DESIGN BRIEF 2020-21 LOBITOS AND PIEDRITAS, PERU - Produced in Partnership by Engineers Without Borders South Africa, UK and USA - Engineers ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
DESIGN BRIEF 2020-21 LOBITOS AND PIEDRITAS, PERU Produced in Partnership by Engineers Without Borders South Africa, UK and USA In collaboration with EcoSwell
This initiative has been delivered in the UK and Ireland since 2011. It is based on a concept developed originally by Engineers Without Borders Australia. This document has been produced by Engineers Without Borders South Africa, UK and USA [August, 2020]. The content has been created in partnership with EcoSwell. To learn more or support the ongoing efforts of EcoSwell please visit their site. Disclaimer: EcoSwell is a third-party organisation and Engineers Without Borders is not responsible for ensuring content on this site. This document is licensed under Creative Commons license CC-BY-SA 4.0. Should you wish to reuse it for commercial purposes we recommend you consider making a donation towards the charities involved in its production, in particular EcoSwell who has engaged the community that feature in this design brief. To find out more: • EcoSwell: www.ecoswell.org • Engineers Without Borders UK: www.ewb-uk.org • Engineers Without Borders South Africa: • Engineers Without Borders USA: www.ewb-usa.org www.ewbsa.org Disclaimer: Across the world there are slight variations in English orthography (writing conventions), the two most recognised variations being British and American spelling. For the purpose of providing consistency, British English has been adopted throughout this document. Please visit www.engineering-for-people.org
CONTENTS Welcome . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4 About . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5 The Competition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Lobitos & Piedritas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 The Area . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 History . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Geography & Climate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Local Governance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Population . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Demographics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Lobitos Map . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Piedritas Map . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Industries & Employment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 The Challenge Areas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 Built Environment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Sanitation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 Energy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 Waste . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 Food . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 Digital . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 Transport . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 Case Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 Augusto Correa, Owner, Hotel Buenavista Lobitos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Darío Carreño, Transport Worker . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47 EcoSwell, Sustainable Development NGO . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 Gino Pérez, Owner, Lobitos Surf School . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49 Henry Espinoza, Director, Waves for Development and Councilor, Lobitos District Municipality . . . . . 50 Jacky Eche, Former Employee, Lobitos District Municipality. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 Juan Eche, Vice President, Lobitos Artisanal Fisherman’s Guild Association . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52 Justo Blas, Master Builder and Member, Piedritas Tourism Committee . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53 Leah Donatiello, Executive Director, High Tides International . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54 Manuel Vásquez, Director, Santa Elena de Piedritas School . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 Marlyne Guerrero, Secretary and Treasurer, Piedritas Tourism Committee . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 Nicolás Landa, Co-Founder, Coast2Coast and Lobitos Cinema Project . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57 Quenni Carreño, Artisan and Administrator, EcoSwell House . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58 Rafael Aramburú, Surfer and Touristic Entrepreneur . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59 Teófilo Erazo, President, Piedritas Community Council . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 Tullio Chapilliquén, Artisanal Fisher and Local Guide, Lobitos Ocean Adventure . . . . . . . . . . . 61 Getting Started . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62
ENGINEERING FOR PEOPLE DESIGN CHALLENGE WELCOME Both on a global and local scale, we are facing challenges that require urgent action. Engineering plays a key role in everyday life and our response to address current and future challenges. We have a global responsibility to help vulnerable communities adapt to changing conditions and to reduce inequality. Participating in the Engineering for People Design Challenge is the beginning of your journey to prepare you to invest your skills and talent to benefit all people and our planet. You have an opportunity to join thousands of university students from across the world taking part in an Engineers Without Borders initiative. This year, This design challenge is not about doing what you students in South Africa, the UK, Ireland and the USA are told or finding a ‘right’ answer to a pre-defined are participating in the Engineering for People Design problem. This is about ensuring you are designing Challenge. Over 41,500 students have participated for and with people to improve livelihoods. You will since 2011 with a different design brief each year. have the freedom to lead the direction of your project. This is more than a theoretical exercise. In this There is plenty of guidance and resources available document, the challenges described are real issues in (in addition to this document) to help you achieve this, Lobitos and Piedritas, two neighboring communities including: on the northern coast of Peru. The opportunities for • An online portal (with videos, photographs, improvement are identified by those people who live discussion forum and lots more information) there. They have offered their perspectives to help available at www.engineering-for-people.org form this design brief, enhance your educational experience and to share challenges faced in day-to- • Other online information about local initiatives day life. available at www.ecoswell.org Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 4
