June 2020 Journal of the International Planetarium Society - Vol. 49, No. 2 - COVID-19: This changes everything - International ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Online PDF: ISSN 233333-9063 Vol. 49, No. 2 June 2020 Journal of the International Planetarium Society COVID-19: This changes everything Page 38
Soon there will be no reason to do without a brilliant starry sky. ZEISS ASTERION® The new star ball for hybrid planetariums. Compact, fast, energy efficient, super bright stars. Affordable. For domes from 8 to 18 m (24 to 60 ft) in diameter. Seeing beyond
Executive Editor Sharon Shanks 484 Canterbury Ln Boardman, Ohio 44512 USA +1 330-783-9341 sharon.shanks@gmail.com June 2020 Webmaster Alan Gould Lawrence Hall of Science Planetarium Vol 49 No 2 University of California Berkeley CA 94720-5200 USA adgould@comcast.net Advertising Coordinator Articles Dale Smith (See Publications Committee on page 3) 10 Letter to the Editor: There’s been a “see” change in observing Jim Sweitzer Membership Individual: $65 one year; $100 two years 12 Guest Editorial: Fulldome storytelling: Embracing the Institutional: $250 first year; $125 annual renewal Library Subscriptions: $50 one year; $90 two years Dome’s uniqueness Michael Daut All amounts in US currency Planetarium Research Direct membership requests and changes of address to the Treasurer/Membership Chairman 18 The Aesthetics of the Planetarium Experience. Research-Based Best Practices Part II: Music Ka Chun Yu Printed Back Issues of Planetarian IPS Back Publications Repository 30 Design considerations for a seasonal constellations maintained by the Treasurer/Membership Chair planetarium program: Comparison of embodied design (See contact information on next page) and computer visualizations Final Deadlines Heather Bradley, Julia Plummer, March: January 21 June: April 21 Christopher Palma, Margaret Teuber September: July 21 Special Section: COVID-19 December: October 21 38 COVID-19: This changes everything Sharon Shanks Associate Editors 44 How planetariums are affected Mark SubbaRao Book Reviews April S. Whitt Calendar Loris Ramponi 46 Putting idle computers to work Cartoons Alexandre Cherman 48 Keeping the community in touch Michael McConville Classroom Education Mark Percy and the Classdome Cadre 49 Ode to the Coronavirus: A Planetarian’s Lament Data to Dome Mark SubbaRao Patty Seaton Education Committee Jeanne Bishop Humor April S. Whitt 49 The hospitality suite goes virtual Mark Webb Ron Walker 50 A pandemic sparks a revolution Guilherme Marranghello Immersive Media Carolyn Collins Petersen International News Lars Petersen 52 The lighter side of a serious situation Steve Tidey Live Interactive Programs Karrie Berglund Mobile News Susan Reynolds Button Planetarium Design/Operations Tim Barry 54 A Week with the GDP winner will be welcomed in Sound Advice Jeff Bowen Berlin (when it is safe) Anna Green Southern Hemisphere Haritina Mogoșanu History/Years ago Tom Callen 56 Week in Italy Winner Susan Button Ron Walker 90 Tributes: Matthew Stein, Larry Krozel 91 Tributes: Oleg Vasilievich Verkhodanov On the Cover contents continue on next page Earth breaking free of the grip of COVID- 19 symbolizes the planetarium commu- Index of Advertisers nity, which is still bringing the stars to American Museum of Natural History....... 15 world. Original artwork by Jackie Baugh- Ash Enterprises................................................. 61 man commissioned by Planetarian; artist Audio Visual Imagineering........................... 85 permitted to retain copyright. Bays Mountain Productions......................... 64 BIG & Digital.................................................... 29 California Academy of Sciences................ 27 Digitalis Education Solutions....................... 17 Endurescreens.....................................................9 Evans & Sutherland........... 23, 55, 57, 59, 87 International Planetarium Society home page: GOTO Inc........................................................... 71 www.ips-planetarium.org Kraftwerk.............................................................5 Metaspace.........................................................35 Planetarian home page: Mirage 3D.......................................................... 65 www.ips-planetarium.org/page/plntrn Navitar............................................................... 69 Ohira Tech/Megastar........Inside back cover RSACosmos..................... Outside back cover Spitz, Inc..................................................... 73, 89 Spitz Creative Media.................................7, 79 www.facebook.com/InternationalPlanetariumSociety You Can Do Astronomy................................. 81 twitter.com/IPS_Planetarium ZEISS......................................Inside front cover Vol 49 No 2 June 2020 Planetarian 1
Off icers June 2020 Vol 49 No 2 President Mark SubbaRao Adler Planetarium Columns 1300 South Lake Shore Drive Chicago, Illinois 60605 USA +1 312-294-0348 6 In Front of the Console: Embracing the mask president@ips-planetarium.org Sharon Shanks 8 President’s Message: How much the world has changed Mark SubbaRao 51 PARTYcles Alex Cherman Past President Shawn Laatsch 58 IMERSA Matters: Using the “down” time for serious Emera Astronomy Center 167 Rangeley Road planning Carolyn Collins Petersen Orono, Maine 04469 USA 60 Seeking What Works: Thanks for a wonderful tenure past-president@ips-planetarium.org as chair Jeanne Bishop 62 From the Classdome: Welcome to the ClassHome Mark Percy 66 International News Lars Petersen President Elect Kaoru Kimura 74 Tales from Dome Under: The Score: Tor 1, NASM 0 Japan Science Foundation/Science Museum Tom Callen 2-1 Kitanomaru-koen, Chiyoda-ku, 76 Sound Advice: When the music is live under the dome Tokyo, Japan 102-0091 +81 3-3212-8506 Jeff Bowen Fax: +81 3 3212 8443 78 41 South: Citizen Science: One way to keep your president-elect@ips-planetarium.org audience engaged Haritina Mogoșanu 80 LIP Service: LIPS in the time of COVID-19 Karrie Berglund Executive Secretary 82 Mobile News: Keep the momentum when your dome Patty Seaton is closed Susan Reynolds Button Howard B. Owens Science Center 9601 Greenbelt Road 84 Book Reviews April Whitt Lanham, Maryland 20706 USA Light from the Void: Twenty Years of Discovery with +1 301-906-5990 secretary@ips-planetarium.org NASA’s Chandra X-Ray Observatory The Lost Constellations: A History of Obsolete, Extinct, or Forgotten Star Lore Treasurer 88 A Different Point of View: The music of leftover brats Ann Bragg Ron Walker Anderson Hancock Planetarium Marietta College 91 Calendar of Events Loris Ramponi 215 Fifth Street Marietta, Ohio 45750 USA 92 Last Light: Musings from isolation April Whitt +1 740-376-4589 treasurer@ips-planetarium.org Director of Operations Jeannie Benjamins Managing Matters 411 Richmond Street East, Suite 200 Toronto, Ontario Canada M5A3S5 operations@ips-planetarium.org 2 Planetarian Vol 49 No 2 June 2020
