Maine Lakes Report 2012 - Lake Stewards of Maine
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Dear Friends of Maine Lakes, This report on the health of Maine lakes reflects the effort of more than 1,000 volunteer citizen scientists who monitored several hundred lake basins throughout the State in 2012. Many of them have been doing so continuously for decades, and a few have been involved for most of the 42 years since the Maine Legislature officially authorized volunteer lake monitoring. Their work is a strong testimony to the level of public commitment in Maine to our clear, clean lakes, and it is probably not coincidental that our lakes have remained as healthy as they have under the watch of these individuals. The Maine Volunteer Lake Monitoring Program (VLMP) is believed to be the longest-standing statewide citizen lake monitoring program in America, having been formed at about the time of the passage of the historic Federal Clean Water Act. The Mission of the Maine Volunteer Lake Monitoring Program is to help protect Maine lakes through widespread citizen participation in the gathering and dissemination of credible scientific information pertaining to lake health. The VLMP trains, certifies and provides technical support to hundreds of volunteers who monitor a wide range of indicators of water quality, assess watershed health and function, and screen lakes for invasive aquatic plants and animals. In addition to being the primary source of lake data in the State of Maine, VLMP volunteers benefit their local lakes by playing key stewardship and leadership roles in their communities. Our primary partners are the Maine Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) and the US Environmental Protection Agency, which provide a wide range of financial, technical and management support to the program. In turn, the VLMP provides these agencies with essential information that they use to manage and protect Maine’s lakes. The relatively small investment of public funding that supports the work of the VLMP is multiplied in value several times through the invaluable, high quality work of VLMP volunteers, and from increasing private support from individuals, organizations and businesses who recognize the tremendous benefits to Maine lakes. Studies conducted throughout the country have consistently shown that lake data gathered by properly trained volunteers are equivalent to, and indistinguishable from that of professional lake scientists, at a fraction of the cost! The additional invaluable benefit of public education and stewardship that VLMP volunteers provide to communities throughout the state is one of Maine’s best examples of grassroots natural resource protection. The effectiveness and strength of the VLMP is in part due to collaborative partnerships with other entities, including agencies and organizations throughout Maine and the U.S. This collaboration has formed a powerful resource for technical expertise, outreach, and access to a great deal of information concerning Maine lakes and their watersheds. Since the earliest days of the program, the VLMP has been at the forefront of gathering lake data in Maine and the U.S. For more than four decades, the total number of active individuals involved in monitoring water quality, and in screening public waters for invasive aquatic species has increased steadily. This document is a testament to their remarkable commitment! Volunt ne e ai er M Scott Williams Lake am VLMP Executive Director gr o M o ni r torin g P
Maine Lakes Report 2012 Acknowledgements Written by: Layout: Contributors & Reviewers: Scott Williams Jonnie Maloney Linda Bacon Roberta Hill Roberta Hill Database/Computer Technical Scott Williams GIS/Mapping: Assistance: Jonnie Maloney Linda Bacon Linda Bacon Christine Guerette John McPhedran Christine Guerette Doug Suitor Jonnie Maloney VLMP Staff VLMP Advisory Board Scott Williams, Executive Director Holly Ewing Roberta Hill, Invasive Species Program Director C. Barre Hellquist Jonnie Maloney, Program Coordinator Martha Kirkpatrick Christine Guerette, Program Assistant David Littell Cat Dioli, 2012 Spring Intern Peter Vaux, Chair Deanna Lorenzo, 2012 Spring Intern Ken Wagner Garrison Beck, 2012 Summer Intern Pixie Williams Jamey Epstein, 2012 Summer Intern Maine DEP Technical Advisors Linda Bacon VLMP Board of Directors Paul Gregory Mary Jane Dillingham, President Karen Hahnel Bill Monagle, Vice President John McPhedran Lew Wetzel, Treasurer Judy Potvin Phoebe Hardesty, Secretary Malcolm Burson Cover: Mud Pond, Oxford George Cross Sibyl French Norton Lamb Bill Monagle Gerry Nelson Matt Scott Clyde Walton Linda Bacon, DEP Liaison Photo by Terri Coolidge Marin Maine VLMP 207-783-7733 24 Maple Hill Rd vlmp@mainevlmp.org Auburn, ME 04210 www.MaineVLMP.org Copyright © 2013 Maine Volunteer Lake Monitoring Program This report is printed on recycled paper.
Table of Contents Overview 2013 VLMP Program Updates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Volunteer Coordinators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . i Appendix Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 A Distribution of Water Quality Data Program Purpose & Goals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 for Maine Lakes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 Program Structure & Administration . . . . . . . . . . . 2 B Water Quality Data for VLMP Lakes . . . . . . . . . . . 33 Water Quality C Range of Average Secchi Disk Transparency for VLMP Lakes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45 How are the Water Quality Data Used? . . . . . . . . 4 Volunteer Training, Quality Assurance & D Explanation of Individual Lake Report Quality Control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 and Sample Lake Report��������������������������������������� . . . . . . . . . . .������������������ . . . . . . . . . 53 How do Volunteers E Invasive Aquatic Plant Monitor Water Quality? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Screening Survey Activity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58 Measuring Lake Water Quality F Certified Volunteer Monitors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 With a Secchi Disk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 G Lifelong Volunteers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 85 Monitoring Dissolved Oxygen & Lake Water Temperature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Glossary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 90 Monitoring Total Phosphorus 2012 VLMP Supporters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 Concentrations in Lakes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Advanced Lake Monitoring . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 2012 Season in Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Invasive Aquatic Species Purpose & Goals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Invasive Plant Patrol Training, Quality Assurance & Quality Control . . . . . . . . . . 17 Invasive Aquatic Plant Screening Surveys . . . . . . . 18 How are Plant Survey Data Used? . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 2012 Season in Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Invasive Aquatic Plant Survey Summary . . . . . . . 22 Known Infestations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Invasive Plant Patrol Leadership . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Support for this report has been provided by: US Environmental Protection Agency Maine Department of through Section 319 of the Environmental Protection Federal Clean Water Act Boater Participation in the Maine Lake & River Protection Sticker Program Ram Island Conservation Fund of the Maine Community Foundation Roy A. Hunt Foundation More than 1,000 volunteer lake monitors throughout Maine who have provided their time, expertise, and financial support.
