Abbotsford St Estate Renewal' to grow public housing - The Centre

Page created by Harvey Thomas
 
CONTINUE READING
Abbotsford St Estate Renewal' to grow public housing - The Centre
ISSUE 177 WINTER 2017
                                                       THE NORTH & WEST MELBOURNE NEWS IS PRODUCED BY VOLUNTEERS AT THE CENTRE

‘Abbotsford St Estate Renewal’ to grow public housing

Public Housing Renewal Program, North Melbourne, sketch plan ‘for discussion’                                                                                             Graphic: David Lock Associates

Katrina Kincade-Sharkey                            gram is part of the Victorian Government’s          DHHS called a public meeting in the grounds        notification and there was no appointed per-
                                                   $2.7 billion in support for social housing and      of the estate during April to deliver formal ex-   sonal contact with their landlord (the DHHS
                                                   homelessness and to renew existing houses           planation of this major lifestyle change for its   Director of Housing) or with the department’s

T
        he Department of Health and Human          on public housing estates across metropolitan       tenants. In leaflets distributed to the 60 or so   manager, stakeholder engagement, Lisa Taylor,
        Services’ communication difficulties       Melbourne and in regional centres of Victoria.”     people in attendance — several of whom were        although she did attend the meeting with sev-
        have devastated many of its North Mel-        This advice continues: “The renewal will         interested neighbours from adjacent streets        eral departmental staff, including a number of
bourne residents, with tenants facing re-hous-     result in a 10 per cent increase of social hous-    — DHHS says it is “… developing our plans          foreign language translators.
ing in potentially unfamiliar regions.             ing homes at each renewal estate.”                  to renew the Abbotsford Street site … and we          That meeting was the first of three planned
   Several dozen of the several hundred DHHS          That generalised, fairly curt notification to    want to work together with residents, local        ‘consultations with residents’ to assess their
residents housed in 16 blocks of apartments        the 108 letterboxed apartments provided no          services and council to decide how to create a     specific housing requirements, allegedly be-
within the Abbotsford, Haines, Curzon and          ability for residents to appeal proposals for       new, integrated neighbourhood”.                    fore any architectural plans are drafted for the
Molesworth streets triangle received initial       redevelopment. It was their first notification of      The leaflet continues, noting the site “…       site. Residents in attendance were asked to
redevelopment notification about their homes       a major life change, delivered to many people       consists of older public housing buildings that    report their specific requirements at the next
on a single typewritten sheet inserted within      who reportedly panicked.                            are rundown and have high maintenance costs.       meeting, but not given a date or location for
their quarterly housing newsletter delivered          Those English-language letters were              The site includes multi-storey ‘walk-ups’ —        that event.
mid-March.                                         received by a housing community of pre-             buildings commonly constructed in the early           DHHS plans to begin work on its Abbots-
   It said the blocks would be replaced within     dominantly disabled, aged and newly settled         1960s without lifts, making them inaccessible      ford Street Renewal by the end of 2017, leav-
the near future with “… vibrant, better-con-       residents, many of whom could not read or           to people with mobility issues, families with      ing little time for this desired ‘consultation and
nected, mixed-tenure neighbourhoods where          understand the details. Certainly included were     small children and elderly Victorians”.            planning’, given the physical and emotional
people can live in housing that is safe and se-    single paragraphs in several languages telling         Further: “We [DHHS] want to improve and         states of many residents.
cure, and meets modern standards”.                 readers where they could access translations of     grow social housing at this estate because it is
   DHHS simultaneously wrote to each of its        the circular, but no specific translations about    close to transport, education and work oppor-      Local residents’ concerns
tenants on that block, but gave no specific        their future homes were included on the notifi-     tunities, as well as support services.”            Neighbouring property owners and residents
timelines for their individual tenancies, al-      cation sheets.                                         Fortunately, the gardens info meet was held     were notified of DHHS public–private rede-
though it has said Abbotsford Street Estate will      Many worried tenants suspect restricted          on a sunny autumn day, with DHHS providing         velopment proposals in late May at a meeting
be completely rebuilt by 2020.                     future access to critical medical, educational      make-up artists to paint young children’s faces,   that several attendees said they’d only learnt
   In questions and answers for the community      and social services for themselves and/or their     while several translators were on hand to speak    of from community centres. Despite DHHS
released to the media on 17 March, DHHS            families in the wake of this ‘estate renewal’.      with parents in their birth languages.
says: “The Public Housing Renewal Pro-                Following its March letterbox circular              But tenants were given no new address                                     Continued on Page 5

COMMUNITY 3 • THE CENTRE 10, 20 • ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT 11 • EDUCATION & TECHNOLOGY 14 • SPORT & HEALTH 16 • TRAVEL & FOOD 18 • HISTORY 19
Abbotsford St Estate Renewal' to grow public housing - The Centre
22 NOTICEBOARD
   NOTICEBOARD                                                                                                                                   North
                                                                                                                                         North and WestandMelbourne
                                                                                                                                                           West Melbourne
                                                                                                                                                                     News News WINTER2017
                                                                                                                                                                            WINTER    2017

                                                                                    NOTICEBOARD
                                                                                    noticeboard

