Are Reckless Pitbull Owners Behind Dyster's Proposed Animal Shelter - THE TRUTH IS ALWAYS FAIR
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
THE TRUTH IS ALWAYS FAIR FREE JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 VOL. 16, NO. 01 FREE Are Reckless Pitbull Owners Behind Dyster’s Proposed Animal Shelter...?
2 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 Is Dyster’s Proposed $3.2 Million Animal Shelter Plan For the Pits? Anna M. Howard Niagara Falls - Is Mayor Paul A. Dys- ter planning to open a city taxpayer funded animal shelter within the next two years and is the city’s troublesome pit bull pop- ulation the real reason for the mayor’s dog pound dream? On November 14 Channel 2 News re- porter Jeff Preval’s story, “Mayor proposes $3.2 mil for possible animal shelter” re- ported that the S.P.C.A. was expected to Mayor Paul Dyster said he may end its relationship with Niagara Falls by build a taxpayer funded animal 2017, and that Mayor Dyster had ear- shelter in Niagara Falls - if he marked $3.2 million for a city shelter. can’t work matters out with the Preval noted that, “$3.2 million is only an estimate at this time.” SPCA. The mention of “Mayor Dyster” and on a porch with pit bulls we know what we “$3.2 million” and “estimate” in the same have, a drug house, right?” story should make city taxpayers nervous. Was the mayor pointing out that there The mayor has earmarked $1.6 mil- is an illegal drug problem or a dog control lion of casino dollars for 2015 and again problem? Was he linking illicit drugs to Mayor Paul Dyster said that a number of Pit Bulls on a porch gener- in 2016 to support his possible animal troublesome dogs? And is he more con- ally indicates that home is a drug house. shelter. cerned about caring for the dogs than re- On December 17, Mayor Dyster ap- ficer and Amy Lewis, the S.P.C.A. direc- It’s nothing short of outrageous that moving the drug problem that it’s peared on the Tom Darro show for his tor. the city, at this time in their fiscal history, connected to? usual, but irregularly scheduled, WJJL Casale owns a rescued pit bull and is even considering taking on the business Are pit bulls the real, and hidden, rea- radio appearance. said, “A dog bites more out of fear…if you of animal sheltering whether it’s a city run son for the mayor’s move to put the cost In response to Darro’s question re- give it love and compassion it will show facility or “a contract with a not for of an animal shelter on the backs of city garding the mayor’s animal shelter plans, you all the love and compassion you could profit.” taxpayers? the mayor laid out what he expected to do want.” Whatever problems exist between the How much of this is a Dyster negoti- if he couldn’t reach an agreement with the Lewis said of pit bulls, “A dog can be S.P.C.A. and the city are not insurmount- ating ploy to get a better contract with the S.P.C.A. Dyster told Darro, “The S.P.C.A. violent in the same way a person can be S.P.C.A? One thing is certain is that if is moving toward no-kill and that’s a good violent. You wouldn’t judge the entire race Dyster does build an animal shelter, it will thing…if the they want to work it out (a on the actions of a single person.” cost the city millions of dollars to operate. contract) we will work it out.” Officer Bower noted that 60 percent A December 28 Niagara Gazette arti- Dyster said he had a trained police of- of the “loose dog calls” in the city involve cle by Philip Gambini titled, “As S.P.C.A. ficer to handle animals, a vehicle for ani- pit bulls. He called the breed “gentle gi- of Niagara deals with surplus of pit bulls, mals and added “we’ve put a place marker ants” saying, “They are some of the most officials defend breed” contained two es- of $1.6 million of casino funds in the next loving dogs I’ve ever come across.” sential takeaway points: pit bulls represent two budgets for a building…we may get a In the wake of the Channel 2 story, the the largest percentage of city dog calls, not for profit to operate it on contract…we mayor’s remarks on Darro, and the and pit bulls are lovable, misunderstood need to get a building or use a current Gazette’s pit bull feature we suspect that animals that make good family pets. building.” someone or some group are salting the To drive home the point of pit bull The question may very well be: Dyster also said something rather local media with information to support lovability the article quoted Kelly Casale, Who is more competent to take strange while on Darro as he described the the Dyster animal shelter plan. the S.P.C.A. adoption director, Dave care of abandoned dogs in Ni- dog control problems of Niagara Falls. He And why would that be? Bower, a city police officer and animal of- agara Falls - the SPCA or the said, “When you see guys sitting around Well, consider the money at stake…at city? least $3.2 million by the mayor’s admis- sion, just to get started. NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER Consider that a shelter – whether city run or “on contract with a not for profit” – able. The mayor needs to compare the cost of a city animal shelter with the an- “The Truth is Always Fair” would require a director, employees, con- nual cost of the SPCA which is less than sultants, a building, equipping the build- $200,000 per year. ing, vehicles, insurance, utilities, Now imagine what the cost of operat- CHAIRMAN & EDITOR IN CHIEF promotion and advertising, legal and vet- ing a municipal animal shelter will be with Frank Parlato erinarian services with all the infrastruc- a dozen employees, food, veterinary care, ture and bureaucracy that comes with it. heat, air conditioning, equipment, and sup- PUBLISHER Salaries, contracts, services. We know plies. Peter Mio where this is heading: straight onto the Four city employees alone (not any- backs of city taxpayers. where sufficient to run an animal shelter), As for the non-stop Dyster adminis- with benefits, will surpass the cost of the MANAGING EDITOR SENIOR EDITOR tration mantra that, “These are casino SPCA contract. Dr. Chitra Selvaraj Tony Farina funds not taxpayer dollars” the Reporter It is inconceivable that a city-run ani- continues to insist, “It’s all taxpayer funds mal shelter will cost less than $1 million when the city receives, administers or per year. PHONE: (716) 284-5595 spends it.” We recommend that the Dyster ad- The Gazette recently, and much to ministration do all it can to reach an agree- their credit, wrote in two articles that city ment with the animal care and control P.O. Box 3083, Niagara Falls, N.Y. 14304 bed tax money (with regard to the New professionals of the Niagara County Phone: E-mail: news1926@gmail.com Year’s Eve guitar drop) was unquestion- S.P.C.A. Website: www.niagarafallsreporter.com ably city taxpayer money because all city All contents copyright © 2014 Niagara Falls Reporter Inc. money is taxpayer money and must be spent responsibly.
