A resource for research and teaching. The Online Portal of the Historical Dictionary of Italian Cartographers
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
J-READING JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND DIDACTICS IN GEOGRAPHY 1, 9, June, 2020, pp. 27-43 DOI: 10.4458/3099-03 A resource for research and teaching. The Online Portal of the Historical Dictionary of Italian Cartographers Annalisa D’Ascenzoa a Dipartimento di Studi umanistici, Roma Tre University, Rome, Italy Email: annalisa.dascenzo@uniroma3.it Received: November 2019 – Accepted: April 2020 Abstract The COFIN national project Studi e ricerche per un Dizionario storico dei cartografi italiani (Studies and researches for a historical dictionary of Italian cartographers) brought together, at the start of the 2000s, fourteen research units and a large group of scholars to prepare bio-bibliographical dossiers on the figures of those Italians (or non-Italians who had worked for many years in Italy) who had produced cartography. The mass of material then collected and sent to the organizers remained largely unpublished or published in different places, without a clear link for the general public. Recently a group of researchers at Rome Tre University have taken this material in hand and instigated its incorporation onto a portal, thus creating an open access, digital depository, organized in Italian and English, and accessible for consultation of its bio- bibliographical entries. The plan behind the portal, Digital DISCI, is the stimulation of research on Italian cartography and the cartographers of our country, but is envisaged as widening the research field to Europe and the rest of the world. The realization of several of the identified objectives depends upon making the project known to the scholarly and educational world. The work of university teachers and students can be a valuable means of spreading information locally and of increasing awareness. Keywords: Biography, Cartographers, Cartography, Dictionary, Digitalization, Dossiers, Portal 1. Introduction storico dei cartografi italiani (Studies and researches for a historical dictionary of Italian Between 2017 and 2019 a small group of cartographers). This project, known by the university teachers and students from Roma Tre acronym DISCI (Dizionario storico dei University, in partnership with the Centro Ital- cartografi italiani), had received funding in the iano per gli Studi Storico-Geografici (Italian period from 2003 to 2005 when the national Centre for Geo-Historical Studies), worked to research group, coordinated by Ilaria Luzzana recover the material which had been sent, years Caraci, then on the faculty of geography at before, to the central unit of the COFIN national Roma Tre University, and with the support of project Studi e ricerche per un Dizionario Claudio Cerreti, was made up of fourteen local Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
28 Annalisa D’Ascenzo units spread throughout Italy. Each of these units From a scientific viewpoint, internationally, brought together a number of shorter-term staff, DISCI was an ambitious and innovative program associates, and contracted researchers to carry to carry out a vast research project on all the the research forward: over 150 officially figures of Italians (or non-Italians who had recognized individuals were thus involved, to worked for many years in Italy) who, in various which should be added other young researchers1. capacities, took part in the production of In the 20th century fundamental works were geographical maps and charts. The temporal arc published on the history of cartography and under consideration, in the end, basically historical cartography which indicated the need extends from the fifteenth to the nineteenth for biographical information on the century. cartographers, for example, the series of the This was the realization of an idea Monumenta Cartographica launched by germinated some years earlier, which brought Almagià, in which biographical details were together the perceived scientific needs of those added to the historical-descriptive files that working on historical cartography and the accompanied the iconographic and cartographic history of map-making. A project was born with reproductions (Almagià, 1929, 1944-1955)2. the intention of filling a void, particularly in our Among these reproductive works the Portugali- knowledge of those figures defined as “minor”, ae Monumenta Cartographica (Cortesao and not actually of the second level necessarily, but Teixera da Mota, 1960; ed. facsimile, English who nevertheless had until now received less and Portuguese, 1987) stands out: a collection of attention from scholars (Cerreti and Taberini, entries on the authors of the maps presented, or- 2001). The repertoires then available were few, dered alphabetically and chronologically, with unsystematic and lacking on the lesser known specific “elementos biográficos”. In terms of figures. Naturally the project had no intention of proper dictionaries, the best known was and is ignoring the “great” cartographers, for whom Tooley’s Dictionary of Mapmakers, with the exhaustive dossiers were to be compiled, but number of entries increased in the revised edi- limited in their size by making reference to the tion (Tooley, 1979-1985; Tooley et al., 1999- informative and specialist published 20043). Another very well known reference monographs already existing. work is The Mapping of the World with entries All cartographic authors seemed to be ordered chronologically and alphabetically by fundamental for building a full and more author (Shirley, 1984, 2001). accurate picture of the history of cartography, None of these works, however, pay systemat- principally Italian but not solely because of the ic attention to the wide range of individuals who exchange-of people, techniques, and materials- brought about the realization of cartography. which took place with other countries of the world. Even the very concept of cartography was meant in a broader sense, taking in a range 1 For more details on the composition of the national of objects from manuscripts to printed materials, group, local units and their distribution, names of the geographical or thematic, or even closer to participants, see the page Researchers, iconography, terrestrial or nautical, survey or https://www.digitaldisci.it/researchers/. administrative, relating to Italy or her colonies. 2 Although with different characteristics, there are many possible examples of these national projects: We shall not dwell further on the genesis and Kamal, 1926-1951; Svambera et al., 1938; Schilder, earlier findings of DISCI, but move to the work 1986-2013. In terms of nation states: Germany: then carried out on these findings in the last Bonacker, 1966. Great Britain: Steer and Eden, 1975- years and more recently (Cerreti, 2003, 2009a; 1976; Worms and Baynton-Williams, 2011. France: D’Ascenzo, 2018). One final focus, however, on Pedley, 1992; Pelletier, 1996. Spain: Cámara Muñoz, those aspects linked to education, which were 2005 and 2016; Sanchez Rubio et al., 2014. Nether- important from the very start of the project. The lands: Pflederer, 2012. Italy: Valerio, 1993. teachers, who gave classes in the course of 3 The latter Dictionary contains about twenty thou- training and updating for the young researchers sand cartographers, engravers and publishers active from the earliest times until 1900. Both versions are involved in the project, bore in mind the currently available only in paper format. question of the theoretical and practical bases Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