                                                       Please deliver contributions, letters
                                                                and feedback to:                                      News from Errol’s Angels
                                                               North and West Melbourne News                          Pam Every
                                                             58 Errol Street, North Melbourne 3051
                                                                Email: nwmnews@centre.org.au
                                                                     Telephone: 9328 1126
                                                       Copy deadline for Spring 2017 edition:
   The North and West Melbourne News
   is a quarterly publication produced by                       Wednesday 9 August
   volunteers from North and West Melbourne                 Advertisers: Wednesday 2 August
   and the inner city. It is now in its 39th year
                                                        Publication date: Wednesday 6 September
   of production. Readers’ contributions are
   welcomed. Where relevant the News may                     Provisional dates for December edition                   Errol’s Angels at the Port Melbourne Community Carnival
   seek alternative opinions in the interests          Copy deadline 1 November, publication 29 November                                                    Photos: Marais Duckworth
   of balance. Contributors’ opinions are their             www.northandwestmelbournenews.com                         Itʼs been a busy year so far for Errolʼs Angels Community Choir
   own, however, and the News takes no                                                                                with two performances in Term 1.
   responsibility for them. We reserve the right                                                                          We kicked off with an appearance at the vibrant Port
   to edit or omit articles and advertisements                                                                        Melbourne Community Carnival in March. Under the direc-
   considered unsuitable or when space is                      Subscriptions to the News                              torship of Maryanne Clements, the Angels performed a well-
   limited.                                            For just $20 you can become a News subscriber and receive      received mix of songs from around the world specially chosen
                                                        paper copies of four editions of the News through the post!   for their maritime theme.
   Articles should be submitted by email to                    To apply to become a subscriber please email               More recently, the choir presented a Musical Soirée, hosted
   nwmnews@centre.org.au. Please use                 nwmnews@centre.org.au or phone The Centre on 9328 1126.          by Panagiota Kagkali, proprietor of Lulu Cafe & Gallery at
   minimal formatting and do not embed                                                                                506 Queensberry Street. In this beautiful, intimate local venue,
   graphics in documents. Photographs should                                                                          more than 65 patrons enjoyed drinks and nibbles along with the
   be sent separately as JPEGs.                                                                                       singing.
                                                         SHORT STORY COMPETITION                                          We rehearse on Thursday evenings from 7.00pm to 9.00pm
   Finance
                                                      The News congratulates North Melbourne                          at the Maternal and Child Health Centre at 505 Abbotsford
   The News is a non-profit organisation                                                                              Street, North Melbourne. New members are always welcome —
   working as a program of The Centre.                 resident Julie Bateman, winner of our                          no auditions necessary. Just phone The Centre on 9328 1126.
   Funding is by way of a limited quota of                    Short Story Competition!
   advertising, sponsorships, subscriptions            Julie will receive a cash prize of $500.
   and occasional donations.
                                                       Read her winning story, The Suitcase,                              Events at North Melbourne Library
   News subscriptions                                                 on page 12.                                     Shadow puppet workshop
   If you would like to receive the North and                                                                         A fun, hands-on workshop. Learn
   West Melbourne News by mail, the rate                                                                              how to create a shadow puppet, and
   is $20 for four copies sent anywhere                                                                               play on the special shadow board.
   in Australia or pro rata for part of the          Melbourne Osteoporosis Support Group                             Strictly for children 10 years and
   calendar year. The News is distributed free
                                                            celebrates its 20th year                                  over. For safety reasons, children
   throughout North and West Melbourne.                                                                               under 10 will not be allowed to participate.
   Further copies are available from The                                                                              Wedneday 5 July, 11.00am to 12.00 noon
                                                       AVOIDING THE PAIN OF BROKEN BONES
   Centre and the North Melbourne Library.                                                                            Free, bookings required
                                                    The Melbourne Osteoporosis Support Group celebrated               Book via Eventbrite link on website or on 9658 9700
   Advertisement sizes and rates                    its 20th birthday in April. This group meets bi-monthly at
                                                                                                                      Little Golden Books
     60 mm W x 92 mm H $75 plus GST                 1.30pm on the fourth floor of Ross House, 247 Flinders
                                                                                                                      Did you have one? Do you still have it? Relive the golden age
   124 mm W x 92 mm H $150 plus GST                 Lane, Melbourne, to support people who have osteopo-              with Little Golden Books. Join in our golden talk and trivia. If
   188 mm W x 92 mm H $225 plus GST                 rosis and inform them of the help that is available to them.      you fancy a show-and-tell for adults, bring your favourite Little
   252 mm W x 92 mm H $300 plus GST                     Interesting speakers address our meetings and mem-            Golden Books along to the North Melbourne Library and relive
   A charge of 25 per cent may be added for         bers receive a newsletter six times a year with information       the golden memories.
   advertisements that require designing.           about research and helpful hints to avoid broken bones.           Wednesday 5 July, 6.30pm to 7.30pm
   For more information phone 9329 1627 or              Printed material and DVDs on bone health can be               Free, bookings required
   email Advertising.NWMN@outlook.com.              borrowed from our library and meetings conclude with              Book via Eventbrite link on website or on 9658 9700
   Community announcements are published            afternoon tea. Minutes of each meeting are circulated with
   free of charge.                                  the newsletter.                                                             North Melbourne Book Group 2017
                                                        Strong bones are important to carry you around;               Third Monday of every month, 6.00pm, North Melbourne Library
   Volunteers                                       weak bones tend to fracture, causing pain. One in two             19 June   Do Not Say We Have Nothing       Madeleine Thien
   The News welcomes new volunteers. If you         women and one in four men will break a bone due to                17 July   The Good People                  Hannah Kent
   have skills in writing, drawing, photography,    osteoporosis.                                                     21 Aug    Ghost Empire                     Richard Fidler
   archiving, subediting and proofreading,              For more information about the group, contact the             18 Sept   His Bloody Project               Graeme Macrae Burnet
   computer technology or design and layout,        president, Beryl, on 9885 2839 or check out our website,          16 Oct    The Sympathizer                  Viet Thanh Nguyen
   please consider joining the team.                www.melbosg.org.au. We are also on Facebook.                      Enquiries to: 9658 9700 — www.melbournelibraryservice.com.au
                                                        New members are always welcome.                                North Melbourne Library, 66 Errol Street, North Melbourne
   Publisher: Michael Halls
   Editor: Position vacant
   Advertising Coordinator: Janet Graham
   Section Editors:
   Arts & Entertainment: Columbia Winterton
   Community: Siobhan Cooney-O’Donoghue
   Education & Technology: Dan Tuturas and                                                                                                    Get moving and
   Ian Truong                                                                                                                                 have some fun.
   History: Cecilia Robinson
   Noticeboard: Janet Graham                                                                                                                  Our gentle Active Hearts
   Politics & Environment: Brianna Faye Lugg                                                                                                  class is a great way for
   Sport & Health: Victor McMillan and Katrina                                                                                                mature adults to stay
   Kincade-Sharkey
                                                       VACANCIES ON THE MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE                                                  mobile.
   The Centre: Janet Graham
   Travel & Food: Suzie Luddon                                      OF THE CENTRE                                                             
   Production team: Janet Graham,                                                                                                             Tuesdays 12pm - 1pm.
   Emma McCashney, Dan Tuturas and                   The Centre is seeking expressions of interest for two to three vacancies
   Jim Weatherill. Peter Alsen provided              on the management committee for the three-year period October 2017                       49-53 Buncle Street,
                                                                                                                                              North Melbourne 3051
   professional assistance with layout.              to September 2020. One vacancy is available to commence immediately.                     Phone: 9320 4700
                                                     To be eligible for nomination you must first join the association (no fee).

            Printed by Express Print                 Information on the role is available from the Returning Officer, Michael J.
          5 Jones Road, Morwell 3844                 Halls, at The Centre in person, by emailing michaelh@centre.org.au or
                Circulation 7000                     by telephoning 9328 1126.
Abbotsford St Estate Renewal' to grow public housing - The Centre
WINTER 2017 North and West Melbourne News                                                                                                                                               COMMUNITY 3

                                                                                         community

  Hotham Gardens — ahead of the trend
  John H. Smith                                                                                                                                         wellbeing of the residents. Her work captured
                                                                                                                                                        the spirit of her mentor, Edna Walling, whose
                                                                                                                                                        vision was to use the landscape to develop a
  “The gardens at Hotham Gardens are amaz-                                                                                                              unity between house and garden.
  ing,” said Neil Cole. “It blew me away when                                                                                                              Mann’s achievement depended on her flair
  I found the place. I am going to really enjoy                                                                                                         for blending plants and colour. Uncommonly
  living here.” I was talking to our newest resi-                                                                                                       for her time, she made use of Australian flo-
  dent at Hotham Gardens.
                                                                                                                                                        ra as well as exotics. Hotham Gardens was
     Hotham Gardens, which was begun in
                                                                                                                                                        created as an urban forest using exceptional
  1959, was a creative innovation. It replaced
                                                                                                                                                        Australian trees and a variety of exotic plants
  substandard housing that existed on the two-
  and-a-half-acre site on the north side of Arden                                                                                                       long before the modern greening of the urban
  Street, North Melbourne, between Curzon and                                                                                                           environment came into vogue.
  Abbotsford streets. The Housing Commission                                                                                                               The sensitive planning of the gardens an-
  of Victoria reclaimed the land, found new                                                                                                             ticipated present-day concerns for community
  homes for the 208 residents and demolished                                                                                                            health and wellbeing, our connection with
  approximately 73 houses.                                                                                                                              nature and the health and sustainability of the
     But there was more to it than slum clear-                                                                                                          environment. With cities working out how to
  ance. Anne Reynolds, who worked for archi-                                                                                                            green themselves, and climate change making
  tect John Mockridge and Associates, said of        Photo of scale model of proposed Hotham Gardens, from The Age, 10.2.1959. From left: Mr
                                                                                                                                                        us more aware of the importance of trees and
  the project: “It was an experiment in a totally    A.V. Jennings, Master Builders’ Association; Roy Grounds, Architects’ Association; Mr V.J.
                                                                                                                                                        plants, 60-year-old Hotham Gardens remains
  different way of doing things that emerged         Bradley, Housing Commission Chair; and Horace Petty, Minister for Housing
                                                                                                                                                        ahead of the trend.
  from architectural firms that collaborated to                                                                            Photo: Fairfax Syndication
                                                                                                                                                           The modern relevance of Hotham Gardens
  design decorations erected on the city intersec-
                                                     Melbourne Professor of Architecture Hugh        three-bedroom units were included in each          is due to the project’s visionary architecture
  tions during the Olympic Games.”
                                                     O’Neill said the development was “very well-    block of 18. The four towers in each block sit     and landscape gardening implemented in 1959.
     The collaborative relationships that gave
                                                     known when it was done, because of its unique   at different angles to each other, reducing the    This innovative marriage of building and
  birth to a new kind of innovation in design
  and landscaping at Hotham Gardens came to          design and its landscaping”.                    number of walls in common. Each block has          garden is being recognised in the striking of a
  include the State Government, the City Coun-          The vision that drove Hotham Gardens was     off-street parking and garages.                    special plaque to be erected on the site.
  cil, the Architects’ Association and the Master    to create ‘own-your-own’ homes catering for        But the second feature that really sets            Hotham Gardens deserves to be celebrated
  Builders’ Association. The land was bought by      a mixed population. The design has a Euro-      Hotham Gardens apart is the landscape gar-         as a significant and valued heritage site in
  the Master Builders’ (Association) Slum Clear-     pean flavour thanks to ideas local architects   dening. Brilliant landscape architect Beryl        North Melbourne. And it is a very good place
  ance Ltd and the rehousing project followed.       gathered from seeing the rebuilding of Euro-    Mann designed gardens that added to the            to live. At Hotham Gardens, what is old is new
     Hotham Gardens attracted a lot of attention.    pean cities after World War II. One, two and    amenity of the properties and enhanced the         again.
Abbotsford St Estate Renewal' to grow public housing - The Centre
4 COMMUNITY                                                                                                                                               North and West Melbourne News WINTER 2017