3 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 Bite Statistics to Sink Your Teeth Into Pit bulls bite. A lot. No matter how you crunch the num- bers, pit bulls are represented all out of proportion to other dog breeds when it comes to biting. It leads the list in unprovoked attacks, Pit Bulls may be every bit as loving as any other breed of dog, but when they are ill-trained, or if they get angry or frightened and bite, as dog sometimes do, they are deadly. They have robust jaw strength, a deadly bite style, tenacity and a high tolerance to pain. attacks on other dogs, mauling and fatal at- tacks on people. The “pit” fans like to attribute human characteristics to these dogs saying, “they’re like people, treat them nice and they’ll love you in return.” from 2005 to 2013 pit bulls killed 176 The problem with that logic is that it’s Americans. false on its face: a dog is not a human. You Suggested solutions to the pit bull cannot equate an animal’s behavior with problem have included sterilization, spe- human behavior whether that animal is cial insurance or permits to own one, and licking your hand or biting it off. outright banning of the breed on a commu- Pit bulls make up 6% of the dog pop- nity basis. Pit bulls have been banned in ulation and are responsible for 68% of dog Ontario, Canada. attacks and 52% of dog-related deaths While neutering is popular with many since 1982 as reported in a Time magazine dog owners, statistics show that pit bulls story “The Problem With Pit Bulls” by are neutered at only 20% the rate of other (Above) The Our Gang Comedy Charlotte Alter, June 20, 2014. breeds due to the fact that many owners films featured a Pit Bull named An April 2011 issue of Annals of Sur- prefer not to sterilize the animal. “Pete”. (Right) A Chinaman in the gery reported that “these breeds should be Ten years ago a rash of pit bull inci- old west, with his Pit Bull. regulated in the same way other dangerous dents prompted then city administrator species, such as leopards, are regulated.” Dan Bristol to consider pursuing an ordi- That report was shared with Time maga- nance to address the city’s pit bull prob- zine by PETA, the animal-rights organiza- lem. Those discussions to work toward a tion. legal solution faded away. The city’s pit The DogsBite.org site reports that bull problem remains. A Pit Bull attacks its owner.
4 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 New Council Chairman Touma to Create Financial Oversight Panel Tony Farina With the City of Niagara Falls facing severe budget challenges in the coming years, there is no better time than now for city leaders to work together to get the city’s fiscal house in order before it comes tumbling down under the weight of grow- ing structural deficits, dwindling reserves, declining property values, and gridlock fueled by the lack of trust on many issues between the mayor and the council. Fighting over the tax cap, how to spend casino money, and how to deal with labor costs, the mayor and city lawmakers Andrew Touma was the top have basically been unable to find a way vote getter in the primary and out of the growing crisis and the council general election among a ro- even spurned the mayor’s request for seven people, and they will work with bust field of council candidates guidance and possibly financial help from [Controller] Maria Brown to gather and last year. the state through the governor’s new Fi- review the information they need to help nancial Restructuring Board. us deal with the problems we are facing Sam Fruscione who was seen as a casu- But on Monday night, the Niagara and make suggestions,” said Touma. “It alty of the fight over the Hamister hotel Falls City Council may have taken a step is not the state’s Financial Restructuring project. While he was expected to form a that could help ease tension between Board (which Touma favored) but it is an- new council majority with Walker and Mayor Paul Dyster and city lawmakers by other option to take a look at our prob- Grandinetti in lockstep with the mayor, installing independent-minded Andy lems.” Touma has shown a strong independent Touma as chairman in a unanimous vote, Touma says he hopes the new com- streak and has demonstrated a willingness succeeding Charles Walker who was mittee will be able to begin its work soon, to look at both side of an issue before often aligned with Mayor Dyster. Walker probably within a month, and he pledged making a decision, voting no on the joined Dyster ally Kristen Grandinetti and to keep his fellow lawmakers informed mayor’s request for $26,000 in taxpayer frequent mayoral critics Glenn every step of the way on the review and money to fund the Hard Rock’s New Choolokian and Bob Anderson in sup- discussions with the administration as the Year’s Guitar Drop. Eventually lawmak- porting Touma as chairman for a one-year oversight process goes on. ers, including Touma, approved $10,000 term. As he has been recently, Touma “We need common ground, and we for the event. would be the critical third vote for any need the mayor to work with us,” said Touma has a long history as a teacher legislation before the council, but as Touma. “The mayor has to realize we and educator and holds two master’s de- chairman he will likely have a stronger [the council] have a voice, and he must re- grees in education from Niagara Univer- voice in shaping that legislation with the spond in such a way that we know he is sity. He currently serves as a teacher on administration as he works to build con- listening. The only way to make this hap- special assignment at LaSalle Preparatory sensus. pen is with common ground. He should School. He is a former assistant principal “I am looking forward to the chal- hold us accountable and we should hold at North Tonawanda Middle School and lenge and the opportunity to help our city him accountable. But we need to find was dean of students from 2007 – 2011 at move forward, and I am grateful for the common ground over the next several Gaskill Preparatory School. support I have received from my fellow years to get things done.” Touma knows that in order for Niag- lawmakers,” said Touma after Monday’s One of the biggest challenges the city ara Falls to escape its current financial cri- vote. “I feel I am prepared for the posi- faces in dealing with the growing finan- sis, it will take more than future tion and I want to make sure my col- cial crisis is the $60 million share of the development projects that have yet to leagues on the council are kept abreast of budget committed to labor contracts, by begin to deliver their benefits. It will take what’s going on every step of the way as far the largest piece of the spending plan. consensus building among leaders and se- we begin our journey together.” “We have to open this up [labor rious discussion with all of the parties at Touma says one of the first things he costs] and take a look at the costs and dis- the table, including labor, to ensure the will do is establish an oversight commit- cuss the need for both sides to make con- city’s future short of a state-imposed con- tee made up of experts in financial mat- cessions to build for the future,” said trol board if it can’t meet its obligations. ters from the private sector who can make Touma. “There are tough decisions to be That’s almost the case in Lockport where informed recommendations to the city made and it will take some time but we the state comptroller is overseeing the and the council on how to deal with the must begin the task.” city’s financial operations after approving many fiscal challenges ahead. Touma was first elected to the council a loan program to keep the city from “It will be a group of about six or a year ago, succeeding long-time member going under. (Left) New York State Assembly- man John Ceretto (R.-Lewiston) was joined by his wife Beth as he was sworn into a third term on Sunday by Niagara Falls Chief Judge Mark Violante. They were joined in Ceretto’s Niagara Falls office for the occasion by Dr. Kevin Bakus, senior pastor at Bible Presbyterian Church of Grand Island. Ceretto said he plans to hit the ground running dur- ing the new legislative term in Al- bany.
