26 Cypress View Veterinary Clinic - Alberta Veterinary Medical ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 2020 Cypress View Veterinary Clinic 26 In This Issue 20 Practices during COVID-19 Celebrating Alberta Veterinary 24 Practice Management: Is Telemedicine Here to Stay? 28 Focus on Wellness: A Community Approach to Suicide Prevention
Inside this Issue VOL. 22, ISSUE 5 The ABVMA Members’ Magazine is a bi-monthly publication of the Alberta FEATURES Veterinary Medical Association delivered free of charge to members of the ABVMA. 20 Celebrating Alberta Veterinary Practices during COVID-19 24 Editor’s Notebook 26 Practice Management: Is Telemedicine Here to Stay? WORKING REMOTELY FROM HOME FOR THE past four months has given me an extra two hours per day that I am not behind the wheel of my car. To fill 28 the void (and to compensate for my teenagers not really Focus on Wellness: A Community On the Cover Approach to Suicide Prevention Cypress View Veterinary Clinic needing me much anymore), I have become an avid news hound. At first, it began with normal curiosity and interest, and has developed into a fascination with REGULAR ARTICLES what is occurring in the world today. My primary revelation was that your news depends Editor’s Notebook..............................................................................................3 upon where you obtain it. I have always known that some news sources lean to the right politically President’s Report...............................................................................................4 while others lean to the left; I had not realized how Registrar’s Report...............................................................................................5 extremely polar opposite their views could be until Council Highlights............................................................................................6-7 you start to compare them. Two different news sources Keeping You Current........................................................................................8-9 reporting on the same event can have radically different conclusions. Even the edited video from the same event Complaints Director’s Report......................................................................10-14 can show different realities. A political rally recorded Membership Matters........................................................................................16 from the back of the stadium looks entirely different PIPS Tip.............................................................................................................16 from one recorded from the podium. One view shows CVMA Report...............................................................................................18-19 people packed in front of the stage, the other shows the empty tiers of seats in the background. The truth Public Recognition Corner................................................................................22 is often blatantly sacrificed to support the political In Memoriam.....................................................................................................25 leanings of the source. Dean’s Corner (UCVM & WCVM).................................................................32-33 The most troubling discovery for me, however, was Student’s Corner (WCVM & UCVM)............................................................34-35 the lack of accountability for many of the officials and politicians that are running our governments. I look ABVTA News................................................................................................36-39 south of our border and see a train wreck unfolding CE Opportunities.........................................................................................41-42 in slow motion on a daily basis. You know that it is Classified Ads...............................................................................................43-50 happening, but you just cannot look away. Thinking that it could not occur in Canada, I look to the east, Go Green..........................................................................................................50 and see scandal after scandal from our federal leaders Advertiser’s Index.............................................................................................50 with seemingly no consequences. No one wants to ABVMA Communication to Members..............................................................51 accept accountability for their actions. With the physical reopening of the ABVMA office, I am happy to note that I am back driving the PRODUCTION CONTACT US two hours per day to attend there. I am also much Editor – Dr. Darrell Dalton Alberta Veterinary Medical Association Design, Layout & Printing – Burke Group Bldg. 3, Elm Business Park happier to be back into an environment where truth Communications and Professional Suite 104, 9452 – 51 Avenue, NW and accountability do matter — in the veterinary Enhancement – Kathy Naum Edmonton, AB T6E 5A6 profession. This is why professional associations exist. ADVERTISING Phone: 780-489-5007 Working with veterinary professionals eases my Display Advertising – Sarah Munn Toll-Free: 1-800-404-2862 Classified Advertising – Mandi Duggan Fax: 780-484-8311 political skepticism and reminds me that there are still EDITORIAL POLICY Return Undeliverable good and honest people out there. Never change. The ABVMA Members’ Magazine Canadian Addresses to: welcomes article submissions, letters to Alberta Veterinary Medical Association Darrell Dalton, DVM the editor and advertising requests Suite 104, 9452 – 51 Avenue, NW on topics and products related to the Edmonton, AB T6E 5A6 Canada Registrar, Alberta Veterinary Medical Association veterinary profession. Canadian Publication Mail The editor reserves the right to reject Agreement 40014637 submissions if they do not meet the ABVMA’s editorial criteria. The editor also reserves the right to edit submissions (including letters to the editor) for clarity, length and correction of factual inaccuracies. WWW.ABVMA.CA 3
