LONDON PRIME RESIDENTIAL PIPELINE 2016 - Arcadis

Page created by Ray Holland
 
CONTINUE READING
LONDON PRIME RESIDENTIAL PIPELINE 2016 - Arcadis
LONDON PRIME
RESIDENTIAL
PIPELINE 2016
LONDON PRIME RESIDENTIAL PIPELINE 2016 - Arcadis
Prime housing has been instrumental        In recent years the shortage of
                                           high quality, ‘fresh out of the box’
                                                                                  Significantly, the issues facing
                                                                                  the London market are potentially
                                           luxury homes in central locations,
in lifting London’s residential and
                                                                                  playing into the hands of other
                                           coupled with favourable exchange       cities across the country.
                                           rates, made for a heady mix that       Birmingham and Manchester,
construction markets out of recession.     investors simply could not resist.
                                           This resulted in huge price hikes
                                                                                  in particular, are coming up on
                                                                                  the rails as developers and
In recent years, investors from all over   right across the capital’s prime
                                           market. In some areas values have
                                                                                  investors - boosted by the more
                                                                                  affordable land values and

the world have taken a shine to the        accelerated up to fifty percent.
                                           However, while planning and
                                                                                  the government’s long-term
                                                                                  infrastructure commitments - are
                                                                                  looking to alternative locations
capital’s real estate market, taking it    development have continued
                                           to surge ahead in light of these
                                                                                  for prime residential investment.

towards unprecedented levels of growth.    trends, the market is evolving.
                                           Successive tax tinkering has had a
                                                                                  The question we pose this year
                                                                                  is – how can developers and

Although London remains a magnet
                                           big impact on the very top of the      investors turn a maximum profit
                                           market and its effects are not just    in a market that keeps changing?
                                           felt in prime but in every area of     What are the consequences of
for developers and investors alike, the    the market. Developers will now
                                           need to be more agile if they want
                                                                                  rising costs and easing demand?
                                                                                  And, crucially, where next for the
market has matured significantly,          to ensure the right margins.           prime residential market?
                                           One feature of the recent ‘boom’
requiring development opportunities        years was sales values steadily
                                           outstripping construction price          Successive tax tinkering has had a big
to be carefully selected.                  inflation. However, higher stamp
                                           duty charges – combined with
                                                                                    impact on every level of the market
                                           other tax reforms and global
                                           economic uncertainty – have
                                           turned the thermostat down on
                                           buyer demand, while construction
                                           costs are now rising faster than
                                           before.
LONDON PRIME RESIDENTIAL PIPELINE 2016 - Arcadis
EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY
•   The amount of ‘prime’ homes      •   The Chancellor should scrap
    due for construction in              extra stamp duty on homes
    London over the next ten             above £1 million and, instead,
    years is expected to hit over        use the planning process to
    35,000 with a total sales            secure an enhanced level of
    value of more than £77 billion       affordable housing

