GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: Kelowna's Voluntary Local Review
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: Kelowna’s Voluntary Local Review GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 1
GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW MARCH 2021 The British Columbia Council for International Cooperation (BCCIC) is a network of civil society organizations and individuals moving toward a better world based in British Columbia, Canada. By compiling this report, BCCIC hopes to contribute to the critical debate on Canada’s role in developing and achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The Global Empowerment Coalition of the Central Okanagan (GECCO) is a Chapter of the BCCIC, working in partnership and participating in initiatives, programming and services. For more information on BCCIC or this publication, go to: bccic.ca or contact us: 322-268 Keefer St., Vancouver, BC, V6A 1X5 Phone: 604.899.4475 The vast majority of this project was conducted through the dedication of passionate volunteers. Some of the research was funded through a few programs. BCCIC receives support from the Government of Canada, provided through Global Affairs. This project also received support from Economic and Social Development Canada’s Career Launch SDG Impact Funding, and the Sustainability Scholars Program at the University of British Columbia. All intellectual content including omissions and errors remains the responsibility and property of the BC Council for Internation- al Cooperation and Global Empowerment Coalition of the Central Okanagan. Cover page Photo Credits: Kolby Milton (Unsplash) GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 2
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This report was prepared in partnership with the British Columbia Council for International Cooperation (BCCIC) and Global Empowerment Coalition of the Central Okanagan (GECCO). We would like to extend a personal thanks to all the contributors who spent countless hours researching, writing, and editing various parts of this report and without whom this report would not have been made possible. PROJECT MANAGEMENT TEAM CORE PROJECT TEAM • Wijesekera, Kusum - Author and Project Manager, GECCO • Anwar, Nimrah - Lead Technical Researcher, BCCIC • Muir-Owen, Sara - Coauthor, PICS at UBC • Collis, Amy - Lead Policy Researcher, BCCIC • Wayne-Nixon, Laurel - Project Coordinator, BCCIC • Erickson, Jonah - Researcher, BCCIC • Harris, Dan - Project Coordinator, BCCIC • Hillis, Laura - Researcher, BCCIC • James, Emma - Writer, BCCIC • Kwok, Alex - Researcher, BCCIC • McLean, Simmone - Researcher, BCCIC • Neubauer, Sarah - Lead Economics Researcher, BCCIC • Schiller, Antonia - Researcher, BCCIC • Tang, Ann - Researcher, BCCIC The Global Goals cover a broad range of topics and issues, and experts in different fields were relied upon to share their insights into the work being done throughout the province and locally in the Kelowna region, to review content, make goal linkages, and provide constructive feedback. We are grateful for their input and wish to thank and acknowledge the following organizations: • BCIT • BC Centre for Disease Control, Provincial Health Services Authority • City of Kelowna • Community Energy Association • Elizabeth Fry Society • First Nations Health Authority • Interior Health • International Institute for Sustainable Development • Kelowna CAT • Ki-Low-Na Friendship Society • Ministry of Environment and Climate Change Strategy • Pacific Institute for Climate Solutions • PROOF Food Insecurity Policy Research • Regional District of the Central Okanagan • UBC Sustainability Initiative • Vancouver School of Economics at UBC • John Ecker, Director of Research & Evaluation - Canadian Observatory on Homelessness • Marika Albert, Policy Director - BC Non-Profit Housing Association These, among numerous other organizations, have been instrumental in the formation of this report. GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 3
NOMENCLATURE BCCIC British Columbia Council for International Cooperation BCIT British Columbia Institute for Technology BI Basic Income BIPOC Black, Indigenous, Person of Colour BOMA Building Owners and Managers Association CAAQS Canadian Ambient Air Quality Standards CAD Canadian Dollar CAT Kelowna Community Action Team CERB Canadian Emergency Response Benefit CFIB Canadian Federation of Independent Business CMA Census Metropolitan Area CO Carbon Monoxide CO2 Carbon Dioxide CSD Census Subdivisions CSO Civil Society Organization C&D Construction and Demolition DES District Energy System DNU Do Not Use EC3 Embodied Carbon Construction Calculator EPD Environmental Product Declaration EV Electric Vehicle FLIR Forward Looking Infrared FNESC First Nations Education Steering Committee FNHA First Nations Health Authority GECCO Global Empowerment Coalition of the Central Okanagan GHG Greenhouse Gas HFI Household Food Insecurity ICBC Insurance Corporation of British Columbia IH Interior Health iOAT Injectable Opioid Agonist Treatment IPCC Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change JHS Journey Home Society kWh Kilowatt-hour LCA Life Cycle Assessment LEED Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LICO Low Income Cut Off LIM Low Income Measure GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 4
MBM Market Based Measure MDMA Methylenedioxymethamphetamine MMIWG Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls MOU Memorandum of Understand MURB Multi-Unit Residential Building NEET Not in Education, Employment or Training NOx Nitrogen Oxides OAT Opioid Agonist Treatment OWMO Organic Waste Management Options PACT Police and Crisis Team PICS Pacific Institute for Climate Solutions PM 2.5 Particulate Matter 2.5 RCMP Royal Canadian Mounted Police RDCO Regional District of Central Okanagan RNG Renewable Natural Gas SDG Sustainable Development Goals SHARP Synchronized Hybrid Ambient Real-time Particulate SOV Single Occupant Vehicle TEOM Tapered Element Oscillating Microbalance TRC Truth and Reconciliation Commission UN United Nations VLR Voluntary Local Review VOC Volatile Organic Compound 2SLGBTQQIA Two-Spirit, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, questioning, intersex and asexual GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 5
TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������7 Analysis Of The Goals ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������8 Introduction .........................................................................................................................................10 Population & Demographics������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������11 Geography........................................................................................................................................12 Leave No One Behind - Indigenous Approach ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������13 Goal 1: No Poverty ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������15 Goal 2: Zero Hunger ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������17 Goal 3: Good Health And Well-Being ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������19 Goal 4: Quality Education �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������22 Goal 5: Gender Equality ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������24 Goal 6: Clean Water And Sanitation ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������26 Goal 7: Affordable And Clean Energy �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������28 Goal 8: Decent Work And Economic Growth ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������30 Goal 9: Industry, Innovation And Infrastructure �������������������������������������������������������������������������������32 Goal 10: Reduced Inequalities������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������34 Goal 11: Sustainable Cities And Communities ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������36 Goal 12: Responsible Consumption And Production ������������������������������������������������������������������������40 Goal 13: Climate Action ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������42 Goal 14: Life Below Water ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������44 Goal 15: Life On Land �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������45 Goal 16: Peace, Justice And Strong Institutions ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������46 Goal 17: Partnership For The Goals ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������48 Conclusion............................................................................................................................................50 Appendix A - Low-Income Measure Overview (Goal 1) ��������������������������������������������������������������������52 Appendix B - Homelessness Overview (Goal 1) ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������54 Appendix C - Household Food Insecurity Overview (Goal 2) ���������������������������������������������������������������57 Appendix D - Household Energy Use Overview (Goal 7) ������������������������������������������������������������������60 Appendix E - Waste Per Capita Overview (Goal 12) ��������������������������������������������������������������������������62 Appendix F - Climate Action Overview (Goal 13) ������������������������������������������������������������������������������64 Appendix G - Kelowna VLR Methodology �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������68 Endnotes ..............................................................................................................................................69 GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In 2015, the international communi- strates the intersectionality of the goals ty adopted the United Nations 2030 and indicators, while also attempting Change takes time. Progress requires Agenda for Sustainable Development, to account for the multijurisdictional understanding the problem, and then a global strategy that outlines 17 am- nature and complexities amongst the measuring the solutions accordingly: bitious, interconnected and universal goals, and the collaborations and part- what’s measured, matters. Quantifiable Global Goals that, implemented togeth- nerships necessary to achieve them. progress is not always easy to achieve er, can create a more liveable, equita- or even adequate in providing a true ble world by 2030. These Sustainable The year 2020 was marked by two key analysis; qualitative results are also Development Goals (SDGs) provide a events, COVID-19 and the Black Lives required to share insight, gain under- framework to address environmental, Matter movement, forcing the world to standing and brainstorm solutions. This social, economic and security challeng- face the extent of inequalities experi- report was created with shared knowl- es faced by nations and communities enced by marginalized groups. Canada edge from numerous organizations worldwide. While originally conceived is not immune to these inequalities throughout and beyond the community as country-level goals, and Canada that have been harboured in a history of Kelowna, in an attempt to capture pledging commitment to implemen- of colonization, systemic racism, and the voices of different groups that are tation, success will largely depend on discrimination. Many Indigenous Peo- often left behind, and to also challenge provinces and municipalities also work- ples continue to live with trauma due our preconceived ideas around viable ing together on the ground, so to say, to the legacies of forced displacement solutions. However, there is still much to implement and measure progress from traditional territories, residential work to be done; more quantifiable and towards achieving the SDGs. school experiences of abuse and ne- qualitative measurements to be made. glect, and the disruption of traditional We can do better. We must do better! Voluntary Local Reviews (VLRs), are culture and practices. Furthermore, sub-national reviews of SDG implemen- African, Caribbean and Black Canadians tation and are increasingly being adopt- live with the history of slavery, racism ed by municipalities. This Kelowna VLR and discrimination that still persists has been greatly shaped through close today. Many of the rules that govern consultation with municipal, regional, society and too many of our social and provincial and federal government economic policies reflect bias and dis- agencies, civil society organizations crimination (both conscious and uncon- (CSO), academics, and Indigenous scious), reinforcing the false premise organizations. With 169 targets and that some people are better or more 232 indicators, it is overwhelming and deserving than others. Such policies virtually impossible for municipalities and governance structures are failing — alone — to comprehensively imple- marginalized people and impacting ment the SDGs. As such, this VLR fo- access and availability of the resources cuses on 28 community-level indicators and opportunities necessary to support that are outcome based, quantifiable well-being.1 This stark reality has and measurable, and localized to the been made evermore apparent during geographical and cultural context. For the COVID-19 pandemic. Inclusive the selected 28 indicators, trends are solutions require us to reflect on our shown, and challenges and progress are personal biases, our lack of knowledge highlighted through examples from the and understanding about inequality, City of Kelowna, the Regional District and to commit to creating an equitable of Central Okanagan (RDCO), Province platform where people, regardless of of B.C., Indigenous organizations, and their background, can share their voice CSOs working throughout the commu- on the issues and solutions, and be Kelowna Waterfront nity. The review of progress demon- listened to. Photo Credits: Adam Ruby Photography GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 7