                                                                 VERY IMPRESSIVE
 27/04/17                                           Michael is gone I find myself almost starting      Last question on WWTBA Millionaire? Ques-
 “If you get everything you want the minute         to fall apart. He’s been in my life for so long    tion won $100,000.
 you want it, what’s the point of living?”          that it’s difficult to understand WHY he could/    The Wicked Girls, Alex Marwood.
 Finn the Human, Adventure Time. By far one         can be gone.                                       LUV, 2012, DVD, Morgan Freeman.
 of my currently favourite shows. Another                                                              The Brass Teapot, 2012, DVD.
 would have to be Abandoned on SBS. Tues-
 days 10.10pm.                                      13/04/17
                                                    Gerald Ridsdale should be released from pris-      14/03/17
                                                    on. Then anyone who wants to should be al-         Why is it that when the media/government talk
 26/04/17 8.51                                      lowed to put in an application to chop a bit off   about it, all they mention is power loss and not
 I’ve oddly never been to a Comic-Con before.       of him. Just my own opinion of an opportunist      the extremely bent hi-tension power pylons?
 Anyone on this apparently social network           abusive priest who is now said to have abused      One of the few other times I’ve seen power
 (Facebook) want to come with me to Mel-            a potential 100 children.                          pylons so seriously damaged was after that Ca-
 bourne’s on Saturday? Wearing my recently          Plus the only reason RBA governor Philip           nadian ice storm in the late ’80s or early ’90s,
 acquired Frank suit (Donnie Darko for those        Lowe was smiling was because he had enjoyed        one that featured in the films of those suicide
 who are not in the know) with my own Sha-          a particularly yummy lunch.                        girls, and there’s another I don’t remember.
 manistic variants.                                                                                    Ask Darryl??

                                                    07/04/17                                           I can pretty much count on one hand the
 26/04/17                                           A Quick Survey:                                    number of times I’ve played computer games;
 Here’s a thought I’ve been having recently.        Blankets or duvet?                                 never really had that much interest in them.
 The most unfortunate and stupid thing about        Duvet myself.                                      Considerably less interest in watching others
 the Victorian Labor Government doing dumb          Sure I was aware of duvets when a teenager,        play them (especially like now, on a bus sur-
 things is that it gives Matthew Guy (extremely     the aunties had them. But personally didn’t        rounded by private schoolboys playing on their       which I’ll be dressed as a mashup of Don-
 useless ex-planning minister against historic      start using them until moving here. Now I can-     phones).                                             ald and Melania Trumpet. Teeny tiny dress,
 architecture) an excuse to be in the media.        not imagine going back to only blankets, does      So little interest that not once did I watch the     five-inch stilettos. With Donald hair and tan.
                                                    not compute.                                       ABC’s hugely rating show Good Game, which            Wheelchair pusher dressed as a nurse??
 A great idea I had yesterday for a patch, to sew                                                      they foolishly removed (sold to Channel 7) last      Went dress shopping today but neither of what
 onto many shirts and jackets, after seeing the                                                        year. And I know I can say ‘foolishly’ as I’m        I found was quite right, though I did rather like
 latest potential terrorist news from Magnificent   20/03/17                                           well aware how popular it was. Many, many            a long one I saw but didn’t buy.
 Paris:                                             It’s a Sad Day.                                    gamer nerds and nerdettes in my circles are
 FUN                                                After some four (?) years, the most excellent      nuts for the show.                                   The joy of being a hoarder
 SPICE                                              and original thing to have happened in Mel-                                                             A text received from my friend Darryl in re-
 ENJOYMENT                                          bourne Central in years, the Little Library, is                                                         gard to my arts studio space:
 TOLERANCE                                          gone. Spoke to a man who said he was there         02/03/17                                             “I’m moving out of Caulfield and into the
 OR                                                 on Friday and shelves were full of books,          I think I’ve just seen the first-ever male-to-       Ivanhoe flat, plus V’s mum’s place in Black-
 RACK OFF                                           whereas shelves are now still full of books, but   male kiss on Who Wants To Be a Millionaire?          burn. We will need space at Preston to store
                                                    they’re multiple copies of only three titles.      Winner won $10k.                                     stuff, so you need to move all your stuff out. I
                                                    Chairs have changed to an ornate rococo and                                                             am happy to give you a hard rubbish collection
 21/04/17                                           carpet to a bland blue, door has been removed                                                           here in Caulfield and could probably arrange
 First time I’ve had this text from North Mel-      and there are leafy faux roses dangling from       01/03/17                                             transport of stuff from Preston if required.
 bourne Library:                                    ceiling.                                           Offal spill on CityLink. Bizarrely looks from        Timeframe is everything out by mid-March or
 “Notice from Melbourne Library Service. The        A sad, sad day.                                    Channel 9 footage that said offal has fallen         sooner.”
 following item is now overdue. Please return       Then a week later it all changed once again,       from an open-topped truck. Not a small load
 ASAP — The Immortal Iron Fist. The Com-            like Alice falling down her rabbit-made en-        truck either. Many thoughts flying around my         Dinosaurs. Dinosaurs. Dinosaurs. I seem to
 plete Collection Vol. 2”                           trance to Wonderland. (Haven’t we all, if being    head, like a blowfly trapped in a milk bottle.       be a wee bit obsessed by dinosaurs. There are
 Usually our library texts look more like this:     truthful, wished we could holiday there?)                                                               hundreds of them here in the apartment in all
 “Notice from Melbourne Library Service.            The new chairs and ceiling hanging roses                                                                sizes and they’re one of the first things we go
 Please pick up reservation from North Mel-         stayed, but are gone again now a month later.      22/02/17                                             for when op-shopping.
 bourne Library by 03 May 2017 — Night-             No idea where the boring books have gone           Thought been in head last few hours, it’s now
 mares & Dreamscapes”                               (apparently some promotional thing) but the        1.17am.                                              John Clarke is dead. John Clarke is dead.
                                                    previous greatness of the Little Library has re-   Yesterday’s plane crash, an assassination that       John Clarke is dead.
                                                    turned. Plus the sliding door never came back.     happened early? Supposed to have been over           How can we possibly cope with the pain and
 17/04/17                                           Comfy chairs and roses are gone again also.        sea maybe 20 minutes later. To get rid of re-        sadness? A world without the wit, humour and
 Last year I was affected by the loss of Prince                                                        tired FBI agent?                                     great intelligence of John Clarke is a particu-
 and of course by our magnificent Sir David         Unknown news for myself and other SK fans:                                                              larly sad and foolish one.
 Bowie but this year every time something           John Swithen, 1972, short story. Pseudonym of      Anti-Trump rally next Saturday                       I grew up listening to his magnificence as Fred
 goes out of its way to remind me that George       Stephen King.                                      Seeking a person to push a wheelchair. In            Dagg. So much has gone with him.
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Authorised by D. Lawson, 296 Brunswick St, Fitzroy VIC 3065.

