Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022

Page created by Derrick Carpenter
 
CONTINUE READING
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
Currency Planning for Multinationals
         in Latin America

                             June 17, 2022
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
Co-Chairs & Speakers
Gabryela Valencia Ayala                   Valeria Estathio
Tax Partner                               Partner
Valencia del Toro & Professionals, S.C.   O´Farrell
Mexico City                               Buenos Aires
+(55) 5251 1705                           +5411 4346-1000
gvalencia@valpro.com.com.mx               estathioV@eof.com.ar

Lavinia Junqueira                         Juan Gabriel Reyes
Partner                                   Pérez, Bustamante & Ponce
Junqueira Ie Advogados                    Quito
São Paulo                                 +593 2 3827640
+55 11 4550 2784                          jreyes@pbplaw.com
lavinia@jlegalteam.com

Aziza Yuldasheva                          Sam Kaywood
US Tax Principal                          Partner
Deloitte Tax LLP                          Alston & Bird LLP
Washington, DC                            Atlanta, GA
+1 (202) 220-2119                         +1 (404) 881-7481
ayuldasheva@deloitte.com                  sam.kaywood@alston.com

                                                                      2
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
Foreign Currency Issues – Mexican Perspective

                   Gabryela Valencia Ayala, Mexico City
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
MEXICO

Legal Framework for
Currency Fluctuation     Mexican Federal Constitution

                                Monetary Law

                              Central Bank Law

                               Income Tax Law

                            Value Added Tax Law

                             Federal Fiscal Code

                                                        4
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
MEXICO

• Autonomous

• Main Objective: Provide the
  country's   economy     with
  domestic currency and to
  maintain a low and stable
  inflation

• Other Faculties: Regulates FX,
  as     well     as    financial
  intermediation and financial
  services

                                    Esta foto de Autor desconocido está bajo licencia CC BY-SA-NC

                                                                                                    5
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
MEXICO

• Central Bank shall act in FX
  matters in accordance with the
  guidelines determined by the FX
  Commission

• Exchange rate policy is the
  responsibility   of     the     FX
  Commission, which is composed
  of officials from the Ministry of
  Finance and Banco de México. At
  the end of 1994, the Commission
  agreed that the exchange rate
  would be freely determined by
  market forces (flexible or floating
  exchange rate).

                                        Esta foto de Autor desconocido está bajo licencia CC BY-SA-NC

                                                                                                        6
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
MEXICO

               Monetary Law
               •Legal tender: MXN
               •Foreign currency shall not
                be legal tender
Esta foto de
Autor
desconocido
está bajo
licencia CC
BY-NC

                                             7
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
MEXICO

                                    • Issue: US Company does not want
                                      to be paid in pesos
Monetary Law

• Payment obligations in foreign
  currency to be fulfilled within
  Mexico should be settled by
  delivering the equivalent in MX
  currency

What Exchange rate?
 Date of payment

                                                                        8
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
Mexican Tax Rules
for Exchange Gains and Losses
Currency Planning for Multinationals in Latin America - June 17, 2022
MEXICO

                                           Why Interest?
Income Tax Law

1. Exchange gains or losses shall be
   treated as interest
2. Interest accrued during the tax year
   is considered taxable income (even if
   not incurred) for advance payments
   and annual tax
3. Taxpayers may deduct accrued
   interest payable during the tax year
   (only annual tax)

                                                           10
MEXICO

EXCHANGE         FLUCTUATION          AND
INTEREST. ARTICLE 8, PENULTIMATE
PARAGRAPH, OF THE INCOME TAX
LAW, GIVES THEM EQUAL TREATMENT,
SINCE THEY ARE SIMILAR IN NATURE…
since they are concepts that are generated
on a daily basis and constitute financial
charges that must be borne, even though
they do not constitute one and the same
thing…”

(Mexican Supreme Court of Justice, 1a. CXVII/2017
(10a.), Weekly Report of the Judiciary and its Gazette,
Book 46, September 2017, Volume I, page 223