ABOUT Within this design brief you’ll find information about Lobitos and Piedritas on the northern coast of Peru, each of our eight challenge areas as well as case studies of the local people and businesses. Finally, BUILT WATER there is some guidance on the design process to get ENVIRONMENT you started. Find out more at www.engineering-for- people.org. The design brief is written so you may focus on one challenge area e.g. Water or Digital, or have a solution that addresses multiple. You are not trying to tackle everything within all the challenge areas, you are in charge of defining the problem that you aim to solve SANITATION ENERGY and deciding how broad or how focused to make it. The Engineering for People Design Challenge is about understanding the context and adopting a reasoned approach to end up with an appropriate idea. Just as in real life, there is no predetermined ‘right’ answer and there are likely to be multiple possible solutions. WASTE FOOD THE COMPETITION By participating in this programme you’ll also be eligible to enter into a competition where we’ll be looking for the teams who have best understood the social, environmental and economic factors present in Lobitos and Piedritas and can clearly demonstrate the application of this understanding into their TRANSPORT DIGITAL engineering design. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 5
LOBITOS & PIEDRITAS Lobitos and Piedritas are neighbouring communities on the northern coast of Peru and are the location of this year’s Engineering for People Design Challenge. Tourism is a growing economic opportunity for this arid region, due to the beneficial conditions for sports such as surfing. However, doing this sustainably to protect the local natural habitat, and including the local community in the economic benefit, is not without challenge. Since early this year, the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic has also had a significant impact on daily life. Investigate the challenge areas highlighted in this document, find out how Lobitos and Piedritas are changing, and as you look for ways engineering design can improve the ability of people to survive, thrive and flourish, consider the long-term consequences of tourism and the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. What could the future look like? To prepare and inspire you to invest your skills and talent to benefit all people and our planet, Engineers Without Borders partnered with EcoSwell to create this design brief in early 2020. EcoSwell and other NGOs in Lobitos and Piedritas have already started a number of initiatives and hold a close relationship with the community. You can: • Read and hear directly from people living in Lobitos and Piedritas in our Case Studies section and view video interviews on the online portal at www.engineering-for-people.org. • Read more about the local context in our Challenge Areas section and on EcoSwell’s website at www.ecoswell.org/projects. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 6
Map data ©2020 ESRI THE AREA Lobitos and Piedritas are neighboring coastal The nearby solid waste dump of the city of Talara has communities located in the Piura region of northern significantly increased the level of pollution in the Peru, South America. Lobitos is a small fishing and community and the surrounding environment. surfing town of 1,300 residents located 17 km from the city of Talara, the tourist capital of Piura. Piedritas The coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic has impacted is a community of 400 residents located halfway many aspects of daily life in Lobitos and Piedritas. On between the city of Talara and Lobitos. The residents 15 March 2020, Peruvian president Martín Vizcarra of Piedritas are in the process of obtaining a land title declared a national state of emergency, closing Peru’s to formally establish the community and gain reliable borders and banning Peruvians from leaving the access to basic services such as electricity and water. house except to access essential goods or perform Both Lobitos and Piedritas are located within an oil essential work. The national state of emergency was concession area. extended until 31 July 2020, but eased some of the quarantine measures by eliminating all-day curfew The region is home to several key industries, including on Sundays and reducing the hours for mandatory oil exploration and extraction, artisanal fishing, surf nightly curfew. Throughout Peru, parades, parties, tourism, ecotourism, and transportation. With year- civic and religious activities, and all large gatherings round swells and miles of coastline, Lobitos attracts remained suspended. Commercial businesses that surfers and tourists from around the world. Piedritas opened must operate at a maximum of 50% capacity is located in a large equatorial dry forest, which offers and ensure the necessary sanitation and preventative many natural assets for ecotourism and forms part measures are in place. International borders of a valuable ecosystem for wildlife and biodiversity. remained closed for passengers, with the exception The recent growth of the tourism industry has caused of repatriation flights. In July, although Piura is no some tensions and resentment among the local longer under mandatory quarantine, six regions of the population in both Lobitos and Piedritas because the country remain under strict lockdown. money generated from tourism largely benefits the foreign business owners and not the lower-income Despite the challenges of the coronavirus (COVID-19) neighbourhoods. pandemic, there is a desire for a sustainable and equitable tourism industry that incorporates the While Lobitos is known for its surf tourism, 30% of unique skills and talents of the local residents, whilst the local population lives below the poverty line and ensuring all people can meet their basic needs, 14% live in extreme poverty. In Piedritas, between 70- preserving the local ecosystem, and diversifying the 80% of the residents are living in poverty or extreme tourism offerings. poverty due to high levels of unemployment and a lack of basic infrastructure and services. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 7
HISTORY 3000-1800 BCE British influence is evident in the town’s layout and Peru was home to the Norte Chico civilization, the buildings, making Lobitos unlike other Spanish oldest civilisation in the Americas and one of the six colonial towns. While the foreign oil companies oldest in the world. built much needed infrastructure, Lobitos was mainly an oil camp with a town and housing for the 1000-1476 CE oil workers. The fishing community grew during The Tallán culture existed along the northern coast this time as there was more local demand. Lobitos and in the Piura region. As a matriarchal society, the also became a major stopping place for large ships women leaders were called “Capullanas.” travelling along the coast. In a number of archeological sites in the Piura 1950S-1970S region, researchers have unearthed “huacas” Piedritas was a town that mainly relied on the (ancient buildings) and “conchales” (ancient raising of livestock, including goats, pigs, and collections of seashells). Exploration of these sites chickens. The town was located in a valley with indicates that the area has been inhabited for ravines and a large carob tree forest that provided centuries and the past cultures lived off the sea and shade and natural grazing for the livestock. land. 1962 1200-1535 Burmah-Castrol (later to become British Petroleum The Inca Empire, the largest and most advanced or BP) bought the majority of shareholding of the state in pre-Columbian America, flourished in Lobitos Oilfield Company. The petrol from Lobitos ancient Peru. was refined and then sold in 229 service stations in 1526-1811 Ireland and North West England. The population at Led by Francisco Pizarro, the Spanish colonised this time included thousands of expats working