VIRGIN GROUP'S CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT REPORT 2010
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
VIRGIN GROUP’S CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT REPORTwell... it’s not really a report... it’s more of a... way this
think piece or “Dicussion Document”. It’s basically... VIRGIN’S VIEW ON A SUSTAINABLE LIFESTYLE doing to help people get closer to that and what we are
CONTENTS VIRGIN GROUP’S CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT REPORT page 6 A Message from Richard Branson The view from the top 7 By Stephen Murphy (group CEO) and Peter Norris (group Chairman) Managing corporate responsibility & 8 sustainable development across the group An explanation of what sustainability means to the Virgin companies, how the Virgin Group is structured and our governance process 12 What Virgin is up to around the world 14 THE VIRGIN TIMELINE 16 Flying High Virgin Atlantic, Virgin America, Virgin Blue Group, Air Asia X, Belgium Air 24 We’re all going on a Summer Holiday Virgin Holidays, Virgin Limited Edition Lifestyle 32 Getting from A to B themes Virgin Trains, Virgin Limobikes, Virgin Racing Virgin’s thoughts, the 38 Staying in Touch key issues and Virgin Media, Virgin Mobile, Virgin Digital Help the companies’ impacts, actions 46 Watching the Pennies and intentions Virgin Money, Virgin Green Fund 50 My Body is a Temple Virgin Active, Virgin HealthMiles, Virgin Life Care, Virgin Spa 56 Out of this World Virgin Galactic Relax and have Fun 60 Virgin Media, Virgin Books, Virgin Games, Virgin Wines, Virgin Experience Days, Virgin Balloon Flights, Virgin Festivals, Virgin Radio International 68 The Virgin people story Our People: The HR department’s review of Virgin’s policies, achievements and how it is striving to do more Our Customers: Virgin’s philosophy behind being the consumer’s champion 74 Virgin Unite and the ‘big ideas’ Virgin Unite, The Elders, The Carbon War Room, Disease Control Hub, the Virgin Earth Challenge, the next big idea and our view on forests 4
A message from Richard Someone wiser than I once said that ‘knowledge is power’ – and so in the 21st Century we have no excuse to sit back and let our planet and its people continue to suffer. As “global citizens” of the world we are facing serious environmental and social challenges; climate change, a lack of key resources, widespread poverty, conflicts and enormous population growth are all threatening to destabilise our fragile status quo. Scientists have been telling us for years that we cannot continue to live the way we do and at last some of us have started to listen, started to act and started to turn back the tide, little by little – at last having grasped that in our small global village what affects our neighbours, affects us all. It would be easy to be overwhelmed by the scale of these global issues, but I am an optimist at heart and I believe in the power of entrepreneurship and innovation. The human race has demonstrated a tremendous capacity to change and adapt in the past and I have faith we can do it again. At Virgin we’re working together to make a difference, by implementing small changes in the way we work, by continuously investing in green technologies and by exploring new possibilities in science and beyond. I believe that in the future we will be able to enjoy healthy and fulfilling lifestyles, whilst minimising the negative impact we have on the world. What seems impossible today could be possible tomorrow. The world has changed a great deal in the 40 years since the Virgin Group started, but I’m proud to be able to say that we’ve moved with the times and we’re still listening. We’ve set up a foundation, Virgin Unite, to help us listen, bring people together and tackle issues with entrepreneurial approaches. We’re also listening to the exceptional men and women who form The Elders, to the scientists, partners and entrepreneurs who make up the Carbon War Room - all these people are helping to educate us as to what is needed both globally and at a grass roots level to help make a difference to lives on a daily basis. Richard Branson 6
The view from the top By Stephen Murphy (group CEO) and Peter Norris (group Chairman) We have always considered ourselves to be a responsible business, and whilst we have understood the environmental and social pressures of our world, this is the first time we have outlined our thoughts and views on corporate responsibility and sustainable development for the whole Virgin Group. At Virgin we have always looked for new, innovative ways to do business by offering consumers another way, a better way, and by being willing to fight their corner. We are determined Virgin will prove that living sustainably and responsibly need not be considered difficult or dull. Sustainable living is often portrayed as a life of sacrifice and compromise as opposed to the choice and freedom we currently enjoy. Unsurprisingly people aren’t motivated by this vision. We want our Virgin companies to provide responsibly produced, sustainable, low carbon services and products that are desirable, easy to use and good value above all else so that our customers can enjoy their lifestyles safe in the knowledge that Virgin is acting responsibly on their behalf. We designed this report (although we feel like it’s more of a story to which we haven’t yet written an ending…) to highlight the enormous range of sustainability issues the Virgin companies face, operating in so many different sectors. Virgin’s products and services span many aspects of life, from mobile phones and financial products to holidays and health clubs. Our challenges and opportunities are consequently just as diverse, but we recognise this gives us the potential to contribute in a meaningful way to a vision of a sustainable lifestyle. We want to use the report to explain how our companies are doing this - addressing their impacts and realising the opportunities – and also to share our vision on responsibility and sustainability along with our plans for the future. As a member of the Virgin Group, each business is responsible for making its contribution to our vision of sustainability. For some, such as the airlines, the task is far harder and so we recognise that each business will progress at its own pace. However, we expect each Virgin company to fully understand its environmental and social impacts, have the ambition to lessen these impacts and work to exert its influence to lessen the impacts of its sector. We are proud of what our companies have achieved so far and some initiatives in particular have really set the bar high for sustainable practices within the group. However, we’re also committed to pushing them to go further and be more ambitious with their goals. ‘Business as usual’ is no longer an option - the world simply doesn’t have enough natural resources to maintain current trends of consumption, and the consequences of climate change and environmental degradation are severe. The global issues we face today are enormous and to solve them we all need to work together towards living more sustainably. To support this, we’ve also established a non-profit foundation, Virgin Unite, that works with our businesses, Richard and global partners to drive change and to encourage entrepreneurial approaches to some of the tough challenges the world is facing today. As a society we need to be prepared for change. Businesses, governments and individuals need to speak the same language and act together to make the right decisions to shape our lives for the future. No single company can solve these problems but if we have the courage to unite, we can find the creative, pragmatic and bold solutions required to meet these challenges head on. Stephen Murphy Peter Norris 7