2012 Volunteer Coordinators Regional Water Quality Regional Invasive Plant Volunteer Coordinators Patrol Coordinators Regional Coordinators (RC) Invasive Plant Patrol Coordinators help organize volunteers and training RC’s organize re-certification workshops, respond to workshops in their region. Additional duties may include providing regional requests from volunteers and assist in the collection technical support, coordinating Invasive Aquatic Plant screening survey of data. activity, and managing data collection. Data Coordinators (DC) Region Coordinator(s) DC’s enter water quality data collected on volunteer data Aroostook County forms into the VLMP’s LakeData database program. Island Falls Lake Association Norm Harte Regional and Data Coordinators commit 25 hours on average Hancock County Region per year to the program. If you are interested in volunteering Hancock SWCD and Hancock County Lakes Alliance Megan Facciolo for a Coordinator position, please contact the VLMP office. Kennebec County 30 Mile River Watershed Association Lidie Whittier Robbins Belgrade Regional Conservation Alliance Toni Pied Region Coordinator Friends of the Cobbossee Watershed Ken Smith Androscoggin Dan Guerette, RC Midcoast Region Alan Anderson, DC Acadia National Park Bill Gawley Aroostook VLMP Staff, RC & DC Citizens’ Association of Liberty Lakes Kerry Black, Linda Breslin Cumberland Charles Turner, RC Damariscotta Lake Watershed Association Julia McLeod VLMP Staff, DC Lincolnville Lakes and Ponds Committee Ken Bailey / Paul Leeper Pemaquid Watershed Association Donna Minnis Franklin VLMP Staff, RC Lew Wetzel, DC Penobscot County Region Baxter State Park Jean Hoekwater Hancock VLMP Staff, RC & DC University of Maine Cooperative Extension Laura Wilson Kennebec Sue & Bruce Fenn, RC & DC Knox Dave Preston, RC Rangeley Lakes Region VLMP Staff, DC Rangeley Lakes Heritage Trust Rebecca Kurtz, Ellie White Lincoln Ed Knapp, RC Southwestern Maine Region Steve O’Bryan, DC Lakes Environmental Association Colin Holme Lakes Coalition Cheryl Welch Oxford Art Bubar, RC Lovell Invasive Plant Prevention Committee Lucy LaCasse Joe Potts, DC Pleasant Lake and Parker Pond Assoc. Pixie Williams Penobscot VLMP Staff, RC Portland Water District Nate Whalen David Hodsdon, DC Raymond Waterways Protective Association Steve McCormack / Betty Piscataquis VLMP Staff, RC Williams, Sibyl French Richard Offinger, DC Saco River Recreation Council Michelle Broyer Sagadahoc Ed Knapp, RC York County Steve O’Bryan, DC Acton Wakefield Watershed Alliance Linda Shier York County SWCD Melissa Brandt, Laurie Callahan Somerset VLMP Staff, RC Lew Wetzel, DC Waldo VLMP Staff, RC & DC Washington VLMP Staff, RC Richard Offinger, DC York George Bouchard, RC VLMP Staff, DC Acadia National Park Bill Gawley, RC Allagash Wilderness Kevin Brown, RC Waterways VLMP Staff, DC Cobbossee Watershed Wendy Dennis, RC & DC District Lakes Environmental Assoc. Colin Holme, RC & DC Passamaquoddy Nation Joe Musante, RC & DC Volunteers play key leadership roles in the VLMP. Here, Invasive Plant Patrol Rangeley Lakes Rebecca Kurtz, RC Lake Team and Regional Leaders convene for the spring IPP Roundtable. Heritage Trust VLMP Staff, DC i
VLMP Program Overview Mission: The Mission of the Maine Volunteer Lake Monitoring Program is to help protect Maine lakes through widespread citizen participation in the gathering and dissemination of credible scientific information pertaining to lake health. The VLMP trains, certifies and provides technical support to hundreds of volunteers who monitor a wide range of indicators of water quality, assess watershed health and function, and screen lakes for invasive aquatic plants and animals. In addition to being the primary source of lake data in the State of Maine, VLMP volunteers benefit their local lakes by playing key stewardship and leadership roles in their communities. Introduction Maine’s 5,785 lakes and ponds, about half of which are in the public domain, are among the most pristine in the nation. Lake scientists have long recognized that protect- ing and keeping lake ecosystems healthy requires knowl- edge of a large and broad cross-section of waterbodies. For 42 years, Maine’s Volunteer Lake Monitoring Program has risen to the challenge by collecting a substantial percentage of the annual water quality data for Maine lakes. As new threats have presented themselves, such ������������������������� as invasive aquatic species, VLMP ��������������������������������������������� volunteers have expanded their level of commitment and stewardship. Recognition of the relationship between healthy lakes and Maine’s economy is well established. Information collected by VLMP volunteers has greatly contributed to this understanding. In 2012, volunteers collected water quality data from 415 Maine lakes across the state. As of Volunteers receive training and are certified through the 2012, 449 waterbodies across the State of Maine have also VLMP. Depending on personal interests and program been screened, at some level, for the presence of aquatic needs, a number of training and monitoring options are invaders. A high percentage of the screening surveys were available. Hundreds of volunteers are trained to monitor conducted by volunteers trained by the VLMP. lake transparency (water clarity) using a simple Secchi Established in 1971, the VLMP, first administered by disk. Some monitor more advanced water quality indica- the Maine Department of Environmental Protection tors, including total phosphorus, dissolved oxygen, chlo- (DEP), became an independent non-profit organization rophyll-a and more. And others are trained to conduct in 1992. A strong cooperative and mutually beneficial screening surveys for aquatic invaders. Many volunteers relationship has been maintained between the VLMP provide data concerning additional characteristics of their and the DEP ever since. We are a valuable resource to lakes, including “ice-out” dates, the presence of certain the state, while the DEP continues to provide quality forms of troublesome algae, and more. assurance and quality control oversight, assists us with Training, basic equipment and technical support are data management, and provides technical expertise to provided by the VLMP at no charge, in return for a VLMP staff and volunteers. commitment from volunteers to monitor their lakes. All Funding for the VLMP is provided through contributions volunteers receive ongoing technical support for as long from individuals, businesses, and grassroots watershed as they are active in the program. Questions concerning groups, as well as grants from the EPA, Maine DEP, and procedures, data collected, the interpretation of results, private charitable foundations. But the greatest value of the algae and invasive plant identification, presenting lake VLMP comes from the efforts of hundreds of volunteers data to watershed communities, and more, are frequently who contribute thousands of hours of their time annually, addressed by VLMP technical staff. Individual contact and and who are the backbone of the Program. support is an essential component of insuring the credibil- ity of lake data collected by volunteers. Overview