ANALYSIS OF THE GOALS This report analyzed and narrowed the province. Included at the end of each and complexities amongst the goals, UN’s 169 targets and 232 indicators subsection is an illustration on the inter- and the intergovernmental and civil down to 28 community-level indicators connectedness and interdependency of society organizations collaborations relevant to Kelowna. The indicators as the goals and their indicators. The goal and partnerships necessary to achieve related to each goal are summarized in summaries can stand alone, each can them. Table 3. be read and referred to independently, while taken together they form a more Although there is much more to discuss, Each section of the report covers one of complete, integrated report on the this report only touches the surface on the 17 goals; with each section describ- SDGs for the community of Kelowna. In the issues and potential solutions. A se- ing trends of selected indicators for many cases, the SDG indicators chosen lect few indicators have been discussed each goal in context of the community for this VLR are multijurisdictional, further in Appendices A through F to of Kelowna. Also highlighted are the spanning municipal, regional, provincial elaborate on programs already under- challenges and progress currently being and First Nations’ government bound- way, as well as recommendations at the made towards achieving each goal, aries. This VLR attempts to account for municipal, provincial and federal levels. through work by various organizations the multijurisdictional nature of these throughout the community and the indicators, as well as the interrelations Table 3: Summary of Kelowna’s Indicators GOALS LOCAL COMMUNITY INDICATORS • Low Income. Number of persons in low income measure (LIM) • Chronic Homelessness. Number of persons living in chronic homelessness conditions • Active Farmland. Percent land base actively farmed • Food Insecurity. Percent of persons in households who are food insecure (marginal, moderate and severe) • Chronic Diseases. Mortality rate attributed to cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and chronic lower respiratory diseases • Illicit Drugs. Illicit drug mortality rate per 100,000 population • Suicide Rates. Illicit suicide mortality rate per 100,000 population • Post Secondary Education. Highest certificate, diploma or degree obtained • Gender-based Violence. Rate of sexual assaults per 100,000 by sex of victim GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 8
GOALS LOCAL COMMUNITY INDICATORS • Water Advisories. Person-days on advisory • Electricity Usage. Average household electricity and use • Gas Consumption. Average household gas consumption • Unemployment Rates. Unemployment rates • Youth NEET. Population aged 15 to 29 Not in Education, Employment or Training (NEET) • Sustainable Transportation. Main mode of commuting to work • EV Stations. Number of electric vehicle charging (EV) stations around community locations, residential areas and commercial areas • Household Income. Median household income relative to average household income • Vacancy Rates. Rental vacancy rate • Housing Affordabiity. Percent of renters spending over 30% and 50% of income on shelter • Air Quality (PM 2.5). Fine particulate matter (PM 2.5) annual, 3-year average • Air Quality (O₃). Ozone levels annual 4th highest daily 8-hour maximum, 3-year average • Green Space. Percent of residents that live within 400m of a park • Waste Generation. Per capita waste disposal rate • Burn Permits. Number of burning permits issued • Community Emissions. Total annual GHG emissions from community activities • Riparian Area. Total riparian area permanently protected • Green Space. Percentage of green space protected from development • Crime Rate. Crime rate per 100,000 population • SDG-related Work. Number of non-profit organizations working on the SDGs in domestic and interna- tional frameworks GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 9
INTRODUCTION In 2015, the international communi- and stimulating economic growth, all corporations should they engage in do- ty adopted the United Nations 2030 while developing local level goals, tar- ing so, can support the achievement of Agenda for Sustainable Development, a gets and policies for climate action and the SDGs through “bottom up” action. global strategy that outlines 17 am- sustainable development. bitious, interconnected and universal A Voluntary Local Review (VLR) is an Global Goals that together can develop The Province of British Columbia (B.C.) emerging process by which subnational a more liveable, equitable world by has a long history of setting progres- governments can evaluate and report 2030. They address five key themes re- sive social and environmental policy on local level progress towards achiev- lated to people, the planet, prosperity, including the adoption of many sustain- ing the SDGs, enabling a community’s peace and partnerships, adhere to five ability and climate related action plans accountability and transparency. A com- key principles: inclusivity, universality, at the local government level. When mon framework enables cities to com- integration, technology driven, and are aligned with existing planning and policy pare progress in achieving the SDGs, locally focused. frameworks, the interrelatedness of the identify areas where priorities may need goals can improve planning and help to be realigned and/or strengthened, Today’s world has the highest level of align outcomes at the local, provincial, and provide evidence to support com- urban growth and urban migration than national and global scale. For mayors, munities’ partnerships and advocacies ever before, with more than half of the policy-makers, and planners working to with other agencies and organizations world’s current population living in cities improve quality of life in local communi- for necessary funds and resources to and 86% of British Columbians living in ties, this set of integrated targets, when address gaps in achieving a common urban and suburban areas. Urbanization localized, can help achieve a commu- sustainability agenda. In the process of brings with it the risk of increased con- nity-wide vision that can be pursued developing this VLR for the community centration and severity of many social, irrespective of policy cycles. Localizing of Kelowna, close consultation with the economic and environmental issues. Yet the SDGs refers to the manner in which City of Kelowna, as well as regional, pro- it also offers an enormous potential to local governments and policy-makers vincial and federal government agen- advance sustainable development ob- adapt, implement, and monitor the cies, CSOs, academics, and Indigenous jectives, with international governance Global Goals at the local level.2 It takes organizations was required. For details continuing to recognize cities as central into account local settings to develop on the Kelowna VLR methodology, refer drivers for sustainable development. In suitable proxy targets, means of imple- to Appendix G. This project can offer recent years we have seen local govern- mentation, and appropriate indicators, examples to other Canadian cities and ments and municipalities increasingly to identify and measure how local and regions seeking ways to participate in, focusing on creating healthy commu- regional governments, universities, civil and help the world to achieve the global nities, encouraging resource efficiency, society organizations (CSO) and private agenda. Figure 1: UN Sustainable Development Goals GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 10