PRESIDENT’S REPORT with cyberbullying and other threatening Health care professionals such as doctors, behaviour from the public. Many people are nurses and veterinary professionals tend to experiencing multiple sources of stress such do well with short-term resiliency. We are as financial difficulty, health concerns and good at putting our heads down and plowing family issues, and additional stress such as a through an acute crisis, coming up for air pet requiring emergency care can cause them once it is over and then putting the rest of our to lash out. This can be a large contributor to lives back together. However, the long-term the stress of our profession, and it decreases effects of this stress are not as easily handled our ability to practice veterinary medicine in the same manner. Stressors such as injury, effectively. Even prior to the pandemic, verbal relationship stress, poor health, family issues abuse towards veterinary staff had been noted or a pandemic lasting months, make it to be commonplace. In a survey published impossible to power through the entire time by the British Veterinary Association in without burning out. 2017, nine out of 10 veterinarians reported It is important to look for techniques that they or a member of their team have that may work for you to improve your felt threatened by someone’s language or long-term resiliency. Everyone has different behaviour while in practice. Numerous coping mechanisms — mine tends to be articles published by VIN, AVMA, CVMA running or biking — and finding what allows and others confirm this is an issue in North your brain to enter into a calm space is key. America as well. Some techniques recommended for health As a veterinarian and a mentor, I want professionals to cope during the pandemic to help promote resiliency in students and involve trying to promote our ability to new graduates as they start their careers as grow during the changing environment. I WANT TO COMMEND ALL OF MY veterinarians and RVTs. Managing the stress This can include taking a step back to focus colleagues and their staff on doing an of difficult client interactions is one of the your attention on the environment and amazing job at continuing to provide care for tougher skills to master, and something that allow yourself to be fully present, curious animals of all species during the challenges can significantly impact happiness within and interactive. If you can promote a calm of COVID-19. As essential service providers, this career. We have to work together as response to what is around you, your ability to we have safely ensured animal welfare and colleagues and as a profession to deal with control your reactions and responses increases. public health needs are met. This is no negative interactions such as threats, violence Allow yourself brief pauses in your day to small task during the ongoing stress of the and cyberbullying. Having a veterinarian or take in and reflect on your feelings and your pandemic. At the time of this writing ( July clinic encountering verbal on online threats reactions. Actions such as grounding yourself, 22), our provincial daily case numbers are or a violent client is difficult on all team acknowledging your reaction to what is once again increasing, and we must continue members. Keeping the ABVMA informed around you, and then setting these reactions to remain vigilant in following physical aside to start fresh with the next task can help distancing and infection prevention. AS ESSENTIAL your mind from becoming overwhelmed. Recently, a veterinarian was struck by an SERVICE PROVIDERS, Remember that kindness and support for emotional and angry client. The majority WE HAVE SAFELY your work team will help reduce negativity of small animal practices are busier than ENSURED ANIMAL and stress in the workplace. Working on a ever, and ensuring that both staff and WELFARE AND positive attitude and trying to remain focused public are kept safe makes everything take PUBLIC HEALTH on the big picture are techniques that can longer. Emergency practices are frequently NEEDS ARE MET. help build resiliency. As we work through this overwhelmed, and wait times can be long. time of change, remember that change brings Curbside appointments make communication of these trends is also important, as this opportunities as well as disruptions, and is a take longer, so situations that are already allows Council and staff to work on potential part of life. All of us at the ABVMA wish to emotional can potentially become combative. solutions, develop courses and can help direct support our members as we continue to adapt. I am very concerned that we will see members to resources to help themselves, more of these types of interactions, along their workplace and their families. 4 ABVMA MEMBERS’ MAGAZINE | SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 2020
REGISTRAR’S REPORT ONE OF THE RECURRING ISSUES veterinarian or technologist performing Following a number of complaint cases that that the Practice Inspection and Practice the procedure is also the person resulted from the anesthetic death of an Standards (PIPS) Committee has been monitoring the anesthetic, informed animal, the Complaint Review Committee dealing with for the past six years is the consent (verbal or written) acknowledging (CRC) and the Hearing Tribunal both requirement for a designated anesthetist the absence of a dedicated anesthetist clearly expressed the opinion that a to be present during any prolonged deep must be obtained from the owner and designated anesthetist must be available sedation or anesthesia. The problem arose appropriately documented.” for all routine procedures. They opined that from the wording of the 2014 PIPS Bylaw: The intent of the task force that developed a veterinarian concurrently acting as both this Bylaw was that the exception was only surgeon and anesthetist cannot properly “A designated anesthetist (separate to be used in an emergency situation, and assess ventilation, circulation, temperature, from the veterinarian or veterinary not as a practice model. Unfortunately, some perfusion, oxygenation and depth of technologist performing the procedure) members interpreted this to mean that if anesthesia while competently performing must be available for each procedure. verbal or written consent was obtained, they surgery, and is therefore inappropriate. The anesthetist must be a registered were within the intent of the Bylaw. This was Failure to provide a dedicated anesthetist, veterinarian or a registered veterinary not accurate, and the PIPS Committee is particularly for a routine or scheduled technologist under the supervision of a seeking to resolve this issue. procedure, may result in allegations or veterinarian. In the circumstance where the In order to correct the misinterpretation, findings of unprofessional conduct in the the 2019 PIPS Bylaw revision made the event of a complaint. Documented informed following changes (changes in bold): consent is only acceptable and applicable for exceptional circumstances. “A designated anesthetist (separate Council has discussed this issue at from the veterinarian or veterinary length and is in agreement with the PIPS technologist performing the procedure) Committee, CRC and Hearing Tribunal. must monitor patients under general Previously a compliance approach has been anesthesia and or prolonged and/or taken to institute this change since 2014, but deep sedation. The anesthetist must be now will move to an enforcement stance. a registered veterinarian, or a registered Council recognizes that there are ways to veterinary technologist under the achieve compliance by most practices as supervision of a veterinarian. If, in the has been demonstrated in the past six years, exceptional circumstance where the for example, having a locum come in part veterinarian believes the procedure time and grouping all surgeries on that must be done without an available day. Practices that do not have a registered designated anesthetist, informed veterinary technologist, employ locum Darrell Dalton, DVM consent must be documented in the veterinarians or locum technologists to act medical record. Written informed as a designated anesthetist, will not pass the Registrar, Alberta Veterinary consent acknowledging the absence of a PIPS inspection to provide SC-4: Anesthesia Medical Association dedicated anesthetist, and the increased services. A designated anesthetist saves animal risk to the patient, must be obtained from lives and that is what this is all about. the owner, appropriately documented and be very clear to the client.” OUR VISION OUR MISSION Healthy animals and people in Serving the public by regulating, enhancing and providing leadership in the practice of the a healthy environment. profession of veterinary medicine in Alberta. OUR VALUES PROFESSIONALISM INTEGRITY LEADERSHIP INCLUSIVITY RESPECT Demonstrating ethics, fairness, Exemplifying honesty, Inspiring a path that is Fostering a safe, positive and Interacting with empathy, responsibility and accountability trust and transparency adaptable and visionary collaborative environment compassion and dignity WWW.ABVMA.CA 5