Aff iliate Representatives European/ Mediterranean Planetarium Rocky Mountain Planetarium Association Association RMPA EMP Michele Wistisen Manos Kitsonas Casper Planetarium Eugenides Planetarium 904 North Poplar Street 387 Syngrou Avenue Casper, Wyoming APA ABP PLANed APLF AMPAC ASP APS 17564 P. Faliro 82601 USA Athens, Greece +1 307-577-0310 +30 210 946 9674 michele_wistisen@natronaschools.org +30 210 941 7372 fax mak@eugenfound.edu.gr Russian Planetariums Association RPA Great Lakes Planetarium Association Yaroslav Gubchenko GLPA Fulldome Film Society BAP CASC CPS EMPA GLPA GPPA PlanIt Mike Smail PO Box 103 Adler Planetarium 60310 Nizhny Novgorod, Russia 1300 S Lake Shore Drive gubchenko@fulldomefilm.org Chicago, Illinois 60612 USA www.apr.planetariums.ru +1 312-294-0365 msmail@adlerplanetarium.org Society of the German-Speaking www.glpa.org Planetariums JPA MAPS NPA PPA RMPA RPA GDP GDP Great Plains Planetarium Association Björn Voss GPPA LWL-Museum für Naturkunde Jack L. Northrup Westphalian State Museum Sci-Tech Instructional Facilitator of Natural History Omaha, Nebraska USA Sentruper Str. 285 jlnorthrup@fbx.com 48161 Münster Germany SEPA SWAP +49-251-591-6026 Italian Association of Planetaria +49-251-591-6098 fax IAP bjoern.voss@lwl.org African Planetarium Association Association of Spanish Planetariums Loris Ramponi www.gdp-planetarium.org APA ASP National Archive of Planetaria Susan Murabana Owen Javier Armentia c/o Centro Studi e Ricerche Southeastern Planetarium Association The Travelling Telescope’s Nairobi Planetario de Pamplona Serafino Zani SEPA Planetarium Sancho Ramirez, 2 via Bosca 24, C.P. 104 John Hare 105 Riverside Lane off Riverside Drive E-31008 Pamplona Navarra Spain I 25066 Lumezzane (Brescia) Italy Ash Enterprises Nairobi, Kenya +34 948 260 004 +39 30 872 164 29 Riverside Drive, Apt 402 +254 722 218 267 +34 948 260 056 +39 30 872 545 fax Cocoa, Florida 32922 USA smurabana@travellingtelescope.co.uk +34 948 261 919 fax megrez58@gmail.com +1 941 730 3434 javarm@pamplonetario.org osservatorio@serafinozani.it johnhare@earthlink.net Association of Brazilian Planetariums www.planetarios.org www.planetari.org www.sepadomes.org ABP Alexandre Cherman Australasian Planetarium Society Japan Planetarium Association Southwestern Association of Rua Bento Lisboa, 106 BL1 AP1005 APS JPA Planetariums Rio de Janeiro, RJ Amanda Kruger Sumito Hirota SWAP 22221-010 Brazil Science Space–University of Wollongong Kawasaki Science Museum Sarah Twidel alexandre.cherman@ UOW Innovation Campus 7-1-2 Masugata, Tama-ku Noble Planetarium planetariodorio.com.br 60 Squires Way Kawasaki, Kanagawa Fort Worth Museum of Science and History www.planetarios.org.br North Wollongong, NSW 2500 Australia 214-0032 Japan 1600 Gendy Street www.planetariodorio.com.br +61 (2) 42865000 hirota@e23.jp Fort Worth, Texas 76107 USA amandak@uow.edu.au planetarium.jp (817) 255 - 9409 Association of Dutch-Speaking www.aps-planetarium.org stwidal@fwmsh.org Planetariums Middle Atlantic Planetarium Society www.swapskies.org PLANed British Association of Planetaria MAPS Jaap Vreeling BAP April Whitt Nova informatie centrum Nina Cameron Jim Cherry Memorial Planetarium Science Park 904 Glasgow Science Centre Fernbank Science Center 1098 XH Amsterdam 50 Pacific Quay Atlanta, Georgia 30307 USA +31 0 20 525 7480 Glasgow, Scotland G51 1EA april.whitt@dekalbschoolsga.org +31 0 20 525 7484 fax +44 (0) 141 420 5010 www.mapsplanetarium.org J.A.Vreeling@uva.nl nina.cameron@glasgowsciencecentre.org www.astronomie.nl www.planetaria.org.uk Nordic Planetarium Association NPA Association of French-Speaking Canadian Association of Science Centres Kai Santavuori Planetariums CASC Sweco Structures LTD APLF Frank Florian Viitankruununtie 34 B 11 Milene Wèndling TELUS World of Science 00970 Helsinki Université de Strasbourg 11211 142 Street NW Finland Jardin des Sciences Edmonton, Alberta T5M 4A1 Canada +358 44 9867 630 12 rue de l’Université fflorian@twose.ca KaiSantavuori@gmail.com Strasbourg F-67000 France www.canadiansciencecentres.ca +33 (0)3 68 85 05 32 Pacific Planetarium Association +33 (0)3 68 85 04 88 fax Chinese Planetarium Society PPA milene.wendling@unistra.fr CPS Benjamin Mendelsohn www.aplf-planetariums.org Jin Zhu West Valley Community College Beijing Planetarium 14000 Fruitvale Avenue Association of Mexican Planetariums No. 138 Xizhimenwait Street Saratoga, California AMPAC Beijing, 1000044 95070-5698 USA Ignacio Castro Pinal P.R. China +1 408-741-4018 Ave. San Bernabé, 723, Casa 7 +86 10-5158-3311 +1 408-741-4072 fax San Jerónimo Lídice, C.P. 10200 +86 10-5158-3312 fax Benjamin.Mendelsohn@wvm.edu México City, D.F. México jinzhu@bjp.org.cn sites.csn.edu/planetarium/PPA +52 (55) 5500 0562 +52 (55) 5500 0583 fax icastrop@hotmail.com Vol 49 No 2 June 2020 Planetarian 3
Standing Committees Awards Elections Finance IPS Permanent Mailing Address Manos Kitsonas, Chair Martin George, Chair Current Officers Eugenides Planetarium Launceston Planetarium International Planetarium Society 387 Syngrou Avenue Queen Victoria Museum Membership c/o Ann Bragg, Treasurer 17564 P. Faliro Wellington Street Mike Murray, Chair Marietta College Athens, Greece Launceston Tasmania 7250 Delta College Planetarium 215 Fifth Street +30 210 946 9674 Australia 100 Center Avenue Marietta, Ohio 45750 USA +30 210 941 7372 fax +61 3 6323 3777 Bay City, Michigan 48708 USA mak@eugenfound.edu.gr +61 3 6323 3776 fax +1 989-667-2270 IPS Web Site: Martin.George@qvmag.tas.gov.au mikemurray@delta.edu www.ips-planetarium.org Conference Current Officers Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Publications Please notify the Editor and Secretary of any changes Upcoming conference host, past Karla Peregrina. Chair Dale W. Smith, Chair on these two pages. conference host, any IPS member Cancun Planetarium Ka’ Yok’ BGSU Planetarium appointed by the president ConsejoQuintanarroense de Ciencia y 104 Overman Hall Contact the Treasurer/Membership Chair for Tecnología Physics &Astronomy Department individual member address changes and general Av. Palenque s/n S.M.21 Mz. 5 CP 77505 Bowling Green State University circulation and billing questions. Addresses Cancún, Quintana Roo, México Bowling Green, Ohio 43403 USA also may be changed online on the IPS Web Site. +1 52 (998) 883 95 57 +1 419-372-8666 +1 52 (998) 201 15 18 +1 419-372-9938 fax dwsmith@bgsu.edu Professional Partners Ad Hoc Committees/Task Forces/Working Groups Armand Spitz Immersive Audio Portable Planetariums Planetarium Education Fund Charles Morrow Susan Reynolds Button, Chair Finance Committee 1961 Roaring Brook Road Quarks to Clusters Barton, Vermont 05822 USA 8793 Horseshoe Lane Education Phone: +1-212-989-2400 Chittenango, New York 13037 Jeanne E. Bishop cm@cmorrow.com +1 315-687-5371 Planetarium Director sbuttonq2c@twcny.rr.com Parkside Administration Building International Relations sbuttonq2c@gmail.com 24525 Hilliard Road Martin George, Chair Westlake, Ohio 44145 USA Launceston Planetarium Science & Data We are gathered together from all +1 440-871-5293 Queen Victoria Museum Visualization Task Force +1 440-835-5572 fax Wellington Street Mark SubbaRao corners of this globe, inspired by the jeanneebishop@wowway.com Launceston, Tasmania 7250 Adler Planetarium world and the universe we inhabit. www.glpaweb.org Australia 1300 South Lake Shore Drive