•   Chelsea & Fulham is the most     •   Although market conditions
    popular location, followed by        are changing and there are
    the regeneration areas of the        fears of an over-supply at
    Southbank and the City and           the lower end of prime,
    fringe                               opportunities exist in mixed
                                         use and mixed tenure
•   The combined floor space             developments
    of these properties would
    eclipse the entire City of       •   Significant growth likely to
    London                               be seen in British regional
                                         economies as major
•   Despite initially encouraging        infrastructure commitments,
    investment to stimulate wider        population and employment
    growth, the government has           growth drive prime demand
    changed policies mid-cycle,
    stemming buyer demand and,       •   Market will recover when
    consequentially, hurting             sales values rise relative
    affordable housing allocations       to construction inflation
                                         between 2018 to 2020.
•   Stamp duty, in particular, is
    becoming more of a tax on
    development than purchasing
    with ‘stamp duty paid’ deals
    impacting margins
LONDON PRIME RESIDENTIAL PIPELINE 2016 - Arcadis
SHORT TERM     MEDIUM TERM    LONG TERM
                                        PROJECT NAME
                                                              (2015-2018)    (2019-2021)   (2022-2024)
                                          1 Palace Street
                                        10 Trinity Square
                                            100 Piccadilly
                              100 West Cromwell Road
                                      102 Jermyn Street
                               103-109 Wardour Street
                             11-15 Grosvenor Crescent
                                        119 Ebury Street
                               119-122 Bayswater Road
                                  1-3 Grosvenor Square
                                    135 Grosvenor Road
                       151-161 Kensington High Street
                             17-35 Craven Hill Gardens
  1-8 Clarges St, 82-84 Piccadilly and 29 Bolton Street
                                18-19 Buckingham Gate
                                         185 Park Street
             19 Queen Elizabeth Street, Butler's Wharf
                                              190 Strand
                                     19-27 Young Street
                                      195 Warwick Road
                                           20 Blackfriars
                              20 Grosvenor Square, W1
                                 213-215 Warwick Road
                                   22 Grosvenor Square
                                         22 Tower Street
                                   24 Buckingham Gate
                                           257 City Road
                                       26 Chapter Street
                               30 Old Burlington Street
                                      31-36 Foley Street
                            35 Marylebone High Street
                                           36 Park Street
                                36 St John's Wood Road
                           375 Kensington High Street
                                      38 Hyde Park Gate
                                      38-44 Lodge Road
                                    38-62 Yeomans Row
                              4-5 Queen Street, Mayfair
                                    406-408 The Strand
                                      4-16 Artillery Row
                                         48 Carey Street
                                 5 & 6 Connaught Place
                                    50-57 High Holborn
                           52-57 & 8-16 Princes Square
                                            55 Broadway
                                           55 Hans Place
                                       55 Victoria Street
                                        56 Curzon Street
                                       60 Sloane Avenue
                                        61 Oxford Street
                                62-68 Rosebery Avenue
                                  66 Chiltern Street, W1
                                   74-76 Chiltern Street
                                     88 St. James Street
                                     9 Marylebone Lane
            90-93 Piccadilly (formerly In and Out Club)
                                     9-10 St Mary at Hill
                   Abell & Cleland House, Westminster
                                             Allen House
                     Amberley Waterfront Apartments
                                 American Embassy, W1
                                    Arundel Great Court
                                  Barts Square - Phase 1
                                  Barts Square - Phase 3
          Battersea Power Station Phase 1 Circus West
                    Bishopsgate Goods Yard (part only)
                                         Bolsover Street
                                 Brewer Street Car Park
                                              Cale Street
                                              Cale Street
                                             Centrepoint
                           Chambers Wharf (part only)
                                 Chelsea Barracks , SW1
                                          Chelsea Island
                      Cleveland Row and Russell Court
                            Confidential - West London
                                           Lancer Square
                    Newcombe House Redevelopment
                        Audley Square Redevelopment
                                  39 Hill Street, Mayfair
                                 77 South Audley Street
                                    1-5 Grosvenor Place
                                   4 and 5 Queen Street
                                           Oxford House
                                         Portland House
                                                    Nova
                                              Kings Gate
                                   Confidential - Victoria
                        Covent Garden Estate - Various
Crossrail Tottenham Court Road, 91-101 Oxford Street
                                           Dudley House
                            Dukes Lodge, Holland Park
                                 Earls Court Masterplan
               Eastbury House, 30 Albert Embankment
                             Elizabeth House, Waterloo
                                       Embassy Gardens
                                                                                                         35,000 HOMES
LONDON PRIME RESIDENTIAL PIPELINE 2016 - Arcadis
Fitzroy Place
                     Former Holland Park School, Airlie Gardens
                              Former TA site, 245 Warwick Road
                                                     Furnival House
                                                         Glebe Place
                                                 Goodman's Fields
                            Great Minster East, Marsham Street
                                      Great Minster House North
                                             Great Portland Street
                                       Grosvenor Gardens House
                                                    Hamilton Grove
                       Hampton House, 20 Albert Embankment
                                                       Harrow Road
                                                         Heron Plaza
                                                 Hertsmere House
                                                    Hortensia Road
                                                  Hurlingham Gate
                                           Hurlingham Retail Park
                                               Hyde Park Barracks
                                         John Lewis Clearings Site
                                             Kensington Park Road
                                           Kings Road Fire Station
                                                     Knighton Place
                                                     Knights House
                                                    Leinster Square
                                                 Lillie Square, SW6
                                                       London Dock
        London Fire Brigade HQ, Albert Embankment (part only)
                                          Lots Road Power Station
                                                Marble Arch Tower
                               Merchant Square Buildings 1 & 6
                                                       Moxon Street
                               North Kensington Sports Centre
                                 North Wharf Gardens - Phase 1
                                 North Wharf Gardens - Phase 2
                                                Odeon Kensington
                                                    One Blackfriars
                                                     One Nine Elms
                                                 One Tower Bridge
                                               Pall Mall, St James's
                                                       Park Crescent
                                                       Parker House
                                                        Parker Tower
                                                 Principal Place, E1
                                  Project London: Fulham Wharf
                                                    Rathbone Place
                                                       Regents Gate
                                              Riverlight (part only)
                                                   Riverwalk House
                                                  Royal Mint Street
        South Kensington Telephone Exchange, Draycott Avenue
                        South Kensington Underground Station
                         South Quay Plaza, 183-189 Marsh Wall
                                      Southbank Place, Waterloo
                                                  Southbank Tower
                           St Dunstan's House, Fetter Lane, EC4
                                               St Edmunds Terrace
                                          St John’s Wood Barracks
                                                         Sugar Quay
                                    Old War Office (57 Whitehall)
The Parabola, Kensington/Holland Green, Kensington High Street
                                  (The Commonwealth Institute)
                         The Solitaire, 158 Brompton Road, SW3
                                           Tottenham Court Road
                       Trenchard House 19-25 Broadwick Street
                                                Vauxhall Bondway
                                                     Vauxhall Cross
                                             Vauxhall Sky Gardens
                                                   Vauxhall Square
                                                      Vicarage Gate
                                     Walton Street Police Station
                                         103 - 109 Wardour Street
                         Westbourne House, Westbourne Grove
                                          13-16 Jacobs Well Mews
                                                           The Stage
                                                Soho Works Estate
                                                  Bankside Quarter
                                                      Fielden House
                                                  Old Queen Street
                                                   20 Poland Street
                                                       6 John Street
                                        101 Prince of Wales Drive
                                                  Ransomes Wharf
                                            24-30 West Smithfield
                                                       Palace Wharf
                                                  Aykon Nine Elms
                                      22-29 Albert Embankment
                                               33 Horseferry Road
                             Ten Broadway (New Scotland Yard)
                                         Royal Mail Sorting Office
                                                33 Greycoat Street
                                54-57 Great Marlborough Street
                                                       Alpha Square
                                               HSBC Pension Fund
                                                    West End Green
                                                 Bayswater Project
                                                         29 New End
                                                     Millbank Tower
                                                      TOTAL UNITS       16,947   9,622   8,486
                                                                                                 77 BILLION SALES VALUE
LONDON PRIME RESIDENTIAL PIPELINE 2016 - Arcadis
DEVELOPMENT                                                                                            Homes per year 2014 versus 2015 index