Map by: Linda Bacon & port the work of those other efforts at the state, regional and Doug Suitor; Maine DEP local levels. Reliable information about Maine lakes, both individually and collectively, is the foundation of all efforts to protect, manage and restore these resources. Program Structure and Administration The VLMP is structured to optimize volunteer participation in both data acquisition and program administration. This reduces the cost of operations, increases feedback to program administrators from volunteers, and strengthens local stewardship. The VLMP is governed by a volunteer Board of Directors. The Board has approved by-laws and a regularly updated Strategic Plan. Board meetings are held several times throughout the year and are open to the public. The VLMP also has volunteer Regional and Data Coordinators that assist with program management at various levels by organizing re-certification workshops, collecting data forms, entering data into the data- Maine Lakes with base, maintaining contact info for the volunteers, and VLMP Volunteer Monitors in 2012 responding to volunteer requests for equipment and monitoring forms. Each of the 16 counties in Maine has its own Regional Coordinator, and there are several local The VLMP is Maine’s leader in providing training and cer- organizations such as Cobbossee Watershed District, tification in the collection of lake data by volunteers, state Lakes Environmental Association, and Rangeley Lakes agency personnel, educators, consultants and others. Heritage Trust that function as Regional Coordinator for volunteers in their service area. Program Purpose and Goals Volunteer training and re-certification workshops are The VLMP fosters stewardship of Maine lakes and their offered during the spring and summer monitoring period. watersheds in order to ensure high water quality and VLMP and Maine DEP staff travel throughout Maine ecological integrity. This is accomplished by the collection to meet with volunteers, provide them with training, of credible lake data by trained citizen volunteers, and by equipment and technical support. providing educational information concerning lakes to the The VLMP is funded by diverse sources, including indi- citizens of Maine. viduals, grassroots lake and watershed groups, state and The VLMP develops and disseminates educational mate- federal agencies, charitable foundations and businesses. rials concerning various aspects of lakes and their water- Maine Volunteer Lake Monitoring Program sheds, including water quality, ecology, management, protection and stewardship. The VLMP acts as a liaison, when possible, to bring together groups and organiza- Regional & Data DEP Technical Coordinators Advisors tions with missions similar to ours to maximize the ben- efits of collaborative synergy. Volunteer A number of organizations work on behalf of Maine’s Monitors lakes and ponds. Some focus specifically on advocacy; others primarily on public education. To some extent, the VLMP mission overlaps with those of other entities. VLMP Staff & All are working in various ways to protect lakes. What sets Board of Directors the VLMP apart is the particular role the organization plays within this larger statewide effort, a role that helps to sup- Overview
The annual Maine Lakes Report is made available to summer. The event also features presentations on a wide our volunteers and is also on our website. Annual water range of technical issues pertaining to lake monitoring, quality reports for individual lakes are also available to assessment and protection. volunteers and the public. The Water Column, VLMP’s newsletter, is distributed twice annually to program volunteers and collaborating organizations, and is available online. The VLMP's Annual Lake Monitoring Conference, at which individuals are recognized for their contributions to Maine lakes, is held annually during the Agencies and Organizations Working in Collaboration with the VLMP Acadia National Park Maine Department of Conservation Natural Areas Program Allagash Wilderness Waterways Maine Department of Environmental Protection Auburn Land Lab Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Auburn Water District Maine Milfoil Initiative Belgrade Regional Conservation Alliance Maine Stream Team Casco Bay Estuary Partnership Maine Water Utilities Association Cobbossee Watershed District Passamaquoddy Tribe of Maine County Soil and Water Conservation Districts Penobscot Nation Friends of the Cobbossee Watershed Portland Water District George J. Mitchell Center - University of Maine Rangeley Lakes Heritage Trust Gulf of Maine Research Institute Raymond Waterways Protective Association Hancock County Lakes Alliance Saco River Corridor Commission Lake & Watershed Associations throughout Maine Saco River Recreation Council Lake Auburn Watershed Protection Commission Sebago Lake State Park Lakes Environmental Association The Nature Conservancy Maine Audubon Society Trout Unlimited Maine BASS Federation University of Maine Maine Congress of Lake Associations University of Maine - Cooperative Extension Maine Department of Conservation US Environmental Protection Agency Volunteer trainings are held annually throughout Maine, as well as at VLMP's Brackett Environmental Center on the shore of Lake Auburn. Overview
Monitoring Lake Water Quality How are the Water Quality Data Used? Lake Diagnostic Studies Data collected by volunteer water quality monitors provide valuable information to lake scientists at the Maine DEP, Each lake has a unique history and "personality." Data the EPA, the University of Maine, public water utilities collected by VLMP allows the Maine DEP and others to and other agencies and institutions throughout Maine in determine the nature and sources of water quality prob- order to help characterize and protect Maine lakes. State lems for individual lakes, and the most effective means for and town planners, conservation groups, economists, lake restoring and protecting them from further decline. associations, businesses, and individuals also use the data. Lake Restoration Projects Data Users Efforts to restore a lake that has declined requires extensive Maine Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) water quality data. Long-term restoration also involves and other state agencies addressing land use problems in the watershed. The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) VLMP and DEP work with volunteer monitors, local lake University of Maine and other educational institutions associations, and watershed communities to identify means County Soil & Water Conservation Districts by which sources of Water Utilities pollution to lakes Towns, Local Planners and Businesses Lake and Watershed Associations can be identified and eliminated. This VLMP lake data, and data obtained through a collabora- is accomplished tive effort with the Maine DEP and other agencies and through lake and organizations, are the primary sources of water quality watershed education information for Maine lakes. The following are just a few and outreach of the ways in which the data are used: services, and by working with groups Lakes that have become choked with excess algae Research to implement lake growth may require restoration measures that range from the application of simple watershed Scientists and researchers use VLMP data to characterize and watershed conservation practices to prohibitively