Mail address: +61 3 6323 3777 Chicago, Illinois 60605 USA Our society draws its strength from 3180 Oakwood Lane +61 3 6323 3776 fax +1 312-294-0348 Westlake, Ohio 44145 USA Martin.George@qvmag.tas.gov.au msubbarao@adlerplanetarium.org our predecessors and from the wide diversity of our present Emerging Communities Planetarium Centennial Task Force Vision 2020 Initiative Dave Weinrich Björn Voss Jon Elvert, Chair membership. Building on our past S250 State Road 35 S LWL-Museum für Naturkunde Baton Rouge, Louisiana heritage, we are inspired to dream Nelson, Wisconsin 54756 USA Westphalian State Museum Of Natural 70802 USA dave.l.weinrich@gmail.com History jelvert1@gmail.com of future accomplishments, working History Sentruper Str. 285 48161 Munster, Germany together as a worldwide society. John Hare, IPS Historian +49-251-591-6026 Ash Enterprises +49-251-591-6098 fax IPS President Dave Weinrich 29 Riverside Drive, Apt 402 bjoern.voss@lwl.org Cocoa, Florida 32922 USA Welcome to the 2012 +1 941 730 3434 Planetarium Design and Operations IPS Conference johnhare@earthlink.net Ian McLennan Baton Rouge, Louisiana #404-1275 Haro Street Vancouver, British Columbia V6E 1G1 Canada +1 604-681-4790 phone + fax ian@ianmclennan.com ian.mclennan@gmail.com Planetarian (ISSN 0090-3213) is published quarterly by www.ianmclennan.com the International Planetarium Society. ©2020 Interna- tional Planetarium Society, Inc., all rights reserved. Also known as The Planetarian from Vol. 1 No. 1 through Vol. 6 No. 4. Titled Planetarian starting with Vol. 7 No. 1 forward. Opinions expressed by authors are personal opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the Interna- Guidelines for contributors •• Contributors agree that their printed version has been received by tional Planetarium Society, its officers, or agents. •• Planetarian welcomes submis- submission is their own original work members), contributors may post the sions of interest to the planetari- and has not appeared elsewhere in submission on a personal website, Acceptance of advertisements, announcements, or um community. Preference is given print or electronically, nor is not blog, or a website of general inter- other material does not imply endorsement by the to articles that closely relate to the being submitted simultaneously else- est as long as the following appears: International Planetarium Society, its officers, or philosophy, management, techni- where in print or electronically. If the Copyright 2013 (or appropriate agents. cal aspects, educational aspects, or submission has appeared elsewhere year) International Planetarium history of planetariums, and to ideas in print or electronically, permission Society; used with permission and Note that photos may be enhanced digitally for print- that can readily be incorporated to re-print must be obtained and provide a link to the IPS. If in doubt, ability only, never for content. into planetarium shows. Authors are a copy of this permission emailed contact the editor with questions. responsible for obtaining all neces- to the Editor with the article. •• The Guidelines for Contributors The editor welcomes Letters to the Editor and items sary copyright clearances, especial- •• Once accepted for publication, on the IPS website should be consult- for consideration for publication.The editor reserves ly for illustrations and photographs. the contributor also agrees that the ed before submitting an article. the right to edit any manuscript to suit this publica- copyright for original works not •• Potential advertisers are invited tion’s needs. •• Research articles dealing with educational aspects of the plan- appearing elsewhere is held by the to check the Advetising Guidelines International Planetarium Society. and Rate Sheet on the IPS website: The online PDF version holds ISSN 2333-9063 etarium and other topics are highly desirable and will be refer- Once a submission has appeared www.ips-planetarium.org/plntrn Planetarian is part of the EBSCO research database. eed if applicable and requested. in Planetarian (but not before the 4 Planetarian Vol 49 No 2 June 2020
STATE-OF-THE-ART RGB LASER PROJECTION 360° SPATIAL SOUND TECHNOLOGY ZEISS OPTO-MECHANICAL STAR PROJECTOR UNIQUE ROTATING PLATFORM AND MUCH MORE... experimenta Science Dome in Heilbronn (DE) | The world‘s first Hybrid Dome Theater hybrid cutting-edge PLANETARIUM SOLUTION STATE-OF-THE-ART PLANETARIUM, EVENT LOCATION, THEATER STAGE, CONCERT HALL, MOVIE THEATER, TRAINING CENTER & MORE... Imagine a venue that combines all this in one – integrating cutting-edge technology and creating an absolutely unique visitor experience that is both educational and entertaining. Kraftwerk LT‘s Hybrid Planetarium Solution is a unique turnkey dome installation with more than just one purpose – many more to be exact! READY FOR YOUR HYBRID DOME? CONTACT US! +43 7242 69269-0 | info@kraftwerk.at
In Front of the Console Sharon Shanks 484 Canterbury Lane Boardman, Ohio 44512 USA +1 330-783-9341 sharon.shanks@gmail.com Embracing the mask It was a cruel type of irony that I titled my March I decided that the astronomy-themed hat was enough justification to pull editor’s privilege column “The importance of face to face,” just in time and share another picture of my granddaugh- for the coronavirus pandemic to hit and face to face to ter. Ellis is rocking a hair scarf her mother, an became “face to face six feet apart and wear a mask.” emergency room nurse, wears for work. And I am frequently reminded of a line from the 1993 movie then I couldn’t decide which one. Photos by Jurassic Park spoken by Dr. Alan Grant, “The world has just John Shanks. changed so radically, and we’re all running to catch up.” We’re running, certainly, to produce and launch content, Lars Petersen noted that masks “are hard to education, and connection with our audiences on line. come upon in Denmark because the authorities And it also feels like were’s stuck in a nightmare, one in don’t recommend them in public. People tend which we run but never make progress fleeing from the to reuse them or do not replace after the max 2 monster. In this case, the monster is uncertainty. We can’t hours of use or when moist.” make decisions without knowing when and how we can Loris Ramponi made a poignant statement reopen (or if we even should or could). through his image. See Page 91. When I wrote this column, news was just starting to Carolyn added the back story for hers: “I like break about major layoffs and staff reductions at the large to sew. In March, I began making face masks for science museums in the U.S. Uncertainty now is future us to wear, and offered one to a neighbor who employment and the sustainability of science centers that was undergoing chemotherapy. She mentioned rely on visitors through the door, not watching on line. it to someone else, and I started to get requests for masks from others. So, I’ve been sewing and Making a point to remember the vendors selling space-themed masks for people who When it became obvious that this issue of Planetari- want something special. an was going to include a lot of content about the effects “Then the project