This definition of sustainable development comes from Gro Harlem Brundtland, Prime Minister of Norway and author of Our allenges Group’s ch Common Future (1987). The Virgin an d varied: id e are very w Atlantic The Virgin team is sustainability s to reduce it working hard issi s, on company’ s carbon em nt is less releva a goal which Games, which for Virgin nt, rbon footpri has a tiny ca to d worki ng but is instea . bl ing addiction prevent gam 8
Managing corporate responsibility & sustainable development across the group So what does this mean for the Virgin also has a role to play in encouraging responsible drinking, companies? and Virgin Money’s predominant social issue is advocating responsible lending. We have interpreted this definition of sustainable development into four main challenges which we believe Because of this wide variation in the challenges our businesses need to meet in the 21st century: different companies face, we decided that highly focused group-wide targets and KPIs would be inappropriate and • emit minimal carbon and other greenhouse gases fail to tackle the sector specific impacts sufficiently . • learn to use the planet’s finite resources responsibly Instead we developed the Product Story approach (explained in more detail on the next page) and asked • strive towards poverty alleviation and the fair treatment each company to review its own individual sustainable of all individuals development story, enabling them to examine on a • offer products and services that enhance emotional and case-by-case basis how they are meeting the four physical wellbeing. challenges outlined above and where they need to make improvements. We believe that we have a part to play in making this a reality and so our vision for sustainability within the Whilst we have already come a long way, the road Virgin Group is to: “make a credible contribution towards stretches indefinitely in front of us. Sustainable living is not sustainable lifestyles whilst meeting or exceeding the the latest vogue or a fad that will die out. We are making a expectations of our staff, customers and stakeholders”. long-term commitment; we aspire to become greener and more responsible every year. Although Virgin is big, we can Our path towards sustainability is based on development achieve relatively little in the grand scheme of things just by means of enlightened capitalism. We have to change by reducing our own impacts. However, by continuously the way we run our businesses by; channelling the trying to lead the debate, raising the bar, challenging entrepreneurial spirit of our people, pioneering new our competitors and lobbying governments, we can technologies, funding Research and Development (R&D) make sustainable businesses a reality as well as being and thereby reducing the resources we use. Then we have economically beneficial. to encourage our competitors to do the same. So it’s not only about profits – it’s about adapting and developing Since Virgin companies span so many sectors, it wouldn’t the products we sell and services we provide, to ensure we be relevant for us to outline just one set of targets and one look after people and the planet, now and in the future. area of focus. Instead we decided the best approach was to explain what issues face the sectors that our companies Some of our companies have relatively small environmental operate in and explain what the Virgin companies are footprints, but more significant social impacts which doing both to maximise their positive impacts and need to be addressed. For example; Virgin Games’ main minimise their negative impacts. You can read all of these responsibility is helping to prevent gambling addiction, in the later chapters. Virgin Wines ensures its wine producers get a fair price and n d for 40 years. They aren’ t just an image but a reflectio d unch ange value for money, quality, es have rem aine The Virgin brand valu the way we do busi ness . Virgin has always stood for of our very essence and gone three a sen se of com pet itiv e cha llenge. But now our brand values have innovation, fun and brand cube to which we have added the a list of brand values but a dimensional; we no longer have Wellbeing & Happiness of People and This report Sustainability of the Planet. evolution to our brand and The Brand Cube represents that fundamental what we at Virgin stand for. very of a high quality We pride ourselves on the deli Value for money the empowerment of our products and services through Good quality of customer feedback to employees and innovative use Brilliant customer service s experience but can ’ continually improve the customer Innovative idering the impact our no longer do this without cons Completely challenging on people’s wellbeing and products and services have Fun are intr insically linked. the planet’s sustainability; they Wellbeing & happiness of people All stakeholders Virgin companies em staff, customers, suppliers, society ploy over 43,000 peo 20 countries worldw ple in over ide. Plus we have a 10,000 staff emplo further yed by partner org Sustainability of the planet deliver a service on anisations who Virgin’ s behalf to our cus Finite resources To learn more about tomers. our People see page Low carbon 68. 9
So how does it all fit together? style of management, although they all make their own operational decisions. We give birth to new Virgin In essence, Virgin is an international investment group companies, help them develop and set best practice with more than 200 companies worldwide. We hold guidelines for crucial elements such as customer service different levels of ownership of the companies: some are standards, brand management and more recently our fully owned by Virgin, we share ownership of others and vision for Corporate Responsibility and Sustainable in some cases the Virgin trademark is carried on ventures Development1 (CR/SD). Then we keep an eye on them which are no longer owned by Virgin at all. Complicated? as they grow and become fully-fledged members of the Well, not really…. Virgin family. Although managing the Virgin Group is pretty much a full We may be made up of many companies but we are a time job, we have developed a canny way of doing it that single brand and so it is vital that we remain consistent keeps things fresh and lively whatever a company does and in order to be credible. Although Virgin’s management, wherever it’s based. At the centre is Virgin Management our various Virgin businesses, Richard himself, Unite (our which oversees all Virgin companies, providing advisory charitable foundation) all exist as separate and distinct services and managerial support. Our people in London, entities, combined we can exert a powerful force in the New York and Sydney offer regional support and between areas in which we work. Virgin is a lifestyle brand and us and the sector teams we manage Richard’s interests we now recognise that our responsibility as a consumer across the whole of the Virgin Group. champion extends to improving our products and services As the Virgin businesses are all so diverse and so that it is easier for our customers to live a sustainable independent, we practise a collaborative and supportive and low carbon life. TARGET: We will update every company’s product story by the end of 