Following Jesus into the climate crisis - INSIDE Global Mennonite enviro task force established, pg. 20 - Canadian Mennonite
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
July 20, 2020 Volume 24 Number 15 Following Jesus into the climate crisis Global Mennonite enviro task force established, pg. 20 INSIDE PM40063104 R09613 In a perfect storm 4 God’s paintbrush of diversity 15 COVID-19 outbreak in Bolivian colonies 25
2 Canadian Mennonite July 20, 2020 editorial A COVID-19 commandment By Virginia A . H o stetl er E xe cutiv e Ed ito r I t is now month five for Canadian communities struggling with the COVID-19 crisis. In this time, we’ve heard many shall love your neighbour as yourself ” (Mark 12:31, NRSV). He was harking back, of course, to an ancient teaching by the highest authority, “I am the Lord, and I command you to love others as believe, to choose what we wear. You have heard it said, “It’s my life and I will choose how I live it.” But, during this global health crisis, focusing on one’s own rights misses the point. pronouncements by health authorities much as you love yourself ” (Leviticus Jesus’ command is simple: “Love your on what members of the public should 19:18, Common English Version). neighbour as yourself.” In other words, and should not do to protect themselves Here’s a straightforward health order: wear a mask. against the novel coronavirus. As it You and I are commanded to love our spreads, health experts continue to neighbour. In this time of contagion, Looking ahead research and learn, experiment and practices such as washing one’s hands, The next issue of Canadian Mennonite make recommendations. As the weeks keeping physically distant and wearing will be digital only and will be dated stretch on, some instructions have a mask are ways people of conscience Aug. 3. Digital subscribers can expect changed; some of them have been express caring to those around them. it in their email inbox five days before downright confusing. I am grateful for those in my life who that date. If you are receiving only the Recently, Waterloo Region, where I heeded this commandment—for my print magazine but want to receive that live, instituted a community-wide order daughter, daughter- in-law and work issue and two more digital-only issues requiring residents to wear face cover- in 2020, you can sign up at ings in all indoor public places and in all public transportation areas. For some of ‘Love your neighbour as yourself.’ In other canadianmennonite.org /subscribe/digital or send an us, this will mean continuing with our email to office usual practice. But, for others, this is a words, wear a mask. @canadianmennonite.org. There is no new and constricting order. extra cost to current subscribers. Here’s how health experts explain the colleague who all showed love by giving benefit of wearing masks. Person A and me cloth masks. When I don one of Corrections Person B both wear simple protective those masks, that act of caring spreads • Gettysburg is located in Pennsylvania. masks over their noses and mouths. to everyone else nearby, neighbour and Incorrect information appeared in Outcome: both are shielded from stranger alike. “Disillusionment and hope,” June 22, droplets that spread the coronavirus. There are reasons why the wearing of page 11. If only Person A wears a mask, Person masks might be problematic. For some • A sentence in Timothy D. Epp’s B still has some protection. Health people, pre-existing breathing difficul- column, “A Black/Menno inventory, professionals tell us that—contrary to ties make mask-wearing impossible. For June 22, page 13, should have read, what one might think—the mask offers those with hearing loss, communication “Black Canadians were among the the highest protection for the person through an opaque mask is difficult. recipients of Anabaptist mission work at nearby, not for its wearer. By covering Cognitive and mental health challenges Sunnidale, Ont., and Winnipeg . . . .” her face, Person A is primarily shielding present an obstacle for some. But for the Also, the Vacation Bible School photo her neighbour. majority of Jesus’ followers today, wear- accompanying the story was taken in This kind of mask doesn’t appear in ing a mask is an order we can follow. Shiloh, Sask., north of the community of the Bible, and yet this concept seems so Some of us balk at following orders. Maidstone, and not in Manitoba. biblical. Consider what Jesus calls the A cloth over one’s nose and mouth can Canadian Mennonite regrets the second greatest commandment: “You get uncomfortable. Plus, it our right, we errors. l Printed in Canada Award-winning member ISSN 1480-042X
contents Canadian Mennonite Vol. 24 No. 15 3 July 20, 2020 / Vol. 24, No. 15 ABOUT THE COVER: In a perfect storm This plastic container of water was left in the forest at MCC 4 partner Sembrandopaz’s experimental farm just outside of ‘As communities moved Sincelejo, Colombia, to provide the birds and animals that call the into the era of physical forest home something to drink. To learn more about the new distancing, I had begun to global Mennonite environmental task force, see story on page 20. reread the Book of Job. As PHOTO: BY ANNALEE GIESBRECHT / MCC protests erupted on top of everything else, I was ‘Being the church together’ 16 struck by how relevant its MC Canada donates $50,000 to Global Sharing Fund to help meet basic dynamic remains,’ basic needs of sister churches in Mennonite World Conference writes Derek Suderman distressed by the COVID-19 pandemic. in the introduction to his feature. COVID-19 outbreak in Bolivian colonies 25 ‘Over the last weeks many people have died of COVID-19,’ including at least one bishop and two ministers, according to Kennert Regular features: Giesbrecht, editor of Die Mennonitische Post. For discussion 6 Readers write 7 Milestones 8 A moment from yesterday 9 ServiceLinks 36 Engaging with ‘people not like us’ 28 Online NOW! 38 Calendar 39 Classifieds 39 Alberta correspondent Joanne De Jong reports on a six-part Zoom series involving young people talking about engaging with ‘the other.’ I’m thinking about sparrows Rick Neufeld 9 A life dedicated to helping others 34 ‘Lining things up’ Ed Olfert 10 ‘Nour Ali’s name is known in households across Manitoba because of his passion for helping people and making the world a better Why I’m not a Canadian Randolph Haluza-DeLay 11 place,’ writes Manitoba correspondent Nicolien Klassen-Wiebe in her tribute to the former refugee who died in a boating accident on A living metaphor Joshua Penfold 12 June 13. 