Annalisa D’Ascenzo 29 the students needed to carry the work forward present writer, because taking this material in (see the special number of the Geostorie journal hand was clearly complicated, given the time which brings together the texts of the operations: that had passed. But the dossiers collected and D’Ascenzo, 2004). Some of them, for example, stored in a cupboard in the “Giuseppe Caraci” provided the cognitive tools needed to tackle Laboratory of Roma Tre University were of research on particular types of map, or enormous value. The information was already illustrated the new possibilities for study and there, an enormous challenge had been met, and restoration work introduced by technology could be capitalized on by using the most (Conti, 2004; Federzoni, 2004a, 2004b). appropriate current information technology tools. Favourable circumstances (a grant from the Department of Human Studies), and a good dose of obstinacy combined with a strong 2. The sources and dossiers of DISCI personal obligation, led to the launch of the The starting point for DISCI were the online portal. As stated above, the main aim of existing publications (monographs, Digital DISCI is that of giving new visibility to encyclopedias, papers, articles in journals) the work already carried out by so many together with the iconographic and cartographic researchers and making available the online materials produced in past centuries, which depository which, in the field of geo-historical underwent appropriate research to discover the studies, is seen as increasingly important. A names of those who had produced them and any good beginning in sight for the realization of the available biographical details. As an example, “Tooley italiano” (Cerreti, 2003, p. 18). we have the maps of the Alexandrian and Gregorian Cadastes, outstanding sources from which to extrapolate long lists of the 3. The Digital DISCI portal. New professionals working in fiscal enquiries and frontiers for research and teaching land registry operations over vast territories. The most innovative and demanding part of Digital DISCI, the portal that brings together the DISCI project was the next. As the research the dossiers produced in its time for the Studies continued in archives, libraries and record and researches for a historical dictionary of offices it triggered the work of analysis and Italian cartographers is an open access, digital study of the sources which was in turn to depository, organized in Italian and English, and produce a long list of results: over 60 titles accessible for consultation of its bio- among monographs, collected volumes, papers, bibliographical entries. All the entries contained, articles, etc. (some examples: Polto, 2006; both those unpublished and those already Quaini and Rossi, 2007; Valerio, 2007). The published elsewhere, have been given ISBN large series of publications from the individual numbers (given that they now appear in a new local bodies, often responding to diverse format, as electronic publications). publishing directions, represents, however, only To place the scientific value of DISCI and its one part of the research results. A great mass of return as Digital DISCI in context, we need to material, for differing reasons, still awaited a observe that there is no other project known definitive version and place of publication. internationally that is similar in its breadth and From these brief indications and the objective depth, in spite of the limits mentioned as to the difficulties of the research, it is clear why the research studies carried out, let alone available files uploaded onto the DISCI portal are so online. There are interesting and rich collections heterogeneous and varied. of maps4, which give information on the authors, The complexity of the material, the boldness of the project, the sheer quantity of results 4 Just as an example, as a support for teachers, we reached over a long period, have posed concrete mention some portal: Europeana, Gallica, Library of problems of management for the central unit Congress, Portal de Archivos Españoles (PARES) which actually held the physical dossiers sent to and Catálogo colectivo de la red de Bibliotecas de los it. Those same concerns have motivated the Archivos estatales. Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
30 Annalisa D’Ascenzo but no ample biographical dictionaries and no and educational undertakings of ever greater open access5. A digital dictionary, freely dimensions. available on the net and bilingual, combines the An example in this sense is the entry already scientific knowledge with accessibility to the present on the military engineer “Odoardi de’ collected materials. Catilini, Odoardo” written by Giorgio Mangani The system has the advantage of being (Figure 1). Recent research has produced new continuously implemented: it is open to receive information, which has led to the upgrading and further materials that escaped attention, or expansion of the entry (D’Ascenzo, 2019) dossiers produced after the early years of this (Figure 2). century and more recently6. Thirdly, the case of bringing about new The progressive, and voluntary, inclusion of dossiers on cartographers as yet unknown. There new files by the authors (both those who are part must be a treasure trove of names and of DISCI and those from outside) will allow information waiting to emerge from the various continuous updating of the database, an Italian and European record offices, or which important operation in at least three ways: those simply need to be put into the system and online cartographers who have already been fully (Cámara Muñoz, 2005, 2016). recorded, around 1,000, can be entered as an The groundwork towards this has already updated/expanded draft or in a new version (as been laid (D’Ascenzo, 2017). A project is happens with the Dizionario Biografico degli currently being drawn up to form an Italian- Italiani – Biographical Dictionary of Italians). Spanish working party. The experiment will For the other, over 6,000, Italian cartographers engage the present writer with the researchers known only by name and with few details, who in the last years have worked and written further information will give body and substance much upon the Italian engineers transferred to to the research, so placing at the disposition of Spain in the course of the seventeenth century. the academic community and of society as a These were military personnel called upon to whole-obviously including the world of work on the defence campaigns