���������������������������������������������������28 Figure 27: Cieling room GF1.����������������������������������������������� 16 Figure 64: View to landing SF1 (looking south).��������������28 Figure 28: GF1 looking south with stairs.�������������������������� 16 Figure 65: Access to rear from stairwell.����������������������������28 Figure 29: Stairwell from ground floor room GF1.����������� 16 Figure 66: Detail to stairs.�����������������������������������������������������29 Figure 30: Room GF2������������������������������������������������������������� 17 Figure 67: Room SF2.�������������������������������������������������������������29 Figure 31: View to Room GF3 from north in GF2.���������� 18 Figure 68: Room SF2 at east.������������������������������������������������29 Figure 32: Room GF3 at south of partition.����������������������� 18 Figure 69: Room SF3.�������������������������������������������������������������29 Figure 70: Room SF4 range.��������������������������������������������������29 iii
Blue Brick Heritage Figure 71: Room SF5.�������������������������������������������������������������29 Figure 72: Fireplace SF5..������������������������������������������������������30 Figure 73: Room SF6.�������������������������������������������������������������30 Figure 74: Room SF7.�������������������������������������������������������������30 Figure 75: Detail to cistern SF7.������������������������������������������� 31 Figure 76: Detail to seat, SF7������������������������������������������������ 31 Figure 77: Detail to window SF7.����������������������������������������� 31 Figure 78: Room SF8.�������������������������������������������������������������32 Figure 79: Detail of floor SF8.����������������������������������������������32 Figure 80: Fireplace SF8.�������������������������������������������������������32 Figure 81: Room SF9.�������������������������������������������������������������32 Figure 82: Room SF10.�����������������������������������������������������������32 Figure 83: Floor SF10.������������������������������������������������������������33 Figure 84: View to SF11.��������������������������������������������������������33 Figure 85: Room SF12.�����������������������������������������������������������33 Figure 86: Detail of Door SF12.�������������������������������������������33 Figure 87: Occulus window SF12.���������������������������������������34 Figure 88: View down east stair SF13.��������������������������������34 Figure 89: View of east stair, FF9/SF13.������������������������������34 Figure 90: Base of west stair, FF9/SF13.������������������������������34 Figure 91: Timber batten boxing in, east stair.�����������������35 Figure 92: View to east stair from stage.����������������������������35 Figure 93: West stair from stage.�����������������������������������������35 iv
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork routes connecting Cork and Limerick, and be- Introduction tween Dungarvan and Killarney. Its strategic loca- The following report comprises phase 2 of tion contributed significantly to the development an Architectural Heritage Impact Assessment of of the town. the proposed development and conversion of the The town hall building is located at the junc- former Mallow Town Hall, Main Street, Mallow, tion of William O’Brien Street and Main Street, in Cork. It was undertaken by Dr Elena Turk MA of a highly visible location at the centre of the urban Bluebrick Heritage for Cork County Council Ar- area. chitects’ Department. An initial assessment (phase Figure Site location 1) was carried out in February 2021, during a pub- lic health mandated lockdown in response to the identification and spread of COVID-19. The pre- Legal Status sent second phase report includes a more complete The town hall is a protected structure (RPS survey of the building, and finalises assessments 27). It is, therefore, subject to statutory protection and recommendations for the project. under the Planning and Development Acts 2000- 2010. The location within an Architectural Con- The property is roughly divided into two areas, servation Area ACA- 1 gives it further protected a section at north running parallel to the street, under the acts. and a section at south set perpendicular. For ease of cross referencing between different specialists The building is recorded on the national in- reports on this development these will be referred ventory of architectural heritage (NIAH) as entry to as the ‘house’ and the ‘hall’ respectively. The number 20815027. It is rated as regionally impor- proposed development includes several interven- tant for architectural, artistic, and social reasons tions facilitated and accessed by a newly created and dated to c. 1930. The NIAH notes that; ‘Traboule’ which is to pass through the extant en- trance and hall of the structure and on to a rear courtyard. Interventions include; • A 200-seat theatre / auditorium to be inserted in the existing hall to the rear. • A ground floor studio space for rehearsals, community gatherings and devising work. • Box-office, administrative and staff offices. • Backstage and technical facilities. • Additional public spaces including a gallery, tourist information office, a cafe bar / func- tion room, and offices for the Local Enter- prise Office on the top floor. The drawings included below were prepared by Cork County Council Architects Department and annotated for the present report. Site location Mallow town is 35km from Cork City, and for many years was considered the administrative hub of the North Cork region. It is locally known as the Figure 1: Site location within Mallow Town, North Cork. ‘Crossroads of Munster’ due to the convergence of several important routes through it including 1