in Peru. Under Spanish rule, much of the ancient the oil fields. culture was lost. 1968 1811-1824 A military coup overthrew the democratically Peru gained independence on 28 July 1821, elected administration of Fernando Belaúnde. The during the War of Independence. Spain made futile military government saw the strategic importance attempts to regain its former colonies and only in of Lobitos and built a military base swelling the local 1879 finally recognised Peruvian independence. population to more than 10,000 people. The new military government, led by General Juan Velasco 1878-1884 Alvarado, took numerous steps to assert Peru’s Territorial disputes occurred with neighbouring diplomatic and economic independence, including countries, including the War of the Pacific and the nationalising the oil industry, expelling all foreign Ecuadorian-Peruvian War (1941). The government operators, and establishing Petro-Peru. started to initiate a number of social and economic reforms to recover from the damage of the war. 1983 Political stability was achieved only in the early Heavy rains from a major El Niño event caused a 1900s. huge mudslide that destroyed much of the dry forest in the valley where Piedritas was located. EARLY 1900S In the aftermath of this devastating event, the US and British entrepreneurs led the early remaining residents resettled just outside of the exploration and exploitation of Peru’s oil fields, the valley, further towards the city of Talara. majority of which were discovered in the remote northern desert coast. An Englishman, Alexander 1990 Milne, discovered the last major oil field near Alberto Fujimori was elected president of Peru, Lobitos and formed the Lobitos Oilfield Company during a tumultuous time of severe economic crisis to mine the fields. where a large percentage of the population of Peru was living in extreme poverty and there was a civil 1920S-1950S war with the terrorist group Sendero Luminoso The International Petroleum Company (IPC), owned (Shining Path). by Standard Oil, acquired 50% of the Lobitos stock. The town of Lobitos and surrounding land became an enclave for British and US citizens. The Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 8
1991 2001 To stabilise the economy, the “Inti” was replaced Alejandro Toledo was elected president and with the nuevo sol (new sol) as the official currency ushered in a new era of political reform that in Peru. involved decentralising the Peruvian government and giving more power and resources to the 1992 municipalities. With these reforms, the Peruvian Fujimori dissolved the Congress and the judiciary, government gave money collected from the suspended parts of the constitution, and assumed oil and mining industries in each locality to the dictatorial powers. He argued that the Congress, municipalities to invest in local development controlled by opposition parties, was obstructing projects. The government, however, did not provide his efforts to fight terrorism, poverty, and corruption. appropriate training in management, accountability, The following year, a new constitution tilted the and transparency for public administrators, balance of government power in Fujimori’s favour governors, and mayors. This lack of planning to enable sweeping legislation and economic and oversight contributed to the prevalence of reforms and facilitate Peru’s re-entry into the global corruption and misuse of public funds at the economy. regional and local government level. 1995-1999 2004 Peru and Ecuador went to war over the border Sofía Mulanovich, a Peruvian, won the World demarcation along the headwaters of the Cenepa Surfing Championship title in Hawaii, which River. The Montevideo Declaration went into effect sparked a renewed national interest in the sport. in May 1999. Part of the peace agreement included reducing the military presence of both countries in 2008 the vicinity of the newly recognised border, which The Association of Surfing Pros hosted an involved removing the Lobitos military base. The international surfing competition in Lobitos. departure of the military had a dramatic impact on the town by not only removing an economic 2008-2011 base, but also removing much of the military base ProInversión, Peru’s state agency for the promotion infrastructure. of private investment, announced the sale of the military base land for a large-scale US$119,000,000 1998 tourism project to position Lobitos as an important A major El Niño event triggered mudslides that international surf and wind surfing destination. brought a large amount of sand to the beach The project was to include the construction of and altered the seafloor. These environmental 400 condominiums, an 18-hole golf course, and changes created perfect waves for surfing, and in shopping centres. The private land auction was the early 2000s, surfers discovered Lobitos and the supposed to take place in 2011 and be signed opportunity for tourism grew. before the transition of presidential powers, but the residents of Lobitos protested because they were 2000 not included in the planning process. Lacking local Fujimori won a controversial election, but amid support, the tourism project failed to take off. growing allegations of corruption, he announced his resignation. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 9
GEOGRAPHY & CLIMATE Peru’s Pacific coastline accounts for 11% of the area The northern coast of Peru has a wealth of mineral of the country and stretches for 2,414 km (1,500 mi) and natural resources. Petroleum fields are located along the western edge of the nation from Ecuador both inland and offshore along the remote northern to Chile. The coastal area is characterised by narrow desert coast, and the oil industry has a long history bands of arid to semi-arid desert, rocky coastline, of extracting oil from the region. Natural resources beaches, and fertile valleys. Rivers that flow down include the equatorial dry forest, which provides a from the Andes Mountains and into the Pacific Ocean habitat for a wide variety of flora and fauna, including feed the fertile valleys. Two important ocean currents, the carob tree and the critically endangered Peruvian the cold-water Humboldt Current and the warm-water Plantcutter bird. The dry forest begins north of Lima, El Niño Current, connect along the coast of Peru to stretching along the coast and all the way to the create an abundance of aquatic life and biodiversity. southern border of Ecuador. Much of what remains of the dry forest has gone through desertification Lobitos and Piedritas are located in Piura, where the and widespread deforestation and degradation. It climate is a tropical dry climate and warm all year is estimated that only 10% of the original dry forest round. Temperatures in Piura are at their hottest during remains. From 2003-2018, the area of tree-covered Peru’s summer months, from December to March, areas in Piedritas increased by 182.13%, however, the when by day, highs generally exceed 32°C (90°F). main body of growth occurred in the invasive species During the winter months of June to September, Tamarix, not the native dry forest. temperatures are slightly cooler. From June to August, daytime temperatures average between 25°C The following resources will help to build on your (77°F) and 27°C (81°F). Due to the arid conditions, knowledge of Geography and Climate: precipitation is lower than 100 mm (4 in) per year, except in the case of severe El Niño events, which can [1] Captured Planet Video - The 6th Extinction: Loss provoke major flooding and annual precipitation that of the Dry Forest in Peru can be as high as 4,000 mm (157.5 in). [2] Dry Forest Site Map Peru’s coast also experiences occasional El Niño [3] Ecoregion - Southwestern Ecuador and events. This phenomenon generally occurs every Northwestern Peru 15-20 years, but in recent years, has been occurring more frequently due to climate change. Warm [4] Last call for the Peruvian Plantcutter ocean currents mix with increased air pressure in an abrupt reversal of atmospheric and sea conditions. This oceanic upheaval produces heavy rains and major climate shifts. In 2017, Peru’s northern coast experienced a major El Niño event, which caused intense rains, flooding, mudslides, and widespread power outages. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 10