in frontier education-a source which will enable cultural strongholds and to map the borders engaged in 5 warfare in the Iberian Peninsula and the Spanish Although chronologically and thematically limited, an example close to Digital DISCI appears the list of Empire. The iconic figure in this situation is the 975 “oficiales del Real Cuerpo de Ingenieros del Tuscan Lorenzo Possi who, between 1665 and siglo XVIII”: http://www.altorres.synology.me/01_ 1677 or thereabouts, under Philip IV and 06_siglo18.htm. Although the list is extensive, fewer Charles II of Spain, served in the monarchy’s than 40 military engineers have a biographical fact army in the battles being fought on its European sheet available on the Web. and North African frontiers (Sánchez Rubio et 6 The setting of the project, at the moment, is clearly al., 2014). Biographical information and linked to the field of university education and references to much other material (maps, teaching; in fact it requires bibliographic and archival reports, various documents) on Possi that have research. But we think that the portal can provide been found in numerous record offices will be future teachers in training with materials and ideas that can be used in their lessons. The personal history extrapolated to build dossiers on the group of of a cartographer and the products made by him tell Italian soldiers who worked with the Tuscan in of the era in which he lived and the territory he ob- his years of service outside Italy. served, with the characteristics of the time. The teachers, together with their students, can look in lo- cal libraries and archives for maps of their area and can obtain digital reproductions. They can also carry out investigations into the authors of the maps, at least identifying their names and the years in which they were active. After having worked on the maps in class, analysing their contents, they can send their files and digital images to the site editors. These ma- terials could feed into the Digital DISCI, possibly even in a new section dedicated to schools and educa- tional projects. Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
Annalisa D’Ascenzo 31 Figure 1. The entry on “Odoardo Odoardi de’ Catilini” in Digital DISCI by Giorgio Mangani (Local unit of Chieti). Source: http://www.digitaldisci.it/odoardo-odoardi-de-catilini/. Figure 2. The new entry (2019) on “Odoardo Odoardi de’ Catilini” in Digital DISCI by Annalisa D’Ascenzo (Local unit of Roma Tre). Source: http://www.digitaldisci.it/odoardi-de-catilini-odoardo-2019/. Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
32 Annalisa D’Ascenzo A further example is that of another military to the cartography of the state (Rombai, 2003) engineer, Carlo Antonio Biancone, author of a (Figure 3)8. small fund of maps of the territory of Teramo, and of Montorio al Vomano in particular, kept in the Archivo General de Simancas. These maps are extremely valuable for the study of the socio-economic situation on the border between the Kingdom of Naples, a constituent kingdom of the Spanish monarchy, and the Marche, which was part of the State of the Church (the Papal State) at the end of the seventeenth century (D’Ascenzo, 2013, 2019)7. The collection has as its object the banditry rooted in the mountains of the Abruzzi and particularly in the high valley of Vomano, between Montagna di Roseto, the Valley of San Giovanni and the Castellana Valley. Although Biancone was already known, along with other Italians whose work is held in the Spanish record office (Principe, 1982), he did not yet have a dedicated dossier. All these new entries need to be built following the approach and structure of the DISCI files, the shared fruit of a long and complex work of standardization and identification of unavoidable fields. Nor are those files representing the summarised revision of more ample work on individual authors (cited in the bibliography) excluded. Equally clearly, apart from entries on actual people, Digital DISCI collects and will continue to collect items on the bodies that produced cartography, whose cultural and educational value has been excellently outlined by Leonardo Figure 3. Entry on “Imperiale e Reale Laboratorio di Rombai in his article detailing the history of the Cartografia (Granducato di Toscana)” by Leonardo foundation of the collective technical bodies Rombai (Local unit of Siena). (institutional offices and magistratures) within Source: http://www.digitaldisci.it/imperiale-e-reale- the bureaucratic administration of the old Italian laboratorio-di-cartografia/. states, from the mid-fifteenth century up to the eighteenth and nineteenth century geometric cadastres, ranging from cartographic businesses Every school could carry out research on local corporate bodies which, over a long period, have been important in the management of our country’s territory: the administration of 7 We are dealing here with pictures of the past, drawn infrastructure and of assets both physical (roads, in great detail and with attention to the aesthetics, canals and embankments, bridges, fortifications, which enable us to see, over and above the obvious factories) and commercial (customs), of resources contents, the space lived in by and organized with a (water), of great estates (principalities, the Tuscan view to its possibilities (economic, technical etc.) and Presidi), land private and public (communities, the needs of the moment. Banditry was an ancient phenomenon against which the viceroy Don Gaspar 8 de Haro y Gúzman (1683-1687), marquis of the Car- For informations on collective public entities see pio, intended to wage a hard and radical war. also Manzi, 2006. Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
Annalisa D’Ascenzo 33 municipalities, woods), controllers of surveys and record offices throughout the national (cadastres and land registries, boundaries, rents, territory and beyond. cultivation), lay or ecclesiastical congregations, consortiums, workshops, civil or military orders. One example of a cartographic production already loaded onto the Digital DISCI portal is the Topografia del Stato d’Ascoli della Marca con suoi confini (1680) of Odoardo Odoardi de’ 4. Envisaged implementations Catilini, cited above, which is interesting for various reasons, among which is its picture of A record of DISCI’s published productions is the boundary between the Pontificate State and in preparation, but it will only be possible to the Kingdom of Naples at the end of the have satisfactory results with authors’ seventeenth century (Branchetti, 2014, pp. 163- contributions. If they are prepared to share the 164) (Figure 4). list of their publications, an updated picture will emerge of the many research works carried out and published to date. At present, those directly involved in checking the materials have been the representatives of the local DISCI units, but an attempt will shortly be made to contact known researchers as well. Scrutiny of the files will also lead to the availability of a bibliography, exhaustive if not fully complete, which will be of great value, as a