5 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 What’s to Become of 2015? (The Niagara Falls Reporter, as other accomplished by awarding the incentives and operate the train station. publications sometimes do, is making its in the first place. The Dyster administration will hire a annual predictions at the beginning of the There will be no effort by the mayor consultant to manage the train station new year. Come back next year at this to raise private sector funds for the 2015 once it’s open. With no consultant money time and see how many of them come Hard Rock Guitar Drop and the mayor to access within a deficit budget it will be true.) and council majority will continue to use drawn from casino funds. The mayor will Niagara Falls Mayor Paul Dyster will casino or bed tax funds to gift the Hard do this while chanting his mantra “it’s not continue to use casino cash, casino fund Rock because “it’s not taxpayer money!” taxpayer dollars.” interest, and bed tax dollars exactly as he The mayor will seek his usual large The Dyster administration, after pleases while claiming, “It’s not taxpayer campaign contributions from the fire de- spending more than $100,000 for parking money.” partment PAC but he’ll be denied as the studies, will hire a consultant to manage The mayor will come out of the gate firemen throw their support to another the city’s “parking plan.” The consultant in early spring with a street paving and re- candidate…unless the mayor makes labor and parking plan overhead will consume pair program targeting key city voting concessions that fly in the face of all he most of the parking receipts. districts. has said about city employees being the Old Falls Street will remain “shop- The 2015 budget will be manipulated root of all budget evils. less” as all tourism activity and visitor after April when it’s “opened” with The financial problems of Lockport dollars are directed to the State Park as The Reporter offers a few pre- money moved around like a pea under a will be reviewed with that review having planned. walnut shell exposing the 2015 budget dictions about next year, which, possible significant impact upon the Dys- Development in the Military Road process as the sham it truly was. incidentally, is a reelection year ter administration. area will continue to expand. Mayor Dys- All budget problems will be laid at for Mayor Paul Dyster. The trash and recycling ordinance ter will continue to pretend he played a the feet of city employees due to “em- will continue to limp along as fines are is- role in the development. ployee pay, pension and health care tually begin next year, the following year sued to ordinance violators resulting in The relationship between the Dyster costs.” The controller (the highest paid or never. confusion and upset for affected residents. administration and Seneca Niagara city hall employee) and council majority There will be plenty of well timed With the train station nearing com- Casino will remain non-existent as city (Charles Walker will receive lifetime “progress reports” on the Wonderfalls pletion, the hopes of the Dyster adminis- hall refuses to meet with the Senecas for health insurance for part time service) project between March and November. tration to secure federal money for its the benefit of the city. will join the mayor (the mayor will re- Nothing will be built next year. operation will vanish under the control of Mayor Dyster will continue to chase ceive lifetime health insurance for part There will be an abundance of photo- the Republican US Senate causing Dyster his Niagara Experience Center much the time service) in slamming the city em- ops and progress reports regarding the and the council majority to use casino same way Captain Ahab pursued Moby ployees throughout the year. train station as the project grows in cost. funds and casino account interest to open Dick. While blaming the city employees for The Underground Railroad Interpre- the budget problems, Dyster and his tive Center lawsuit won’t be settled and council majority will give favored em- the building will remain shuttered as the ployees raises, stipends and overtime work and expenses of the project’s com- while claiming that retirement costs for mission defy investigation. the city are out of control. Mayor Dyster will cut the ribbon to The concerns of there being no the Jayne Park John Maroon walking path “morals clause” in the city’s NFC loan to local media fanfare in the spring, se- program will be raised in the media but cure in his belief that he’s pleased the the mayor, as chairman of the NFC, will Cayuga Island residents with the ghastly ignore the matter and keep handing out "improvement" of Jayne Park and secured loans and grants to friends of his admin- their vote. istration. The mayor will continue to violate The mayor’s reelection campaign and the city charter by refusing to hire a city the city’s street paving, park maintenance engineer as he insists on using an engi- and all other programs will be coordi- neering consultant at greater cost to the nated in order for the mayor to obtain city taxpayer. maximum reelection benefit via media After handing a $20,000 retirement coverage. incentive to many city hall employees the There will be plenty of well timed mayor will slowly bring his favored re- “progress reports” on the Hamister hotel tired employees back into city hall as part project between March and November. of his “retire and rehire” program, which But it remains unclear if the hotel will ac- contradicts what Dyster claims to have
6 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 Astounding Difference in Price Paid, and Service Between Maid and Hornblower Frank Parlato As a result of robust bidding, the Canadians got more money and improved bid, it was strange, and provoked some criticism in this publication - although it After many claims to the contrary, services. was ignored elsewhere - how Glynn Hornblower Niagara Cruises proved that The NPC estimated they will net avoided competitive bidding in New York a company other than Maid of the Mist $300 million more over the lifetime of the after he lost the Canadian lease. could offer boat rides below the falls. Hornblower lease than what Glynn would At the time he lost the Canadian Last year was the first season for have paid with the lease he had signed- lease, Glynn was operating in New York Hornblower, who won a bidding contest and which was invalidated by the Minis- under a lease that dated back to 2002, one in Ontario in 2012 to offer boat tours fol- ter of Tourism following an expose in