490 Dutton Drive, Unit C5, Waterloo, ON, N2L 6H7 Canadian Mennonite Staff Publisher, Tobi Thiessen, publisher@canadianmennonite.org Phone: 519-884-3810 Toll-free: 1-800-378-2524 Fax: 519-884-3331 Executive Editor, Virginia A. Hostetler, editor@canadianmennonite.org Website: canadianmennonite.org Managing Editor, Ross W. Muir, managinged@canadianmennonite.org Facebook.com/Canadian.Mennonite @CanMenno Online Media Manager, Aaron Epp, onlinemgr@canadianmennonite.org Editorial Assistant, Barb Draper, edassist@canadianmennonite.org Please send all material to be considered for publication to Interim Graphic Designer, Wendy Helgerman, designer@canadianmennonite.org General submission address: submit@canadianmennonite.org Circulation/Finance, Lisa Jacky, office@canadianmennonite.org Readers Write: letters@canadianmennonite.org Advertising Manager, D. Michael Hostetler, advert@canadianmennonite.org, Milestones announcements: milestones@canadianmennonite.org toll-free voice mail: 1-800-378-2524 ext. 224 Calendar announcements: calendar@canadianmennonite.org Senior Writer, Will Braun, seniorwriter@canadianmennonite.org publications mail agreement no. 40063104 registration no. 09613 B.C. Correspondent, Amy Rinner Waddell, bc@canadianmennonite.org return undeliverable items to: Canadian Mennonite, Alberta Correspondent, Joanne De Jong, ab@canadianmennonite.org 490 Dutton Drive, Unit C5, Waterloo, ON, N2L 6H7 Saskatchewan Correspondent, Donna Schulz, sk@canadianmennonite.org Manitoba Correspondent, Nicolien Klassen-Wiebe, mb@canadianmennonite.org Mission statement: To educate, inspire, inform, and foster dialogue on issues Eastern Canada Correspondent, Janet Bauman, ec@canadianmennonite.org facing Mennonites in Canada as it shares the good news of Jesus Christ from an Anabaptist perspective. We do this through an independent publication and One-Year Subscription Rates other media, working with our church partners. Canada: $46 + tax (depends on province where subscriber lives) U.S.: $68 International (outside U.S.): $91.10 Published by Canadian Mennonite Publishing Service. Regional churches and MC Canada appoint directors to the board and support 38 percent of Subscriptions/address changes Canadian Mennonite’s budget. (e-mail) office@canadianmennonite.org Board Chair, Henry Krause, hakrause@telus.net, 604-888-3192 (phone) 1-800-378-2524 ext. 221
4 Canadian Mennonite July 20, 2020 feature In a perfect storm By D erek Su d er man Special to Canadian Mennonite ‘Job’s Comforters,’ left, turn into his accusers in ‘Job Rebuked by his Friends,’ right. Both watercolour paintings were created by William Blake in 1805-06 for a series on the Book of Job commissioned by Thomas Butts. (Public Domain) Y ears ago, I saw a movie about a fishing crew Job’s protest caught at sea when two storms and a Job begins as a wealthy, well-respected, diligently hurricane converged to create a “perfect religious man. In wave after wave of suffering, he loses storm.” I have been reminded of this as possessions to marauders (economic collapse), all of his widespread protest after the death of yet children die (trauma), and finally he becomes sick another African-American man in the custody of white (disease). Job sits in anguish, and friends come in order police officers crashed into an already devastating to “comfort” him. novel-coronavirus pandemic and economic crisis. While Although this story is often depicted as a theodicy that the medical and economic crises seem unprecedented, puzzles over God’s link with suffering, the narrator and all racial injustice has brewed for centuries, and the of the characters, including Job himself, see some form of combination has been devastating. connection between God and suffering. The central The pandemic has raised age-old questions: question here does not appear to be, “Is God related to suffering?” but rather, “How should Job respond?” • Did humans bring COVID-19 on ourselves? From the beginning, speech is central. Even after • Where is God in all of it? enormous suffering, Job “does not charge God with wrongdoing” (1:22) and “does not sin with his lips” (2:10). And in the case of racism and policing, we now face Finally, Job emerges with a heart-wrenching speech, dueling perspectives: Appeals to “law and order” seek to wishing he had never been born—or even conceived! maintain the status quo, with some tinkering at the Startled, the friends go on the attack to defend God, edges, while voices of protest scream that profound citing traditional theology to explain his plight. Since change is needed. God is just, you must have done something wrong. As communities moved into the era of physical Perhaps God is teaching you a lesson. distancing, I had begun to reread the Book of Job. As But Job will have none of it. He voices his exaspera- protests erupted on top of everything else, I was struck tion—with his situation, his friends and his by how relevant its basic dynamic remains. God—becoming increasingly frustrated and angry. He
Canadian Mennonite Vol. 24 No. 15 5 even calls on God to show up and explain what’s going on. This debate rages for more than 30 chapters—trad- itional theology meets existential crisis. In our present moment, this debate sounds quite familiar. Is COVID-19 a form of divine punishment for sin? If not, why would a loving God allow it? Does this pandemic prove that God is not in control? After the killing of Floyd, what is an appropriate way to get people’s atten- tion? Are protest and anger disruptive, even sinful, especially during a pan- demic? Or are they okay, perhaps necessary? If Floyd’s killing is the spark that lit the flame, it’s clear there’s a lot of accumulated tinder all around. In this moment, whose voices—and lives—matter? Can lived experience legitimately challenge inherited tradition? Experiencing Job A while back, I taught a course on Job. I had a number of bright, young engi- ‘The Lord Answering Job Out of the Whirlwind,’ part of a series of paintings on the Book of neering and computer science students Job by William Blake, 1805-06, commissioned by Thomas Butts. (Public Domain) who were clear, structured thinkers. They read Job as an intellectual puzzle to be solved. What doctrine answers existential angst embodied beside them. being separate from it. this dilemma? How do we square God’s I spent a whole term encouraging For me, this has provided a helpful omnipotence and goodness with the students focused on correct, universal way to think about a hurricane or virus. presence of evil and suffering in the doctrine to also attend to lived experi- While insurance companies still speak world? ence—and their classmate!—but with of “acts of God,” natural disasters are In the same class, there was a mature little success. not signs of a punishment that God student who had been a high-flying micro-manages, on the one hand, or executive in a prestigious national Job and the ‘perfect storm’ evils that God fails to control, on the company. He was living the high life, of COVID-19 other, but rather they reflect the complete with horses in an equestrian Remarkably, God actually does respond wildness built into creation. stable and a yacht in Florida, before he to Job (chapters 38-41), although Job 38-41 provides a helpful antidote suffered a severe car accident resulting without giving Job an answer. While Job to a runaway human-centred perspec- in a brain injury. Having fallen off the thinks that the universe should be fair tive in which Christians have justified social ladder, he was reinventing and he demands an explanation for why environmental destruction by appealing himself, training to become a all of this happened to him, God to God’s command to “have dominion” social-support worker to help those in responds by moving from Job’s micro- (Genesis 1:26). Beyond the current need. Eager and engaged, he still had scopic focus to a broad-angle lens crises, this reorientation holds signifi- trouble articulating himself and would describing God’s care for all of creation. cant potential for re-thinking our role in often lose his train of thought. Perhaps most intriguing—and disturb- the ongoing climate emergency, placing As the course proceeded, it was like ing—the Behemoth appears as the “first ourselves within creation rather than living in a parable, with the class of the great acts of God” (40:19). above it. mirroring the dynamic of the book. I Biblical creation is often described as saw Job’s friends draw on traditional God bringing order out of chaos, but Did Job sin? views to explain his suffering, insisting this symbol of power reflects a wildness In our time, we should also reconsider on logical coherence and predictable bordering on chaos and destruction that how we understand the climax of Job’s consequences, largely oblivious to the forms part of God’s creation, instead of response to God: “Therefore I despise