2010. The second step: Dashboard The detailed Product Story is then simplified into a succinct Dashboard The first step: Product Story process which highlights the main risks and Each Virgin business has its own opportunities, progress made and Product Story, a document that outlines all the next steps. A traffic light system corporate responsibility and sustainable measures the level of risk and development (CR/SD) issues that a particula opportunity of any given issue and r company faces, put together by quizzing our busi a star system indicates the CR/SD nesses in depth about all the products and services team’s assessment of how well the they offer. The Product Story covers all aspe company is addressing the issue. cts of corporate responsibility and sustainable The Dashboard is checked and development and so includes what the business updated at least twice a year or is doing well at and striving to improve, as well as more frequently if a company has the areas which need significant work. a red traffic light against a headline Researching and writing the Prod issue. It is completed by Virgin uct Stories hasn’t given us all the solutions, but Management’s CR/SD team in by underscoring both the good and the bad bits, collaboration with the company and we can now say, hand on heart, that we know is then passed onto the company’s the whole truth (and nothing but the truth) and so MD/CEO and Managing Partner at are better positioned to improve our companies’ impa Virgin’s management. cts and help our consumers to live more sustaina ble lifestyles – which, is ultimately the aim of this process. 10
New Economics Foundation – Happy Planet Index 2.0. http://www.happyplanetindex.org/learn/why-we-need-hpi.html How does this actually work within the what their contribution should be within their sectors and Virgin Group? in comparison to their peers. We want Virgin companies to share their thinking and aim for a common goal so that At Virgin Management, it’s the role of the CR/SD team we can achieve more, both by supporting one another to have an overview of the main trends, risks and and also by pushing each sector in a more sustainable opportunities of global issues, so that we’re well informed direction. Rather than taking a top down governance and understand how they will affect Virgin businesses (and approach towards corporate responsibility and sustainable of course how we affect them). Armed with this knowledge development, we prefer to explain, guide and encourage we act as a sounding board for all the businesses. We are the Virgin companies. In this way, we will ensure they also improving our investment and brand criteria so that understand that embracing sustainability as a core value any new company that joins the Virgin Group will be asked means acting now on relevant issues which will ultimately to adhere to our corporate responsibility and sustainable be beneficial for their bottom line. We must change the development approach. mindset that running a business in a responsible and The aim is to agree a consensus with all our companies on sustainable way means sacrificing growth and profits. 1. You can find a definition of SD on page 8 The S “ If you were talking to your mates over a beer about your Product D Coun chaire cil is Story, would you be proud, or would you be ashamed?” d by V Group irgin ’s CEO Steph , en Mu and co rphy nsists senior of manag Virgin ement, The third step: Risk and Opportunity Register Unite and which is discussed the CR Key headline risks and opportunities are added to a register, /SD te this meeting appropriate am. at a quarterly SD Council meeting and following actions are taken . companies fulfil their These governance steps have been designed to help all our onerous . They focus on the benefits responsibilities without making the task too ibility and sustaina ble develop ment to the business , for of corporate respons and cost example by creating a competitive advantage, ensuring resource efficiency, as well as by managing risk. new risks are We need to keep listening to our companies to make sure as possible. We at identified and solutions found and disseminated as quickly in robust science and sharing our methods of Virgin believe in putting our trust . We are constan tly learning and we will commun icate our progress best practice to you as we go. TARGET: We will review and update the risk and opportunity register eve ry six months. 11
5 Virgin festiVals with a car-share programme to encourage What Virgin is up to festival-goers to car pool around the World… 30,000 hours 2,000 of volunteer time generated at Virgin people partying to a lady gaga oVer Mobile Festival us 2009 (freefest) concert in toronto in aid of 200 billion Virgin Mobile Canada’s re*generation campaign steps taken by Virgin HealthMiles members (since 2006) 20,000 Virgin mobile limited edition re*generation samsung phones sold to help combat youth homelessness 110,000 mobile phones reused through Virgin Mobile US’ pass it on programme in six months 65 house visited each day thanks t on motorbikes provided b businesses and set up b 500 plane tickets oVer donated to not-for-profit organisations every year by £250,000 donated by Virgin Virgin America Holidays and its customers to the travel foundation and other charities worldwide in 2009 2 spaceships being built by Virgin Galactic in a spaceport powered by renewable sources 300 people 30 signed up to go on Virgin Galactic flights 200 groWers that Virgin Wines buys from in preViousl south america disadVan Women working as therap Virgin Spa 160 sustainability oVer audits 1,200 completed worldwide at Virgin Holidays’ partner hotels ideas sent in to the Virgin Earth Challenge
5,278,389 £2.6 52% tonnes of million aVerage Waste co2e worth of time, funds and gifts-in-kind donated by reduction Virgin Atlantic’s carbon in Virgin Atlantic’s ground footprint in 2008 Virgin Atlantic passengers operation main sites and staff over 2008/2009 (between 2008 and 2009) 2,000 people partying to a lady gaga concert in toronto in aid of 100,000 kWht generated by the solar panels on Virgin Mobile Canada’s re*generation campaign Virgin Active health clubs in Venice (from april 2008 - october 2009) 20,000 66 solar 80,000 kWht panels Virgin mobile limited generated by the solar panels on edition re*generation Virgin Active health clubs in brescia samsung phones at kasbah tamadot, a freccia rossa (from may 2008 - sold to help combat youth Virgin Limited Edition september 2009) homelessness property 21 million people globally listen to Virgin Radio international’s fm radio programming 65 households visited each day thanks to health workers 175 people on motorbikes provided by staff at Virgin work for businesses run businesses and set up by Virgin Unite by young entrepreneurs supported by the branson school of entrepreneurship, set up by Virgin Unite 110 patients seen every day at the bhubezi community healthcare centre set up by Virgin Unite and partners and supported by Virgin Limited Edition 6 caribbean 72 sri lankan nationals have gained or are studying for beach sellers university degrees in tourism management thanks to Virgin 332 retrained as tourist guides through Virgin Holidays’ support of the Holidays scholarships healthZones, travel foundation clinics and biokineticists in the Virgin Life Care network 30 preViously 3,000 disadVantaged people Women benefiting from the three boreholes working as therapists at installed by Virgin Spa 361 kW of solar panels on Virgin ulusaba, a Virgin Limited Edition property Active south africa health clubs 515 12 grey 90 energy pieces Water oVer of gym recycling & Water meters 1,200 in Virgin Active health clubs equipment systems ideas sent in to the donated to charities by Virgin Active in 2009 in Virgin Active health clubs Virgin Earth Challenge