An oil rig at sunset in Lobitos LOCAL GOVERNANCE The current mayor of Lobitos serves as part of the Piedritas is not incorporated into a municipality, governing body for the Lobitos District Municipality. but receives some support from the city of Within the district of Lobitos, there is a small Talara. Although Piedritas does not have a formal parliament called the council. All but one of the government structure in place, it has a small council members are affiliated with the Somos community council composed of five people who are Perú (We Are Peru) political party. The number of well respected in the community and very committed representatives on the council reflects the number to their roles. The council oversees and coordinates of votes the party achieved in the last election. The many of the community’s activities and development municipality receives funding from the Peruvian projects. The residents of Piedritas respect the council government to oversee public projects in areas such and follow its guidelines. as sanitation and wastewater management. POPULATION According to The World Factbook, the total 1997-1998, a major El Niño event created the perfect population of Peru is estimated at 32,914,989 people. conditions for surfing, which resulted in an influx At the regional level, Piura has a total population of of surfers and tourists from 1998 to the late 2000s. 1,856,809 people (National Institute of Statistics & In recent years, many of the people who moved to Informatics (INEI) - Peru). Lobitos for surfing and business opportunities have left because the town is no longer as peaceful as it TOTAL POPULATION OF LOBITOS: 1,300 once was. The change of population is reflected in the The population of Lobitos has varied considerably census data with a change from 1,456 people in 2010 over time. One of the population swells was from to 1,340 in 2017. The population also experienced the early 1900s to 1968 where the population rose further decline due to youth leaving the town in by thousands of expats due to the rise of the oil search of education and job opportunities. industry before nationalisation in 1968 (where expats were forced to abandon the town). Another swell TOTAL POPULATION OF PIEDRITAS: 400 of population occurred with an enhanced military From 2013-2015, there was a steady flow of migration presence (up to 10,000 people) from 1968, to when to Piedritas, with a relatively consistent population most military personnel were evacuated in the 1990s prior to this. Each year, the population grew by (due to peace agreement with Ecuador). Some of approximately 10-15 families or 75-90 people. In the the infrastructure was therefore abandoned due to past three years, the rate of migration has slowed, with changing population or change in ownership. From only a few new families joining the community. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 11
DEMOGRAPHICS Peru’s 2017 National Censuses of Population AGE and Housing provide demographic data on In general, the population in Lobitos is young Lobitos, but not Piedritas. The demographic data (see Figure 1), however, in recent years, there on Piedritas comes from a local survey in which has been a decline in the number of young 40 households responded. Despite the small people from ages 10-19 years and 20-29 years. sample size, the survey data provides an important In Piedritas, the majority of the population reference point for Piedritas. In this section, only surveyed was over 30 years old. gender and age demographic data is listed for Piedritas. 258 GENDER 228 236 213 In Lobitos and Piedritas, the men are mostly 179 dedicated to working and providing an income for the household, while the women care for the children and manage the domestic responsibilities. 112 These gender norms, however, are not the same 87 for every woman in the two localities. In Lobitos, 49 a larger percentage of women work in municipal 19 jobs, cleaning or cooking or running their own 2 home shop or business. In Piedritas, the women actively participate in community activities, particularly the community greening projects Figure 1: Age of population in Lobitos and environmental education workshops. The women typically bring their children with them to LANGUAGE the workshops. Women also attend meetings and In Lobitos and Piedritas, the majority of the activities at the Santa Elena primary school. population speaks Spanish. In Lobitos, a small percentage of the population speaks EMPLOYMENT Portuguese due to Brazilian tourists who opened In Lobitos, the majority of the population is of businesses during the tourism boom. In addition, working age (72.1%), which is more than 15 years a small segment of the population speaks of age. Almost half of the population works for Quechua, the language of the Inca Empire and payment or goods. the most spoken indigenous language in the Below, are rough estimates of the percentage Americas. of the working population employed in various industries and commercial activities: RELIGION • 50% artisanal fishing industry In Lobitos, the majority of the population is • 20% small shops/businesses/restaurants Catholic (see Figure 2). Others identify as • 10% hotel industry Evangelical and Christian. There is a segment • 5% municipality workers of the population that does not profess any • 5% farming / raising livestock religion. • 5% trade jobs (carpenter, plumber, construction worker, etc) • 5% private security guard for a company or other operational job Slightly more than half of the population does not work for money or goods, which includes many women who work in the home. Catholic 72.5% Figure 2: Religion in Lobitos Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 12