                                            RM              EL B O U R N E
                   FE D ER A L M EM B ER FO

         STANDING UP FOR WHAT MATTERS
         GF1 296 Brunswick St, Fitzroy VIC 3065.
            (03) 9417 0759      adam.bandt.mp@aph.gov.au
         adambandt.com                              @Adam.Bandt.MP           @AdamBandt
Abbotsford St Estate Renewal' to grow public housing - The Centre
WINTER 2017 North and West Melbourne News                                                                                                                                                      COMMUNITY 5

  ‘Abbotsford St Estate Renewal’ to grow public housing
  Continued from Front page                          ity of tenants who were not in attendance.          en us no dates for moving out, or for returning
                                                                                                                                                             They have
  claims that all neighbouring properties had
  been letterboxed about the meet, several swore
  they had not received notification.
                                                        Significantly, many of these people battling
                                                     language difficulties and professional re-edu-
                                                     cation in their search for work to care for their
                                                     young families are Afghanis, Sikhs, Sudanese,
                                                                                                         here, whenever that might be. And if we take
                                                                                                         their ‘new’ addresses, wherever they may be,
                                                                                                         how do we know there’ll be room for all who
                                                                                                         want to come back?
                                                                                                                                                             paid their
     That neighbourhood meeting — at DHHS’s
  Melrose Street centre — uniformly rejected
  the “plan for discussion”, which included
  public housing buildings close to footpath pe-
                                                     Somalis and mainland Chinese. Many were
                                                     already socially marginalised by war and tra-
                                                     ditional ethnic bias back home, so desperately
                                                     seek a better future for themselves and their
                                                                                                            “How do we know there’ll be room for
                                                                                                         us all if half of the places become private?”
                                                                                                         Bob’s turmoil is patent. Long-term potential
                                                                                                                                                             dues
                                                                                                         effects on the health of the significant number
  rimeters, accommodation extending to 10–12         families.                                           of outpatients living on the estate should well     Katrina Kincade-Sharkey
  storeys and vastly less open area between             Many both recent and well-established mi-        have been considered before these insensitive
  those buildings.                                   grant settlers on the estate escaped personal,

                                                                                                                                                             R
                                                                                                         re-housings were planned.
     Created by David Lock Associates Town           political, economic and social persecution that                                                                  esidents at Abbotsford Street Estate fill
  Planning & Urban Design, this proposal sug-        destroyed their notions of any comfortable                                                                       three sectors: relatively recently set-
  gested continuing Wood Street as a treed walk-     home life.                                                                                                       tled new Australians from Africa and
  way access across the block to Molesworth             Now, many speak bitterly of settlement                                                               central Asia; middle-aged and elderly locals
  Street.                                            days when they were encouraged to relax, to                                                             who’ve lived there for two generations; and
     Significantly, there was to be no under-        feel comfortable and to view their Abbotsford                                                           physically disabled outpatients attending local
  ground car parking for public or private           Street Estate accommodation as their new                                                                hospitals and/or critical medical clinics.
  owners, this deemed “far too costly”, so “car      Aussie home.                                                                                               After I had been diagnosed with chronic
  space will be provided on the buildings’ lower        This chronic avoidance of personal notifi-                                                           myeloid leukaemia (CML) on returning to
  floors”, according to a facilitator from KJA.      cation has drawn major criticism from social                                                            Australia in 2001, my long-term Footscray GP,
     Further, little consideration had been given    and community workers, health profession-                                                               Dr Jeff Rubin, referred me to his colleague,
  to providing space for large families in either    als, teachers, local shopkeepers, sympathetic                                                           then Dr — now Professor — Andrew Grigg, at
  the public or private residences, the majority     neighbours and residents themselves, but uni-                                                           Royal Melbourne Hospital.
  of units providing only one or two bedrooms,       formly all residents interviewed were tentative                                                            These two had respected each other’s
  “ideal for inner-city living”.                     to identify themselves in fear of departmental                                                          dedicated practices since their studies at
     Response to the multi-storey plan was           rejection of any future claims.                                                                         Melbourne University, so my GP was well
  uniformly negative, despite the 10 per cent           Each resident interviewed said they believed                                                         acquainted with Grigg’s participation in in-
                                                                                                         Face painter Susan from Animals 2U with Nour
  planned increase in public housing tenancies.      any public statement could jeopardise their                                   Photo: Jim Weatherill
                                                                                                                                                             ternational trials of drug treatment regimes to
  The presenters told the meeting there were         future public housing prospects.                                                                        relieve blood cancer symptoms and, hopefully,
  plans for private housing on two-thirds to            Rather than mere and certainly expensive                                                             one day achieve a CML cure.
  three-quarters of the block’s area. If developed   renovation, this large domestic housing estate      Keep people local                                      This writer was lucky: sure, the initial In-
  thus, it may house as many as 960 residents        will be redeveloped to accommodate, at latest       But not all Abbotsford Street Estate’s residents    docid steps weren’t great, but Grigg consulted
  on the Abbotsford Street Estate, yet this was      estimates, a 50/50 residential cohort, meaning      were negative. ‘Matt’, a 35-year-old disabled       on several trials with haematology units across
  “merely a plan for discussion”.                    half public/half private property owners.           pensioner, agreed with renewal: “It’s high          the globe. This eventually led to his CML
                                                        A two-way housing mix would be similar to        time they tore down these derelict old blocks       patients undergoing several generations of
  Resettlement woes                                  the bedevilled DHHS project on Racecourse           — the windows rattle, the water temperature         twice-daily self-injection with world-leading
  At least 50 per cent of this estate’s tenancy is   Road, Ascot Vale, opposite Melbourne Show-          doesn’t last, rainwater comes in in storms and      chemotherapy imatinib mesylate, marketed
  long-term, that is 10 years-plus, with many of     grounds, where tenant trauma has been signif-       they’re old and smelly.” Departmental advisors      as Glivec and Dasatinib, which treatments
  those currently in outpatient attendance at the    icant, according to local health professionals,     claimed their Phase One Engagement Program          achieved remission for many of us.
  Royal Melbourne, Royal Women’s and Royal           Epsom Road shopkeepers and residents them-          would do its “utmost to keep people in the             It wasn’t all hunky-dory, though: years of
  Children’s hospitals, as well as Peter MacCal-     selves.                                             local area, if they want to remain here”.           sleepless nights and wayward temperature sen-
  lum Cancer Centre and numerous other nearby           “Rather than being ‘equal’ residents here           DHHS has promised rent subsidies for             sitivities were no fun, but I’m still here — all
  medical facilities. Had they been aware of         [at Racecourse Road’s new development],             current public housing tenants forced to rent       thousand kilos of me — and I have no inten-
  the April DHHS meeting, it is probable many        we’re expecting to be treated like second-class     privately until the Abbotsford Renewal is com-      tion of passing on for several decades yet.
  would not have felt able to attend.                ‘dogs’,” growled ‘Mario’ (not his real name),       pletely habitable. Historically, this subsidy has      Fundamental responsibility for this glorious
     Several local GPs and medical specialists       a 69-year-old former bricklayer who lived on        lasted for two years, but advisors claim Ab-        remission lies primarily with those brilliantly
  agreed all patients — especially those who         Racecourse Road for seven years until redevel-      botsford Street Estate Renewal is only at ‘early    dedicated medicos, but the inordinate patient
  may be budget-stressed or otherwise socially       opment began.                                       engagement’ timetable.                              comfort organised by Royal Melbourne Hospi-
  prejudiced — needed confidence and emo-               He was offered an outer-suburban unit               Aiming to adequately meet modern living          tal social workers and provided by the former
  tional comfort in their continuing care, with      needing bus and train connections to the CBD,       standards with this new development, DHHS           Department of Human Services (now DHHS)
  assured housing being critical. Yet until 1 June                                                       has still promised its current tenants that no      in ‘placing’ me at Abbotsford Street Estate
                                                     then a tram to Peter Mac Cancer Centre for
  there have been no programmed personal dis-                                                            more than 25 per cent of their government           cannot be under-estimated.
                                                     treatment of his acute emphysema. He refused
  cussions with residents, especially no individ-                                                        income — that is, disability or aged pensions,         Accommodated on the ground floor of a unit
                                                     the offer.
  ual explanations in their native languages with                                                        or unemployment or new settler allowances —         block on Abbotsford Street, my days awoke to
                                                        “Now I board in Maidstone with my former
                                                                                                         will be charged for their rent.                     chirping bird calls from eucalypt and poplar
  the several dozen recently settled Africans.       wife, who gave me her spare room, thank God,
                                                                                                                                                             trees surrounding our public tenancy homes.
  Consequently there has been no relief from         but also with her new bloke and his teenage            DHHS rentals at Abbotsford Street Estate
                                                                                                                                                                Family and friends were tentative at this
  the emotional distress felt by many about their    son, all of which is fine bar my breathing dif-     will provide more one and two-bedroom
                                                                                                                                                             ‘down-market’ residential move, but all soon
  housing futures.                                   ficulties climbing on buses and trams to the        apartments for North Melbourne, which are in
                                                                                                                                                             saw a relatively efficient redevelopment of the
     Yes, DHHS provided interpreters for the         hospital,” Mario says, gasping for breath.          high demand, while also introducing homes
                                                                                                                                                             journo they’d known. She wasn’t working,
  information meeting, but that was not followed        Abbotsford Street Estate resident ‘Bob’ is       for private sale to help address the constantly
                                                                                                                                                             but she was safe and secure in a double-keyed
  by individual doorknocks or later appoint-         also receiving treatment for late-stage lung        growing demand for inner-city housing. The
                                                                                                                                                             entry apartment that was clean and fully
  ments for personal explanation with the major-     cancer at Peter MacCallum. “But they’ve giv-        Abbotsford Triangle is a potential goldmine.
                                                                                                                                                             equipped.
                                                                                                                                                                And it was so quiet back then. Nowadays,
                                                                                                                                                             several years after moving out, I still miss
                              WOOD PHARMACY – NORTH MELBOURNE                                                                                                those birds. It’s hard to imagine such peaceful
                                                                                                                                                             quiet while living adjacent to a main street, but
         67 Errol Street, North Melbourne 3051 • Ph: 9328 1960 • Fax: 9328 1531                                                                              the estate’s blocks were all double-brick and as
                                                                                                                                                             comfortable as their tenants made them, so it
                                                                                                                                                             was easy to truly relax.
                                                                            At Wood Pharmacy North Melbourne, we want to help you                               I now believe relaxation was the factor
                                                                            optimise your use and understanding of your medicines.                           enabling my varying new chemotherapies to
                                                                            Please ask us about:                                                             function.
                                                                               •   Your annual Medscheck                                                        But the real joy of that home was the other
                                                                                                                                                             residents. True, this supposed journo didn’t
                                                                               •   Weekly medication packing
                                                                                                                                                             even know the names of most of her co-dwell-
                                                                               •   Medication delivery
                                                                                                                                                             ers, but we all ‘knew’ each as close as family,
                                                                               •   MedAdvisor phone app to order repeats from home!
                                                                                                                                                             rarely passing without fond acknowledgement
                                                                            We also stock popular brands such as:                                            and usually recognising others’ visiting family
                                                                                                                                                             and friends.
                                                                               •   MooGoo skincare
                                                                                                                                                                Abbotsford Street Estate residents formed
                                                                               •   Tilley soaps
                                                                                                                                                             a true community, so it is vital that each res-
                                                                               •   Bioceuticals practitioner-only supplements                                ident be offered the option of returning after
                                                                               •   Organyc women’s hygiene range                                             ‘renewal’. Most of those who live there have
                                                                               •   Bioderma and Uriage                                                       withstood personal trauma, be that physical,
                                                                                                                                                             political or economic. They’ve done their time;
    OPENING HOURS: Mon to Fri 8.30am to 6.30pm, Sat 9am to 2pm, Sun 10am to 2pm — closed on public holidays                                                  they’ve well paid their emotional dues. Now
                                                                                                                                                             it’s time public housing gave back.
6 COMMUNITY                                                                                                                                              North and West Melbourne News WINTER 2017