COUNCIL HIGHLIGHTS 2020 ABVMA Council Back row, left to right: Tracey Ruzicka, RVT, Karen Melnyk, RVT, Dr. Natasha Kutryk, Dr. Noel Ritson-Bennett, Dr. Gurmeet Singh Tuli, Dr. Colleen Pratt, Dr. Daren Mandrusiak, Kate Simon, RVT Front row, left to right: Dr. Chris Berezowski, Mick Howden, Dr. Pat Burrage, Dr. Kirsten Aarbo, Dr. Lisa Lomsnes, Dr. Louis Kwantes, Dr. Jonathan Leicht, Ross Plecash Missing from photo: Dr. Darrell Dalton, Dr. Douglas Freeman, Dr. Keith Lehman, Dr. Baljit Singh June 24-25, 2020 – Virtual Meeting Jonathan Leicht, DVM Council strategic thinking session: planning mechanism in case COVID does representative of many veterinarians’ views continuing professional development not allow full reopening in coming months. in Alberta, and additionally the CVJ was • What defines continuing education (CE) • ABVMA will be an Organizational becoming more companion animal focused. in 2020 and related competency skills. Member of the CVMA. There are no • ABVMA sent letter of response to Limits on ability to audit, best methods separate CVMA fees on member invoices. the CVJ for publishing in the next for auditing; peer advisory roles, how The Organizational Membership fee CVJ edition. best to track competency assessments. is expected to be similar to what was Is the gathering of data leading to previously remitted as individual member ABVTA report purposeful outcomes and what are we fees and therefore will have minimal • Discontinuation of the current Canadian trying to measure? impact on the budget. Vet Practice Magazine to members • CE and relationship to area of practice; • Five per cent reduction is provided for • Continued discussion with a number of discussion on applicability of particular in COVID draft budget in registration the graduated students that are awaiting CE and whether ABVMA tracking and # revenue (RVT and DVM combined). VTNE examination changes with of hours is relevant to 2020. • Expenses: To remain consistent in 2021, COVID and planning contingency for • Outcome of discussion: Current 20 COVID budget outlines worst case AGM event hours (DVM)/15 hours (RVT) to remain scenario if meetings continue virtually; while emphasizing continued support for effects on CanWest, AGM, registration UCVM report to Council applicable CE by ABVMA. days, etc. • Expansion of DVM program; new • Goal is to pass budget by August 2020, building is complete at Spyhill and Audit Committee review which will allow for further knowledge of expansion of DVM students to fifty • Financial guidelines: A change in wording COVID situation. for 2021 is approved by the Council will allow investing in higher return/low on Education. risk stocks if council decides this is a good Canadian Veterinary Journal (CVJ) • Six professorships and four staff positions decision in future, but not at present. (Up ethical question discussion by Council are posted for hiring by September 2020 to 10 per cent of reserve investment pool) • ABVMA was contacted by a number • Diagnostic Unit - $3.5 million grant for of member veterinarians that were additional support and workload. This Draft 2021 normal budget and draft distraught by the CVJ ethical question of is the first time government has made 2021 COVID budget the month member letters published in investment in this area in decades and will Dr. Dalton prepared a normal budget as CVJ (May 2020). Major concerns were allow additional surveillance, testing and well as COVID budget scenario to provide raised that remarks were inflammatory, not diagnostics resources in Alberta. 6 ABVMA MEMBERS’ MAGAZINE | SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 2020
WCVM report to Council • Council was provided information that multiple E-News bulletins framing • Council received update on COVID Alberta veterinary numbers are falling to the application of the bylaw. Prior management at WCVM behind population growth, possibly worse “informed consent” guidelines when an • Application process update for than many jurisdictions throughout North anesthetist could not be made available 2020 DVM intake including non- America, therefore project is very timely. was also discussed. interprovincial agreement intake. • Council approved motion for PIPS There will be nine students from Alberta Discussion on majority ownership of Committee to develop guidelines for an in the incoming class at the non- permit holders exemption that practices could only apply interprovincial agreement tuition rate. • A lively discussion occurred on what for in “exceptional” circumstances. • A new curriculum is being introduced defines majority ownership, who is the this year to enhance clinical education. responsible veterinarian in practice, what CanWest update Additional labs/physical skills would allow for RVTs to own shares in a • Council was provided an update on development. Removal of histology, veterinary practice entity in Alberta and ABVMA’s contractual obligations to the embryology and biochemistry. what defines a veterinary permit holder. Banff Springs Hotel relative to hosting • Discussion on visibility of permit CanWest and commitments to the Presentation by UCVM Dr. Jacob holders and transparency; Council conference venue and proposal to deliver Thundathil and Dr. Tessa Baker on a was provided information on where all CanWest in virtual format. combined degree program proposal: permit holder information is accessible DVM/MSc and DVM/PhD on ABVMA website. Edmonton Humane Society (EHS) • Goal to expand opportunities for • Outcome of discussion was to move into microchip program for reclaimed pets practicing veterinarians and other committee to answer the following: Council reviewed and approved EHS DVM professionals. (1) Further clarify ownership definition proposed microchip program for reclaimed • Graduate certificates as well as part-time (2) Explore options provided by other pets. EHS will be able to provide a microchip graduate studies. No graduated programs professions in Canada and the US for stray animals presented to EHS from of this manner in Canada with multiple (3) Develop “ABCs of corporate outside the city at time of reclaiming with programs already in place in the US. ownership structures.” the informed consent of owners. • Goal to enrich clinical skills, provide a