blossomed into a mask- of COVID-19 on the planetarium community, I decided making task force in our area. People in our to make one of my occasional story contribution and Colorado county have donated fabric, thread, survey the vendors to see how they were faring. Planetar- etc. to the task force. Sewists have banded ium vendors are family, even if they are only one or two together and are busily making masks to donate colleagues from a large company or from a company of one or two. to first responders, law enforcement, hospice workers, local veterinari- About half of the vendors I contacted replied, and I think their answers ans, other essential workers, immune-compromised neighbors, etc. It’s are a good sample of the care and camaraderie that everyone in this been a real joy to learn the little scraps of material I have been whip- community feels about each other. ping through my sewing machine are helping others stay safe as they do their jobs during the epidemic.” And now, about the masks I did not request masked photos from the four authors of the research The other thing special in this issue is the response to my request for paper on embodied design that starts on page 30. It would be hard to the associate editors and other contributors to share selfies in masks. explain later when their article is shared. Susan Button started it all when she shared a picture her granddaugh- ter had taken, and it grew from there. A farewell for Jeanne Bishop Some of the photos came with stories, and some of the masks are Finally, Jeanne Bishop went a step further and added gloves to her as creative as the the people whose lives they are helping to keep safe. image. Oh, that is so typical Jeanne—to go above and beyond. I will Astronomy themes are favorites, of course. miss her presence in Planetarian. Michael Daut shared train robber Michael, and a fierce and sinister She announces (page 60) that this will be her final contribution Alex Cherman stuck a pose with a Marvel Comics-themed mask. to Seeking What Works, the column focused on the IPS Education Guilherme Marranghello’s mask is hand decorated with planets Committee. She is retiring from her role as committee chair. and satellites. April Whitt chose astronomy, and a pair of sun glasses is Anyone doing planetarium research knows that the name of Jeanne enough to change up for her second picture for Last Light. Mark Percy Bishop appears frequently; she was one of the first to publish scholar- represents the United Federation of Planets in his mask, and you can ly articles about education under the dome and those papers are cited tell that Mike McConville is smiling behind his constellations bandana. frequently in later studies. Ron Walker (being typical Ron) is protected behind the face hugger She has spent her entire life, literally, immersed in planetariums from the movie Alien. Mark SubbaRao makes up for his plain (albeit and involved with the International Planetarium Society. She has neon green) mask with having a telescope in the background. been here for us since the beginning So much of what we try to do as Masks are not as common outside the U.S. Tom Callen photoshopped a society—to educate, share and lead—have been set by her example. one into his picture, but he noted it is also anaglyphic. We, as a society, will miss her quarterly contributions. I 6 Planetarian Vol 49 No 2 June 2020
FULLDOME www.spitzinc.com/fulldome_shows Vol 49 No 2 June 2020 Planetarian SHOW DISTRIBUTION7 Contact: Mike Bruno mbruno@spitzinc.com T: 610.459.5200
President’s Message Mark SubbaRao Adler Planetarium 1300 South Lake Shore Drive Chicago, Illinois 60605 USA +1 312-294-0348 msubbarao@adlerplanetarium.org How much the world has changed My March President’s Message talked about what a wonderful time affiliates across the globe. Affiliate reps will be needed more than ever we were to have at the conference in Edmonton. I talked about the as the communication link between their members and the board. great sessions that were planned, the opportunities to greet old friends and make new ones, and to seal the deal I even included a picturesque New director of operations photo of Jasper National Park where the post conference tour was to Due to a staffing change at the association management company be held. that the IPS has engaged, Managing Matters, we now have a new direc- In the three months between issues, the world has changed. The tor of operations. The IPS would like to thank COVID-19 pandemic has been devastating to our community. Plane- our previous Director of Operations Kristen tariums all around the world are shuttered and we have been hearing Lepine dos Santos for her service to the orga- about many members losing their jobs.. We face great uncertainty of nization. when we’ll be able to open our planetariums again, and how much Jennie Benjamins has taken over this we’ll need to change how we operate when we do open our doors. role. Jennie has worked in the association At the same time it has been inspiring to see how our community management industry for over three and a has responded. Almost overnight planetarians started teaching them- half years. She has developed and executed selves new skills and started producing online content. I’d like to recog- an association rebrand, managed member- nise the work of Michael McConville and the other organizers of The ship development plans, and commu- Dome Dialogs eConference series through Facebook and Zoom. These nication strategies for her clients. Her webinars have been a great service to the community, both for the professional background is based in the not- content of the sessions and the fellowship that these virtual gatherings Jennie Benjamins for-profit sector with various roles ranging bring. from fundraiser to marketer and publi- As an industry, we need to transition from survival to recovery. cist. Jennie is excited to be part of the IPS community and looks Ideally we will do this in a way that makes us more efficient and stron- forward to connecting with all of you. I ger in the long run. While we were hit with the impact of the pandem- ic seemingly overnight, that recovery will be much longer. IPS also needs to change to adapt to the new needs of our commu- Coronavirus forces deadline extensions nity. I’d like to thank Thomas Kraupe for co-chairing the new IPS In light of the disruptions caused by the pandemic, the IPS COVID-19 Task Force with me. So far we’ve sent out surveys, issued a Council has voted to extend the deadline for the submission of mini-grant program, increased the frequency of the Communicator bids for the 2024 conference. Bids are now due on September 1, newsletter, and opened the new Planetarium Network forum. (https:// 2020. ipshub.mn.co/) More information about the bidding process is available from While we won’t be able to gather in person, we are excited about President Mark SubbaRao at the email listed above. the upcoming virtual IPS conference now being planned. My hope is In addition, the deadline for nominations for the positions that this virtual event becomes a model for get-togethers in the future. of president