6 Canadian Mennonite July 20, 2020 myself, and repent in dust and ashes” protesters clamour for change, I need to Job’s friends did, or focus on others’ (Job 42:6). In the King James Version, check an instinct to be defensive in individual sins while ignoring our own “despise” appears in italics, and the order to listen to experiences far complicity in structural ones. This is a word “myself ” is added in translation, removed from my own. moment for our perspectives to be although it is not present in the original In doing so, I should also recognize challenged and our minds changed. text. While many versions clarify this that systemic racism has long been It is not easy making sense of experi- ambiguity, the original phrase does not justified with the Bible I hold dear. Far ences that defy prevailing logic. But as actually specify what Job despises or from aberrations, slavery, the Doctrine the Bible repeatedly demonstrates, at rejects: Himself? His “case” against of Discovery, and Indian Residential times the explanatory power of a former God? His former perspective? Schools reflect our tradition’s historic perspective just doesn’t cut it in differ- Even more significant, the English complicity in structural sin. Rather than ent circumstances. We can recall the word “repent” suggests that Job admits defending Christianity, on one hand, or words of Jesus, who also suffered under wrongdoing. In a common reading, Job jettisoning it, on the other, to partici- systemic oppression: “Every scribe admits that he sinned by speaking up, pate in this living tradition means trained for the kingdom of heaven is like repents and then receives double what critiquing where it has gone astray and the master of a household who brings he lost—a nice tidy perspective that then seeking new understandings for out of his treasure what is new and what keeps intact the doctrine of retribution, moving forward. is old” (Matthew 13:52). with God as Santa Claus doling out Unlike Job, who enjoyed a privileged There is treasure to be found, but it rewards and punishments. social and economic status, in our day does take some digging . . . l However, the Hebrew word translated systemic marginalization has produced as “repent” here has multiple meanings. disproportionate negative effects on Derek Suderman is associate Remember how the friends came in those of lower economic means. While professor of religious studies order to “comfort” Job (Job 2:11)? This COVID-19 is not a judgment for sin, the and theological studies at is the same term. The same phrase as in structural sin of racism has amplified its Conrad Grebel University Job 42:6 also appears in Exodus 32:14, tragic effects. College and the University of when God concedes to Moses lobbying So let’s not get turned off by anger, as Waterloo, Ont. for the Israelites, and in Jonah 3:10, when God responds to the repentance of the Ninevites. In both cases God ΛΛFor discussion “relents” or “changes his mind” about punishing them. 1. During this coronavirus pandemic and economic crisis, what suffering have you seen So Job could be saying “I am com- in others and in yourself? Is this suffering catastrophic enough to be compared to Job’s? forted” or “I change my mind.” In fact, Why have concerns about racism and policing, which have been brewing for many years, since this term is never used in the erupted at this time? What fundamental changes is our society experiencing? sense of “repent” elsewhere in the book, this seems the least likely translation. 2. Derek Suderman says that the pandemic has raised age-old questions. Do you sometimes Far from condemning Job’s words, wonder whether God has a purpose in bringing COVID-19? Does it make you question God chastises the friends: “For you have God’s omnipotence or goodness? How does God respond to Job’s questions in the end? not spoken of me rightly as my servant Job has” (42:7-8). In the end, it wasn’t 3. Natural disasters “are not signs of punishment,” writes Suderman. They are not “evils the systematic theologians trying to that God fails to control,” rather, “they reflect the wildness built into creation.” Do you defend God who were in the right, but agree? What other questions arise from this explanation? the one who got frustrated and angry. While Job’s friends collapsed God into 4. Suderman concludes that “[t]he sin did not lie in Job’s lament after all, but in his friends’ their conception of the divine, only Job certainty about their erroneous positions!” What are the limits of systematic theology? spoke to, and sought a relationship with, Why does uncertainty make us feel uneasy? God. The sin did not lie in Job’s lament after all, but in his friends’ certainty 5. What injustices has the pandemic exposed in Canada? What are some steps we can about their erroneous positions! take to expand justice for all? Among the friends —By B arb D r ap er At present, I feel like one of Job’s friends. A Bible scholar passionate S ee related God and Suffering resources at about the church, I am deeply invested www.commonword.ca/go/1569 in the received tradition. But as
Canadian Mennonite Vol. 24 No. 15 7 opinion ΛΛReaders write terms.” This letter reinforces the underlying racism and disdain for Indigenous people in our society. Instead of LL Today’s society is a progression of propping up those who are part of the problem, how Canada’s colonial past about silencing them? How about not giving them a platform or giving their ideas passive approval? Re: “ ‘Decolonize’ and ‘settler’ meaningless terms” If CM wishes to positively contribute to tearing down letter, June 8, 2020, page 8. the idea of white supremacy, perhaps a good place to It is a nice idea that “our great-grandfathers and look first is within CM itself. You actually have the great-grandmothers . . . through industry and innova- power to take away the voices of those who contribute tion, built our advanced, civil, 21st-century society to the oppression of people. Why are you not using it? with its advanced parliamentary government, social Bev Hunsberger (online comment) system and compassionate health-care system.” By listening to the voices of Black, Indigenous and People of Colour (BIPOC), I am learning that the LL Mennonites should actively support history of Canada is much messier and more painful good cops than that. This supposedly upstanding and clear- eyed “industry and innovation” was only made Bad cops and racism are important topics, but we possible by the horrible use of the bodies of non- must also take a positive approach. I think most white people, resulting in their cultures being policing in Canada is good. decimated, to say