Blue Brick Heritage ‘The tall form of this building marks it out on the streetscape. It occupies a prominent site closing The Town Hall is proximity to RMP Co033- the vista from William O’Brien Street and having 006-, a church and graveyard located c.70m the J.J. Fitzgerald monument sited in front. Its red southeast. The town itself is classified as an ar- brick and limestone façade offers variety of tex- chaeological monument (Mallow RMP CO033- ture and materials to the street. The regular and 093-- Historic Town), and the Town Hall building symmetrical form is articulated by the quoins and is within the zone of potential established around platbands and enhanced by the retention of mar- this site. It is, thus, protected under the National gin sash windows to all openings. The well-carved Monuments (1930-2004) acts. As part of a heritage door and window surrounds to the centre bay offer site the area is protected under the National Herit- a focal point to the façade and add artistic interest age Plan (2002) and is protected under the policy of to the façade. The Celtic interlace motif to the door the Cork County Development Plan Objective HE surround is a typically Gaelic Revival feature and 3-1 ‘Protection of Archaeological sites’. mirrors similar detailing to the O’Brien monu- ment.’ (www.buildingsofireland.ie). The NIAH was established on a statutory ba- Archaeological and historical sis under the Architectural Heritage (National background Inventory) and Historic Monuments (Miscellane- ous Provisions) Act 1999. Its purpose is to identify, record, and evaluate the post-1700 architectural Mallow Town heritage of Ireland, as an aid in the protection and The placename ‘Mallow’ is derived from the conservation of the built heritage. Buildings listed Irish Magh nAla (the plain of the rock). The earli- in the NIAH are given special consideration in the est settlement in the area probably centred around Cork County Development Plan. an important fording point over the River Black- water, believed to be the ford known as Ath na Ceall (Bolster, 1971, 11). The town proper owes its continued development to a constant military presence in the area, beginning in the early period of the Norman invasion and continuing into the nineteenth century. The protection and security this presence offered encouraged the formation of a large settlement. King John is believed to have built a castle at Mallow in 1175, with Mallow Manor being estab- lished within 20 years of this by the Flemings fam- ily (it was soon transferred to the Roches by mar- riage). Ownership of the manor passed to Desmond Fitzgerald in 1282 (Zajac, 1995, 71). The town was considered important by the Fitzgerald’s for two reasons- it formed one in a chain of castles and for- tifications in a line between Cork harbour and the Fitzgerald stronghold in Limerick. It also created a fortified border between Norman occupied lands and those still held by the native Irish population Figure 2: HIstoric Environment Mapping, Town Hall (Crowley, 1997, 106). A licence was granted to the outlined. Fitzgerald’s in 1287 to collect tax for seven years to 2
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork pay for improvements to fortifications to Mallow Munster (Power 2007, 23). Early plantation devel- and Tralee (ibid). Although this was in the form opment in Munster is marked by the creation of of a murage grant, the funds were probably spent eight boroughs, three on sites associated with the on fortification of the castles in Mallow (there is iron industry in the Blackwater Valley (Tallow, Lis- no trace of a town wall). By 1298 an inquisition’s more, and Mallow). (Figure 3). findings were recording approximately 60 Anglo- The early stages of the plantation failed, due Norman families resident in the Ville of Mallow to the uprising of 1598, but towns like Mallow still (Zajac, 1997, 72, Crowley, 1995, 107, Bolster, 1971). benefited from the influx of new settlers to the St Anne’s Church, located to the south-east of the countryside. By the 1580s Mallow castle had been Main Street, is believed to be medieval in date and in the ownership of Sir Thomas Norreys, who re- would have served this community, which at the built the site as a fortified house (Mallow Castle). time was comprised of houses clustered along the In 1612-3 Mallow was granted a town charter by main street with Mallow Castle at the east and the James I, this gave the town all the rights of a bor- church to the south. The western terminus of the ough with the power to return representatives to town was soon to be defined by a second smaller government. The town continued to grow into the castle, called ‘Short Castle’ or ‘Castlegarr’ and seventeenth century, and by 1622 had 80 English would have been located towards the middle of houses on the main street (and up to 607 houses the current town of Mallow, near the Short Castle in total in the town and hinterlands) (Crowley, Street junction. 1997 and Grove-White 1916, 68). By 1641 there were 200 houses along the Main Street of Mal- The plantation period saw exponential growth low, 30 if which were well built of stone with slate in the urban core of the town. Munster became the roofs (Power et al 1994, Bolster, 1971, Zajac, et al first site of mass plantation in 1586 and by 1598 an 1995, Crowley, 1997). The town was attacked and estimated 4,000 settlers from Britain were living in burnt in 1642 during the Gaelic-Catholic rebellion. Figure 3: Speed's Map of Cork 1610 after Cork City Library digital archives. 3
Blue Brick Heritage Mallow was again attacked in 1645, by the Earl of The town continued to improve and grow into Castlehaven, at which time it was nearly reduced to the nineteenth century. A grant from the board of ruins. The area’s continuing strategic significance first fruits in 1818 provided for the replacement of helped it to recover and a grand jury presentment the medieval Saint Anne’s Church with St James’s to improve the fortifications of the town was made Church (designed by the Pain Brothers) - com- in 1660, when a threat from French forces was felt plete by 1824. St James’s avenue was opened lead- by settlers (Crowley, 1997, 110). In 1689 McDonagh ing from Davis Street to the church. By 1831 when forces planned an attack on the town to regain lost the Ordnance Survey team visited the town it had lands, however they were routed by Danish forces places of worship for numerous denominations under the command of S’Gravenmore and up to and many schools. More importantly, the efforts 500 Irish men are reputed to have been killed in of the Jephson family, the landlords of the Mallow the meadow to the south of the town (Lewis, 1837). Castle demesne, encouraged the economic and po- litical survival of the town with the construction By 1700 no less than 27 per cent of the popula- of the market square in 1823 and the Spa House tion was of Scottish or English origin or descent in 1828. compared with a mere two percent in 1600 (Cullen 1981, 15). Mallow spa was discovered in the 1720s The field books describe the town as ‘tolerably and it led to the development of the town as small handsome and contain[ing] some very good build- Georgian watering hole. By a census of 1775 there ings’ (Crowley, 1997, 109). Hamilton, around the were 400 houses north of the river along the main same date (1832, 381), described the town as ‘an and side streets (Bolster, 1971, 