elect, secretary, and treasurer for 2021-22 has been Perhaps in the future we can hold a conference every year, alternating extended to September 2, 2020. between in-person and online meetings. Candidates normally present their reasons for wanting to become an officer to IPS members in person during conferences, From council to board but because the 2020 conference has been cancelled the Election IPS was scheduled to hold a council meeting on June 19 during the Committee is requesting that all nominees submit a 3-minute Edmonton conference. It still will be held, albeit virtually instead of in video that will be accessible to all members via the IPS website. person. At that meeting we will transition from our current governing Nominations must be received by Martin George, Elections structure of a council made up of affiliate representatives to the new Committee chair, by 12h Universal Time on September 2, at board structure with representatives from each continental zone. martingeorge3@hotmail.com. Acceptances by nominees are We’ve gotten many questions about what that will mean for affil- asked to be received by, at the latest, one day later. Persons who iates and their relation to IPS. For the most part little will change in have accepted a nomination at any time before the closing date that relationship. IPS will still be, at its core, an organization made up are encouraged to prepare their video as soon as possible. of affiliates. In fact, we are actively encouraging the creation of new IPS Note that the terms of office for secretary and treasurer are two years each, but the office of president elect will be followed by two years as president in 2023-24 and two years as past IPS President Mark SubbaRao, among his many associations, also is the director of the Space Visualization Laboratory at the Adler Planetarium. president in 2025-26. I 8 Planetarian Vol 49 No 2 June 2020
WORLD CLASS PROJECTION DOME SCREENS FOR PL A N E T A R I U M S UNIQUE QUALITY FROM CONCEPT TO EXECUTION Pro+ the perforated aluminium screen series by Endurescreens provides the most advanced seam matching technology available today. Contact us: For general inquiries: office@endurescreens.com For sales-related matters: l.yin@endurescreens.com Vol 49 No 2 June 2020 www.endurescreens.com Planetarian 9
Letters to the Editor An open letter to my fellow planetarians: There’s been a “see” change in observing 1 Jim Sweitzer, PhD Science Communications Consultants, LLC Chicago, Illinois USA j.sweitzer@icloud.com Dear Friends and Colleagues focal ratio is F/4, so at Please excuse the puns (it’s been a long few weeks), but I wanted to the size of its CMOS share my recent experiences with a new type of electronically-assist- color-imaging chip, ed telescope that has been keeping me “focused” while staying home. it achieves a resolu- The eVscope. Used with permission from It’s called the eVscope, and it’s made by Unistellar of France. tion of 1.7 arc seconds Unistellar Optics. (unistellaroptics.com/) I was one of the first in the U.S. to buy one and I per pixel across a full have been using it from my backyard on the west side of Chicago, Illi- image diameter of nois. about 25 arc minutes. It delivers a 1.2 megabyte image. (Of course, eVscope is not the only electronically-assisted telescope The scope has its own onboard computer that automatically to come on the market recently. The Stellina telescope from Vaonis, conducts starfield identification, so it’s easy for the user to point it, find also a French company, is another. (https://vaonis.com/about-us) Both objects and then track them. This latter feature alone makes it a winner retail for about $4,000. Others are surely in the works.) in light-polluted skies where it’s hard to see enough stars to locate any The Class 9 Bortle scale skies in my neighborhood are as light-pollut- dim object, even with binoculars. I’ve found pointing accuracy is never ed as they get, but I have been amazed at the scope’s performance and off by more than a couple of arc minutes and tracking never waivers. intrigued by the opportunities it offers to our community. First let me tell you a little about the scope itself and then about its educational Put the scope in enhanced mode potential. But finding the quarry is just the first step. Once you are on target, The eVscope is an all-electronic Newtonian telescope with a modest the telescope can be put into “enhanced” mode where it takes a stream 114 mm (4.5 inch) objective mirror. (Links at the end of this letter will of 4-second exposures, which it continually rotates and averages in a take you to a couple of webpages with more details.) It only weighs 9 process called stacking. If you then integrate for a couple of minutes, kg (approximately 20 pounds), including the tripod (see picture 1). The even in Chicago skies, you can easily image and start to see fine details 2 3 4 From left: M51—Four minute Exposure from Chicago; M61 with its new supernova; M42—After only 3 minutes of image stacking. All images by author. 10 Planetarian Vol 49 No 2 June 2020
of 9th or 10th magnitude deep sky objects. (See pictures 2, 3, 4, and 5 is a tiny, onboard monitor on the telescope with an eyepiece so you for typical images from my location. The last picture in that series was can watch the same enhancement process on your phone screen. My tweaked a bit with Adobe Lightroom after the session.) guest observers have all enjoyed watching the signal to noise gradual- Dark sites can do even better in less time. (See picture 6 from a ly improve on the screen in real time. Within a couple of minutes, you colleague in France who observes with his at a Class 4 Bortle site.) Even usually have a great image. where I live, I can easily see stars at least down to 16th magnitude and I have found that although some like to look through the onboard fainter. eyepiece, most are happy to watch the image continually improve on Along with the fact that this scope allows me to see deep sky objects the phone. And because the images are already on the phone, they are from my urban backyard, its ease of use and portability are among easy to share. I’ve used Zoom to bring people along in real time and also its biggest pluses. Yes, it is possible to configure a normal 8- or 11-inch texted or air dropped images to my guest observers right after observ- amateur telescope to do this type of “go-to” finding and imaging and ing sessions. even get higher resolution images, but not as easily and quickly as with the eVscope. Possible for dome casting? Instead of hauling 40-70 pounds of gear into the backyard, align- I foresee that this kind of scope could be easy to stream into a dome ing it, and setting up my computer to process the images, I carry a cast. Imagine one of these devices backpacked into Tierra del Fuego to 20-pound scope and tripod in my backpack. I level it and I’m ready to image a far-southern comet for sharing around the world via the Inter- go. Additionally, because of the way it tracks and records images, this net. For international astronomical educational efforts, these seem scope, unlike others, would be just as well-suited for rooftop concrete