Kelowna as viewed from Knox Mountain Photo Credits: Amanda Schauerte POPULATION & DEMOGRAPHICS Disaggregated demographic informa- income level, and race to support evi- tion is key to understanding the nature dence-based, equitable policy solutions. The population and demographic of Kelowna’s population including age patterns in Kelowna are an important ranges, income levels, and race. Those While Kelowna’s population is projected factor when localizing and aligning the who are most vulnerable and most to grow 23% by 2030 as compared to SDGs. Urbanization is a continuously affected by certain policies and pro- 2015 (refer to Table 1), the most sig- increasing trend across the Province grams are largely driven by systemic nificant growth will be occurring in the of B.C. and cities including Kelowna differences in how various age groups, 20-39 and 65+ age groups as shown in are subject to encounter the issues class and races are treated. In order to Table 2. Age demographics are import- associated with this trend, including effectively meet communities’ needs, ant to identify and project when eval- restrained economic resources, higher cities must understand the makeup uating progress towards achieving the cost of living and the varying needs of of the communities they are trying to SDGs. The growth in aging populations a changing population. It is impera- help and prioritize equity in policy and tied with varying socioeconomic and tive that demographic patterns of the services that reflect the needs of the racial factors highlight the importance population are identified to set up the different groups. The Chief Public Health of collecting demographic information community for success when handling Officer (CPHO) of Canada states “while to understand the varying needs of the future challenges and to a leader in the COVID-19 pandemic affects us all, population and offer a myriad of solu- sustainable development. Actual and the health impacts have been worse tions to address these specific needs. projected population for Kelowna and for seniors, essential workers, racialized There are other marginalized and vul- Kelowna CMA is outlined in Table 1. populations, people living with disabil- nerable groups (e.g. disabled bodies or ities and women”.5 Yet there remain members of 2SLGBTQQIA) who may not Table 1 - Actual and Projected Popula- large gaps in the collection of racial and be explicitly factored into data collec- tion for Kelowna and Kelowna CMA3 4 ethnic data in Canada.6 It is impossible tion but may still face different experi- to eliminate systematic economic, social ences from both the issue and solution and health issues without a full picture standpoint. The data gaps must be 2015 2030 of who is impacted and how. The pan- considered to shed light on the impacts (actual) (projected) demic, Black Lives Matter movement, faced by all citizens and to ensure no Kelowna 128,769 157,468 and climate crisis all point to underlying one is left behind when implementing Kelowna 197,759 242,259 social inequalities that require, at a the SDGs in Kelowna. CMA very minimum, the breakdown of data at the community scale based on age, GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 11
Table 2: Projected age distribution data comprised of nutrient and mineral-rich Country; Indian Reserve communities, for the City of Kelowna 7 soils; the bedrock of the Okanagan including Duck Lake 7, Tsinstikeptum 10 Valley’s crucial agricultural economy. and Tsinstikeptum 9; and two regional Age The Okanagan Valley is the second-most electoral districts within the Central 2010 2020 2030 important agricultural region in British Okanagan. Kelowna’s VLR indicators are Bracket Columbia, with the majority of BC’s fruit limited to the data available at the city 0-19 20% 18.2% 16.6% trees being grown in the Valley. The first level (Kelowna, City; CSD) or regionally 20-39 25.1% 25.8% 26.3% apple trees were planted in Kelowna in (Central Okanagan, Region; Kelowna 40-64 33.9% 32.7% 31.5% 1862.8 By the 1930s, irrigation systems CMA) to ensure statistical relevance and 65+ 21% 23.3% 25.6% transformed this semi-desert into a to reflect accurate trends. premier fruit-growing location. Today, grapes grown in the valley support both The First Peoples of the Central Okana- GEOGRAPHY local and coastal wineries, and the re- gan district are the Syilx/Okanagan. gion’s thriving wine industry has been a BCCIC and GECCO, we would like to major contributor to the area’s growing acknowledge that this VLR covers the Kelowna is one of the largest metro- tourism sector.9 traditional, ancestral and unceded ter- politan areas in the province of British ritories of the Syilx / Okanagan Peoples. Columbia. The city is located in the The data to support the indicators out- The Syilx People of the Okanagan Nation Okanagan Valley in British Columbia’s lined in Kelowna’s VLR data is gathered is made up of seven member commu- Southern Interior. Much of this region from two key geographical data sources, nities North of the Canada/US border: is forested with dry, open, largely pine Statistics Canada’s census subdivision the Okanagan Indian Band, the Osoyoos forests. Dry grasslands prevail in the (CSD) and Census Metropolitan Area Indian Band, the Penticton Indian Band, arid lower altitudes of the basin, while (CMA) data. The CSD matches the city’s the Upper Nicola Band, the Upper and in the southern Okanagan Valley, the geographical boundaries, while the CMA Lower Similkameen Indian Bands, and climate is dry enough to be classified as encompasses the surrounding Central the Westbank First Nation.10 Members a semi- desert. The city itself lies rough- Okanagan region. The CMA is multi- share the same Nsyilxcən language, ly midway along Okanagan Lake, the jurisdictional, comprised of the cities, culture, and customs, with deep con- largest lake (roughly 120 km by 3.5km) Kelowna and West Kelowna; the district nections to the unique land, flora, and in the Okanagan valley. The valley is municipalities of Peachland and Lake fauna of the valley.11 Figure 2: Map of Kelowna and Surrounding Regions in the Province of B.C. GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 12