the he secured without bidding because he lowing an investigative series in this pub- Reporter and an investigation by the In- had the Canadian lease. lication that blew a hole wide open in the tegrity Commission of Ontario, led by New York state law requires compet- longtime and secretive lease process used Commissioner Lynn Morrison. itive bidding for leases and concessions to secure a monopoly for Maid of the Not only did the Canadians get more on state land, except in special circum- Mist for more than 40 years. money they also got a better product. stances - such as where no other company The combined ridership on both sides Some say the decades of monopoly could perform the services. of the Niagara makes it the second most told on Maid of the Mist's product. Glynn Since the only winter storage docks popular boat tour in North America be- operates antiquated boats. When he had and fueling facilities were in Canada at hind the Statue of Liberty tours and just both sides of the Niagara, he had no com- the time and, at that time, Glynn had the ahead of Alcatraz Island boat tours. pelling reason to make his tour excep- Canadian as well as the New York boat Hornblower Cruises, a San Fran- tional or offer products now newly tour concession, he would fuel and store cisco-based tour company, offers the introduced in Canada by Hornblower. his boats in Canada during the winter. tours to the Statue of Liberty and Alcatraz Glynn's boats are without bathrooms, Glynn procured the New York lease Island, making them the largest boat tour seats, handicap access, dry areas; there in 2002 --circumventing state finance law company in North America. are no evening or early morning tours and that requires competitive bidding -- by They proved they could pull it off in no timed tickets. making the argument that whoever has Niagara Falls - securing some 1.6 million James Glynn may have lost the The Maid of the Mist has one boat the Canadian lease must have the New customers in Canada this year, all without Canadian lease but he did well, tour – 20 minutes long and admission is York lease, since there was nowhere to a hitch and rivaling what the Maid of the very well, negotiating the New on a first come, first serve basis. During dry dock boats in the winter on the New Mist used to do in Canada before that York lease. holidays and weekends during the sum- York side. company lost its lease in Ontario. mer season, waits are three to four hours Angela Berti, spokeswoman for the While ridership was about the same payments before the company lost its to take the 20 minute tour. state park, said at the time that Glynn is in Ontario, the difference was -- the result Canadian lease. This does not happen in Canada. the only one who could provide the boat of competitive bidding - the amount of On the New York side, Gov. Andrew Hornblower has timed tickets. If you tour, because he has a lease on the Cana- money the Niagara Parks Commission of Cuomo chose not to allow the boat tour book the 3 pm tour, you board at 3 pm, dian side that "allows (N.Y.) Maid of the Ontario got for the boat tours operated by lease to go out to bid. One of the argu- without having to wait in line. Mist Corporation to dock its boats on the Hornblower-- more than $10 million - ments used to secure the no bid lease sta- “(We have) bathrooms, snack bars, Canadian side." which was three times what the Maid of tus for Maid of the Mist in New York was flat screen videos and multiple language So, because Glynn had the Canadian the Mist paid during its last running year that it was said nobody other than Maid video tours, disabled access, all the mod- lease, New York deemed in 2002, he did - 2013, in Ontario. of the Mist would be capable of success- ern features you would expect if you not have to compete for the New York Maid of the Mist owner and operator, fully operating boat tours under the falls don’t have a boat that is 40 years old", lease. James V. Glynn of Lewiston, had leases in New York. MacRae said of Hornblower's boats. But when he lost the Canadian side, on both sides of the border since 1971. He Hornblower proved this to be untrue And he has sunset tours and fire- by the state's earlier argument, Glynn lost the lease in Canada – after losing in a on the Canadian side, much to the Cana- works tours. should have lost the New York lease since bidding contest with Hornblower - and dian's profit. Glynn never had a night tour. the state had argued that whoever has the several other companies - in 2012. Maid The Reporter contacted Terry Still, with all these gains the Canadi- Canadian lease has to have the New York operated its final season in 2013 then MacRae, CEO of Hornblower, months ans made by putting their boat tour out to lease. This would have meant Horn- made way for Hornblower in Ontario. before Glynn was awarded the new no bid Maid of the Mist held onto its lease lease for Maid of the Mist in New York. in New York. MacRae told the Reporter he was With the new Ontario lease, Horn- willing to assume operations in New blower pays 22.5 percent of gross sales in York, guarantee there would be no inter- rent to the NPC. ruption of service, and pay $100 million Maid of the Mist pays eight percent more than Glynn's lease to the state of to New York State Parks. New York. The boost in rent in Ontario comes at Gov. Cuomo declined to consider an important time since the NPC had been Hornblower's $100 million offer. losing about $4 million per year in oper- in 2014, Hornblower paid more rent ations of its parks in Ontario. This extra to the NPC than the entire Niagara Falls money will aid in improving their parks State Park received from all combined and in the all-important competition for sources of revenue – parking, boat tours, tourism dollars, this could not have come souvenirs and concessions put together. at a better time. For years, the NPC got 10- 15 percent To win their bid, Hornblower guaran- rent from Glynn in Ontario. Glynn oper- teed more than $10 million per year for ated in secret with NPC commissioners the first five years of the lease, meaning who never disclosed terms of Glynn's the NPC will get from Hornblower's lease contract. A series of articles by the Re- alone a figure far greater than its recent porter about these secret arrangements on deficit and should now be able to run at a the Canadian side led to the dismissal of surplus. every NPC commissioner and resulted in Maid of the Mist in Ontario was pay- the Ontario Minister of Tourism, ing around $3 million per year in lease Monique Smith, ordering the boat tour out to bid.