 CHALLENGE: selling
 North and West benefits
 Katrina Kincade-Sharkey                              founder in July 2007.
                                                                                                              BECOME A MEMBER OF YOUR LOCAL TRADERS GROUP
                                                         The Precinct Association now encourages

 P
                                                      traders to leverage off each other, this both
                                                                                                                       THE NORTH & WEST MELBOURNE PRECINCT
        rofessional, cost-effective, stylish: those   educating customers on the benefits of this
        mantras have drawn businesses — and           precinct, and keeping business with local ser-                                            ASSOCIATION!
        their client bases — to this region           vices.
 through most of Victoria’s modern history.              NWMPA’s seven-member committee meets
                                                                                                              Applications are now open for membership of the North & West Melbourne Precinct
    Yet communicating North and West Mel-             every six weeks in rotation at each member’s
                                                                                                              Association (NWMPA) for the 2017–18 financial year. Be an active contributor to the
 bourne’s market provision nowadays is an ex-         business premises. Their next meeting is
                                                                                                              future of your local business area and benefit from member-focused marketing campaigns.
 pensive effort for any trader, especially against    scheduled for 7.30am on Thursday 15 June at
 the profusion of good, bad and oh-so-indiffer-       architect Neville Page’s practice, Greenway
 ent promotions splattered across our mass me-        Hirst Page Pty Ltd, first floor, 464 Victoria           Cost: $60 per year                             Fling Street Festival, Errol Street Open Air
 dia. Advertising is the blood of public commu-       Street, North Melbourne.                                                                               Christmas Party and two new events to be
 nications; it’ll draw yours with gleeful gusto.         North & West Melbourne Precinct Associ-              What you get:                                  introduced to the area in 2017–18.
    Experts agree the only way to raise the mar-                                                              - High-quality business profile listing on     - Opportunities to join the NWMPA Man-
                                                      ation’s annual general meeting will be held
 ket awareness of any trading precinct is for                                                                 the NWMPA website, including images,           agement Committee.
                                                      at 6.00pm on Monday 31 July, venue to be
                                                                                                              map pin-point and click-through to your
 shopkeepers, professionals and traders of all        advised.
                                                                                                              business website.                              Plus a number of new benefits!
 sorts who run businesses in the region to get           Recent improvements proposed by NWMPA
                                                                                                              - Access to four newly structured Business     - The first 50 members to join with a paid
 together to SELL ONE MESSAGE. And the                and adopted by the City of Melbourne include
                                                                                                              Networking events during the year featur-      membership for 2017–18 will be able to
 easiest message to sell is LOCATION.                 provision of extra public toilets adjacent to
                                                                                                              ing speakers from a variety of business,       book in a free professional photography
    We all know the individual styles of Collins      North Melbourne Town Hall, corner Queens-
                                                                                                              marketing and commercial backgrounds.          session through the NWMPA and will be
 Street, of Chapel and Brunswick, of Sydney           berry and Errol, as well as the suggestion
                                                                                                              - Opportunity to post event listings and       provided with four high-quality, profes-
 Road and the Trak Village. Whatever their            by trader Louisa Chalmer to develop a com-
                                                                                                              business promotions on the NWMPA web-
 pluses or traffic hassles, they each record          prehensive marketing and physical planning                                                             sional photos to keep. These photos will
                                                                                                              site at no additional cost.
 massive foot traffic and capital turnover. North     strategy for the local area. Ms Chalmer is one                                                         also be owned by the NWMPA and used to
                                                                                                              - Exclusive access to specialised demo-
 and West Melbourne have it all; we just need         of the owners of Clever Polly’s restaurant and                                                         promote your business on our website and
                                                                                                              graphic reports and tourism data for Mel-
 to communicate that essence to the wider pop-        wine bar.                                                                                              social media channels.
                                                                                                              bourne.
 ulation.                                                Mr Halls explains: “Our aim is to help busi-                                                        - Free membership of the North West
                                                                                                              - First access to communications and busi-
    Any communication must be led by com-             nesses expand, to survive well by promoting             ness development opportunities from local      Business Network — a new and interactive
 mon themes of ease of access, variety of             and expanding North and West Melbourne as               council.                                       business resource and support platform
 produce and expert professionalism, and then         a business area, simultaneously expanding our           - Ongoing social media campaign specif-        operated locally in North Melbourne, to be
 delivered in a handy, easy-welcoming manner.         client base. This strategy is for the business          ically for your business, via the growing      launched in July 2017.
    North and West Melbourne are overlaid with        period 2017 through 2021.                               NWMPA channels.                                - Increased exposure for your business
 genuine heritage style, this region encompass-          “The Precinct Association won another plus           - Increased opportunity for your business      through the NWMPA’s new, dedicated pres-
 ing a plethora of world-leading technocrats,         for local traders in having brighter lighting           or event to be featured in direct City of      ence within the North and West Melbourne
 designers, medicos, teachers and many others,        installed along Victoria and Errol streets, that        Melbourne print and online marketing cam-      News.
 each caring for this community’s welfare, both       being just one forerunner to its marketing strat-       paigns, therefore reaching over 500,000
 professionally and personally.                       egy for current and future members in terms of          potential customers/clients.                   You can secure your membership for the
    North & West Melbourne Precinct Associ-           this local area’s attractiveness and tradeability.      - Opportunities to participate in a number     2017–18 financial year by emailing us:
 ation (NWMPA) has several dozen members,                “The Precinct Association will now consult           of local events, including the annual Spring   northwestmelbourneprecinct@gmail.com
 but a potential body of hundreds. Its current        a top urban planner to develop a vision for the
 membership mainly provides business and pro-         area, then a tangible, yet readily achievable,
 fessional services, as well as hospitality, but      plan for that vision,” he stresses, enthusiasti-
                                                                                                           North & West Melbourne Precinct Association (NWMPA) Members 2017
 also comprises information technologists, re-        cally.
 tail and tourism advisors and communicators.            “In the meantime we’ll continue with our          A1 Used Computer Systems,                         Multiply Accountants & Advisors,
 Tutors and knowledge sector professionals are        four-seasons promotions, advertising in both         630 Queensberry Street – 9326 6261                649 Spencer Street – 9093 4888
 also members.                                        Docklands News and North and West Mel-
                                                                                                           Alexkarbon Real Estate,                           Nick Theodossi Prestige Cars,
    NWMPA’s constitution welcomes anyone              bourne News, our Spring Fling jaunt, the next
                                                                                                           122 Errol Street – 9326 8883                      185 Arden Street – 9373 7777
 trading as a business within the precincts of        development stage of Northside Winter Festi-
 North and West Melbourne’s postcodes.                val and our end-of-year Christmas Festival,”         Allen Kong Architect Pty Ltd,                     North Melbourne Books,
    “We’re also allowed to admit as members           he says, barely drawing a breath.                    464 Victoria Street – 9328 2320                   546 Queensberry Street – 9041 4216
 business people who live locally but trade              Local branding and marketing is a massive         Andrew Harris Optometry,                          North Melbourne Football Club,
 elsewhere,” says Michael Halls, NWMPA vice           undertaking, but experts agree that done to-         56 Errol Street – 9329 9372                       204–206 Arden Street – 9320 2400
 president and director of The Centre – Con-          gether it will locate, promote and trade North       Bakers Delight – North Melbourne,                 North Melbourne Podiatry,
 necting Community in North & West Mel-               and West Melbourne to a far wider, regular           29 Errol Street – 9329 0467                       283 Victoria Street – 9329 6618
 bourne, which produces this newspaper.               market base.
                                                                                                           Bubbleblue,                                       Pitcher Partners,
    The Centre’s primary concern is the so-              Further information will be provided by
                                                                                                           1–3 Provost Street – 0404 882 404                 Level 19, 15 William Street – 8610 5000
 cio-economic welfare of its local participants       NWMPA secretary Ms Loan Nguyen, owner/
                                                      manager of North Melbourne Podiatry, 283             Butcher Shop Cafe,                                Pocket Cafe, 29 Melrose Street – 9041 4441
 and their surroundings, these factors linking
                                                      Victoria Street, West Melbourne, telephone           72 Hawke Street – 9939 4326                       Rotary Club of North Melbourne,
 almost exactly with those of the Precinct
 Association, of which The Centre was a joint         0420 840 924.                                        City North Physiotherapy Clinic,                  PO Box 304, North Melbourne 3051
                                                                                                           59 Errol Street – 9328 3733                       Select Right, 7 Purcell Street
                                                                                                           Clever Polly’s,                                   Strang Systems Pty Ltd,
                                                                                                           313 Victoria Street – 9077 9294                   94 Errol Street – 9329 6111