costly, the quality of individual lakes, and to identify water protection projects. and risky, in-lake treatment measures. quality trends. A number of agencies and institutions in Maine use this information to help determine the Lake Protection economic benefits provided by lakes, and the potential Town planning boards, lake associations, conservation loss of these benefits when water quality declines. Recent commissions and others use water quality data to develop economic studies using VLMP data have linked lake local standards for lake protection. The Maine DEP uses the water clarity to shoreline property values. information to establish phosphorus control standards for individual lakes. VLMP data have been used to determine State agencies use VLMP data to assess fishery habitat. the "Lakes Most at Risk" for the Maine Stormwater For example, dissolved oxygen data are used to determine Management Law, and for establishing "Priority Lake the extent to which individual lakes are able to support Watersheds" for Maine's Nonpoint Source Program. The coldwater species, and whether or not fishery habitat is Federal Clean Water Act requires states to evaluate the changing with time. status of their lakes and report the results to the EPA, and Understanding the relationship between watershed land Maine's Water Classification Program requires a similar use and lake water quality is key to protecting lakes. assessment. VLMP data are used extensively for this VLMP data are used to further our understanding purpose. (See Appendix B for details.) of this relationship, and help determine appropriate Outreach and Technical Assistance standards for lake protection by federal, state and local planners. The information is also used to develop public The VLMP provides data, analysis, and training to those educational materials. across Maine interested in understanding and protecting lake water quality, and preventing the introduction of Water Quality
invasive aquatic plants. Many schools throughout Maine Individuals who collect and submit Maine lake data to the use VLMP lake data. The VLMP is a resource to educational VLMP and DEP, regardless of whether they are volunteers institutions with lake studies programs, from elementary or professionals, must be certified. Becoming certified to grades through graduate studies. The VLMP staff works collect water quality data entails a comprehensive train- with lake associations and organizations like the Maine ing process. Volunteers are required to attend an initial Congress of Lake Associations to help those who have an workshop at which they are provided with information interest in understanding and protecting lakes to achieve concerning lake function and ecology, lake and watershed their goals. The real estate industry and tourism-based relationships, perspective on various threats to lakes, moni- businesses have a vested interest in the quality of Maine toring protocol and procedures, and direct field experience lakes. The VLMP works with numerous local and state in the gathering of data. Individuals and the equipment business groups to provide water quality and economic that they use are evaluated, and their data are recorded analysis information to the business community. Fishing for future reference. Each individual is assigned a unique organizations such as Maine BASS Federation also partner certification number to link them to any and all data that with the VLMP to protect Maine's fishing heritage from they submit to the VLMP or Maine DEP. the threat of invasive aquatic plants. Volunteers are required to periodically attend re-certification Legislative Initiatives workshops that are held throughout Maine annually. Re- As an important source of quality data and objective certification requirements vary, depending on the type of information, the VLMP provides the Maine Legislature data being collected. Workshops provide volunteers and with objective testimony concerning critical issues relating staff with opportunities to discuss technical issues and to Maine lakes. However, in order to protect the integrity questions, changes in protocol, the analysis of data, and of the data, the VLMP does not advocate for or against to inspect monitoring equipment. Volunteers and staff (lobby) specific political initiatives. The VLMP is an also review data gathering procedures, take readings and apolitical organization. compare results. The workshops also provide volunteers with an opportunity to provide feedback to staff on various Volunteer Training, and Quality aspects of the program. Assurance and Quality Control All data, including volunteer-collected information, are useful only when accurate, of acceptable quality, and reliably collected. In order to ensure that the lake water quality data collected by the VLMP are credible, all Photo by Linda Bacon contributors of this data must meet specific technical standards. This system of quality assurance, and the standards that must be followed by volunteers, staff and others who participate in the gathering and processing of data, is commonly known as "QA/QC" (quality Volunteer water quality monitors review Dissolved Oxygen monitoring assurance/quality control). The VLMP standards of procedures with VLMP staff at a re-certification workshop on Long Lake. quality assurance are defined in a plan that is approved Quality ������������������������� Assurance/Quality Control by the EPA (referred to as a Quality Assurance Project The program accepts data only from monitors who are able to Plan, or QAPP). Such a plan is required of all entities meet Quality Assurance/Quality Control standards. This strict that receive funding from the EPA for data collection. rule affirms the credibility of the VLMP as an organization, It assures that those who use the volunteer data may as well as the value and utility of the data. It allows the data do so with confidence. The QAPP is available on our gathered by our volunteers to be used with confidence, and assures volunteers that their monitoring efforts are well spent. website at: www.MaineVolunteerLakeMonitors.org, on the "Water Quality Monitor Forms and Procedures" page. The primary role of the Maine DEP partnership with the VLMP is to provide QA/QC guidelines and standards for data collection and management. The DEP staff serve as quality control agents, providing technical support to VLMP staff, as required. The VLMP and DEP staff work cooperatively to ensure that available resources are used efficiently. Water Quality