CONTINUES TO
                                                                                                        6000

                                                                                                       5000

SURGE AHEAD                                                                                            4000

                                                                                                       3000
The market has cooled in recent                   In terms of timings, we predict
months with some developers                       a two-year peak in the number                        2000
reporting a slowdown in sales                     of new prime homes being
                                                                                                        1000
and enquiries. In spite of this,                  completed in 2017 (5,414)
the development pipeline has                      and 2018 (5,130). At this point,
                                                                                                            0
surged ahead 40 percent since                     construction will have completed                                2015          2016      2017        2018       2019                2020    2021        2022             2023         2024
last year with over 10,000                        on just under half of the total                                                      Homes per year 2014 index                       Homes per year 2015 index
additional homes now planned                      number of homes currently
for construction.                                 planned, leaving a staggering
                                                  £36 billion worth of property
A major reason for this has been
                                                  still to be built. Given the amount                             SHORT TERM                                       MEDIUM TERM                                      LONG TERM
the continued attraction of prime
                                                  of development remaining and                                    (2016 - 2018)                                     (2019 - 2021)                                   (2022 - 2025)
London new build to a wide
                                                  the possible need to re-configure
range of international investors.
                                                  the product mix in response to
Developers from the likes of
                                                  the current market dynamics,
Malaysia, Hong Kong, USA, India
                                                  it is conceivable that the some                                             16,947                                              9,622                                          8,486
and UAE, as well as the UK, have                                                                                                                                                 Homes
                                                  projects could take longer to                                                Homes                                                                                             Homes
entered the market acquiring sites
                                                  be completed.
later in the cycle to bring forward
new schemes with revised and
intensified levels of development.                                                                                              48%                                                28%                                            24%
Many of these are now forecast                                                                                          Pipeline Volume                                    Pipeline Volume                               Pipeline Volume
to complete between 2019 and
2025.

                                                                                                                           £41 Billion                                       £22 Billion                                    £14 Billion
                                                                                                                            Sales Value                                       Sales Value                                    Sales Value

Our pipeline is based on a snapshot analysis of new private residential projects being built or planned for delivery in central London through to 2025 with an average sales value greater than £1,350/ft2.
Given the complex nature of planning, funding and phasing the delivery of these developments, estimating the delivery dates of schemes is not an exact science. However, by producing a theoretical timeline, we are able to discuss the headline
trends and shape of the ten-year pipeline.
LONDON PRIME RESIDENTIAL PIPELINE 2016 - Arcadis
MAPPING
OUT LOCATION                                                                                                     KEY
                                                                                                                       Chelsea & Fulham - 10,914

                                                                                                                       Southbank - 8,863
                                                                                                                                                    Bayswater & Paddington - 933