                                                      Esta foto de Autor desconocido está bajo licencia CC BY-SA

                                                                                                                   11
MEXICO

4. Exchange loss ≤ loss obtained by    • Issue: potential limitation in loss
   applying the Central Bank             deduction for exchange rate, thin
   exchange rate                         capitalization rule, potential
                                         application of anti-abuse rules e.g.
                                         rules re-characterizing interest into
                                         dividends (hidden dividends)

5. Exchange gain ≥ gain obtained by
   applying the exchange rate of the
   Central Bank

                                                                                 12
MEXICO

                              • The exchange rate at which the
                                foreign currency in question was
                                acquired
FEDERAL FISCAL CODE :
Taxes and their accessories
must be incurred and paid     • The exchange rate published by
in local currency               the Central Bank on the day prior
                                to the day on which the taxes are
                                incurred

                                                                    13
MEXICO

Are exchange gains                                        • No grounds for taxing
obtained by a Foreign
Resident subject to
withholding tax?                                          • Except Mexican PE of a foreign
                                                            resident: applies same rules as
                                                            Mexican companies

   Esta foto de Autor desconocido está bajo licencia CC
   BY-NC

                                                                                              14
MEXICO

• Currency fluctuation is not a
  taxable event for Mexican VAT
  purposes

• As VAT is charged on a cash
  flow    basis,     any    exchange
  fluctuation on the transaction
  value, will constitute “tax base” to
  which VAT rate will be applied

                                         15
MEXICO

                                        Payment agreed in USD
           US Company                   and paid in USDn

                           Payment
Loan                       Principal+
                           interest

          MX Company

       Escenario 2: Loan

                                                                16
MEXICO

                                        Account
                   US Company           Receivable
                                        (AR)
                                   Payment
                                   Principal+
                                   interest

Account
                  MX Company
Payable (AP)

               Escenario 2: Loan

                                                     17
MEXICO

MX Resident                                       US resident
•   WHT on interest payments (tax rate            •   No Fluctuation effect
    applies    depending    on particular
                                                  •   No VAT effect
    circumstances and DTCs)
•   Considers taxable income exchange gains
    accrued or deducts exchange loss
•   Applies limits to deductions    of interest
    e.g. thin captalization limit
•   VAT on import of services; however by
    application of reverse charge mechanism
    no economic burden (for other type of
    transactions e.g.    leasing transactions,
    reverse charge is not aplicable)

                                                                              18
MEXICO

Hedges
• Since loan is agreed in USD and         • MEXCO requires a hedge
  interest is agreed at a variable rate   • Common instruments
  MEXCO requires to cover interest
  risk and currency risk                      Forward: covers currency risk
                                              Cross currency swap: covers currency
                                               and interest risk

                                          • MEXCO enters into the derivative
                                            transaction with a foreign Bank

                                                                                      19
MEXICO

Forward                                   Cross Currency Swap
• Qualifies as an equity derivative       • Qualifies as a debt derivative
• Currency derivatives have no            • Is taxed as interest; thus if a gain is
  source of wealth in Mexico; thus if a     triggered by the foreign Bank, it is
  gain is triggered by the foreign          subject to withholding tax
  Bank no withholding tax will apply
  in Mexico

                                                                                      20
Foreign Currency Issues – Argentine Perspective

                         Valeria Estathio, Buenos Aires
Argentina

           Restrictions to access the FX market

Since when?           September 2019

                          Effects

Importers of goods        Exporters       Payment of dividends
                                          royalties, services

                                                                 22
Argentina

Blue chip swap transactions [OUTFLOW]

                                        PURCHASE OF
            LOCAL    VEHICLE   AR$     SECURITIES WITH
            TRANSFERS PESOS             DUAL LISTING
            TO    BROKERAGE               THROUGH
            ACCOUNT                        BROKER