RACE & ETHNICITY Mestizo (71.28%) In Lobitos, the majority of the population identifies as mestizo. The term mestizo Black or Afroperuvian (11.88%) means mixed in Spanish, and is generally used throughout Latin America to describe White (11.19%) people of mixed ancestry with a white European and an indigenous background. Quechua (3.32%) 12% of the population identifies as Black or Afroperuvian. Afroperuvians are citizens of Other (1.18%) Peru with African heritage who were enslaved and brought to Peru during colonial times. Do not know/ Do not wish to The Afroperuvian population currently suffers respond (1.15%) from marginalisation and racial discrimination, which negatively impacts their social mobility Figure 3: Race & Ethnicity in Lobitos and access to basic services. Three percent of the population is Quechua, indigenous people originally from the Andean region of Peru. Indigenous groups and those of indigenous descent also face marginalisation and racial EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT discrimination in Peruvian society. The level of educational attainment varies in Figure 4: Education in Lobitos Lobitos (see Figure 4), with a larger portion of the population having completed either primary 413 school or secondary school. 398 PREVALENCE OF DISABILITY 7.32% of the people in Lobitos live with some form of disability. In Lobitos, 3.73% of the population experiences partial blindness or loss 109 100 of vision. 1.67% of the population experiences 88 65 66 difficulty walking or limited mobility. 41 18 l l e) y y .) e) c.) e ve oo ar ar nc at et et (in le ch im nd r . (i to pl pl No ad yS Pr om om co oc Ed r Se rD er rg (c al . (c rs de ic so ad Ed Nu hn Un r r rg te al c Te as de n ic M Un ch Te Fishers off the coast of Lobitos Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 13
LOBITOS MAP Municipal Area N Military Area Neighbourhoods Zarumilla Lobitos surf spot Barrio Primavera Centro EcoSwell Hotel Area Near Beach Nuevo Lobitos Bellavista Villa del Pescador Map data ©2020 Google • Lobitos is composed of six main neighbourhoods, • In Barrio Centro, the military rents out the houses which are under the jurisdiction of different to existing families of Lobitos and newer residents. entities, including the Fisherman’s Guild, Bellavista is a small neighbourhood located on a military, and Lobitos District Municipality. These hill behind Barrio Centro. neighbourhoods vary in size, demographics, and • A dry gully or ravine separates Nuevo socioeconomic status. Lobitos, which is under the jurisdiction of the • The fishing community mainly resides in Lobitos District Municipality, from the military Primavera, with a population of approximately 800 zone. Approximately 500 people live in this people. Most of the families in this neighbourhood neighbourhood. Many fishing families live in the have lived in Lobitos for generations and work poorer areas of Nuevo Lobitos. The coastal area of in the artisanal fishing industry. Primavera is an Nuevo Lobitos is a popular tourist destination that underserved neighbourhood where some of the caters to surfers and foreigners. poorest people of Lobitos live. • The Zarumilla, Castilla, Barrio Centro, and Bellavista neighbourhoods are located within the military zone. All of the land in this area is under the control of the military, which rents out old houses and buildings to residents. Approximately 150 people live in Zarumilla. In 2016, there were 5-10 families living in Castilla, but due to the growing demand to live in this area, that number has doubled. Map data ©2020 Google Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 14
PIEDRITAS MAP Section 1 N Section 2 Section 3 Section 4 Section 5 Map data ©2020 Google • The housing in Piedritas is organised into • The more vulnerable and impoverished families five sections, according to which houses are live on the other side of the road (east of Map data ©2020 connected to the electrical grid. Panamericana Norte) in basic housing with no • The houses in sections one and two are located water or electricity. Approximately half of these right next to the Santa Elena primary school and families dedicate their lives to the logging of the road that passes through Piedritas (west carob trees and the production of charcoal. The of Panamericana Norte). The longer-standing other families in this area raise and sell livestock, families who live in this area have achieved a including goats, horses, chickens and pigs. higher socioeconomic status, and some own small businesses located near the community’s ecotourism route. Map data ©2020 Google Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 15
INDUSTRIES & EMPLOYMENT The residents of Piedritas engage in a variety of commercial activities, while roughly half of the population in Lobitos works in the fishing industry. Some residents engage in small-scale subsistence agriculture and raise goats, pigs, or chickens and sell the meat and dairy products. The people of Lobitos and Piedritas are heavily reliant on the nearest city, Talara, for buying food and goods and accessing Surf school in Lobitos essential services such as banks and hospitals as they are not available locally. TOURISM & ECO-TOURISM Surf tourism plays a critical role in Lobitos’ economy, Artisanal and commercial fishing are practiced bringing an estimated 8,400 people to Lobitos each along the coast. The Talara Provincial Municipality year and contributing a total of US $3,555,612 to the and Lobitos District Municipality provide some local economy. EcoSwell led a multi-stakeholder employment opportunities, including street cleaning, National Wave Break Protection Campaign in Lobitos, garbage collection, security, trades, and when which now protects by law five of the local world class available, local construction projects. Previous wave breaks (Piscina, Muelles, Lobitos, El Hueco, administrations used to hire over 50% of the Baterías) against any potential development threats. population on a rotating basis throughout the year, however, the current mayor of Lobitos stopped this Because of the changing surfing conditions in practice because it was financially unsustainable Lobitos, the tourism industry is keen to diversify and fostered corruption and misuse of public funds. its offerings to include fishing, diving, kite surfing, Opportunities for advancing individual or household kayaking, and mountain biking to attract new visitors. economic prospects through municipal employment The municipality of Talara is interested in Piedritas’ are limited. growing ecotourism industry, which could help boost overall tourism in the area. Although the oil industry is one of the largest industries in Lobitos, the only residents employed Deforestation and environmental degradation are work predominantly as security guards. Over the two of the main challenges Piedritas faces in its last decade, oil prices have declined severely, which efforts to build a sustainable ecotourism industry. In has reduced the amount of oil royalties the central the early 1990s, newly built highways offered easier government can provide to the Lobitos District access to Talara, prompting an influx of domestic Municipality. and international imports into the area. Residents struggled to sell their produce in the local markets The oil companies built several oil platforms on top due to the competitive prices of imported goods. of reefs that provide an important habitat for marine Unable to sell their produce, many of the residents life. These platforms have disrupted the local fishing turned to logging the carob tree and selling charcoal industry because the oil companies prohibit fishing to generate an income, which caused significant near the platforms. Oil spills happen frequently and damage to the dry forest. To address these issues, often go unnoticed due to a lack of government EcoSwell has implemented, with support from energy patrols and regulation. company Enel, the “Green Piedritas” Environmental Education and Community Ecotourism Project, LA COSTANERA educating the community on the harmful impacts of The central government is planning to build a new producing charcoal and implementing initiatives to highway called La Costanera, which will run along preserve the local ecosystem. the entire coast of Peru, parallel to the Pan-American Highway. By providing a direct and accessible route Recently, the community started to receive its first along the coast, La Costanera could significantly groups of tourists and visitors. Integrating ecotourism increase the influx of tourists to Lobitos. into the beach and sun tourism of Talara would diversify the tourist experience and help Piedritas capture the flow of tourists traveling through the community to reach the coast. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 16
