In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine

Page created by Jeff Yates
 
CONTINUE READING
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
In this issue...
Buzzing with prospects page 18    Soil-led solutions page 74
New OSR varieties, new IPM ways   Worcs farmer pioneers carbon culture

Robot farming page 60             Virus-beating beet page 77
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
Opinion
                                                                                  4    Talking Tilth - A word from the editor.
                    Volume 23 Number 6
                                                                                  6    Smith’s Soapbox - Views and opinions from an Essex peasant…..
                            May 2021
                                                                                 58 Tech Respect - CPM ’s machinery editor surveys the search for UK Ag’s next step.
                                                                                 72 Trade Talk - Industry views from AICC chairman Sean Sparling
                                                                                 91 Last Word - A view from the field from CPM’s technical editor.

                                                                                  Technical
                                                                                  8    Crop Doctor - Disease slows in dry April
                                                                                       The cool, dry April has slowed crop growth and disease development.
                                                                                 12 New fungicide - Flag leaf gets new option
                                                                                       Univoq brings a new site of action to T2 fungicide programmes.
                                                                                 14 Bioscience Insider - Finding the unicorn
                                                                                       The story of one of the more recent discoveries in plant physiology.
                                                                                 18 Battling the beetle - Cover all bases
                                                                                       There’s a whole host of measures currently surfacing that seem to help.
CPM would like to thank Jake Freestone for supplying the stunning front cover    22 Insiders View - Something to get Excited about…
 photo. At his request we have donated £50 to the Mind your Head campaign              Improved genetics may encourage oilseed rape growers.
                        Editor                                                   26 Innovation Insight - A breakthrough in genetics
                  Tom Allen-Stevens                                                    Two OSR varieties contain a new resistance gene – RlmS.
                    Technical editor                                             30 Regenerative agriculture - Biology comes first
                  Lucy de la Pasture                                                   Wheat options for the regenerative agriculture grower this autumn.
                   Machinery editor
                Charlotte Cunningham                                             34 Insiders View - Sky-high resistance
                                                                                       A Group 3 offering which claims the title of the best septoria resistance.
                        Writers
     Tom Allen-Stevens       Charlotte Cunningham                                38 Fit for the Future - An integrated approach
                                                                                       The role genetics and variety choice play in IPM strategies.
        Mike Abram             Lucy de la Pasture
        Rob Jones                                                                42 Real Results Pioneers - Tools for a new way of farming
                                                                                       Spring barley has been part of the cropping mix on a Shropshire farm.
                Design and production
                    Brooks Design
                                                                                 46 Rotational Resilience - A rye resurgence?
                                                                                       Elsoms has been investing in the crop’s research and genetics.
              Advertisement co-ordinator
                     Peter Walker
                                                                                 50 Agri-intelligence update - Stewarding the Transition
                                                                                       The mist is beginning to clear on environmental enhancement.
                       Publisher
                                                                                 54 Theory to Field - The rise of bromes
                   Angus McKirdy                                                       Results from a four-year AHDB project.
            Business development manager
                 Charlotte Alexander
                   To claim two crop protection BASIS points, send an email to
                                                                                  Machinery
                   linda@basis-reg.co.uk, quoting reference CP/100659/2021/g.
                                                                                 60 Smart technology - Driving evolution
                   To claim two NRoSO CPD points, please send your name,               The global requirement for more sustainable agriculture is driving innovation.
                   NRoSO member number, date of birth and postcode to
                   angus@cpm-magazine.co.uk                                      64 Material handlers - Lessening the load
                                                                                       The right handler can bring a multitude of benefits on farm.
  *the claim ‘best read specialist arable journal’ is based
      on independent reader research conducted by                                68 On Farm Opinion - Consistency pays off
                                                                                       Running a fleet of efficient tractors brings huge benefits.
                 McCormack Media 2020
                  Editorial & advertising sales
  CPM Ltd, 1 Canonbury, Shrewsbury, Shropshire SY3 7AG                            Innovation
  Tel: (01743) 369707 E-mail: angus@cpm-magazine.co.uk
                                                                                 74 Climate Change Champions - An active community
  Reader registration hotline 01743 861122                                             The thriving soils of a Worcestershire estate are carefully managed.
                          Advertising copy
                        Brooks Design,
     24 Claremont Hill, Shrewsbury, Shropshire SY1 1RD
                                                                                  Roots
     Tel: (01743) 244403 E-mail: fred@brooksdesign.co.uk
                                                                                 77 Sugar beet varieties - Virus tolerance makes debut
 CPM Volume 23 No 6. Editorial, advertising and sales offices are at                  The 2022 BBRO/BSPB Recommended List was released last month.
        CPM Ltd, 1 Canonbury, Shrewsbury, SY1 9NX England.
    Tel: (01743) 369707. CPM is published eleven times a year by                 80 Potatoes - Alternaria – another evolving threat?
     CPM Ltd and is available free of charge to qualifying farmers                    Early blight has become a more significant disease in some varieties.
              and farm managers in the United Kingdom.
    In no way does CPM Ltd endorse, notarise or concur with any of the           84 Research Briefing - Blight wars: late blight strikes back
    advice, recommendations or prescriptions reported in the magazine.                Latest analysis of blight strains shows a further evolution of the pathogen.
 If you are unsure about which recommendations to follow, please consult
  a professional agronomist. Always read the label. Use pesticides safely.       88 Pushing performance - Getting the most from chemistry
      CPM Ltd is not responsible for loss or damage to any unsolicited                The odds of hitting your target go dramatically up when you aim at it.
                      material, including photographs.
                                                                                                                      crop production magazine may 2021 3
    CPM (Print) ISSN 2753-9040         CPM (Online) ISSN 2753-9059
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
accuracy of what he’s doing,       inefficiency. He also needs to        up by fourth generation
                                        is stupefying.                  learn to do the job while he’s        farmer Sam Watson-Jones
                                              Tom’s ready for           moving along, which will be no        and tech entrepreneur
                                            commercial roll-out. You    mean feat, considering he has         Ben Scott-Robinson, who
                                              don’t buy him, but hire   to remain well earthed while          formed the Tom, Dick, Harry
                                                him in, under the       zapping and needs pinpoint            and Wilma vision and the plan
                                                Small Robot Company     precision.                            to commercialise it as a
                                               (SRC) Farming as a          Harry will complete the trio       service. Presented just three
                                            Service arrangement,        of trundling farm bots and will       years ago at Oxford (still with
                                          which works a bit like        plant the seeds. He’s still in        no prototype) importantly
Is robot                               contract farming. The price      development, says SRC, but             farmers have led its
farming real?                        paid by Hants grower Craig         rumours suggest he’ll use a           development since.
                                    Livingstone, who’s been trialling   novel low-draught planter unit           So it genuinely was a very
                                    the service, is £40/ha, and for     to ensure the system keeps its        moving milestone moment to
I think it was a bit of a           that he receives four scans in      low ground pressure promise           see Tom operate autonomously
milestone moment.                   the autumn and three in the         –– Tom puts less impact on the        and Dick actually kill weeds.
   Tom was shuffling about on       spring. Over a 6ha field, Tom’s     soil than a human foot.               The technical barriers they’ve
the headland, his AI somewhat       found 12.7M plants, around             So why’s this a milestone          overcome have been numerous
laboriously lining him up for the   250,000 of which were weeds.        moment? I’ve followed the             and immense, and the doubts
next bout he was due to scan.          These are analysed by            concept ever since it was             that it could never happen have
Dick meanwhile had gathered         Wilma, the AI brains of the         presented by Prof Simon               been overcome. It makes you
his spiderlike frame over a patch   operation, who can now              Blackmore at the Oxford               wonder where agri-tech will
of weeds, sank in his earth rod,    distinguish between wheat           Farming Conference in 2014.           take us next.
and three fast-moving probes        and grassweeds, including           Interestingly titled ‘Farming
were seeking out the weeds,         blackgrass. What you get is a       with robots 2050’, the idea was
                                                                                                               Tom Allen-Stevens has a
frying them with a crackle and      per-plant map of your fields.       brilliant –– why use heavy,
                                                                                                               170ha arable farm in Oxon
spark of electricity, much to          Dick is only at the prototype    expensive and damaging
                                                                                                               and is an investor in the
the delight of the onlooking        stage, says SRC. Guided by          machines when the job could
                                                                                                               Small Robot Company.
journalists.                        Wilma, this is the weeding          be done far more efficiently
   For those a bit perplexed,       bot which uses technology           with a swarm of robots? But it         tom@cpm-magazine.co.uk
we’re talking robots. Last month    developed by Rootwave to put        was pure sci-fi.                       @tomallenstevens
saw the commercial launch of        an 8kV electric charge through         Inspired by this, it was taken
Tom, an orange-bodied cross         the weed, effectively boiling it
between a deer and an ATV, that     so it dies. It runs off a Tesla
                                                                        Tom the scouting bot and Dick, armed with weed-zapping probes.
autonomously prowls the crops       battery, and the aim is to get
up to GS30, mapping everything      the weeds when they’re small,
that he finds. Covering 20ha        which requires a zap of only
in an 8hr day, he gathers a         around 10W for 0.5s. How long
staggering 6TB of data –– this      the battery will last presumably
includes the pinpoint position of   depends on your weed burden.
crop plants and importantly,           Dick’s going to be tested this
exactly where the weeds are.        autumn. His handler, senior
   He’ll spot a slug, a lapwing     robot engineer Andy Hall,
nest, a beetle. Give him a nose     assures that he’s very accurate
and he’ll smell your soil, ears     at locating weeds in the X, Y
and he’ll record the birdsong.      plane (forwards, sideways),
The potential for this fledgling    but still has to perfect the Z
bot, still nervously righting his   movement (up and down) of
wheels and gathering his            his three probes –– a spark,
position, keen to be sure of the    although exciting, is a sign of
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
sweet smell of first-cut silage          of intervention support and         longer reverberate with the
                                   and oilseed rape pollen has laid         protective tariffs.                 song ‘Hooray, hooray, the first
                                    across the mid-spring air, there           For the farmers these were       of May, subsidy form-filling
                                        has been a less noble               heydays largely free from red       begins today’.
                                           fragrance of paperwork           tape when the financial support        But the question remains,
                                             filling the farmyard during    arrived embedded in the grain       although by the mid-2020s
                                             the fifth month of the year.   cheque. All the farmer had to       most of us will be free of this
                                             Since the early 90s, May       do was grow the crop and sell       May-time task, what new
                                          has been the month when           the produce. But for three          tangled bureaucratic labyrinth
                                       you need to get the support          decades now, with the advent        will have replaced it? With new
May the mayhem                     payment applications in.                 of set-aide and area payments       convoluted tiers of countryside
                                        There was a time called the         introduced in the early 90s,        stewardship alongside an ever
diminish                           1980s, almost forgotten now,             forms and maps have been            longer list of equipment grants
                                   when life for the arable farmer          found strewn across the farm        not to mention the SFI, the FSF,
                                   was remarkably free from form            office desk every May.              the FIF and whatever new three
For a generation of farmers        filling. In these times subsidies           For those of us who can          letter acronyms are coming
the merrie month of May isn’t      vital to most farm’s income were         remember those A3-sized IACS        over the hill –– one suspects
just associated with emerging      paid somewhat covertly through           forms with their endless lines of   the paper chase is not likely to
barley awns and fungicide          a price support system called            eye-boggling boxes to fill in,      diminish in the future.
applications to wheat flag         intervention buying. When world          today’s BPS form seems a walk          Of course, we are promised
leaves but it has also become      grain prices slumped towards             in the park, especially this year   a post-Brexit world of simpler
a month of last minute form        the £50/t level, UK farmers              with no EFA to worry about.         forms and lighter inspections.
filling.                           along with their EU brethren             Things used to be a lot more        I suspect I’m not the only one
    For thirty years now, as the   could achieve £100/t because             nerve-jangling where a slip of      who will only believe these
                                                                            the pen or the striking of a        Brexiteer promises when I
                                                                            wrong calculator button could       actually witness them firsthand
                                                                            lead to mayhem more prickly         on my farm. Outside of these
                                                                            than a maybush.                     hopes of a simpler life not
                                                                               How many of us in the past       dogged by worries as to
                                                                            have tarried around the post        whether we have got our
                                                                            box before inserting a massive      applications in on time and
                                                                            envelope stuffed with forms         correctly done, I have one more
                                                                            and maps or hovered an index        wish of the new system and
                                                                            finger over the ‘submit’ button     that is that it no longer haunts
                                                                            torturing ourselves with the        my once favourite month of
                                                                            thought we have made a              the year –– that being the very
                                                                            schoolboy error that will have      merrie month of May.
                                                                            consequences far worse than
                                                                            a school detention? I’ll admit to
                                                                            nightmares where my name is
                                                                            to be found in the local papers
                                                                            under the headline ‘Local
                                                                            farmer in subsidy fraud
                                                                            scandal’ merely because
                                                                            I’d got a decimal point in the
                                                                            wrong place or rubbed out            Guy Smith grows 500ha of
                                                                            the wrong line on a map.             combinable crops on the north
                                                                               But now, of course, we have       east Essex coast, namely
                                                                            the prospect of life without         St. Osyth Marsh –– officially the
                                                                                                                 driest spot in the British Isles.
                                                                            IACS-cum-SPS-cum-BPS forms
                                                                                                                 Despite spurious claims from
                                                                            dominating our May-time frolics.     others that their farms are
                                                                            Maybe we will be able to get         actually drier, he points out
                                                                            back to proper farming as well       that his farm is in the Guinness
                                                                            as those other outside activities    Book of Records, whereas
                                                                            that traditionally start in May.     others aren’t. End of.
                                                                            In a few years hopefully the         @essexpeasant
                                                                            farmhouse kitchen will no