                                                                                                                                                    Mayfair - 589

                                                                                                                       City & Fringe - 5,898        St. John’s Wood - 427
The exclusive west London             One such area is the Southbank
                                                                                                                       Victoria & Pimlico - 1,960
postcodes of Chelsea & Fulham         where continuing transformation                                                                               Belgravia - 401

are currently proving the most        has seen the area swiftly                                                        Midtown - 1,754              Knightsbridge - 343

popular areas of the capital.         establishing itself as London’s                                                  Docklands - 1,600            Marylebone - 252

Here, almost 11,000 new luxury        third major business district.                                                   Kensington - 1,104           Hampstead - 17

homes are planned with a sales        Here, the value of prime residential                          17
value of around £20 billion.          development has reached £14
This figure, however, is heavily      billion, up 37 percent on 2015.
influenced by the future              Likewise, in the City and fringe the            427
regeneration of Earls Court           ‘tech city’ revolution coupled with
which represents around two           new Crossrail stations is proving                     252

thirds of the planned development     a growing draw for investment.
in the area, and for which the        The total number of homes
programme is currently being          planned in these areas has seen a        933            589
                                                                                                         1,754
reviewed.                             40 percent increase on last year.
                                                                                                                 5,898
In the main, however, the                                                                   401
concentration of new build                                                                                                                                            1,600
activity has been focused on                                                 1,104    343
emerging locations. These areas
are outside the traditional ‘golden
postcodes’, where developers see
potential for house price growth                                                                           8,863
fuelled by regeneration schemes
creating improved business
                                                                             10,914         1,960
links, social and retail amenities
and, critically, new transport
infrastructure.
DIFFERENT GRADES OF LUXURY AVOIDING THE
                           SQUEEZE IN A
When it comes to types of home,
in terms of sales values, over
                                            By contrast, we have seen very
                                            low rates of growth in the number
                                                                                 supply at the bottom end of
                                                                                 prime, there still appears to be

                           CONSTANTLY
two thirds of new build prime               of super prime and prime in          opportunity for smaller and
properties are now valued                   more central locations such          differentiated boutique schemes
between £1,350 - £1,750/ft2                 as Kensington, Knightsbridge         at the top end of the market in

                           CHANGING MARKET
with a further 21 percent valued            and Belgravia. This reflects the     excellent locations.
between £1,750 -£2,250/ft2. This            higher land values in these areas,
demonstrates that the bulk of the           coupled with a typically smaller
units are at the bottom end of the          average size of development.
                                                                                                                    Looking ahead, we predict that      In addition, we are also seeing
prime market.                               In comparison to fears of over
                                                                                                                    the financial viability of prime    strategic reviews being carried
                                                                                                                    residential development will        out on a number of projects. This
                                                                                                                    be under pressure for the next      is in order to refine the proposed
                                                                                                                    two-to-three years. During this     product mix and unit sizing to
 Number of units per sales band 2014 vs 2015                                                                        period, construction costs are      reflect the changing purchaser
  25000                                                                                                             forecast to rise faster than        demographics of a market which
                                                                                                                    sales values, making further        now has a greater focus on owner
  20000                                                                                                             erosion of developers’ margins      occupiers and domestic home
                                                                                                                    a possibility until values for      buyers.
                                                                                                                    prime property recover. This
                         Units per year 2014 index

  15000                                                                                                                                                 In the current climate, the
                                                                                                                    is forecast by several leading
                                                                                                                                                        development control process
  10000                                                                                                             agents to be between 2018
                                                                                                                                                        needs to be stronger than ever
                                                                                                                    and 2020.
                                                                                                                                                        before. Fully exploring the
   5000                                                                                                             Our view, supported by              relationships between costs and
                                                                                                                    conversations with several          value is vital when it comes to
      0                                                                                                             clients, is that because of the     both creating fundable schemes
                    1,350 -1,749                           1,750 -2,499                       >2,500                disparity between construction      and securing the best possible
                         Number of units 2014                        Number of units 2015                           prices and sales values, it is      returns. Given a blank sheet of
                                                                                                                    likely that developers of prime     paper, our recommendation is
                                                                                                                    residential will now need to find   to work backwards from a sales
                                                                                                                    at least 10 percent cost savings    aspiration target when shaping a
                                                                                                                    to achieve their desired internal   scheme, but the inevitable reality
                                                                                                                    rate of return and remain viable.   is that developers are challenged
                                                                                                                                                        by having to deliver more for less.
Design and build has been
the predominant form of
                                    COST PRICE GROWTH
procurement and delivery in
the prime residential market in
recent years. However, many
                                    VERSUS VALUE GROWTH
of these successful projects
were secured under contract                                                                                                       market recovery
prior to the rebound in market                                 40
prices in 2014. Since that time,
developers have found it                                       35
increasingly expensive to pass
delivery risk to the point at
                                                               30
which the viability of projects
is being threatened.
                                                               25
In our view, more innovation in
                                     Percentage change index