OVERVIEW: THE CHALLENGE AREAS Before introducing the challenge areas, it is important to note that the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are a useful framing for tackling this design challenge. 2020 marks 10 years until the rapidly approaching deadline for achieving the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The goals, launched in 2015, laid out 17 areas to end poverty, protect the planet and ensure that all people enjoy peace and prosperity. A number of UN Sustainable Development Goals are linked here to provide a first step for wider reading. Read through the goals to explore to understand both the local and global perspective, whilst reading about Lobitos and Piedritas. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 17
BUILT ENVIRONMENT The built environment includes all human-made physical spaces where we live, take leisure and work. These include housing, public spaces, healthcare facilities, schools, markets and shops that people need for a healthy and thriving society. When properly designed, an inclusive built environment can help solve a number of other issues such as the provision of clean water, adequate sanitation, access to education, reliable energy and the disposal of waste. What ideas can you come up with to improve the existing homes, buildings and public spaces to meet future needs? Whilst generating ideas for this area, it will be important to consider the imminent growth of tourism in the area to ensure the development of inclusive solutions that meet the needs of the whole community. FOOD Food security occurs when all people have access to sufficient, safe, and nutritious food that meets their requirements for an active and healthy life in ways the planet can sustain into the future. A changing climate, growing global population, rising food prices, and environmental stressors create a number of challenges for the production and consumption of food. These global changes can be particularly challenging for coastal communities which often source food from the land and sea. Undernutrition, overweight and obesity are different forms of malnutrition, and it is common to have people with these differing forms living side-by-side in one country, in one community, or even in the same household. Small-scale sustainable food producers, resilient and regenerative agricultural practices, maintaining gender diversity and providing timely access to up- to-date information are all key to achieving reliable food systems. What ideas can you come up with to improve food systems and nutrition and promote sustainable practices to meet current and future needs? Whilst generating ideas for this area, it will be important to consider the imminent growth of tourism, and thus greater demand for locally available food, to ensure the development of inclusive solutions that meet the needs of the local community. How might these opportunities be realised, whilst including safety protocols needed to combat the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic? ENERGY Reliable access to energy, in particular electricity, often reduces the time people spend on everyday tasks. This means that they can engage in other activities such as education, employment and entertainment, thereby improving the quality of life. Although energy is an essential requirement for human development and the eradication of poverty, most of our energy comes from finite fossil fuels. In the 21st Century, there is a significant global challenge to balance out energy demands against the associated environmental impacts. What ideas can you come up with to improve access to safe, low-cost energy to meet current and future needs? Whilst generating ideas for this area, it will be important to consider the imminent growth of tourism, and thus greater demand for reliable energy, to ensure the development of inclusive solutions that meet the needs of the whole community. WASTE Human activity produces waste. It is vital to address and properly manage waste to prevent environmental damage, health risks and the development of unsightly and undesirable areas. Reducing, reusing and recycling waste are key priorities for sustainable human development. Waste is an evolving issue, with the majority of waste ending up in the landfill. What ideas can you come up with to improve the situation to meet current and future needs, whilst restoring the local environment? Whilst generating ideas for this area, it will be important to consider the imminent growth of tourism, and thus greater demand for clean spaces, to ensure the development of inclusive solutions that meet the needs of the whole community. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 18
WATER Water is an essential resource, and to lead healthy lives, people need a reliable supply of clean drinking water. Water is also used in industrial processes we depend on for food, energy and the production of many of the products we use daily. Water is vital for human development. What ideas can you come up with to improve the resilience and availability of the water supply to meet current and future needs? Whilst generating ideas for this area, it will be important to consider the imminent growth of tourism in the area, and thus greater demand on the available water resources, to ensure the development of inclusive solutions that meet the needs of the whole community. SANITATION Sanitation is critical for maintaining public health. Sanitation involves the safe management, treatment and eventual safe end use or disposal of water that is contaminated and presents potential health problems. This includes sewage, water run-off from buildings, and water that has been used for purposes such as washing and cleaning in both domestic and industrial purposes. With treatment, contaminated water can be returned to the water cycle with minimal environmental issues. What ideas can you come up with to improve access to sanitation and to decrease pollution to meet current and future needs? Whilst generating ideas for this area, it will be important to consider the imminent growth of tourism, and thus greater demand for decent sanitation, to ensure the development of inclusive solutions that meet the needs of the whole community. TRANSPORT Mobility and access to transport infrastructure allow people and goods to move around freely. Mobility plays a key role in making societies more inclusive through enabling access to key services and educational, economic and social opportunities. Transport infrastructure comes in many forms such as pedestrianised areas, cycling facilities, boats, public transport, shared-ownership transport, rented and hired transport and private transport. What ideas can you come up with to improve transportation on land or at sea to meet current and future needs? Whilst generating ideas for this area, it will be important to consider the imminent growth of tourism and the planned La Costanera highway to ensure the