6 crop production magazine may 2021
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
Disease slows in dry April
                                                                                                           “    There’s a
                                                                                                         lot of leaf death and
                                                                                                          it’s damage that’s
                                                                                                         completely unrelated
                                                                                                               to disease.
                                                                                                                                    ”
                  Technical
                Crop Doctor
       The cool, dry April has                  stress from the abnormally cool weather.        sampling of the newest leaf layers has
slowed crop growth, disease                        “There’s been less than 5mm of rain          detected no yellow rust so far this season
                                                at Cawood so far this month, though the         and septoria levels appears to be static in
          development and T1                    forecast today gives a 40% chance of            the crop. It all adds up to making fungicide
 fungicide applications. CPM                    showers. It’s also been cold with frosts        decisions at T1 much more tricky than
                                                at night, but daytime temperatures have         normal, says James.
    joins the Crop Doctors as                   improved so far this week,” says                    “Even though there’s septoria bubbling
   they get back out into the                   James Howat, Bayer commercial technical         away in the lower canopy, it’s difficult to
                                                manager (CTM).                                  know whether the lesions are active
    field to see how different                                                                  enough or whether it will be wet enough
       varieties have fared at                  Yellow tipping                                  to spread up the canopy.”
                                                Wandering into a plot of KWS Palladium, a           There’s clearly going to be a call on
Cawood, Long Sutton, Callow                     hopeful for the AHDB Recommended List,          T2 decisions too. Plots will get Ascra
               and Great Tew.                   Fiona has a closer look at the yellow           (prothioconazole+ bixafen+ fluopyram) but
                                                tipping. “You can see clear crimp marks         James will use at the minimum 1.0 l/ha rate
            By Lucy de la Pasture               on the leaves where the growth has been         if it remains dry and septoria pressure
                                                checked by either a frost or a PGR              in the upper canopy isn’t a serious
                                                application in the cold weather. A lot of the   concern. “At the 1.0 l/ha rate it still delivers
 As the country begins to open up after         varieties are showing tipping, but the          a 65% azole dose, in line with stewardship
 lockdown, the Crop Doctors are able to get     degree probably varies between varieties        recommendations.”
 back out into the field to assess the Bayer    because they will have differed in growth           Fiona’s thoughts are that it will need
 regional trials sites, albeit not as their     stage at the time of the stress, making         particularly ‘splashy’ or sustained rain
 usual double act. SRUC’s Prof Fiona            some more susceptible than others.”             events for septoria to make the jump from
 Burnett visits Cawood in North Yorkshire          Another leaf effect visible in some wheat    leaf six to the newly emerging leaves,
 and Long Sutton in Lincolnshire on             varieties, KWS Firefly in particular, is        with leaf three emerging at the time
 27 April, while ADAS’s Jonathan Blake          abiotic spotting –– further indicating that     of her visit and leaves four and five
 reports from the Callow site in                the weather during April has been a long        appearing clean. But even so, it’s not a
                                                                                                                                               ▲