10 companies 1 cup working in renewable energy and recycling resource efficiency invested in by Virgin Green Fund scheme at a V Festival 11,000 homes powered by the energy saved through Virgin Trains’ regenerative brakes each year 400,000 discounted tickets sold each month by Virgin Trains 35,000 30 people runners in the london marathon enjoying a relaxing spa treatment everyday with sponsored by Virgin Money UK Virgin Experience Days 72 energy meters in Virgin Active health clubs 60 marriage proposals on Virgin Balloon Flights in 2009 500 jackets and bags remade from retired Virgin hot air balloons by Worn again in 2009 244,681 Virgin books printed on fsc paper 11 ducks & 4 flamingos at the roof gardens, a Virgin Limited Edition property 400 children 6,000 mobile provided with free home phones access to the internet by Virgin Media in 200 traded in by Virgin Media customers in 2009 partnership with the e-learning foundation elderly (summer 2008 - summer 2010) people in 17 sheltered housing schemes provided with free 13,000 bottles internet access by Virgin Media (2008 - 2011) of organic wine sold by Virgin Wines 1.6 million every year set top boxes 25,000 bottles and modems of fairtrade wine sold by Virgin Wines re-used and recycled by every year Virgin Media in 2008 25,000 45,000 people people signed up to a year zipping past Virgin Games to 4 biodiesel traffic on Virgin play safely online 1offsetmillion Limobikes Virgin Blue flights generators used on the stages at the four V Festivals in australia
Virgin TiMELinE… We’ve done a lot the back of 3 pages 1970 1971 197 1968 First Virgin First issue The first Virgin Record Shop opens in Recording Start of Virgin of Student Oxford Street, London opens at “ Mail Order Magazine Manor” ne operation Oxford, En 1991 1992 Virgin Radio hits the airwaves on AM across the UK 1993 Virgin Dir Personal Financial Service o Virgin Publishing (Virgin Books) is for busine formed Virgin Cin and Virgi Virgin Limobike Records is launches sold to Thorn UK. Virgin EMi launches in London 2003 Virgin Galactic, Virgin 2005 2002 Virgin Radio goes live in 2004 Games, and Virgin Spa launch. Virgin Thailand, Unite, the non-profit Virgin Credit foundation of the Virgin Virgin M Card launches group is established. launches in Australia Virgin Active launches Canada. its first clubs in italy Active ex into Spai and Port Virgin Bl joins with governm Samoa t Virgin Mobile arrives in the US, ‘Polynes Virgin Megastore launches in Australia
t. In fact, we couldn’t possibly fit ev s - but here are some of our b 72 1973 1984 Launch of Virgin Record Label and Virgin Music 1977 Virgin Records signs the Sex Publishing Pistols n g Studio “The ear ngland 1 rect Virgin Trains and V Festival UK start 1996 1997 Virgin Trains Virgin Active l opens 1995 up. Virgin Express airline takes off. V2 wins the 15 year franchise. launches its health and lifestyle centres. Virgin ess. Music is created Virgin Radio Mobile launches nemas and signs The in the UK Virgin’s first in Stereophonics is acquired consumer tele- es by ginger communications s in the Productions venture. Ulusaba n Radio s on FM is acquired by n Virgin Hotels 2007 2008 5 2006 Virgin Media arrives as the UK’s first company to offer TV, broadband, phone Mobile and mobile. Virgin s in America takes to Virgin Green Fund and Virgin the US domestic . Virgin We set up Virgin Life Care are launched. Virgin skies. Virgin Radio xpands Mobile india. Festival launches in Canada and italy launches. Al in Virgin Radio in the US, Virgin Money launches gore joins richard to tugal. the UK becomes in South Africa and Virgin Mobile announce the Virgin lue Absolute. Virgin launches in France and South Earth Challenge. h the Radio launches in Africa. in the UK Virgin Mobile Virgin Money ment of France, Toronto, merges with nTL/Telewest. Virgin launches in the US to launch Turkey and Dubai. HealthMiles launches nationally sian Blue’ TV station Virgin across the US 17 launches in France
ly fit everything we’ve done on to f our best bits… ds 1984 1987 1988 Virgin Atlantic Airways and Virgin Cargo Virgin Hotels launches are born and Virgin Records (Virgin Limited Edition) a year later America is Virgin Holidays founded and is formed Virgin Airship & Balloon Company (Virgin Balloon Flights) is formed 2001 1999 2000 Trains Virgin Active he launches its Virgin Experience Days r health and lifestyle Virgin Wines; launches. Virgin Active ise. centres. Virgin Virgin Mobile launches in South Africa. Radio Mobile launches Australia and Virgin Megastore welcomes UK Virgin’s first Virgin Blue all its first Middle East customers uired consumer tele- launch ger communications ctions venture. Ulusaba is acquired by Virgin Hotels 2008 2009 2010 We partner with Brawn gP for the Formula 1 season and Jenson Button takes the winner’s podium in his first race. We sell our stakes in Virgin (so far) Virgin Money Mobile Canada and Virgin Mobile US but both will continue to carry the acquires Church House Virgin brand. Virgin becomes official sponsor of the London Marathon Trust, our first steps into and launches Virgin Money Giving. We launch Virgin Digital Help in the banking, Virgin buys We set up Virgin UK. Virgin Mobile France buys Tele2, its mobile telecom rival. Launch of into Assura Medical, Mobile india. V Australia with flights between Australia and the US. our first entry into the Virgin Radio in Virgin Radio launches in Jordan, Montreal, Ottawa UK healthcare market. the UK becomes and Vancouver. in December we launch our We look forward to the Absolute. Virgin Formula One team Virgin Racing first Virgin sponsored Radio launches in France, Toronto, London Marathon – Turkey and Dubai. so get your running TV station Virgin shoes ready… 17 launches in France
Flying High “We all know that aviation has some serious environmental impacts - Virgin Atlantic particularly on our climate. Virgin America Although there’s no prospect Virgin Blue of a 100% sustainable aeroplane taxiing down the Brussels Airlines runway any time soon, that’s Air Asia X not a call for complacency. There’s huge potential to take action now to at least reduce aviation’s impact and increase the chance that, one day, it might approach sustainability. I’m encouraged that Virgin is both being frank about the problems - and engaged with the solutions.” Martin Wright Editor in Chief at Green Futures 16