complement graduate program, potential Discussion and motion approved on Public euthanasia source of income for DVMs and allows PIPS requirement for “designated EHS proposal on ability to provide end-of- for additional credentialling. There was anesthetist” bylaw life services for low income individuals who also positive discussion on the appetite • Council discussed memo provided by cannot afford services otherwise and for in the community for these types of PIPS Committee based on 2019 approved removal of aggressive dogs from the public. programs to exist. bylaw update as well as letter of review Council provided feedback that by Complaint Review Committee that would rely on confirmation of intent and Veterinary Profession Labour Market clinics no longer be given approved status clarification back from EHS. Workforce Project when there is not a separate dedicated • Approved grant now in place. Consulting anesthetist during procedures requiring company has now been hired to identify sedation or anesthesia. “scoping interviews” to determine survey • Council provided timelines for prior questions to be developed. notices to membership, inclusion in DR. JONATHAN LEICHT COMPLETED HIS DVM AT WCVM IN 2009. His career began in small animal practice before joining Novartis Animal Health in multiple sales and key account management positions. In 2015, Jonathan started with VCA Canada in ever-growing operational roles, including Senior Regional Operations Director Specialty, Western Canada. In October 2019, he moved back into private practice as well as joined Mosaic Veterinary Partners as Director of Operations. Starting in July 2020, he’s co-hosting a new interview style podcast called the Veterinary Project. When not in clinic, you will find him working on a renovation project or outside playing and travelling with his wife and two young kids. Jonathan Leicht, DVM Member of Council, Calgary Region WWW.ABVMA.CA 7
KEEPING YOU CURRENT Announcements and Member Engagement WCVM DEAN STEPS DOWN CALL FOR ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING (AGM) As announced by the Western College of Veterinary Medicine RESOLUTIONS (WCVM) on June 24, 2020, Dr. Douglas Freeman, dean of WCVM, • See the full notice published on page 4 of the July/August 2020 stepped down on June 30, 2020. Members’ Magazine Freeman served as the regional veterinary college’s leader for two • Members who wish to submit a resolution for consideration for five-year terms from 2010 to 2020. For personal reasons, he decided the AGM in February 2021 must submit this to the ABVMA not to pursue a third term. office by: Tuesday, Oct. 15, 2020 WCVM faculty member Dr. Gillian Muir became the college’s 2020 CANWEST VETERINARY CONFERENCE, acting dean for one year beginning on July 1. Muir is a professor OCT. 17-20, 2020 and head of the WCVM’s Department of Veterinary Biomedical Registration for the 2020 CanWest Veterinary Conference is now Sciences. She received her DVM at the WCVM in 1988 and open. For details, visit: www.canwestconference.ca. completed a PhD degree in neuroscience at the University of British Columbia. MEMBER WELLNESS PROGRAM The university will begin an international search for the next The program offers members that qualify access to recovery treatment dean in the fall of 2020. due to incapacitation from addictions through interest-free loans The full release can be found at: https://wcvmtoday.usask. for residential treatment. This program is funded entirely through ca/articles/2020/06/dean-steps-down-from-usask-veterinary- voluntary member donations. Thank you for your support. Watch your college.php or for more information, contact: Myrna MacDonald, renewals this November to donate or contact the ABVMA office. Communications, Western College of Veterinary Medicine For more information on the member wellness program contact (WCVM), 306-291-9950 | myrna.macdonald@usask.ca darrell.dalton@abvma.ca. MALATEST LABOUR MARKET WORKFORCE PROJECT The ABVMA and ABVTA are conducting a labour market study In his role as Dean of WCVM, Dr. Freeman served to address the current shortage of veterinarians and veterinary as Ex-Officio on ABVMA Council from 2010 to 2020. technologists in Alberta. The study is funded through a grant from The ABVMA would like to thank him for his service. the Alberta Ministry of Labour and Immigration. Having the right number of people, with the right skills, in COUNCIL ELECTION NOMINATIONS the right places, at the right time is essential for the stability • Nominations for 2020 Council vacancies are now open and sustainability of the veterinary profession in Alberta. The • Visit Announcements & News > Announcements on your member project will collect data, provide data analysis and components portal to view a letter about Council from Dr. Kirsten Aarbo, for a complete veterinary professional workforce study and plan the Council Nomination Form and Council Terms of Reference. for Alberta. The following is being considered: projected growth, (Login required.) the current workplace, recruiting and retention, retirement and • Nominations close: Sept. 18, 2020 succession planning. ABVMA AWARD NOMINATIONS To inform this study, we ask for your participation in an • Nominations for 2020 ABVMA Awards are now open. online survey that will be administered from the end of August to • Visit Announcements & News > Announcements on your member November. Your experiences and perspectives as veterinarians and portal to view the Nomination Form. (Login required.) veterinary technologists are essential to this study. • Nominations close: Sept. 18, 2020 Association Activities The Registrar, Deputy Registrar, Assistant Registrar and Communications Manager (R/DR/AR/CM) participated in regular meetings to discuss COVID-19 information for members and the public. ABVMA Leadership and Council represented the association through numerous activities over the last two months: JULY 2020 8: P/PP/R/DR/AR Executive 10: R/DR CCVR teleconference 2: R/DR/AR/CM Labour Market Council Meeting CM teleconference with ABVTA Workforce Project Teleconference R/DR CCVR teleconference Executive Director CM teleconference meeting with 9: R/DR/AR/CM CVMA Virtual Annual 13: R/DR COC (Appeals-Registration ABVTA, Executive Director General Meeting Committee) 6: DR virtual hearing R/DR CCVR teleconference 14: DR Tails of Help Board of Director’s R/DR/AR Labour Market Workforce CM bi-weekly call with ev+ Digital teleconference Project Key Informant Interview Marketing Agency R/DR AARCS Edmonton CM teleconference with UCVM Facility Meeting Director of Student Services 8 ABVMA MEMBERS’ MAGAZINE | SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 2020