How Do Volunteers Monitor Lake The enrichment of lakes with the nutrient phosphorus and excess algae, resulting from watershed development, is Water Quality? referred to as "cultural eutrophication" (CE). Stormwater There are many imminent threats to Maine lakes. Near runoff from disturbed or developed areas of lake water- the top of the list, and perhaps the most pervasive, is the sheds typically carry high concentrations of phosphorus, potential for lakes to become nutrient enriched and more sediment particles, and other pollutants considerable biologically productive as a result of development in lake distances, eventually flowing into a lake. Lake watershed watersheds. This condition is characterized by declining boundaries may be situated close to the shoreline, or they water clarity (transparency), resulting from an increase in may extend for miles away from the lake. In either case, the growth of algae. Excess algae in lake water can cause stormwater runoff from developed areas of lake watersheds is a potential threat to water quality, unless conservation Watersheds & practices are in place to control stormwater runoff. Water Quality For this reason, the primary focus of volunteer water The Damariscotta Lake quality monitoring is the collection of information related watershed encompasses an area of more than to changes in lake biological productivity over time. 50 square miles in five Water quality data gathered by volunteers can be used to communities and extends determine whether individual lakes are becoming more miles from the lake shore. Storm water runoff from productive, less productive, or are stable. Many years of developed areas within the data are generally required to make these determinations watershed can carry soil and other nonpoint source with confidence. pollution into the lake. Measuring Lake Water Clarity (Transparency) With A Secchi Disk One simple method of assessing the effect of cultural eutrophication in lakes is to measure the concentration of planktonic (suspended) algae in the water. Algae are at the base of the lake ecosystem food web. Volunteer water quality monitors begin monitoring their lake by measuring Secchi disk transparency. The Secchi disk is a simple device that is used to estimate algal concentrations, a disturbance to the normal equilibrium of the aquatic based on water clarity. Volunteers in the VLMP are ecosystem. As algae die and decompose, bacteria con- provided with a viewing scope and a Secchi disk that is sume oxygen that is dissolved in the water. Increased algal attached to a calibrated line. They are instructed on the growth can lead to a decline in oxygen levels, especially procedure for taking a Secchi disk reading by training during the warm summer months. Oxygen loss can reduce staff. Ideally, readings should be taken a minimum of critical habitat for coldwater fish (trout and salmon), and twice monthly from May through September or October. it can accelerate the decline of water quality. This frequency is optimum for identifying water quality Oligotrophic Mesotrophic Eutrophic low productivity moderate productivity high productivity Cultural Eutrophication The enrichment of lakes with nutrients, sediment and algae from human activities, resulting in increasing biological productivity and an acceleration of the natural aging process of the lake. Images Courtesy of University of Wisconsin Extension Water Quality
trends over time. Readings are generally taken at the penetration into the water column is substantially attenu- deepest point in a lake. ated. Shallow lakes may be subject to moderate concen- trations of re-suspended bottom sediments in the water The Secchi disk is generally a reliable device for quickly column, resulting from wind turbulence. Both color and and inexpensively assessing lake water quality. The primary sediment can limit the utility of Secchi transparency data uses of Secchi transparency data are: 1) to characterize or as an indicator of biological productivity. However, for define the existing water quality of a lake, and 2) to iden- most Maine lakes, Secchi transparency is a reliable and tify and track long-term water quality trends. relatively accurate method for assessing water quality. How a Secchi Disk Measures Water Clarity Seasonal Changes in Secchi (Transparency) Transparency The Secchi disk is used globally to assess lake water The tiny plants (algae or phytoplankton) and animals (zoo- quality because it is a quick procedure that can be performed by virtually anyone with minimal training and plankton) that are suspended in lake water influence trans- inexpensive equipment. parency. These living aquatic communities undergo seasonal and annual growth cycles, resulting in changes in their over- all density, and in their location in the water column. Secchi transparency is often at a low point soon after the ice melts in the spring. That is when lakes mix, or "turn Penetration Light over," causing nutrients and sediments from the lake bottom to become suspended in the water for a period of time. Silica that is swept up from the bottom sediments stimu- lates the growth of diatoms, a type of algae that experiences In turbid lakes with In clear lakes with peak growth in the spring and fall (see diagram below). high algal density, light low algal density, light Diatom "blooms" often result in a brief period of reduced penetration is limited, penetrates deeper, transparency in lakes. As the water warms and stabilizes resulting in lower clarity resulting in greater clarity during the summer, other types of algae will dominate the and measurably shallower and measurably deeper water column, depending on water temperature, nutrient Secchi disk readings. Secchi disk readings. levels and other factors. Some lakes become progressively less clear through the summer months, while others may Secchi disk transparency is an indirect water quality become clearer. The concentration of phosphorus in the indicator, because an assumption is made that water clar- water, the shape and depth of the lake basin, the orienta- ity is affected primarily by algal growth in the water. tion of the basin to prevailing winds, and the weather all That assumption is reason- influence water clarity, or transparency. Individual lakes are able in most cases. However, unique in the way that they respond to these influences. other factors may influence transparency, including the amount of sediment that is suspended in the water, and natural water color. Natural color and suspended sediments vary widely from one lake to another. Color is influenced by the concen- tration of natural dissolved Secchi Transparency organic substances in the The distance one can see into the water column is measured with water. These "humic acids" a viewing scope and a Secchi disk can stain the water in some attached to a calibrated line. lakes to the point where light image courtesy of waterontheweb.org Water Quality
Volunteer lake water quality monitors learn over time what The following graphics illustrate the variability in Secchi is "normal" for the lake that they monitor. transparency readings that may occur in lakes during a single season, and from year to year. Figure 1 shows the Many Secchi transparency readings are needed over a variation in annual Secchi transparency over a period of period of years in order to confidently detect and track years in Annabessacook Lake, Kennebec County, and trends in lake water quality. The natural variability of Cold Rain Pond, Cumberland County. Figure 2 shows water clarity and other indicators of lake quality compli- the seasonal Secchi transparency variation in both lakes for cates the detection of trends, which is why many complete the 2012 season. seasons of data are generally needed in order to be able to recognize a true change in water quality. Thus volunteers are asked to collect complete seasons of data from May through September—or later—each year. Comparison of Secchi Transparency Variation in Two Maine Lakes Figure 1 Figure 2 Annual Variation in Lake Water Clarity Seasonal Variation in Lake Water Clarity (Secchi Transparency) for Two Lakes (Secchi Transparency) for Two Lakes Annabessacook Lake Annabessacook Lake Cold Rain Pond Cold Rain Pond Figure 1 shows the annual average Secchi transparency readings Figure 2 shows the variation of Secchi transparency readings in a for two Maine lakes. The minimum and maximum readings for single season for two Maine lakes. In 2012 the Secchi Transparency each year are indicated by the bars above and below the disk which in Annabessacook Lake varied from a low reading of 1.4 meters in indicates the average. The graph for Annabessacook Lake shows October to a high of 6.3 meters in August, with an average for the the annual average Secchi transparency to range from 2.0 to 4.9 season of 4.0 meters. During the same year Cold Rain Pond varied meters over a 37-year period. The graph for Cold Rain Pond shows from 2.9 meters in August to 5.6 meters in May with an average of a smaller range from 3.9 to 5.3 meters over a 25-year period. 