Modern aviation has changed the way we live, recognises its environmental impacts and is Aviation’s global making the world a much smaller place. We working to minimise them while maintaining and economic impact* is now have a greater understanding of other enhancing the benefits it can bring to economies estimated to be 7.5% of civilisations and in many cases our cultures have and societies3. The industry’s first step towards world GDP. started to merge. Air travel is much faster and a carbon-free future is to work towards carbon *direct, indirect, induced and catalytic more reliable than other modes of transport over neutral growth – meaning that any growth above Source: Air Transport Action large distances1. Travelling is now a reality and the baseline will be matched by equivalent Group. Air transport drives eco- nomic and social progress. The an achievable goal for many people who could reductions in other sectors. economic and social benefits never have afforded it before. We are proud to of air transport 2008. (http:// Aviation represents by far the biggest www.atag.org/files/ATAG%20 have been in aviation for 26 years and believe in brochure-124015A.pdf) environmental impact of all the Virgin businesses. a sustainable future for the industry. Climate change is therefore top of the agenda We believe in the positive contribution global for both the Virgin Group and Virgin branded travel makes to the world. Flying is crucial to the airlines and we are committed to preventing As the Virgin Group global economy and central to many people’s runaway climate change . We won’t hide from owns a stake in many lifestyles – it links families, communities and the difficult arguments surrounding aviation and airlines around the businesses resulting in vibrant and successful the environment, in fact, we want to be right at world, it is now possible cultures and economies . their heart, pushing our industry, our suppliers, to circumnavigate the and our regulators to be bolder and to help Aviation also has negative impacts. It produces world on a Virgin plane. make flying a more sustainable way to travel. Air a significant contribution to man-made carbon We own stakes in eight travel is not about to disappear, particularly in dioxide (CO2) emissions . It is central to the airlines, Virgin Atlantic, the developing world. Airlines, such as Air Asia X climate change debate as it is one of the fastest Virgin America, Brussels (part owned by Virgin) are growing rapidly and growing contributors of greenhouse gases Airlines, Air Asia X and giving more and more people and businesses (GHGs) and is forecasted to continue growing the Virgin Blue Airlines access to an increasing number of destinations for the next thirty years2 . The aviation industry Group (Virgin Blue, V and markets. Australia, Pacific Blue and Polynesian Blue) as well as being involved with private planes. Global CO2 emissions from aviation are equivalent to about 1.9 - 2.4% of total global CO2 emissions Source: Committee on Climate Change. International Aviation 1. Oxford Exonomics. Avia- tion: The Real World Wide Web (http://www.oef.com/ OE_Cons_Aviation.asp) 2. Friends of the Earth (May 2005) Briefing: Aviation and the economy (http:// www.foe.co.uk/resource/ briefings/aviation_and_the_ economy.pdf) 3. Air Transport Action Group. Air transport drives eco- nomic and social progress. The amount of CO2 emissions from The economic and social benefits of air transport aviation is expected to grow by 2008. (http://www.atag.org/ files/ATAG%20brochure- 124015A.pdf) around 3-4% per year. 4. “Virgin Airlines” refers to Source: International Civil Aviation Organisation, Environnent Section. all airlines owned by Virgin http://www.icao.int/icao/en/env/aee.htm or branded with the Virgin CO2 name. 17
Aviation accounts for 7 out of the 8 million tonnes of CO2 emissions emitted annually by the Virgin Group. We at Virgin believe that the Virgin airlines4 can Industry Taskforce on Peak Oil & Energy The UK Industry have a positive influence on this movement. Security Taskforce on Peak Oil Although we represent a small part of the and Energy Security • Virgin Blue was the first airline to offer an aviation industry we have a high profile and (ITPOES) is a group airline run offset programme a loud voice, which we are using to push the of British companies debate forwards. That is why: • Virgin America was the first commercial concerned that threats passenger airline to join the US Environmental to energy security • we were the first carriers to call for global Protection Agency’s Climate Leaders are not receiving the legislation on airline CO2 emissions programme, and the first US airline attention they merit. • Virgin Atlantic was the first to fly on renewable to document its carbon footprint via It has produced two fuels internationally-accepted standards on The reports that can be read Climate Registry at: peakoiltaskforce.net • Virgin Atlantic was a founding member of the Aviation Global Deal Group5 and the • we have produced a paper “Aviation in a Low 5 Aviation Global Deal Group Sustainable Aviation Fuel Users Group6 Carbon World” which outlines our thoughts on (www.agdgroup.org) 6 Sustainable Aviation the subject. To read the report visit Fuel Users Group • the Virgin Group participates in the UK http://www.virgin.com/people-and-planet. (www.safug.org) Virgin Blue’s carbon offset launch 2007. The milestone of one million guest seats Holding the globe is (from left offset was reached in to right) Malcolm Turnbull (the July 2009. Australian Environment Minister in 2007) and Brett Godfrey (CEO Virgin Blue) Virgin Blue passenger who offset the millionth seat receiving a memento from Professor Tim Flannery. 18
Virgin America’s fleet Here is what our companies are doing to has a lower carbon footprint than other US make flying high more sustainable: airlines due to its upfront investment in new aeroplanes and its fuel- saving practices. Emissions The Virgin airlines believe that a successful Gold Standard global climate change framework for the industry Carbon Dioxide emissions from aviation should be based on the following key principles: offsetting makes sure represent over 90% of the Virgin Group’s entire that the money goes carbon footprint making it our top priority. • first and foremost, any system needs to be directly to a project The Virgin branded airlines are committed to environmentally effective. It must impose a which has immediate reducing emissions per passenger through a robust cap on overall emissions and truly allow positive impacts, both in number of efficiency measures including the aviation to play its part in meeting global the local communities adoption of new technologies and by investing in greenhouse gas reduction targets and the environment. new ultra-efficient aircraft. • it must be mandatory, applying fairly to gnikraP ippots oN gnirud gnippots Airlines oN have ot detctwo of CO2 emissions: irtser sources all airlines based on their emissions and semit detacidni doirep sredloh timrep establishing a sectoral approach that sets out The members of the f tpecxe sesub rof tpecxthose e from the tailpipe of the aeroplane7 and selcihev oN AGD are: secen sa those from the ground facilities. mumixam rAs evo the tailpipe specific targets for aviation whilst allowing ro nwod thgiew ssorg • Air France-KLM essap emissions account for around 99% of the total, airlines to access cost effective emissions nwohs • British Airways that is where the airlines’ main )sennofocus t ni( lies: reductions from other sectors through the • Cathay Pacific carbon markets • Finnair gnippots oN gnitiawhas • Virgin Blue oN already achieved a 10% )yawraelC( • it needs to minimise the risk of competitive • Qatar Airways decrease in emissions per passenger on board8 • Virgin Atlantic due to investment in new aircraft9 distortion • Virgin Blue Airlines evig yltsom redrob der on tub selcric eulb htiw sngiS • Virgin Atlantic has • it needs to avoid unintended negative Group .noitset curtasntarget ofp reducing the i evitiso carbon emitted per passenger kilometre by consequences such as carbon leakage13, whilst • BAA upholding the central pillar of the UNFCCC14, • LOT Polish Airlines 30% between 2007 and 2020 • The Climate Group of “common but differentiated responsibility” • Virgin America operates a fleet that is up to - where developed countries bear a greater 25% more fuel