                                                          Gap between
                                                          official currency
                                                          rate and implicit
                                                          currency rate of
                                         LOCAL VEHICLE
                                                          approx. 100%
              LOCAL VEHICLE
             COLLECTS USD IN    USD           SELLS
                                          SECURITIES IN
                ARGENTINA                  ARGENTINA
              BANK ACCOUNT                AGAINST USD
               OR ABROAD                    THROUGH
                                             BROKER

                                                                              23
Argentina

  Blue chip swap transactions (Inverse) [INFLOW]

                                            PURCHASE OF
             USD                   USD     SECURITIES WITH
PARENT CO.         LOCAL VEHICLE
                   TRANSFERS USD
                                            DUAL LISTING
                                              THROUGH
                   TO BROKERAGE                BROKER
                      ACCOUNT
                                                             Gap between
                                                             official currency
                                                             rate and implicit
                                                             currency rate of
                                                             100%
                   LOCAL VEHICLE    AR$      LOCAL VEHICLE
                                                 SELLS
                     COLLECTS                  SECURITIES
                      PESOS IN                  AGAINST
                     ARGENTINA                 ARGENTINE
                   BANK ACCOUNT             PESOS THROUGH
                                                BROKER

                                                                                 24
Argentina

• INFLOW – Eg. Capital Contribution by foreign shareholder

     PARENT CO.
                                                        Convert USD into AR$ at the official
                                                        currency rate – Allows access to the
                                      Alternatives      FX market for repatriation
               CAPITAL CONTRIBUTION

                                                        Blue chip swap transaction – Saving in
                                                        terms of USD

        SUB.
                                                     Transfer of USD       Transfer of securities

                                                                                                    25
Argentina

• INFLOW – TAX IMPLICATIONS

• Income Tax: taxable gain resulting from the sale of securities
               [tax rate: 25% to 35% depending on accumulated net taxable income]
                 » Economic reality principle?

• Tax on credits and debits on local Bank accounts: 0.6%
                 » Impact of this tax depends on the structure of the transaction

                     Transfer of USD vs transfer of securities

• No tax implications on VAT and Gross Income Tax

                                                                                    26
Argentina

• INFLOW – Blue chip swap performed by non resident shareholder
    PARENT CO.
                                     USD               Purchase of securities with dual listing
                                                       through broker

  LOCAL VEHICLE
                                      AR$              Parent Co. sells securities in Argentina
                                                       against pesos through broker
                           E.G. CAPITAL CONTRIBUTION

Aspects to consider: - Purpose of the transaction
                                                                      EXEMPTION
                     - Risk of PE?
                                                                      INCOME TAX
                     - Corporate law requirements

                                                                                                  27
Argentina

   Blue chip swap transactions [OUTFLOW] – E.g. Payment of
   dividends, royalties, services to related parties
                                                    PURCHASE OF
                          LOCAL VEHICLE
                           TRANSFERS        AR$    SECURITIES WITH      Gap between
                                                    DUAL LISTING
                            PESOS TO
                           BROKERAGE
                                                     THROOUGH           official currency
                                                      BROKER
                            ACCOUNT                                     rate and implicit
                                                                        currency rate of
                                                                        approx. 100%

                                                       LOCAL VEHICLE

              USD
                          LOCAL VEHICLE
                         COLLECTS USD IN
                                            USD             SELLS
                                                        SECURITIES IN
                         ARGENTINA BANK                  ARGENTINA
PARENT CO.   DIVIDENDS     ACCOUNT OR                   AGAINST USD
                             ABROAD                       THROUGH
             ROYALTIES                                     BROKER
             SERVICES

                                                                                            28
Argentina

• OUTFLOW – FX Restrictions

The performance of blue chip swap transactions prevents the local
entity and its related parties to access the official FX market (e.g. for
payment of imports) for 180 días (90 days prior to the swap and
commitment for 90 days after the transaction)

     Crypto?             Argentine Central Bank issued regulations
discouraging its offer by local banks

                                                                            29
Argentina

• OUTFLOW – TAX IMPLICATIONS

• Income Tax: loss derived from the sale of securities

                     Before 2018    Challenged by Tax Authority
                                    Recent case law allows deduction

              After 2018     “Specific” loss vs “ordinary” loss
                              FX losses vs losses from sale of securities

                                                                            30
Argentina

• OUTFLOW – TAX IMPLICATIONS (Cont.)