7 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 A Tale of Two Boat Tours and the Companies that Provide Them Glynn's new Maid of the Mist lease The low four percent rent combined was canceled by the Minister of Tourism with the profits from the observation deck and every NPC commissioner who made things topsy-turvy in New York. worked to secure Glynn's secret rent re- It so worked out that the Landlord duction -- along with the NPC general (New York) actually paid the tenant manager and his assistant, were fired or (Glynn). resigned. When Cuomo awarded Glynn his And Ontario picked up $300 million new 30 year lease last year he raised the more than the Glynn lease that was can- rent from four percent to eight percent but celed. continued the plan to allow Glynn to keep Funny our reporting in Canada led to 75 percent of the observation deck excellent results. money. What happened in New York was So consider the differences: every bit as shocking. But nothing hap- Hornblower paid $10 million to the pened. NPC. Consider: Glynn held the boat tour Glynn paid $800,000. But this was lease on the New York side since 1971, offset by the $750,000 he took in from the paying 10 percent of gross sales from Observation Deck. Glynn wound up 1971 until 2002. sending a net check to New York for As the Reporter was first to expose, $50,000. Glynn saw his 10 percent rent secretly re- The single biggest attraction in the Hornblower cruises offer new boats with more amenities than the duced to 4 percent in 2002 - the same year falls is a big money maker for Ontario and Maid of the Mist New York officials said only Glynn could in New York it is a big money maker for operate in New York since he had the Glynn. blower should have been awarded the York $100 million. Canadian side. And it appears for the next 30 years, New York side - based on New York's ear- After the award to Glynn, Horn- Not only did they reduce his rent Canada parks will be getting more than lier argument- the "sole source" argument blower's MacRae reiterated he would pay from 10 to four percent, the state gave $10 million a year while New York will used by New York for Glynn. $100 million more in rent than Glynn. He Glynn control of the state-owned obser- get next to nothing for the most lucrative By logic one would assume that ei- sued to pay the $100 million and lost in vation deck and allowed Glynn to keep 75 state-owned attraction in Niagara Falls. ther Hornblower gets the American side State Court. percent of the revenue generated. More Over time this will give Canada a se- because you cannot build docks on the All of this would have gone mainly than a million people annually pay one rious financial edge. New York side, or, if you can build docks unreported except for the fact that the Re- dollar to use the observation deck. New on the New York side then it should go porter took an interest in these matters York, prior to 2002, kept all the money. out to bid. and published the terms of Glynn's leases; It was natural enough then that after the public never knew what they were Glynn lost the Canadian lease, Horn- getting for rent on their own park prop- blower said NY law required the New erty. York boat tours to go out to bid, since The Reporter learned that, for exam- Glynn got the New York lease in 2002 ple, back in 2007, Ripley Entertainment only because New York state argued they Inc. thought it might be able to provide a could not build winter storage docks on better boat tour in Ontario than Glynn. the US side. Instead of giving Ripley a chance to Now Hornblower had the Canadian bid, Niagara Parks commissioners stalled docks. Ripley while they secretly drafted a new However, when Glynn lost the Cana- lease for Glynn two years ahead of time. dian lease, New York did not use the same The commissioners secretly renewed argument for Hornblower they used for Glynn's lease on the Canadian side in Glynn. 2008 for 25 years, reducing his rent from Under the shepherding of Gov An- 15 percent to a sliding scale that bottomed drew Cuomo, it was discovered that out at 5.5 percent. docks could be built on the New York side The Reporter obtained the secret min- after all. utes of the NPC meetings that revealed Cuomo discovered they could build the terms of the lease. In the wake of our docks on state land at the site of the for- stories, local Ontario civic group, Pre- mer Schoellkopf Power Plant. And the serve Our Parks, began a letter writing state helped Maid of the Mist come up campaign. Park employees, facing layoffs with a $32 million plan to convert the for- and fewer hours, marched on the park en mer Schoellkopf Power Plant, on the masse. Citizens distributed our newspaper American side, into a winter storage fa- in Ontario. Links to our website were sent cility. out to thousands of people. Then, instead of putting it out to bid We shared proof that Glynn's rent had - since because now docks could be built been secretly reduced with the Toronto in New York - and therefore any number Globe and Mail, Canada's national news- of boat tour companies could compete to paper. They covered our story. Other offer tours, Cuomo decided not to put the Canadian papers followed suit boat tours out to bid, but declare it a "spe- And that's how Glynn lost his Cana- cial circumstance" and allow Glynn to dian lease. build docks for himself and not compete Amid this publicity, Ontario Integrity for best price and services. Commissioner Lynn Morrison ordered a Cuomo handed Glynn a 30 year lease forensic investigation by the Ministry of at eight percent rent, about a third of what Finance. Tourism Minister Monique Hornblower is paying in Canada. Smith ordered audits of park governance This decree by Cuomo cost New and procurement.
8 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 Dyster’s Use of Casino Cash for Cop Cameras Comes into Focus Anna M. Howard straight to the taxpayer casino cash and write a check for cameras. cameras. That’s not the question at the moment. Instead we have to ask why Dyster’s city hall is a closed envi- Dyster made this move and who will be Mayor Dyster plunked down ronment where cash flows like water for the camera supplier? $22,500 for police body cameras and he raises, stipends, overtime, consultants, And by the way, how are police did with casino cash. contracts and “transformative projects” cameras to be considered "economic de- Why did he raid the casino account such as the train station, courthouse and velopment". Dyster's argument against when he could have applied for federal soon to be Dyster Doghouse. the use of casino money when he doesn't grant money through an initiative Dyster is so insistent upon opening want it used is "It is not economic devel- launched by the Obama White House his own animal shelter that he earmarked opment." just last month? $1.6 million of casino cash in both the The entire process appears similar to Instead of seeking the federal funds, 2015 and 2016 city budgets. the mayor’s manner of purchasing $2.3 like other municipalities, he chose to run We have no issues with the police million of trash totes with casino money. In both instances there was no dis- cussion, no transparency, and a manufac- tured “sense of urgency”. One parting thought since the “casino cash for cop cameras” is a done deal with the taxpayer money already spent: maybe it’s time to put cameras in the city hall offices where the big deci- sions are made. It’s time for us to hear what conver- sations are taking place, what phone calls are being made and learn who the city government shot-callers really are. Property is the fruit of labor; Property is desirable; It is a positive good in the world. That some should be rich shows that others may become rich, and hence is just encouragement to industry and en- terprise. Let not him who is houseless pull down the house of another, but let him work diligently and build one for himself, thus by example assuring that his own shall be safe from violence when built. Abraham Lincoln March 21, 1864 Is government supposed to entertain the governed?