22). The late 18th agreeable post town and watering-place…a bor- century road maps created by Taylor and Skinner ough town returning a member of parliament… show the town development around an important [with]a church, a Roman Catholic Chapel, a public east-west/north-south crossroads. reading room and library, meeting houses, market house, cavalry barracks and a handsome bridge over the Blackwater’. While Hansbrow, in 1835 (322) noted that the town had several fair days and market days and had a population of 5,229. By 1837 Lewis paints an attractive picture of Mallow as a thriving, wealthy and somewhat up- market town; ‘…greatly enlarged and much improved; sev- eral spacious houses have been built, a new street has been opened to the north of the main street, and the latter has been lengthened by the addition of several respectable private houses at its western extremity. Most of the houses in this street have a projecting square window on the first floor, which has a singular but not unpleasing effect; the prin- cipal footpaths are flagged, though the streets are not paved; and the inhabitants are amply supplied with excellent water. The total number of houses, including the suburb of Ballydaheen, was, in 1831, 996, of which number 426 are slated and the re- mainder thatched; they are generally well built, and the town has, on the whole, a handsome and Figure 4: Taylor and Skinners Road Map, 1777. cheerful appearance… The season usually com- mences in May, and terminates in the beginning of 4
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork October, during which period there is a consider- on one meal or half a meal of bad potatoes a day’ able influx of company…. The inhabitants carry on (Bolster, 1971, 72). However, by the 1850s the popu- an extensive and lucrative trade with the opulent lation had begun to recover and the Griffith Valua- and populous districts in the neighbourhood… tion records numerous thriving trades based along There are in the town and its immediate vicinity the principal streets. By the 1871 census there were three soap and candle manufactories, three tan- 804 houses in the town and some of its prosper- yards, three flour-mills… the extensive brewery ity began to return with improvements in farming and malting establishment… two lime and salt and agricultural trade. By 1916, when Grove-White works, and a small manufactory of blankets and surveyed the town, the Town Hall had been built flannel... Branches of the Provincial and Agricul- and the main streets were lit by gas light (Grove- tural Banks have been recently established in the White, 1916, 71). The later business directories of town. The projected railway from Dublin to Va- the 1920s and 1930s give a much wider range of lencia will, if carried into effect, pass close to the business for the area including arms and ammuni- town… (Lewis, 1837, 338). tion dealers, bakers, smiths, boot and shoemakers, warehouses, builders, cattle dealers, china, glass Mallow workhouse was built in 1842 and by and earthenware dealers, milliners, grocers, hair- 1848 the town was connected to the Great South- dressers, hosieries, ironmongers, lodging houses, a ern and Western Railway network (Crowley, 1997, music teacher, a painters, a pawnbrokers, a plumb- 108). While the town was prosperous with numer- er, a stationer, refreshment rooms, tobacconists, ous great houses in the vicinity, the famine did undertakers and numerous vintners (Guy, 1921, have a significant impact (population decreased by 375-378). 33% in the parish at this time according to Crowley (1997, 109)). At the peak of the famine one visi- tor to mallow records ‘Nearly one half of the en- The Town Hall tire population are in actual want of food, living The first edition OS mapping shows that the plot layout and building footprint c.1840 was re- markably like the present layout. The laneway to the east of the property is shown as a full func- tional open lane rather than the covered entrance and passage it is today. William O’Brien Street is named New Street, while Davis Street is named Main Street. The open courtyard area towards the centre of the site is shown as infilled with buildings. The second edition/25inch mapping is more detailed, but again shows that by the turn of the 1900s the site had most of its modern character- istics with buildings roughly following the same footprint. The two distinct parts of the property as experienced today are indicated (house at the front and hall to the rear) and a small inset building is in roughly the location of the present open courtyard area, although on a slightly different footprint. For many years, the site functioned as a com- Figure 5: Ordnance Survey Map of the Manor of Mal- mercial property, it was run as the Queen’s Arms low, 1831. Hotel by Mr Ned Riordan for a time in the 1800s, 5
Blue Brick Heritage but by 1891 was in the ownership of James Rafferty. generously proportioned rooms falling quietly into Recorded as a draper on Main Street Mallow in the disrepair. (Mallow Town Hall Theatre, Cork Coun- street directories from this time, by 1907 Rafferty’s ty Council). was also a boot and shoe warehouse (Guy 1891 & 1907). In 1908 ‘Rafferty’s High Class Drapery Store’ was converted into the town hall, with an UDC chamber, ballroom, library, and social club. Sev- eral images in the Eason collection of the national library photographic archives show this early 20th century building, a three bay three storey gabled structure, with attic and dormer windows to the roof. There are two storey box bay windows flank- ing an elliptical arched entrance with raised let- tering over (reading Town Hall), and the façade was ornamented by harp motif and several foliate swags. (Figure 8). The site was destroyed by British forces in 1920 as a reprisal for a raid on Mallow Army Barracks by Irish rebels (Bolster 1971). A hand recoloured photograph from the early 1920s shows the burnt remains of the building, with the central steps, part of an arched entrance and the western gable with chimney stack still standing. There may be, therefore, fragments of this original building re- tained in the present structure. (Figure 9). The UDC invited tenders for the rebuilding of the site in December 1924, and O’Flynn and O’Connor architects submitted proposals (www. dia.ie). The present building on site was erected in 1926 (Browne 2020). Denis Joseph Buckley is re- corded in the Irish Builder (IB 82, 20 Jul 1940, 474) as having carried out some repairs to the building in 1940. The Mallow Pilgrim Players hosted regular shows in the first-floor concert hall in the mid-20th century, Jimmy O’Dea, Maureen Potter and Cecil Sheridan all performed here (www.independent. ie). The building is owned by Cork County Coun- cil and was partially refurbished in 2013 with re- medial works to the roof, repair or replacement of windows along with structural and masonry re- pairs. However, the building has remained largely unoccupied and unused for some years with its 6