procurement practice is needed                                 20
as some clients can no longer
afford the multiple layers of                                  15
back-to-back risk pricing passing
through the supply chain to
                                                               10
a main contractor. Clearly,
smarter approaches than ever
                                                                5
before are needed when it
comes to managing value
creation and optimising the                                     0

technical elements of buildings,
such as the mechanical                                          -5
and electrical services and
infrastructure, in order to help                               -10
                                                                     2012   2013     2014         2015         2016        2017         2018        2019   2020
developers ‘beat the market’
and stay viable.                                                                   Arcadis TPI % annual increase      Arcadis TPI cummulative

                                                                                   Savills cummulative index          Annual capital growth %

                                    It will not be until 2018 that capital values will start moving ahead of
                                    build costs, suggesting a window of recovery for the prime new build
                                    market between 2018-2020.
TAXING TIMES FOR PRIME                                                                                            Tax Tinkering – a chronology

PROPERTY IN THE CAPITAL
                                                                                                                                                     Introduction of tax on
                                                                                                                                                     ‘enveloped dwellings’ valued
                                                                                                                                       April 2013    over £2m. Capital gains tax
                                                                                                                                                     introduced for AETDs at 28%
                                                                                                                                                     on gains

The government initially             Since the end of 2014, significantly   Wider tax increases have also         15% stamp duty rate imposed
                                                                                                                  on purchases by ‘non-natural      March 2014
encouraged investment in the         higher stamp duty rates have           created problems. Initially           persons’ (corporate entities)
prime housing market as a            been introduced for transactions       observed as unlikely to dampen
means to stimulate economic          at the high end of the market. On      investors’ appetite for prime                                            Tax free period reduced when
growth. However, since then, it      top of this, as of April this year a   property, the increasingly                                 April 2014    converting a main residence
has changed its policies mid-way     punitive, additional three percent     convoluted and expensive regime                                          into an investment property
through a development cycle,         surcharge on second home               has since been met with global        Replacement of the stamp
raising taxes to fend off voters’    ownership was introduced. This         currency devaluations, shocks in      duty ‘slab’ system seeing a
                                                                                                                  higher tax burden on properties   December 2014
concerns over rising house prices    rate now applies to all buyers         the stock market and falling
                                                                                                                  at the top end
and a consequential lack of supply   regardless of where they are           commodity values. PwC observe
                                                                                                                                                     Expansion of the ‘enveloped
for British families.                from or the whether or not             that the British property tax                                            dwellings’ tax rules to cover
                                     they are purchasing through a          system is also now the most                                April 2015    properties valued at over £1
The ongoing catalogue of far
                                     company structure, and have            ‘complex’ in the world, endangering                                      million and also over £500k
reaching tax reforms and fiscal                                                                                                                      from April 2016
                                     proven damaging for the central        London’s reputation as an
regulations have made the UK a
                                     London prime market. Certain           investment haven.                     3% stamp duty surcharge on
more expensive and complicated
                                     parts have virtually ground to a                                             all second property purchasers    April 2016
market in which to invest. Not                                              The full impact of the government’s
                                     standstill as a result.
only has this impacted many large                                           tax tinkering is still unclear.
developers who have already          Many homes in this bracket with        Nevertheless, a convoluted                                               Capping of mortgage interest
committed significant funds, but     an average value of between            tax system and the spectre of                              April 2017    tax relief down to 20%
it also risks a downward spiral of   £4-£5 million have seen the            further possible changes is,
less affordable homes being built    stamp duty levy increase by            undoubtedly, in danger of             Removal of permanent
                                                                                                                  non-domicile tax status for
and supplied elsewhere, defeating    over £150,000. While for those         undermining confidence in a           those living in the UK more       April 2017
one of the core purposes of the      intending these properties as a        market that previously attracted      than 15 of the last 20 years
reforms.                             second home, the levy has grown        investors off the back of its track
                                     by around £275,000. This increase      record for political and financial                                       Capital gains tax payable on
                                     alone is well over the average         stability.                                                  May 2019     profit of the sale of property
                                                                                                                                                     within 30 days
                                     house price in the UK.
                                                                                                                  Full transition to taxing
                                                                                                                  landlords based on turnover       April 2020
                                                                                                                  rather than profit
STAMP DUTY CHANGES
ON PRIME PROPERTY
                                            £73,750                                                    £363,750
                                  £43,750                                                       £273,750
                       £40,000                                                          £210,000