Guitar Drop Strikes Sour Political Note sociation in the city that could have be- Truly unfortunate was the political Anna M. Howard come involved in raising dollars and food fight that was touched off as the sponsoring the event? funding dispute generated news stories It was such a shame. Could the city-subsidized businesses about the disparity between the Ameri- All the unnecessary hand wringing on Third Street have worked to bring can and Canadian New Year’s Eve cele- and gnashing of teeth over the city fund- some heavy hitters to the table for a New brations. ing or not funding the Hard Rock Café Year’s Eve “Celebrate the First on Third” The American side isn’t as built up New Year’s Eve Guitar Drop. event? as the Canadian side and since that’s no While Mayor Paul Dyster pulled his Where were USA Niagara and their secret it shouldn’t be an embarrassment political punch by withdrawing his initial plans to develop a downtown Business in itself. It should be seen as a problem request for a $27,000 contribution from Improvement District with special to solve. the city’s bed tax account, the mayor events? What is embarrassing is the contin- eventually convinced the council major- Did anyone from city hall or the ual circular firing squad and lack of cre- ity to contribute $10,000 in bed taxes to- Hard Rock suggest anything more cre- ative thinking that’s part and parcel of ward the New Year’s Eve celebration. ative than “let’s have the taxpayers kick city government. The shame is that it didn’t have to go in again?” Maybe the Dyster administration can that way. Was the Hamister Group approached make a New Year’s resolution to find ap- Why didn’t the city work, during the as a sponsor? This would have been a propriate funding for the 2016 guitar course of the past year, to locate corpo- perfect opportunity for the group to in- drop. rate sponsors. Why didn’t the Hard Rock troduce themselves in the downtown, a They’ve got a one-year heads up. find corporate sponsors instead of asking downtown they will soon be locating in the city to pick up part of the tab? according to Mayor Dyster with a heav- This billion-dollar corporation, ily taxpayer subsidized hotel. owned by the Seminole Nation, operates How about Uniland and the Wonder- facilities across the globe and they could- falls project? Uniland’s project has been The Niagara Falls Hard Rock Cafe n’t manage this local lift? announced and supported by Governor celebrated the New Year by drop- If Hard Rock couldn’t step up fully Cuomo with major taxpayer contribu- ping a 10 foot Gibson Guitar from or completely then why didn’t Gibson tions. Did anyone dial Uniland’s num- a 120 foot scaffold. Niagara Falls Guitar Corp chip in? ber? taxpayers paid $10,000 for the There’s the one-of-a-kind location of Did anyone call the Maid of the Mist party. Niagara Falls, the billion Dollar Hard or Delaware North to see if they had an Rock Corporation and the world-class And yet, with all those big names on interest in coming aboard? “Because God has made us for Gibson guitar company --and yet it went the local playing field it came down to And, heaven forbid, did anyone con- Himself, our hearts are restless off the rails. the mayor and council majority raiding sider contacting Hornblower Tours? until they rest in Him.” Do we still have an active Attrac- the bed tax because “it’s not taxpayer Remember, folks: “Two nations one ― Augustine of Hippo tions Association or an active Hotel As- money” to throw a New Year's Eve party. attraction.” Palace Theatre to Stage ‘Harvey’ With Veteran Cast The Historic Palace Theatre will Chauvenet and Betty Chumley, Danielle presents the third show in their our White as Miss Johnson and, William 2014/2015 90th Birthday Season, HAR- Curr as the cab driver. VEY—a comedy in three acts, on Janu- Tickets are $20 for adults, $18 for ary 16th through January 18th, 2015. seniors, and $15 for students. Group Performances are Friday and Saturday at rates available. Tickets may be pur- 7:30 pm and Sunday at 3:00 pm. chased by calling (716) 438-1130, visit- Written by Mary Chase and directed ing the Palace BOX OFFICE Monday - by Steve Copps, HARVEY is a comedy Friday from 10 am – 2 pm, or at Mills about a man, Elwood P. Dowd, and his Jewelers. For more information visit our invisible friend Harvey the Pooka which website at inspired the 1950 film of the same name www.lockportpalacetheatre.org. starring Jimmy Stewart. The story cen- ters on Elwood’s sister, Veta Louise Sim- mons, and her concern for Elwood’s mental health as ‘it stands to reason no- body has ever seen a white rabbit six feet high.’ This production will star Eric Glynn as Elwood P. Dowd. Veta will be played by Jennifer Ossont while her daughter Myrtle Mae will be played by Amanda McNulty. The family attorney Judge Omar Gaffney will be played by City Court Judge, and Palace Board Member, William J. Watson. Rounding out the cast will be Stephen Smith as Dr. Chumley, Jake Hayes as Dr. Lyman Sanderson, Leanne Troutman as Nurse Kelly, Dan Urtz as Duane Wilson, Peg Merrill as both Mrs.