 Herefordshire and the Great Tew Estate         way from the norm. In the barley plots,
 in Oxfordshire on the second day of            physiological spotting is even more
 the tour.                                      prominent, she notes.
                                                   As far as disease goes most of the
 Nowt brewing in Yorks                          varieties look relatively clean, explains
 At the end of March the Crop Doctors gave      James. “The plots received 1.0 l/ha Aviator
 the winter wheat and barley sites at           XPro (bixafen+ prothioconazole) at T1 on
 Cawood an almost clean bill of health.         25 April. We’ve found around 80% of plots
 The prolonged dry period in April means        have mildew lurking at the base of the
 very little has changed on the disease front   canopy on lower leaves and stems, some
 but the soil is now visibly cracked, more      septoria is present on leaf six but there’s     Mildew is lurking at the base of the majority of
 reminiscent of June than April, and both       very little yellow rust to be seen.”            varieties at Cawood, pictured here in Crusoe.
 wheat and barley are showing signs of             The Rapid Disease Detection (RDD)

  8 crop production magazine may 2021
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
In this issue... Buzzing with prospects page 18 New OSR varieties, new IPM ways Soil-led solutions page 74 - cpm magazine
Crop Doctor
    good reason to take out the T1 in                   “You don’t expect yellow rust to go from
▲

her book.                                           being present at that level at the end of
    “Septoria is pretty visible, even though        March to being not much of an issue by
low down, and there is also mildew there.           the end of April. It would normally have
It’s worth remembering that chlorothalonil          been catastrophic in the untreated plots by
gave fungicide programmes invisible help            now but this season the frost has controlled
in the past, effectively propping up                it as well as any fungicide,” he says.
programmes. To get to the same point                    Although yellow rust could still be found,
without it will mean making the best use of         most noticeably in KWS Zyatt but also
the available chemistry, and that probably          present in Gleam, Shabras and KWS
means using an SDHI plus azole at T1 at a           Kinetic, the infection is in distinct foci
site like this but moderating the dose due to       rather than being widespread, notes              Eyespot lesions were hard to spot but the
the lower-than-normal disease pressure.”            Darren. The dead leaves in the lower             eagle-eyed Crop Doctors found some
                                                    canopy and leaf scarring in Zyatt are            non-penetrating stem-based browning in
Behind at Long Sutton                               evidence of the disease that has been            Skyscraper at Long Sutton.
Further south at David Hoyle’s farm in Long         and gone.
Sutton, South Lincolnshire, the wheat is                Septoria is even harder to find at the       day before is like comparing apples
about two and a half weeks behind where it          site, where even KWS Barrel –– one of the        with pears.
would normally be at the end of April and           best indicators of septoria pressure ––               Drilled at the end of September, the
T1 sprays are still a good week away, says          appears to be remarkably clean. Darren           Callow plots have much thicker, bolder
Darren Adkins, CTM at Bayer.                        reports that the RDD sampling has found          canopies than the later drilled Lincolnshire
    “The site received a T0 on 13 April and it      zero latent septoria infection present on        site. With just 22mm of rain during March
hasn’t really moved on since then due to            leaves four and five, confirming that, for       and a further 11mm in the form of snow
the dry and cold.”                                  now, disease pressure is low.                    during April, the cracking in the ground
    David confirms that so far there have               For David, the T1 spray will be more         bears testimony that the western site is
been 15 frosts during April, often a cold           about the physiological benefits than            also dry for the time of year. Even so,
northerly wind and just 5mm of rain since           disease control and he is cutting back his       septoria is surprisingly easy to find and
15 March. Potash applied on 23 March is             fungicide spend at this timing. “I’m planning    more active than at the previous sites on
still evident on the baked soil surface,            on using either prothioconazole on its own or    the Crop Doctor tour, says Jonathan.
further evidence of an April without                with tebuconazole or a strobe as a partner            “Where septoria was found on leaf six
showers.                                            or with folpet as well, depending on the         at the other sites, here there are active
    The wheat plots were muddled in at the          variety. I’m saving the better chemistry         lesions on the tip of leaf five which is
end of October after veg, he adds, leaving          for later, using an SDHI at T2 and T3 as         close to the newly emerging leaves and
a crop that Jonathan Blake describes as             historically we’re often wet here during         increases the risk of septoria spreading
‘open’. He had called into the site a few           June, so we can capitalize on the soil’s         up the canopy.”
days earlier on 23 April and he joins his           natural water holding ability and keep the            In spite of differences in the canopies
fellow Crop Doctor virtually to compare             crop greener for longer to drive yield.”         between varieties, with KWS Barrel low and
notes on disease levels at the site.                    The bigger decision is which PGR to          flat to the ground and KWS Extase looking
    “There’s a lot of leaf death at Long Sutton     use, he adds. “Crops are small and               upright and knee height, there’s very
and it’s damage that’s completely unrelated         stressed now, but if it becomes warm and         little difference in their physiological
to disease. It’s the leaf tipping that makes it     wet then they’re going to romp through           development, with leaf three emerged,
a difficult crop to look at.”                       their growth stages and fall over.”              says Gareth. He reports the site received
    Dissecting plants, Jonathan finds leaf              Comparing the site to her earlier visit      its T1 spray the previous day, in advance
four emerging –– making leaf emergence at           to Cawood Fiona says the tipping isn’t as        of the light rain that fell overnight and into
the site a leaf behind the more northerly site      evident at Long Sutton, but that’s because       the morning of the visit.
at Cawood. During the Crop Doctors last             it’s slightly hidden by the leaf above it in          David adds that most of his crops in his
visit, yellow rust was the biggest concern          the canopy. “The openness of the crop            North Herefordshire/South Shropshire/
and was readily found in a number of                means there’s very little humidity in the
varieties.                                          canopy to get disease cycling.
                                                    Consequently it’s less evident than at
                                                    Cawood, which although a low disease
                                                    site I consider warrants a reduced rate
                                                    of SDHI. I would agree that here at
                                                    Long Sutton a lighter touch is justified.”