15: R/DR/AR Executive meeting with AUGUST 2020 Dr. Simon Otto - One Health Antimicrobial 5: R/AR/CM Executive Meeting with Dr. Simon Otto - One Health Stewardship Conference Antimicrobial Stewardship Conference 17: R/AR/CM Labour Market Workforce Project Update Meeting CM bi-weekly call with ev+ Digital Marketing Agency 20: R/AR/CM Program Planning Committee Meeting - One Health 12: P/PP/R Executive Council Meeting Antimicrobial Stewardship Conference 14: R Labour Market Workforce Project Update Meeting 21: P/PP/R/DR/AR Executive Council Meeting 18: DR Tails of Help Board teleconference R/AR/CM Executive meeting with Dr. Simon Otto - One Health 19: R/CM Executive Meeting with Dr. Simon Otto - One Health Antimicrobial Stewardship Conference Antimicrobial Stewardship Conference CM bi-weekly call with ev+ Digital Marketing Agency CM bi-weekly call with ev+ Digital Marketing Agency AR Project meeting teleconference with ev+ Digital 20: DR Hearing Marketing Agency CM CVMA Communications Meeting 27: R/DR/AR/CM Government relations meeting with Pam Cholak 26: P/PP/R/DR/AR Executive Council Meeting 28: R/DR/AR/CM Project Advisory Team Labour Market 27: R Triplicate Prescription Program Steering Committee Workforce Project 28: R/DR/AR Labour Market Workforce Project Update Meeting CM call with Meltwater, media monitoring company 31: P/PP/R/DR/AR/CM UCVM Virtual Welcome to the 29: P/PP/R/DR/AR Executive Council Meeting Profession Ceremony 30: DR Consent Discussion Aug. 31 - Sept. 1: P/PP/R/DR/AR Virtual Council Meeting DR Companion Animal Disaster Response Committee Steering Committee Meeting LEGEND 31: R/DR/AR/CM Program Planning Committee - One Health P = PRESIDENT PP = PAST PRESIDENT VP = VICE PRESIDENT Workshop, teleconference with One Health Workshop, One R = REGISTRAR DR = DEPUTY REGISTRAR Health Consortium organizers AR = ASSISTANT REGISTRAR CM = COMMUNICATIONS MANAGER R/DR/AR/CM Labour Market Workforce Project Update Meeting WWW.ABVMA.CA 9
COMPLAINTS DIRECTOR’S REPORT COMPLAINT CASE #19-17 CONSENT ORDER A letter of complaint was received against AGREED STATEMENT OF FACTS: a veterinarian regarding the care provided 1. At all material times, the veterinarian has to a cat that had a complaint of diabetes been a registered veterinarian with the and presented with a complaint of lethargy Alberta Veterinary Medical Association and anorexia. (ABVMA) since 1999. The veterinarian undertook diagnostic 2. The veterinarian is the responsible testing and treatment, with the cat returning veterinarian for the veterinary practice. approximately two weeks later with a 3. SG and MJ were the owners of a 14-year- complaint of not eating. The veterinarian old cat who was a diagnosed diabetic. undertook further diagnostics and prescribed 4. On Feb. 20, 2019, the cat presented to treatment. There was no record that diagnostic the veterinarian with a complaint of imaging was contemplated or offered. lethargy and anorexia. The cat had a Another two weeks later the cat was history of diabetes, was being treated presented again with more severe signs at with Caninsulin and on presentation had which point abdominal radiographs were a temperature of 39.1oC. taken and the owner ultimately decided to 5. The veterinarian undertook blood testing proceed with euthanasia. The owner was including blood glucose, CBC, chemistry concerned with how the euthanasia was (general 17) and T4. The CBC showed undertaken and proceeded. an elevated white blood cell count and The complaint was investigated and the low packed cell volume (PCV). The report of the investigation was provided to veterinarian prescribed an antibiotic, Clavaseptin and Famotidine with a plan the Complaint Review Committee (CRC) to recheck blood glucose and PCV in for review. The CRC made a decision that one week. the matter be referred to the Hearings 6. The veterinarian re-examined the cat on Director for a hearing. March, 2019, with the complaint of not The member entered into consent eating well. The cat’s temperature was discussions with the members of the now at 38.3oC , the PCV had increased CRC. The member provided an admission and he was dehydrated. The veterinarian of unprofessional conduct and signed a noted that abdominal palpation was Consent Order. normal with no mass palpable. The cat was treated with subcutaneous fluids to address the dehydration. The veterinarian COVID-19 prescribed Cyproheptadine and two cans of recovery food. The COVID-19 pandemic response 7. There is no documentation in the necessitated the temporary pause to some medical record of a recommendation aspects of the complaints and discipline and/or discussion of diagnostic imaging process. The receipt of complaints was not related to the Feb. 20, 2019, or March 7, interrupted, and investigations have resumed. 2019, examinations. Hearings that normally require in-person 8. On March 18, 2019, the client became attendance in meeting rooms for extended concerned about the cat being constipated. periods are not possible while adhering to It was presented again to the veterinarian social distancing requirements. The ABVMA, on March 19, 2019, with concerns of foul like many professional regulatory bodies and smelling vomit and constipation. Blood civil courts, has turned to virtual hearings. glucose and PCV were evaluated and This matter proceeded to hearing within normal limits. Following a lengthy held virtually through the online discussion, the client consented to abdominal radiographs, which indicated a videoconferencing platform WebEx on distended small bowel and a possible mass May 6, 2020. at the ileocecal junction. 9. After further discussion, the client agreed to euthanize on March 19, 2019. There is no record of these discussions in the medical record. 10 ABVMA MEMBERS’ MAGAZINE | SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 2020
10. The veterinarian sedated the cat prior to this Order, the following additional the complaint and failed to comply with a the euthanasia with medetomidine, continuing education obligations, as request of the appointed investigator. ketamine and butorphanol. The cat approved by the Complaints Director: The matter of the veterinarian failing unexpectedly vomited soon after i. an additional five hours of to comply with a request for a response sedation, resulting in the client being continuing education on feline and interview was referred to the hearings upset. The veterinarian injected medicine; and director for a hearing. euthanasia solution intra renal once the cat was fully sedated. ii. an additional five hours of The member entered into a consent continuing education on discussion and ultimately signed an 11. The cat was euthanized on March 19, 2019. medical records. admission of unprofessional conduct and AGREED FINDINGS OF 3. The veterinarian shall pay a fine in consent order. During which he provided a UNPROFESSIONAL CONDUCT: the sum of $500 with respect to the final explanation as to his failure to respond Pursuant to s. 35.1 of the Veterinary Profession insufficient medical records. This fine to the complaint. Act (VPA), as the result of negotiations shall be paid within six months of A hearing was held on March 6, 2020. between the parties and as reflected in the the date of this Order. 