through aggressive assimilation policies. Historical and ongoing policies of colo- nization and assimilation as well as sys- temic racism are the root causes for the current situation that Indigenous Peo- ples in Canada experience today. The 1876 Indian Act, which is still in effect today, and the residential school sys- tem, ending only in 1996, are examples of some of the most damaging elements of Canada’s colonial history. Designed to ‘re-educate’ Indigenous children, Canada forcibly removed children from their families and forbade them from acknowledging their heritage, language and culture. In 2015, The Truth and Rec- onciliation Commission concluded these policies amounted to a cultural geno- cide. The physical and mental trauma experienced by residential school sur- vivors continue to reverberate through The sacred spirit of Lake Okanagan is known as N-ha-ha-itk by the Syilx Peoples Indigenous communities, having been but was renamed as Ogopogo in the 1920s by folk singers. Photo Credits: Amanda Schauerte passed down. While the process of this VLR attempts LEAVE NO ONE BEHIND - nation that results in unequal outcomes to reflect and act on what reconciliation INDIGENOUS APPROACH for disadvantaged populations and to can look like, there is still significant take action to help the furthest behind work to be done. This is not a one-time This VLR covers the traditional, ances- first”. 12 commitment, but a continuous and and tral and unceded territories of the Syilx on-going effort to learn about Indige- / Okanagan Peoples. We at BCCIC and In Canada, considerable disparities in nous history, challenge stereotypes, and GECCO, recognize our obligation to social and economic conditions con- consult with Indigenous organizations. redress the current unequal power dy- tinue to persist between Indigenous Though no formal partnerships with namics that emanate from the historical groups (First Nations, Metis and Inuit) Indigenous-led organizations were able and ongoing consequences of colonial- and the general population.13 In par- to be established for this VLR, the team ism, as recorded in Truth and Reconcilia- ticular, Indigenous Peoples face worse consulted the local urban Indigenous tion Commission of Canada’s (TRC) final health outcomes, a poorer standard of organization, Ki-Low-Na Friendship report. We acknowledge that our efforts housing, less access to adequate food Society. This VLR also reflects the team’s to incorporate Indigenous perspective and higher levels of incarceration than insight and learnings from the First and TRC: Calls To Action in this VLR non-Indigenous Peoples. It is important Nations Health Authority (FNHA) and BC process are only a starting point, and to acknowledge that this has not always First Nations Justice Council, among oth- there is still significant work to be done been the case. Indigenous Peoples er First Nations programs and initiatives in order to forge a new relationship have existed on Turtle Island﹘what is underway. Through this VLR process it centred around Indigenous engagement now understood as North America﹘for was learned that access to and collec- and perspectives, and on honour and centuries before colonial settlers arrived tion of data on Indigenous Peoples must respect. in 1491. Existing in great numbers, be carried out in collaboration with Indigenous groups spanned from Alaska Indigenous-led organizations and may Underpinning the success of the SDGs down into South America and had their also require approval from the local is the commitment to leave no one be- own economic trade routes, systems of First Nations Government. Furthermore, hind. Essentially, if the lives of the poor- permaculture and agriculture, education interpretations of this data, including est and most marginalized segments systems, sanitation and systems of gov- issues and impacts affecting Indige- of society do not improve, the goals ernance. However, in the centuries after nous populations, must be made with will not be achieved. In practice, this the arrival of European settlers, Indig- Indigenous Peoples’ and Indigenous-led commitment translates to “a three-part enous Peoples were forcibly displaced organizations. Undoubtedly, there is still imperative: end absolute poverty in all from their land, stripped of basic human much learning to be done. its forms, to stop group-based discrimi- rights and dehumanized and devalued GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 13
Kelowna originates from the word ki?lawna? from the Nsyilxcən language, spoken by the Syilx People, meaning grizzly bear. Photo Credits: Amanda Schauerte Partnerships take time, intention, of the physical, emotional, mental and dedication and commitment in order to spiritual realities”.15 build trust. We recommend for future VLRs in Canada, such partnerships serve The Journey Home Strategy (Goal 1) and as the foundation to the report and be Kelowna Community Action Team (Goal initiated in the early phases. 3) are examples of where the City of Kelowna, CSOs and Indigenous groups In Canada, to achieve the SDGs, have and continue to work collabora- recognizing and disrupting the inter- tively to achieve the SDGs. Throughout generational trauma experienced by this report, the team highlights ways the Indigenous Peoples through holistic and community is working with Indigenous multifaceted approaches and programs organizations to make progress towards rooted in Indigenous cultures is vital to the goals, and identifies opportuni- improving their health and well-being.14 ties for working together through the The Ki-Low-Na Friendship Society iden- future. However, there is still much tifies the medicine wheel (Figure 3) as a work to be done. Further relationship Figure 3: An Example of a Medicine core framework to transforming health building and collaboration is necessary Wheel as Provided by Ki-Low-Na Friend- among Indigenous Peoples, and central to build on essential work underway. ship Society to tackling current social issues such This VLR recognizes the importance of as homelessness. Medicine wheels are traditional Indigenous knowledge in culture-specific and come in more than solving the pressing challenges faced one form, yet they all “represent the today, and in achieving the SDGs. alignment and continuous interaction GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 14
NO POVERTY Local Community Indicators: • Low Income. Number of persons in low income measure (LIM) • Chronic Homelessness. Number of persons living in chronic homelessness conditions SDG 1 aims to end poverty in all its KELOWNA TRENDS 64 cohort is a broad age range, exhibit- forms everywhere. At the local level, ing differences in lifestyles, education, Kelowna’s progress towards achieving In 2017, nearly 30,000 people in the and work experience. Differentiating the this global goal lies in collective local Kelowna CMA were living in LIM, as group into 0-24; 25-64; and 65+ age cat- action, partnerships and programs shown in Figure 1.1. The LIM poverty egories would help to better determine for all persons and families with low threshold in Canada is 50% of median important characteristics of the cohorts, incomes, and by alleviating, and income, with the poverty rate defined such as financial needs of these unique eventually eliminating, homelessness as the proportion of households living categories. Further recommendations throughout the community. Poverty on less than half of the median in- for age and demographic breakdowns is not exclusive to low income and come.16 For the Kelowna CMA, the total can be found in Appendix A. homelessness. It is also tied to many number of people in LIM increased by other SDGs, such as food insecurity 8% from 2013-2017, while the percent- Homelessness can be described as, (Goal 2) and good health and well- age of the population within LIM has “the situation of an individual, family or being (Goal 3). Successful measures remained relatively the same at 15% community without stable, permanent, and targets for Goal 1: No poverty will, for this same period due to population appropriate