                                                    Septoria lurking at Callow
                                                    On day two of the Crop Doctor tour
                                                    Jonathan Blake visited his local Bayer
Wheat is being irrigated at David Hoyles’ farm as
                                                    trials site at Callow in Herefordshire,          Yellow rust had largely been subdued by the night
part of an AHDB project, even though costs vary
                                                    accompanied by Bayer CTM Gareth Bubb             frosts but was still bubbling away in KWS Zyatt at
from £80-400/ha depending on the water supply
                                                    and AICC agronomist David Lines.                 Long Sutton.
and infrastructure.
                                                    Comparing the site with Long Sutton the

    10 crop production magazine may 2021
Crop Doctor
Worcestershire patch are levelling up when                            Wolverine is another variety to watch
it comes to growth stage, with even the                            carefully, believes Jonathan. “It was drilled
late-drilled wheats now with leaf three                            early because of its BYDV resistance
40-50% emerged.                                                    but has since had its septoria rating
    Yellow tipping and leaf scarring is                            downgraded on the RL to 5.2, which when
evident at the Callow site, similar to the                         combined with early drilling will accentuate
two sites visited the previous day, but                            the problem.”
some varieties stand out for all the wrong                            Yellow rust is almost absent, with
reasons. Jonathan describes Costello as                            the exception of KWS Kinetic –– an
looking particularly ‘ugly’, RL candidate                          observation which could mean something
variety RGT Bairstow as ‘not pretty’ and                           interesting is going on with yellow rust
Kinetic as ‘yellow from a distance’.                               strains since none of the other susceptible
LG Skyscraper has easy to find septoria                            varieties have infection, points out Gareth.
and noticeable leaf scarring, Graham is                               “At Callow it’s not a protective scenario
far from clean and Gleam has a structure                           for septoria as it was at Long Sutton, so it
where the septoria infection is particularly                       warrants an SDHI at T1 in many varieties,”
close to the emerging leaves, he notes.                            says Jonathan. “With some of the more
In contrast, septoria resistant variety                            septoria-resistant varieties you can
                                                                                                                                   Septoria is evident in both early and later-drilled
Theodore stands out as ‘green and clean’.                          probably get away with a lower input
                                                                                                                                   Gravity at Great Tew in Oxfordshire.
                                                                   strategy because although it’s still possible
                                                                   to find septoria, it will progress more slowly
                                                                   in the crop as there will be less latent                        Even in later-drilled fields, Gravity has
                                                                   infection than usual.”                                          active septoria on leaves five and six,
                                                                      Gareth adds that the interval between                        he says.
                                                                   T1 and T2 is likely to be much closer than                          Having seen three of the four sites for
                                                                   normal this spring but warns that, whatever                     himself, Jonathan’s of the view that visible
                                                                   happens, not to be tempted to compromise                        disease levels aren’t that dissimilar to
                                                                   the timing of the T2 –– which remains the                       normal on the lower leaf layers at Great
                                                                   most crucial timing in wheat, even if it’s                      Tew and Callow, but the big difference is
                                                                   less than three weeks after the T1 goes on.                     likely to be lower levels of latent infection
                                                                                                                                   on leaves five, four and newly emerging
                                                                   Promise at Great Tew                                            leaf three, a result of the predominantly
                                                                   Final destination on day two is Colin                           dry weather during April.
                                                                   Woodward’s farm at Great Tew in                                     Ben agrees and adds, “Leaf four has
                                                                   Oxfordshire, where he takes Jonathan and                        been present for 3-4 weeks this spring and
                                                                   Bayer’s Ben Giles for a whistle-stop tour of                    normally that would result in plenty of latent
At Callow, septoria lesions on the older leaves of                 some of his wheat in the welcome rain.                          septoria in the leaf, but this year the results
Skyscraper are right next to emerging leaves due                      Jonathan reports ‘substantial levels of                      from the RDD sampling have consistently
to the structure of the canopy.                                    septoria’ in September-sown Gravity, which                      picked up no latent disease across sites
                                                                   is always a good barometer for septoria.                        and varieties on leaf four.”
                                                                                                                                       He highlights the most recent RDD
   National septoria snapshot – April 2021, week three                                                                             results from five varieties at the local Bayer
                                                                                                                                   site, Hinton Waldrist, from testing earlier in
                                                                                                                                   the week. “As an example, RGT Saki had
                                                                                                                                   visible septoria on leaf six, the RDD results
                                                                                                                                   showed latent infection on leaf five but zero
                                                                                                                                   infection on leaf four.”
                                                                                                                                       Ben believes it’s important not to be
                                                                                                                                   lulled into a false sense of security
                                                                                                                                   because, even though the dry weather has
                                                                                                                                   paused the spread of infection, septoria is
                                                                                                                                   present in crops and the important leaves
                                                                                                                                   are about to emerge. Much will hinge on
                                                                                                                                   the weather during May, he says.
                                                                                                                                       The rain has certainly made the T1
                                                                                                                                   decision much easier for Colin, particularly
                                                                                                                                   for the Extase which hasn’t received any
                                                                                                                                   fungicide up until now. “With wheat prices
                                                                                                                                   at around £200/t it’s going to be worth
                                                                                                                                   looking after crops this spring and
Source: Bayer Rapid Disease Detection monitoring – samples of the newest leaf layers are taken from single commercial fields and   maintaining green leaf for as long as
are not representative of the whole country.
                                                                                                                                   possible,” he says. ■