tailor-made. platforms or decks and doesn’t require a separate pier. Astronomically, the eVscope was primarily designed for and works best at sighting deep sky objects, like galaxies, clusters or nebulae— It operates from an app objects that would work well at about 100 magnification. When an I operate the telescope from an app on my smart phone. The eVscope image is in enhance mode, it’s like looking directly through a 1-meter does autonomous star field detection within a minute and then it’s reflector. ready to start hunting deep sky objects. It’s easy to choose the objects The eVscope was also designed for recording astronomical events from an intelligent menu or enter coordinates yourself. like exoplanet transits or asteroid occultations because it can record Once you’ve slewed to your nebula, the image enhancement and hour-long sequences of images. stacking begin with the press of an icon on the phone screen. There The SETI Institute will be coordinating the global network of eVscopes in Citizen Science projects. The Citizen Science data and offline image analysis offer intriguing oppor- 5a tunities for educational programming for 5b high school and college students, as well as in Astronomy 101 classes on most campuses— with or without formal observatories or plan- etariums. The eVscope, however, is not designed for small, high surface brightness observing of details on the moon or planets, primarily because it does not have the focal length for higher magnification. For solar system observ- ing, I use a small, 4-inch Maksutov, which is portable and performs well in urban skies too. But consider a moment those solar system targets for public programming: If you are restricted to doing public programs when the planets are convenient or the moon is around first quarter, you have a limited number of 6 days and times per year, all of which are weath- er-dependent, when you can conduct observ- ing sessions. Gazing beyond the solar system The eVscope, on the other hand, reaches numerous targets on any clear night. And, instead of being limited to just 10 astronomical units, you can easily gaze out over 80 million light years. As an experiment, I went even further and captured light from a quasar 2.5 billion light years away. The deep sky subjects, however, bring with them their own challenge—that of explaining them to the average viewer. It’s fairly easy to help people understand what they’re look at Above: Image 5a, M81 a few minutes into imaging process as seem from phone, and (Image 5b) the when they view the moon, Saturn, or even a same image tweaked a bit later in Lightroom. Photos by author. Image 6, M16 from a dark site. Courte- sy of J.M. Laugier. (Continues on page 37) Vol 49 No 2 June 2020 Planetarian 11
Guest Editorial Fulldome storytelling: Embracing the dome’s uniqueness By Michael Daut Board Member IMERSA msdaut@gmail.com As a continuation of last year’s article1 about audience impact in In addition, the concept of “story” includes all aspects of a cinematic Planetarian, I am continuing our focus on principles of storytelling and production: visuals, acting, narrative, music, sound effects, and some- world-building that are unique to digital fulldome theaters (with some times even silence. parallels to virtual reality experiences). The immersive dome has native characteristics that battle against The immersive dome’s cinematic language is different from tradi- tried-and-true narrative story conventions. Stories conceived tradi- tional “flat” cinema and the audience experience is certainly different. Here, 1 we explore some of the intangible qual- ities that make the dome what it is and imagine how to harness these special attri- butes to unlock the medium’s true poten- tial through immersive storytelling. Incidentally, I take a much deeper dive into this topic in the recently-published textbook The Global Impacts and Roles of Immersive Media, edited by Jacqueline Morie and Kate McCallum2. I also want to acknowledge contributions to my thinking in this article by two of my fellow immer- sive storytellers, Carolyn Collins Petersen and Ryan J. Wyatt. They have long written for immersive spaces and taught about storytelling under the dome, and their insights are invaluable. Deciphering dome storytelling The topic of story is a fascinating place to start our conversation, since the impor- Image 1. The fabled Cinerama Dome on Sunset Boulevard in the heart of Hollywood, tance of story is often elevated to a nearly once home to the extreme wide-screen Cinerama film format. All photos by Michael Daut. mythic status as the rare quest that must be sought out conquered first, before taking any successive steps. (I do this as well) These “perfect stories” are as rare tionally do not always work in fulldome. When they do, they are as magical unicorns and all-powerful genies and are just as unlikely to usually just okay, but they often fail to lean into all the unique bene- be captured. The overused trope that “story is everything” has proba- fits that the digital dome medium uniquely can afford. Conversely, bly done more to paralyze would-be-creatives in their starting blocks ignoring certain key storytelling tools from traditional cinema can than to inspire authentic next-level storytelling. To be honest, stories also hamstring the experience you are designing for your audiences, typically develop much more organically. They often define them- who are hoping to be immersed in the dome. Seems like an impossible selves only after hacking through lots of bad ideas to get to a few good conundrum. It, thankfully, is solvable. ones that need care, craft, sweat, perseverance, and polish to emerge. Here are a few principles I’ve learned as I work to decipher the dome’s story language. On a most essential level, fulldome is not cinema. It is not theater. It is not a themed entertainment experience. It is also not 1 “Guest Editorial: Planetariums need to build and engage audiences to survive,” Vol. 48 No. 1, March 2019. a blend between the three. It is something greater than the sum of its 2 The Global Impacts and Roles of Immersive Media, Handbook of Research On series; parts. IGI Global, 2019. See igi-global.com/book/handbook-research-global-impacts- roles. 12 12 Planetarian Planetarian Vol 49 No 2 June 2020