 Northside Winter Festival
                                                                                                           Contours Travel,                                  Synergetics, 490 Spencer Street – 9328 4800
                                                                                                           287 Victoria Street – 1300 135 391
                                                                                                                                                             The Centre, 58 Errol Street – 9328 1126
                                                                                                           Dolcetti Cakes,
                                                                                                                                                             The Comic’s Lounge,
                                                                                                           223 Victoria Street – 9328 1688
 North and West Melbourne are getting a new festival! Celebrating everything unique about the                                                                26 Errol Street – 9348 9488
 precinct, with an enchanting twist.

                                                                     Electron Workshop,
                                                                                                                                                             The Courthouse Hotel,
                                                                                                           31 Arden Street – 9270 5850
                                                                                                                                                             86–90 Errol Street – 9329 5394
                                                                                                           Ferguson Plarre,
                                                                                                                                                             The Eco Laundry Room,
 The Northside Winter Festival will bring the                                                              27 Errol Street – 9329 3588
                                                                                                                                                             37 Melrose Street – 1300 326 880
 historic streets of North and West Melbourne                                                              Greenway Hirst Page Pty Ltd,
                                                                                                                                                             The Paw Principality,
 to life for 10 days this July–August with                                                                 1st Floor, 464 Victoria Street – 9329 2611
                                                                                                                                                             60 Errol Street – 1300 225 202
 an exciting line-up of live music, walking                                                                Guild of Objects,
 tours, pop-up cinemas, theatre, comedy, retail                                                                                                              TAS Australia
                                                                                                           690 Queensberry Street
 markets, special dining experiences and local                                                                                                               Vega Associates, 25/16 Courtney Street
                                                                                                           Joseph Louis Realty Pty Ltd,
 trader events. This event is being produced                                                                                                                 W.B. Simpson, 30 Errol Street – 9328 1213
                                                                                                           496 Queensberry Street – 9329 5050
 by the North & West Melbourne Precinct
 Association Inc.                                                                                          MBG Education Pty Ltd,                            Wayne Lynch Master Jeweller,
                                                                                                           123 Chetwynd Street – 1300 137 389                93 Errol Street – 9328 5500
                                                                                                           Melbourne Natural Medicine Clinic,                Willows and Wine,
                                                                                                           49 Chetwynd Street – 9686 2566                    315 Victoria Street – 0411 686 080
 What: Northside Winter Festival
 When: 27 July – 5 August                                                                                  Melbourne North Service Centre,
 Where: Errol Street, Victoria Street, Queensberry Street and inside various local venues                  175 Arden Street – 9328 4237
WINTER 2017 North and West Melbourne News                                                                                                                                             COMMUNITY 7

                                        Residents About Integrated
                                        Development (RAID@3051)
                                        Marg Leser                                              and the area surrounding the Queen Victoria       3051 population plus an additional 15,000 to
                                                                                                Market.                                           20,000 people.
                                                                                             ● In Dr Woodcock’s view the design presents            Much more public open space must be found