                                                                                                                                       crop production magazine may 2021 11
“    Inatreq is
                                                                                                                       in a new chemical
                                                                                                                              class.
                                                                                                                                            ”
  Flag leaf gets
           new option
                 Technical
             New fungicide
Univoq has been launched by                               Greg explains that fungicides are                  Greg notes the shrinking chemical
Corteva Agriscience, bringing                          grouped by the Fungicide Resistance Action         armoury as actives lose approval and
                                                       Committee (FRAC) according first to their          pathogen resistance builds to those
    a new site of action to T2                         biological effects on the fungal cell, so          remaining. “As remaining chemistries come
      fungicide programmes.                            whether they have an effect on respiration,        under increasing selection pressure, it’s
                                                       steroid biosynthesis, or perhaps cell division.    important we protect them, and that’s where
 CPM finds out how it works,                           They’re then classified according to               QiI will come in,” he says.
 how it performs and how to                            target site and cross-resistance with those           “But history teaches us the risk of
                                                       target sites.                                      resistance to single-site inhibitors is high and
                 look after it.                                                                           FRAC assumes for QiIs it is medium to high.
                                                       No cross-resistance                                So Inatreq needs a robust resistance
              By Tom Allen-Stevens                     “Inatreq affects respiration, sitting in the       management strategy, particularly for
                                                       C4 Group 21: complex III cytochrome bc1            septoria.”
  Cereal growers have a new fungicide for              ubiquinone reductase group. Cyazofamid                Only one QiI-containing product may be
  the flag leaf spray and a new site of action         and amisulbrom, both used for potato blight,       applied to a cereal crop in a season, and
  on septoria –– the first to be registered in         also sit in this group. But unlike Inatreq, they   dose should be adjusted appropriately ––
  the UK for 15 years.                                 have no practcal activity on ascomycetes           1.5 l/ha is likely to be right for susceptible
      Univoq combines Inatreq, the new                 and basidiomycetes fungi. So although they         varieties and locations where septoria is a
  active from Corteva Agriscience, with                sit in the same group, there’s no risk of          significant problem, he says, while a typical
  prothioconazole. It offers curative and              cross-resistance because they’re not used          dose is likely to be 1.25 l/ha.
  protectant control of all septoria strains,          in the same market segment.”                          “Always apply it in a mixture with different
  as well as label approval for other major                As for its mode of action, Inatreq affects     MoAs at balanced doses. Use other
  diseases in wheat, rye, triticale and durum          the mitochondria –– the power station of           integrated strategies, such as resistant
  wheat. Univoq’s iQ-4 formulation is designed         fungal cells. It blocks fungal respiration and     varieties and decision support systems.
  to ensure it sticks to and spreads across            reduces the ability of a cell to produce           All of these elements should be folded
  the leaf.                                            adenosine triphosphate, inhibiting growth          into an effective resistance management
      “Inatreq is the first example of a new           so the fungus dies, continues Greg.                strategy,” stresses Greg.
  chemical class –– the picolinamides and                  “Strobilurins also bind at complex III, but       Available as the co-formulation Univoq,
  its active ingredient is fenpicoxamid,”              on the outside of the membrane (QoI) while         this offers effective control of major diseases
  explains Dr Greg Kemmitt, global fungicide           SDHIs target complex II. So there’s no             in wheat, notes Stuart Jackson, Corteva
  development lead at Corteva.                         target-site cross-resistance to other              technical lead for cereal fungicides.
      “An interesting aspect is that it’s derived      chemistries.”                                         He points to 2019 trials with KWS Barrel at
  from fermentation. We take streptomyces                  Tests on UK septoria isolates were carried
  bacteria and ferment it to produce an                out at Rothamsted Research by Prof Bart
  antibiotic –– UK-2A. Then there’s a                  Fraaje. All had G143A mutation for strobilurin
  single-step modification with this to deliver        resistance and various mutations in Cyp51,
  Inatreq. When it’s sprayed in the field, the         conferring varying levels of resistance to
  novel element is that it converts back to the        triazoles. These were very effectively
  natural product UK-2A inside the plant or            controlled by Inatreq and fluxapyroxad.
  fungal tissue, which has the fungicidal activity.”   Against isolates exhibiting overexpression
      There’s also a new target site –– the first in   and one that may also contain a non-specific
  nearly two decades in cereals. Inatreq is a          efflux pump, Inatreq again showed very
  quinone inside inhibitor (QiI). “This brings it      good control, reports Greg. “When tested
  outstanding curative and protective activity         on isolates that show a degree of resistance       Outstanding is how Stuart Jackson describes
  against septoria as well as useful activity on       to the SDHI bixafen, Inatreq again gave            Univoq’s level of control of septoria in wheat.
  leaf rusts,” he says.                                good control.”

  12 crop production magazine may 2021
Sawbridgeworth near Stansted                      trials in 2019 at Bishop’s Frome,
airport comparing T2 doses                        Herefordshire, on some
of Univoq at 1.25 l/ha, 1.5 l/ha                  Reflection with very high levels
and 2 l/ha against a 75% dose                     of yellow rust. Elatus Era and
of Ascra (bixfen+ fluopyram+                      Ascra gave good control when
prothioconazole), Elatus Era                      assessed 50 days after
(benzovindiflupyr+ prothiocona-                   application and Univoq per-
zole) and Librax (fluxapyroxad+                   formed at least as well as Elatus
metconazole).                                     Era in the trial,” says Stuart.
   “There were very high levels                       Brown rust trials were carried
of septoria in the untreated plots.               out at Little Clacton, Essex in
Univoq showed outstanding                         2020 on Crusoe. “Assessed 57
disease control when assessed                     days after treatment was applied,
at 40 days after application,                     Univoq was every bit as good
significantly better than the                     as the standard Elatus Era
current SDHI offering. This                       treatment.”
manifests into grain in the shed                      Univoq contains 50g/l of
–– significantly increased yield                  fenpicoxamid and 100g/l of
over Ascra,” he adds.                             prothioconazole with only one
   In 2020, Univoq was                            dose allowed at a maximum rate
compared with Ascra and                           of 2 l/ha. It can be used from GS
Revystar XE (fluxapyroxad+                        30-69 to control septoria, yellow
mefentrifluconazole) at Ivington                  rust, brown rust, fusarium, tan
near Leominster in AICC trials                    spot and powdery mildew in all
again on Barrel. Here it gave                     winter and spring varieties of
noticeably better control than                    wheat, rye, triticale and durum
Ascra and Revystar, reports                       wheat. There’s an aquatic buffer
Stuart, and again the benefits                    zone of 12m and for the first
came through in yield response.                   30m, 3* low-drift nozzles should
   “We put Univoq in yellow rust                  be used. ■

  Trial comparisons give Univoq the edge
  A summary of 24 trials in 2020, in              a partner fungicide for brown rust
  which disease was present                       or follow up with a T3 spray. It was
  throughout the season, compares                 the out-and-out septoria trials
  Univoq at 1.25 l/ha with Revystar               where Univoq performed better
  at 1 l/ha (chart below). 58% of the             than Revystar.”
  trials showed a yield benefit for                   In 2019, Univoq at a 62.5%
  Univoq, delivering an overall average           dose was compared with an 80%
  yield advantage of 0.14t/ha.                    dose of Ascra in 60 trials from UK
      “The trials where it didn’t                 and Ireland. 73% of trials showed
  perform as well as Revystar were                a yield advantage of Univoq over
  brown rust trials where we                      Ascra Xpro, delivering an overall
  deliberately didn’t apply a T3 spray,”          average benefit of 0.25t/ha. Again,
  notes Stuart. “Univoq offers about              Ascra performed better in brown
  3-4 weeks control of brown rust. If             rust trials, while it was the septoria
  you need extra protection, the dose             trials where Univoq came to the
  should be increased to 1.5 l/ha, add            fore, notes Stuart.
    Univoq trial comparison with Revystar XE, 2020

  Source: Corteva Agriscience, summary of trials in UK and Ireland.
“ The
                                                                                                               trehalose
                                                                                                          pathway maintains
                                                                                                         the balance between
                                                                                                            the source and
                                                                                                                  sink.
                                                                                                                              ”