4. The veterinarian shall pay costs in AGREED STATEMENT OF FACTS: “Agreed Findings of Unprofessional Conduct” section of the Consent Order, the veterinarian the amount of $4,000 within six 1. The veterinarian has been a registered made an admission of unprofessional conduct months of the date of this Order. veterinarian with the Alberta Veterinary 5. If the Complaints Director deems Medical Association (ABVMA) since 1981. concerning the following two allegations: there to be a violation of this Order, 2. The veterinarian was the responsible Medical Management and Treatment the veterinarian, upon notice by the veterinarian for the veterinary practice 1. That the veterinarian failed to offer Complaints Director and/or the during the relevant period of time being proper diagnostic options to the owners Registrar, shall be suspended from March 2019. of the cat on Feb. 20, 2019, and/or the practice of veterinary medicine 3. A complaint was received by the March 7, 2019, and/or March 19, 2019. pending a Hearing into allegations ABVMA on March 20, 2019, from the of unprofessional conduct resulting owner of a short-haired black male cat. Medical Records from the breach of this Order. 4. Veterinary medical services were 2. That the veterinarian failed to create or provided by an associate veterinarian The Complaints Director and/or maintain appropriate medical records for to the cat at the veterinary practice the cat. the Registrar shall maintain this where the veterinarian was the discretion until such time as all responsible veterinarian. ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF provisions of this Order are satisfied. 5. An investigation was initiated into the RESPONSIBILITY: 6. There shall be publication of this complaint pursuant to a decision of the It is acknowledged by the ABVMA and the Order on a without-names basis (and Complaints Director on April 26, 2019. veterinarian that his conduct as described without identifying information). The veterinarian received notice of the above constitutes unprofessional conduct. investigator appointment and a request The veterinarian has accepted responsibility was made for a response to the letter of for his conduct pursuant to s. 35.1 of the complaint and all relevant medical COMPLAINT CASE #19-13 records. A response was requested by VPA. The sanctions set out below are jointly A complaint was received from a member May 21, 2019. agreed to and based upon, in part, the responsibility accepted. of the public concerning the care provided 6. Further requests for a response to the to a cat with a diaphragmatic hernia. The complaint were forwarded to the NO RIGHT TO APPEAL: complaint was submitted against four veterinarian on June 10, 2019, and July 2, parties and resulted in four complaint 2019. No response to the complaint was The ABVMA and the veterinarian agree that received by the ABVMA. there shall be no right of appeal from this cases. One against each of two veterinary practices involved in providing care and one 7. The investigator, through a series of Consent Order. emails, requested an opportunity to veterinarian working at each practice. ORDERS AS TO SANCTIONS: interview the veterinarian with respect The complaint was investigated and the to the complaint. The veterinarian The Hearing Tribunal orders that the issues raised by the complainant were all refused to undertake an interview with appropriate sanctions in the circumstances of dismissed in the four complaint cases. the investigator. this matter are as follows: The Complaint Review Committee 8. At a consent discussion meeting with the 1. A written reprimand shall be issued (CRC) was able to make the decision that CRC on Jan. 23, 2020, the veterinarian against the veterinarian. the complaints raised by the complainant provided a final explanation as to his 2. The veterinarian shall be required to could be dismissed even though the failure to respond to the complaint. successfully complete, at his own responsible veterinarian for one of the cost, within six months of the date of practices failed to provide a response to Continued on next page WWW.ABVMA.CA 11
PRESIDENT’S REPORT COMPLAINTS DIRECTOR’S REPORT CONTINUED The Hearing Tribunal received a copy ORDERS AS TO SANCTIONS: OF THE ALBERTA VETERINARY of a letter that the veterinarian provided to The Hearing Tribunal orders that the MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, the CRC during the consent discussion. The appropriate sanctions in the circumstances of AND IN THE MATTER OF THE Hearing Tribunal ordered that this letter this matter are as follows: REVIEW OF THE PRACTICE outlining his personal circumstances that 1. A reprimand will be issued against OF THE VETERINARIAN AS occurred at the time he was notified of the the veterinarian. APPROVED BY COUNCIL OF complaint be sealed. The Hearing Tribunal 2. The veterinarian shall pay a fine THE ALBERTA VETERINARY decided these were private matters that do in the sum of $500 within six MEDICAL ASSOCIATION. not need to be part of the public record. The months of the date of this agreement. Hearing Tribunal agreed with the members of WHEREAS as a result of a failed Practice This fine for failure to comply with a the CRC in attendance at the Jan. 23, 2020, Inspection and Practice Standards request from an investigator is lower consent discussions that these were significant (PIPS), the PIPS Committee referred than what would normally be sought and challenging personal circumstances for the veterinarian’s practice to the Practice by the ABVMA given the personal the veterinarian. He demonstrated remorse, Review Board (PRB) in accordance with circumstances that mitigated for the and he was very apologetic and candid about s.55(2) of the Veterinary Profession General lower fine. Although the Hearing his lack of response to the complaint. He Regulation, RSA 2000, as amended. Tribunal is very sympathetic of the agreed to take responsibility for his actions. veterinarian’s personal circumstances, AND WHEREAS on May 28, 2019, the they are of the opinion that this PRB met and agreed that a review of the FINDINGS OF THE HEARING TRIBUNAL could have all been avoided. veterinarian’s practice should be undertaken 3. The veterinarian shall pay costs in the in accordance with s. 11(1)(b). Failure to Cooperate with an Investigator amount of $4000 within six months AND WHEREAS Council of the ABVMA 1. That the veterinarian failed to of the date of this agreement. approved this on April 24, 2019. provide a response to the complaint 4. If the Complaints Director deems notwithstanding ABVMA requests there to be a violation of this Order, AND WHEREAS on June 28, 2019, on of April 26, 2019, June 10, 2019, and the veterinarian, upon notice by a voluntary basis the veterinarian attended July 2, 2019. the Complaints Director and/or before the PRB and agreed to proceed with 2. That the veterinarian failed or Registrar, shall be suspended from the review. refused to comply with the request of the practice of veterinary medicine AND WHEREAS on Sept. 16 and Oct. 22, the investigator of the ABVMA to pending a hearing into allegations 2019, an ABVMA inspector undertook an respond to the complaint. of unprofessional conduct resulting inspection of the veterinarian’s practice. from the breach of this Order. ACKNOWLEGEMENT OF AND WHEREAS the reports of the The Complaints Director and/or RESPONSIBILITY: inspector were provided to the PRB. the Registrar shall maintain this It is acknowledged by the ABVMA and the discretion until such time as all AND WHEREAS the PRB met on Nov. veterinarian that his conduct as described provisions of this order are satisfied. 