• Tax on debits and credits on local Bank accounts: 0.6%

                Effective impact 1.2%

      Investment via mutual funds

• No tax implications on VAT and Gross Income Tax

                                                           31
Foreign Currency Issues – Brazilian Perspective

                          Lavinia Junqueira, Sao Paulo
The Brazilian FX market

• Regulated market:
   • National Monetary Council / Central Bank
• Purchase and Sale of BRL only with authorized intermediaries
• FX transactions reported to Brazilian Central Bank and subject to
  tax (IOF/Exchange)
• Local transaction tax/cost basis in BRL

                                                                      33
The Brazilian FX market

• Dec. 2021  Changes to the regulatory framework
1. Bank account in foreign currency

2. Non-resident bank account with the same treatment of resident’s bank accounts

3. Payment orders in Brazilian Reais

4. Outflow of funds as profits, dividends, interest, amortization, royalties, scientific, administrative and similar technical
    assistance services with no prior registration in the Central Bank

5. Authorization of private offsetting of credits

6. Payments in foreign currency

7. Financial institutions allowed to allocate, invest and destinate the funds to credit and financing operations abroad

8. Peer-to-peer purchase and sale of foreign currency in cash up to US$ 500

9. Elimination of the restriction on the use of proceeds held abroad by exporters.

                                                                                                                                 34
The Brazilian FX market

• Mar. 2022  Changes to the IOF/Exchange rules
          IOF/Exchange / Year          2021     2022    2023    2024    2025    2026    2027    2028    2029
  Exports                               0%       0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%
  Imports                               0%       0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%
  Dividends/Interest on Equity          0%       0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%
  Capital increase/decrease                                                                             0.38
                                       0.38%    0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0.38%
                                                                                                          %
  Inflow and outflow of loans with a
                                          6%     0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%     0%
  tenor up to 180-days
  Inflow and outflow of loans with a
                                          0%     0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%     0%
  tenor above
  Investment in financial portfolios in
                                          0%     0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%      0%     0%
  Brazil (Resolution 4,373)
  Exchange transactions with credit,
  debt, and prepaid cards for travels 6.38%     6.38%   5.38%   4.38%   3.38%   2.38%   1.38%    0%     0%
  abroad.
  Purchase of foreign currency or
  transfer of funds to foreign accounts. 1.1%   1.1%    1.1%    1.1%    1.1%    1.1%    1.1%     0%     0%

  Other exchange transactions          0.38%    0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0.38%   0%

                                                                                                               35
Case Study – Capital Cost Basis in Brazil
                       Base Case
          D0                  Dn         $ 100
     Foreign                Foreign      Capital    Buyer
    Company                Company       = BRL
$ 100          = BRL                     1000
                                                               Even though there is no gain in
Capital        500                                             USD the foreign investor pays
                                                               capital gain tax in Brazil on the
    Brazilian                                      Brazilian   BRL gain
    Company                                        Company

Description                 BRL             USD                Possible alternatives:
Sale Price                  1000             100               • International trade financing
                                                                 in USD
Cost Basis                  -500             100               • Debt financing in USD
Capital Gain                 500              0                • Holding vehicle abroad
                         15% to 22.5%
                          capital gain

                                                                                                   36
Case Study – Treatment of Loans in Brazil
                                                      Debt
        D0                             Dn
    Foreign                        Foreign
   Company                        Company                    BRL 500 foreign exchange loss is:
                                                             • deductible for corporate income tax purposes
$ 100          = BRL         $ 100           = BRL             under the real profit regime (34%) (subject to
Debt           500           Debt            1000              thin cap) (cash basis; possible to choose
                                                               accrual basis on an annual basis)
   Brazilian                      Brazilian                  • not subject to Brazilian withholding tax
   Company                        Company
                                                             Foreign exchange gain is:
 Description             BRL             USD                 • taxable for corporate income tax purposes
 Principal                -x-             100                  under the real profit regime (34%) and
                                                             • PIS/COFINS (4.65%) (subject to thin cap)
 Cost Basis               -x-             100                  (cash basis; possible to choose accrual
 Tax                      -x-               0                  basis)
  Thin capitalization limite 2Debtx1Equity (non-tax
        haven); 0.3Debtx1Equity (tax haven)