          Technical
  Bioscience Insider
                                                Finding the unicorn
      One of the more recent                    What does the science say?                            Such is the interest in T6P that there’s now
                                                                                                   an abundance of peer-reviewed research
         discoveries in plant                   It’s widely accepted that T6P is an indicator
                                                                                                   that demonstrates the role it plays in crops
                                                of the sucrose status in plants. It inhibits
 physiology is the trehalose                    SnRK1 protein kinase, which acts as a              and the potential T6P offers to optimise the
                                                                                                   genetic yield potential of crop plants by
   metabolic pathway. CPM                       metabolite sensor to constantly link supply
                                                                                                   manipulating its levels.
                                                and energy demand. Together the two
     finds out how one of its                   systems form a feedback loop which signals            In a paper published in Plant Physiology
                                                                                                   in 2018, this was explored by a team at
signalling molecules can be                     to the plant where it needs to allocate its
                                                                                                   Rothamsted Research, led by Dr Matthew
                                                resources.
 used to help crops recover                         An easy analogy that illustrates the           Paul. He noted that the T6P pathway may
                                                                                                   widely impact crop improvement.
    from drought stress and                     importance of the T6P metabolic pathway is
                                                                                                      The authors also state that increasing T6P
                                                to consider it as the fuel gauge, it tells you
                 yield more.                    how much is in the tank and how far you            promotes biosynthetic pathways associated
                                                can travel, explains John.                         with grain yield, such as starch synthesis,
           By Lucy de la Pasture                    T6P is formed from glucose-6-phoshate          pointing out that ‘crops are not yet optimized
                                                and UDP-glucose (derived from sucrose).            to maximize their biosynthetic pathways for
                                                “So important is T6P in crop plants that           yield in sinks and growth recovery that are
For over a century it’s been known that         it’s emerged from relative obscurity to be         promoted by high T6P, or for the mobilization
trehalose-6-phosphate (T6P) is produced         recognised as an essential signal metabolite       of reserves and sugar transport that can
in some primitive plants, such as moss,         in plants, with influence on growth
liverworts and ferns, but the general           and development that rivals any other
consensus among scientists was that it          signalling molecule, including the major
wasn’t synthesised in higher, flowering         phytohormones.
plants. On the rare occasion when traces            “T6P signalling regulates metabolism
of the metabolite were found, it was            in the light of carbon availability and
quickly dismissed as being a result of          reprogrammes metabolism between
microbial contamination. The existence of       anabolic or catabolic pathways depending
T6P in higher plants was truly as mythical      on the carbohydrate status of the plant.
as a unicorn.                                   It’s particularly supportive during times of
   The nature of scientists is to be curious    late drought stress as T6P coordinates
and probe the limits of current knowledge,      carbohydrate partitioning to maintain yield,”
but it wasn’t until relatively recently, just   explains John.
20 years ago, that a T6P synthesis pathway          “It acts as the key regulator in the balance
was found to exist in flowering plants.         between primary and secondary metabolism
This discovery opened the door to the           and upregulates photosynthesis to                  T6P is so important in crop plants that it’s
unexpected and far-reaching effects that can    compensate for any stresses plants are             emerged from relative obscurity to be recognised
be achieved from tinkering with the plant’s     under, so maintaining growth and grain             as an essential signal metabolite, says
metabolism, says John Haywood, director         development while using resource to                John Haywood.
of Unium BioScience.                            combat the stress.

 14 crop production magazine may 2021
Bioscience Insider

   Regulation of source-sink relations by T6P/SnRK1                                       Effects of T6P on   chlorophyll
                                                                                                          The effects of T6P on chlorophyll levels in Winter Wheat
                                                                                                                             Suffolk June 2019
                                                                                         0.06000

                                                                                         0.05500

                                                                                         0.05000

                                                                                         0.04500

                                                                                         0.04000

                                                                                         0.03500

                                                                                         0.03000

                                                                                         0.02500

                                                                                         0.02000
                                                                                                              Unt                        T6P GS 37                   T6P GS 37 & 59

Source: Matthew J. Paul et al. Plant Physiol. 2018;177:12-23                           Source: Unium trial, Suffolk 2019

enable resilience that are                        has been widely researched and       the more we can see its impact
promoted by low T6P.’                             numerous peer-reviewed papers        on the plant’s ability to achieve its
   Through understanding the                      have been produced describing        potential by managing sucrose
effect of T6P on the plant, it’s                  its importance, how to practically   levels effectively and maintaining
possible to see how it could                      make use of T6P’s undoubted          them in balance.”
be applied to enhance plant                       potential in crops has been             So in theory, supplementing
performance. “Increasing T6P                      largely ignored, explains John.      plants with exogenous
levels promotes flux through                          “Increased chlorophyll levels    applications of T6P should bring
the biosynthetic pathways                         and green leaf area duration         advantages but manufacturing it
associated with growth and yield,                 supports the impact T6P has          isn’t an easy process, explains
whereas decreasing T6P levels                     upon source-sink relations,          John. But having cracked it,
promotes the mobilization of                      ie between the photosynthetic        Unium now have the first
carbon reserves and the                           factory and grain production.        commercially available product
movement of carbon associated                     The enhanced movement of             containing the metabolite,
with stress responses.                            carbohydrates to the grain is        namely 3Alo-T6P.                                 Elevating levels of T6P during the
   “Low T6P levels decrease                       supported by increased                                                                flowering period alleviates
gene expression for primary                       photosynthetic rates and             Proving the concept                              physiological stress.
metabolism (owth) and increase                    duration.”                           Taking 3Alo-T6P into the field
gene expression for secondary                         Because this pathway is the      threw up a number of questions                   could prevent exogenous
metabolism. This particularly                     key regulator of the carbohydrate    when a small number of crops                     applications of T6P from
occurs during flowering periods,                  management in plants, by             didn’t show the improvement                      overcoming any shortfall of
so upregulating T6P at this time                  stimulating this at the correct      in yield that the majority of                    the metabolite in crops,”
will promote primary metabolism                   timing it’s possible to influence    others were.                                     explains John.
for longer, thereby increasing                    plant metabolism, gene                  “It wasn’t until Unium started                   “By looking at the pathway
yield.”                                           expression and overall growth.       to examine the T6P pathway                       in detail, it’s evident there’s
                                                  It also plays a key role in starch   with leading plant physiologists                 a cascade effect from an
From Science to                                   production and amino acid            in the US, that several ‘pinch                   application of the stimulatory
Bioscience                                        metabolism, explains John.           points’, or other key limiting                   metabolite. By careful
Even though the T6P pathway                           “The more we learn about T6P,    factors, were discovered that                    considering the rest of the
                                                                                                                                        pathway, it was possible to
   Yield response to 3Alo-T6P                                                                                                           look at what the next ‘limiting’
                                                                                                                                        step may be so that could be
                                                                                                                                        overcome as well. This
                                                                                                                                        approach has helped build a
                                                                                                                                        more robust, reliable treatment.
                                                                                                                                           “Our detailed, in-field
                                                                                                                                        research also discovered a
                                                                                                                                        link with nutrition –– we know
                                                                                                                                        manganese and boron, in
                                                                                                                                        particular, are very important in
                                                                                                                                        carbohydrate management and
                                                                                                                                        an insufficiency in either of
                                                                                                                                        these will reduce the effect of
                                                                                                                                        the T6P, hence why this is
                                                                                                                                        clearly stated on the label.
The negative responses were all found to correlate with manganese/boron insufficiency                                                   This is the first time there’s
                                                                                                                                        been label recommendations
Source: Unium trials, 2018-2019
                                                                                                                                        which link use of a biostimulant
                                                                                                                                                                                      ▲

                                                                                                                              crop production magazine may 2021 15
the balance between the source
                                      and sink so crops can withstand
                                      drought impacts. By making
                                      sure the supply of T6P is
                                      elevated, the flow of
                                      carbohydrates to the grain
                                      is maintained, reducing the
                                      impact of drought on yield.”
                                         Initial proof of concept
The beneficial effects of 3Alo-T6P    work was carried out by
will be negated if crops are low in   CMI/Greencrop in the UK and
manganese or boron.                   Advanced Crop Chemicals in
                                      the USA, adds John.
   to specific nutrients in              “When T6P precursor