10 Three Sisters Islands Latest Casualty of State "Improvements" Approved by Dyster James Hufnagel walkways, which are fenced in so that visitors can no longer get anywhere near Mist and Delaware North and fattening the wallets of Cuomo campaign contrib- It appears that Three Sisters Islands, the river. utors, when completed, promises to fur- a major attraction in the Niagara Falls Posing as a tourist, this writer spoke ther isolate the millions of tourists who State Park, from now on will be closed to on the phone with a staffer at the Lehman visit Niagara Falls State Park every year, the public during the tourist off-season. Visitors Center in the park (which is now where they park, sightsee, eat, purchase Presently the stairway below the ex- referred to on official State Parks web gifts and souvenirs and then leave without panded parking area, as well as the nar- sites as the “Niagara Falls Visitor Cen- having need or reason to set foot in the row bridge affording access to the islands, ter”), who stated that the reason Three city. have both been gated off with heavy Sisters Islands is off-limits is because vis- It’s enough to make you wish there metal barriers bearing signs that forbid itors may slip and fall on the pavers made had been at least one local official in a po- trespass on the small, formerly naturally- slick with ice and accidentally fall into sition to influence these matters, to speak It’s shocking really: For the landscaped archipelago. the river above the falls. Seriously, that’s and act against the crass commercializa- first time Three Sisters Islands One of the most popular features of what he said. tion and the sequestration of tourist dol- are closed to the public. Why? one of the most popular parks in the “We check on it every morning, and lars there, which flow into the pockets of Because the super-expensive world, Three Sisters Islands draw a large on days when it doesn’t look too danger- Albany, James Glynn and Jeremy Jacobs $60 per square foot pavers, percentage of the millions who annually ous, we open it up so that people can walk instead of city merchants, restaurateurs that Albany consultants de- visit Niagara Falls State Park. Genera- around out there,” he added. and souvenir and gift shop-owners. And signed, for an Albany quarry to tions have reveled in the ability to get It is the $60 per square foot pavers in fact, there was. make the sale, are so slippery right out in the middle of the river rapids, now composing a labyrinth of ugly walk- $25 million, or well over half, of the that the Islands must be closed gamboling on well-worn pathways be- ways on the islands, conforming to an Al- Niagara Falls State Park Landscape Im- during winter and rainy days. tween ancient boulders which bore testa- bany-area landscape architecture firm's provements are funded through the Niag- The old limestone paths that ment to the primal forces of river erosion rigged specifications and purchased and ara River Greenway. Therefore, the entire were needlessly replaced had and glacial scouring. The three islands trucked in from an Albany-area quarry, multi-year undertaking, in application both heavy contributors to Gov. Cuomo's form, had to be approved by the Green- sure footing and served the were thick with trees, and just a few years recent successful re-election campaign, way Commission. public for a century without ago, a botanical study found each of the that are dangerously slippery when wet. On July 17, 2012, Greenway Com- having to close the Islands. islands supporting its own unique set of flora. During the winter months, that's most of mission Vice-Chair and Mayor of Niagara state and federal regulators? Have any Writers, poets, painters and photog- the time. So the net effect of the "im- Falls Paul Dyster presided over the Com- economic impact studies been done to de- raphers have been enraptured by Three provements", ironically, is to necessitate mission’s final discussion and vote on the termine if expanding parking and vending Sisters over the course of our history, the closure of the islands for safety pur- Niagara Falls State Park Landscape Im- in the park will affect businesses in the drawing inspiration from the unspoiled poses. provements plan. city?” beauty and unique and breathtaking com- Actually, we visited Three Sisters on According to the minutes of the According to the minutes, “Vice bination of river and rapids, sun and sky, several different occasions last month, on meeting concerning the Landscape Im- Chairman Paul Dyster called for a vote tree and rock. some days when the temperature was provements Plan, just the following two with a majority finding the project con- It was nice, but now it’s gone. well into the 40’s and there was no ice to questions were asked by Commissioners: sistent to the Niagara River Greenway Last year, pursuant to Gov. Cuomo’s be found anywhere. The barriers were al- “Are these projects just maintenance?” Plan.” Niagara Falls State Parks “Landscape Im- ways in evidence, while a lone worker in and “What is the period of time and how So for all the protestations on Mayor provements” Plan, Three Sisters Islands a State Parks pick-up truck slowly drove will the funding work?” Dyster’s part that he has no direct influ- were, in the opinion of many, ruined. back and forth past the entrance, clearly The following questions, apparently, ence on happenings in the Niagara Falls First, the treasured space was denuded of keeping an eye on the situation. were not asked: “Will there be an oppor- State Park, when he actually had an op- the bulk of its foliage. Then most of the The so-called “Landscape Improve- tunity for local citizens to provide input portunity to make a difference, when it aforementioned boulders were either ments” plan, in reality a massive refash- to the plan? Have the various projects, was most critical to the future of his city buried or hauled away. Bulldozers leveled ioning of the park towards the end of which involve substantial impacts on the and when it was still largely unnoticed by what was left to allow for ugly, artificial boosting the bottom lines of Maid of the landscape and river, been approved by the majority of citizens, he sat mute. More ‘Bad’ Improvements to Goat Island Night is soon to become day on Fred- tourist season. On the other hand, two erick Law Olmsted's Goat Island preserve large Delaware North trucks have been as enormous light poles are presently parked here for several weeks. When State being installed on Goat Island's south Parks is done, this formerly scenic area parking lots, as part of the Niagara Falls will be virtually indistinguishable from a State Park "Landscape Improvements" Walmart parking lot. Gov. Cuomo, Parks plan. Of course, Olmsted wanted Goat Is- Commissioner Rose Harvey and Regional land to be forested, and local residents Director Mark Thomas are the govern- have long been at a loss to understand why ment officials most responsible for this af- a sprawling parking lot is necessary at this front to our heritage, not to mention good scenic location, located far from attrac- taste, with the tacit approval of local tions on the other end of the island. Rarely politicians unfortunately too numerous to are more than a handful of vehicles parked list here. in this lot, even during the height of the
11 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 Choolokian and Council Made History with 2012 Fracking Ban Last month, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo an- lease recognizing the governor’s fracking ban. In the re- nounced his New York State fracking ban. lease the mayor noted that the city council had unani- But it was nearly three years ago that the Niagara mously passed a fracking ban in 2012. Falls City Council banned fracking and the treating and What the mayor might have mentioned in his press or transportation of fracking waste water/materials within release is that until his press release, following the gov- the city. ernor's fracking ban, he has not publicly supported the While the media and environmentalist have praised city's ordinance/ban. the governor’s ban, what has gone largely unnoticed is As those close to the passage of the Niagara Falls the groundbreaking city ordinance/ban that the 2012 fracking ban know, it was Choolokian who was the driv- council passed into law in March of that year. ing force behind the fracking ordinance passage. At the time the ordinance gained some positive na- Chairman Fruscione, Choolokian and Anderson tional attention, but here in Niagara Falls the ban attracted drafted the fracking ordinance and presented it to council mostly negative comments by some members of the com- colleagues, Charles Walker and Kristen Grandinetti, for munity and especially those in power at the Niagara Falls passage. Water Board. What makes the fracking waste water ban so signifi- Representatives and legal counsel from the Water cant, is that while Gov. Cuomo banned fracking in New Board visited council members Sam Fruscione and Glenn York State, he has not banned the treatment of fracking Choolokian after the ordinance passage, putting them on waste water. notice that a lawsuit was likely to be filed that would chal- With benefit of three years of hindsight it’s now easy lenge the frack banning ordinance and the council’s au- to see that the passage of the ordinance banning not only thority to issue the ordinance. fracking but the treatment in Niagara Falls of fracking Glenn Choolokian shepherded the fracking The three member council majority – Fruscione, waste was historic for Niagara Falls. ban in Niagara Falls. Choolokian, and Robert Anderson – refused to relent and the ordinance stood as written. Last month, Mayor Paul A. Dyster issued a press re- First Baby of 2015 At Memorial Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center greeted its first baby of 2015 at 2:03 p.m. Friday (Jan. 2) when Marissa Gilling- ham of Niagara Falls gave birth to son Brendan Alexander Man- gel. Brendan, shown here with his mother and father Harold Mangel Jr. in their private labor and delivery suite at Memorial’s Mary C. Dyster Women’s Pavilion, meas- ured 20 inches tall and weighed in at 7 lbs., 10 ounces. He was delivered by Dr. Donna Feldman. It is the policy of the Niagara Falls Reporter to accommodate publication requirements for St. Jude Novena prayer requests without charge. Donations are accepted. Thank You St. Jude for answering my prayer, J. S. J.