                                        R
                                                esidents About Integrated Development           as a concentrator rather than a distributor of    for the current and future population of 3051.
                                                (RAID) considers that future planning           traffic and, with the significant population
                                                needs to include not only physical in-          growth projected for Melbourne, has the           Haines and Shiel Street develop-
                                        frastructure but also enhancement of transport,         potential to create demand for the shelved        ments
                                        heritage building and streetscapes. The pro-            East West Link.                                   There have been a number of developments
                                        active planning of community infrastructure          This contentious project is likely to have a         approved or commenced in the Haines and
                                        must include spaces for active and passive           significant impact on 3051 through increased         Shiel Street precinct opposite our sole public
                                        recreation, education, community services,           traffic volume and movement and a reduction          playground at Gardiner Reserve.
                                        landscaping and affordable housing.                  in the visual amenity of the area. Health may           The 13-level 43-unit development at
                                           RAID@3051 Inc continues to represent the          also be affected by increased noise, loss of         104–110 Haines Street is in construction and
                                        views of the local community by informing            open space and diminished air quality caused         the six-storey 22-unit development at 1 Shiel
                                        integrated long-term and sustained planning          by diesel and other emissions.                       Street is now complete. Twenty-seven apart-
                                        for urban renewal in North Melbourne and                                                                  ments are proposed for 114–116 Haines Street.
                                        surrounding areas. RAID is a non-partisan in-        Update on the Woolworths site                        The status of the two 10-storey towers on the
                                        corporated local organisation that is committed      The Woolworths triangular site bounded by            corner of Macaulay Road and Haines Street
                                        to open, transparent governance.                     Macaulay Road, Vaughan Terrace and Canning           remains unclear.
                                           RAID’s experience over several years has          Street has been re-branded as Arden Gardens.            The new developers of the Woods Motors
                                        reinforced the contribution that residents can       It will consist of two towers containing ap-         site at 3–15 Shiel Street are seeking to radi-
                                        make to policy development and implementa-           proximately 300 apartments, a supermarket            cally amend the previously approved 64-unit
                                        tion affecting the 3051 postcode. We welcome         and other shops. The Hickory Group has been          development to accommodate 124 units in
                                        residents’ involvement in a range of roles.          appointed as builders for the site and construc-     a 12-storey podium and tower. This would
                                                                                             tion has now commenced.
                                                                                                                                                  appear to be allowed under the proposed plan-
                                        Annual general meeting                                  Construction of stage 1 is scheduled for
                                                                                                                                                  ning panel amendments, but would not have
                                        RAID@3051’s AGM on 5 April at the North              completion by the end of 2018. Members of
                                                                                                                                                  been allowed under the original Arden–Macau-
                                        Melbourne Recreation Centre was well sup-            the RAID committee met with the Hickory
                                                                                                                                                  lay Structure Plan setbacks.
                                        ported by RAID members and the community.            Group and raised concerns about the construc-
                                                                                                                                                     The amendment is currently before the Plan-
                                        Committee members elected at the AGM                 tion process including construction noise, traf-
                                                                                                                                                  ning Minister and as such is “seriously consid-
                                        were: Peter Hogg (chair), Marg Leser (deputy         fic management into and surrounding the site,
                                                                                                                                                  ered”. It is in effect the operative height control.
                                        chair), Tess Demediuk (secretary/treasurer),         parking arrangements for workers’ vehicles
                                                                                                                                                     RAID wrote to the minister to urge prompt
                                        Lorna Hannan and Angela Williams. Annual             and safe access to the 402 bus stop adjacent to
                                                                                                                                                  rejection of the planning panel amendments
                                        membership remains $1 and the initial joining        the site in Canning Street.
                                                                                                                                                  to prevent this project from proceeding in its
                                        fee is also $1. In addition to reports from the         The Hickory Group representatives advised
                                                                                                                                                  current form, but we were unsuccessful. Why
                                        chairman and treasurer two guest speakers            that they are keen to liaise with the community
                                                                                             and to keep people informed as the develop-          the planning panel made the decision to allow
                                        presented.
                                                                                             ment progresses. They have provided an email         12-storey developments along Shiel Street with
                                           Councillor Nicholas Reece, chair of the
                                        City of Melbourne’s planning portfolio,              address for individuals in the community to          minimal setbacks is a matter of conjecture.
                                        stated he was interested in ongoing dialogue         subscribe to if they wish to receive updates or         The largely intact low-rise 19th-century
                                        with the community. He referred to Victorian         raise issues: ardengardens@hickory.com.au            streetscape on the north side of Shiel Street
                                        Government decisions impacting the City of              The permitted hours of construction site          will be juxtaposed with high-rise on the south.
                                        Melbourne and its residents. He provided an          work within the City of Melbourne are Monday         This would seem to be contrary to generally
                                        overview of Amendment C190, which will               to Friday from 7.00am to 7.00pm and Saturday         accepted good urban design and planning.
                                        implement new land use and development               from 8.00am to 3.00pm. Any work outside                 The Macaulay Road/Haines Street devel-
                                        controls.                                            these hours requires an out-of-hours permit to       opment, the Woods Motors site in Shiel Street
                                           Amendment C190 is currently seeking               be issued. Workers are permitted to be on site       and Arden Gardens all adopt a ‘podium and
                                        approval from the Minister for Planning. In-         prior to this time, however must not undertake       tower’ model of urban development, which is
                                        formation and updates can be found at www.           any building work. Any issues can be reported        now likely to become the dominant develop-
                                        participate.melbourne.vic.gov.au/ardenmacau-         to the City of Melbourne on 9658 9658.               ment model in Arden–Macaulay. As an urban
                                        layc190.                                                                                                  design approach it leaves much to be desired.
                                           Other matters raised with Councillor Reece        Draft Arden Vision and Framework                        RAID believes we can do much better than
                                        included the contentious Victorian Govern-           The Arden Urban Renewal Precinct will have           repeat the mistakes of Docklands and South-
                                        ment decision on Residential Zones and the           a significant impact on 3051. It involves a          bank but the tower-and-podium model is the
                                        implications of the recently released Victo-         56-hectare base for 34,000 jobs and 15,000           most profitable. Unfortunately we can expect
                                        rian Better Apartments Design Standards.             residents and will include the new Arden Met-        to see more of it.
                                        RAID had lobbied that these should include           ro station. More information is available at
                                        minimum standards in respect of size, storage,       www.ardenmacaulay.vic.gov.au.                        Who is RAID@3051?
                                        light, ventilation, open space and accessibility,       One of RAID’s principal goals is to advo-         RAID@3051 Inc is a community group
                                        thus resulting in improved design,                   cate for the urban infrastructure required to        formed in 2011 to respond to the proposed
                                        sustainability and livability of apartments.         meet the needs of current and future popu-           Woolworths development in the residential
                                           Dr Ian Woodcock, chair of the Inner Mel-          lations. There is a substantial backlog in all       area bounded by Macaulay Road, Vaughan
                                        bourne Planning Alliance (IMPA), of which            forms of infrastructure across the country and       Terrace and Canning Street, North Melbourne.
                                        RAID was a foundation member, is also a              the Melbourne Metro is a pivotal project for         RAID is concerned about the impact of in-
                                        planning and urban design academic with a            the future bigger, denser Melbourne of the           creased density, population and traffic on the
                                        specialist interest in Melbourne’s public trans-     2020s and beyond.                                    already overstretched community infrastruc-
                                        port. He presented on the important topic of            The method in which the Arden Urban Re-           ture.
                                        the Western Distributor and its potential im-        newal Precinct, around the new Arden station,           RAID is seeking immediate traffic-calming
                                        pact on postcode 3051.                               is implemented is critical to the future of North    measures to make the area safer for pedestri-
                                            Key points, which generated discussion           and West Melbourne, Kensington and E-Gate.           ans. We are also urging the City of Melbourne
                                        from the floor, included:                            RAID contributed to the initial community            and state planning bodies to lock in a range of
                                        ● The Western Distributor has been re-brand-         consultations on the Draft Arden Vision &            open spaces in all future developments.
                                           ed as the West Gate Tunnel Project.               Framework in October 2016.                              We continue to lobby the City of Melbourne
                                        ● It is now a significantly bigger project than         The State Government owns large parcels           for Gardiner Reserve to be enlarged and for the
                                           what was originally projected in both size        of land in the precinct, so has the opportunity      immediate provision of a community hub in
                                           and estimated cost.                               to develop this well. However, the initial signs     the Hotham Hill area and in all new precincts.
                                        ● The most recent design appears not to              are not reassuring. Sketches of the precinct         RAID endeavours to work constructively with
                                           link directly to the docks. The planned           show buildings of 12 and 15 storeys, poten-          all involved in 3051.
                                           ground-level and elevated roads near the          tially resulting in 30 storeys if history is any        RAID is strongly committed to stakeholder
                                           E-Gate site may impact on future urban de-        guide. Furthermore, it is clear that the intention   engagement.
                                           velopment of this area, and the project will      is to use Arden Oval as the primary open space
                                           potentially compete with the Regional Rail        for the precinct.                                    Connect to RAID@3051
                                           Link and Melbourne Metro.                            North Melbourne Football Club has submit-         For further information about RAID or to be-
                                        ● The lack of design clarity does not enable         ted a major redevelopment plan to the Victori-       come a member and receive our e-newsletter,
                                           surety as to where the traffic will decant into   an Planning Authority, which can be viewed at        contact us by email to raid3051@gmail.com,
                                           North and West Melbourne, but Dr Wood-            www.nmfc.com.au/news/2017-05-09/norths-              access our website at www.3051-integrated.
                                           cock considered it would probably have            bold-plan. The oval cannot be relied on to ser-      com or follow us on Facebook by searching
                                           significant impact on 3051, Dudley Street         vice the active recreation needs of the current      3051 RAID.
8 COMMUNITY                                                                                                                                                North and West Melbourne News WINTER 2017