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork Figure 6: First Edition OS map, Mallow c.1840. Figure 7: 25 inch OS map, c.1900. Figure 9: Detail from 'Town Hall ruins, Mallow' c.1920 (www.rareirishstuff.com). Figure 8: Eason Collection image c.1900 NLI EAS_0900 . 7
Blue Brick Heritage Extant Structure record The site is understood as having two distinct parts, the Town Hall building (the house) at the north, fronting onto Davis Street, and a hall/the- atre (the Hall) at the south. Rear access from the Main Street (Davis Street) at present is via a nearby arched entrance leading to a carpark, part of the neighbouring Ulster Bank. The plot bends at an ob- tuse angle to the south with the house at north end of the property aligned with Davis Street (north- west to southeast) and the rear aligned roughly north-south creating a right angle with St Marys Church (located to the south). External description Roof (house and hall) Overall the roof is in moderate condition, it was replaced within the past decade, with some repairs spliced into the extant structure, however Figure 10: View to roof at west gable 'House'. there continues to be issues with water ingress in- ternally. Proposals include repairs to the roof to address this. The roof of the house at north end is gabled, running parallel to Main Street. It is slated, with a single small rooflight concealed by a redbrick parapet with render coping. There is a rendered chimneystack to the west gable end and a red- brick stack to the east- this appears to have been repointed within the past 10 years. A third ren- dered chimneystack is set along the southern edge of the ‘house’ roof. The building retains cast-iron rainwater goods. The flue covers are modern. There are box rainwater hoppers leading from the par- apet to the west gable, the downpipe in this area gas been somewhat modified to accommodate the remains of an adjoining gable associated with the neighbouring property. This gable remnant meet- ing the west wall of the town hall at second story level, slightly higher than the present roof line on the street. (Figure 10) The hall, at the south half of the site, has a gabled roof running perpendicular to that of the Figure 11: View to roof, hall at rear, from west. 8
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork ‘house’. It is slated. There are dormer windows on either face at the north end of this section of roof. A small chimney breaks the roofline near the im- post at the north end south of the Dormer window (Figure 11). At the south end of the roof, on the west elevation, a larger dormer window crosses the roofline and is set partly in the buildings wall. (Figure 11). The small link building joining the house to the hall is flat roofed and thought to be leaded, al- though access was not possible. Front (north) elevation. The façade onto Davis Street is a five bay three story building (Figure 12). There is a red brick par- apet wall to the roof with render coping and shoul- dered render panels to either end. The walls, too, are red brick English garden wall bond. There are tooled limestone corner pilasters and flush lime- Figure 12: Front. stone string courses defining the division between floors and at junction of walls and parapet, and a limestone plinth course. The window openings are all square-headed and all have replacement timber margined one- over-one pane timber sliding sash windows, red brick voussoirs and cut limestone sills. They di- minish in size to the upper floor. The window opening to central bay of first floor has a decorative cast-iron balcony and carved limestone surround comprising architrave and frieze with square re- cessed panel and attached oval panel, flanking pilasters with square-headed recessed panels, and fluted console brackets supporting cornice. The door to the centre bay ground floor is round-headed, with timber panelled double-leaf door and spoked fanlight, carved limestone sur- round comprising voussoirs and projecting key- stone surrounded by square-headed architrave with adjoining rope twist moulding and Celtic in- terlace motif in relief. It is approached by a ramp from the west side, and steps to the front. Inter- nally there is evidence that this is the original door, shorted by the removal of parts of the upper panels Figure 13: East. 9
Blue Brick Heritage when the entrance was elevated to accommodate a wheelchair accessible ramp. The latter is cement with metal handrails and approaches from the west. There are two wall mounted plaques to the ground floor east of the door. The north elevation of the rear section (the hall) is apparent as the top of a gable over the flat roofed link section. The walls are rendered. There is a single window opening, an oculus, which opens onto the hall balcony internally. (See, Drawing 1 below) East elevation The walls are plaster rendered. The return of the house at north end stands three storeys, ad- joined by a flat arched carriage entrance and three storey high neighbouring building (Ulster Bank). Within the arch a shallow step back in the wall of the Town Hall may suggest the remnants of the Figure 14: East. 19th century building (burned in 1920s). A tim- ber framed awning window covered by a security grill is set in a low half-basement opening imme- The ground floor window openings comprise a diately inside the arched entrance passage. Above blocked square headed door opening at south end, this, two bays of flat headed window openings with apparent as a colour change in the plaster in pre- replacement timber sash and render sills light the vious surveys- although this is now less clear be- house structure. (Figure 13). cause of repainting. Next to this, at north is a small blocked window opening. To the north of this are The short link section stands three stories high three rectangular window openings, each with two and is a single bay wide, it has square headed win- timber framed panes, set high over what is prob- dow openings with render sills and replacement ably infilled door space. At the north end of the timber sash window. The uppermost sill is slightly elevation there are a further two window openings. enlarged. (See, Drawing 1 below, and