the least. A quick look into the We should join the efforts to maintain it and make history and labour behind the Canadian Pacific it better. Dismantling police forces certainly isn’t a Railway is just one place to find terrible mistreat- realistic option. What we’re really looking for are ment in the name of “industry and innovation.” improvements, such as better screening of people Why do we have to be aware of this today, when who apply to become cops, quicker firings of those this kind of extreme mistreatment is in the past? who prove bad at it, and the elimination of poor Why do we have to understand the words “settler” techniques that might include neck-holds. and “decolonize”? It’s because the way our society is Mennonites should be involved, not simply joining organized today is a progression of the past, as it was the critics and working for alternatives to policing. We intended to be. It is strongly centred on whiteness. must also express our support for quality policing. We Think of our historical heroes, names of streets, want and need it as much as everyone else. However, representation in movies. Just try to find a bandage many Mennonites are shy about such things. We to match your skin colour if you are not white. admire good policing, but it’s never been worked into Decolonizing means becoming aware of how our theology. Overall, we’re much too silent. strongly our current “civil society” revolves around In addition, we should be encouraging and praising the experience of white people and marginalizes those among us who want to be in this profession. everyone else. It means listening to the BIPOC Peaceful people make good cops, and we should strive voices when they say they are not thriving, and then as a people to do our fair share of the world’s dirty actually believing what they say. work. But Menno cops may face social ostracism. Serena Erb, Str atford , O nt. How backward. We love that the world is made safer by police and that 911 will bring them to our aid, yet some people seem to think it’s a sin for a Mennonite LL Silence those who are problemmatic to be one. How contradictory. If there aren’t enough good cops, part of the blame lies at our own feet. Re: “What lingers in the air,” June 8, 2020, page 2. I suggest that we have many deep discussions As the executive editor of Canadian Mennonite, about crime issues, and not avoid them. I suggest we Virginia A. Hostetler has the opportunity to actually become very honest about our desires for good affect change and yet she does not. Part of the policing and a stable society. It’s very good to side dominant white culture oppressing people of colour with victims of racism and police abuses, and to be is the idea that we all have the right to express our voices for change in such things, but we must also be opinion—or freedom of speech—even if it reinforces active and vocal about good police forces. white supremacy. Howard B oldt, O sler , Sa sk . There was a letter published in print (June 8, page 8) from an online comment that is still prominently featured in the online Readers Write section called “‘Decolonize’ and ‘settler’ meaningless, pejorative
8 Canadian Mennonite July 20, 2020 LL What does Atonement have to do ΛΛMilestones with homelessness? Births/Adoptions Re: “Pastor praised, criticized for open letter to governments” letters, May 25, page 8. Andres—Morgan Hostetler (b. May 30, 2020), to Angie I did not understand that David Driedger was Hostetler and Ryan Andres, First Mennonite, Edmonton. advocating “an imposed, enforced governmental Bartel—Twins Georgia Grey and Rusty Walter (b. April 30, action,” as Walter Bergen wrote. Driedger was 2020), to Calvin and Leah Bartel, North Star Mennonite, supporting a petition that asks the government to Drake, Sask. consider legislation that would provide a fair living Graham—Dominic Ian Benjamin (b. May 26, 2020), to David wage for everyone. Graham and Lise McMillan, Grace Mennonite, Steinbach, The parable in Matthew 20:1-16 is about labourers Man. in a vineyard who were hired at different hours of Kim—Loa (b. June 17, 2020), to Jinah Im and Pablo Kim, the day, but it starts with: “For the kingdom of heaven Toronto United Mennonite Church. is like the landowner who went out early . . . .” The Morasch—Audrey Maeve (b. June 18, 2020), to Maegen and workers all received a fair living wage, but the ones Paul Morasch, First Mennonite, Edmonton. who were hired in the morning, did not like it. Why? Schellenberg—Arlo Everett Friesen (b. April 14, 2020), to Bergen also writes, “If the Christ of the gospels is Terry Schellenberg and Lenore Friesen, Sterling Mennonite, to be believed, then the levelling comes not through Winnipeg. an imposed, enforced governmental action, but by the Atonement of Jesus Christ.” In whatever way Baptisms Atonement might be understood, does it materially change the condition of a jobless, homeless person? Jessica Vikse—Rosthern Mennonite, Sask., at the church, Peter H . Peter s, Winnipeg June 14, 2020. Kate Hanson, Tianna Bartsch—Rosthern Mennonite, Sask., at Christopher Lake, June 14, 2020. LL ‘By virtue of the absurd’ Marriages Re: “Embrace the paradox,” May 25, page 13. I actually had a very similar experience with Epp/Podaima—Rebecca Epp (Douglas Mennonite, Winni- Danish philosopher Soren Kierkegaard as Troy peg) and Evan Podaima, at Douglas Mennonite, June 6, 2020. Watson had. Kierkegaard’s work also helped to make sense of Christianity for me. His depiction of the Deaths Christian paradox is obviously central to this making sense, “by virtue of the absurd.” I’ve also been Bartel—Leonhard, 86 (b. Sept. 10, 1933; d. May 22, 2020), inspired by his explanation of sin as despair. It helps Greendale River of Life, Chilliwack, B.C. to clarify that, while there are many kinds of sins we Harder—Hella, 93 (b. Oct. 6, 1926; d. May 31, 2020), First may or may not agree on as sins, we can all agree Mennonite, Edmonton. that, one way or another, the state of sin originates in Klassen—Johanna (nee Friesen), 100 (b. April 29, 1919; d. a lack of faith, and take it from there. March 30, 2020), Wildwood Mennonite, Saskatoon. Paul Redekop, Winnipeg Mathies—Helen, 100 (b. March 6, 1920; d. June 11, 2020), Vineland United Mennonite, Ont. Rosenberger—Velma, 86 (b. Aug. 23, 1933; d. June 26, 2020), North Star Mennonite, Drake, Sask. (formerly of Sharon Men- nonite, Guernsey, Sask.). Zehr—Elaine (Bender), 87 (b. March 28, 1933; d. May 22, We welcome your comments and publish most letters from 2020), Emmanuel Mennonite, Abbotsford, B.C. subscribers. Letters, to be kept to 300 words or less, are the opinion of the writer only and are not to be taken as endorsed by this magazine or the church. Please address issues rather than individuals; personal attacks will not Canadian Mennonite welcomes Milestones announce- appear in print or online. All letters are edited for length, ments within four months of the event. Please send style and adherence to editorial guidelines. Send them to Milestones announcements by e-mail to milestones@ letters@canadianmennonite.org and include the author’s canadianmennonite.org, including the congregation name contact information and mailing address. Preference is and location. When sending death notices, please also given to letters from MC Canada congregants. include birth date and last name at birth if available.