summation of the texts cited in each entry. The educational value of such a tool is obvious, for carrying out further research work, which could be particularly suited to graduate, master or doctoral dissertations. Work of this sort will Figure 4. Odoardo Odoardi de’ Catilini, Topografia most certainly feed into the Digital dictionary of del Stato d’Ascoli della Marca con suoi confini historical Italian cartographers. (1680), dedicata a Monsignor Giandemaria governa- tore di Ascoli e Commissario generale Apostolico A further section of the portal, already contra banditi nello Stato Ecclesiastico. [Topography designed, will take account of Italian of the State of Ascoli della Marca with its boundaries cartographers’ iconographic materials and (1680), dedicated to Monsignor Giandemaria, Gover- cartographic productions already found nor of Ascoli and Apostolic General Commissioner elsewhere online. The links to digitalized in the Ecclesiastical State against outlaws.] Printed documents from national or foreign record etching9. offices will be collected and supplied so that users can see this material. This part of the overall project, which aims to be a reference 5. University teaching resource for students of cartography and the In the preceding section a series of history of cartography, will also be open to the approaches were listed that have already been partnership of those who wish to add their own followed to feed into the Digital dictionary of contributions. More importantly, we suggest that historical Italian cartographers. such research could be suggested to students enrolled in university courses, while the very nature of research on the Web also makes it 9 https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:11_-_Topografia_ suitable for groups of younger pupils or Del_Stato_D%27Ascoli_Della_Marca_Con_Suoi_Conf individuals, who, up to the end of compulsory ini,_1680_Odoardo_Odoardi_de%27_Catilini.jpg. schooling (in the medie superiori), could report Other examples: Archivio di Stato Roma, CDM, I, on the digital reproductions found in archives cart. 6, n. 247.; Istituto Geografico Militare, http://www.igmi.org/ancient/scheda.php?cod=13040. Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
34 Annalisa D’Ascenzo Until now, given that the portal has only find in historical cartography a solid support for recently gone online, the possibilities of using helping students to understand the evolution of the materials for teaching have been limited to a the techniques and the continuance of require- few known cases, all, at present, in the context ments that the map reveals and conserves. Fur- of the academic world. thermore, the teachings want to show over and In the academic year 2018-2019, for above its fundamental role (or rather necessity) example, a group of students from Roma Tre in the knowledge, organization and administra- University, enrolled in the workshop “GIS for tion of the territory. As we have learnt, as well cultural heritage” in their course of study in as their value in confirming earlier territorial as- historical sciences and international cooperation, sets, maps add evidence of the mentality and worked on Montorio al Vomano. Our colleague cultural footprint of society of the past (for the Arturo Gallia structured a proportion of the cultural and applicative aspects of the most re- classes around the study and evaluation of the cent geo-historical studies we cite for example: outstanding historical cartography which smaller Dai Prà, 2018; Dai Prà and Alaimo, 2013; Dai towns can lay claim to in the regional picture. Of Prà et al., 2018; Mastronunzio and Dai Prà, all the illustrations gathered, those of the 2017). greatest value are certainly the maps and plans The courses mentioned above are offered at drawn up by the known military engineer Carlo all levels of the teaching programme: from the Antonio Biancone, which depict, in great detail, workshops cited to curricular courses for both the country at the end of the seventeenth century the three year degree course and the master’s (D’Ascenzo, 2010, 2013). Elements of the urban course. For doctorates11 there are the doctoral fabric, today lost or forgotten (walls, gates, seminars organized by the geographical histori- fountains), emerge from the historical maps and ans attached to the Faculty for those enrolled in restore a memory of places lost over the course the various on-going courses12, in addition to the of the last three centuries. Such elements, annual seminars, “Dalla mappa al GIS” (From together with those places currently important the map to GIS)13, which centre on cartograph- for its present population, have been analysed ical documentation, historical and current, and and restored in a tourist map by the participants the epistemological and theoretical thinking on in the workshop (Figures 5 and 6). The students use of the instruments of geographical enquiry in were able, after a field trip on site, to evaluate analysis of the relationships between people and the changes which the ancient town had territory. On the latter we have, for many years undergone and the town’s current problems (not now, benefited from the active participation of least the damage caused by the earthquake of our colleagues from the Capitoline Superintend- 2009, still visible today) experienced by its ency of Cultural Heritage, Directorate of opera- inhabitants. The students could therefore tions on monumental buildings. propose those items from the town’s natural and cultural heritage which would be of interest to visitors wishing to learn of the geo-history of Montorio and its identity in the modern age. 11 The Alexandrian and Gregorian Cadastres are Doctorate in “History, territory, cultural heritage” often used by a group of historical geographers earlier entitled “History (Politics, Social Culture, Ter- ritory)”. from Roma Tre both as the starting point for his- 12 In March 2019 the Doctoral Seminar of Geography torical-geographic research, in particular on the hosted a series of lectures by Gianluca Casagrande region of Roma (Master’s thesis), and also in (European University of Rome), “Low-cost technolo- their classes10. There are several courses which gy for the recognition and documentation of minor landmarks”, and by Nicola Gabellieri (University of 10 On the multiple importance of the Cadestre and ar- Trento), “A historical-geographical approach to inte- chive sources we cite we cite the collective volumes grated sources through the study of rural landscapes: edited by Gallia (2016) and Carallo (2017), which the case-study of Val Bisagno between abandonment collect the results of the Seminars Dalla mappa al and hydro-geological vulnerability”. 13 GIS: http://www.labgeocaraci.it/category/ The list of publications is available at the link on pubblicazioni/mappagis/. See also Sinisi, 2014. note 10. Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