housing, or the immediate by default, ensure progress is being growth.17 The 0-17 years age group has prospect, means and ability of acquiring made in many other SDGs. This report fallen by about 14% from 6,910 people it…”.18 “Point in Time (PiT) Counts” in provides data on two local community in 2013 to 5,970 in 2017; while the 65+ Canada help identify a minimum num- indicators for Goal 1: cohort saw nearly an 80% increase, ber of individuals experiencing home- from 2,570 to 4,580. Those aged 18-64 lessness on a given night in a communi- • Number of persons in low income comprise about 65% of the total num- ty. While this provides a snapshot of the measure (LIM) ber of low-income individuals, at 19,040 number of people living “on the street” • Number of persons living in chronic people. This group experienced about a and in homelessness situations on that homelessness conditions 7% increase from 2013 to 2017. The 18- day, it often underestimates the severity of the situation by failing to account for the hidden homeless population (e.g. Figure 1.1: Number of Persons in Low Income (after tax) in all Family Units, By Age people who “couch-surf” with friends, Groups family and acquaintances), and those cycling in and out of homelessness. 0-17 years old 18-64 years old 65+ years old 30,000 Figure 1.2 illustrates the number of 2,570 3,080 3,810 4,080 4,580 people living in chronic homelessness 25,000 conditions (both absolute and tempo- 20,000 rary situations) according to Kelowna PiT counts, which have shown a 20% 15,000 17,840 18,520 18,800 18,970 19,040 increase from 2016 to 2018. Kelowna’s 10,000 Journey Home strategy reveals approx- imately 2,000 people in Kelowna will 5,000 6,910 experience homelessness during the 6,690 6,570 6,170 5,970 course of a year.19 Furthermore, 26% of 0 the homeless population in 2018 were 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Indigenous Peoples, though they only Data level: Kelowna CMA SourceStatistics Canada. Table 11-10-0018-01 After-tax low income status of tax filers and dependants based on Census comprise 4.4% of Kelowna’s popula- Family Low Income Measure (CFLIM-AT), by family type and family type composition tion.20 21 For further information on how GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 15
Figure 1.2: Number of persons living in chronic homelessness conditions tation; Goal 10 household income; Goal 11 affordable housing). Some programs 800 already underway or that could be con- Absolute Homeless Count sidered to assist in reducing poverty in Living in Temporary Housing Kelowna and beyond, include: 600 319 • Journey Home, a five-year, local level strategic plan to address 273 homelessness throughout the 400 community. 286 • A Regional Poverty Reduction Strat- 200 233 egy informed by the Central Okana- gan Community Wellness Analysis, which was prepared in 2020 by the - Central Okanagan Poverty Reduc- 2016 2018 tion Committee. Data level: Kelowna Source: Central Okanagan Foundation, Point In Time Counts • Basic Income province-wide study, released in January 2021 provides 65 recommendations for reforming B.C.’s income and social support Canada’s colonial legacy has placed and other appropriate solutions for system. The timing of this report Indigenous populations at a greater risk those under the LIM poverty level will prohibited analysis of the suite of for homelessness throughout Canadian serve those most vulnerable to home- recommendations in this VLR, but cities, as well as potential solutions to lessness. Disaggregated demographic offers opportunity for Kelowna to address this disparity, refer to information is critical for the successful review this important study as part Appendix B. development of programs and policies of future projects. geared at combating poverty. Elimi- CHALLENGES AND nating homelessness, and developing • Living Wage Canada, which calcu- COMMUNITY PROGRESS solutions to end poverty will require lates a living wage across Canada the support and implementation of and offers certification programs for Those under LIM are at a higher risk of programs from various levels of gov- companies to join. becoming homeless. When you become ernment including municipal, provincial homeless, you lose all sense of security and federal; CSOs; and industry as it has For further details on these strategies and privacy; your life becomes gravely many intersectional elements that are and linkages to other goals, refer to exposed and even criminalized (Goal linked to many other SDGs (e.g. Goal 2 Appendix A and Appendix B. 16). Targeting prevention techniques Hunger; Goal 3 Health; Goal 9 Transpor- Goal 1 Interrelations GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 16
ZERO HUNGER Local Community Indicators: • Active Farmland. Percent land base actively farmed • Food insecurity. Percent of persons in household who are food insecure (marginal, moderate, and severe) Addressing the goal of zero hunger is • Percent land base actively farmed reduction. Identifying Kelowna’s farmed tied to ensuring healthy and sustainable • Percent of persons in households land by crop type can further help to food for all, through strategies to who are food insecure (marginal, determine the degree of benefits of increase food security, reduce hunger moderate and severe) actively farmed land as well as possible and support sustainable and local issues or impacts, such as water agriculture. Locally, Kelowna’s 2030 KELOWNA TRENDS contamination from livestock and/ Official Community Plan defines food or pesticide use (Goal 6). Finally, an security as “All community residents Figure 2.1 identifies the percent of increase in locally produced food can [having] access to sufficient, safe, Kelowna’s land base that is actively offer residents greater access to fresh healthy and culturally acceptable foods farmed. This has remained relatively and healthy local products should they produced in a manner that promotes consistent (33-35%) since 2012, have the means to purchase. health, protects the environment and however there was a decline in 2018 adds economic and social value to due to crop switching (e.g. cattle to Figure 2.2 displays household food communities”. For the community of tree farm; apples to grapes). B.C. insecurity levels in Kelowna’s census Kelowna, part of ensuring access to Assessment does not deem land metropolitan areas from 2007 to 2018. healthy foods means also ensuring actively farmed unless farm revenue is The trend over this time period has not adequate farmland, and promoting being generated.22 Once these recent changed much and indicates that over local food production and purchase. crop transitions are complete and 10% — more than 15,300 individuals From an Indigenous perspective, the farms begin generating revenue in 2017/18 — struggle to afford a basic access to foods means access to lands again, Kelowna’s “actively” farmed healthy diet. to practice harvesting in traditional land indicator should rise. Benefits of ways. These are important strategies active farmland include reducing heat CHALLENGES AND to address zero hunger. This report island effect; flood control; and carbon COMMUNITY PROGRESS provides data on two local community indicators for Goal 2: Food insecurity impacts the physical and mental health and well-being of Figure 2.1: Percent Land Base Actively Farmed families and individuals (Goal 3). For 40% further details on the impacts and costs to the healthcare system as well 35% as mental health outcomes related to food insecurity, refer to Appendix C. The 30% root cause of household food insecurity is often an issue of inadequate 25% income, especially given rising costs of housing, alongside limited supply of 20% affordable housing (Goal 11). Policies and programs focused on improving 15% household incomes (Goal 10) will assist in reducing food insecurity levels. 10% Finally, although the food insecurity 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 indicator used for this report does not Data level: Kelowna account for Indigenous Peoples on Source: City of Kelowna reserve communities, or reflect food GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 17