efficient than other fleets in the burden of responsibility for emissions lciheV tfel peeK tfel nruT daeha tfel nruT ylno daehA ssap lobmys fi thgir( lobmyUSs fi thgi.r( lobmys fi thgir( The AGD proposal t edis )desrever )desrever )desrever reductions as they have benefited from carbon suggests a carbon em issions as reduction Our major airlines also offer Gold Standard for intensive industries for much longer than cap and trade system itsed their carbon offsetting: developing economies. that would include all airlines. A CO2 cap • Virgin Atlantic = My Climate10 Virgin Blue and Virgin Atlantic are members or target would be of the Aviation Global Deal Group (AGD established, creating • Virgin Blue = Australian Government’s Group), a group that came together to think a number of carbon detaGreenhouse eb Friendly™ Program 11 fo dnE deeps muminiM gergeS ot etuoR tuobadnuor-iniM about practical solutions for how aviation ps elcyc ladep ladep yb desu tuobadnuor( allowances for aviation. nairtsedep dna • eVirgin ylno selcyc evig - noitalucric12 America = Carbonfund.org . emissions could be included in such a A proportion of those tuor selcihev ot yaw eht morf framework . The AGD Group’s policy allowances would be Although all the Virgin airlines )thgir etaare idemmworking hard i mechanism, which we have proposed as one auctioned to airlines, to reduce the emissions per passenger, total of the ways in which aviation can be brought with the revenues being emissions will continue to grow in the short to into a global framework, recommends that this hypothecated for climate medium term in line with business growth. Virgin common but differentiated responsibility is change related projects Atlantic predicts that its emissions will peak in the developing world. achieved by distributing revenues generated by a within the next decade owing to efficiency gains You can get more fart yaw-enO nairtsedeP sector-wide cap and trade scheme . We believe apmoc :eton( gnissorc information on the AGD outstripping the airline’s growth. a proportion of aviation’s carbon allowances ehA‘ ralucric revo tniop ylno smarT dna sesuB website: )ngis ’ylno yawmart should be auctioned, with the proceeds going to ylno selcyc www.agdgroup.org climate change related projects in the developing world. Global Policy The Virgin airlines support the principle of 7 This included the APU emissions (APU = Auxiliary We believe it is critical for governments to carbon cap and trade as the most effective way Power Unit generates al elcyc ladep wolf-htiW enal sub wolf-artnoC dna sub wolf-htiW of maintaining a robust cap on CO2 emissions electricity when the plane is agree a global framework for CO2 emissions enal elcyc on the ground). reductions from aviation; a framework that is whilst also allowing the market to decide the 8 Measured in revenue passenger / kilometre (an both environmentally effective and economically most effective way to achieve the necessary industry measure related to emissions reductions. the number of passengers efficient . carried divided by the total number of kilometres flown) Emissions from international aviation are not However, there is a concern that domestic or 9 Since commencing operations in 2000 currently included in the Kyoto Protocol but the regional schemes cannot be truly effective for an 10. My Climate Virgin airlines, along with their industry peers, international industry such as aviation. It would (www.myclimate.org) 11. Australian Government’s have united behind the principle of a global make sense to develop a global scheme for the Greenhouse Friendly™ Pro- framework specifically for the sector. sector, thus minimising competitive inequalities gram (www.climatechange. gov.au/greenhousefriendly/) between different carriers and imposing a 12. Carbonfund.org (www. carbonfund.org) much more meaningful absolute cap on carbon 13. For a definition of carbon emissions worldwide. leakage go to page 21. 14. United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change 19
Peak Oil is the point at which the depletion of existing reserves can no longer be replaced by additions of new flow capacity - in other words it is the point at which the world peaks in oil production. Up until now we have always had more oil to use than there was in the previous year. However as oil is a finite resource this cannot continue indefinitely. Once oil production peaks the world will have to start to use less oil each year due to dwindling supply which will lead to an Virgin Atlantic biofuel increase in the price demonstration flight of oil. Source: The UK Industry Taskforce on Peak Oil & Energy Security. The Oil Crunch: Secur- ing the UK’s energy future. (This report was part funded by the Virgin Group). This innovative Fuels overcome, biofuels are not yet being produced study brings together on a viable scale, although this emerging sector airlines, defence and The era of ‘cheap oil’ is coming to a close and is growing fast. research organisations, peak oil is fast approaching as extraction and governments and fuel refining become increasingly difficult and more Second and third generation biofuels do not use providers to identify environmentally damaging and energy intensive. food products as their feedstocks. These biofuels opportunities and Oil is a finite resource and technological would be made from waste biomass or plants barriers to achieving advancements can only go so far. We need such as algae and salt water tolerant halophytes a predetermined to look for alternative aviation fuels, not only and could be commercially viable in sufficient sustainable fuel mix by because of the urgency arising from climate quantities for the aviation industry to use within 2025. (An Australasian change, but simply because we are running the next five years. Virgin Atlantic anticipates Region SAFUG Initiative). out . Along with other stakeholders, the Virgin that up to 5% of its fuel will come from airlines are championing the development of sustainable biofuels by 2015 and Virgin Atlantic fuels based on second generation biofuels that along with Virgin Blue and Virgin America aspire are harvested from sustainable sources in order to a 10% biofuels mix by 2020. to reduce the sector’s dependence on declining What Virgin is doing with regards to biofuels: oil supplies and reduce its carbon footprint. • Virgin Atlantic was the first commercial airline However, the sustainability debate surrounding to use biofuel in a demonstration flight biofuels is extremely complex and biofuel production has been associated with a swathe • the Virgin Group, through the Virgin Green of unintended consequences including; the Fund, is investing in research and development link between biofuel production and increases of emerging fuels (for more information on the in food prices, the loss of natural habitats and Virgin Green Fund go to page 49) the fact that many are so fossil fuel intensive in • Virgin supports the Roundtable on Sustainable their production, that they may have no carbon Biofuels benefit at all! Although many biofuels have been made unsustainably and inefficiently in the past, • Virgin Atlantic was a founder member of we believe they have the potential to become the Sustainable Aviation Fuel Users Group15 sustainable and efficient in the future. (SAFUG) Any large scale move towards biofuels would • Virgin Blue under the SAFUG banner, is occur incrementally over time. Blends of biofuel working with other regional members and conventional kerosene would be introduced, to commission a roadmap for the and then over time the proportion of biofuel will commercialisation of sustainable aviation fuels be increased. However, even with low percentage in Australia and New Zealand . blends, the sheer quantities of biomass required 15. http://www.boeing.com/ commercial/environment/ to produce sufficient fuel for aviation would pdf/sustainable_aviation_ be colossal. Even with the sustainability issues fuel_users_group.pdf 20