28, 2019, for the purposes of evaluating the above constitutes unprofessional conduct. The 5. There shall be publication of this inspections undertaken by the inspector. veterinarian has accepted responsibility for his Order on a without-names basis (and AND WHEREAS the PRB determined that conduct pursuant to s.35.1 of the Veterinary without identifying information). the veterinarian has taken appropriate steps Profession Act (VPA). The sanctions set out to be in compliance with the PIPS Bylaw and below are jointly agreed to and based upon, in accordingly on the basis that the veterinarian part, the responsibility accepted. PRACTICE REVIEW BOARD agrees to the terms as set out below will The Hearing Tribunal appreciated the (PRB) conclude the review of her practice. cooperative nature that the veterinarian displayed during the hearing. ABVMA Bylaws provide that a member AGREEMENT who fails to satisfactorily comply with SANCTION OF THE HEARING the Practice Inspection and Practice 1. A caution will be issued against the TRIBUNAL Standards (PIPS) inspection and satisfy veterinarian, which will remain in As a result of the findings of the Hearing the requirements of the PIPS Bylaw will be the ABVMA member file. Tribunal with respect to allegations of referred to the PRB. 2. The veterinarian shall pay costs of unprofessional conduct, the Hearing The following is an agreement entered the PRB process in the amount of Tribunal makes the following orders in into by a member and the PRB. $4,000 by Sept. 30, 2020. accordance with s.41.1 of the VPA. 3. The veterinarian shall be IN THE MATTER OF THE responsible for successful passing NO RIGHT TO APPEAL: VETERINARY PROFESSION ACT, of the PIPS inspections in the R.S.A. 2000, c. V-2, As Amended regular inspection schedule. The ABVMA and the veterinarian agree that there shall be no right of appeal from this AND IN THE MATTER OF A 4. There shall be publication of Consent Order. PRACTICE REVIEW BOARD this Agreement on a without- REVIEW INTO THE CONDUCT names basis (and without THE VETERINARIAN, A MEMBER identifying information). 12 ABVMA MEMBERS’ MAGAZINE | SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 2020
The veterinarian successfully satisfied the AND WHEREAS on July 26, 2016, • there were repeated sales of bottles review undertaken by the PRB, and provided submissions were received from the VPE and of Ketamine to farmers with no that the terms of the agreement are met, the the responsible veterinarian. medical notes or incorrect logging matter will be concluded. AND WHEREAS on Oct. 4, 2016, the and no controlled drug log; PIPS Committee determined that the • no TPP pad nor client nor invoices medical records were inadequate and that in the computer to match the sales; a review of the large animals ABVMA • there was a lack of medical records, A veterinary practice that failed to meet the medical records handbook be undertaken. animal IDs and euthanasia logs not minimum standards of the PIPS Bylaw and a veterinarian employed at the practice were Further clarification from the responsible matching invoices; both referred to the PRB. veterinarian with respect to volumes of • a question was raised whether In this matter, the veterinarian who was Ketamine was required. the veterinarian was working as the responsible veterinarian at the time of an employee at the VPE AND WHEREAS the PIPS Committee or independently; the 2015 practice inspection sold the practice sent correspondence on Dec. 8, 2016, • there were no available documents but remained on at the VPE as an employee. requiring a re-inspection in January 2017 and to reflect the veterinarian’s There were significant deficiencies related to requesting submissions of medical records appointments, controlled drug the practice of the employee veterinarian that from all veterinarians and controlled drug logs logs or invoicing. were not identified and corrected by the VPE. to be submitted after the re-inspection. The employee veterinarian and the AND WHEREAS in 2017, VPE was sold responsible veterinarian entered into AND WHEREAS a re-inspection was to a corporation approved as a permit holder agreements with the PRB. The following is undertaken on Jan. 3, 2017. The veterinarian owned by the new responsible veterinarian the agreement with the employee veterinarian. provided further submissions on Feb. 27, 2017. and her husband. IN THE MATTER OF THE AND WHEREAS at the PIPS Committee AND WHEREAS deficiencies were VETERINARY PROFESSION ACT, R.S.A. meeting on Oct. 3, 2017, the PIPS noted with respect to VPE at the June 2000, c. V-2, as amended Committee determine there were no changes 2019 inspection. in the insufficient practices of the veterinarian. AND IN THE MATTER OF A AND WHEREAS Council of the ABVMA The PRB required that all controlled drugs be PRACTICE REVIEW BOARD approved a review of the first responsible locked in ambulatory vehicles and that further REVIEW INTO THE CONDUCT OF veterinarian’s (now an employee) veterinary documents be submitted. In addition the THE VETERINARAIN, A MEMBER medicine practice on Sept. 3, 2019. PIPS Committee referred the matter to PRB OF THE ALBERTA VETERINARY for non-compliance. AND WHEREAS the PRB met with the MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, AND WHEREAS correspondence was first responsible veterinarian on Sept. 23, AND IN THE MATTER OF THE 2019, for the purpose of addressing the matter sent to the new responsible veterinarian at REVIEW OF THE PRACTICE of his practice status and deficiencies with the VPE on Feb. 13, 2018, advising of the OF THE VETERINARAIN AS respect to his veterinary medicine practice. additional deficiencies and informing that APPROVED BY COUNCIL OF THE the previous responsible veterinarian had AND WHEREAS the veterinarian ALBERTA VETERINARY MEDICAL been referred to PRB. acknowledged that his practice of ASSOCIATION ON SEPT. 3, 2019 AND WHEREAS further submissions veterinary medicine did not meet WHEREAS on Sept. 24, 2015, an inspection minimum practice standards. were received from the VPE and the new was undertaken at a VPE at which the responsible veterinarian on March 9, 2018. AGREEMENT veterinarian was the responsible veterinarian. AND WHEREAS at the PIPS Committee 1. A written reprimand will be issued AND WHEREAS as a result of the meeting of June 6, 2018, it was determined against the veterinarian which will PIPS Committee review of the inspection, that the VPE had successfully completed the remain in the ABVMA member file. correspondence from the ABVMA dated practice inspection portion of the ABVMA 2. The review of the veterinarian’s April 18, 2016, was sent to the veterinarian Quality Assurance Program of Sept. 24, 2015. practice, regardless of the VPE in and the veterinary practice requesting proof of radiation equipment certification; the AND WHEREAS the VPE was again which he is working as approved by responsibility of the veterinary practice to due for a rotational inspection which was Council of the ABVMA on Sept. 3, develop and implement large animal narcotic conducted in June of 2019. 2019, will continue for a period of one drug logs; and develop and implement large year from the date of this Agreement. AND WHEREAS the PIPS Committee 3. The veterinarian shall undertake the animal medical records. A requirement to met with respect to this matter and submit three months of narcotic control drug following continuing education: determined that the conduct of the first i. The veterinarian shall undertake logs as well as five sample large animal records responsible veterinarian, now an employee, was requested. Further, an order was made by and complete a medical was of significance and concern as follows: records course approved by the the PIPS Committee requiring the VPE to be • there was neutering cats on farms subject for a re-inspection within six months. ABVMA within 90 days of the with Ketamine with no medical date of this Agreement; notes, no analgesic, no monitoring; Continued on next page WWW.ABVMA.CA 13