Annalisa D’Ascenzo 35 Figures 5 and 6. The project of a tourist map on Montorio al Vomano (2018). Produced by the “Giuseppe Cara- ci” geocartographic Laboratory, Department of Humanities, Roma Tre University. Elaboration of: Antonio Ca- stellani, Marta Feliciangeli, Arturo Gallia, Emiliano La Rocca, Luca Lapponi, Giulia Marani, Adriano Marinuc- ci, Damiano Moschetta and Nicolò Prosperi. Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
36 Annalisa D’Ascenzo As regards the Master’s degree, for some years this has combined lectures14 with further study wherever original materials have been pre- served: of particular importance is collaboration with the Roman archives, including, thanks to the directors, the State Archive. In the central locality, Sant’Ivo alla Sapienza, and in that at Galla Placidia, series of theoretical and practical classes are held15. On the subject of teaching, attention must be drawn to the in-depth analysis of original mate- rials carried out in the State Archives by Susan- na Passigli. In an article she emphasises the im- portance of work on the inventory of the archive offices of the Trenta Notai Capitolini preserved in the Archive of the State of Rome (Verdi, 2009) as a contribution to the inventory of the older plans of the agricultural hamlets of the Agro Romani drawn up by Jean Coste (Coste, 1969, 1973). Passigli points out the cultural and didactic value of such research on the maps of these hamlets linked to notarial deeds in the modern age, which she uses in her university teaching16 (Passigli, 2018). To underscore further the value of these geo- historical studies, we should not forget that we owe to Susanna Passigli the many files uploaded onto Digital DISCI on the ‘land-surveys’ includ- ed in the Alexandrian Cadastre (Figure 7). The many entries, on the other hand, on the ‘cartog- rapher’ authors of the maps of the Gregorian Cadastre (Figure 8) are thanks to Adriano Rug- geri17. 14 Interdepartmental Master at level II in “Digital Figures 7 and 8. Examples of entries on cartographers Earth and Smart Governance. Strategies and GIS working on the preparation of the “Catasto alessan- tools for the management of territorial and cultural drino” and the “Catasto gregoriano” by Susanna Passig- heritage”. We highlight particularly the modules li and Adriano Ruggeri (Local unit of Roma Tre). “Cartography and historic-environmental analysis” 1 Sources: http://www.digitaldisci.it/francesco-torriani/; and 2 (taught by Carla Masetti and Annalisa http://www.digitaldisci.it/magoni-giovanni-maria/. D’Ascenzo, M-GGR/01). 15 Thanks are due to Doctor Luisa Falchi, a splendid and enthusiastic scholar and guide through the mar- vellous original materials and in the fields of docu- ment conservation. 16 Storia della città e del territorio (M-STO/02) [His- tory of the city and territory]. 17 Researchers with extensive archival research experience (Passigli and Ruggeri, 2014). Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
Annalisa D’Ascenzo 37 6. New developments. The Digital researchers attentive to the world of school dictionary of historical Italian (Seimplatton, 2013, 2019). cartographers in schools In our opinion, historical-geographical documentation and historical cartography have As in the preceding section, this section enormous communicative value. In general are reports a number of future projects which have drawn in stages and with intelligible symbols, been considered. These revolve in particular not too technical or complicated, which can around the school world, or rather, and better, to therefore be read and understood with a the teaching of geography to the teachers of the minimum of preparation. They can be drawn by future. hand – the ease of graphic rendering, with a The group of teachers promoting the research range of colours, which appeals to so many for DISCI and Digital DISCI have direct young. They can take various formats, from the knowledge, through their own teaching more manageable “cabreos” maps of private experience, particularly at universities, of the properties, right up to the great cadastres, and success of historical-geographical have therefore the ability to strike the documentation and historical cartography in imagination and remain in the memory. capturing the attention and curiosity of the Although we have not had wide educational young. In addition to the educational success experience with children and adolescents, we among students of the humanities and courses know that comparison with the maps of the past for future teachers, we have been encouraged by helps younger people to understand the two the positive experiences recorded on public fundamental dimensions of time and space. To occasions of meeting younger boys and girls. understand how the shape and dimensions of the For example, those who are enrolled at globe has been pictured and measured, from secondary schools and attend meetings for ancient times to modern times and to our present prospective college or university students, or the day. How and why, for what erasons, knowledge children who take part in extra-curricular events of the planet or of its many parts has been (GeoNight, exhibitions, seminars). There is modified and increased over the centuries. How actually little bibliography on such educational the cultural context is important to reconstruct projecyts; it is a frontier still to be explored. We ancient knowledge, to understand the note, however, that the theme of using historical relationship with others and with diversity, cartography for educational purposes has been people’s fears. The concept of borders. How discussed in Spain (León Guerrero, 2011, 2019). much near and far depends on technology and Not surprisingly, Italy and Spain are two the means of communication. The basic countries with a great tradition of historical- explanations are already all there for the most cartographical studies and an abundance of ancient representations of the oecumene (the archive material18. The launch of a speech in this known world), the mediaeval and modern direction was addressed in the summer courses planispheres, the atlases and chorographies (De of the Petrus Apianus' Academy, open to the Vecchis and Morri, 2010, pp. 54-57, 102-109). international participation of teachers and In this first phase of the project we hope first of all to make the depth and validity of historical 18 In corroboration of the didactic use of this docu- cartographic sources clear to all teachers, mentation, we can cite the exhibitions Cartografías together with the many analytical connections de lo desconocido. Mapas en la BNE (Madrid, 2017- that they allow to be drawn between the 2018) and Quand les artistes dessinaient les cartes. disciplines: geography, history, literature, Vues et figures de l’espace francais Moyen Age et economics, politics, history of religion etc. The Renaissance (Paris, 2019-2020). A recent Italian pro- question of teaching how to teach remains open. ject which supports the educational value of such ma- As Lévy wrote, with reference to France but the terials is the work-group AGeI “Musei di Geografia: argument applies equally to Italy: organizzazione della conoscenza, valorizzazione e divulgazione del patrimonio geografico accademico” (GEOMUSE; https://www.ageiweb.it/gruppi-di- lavoro/geomuse/). Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