development of inclusive solutions that meet the needs of the whole community. DIGITAL The world is becoming increasingly connected. Whilst many people benefit hugely from modern advances in information communications, some of us have not had the same opportunities. Enabling access to technologies from which information flows, knowledge is gained and people communicate is recognised globally as an important factor in reducing the inequality gap. Information communication technologies (ICT) facilitate educational, social and economic opportunities for people. ICT comes in many forms, such as radios, televisions, computers, internet networks, mobiles and mobile platforms, data loggers and sensors, small data and big data. Due to recent social distancing measures, the ability to buy/sell, work, connect and perform many other tasks has been limited to those that have available digital systems. What ideas can you come up with to use digital technology to meet current and future needs? How can you leverage digital systems to facilitate daily life where social distancing is a necessity to protect against the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic? Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 19
BUILT ENVIRONMENT In Lobitos and Piedritas, plans to expand community facilities and enhance conservation efforts of the dry forest are renewing the built environment. What ideas can you come up with to improve the existing homes, buildings and public spaces to meet the future needs of the whole community, whilst restoring the local environment? It will also be important to consider the imminent growth of tourism in the area to ensure the development of inclusive solutions that meet the needs of the whole community. OVERVIEW The built environment of Lobitos and Piedritas shapes Both communities are located within a largely residents’ and visitors’ experience of the place. As desertified dry forest. The conservation requirements with any setting, the built environment influences to preserve the dry forest are impacted by the built aspirations, sense of self-worth, safety and security. environment. The increase in precipitation brought by Both towns have evolved over time to feature both El Niño brings opportunities for vegetation restoration public buildings and residential homes. in Piedritas. The built environment in Lobitos has gone through There are local examples of the impacts of poorly significant periods of change over time. Lobitos has managed tourism, which is of concern to the people about 58 hotels and hostels, a few restaurants, and of Lobitos and Piedritas. The nearby tourist hotspot of other tourist-related businesses, including surfboard Mancora is known for the environmental and social shops and yoga studios. damage caused by the tourism industry. Unmanaged waste and sanitation presents health risks, In Lobitos, the oldest homes are around 100 years environmental pollution and affects the location’s old, while others were built during the 1970s. Living aesthetics. Buildings that have been located too close conditions range within the key areas of Lobitos. In to the shore affect the movement of the sand and general, many buildings are poorly adapted to the have significantly changed the quality of the waves. desert environment. New developments in Nuevo Many of the people financially benefiting from tourism Lobitos and Primavera have no sewer connection or in Mancora are not from Mancora, and the local septic tank and are not connected to the grid. People people have seen their quality of life go down rather use friends’ toilets or defecate outside. Approximately than up, resulting in increases in civil unrest, crime and 5% of the people in Primavera do not have toilets. inequality. Across all the non-military areas there are fenced off plots of land ‘owned’ (no formal land titles) mainly by There are, however, other local examples where people that have migrated to Lobitos, but also some the communities have dealt with the issues in a local residents. more effective manner. For example, Los Órganos is considered to have better managed the waste In Piedritas, there are two main tourist businesses that and sanitation issues and preserved the natural receive visitors from Talara. Piedritas is traditionally environment rather than destroy it. an animal farming/logging community and has only recently opened to tourism. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 20
Municipal Area Military Area Neighbourhoods Castilla Zarumilla Lobitos surf spot Barrio Primavera Centro Primavera EcoSwell Hotel Area Near Beach Nuevo Lobitos Bellavista Villa del Pescador Map data ©2020 Google MAP Military Zone (Zarumilla, Castilla, Barrio Centro and In Barrio Centro, the houses are mostly made of wood Bellavista): and were built by the British during the booming oil years. In Bellavista, there are also wooden houses built There are a few hostels in the military zone, but no by the British, some of which are close to 100 years new houses or hotels are being built in this area. old. The area mostly includes restored old wooden In Primavera, the fishing community has a land title for houses previously used by those who worked in the their whole neighbourhood. oil companies and some newer (1970s) brick houses. Most have yard space and are detached. Some parts The houses and buildings are mostly made of of this area are still collapsed and there are still many concrete, but some are made of plywood and empty buildings and houses that have yet to be corrugated iron or tin roofs. restored. In recent years, the neighbourhood has been growing The military zone also has more trees and vegetation because the Fisherman’s Guild has been giving than the surrounding areas. out small plots of land to the family members of the fishers. Zarumilla has many concrete houses built during the military regime to house military personnel, which are Most homes have limited yard space and are in close now rented out to newer residents of Lobitos. proximity, often sharing walls with neighbours. In Castilla, many of the concrete houses were in Recently, the neighbourhood of Nuevo Lobitos has complete disrepair with cracked and crumbling walls experienced population growth because the previous and no roofs or windows. Because of the growing mayor created a new residential area with 60-80 plots demand to live in this area, the military started to rent of land. out houses at very low contract prices to people from Talara and other areas. These new residents have Most of the houses built on these plots are simple restored many of the collapsed houses and moved in. structures made of brick or plywood. Nuevo Lobitos also includes a strip of hotels, shops, and restaurants along the beach, which is a popular tourist destination that caters to surfers and tourists. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 21