Canadian Mennonite Vol. 24 No. 15 9 From Our Leaders I’m thinking about sparrows R i ck N eu fel d “So do not be afraid. You are of more value than many sparrows” (Matthew 10:31). I am thinking about sparrows today, about how many of them there are, and yet how little I notice them until am wondering who the “you” is of whom Jesus speaks in this passage. Is it you? Is it me? I have always thought so, at the drive-through last week. • All the nameless, faceless ones who harvest and butcher and pack the food they stop for a quick perch on the or at least I have always rested in this that lines my shelves and fills my freezer. railing of my deck and I find myself powerful promise that God’s eye is on wishing that they were some other us, as God loves us with an amazing I also think of so very many people of variety of backyard bird, perhaps love that knows us so well that God has colour whose stories have been over- something with just a little more the very hairs on our heads numbered. looked or downright ignored—to their colour—like a wren or a goldfinch or an Today I am taken also to the many very peril—by those of us in the oriole. Even a chickadee or a nuthatch others. All those others I too often do dominant culture. Today, I think about will do. Dull in colour, yes, and lighter not pause to notice. Not unlike spar- these “sparrows,” at least in terms of than air itself, these sparrows seem to rows, in a way. how much more God loves them. be. We have called them “essential Indeed, all so deeply loved by God in I am thinking about sparrows and workers” of late and, yes, those include spite of the fact that we who walk how I have learned that, if you look doctors and nurses and health-care alongside often do not see or really hear closely, they really don’t all look alike, workers, of course. I cannot help but them at all. although the differences are subtle and believe that in an especially powerful Especially today, I am wondering even invisible to one who has never and particular way God’s heart is with: what God’s call is for me and for us in taken the time to actually pay attention. all of this. l I am thinking about sparrows today • The young woman who, behind a and I am hearing Jesus’ promise that plexiglass screen, checked me out at the Rick Neufeld is Mennonite those who follow him into the struggle grocery store the other day. Church Manitoba’s director of life are of more value than many of • The health-care aide who has no of leadership ministries, and them and that all the while God has choice but to go to work to feed her interim executive minister God’s eye on the sparrow, even as God family. until the end of this year. has God’s eye on all of us. • The middle-aged woman with a I am thinking of sparrows today and I heavy accent who handed me my order A moment from yesterday Public school teachers Samuel B. Nafziger, Dick Neufeld, Sara (Lehn) Harder, Martin Goerzen, Grace Harder, John C. Harder and C. Boldt, are pictured in the most northerly Mennonite farm community in the world, at Fort Vermilion, Alta,. in 1958. Their presence was controversial, as some Old Colony Mennonite settlers resisted the development of public schools, fearing their “worldly” effect on children. To build trust, the superintendent recruited Mennonite teachers from the more modern Mennonite Church. Young teacher Sara Lehn won over the bishop’s wife by conversing with her in Low German; the wife then introduced Sara to her husband as “one of our kind.” The schools also included Indigenous and Métis students. Text: Laureen Harder-Gissing, with reference to Dawn S. Boden’s “Resistance, acquiescence and accommodation,” Mennonite Quarterly Review, 2010. Photo: The Canadian Mennonite / Mennonite Archives of Ontario archives.mhsc.ca
10 Canadian Mennonite July 20, 2020 In the Image would be quite believable if one hadn’t observed her earlier confrontation with ‘Lining things up’ a younger cousin regarding his most recent hockey hero, her laughter as she turns to hear big Mike’s latest outra- By Ed O l fer t geous quote, her passion as she leans her confident alto into a favourite hymn. A recent article in Canadian Menno- nite included a story of the closing of Superb Mennonite Church (“Superb for that wedding he is to usher. Today, The pastoral prayer begins. The Holly frets as she looks down at the ugly Olferts sit quietly, heads bowed. Jeb has sneakers from Zellers. the advantage; his slouch passes helped me continue to have faith,” June Next to Holly sits Jen. Jen is wearing a reasonably well as a prayer posture. 22, page 20). Superb was my home. I little sun dress. It doesn’t matter if it’s 40 The prayer goes on. And on. Some- was dedicated, married, baptized and below or 40 above, Jen is wearing a where, a child is born and learns to raised a family there. dress that is only “this” long. Now, Jen is walk. Somewhere, a war starts, UN It is the late 1980s, and the Holly and cold. She is slipping her hands between negotiators arrive and truce is bar- Ed Olfert family are in their bench, fully her dad’s, moaning, “I’m so cold.” gained. The economies of small engaged in Sunday morning worship. Wearing this dress has little to do countries grow, then ebb away, while the They sit five strong, filling a pew. At with it, 40 below or 40 above has little to prayer continues. the aisle end is Jeb, the youngest, tall, do with it. There is simply no blood in Jeb has not moved, but will later make long-legged. He is leaning forward with Jen’s body; if she was wearing a snow- a mild observation about watching the his elbows on his knees, looking totally mobile suit, Jen would be slipping icy entire lifecycle of an insect on the floor bored, looking like his mind is miles fingers into Dad’s hands and moaning, between his Zellers sneakers. away. However, history has shown that “I’m so cold.” Holly still frets, but now how to clear Jeb is fully aware of the community that Then there is Ed, struggling with her house of smoke from a burnt roast. surrounds him, aware of things said, weighty spiritual matters. “How will the Ed remains enveloped in his spiritual sensitive to feelings, at peace with it all. farm chemical bill get paid?” “Why do moment until lips brush against one ear Beside Jeb sits his mother, Holly. those pistons in the free air Skidoo keep and he hears, “Dad, that’s not a prayer, Holly is a little stressed today. Some melting?” Ed, with the attention span of that’s another sermon!” weeks ago Jeb went shopping with his a gnat, keeps closing one eye while the Then, from the other side, more dad and came home proudly sporting a other lines up the second pew with the gently, into his deaf ear, but he knows, pair of canvas sneakers from Zellers for first, the top of the pulpit with the “Dad, you’re lining things up again!” l only $4, perfect canoe shoes for that window shade, the hymn book with the upcoming school excursion. But this Duo-Tang behind it. Ed is getting the Ed Olfert (p2pheo morning Jeb appeared from his elbow and being accused of “lining @sasktel.net) is grateful bedroom dressed in those sneakers. things up.” for the Superb community Holly offered a comment regarding their By the wall sits Kira, the eldest of the that loved his family. beauty, and Jeb spontaneously decided three. The dark cloud on her forehead that they would become his full-time announces that she doesn’t want to be Sunday shoes and also perfect footwear here; she is too tired, too bored. That Et cetera WCC releases online COVID-19 pandemic publication The World Council of Churches (WCC) has released an online publication, “Health and hope: The church in mission and unity,” a collection of previously published articles that resonate with the worldwide struggle amid the COVID-19 pandemic. The collection, published by Wiley, is a combined edition of The Ecumenical Review and International Review of Mission, and marks only the second time in history that such a combined edition has been produced. The historical perspective also lends a new air of appreciation to current efforts to care for each other, efforts that have erased the boundaries between faith groups and nations. The publication is available at bit.ly/wcc-health-hope. Source: World Council of Churches