3.9 meters. In a single season Secchi transparency may vary only one Annual variation in Secchi transparency is, for the most part, the or two meters, such as in Cold Rain Pond, or it may vary by several result of seasonal changes in the composition, density and location meters, as in the case of Annabessacook Lake. of algal populations in lakes. Both natural (weather) and human In most lakes if only one or two Secchi disk readings were taken (watershed development) factors influence this process, requiring during the year, a misleading picture of the overall transparency a minimum of 10 years of data to confidently detect trends in could emerge, depending on the timing of the readings during water clarity. the summer. Water Quality
Monitoring Dissolved Oxygen and Some oxygen loss occurs naturally during the summer months as water temperatures rise, because the solubility Lake Water Temperature of oxygen in water is inversely proportional to the water Another critical indicator of the health and quality of lakes temperature. In other words, cold water is able to contain and ponds is the concentration of oxygen that is dissolved more oxygen than warm water (all other factors being in the water. Dissolved oxygen (DO) levels in lake water held equal.) However, as lakes become more biologically are influenced by many factors, including water tempera- productive, and organic matter accumulates in the sys- ture, the concentration of algae and other plants in the tem, the potential increases for oxygen levels to decline as water, and the amount of nutrients and organic matter the organic matter decomposes in deep, stratified areas. that flow into the water body from the watershed. Oxygen Oxygen depression or depletion can stress fish and other is produced through plant metabolism (photosynthesis), aquatic biota, and under certain circumstances, it can and it is consumed during respiration and decomposition. cause an acceleration in the decline of water quality. Oxygen in lake water is also influenced by wind and wave action through weather events and the exposure of surface water to atmospheric sources. An adequate supply of dissolved oxygen in lake water is essential to fish and other aquatic life forms. DO is also a sensitive indicator of change in water quality, and of the ability of a water body to support aquatic life. The loss, over time, of DO in the deep areas of a lake, especially during summer months, may indicate that the ecosystem is stressed and changing. Biological activity peaks in lakes and ponds during the warm weather months. It is also at this time that the phe- nomenon of thermal stratification (see Figure 3) occurs. The combined influence of the two processes has a pro- nounced effect on water chemistry, and in particular on dissolved oxygen levels. The physical isolation of deep, cold water at the bottom of a lake from the surface water Volunteers take a temperature and DO profile at a VLMP training workshop. during summer stratification prevents the oxygen supply in the deeper water from being replenished. The period Volunteer monitors are trained to measure oxygen con- of isolation varies from one body of water to another, centrations in the water using inexpensive chemical kits and depends on depth, and the influences of weather. and a simple sampling device. This method is accurate Stratification may last from several weeks to a few months and reliable, although somewhat time-consuming. The and it may exist only during warm, calm periods in shal- temperature of the water must also be recorded for each lower waterbodies. oxygen reading. A more costly, but time-saving alternative Figure 3 involves the use of a probe that is attached to an oxygen meter via a cable. The probe and meter simultaneously measure dissolved oxygen and water temperature, and the information is displayed on the meter. Oxygen concentrations and water temperature are gener- ally recorded throughout the summer stratification period, from early spring through late summer and early fall, when DO levels are likely to be lowest in Maine lakes and ponds. Based on University of Wisconsin Extension image Readings are generally taken from the water surface to the bottom of the deepest area of a lake, at one-meter inter- Thermal Stratification As lake water is warmed in the summer, in deeper lakes, three vals (depending on the individual water body.) Dissolved distinct temperature layers form: oxygen is measured in milligrams per liter (mg/L) or parts 1) warmer (less dense) epilimnion layer at the surface per million (ppm). 2) the thin thermocline (transition) layer 3) the cold and deep hypolimnion layer Water Quality
Figure 4 illustrates the influence of seasonal Figure 4 Effects of Thermal Stratification on Dissolved Oxygen thermal stratification on water temperature Concentrations in Oligotrophic and Eutrophic Lakes and dissolved oxygen concentrations in lakes with both high and low biological produc- tivity. Oligotrophic lakes have low concen- trations of phosphorus and algae, and deep Secchi disk readings, whereas eutrophic lakes have high concentrations of phosphorus and algae and shallower Secchi disk readings. Spring turnover occurs shortly after “ice- out.” Spring winds cause the lake water column to mix thoroughly, resulting in uniform temperature and oxygen concentra- tions from the surface to the bottom of the lake, as shown in the graph on the far left. During summer stratification, temperature profiles are similar for both oligotrophic Image from Water on the Web and eutrophic lakes, showing uniform www.WaterOntheWeb.org T = Temperature in Celsius DO = Dissolved Oxygen in mg/L temperature near the surface to several meters depth (epilimnion). Water temperature drops Monitoring Total Phosphorus rapidly through the thermocline, then stabilizes in the deepest area of both lakes (hypolimnion). The temperature Concentrations in Lakes gradient from the surface to the bottom of the lake can Volunteer monitors are trained to collect total phosphorus be as much as twenty degrees in deep lakes. However, samples from their lakes, using a simple process of obtain- in oligotrophic lakes dissolved oxygen levels rise as the ing a sample from a few inches below the water surface water temperature drops in the thermocline, whereas in at the designated monitoring station. Total phosphorus