PRESIDENT’S REPORT COMPLAINTS DIRECTOR’S REPORT CONTINUED ii. The cost of this course shall professional responsibility for the conduct of AND WHEREAS the veterinarian, be the responsibility of the the employee veterinarians, in this case there as the responsible veterinarian, veterinarian and successful were significant and recurring deficiencies acknowledged that the VPE did not completion of this course must in the practice of the employee that were meet minimum practice standards. be provided to the ABVMA reasonably expected to have been corrected Complaints Director. by the practice. The following agreement AGREEMENT 4. The veterinarian shall be responsible considers the responsibility accepted by 1. A written caution shall be issued to regularly maintain the following: the responsible veterinarian and practice in against the veterinarian, which will i. Appointment book that must be failing to meet the minimum standards of remain in the ABVMA member file. kept at the VPE; the PIPS Bylaw. ii. Medical records on file at VPE The following is the agreement with the 2. The veterinarian shall be with respect to all veterinary responsible veterinarian of the VPE. responsible for the general medicine practiced; oversight of the veterinary IN THE MATTER OF THE medical practice of the employee iii. Controlled drug log including VETERINARY PROFESSION ACT, a “Use” log for all controlled, veterinarian while an employee R.S.A. 2000, c. V-2, as amended and/or general contractor of narcotic and targeted drugs; iv. Appropriately record all AND IN THE MATTER OF A the VPE. This shall include dispensing of pharmaceuticals in PRACTICE REVIEW BOARD the following: accordance with PIPS Bylaw and REVIEW INTO THE CONDUCT i. Responsibility of the VPE ABVMA Guidelines. OF THE RESPONSIBLE to obtain from the employee The veterinarian shall be responsible for VETERINARAIN A MEMBER OF veterinarian and maintain maintaining these documents at the practice THE ALBERTA VETERINARY availability for verification such that they are available for verification MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, of compliance; and compliance. The veterinarian shall be ii. Daily appointment calendars; AND IN THE MATTER OF THE accountable to the VPE or the VPE in iii. Medical records; REVIEW OF THE PRACTICE which he is working with respect to all iv. Properly completed controlled OF THE VETERINARIAN AS practice responsibilities. drug log; APPROVED BY COUNCIL OF 5. Attend the next Registration Day. v. Records of prescribing THE ALBERTA VETERINARY 6. The veterinarian shall pay costs of and dispensing that are MEDICAL ASSOCIATION ON the PRB process in the amount of compliant with PIPS Bylaw Sept. 3, 2019 $4,000 within six months of the date and ABVMA Guidelines. WHEREAS VPE is owned by a of this Agreement. 3. The veterinarian shall pay costs of corporation approved as a permit holder 7. The veterinarian’s practice shall be the PRB process in the amount of owned by the veterinarian and her subject to an unannounced practice $4,000 within six months of the date husband effective March 2017. inspection within one year of the of this Agreement. date of this Agreement. The cost of AND WHEREAS the veterinarian is 4. The veterinarian and the VPE shall this practice inspection shall be the the responsible veterinarian for the VPE. be subject to the ongoing review by responsibility of the veterinarian. AND WHEREAS the veterinarian is the PRB for one year from the date Failure to successfully pass the responsible, in part, for the compliance of of this Agreement. practice inspection as determined the first responsible veterinarian/employee by the PIPS Committee and/or the 5. The VPE shall be subject to an veterinarian with respect to his practice of Complaints Director until such time unannounced practice inspection veterinary medicine at the VPE. as there is an Order of the PRB or within six months of the date of this other authorized decision maker AND WHEREAS the responsible Agreement. The cost of the practice may result in the suspension of the veterinarian is responsible for ensuring inspection shall be the responsibility veterinarian’s permit to practice the compliance of the employee of the veterinarian. Failure to veterinary medicine. veterinarian with respect to all elements successfully pass the practice 8. There shall be publication of this of the practice of veterinary medicine at inspection as deemed by the PIPS Agreement on a without-names basis the VPE. Committee and/or the Complaints (and without identifying information). AND WHEREAS the veterinarian Director may result in the suspension The new responsible veterinarian for the met with the PRB on Sept. 23, 2019, of the practice of the VPE. VPE accepted responsibility for the practice for the purpose of addressing the 6. There shall be publication of this not meeting the minimum standards of the matter of the VPE’s noncompliance Agreement on a without-names basis PIPS Bylaw and shared responsibility for the with the PIPS bylaws, deficiencies in (and without identifying information). deficient practice of the employee veterinarian. the inspection and the noncompliance While the responsible veterinarian of an employee veterinarian while does not normally assume or share the practicing veterinary medicine. 14 ABVMA MEMBERS’ MAGAZINE | SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 2020
WEIGHT MANAGEMENT SPARK A CONVERSATION. SPARK THEIR METABOLISM. Focus your weight conversation on metabolism — known to slow naturally over time — and make it easier for pet parents to commit to weight loss success. Prescription Diet Metabolic is the only 1 nutrition clinically proven to activate metabolism1 2 Helps control begging in 9 out of 10 dogs2 3 96% of dogs lost weight in two months at home3 Ask your Hill’s territory manager about weight nutrition that’s A STEP AHEAD FOR THEIR BEST LIFE 1 Hill’s data on file. Based on current therapeutic products in market. 2 Data on file. Hill’s Pet Nutrition, Inc. 3 WWW.ABVMA.CA Veterinarian-supervised feeding study with 351 client-owned pets; 314 pets completed after 67 days. Data on file. Hill’s Pet Nutrition, Inc. 15 The Hill’s Transforming Lives logo, the Hill’s Prescription Diet logo, the S+OX SHIELD logo, Hill’s, Prescription Diet, and Metabolic are trademarks of Hill’s Pet Nutrition Canada, Inc.
You can also read