Figure 2.2: Household Food Insecurity security from an Indigenous perspec- tive, such data is available through 50% FNHA’s First Nations Regional Health 40% Survey.† Obtaining this data requires developing partnerships with local and 30% neighbouring Nations, which can in 20% turn help provide a community-wide approach towards evaluating and 10% monitoring food security in Kelowna. Appendix C includes a discussion on the 0% importance and value of Indigenous 2007-2008 2011-2012 2015-2016 2017-2018 Peoples’ traditional food and possible Data level: Kelowna CMA solutions to overcome barriers to access Source: PROOF (2014), PROOF (2017/2018) and Statistics Canada, Canadian Community Health Survey such foods in settler society (Canadian) Note 1: For the years 2007-2008 and 2011-2012, use with caution (coefficient of variation 16.6% to 33.3%). Note 2: People living in Aboriginal settlements and full-time members of the Canadian Forces are excluded from the survey. systems such as food banks. Goal 2 Interrelations † First Nations Health Authority About Us available at https://www.fnha.ca/Documents/FNoteNHA_AboutUS.pdf. Note: The FNHA is part of a unique health governance structure that includes political representation and advocacy through the First Nations Health Council, and technical support and capacity development through the First Nations Health Directors Association. The First Nations health governing structure works in partnership with BC First Nations to achieve a shared vision. GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 18
GOOD HEALTH AND WELL-BEING Local Community Indicators: • Chronic Diseases. Mortality rate attributed to cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and chronic lower respiratory diseases • Illicit Drugs. Illicit drug mortality rate per 100,000 population • Suicide Rates. Illicit suicide mortality rate per 100,000 population Goal 3 aims to ensure healthy lifestyles Mental Health CHALLENGES AND and well-being for everyone at all COMMUNITY PROGRESS ages through preventative measures • Illicit drug mortality rate per to avoid illness and disease, and 100,000 population Understanding these complexities, provide modern, efficient healthcare • Illicit suicide mortality rate per as well as lifestyles and preventative for everyone. Maintaining good health 100,00 population measures tied to socioeconomic and well-being must factor in both status, are important considerations physical and mental health — and PHYSICAL HEALTH when addressing chronic disease and from an Indigenous perspective, FNHA mortality rates, and in measuring well-being also includes healthy spirit, health and well-being throughout heart, mind and body. As the world KELOWNA TRENDS the community. The BC Centre for continues to face the COVID-19 global Disease Control will be releasing a health crisis, the need for whole mind Of the three chronic conditions finalized “Healthy Social Environments and body well-being is becoming illustrated in Figure 3.1 cardiovascular Framework” in early 2021, which more evident. For Kelowna, progress disease yields the highest mortality provides a health-based framework towards achieving good health and rate in both Kelowna and B.C. All three towards supporting socially well-being, especially in context of an diseases exhibit lower mortality rates connected and resilient communities. aging population, is measured by three in Kelowna as compared to rates in the Socioeconomic determinants influence physical and mental health indicators: Province. Attributing mortality rates chronic disease rates, including food to chronic conditions is complex and insecurity, limited access to health Physical Health challenging. For instance, diabetes services, reduced employment mortality rates, although the lowest opportunities (Goal 8), and lower • Mortality rate attributed to of the three chronic diseases, may be incomes (Goals 1 and 10). People who cardiovascular disease, diabetes, underreported as the main cause of suffer from household food insecurity and chronic lower respiratory death as complications can lead to have higher rates of chronic diseases, diseases cardiovascular and kidney disease. including heart disease, diabetes and cancer when compared to food secure/ Figure 3.1: Mortality Rate Attributed to Diabetes, Cardiovascular Diseases and higher income earners (see Goal 2 and Chronic Lower Respiratory Diseases Appendix C). The 2020 health crisis from COVID-19 has further highlighted 160 the gravity of socioeconomic inequities 155.5 Kelowna Province of B.C. 140 in relation to higher rates of chronic 120 137.6 disease, including higher risks of COVID-19 related complications 100 and mortality.23 Understanding and 80 analyzing demographic data to account for socioeconomic determinants and 60 inequities as they relate to chronic 40 disease is essential in determining 33.41 33.18 preventative measures, supporting 20 25.52 25.99 healthy lifestyles and managing modern 0 healthcare systems to enhance physical Diabetes Cardiovascular Diseases Chronic Lower Respiratory and mental health and well-being Diseases for all. More information about First Data level: Kelowna Source: Interior Health, Data to Support Sustainability Development Indicator Report for the City of Kelowna Nations social determinants and health Note: Due to low counts, the age standardized rates provided are for the aggregated time period of 2013-2017. can be found in the memorandum GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 19