                                                                                                                37
Case Study – Holding Company
                      Why hedge?                      Divestment Alternative 1
Holding Company       • Keep USD cost basis up-
                                                                 $ 100
        D0               to-date.
                                                     Foreign     Capital    Buyer
                      • Financial reasons.
     Foreign          Alternatives for hedging:     Company      = BRL
    Company           • By BR Company: taxable                   1000 $ 100
              BRL x      (34% + 4.65%)                                 Capital
$ 100
              USD     • By Holding Company
Capital
              hedge        • In BR Exchange: 0%                            Foreign
     Foreign               • Over-the-counter:                             Holding
     Holding                 10% (no-tax haven)
                  BRL x    • BR fund: 15% (no-tax                      $ 100
$ 100      = BRL USD         haven)                  Indirect          Capital
Capital    500    hedge • Abroad: no BR tax.         Sale not
                                                       yet                 Brazilian
   Brazilian                                        taxable in             Company
                       Brazilian                      Brazil
   Company
                        Market

                                                                                       38
Case Study – Holding Company

                            Divestment Alternative 2

                                     $ 100
 Foreign                 Foreign     Capital     Buyer
                                                               By
Company                 Company
                                     = BRL                     • Interposing a holding
     $ 100                           1000                         company
                                          $ 100        = BRL   • postponing the direct
     Capital
                                          Capital      1000       investment into Brazil to a
 Foreign                                                          future merger
                                                Brazilian
 Holding                                                       • maintaining the USD value
                                                Company
                                                                  in the holding Company,
           Merger
                    Description         BRL            USD     = the foreign investor keeps
Brazilian                                                      the USD cost basis
Company             Sale Price          1000           100
                                                               allowance
                    Cost Basis          -1000          100
                    Capital Gain          0              0
                               No capital gain tax

                                                                                                39
Foreign Currency Issues – Ecuador Perspective

                            Juan Gabriel Reyes, Quito
ECUADORIAN BACKGROUND
•   Year 1999        1 US Dollar = 3.500 Sucres.

•   Year 2000        Inflation reached 91%.

•   January 9, 2000: On national television, the President of Ecuador announced the following:
     - US Dollar is now the official currency.
     - Official exchange rate: 1 US Dollar        25.000 Sucres.
     - Retention of all Sucres and US Dollars in Ecuadorian banks of more than USD 500.

•   March 13, 2000: Entry into force of the Law for the Economic Transformation of Ecuador
    (Trolleybus Law), through which more than 20 laws were amended.

•   At this moment most of Ecuadorian private banks had declared bankruptcy or become state-
    owned; many people lost their life savings.

                                                                                                 41
ECUADORIAN BACKGROUND

Consequences:

•   Inflation lowered from 91% to 3% – 4%.

•   Now, the US Dollar as official currency is more popular than soccer
         - 88.7% of Ecuadorians support dollarization. [Source: ASOBANCA]
         - 69% of Ecuadorians are soccer fans. [polling company: PIVOT]

•   No President of Ecuador has ever proposed to go back to an Ecuadorian currency;
    protecting dollarization is a common political offering among candidates.

•   All foreign currency gains / losses special tax treatment laws were repealed.

                                                                                      42
ECUADORIAN TAX TREATMENT
•   All currency exchange gains / losses are treated as income / expense.

•   Their taxability or deductibility depend on the nature or essence of the transaction.
     - Gains will always be taxable.
     - Losses will be deductible if the transaction that caused them had the purpose of obtaining,
       maintaining or increasing taxable income.