figure 14). The hall at south stands seven bays long and South elevation two-stories high with attic. The attic is lit by a dor- mer window at north. The south elevation is dominated by the gable The first-floor window openings comprise of of the hall section. The walls are painted render. a high four pane timber framed window set in a It is three bays wide, with square headed window square opening at south, four tall timber framed openings to first floor level (two high square win- windows (2x4 pane) set in rectangular openings dows to east and a larger square opening io west of towards the centre, and a low square window with centre) and a door and window opening to ground timber framed fixed pane and awning window to floor. A cement pier is set against the wall to the the north end. At the south end two small rectan- east of the door, and a block pedestal for an oil tank gular windows between first and ground floor level adjoins the gable east of this. light a stair internally. (See, Drawing 1 below, and Figure 15). 10
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork West elevation The west elevation is rendered and paint- ed. There are two bays of windows visible to the ‘house’, narrow strip/clerestory windows to ground floor overlooking an adjoining felt flat roof. Above this is a square headed opening and to the upper floor there are two windows, all with replacement timber windows. The link section is three bays wide; three win- dows are evenly spaced to the second floor level, with a wide multiple pane window below this to first floor. A door is set to ground floor level at the south end of the link near where it joins the hall. The hall at south is six bays wide. At north end attic level, a true dormer window (blocked) is set into the roof, while at the opposite end a half dor- mer window spans the roof and upper floor level. The first-floor window openings comprise of four tall timber framed windows (2x4 pane) set in rect- Figure 15: South. angular openings towards the centre. The south- ernmost of these windows has a door addition to its base (timber battened), opening onto an exter- nal fire escape stair. This is iron framed, with Doric style pillars supporting i-bars. The capitals of the pillars have raised lettering reading Moore Bel- fast. A low square window (timber framed fixed pane and awning) is set to the north end in line with the dormer bay. Two smaller widow openings at the south end of the elevation span the ground and first floor level and overlook the fire stairs. To the ground floor level there is a square headed door at north (timber batten). A paired window open- ing (replacement timber sliding sash) immediately south of this, a door (glazed uPVC) south of this Figure 16: West. opening onto a ramp and series of steps travers- ing a step in the ground level and accommodating elevation changes associated with the raised floor internally. There are two doors south of this step in ground level, one leading to a boiler room and the second, with overlight, accessing the hall proper. South of this a block pedestal wall supports an oil tank adjoining the wall. A door beneath the fire escape stairs (double leaf timber battened) and a window at the southern end completes the open- ings to this elevation. (See, Drawing 1 below, and figure 16, 17). Figure 17: Fire stair detail. 11
Blue Brick Heritage Elevations PROJECT CLIENT DRAWING NO. DRAWN BY DATE SCALE Mallow Town Hall Cork County 01 Cork County Council- 11/02/2021 not to scale Theatre Council annotated by ET 12
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork Room GF2 Room Room Room GF1 GF4 GF3 Room GF8 Room Room GF5 GF7 Room GF6 Room GF9 Room Room GF10 GF11 Room B 2 Room B3 Room B Room 1 GF12 Room GF13 Basement Ground Floor Basement and Ground Floor Plans PROJECT CLIENT DRAWING NO. DRAWN BY DATE SCALE Mallow Town Hall Cork County 02 Cork County Council- 11/02/2021 not to scale Theatre Council annotated by ET 13
Blue Brick Heritage Internal description Basement There are three rooms to the basement, which is located under the house at the north of the site. The access from the ground floor is via a five panel timber door with simple architrave. The walls of the stairwell are unrendered cement blocks. (Fig- ure 18, and See drawing 2 for room locations). Room B1 The basement stairs, leading from the centre of the ‘house’, access room B1. The stairs have lipped timber risers, simple handrails and undecorated newel posts. (Figure 19). Two timber supports Figure 18: Door to basement from ground floor level. stand at the base of the stairs to the east. The room is roughly rectangular in plan, with the north wall broken by two openings linking this room to Room B2. The ceiling is covered in panel board and is supported by metal beams on cement block columns. The walls are lightly plastered but it is possible to see the outline of stones in places. The floors are cement. (Figure 20). Room B2 Accessed via two breaks in the south wall con- necting this room to Room B1. The ceiling is sup- ported by metal beams on cement piers. A cement rendered projection from the north wall now forms part of the ceiling supports, it may be associated with the entrance area of the original 19th century town hall (a projecting porch with recessed stepped Figure 19: Basement stairs. entrance is shown on archival images, this would have necessitated some supporting walls here in the basement area, ref to Figure 8 above, figure 9 above appears to show the arched entrance in situ after the fire). A chimneybreast juts into the room from the west wall and pipes enter from the street in the northeast corner. The walls are plastered and rendered in places, but the northeast corner of the room has some clearly discernible coursed rubble wall fabric; the floors are cement. (Figure 21). Figure 20: Room B1. 14
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork Room B3 The west wall of the room is angled giving the room a roughly triangular plan and reflecting the site plot layout. The room is entered via a timber battened door leading from Room B1 at the foot of the stairs. (Figure22). The floor is cement and the ceiling panelled in board. At south the walls is stepped where a chimneybreast projects out. (Figure 23). The wall is primarily of stone but with some brick infill in the chimneybreast. The walls at east and west are scarred with the remains of seg- mental arched cubby openings associated with its former use as a coal store. The arches survive best (although not at all complete) at west, were there are clear remains of two levels of arched shelves built of red brick, well fired but probably seconds. Figure 21: Room B2. There are shaped bricks forming a sloped line Figure 23: Room B3 from north end. Figure 22: Door to Room B3. Figure 24: Detail of arches. 15