    £1m                                                                 £3m
  PROPERTY                                                             PROPERTY
    PRICE                                                                PRICE

                                         £663,750                                                       £1,413,750
                                  £513,750                                                      £1,113,750
                       £350,000                                                         £700,000

    £5m                                                                £10m
  PROPERTY                                                             PROPERTY
    PRICE                                                                PRICE

                                                                                                              Homes in £4-£5 million bracket have
                                                                                                              seen the stamp duty levy increase by
                                                                                                              as much as £275,000
 OLD RATE - PRE 4 DECEMBER 2014         NEW RATE - PRIMARY RESIDENCE         NEW RATE - SECONDARY RESIDENCE
THE UNINTENDED
                                                                                Another flashing light on the
                                                                                dashboard is that of the mid-market.
                                                                                With stamp duty growing rapidly

CONSEQUENCES OF                                                                 at the highest price brackets,         The choking effect of the new higher
                                                                                there are also signs that those        stamp duty rates is leading to delayed
                                                                                looking to invest in residential

TAXING AT THE TOP
                                                                                                                       starts and putting affordable housing
                                                                                property are now beginning to
                                                                                                                       contributions at risk
                                                                                acquire properties valued around
                                                                                the £1 million to £1.5 million
                                                                                mark. This rush to market is at
Several industry experts have            fewer affordable homes being           risk of causing something of a
commented that the government            delivered across the London            distortion. Developers are now
has overshot its mark by taxing          market, potentially aggravating        being forced to focus on building
the upper end of the market too          the well-documented housing            more one bedroom flats and
severely at 12 percent. The higher       crisis.                                fewer family homes in order to
rates of stamp duty on prime                                                    keep purchase prices below the
                                         Home ownership is one of the           magic £1.5 million threshold.
properties under the new slice
                                         most important levers of social
system came at a time when the
                                         mobility. However, if the purchasing   Furthermore, the choking effect
market was already suffering from
                                         process is too costly for prime        of the new higher stamp duty
falling off-plan sales and rising
                                         property, wealthy homeowners           rates is leading, in some cases, to
construction costs. Despite
                                         are less likely to buy upwards.        delayed or cancelled starts for
fears of an over-supply of prime
                                         This, in turn, leaves no room for      new build prime developments.
properties in London, the reforms
                                         middle-income buyers who also          Consequentially, the badly-needed
have inadvertently exacerbated
                                         wish to climb the ladder or the        affordable housing contribution
an excess of properties at the
                                         lower-income buyers beneath            made by these schemes is also
top end of the market by increasing
                                         them in the chain. In the medium       cancelled out. Meanwhile, fear
the total costs involved in purchasing
                                         term, the result of this stagnation    also exist that landlords will also
them. The inevitable stand-off
                                         is fewer transactions going            just simply increase rents to offset
which has resulted between
                                         through and prices increasing          the impact of the reforms, making
purchasers and sellers has
                                         further as supply continues to         the capital even less affordable
induced a level of anxiety in the
                                         outstrip demand.                       for renters.
development and finance markets
that is not conducive to stimulating
further new build. This means
there will be less in stamp duty
receipts to the Treasury, and
OSBORNE’S HAIRCUT
                                                                                                             The potential erosion to gross         To ensure a buoyant housing
                                                                                                             development value and margins          market across the board, a
                                                                                                             linked to stamp duty discounting       reduction in the top rate of stamp

FOR DEVELOPERS                                                                                               is now a significant issue for
                                                                                                             developers, especially when
                                                                                                             considered in combination with
                                                                                                                                                    duty must be imposed to release
                                                                                                                                                    pressure on developers who have
                                                                                                                                                    committed to land purchases
                                                                                                             unforeseen increases in construction   under the coalition government
                                                                                                             costs. The overall result of this is   and prior to December 2014.
The key issue with stamp duty is
                                       Prime London Developments                                             a potential double whammy for          Alternatively, the Chancellor
that it has to be paid with cash. In
                                       Scheme of circa 240 apartments at a sales value of £1600/ft2          developers to navigate in their        should scrap the extra stamp duty
a buyers’ market of dipping asset
                                                                                                             appraisals.                            costs on new build schemes and,
values, many developers –
                                                                                                                                                    instead, negotiate directly with
particularly those of larger                                                                                 There is also a risk that higher       developers for a higher direct
schemes – who cannot merely                                                                                  stamp duty charges could result        affordable housing contribution
wait for the market to shift are                     4%                                        £9m           in exponential downward impact         at a more viable level. This would
particularly under pressure to                      hit on                                  extra stamp      on values, as price-sensitive
                                                    margin                                      duty
                                                                                                                                                    avoid frightening developers and
offer incentives such as ‘stamp                                                                              investors sit out the cycle and        investors away from the London
duty paid’ in order to secure sales.                                                                         wait for the bottom of the market      market, holding back regeneration
The end result being that stamp                                                                              prior to purchasing.                   and badly-needed affordable
duty is increasingly a tax on
                                                                                                                                                    housing supply.
developers rather than buyers.                               All units sold off-plan to investors