•   There are important differences in currency exchange gains / losses according to accounting rules
    vs. tax law; in case of controversy tax law must be applied:

    “ (…) for tax purposes, accounting standards (NEC) must take into consideration the provisions of the
    Internal Tax Regime Law and its Regulations. This implies that in tax matters, the accounting principles
    are subject to the provisions of the legal regulations.” [emphasis added]
                                            Appeal No. 601-2012, p. 37, National Court of Justice, December 17, 2013.

                                                                                                                   43
ECUADORIAN TAX TREATMENT

• Internal Tax Regime Law - Article 10.-

        “(…) for the purpose of determining the taxable base subject to this tax –income
        tax-, expenses and investments made for the purpose of obtaining, maintaining
        and improving income from Ecuadorian sources that are not exempt will be
        deducted.” [emphasis added]

• Regulations to the Internal Tax Regime Law - Article 28, paragraph 8, subparagraph a.-

       “Losses caused in case of destruction, damage, disappearance and other events
       that economically affect the taxpayer's assets used in the income-generating activity
       and that are due to fortuitous events, force majeure or crimes, in the part that has
       not been covered by indemnity or insurance are deductible.” [emphasis added]

                                                                                               44
FOREIGN TRANSACTIONS

US tax effects                           Brasil tax effects

                                        Argentina tax effects

             Corporation
  Location: United States of America     Mexico tax effects
    Currency: United States Dollar

                                                                45
FOREIGN TRANSACTIONS
           Corporation
Location: United States of America
  Currency: United States Dollar              Corporation
                                              Location: Brazil
                                              Currency: Brazilian real

                                               Corporation
                                               Location: Argentina
                                               Currency: Argentine peso

                                              Corporation
                                              Location: Mexico
          Corporation                         Currency: Mexican peso
       Location: Ecuador
  Currency: United States Dollar

                                                                          46
Foreign Currency Issues – U.S. Perspective

                   Aziza Yuldasheva, Washington, DC
U.S. Tax on Foreign Currency Transactions
                      Basic Principles
• All U.S. tax determinations must be made in a U.S. tax functional currency
  (determined separately from local GAAP, U.S. GAAP, IFRS, or local tax
  functional currency)
• Individuals and qualified business units (“QBUs”), i.e., corporations,
  partnerships, trusts, estates, as well as disregarded entities (“DEs”) and
  branches that are QBUs, can have a functional currency
• U.S. resident individuals, U.S. corporations, U.S. partnerships, and
  DEs/branches operating in the U.S – USD is generally required
• Foreign corporations, foreign partnerships, and DEs/branches operating
  outside of the U.S. – unless USD is otherwise required under special rules,
  functional currency is generally based on the economic environment and
  books and records

                                                                                48
U.S. Tax on Foreign Currency Transactions
                   Basic Principles (cont.)
• Nonfunctional currency cash, debt instruments, accounts receivable/payable
  (“AR/AP”), and currency derivatives—gain/loss related to FX fluctuations is
  computed separately
   • Generally ordinary income/loss (not capital and not interest, with rare
     exceptions)
   • Generally recognized on a realization basis; in some cases, must be M2M
     or can elect to M2M; in some cases, amounts may be deferred, disallowed,
     or otherwise not recognized
   • Generally taxed at a regular U.S. tax rate (except certain gains/losses of
     controlled foreign corporations (“CFCs”))
• Additional rules for gains/losses related to translation of earnings, assets, and
  liabilities of foreign corporate subsidiaries and flow through operations

                                                                                      49
U.S. Tax Implications of FX Markets
                            General Relevance
So, when is FX fluctuation relevant for U.S. tax purposes?