CURRENT SITUATION In Lobitos, there have been several new government EXISTING COMMUNITY FACILITIES: infrastructure initiatives, some of which have had • There is limited public infrastructure, and the hot varying success due in part to a poor sense of local climate makes it difficult for people to make use of ownership. These projects included a market in Nuevo any unshaded public space. Lobitos (which closed in 2019 due to poor location • As fútbol (football or soccer) is the major sport choice and lack of local demand), a preschool (which in Peru, the school in Piedritas has a concrete resulted in a major conflict with an oil company) and pitch for the children to play. There are two fútboll high-tech security huts interconnected with cameras pitches in Lobitos (in Primavera and Nuevo and Wifi throughout Lobitos (which resulted in conflict Lobitos), and there also is a cement pitch in the between surfers and the military). middle of the town with lighting available. • In Piedritas: Since 2015, tourism in Lobitos has been declining. » The Santa Elena primary school is the main The rapid development of housing and hotels along community facility and the others include an the coast has disrupted the natural flow patterns of information centre, hiking and bird watching the sand and wind, which has negatively impacted trails and two restaurants (Sol y Campo and Villa the quality of the waves. Many advanced surfers Jordan) for tourists. have left Lobitos in search of less crowded beaches. » Piedritas only has public lighting along the main One option the town is currently considering is trying road and school. to attract more beginner and intermediate surfers » The school (built by the energy company, Enel) because the current waves are better suited for those is made with Caña de Guayaquil (bamboo-like who are learning how to surf. material), bricks and iron/steel beams. Some Piedritas has an ambitious long-term plan entitled the of the classrooms are made of large shipping ‘Piedritas Verde Project’ (Green Piedritas) focused containers [2]. on environmental sustainability and ecotourism to: • In Lobitos: » There are three main churches and several • Acquire a land title and gain reliable access to communal facilities where residents can gather, basic services such as water and electricity including parks, plazas, hotels, restaurants, the • Expand the local facilities to include a chapel and pier, and the Fisherman’s Guild Community Hall. marketplace » The pier is where the fishers keep their • Build hiking trails leading to the wetlands and equipment. The building used to have a archaeological sites, a canopy tower, and functioning toilet and shower block, but it has birdwatching sites fallen into disrepair and is no longer accessible. • Be recognised in bio-commerce, ecotourism and » There is a public medical centre in Lobitos, fair trade located in the Primavera neighbourhood. The • Enable further academic research about the dry public centre has three nurses and no doctors. forest The nurses can perform simple procedures and • Restore the carob tree forest ecosystem have access to basic medications, including vaccinations. The nearest large hospital is a 1.5 HOUSING: to 2 hour drive via the Pan-American highway to • There are 102 homes in Lobitos [1]. Piedritas is the city of Piura. made up of 60-70 homes, with only around 2-5% » There is street lighting in most of Lobitos, more of them constructed from brick. Most of the homes so in Nuevo Lobitos than in the military zone, but are single story structures made of plywood and not all of the street lights work. corrugated iron, with the majority of them built » The public spaces in Lobitos, such as the town using local labour. square, sports courts and small park areas, are • A typical household will include between five to made of concrete, with little available human- six family members, and it is common for newly made or natural shade. These spaces are mostly married couples to leave the family home and unusable during the day because of the heat. seek new housing. • Lobitos and Piedritas are considered to be open [1] Lobitos Map of homes by area and safe towns, although in recent years, there has been a noticeable increase in petty theft. [2] Video of Santa Elena primary school • Houses have been broken into with TVs, motorcycles, and laptops stolen. The residents have started to put up more fences, where before the spaces were very accessible. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 22
RELEVANT CASE STUDIES Take a look at the following case studies for more information and ideas: IN LOBITOS: • Darío is a transport worker who discusses the need for well-equipped bus stops and enhanced public spaces. • Gino, owner of the Lobitos Surf School, discusses his aspirations to expand his business with new facilities for visitors and residents. • Jacky, former Lobitos District Municipality Employee, describes the need for collaboration between stakeholders to upgrade the community's educational facilities. • Leah, Executive Director of High Tides International, discusses the organisation’s after-school educational activities and the facilities that need upgrading to support educational opportunities for children in Lobitos. • Nicolás, co-founder of Coast2Coast and Lobitos Cinema Project, highlights the need for physical spaces to enhance community development initiatives. IN PIEDRITAS: • Justo, Master Builder and Member of the Piedritas Tourism Committee, and Teófilo, President of the Piedritas Community Council, highlight the need to build multi-use community facilities in Piedritas. • Manuel, Director of the Santa Elena de Piedritas School, describes the growth and development of the school. • Marlyne, Secretary and Treasurer of the Piedritas Tourism Committee, shares her insights on reforestation efforts in Piedritas. SUGGESTED STARTING POINTS To get you started, we’ve outlined some initial starting points. These are only suggestions, and you can come up with your own if you have identified another issue from the design brief or your own research. Creating new and retrofitting existing public spaces inside the dry forest that provide opportunities for economic activity, shade from the sun and services such as waste collection points would greatly improve the prosperity of Lobitos and Piedritas. Can you come up with innovative ways of developing mixed-use public spaces? The growth of the tourism industry has caused some tensions between the local population and foreign business owners. Can you think of creative ways to build public spaces where the local residents, foreign business owners and tourists can interact, either commercially or socially, to build more cohesion and sense of community and include the local residents in the long-term plans for tourism? Increased tourism has brought development to Lobitos. Piedritas’ community council designated a large area of public land across the road from the Santa Elena primary school for community facilities. In addition, the community wants to build a small chapel and a marketplace to sell local artisanal and organic products to visitors. Can you suggest ideas to help Piedritas expand its existing infrastructure? The Green Piedritas Project also has an ambitious long-term plan focused on environmental sustainability and ecotourism. Can you propose ways to help achieve this plan? REMEMBER: Consider the overall context of the social, environmental and economic factors in Lobitos and Piedritas. This is part of our marking criteria and is key to the success of any engineering intervention you come up with. We recommend you read all the other Challenge Area pages and our guidance pages on getting started. You will need to conduct your own research beyond the information available here to show your depth of understanding. Additional information can be found in the pages about Lobitos and Piedritas and online at www.engineering-for-people.org. Engineering for People Design Challenge: Design Brief 2020/21 Page 23
You can also read