eutrophic lakes, oxygen levels drop, resulting from the analysis includes both organic and inorganic forms of the decomposition of organic matter in the lake. element that may be present in the water, in solution or in particulate form. Shorter days and cool weather in the fall cause the water temperature to drop to the point where the water column Phosphorus is the nutrient that most influences the mixes, resulting once again in near uniform temperature growth of algae in lakes. An increase in the concentra- from the surface to the bottom. The mixing process intro- tion of total phosphorus in lake water generally indicates duces oxygen from the atmosphere into the water, resulting a potential increase in biological productivity (trophic in uniform, high concentrations of dissolved oxygen for both lake types. Figure 5 Pennesseewassee Lake During winter stratification, water temperature profiles 2007 Monthly Total Phosphorus are once again similar for both lake types. Ice on the lake Concentrations surface causes the surface temperature to be slightly lower than in the deep water below. The temperature gradient from the surface to the bottom is relatively small, usually Total Phosphorus (ppb) only a few degrees. The oligotrophic lake retains high concentrations of dissolved oxygen from the surface to the bottom of the lake, but highly productive eutrophic lakes may be depleted of oxygen. The two examples illustrated represent opposite ends of the lake productivity continuum. Every lake is unique, resulting in many variations in both the temperature and oxygen regimes that may be encountered throughout the year. 10 Water Quality
state) of the system. Tracking in-lake phosphorus levels the season. However, if a single sample for the season was over time is another way of monitoring changes in lake taken in June, the concentration of that sample (12 ppb) water quality. Combined with Secchi transparency read- would suggest much more phosphorus-based productivity ings, TP data provides additional information about lake in the lake for the summer. ecosystem dynamics. Ideally, phosphorus samples should be taken from early Advanced Lake Monitoring summer through the end of the sampling season in Accurate lake water quality characterization requires that September or October. However, the sample analysis periodic "baseline" data be collected for all of the lakes in involves laboratory fees, and volunteers are often limited to the VLMP. Maine DEP and VLMP staff strive to collect taking one or two samples during the late summer (about additional water quality data for all lakes in the program, mid-August), when biological activity is at a peak. The and for other lakes and ponds with special concerns. This VLMP arranges to provide volunteer monitors with special is done on a rotating basis, and as financial resources allow. sampling and laboratory mailing containers to facilitate Baseline sampling of program lakes occurs approximately the collection of phosphorus data. every three to five years during the late summer. Volunteers who wish to assist in obtaining advanced baseline samples As is the case with most indicators of lake water qual- from their lakes may participate in special workshops ity, the concentration of phosphorus in lake water varies offered by VLMP and DEP staff. This additional informa- within individual seasons, and from one year to the next. tion adds considerable value to data collected by volunteer Therefore it is important to collect multiple samples monitors. Using sample methods such as those in Table 1, during the monitoring season, when possible. Figure 5 baseline data are gathered for the following indicators of illustrates an example of the variation in total phosphorus lake water quality: samples (measured in parts per billion- ppb) from a Maine lake over the course of the five month monitoring season. • Total Phosphorus • Total Alkalinity The average total phosphorus concentration in this lake • Chlorophyll a • Phytoplankton • True and Apparent Color • Anions and Cations for the five month period is 9 ppb, which just happens to • Conductivity • Zooplankton be within 1 ppb of four of the five monthly samples taken. • pH If a single sample was taken in the month of August, which is the optimum time for a single phosphorus sample taken For an explanation of these indicators of lake water quality, during a five month monitoring season, the concentration please see Appendix A on page 30. of that sample (7 ppb) would be close to the average for Table 1 Examples of Water Sampling Methods Surface Grab Epilimnetic core Profile Grab Water is collected from just below the lake Using special weighted plastic tubing, an A discrete sample is taken at a specific depth surface, using a special sampling bottle. integrated (mixed) water column sample is in the water column, using a device designed taken from the upper temperature stratum to “grab” a sample at that depth. of the lake where most algae growth takes place. Epilimnetic core samples are taken to Bottom Grab determine the average concentration in the A discrete sample is taken one meter water column for a number of variables. from the bottom of the lake using a grab sampling device. Water Quality 11
2012 Water Quality Monitoring For lakes in which the majority of phosphorus is from the watershed, it is reasonable to speculate that reduced storm- Season in Review water runoff during the spring and summer, when Maine lakes are the most biologically productive, is likely to result in Influences on Lake Water Quality lower concentrations of sediment and nutrients being trans- Weather often plays a significant role in the seasonal and ported to the water from the watershed, resulting in less food annual variability of lake data. The indicators that are used for algae, fewer sediment particles in the water, and deeper to assess lake water quality can vary significantly as a result Secchi disk readings. of the timing, intensity and duration of precipitation, wind, Figure 6 cloud cover, and air/water temperatures.. Volunteer lake Comparison of 2012 water clarity of 415 Maine lakes monitors help take these influences into account by record- to their long-term clarity. ing weather data on lake survey forms, especially notable local events, such as heavy rain and periods of sustained Table 2 strong wind. Deviation Number of (meters) Lakes Human activity also influences lake water quality. -1.6 or less 5 Development in lake watersheds causes changes in the 39.5% -1.1 to -1.5 10 quantity and quality of stormwater runoff to lakes and More Clear 49.6% -0.6 to -1.0 58 -0.1 to -0.5 133 ponds. Runoff is the vehicle that carries pollutants such as Less Clear Zero 45 phosphorus and sediment through watersheds into lakes. 