Fulldome is its own creature of disbelief” enabled by all aspects of On a most essential level, fulldome the medium (script, visuals, narrative, borrows DNA from cinema, theater, 2 soundtrack) that they feel the story and themed entertainment to create actually is happening to them. something new that has its own set of In fulldome, there is no natural strengths and weaknesses. aesthetic distance between the audi- With this in mind, here are some ence and the content. If cinema allows things that the dome does naturally: the audience to peer anonymously •• places the audience inside a through a window, fulldome places the “virtual” space; audience in the room with the charac- •• reveals a lot of (potentially distract- ters with no “safe” or “hidden” perspec- ing) context surrounding the main tive. Therefore, fulldome thrusts focus of a scene; the audience right into story spaces •• offers a sense of kinetic motion as whether the audience realizes this— if the audience is moving through or whether they want to be there or the scenes (rather than the camera 3 not. Savvy directors must learn how or the scenes themselves moving); to use this reality to their advantage •• adapts to the scale and shape of the and warm the audience to the idea of scene, with the skill of a mystical story immersion without letting the shapeshifter, changing the dome’s audience members know that they are apparent shape and size to suit the immersed from the moment the visuals content projected on it; appear on the dome. •• provides a specific vantage point to the audience inside each scene Theater vs fulldome as either a first-person participant Again, to oversimplify, theater is a or as a third-party observer with communal experience in which live a level of closeness determined by performers draw energy and insight the director; 4 from an audience that is also inside a •• creates an alternate world of both specific physical space with them. That sight and sound (using purposeful- experience affords an organic dynamic ly directed music and narration) for of push and pull between the players the audience to inhabit. and the observers. Theater heightens •• Here Here arearethings thingsthat thatthe the dome dome does the experience due to the unpredict- not donotnaturally do naturally (or may(ornot maydo not well do or ability of a live performer who could evenwell at all): or even at all): do essentially anything inside that •• quick shifts in audience perspec- space. Audiences cannot move from tive (a.k.a. traditional fast-cut film seat to seat in a theatrical setting, but editing); performers can exit the physically •• restricted views; defined stage space and move through- •• sudden changes in scale of people out the audience. or objects on screen; The stage itself can transform •• very short shots; through a variety of methods from sets, •• certain transitions like dissolves or lights, curtains, and other tradition- superimpositions; Image 2. A scene from James Hood’s Mesmerica in a digital full- al stagecraft to more elaborate video dome theater. •• provide an aesthetic distance projection mapping or even LED video between the audience and the Image 3. A full-scale Millennium Falcon delights guests at Star panels used as standing set pieces. With content; Wars Galaxy’s Edge in Disneyland, Southern California. all of these available tools, the space •• create passive connection with the within the theater does not typically Image 4. Immersed in the story world of Star Wars, guests at expand or contract physically and the audience. Disneyland are invited to wait inside the Millennium Falcon These lists are by no means compre- in various spaces like this for their turn to pilot the starship audience area also remains consistent- hensive, and I certainly don’t pretend through a smuggler’s run across the galaxy. ly defined. to understand all there is to know about In fulldome, such dynamic experi- this incredible medium. However, they ences can happen with the incorpora- do establish some fundamental differences and similarities between tion of a single “live” performer or multiple performers to leverage the the dome’s spiritual ancestors: cinema, theater, and themed entertain- organic push and pull between the actors and audience. Also, since a ment. dome provides such a powerful sense of place for an audience, it can serve as an immersive backdrop and soundstage for a theatrical perfor- Cinema vs fulldome mance. Since the performers and the dome exist on different physical In an overly simplistic way, cinema is a voyeuristic experience in levels—the actor in front and the dome above—directors must care- which the viewer is invited to look through a “window” into a story fully choreograph action between the two. The audience needs to they can enjoy from a safe distance. Surround sound adds to the sensa- be able to shift focus from the performer to the dome and back again tion of immersion, but visually, audiences do not find themselves without creating confusion, which means the dome and the perform- surrounded by story imagery. It is not until the audience willing- ers shouldn’t be doing too much at the same time. The dome can also (Continues on next page) ly engages in the story emotionally through the “willing suspension Vol 49 No 2 June 2020 2020 Planetarian Planetarian 13
5 5 Image 5. The iconic Sleeping Beauty Castle, designed by Walt Disney and his team of Imagineers, welcomes guests into richly immersive worlds of fantasy and imagination. Image 6. Inside Hollywood’s historic Pantages theater awaiting a performance of Disney’s Frozen: The Musical. 6 gies. of Those adventuresthe reasons—including typically fact that last from they five almost 6 to 15 minutes always feature afor a number story that takes of place reasons—includ- in real time ing the over the fact that actual they almost running time of always the ride,feature with noa storyin gaps that timetakes place in real time over the actual continuity. running time of In fulldome, thethe ride,ofwith sense no gaps presence in time is virtual at continuity. best, and actual kinetic motion is only illusory. In fulldome, Story the sense time can jump of presence forward from scene is virtual at to scene, best, skillful and and actual kinetic editing can motion allow the is only illusory. audience to Story time move fromcanonejump sceneforward fromwithout to another scene toascene, sense anddisruption. of skillful editing can allow The addition the audience of physical to sets and move live from can actors one help sceneapproximate to another withouta theme a sense park of disruption. experience even more closely, blurring the lines The addition between of physical actual experience and sets and experience. virtual live actors can help approximate a theme park experience even more closely, Fulldome blurring the lines between is unique actual Fromexperience and virtualabove, the comparisons experience. it should be take audiences to much more photorealistic locations, covering evident that the fulldome medium has consider- The dome can also take audiences to much more photorealistic loca- distances that would be nearly impossible in a traditional theater. Also, Fulldome able aestheticispower unique that has so often been left underutilized, or worse, tions, covering distances that would be nearly impossible in a tradi- in these virtual spaces, the live performers can serve as “docents” to From by misused thefulldome comparisons above, creatives. It’sittime should to upbeour evident game that and the full- leverage tional theater. Also, in these virtual spaces, the live performers can serve guide the audience through the spaces and provide insight for them, dome medium the natural has considerable abilities of the domeaesthetic to its fullpower thatto potential has sostories tell often been that as “docents” to guide the audience through the spaces and provide much as an experienced guide on a city tour or in a museum exhibit. left underutilized, can only exist in