  CFC regime – U.S.                             •
                                                •
                                                    Translation of CFC’s earnings subject to U.S. tax
                                                    Tax on CFC’s unrepatriated earnings, including FX gains/losses on
  shareholder level                                 nonfunctional currency transactions, under “subpart F” or “GILTI”
                                                    regime
                                                •   Tax on FX-related change in value of previously taxed earnings upon
                                                    repatriation or certain other events
  Pass-through regime –
  U.S. partner/owner level                      •   Translation of income, assets, and liabilities of pass-through QBUs –
                                                    e.g., certain foreign partnerships, DEs, and branches
  (also applies to a CFC as a                   •   Tax on FX gains/losses recognized by such QBUs on nonfunctional
  partner/owner)                                •
                                                    currency transactions
                                                    Tax on partner’s/owner’s gains/losses related to translation of assets,
                                                    liabilities, and earnings of the QBUs upon remittances from or
                                                    dispositions of the QBUs
  Non-USD financial
                                                •   Tax on gains/losses on disposition of non-USD cash
  transactions entered into                     •   Tax on FX gains/losses on interest and principal of non-USD debt
  directly by U.S. taxpayers                        instruments (upon payment, modification, disposition, etc.)
                                                •   Tax on FX gains/losses on non-USD accounts receivable/payable
                                                    (payment, disposition, etc.)
                                                •   Tax on currency derivatives (timing varies)

                                                                                                                              50
U.S. Tax Implications of FX Markets
                          General Relevance (cont.)
• When else are U.S. tax rules implicated?
   • Special rules for hyperinflationary currencies
     •   “DASTM” rules for translating P&L and balance sheet from ARS or VEF to USD; annual gain/loss on
         remeasurement of ARS and VEF monetary assets/liabilities vis-à-vis USD
     •   Mark-to-market and special treatment of FX gain/loss on of debt instruments denominated in ARS or VEF
   • Effect of local currency-related restrictions on repatriation and payments
     •   Potential deferral of U.S. tax under subpart F
     •   Potential deferral of U.S. tax of direct income/expenses
     •   Potential taxable losses
   • Unique forms of investments and financial transactions
     •   Complex issues in characterization, determination of gain/loss, and taxation of investment mechanisms at
         foreign entity and/or U.S. affiliate level
   • Transfer pricing
     •   Pricing of intercompany FX/financial transactions
     •   Pricing of intercompany operating flows in currency controlled or devaluation environments
   • Foreign tax credits
     •   Credit for taxes on FX gains/losses and inflation adjustments

                                                                                                                    51
Select U.S. Tax Risks of FX Risk Management
•   Even if an entity manages its FX risk through natural hedging or derivatives, reducing its book and local tax exposure,
    the U.S. tax rules may, if not properly addressed, still result in significant tax costs
•   Thus, otherwise offsetting FX gains/losses may not offset for U.S. tax purposes and create tax whipsaws and
    tax leakage because of one or more of the following reasons:
    •   Amount: A particular gain or loss might not be recognized for U.S. tax purposes (e.g., if there is a disregarded
        transaction or if a loss is permanently disallowed)
    •   Timing: Otherwise offsetting gains and losses are recognized in different tax years for U.S. tax purposes (e.g., a
        gain is M2M or a loss is deferred)
    •   Characterization/tax rate: Otherwise offsetting gains and losses are taxed at different tax rates in the U.S. (e.g.,
        gain is included in subpart F income and loss is a tested loss)
•   Hedging rules are complex, and proper and timely HEDGE IDENTIFICATION is critical
•   Additional discussion points:
    •   Direct vs. back-to-back vs. proxy/synthetic hedging – U.S. tax comparison
    •   Balance sheet vs. cash flow vs. net investment hedging—U.S. tax treatment
    •   U.S. trade or business / PE risk if certain lending and/or FX activities of a foreign subsidiary are performed in the
        U.S.
    •   Mitigation strategies

                                                                                                                                52
Sample U.S. Tax Issues Related to Investments

• How to measure basis, value, FX gain/loss, and non-FX related
  gain/loss, particularly where the official exchange rate has limited
  applicability
• Characterization of investment vehicles, instruments, and income
  from the investments (e.g., debt, contingent debt, derivative, stock (incl.
  PFIC stock), partnership interest; FX vs. interest vs. market gain/loss)
• Who recognizes any gain/loss for U.S. tax purposes
• U.S. tax on distributions from foreign affiliates and contributions to
  foreign affiliates involving investments
• Denomination of debt instruments