Canadian Mennonite Vol. 24 No. 15 11 Mind and Soul Why I’m not a Canadian R an d o l p h Halu z a-D eL ay I am an immigrant. After serving with Mennonite Central Committee in Canada, I chose to stay in this amazing “A modest proposal for peace”: That the Christians of the world agree not to take up arms against one another. and Ireland and Iraq and El Salvador and . . .” on they went. Our religious faith gives us visions for country. The Canadian way was closer Ponder history: Irish Catholic vs. Irish society. This is the definition of “political to the “thousand points of light” to Protestant. German Lutheran against theology”: “explicit ideas that religious which one of the leaders of my left-be- American Lutheran. Rwandan Catholic communities hold about authority and hind country called his own people. (I’ll vs. Rwandan Catholic. What would be justice, and how to enact those ideas.” leave you to guess what country.) different if Christians did not take up Our faith is automatically political. It Canada Day has just passed as I write arms against each other or, in defence of demands we think about Indigenous this. Normally my neighbourhood is a the nation, against fellow brothers and peoples; about poverty, the poor and gigantic party with a rich tapestry of the sisters? what causes poverty; about caring for the many cultures that have chosen to come Clearly in that last example not only creation and the effects of fossil-fuel use; to Canada. The joy is more than just national loyalties can take the place of and whether policing is the best vehicle food and fireworks. But 29 years here the lordship of Christ. Tribal allegiances for social health and safety. and I am still not a Canadian citizen. claimed first place in Rwanda. Therein is There are a few things a nation-state The obstacle for me is to be exclusive- the issue—anything that tries to seize does and needs to do. It serves a ly committed to the one Lord that first place in our devotion should be coordinating function. It navigates the transcends national boundaries. To be a anathema (which by definition is a system of other nation-states. The citizen means to declare (avow, accept) formal denunciation or vehement pandemic response is a clear example of allegiance to a nation-state. The nation dislike). the roles of different levels of govern- is an entity that seeks to capture our Support for the military is rarely a ment, especially the national. loyalties and identities. As a Christian, question for Christians in my former And we all have to travel on some I do not think anything should replace country. Every leader must announce nation’s passport. Crossing borders with allegiance to the Alpha and Omega. that God blesses the country. When my my former country’s documents gets Let me be clear. I strongly identify as kids were little, a relative sent a CD of increasingly troublesome. I may a Canadian. I am very committed to this “patriotic songs” to them. A stunning someday become a Canadian citizen country, involved in all areas of advo- number of these songs were explicitly after all. l cacy and politics (except for voting). religious. It is a very fond memory to I pay my taxes in full and gladly receive recall those kids singing along—and Randolph Haluza-DeLay the services. Nevertheless, since the replacing the actual country in the song attends First Mennonite earliest days of my Christian journey, with any other country they could Church in Edmonton. I have carried a postcard that presents remember: “God bless . . . and Canada Et cetera MCC distributes school kits in Cambodia Nearly 48,000 Mennonite Central Committee (MCC) school kits arrived in May 1983 and were stored for dis- tribution during the 1983-84 school year. Along with the kits, some 170,000 notebooks were supplied, plus a small amount of corrugated roofing for village schools. Source (text and photo): MCC
12 Canadian Mennonite July 20, 2020 Tales From the Unending Story others would prefer not to relate to. Although having all power and prestige, A living metaphor Jesus decided to hang out with the lowest of the low. Emmanuel entered into a subjugated nation, a people living J o sh u a Penfo l d under the rule of almighty Rome. Jesus lowered himself further by I t’s outlandish really, what God asks Hosea to do. To think that someone known for his holiness and intimate relationship with the divine would take up residence with a woman everyone full-blown tantrum, with a barrage of booming expletives for all to hear. I’m realizing just how humbling this associating with those the leaders and rulers of that subjugated nation wouldn’t dare be seen with. He des- experience is for me, especially my ego. cended the status ladder so far as to This is not how I roll in my life, and in associate with shepherds, fishermen, knew was promiscuous. these situations I find myself worrying lepers, and “sinners” of all kinds. It would have been one thing if God about how we are being perceived, Amazingly, not only did Jesus not had sent Hosea to Gomer to pass on a specifically how I am being perceived. seem to mind it, he embraced it, invited message, although even that would have No one knows the context of why it and turned the world upside down, looked bad, someone like him meeting Andrea and I are together, and I wonder telling everyone to look to these with someone like her. But no, what if everyone is silently labelling us and embarrassing riffraff as a living meta- God requested of Hosea was far more judging us together. phor of the Kingdom of God. unthinkable and humiliating: a call If I’m honest, I realize that, if I was a Reading Hosea, thinking of Jesus and designed to fail. Hosea, the prophet of bystander, I would likely think that way reflecting on my own work, I realize just God, was to marry Gomer, the harlot, too. I am aware that my association with how concerned I still am about my own just so she could cheat on him and be a Andrea affects how the people who image, my own ego, my own status, and living metaphor of Israel’s unfaithful- witness us perceive me, and it’s rarely in what others think of me. Once again, ness. a positive light. I’m amazed by Jesus’ love for all human- I am a personal-support worker for Is this how Hosea felt? Did life with ity, with no regard to