                                                    on 22 and 23 May, local people who attended         ● We don’t need shops and cafes on the site;            the E-Gate site and will destroy potential
                                                    complained about the lack of, or late distribu-        there are already many within easy walking           connections between West Melbourne,
                                                    tion of, written information.                          distance.                                            E-Gate and Docklands.
                                                       They also expressed concern that selling off     The government’s commitment to increase              If it goes ahead, the WGTP is likely to bring
                         North and West             part of the land to private developers was an       social housing on the estates by 10 per cent         more traffic into North and West Melbourne
                         Melbourne                  attempt by the government to make a profit at       seems tokenistic when housing for the disad-         and the CBD.
                                                    the expense of public housing tenants and the       vantaged is in such short supply and the need           In a further slight, Transurban has given citi-
                         Association                estate’s amenity. The sketch plan tabled at the     for it increasing rapidly as Melbourne’s popu-       zens only five weeks to respond to 10,000 pag-
                                                    meetings showed much denser site coverage           lation swells.                                       es of EES (Environmental Effects Statement)
                                                    than the current layout as well as buildings up                                                          documents. Submissions on the EES are due
 The Association’s 2017 AGM                                                                             West Gate Tunnel Project (WGTP)
                                                    to 10–12 storeys high.                                                                                   by 5.00pm on 10 July.
 The NWMA annual general meeting for the                                                                In another instance of perfunctory communi-
                                                       There was wide agreement with the follow-                                                                It is vitally important to make submissions so
 financial year 2016 took place in April this                                                           cations, some residents were letterboxed about
                                                    ing feedback:                                                                                            that community voices are heard. Lodge them
 year. Running through his tabled report, the                                                           a ‘pop-up’ display of WGTP plans after it had
                                                    ● We support and welcome social housing.                                                                 at www.planning.vic.gov.au/west-gate-tunnel-
 chair, Kevin Chamberlin, commented that in                                                             taken place! Nonetheless many did visit the in-
                                                    ● We don’t need more private housing in an                                                               project-hearing and request to make an oral
 the Association’s 50th year it was pleasing to                                                         formation booth outside North Melbourne Post
                                                       area already saturated with new develop-                                                              submission at the panel hearing if you wish.
 see the membership growing and that younger                                                            Office on 18 April to learn more about the pro-
                                                       ments.                                                                                                   You can view the EES documents at www.
 people were joining.
                                                    ● The proposed building heights are unaccept-       ject (formerly known as Western Distributor).        westgatetunnelproject.vic.gov.au/eesdocu-
    The committee was elected unopposed and
                                                       able in this residential and historic part of       If approved, the elevated extension of            ments/ or read hard copies at North Melbourne
 comprises: Kevin Chamberlin (chair), Jane
                                                       North Melbourne.                                 Wurundjeri Way will have a devastating effect        Library.
 Poynter (secretary), Michael Horscroft (treasur-
                                                    ● High-rise buildings do not promote commu-         on West Melbourne for the following reasons:
 er), Janet Graham (assistant secretary) and Bill
                                                       nity connectedness.                              ● It will be noisy. WGTP modelling shows             NWMA’s 50th birthday
 Cook, Cecilia Gason, Sue Scarfe and Geraldine
                                                    ● What fosters a safe environment is a mix of          that traffic noise will (just) meet the           To celebrate this milestone the Association is
 Suter (ordinary committee members).
                                                       residents, including the elderly and especial-      VicRoads standard of 63 dB(A). On this            planning at least one event this year, including
 Abbotsford Street Estate ‘renewal’                    ly families.                                        basis no sound barrier is planned.                something for the Spring Fling. If any readers
 As part of the State Government’s $185 mil-        ● The estate should therefore contain fewer         ● The road will be 10 metres high, which is          have suggestions for a suitable event, please
 lion plan to redevelop nine public housing sites      single-bedroom dwellings and more with              higher than the Regional Rail Link tracks,        let us know.
 across Melbourne, it is proposing to demolish         three or four bedrooms.                             and within 100 metres of residences.
 and rebuild the North Melbourne estate on the      ● All current residents must be guaranteed          ● It will increase pollution, with thousands of      Contact details for NWMA
 land bounded by Abbotsford, Haines, Curzon            accommodation in the new estate.                    trucks using the road every day and night.        Meetings are held at 7.30pm on the third
 and Molesworth streets. (See cover story in        ● There should be much more open space of           ● It will destroy visual amenity, just when the      Tuesday of the month at the Bastow Institute
 this edition.)                                        varying types to cater for children’s play and      City of Melbourne has launched plans to           in Queensberry Street. Email info@nwma.
    There has been much criticism by the               ball games (kick-to-kick), informal social          beautify Railway Place as part of the West        org.au for information or visit our website at
 estate’s tenants and local residents of the           gatherings and community gardening.                 Melbourne Structure Plan with vehicle re-         www.nwma.org.au. At the meeting on 20 June,
 Department of Health & Human Services’ poor        ● Buildings should be no more than four sto-           strictions, more plantings and pedestrian and     guest speakers from Melbourne City Council’s
 efforts to contact and engage those affected.         reys, to prevent overshadowing and maxim-           cycle links to Docklands.                         Placemaking and Engagement team will be
 At meetings called for neighbouring residents         ise access to sunlight.                          ● It will compromise future development of           presenting.

 Local community lawyers say reduce
 homelessness, don’t criminalise
 John Mangan and Dan Stubbs                         House drop-in centre in North Melbourne, was        Activities Local Law are against the spirit of       nise that “people with special circumstances
                                                    referred to Inner Melbourne Community Legal         the law, contravene the Victorian Charter of         are disproportionately, and often irrevocably,

 S
                                                    (IMCL) service in Queensberry Street, who           Rights and Responsibilities and undermine            caught up in the system. In a just society, the
        teve was doing it tough. He had been in     helped him handle his fines.                        recent council and state measures that will help     response to people with special circumstances
        crisis accommodation in the inner city         The legal service helps over 200 people          significantly in reducing homelessness in the        should not be to issue them with an infringe-
        for a number of weeks when he picked        each year who are homeless, or in danger of         long term.                                           ment notice”.
 up a fistful of parking fines. There were only     homelessness. A significant proportion of              As the council has acknowledged, it is not          IMCL proposes improving services and af-
 two-hour parking bays in the vicinity and he       those people have problems with infringe-           illegal to be homeless. However, the amending        fordable housing options for Victorians, rather
 wasn’t able to get a permit. Being homeless,       ments.                                              law will make it an offence for a person to          than putting the homeless on an ‘infringements
 it was one more stress he didn’t need while           Based on its extensive experience of the         ‘camp’ in any public place. Given that the term      roundabout’ which will drain community re-
 trying to sort things out.                         impact of infringements on people experienc-        ‘camp’ is undefined and open to broad inter-         sources while being unlikely to stop people
    He’s one of hundreds of Melburnians who         ing homelessness, the service has made a sub-       pretation, this effectively includes — whether       with limited choices sleeping rough.
 could be affected by new laws designed to          mission to the City of Melbourne opposing the       intended or not — homeless people sleeping             In the case of Steve, the legal service and
 reduce the number of people sleeping rough.        changes to the sleeping-rough laws.                 rough, and may make criminals of them.               Ozanam assisted him in securing permanent
    “If you’re sleeping rough, you have no             The service is particularly concerned that          IMCL’s submission notes that when the             accommodation. IMCL agrees with Steve, that
 money,” Steve says. “So how are you going to       criminalising homelessness will further             Infringements Act was introduced 11 years            the focus should be on solving the problems
 pay the fines? A lot of these people have got a    entrench disadvantage, and tie up both the          ago the Victorian attorney-general, Rob Hulls,       of homeless people, rather than adding to their
 mental illness or substance or alcohol issues,     authorities and the rough sleepers in lengthy,      detailed that the law endeavours “to filter peo-     woes with onerous fines.
 so fines are just going to be on top of having     expensive processes that in many cases are          ple out of the system who cannot understand
 no money and having no home.”                      unlikely to see the fines paid.                     or control their offending behaviour”. The           You can view IMCL’s submission on their
    Steve, who was getting help at Ozanam              In fact, the proposed amendments to the          legislative framework, he said, ought to recog-      website, www.imcl.org.au.

                                                                                                                                     City North                                 Physiotherapy
                                                                                                                                   PHYSIOTHERAPY CLINIC                         Massage
                                                                                                                                                                                Pilates

                                                                                                                      59 Errol Street
                                                                                                                     North Melbourne
                                                                                                                                                                                         city
                                                                                                                  Open Monday to Saturday                                                north

                                                                                                                                                                                physiotherapy clinic

                                   Photo: Ralph Alphonso, courtesy Inner Melbourne Community Legal
You can also read