12 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER JAN 06 - JAN 14, 2015 Mafia 'Betray the Gospel,' Italian Bishops Say in Rare Rebuke By JOSEPHINE MCKENNA light the "painful evil" it caused. On Wednesday, the pope called for a ROME (RNS) Catholic bishops from "It is clear that this announcement will "conversion" from a corruption scandal link- the southern Italian region of Calabria have be like a sharpened sword that will injure ing Rome's politicians, a former right-wing broken their silence and spoken out against those in a situation opposed to the gospel," terrorist and other criminal elements. the "inhumane" power of the Mafia that the Calabrian bishops said in the document. In March, the Argentine pontiff met the dominates their poverty-stricken area. "It is here that the debate on the victims of Mafia violence and later called for The 12 prelates from the Bishops' Con- 'Ndrangheta begins. Those who are part of it the excommunication of the Mafia from the ference of Calabria endorsed a document not only betray the gospel but it is as if they church when he visited Calabria in June. condemning the local Mafia, or 'Ndrangheta, were trampling all over it every day." In the past, Italy's organized crime on Friday (Jan. 2), just two days after Pope The bishops expressed concern about groups have had a cozy relationship with the crime had now reached a "globalized" di- Francis took a strong stand on Mafia corrup- the impact of high unemployment and the Catholic hierarchy. Inside 'Ndrangheta, the mension and was finding allies on the fringes tion in Rome in a forceful New Year's Eve spread of political corruption in a region initiation ceremony is known as a ''baptism," of politics through corrupt and deviant allies message. where 'Ndrangheta has mushroomed into and for many members mob ties are no less in positions of power. Monsignor Salvatore Nunnari, president one of the most powerful organized crime sacred than their affiliation with the church. "The church salutes only the wounded of the Calabrian bishops, said the conference groups in the world through drugs and arms Newcomers must swear allegiance to St. man and shouts out his pain and indigna- believed the Mafia was "something inhu- trafficking, extortion and other operations. Michael the Archangel, the patron saint of tion," said the bishops, who referred to the mane," and church leaders wanted to spot- The bishops said the nature of organized 'Ndrangheta. spread of bribes and political favors. Musician With Down Syndrome to Perform, Inspire at Jewish Community Center On January 11, 2015 from 2-4pm “Hand workshops. Since March of 2000 he has per- Games ’99 Special Olympics in swimming, in Hand with Yad B'Yad: A Musical Per- formed in over 40 states and 13 countries. and numerous medals in alpine skiing, cross formance by Sujeet” will take place at the He is the recipient of 16 international and country running, and bowling. Maxine & Robert Seller Theatre in the Jew- numerous national awards for his music and This concert is part of the JCC Concert ish Community Center, 2640 North Forest self-advocacy, one of which is the Presi- Series, in cooperation with Yad B'Yad. There Road, Getzville, NY 14068). dent’s award received in Singapore in 2000. is a suggested donation of $18.00 at the door, Sujeet Desai is a 33 year old musician Sujeet has had two documentaries cre- with proceedings benefiting Yad B’Yad. Stu- with Down syndrome who has recently ated on his life, was featured in the Wall dents are free. Please join us for a light moved to Williamsville, NY. Sujeet plays Street Journal, the New York Times, and has kosher reception following the performance. seven instruments, including the Bb and bass appeared on national TV shows including To learn more about Sujeet please visit clarinet, saxophone, violin, trumpet, piano The View, 20/20, and Oprah Winfrey. In his his website www.sujeet.com and drums. A graduate of the Berkshire Hills spare time, Sujeet is also an accomplished Or find him on Facebook at Music Academy in Massachusetts, Sujeet athlete having achieved 3rd level 2nd Dan http://www.facebook.com/sujeetmusic travels worldwide to do inspirational solo Black Belt in Tae Kwon Do, and is a winner musical performances and self-advocacy of gold and silver medals in the World Memorial’s Competitive EDGE Sports Performance Program to Hold Open House The Competitive EDGE Sports Per- are committed to improving athletes’ per- formance Program will hold an open house formance through education, hard work, nu- from 6 to 8 p.m. Thursday (Jan. 8) at its new trition and injury prevention,” said Memorial location in the Niagara Falls High School Sports Medicine Director Tony Surace, Field House. M.Ed., A.T.C. “We use up-to-date training A service of Niagara Falls Memorial techniques for the dedicated athlete who Medical Center, the Competitive EDGE is a wants to work hard and become a better ath- dedicated sports performance program that lete in his or her desired sport.” helps athletes at all levels from across West- Thursday’s open house will feature in- ern New York increase their success on the formation and demonstrations on strength field, ice or court. training, Plyometrics, agility training, sports The program’s new home on the Niag- nutrition and Pilates, as well as the Compet- ara Falls High School campus features a itive EDGE’s ACL Bridge, Return to Throw- large open arena for training and a fully fur- ing and sport-specific training programs. nished weight room with Olympic Hammer Convenient access to the Niagara Falls Strength racks, cardio equipment, TRX total- High School Field House is available from body resistance exercise equipment, Pine Avenue via Packard Court, east of 39th weighted sleds, agility ladders and much Street. For information about the Competi- more. tive EDGE or Thursday’s event, call (716) “Our certified athletic trainers and cer- 215-0723. tified strength and conditioning specialists
You can also read