of understanding (MOU): Tripartite KELOWNA TRENDS in Figure 3.3, suicides in the Central Partnership To Improve Mental Health Okanagan have remained relatively and Wellness Services and Achieve With the sharp increases in drug related consistent from 2013 to 2017, except Progress on the Determinants of Health overdose deaths (Figure 3.2) — most for an unexplained hike in 2016 (also and Wellness established by the First of which are linked to fentanyl (a toxic observed in illicit drug mortality rates, Nations Health Council, the Province of synthetic opioid) — an ongoing public Figure 3.2). British Columbia and the Government state of emergency has been declared of Canada, with First Nations Health by B.C.’s Provincial Health Officer since CHALLENGES AND Authority as a supporter.24 Although 2016. Additionally, between 2017-2020, COMMUNITY PROGRESS not analyzed in this report, it is more than 80% of illicit drug deaths in recommended that Kelowna review B.C. had fentanyl detected.26 Even more Acting on illicit drug mortality rates this MOU as a foundation to future concerning is the higher rate of illicit requires a greater understanding of health and wellness projects and drug mortality in Kelowna compared mental health and substance use programs. Finally, mortality indicators to the Province of B.C. This disparity disorders. Stigma and discrimination aren’t necessarily the most effective should be further investigated to from the general public as well as measure of wellness for communities in identify and improve understanding of amongst first responders, health Canada. Future reporting may wish to contributing factors. Since the COVID-19 care professionals and government include and evaluate other measures of pandemic began, data from BC Centre representatives create barriers, often wellness. for Disease Control and FNHA indicate preventing people who use drugs and/ B.C. has experienced yet another surge or who have substance use disorders MENTAL HEALTH in illicit drug deaths, due to increased from accessing the support and drug toxicity and more people using treatment they need.29 Many people Like chronic disease rates, poverty alone due to physical distancing and view drug use as a “choice”, believing it (Goal 1), and food insecurity (Goal 2) stay-at-home measures.27 28 is only used among people with flawed can also contribute to poor mental character and/or those who lack self- health outcomes. Studies show anxiety, In B.C., suicide continues to be one control, which is not only inaccurate, major depression and suicidal thoughts of the leading causes of death for but also extremely damaging. increase as food insecurity increases (as young people. Since 2013, for reasons Many Canadians use some form of shown in Figure C.1 in Appendix C). In unknown, the Central Okanagan psychoactive substances, including Canada, over 90% of people who took has had higher rates of suicide than prescription and nonprescription their own life were suffering from a the province. Investigation into this “drugs” and some end up suffering mental health problem or illness.25 difference is recommended. As shown from addiction due to reliance on them for treatment of chronic physical and/ or mental pain, loss of or uncertain Figure 3.2: Illicit Drug Mortality Rate per 100,000 Population employment, exposure to abuse and trauma, and other stressful events.30 50 Further, it has been found that in B.C., Central Okanagan Province of B.C. Indigenous Peoples suffer higher rates of drug addiction due to multiple 40 issues such as food insecurity (Goal 2), poverty (Goal 1), poor access to housing (Goal 11), and systemic racism, further 30 amplifying the stigmatization of drug use.31 32 A recent study in B.C. indicates negative stereotypes of Indigenous 20 Peoples are pervasive in the healthcare system; this racism negatively affects 10 an individual’s health and well-being and limits access to proper medical treatment: “all forms of racism 0 experienced by Indigenous Peoples 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 leads to avoidance of care in large Data level: Central Okanangan (Local Heath Area) part because Indigenous Peoples seek Source: BC Coroners Service to avoid being stereotyped, profiled, belittled and exposed to prejudice.”33 GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 20
Figure 3.3: Suicide Rate per 100,000 Population of specially trained police officer and a 25 mental health nurse to work together Central Okanagan Province of B.C. to apply non-violent de-escalation techniques to assist the person in 20 distress, while potentially reducing trauma experienced by the person in 15 crisis and the person responding to the crisis. 10 To effectively address the structural factors that give rise to illicit drug use 5 and suicide, programs and services aimed towards ending poverty (Goal 0 1), zero hunger (Goal 2), reducing 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 inequalities (Goal 10); and improving physical and mental health are a key Data level: Central Okanangan (Local Heath Area) Source: BC Coroners Service priority. Alongside such programs and services, greater attention needs As reducing illicit drug mortality • First Nations Health Authority is to be given the complexities and requires multifaceted solutions around implementing culturally relevant stigmatizations of illicit drug use and harm reduction, the community has programs such as land-based suicide. Stigma, discrimination and been creative in developing programs healing services. racism need to be addressed so those and less stigmatizing and more that require health care services are accessible means of dispensing harm Stigmatization also influences the provided supportive preventative reduction kits and safe supply, such as: complexities around emergency measures, and the respect and response to those in crisis. First treatment they deserve. The TRC • The creation of Kelowna responders such as police and Calls to Actions 18-24 focus on closing Community Action Team (CAT); a paramedics play a vital role in suicide the gap in health outcomes between knowledge hub, actively developing prevention — especially when Indigenous and non-Indigenous Peoples strategies for Kelowna and the responding to mental health calls in areas such as chronic diseases, surrounding region, to take action — but can also be at higher risk of suicide, and mental health. Continued on the overdose crisis. Kelowna suicide due to the exposure of trauma efforts amongst local, provincial and CAT is made up of people with experienced in their work. Kelowna’s federal governments, working with First lived and living experiences, Police and Crisis Team (PACT) seeks to Nations and CSOs on the collection, and representatives from law connect those in crisis with the services use of data, information and resources enforcement, health authorities, they need as well as reduce stigmas (including demographic information, local governments, Indigenous associated with both those in crisis and on gender, age, race, etc. that organizations and CSOs among those responding to the crisis. Formed respects privacy) will be critical to the others. in 2017, this partnership between IH development of successful policy and • Interior Health (IH) and numerous and Kelowna RCMP supports a team programs for Goal 3. CSOs throughout Kelowna, such as The Bridge and Urban Health Centre, are working to Goal 3 Interrelations distribute naloxone kits, which can quickly reverse the effects of an overdose from opioids (e.g. heroin, methadone, fentanyl and morphine). • Providing readily accessible and free vending machine delivery of harm reduction supplies. • For those with severe substance use disorder, an effective treatment option, injectable Opioid Agonist Treatment (iOAT), is being administered at an IH centre in downtown Kelowna. GLOBAL GOALS, LOCAL ACTION: KELOWNA’S VOLUNTARY LOCAL REVIEW 21
You can also read