himself. Oh that someone who is so far from my lifestyle Gomer change his social status? Did my life might be less concerned about and circles of contact that our lives Hosea worry that he would be wrongly my own image and, instead, become a would never have intersected in regular perceived? Did he worry about his living metaphor of God’s outlandish and life. Andrea (a pseudonym) struggles image? Did Gomer’s lifestyle force him selfless love for all. l with various diagnoses and addictions, to interact with people and parts of and is an incredibly challenging person town that he didn’t know existed and Joshua Penfold to support. She is not someone I would didn’t want to be caught dead in? Did (penfoldjoshua@gmail normally want to be associated with. Hosea worry that his entire calling as a .com) is a member of We have had multiple occasions in prophet would be washed away in this Tavistock (Ont.) different public settings where Andrea union, and that his reputation would Mennonite Church. will become enraged when she pushes dissolve to nothing? the established boundaries and I won’t Then I think of someone else who bend to her wishes. She will unleash a intentionally associated with people Et cetera Discrepancies in COVID-19 death rates Long-term care homes in Ontario that are owned by for-profit corporations have had a higher COVID-19 death rate than non-profit homes or those owned by a municipality, reported the Ontario Health Coalition on May 6. The study looked at 700 for-profit, 275 non-profit and 82 municipal homes. The rates of death of homes with COVID-19 outbreaks were: • 9 percent in for-profit homes • 5.25 percent in non-profit homes • 3.62 percent in public (municipal) homes Source: OntarioHealthCoalition.ca
Canadian Mennonite Vol. 24 No. 15 13 Viewpoint tolerance in the sense of indifference, but a real interest in the other, and an Receptive ecumenism honest, common search for biblical wisdom and theological reflection that meets the reported challenges. Students start to ask each other: How Becoming vulnerable to the other do you do that in your community? On what grounds? Why can’t I do that/ Fer nan d o Enns believe that in my own church? Or can I? Now the classroom becomes a real T here is a moment when everything changes among the students who take the Mission and Ecumenism course at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, to cherish what they have learned ecumenical space, an image of the “one from their belief systems and household of God” in all its diversity. We personal experiences with church. have become believers who seek to Becoming receptive strengthen each other in faith by sharing doubts in the presence of the other. Can the Netherlands, where I teach. The Then comes a moment when everything we receive together that which is of God? student composition of this compulsory changes. course is quite diverse; the majority This usually happens when I intro- Receiving the gifts represent shades from the Reformed duce the concept of “receptive For me, it is always a miracle how the tradition: some (mostly young men) ecumenism.” Instead of asking, What do spirit changes, how gently the students who consider themselves as “conserva- other traditions need to learn from behave toward each other, how cautious tive” or biblicist; some (mostly women) mine? the leading question is, What are they are in pointing to the strengths of are “liberals.” There are Baptists (“evan- the weaknesses that I experience in my the other’s tradition. gelical”), Mennonites (considered the own community? and, Are there “gifts” Having been involved in official most liberal), Pentecostals and students in other traditions that could help me to ecumenical dialogues and institutions without a clear religious affiliation. overcome these weaknesses? over decades, I realize that becoming Most of the students are rather Paul Murray, who has developed this receptive to the other is quite different sceptical about ecumenism. Some do approach at the Durham Centre for from trying to convince others why my not believe there is any need to reflect Catholic Studies, says the assumption is way is not only legitimate, but superior. on their relation to other Christians. that “if all were asking this question Unless I make myself vulnerable to the Others believe that inter-Christian seriously and acting upon it, then all other—trusting that they will not relations are irrelevant in the context of would be moving in ways which would destroy my faith but become a compan- multi-religious encounters and extreme both deepen our authentic respective ion in growing it—I will not be able to secularism. identities and draw us into more receive the gifts of a global church that intimate relationships.” celebrates its reconciled diversity as a Laying the foundation Of course, there is some reluctance in blessing from God. During the first sessions of the course, the beginning. The students split up into Besides, isn’t this approach exactly the my Reformed colleague, Heleen groups of three or four, composed of wisdom of the peace church, which Zorgdrager, and I lead the students to different backgrounds. This provides a teaches nonviolence as yet another study biblical texts on the unity of the safe space to share problems, difficul- essential mark of the Church of Christ? church, like John 17 or Ephesians 4. ties, challenges—even pain—they Being nonviolent to another opinion, As we reflect on ecclesiology (the experience in their own community. culture, mentality, tradition makes my nature of the church), we discover that own faith vulnerable. As we know from “being one” is an essential mark of the Sharing vulnerably our own history, this takes a lot of church in every tradition. When they return to the larger group, courage and deep trust in God’s guiding We also learn about the history of the everything feels different. Students now Spirit. ecumenical movement. report, sometimes with tears in their I am proud of my students for their Up to this point, most students prefer eyes, the experiences they never thought confidence! And I learn a lot from them. to stay in their comfort zone. They have they could share with anyone, let alone l learned to “tolerate” others, but I sense someone outside their own circles. they hold stereotypes about each other The other students listen in a very Originally published in the April 2020 (and their Mennonite professor). sensitive way. All the arrogance and issue of Courier/Correo/Courrier. None of them really question what ignorance from earlier sessions is gone. Reprinted by permission of the author they have believed so far. And I encour- Now they relate to each other, and Mennonite World Conference. age them to present their own identity, gradually building trust. It is no longer