                                                                                53
Disclaimers
Disclaimer for Speaking Engagements including Deloitte Speakers Only:
This presentation contains general information only and Deloitte is not, by means of this presentation, rendering
accounting, business, financial, investment, legal, tax, or other professional advice or services. This presentation
is not a substitute for such professional advice or services, nor should it be used as a basis for any decision or
action that may affect your business. Before making any decision or taking any action that may affect your
business, you should consult a qualified professional advisor.
Deloitte shall not be responsible for any loss sustained by any person who relies on this presentation.
Disclaimer for Speaking Engagements including both Deloitte and Non-Deloitte speakers:
This presentation [and related panel discussion] contains general information only and the respective speakers
and their firms are not, by means of this presentation, rendering accounting, business, financial, investment,
legal, tax, or other professional advice or services. This presentation is not a substitute for such professional
advice or services, nor should it be used as a basis for any decision or action that may affect your
business. Before making any decision or taking any action that may affect your business, you should consult a
qualified professional advisor. The respective speakers and their firms shall not be responsible for any loss
sustained by any person who relies on this presentation.

                                                                                                                       54
Questions?

             55
For More Information
Gabryela Valencia Ayala has a Law Degree from Universidad Panamericana (Mexico City) and
an L.L.M. in International Tax Law by the Vienna University of Economics and Business. She
has been a tax advisor since 2007 and her experience comprises tax consulting services for
domestic and cross-border transactions. She is currently partner of the tax area of Valencia del
Toro & Professionals, S.C.

Valeria Estathio is partner at O´Farrell (Buenos Aires, Argentina) since 2014. Her practice
includes tax advising in local and cross border transactions as well as tax litigation. She has a
Law Degree from Universidad de Buenos Aires, an LLM in Law & Economics from Universidad
Torcuato Di Tella (Buenos Aires) and an LLM in International Taxation from New York University.

Lavinia Junqueira, Partner | Junqueira Ie Advogados, São Paulo, Brazil
Mother, entrepreneur, environment guardian, advisory board member & lawyer
LLB | University of São Paulo (USP)
Master in Economics | Pontifical Catholic University of São Paulo (PUC/SP)

                                                                                                    56
For more information
Juan Gabriel leads Pérez, Bustamante & Ponce’s tax practice for the last 20 years. His work
focuses in tax planning and structuring matters, representing clients in administrative and
judicial tax claims. He provides tax analysis for M&A and helps defining structures to streamline
the tax cost and minimize risks. In recent years, Juan Gabriel has achieved wide recognition in
matters relating to advising high-net-worth individuals on estate planning, corporate governance
and wealth structuring.

Aziza Yuldasheva is an international tax principal in Deloitte’s Washington National Tax office.
She advises companies regarding foreign currency transactions, cross-border financing, and
global treasury operations. She assists multinationals in setting up tax-efficient cash pooling
arrangements, hedging programs, and collection/payment centers. She also provides tax advice
on treasury matters related to M&A transactions, internal restructuring, and repatriation.

                                                                                                    57
For more information
Sam Kaywood has a B.S. before attending Emory Law School, where he graduated in 1986.
Sam is a frequent lecturer and speaker on international tax and tax issues arising from inbound
investment, intellectual property and outbound operations and particularly active in matters
relating to Latin America. Sam is a member of the State Bar of Georgia, the American Bar
Association, and the International Bar Association, and is active with the Southeast Branch of
the International Fiscal Association. Sam is the former Chair of the Committee on U.S. Affairs of
Foreigners and Tax Treaties, which is part of the Tax Section of the American Bar Association.
Sam is also an Adjunct Professor at Emory University School of Law where he teaches
International Taxation.

                                                                                                    58
You can also read