Assuming the extra cost of
the new stamp duty rates are
discounted from the sales prices,
as agreed on many new build            Super Prime London Developments
schemes, we estimate the               Scheme comprising circa 70 apartments at a sales value of £4000/ft2
charges take a serious chunk out
of gross development values and
developers’ margins.
                                                     7%                                       £36m
                                                    hit on                                  extra stamp
                                                    margin                                      duty

                                                              All sold to second home owners
                                                                         or investors
WHERE NEXT FOR DEVELOPERS?
                                                                                                                                            In essence, the medium-term
                                                                                                                                            impact of growing costs for prime
                                                                                                                                            residential property will see
                                                                                                                                            developers target locations where
Developers need to be nimble                                                                                                                buyers can get more ‘bang for
and turn the difficult market to                                                                                                            their buck’. This is particularly
their advantage. Given the fears                                                                                                            the case with homes in the sub
expressed about a potential                                                                                                                 £1,000/ft2 bracket with a greater
over-supply of prime London                                                                                                                 variety of tenure. Such a move
homes and recent anxiety that                                                                                                               may bring developers more
                                     ‘Flight to quality’       Mixed use                  The new £1million        Outer London
investors may walk away from                                                                                                                closely into direct competition
                                     Large-scale, multi-unit   Developments close to      neighbourhoods           Boroughs and
deposits on new build projects, we                                                                                                          with house builders, or encourage
                                     schemes have boomed       stations and transport     According to Oxford      commuter belt            more joint venture working.
may see changing patterns over                                 hubs have big potential.
                                     at the lower end of                                  Economics, the sheer
the coming months and years.                                                                                       Acute under supply
                                     prime, while the          Combining prime            pressure of population   of housing will
                                     pipeline for new build    residential with retail    growth will see          increasingly mean
                                     above £3,000/ft2 has      and grade ‘A’ office       London house prices      that Outer London
                                     remained quite flat.      space – we forecast        double by 2030. We       Boroughs and
                                     Overseas developers,      continued growth           predict that areas in    commuter towns will
                                     in particular, may        in the pipeline at         London where flats       have to absorb the
                                     prefer to invest in       Canary Wharf,              are currently valued     population overspill
                                     small to medium sized     Paddington, Victoria       at less than £1          from Central London.
                                     projects with fewer       and Hammersmith            million, and houses      This will see prices
                                     units in higher value     locations where new        under £2 million, will   grow substantially. As
                                     locations where           transport infrastructure   be the next areas for    a result we expect
                                     supply is lower, such     is gathering pace and      prime development.       additional growth in
                                     as Kensington,            values are increasing      We expect to see         locations such as
                                     Knightsbridge, Mayfair    between 25 and 30          growth in locations      Wembley, Stratford,
                                     and Marylebone.           percent.                   such as Camden,          Croydon, Brent Cross,
                                                                                          Kentish Town, Maida      Cricklewood,
                                                                                          Vale, Clapham,           Tottenham Hale,
                                                                                          Canada Water,            Havering, and Abbey
                                                                                          Wapping and Old          Wood.
                                                                                          Oak Common.
EXPANDING                                                                    Areas of opportunity

HORIZONS                                                                           Midlands Engine
                                                                                   West Midlands Combined
                                                                                   Authority region