14 Canadian Mennonite July 20, 2020 Personal Reflection I am my brother’s keeper Ar t Sh eil Many years ago now—I’m getting a to a fundamental social contract. That way,” often equated with rugged individ- bit long in the tooth—I took what I contract involved acknowledging what ualism, and by no means limited to the thought would be a bird course in my I would forgo for your benefit and what United States. Besides the fact that “new second year at what was then known as you would forgo for my benefit, in order normal” is an oxymoron, the energy Waterloo College. It turned out to be for us to live together in community. He seems to be all directed at how quickly anything but, and I remember more also claimed that every civilization be- we can get back to the way things were. from that course than from any other in gan its decline when that social contract Jesus sent his disciples out to an- my seven years of university education. weakened in the face of the rise of indi- nounce a new kingdom, a kingdom It was a course on political philosophy. vidualism. The dominant philosophy is based on his way. That kingdom is The response to “shelter at home” played out for us all over the world in not a place. It is an experience: your brought on by the COVOD-19 pan- the simple refusal to wear a mask, for experience when others put you ahead demic brings back one of the key the benefit of others, when you insights we discussed in that course. go shopping. The response I refer to involves scenes Maybe it’s a preacher’s lia- of crowded beaches, the absence of bility, but I cannot keep from masks, the rush to fill the bars minutes contrasting this “way” of man- after they opened, and, most significant- aging our life with the words of ly, the protest marches demanding that Jesus: “I am the way, the truth, the country be opened so we can get and the Life” (John 14:6). The back to the “American way.” way of Jesus sounds very much However, I do not want to be seen as like embracing a social con- simply an American basher. The “way” tract. He is called “the Man for referred to is the same in every corner others.” Early Christians were of the civilized world. It focuses square- known by how they loved one ly on individual rights and freedoms. It another. “If meat will cause my PIXABAY PHOTO BY CANICEUS leads churches to defy directives from brother to offend, I will eat no political and health professionals, and meat,” the Apostle Paul wrote The way of Jesus sounds vast crowds to fill the streets demanding in I Corinthians 8:13. “If my very much like embracing a what they see as their right. not wearing a mask may en- In the course I took in 1960, we were danger my brother, I will wear social contract. He is called asked to read and discuss Walter a mask,” he might have written ‘the Man for others.’ Early Lippmann’s book The Public Philosophy, today. published in 1955. The author analysed The “deep disorder in our so- Christians were known by the writings of the leading journalists of ciety” that Lippmann identified how they loved one another. the day and claimed that what drove has been attested to in various their thinking was simply a reflection of ways since he wrote about it the dominant philosophy in our society. 75 years ago. You can fill library shelves of themselves, and for others when we He concluded that “there is a deep with books about the “Me generation.” put them ahead of ourselves. It may be disorder in our society.” That disorder, I worked for many years with youth as simple as stepping out of the aisle so he claimed, was not the result of any who were frequently the negative result another person can pass a safe distance outside pressure but was generated of the “it’s all about me” parenting de- away or wearing a mask when such entirely from within ourselves. bacle. Sadly, the Christian church, and distance is not possible. He came to that conclusion after we its members, from time to time have Then we begin to heal the deep dis- studying the rise and fall of civilizations also been seduced by the appeal to look order in our society and bring in God’s as far back as recorded history and out for No. 1. Kingdom. l archaeological studies could take him. We hear a lot right now about some- What he claimed to find was that every thing called the “new normal.” We also Art Sheil is a co-pastor of Nairn civilization rose when citizens bought in hear a call to return to the “American Mennonite Church, Ailsa Craig, Ont.
Canadian Mennonite Vol. 24 No. 15 15 Viewpoint God’s paintbrush of diversity G l en Guy to n Mennonite World Conference I t does not happen often, but I am at a loss for words as cities across the United States burn, and as I have endured several weeks of seeing Black bodies sacrificed in the name of order the globe. Missionaries have come from North America and Europe, wrapping God in the cloak of whiteness. But, as Anabaptists, we must insist that and discipline. I am torn between being we are all created in God’s an enraged Black man and being a image. The Spirit connects us leader in a predominantly white all and we should treasure the institution whose members are united brush of diversity that God uses by theology and, for many, a common to paint humankind. ancestry. Along with thoughts and The most recent names that have prayers, we need action. We shredded my heart are George Floyd, need to be unified around who Breonna Taylor and Ahmaud Arbery. we are as a global body of I watched in horror as a woman peacemakers. I have challenged named Amy Cooper who, walking her the church in the United States unleashed dog, attempted to weaponize to reflect on the following: the police against Christian Cooper (no relation), who simply wanted to peace- • How will you join God’s fully watch birds in Central Park in New peace at work in your commu- York City. nity or nation? Christian Cooper, like me, is an • Are there people or organi- African-American man. The language zations in your communities who UNSPLASH PHOTO BY SHRAGA KOPSTEIN used on the white woman’s call to police demonstrate what peace looks means that any Black male—me or my like? son—could have fit the description, giving the responding officers a licence to kill with the qualified immunity that Missionaries have come from North America withholds justice. and Europe, wrapping God in the cloak of Systems of racial power would like nothing better than for leaders like me whiteness. But, as Anabaptists, we must insist to lay my Blackness and pain aside; that we are all created in God’s image. however, they are part of what shapes my identity. As a leader, I am called to push down • Where have you found God’s peace oppression anywhere we see them. The my fear and sadness. I need to call upon in the work that you’re doing? violence and unrest that is happening the people of Mennonite Church U.S.A. • What are some things you can do to now in the United States is not an I also call on my Anabaptist family from actively be a conduit for transformative accident; it is what the system is around the world to speak out against peacemaking? designed to do, and it jeopardizes all of racial injustice at home and abroad. us. l We must reject cultures that demon- People from around the world have ize dark skin. We must reject cultures reached out to me, asking how they can Glen Guyton is the that cause some to whiten their skin help. Let us stand for justice. Together, executive director of because that is somehow perceived as we can make a difference. We need to Mennonite Church U.S.A. better. engage in more costly peacemaking, Our Anabaptist churches need to rooted in radical discipleship, which speak to the growing injustice around seeks to dismantle systems of
You can also read