38 Annalisa D’Ascenzo Siamo ancora lontani da una formazione find an early historical foundation in the all’analisi di un oggetto grafico come realtà Alexandrian Cadastre map of 160020. globale… Per gli attori del sistema educativo, la posta in gioco consiste, nel contempo, nel Such evidence opens up the possibility of the mantenersi quanto più sensibili è possibile “casually” appearing lake entering the realm of all’ascolto delle innovazioni e a considerarsi history and can support-through the testimony of responsabili della costruzione negli allievi di the past-its previous existence, the recovery of competenze aperte alle esperienze future. In- memory, its identity, the ability to protect the segnare la carta è anche imparare ad impara- basin and surrounding area. Territorialization, just re, per rendere possibili gli apprendimenti al- as narration and illustration, can find support and la lettura e anche alla concezione delle carte, i furtherance in historical cartography. “Social cui principi non esistono ancora (Lévy, 2007, energy” can benefit from knowledge of the past. pp. 59-60). Finally, carrying our example to a regional scale, let us draw attention to a recent initiative Currently the aim is to involve teachers in organized by our colleagues in the University of training, preparing them adequately and Trento, led by Elena Di Prà and the recently encouraging them to work on and with the founded Geo-Cartographical Centre for Study historical maps within the obligatory internship and Documentation (GeCo). Their work has led which is an integrated part of the course of to the preparation of the exhibition at Rovereto, “Geography and Geography-Teaching” in the “Imago Tridentina: The historical cartographic current graduation course in Primary Education manuscripts of Trentino in the territorial at Roma Tre University. archives”. As the title explains, this is an Teachers can therefore work with their exhibition of hand-drawn maps produced students on limited areas directly known to the between the sixteenth and twentieth centuries, children, by choosing maps with details of the preserved in several provincial archives, and areas in which the schools are situated. Or to now finally seen together, forming a unitary widen the vision to the province or to the region picture. The exhibition is intended not so much as a whole, by focusing on analysis of what has as a point of arrival as a moment for scientific remained and what has changed in the area, for reflection and above all of sharing with the example in the field of toponymy and “odon- community at large the rich texture and complex ymy” - the renaming of places - on the use of the nature of cartographic production with the aim soil, the construction and use of green spaces-the of showing Trentino as it was and is. Organized increasingly important “lungs” of our modern in seven thematic sectors, it presents Trentino as cities. a great cartographic laboratory over the At the neighborhood level, on this topic, an centuries21. A diachronic journey in which the article published in the Rivista geografica historical maps are placed as a true album of italiana by Marco Maggioli and Massimiliano Tabusi comes to mind (Maggioli and Tabusi, 2016). Starting from a different subject, the tive implications will give further and interesting writers drew the scientific community’s background information and points for discussion to the population and the administrators. attention to a “natural” lake created following 20 Archivio di Stato Roma, Catasto Alessandrino, Svi- building operations in the area of Portonaccio. luppo delle strade Prenestina e Casilina fuori Porta The obvious question which the geographical Maggiore e fuori Porta S. Giovanni, 430/1 [Deve- historian and scholar of cartography poses is lopment of the Praenestine and Casiline roads outside this: do documents exist which bear witness to the Porta Maggiore and Porta S. Giovanni]. 21 the existence of something similar in a lacustrian The Exhibition in the Palazzo Alberti Poja di Rov- basin in the area before the present day? This ereto (TN), will remain open, at the request of local curiosity, not yet fully resolved19, does however businesses, from 10 October 2019 until 15 May 2020. The seven thematic sectors are: Rovereto and the Vallagarina; Woods and forests; Water and hydraulic 19 It is proposed here shortly to develop the research operations; Borders, territories and estates; Cities and on historical cartographic material in greater detail settlements; Military cartography; Cartography of the and for longer periods; in the certainty that the cogni- nobility. Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
Annalisa D’Ascenzo 39 memories, to leaf through in order to recontruct university teachers and students can represent a the biography of the territorial context. valid means of diffusion of information locally A further means towards public knowledge and of an increase in awareness. and empathy will certainly come from the The Digital DISCI is a useful tool, historical, biographical research on the actual authors of cultural and cognitive, but above all forward- these maps, interpreters and protagonists in a looking for the study of the territorial practices time of gaining knowledge of and working in the adopted in the past, for the safeguarding, territory, witnesses to the intelligence and improvement and management of the operational competencies that merit added environmental and socio-economic resources of recognition. Our colleagues, conscious of and the territories. This knowledge, however, will convinced by this opportunity, are working to only gain social importance and function if it is build the files for the Digital DISCI. communicated, explained and transmitted to It seems, to the current writer, that these younger generations. Education, at all its levels, reflections and researches, like the initiatives still has this task today; both compulsory school behind the exhibitions, which can spread quality and then the higher levels can only become knowledge to the public, are extremely involved with the conscious and active important. Cultural proposals that exhibit participation of teachers. The work of university materials that can be read at various levels bring teachers is fundamental in making available to about community awareness. The historical society all the knowledge that has been realized maps, if correctly contextualized and interpreted, in the universities and which, through children are intelligible to a range of ages and and young people, can enter the families and be educational levels and have, in our opinion, part of the instruction and upbringing of the next much to do with the public role of geography generations. The portal of the Historical and hence of geographers. They bring people Dictionary of Italian cartographers is only one close to geography and its sources, they show example among many recently arising in the the usefulness of knowledge and the specialists, field of geography. and they create communities, a sense of places, As the work is being reviewed for recognisable and to which everyone can belong. publication, the world is on high alert in the struggle against a medical emergency of unknown magnitude. 