What is Carbon Leakage? What is Emissions Trading? Carbon Leakage is where an increase in emissions occurs outside a region due Emission Trading Scheme (ETS) means that a robust cap is imposed on to a policy to cap emissions in that region. With the carbon dioxide emissions from different polluting industries. Carbon inclusion of aviation within allowances are issued to participating companies up to the level of the European Union Emission Trading Scheme (EU-ETS) the cap. At the end of the year each company has to have sufficient there is a risk that carriers will move activities outside allowances to cover each tonne of CO2 they’ve emitted during the year. the EU to avoid the EU-ETS Because the ETS is designed to encourage lower carbon behaviour by costs or that increased costs will lead to loss of market companies, airlines won’t be given sufficient allowances to cover their share with demand shifting activities and will have to purchase these from other industries who have to non EU-ETS affected carriers. This would result been able to reduce their emissions more quickly. The European Union in no overall reduction in Emission Trading Scheme is going to include aviation and will come into global carbon emissions as the emissions would simply effect in 2012. be shifted to other markets and regions. This is one of the reasons why we support a global sectoral approach for aviation and believe a worldwide solution is needed for what is a worldwide problem. The Sustainable Aviation Fuel Users Group is an initiative to promote sustainable, second-generation biofuels for the aviation industry. Virgin Atlantic made a declaration, along with other airlines, of its commitment to advance the development, certification, and commercial use of drop-in sustainable aviation fuels that do not compete with food cultivation for land or water. These have lower life-cycle carbon footprints than traditional jet fuel, do not lead to deforestation or the loss of high value, endangered or sensitive ecosystems and retain socioeconomic benefits in the communities in which they are cultivated. (www.safug.org) On 24 February 20 08, Virgin Atlantic ls became Roundtable on Sustainable Biofue the first airlin e in the world to operate a commercial body which is aircraft on a biofu is an international multi-stakeholder The Boeing 747 fle el blend. ls to make it w a short flight fr creating standards and audit protoco London to Amsterdam om party certification , using a 20% biofu possible through independent third kerosene blend in one of its four engines. el/80% ainable to identify biofuels that come from sust ures that new The purpose of the sources. Third party certification ens demonstration fligh t was mental and to move the deba supply chains develop to high environ that biofuels are tec te forward by proving ut competition social standards, so that concerns abo Virgin Atlantic knew hnically a feasible solution. ation and with land for food cultivation, deforest that the biofuel used its test flight would for be addressed relative life-cycle carbon footprints can not be commercially for the industry, bu via ble on the RSB on t wanted to demons and reconciled early on (read more that biofuels coul tra te b.org). d be a future solution page 37 or on their website at: www.rs for the industry. 21
30% reducti on target: Virgin Atlantic e carbon intensi ty A 30% reduction in th se n g er an d ca rgo kilometre of each pas . 2007 and 2020 flown between Operational efficiencies • Virgin Blue has a Fuel and Emissions Management Team that examines every aspect of flight operations All airlines need to invest in modern fleets that operate to continuously improve efficiency. Recent initiatives as efficiently as possible and are backed up by low include installing winglets on the 737NG fleet as well as carbon ground support systems . But airlines are only applying a coating to the aircraft that reduces drag and one of the many stakeholders in the aviation industry therefore emissions orders and so it’s fundamental that the entire sector works together. The speed at which the aviation industry can • Virgin America utilises advanced avionics to fly more hibitive. step changes in aircraft and engine reduce its emissions is mainly reliant on manufacturers to efficiently, and cost index flying which is the practice of y protechnological are mostldeliver regulating cruising speeds to reduce fuel burn messthe e. agavailability ualify their also design, of sustainable low carbon fuels and • Virgin Atlantic’s Fuel and Weight Savings Group improved air traffic control measures to ensure more champions new best practice and efficiency measures . efficient use of airspace. Since aviation can have a impact on communities that are What the Virgin airlines are doing on energy efficiency: local to airports, our airlines have initiatives at airports • developing and implementing operational best practices around the world which directly benefit local communities. ng to reduce CO2 and NOx l speed emissions School crossi For example: ationa 16 N patrol Maximum limit applies • lobbying • the total noise output of Virgin Atlantic’s fleet has been speed governments and air navigation service providers for more efficient airspace routings reduced since 2001/2 despite an increase in fleet size nd of • utilising a young, advanced fleet of fuel efficient aircraft • improving the availability and reliability of electricity mph zone supply for ground operations at airports around the world will reduce emissions and improve local air quality • Virgin Blue has invested in a young fleet of aircraft which has a reduced noise footprint. No entry for 16. Nitrous Oxide ry ated tempora vehicular tra ffi c Manually oper si gn s ive way to STOP and G O traffic on Virgin Atlantic major road target: To reduce ener gy consumption at all the UK s ites that it controls by 10% No reduced noi ot or Nby o bu20ses 12 an d ov er taking se footprint om 20% Nby (o ve r8 No cycling 2020. vehicles passenger seats) 22