theor fulldome worse, misused medium. by fulldome creatives. It’s time to insight for them, much as an experienced guide on a city tour or in Even with pre-rendered movies, a live actor can perform along with up our What game and leverage follows, the natural in no particular abilities order, of the are some dome ideas andtorandom its full a museum exhibit. Even with pre-rendered movies, a live actor can appropriately designed content, as in Adler Planetarium’s Destination potential to tell stories that can only exist in the fulldome musings to stimulate and encourage new approaches to fulldome story- medium. perform along with appropriately designed content, as in Adler Plan- Solar System show, which integrates a performer beautifully into the What follows, in no particular order, are some ideas and random telling. etarium’s Destination Solar System show, which integrates a performer entire experience, providing a dynamic connection to the audience musings to stimulate and encourage new approaches to fulldome story- beautifully into the entire experience, providing a dynamic connec- telling. Stories or story worlds? tion to the audience. Theater vs themed entertainment A change in perspective regarding story might be a good place Themed entertainment, at its finest, places audiences inside and Stories or story to start. Instead worlds? of placing the initial focus on creating a great story, Theater vs themed entertainment A change in perspective regardingcompelling story might beworlds a goodforplace moves them through a physical space while providing a tactile experi- perhaps we should consider creating story our Themed entertainment, at its finest, places audiences inside and ence that activates all the senses (except perhaps smell and taste). This to start. dome Instead shows of placing to explore. the initial Instead of leaning focus ontelling into creating a great stories andstory, then moves them through a physical space while providing a tactile experi- is the closest entertainment comes to reality, and yes, I’m including perhaps creating we should places consider for these creating stories to take compelling place, why story notworlds for our lean into the ence that activates all the senses (except perhaps smell and taste). This walk-through VR experiences like The Void and Dreamscape in the dome dome’s ability to create rich visual and auditory environments forthen shows to explore. Instead of leaning into telling stories and the is the closest entertainment comes to reality, and yes, I’m including category of themed entertainment. creating places audience to explorefor these wherestories storiestocantaketakeplace, place.why not lean into the walk-through VR experiences like The Void and Dreamscape in the Whether carried by a train car, a ride vehicle on a track, a boat, or dome’s ability Yes, it’s subtle,to but create it isrich visual anddifference. an important auditory environments A story without forrich the category of themed entertainment. more advanced trackless vehicles like in Star Wars: Rise of the Resis- audience to explore places to explore canwhere stories fall flat on thecandome. take place. Such a canvas craves rich- Whether carried by a train car, a ride vehicle on a track, a boat, or tance at Disney parks, or in a “flying” wardrobe mounted on a six- Yes, ness toit’s fillsubtle, its vastbut it is Conversely, space. an important difference. rich A storywith environments without rich nothing more advanced trackless vehicles like in Star Wars: Rise of the Resis- degree-of-freedom robotic Kuka arm in Universal’s Harry Potter and places to explore happening can make can fall the flat on thefeel audience dome. Suchin trapped a canvas detailedcraves spacesrich- for tance at Disney parks, or in a “flying” wardrobe mounted on a six- the Forbidden Journey, these attractions create a powerful sense of nessreason. no to fill itsIt’svast space. Conversely, a delicate balance, but rich environments given the power with nothing of the dome degree-of-freedom robotic Kuka arm in Universal’s Harry Potter and presence. They facilitate the audience’s willing suspension of disbelief happening to transportcan anmake the audience audience, buildingfeel trapped story worlds in detailed seems morespaces for valu- the Forbidden Journey, these attractions create a powerful sense of by taking them on a physical journey through “real” places, with all no reason. It’s a delicate balance, but given the able than simply building stories without first considering where the power of the dome presence. They facilitate the audience’s willing suspension of disbelief their sights and sounds. to transport stories could take an audience, place. Thisbuilding is akin tostory worldsinseems level design videomore gamesvalu- that by taking them on a physical journey through “real” places, with all Rather than virtual environments, themed entertainment worlds able thana simply provide sandbox building stories for players to without explore with first considering where the varied and sometimes their sights and sounds. are as real as they can be. Interestingly, these attractions rely on stage- stories hiddencould taketo locations place. Thisand explore is akin to level design in video games that uncover. Rather than virtual environments, themed entertainment worlds craft from theater, cinematic projection and/or projection mapping, provide a sandbox for players to explore with varied and sometimes are as real as they can be. Interestingly, these attractions rely on stage- and even, in some cases, fulldome technology. Disney’s Soarin’ Around hidden Creating locations a space to explore and uncover. craft from theater, cinematic projection and/or projection mapping, the World and Universal’s Transformers: The Ride 3D are good exam- After figuring out the amazing story worlds where the fulldome and even, in some cases, fulldome technology. Disney’s Soarin’ Around ples of creating synergy between different techniques and technologies. Creating a space experience will unfold, it’s critical to map how the story will take the World and Universal’s Transformers: The Ride 3D are good exam- Those adventures typically last from five to 15 minutes for a number After figuring advantage out of these the amazing locations storysurprises and what worlds where you canthebuild fulldome into ples of creating synergy between different techniques and technolo- experience each space for the audience. The words and the story can andwill will unfold, it’s critical to map how the story musttake be advantage of these interdependent: the locations locations and what surprises are essential for the you storycan andbuild into the story Michael Daut is an independent producer and writer living in California. He Michael Daut is an independent producer and writer living in California. He each space must makefor the audience. effective The words use of them. and the story can Even environments and of devoid must be audio is a member of the IMERSA Board of Directors. is a member of the IMERSA Board of Directors. (Continues on page 16) 14 14 Planetarian Planetarian Vol 49 No 2 June 2020
You can also read