7. Conclusions Many other questions should have been addressed to give a potentially more exhaustive The Digital DISCI portal is ready to receive and interesting picture which would make this the contributions of all those who would like to paper more useful as a source for researchers or provide new information on Italian cartographers, students who want to explore these topics. in a variety of forms. Certainly the relationship between historical As has already been said, the project idea on cartography and WebGIS, in an educational which the Digital DISCI portal rests is the context, merits a deeper examination, but the stimulation of research on Italian cartographers space available oblige us to leave this to another and the cartography of our country, but with the occasion. In conclusion, howver, the contingent intention of expanding our field of operations to situation obliges us at least to mention the Europe and the rest of the world. With the question of the digital divide which now shows preparation of a rich repository, the intention is itself as dramatically real, not only for updating participation in the creation of national and deeper examination, but also for the very interconnected poles of study, which will allow operation of teaching activities now that the the reconstruction of the history of the flow of schools have been closed. people, techniques and knowledge in the field of In Italy, on 6 April 2020, Istat published the how the land is drawn and represented. To research paper, Spaces at home and availability achieve many of the objectives identified, wider of computers for children and young people, knowledge of the project in the academic world from which emerges data that are not surprising, is important, but not only. The work of Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
40 Annalisa D’Ascenzo but give no comfort22. At a national level, in the References two year period 2018-2019, 33.8% of families did not have a computer or tablet at home 1. Almagià R., Monumenta Italiae Cartographi- (41.6% in the South), a percentage which drops ca, Florence, Istituto Geografico Militare, 1929. to 14% if there is at least one minor in the house. 2. Almagià R., Monumenta Cartographica However, only 22% of families have a PC or Vaticana, Città del Vaticano, Biblioteca tablet for every family member (14.1% in the Apostolica Vaticana, 4 voll., 1944-1955. South). If the parent needs to use the PC for his or her work, how can the child be given the pos- 3. Bonacker W., Kartenmacher aller Länder sibility of following the e-learning lessons? und Zeiten, Stuttgart, Hiersemann, 1966. 4. Branchetti M.G., “Stampe artistiche e car- More specifically, we learn that 12.3% of tografia”, in Sinisi D. (Ed.), Luoghi ritrova- young people between 6 and 17 years do not ti. La Collezione I di disegni e mappe have a PC or tablet at home (around 20% in the dell’Archivio di Stato di Roma (secoli XVI - South), and only 6.1% live in houses in which XIX), Rome, Ministero dei Beni e delle At- each person has one. Moreover, only 6 out of 10 tività culturali e del Turismo, Direzione minors have a space suitable for them to follow Generale per gli Archivi, 2014, pp. 159- the distant-learning lessons. 175. The imbalance is confirmed between North, 5. Cámara Muñoz A. (Ed.), Los ingenieros mi- Centre, and South, and between large centres litares de la monarquía hispánica en los si- and small towns. glos XVII y XVIII, Madrid, Ministerio de But it is clear that the problem is not only Defensa-Centro de Estudios Europa whether the child possesses a PC or tablet, but is Hispánica, 2005. also about access to the Web, about having a 6. Cámara Muñoz A. (Ed.), El dibujante inge- stable connection that is adequate for supporting niero al servicio de la monarquía all the family’s needs. hispánica: siglos XVI-XVIII, Madrid, Fun- There are educational, economic and infra- dación Juanelo Turriano, 2016. structure challenges that raise questions for the 7. Capel H. et al., Los Ingenieros Militares en whole community. They perhaps show the road España (Siglo XVIII). Repertorio biográfico that must be followed, with investments, to try e inventario de su labor científica y espa- to prepare the country – the public sector – for cial, Barcelona, Universidad de Barcelona, the challenges of today and tomorrow, for the 1983. age that will emerge after the Covid-19 pandem- 8. Carallo S. (Ed.), Il progetto del territorio ic. Technological facilities, individuals, comput- nelle fonti d’archivio, Rome, LabGeo Cara- er-literacy, infrastructure, and access to the Web ci, 2017. present us with the tests by which we must 9. Cerreti C., “Progetto DISCI e storie di fa- measure ourselves. Both before and well beyond miglia”, Geostorie, XI, 1, 2003, pp. 17-25. the sector’s educational projects on specific his- 10. Cerreti C., “Il Progetto DISCI (Dizionario torical-geographical materials. Storico dei Cartografi Italiani)”, in Aversano V. (Ed.), Studi del La.Car.Topon.St. Labora- torio di Cartografia e Toponomastica Storica, N. 3-4 (2007-2008), Penta di Fisciano, Gu- tenberg Edizioni, 2009a, pp. 23-25. 11. Cerreti C., “Presentazione di Studi del Car.Topon.St. 1-2. Le Biografie di Cartogra- fi”, in Aversano V. (Ed.), Studi del La.Car.Topon.St. Laboratorio di Cartografia e Toponomastica Storica, N. 3-4 (2007-2008), Gutenberg Edizioni, Penta di Fisciano, 2009b, 22 pp. 27-28. https://www.istat.it/it/files//2020/04/Spazi-casa- 12. Cerreti C. and Taberini A. (Eds.), “La car- disponibilita-computer-ragazzi.pdf. tografia degli autori minori italiani”, Me- Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
Annalisa D’Ascenzo 41 morie della Società Geografica Italiana, le di Studi e Ricerche di Geografia, 12, 2, 65, 2001. 2010, pp. 135-147. 13. Conti S., “Gli autori di carte nautiche”, 23. D’Ascenzo A., “Immagini del passato: Geostorie, 12, 2-3, 2004, pp. 87-99. Montorio al Vomano nella cartografia stori- 14. Cortesao A. and Teixeira da Mota A. (Eds.), ca del tardo Seicento”, in Marinaro E. (Ed.), Portugaliae monumenta cartographica, Li- Montorio al Vomano. Immagini per la me- sboa, Neogravura, 3 voll., 1960; Facsim. re- moria, Teramo, Ricerche&Redazioni, 2013, print.: Lisboa, Imprensa Nacional-Casa Da pp. 22-32. Moeda, 1987. 24. D’Ascenzo A., “Lorenzo Possi e l’”officina 15. Coste J., I casali della campagna di Roma cartografica” degli ingegneri militari al ser- all’inizio del Seicento, Rome, Società ro- vizio della Monarchia ispanica (XVII seco- mana di storia patria, 1969. lo)”, Officina Cartografica. Materiali di 16. Coste J., I casali della campagna di Roma studio, in Gemignani C.A. (Ed.), Milan, nella seconda metà del Cinquecento, Ro- Franco Angeli, 2017, pp. 165-177 me, Società romana di storia patria, 1973. 