Blue Brick Heritage Figure 27: Cieling room GF1. Figure 25: Entrance door (Room GF1). Figure 28: GF1 looking south with stairs. Figure 26: Room GF1 looking north. Figure 29: Stairwell from ground floor room GF1. 16
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork along the north wall. (Figure 24, above). The north wall proper is a rougher built stone wall, and the red brick components of the room are clearly butt- joined onto this. The stone wall is slightly wider at base. It is likely that the rubble wall represents the remnants of the 19th century building, and these brick-built arched shelves were added after the initial build, it is unclear whether they represent the remodelling associated with the new structure (1920) or if they indicate an intermediate phase of works on site (see discussion of date and phases below). Ground floor There are 12 rooms to the ground floor, exclud- ing subdivisions, and a boiler room which is ac- cessed from external doors only. (See drawing 2). Figure 30: Room GF2. Room GF1 ing in the stringers indicating the former presence This room, a hallway, leads from the main of gas lighting to the stairwell. (Figures 28 & 29, door at the north through the building towards the previous page). There is a blocked door in the west south. The door at north opens into a small lobby wall at the foot of the stairs (ref Figure 26). The hall area with (replacement) limestone slab floor. The continues past the stairs at east, with a door access- main entrance door, although likely original, was ing Room GF5 midway along, and a door accesses modified with the shortening of the uppermost the rear of the property via room GF6 to the south. panels to accommodate the changes to the entrance A third door, accessing the stairs to the basement, when the ramp was added. (Figure 25, above). A is set under the stairs near the south. Timber door modern unpanelled door in a (modern) panelled architraves remain in situ and doors are timber wall to the east side of the lobby opens into a small panelled, probably all dating to the construction of cupboard (not accessible). A sliding door set with- the building proper in the 1920s. in the (replacement panelled) west wall of the lob- by opens into the former tourist office and a sec- Room GF2 ond glass sliding door within a panelled early 20th century doorcase accesses the main hall at south. Located in the northwest corner of the build- (Figure 26, previous page). South of the 20th cen- ing, this room was most recently used as the tour- tury doorcase the ceiling is plastered and retains ist information office, it was formerly the council scalloped architrave and ceiling rose. There are chamber. Room GF2 is accessed via a sliding door several recessed directional lights. (Figure 27, pre- opening off the lobby/porch at the north of room vious page). A stair leading to the upper floors is set GF1. The original door, opening off the hall prop- against the west wall. This is an open well timber er, is blocked. The room is lit by two windows in stair with; ball finials on square plan shouldered the north wall overlooking the street. (Figure 30). newel posts; timber handrail with turned balus- There is a blocked fireplace in a projecting chim- ters, winding in an s curve around the half land- neybreast in the west wall. A beam supports the ing; closed stringers and lino covered treads; and ceiling over, which retains architraves and picture the remains of a single glass outlet at the top land- rail. 17
Blue Brick Heritage Room GF3 Room GF4 Room GF3 is located to the south of GF2 and This room occupies the northeast corner of the accessed via an opening in the north wall of the property and is lit by two windows (replacement room, which has an incorporated counter forming sash) in the north wall overlooking the street. Sig- part of the tourist information office facilities (Fig- nificant damp is evident in the northeast corner of ure 31, view from GF2). The room is subdivided the room, particularly in the north wall. (Figure and the southern part in use as an office (Figure 33). The room is accessed via a door in the south 32). A door in the south accesses the link section wall, which is a narrow partition wall with a hatch of the property and Room GF7. The west wall is window set to the west of the central door. (Figure angled lending the room a triangular shape. There 34). There is a fireplace (blocked) in the east wall, are steps leading up from the south in the doorway. set in a projecting chimneybreast. The partition Two clerestory windows in the west wall light the wall joins this chimneybreast south of centre indi- room. cating it is modern. Figure 31: View to Room GF3 from north in GF2. Figure 33: Room GF4 north wall. Figure 32: Room GF3 at south of partition. Figure 34: View to room GF4 from south. 18
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork Room GF5 Room GF6 Room GF5, formerly a town council office, is This room functions as a hallway in the link located to the south of GF4, in the southeast corner building section of the property, it is located south of the ‘House’ section of the property. (Figure 35). of Room GF1. The room is irregular in shape, wider A door in the west wall accessed the room, and a at north than south and with angled walls to east second door in the south wall, near the southwest and west. Doors in the north wall access Rooms corner, accesses the rear of the property. There are GF1 and GF5, a door in the south wall accesses the steps up to GF5 in this doorway. The room is lit by ‘Hall’, a door in the east access GF9 while a door two windows in the east wall. The ceiling is sup- in west access GF7. There is a ramp in the north- ported by beams. The ceiling is plastered and the west corner of the room leading up to the door to floor carpeted, the walls are plastered and divided GF1, and steps in the doorway to GF5. A door in by a dado rail and picture rail, both of which ap- the west wall, in the southwest corner of the room, pear to be modern. A fireplace surround set in the access the exterior. There are no windows. The ceil- south wall of the room has simple moulded mantel ing is plastered, as are the walls, with modern dado and chamfered fire surround. (Figure 36). This is rail. The floor is covered in lino. (Figure37). similar to a fireplace extant in FF2, although the latter is larger, and probably dates to the recon- struction of the building in 1926. Figure 37: Room GF6. Figure 35: View to room GF5 from north. Figure 36: Fireplace room GF5. Figure 38: Room GF7. 19