0.1 to 0.5 115 Weather has an obvious bearing on this process, as well. 0.6 to 1.0 33 Separating and understanding natural watershed influences 10.8% 1.1 to 1.5 1.6 to 2.0 14 0 from those associated with human activity, and identifying No Change 2.1 or more 2 true changes in lake water quality over time, is a challenging undertaking, to say the least! Note: Consideration was not given to whether or not some Secchi disk In a typical annual cycle, a high percentage of the annual readings hit bottom, or whether 2012 was the first year for which data were gathered on a small number of lakes. phosphorus loading to lakes from their watersheds is likely to occur during the spring runoff period. When spring and early summer stormwater runoff is above or below normal, 2012 Weather Influences on Maine Lakes we might expect that there would be more or less algae Maine weather during the winter, spring and summer of growth during the summer months, resulting in reduced or 2012 was unusual, and could be characterized as “extreme.” improved water clarity for a majority, but not all, lakes. Precipitation during the winter and spring throughout Each lake (and its watershed) has unique characteristics that much of Maine was light, resulting in a lower than nor- cause it to respond in a particular way to human and natu- mal snowpack and spring runoff. The weather was also ral influences. The shape, depth, and size of the lake basin, abnormally warm throughout much of the winter, and the topography, hydrology and geochemistry of the water- especially in March, when air temperatures exceeded 80 shed, the orientation of the basin to prevailing winds, and degrees F. in southern and central areas of the state. Lake other natural factors, account for some of the seasonal and ice melted rapidly, and most lakes throughout Maine were annual “natural variation” that is observed in lake systems. free of ice from 3-4 weeks earlier than their historical While some lakes may be clearer during periods of reduced average. National Weather Service records indicate that precipitation, perhaps because there is less phosphorus Portland experienced the 2nd warmest April in 72 years, and sediment-laden stormwater runoff flowing into them and May was the 9th consecutive month during which the during such times, others may not show the same posi- temperature was above normal. While June temperatures tive response because they already support moderate algae were closer to normal, July 2012 was the warmest (July) on growth and experience late summer dissolved oxygen loss. record, and Portland experienced the 5th warmest August For this latter set of lakes, wind levels during the summer in 72 years. Precipitation was above normal in May, June, months may play an important role in whether or not phos- July and August. phorus from bottom sediments becomes available to algae The early loss of ice cover, combined with very warm air near the surface, a phenomenon called internal recycling. temperatures caused thermal stratification to occur earlier Phosphorus in sediments is generally either bound weakly than normal in the spring. On June 3 an intense rain event to iron or more permanently to aluminum. When dissolved occurred, during which areas of southern and central Maine oxygen is depleted, iron can release its phosphorus to the received from 6 to 8 several inches of precipitation in just waters above and heavy winds may circulate the water such over 24 hours. Many volunteer monitors reported observa- that the phosphorus gets recycled to the surface waters tions of severe soil erosion from stormwater runoff in their becoming available to support algal growth. lake watersheds, often resulting in dramatic drops in Secchi 12 Water Quality
transparency. For example, early season Secchi readings on Figure 7 Thompson Lake in Oxford were in the 9 meter range, but Yearly Comparison of Lakes that were Clearer, Less following the June storm, the Secchi reading dropped to 5.3 Clear, or the Same as their Long-Term Annual Average meters. Similarly, in Lake Auburn, only a few days before the storm, the Secchi reading was 7.3 meters, but water clar- ity dropped to 5.6 meters following the storm. Continued abnormally warm weather resulted in lake surface tempera- tures in southern and central Maine reaching, and in some Percentage of Lakes cases excedeing 80 degrees F. by the end of June. Maine lakes as a whole, were less clear in 2012 than in 2011 and 2010, as Figure 8 illustrates. The annual average Secchi transparency for all lakes monitored throughout the State was 5.21 meters. In addition to the continued drop in overall lake clarity in 2012, fewer individual lakes were as clear as they have been historically, compared to 2011 and 2010, as the following summary details. Year 2012 Secchi Transparency (Water Clarity), and compare this to previous years (Figure 8). For example, Compared to Historical Data in 2003, the statewide Secchi transparency average was one The VLMP and Maine DEP compared the 2012 average of the highest on record at 5.75 meters. But reduced water Secchi disk values for 415 Maine lakes to their long-term clarity for a larger number of lakes in 2004 lowered the aver- (historical) average Secchi values. Within that group, 164 age to 5.39 meters. In 2005, the average dropped to 5.26 lakes (39.5%) were clearer, 45 (10.8%) were the same as meters and in 2006, statewide Secchi transparency dropped their historical average, and 206 lakes (49.6%) were less to 5.1 meters, the lowest annual average in seven years. In clear (Figure 6). Deviations from the average in both 2007, Maine lakes rebounded to 5.65 meters—the fourth directions (plus and minus) varied from as little as a tenth clearest year for Maine lakes since 1974. But the following of a meter to nearly two meters. Table 2 lists the ranges year, the average dropped to 5.34 meters, which may come of clarity deviation for the set of lakes that were compared as no surprise, considering that lakes that were monitored in 2012. in 2008 were more or less evenly split between those that were clearer than, and less clear than they had been histori- Figure 7 illustrates the variation described above during the cally. The average continued to fall to 5.14 meters in 2009, past decade. Compared to the past decade, 2012 was one following two extremely wet years in the State of Maine. In of the least clear years for many Maine lakes, in that nearly 2010, the statewide Secchi average increased to 5.6 meters, half of the lakes monitored were less clear than their histori- one of the two clearest years for Maine lakes in the past cal average. This percentage was only matched or exceeded seven years, but in 2011 – a much “wetter” year than 2010, during two other years (2006 and 2011) since 2001. the average dropped to 5.33 meters. In 2012, the average Another way to consider conditions monitored in 2012 is continued to drop to 5.21 meters, one of a few low statewide to determine the average of all of the individual lake annual averages in the past decade. Secchi averages for a given year (average of all the averages), Figure 8 Annual Secchi Transparency Averages for Maine Lakes Figure 8 is a plot of the average annual Secchi disk transparency for all Maine lakes for which data have been available from 1970 through Secchi Depth (meters) 2012. During the first few years of this period the number of lakes on which the average is based was relatively small. This may account for the high degree of fluctuation up until 1975, when the number of lakes in the data set exceeded 100. Since 1975, the number of lakes used to determine the annual average has increased steadily to more than 400 per year. The graph shows that for most years after 1975 the statewide average has been between 5.0 and 5.5 meters. The 2012 Year average was 5.21 meters. Water Quality 13
You can also read