25. D’Ascenzo A. (Ed.), Digital DISCI. Il por- 17. D’Agostino A. and Maggioli M., “Un mo- tale del Dizionario storico dei cartografi dello di interpretazione del Catasto Grego- italiani, Rome, Labgeo Caraci, 2018 (onli- riano: il territorio di Nemi”, in Di Blasi A. ne). (Ed.), Proceedings XXIX Congresso Geo- 26. D’Ascenzo A., “Límites de papel. Las grafico Italiano. Geografia: dialogo tra ge- representaciones, percepciones y narrativas nerazioni, Bologna, Pàtron, 2005, II, pp. de la frontera norte entre el Estado 187-194. Pontificio y el Reino de Nápoles en el siglo 18. Dai Prà E., “Per una geografia storica ap- XVII”, in Melón Jiménez M.A., Rodríguez plicata: prolegomeni a un Centro per lo stu- Cancho M., Testón Núñez I. and Sánchez dio, la valorizzazione e la fruizione attiva Rubio R. (Eds.), Dinámica de las fronteras della cartografia storica”, Bollettino Asso- en periodos de conflicto. El imperio ciazione Italiana di Cartografia, 162, 2018, español (1640-1815), Cáceres, Universidad pp. 108-122. de Extremadura, 2019, pp. 319-336. 19. Dai Prà E. and Alaimo A., “Dispute confi- 27. De Vecchis G. and Morri R., Disegnare il narie: la cartografia storica al servizio del mondo. Il Linguaggio cartografico nella territorio”, in Dai Prà E. (Ed.), APSAT 9. scuola primaria, Rome, Carocci, 2010. Cartografia storica e paesaggi del Trenti- 28. Federzoni L., “Cartografia e cultura. Brevi no: approcci geostorici, Mantova, Società considerazioni sulla figura e sul sapere del Archeologica Padana, 2013, pp. 271-282 cartografo”, Geostorie, 12, 2-3, 2004a, pp. 20. Dai Prà E., Allegri D., Scorpio V, Comiti F. 11-24. and Zolezzi G., “Alla ricerca della pax 29. Federzoni L., “Considerazioni preliminari idraulica. L’utilità della cartografia per la sul restauro virtuale di carte geografiche an- prevenzione del rischio idrogeologico. Il tiche e sui più recenti strumenti tecnici di progetto ETSCH 2000”, Proceedings XXII riproduzione e di lettura”, Geostorie, 12, 2- Conferenza Nazionale ASITA, Bolzano, 3, 2004b, pp. 139-150. ASITA, 2018, pp. 23-30. 30. Gallia A. (Ed.), Cartografia storica e GIS 21. D’Ascenzo A., “Presentazione numero mo- nella gestione, tutela e valorizzazione dei nografico Progetto DISCI. Questioni e pro- beni culturali, Rome, LabGeo Caraci, 2016. blemi di repertoriazione dei cartografi ita- 31. Kamal J., Monumenta Cartographica Afri- liani”, Geostorie, 12, 2-3, 2004, pp. 53-54. cae et Aegypti, Le Caire, 1926-1951, 3 voll. 22. D’Ascenzo A., “Banditismo e cartografia 32. Karrow Jr. R.W., Mapmakers of the Six- storica. Un percorso storico, geografico e teenth Century and Their Maps - Bio- naturalistico nel Parco nazionale del Gran Bibliographies of the Cartographers of Sasso e Monti della Laga per la valorizza- Abraham Ortelius, 1570, Chicago, Specu- zione del patrimonio locale e la tutela indi- lum Orbis Press, 1993. rizzata a un turismo sostenibile”, Semestra- 33. Lago L., Imago Italiae. La “Fabrica” dell’Italia nella storia della cartografia tra Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
42 Annalisa D’Ascenzo medioevo ed età moderna. Realtà, immagi- nella Collezione di disegni e mappe”, in Sinisi ne ed immaginazione dai Codici di Claudio D. (Ed.), Luoghi ritrovati. La Collezione I di Tolomeo all’Atlante di Giovanni Antonio disegni e mappe dell’Archivio di Stato di Magini, Trieste, Edizioni Università di Roma (secoli XVI - XIX), Rome, Ministero Trieste/Goliardica Editrice, 2002. dei Beni e delle Attività culturali e del Turi- 34. León Guerrero M.M., “Didáctica del espa- smo, Direzione Generale per gli Archivi, cio y la historia a través de la cartografía hi- 2014, pp. 55-136. stórica”, Revista de estudios colombinos, 7, 44. Pedley M., Bel et Utile: The Work of the 2011, pp. 77-86. Robert de Vaugondy Family of Mapmakers, 35. León Guerrero M.M., “La cartografía histó- Tring, Map Collector Publications Ltd., rica como recurso didáctico”, in López Tor- 1992. res E., García Ruiz C.R. and Sánchez Agu- 45. Pelletier M. (Ed.), How to identify a map- stín M. (Eds.), Buscando formas de en- maker: an international bibliographic señar: investigar para innovar en didáctica guide / Comment identifier un cartographe: de las Ciencias Sociales, Valladolid, Edi- guide bibliographique international, Tring, ciones Universidad de Valladolid, 2018, Map Collector Publications-Paris, Comité pp. 861-870. français de cartographie, 1996. 36. Lévy J., “La carta, uno spazio da costruire”, 46. Pflederer R., Finding Their Way at Sea: in Casti E. (Ed.), Cartografia e progetta- The Story of Portolan Charts, the Cartog- zione territoriale. Dalle carte coloniali alle raphers Who Drew Them and the Mariners carte di piano, Turin, UTET Università, Who Sailed by Them, Houten, H&DG Hes 2007, pp. 42-61. & De Graaf Publishers, 2012. 37. “Los Ingenieros militares en la historia de 47. Polto C. (Ed.), Chorographia: formae et España”, Revista de Historia Militar, LVI, species. L’esperienza cartografica in Sicilia 2012, Núm. Extraordinario. e nella Calabria meridionale tra XV e XIX 38. Maggioli M. and Tabusi M., “Energie so- secolo, Messina, Edas, 2006. ciali e lotta per i luoghi. Il ‘lago naturale’ 48. Principe I., Il progetto del disegno. Città e nella zona dell’ex CISA/SNIA Viscosa a territori italiani nell’Archivo General de Roma”, Rivista Geografica Italiana, 123, 3, Simancas, Reggio Calabria, Casa del Libro, 2016, pp. 365-382. 1982. 39. Manzi E., “Il Reale Officio Topografico di 49. Quaini M. and Rossi L. (Eds.), Cartografi in Palermo fra contingenze militari e spunti il- Liguria (secoli XIV-XIX), Genova, Brigati, luministici (1807-1848 circa)”, L’Universo, 2007. 3, 2006, pp. 398-423. 50. Rombai L., “La cartografia degli enti collet- 40. Mastronunzio M. and Dai Prà E., “La carta tivi. Problemi di attribuzione di responsabi- storica come laboratorio interdisciplinare: lità, Geostorie, 12, 2-3, 2004, pp. 101-117. intersezioni metodologiche”, in Gemignani, 51. Sánchez Rubio C., Sánchez Rubio R. and A.C. (Ed.), Officina cartografica, Milan, Testón Núñez I., El Atlas Medici de Loren- Franco Angeli, 2017, pp. 233-245. zo Possi. 1687, Badajoz, 4 Gatos - Funda- 41. O’Connor M., “Review of Tooley’s Dic- ción Caja de Badajoz, 2014. tionary of mapmakers”, Journal Cartog- 52. Sánchez Rubio R., Testón Núñez I. and raphy, 17, 1, 1988. Sánchez Rubio C., Imágenes de un Imperio 42. Passigli S., “Nuove piante di casali della Perdido. El atlas del Marqués de Heliche, Campagna Romana dai protocolli dei notai Badajoz, 4 Gatos, 2004, versione Cd-Rom. romani (seconda metà del Cinquecento e 53. Seimplatton J.M.A., “Historical cartography primi del Seicento”, in Verdi O. (Ed.), Arte, and teaching. New frontiers for Geography?”, architettura e decorazione nelle carte dei Conference paper, Petrus Apianus’ Academy, notai romani: 1582-1888, Rome, Università First summer school, 2013. degli Studi Roma Tre – CROMA, 2018, pp. 54. Seimplatton J.M.A., “New worlds and new 111-140. geographies. Teaching whit planispheres 43. Passigli S. and Ruggeri A., “Piante cinque e and portolanic charts at primary school”, seicentesche dell’Agro Romano conservate Petrus Apianus’ Academy, Fourth summer Copyright© Nuova Cultura Italian Association of Geography Teachers
You can also read