▲
the UK.”                              molecules were applied to
   Typical effects when Unium’s       wheat, a ‘pulse’ was created.
T6P is applied are enhanced           This resulted in sucrose being
root development, improved            drawn into the grain to make
shoot development and darker          starch, which increased grain
leaves due to enhanced                size and yield by 20%.”
chlorophyll production,                  Further trials have shown an
increasing the photosynthetic         average 8% increase in yield
capacity of plants. Typical T6P       from 3Alo-T6P application over
deficiencies are the opposite ––      69 trials, producing a return on
pale, larger and thinner leaves.      investment of £64/ha, proving
Similar impacts have been seen        itself to be very consistent and
in potatoes when unirrigated,         reliable, he adds.
he notes.
   Flowering is a critical time in    Pioneers in the field
a crop’s development and it’s         The science behind T6P is
also a time when the crop is          exciting and it appears to be
very sensitive to environmental       doing something different to
stresses, such as drought ––          other biostimulants on the
which is something that seems         market, says Mark Hemmant,
to be occurring more regularly        technical manager at Agrovista.
during British summers. This          But turning field trials results
can result in reduced seed set,       into reliable field-scale
a reduction in the number of          treatments doesn’t always
grains per ear, smaller seed          follow suit, which is why
size and grains of lower nutrient     Agrovista invest in further
content. Numerous research            development work before
studies have shown the positive       adding biostimulants products
impact T6P has on drought             to their Innovation range.
tolerance, he highlights.                “Last year was the first year
   Wheat grain has three              we had T6P in trials and it was
phases of development;                a challenging season all round.
pre-grain filling (first 10 days      We had some really good
after anthesis), the transition       anecdotal evidence in oats that
phase to grain filling and the        there was an uplift in quality as
desiccation phase (30 days            well as yield,” he says.
after anthesis), explains John.          “The oat seeds had higher
   The levels of T6P are at their     specific weights where T6P
highest in the pre-grain filling      had been applied and that’s
phase, falling dramatically from      important in a crop where so
10 days post-anthesis. So by          much depends on getting a
maximising the T6P levels             milling premium. Oats are one
during this period by applying        of those all or nothing crops
3Alo-T6P at the T2 timing, it’s       where a small difference in
possible to help mitigate             grain quality can make a big
drought stress and maximise           difference to the price you can
yield, he believes.                   sell it for.”
   “The T6P pathway maintains            The influence T6P has on
grain quality is an area
Agrovista intend to explore
further in trials this year. “We’ll
be investigating the impacts on
grain quality on various cereals
–– particularly where achieving
milling spec is critical for
profitability of the crop. It
could be a game changer,”
says Mark.
   More work is also going into
finding the best timing and
whether there is any synergy to
be had in sequencing different
biostimulants in the spring.
   “We’re looking at whether the
best effects from T6P are at T2            Mark Hemmant believes that the
or T3 or by applying it at both            grain effects noted in the field after
timings. We also found in last             T6P application in oats could be a
year’s trials that the biggest             game changer if consistent.
yield response was from a
sequence of products, with an              the drought, which makes a
amino acid at GS30, Klorofill at           recommendation a difficult call
T1 and T6P at T2.                          at this stage.
   “We’ll be trying to understand             “Because environmental
better whether this was an                 stresses are so difficult to
accumulative effect or due to              predict, our advice is to target
one part of the programme in               biostimulants during periods
particular, though it’s likely that        where the crop comes under
there’s also a seasonal effect to          physiological stress, such as
take into account too.”                    stem extension and during
   The science behind T6P is               flowering. For that reason,
also strong when it comes to               applying T6P at T2 is a good
drought recovery, though Mark              timing to help the crop deal
feels that a lot may depend                with any stresses associated
on the timing and duration of              with anthesis.” ■

  Bioscience insider
  As the chemistry toolbox continues       different seasons.
  to shrink, a mesmerising array of        Its impact on
  new bio-solutions are coming to          seed quality is
  market, offering a range of benefits     of additional
  and complementary additions.             importance for
  Evaluating just how effective they       farm-saved seed when 3Alo-T6P
  are, and where they’re best placed       is applied to the mother crop,
  can be tricky, however.                  increasing yield and nutrient density
      This series of articles opens a      of the seed, which has a knock-on
  window on the science behind             effect on the daughter crop
  these innovations. CPM has               performance. This effect amounts
  teamed up with Unium BioScience          to an average 9% increase in gross
  to explore the background, unravel       margin across both crops. This was
  the physiological processes and          confirmed in YEN analysis, where
  provide analysis on the results of       T6P increased the grain nutrient
  trials. Above all, these articles give   content by approx. 15-20% across
  the grower an inside view on             the board, giving a more nutrient
  some of the exciting opportunities       dense seed and grain.
  biosolutions offer in the field.             Learn more by joining
      3Alo-T6P has proven a very           the Unium technical group
  consistent and reliable product in       https://www.uniumbioscience.com/
  Unium trials over several                unium-technical-group
“   It’s not
                                                                                                          just the variety that
                                                                                                        makes the difference –
                                                                                                        it’s everything you do
                                                                                                                around it.
                                                                                                                                  ”

             Technical
   Battling the beetle                              Cover all bases
     There’s a whole host of                        other year rotation with wheat and spring      strength and ability to crack on rapidly in
measures currently surfacing                        barley. It’s a strategy he’s sticking with,    the spring.
                                                    along with rejecting early drilling as a way      “We’re not fans of PGRs, so we don’t want
   that seem to help oilseed                        to battle CSFB.                                our crops over-growthy ahead of the winter.
  rape through those crucial                           “Our establishment recipe saw last          After the Proline (prothioconazole) they
                                                    year’s Marshchapel crop through alarming       get with their Astrokerb (aminopyralid+
  early stages. CPM talks to                        levels of flea beetle,” explains Mark. “But    propyzamide) in late November we don’t
  two growers for whom it’s                         harvesting delays meant we sowed later         spray them again until mid-flowering. So,
                                                    and into less good conditions than we like.    good light leaf spot resistance and stem
     not so much which, but                         Then it was overwhelmed by a combination       strength are vital. We also really value the
     how many of these are                          of intense slug pressure and winter flooding   pod shatter resistance that allows us to
                                                    on the heavy ground.                           hold-off on combining for the highest
           implemented that                            “We went out of OSR 20 years ago            yields without added risk.”
              brings results.                       because our original plough-based regime          Keen not to have their OSR too forward
                                                    wasn’t performing. But almost every year       too early, 12 August is the earliest date the
             By Tom Allen-Stevens                   since we’ve come back into the crop with       Stubbs family are prepared to sow. They
                                                    modern hybrids and single-pass seeding,        aim to finish before the final week of the
                   and Rob Jones                    we’ve averaged 4.5t/ha or more across our      month to get their crops established
                                                    farms. And, despite some early flea beetle     ahead of the early September peak of
  For many oilseed rape growers 2020                damage, we took the bronze YEN award           flea beetle migration.
  harvest was a disappointing one, but for          with 6.77t/ha from our DK Exclaim entry in
  some this led to a determination to               2019, going one better last season with
  improve chances of a good crop this year.         V316OL averaging 6.71t/ha for the silver.”
  Finding a combination of measures and                A&C Stubbs and Sons currently have
  implementing them carefully looks as              50ha of DK Exclaim and 160ha of HOLL
  though it may pay off come harvest.               –– mainly the latest variety, V367OL ––
                                                    in the ground. With fewer early pest or
  YEN-winning defiance                              establishment pressures, the 2021 crops
  Last season was the first time Lincs              are looking especially promising, boding
  grower, Mark Stubbs had any oilseed rape          well for overall farm performance as well
  fail since his family partnership re-introduced   as further YEN success.
  it 10 years ago. But this certainly hasn’t           “We deliberately chose hybrids for our
  deterred the double Oilseeds YEN award            return to OSR growing, starting off with
  winner from growing the crop.                     Excalibur and now DK Exclaim, together
      Based at Marshchapel, Calcethorpe, on         with high value HOLL-growing,” Mark
                                                                                                   Mark Stubbs received a YEN silver award for his
  the Wolds near the coast, he grows the            says. “Dekalb varieties have always suited
                                                                                                   2020 oilseed crop and a bronze award in 2019.
  crop on a tight one-in-three or once every        us well for their consistent all-round

  18 crop production magazine may 2021
Single-pass seeding, aim to finish drilling before the final week of August are
among measures that ensure successful establishment at Marshchapel.