Working with communities Sustainable tourism There are now five holiday flights to every Each year, Virgin Atlantic, Virgin Unite and Aviation has played a key role in expanding business flight made Virgin Holidays, along with the support of their tourism, which has in turn boosted air travel. overseas by a UK passengers and staff, collectively invest millions Over 40% of international tourists now travel by resident. of pounds in community projects within the plane17 and in the UK growth in air travel is being Source: Cairns, S., Newson, C., destinations they travel to and work in. Under driven by an increase in international leisure Boardman, B. and Anable, J. Predict and decide Aviation, the Change is in the Air programme, Virgin flights18 . climate change and UK policy. Environmental Change Institute Atlantic and its passengers will be supporting Oxford University. Tourism can be a catalyst for positive social two organisations, The Travel Foundation and and economic development, but it is becoming Free the Children, which both work towards increasingly evident that some aspects of sustainable futures for young people in its Air tourism accounts tourism are currently unsustainable . The Virgin destinations. for 8 million direct jobs airlines, along with Virgin Holidays and Virgin and 18 million indirect Virgin Blue’s “Red Jet” charity foundation is Limited Edition, are working towards gaining jobs as well as $396 currently focusing on “Indigenous Communities a greater understand of their impacts and billion US in global GDP. and Natural Environments” in Australia. The promoting sustainable tourism. To find out more Source: Oxford Exonomics. foundation has provided assistance to several go to ‘We’re all going on a Summer Holiday’ on Aviation: The Real World Wide Web projects including a residential energy efficiency page 24. programme in Alice Springs and a savannah fire management project in Arnhem Land. Virgin America works with the California State Parks Foundation and selects California-based carbon offset projects via its partnership with Carbonfund.org. Virgin America also hosts 17. Air Transport Action Group. regular e-waste collection events to clean-up Air transport drives eco- nomic and social progress. local beaches and parks. The economic and social benefits of air transport 2008. (http://www.atag.org/ files/ATAG%20brochure- 124015A.pdf) 18. Cairns, S., Newson, C., Boardman, B. and Anable, J. Predict and decide Avia- tion, climate change and UK policy. Environmental Change Institute Oxford University. 23
WE’RE ALL Information signs - continued GOING ON Hospital ahead with Tourist No thro for v A SUMMER Accident and information Emergency facilities point Traffic has priority over oncoming vehicles HOLIDAY Area in which cameras are Bus lane used to enforce junctio Recommended route Home Zone Entry for pedal cycles traffic regulations Road works signs Virgin Holidays Virgin Limited Edition Temporary hazard Road works Loose Temporary lane at road works chippings (the number and of arrows and may be varied a to lanes open an Slow-moving or Mandatory Road works End of road w stationary works speed 1 mile ahead any temporary r vehicle blocking a limit ahead including spe traffic lane. Pass in the direction shown by the arrow. 24
Information signs All rectangular End of controlled parking zone Entrance to Entrance to congestion controlled charging zone parking zone “Susta in is tou able touris rism th m the m at lea anag ds to resou em rces in ent of all that e such co a way and a nomic, soc esthe ial cabus n belane tic n With-flow fulfille eedLane s designated ahead mawhichintain d whil for use by high in e Parking place for tegrityand g cultural occupancy pedalincycles solo motorcycles taxis may also , esse ecolo use ntial vehicles (HOV) - gic see rule 142 biolog al process ical d es, life su iv ersity pport a Sourc system nd (ww e : W w.un orld Tou s”. wto.o rism rg) Orga nizati on Start of motorway and point from End of which motorway Ap motorway regulations apply Holidays are great for recharging our batteries and allowing us to relax both mentally and physically. prohibitive. Travelling is also a great way to expand our horizons essage. and the growth of the travel industry in recent years Traffic on the main Additional traffic joining from left has been invaluable in increasing our understanding carriageway comingof ahead. Traffic on main carriageway has priorityTourism leads g School crossin National speed from right has priority over joining traffic from other cultures and customs. Maximum patrol limit applies over joining traffic righttohand a wide lanerange of slip of road speed potential employment opportunities by In the introduction we talked about how there were 565 million international tourist generating jobs across important it is that our vision of a low carbon journeys made and that figure is forecast to grow a whole range of skills lifestyle No entry for in the future is desirable and free from to over 1.6 billion by 20204. and occupations. Many d temporary icular traffic Manually operate signs sacrifice. veh Holidays represent happy times in our of the jobs in tourism STOP and GO With such massive growth comes huge lives but the travel and tourism industry, like attract younger workers challenges; overdevelopment, over-reliance ‘Countdown’ markers atonexit from motorway (each bar many others, makes both positive and negative who might otherwise tourism for economic growth in developing represents 100 yards to the exit). Green-backed markers contributions in the wider world. At Virgin, we may be used on primary routes and emigratemarkers white-backed in search of No countries, an ever increasing carbon footprint, No buses describe overtaking sustainable tourism as ‘when locals employment. with black bars on other routes. At approaches to No motor (over 8 depletion of destinations’ natural resources and vehicles passenger benefit as much as visitors and where the resorts concealed level crossings white-backed Source: markers withThe Aviation: redReal World seats) damage to land and ocean bars based may be ecosystems. Wide Web. Oxford Economics. used. Although these will be erected at equal we enjoy today are preserved for others to enjoy Mo The challenges facing thedistances the bars doare tourist industry not represent 100 yard intervals. show in the future’ . enormous and cover many different and complex Travel and tourism is the world’s largest industry issues that are hard to unpick. It is therefore Globally, tourism andNoavehcritical icles component of the global economy, critical to ensure that our travel and tourism directly 112 employs 79 No vehicles No vehicle or over fuelling million people and width shogrowth and employment . It represents related businesses are doing their best to over wn combination of height shown vehicles over 10% of global GDP1 and 8% of employment address these challenges. in total supports 226 length shown worldwide2 . It also encourages development million jobs when Overdevelopment is a key challenge which is downstream effects are of infrastructure, such as transport networks, likely to worsen as travel becomes increasingly taken into account. sanitation works and other public amenities. No left turn No accessible. Despite the economic benefits that U-turns Many developing countries are highly reliant on Source: Aviation: The Real World No goods veh icles tourism can bring to a region, there are often Wide Web. Oxford Exonomics. tourism over maand ximum in some countries it can represent gross weight some environmental and social trade-offs for up to 30% nes shown (in ton of) GDP3. The industry’s predicted except for loading the local population. When a new destination 1. GDP – Gross Domestic growth reflects and unloading the increasing mobility of Product suddenly becomes popular, resorts can be 2. World Travel & Tourism populations comprehen sive in emerging economies: in 1995 Council Leading the Chal- use, a s commonly in ns, ny of the sign Your Traffic Sig lenge on Climate Change de shows ma booklet Know signs give n in the Department’s s the vast majority of February 2009 m is es and exp lain all drawn to also illus trat de are not The booklet Highway Co lish ility of popula tions 3. Why your world is about to illustrated in The Welsh and Eng increasing mob er. The signs used including ies get a whole lot smaller. Jeff some signs are seen on the roa ds. in emerging econom ual versions of of sign s may still be Rubin. Pg 235 ign s Some older des 4. UNWTO World Tourism Barometer growth & employment train BOAT plane 25
You can also read