Blue Brick Heritage Room GF7 Room GF8 Located in the west of the link section, this This room comprises a toilet block attached room serves as a kitchen and hall, divided by an to the west side of the building. The room is lit by L-shaped partition wall, and lit by a skylight in the a skylight, two windows in the north wall, one in ceiling and a window in the south wall (Figure 38). the west and one in the south. The room is divided The room is accessed via a door in the east wall into four by partition walls, creating a lobby/entry leading from GF6, and a door in the west wall leads at east, and two toilet cubicles and a clean store at to an attached toilet block (GF8). A door with steps west. (Figure 39). in the north leads to GF3. Room GF9 Located to the east of the link section of the property and accessed via a door in Room GF6. This room is wedge shaped, narrower at east, and with an angled west wall. The room was most re- cently an office. The walls and ceiling are plastered, a moulded picture rail and skirting board remain to the north and south walls, the west wall is a re- cent rebuild, the window in the east occupies al- most all of the east wall, a plywood boxed in area immediately south of the window conceals the rest of the east wall. The floor is carpeted. (Figure 40). There is a small early 20th century style fireplace surround to a blocked fireplace in the north wall. (Figure 41). Figure 39: View to room GF8. Figure 41: Fireplace room GF9. Figure 40: Room GF9. 20
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork Room GF10 Forming the northeast corner of the ‘hall’ cre- ated by recent partition wall construction. The ceiling is plastered plywood, the walls plastered and the floor carpeted. The room is lit by two win- dows in the east wall, and accessed via a door in the northwest corner. (Figure 42). Room GF11 Forming the northwest corner of the hall sec- tion of the property this room is in use as a storage space. The ceiling is plastered plywood, the walls Figure 42: Room GF10. plastered and the floor carpeted over replacement timber boards. (Figure 43). A plasterboard parti- tion wall in the north of the room divides the main space from a narrow hallway. (Figure 44). Part glazed doors in the west wall light both rooms. Room GF 12 This room comprises the southern end of the hall. The room is lit by small windows in the south and west and a door at south accesses the exterior. There is a sink against the south wall. Hall area – not listed The main area of the theatre hall has a raised Figure 43: Room GF11. floor, creating a subfloor at this ground level. The subfloor space was not accessed. The boiler room occupies the northwest corner of this area accessed via an external door. The boiler room was not accessed. Figure 44: Room GF11 hall. 21
Blue Brick Heritage Room FF2 Room FF3 Room FF4 Room FF1 Room FF5 Room Room FF6 SF2 Room Room Room SF3 SF4 FF7 Room Room SF6 SF1 Room SF5 Room SF7 Room Room SF9 SF8 Room Room SF10 Room FF8 SF11 Room SF12 Room FF9 First Floor Room SF13 Second Floor First and second Floor Plans PROJECT CLIENT DRAWING NO. DRAWN BY DATE SCALE Mallow Town Hall Cork County 03 Cork County Council- 11/02/2021 not to scale Theatre Council annotated by ET 22
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork First floor There are 9 rooms to the first floor, excluding subdivisions and a boiler room which is accessed from external doors only. (See Drawing 3). Room FF1 This room comprises the main (central) stairs at first landing and first floor level (Figure 45). Double doors open off the stairwell at half-land- ing/mezzanine level. These access the south of the property via the link building (Room FF6). A narrow partition wall divides the main run of the stairs from the first-floor hallway proper. There are three doors to this hallway, a blocked set of double Figure 45: Room FF1, doors to hall from stairs. doors in the north accessing Room FF2 (Figure 46), and doors to the west and east accessing rooms FF3 and FF5, respectively. The walls and ceiling are plastered, with recent dado rail, the floor is lino covered. The double door architrave at mezzanine and 1st floor landing are matching, with channelled mouldings and circular panels to the corners, the doors are timber panel, mid-20th century in style. Room FF2 Occupying the northwest corner of the ‘house’ section of the property, this large room is lit by four (replacement) margined sash windows in the north wall overlooking the street. There is a fireplace against the west wall with panelled risers flanking Figure 46: FF1 doors at first floor landing. scalloped hearth opening (identical to fireplace in GF5), and moulded sill. The hearth opening itself is bricked up. (Figure 47). A door in the south wall near the southwest corner accesses Room FF3. A door in the east wall near the southeast corner ac- cesses Room FF4. (Figure 48). The ceiling has plas- tered (steel) beams, scalloped cornices, and shows significant damp ingress. The walls are plastered with picture rail and timber door architraves re- mains to the south wall and southeast corner. The skirting boards are removed and there is evidence of damage and damp along the west wall in par- ticular. This may be related to the possible integra- tion of surviving early 19th century fabric into the 1926 building along this wall, the earlier fabric be- Figure 47: Room FF2. 23
Blue Brick Heritage ing potentially more porous. The floor is lino and carpet over timber beams. Room FF3 Set to the south of FF2 and west of the stairs (FF1). The room is divided by partition walls into a lobby, clean store, and ladies and men’s toilets. A single window in the west wall lights the wedge- shaped room(s), which is accessed via a door in the north wall from FF2 and a door in the east wall from FF1. The floor is tiled the walls and ceiling plastered and painted, there are no features of ar- chitectural heritage interest. (Figures 49, 50). Figure 48: Room FF2, south wall and southeast corner. Room FF4 This room is set in the northeast corner of the ‘house’. FF4 is lit by a window in the north wall overlooking the street (replacement timber sash). There is a fireplace in the east wall, with fire sur- round identical to that in FF2 but with the hearth opening area retiled in recent ceramic tiles. As elsewhere, the ceiling is supported by beams clad in plaster. There are scalloped cornice mouldings