    Taking care to preserve               canopies we know deliver best
soil moisture and maximise                with our three-split, 210kgN/ha
seed-to-soil contact in their             liquid fertiliser programme.
establishment, they are never                 “We generally set the low
afraid to drill when the soil             disturbance legs at about 15cm
surface is dry either, providing          but can go deeper to deal with
rain is forecast. That way they           any compaction. Dropping the
know the crop is ready to go as           seed behind the packer into the
soon there’s enough moisture              25cm grooves created by the
for germination.                          DD rings we’ve fitted ensures
    Their successful main                 it goes in at a consistent 2-3
defence against CSFB is crops             cm before being pressed firmly
that come through evenly and              into place with the double set of
all at once, growing away                 DD rings we tow behind
rapidly to establish themselves           the machine.
strongly below ground more                    “After extra consolidation
than above it.                            and slug pelleting from the
    Mark believes that building           Cambridge roll within 24-48
soil structure and health over            hours, followed by 125kg/ha of
the past 10 years has really              DAP, we leave the crop to do
helped. The least possible                what it does best. Falcon
tillage in the rotation, winter           (propaquizafop) ensures we
covers ahead of spring                    keep on top of cereal volunteers,
cropping and regular organic              with Centurion Max (clethodim)
manuring, has seen soil organic           a key element in our
matters climb from around 2%              programme ahead of the
to over 6%.                               Astrokerb for the blackgrass
    “We bale all our straw                control that’s one of the main
because we don’t want it                  reasons we grow the crop. We
interfering with establishment or         only use an insecticide when
providing shelter for the slugs,”         we can’t avoid it.”
he explains. “However, we                     As the family have a good
leave 10-15cm of stubble to               local source of poultry manure
protect the soil surface from             and application without
drying out and give our OSR               incorporation is permitted after
seedlings the best micro-climate.         sowing, they’re planning to try
    “Our one-pass modified                this instead of the DAP in the
Discordon works well,                     coming autumn for some extra
following the baler as closely            CSFB deterrence.
as possible and sowing at                     Although large amounts
45 seeds/m2 to deliver our target         of shot-holing are seldom
population of 20-25 plants/m2.            apparent in them, Mark
With the spring development               believes his policy of only
ability of our preferred hybrids,         spraying off OSR volunteers
this gives us the really                  from his previous crops a week
thick-stemmed, well-branched              or so ahead of early October
                                                                              ▲
Battling the beetle
                                                         believes will see it through any CSFB
                                                         damage.
                                                            Based at Topps Farm on the 550ha
                                                         Breamore Estate near Fordingbridge,
                                                         Hants, David’s no stranger to predatory
                                                         damage in his OSR crop. “We have a lot
                                                         of pheasants who can graze it down to
                                                         nothing in places. So I’m used to putting
                                                         in place inventive measures to ensure a
                                                         good establishment,” he says.
                                                            “The difference with CSFB is that it’s over
                                                         the whole field, rather than just the margins.
                                                                                                                                Varieties with pod shatter resistance allow
                                                         But just as with pheasants, you can’t afford
                                                                                                                                combining of the Marshchapel crop to be held
                                                         to start off the season on the back foot.”
                                                                                                                                off for the highest yields without added risk.
                                                            Last year, he had 109ha in the ground,
                                                         in a rotation that includes winter wheat,
                                                         winter and spring barley, linseed and                                  on growth quickly in the spring, with a
A trial field of DK Exsteel that performed twice         spring oats, with occasional poppies. The                              medium harvest,” notes David. “We drilled
as well as the rest of the 2020 crop convinced           soil type overlying chalk is mostly medium                             at 40 seeds/m2, aiming for an established
David Northway to stay with OSR.                         loam with some gravel and a little clay.                               crop of 30 plants/m2. Most of the crop was
                                                            “There were lots of reasons why autumn                              direct-drilled and we tried to leave a long
   wheat drilling almost certainly helps                 2019 was a poor year for the crop. Over                                stubble as we think that helps, too.”
▲

to divert CSFB from his new seeds.                       most of the area it yielded just 2t/ha. But                                David believes a consistent seed depth
   In addition to preventing canopy growth               we had one trial field of DK Exsteel. It                               is important, and this is an aspect he
until he really wants it in the spring, not              wasn’t in the best place, drilled into                                 struggles to achieve with the farm’s 6m
drilling in the first part of August also                north-facing white chalk, but it performed                             Amazone Cayena drill. “The two banks of
means few, if any problems with CSFB                     head and shoulders better than the rest                                tines don’t work independently, so you do
larvae; certainly none that are any threat               and came off the field at 4.1t/ha.                                     need a level seedbed. We subsoiled a fifth
to the well rooted and resilient stands                     “That convinced us it was worth staying                             of the area which, although it established
achieved by his establishment regime.                    with the crop, so we put the whole 52.5ha                              with more vigour, appeared to thin out
                                                         into Exsteel this year, although it’s not just                         more from CSFB.
Multiple measures                                        the variety that makes the difference –– it’s                              “An interesting factor this season was
Like many growers, David Northway                        everything you do around it.”                                          the cover crop, established right next
suffered heavy losses with his oilseed                      In autumn 2020, the crop was drilled                                door to the OSR about ten days later
rape crop last year. So he’s put in place                on 22 August. “The variety fits with our                               and containing two types of radish and
a number of measures this year that he                   system as it’s an early developer, puts                                brown mustard. I think the CSFB were

    National study confirms far less CSFB damage this season
    Early results from the 2021             noticeably lower autumn CSFB                “Unfortunately, as ever, some                     improved. And even where they are
    National Cabbage Stem Flea Beetle       pressure as well as much better          growers have clearly suffered more                   carrying significant larval burdens,
    Management Study confirm a              soil moisture conditions at drilling,”   than most. However, it’s really                      many crops appear to be sufficiently
    marked reduction in crop damage         observes Bayer study co-ordinator,       heartening to see how markedly the                   well-established and vigorous enough
    from the pest so far this season.       Lizzie Carr-Archer.                      national position seems to have                      to deal with them.”
       Growers across the country,              “Less than 20% of the 187
    sowing almost 12,000ha of winter        crops in our initial data were judged                      National winter OSR crop position
    OSR last autumn, report a re-drilling   to have suffered an intense or
                                                                                                            100%
    rate of just 4% in the benchmarking     substantial challenge from flea beetle                          90%
                                                                                                                                       90%                     90%
    study run by Bayer with ADAS and        last autumn against more than 50%                               80%
    NIAB in late March/early April. This    in 2019. At the same time, only
                                                                                      Proportion of crops

                                                                                                                                              67%
                                                                                                            70%
    compares with 14% dentified in the      around 15% of this season’s crops                                                                                         61%
                                                                                                            60%
    almost identical study undertaken at    had to deal with low or very low soil                           50%
    the same time last spring.              moisture conditions at establishment                            40%
       What’s more, 90% of this             compared with nearly 40% last |                                 30%
    season’s crops survived to the          season.                                                         20%          14%
    spring and all are being taken              “For the second year in a row,                              10%    4%
    through to harvest, against 67%         earlier August drillings gave higher                             0%
                                                                                                                   Re-drilled     Surviving to the spring Being taken to harvest
    and 61% respectively in 2020            levels of crop survival,” she notes.                                                   2020/21        2019/20
    (see chart right).                      “The differences between these and
       “This much improved position         later drillings was far less than in     Source: Bayer National CSFB Management Studies 2020 and 2021
    results from a combination of           2019, though.

20 crop production magazine may 2021
You can also read