With some investors finding           The real game changer that will              The Northern Powerhouse
themselves priced out of the          accelerate future regional growth            Manchester, Liverpool, Leeds,
traditional London market, the        is the move to fiscal devolution             Sheffield and Hull
UK’s regional markets are fuelling    deals across the UK. Devolved
opportunities for development,        combined assemblies are                      West of England City Region
with the likes of Manchester,         empowered to take control of                 Bristol, Bath, North Somerset
Birmingham, Leeds, Bristol,           collecting business rates and                and South Gloucestershire
Edinburgh and Glasgow coming          co-ordinating the spatial planning
into sharper focus. Institutional      and infrastructure priorities               Oxfordshire and Cambridge
investors have seen the attraction    across their regions in line with a
of these locations in terms of        common economic development
accessible land values, capital       plan. So, too, will enterprise zones
growth and yield.                     create clustering opportunities
                                      for businesses, along with
The British government’s
                                      improvements in amenities, social
commitment to improving
                                      infrastructure, education, health
connectivity, including the likes
                                      and housing.
of HS2 and HS3, are breathing
renewed confidence into regional
markets, such as Manchester and
Birmingham. Businesses are being
encouraged to locate operations
in these less expensive areas that
offer improved prospects and
infrastructure. In turn, the growth
in business interests is driving
population growth and an
increase in demand for housing                                               London
in prime regional city locations
valued between £300/ft2 to
£475/ft2.
WHAT DOES 2017 PROMISE FOR PRIME?
                                                                                                                                                     Following six-to-seven years of
                                                                                                                                                     unprecedented growth, it appears
                                                                                                                                                     the market has reached the
                                                                                                                                                     mid-point of the pipeline delivery
                                                                                                                                                     cycle and the government has
The challenges facing developers
                                      2017 prime predictions                                                                                         acted to stem this in order to
have risen over the last twelve
                                                                                                                                                     quell fears over a prime London
months. The market has flattened
                                                                                                                                                     asset bubble crash.
considerably as demand from
overseas purchasers has waned               Slowing pipeline growth in 2017 caused by market uncertainty and a potential Brexit                      Ironically, the high levels of
and successive rises in stamp duty                                                                                                                   taxation brought in at the top of
have hit hard. Taken within the                                                                                                                      the market now threaten to drive
                                            Growth in City and Fringe, Canary Wharf and prime outer London to continue at pace
context of a June referendum                                                                                                                         a flood of vendors into the city’s
on EU membership, all of this                                                                                                                        mid-market, depriving families
combines to ‘frighten the horses’           Strategic reviews of projects leading to re-positioning of product mix aligned towards owner             of more affordable housing stock
and a period of inertia has set in.         occupiers and smaller apartments below £2m                                                               in the suburbs, while simultaneously
                                                                                                                                                     precipitating the risk of a glut
                                            A renewed focus on cost reduction, leading to reduced basement and amenity provision where               of prime London homes valued
                                            business case is marginal                                                                                above £2 million languishing
                                                                                                                                                     on the market and creating
                                            Programme reviews for larger schemes linked to deferred delivery, phasing of build and re-financing      distressed assets and investors.
                                                                                                                                                     Several developers detected
                                            Shifting moods in procurement attitudes among developer clients away from simple ‘one size fits          some time ago that the ‘cheese
                                            all’ two stage design and build procurement                                                              was moving’ in London and have
                                                                                                                                                     responded accordingly. Some are
                                            Clients becoming increasingly open to more hands-on control of risk and supply chain                     now actively pursuing mixed
                                            relationships in order to optimise price                                                                 tenure schemes and mixed use
                                                                                                                                                     developments located in outer
                                            Increase in joint venture partnerships between developers and house builders to access supply            London locations, the commuter
                                            chain and spread risk                                                                                    belt and other regional cities
                                                                                                                                                     where the mainstream UK owner
                                            Continued trend towards mixed use development including offices, hotels and retail                       occupier is the target. Other
                                                                                                                                                     developers have remained
                                                                                                                                                     focused on building out their
                                            Increasingly polarised market with well-located, smaller boutique prime / super prime schemes
                                                                                                                                                     committed projects in the
                                            and build to rent becoming preferred assets
                                                                                                                                                     prime central locations and
                                                                                                                                                     responding to shifting market
                                            Possible re-awakening of the Asia capital markets in the event of post-Brexit devaluation of sterling.   need by refining their product
                                                                                                                                                     mix, specification, delivery
                                                                                                                                                     programmes and sales strategies.
Without a cut in stamp duty,
the next few years are likely to
see slower growth in the prime
London market. Against a
                                                                         CONTACT
background of low transaction
                                    Some are now actively pursuing
levels, we may also see more        mixed tenure and mixed use schemes
developers delay bringing           in outer London locations and the
forward projects and regeneration   commuter belt
schemes that would, in turn,
benefit London’s civic amenity,
create jobs and aid the City’s
competitiveness.
In the meantime, the current
squeeze on viability and the                                             Mark Cleverly
imbalance between construction
costs, sales values and higher                                           Head of Commercial Development
transaction costs, coupled with                                          T +44 (0)7736 900 211
concerns of over supply in some                                          E mark.cleverly@arcadis.com
locations, suggests a period of
adjustment. We expect recovery
in the prime central London
market will come about once
sales values, as predicted,
rebound again between 2018
to 2020.
Until this happens, we expect the
lion’s share growth to be centred
around the fringes, prime outer
London and in certain regional
economic centres.
www.arcadis.com/uk
          @ArcadisUK

          Arcadis United Kingdom

9627AUK
You can also read