to the north, east and south. The west wall is an insert, made of plasterboard, and does not have a cornice moulding, the picture rail does carry onto this wall suggesting it is a later addition to the room. The floor is carpeted, where this has been Figure 49: Room FF3. lifted against the north wall the floorboards are re- vealed, there has been significant damp ingress in the northeast corner of the room. The doors retain channelled architrave identical to those noted else- where. The doors are panelled early 20th century in date. (Figure 51, 52, 53). Room FF5 Located to the south of FF4, this room is lit by windows in the east wall (replacement sash) and has a fireplace against the south wall. (Figure 54). The ceiling is supported by a single beam, clad as elsewhere. The room is accessed via a door from the hall (FF1) in the west wall near the northwest corner, with the same channelled architraves and timber panel doors noted elsewhere. A second door in the north wall accesses Room FF4. The room Figure 50: Room FF3. 24
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork Figure 51: Room FF4 from south. Figure 54: Room FF5. Figure 52: Fireplace room FF4. Figure 55: Fireplace FF5. Figure 53: Room FF4, door.. Figure 56: Room FF6 from south. 25
Blue Brick Heritage was in use as a bar, the bar counter is set in the east next to the window. The floor is carpeted over tim- ber, the walls and ceilings plastered and painted. The scalloped cornice mouldings and picture rails noted in other rooms at the front of the ‘house’ are again present here. The fireplace in the south wall again matches those in other rooms, with moulded mantel and chamfered fire surround, it has been overpainted and the hearth opening is painted brick. A fire hood sits within the opening, having fallen from its original position. (Figure 55). Room FF6 This room occupies the entire link building be- tween the ‘house’ at north and the ‘hall’ at south and it recently functioned as the Library Foyer. The room is wedge shaped, narrower at east, and is lit by windows in the east (replacement timber sash) and west walls (timber fixed pane). Three open- ings in the south wall access room FF7, and double doors in the north wall near the northwest corner Figure 57: Room FF7. access the stairs (FF1). There are three beams to the ceiling, plastered over but without the decorative cornice mouldings seen elsewhere. The panelled walling below the dado rail is recent cement wall panelling. There is a moulded timber architrave to the windows to both east and west. (Figure 56). Room FF7 This room occupies the north end of the ‘hall’. The room is divided in two by a narrow, doglegged partition wall to the east of centre, with a sink set against the partition wall at north and a door at south. There are windows in the east and west walls. A door to the south wall leads to Room FF8. The floor is lino, the walls and ceiling painted plas- ter. (Figure 57). Room FF8 This room comprises the ‘hall’. It is lit by three tall windows in both the east and west walls. The southmost ope at west has been extended to incor- porate a door at base, opening to an external fire Figure 58: Room FF8 looking North. escape. Doors in the south wall, near the south- west and southeast corners, access timber stairs 26
Mallow Town Hall, Mallow Town Hall, Mallow, Co. Cork Figure 60: Room FF8 from north. Figure 59: West wall FF8. and Room FF9, the under-stage area. The room has walls panelled (modern) below dado level. The ceiling has an exposed timber open truss roof, with boarded ceiling over, and arched truss, plain tie-beams and decorative turned posts. The stage opening at south has a moulded paster architrave (the ope itself is boarded over). (Figure 58, 59, 60). Room FF9 This room serves as the under-stage area, the ceiling is low, with the base of the joist above 56.81. (Figure 61). There are timber stairs to the east and west, lit by two windows respectively (Figure Figure 61: View to room FF9 (understage). 63, see also room SF13 for detailed description of stairs), and partition walls throughout (Figure 62). The 2010 survey shows timber battened walling to parts of this room, with possible internal windows with moulded timber architraves. However, when surveyed in 2021, the stud walls were exposed and the battening and details had been removed -the asbestos survey had identified both asbestos con- taining wall panelling and asbestos ceiling panel- ling throughout this area. Figure 62: Detail to studwork. 27
Blue Brick Heritage Second floor There are 13 rooms to the second floor, exclud- ing subdivisions and a boiler room which is ac- cessed from external doors only. (See drawing 3 for room locations). Room SF1 This room, the upper level of the stairs, is lit by a large roof light (replacement). (Figure 64). There is a hatch to the attic to the north of the stairwell. The u-shaped landing has two doors in the west Figure 63: Steps FF9 stairs. wall, one in the north and one in the east near the northeast corner of the room. There is a doorway with two steps (up) opening off the landing in the south wall accessing the south of the property (Figure 65). The wall here has a large crack visible where plaster has been removed, it is possible to see in this area, and in the texture of plaster over the mezzanine door, that the upper levels of the wall are repaired, or even rebuilt, in cement blockwork, but that the original wall was coursed rubble stone. The stair banister is supported across the well opening by an iron brace bar, and a gas outlet is apparent in the stringer at mezzanine landing level (Figure 66). Figure 64: View to landing SF1 (looking south). Room SF2 This room occupies the northwest corner of the ‘house’. The floor is lino over timber, the walls and ceiling plasterboard. There is a partition wall dividing the room in two, to the east of centre (Fig- ure 67, 68). The three windows (margined sash) in the north wall have simple timber architraves. A door in the south wall leads to Room SF3, and a second door in south leads to SF1, the stairs. The fireplace is modern (1970s style faux stone). The plaster has been removed from the walls in places revealing predominantly brick walls, continuous between the front (north) and side (west). The pre- vious town hall building was not as tall as the pres- ent structure. The change in building fabric on the west and east walls at this level appears to confirm that the stone components seen at the lower level are vestiges of the previous structure. The top of Figure 65: Access to rear from stairwell. 28
You can also read